Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Article History
Received: February 18th, 2015 The unique dual circulation of the liver confers relative protection against ischemic
Accepted: March 23rd, 2015 injury; however, low oxygen tension in the microcirculation (sinusoidal blood of the hepatic
Published: March 24th, 2015 acinus) may render hepatocytes in zone 3 relatively vulnerable to ischemic injury and
necrosis. Severe congestive heart failure is associated with two distinct forms of liver
dysfunction under the umbrella term cardiac hepatopathy. The two entities include: jaundice
Citation
related to passive congestion (congestive hepatopathy from backward cardiac failure) and
Shah SC, Sass DA. Cardiac Hepa-
topathy: A review of liver dysfunc- acute hepatocellular necrosis caused by impaired hepatic perfusion (hypoxic hepatitis from
tion in heart failure. Liver Res Open forward cardiac failure). This article provides a comprehensive, up-to-date review on the topic
J. 2015; 1(1): 1-10. doi: 10.17140/ and focuses on the epi- demiology, pathology, pathogenesis, clinical manifestations,
LROJ-1-101 diagnostic testing and treatment strategies pertaining to liver disease in circulatory failure.
INTRODUCTION
The relationship between cardiac and hepatic dysfunction has been a well-recognized
entity for over two centuries.1 Yet, the complexity and nuances of the association still remain
a topic of intense interest and research. Studies dealing with this topic are relatively few, not
rarely with contradictory results. There are several reasons for the variant results: heart failure
etiology has changed over the years, being mainly related to rheumatic valvular disease in the
Copyright earliest studies and to ischemic cardiomyopathy more recently.2 Also, the outcome of heart
2015 Sass DA. This is an open failure has dramatically improved due to superior medical therapies, not to mention
access article distributed under the widespread use of heart transplantation. Thus, cardiac cirrhosis, once the paradigm of liver
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
involvement in heart failure, is now rare.
International License (CC BY 4.0),
which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in Concomitant hepatic and cardiac disorders may be categorized according to etiology.
any medium, provided the original That is: (i) cardiac disease affecting the liver, (ii) hepatic disease affecting the heart, or (iii)
work is properly cited.
cardiac and hepatic disease secondary to a shared etiology.3,4 In this review, we chose to fo-
Macrocirculation
Microcirculation
CONGESTIVE HEPATOPATHY
Histopathology and
Pathogenesis
Figure 1: Cut surface of the congested liver reminiscent of the classic nutmeg appearance
which is caused by chronic passive congestion of the central veins with hemorrhage and
necro- sis in zone 3. Red cells pool and distend the sinusoids around the central vein. These
regions develop a darker red-violet color, in contrast to the surrounding tan liver parenchyma.
F
e Other common, yet
a nonspecific, findings include
t pe- ripheral edema, pleural
u effusion, splenomegaly, and
r jaundice (Table 1). Ascites is
e also clinically present in up
s to 20% of pa- tients with
congestive hepatopathy
Figure 2: H/E section of liver (10x In the majority of (although 41% at autopsy
magnification) with sinusoidal dilation in
zone 3. As the severity of the lesion patients, the clinical picture is have ascites).25 However, it
increases, the sinusoids around the central
vein become distended with extravasated domi- nated by signs and must be noted that the ascites
red cells and there is adjacent hepatocyte
plate atrophy.
symptoms of right-sided heart is a result of right-sided heart
failure rather than those of failure and not intrinsic liver
liver disease (Table 1). dysfunc- tion, as is the case in
I Hepatomegaly is the most other causes of cirrhosis.
n
c common manifestation with Although the Se- rum ascites-
i reports as high as 95% to albumin gradient (SAAG) is
d 99% in acute or chronic heart greater than 1.1 g/dL,
e failure. A mild, dull, right consistent with portal
n
c
upper quadrant pain is often hypertension, the ascitic fluid
e present and is likely protein level is
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
characteristically high, and Open
oftentimes >2.5 g/dL. This Journal
high pro- tein content is an
indication of the preserved
synthetic function of the
liver,26 a finding unique to
cardiac cirrhosis and critical
in differentiating it from
other causes of cirrhosis. The
under- lying
pathophysiology of cardiac
ascites remains uncertain,
but some have proposed that
sinusoidal hypertension with
disrup- tion of fenestrae
ultimately allows for
exudation of a protein rich
fluid.6,26 Other useful ascitic
fluid parameters are the
Lactate de- hydrogenase
(LDH), and red cell counts,
as these generally tend to be
higher in cardiac cirrhosis.26
Congestive changes
can readily be seen on
abdominal imaging. Liver
ultrasonography typically
shows hepatomegaly with a
homogeneous increase in
echogenicity throughout the
liv- er and dilation of the
suprahepatic veins and
Inferior Vena Cava (IVC).
Computed tomography and
magnetic resonance imaging
will similarly demonstrate
hepatomegaly, distension of
the he- patic veins and IVC,
early reflux of contrast
material from the right
atrium to the IVC, and a
heterogeneous, mottled-
appearing liver parenchyma,
often referred to as a mosaic
pattern, which corresponds
to the nutmeg liver seen on
gross inspection.27 As- cites,
pleural and pericardial
effusions are also frequently
report- ed.
In terms of
hemodynamic parameters,
heart failure pa- tients
exhibit an increased right
atrial pressure and the free
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
Open
Journal
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
wedged hepatic venous Open
et al. correlated alterations in useful than albumin level at
pressures are also commonly Liver Function TestsJournal
(LFTs) Decreased albumin tracking progression of
elevated, with a normal with either acute or chronic (seen in about 30-50% of cardiac he- patopathy based
hepatic venous pressure decompensated right-sided cases) is a very nonspecific on the observation that PT
gradient.28,29 This finding of heart failure regardless of finding, as it is fails to correct with Vitamin
normal intrahepatic portal etiology or severity of heart overwhelmingly common in K34 but does usually correct
pressures is clinically disease.25 hospitalized patients and with compensation of heart
relevant and likely underlies, In acute dysfunction, both those with chronic diseases. failure, suggesting a direct
at least in part, the minimal excretory function and With re- spect to synthetic effect on hepatic synthesis.
hepatic symptoma- tology parenchymal destruction were function, Prothrombin Time The PT is mildly abnormal in
associated with the majority most pronounced, while a (PT) may be more 80% of cases. Although
of cases of cardiac hepatopa- cholestatic pattern was most serum ammonia level is
thy. pronounced in chronic occasionally increased,
decompensation, findings that hepatic encephalopathy is not
Histologically, have been corroborated in a a salient feature of congestive
relative sparing of the portal more recent study by Myers heart failure.35
tracts from fibrosis a et al.2
distinguishing factor of T
cardiac cirrhosis compared to Elevated serum r
e
other etiologies of cirrhosis bilirubin is also a common
a
as previously noted also finding in car- diac t
likely contributes to the lack hepatopathy, except perhaps m
of stigmata classically in constrictive pericarditis,31,32 e
associated with portal with reports of mild elevation n
t
hypertension. Spider (usually <3 mg/dL and
angiomata and portosystemic mostly unconjugated) in up
The cornerstone of
shunts like hemorrhoidal to 70% of patients.6,15,25 The
management of all forms of
plexus varices, caput hyperbiliru- binemia in
con- gestive hepatopathy,
medusae, and esopha- geal congestive heart failure is
from asymptomatic, mild
varices are very rarely, if at multifactorial and likely
elevations in he- patic indices
all, present in cases of results from a combination of
to cardiac cirrhosis is targeted
cardiac hepatopathy.6,15,30 hepatocellular dysfunction,
toward treating the
Even with progression to ob- struction secondary to
underlying cardiac
cirrhosis, hepatic symptoms passive congestion and
dysfunction and any triggers
and manifestations of portal pressure atrophy of the
accounting for acute
hypertension do not pre- canaliculi, pulmonary
decompensation.
dominate, which is again in infarction, bile thrombi,
Reversibility of biochemical
contrast to cirrhosis of other hemolysis, and
aberrations in cardiac
etiolo- gies. medications.1,31 Increases in
hepatopathy was described as
the serum bilirubin have been
early as 1930 when Jol- liffe
Congestive heart shown to correlate with the
et al. reported normalization
failure results in a broad severity of right atrial
of liver biochemistries with
range of liver biochemical pressure and passive
restoration of appropriate
abnormalities. Generally, a congestion.1,33 Bilirubin is
cardiac function.24
hepatocellular pattern with significantly more elevated in
predominantly elevated patients with physical exam
Jaundice, hepatic
transaminases is seen in findings of volume overload,
congestion and ascites may
hypoxic hepatitis, which is a such as S3 gallop or
respond dramatically to
rare occurrence given that the pulmonary crackles, thus
therapy with diuretics;
liver is rela- tively protected implicating its value as a
however these drugs should
from hypoperfusion and prognostic factor and
be used with caution to avoid
hypoxia. More contem- indicator of more severe
dehydration, hypotension and
porary research describes the hemodynamic dysfunction.4
hepatic ischemia by
biochemical profile in Despite the common finding
precipitating zone 3
congestive heart failure as of hyperbilirubine- mia, the
necrosis.36 It is of vital
mostly cholestatic. In their presence of clinical jaundice
importance to maintain an
study in the 1960s, Richman is not common.
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
adequate cardiac output. Open
function typically remains
Serial large-volume Journal
stable and even when cardiac
paracenteses can relieve cirrhosis and ascites ensue,
symptoms in those with patients with congestive
diuretic-refractory tense hepatopathy rarely develop
cardiac ascites6,37,38 but over other features of hepatic
time can lead to protein loss insufficiency.1 Fulminant
and exacerbate the protein liver failure, although
malnutrition com- monly documented, seems to be
seen in those with advanced restricted to those with
heart failure. Transjugular superimposed ischemic liver
Intrahepatic Portosystemic injury rather than passive
Shunts (TIPS) or peritoneal- congestion alone.45,46
venous shunts are contra-
indicated in this population Several studies have
as they can lead to addressed the prognostic
exacerbation of the impor- tance of liver
underlying heart failure. function abnormalities in
Cautious use of predicting short and
anticoagulants is advised
because patients have a
baseline mild increase in
PT/INR and are especially
sensitive to warfarin and
other related compounds.39 In
patients refractory to medi-
cal therapy who are suitable
operative candidates, both
LVAD implantation40,41 and
cardiac transplantation42 have
been shown to improve and
reverse the congestive liver
injury associated with the
failing heart. In select
patients with established
cirrho- sis, combined heart
and liver transplant is a
feasible option.43
Recently, there has been a
report of possible reversal of
cardiac cirrhosis with heart
transplantation alone,
effectively removing the
source of the insult.44
However, such cases are the
excep- tion.
P
r
o
g
n
o
s
i
s
Despite the
potential nonspecific and
variable symp- tomatology,
hypoxic hepatitis is more
commonly diagnosed in-
cidentally with routine liver
function tests anywhere from
2-24 hours after an episode
of systemic hypotension.
Laboratory abnormalities in
hypoxic hepatitis are
consistent with a hepato-
cellular pattern. First, there is
a marked increase in
aminotrans- ferases and
Lactate dehydrogenase
(LDH), with AST and LDH
rising most sharply and
peaking in the first 12-48
hrs, while the rise and peak
ALT is not as dramatic.50,59
Moreover, maximal el-
evation of ALT is less than
AST and given the longer
half-life of
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
Open
Journal
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
ALT, it reaches normal coagu- lopathy, whichOpen
can be certain, as one report found ten is not a true hepatic
levels later than AST. Even Journal
asymptomatic or symptomatic that hypoxic hepatitis was encephalopathy and is
so, the ami- notransferase and most often related to the only an independent risk actually a conse- quence of
levels characteristically fall underlying etiology. Bilirubin factor in those requiring the inciting factor leading to
by greater than 50% within may be mildly elevated and vasopressor therapy.50 hypoxic brain damage.
72 hours of resolution of the tends to peak after the Importantly, the cause of
underlying insult and return transaminases and LDH lev- death is usually not due to
to normal within 7-10 els begin to decline. The hepatic fail- ure but related to Because this entity is
days.34,50,60 Increases in LDH effects of systemic the underlying precipitating essentially an observed
level tend to be massive and hypotension are not isolated factor itself, such as sepsis or labora- tory abnormality,
ALT/LDH ratio of less than to the liver, and increases in cardiac decompensation.50,53 albeit an alarming one,
1.5 often distin- guishes creatinine level from acute Moreover, although en- treatment is targeted at
ischemic injury from other tubular necrosis are nearly cephalopathy is frequently identifying and addressing
forms of acute hepatitis.61 It universal early in the clinical noted in hypoxic hepatitis, it the inciting event. Awareness
is of interest to note that the course. most of- of potential exacerbating
liver may not retain its factors, such as mechanical
normal archi- tecture after The differential ventilation or
regeneration if the reticular diagnosis for hypoxic vasoconstrictors that may
framework is damaged. The hepatitis includes acute viral compromise hepatic blood
most common compensatory hepatitis, autoimmune flow, as well as metabolic
responses seem to be either hepatitis, drug-induced liver monitoring to prevent
thickening of hepatocellular injury (e.g. acetaminophen), derangements like hy-
plates with preservation of acute Wilsons disease and poglycemia and lactic
trabe- cular and cord-like acute vascular thrombosis e.g. acidosis50 are essential. Also
pattern or nodular masses of hepatic artery and portal vein important is recognizing that
hepatocytes.19,62 thrombo- sis. While viral other organs may be
The latter, known as nodular hepatitis and alcoholic implicated, including ini-
regenerative hyperplasia, is hepatitis can usually be tiation of systemic
less common but can differentiated from hypoxic inflammatory response
manifest as a grossly granular hepatitis based on the syndrome with pos- sible
or nodular liv- er.18 ALT:AST and AST:ALT disseminated intravascular
ratios, respectively, it may be coagulation,64 new or
The integrity of difficult to differentiate drug- worsened respiratory
hepatic synthetic function is induced hepatitis from compromise with
also com- promised in hypoxic hepatitis. hepatopulmonary syndrome,65
hypoxic hepatitis, as car- diac compromise with
determined by PT/INR. If the T
myocardial infarction, or
INR remains above 1.5 r renal compro- mise with
despite adequate stores of e acute kidney injury.
a
Vitamin K, the diagnosis of t
acute liver failure is m Several experimental
appropriate.63 Synthetic func- e therapies have been
tion is also of prognostic n
t described. To improve
importance, with INR above hepatosplanchnic blood flow,
2.0 associ- ated with an infusion of renal-dose do-
independent increase in Early recognition
pamine66 has been suggested,
mortality.50 and management is critical
but to date no proven clinical
and is the primary prognostic
ben- efit has been shown.
Elevated lactate is factor. The importance of
Adenosine infusion has been
also a common biochemical recognizing hy- poxic
used in animal models but
ab- normality in hypoxic hepatitis is underscored by
there are no human data to
hepatitis although Fuhrmann reports of associated
support its use in this set-
et al. noted its lack of mortality in Intensive Care
ting. Other investigators have
independent predictive value Unit (ICU) patients of over
suggested a role of
in mortality.50 Rarely, 50%.50,53 However, its role as
antioxidants6 or N-
laboratory abnormalities can an independent risk factor in
acetylcysteine,67 however
even include consumptive ICU patients is still un-
these findings are only
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
limited to case reports and However, because Open this
thus need to be corroborated hepatic ailment occurs Journal
in the
in randomized controlled critically ill patients, survival
trials. Nitric oxide has in most series is rather poor.
shown some promise, given In the largest pub- lished
its role as an endothelin series to date (142 episodes
antagonist and consequent in 10 years of surveillance):
ability to counter the 1-month and 1-year
vasoconstriction of hepatic survivals were 53% and 28%
vascular beds in ischemia.68 respec- tively.53 Fulminant
Similarly, research has been hepatic failure rarely occurs
focused on angiotensin and seems to be restricted to
receptor II blockers and ACE patients with longstanding
inhibitors as possible congestive heart failure,
antagonists of Renin- cardiac cirrhosis45 or other
angiotensin-aldosterone forms of chronic liver
system (RAAS) activation, a disease.
pathway very much
implicated in hypoxic
hepatitis.69 Molecular Adsor-
bent Recirculating System
(MARS) and single-pass
albumin dialysis, both of
which have shown benefit in
acute and acute- on-chronic
liver failure, have also been
researched as potential
therapeutic modalities in
hypoxic hepatitis but with
uncertain benefit.70-72 To
date, no liver-specific
treatments have been prov-
en to improve outcome.
Furthermore, hypoxic
hepatitis is not an indication
for liver transplantation as
the hepatic derangements are
reversible with correction of
the underlying disorder.
P
r
o
g
n
o
s
i
s
The majority of
patients with hypoxic
hepatitis follow a benign
self-limited course with
complete resolution of
transami- nases to normal
values within 3 to 7 days of
the inciting event.57
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
Open
Journal
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
C The authors have
Open & hepatol. 2009; 3(1): 51- 8. Rappaport AM. The
O no conflicts of Journal 64. doi: microcirculatory hepatic unit.
N 1 Microvasc
C
interest to
disclose. 0 Res. 1973; 6: 212-228.
L
U . doi: 10.1016/0026-
S PE 1 2862(73)90021-6
I RS 5
O O 8
N
9. Rappaport AM. Hepatic
NA 6
L blood flow: morphologic
/ aspects and
Hepatic injury as a AC
KN 1 physiologic
consequence of cardiac O 7 regulation. Int Rev
disease is a relatively W 4 Physiol. 1980; 21: 1-
common, but often poorly LE 7 63.
recognized, syndrome. An D 4
GE
understanding of the hepatic 1
M 10. Megalla S, Holtzman D,
circulation and normal liver EN 2
Aronow WS, et al. Prediction
archi- tecture is important to TS 4
. of cardiac hepatopathy in
appreciate how the
3 patients with right heart
hemodynamic changes of The authors wish to thank
. failure. Med Sci Monit. 2011;
heart failure affects the liver, Suganthi Soundararajan, MD,
1 17(10): 537-541.
leading to the associated De- partment of Pathology,
clini- cal, biochemical and Drexel University College of .
5 11. Hoffman BT, Pate MB,
histologic features. The Medicine, Philadelphia, PA
1 Marsh WH, Lee WM.
hepatic manifesta- tions of for kindly providing the
Cardiomyo- pathy
congestive hepatopathy pictures.
4. Naschitz J, Slobodin G, unrecognized as a cause of
and hypoxic hepatitis may
Lewis R, Zuckerman E, hepatic failure. J Clin Gas-
range from mild liver enzyme R
E Yeshurun D. Heart diseases troenterology 1990; 12(3):
abnormalities to progressive
F affecting the liver and liver 306-309. doi:
liver injury and, rarely, liver
E diseases affect- ing the heart. 10.1097/00004836-
failure. A team approach R Am Heart J. 2000; 140(1): 1
characterized by E
111-120. doi: 10.1067/ 9
collaboration amongst both N
C mhj.2000.107177 9
cardiologists and
E 0
hepatologists is critical for S 5. Lautt WW, Greenway 0
optimizing patient care and 6
maximizing positive CV. Conceptual review of
1. Sherlock S. The liver in hepatic vascular bed. 0
outcomes. heart failure: relation of 0
Hepatology. 1987; 7: 952-
anatomical, functional, and 963. doi: 10.1002/ 0
C -
circulatory changes. Br heart hep.1840070527
O
J. 1951; 13: 273- 0
N
F 2 0
6. Giallourakis C, Rosenberg
L 9 0
P, Friedman L. The liver in
I 3 1
C heart failure. Clin Liver Dis. 5
. 2002; 6(4): 947-967.
T
S
2. Myers R, Cerini R, Sayegh 12. Aboulhosn JA, Oudiz RJ,
7. Wong F, Greenbloom S,
O R, et al. Cardiac Hepatopathy: Dave AS, Ardehali A, Ross
F Blendis L. The liver in heart
Clinical, hemodynamic, and DJ. Suc- cessful tricuspid
failure. In: Friedman L,
histologic characteristics and valve replacement in a patient
I Keeffe E. Handbook of Liver
N cor- relations. Hepatology. with severe pul- monary
Disease. 2nd Ed. Churchill
T 2003; 37(2): 393-400. doi: arterial hypertension and
Livingstone; 2004.
E 10.1053/ jhep.2003.50062 preserved right ventricular
R sys- tolic function. Case Rep.
E
S 3. Moller S, Dumcke C, Krag Med. 2009. doi:
T A. The heart and the liver. 10.1155/2009/108295
Ex- pert Rev Gastroenterol
LIVER RESEARCH
ISSN 2379-4038 http://dx.doi.org/10.17140/LROJ-1-101
13. Sheth AA, Lim JK. 159-166. Open
Liver disease from Journal
asymptomatic con- strictive 19. Lefkowitch J, Mendez L.
pericaditis. J. Clin Morphologic features of
Gastroenterology 2008; hepatic in- jury in cardiac
42(8): 956- disease and shock. Journal of
958. doi: Hepatology. 1986;
10.1097/ 2(3): 313-327. doi:
MCG.0b 10.1016/S0168-
013e3180 8278(86)80043-5
31915c
20. Allen L, Felker G,
14. Harding MB, Harrison Pocock S, et al. Liver
JK, Davidson CJ, Kisslo KB, function abnormali- ties and
Bashore TM. Critical mitral outcome in patients with
stenosis causing ischemic chronic heart failure: data
hepatic failure. Successful from the Candesartan in
treatment by percutaneous Heart Failure: Assessment of
balloon mitral valvotomy. Reduction in Mortality and
Chest 1992; 101(3): 866- Morbidity(CHARM)
889. doi: program. Eur J Heart Fail-
10.1378/chest.101.3.866 ure. 2009; 11(2):170-177.
doi: 10.1093/eurjhf/hfn031
15. Dunn G, Hayes P, Breen
K, Schenker S. The liver in
conges- tive heart failure: a
review. Am J Med Sci.
1973; 265(3): 174-
1
8
9
.