Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Save Lives!
Make Hospitals Safe in Emergencies.
RECAP
Regional emergency collaboration, action and preparedness
EMERGENCY and HUMANITARIAN ACTION Special Issue | World Health Day 2009
Hyogo, Japan
A Model Approach to Disaster Risk Reduction
In the early morning of telecommunications, electrical Other advances were the The Hyogo Emergency
17 January 1995, a magnitude supply, as well as shortage renewal of the Emergency Medical Center (HEMC) was
7.3 earthquake struck the of medical manpower and Medical Information System established as the main DMC
Hyogo prefecture in Japan. damage to equipment led (EMIS), establishment of a in Hyogo in August 2003. As
Known hence as the Great to an overwhelming failure Disaster Medical Assistance of January 2008, there were
Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake of hospitals and health care Team (DMAT), education and 15 DMCs in Hyogo. Sitting at
or the Kobe Earthquake, the delivery services. training of medical staff on the core of the disaster health
quake affected 1.7 million The earthquake exposed disaster medicine, amendment management system, these
people in its immediate the vulnerabilities and of the National/Local centres have the capacity to
aftermath and left 6533 dead limitations of the existing Disaster Response Plan and, provide health services non-
and 43 792 injured. More disaster response and mutual cooperation among stop, utilize the EMIS, support
than half a million homes preparedness efforts of neighbouring fire departments. continued on page 2
Hyogo, Japan: A Model continued addition to these functional remodeling efforts, Hyogo reduction in a comprehensive,
a high patient load (including requirements, DMCs are has already far exceeded multi-disciplinary manner.
long-distance transfers), treat required to possess anti- pre-disaster development The reconstruction of the
serious emergency cases (such seismic structures and other levels. It is clear that Hyogo, affected areas and the
as multiple trauma), store reinforcements to maintain has learnt a valuable lesson. remodeling of the disaster
emergency relief goods and structural integrity in the face On the tenth year anniversary health management system
materials, and train medical of future disasters. of the disaster, Hyogo hosted highlighted the key roles
staff in disaster medicine. Fourteen years the World Conference on of health services, health
Doctors acting as Disaster after the Great Hanshin Disaster Reduction during human resources, health
Medical Coordinators are Earthquake, due to the which the Hyogo Framework information systems,
nominated for each centre. In massive reconstruction and for Action (HFA) 2005- and training in disaster
2015, a blueprint to guide preparedness and response.
disaster risk reduction efforts The creative reconstruction of
worldwide, was drafted. Hyogo received tremendous
One HFA key activity is legislative and financial
‘’integrating disaster risk support, and sparked debates
reduction planning into the on how to further increase
health sector and promoting advocacy of stakeholders and
the goal of hospitals safe hospital administrators to
from disasters’’. hospital safety.
The experience of Hyogo Presented by Takashi Ukai,
is an excellent paradigm for MD, PhD, of the Hyogo Emergency
the vulnerability of hospitals Medical Center, Humanitarian
to disasters, the impact of Medical Assistance, during the
hospital failure in disasters Regional Meeting on Safe Hospitals,
and emergencies, and of the 8-10 December 2008, Phnom Penh,
need to approach disaster risk Cambodia
Viewpoint: From Quality Patient continued our future and our family’s future, In this early stage of my appreciation of the importance of
safe patient care, that best effort but also for the sake of our client- experience with the safe hospital a safe hospital initiative by all staff,
is enough in emergencies, and that patients, the raison d’etre of our campaign, in both private and full commitment and support of
disasters rarely affect hospitals. hospital. Making our hospitals safe government hospital settings, I feel the leaders, full cooperation and
If I were a patient, I would ike should also be considered part of there must be commitment and collaboration of the staff, and a sense
to be provided quality medical care, our personal citizenry, our hospitals’ full support from top management of social responsibility, a safe hospital
one that is associated with a correct social responsibility. Making our to get the safe hospital initiative can be developed, gradually and in
diagnosis and accurate and effective hospitals resilient in order to be able implemented. In private hospital due time. One can start complying
treatment with minimal side-effects. to handle victims of mass casualty settings, once there is commitment with the functional requirements of a
I would also like to be provided with incidents and prevent massive loss and full support from top safe hospital and placing mitigating
a safe management regimen, one of life and limb will contribute to management, resources needed measures for the structural and non-
that will NOT subject me to a high a faster post-disaster economic to fulfill the requirements for safe structural requirements if they cannot
risk for complications and death, recovery. hospital development are relatively be remedied at once.
and not to say, medical Being both a hospital easier to procure than in government Needless to say, safe hospital
errors. Furthermore, I Making our manager and a medical hospital settings. In public development will reduce the
would like to be treated hospitals safe practitioner in government institutions, however, budgetary probability of a building collapsing
in a safe hospital, one should also be and private hospitals, I have constraints, administrative protocols during a disaster and will allow the
that will NOT collapse considered part expanded quality patient and organizational behaviour have hospital to continue to function
during earthquakes of our personal care to patient safety to always been challenges. With lack of during emergencies. Safe hospitals
which may occur when citizenry, our safe hospitals from 2003 financial resources, the structural and will avoid loss of properties, lives of
I am in the hospital hospitals’ social to present. Thanks to the non-structural requirements for a safe patients and staff, and increase its
and one that will NOT responsibility. campaign of the World hospital development are the hardest surge capacity to function in times
burn me to death when Health Organization’s global to comply with. A well-organized of need. In short, hospital managers
there is an accidental fire. I suppose alliances on patient safety and safe and collaborative emergency and should look at the benefits of the
any human being, regardless of hospitals which have opened my disaster committee is essential in safe hospital initiative in terms of
position in the society, would want eyes and which have facilitated this fulfilling the functional requirements reducing risk, protecting health
the same things that I wish for in a expansion and shifting of paradigm. for a safe hospital development. No facilities, and saving lives. I hope in
hospital. On the disaster aspect, I started with matter what the constraints are in the near future I will be using and
All hospital managers will one continual development of disaster a hospital setting, whether public seeing slogans like “Our hospital is
day most likely be a patient seeking preparedness plans focusing on or private, as long as there is full safe.”
treatment in a hospital and wishing response plans and drills on patient
11 March 2009
the same things. As early as now, we surge, fire and earthquake. Lately, I
should start expanding and shifting am now focusing on the structural Reynaldo O. Joson, MD
the paradigm to include patient safety of the hospitals with which I Assistant Medical Director, Manila Doctors Hospital
safety and safe hospital, not only for am connected. Chairperson, Department of Surgery, Ospital ng Maynila Medical Center
Philippines
Safe Hospitals Start with Safe Buildings
Philippines: Safe Buildings continued design. Other considerations aware and understand that the is an essential element in
infrastructures? Does climate include the choice of location, infrastructure they build should the campaign but in order to
change have any impact on the types of materials to be used, withstand disasters. achieve resilient facilities, the
safety of buildings? compliance to Building safe health entire spectrum of construction
Safe hospitals
Architects and building and infrastructures covers a variety of from policies to design and
start with architects
engineers who occupancy permits, existing concerns in our society. implementation must be taken
and engineers who
can build safe and the capability These include policies on the part of into consideration. This is why
understand and can
health facilities of construction government officials and hospital collaboration among government
design buildings with
must adhere to the companies and administrators, implementation of agencies, academic institutions and
disaster reduction in
country’s building individual workers. laws, regulation of professionals, the private sector is crucial.
mind.
codes, considering The choice of awareness and training of the Based on the presentation
the integrity of the structural and location is crucial for a hospital to construction sector, finance and of Arch Cristopher Espina of the
roof frames with the types of survive floods, earthquakes and resource management, close University of the Philippines, College
disasters that occur in a particular strong winds. The auxiliary who monitoring of projects and human of Architecture, during the Regional
locality. build the foundation, prepare the resource development. Meeting on Safe Hospitals, 8-10
But safety of hospitals in concrete mixture and complete Inclusion of safe hospitals in December 2008, Phnom Penh,
disasters extends beyond the the rest of the building must be academic and training programmes Cambodia
uniquely diverse natural landscape structural failures. Health personnel, destruction from natural disasters. response, Malaysia has
and topography, is host to an as much a pillar of the health To name a few, Wewak Hospital taken a more proactive
equally diverse array of natural system as the elements that keep stands on a tsunami risk area while stance, rather than
hazards, making it the most the hospital standing, are equally Kimbe Hospital is flanked by not its reactive approach
vulnerable to natural disasters vulnerable. Many hospital staff one but two active volcanoes. Lae from before. Hospitals
among the Pacific island Member with chronic respiratory problems, Hospital, the only national referral serve as vital centres of
States. Papua New Guinea is such as asthma, were forced to hospital for cancer patients, stands communication during
situated on the boundary between transfer. With structural damage on a tectonic fault which puts it at disasters. Information
the Pacific and the Australian and functional losses, as well as loss constant risk from earthquakes that in times of crises is an
tectonic plates and has eight active of health personnel, the remaining can cause spillage of radioactive essential resource and
volcanoes. Hazards that continually hospital staff suffered from very low material. hospitals are a critical part
plague the country include volcanic morale. Thus, there is a need to of the communication
eruptions, earthquakes, tsunamis, The economic impact of this strengthen policies on site selection, network that must be
tropical cyclones, large-scale disaster was due to loss of expensive construction and development of in place in times of
landslides, flooding, sporadic hospital health facilities emergencies. Hospitals
droughts, frosts in highland areas, equipment Past experiences and ever- in Papua New need to establish and
and rising sea levels brought and high present hazards continuously Guinea. Similar maintain efficient and
about by climate change. Tsunamis maintenance emphasize the pressing need to the experience effective communication
and landslides occur secondary cost for for new policies to ensure of Fiji, past with all agencies involved.
to earthquakes that occur with buildings, hospitals safe from disasters. experiences and In Malaysia, emphasis
regularity throughout the year. There equipment, ever-present has been placed on
is also a high risk of technical and and vehicles. For the hospital’s hazards in Papua New Guinea establishing swift and clear
human-generated disasters, such remaining staff, the cost of living continuously emphasize the communication during
as oil spills, industrial pollution and became increasingly burdensome, pressing need for new policies to disasters; the nation is
unregulated and destructive land- and hardship allowance was thus ensure hospitals safe from disasters, strengthening its intra-
use practices. introduced as part of their benefits. as well as policies on minimum agency communication
In 1994, the Nonga General Over the next years, Nonga General standards for hospital safety. As a (seamless bottom-to-top
Hospital was closed due to damages Hospital would be closed and prerequisite to these, there exists transfer of information
inflicted by the eruption of the reopened several times due to the the need to increase advocacy and and vice versa) as well
Rabaul volcano, one of the country’s volcanic eruptions. awareness of politicy makers, health as improving its inter-
most active volcanoes. Immediate After more than a decade, the professionals and the communities. networking (establishment
damages, such as structural government finally granted the Presented by Dr Victor Golpak, of medical emergency
collapses, were noted due to the request for hospital relocation to a Papua New Guinea Ministry of call centres nationwide
weight of volcanic dust and debris. safer zone. However, several other Health, during the Regional Meeting with direct links to lead
Over time, volcanic dust and toxic hospitals in the country continue on Safe Hospitals, 8-10 December government emergency
emission of sulfur dioxide gas to stand in hazardous areas which 2008, Phnom Penh, Cambodia agencies). Malaysia is
resulted in corrosion of currently updating its
building materials and emergency response
air-conditioning units, plans in order to provide
as well as corrosive equitable access to health
damage to hospital care both in and out of
equipment. Beds were disasters. An ounce of
reduced from 450 to prevention is still worth
a mere 30 beds for more than a pound of cure.
emergency use. Having Presented by Dr Ahmad
its operating rooms Tajuddin Mohamad Nor and Dr
closed, the hospital Mohd Safiee bin Ismail of the
also lost its capacity to Ministry of Health of Malaysia
conduct major surgeries. during the Regional Meeting on
The depth of Safe Hospitals, 8-10 December
damage to the hospital 2008, Phnom Penh, Cambodia
For more information about Emergency and Humanitarian Action in the Western Pacific Region, The Regional Roll Out of the Safe Hospitals Campaign Editorial Staff:
contact:
is supported by the European Commission
Humanitarian Aid department Dr Arturo M Pesigan
EMERGENCY and HUMANITARIAN ACTION
Dr Lester Sam Geroy
World Health Organization E-mail: eha@wpro.who.int Dr Rene Andrew Bucu
Regional Office for the Western Pacific Phone: +632 5289810 Dr Paul Andrew Zambrano
United Nations Avenue, PO Box 2932 Facsimile: +632 5289072 Ms Glessie Salajog
1000 Manila, Philippines Mr Zando Escultura
RECAP Regional Emergency Collaboration Action and Preparedness is the Newsletter of the Emergency and Humanitarian Action Program of the Regional Office for the Western Pacific of the World Health Organization.
The reported events, activities and programs do not imply endorsement by WHO-WPRO and the statements do not necessarily represent Organization policies.