Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1.1 Commitment
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Senior managers visibly involved in
Division/site recognized HSE activities, initiatives and reviews.
as a leader in the The importance of HSE is
particular aspect of the communicated in business decisions.
management system Employees actively participate.
Adequate resources provided for
achievement of HSE objectives
LEVEL 3 Managers are fully aware of the high
This particular aspect of the priority areas for improvement and
management system is being status of action plans. Investment is
addressed systematically. HSE seen as good business sense.
Reaching the respective targets. Resources generally available.
Integration with other activities
initiated
LEVEL 2 Management setting objectives and
Performance and results structure in place. Very much a top-
inconsistent. System being down approach. Resources limited to
implemented but generally at specific HSE objectives.
minimum levels. Plan Do
Check - Act process understood
but not put into practice.
LEVEL 1 HSE given less than equal priority.
Overall, performance is poor. Seen as incompatible to achieving
Awareness may be there, but operations, production and other
the implementation of this business objectives. HSE resources
particular aspect of the scarce.
management system is
haphazard or not in evidence.
SCORE:
1.2 Leadership
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Senior managers encourage a culture of
Division/site recognized belief, motivation, individual responsibility
as a leader in the and participation in HSE improvement. HSE
particular aspect of the culture accepted throughout the
management system organization. Employees involved at all
levels. Personal involvement very visible.
LEVEL 3 Managers and supervisors actively
This particular aspect of the participate in HSE activities, set a good
management system is being personal example and jointly develop both
addressed systematically. HSE "result" and "Activity" targets with
Reaching the respective targets. employees and contractors. General
Integration with other activities acceptance of HSE culture.
initiated Most employees involved in HSE issues.
LEVEL 2 Senior managers discuss and review
Performance and results progress towards specific "results" and
inconsistent. System being "activities" HSE targets, not active in
implemented but generally at development of objectives. Employees not
minimum levels. Plan Do convinced that HSE is a core value but
Check - Act process understood participated in process. HSE culture not
but not put into practice. widespread.
LEVEL 1 Management not visible in HSE process.
Overall, performance is poor. Leaders communicate HSE expectations but
Awareness may be there, but do not use or refer to Safety Management
the implementation of this System. Poor HSE culture. Employees do
particular aspect of the not feel they are involved.
management system is
haphazard or not in evidence.
SCORE:
2.1 Policies
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Policies clearly defined and
Division/site recognized implemented consistent with
as a leader in the corporate parent. Process in
particular aspect of the place to revise policies.
management system Work force fully aware of all
policies.
LEVEL 3 Good awareness and sensible
This particular aspect of the application of all policies.
management system is being
addressed systematically.
Reaching the respective targets.
Integration with other activities
initiated
LEVEL 2 HSE policy explained at
Performance and results induction training. No clear
inconsistent. System being direction on other policies.
implemented but generally at Generally only management
minimum levels. Plan Do aware of policies.
Check - Act process understood
but not put into practice.
LEVEL 1 HSE policy posted but not
Overall, performance is poor. generally explained or
Awareness may be there, but understood. HSE policy is
the implementation of this the only one posted. Limited
particular aspect of the awareness of policies.
management system is
haphazard or not in evidence.
SCORE:
2.2 Objectives
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Senior managers, site and individuals
Division/site recognized set challenging objectives for
as a leader in the continuous improvement.
particular aspect of the Performance objectives clearly
management system identified and communicated to all
concerned. Personnel at all levels are
assessed on achieving these
objectives.
LEVEL 3 Coordinated objectives set and
This particular aspect of the reviewed quarterly. Objectives on
management system is being target. All employees and most other
addressed systematically. parties aware of objectives.
Reaching the respective targets.
Integration with other activities
initiated
LEVEL 2 Objectives set. Not well coordinated
Performance and results or reviewed regularly. Action plans
inconsistent. System being not focused on objectives. Levels not
implemented but generally at realistic. Patchy level of achievement.
minimum levels. Plan Do Incomplete communication of
Check - Act process understood objectives to interested parties.
but not put into practice.
LEVEL 1 Objectives not set for site and/or
Overall, performance is poor. individuals. Not seen as a priority or
Awareness may be there, but the tool. Objectives not adequately
implementation of this particular communicated to employees involved
aspect of the management system or subcontractors.
is haphazard or not in evidence.
SCORE:
SCORE:
6.1 Inspections
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Continual development and
Division/site recognized revision of checklists and
as a leader in the schedule to meet changing
particular aspect of the requirements. Importance of
management system inspections fully accepted at all
levels of management. Effective
schedule targeted at critical
areas.
LEVEL 3 Full complement of custom
This particular aspect of the checklists with published
management system is being inspection schedule. Cross
addressed systematically. department inspections.
Reaching the respective targets. Significant deficiencies handled
Integration with other activities by action plan tracked to closure.
initiated High level of compliance.
LEVEL 2 Broad spread of inspections.
Performance and results Mainly internal. Follow-up on
inconsistent. System being immediate remedial action
implemented but generally at only.
minimum levels. Plan Do
Check - Act process understood
but not put into practice.
LEVEL 1 Some inspections conducted
Overall, performance is poor. with no structure. No follow-up.
Awareness may be there, but the Many deficiencies.
implementation of this particular
aspect of the management system
is haphazard or not in evidence.
SCORE:
6.2 Records
Score Guide Assessment Criteria Assessors Comments
LEVEL 4 Records for HSE measurements
Division/site recognized are available on locations and
as a leader in the trends are openly discussed as
particular aspect of the part of the improvement process.
management system Proactive approach to simplify
records as much as possible.
LEVEL 3 Systematic collection of data with
This particular aspect of the few minor omissions. Some
management system is being review of data to check trends
addressed systematically. and create useful statistics.
Reaching the respective targets.
Integration with other activities
initiated
SCORE:
SCORE:
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________