Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
06 Regional Economic
Integration in the
Bay of Bengal
12
Bridging the
Persons with Difficulties
in the Sri Lankan
Labour Market
Inquiry into the Key Social and Sri Lanka and the Pivot to Asia
Inside IPS : Saman Kelegama
Top Policy Researcher with a
61 Colombo 07, Sri Lanka
Tel: +94 11 2143100, +94 11 2665068
Cultural Constraints in the New Global Order Mission In a Nutshell URL: www.ips.lk
Blog: Talking Economics
Web: www.ips.lk/talkingeconomics
Twitter: www.twitter.com/TalkEconomicsSL
Copyright and Disclaimer
All material published in the Talking Economics Digest are copyright of the Institute of Policy Studies of Sri Lanka (IPS), unless otherwise specified. It cannot be quoted without due Design/Layout
acknowledgement to the IPS and the author. It cannot be reproduced in whole or in part, without the written permission of the IPS. The content, comments and posts of the Talking
Economic Digest and the IPS blog represent the views of individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the IPS. Shiran Sabar - Frontallobe Innovations
2 3
Condolence Message A Visionary, whose Legacy was
by the IPS Board on Built on Humility and Humanity
the Passing of In Appreciation of Dr. Saman Kelegama, by the Staff of the Institute of Policy Studies of Sri Lanka
Dr. Saman Kelegama Those of us who have been fortunate enough to work with Dr. Saman Kelegama during his long and distinguished tenure at the
Institute of Policy Studies of Sri Lanka (IPS), first as a Research Fellow from 1990 and then at the helm as its Executive Director
from 1995, are immeasurably saddened by his sudden demise on Friday 23 June, 2017.
His legacy at the IPS was driven by three core beliefs that he held dear; foster independent thinking, secure financial stability,
It is with deep sadness that we, the members of IPS governing board, received the
and provide an enduring IPS identity. His ideas and vision have bequeathed to us a sense of all that is possible to achieve, if
news of the sudden passing of the Institutes Executive Director, Dr. Saman Kelegama.
there is drive and determination to pursue your dreams.
He embodied IPS from its early days. Saman had worked at IPS since 1990, and led it as
Executive Director since 1995. He spearheaded its expansion. More than anyone, Saman
The culture of independent thought that Dr. Kelegama nurtured has seen innumerable numbers of us returning to the IPS, time
made IPS Sri Lankas leading institution for economic policy research. He built the IPS
after time, on completing post-graduate studies or professional qualifications abroad. His mantra of you are representatives
endowment fund, got its new building constructed, and oversaw its move to its present
of IPS inculcated a spirit of commitment and self-belief in all of us. The liberal, free thinking environment fostered intellectual
offices on Independence Square. It is testament to Samans character and resolve that
growth of the many researchers who have passed through IPS doors and encouraged our team of support service professionals
he protected and preserved the independence and integrity of IPS as a non-partisan
to innovate and deliver. We believe it is this legacy of independent research and engagement in public policy discourse that is
research organisation, free of political bias. That is no mean feat in Sri Lanka. His legacy
Dr. Kelegamas enduring legacy, not only to IPS but to Sri Lanka and the wider regional community.
is a solid institution that will continue to be the lodestar for evidence-based economic
policy in Sri Lanka.
Dr. Kelegama understood from the outset that in order to sustainably build human capital, research capacity, and an efficient and
effective organizational machinery, long-term financial security is a must. He worked tirelessly towards this end from the outset.
We also note that Samans passing is a loss to the government and the country, and
On taking the helm as the Executive Director, his first priority was to secure a financial base for the IPS in 1995. His foresight
not just to IPS. Saman had a long record of public service, having served on numerous
and diligence allowed us to expand our activities over time and weather changes in fortunes when raising research grant funds.
government commissions and advisory boards, which included contributing to the
last Presidential Tax Commission. In the last two years he was especially active in
Dr. Kelegama was also passionately convinced that a growing organization must have an identity that is uniquely its own. This
government service as the leading official and adviser on trade policy in the Ministry of
he envisioned in the form of a permanent office for the IPS, custom built to suit our own requirements. He embarked on this
Development Strategies and International Trade. He played a critical role in Sri Lankas
journey as early as 2000. Again, his vision and foresight was commendable. It took him a further decade in which to realize his
trade negotiations with India, China and Singapore, and contributed to the formulation of
dream, when the IPS head office was ready for occupation in 2010. Through all the years of innumerable delays in obtaining
a new national trade policy strategy.
land and raising funds for construction, Dr. Kelegama persevered tirelessly against all obstacles, and personally oversaw the
project over a three year period until completion. His commitment to bequeathing a beautiful office in which we are so fortunate
Saman will also be missed beyond our island shores. He was a fixture in South Asian and
to work in will never be forgotten.
wider Asian policy networks; and thanks to him IPS is well embedded in these networks.
We are all moved by expressions of condolence from Samans and IPS friends
Through all his pioneering efforts to build a strong and stable organization, Dr. Kelegamas humility and humanity are perhaps
around the world.
what we will remember most. His career is too long and distinguished to detail here, but he was the most modest of men. On
most occasions, we, the staff of IPS, would find out the details of his numerous high profile appointments and accomplishments
The IPS board and staff will ensure IPS builds on Samans legacy. We would also like to
only well after the event or through other sources. Dr. Kelegamas belief was that you just get on with the job. His humility was
take this opportunity to express our heartfelt condolences to Samans wife, son, daughter
only surpassed by his humanity. No personal difficulty faced by a staff member was ever too small for a sympathetic hearing
and other family members.
from him. We must be sympathetic on humane grounds was his second mantra.
Dr. Kelegama left us too soon. We have lost a visionary head and the IPS will never be the same without him. But, we have all
gained from working with him. We want to thank him for his ideas and vision; he inspired us all, and his legacy will live on.
4 5
Regional Economic
Integration in the Bay of Bengal
This article is based on the synopsis of the lecture delivered at the BIMSTEC Secretariat, Dhaka, on 19 February 2016. It originally
appeared on The Daily Star on 25 February 2016.
By Saman Kelegama
This year marked 20 years since the establishment of Bay of Bengal BIMSTEC also envisaged a market driven integration process when it People-to-people contacts can be improved by improving air connectivity The external funder to facilitate BIMSTEC regional integration could be
Initiative for Multi-Sectoral, Technical, and Economic Cooperation first mooted an FTA in 2004. It was supposed to be in full operation and tourism promotion via inter-governmental cooperation in the region. the ADB. The role ADB played in sub-regional cooperation in the Greater
(BIMSTEC), a regional organization involving a group of countries in by 2011, but did not become a reality by then. This is most probably Buddhist circuit is one such example for BIMSTEC tourism promotion. Mekong sub-region is well known. With the concurrence of the BIMSTEC
South Asia and South East Asia, including Sri Lanka. To mark this because some member countries of BIMSTEC questioned the need for member countries, the BTILS project can be initiated by the ADB.
occasion, Dr. Kelegama, Executive Director of IPS, argues that the another FTA when the tariff levels in the region are already low. As it is For sectoral cooperation to be effective, there needs to be strong Thereafter, attracting additional funds to complete the project will not be
two key functional aspects of BIMSTEC, which are market-driven well known, via unilateral liberalization as well as through bilateral and institutions and information. Four areas need particular focus: BIMSTEC a problem. However, duplication with the initiatives of BCIM and BBNI
integration and government-driven integration, should be utilized regional liberalization via the existing FTAs and RTAs (regional trading Secretariat; BIMSTEC Chamber of Commerce and Industry; external needs to be avoided. The Asian Highway that ESCAP suggested sometime
selectively to seek quick gains to the region. arrangements) in the region, the tariff levels have come down. Despite partners, viz., ADB and ESCAP; and interaction of the BIMSTEC network of back can also be part of the BIMSTEC connectivity and ESCAP can
delays, a BIMSTEC FTA still remains in its agenda. think tanks with BIMSTEC officials, and BIMSTEC Chamber. provide technical assistance to drive the project. Japan played a key role
The Bay of Bengal is rich in natural resources and embraces both South with FDI in ASEAN economic integration, likewise ADB and other external
and East Asia. Although a number of regional groupings like Bangladesh- It is argued here that the two key functional aspects of BIMSTEC, which funding led connectivity improvement can catalyze BIMSTEC economic
A strong Secretariat is required to push the activities of the regional integration.
China-India-Myanmar (BCIM) and Bangladesh-Bhutan-Nepal-India (BBNI) are market-driven integration and government-driven integration, should
grouping in between summits. The SAARC Secretariat has proved to
partially cover the region, it is the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi- be utilized selectively to seek quick gains to the region.
be an ineffective body, whereas the ASEAN Secretariat has been able Finally, the role of think tanks cannot be overlooked in regional economic
Sectoral, Technical, and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC) that covers the
to drive the ASEAN agenda of the organization more effectively. The integration. They can play a crucial role as knowledge-partners of
entire region and provides a framework for regional economic integration. As for market integration, BIMSTEC should not have high hopes on an
BIMSTEC Secretariat needs to be similarly empowered like the ASEAN BIMSTEC. It is understood that there is both a Track 1 and Track 2 think
FTA coming into operation. Indications are that it will drag on for a long
Secretariat, and delegated by member states to play a more proactive tank networks for BIMSTEC. Both these tracks can interact with each
BIMSTEC accounts for US$ 2.7 trillion GDP, 21 percent of global time. In this situation, more emphasis should be given on trade facilitation
role in driving the BIMSTEC agenda. This becomes all the more important other and network with the BIMSTEC senior officials and private sector to
population (1.3 billion population) and 7 percent of intra-regional via liberal transit, business-friendly customs, transport corridors, etc.
in the absence of a Charter for BIMSTEC. bring about necessary policy changes to activate sectoral cooperation.
trade. BIMSTEC provides South Asian countries a conduit for economic Such a process will partly address some of the non-tariff barriers in the
cooperation with East Asia countries and a link to East Asian production region and catalyze trade. According to the ESCAP, Trade Facilitation is a When BIMSTEC started, Indias Look East policy coincided with
networks and value chains. It can become a building block of a future more powerful driver of trade than tariff reductions when tariff levels are BIMSTEC working mechanism has six layers: a leaders summit; Thailands Look West policy and there was much enthusiasm to drive
Asian community; however, the progress so far has been exceedingly already low, and this argument is aptly applicable to BIMSTEC. ministerial meetings; senior officials meeting; expert group meetings; the organization by these two member countries to integrate a part of
slow. business and economic forums; and BIMSTEC Working Group (BWG). South Asia to the growing economies of East Asia. But since then, India
As for government-driven integration, it is prudent to focus on a few Basically, leaders summit to expert group meetings are at the inter- and Thailand had embarked on an FTA and India and ASEAN had worked
Launched in 1997, BIMSTEC began as a sectoral cooperation grouping sectoral cooperation projects related to connectivity and people-to- governmental level, and the new BIMSTEC Secretariat has absorbed out an FTA. Thus both these member countries do not have the same
partly to better utilize the natural resources in the region and partly to people contact rather than spreading too thin by focusing on a large all the work of the BWG. The business and economic forums should enthusiasm to push the organization for deeper integration as before.
quicken integration of the region. Sectoral cooperation was broadened number of sectoral cooperation projects. Road, rail and sea transport basically be absorbed by the BIMSTEC Chamber of Commerce and The other member countries are less powerful and passive partners of
by extending it to many selected areas normally referred to as Multi- facilitation through road and rail links, transport corridors, multi-modal Industry located in Colombo, Sri Lanka. The Chamber should closely BIMSTEC. Thus BIMSTEC is no longer a member-driven organization, and
Sectoral Cooperation. Such cooperation is government-driven in contrast systems, transit arrangements, etc., which have been highlighted by the coordinate with the BIMSTEC Secretariat and drive the BIMSTEC in this context, the Secretariat becomes vital in driving the organization.
to mostly market driven integration through an Free Trade Agreement 2009 ADB Study on BIMSTEC Transport Infrastructure and Logistic Study economic integration agenda. The CUTS (India) proposal to have an Clearly, empowering the BIMSTEC Secretariat should become a priority
(FTA). BIMSTEC has identified a number of areas for sectoral cooperation (BTILS) needs to be worked on to improve connectivity. Perhaps digital annual BIMSTEC economic summit should be welcomed and should be of the member countries to keep the BIMSTEC Work Programme moving
such as tourism, fisheries, transport, etc. connectivity may also be considered to strengthen physical connectivity. closely coordinated with the BIMSTEC Chamber. and producing gains to the people of the Bay of Bengal region.
6 7
Combating
In a bid to improve Sri Lankas living standards, the government year olds). The major reasons for economic inactivity were household and other job related skills to improve their employability.
envisages creating one million jobs in the next five years. On average, the duties (47 per cent), studies (20 per cent), and being retired or being too
economy has been creating 60,000 jobs a year from 2011 to 2015. This old to work (21 per cent). A significant proportion of youth are neither in education nor in
employment (NEETS). The proportion of NEETS more than doubles from
Labour Shortages
will need to be more than tripled to reach 200,000 jobs a year to create
one million jobs in five years. This article is mainly concerned with the economically inactive youth. 16 per cent to 37 per cent from 15-19 year olds to 20-24 year olds.
Figure 1 shows that youth enter the labour market late. Part of the delay
With labour shortages being experienced by most industries, one main in entering the labour market is because, youth stay in education longer. Although they spend more time in education, the educational outcomes
by Mobilizing challenge in reaching this goal would be in finding workers. In 2015, Only 11 per cent of 15-19 year olds and 45 per cent of 20-24 year olds of youth are not satisfactory. Of the 25-29 year olds, only 8 per cent
the country had an unemployment rate of 4.7 per cent (according to the are in employment. obtained a degree or a higher level of education. The rest did not have
Labour Force Survey of the Department of Census and Statistics). In any tertiary level qualifications. This indicates that although close to 20
per cent of youth are in education, they are studying to improve skills
Sri Lankas
A large proportion of youth are students (see Figure 1). Around 72 per
Figure 1: What are youth doing? rather than to gain qualifications that would enable them to undertake
cent of 15-19 year olds and 18 per cent of 20-24 year olds are students.
This is not surprising as many are 18 or 19 years old when they do their professional and technical level jobs.
A-levels for the first time. They have to then wait several months to get
Youth to Be
Policies for Improving Youth Labour Force Participation
their results. If selected, most have entered their twenties before entering
20-24 years
Economically Active
universities with four year degrees when they are 22. aim to reform general education so that individuals enter the labour
market when they are 18 years old, or continue to obtain tertiary level
Despite being students, only a small proportion of youth in education are education at universities or vocational training institutions. To achieve
in a university or a vocational training institution. Of the 15 to 24 year this, the efficiency of the education system will need to be improved and
By Nisha Arunatilake and Neluka Gunasekara
olds only 4.7 per cent were in university, and only 4.3 per cent were in restructured.
15-19 years
11.4 0.5 72.0 16.1 Figure 2: Where are the youth studying?
Policies should aim at reducing the transition time between general and
Youth (15 - 24) tertiary education and ensuring that the education courses are completed
1.4 according to a schedule. Improving the efficiency of education will also
help to increase female labour force participation indirectly. If females
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 4.3
enter the labour market in their early twenties, they are more likely to
8.9
Employed Unemp and in Edu/Train Not in LF and in Edu/training NEET* gain several years of experience before their reproductive years. With
prior experience in the labour market, they are more likely to resume
Source: Authors calculations based on Labour Force Survey 2015 data. 4.7
Note: NEET* Neither in Employment nor in Education or Training. Unemployed who are not in education or
School work after their reproductive years than those who never work. On the
training are also usually included in the NEET category.
University
other hand, engaging in education till their late twenties allows females
very little time to gain experience before starting a family.
economy, a small proportion of the economically active are unemployed. Other Edu Inst.
This is because new entrants to the labour market and those who are Improving the quality of tertiary and vocational training, and making them
Vocational/Technical Inst.
changing jobs take time to find jobs - which in economic terms, is called 80.7 more relevant to the market place can improve the early employability of
structural unemployment. Other young people. Further, job-search assistance can facilitate job-matching
and ensure that young people receive training that is in demand in the
A majority of workers for the envisaged new jobs will have to come from market. Given budget constraints, expanding publicly provided vocational
the currently economically inactive population. These consist mainly of training may not be an option. Further, already a variety of institutions
Source: Own calculations based on LFS 2015 data
females, old persons and youth. Hence, policies for creating one million Note: Only students not in the labour force and studying are included in this analysis. are involved in providing vocational and technical training in the country.
jobs will need to specially target these population groups. According to Hence, the way forward would be to streamline the publicly funded
2015 labour force survey data, 75 per cent of the economically inactive vocational training institutions. . Others are either in school (81 per cent), vocational and technical training sector, and encourage more training that
were females. Across age groups, 22 per cent of the inactive individuals in other education institutions or are students who are not attached to are linked to existing vacancies, through partnerships with firms, training
were aged 65 years or more, and 27 per cent of them were youth (15-24 any education institution. Many spend time and money improving their IT providers, and the government.
8 9
of a proper parallel higher education system Owing to this situation, most school leavers in quality among private HEIs. For example,
with the private sectors involvement, and usually find unskilled work or engage in casual the South Asian Institute of Technology
underdeveloped TVET. For example, the Central jobs. For example, calculations based onCensus and Medicine (SAITM) was recognized as
Bank of Sri Lanka (CBSL) Annual Report of of Population and Housing 2012 data show a legitimate degree-awarding institute to
2016 shows that, of the 155,450 students that only 4% (470,000) of the age 25 and award the degree of Bachelor of Medicine and
Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) in 2011, under the
Figure 1: Engaged in Education 15-29 year olds, 2014 University Act, but it has garnered opposition
from state university students and Government
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
doctors due to certain concerns on standards to
be met and maintained, especially with regards
to clinical training. This is mainly because there
15-19
is no proper monitoring mechanism to ensure
the quality of the programmes offered by such
Age
A Challenge in Sri Lankas Quest for School leavers are the prime target for specific
training and skills development programmes
aimed at meeting the skill demands of the
Economic Growth
25-29
country. Thus, a minimum of two years of
training is recommended for students after
School University Other education institute VT Does not attend sitting for O-Levels, to address the skill gaps
By Priyanka Jayawardena Source: Calculated using DCS, LFS 2014 data of school leavers. Training programmes should
be more work-oriented to suit different fields
who were eligible for university entrance from above population have degree level education.
such as hospitality, construction, textile
A-Level exams in 2015/2016, only 18.6% were Further, only around 10% of age 20 and above
and garment sectors, etc. Public-private
admitted to state universities due to limited population have formal professional or technical
training relevant to their occupation. However, partnerships, and schemes of direct recruitment
placements. Consequently, each year, about
125,000 students who qualify have to abandon according to the World Bank study mentioned to the industry through vocational education
According to the Governments Economic Policy major challenge in catering to these emerging Similarly, 75% of employers expect higher- their ambitions to enter a university (Figure 2). above, about 60% of employers expect workers and training institutes, are essential.
Statement issued in October 2016, Sri Lanka skill requirements. In this backdrop, this article skilled workers to possess computer skills in high-skilled occupations to have completed
envisions achieving sustainable development explores some policy options to bridge the and 38% of employers expect similar soft The expansion of higher education opportunities
Figure 2: Performance in National Exams, 2015
by linking the country to global supply chains skill gaps to achieve the Governments stated skills from lower-skilled workers. However, in Sri Lanka have enabled many students,
and increasing trade. The Government hopes objectives. calculations based onCensus of Population who would otherwise have studied abroad, to
125,000
to create more exposure and opportunities and Housing in 2012 show that, of the age 15 Entered to University Qualified Students graduate locally at a considerably lower cost,
for entrepreneurs and skilled professionals in and above population, knowledge in English university
A World Bank study on Building the Skills saving foreign reserves and minimizing the
25,624
various sectors, including the digital economy, for Economic Growth and Competitiveness in literacy (ability to speak, read and write) and outflow of knowledge (referred to as brain
tourism and commercial agriculture, and to Sri Lanka based on a survey of employers computer literacy were around 22% and 23% Qualified to applying
for university NO ENTRY drain).
attain the status of a modern manufacturing perception of skill demand against the skills respectively, indicating a large skills gap. 155,447
economy. In this context, quality higher available in the workforce reveals 56% of However, policy makers have to ensure that
Failed A/Ls
education and training is crucial if the Sri employers consider that high-skilled workers Reasons for the Skill Gaps Sitting for A/L
255,191 100,000 quality and standards are not compromised,
Lankan economy is to move up the value chain should have passed A-Levels, while 70% of through effective monitoring and control
beyond simple production processes and employers consider that low-skilled workers Sri Lankas tertiary enrolment rate is low. Sitting for O/L Failed O/Ls of private providers. The prevailing quality
products. should have passed O-Levels. But the real As of 2014, only 5% of 20-24 year olds were 314,635 130,000
assurance mechanisms and regulatory systems
situation is that, of the age 20 and above enrolled in a university, while another 8% have very narrow coverage, excluding the vast
Sri Lankas human capital is an essential population, only 17% have passed A-Levels, were enrolled in other educational institutions non-state HEIs functioning independently.
resource in achieving the envisaged and another 17% have passed O-Levels and only a 3% of the same age group were
(calculations based on LFS 2014 data). This enrolled in Technical Education and Vocational On the other hand, with regards to vocational technical or vocational education and training,
development goals and transforming the Thus, it is necessary to strengthen the
means that there is a significant gap in meeting Training (TEVT) courses (Figure 1). These training, the transition from school to vocational and 24% think low-skilled workers should
economy into a modern manufacturing one. regulatory mechanism of these institutes by
the skills demand of the country. figures indicate that tertiary enrolment rates in training is not smooth. A majority of school have received training. Thus, this limited
Thus, it is increasingly important for the incorporating new rules and regulations. It is
Sri Lanka are quite low, compared to those of leavers leave the education system after number of workers with higher education acts
country to be equipped with new technological
as a constraint in meeting the labour market crucial, therefore, to identify desired standards
innovations, and an educated workforce with Also, today there is a rapidly growing demand other countries in the region. For instance, Sri their O-Levels and A-Levels. Each year, about
demand for skilled workers. of these institutions with respect to their
market-oriented skills. High quality human for soft skills especially English literacy and Lankas gross tertiary enrolment rate (21%)is 300,000 students sit for O-Levels but only
below the averages for lower middle income student recruitment criteria, fee structure,
resources with expertise in science and IT prowess. Individuals competent in English 50% 60% of them passed O-Levels and
countries (22%) and upper middle income Limited opportunities in the state sector have academic programmes, quality assurance and
technology and a skilled labour force are have access to better quality jobs with higher qualify to sit for A-Levels. Further, each year
necessary, specially to compete globally. Even countries (44%), according to the World Banks about 250,000 students sit for A-Levels but resulted in the emergence of a parallel system accreditation, etc. As in the case of SAITM, and
salaries and benefits in the domestic labour
lower-skilled jobs increasingly require talent market, as well as internationally. The study World Development Indicators of 2014. only 60% of them qualify to enter public of non-state sector higher education, with other institutes offering professional degrees,
and knowledge. As such, vocational training mentioned above reveals that about 80% of universities. Thus, each year about 130,000 the establishment of private higher education the first intake should be allowed only after
and secondary education need to prepare employers expect higher-skilled workers to The main reasons behind Sri Lankas low and 100,000 students leave the school system institutes (HEIs) many of which are affiliated the institute has obtained the compliance
prospective employees for a complex, digital know English and 40% employers expect tertiary enrolment rate are capacity constraints without succeeding at the O-Level and A-Level to foreign universities. There are concerns certification from the relevant professional
work environment. Today, Sri Lanka faces a similar soft skills from less-skilled workers. of the state university system, unavailability examinations, respectively. among many stakeholders about the variability body.
10 11
Figure 1: Proportion of economically active 15 and above population, by gender and prevalence of difficulty Sri Lanka recognizes that every person
WHO IS A PERSON WITH DIFFICULTIES? has a right to earn a living, this include
Any person who, as a result of any deficiency in his physical or mental 90 persons with difficulties. Several policies
capabilities, whether congenital or not, is unable by himself to ensure for 75.6
78.5 and legislation to support persons with
80
himself, wholly or partly, the necessities of life is defined to be a person with BOX 1 disabilities have been enacted or adapted
difficulties in Sri Lanka. 70
in the last 25 years. These include: a) the
60 54.2 Rehabilitation of the Visually Handicapped
51.6
Protection of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act No. 28 of 1996 46.4
50 Trust Fund, Act No.9 of 1992; b); Protection
40 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
29.1 29.7 31.4
30 Act, No.28 of 1996; and, c) the National
16.2 Policy on Disability for Sri Lanka of 2003.
20
10
However, the share of population
0 economically active (i.e., either employed
All Pop with Pop All Pop with Pop All Pop with Pop
difficulties without difficulties without difficulties without
or unemployed) was much less for those
difficulties difficulties difficulties with difficulties, compared to those without
difficulties. This indicates that the labour
Sri Lanka Males Females
market for persons with difficulties is
Source: Constructed using data in Nisha Arunatilake, (2016), Labour Market Characteristics Thematic Report based on Census of Population not as favourable as that for persons
and Housing 2012, United Nations Population Fund, Colombo.
without difficulties (see Figure 1). It is
noteworthy that the unemployment rate
Figure 2: Total employed population, by employment status and prevalence of difficulty
(the unemployed as a per cent of those employed or available
50.0 for work) was lower for persons with difficulties, compared
46
45.0
to persons without difficulties. This is not unusual; when it is
41 difficult to find work, people stop looking for work or give up
40.0 hoping to work.
35.0 33
32
Even the persons with difficulties were more likely to be in
30.0
vulnerable employment (i.e., either unpaid family workers or
25.0 own account workers, who usually do not benefit from social
20.0 security provisions enjoyed by persons working in the formal
16 sector). As shown in Figure 2, close to half (46 per cent) of
15.0
persons with difficulties were own account workers and a
10.0 9
8 larger proportion of them were unpaid family workers. Access
5 to government employment was also less for persons with
5.0 3 3 2 3
difficulties.
-
Total employed without difficulties Total employed population with difficulties
Policy Recommendations
Government employee Semi Government employee Private sector employee
Employer Own account worker Unpaid family worker Given that the proportion of persons aged five and above
Source: Constructed using data in Nisha Arunatilake, (2016), Labour Market Characteristics Thematic Report based
population experiencing a difficulty is notable, it is prudent to
on Census of Population and Housing 2012, United Nations Population Fund, Colombo.Note: For employed population strengthen policies to improve labour market participation of
15 and over.
persons with difficulties.
Chitra is a language teacher at the high school near her home. She is
Labour Market
persons with difficulties.
According to the Census of Population and Housing (2012), 1,617,924
million (or 87 per every 1000 persons aged five and above population Inclusion of persons with difficulties in employment can start with the
public sector. The results show that the public sector can do more to
in the country) have either partial or full difficulties in seeing, hearing,
By Nisha Arunatilake provide employment to persons with difficulties. The share of persons
walking, cognition, self-care or communication. Amongst the different
with difficulties employed in the public sector was less than for persons
types of difficulties, the most prevalent difficulty is in seeing. For every
without difficulties.
1000 persons, 54 persons have difficulties in seeing. Other difficulties (in
order of prevalence) are: walking (39 per 1000 population), hearing (21 (This blog draws on a study by Nisha Arunatilake (2016), Labour Market
per 1000 population), cognition (18 per 1000 population), self-care (11 Characteristics Thematic Report based on Census of Population and
per 1000 population) and communication (10 per 1000 population). Housing 2012, United Nations Population Fund, Colombo. )
12 13
World Day of Social Justice, a commitment, made by the UN in Beyond macroeconomic impacts, labour force participation is also While socio-cultural perceptions and attitudes impact a womens
2007, is rooted in the ILO Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair fundamentally important for poverty alleviation and economic decisions to enter the labour force, these factors also influence hiring
Globalization and focuses on guaranteeing fair outcomes for development. Women constitute a majority of the poor and increasing practices. A recent study conducted by the ILO titled Factors Affecting
all through employment, social protection, social dialogue, and access to wage employment is critical to ensuring that women have the Womens Labour Force Participation in Sri Lanka (2016) reveals the
fundamental principles and rights at work. Unsurprisingly, an means to overcome persistent poverty. extent to which socio-cultural norms and perceptions hinder womens
important focus of this commitment is the economic empowerment access to employment opportunities. Although the study did not find
of women and girls. According to the United Nations: Observance evidence of overt discrimination, it found that gender stereotyping led
Socio-cultural Constraints to Female LFP
of World Day of Social Justice supports efforts of the international to indirect discrimination in the hiring process. For example, Key Person
community in poverty eradication, the promotion of full employment Interviews in the study revealed that managers were more likely to hire
and decent work, gender equity and access to social well-being for Evidence from studies on female LFP in Sri Lanka reveals that household men due to extraneous considerations such as higher probability of
all. income and status of wealth play a significant role in determining a women having family responsibilities.
womans decision to seek employment. Studies such as Guntalika
It is in this context that this article chooses to examine the status of (2013) show that receipt of remittances and earnings of male household Policy Recommendations and Conclusion
female labour force participation (LFP) in Sri Lanka. In doing so, it members deter labour force participation among married women and
recognizes the enduring positive impact of female LFP on broader female heads of household. While it is hard to locate the precise driving
While the Government of Sri Lanka has recognised the need to address
economic outcomes and, more importantly, on poverty alleviation force behind this trend, it is safe to posit that these trends are largely
the low rate of participation among women in the country, its focus has
and social protection among women. reflective of traditional views on male and female income earners.
not been on addressing these
cultural norms and practices that
Labour force participation, as defined by the ILO, is a measure of Figure 1: GDP Losses Due to Economic Gender Gaps in Select Countries (as a % of GDP) continue to hold women back. If
the proportion of a countrys working-age population that engages Sri Lanka hopes to tap into the
actively in the labour market, either by working or actively looking 40 productive potential that women
for work. According to 2015 estimates, the rate of labour force hold to stimulate growth, it must
35
participation among women in Sri Lanka is 35.9. This means that work to change the pervasive
a disproportionate majority of women remain outside the labour 30 perceptions around womens
market, with no access to wages, pensions and other benefits tied work. It must also work to develop
to gainful employment. 25 greater support systems for women
20
who continue to operate within
While evidence points to several pervasive constraints on womens current socio-cultural frameworks.
participation in the labour force ranging from protectionist 15
Dominica
Ecuador
Greece
Italy
Japan
Honduras
Paraguay
Philippines
Chile
Indonesia
Mexico
Panama
Costa Rica
Djibouti
Belize
Guatemala
Malaysia
Maldives
Mauritious
Sri Lanka
Fiji
Sao Tome
Malta
Niger
Suriname
Turkey
India
Morocco
Kuwait
Yemen
Bangladesh
Lebanon
Tunisia
Egypt
Bahrain
Pakistan
Algeria
UAE
Iran
Oman
Qatar
womens roles and responsibilities in the household. These cultural on women. This is particularly
Labour Force
run. If Sri Lanka is serious about transitioning from its status as a is likely to increase the dependency
lower-middle income country, it must address these key constraints burden on women in the future.
in order to ensure that women become an engine of sustained Introducing day-care options at places of employment is another
Although women are considered to be economic actors, their income
Participation
economic growth. alternative worth considering.
is regarded as supplementary to that of male income earners who,
traditionally, play the role of primary breadwinner. Therefore, women who
Why is Increasing Female LFP Important for receive income from other sources such as remittances, or live with the Similarly, the introduction of flexible work options such as part-time
Sri Lanka?
in Sri Lanka:
work and working from home could also support a womans ability
high-earning male family members, do not feel the need to seek gainful
to achieve a work-life balance. A survey of more than 1,000 workers
employment opportunities in the market.
While female LFP is an important social goal in itself, it is also in Australia, a country where over a 50% of Australian organizations
crucial from an economic growth perspective. Empirical evidence have a workplace flexibility policy in place, revealed that women were
the Key Social as Cuberes and Tiegner (2015) demonstrate the extent to which as mothers and caretakers, it is also indicative of the disproportionate that, with the right systems in place, women are willing and able to
gender gaps negatively affect per-capita income and productivity; burden of unpaid care work that women continue to shoulder. The economically empower themselves.
according to their findings, gender inequality creates an average opportunity cost that results from cutting back on work hours or dropping
and Cultural
income loss of 16% in the short-run and 17.5% in the long-run out of paid labour force is well documented. Nancy Folbre, a leading Finally, Sri Lanka should promote policies that support the more equitable
for developing countries. In Asia alone, UNESCAP estimates that economist at the University of Massachusetts calls this opportunity distribution of family responsibilities in the household. For example, the
restrictions on womens access to employment opportunities result cost the care penalty and argues: unpaid work, by definition, carries expansion of paternity leave benefits could encourage men to take up
Constraints
in a loss of $42 $47 billion per year. Other studies also highlight a pecuniary penalty: one forgoes the potential earnings from working greater responsibility in child-care activities. In addition to sharing the
significant losses to GDP that occur due to gender asymmetries in the same hours in a paid job. In addition, because pay is affected by costs of family care, Nancy Folbre argues that the impact of such policies
the labour market; an IMF staff note estimates an average loss of how much job experience one has, women who leave employment to could also have a positive effect on re-engineering gender roles in
20% to the Sri Lankan economy stemming from lower participation rear children suffer wage penalties for years after they re-enter the job society by validating the value of care work. As a result, they could have
By Anarkalee Perera rates among women (Figure 1). market. a large cumulative and ripple effects on society as a whole.
14 15
As a relatively new industry in Sri Lanka, the apparel industry has played Despite the high level of female participation in the apparel sector, resulting from poor infrastructure facilities (inadequate transport and Creating more social recognition - Social acceptance and recognition
an important role in the economy as a major income source and an labour shortage remains a key challenge in the industry. The issue of housing near factories). Women also prefer alternative sectors because is an important element in tackling the issue of labour shortage at lower
avenue for creating employment opportunities, especially for women, labour shortage has become so severe that there have been proposals of the social recognition and job esteem attached to the employment levels of the apparel sector. There have been several effective campaigns
over the last few decades. It has also created a global brand name to automate the manufacturing process of the apparel sector in order to opportunities in industries such as tourism and retail. by some leading firms in the industry and by industry associations (e.g.,
for the country, positioning Sri Lankas name at a prestigious level for overcome this issue. Labour shortage is more prominent in the machine
Women Go Beyond, Abhimani). However, the social stigma attached
high quality garment products. The Sri Lankan apparel industry which operator positions, which are mostly occupied by women. With a low Changing career aspirations of the younger generation - Unlike the to the women working at the garment sector prevails and holds back
operates in a highly competitive global market, mostly occupies female labour force participation rate and a high unemployment rate of women
young girls who joined garment factories as machine operators in the women from taking up jobs in this sector. More awareness should be
workers. However, it is observed that the industry has been experiencing at the national level, (in 2015, the female labour force participation
early stages of the apparel industry, today, most young women have created about the contribution made by the women occupied in the lower
a labour shortage over the years, especially in recruiting women for the rate was 35 per cent and female unemployment rate was 7.6 per cent
obtained basic educational qualifications such as G.C. E. Ordinary Level levels of the apparel sector for the countrys economy and they should be
position of machine operators. In this backdrop, a recent study on An whereas these values for males were recorded as 75 per cent and 3
per cent respectively), it is quite alarming to see that the apparel sector Certificate. Along with higher level of education, their career aspirations appreciated more.
Empirical Investigation of Labour Shortage in the Manufacturing Sector
in Sri Lanka* examines the possible reasons and recommends viable is experiencing a difficulty in filling vacancies even in the occupation have also changed. They tend to perceive garment factory work as a low
solutions for the issue of labour shortage in the apparel sector. category, where women dominate (i.e., machine operators). skilled job and these target oriented hardworking machine operator jobs Professionalization of jobs and creating clear career paths by offering
are not no longer able to attract young women into the industry. Instead, standard professional qualifications and certificates for occupations
Apparel Sector in Sri Lanka The Causes they seek for more prestigious computer based jobs where they can categories such as machine operator would increase the willingness of
enjoy more flexibility and social interaction. women to take up those jobs. It is also important to make clear career
The Sri Lankan apparel industry boasts of a long history. However, it There are several reasons behind the difficulty in attracting women to
boomed to become the largest industry in Sri Lanka after the late 1970s, fill the vacancies of the lower level job categories. Based on interviews paths for them by identifying their skills and giving promotions. This
owing to three major contributory factors. These were, market-oriented with Human Resource Managers of some leading as well as medium and
Addressing the issue would help to attract women with higher education qualifications to the
liberal economic policies introduced in 1977, supportive measures small scale firms, the following points were identified as the key reasons industry.
Factors that create and intensify labour shortage in the apparel industry
taken by the then government through the Board of Investment (BOI), for the labour shortage in the apparel industry; competition, mobility, bad
and the quota hopping under the Multi-Fibre Arrangement (MFA). social image, and changing career aspirations. should be tackled immediately, considering the high competition facing
There are large as well as medium and small sized firms operating in
Export-led industries were given greater emphasis and promoted under the Sri Lankan apparel industry in the global market. Offering competitive
the industry. All the firms in the industry may not be able to take these
The Dwindling
Stitching Hands:
Labour Shortages in
the Apparel Industry in
Sri Lanka
By Sunimalee Madurawala
marketoriented, liberal economic policies, by providing various types of Competition from other sectors Apparel sector has to compete with salaries and creating attractive working environments, providing more
measures and offer these benefits in order to attract eligible women due
concessions. Availability of educated labour at a relatively cheaper cost other sectors, especially service sector industries such as tourism and gender sensitive working options, enhancing the social recognition,
retail, to attract labour. Wages offered by these sectors are competitive to financial constraints. But given the high competition for labour with
made Sri Lanka an attractive investment location for investors, especially and professionalization of jobs are some measures that can be taken to
and in some cases slightly higher than the wages offered by the apparel other booming sectors and concerning the future of the industry, all the
as the apparel industry is labour intensive. address the issue.
sector. That being said, wages are not the only factor that attracts labour, firms in the apparel sector have to address the issue very effectively.
Since its peak, the apparel sector has been a key contributor of the especially women, to these sectors. The working environment also plays Individual as well as industry level approaches are also needed.
Offering competitive salaries and creating better and pleasant
Sri Lankan economy, especially in terms of the export earnings and an important role in this regard. A pleasant working environment that
working environments - In order to compete with the other rival sectors
employment generation. According to the Central Bank of Sri Lanka, in provides facilities and comfort attracts labour more easily. Sustainability of the apparel sector is vital for the countrys economy.
in attracting labour apparel sector has to offer higher salaries. Other than
2015, total exports of the country accounted to US$ 10,505 million out of It plays a key role in employment creation, especially for women, thus
which 46 per cent was earned from the apparels. Total export earnings Mobility Issues - Proximity and the ease of accessing the workplace this, creating pleasant working environments is another key strategy to
attract more women to the apparel sector. This should entail providing empowering women who occupy this sector. Employment in the apparel
from the apparel sector indicate a growing trend and accounted for US$ are important factors for women when choosing a job. This is particularly
important for married women and women with children. Due to their not only the basic facilities such as drinking water, separate toilet sector has created an environment where women can enjoy economic
4,674 million in 2016. Apparel industry provides direct employment
familial responsibilities, they are reluctant to migrate and to work in facilities but also other amenities such as dining rooms, clean and tidy independence and enhance their well-being to a greater extent. Hence
opportunities to over 300,000 and to 600,000 indirectly.
urban areas or in the free trade zones, where many garment factories are surroundings, proper workspaces, and suitable temperature and lighting. it is very important to protect the industry while giving dignity and
Women in the Apparel Industry located. Even single women are hesitant to live in urban areas because of Other engagement activities (celebrations for special days, community recognition to the stitching hands which back the countrys economy.
the difficulty in finding safe accommodation. work, and entertainment activities) are also important.
From its conception, the apparel industry workforce has been dominated An Empirical Investigation of Labour Shortage in the Manufacturing
by women; in fact, women have always managed to secure more than Bad social image - There is a negative social perception associated with
More gender sensitive working options and facilities - Given that Sector in Sri Lanka by Prof. Athula Ranasinghe (University of Colombo,
80 per cent of the employment share in the industry. This share is women who in garment factories. Female factory workers in the apparel
the machine operator category is the most severely affected occupation Sri Lanka), Sunimalee Madurawala (Institute of Policy Studies of Sri
significantly higher than the womens share in the national labour force, sector are stigmatized as promiscuous and are referred to as Juki girls,
category due to labour shortage, more gender sensitive work options Lanka), Dr. Jen Je Su, and Thushara Senadeera (Griffith University,
which was only 35 per cent in 2015. Even though the majority of the a derogatory term for machine operators. Thus, due to the low social
apparel sector workforce comprises of women, they are mostly confined recognition and the bad reputation of female garment factory workers, (e.g., flexible working hours, working from home and work sharing) Australia) funded by the Australia Awards Fellowship Programme 2016.
to the lower levels of the production process, (e.g., machine operating), young women are reluctant to join the industry. This stems from safety and facilities (e.g., day care facilities and maternity aids) would help in This article is based on the Key Informant Interviews conducted for this
and men tend to dominate the upper management positions. concerns for females and exposure to sexual harassment and abuse attracting more women to the industry. study.
16 17
This year, the world celebrated its (IP) Day focusing on the theme of Patents play a pivotal role in protecting new innovation, as it provides S&T institutes too are facing the same issues in enhancing innovations. An effective IPR system especially with proper patenting policy and
innovation improving lives which aims to explore how innovation property rights for inventions usually for a specific period of time and Furthermore, ownership of inventions from research granted by the implementation mechanism stimulates almost all of these factors and
makes lives healthier, safer and more comfortable. A well-built IP system provide the right to exclude others from exploiting the invention during government resides with the government and not with the grantee of the creates an environment which provides incentives for innovations.
stimulates innovation by attracting investments, rewarding inventors, that period. Furthermore, to obtain a patent the inventor has to disclose funds which creates a disincentive for government employees to engage As an example, strong IPR systems will overcome the issue of private
encouraging inventors to develop their ideas and ensuring that their the patented invention to the public, where it will provide an opportunity in innovations. This also acts as a negative factor when improving human investments in R&D, by providing effective protection for investors,
new knowledge is protected. Almost all innovations can be protected for others to use and develop the technology further. Therefore, the patent capital to enhance innovations in the country. encourage people engagement in innovations by providing credibility for
inventors and promote commercialization of innovations.
When comparing Sri Lanka with other
selected countries on resident applications International best practices, as shown in Singapore, China, Malaysia
Role of IPRs in
per million population (by origin), in 2015 and India, have suggested that a well-constructed and a balanced IP
Sri Lanka was on par with India. However, system accelerates innovations, whereas a weak IP system reduces
when compared with other Asian countries, domestic incentives for innovations. Policies and processes for
Sri Lanka was not in a favorable position issuing and enforcing patents are the most important aspect of IPR for
Stimulating
(Figure 3). innovation. Since the late 1970s, Singapore has taken several steps to
enact new patent laws and has established a court of IP to strengthen
In 2013, the highest number of its IPR policies and to improve innovations. India enacted its Patent Act
patents issued was in the fields of IT, in the 1970s and since then patents were expanded to several areas
Innovations
telecommunication, and electronics (49 such as pharmaceuticals, agriculture developments, etc. Since 1979
patents out of total 326). The other fields China has also recognized the importance of IPRs and passed its patent
were agriculture related developments law in 1984. The Republic of Korea has carried out a massive public
(44), development of domestic appliances/ awareness campaign on IPRs and patents in schools, universities, and
By Dilani Hirimuthugodage utilities (44), drugs, cosmetics & other R&D institutes.
related product developments (33), and
automobile and related inventions (31). Figure 3: Resident Applications per Million Population (by origin)
The highest number of innovations in IT, 800
706
telecommunication and electronics could be due to the fact that those 700
with Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs). Therefore, every country has system is created to balance the interests of both inventors and the inventions can be more easily applied in industrial use than other
recognized the importance of protecting the intellects of its people. Sri general public. According to Sri Lankas Intellectual Property Rights Act inventions. Even though Sri Lanka is a signatory to the Trade Related
600
Lanka too encourages its people in this regard, through several policies 2003, patents are available for inventions, products and processes in all
Number of Applications
Intellectual Property Rights Agreement (TRIPs), Sri Lankas IP system 500
and programmes designed to enhance innovations. Some of these fields of technology. Patents allow an inventor to control the commercial does not provide patent protection for new plant varieties as suggested 400
policies and programmes are directly linked with IPRs. use of his/her invention. by the Agreement, which is one of the factors that discourages plant
300 265
breeders in developing new plant varieties. Since enacting Sri Lankas
Figure 1: Number of Patents Registered Locally Given the importance of patents, this blog article discusses the role of IPR Act in 2003, the country has not yet made any national policies, 200
600
IPRs, especially patents, in stimulating innovations. strategies etc., to enforce patent protection for new plant varieties.
100 42
500 10 1 10
Sri Lanka: where do we stand? 0
China India Malaysia Pakistan Singapore Sri Lanka
400
Figure 2: Number of Patents Registered by Residents by Sector (As a %) in 2013 Source: WIPO statistics database. Last updated: February 2017
300 There are several criteria to evaluate Sri Lankas generation of
innovations. One such important criterion is the number of patents Higher Education Furthermore, international best practices have highlighted that being
200 Institutes 1%
registered at the National Intellectual Property Office (NIPO). Figure 1 a signatory to TRIPs alone is not sufficient. What is most important is
100 describes how patents have been registered by residents and non- S&T national enforcement. Governments should use straightforward strategies
Institute 2%
residents. It shows that, from 2011 to 2013, there has been an increasing such as establishing proper IPR management systems in universities and
0
trend in residents patents registration, but since then, it has been Private 5% other research institutes, awareness programmes, incentives such as
2010 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2015
decreasing. However, the total number of patents registered locally Institutes 92% vouchers and rewarding systems for inventors and consider modernizing
Residents Non-Residents Total (residents and non-residents) indicates an increase. This suggests that Individuals the IPR Act with timely changes to enforce these rules.
Source: Sri Lanka Science, Technology and Innovation Handbook: 2015, National Science Foundation and the number of innovations is gradually increasing. This slow growth could
WIPO Statistics
be explained by cost of patenting, high cost of annual renewals, and the For an effective use of IPRs in stimulating innovations, Sri Lanka
lack of awareness among scientists. should explore alternatives such as integrating with regional patenting
Sri Lanka was ranked 91st out of 128 countries in the Global Innovation
organizations, sharing information and building good relationships with
Index (GII) in 2016. It was a drop of 6 places when compared with the Source: Sri Lanka Science, Technology and Innovation Handbook (2015), National Science Foundation
It is also interesting to evaluate the various types of institutions and other national patenting offices as a solution to sharing the high cost of
GII in 2015. According to GII 2016, Sri Lanka is second only to India
individuals that have obtained patents in Sri Lanka as it shows peoples patenting, including the cost of renewals. Recently, Sri Lanka reduced
(66th place) in the South Asian region but, when compared with other Furthermore, the reports on Integrating Intellectual Property into
interest and their knowledge on patenting. According to the latest the cost of patent registration and created new cost structures with three
Asian countries (Singapore 6th, China-25th, Malaysia 35th places) Sri Innovation Policy Formulation in Sri Lanka and Science, Technology &
available data from the Sri Lanka Science, Technology and Innovation categories with students, individuals and private firms to encourage
Lanka falls far behind. This highlights the fact that Sri Lanka is not only Innovation: Strategy for Sri Lanka (2011-2015) have also highlighted the
Hand Book, more than 90 per cent of patent holders are individuals (91), patenting. Simultaneously, it is of utmost importance to create public
lagging behind in the number of innovations but also in its protection and fact that the intellectual property management system with regards to
5 per cent are private institutes, 2 per cent are Science and Technology awareness on IPR services, especially patenting, its importance, how
promotion of innovations. innovations in Sri Lanka is very poor.
(S&T) institutes and 1 per cent is higher education institutes (Figure 2). patents support and encourage inventors by providing recognition, and
It is important to note that higher education institutes are at the very how to transform inventors knowledge into tradable assets. Effective
Protecting Innovations through IPRs bottom when obtaining patents. According to the reports on Integrating What needs to be done? enforcement of the existing IPR policy and effective management of IP
Intellectual Property into Innovation Policy Formulation in Sri Lanka, this is also crucial. It is also important to provide IPR policy managements
An effective and well-built IPR system consisting of one or more different could be due to limited research conducted by such institutes, lack of Several factors shape a countrys generation of innovations. Amongst for research institutes, universities and other higher education facilities,
IPR tools such as patents, copyrights, trademarks and trade secrets will research interest in staff and students, poor management system of them, the most important are the R&D initiatives in place, the stock of especially in the areas of commercialization, research collaborations and
protect the ownership of innovation and thereby, encourage innovations. IPRs, lack of awareness of patenting, and the high cost of patenting. The human capital, and strategies of commercialization of new knowledge. ownership of innovations to encourage innovations.
18 19
Black pepper (Piper nigrum L.), known as the King of Spices, is the most Given that majority of black pepper from Sri Lanka is exported to the low There are Sri Lanka Standards for Black Pepper (SLS 105 Part 1: 2008)
important and widely used spice in the world. Pepper production is confined to a end of the market (India), Sri Lanka should explore high end markets and White Pepper (SLS 105 Part 2: 2008); however, neither of these
few countries in Asia including Sri Lanka and the Pacific, Brazil and Madagascar. elsewhere (USA and EU), which are yet to be fully exploited. At the same product standards is required for export at the moment. Systems
Currently, Sri Lanka ranks at 5th place in terms of area under pepper cultivation time, stringent standards in the developed countries can act as a trade certifications are increasingly obtained by the pepper industry at the
Come
(after India, Indonesia, Vietnam and Brazil), and 7th place in terms of production, barrier to entering those markets, and therefore, Sri Lanka needs to exporter level and these include, ISO22000 Food Safety Standards,
with a world share of 5.7% in production. Also, Sri Lanka is the 5th largest upgrade its standards. Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP), and Good
exporter of black pepper, after Vietnam, Brazil, Indonesia, and India. However, Manufacturing Practices (GMP). Few exporters have also obtained
productivity levels in the industry remain low, despite improvements seen over organic and fair trade certifications. However, these standards have been
Together
the years. voluntarily adopted by the exporters.
PEPPER INDUSTRY IN SRI LANKA
Sri Lankan pepper, like other spices from the island, is well-known for its Quality needs to be adhered across the value chain from the point
superior inherent properties. For example, Sri Lankan pepper has higher piperine Pepper plant is a perennial, evergreen, climbing vine. Dries fruit of harvest and onwards not just at the point of export. Unfortunately,
content, which gives it a superior quality and pungency. Piperine content in or peppercorn is used as condiment; the same is used to this does not always happen. For example, collectors/shops buy any
produce white, red & green pepper.
Raising Standards
Sri Lankan black pepper is 2-6 times higher than in other countries. However, supply of pepper produced by farmers, regardless of the quality of
Central Sabaragamuwa Uwa North Western
the export of sub-standard products can ruin the reputation of Sri Lanka in the pepper produced by smallholders. This is due to weaknesses in the
international market as a supplier of high quality spices. Therefore, significant coordination in a fragment chain, lack of awareness/regulations and poor
Province
measures need to be collectively taken to upgrade standards governing the infrastructure in terms of proper drying/storage, etc.
There are numerous actors performing various functions in the Sri Lankan pepper Improve attitudes of the agents in the value chain towards adopting
value chain, as shown in Figure 1. The figure vertically maps the functions/ By Janaka Wijayasiri #5 #7 #5 good agricultural and manufacturing practices not only to increase
activities, stakeholders and supporting services in the chain from point of inputs Area under Pepper Production Exporter in the World the productivity but the quality of pepper by Organizing field trips
Cultivation in the in the World
to retail. World and constructing model farms in each village to educate farmers
about proper agronomical practices include drying and storage of
In Sri Lanka, pepper is cultivated in the wet and intermediate agro ecological pepper;
zones, in the mid and low country regions, mostly by smallholders.
Most of the smallholders grow pepper in their own small plots Figure 1: Pepper Value Chain in Sri Lanka Provide assistance to build/upgrade process facilities like steam
of land (home gardens), which are less than 20 acres or sterilization treatment plants, and buy equipment like dryers. The
8.1 hectares. Apart from cultivating pepper in their ACTIVITIES STAKEHOLDERS SERVICES Ministry of Primary Industries (MPI) will be providing a 50% grant
own lands, harvesting of pepper is also done by Inputs DEA/own nurseries/shops Department of for entrepreneurs to upgrade/add value their product/production
farmers, with the help of hired labour; some (sun/ Export Agriculture
Cultivation/ (DEA) and such assistance could be made use for this end.
machine) dry their harvest and sell, while others Production Smallholders (93%) Estates (7%)
Farmer Groups
dispose it in a fresh form. A majority of the farmers Collection/ Village collector/Dryer
Exporters Establish central collecting/processing/ storage centres to improve
sell their product to village collectors or shops in the Pre -processing
The Spice Council quality of pepper at the intermediary stages of the value chain;
town, which are important intermediaries in Wholesale
Traders
Town/Regional (TSA)
the pepper value chain.
Marketing Brokers
Spices & Allied
Products Producers & Improve efficiency and reach of extension services by increasing
Traders Association resources to the Department of Export Agriculture (DEA) to carry out
Local collectors are sometimes Wholesale
(SAPPTA)
Pettah buyers their activities;
farmers themselves or rural Sri Lanka Standards
Processing/ Institute (SLSI)
entrepreneurs who purchase Processors/Exporters
Exporting
pepper directly from farmers.
Industrial Technology
Institute (ITI)
Encourage exporters to integrate backwards in the value chain
Retailing Local Market (40%) International Market (60%) by providing land or to purchase directly from farmers/farmer
Other than being involved in the Export Development
Board (EDB) organizations to ensure a consistent quality;
spice wholesale trade, operating
Source: IPS, 2017
from stores based in town
bordering spice growing areas, traders also Implement mandatory standards at the point of exports to ensure
purchase pepper from collectors/ farmers/ estates/ quality of Sri Lankan pepper exports whilst encouraging the
lessees, after which they clean, dry, store, pack and adoption of quality systems such as HAACP/ISO22000 as well as
Lack of Supply of Quality Black Pepper
transport the pepper to buyers, mostly in Colombo. good agricultural and manufacturing practices in the value chain
Buyers include spice exporters, low local spice manufacturers Currently, there is an inadequate supply of black pepper throughout the Improve awareness of farmers, collectors, traders, and processors
and marketers, Pettah buyers, and hotels/restaurants/ year to meet the international demand. Moreover, the quality of black of quality requirements of export markets
households. Currently about 60% of pepper production of the pepper production is inconsistent due to the fragmented production
country is exported, while the remainder is consumed domestically and absence of standards governing the pepper value chain. Quality Invest in advanced testing equipment, which can detect lower limits
according to government sources. Pepper bought by exporters is characteristics in pepper include appearance of the pepper, its maturity, of pesticides, aflatoxins, ochratoxins, etc.; test that are necessary to
then dried, cleaned, graded and packed to meet the requirements bulk density, moisture content and presence of extraneous matter (dust, export to more developed markets.
of the international buyers. Currently, India alone buys 62% of pepper stones, leaves) in the product. Unlike the tea industry, no compulsory
exports from Sri Lanka to the world followed by, Germany, Pakistan, system to control quality by the government exists at the moment. As a (This article is based on a JICA study on Analysis of Cinnamon, Pepper
Egypt, USA, UAE, UK, Vietnam, Saudi Arabia and Spain. Together, the top ten result, exporters depend on the requirements prescribed by importers, and Cardamom Value Chains in Sri Lanka, which was conducted by the
countries account for 91% of total pepper exports from Sri Lanka. and usually request quality-certifying bodies to certify the pepper. IPS.)
20 21
Sri Lankas
The Sri Lankan economy appears to be enmeshed in a growing debt overhang. The from 2.2% of GDP in 2015 (or an annual average of 1.7% of GDP in the In addition to the above, the Central Bank settlement of foreign currency
latest figures released in the Central Bank Annual Report 2016 indicate that total general two preceding years). Thus, Sri Lankas reliance on foreign loans to drive swaps, obtained primarily from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in 2015
government external debt has grown by 10% in 2016 to US$ 27.2 billion. Even averaging development is on-going. Long-term loans to the government and foreign to prop up reserves, drained a further US$ 1.1 billion as debt service
Debt
out for 2015-2016, annual debt growth was 6.2% compared to 4.5% in the preceding investments in Treasury bills and bonds in 2016 brought in US$ 1.4 billion payments in 2016. All told, the overall impact of debt management has
two years. and US 1.2 billion respectively, to cover fiscal requirements. still left the country without adequate official reserves and an increase in
the outstanding volume of external debt.
It is also not the case that the country is witnessing a lowering of the costs and risks Figure1: External Debt Dynamics
Overhang: of its external debt profile. The share of higher cost non-concessional and commercial
external borrowing has crept up to 53% in 2016 from 51% in 2015, owing in part to US$
2.2 billion raised through an International Sovereign Bond (ISB) and a syndicated loan in 1A. OUTSTANDING GOVT. EXTERNAL DEBT
The medium-term trajectory of macroeconomic indicators suggests that
debt indicators will worsen before they stand a chance of getting better.
External indebtedness is typically based on two ratios i.e., the value
Getting Better,
2016. 30000 of total debt service to a countrys national income and export earnings.
These are employed given that they capture two important aspects of a
25000
The combined impacts make for a risky external sector outlook for Sri Lanka in the near countrys potential capacity to service its debt; export earnings are an
or Worse?
term. Already, an estimated US$ 5.7 billion of ISBs and syndicated loans are scheduled for 20000 indicator of foreign exchange to service debt, and national income is a
settlement over a period of three years, beginning in 2019. As of mid-2017, the country 15000 broad measure of income generation in an economy. By such measures,
is facing an incipient crunch point with regards to its ability to withstand any exogenous various debt indicators for Sri Lanka are worsening as GDP growth slows,
10000
shock to the economy. The most recent available data suggests that official reserves and signals of a sustained recovery in exports remain elusive.
By Dushni Weerakoon have plummeted to US$ 5.1 billion at end March 2017, sufficient for only the minimum 5000
recommended threshold of three months of import cover. Not surprisingly, Sri Lanka is 0 Government external debt to GDP rose further to 79.3% of GDP and
looking to tap international capital markets once again by mid-2017 to raise urgently 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 public external debt to 34.2% of GDP in 2016. A decline recorded in
needed funds through ISBs and syndicated loans. Sri Lankas debt service ratio to 25% in 2016 owes more to the overall
Loans ISBs T-bills & bonds
drop in debt service payments rather than to a surge in earnings from
Thus, despite the existing external debt overhang, foreign borrowing shows no signs of exports of goods and services. The latter is stagnating at 20% of GDP for
1B. DEBT SERVICE PAYMENTS
lessening in 2017 either. The continued recourse to foreign borrowing has often been a third consecutive year, while earnings from exports of goods alone have
blamed on the need to service high debt costs on past borrowings. This is partly so, but 4000 continued its downward spiral to a low 12.7% of GDP.
the explanation is a little more intricate going by the available figures released by the 3500
CBSL on external debt settlements (Figure 1). 3000 Sri Lanka has nonetheless made a start towards debt sustainability
2500 with a stronger fiscal outcome in 2016 under the watchful eye of the
In actual fact, total external debt service payments dropped in 2016. Amortization and 2000 IMF. The primary account deficit has shrunk from 2.9% of GDP in 2015
interest payments on general government debt fell to US$ 1.9 billion in 2016 from US$ 1500 to 0.2% of GDP in 2016; debt begins to stabilize when the interest
2.8 billion in 2015 (and an average of US$ 2.2 billion in the two preceding years). The 1000 payment is exactly off-set by a primary balance. Thus, the real test of
spike in 2015 came largely from the maturing US$ 500 ISB settlement. Thus, the total 500 debt sustainability will come with progress on fiscal consolidation efforts
settlement for 2016 was well within US 2.2 billion foreign capital market borrowings 0 where improved domestic resource mobilization will lessen dependence
raised in the year. 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
on foreign borrowing. In the interim, the next two years are critical; Sri
Project loans Debt securities IMF Swap Lanka must urgently address the current dip in export performance and
However, foreign financing for budgetary needs in 2016 exceeded the estimated 2.3% of build hard currency buffers in view of its risky ISB redemption profile
GDP. The final outcome tallied at a high 3.3% of GDP or approximately US$ 2.7 billion, up Source: Data from Central Bank of Sri Lanka (CBSL), Annual Report, various issues. post-2019.
22 23
relief. Gaining tariff-free access to a European market that has seemingly More concerning, however, are the structural limitations of the Sri
recovered from the 2009 financial crisis and regional economic pressures Lankan economy that will hinder the ability to fully leverage the benefits
such as the Greek debt crisis bodes well for improved demand for Sri of GSP-Plus. Crucially, the apparel sector is currently facing significant
Lankan goods. This will especially be a boon to the apparel and fisheries labour shortages that undermine the ability for the sector to expand
sectors that suffered significantly in recent years and face growing sufficiently in a manner that can cater to expected increases in demand.
pressures from regional competitors. Other export sectors such as small Similar structural issues such as high para-tariffs and policy instability
manufacturing and especially those that have emerged in a post-conflict also reduce the competitiveness of the Sri Lankan economy. Whereas
Sri Lankan economy will also get an opportunity to penetrate the Sri Lankas competitors such as Bangladesh and Vietnam are embarking
European market. on large-scale economic reform agendas, Sri Lankas relative reticence
restricts its potential for growth.
Temporary Relief, Not Permanent Solution
In addition to these structural challenges, Sri Lanka should also be
The abovementioned benefits, however, will be restricted to the short cognizant of the impact of Brexit on leveraging GSP-Plus. Since the
term and Sri Lanka should prepare its export sector and the economy referendum and the subsequent triggering of Article 50, the United
overall for the eventuality when these benefits expire. Critically, Sri Lanka Kingdom is scheduled to leave the European Union on the 29th of March
2019. Worryingly for Sri Lanka, approximately 30% of
Sri Lankas exports to the EU are to the UK. Sri Lankan
Export Merchandise from Sri Lanka to the EU exports will no longer qualify for preferential access to the
In the year 2016, 31% of exports UK once it leaves the EU, unless a similar arrangement
from Sri Lanka was to the is negotiated directly between Sri Lanka and the UK.
European Union Therefore, Sri Lanka should prepare to face an economic
Export Value to EU shock, at least temporarily, to its export sector once the
$3,101,000,000 UK officially leaves the EU.
GSP-Plus:
Sri Lankan exports, which have been flagging in recent times, gained some Fuel (0.14%) Other (8.12%)
much needed relief with the European Unions (EU) Foreign Affairs Council A combination of structural failures, protectionist
deciding to grant additional trade preferences to Sri Lanka under its GSP-Plus Exports to the European Union (EU) economic policies, and external factors has led to Sri
initiative. By granting this concession, Sri Lanka will now benefit from the 4000 Lankas export sector performance diminish in recent
An Elixir or Just full removal of tariffs on Sri Lankan imports into the EU on 66% of tariff lines
3000
years and fail to fully realize its potential. The withdrawal
Woes?
Source: Central Bank Annual Report 2016
are undertaken to address structural weaknesses in the
GSP-Plus concessions were initially granted to Sri Lanka in 2005, after the economy.
Tsunami. However, in 2010, the EU withdrew Sri Lankas preferential access
under GSP-Plus to the European market due to the governments failures in Sri Lankas Exports to the EU & UK
By Kithmina Hewage and Semini Satarasinghe adhering to human rights standards set under the provisions of the scheme. Such reforms need to focus on promoting growth,
4000
tackling demographic issues, fostering an efficient
Between 2005 and 2010, under GSP-Plus access, Sri Lankan exports to the EU
public taxation system and improving the labour market.
grew on average by 7.96%, notably amidst a decline in consumer demand in 3000
the Numbers:
before GPS + exports after GSP + exports in exports in exports
(US$ Mn .) to EU (US$ Mn .) to EU to EU after GSP + items in question. Similarly, the duties on other items
(US$ Mn .) of export interest are high, and vary significantly
Animal & Animal 93.2 2.8 123.2 3.3 30.0 32.2
What is the
Products at the disaggregated product level. Under the GSP
Vegetable Products 259.0 7.9 265.7 7.1 6.7 2.6 Plus scheme, these would be brought down to zero,
Foodstuffs 52.1 1.6 58.3 1.6 6.2 11.8 providing a substantial duty advantage to the Sri
Real Export
Mineral Products 3.8 0.1 3.8 0.1 0.0 0.0
Lankan exporters, trading with the EU.
Chemicals & Allied 39.1 1.2 39.1 1.0 0.0 0.0
Industries
Plastics/Rubbers 359.2 11.0 359.7 9.6 0.5 0.1
Due to tariff reductions by the EU, there will be trade
21.1
0.5
0.6
18.0
21.1
0.5
0.6
0.3
0.0
1.6
0.0
creation effects, as products from Sri Lanka become
cheaper, and there will be new buyers in the EU who
GSP Plus to
Products
would now want to buy from Sri Lanka. At the same
Textiles & Apparel 2,032.6 62.1 2,457.2 65.4 424.6 20.9
Footwear/Headgear 14.2 0.4 14.6 0.4 0.4 3.1 time, there will be some trade diversion; that is, there
Stone/Glass 127.5 3.9 128.6 3.4 1.1 0.9 will a shift of demand from other competing, supplying
Caveat
million, as a result of regaining the GSP Plus benefit, according
to preliminary estimates using a partial equilibrium model. The
EU GSP+ Table 2: Top 5 Products Benefiting from GSP Plus
Came into force: 19 May 2017 According to available literature, the EUs GSP scheme
estimation is derived employing the SMART Simulations of the Total Trade Trade Trade
HS Code Description Effect Creation Diversion
Old Simple New Simple has had an overall positive impact on the beneficiary
World Integrated Trade Solutions (WITS), and disaggregated trade Duty Rate Duty Rate
(US$ M n.) (US$ M n.) (US$ M n.) countries; it has increased developing countries
data (at HS 6 digit level). This figure is slightly higher than the GSP+ provides additional tariff preferences to developing Articles of apparel and
number quoted by the EU a benefit of over Euro 300 million countries which are vulnerable due to lack of diversification 61 clothing accessories, 265.5 125.7 139.9 9.34 0 exports and welfare. In addition, the literature further
(about US$ 335 million) reported in the local media.
and insufficient intergration with the global trading system. knitted or crocheted suggests that the EUs GSP has helped with export
%
Articles of apparel and
62 clothing accessories, not 149.7 61.6 88.1 9.1 0 diversification and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI).
Vulnerable developing countries need to fulfil
eligibility criteria linked to 27 international conventions.
knitted or crocheted While the SMART model yields important (positive)
On 19 May 2017, the EU granted Sri Lanka better access to its Fish and crustaceans, 0
3 30.0 18.7 11.3 6.36 quantitative results, the model captures direct effects
market for exports under the Generalized Scheme of Preferences molluscs and other
GSP+ will consist of the full removal of duties on aquatic invertebrates of a trade policy change only in one sector of an
Plus (GSP Plus). While the scheme is conditional on Sri Lanka Vehicles other than 0
66% of tariff lines, which is estimated to lead to economy; that is, the model assumes that changes in
making progress on human and labour rights and sustainable 15% increase in experts from Sri Lanka to the EU. 87 railway or tramway 10.9 7.3 3.6 2.13
development, it can boost exports to the EU, Sri Lankas rolling stock, and parts that sector have no, or minimal impact on other sectors.
Animal or vegetable fats 0
largest export market. GSP Plus aims at furthering Sri Lankas TOP BENEFICIARIES IN SRI LANKA 15 and oils and their 4.2 3.6 0.7 2.13 Thus, the results may be sensitive to assumptions
development through more trade, as well as by diversifying cleavage products and parameters used. Despite its shortcomings, a
exports and attracting investment with the removal of custom partial equilibrium framework is useful as it allows
Source: WITS/SMART Simulation
duties by the EU. Sri Lanka is now among eight other GSP the utilization of widely available trade data at the
Plus beneficiaries, which include Armenia, Bolivia, Cape Verde, appropriate level of detail to capture variables of
Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia, Pakistan, Paraguay, and Philippines. Aside interest to policymakers and others.
While Sri Lankas exports are likely to grow on average at 15 per cent,
from GSP Plus, the EU has two other trade arrangements 1)
the growth rates differ depending on the export category in question. For
a general arrangement (Standard GSP), which is targeted at GSP+ preferences can make a significant contribution to Sri Lankas economic It is also important to bear in mind that the impact on exports occurs
development by increasing exports to the EU market example, exports of animal and animal products are estimated to grow by
developing countries that are classified by the World Bank as within two years after preferences have been granted, according to
EU Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmstrom
as much as 32 per cent (or US$ 30 million). Sri Lankas main exports to
lower or lower-middle income countries; and 2) Everything But economic assessment of the EU GSP arrangements in developing
the EU, textiles and apparel, accounting for bulk (62 per cent) of the total
Arms (EBA) arrangement for 49 Least Developed Countries Source: European Commission & own research
exports to the regional bloc, is likely to grow by more than 21 per cent (or countries. Further, utilization rates vary significantly from country to
(LDCs). US$ 424.6 million) as a result of GSP Plus. country, and differ by arrangement types. Of the three schemes
an increase in export, but numbers vary significantly between the three different
Standard GSP, GSP Plus, and EBA utilization rate was found to be the
Biggest Beneficiaries of GSP Plus arrangements, product groups and beneficiary countries.
A breakdown of the above overall figures indicates that exports, which lowest for the GSP Plus arrangement; reportedly 66.1 per cent in 2014.
stand to benefit the most from the duty free access to the EU, include Nonetheless, GSP Plus can make an important contribution to increasing
What is the likely economic impact of GSP Plus on Sri Lankas Table 1 contains results from simulating the removal of tariffs by the EU on articles of textile and apparel, fish (fresh or chilled), bicycles and other Sri Lankas exports to the EU market, especially at a time when Sri
exports? Previous studies show that the GSP benefit can lead to Sri Lanka, with the exception of tariffs on some sensitive (agricultural) items. cycles, and coconut oil, to name a few (Table 2). Currently, under the Lankas exports are performing poorly.
26 27
In October 2011, then US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton outlined a instability faced by their counterparts in Europe, and circumstances have
new foreign policy vision for the United States that rebalanced its focus ensured that China in particular, has the opportunity to truly ascend to
to East Asia and Pacific from the Middle East. Given the costly American become the new leader in international trade. The irony is that, within
interventions in the Middle East, the Obama administration believed the same week, the leader of the United State the bastion of free trade
that a diplomatic and military pivot to Asia would best enable them to delivered an inaugural address promoting protectionism while the
benefit from the economic dynamism of the region while also balancing President of China a communist nation delivered an address extolling
Chinas military strength. At the time, the pivot to Asia was considered a the virtues of globalization at the World Economic Forum in Davos.
demonstration of American intent to influence the balance of power in the Where the TPP failed as a mega-regional to dictate 21st century trade
region, as well as geo-politics and economics of the region. Six years on, rules, China along with India is now touting the Regional Comprehensive
however, it is the regional and global balance of power that appears to be Economic Partnership (RCEP). If successful, the RCEP is likely to
pivoting towards Asia. present an alternate path towards trade liberalization based on a more
developing-country-perspective, compared to that of the TPP. In addition
Obamas Pivot to Asia to leading through mega-regional trading arrangements, Chinas booming
middle class allows them to transform the economy from an almost
Following the announcement of the pivot, the American foreign exclusively export-oriented economy to one that is more balanced.
policy establishment moved to strengthen its military capabilities
Figure 1: RCEP and TPP Members
in the region and these moves were most prominent with
growing tensions in the South China Sea region. More important
however, especially from Sri Lankas interests, was the economic RCEP TPP
strategy laid down by the Obama administration. The crown
jewel of Obamas economic pivot to Asia was undoubtedly the
Canada
Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). The largely US-led agreement China Korea Japan
included 12 Pacific countries that covered a significant share
of international trade. Strategically, the agreement did not USA
include China and also set out to dictate new rules for trade and India Indonesia Malaysia Vietnam
investment while circumventing the gridlock of the WTO. The Mexico
Brunei
regional economic focus was, therefore, two-pronged; undercut Cambodia Lao
Chinas growing economic prowess through trade alliances and Singapore Australia
Chile
reforms to trade rules, and tap into the economic dynamism of
Thailand Philippines
the greater ASEAN region. New Zealand
Peru
Myanmar
Trumps Isolationism
Taiwan
However, President Donald Trumps America First stance
has completely overturned the expected trajectory of Asian Source: ASEAN Trade Union Council
Sri Lanka
isolationist economic and foreign policy. Moreover, his Buy American, beneficial to small developing economies. Countries such as Sri Lanka
Hire American stance could potentially undermine the role of the US will find it easier to make the incremental commitments needed to join
as a leader in international trade. One of his first actions as President a mega-regional such as RCEP rather than the complete institutional
was to withdraw the US from the TPP. Moreover, some quarters of the overhauls required for TPP accession. Moreover, the rise of protectionism
and the administration has also seemingly embraced a punitive tariff on Mexican
and Chinese imports. If such a policy were to be implemented, the
impacts on the American and the global economy will undoubtedly be
in the US and the expected instability in Europe due to growing
nationalism and Brexit has made it abundantly evident that Sri Lanka
needs to diversify its export markets. The economic dynamism of the
Pivot to Asia
catastrophic with close to one-third of American trade occurring with future lies in the greater-ASEAN region and the economy needs to make
Mexico and China. Moreover, Trump has also demonstrated his disdain at the necessary adjustments that can cater to these markets. In order
regional trading agreements such as NAFTA. In withdrawing from the TPP to successfully do so, however, the country needs to urgently address
and also pursuing a protectionist trade policy, not only has the US forgone fundamental economic reforms in trade and investment policy along with
in the
the opportunity to gain from the benefits of the free trade agreement, but other institutional reforms.
also the opportunity to mould the rules of trade in the 21st century. The
regimes ambivalence to regional trade and internationalism, therefore, Increasingly, investors from emerging economies (commonly referred
has created an opportunity for a new leader to emerge in international to as Third World MNCs) are starting to move outwards towards other
as fishing, sea transportation, tourism, offshore mining, and energy Blue Economy renewable energy, and circular material flows keeping within the limits
of one planet. The United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP)
diverse range of coastal and marine ecosystems, and high potential for
tourism and recreation industries. However, these opportunities also have
generation, play a significant role in the national economies of many
countries, including Sri Lanka. Expansion of marine economic activities The origin of the concept of Blue Economy is often traced to the book promoted the idea that blue economy is a marine and coastal analogue challenges attached to them. The oceans around the country are highly
can be considered as one frontier of globalization. Unfortunately, the titled The Blue Economy: 10 years 100 innovations 100 million to the Green Economy (GE); in essence, it implies that blue economy is contested by global powers, and being a small player in global political
growing human activities in the oceans, while helping to increase the jobs, written by Gunter Pauli, first published in 2010. However, Paulis applying the concepts of green economy to the unique and irreplaceable arena, Sri Lanka has to take cautious path.
prosperity all over the world, are also responsible for the degradation of concept refers to a business model, aimed at transforming society from role of marine and coastal ecosystems. These definitions help to dispel
marine ecosystems. scarcity to abundance, with the help of locally available resources, misunderstandings, emphasizing the sustainability dimension, without The government of Sri Lanka has promoted a blue economy initiative
through adopting innovative measures to address environmental and that no value addition of advancing the concept. In the final count, a under the Sri Lanka NEXT programme in October 2016. This can
Marine ecosystems fulfil environmental functions that are essential related problems. It does not essentially imply ocean based economic blue economy should essentially be a green economy. The legitimacy be considered as a timely effort. In addition, the country aspires to
for the survival of humans and other living beings. The oceans absorb prospects. Despite Pauli being credited with coining the term, the of the concept was further enhanced due to the adoption of sustainable become a maritime hub in the region, taking the advantage of central
a major share of carbon dioxide emissions that humans produce, concept of blue economy is now being widely used to refer to human development goals (SDGs) by world leaders in the UN General Assembly geographical position and the closeness to major sea lanes. There were
play an important role in the stability of global climate systems, and activities based on oceans, taking them as one entity. Unfortunately, it in 2015. The Goal Number 14 of the SDGs, Life below Water, is aimed at some steps taken in this direction, with mixed results. The country has
accommodate and protect a major part of global biodiversity, making carries many meanings and interpretations, creating doubts in the minds enhancing conservation and sustainable use of ocean-based resources, been promoting its image as a tourism destination, with unique marine
the world habitable for all of us. These global ecosystem services of the of interested public on the subject. It appears that some parties are trying through wise management of resources and protection of marine and and coastal attraction, with some success. Despite these ad hoc efforts,
oceans have come under threat as a result of human activities such to emphasize the ecological perspectives, while others are considering coastal ecosystems from pollution, including the impacts of ocean however, Sri Lanka is yet to come with a viable blue economy strategy
as, over exploitation of resources, illegal-unreported-unregulated (IUU) it merely as an umbrella term for all economic activities in the maritime acidification. that combines the strength of these efforts.
32 33
Pay as You Throw! Free riding and over-consumption
Some consumers of this solid waste disposal service do pay an indirect
How much waste?
The World Bank estimates that per capita solid waste generation per
Vavuniya. 180
Trincomalee, 653
Collect by local auth. % Burry by occupant % Dispose by occupant% Notes: Size of circle indicates average weight of solid waste per day per district in tons.
Source: Authors calculations based on detailed Census 2012 data from DCS and World Bank Estimates
Burn by occupant % Compost by occupant % Other %
Consumer pays
Source: Census 2012 data from DCS
in Sri Lanka:
many.
Wastewater management in Sri Lanka
Wastewater is an uncomfortable and unpleasant subject that many
prefer to avoid. However, it cannot be easily ignored as everyone is The current wastewater management systems in place in Sri Lanka are
An Uncomfortable Reality faced with the problem of wastewater on daily basis, whether at home,
work place or during the everyday commute. Developed countries have
invested large amounts of resources to manage wastewater, giving
abysmal. Being a developing country, Sri Lanka is also plagued with
inefficiencies in wastewater management mentioned above. Sewer
connections are only available for restricted areas in the Colombo city
By Athula Senaratne it high priority and treating the issue as a matter of social welfare. In and for a few other major cities. Inherited from the colonial period,
fact, the level of priority and resources allocated for solving the issue some sections of these systems are dilapidated and are in dire need
of wastewater reflect a fundamental difference in attitudes towards of renovations and upgrades. Extension work on the pipe system
This years theme of the World Water Day focuses on wastewater. This article social welfare between developed and developing societies. In many is moving at a snails pace and the existing systems do not have
highlights the urgent need for effective management of wastewater, given the developing countries, even educated and wealthy members of society centralized treatment facilities. Wastewater collected from the Colombo
severity of the problem and the catastrophic outcomes it could result in, if not seem to be intent on turning a blind eye to the harsh reality and prefer to sewerage system is dumped in to the sea in two locations. Many other
handled wisely. stay in their own comfort zones, rather than actively seeking solutions to fast-developing coastal towns follow this lead, making them leading
the issue. The usual inclination is to dispose the waste from ones own contributors to marine pollution.
Water can easily become wastewater due to many reasons mostly tied to premises without giving much thought to the health and environmental
human activity. The most common sources of wastewater include domestic repercussions of their actions. In this sense, the wastewater problem is Beyond the limited area covered by pipe connected facilities, outskirts
effluent consisting black water (excreta, urine and fecal sludge) and grey water remarkably similar to the garbage problem. Some people carry domestic of city areas and surrounding suburbs mostly have to depend on onsite
(kitchen and bathing wastewater), effluents from commercial establishments garbage bags in vehicles and covertly dump it at isolated places. The wastewater disposal methods. The common practices include individual
(e.g., restaurants and hotels) and other working places including hospitals, storm same motive is visible when a suburban household surreptitiously facilities of septic tanks or open-bottom soakage pits for black water and
water and urban run-off and effluent from industrial, agricultural, horticultural and empties its wastewater pits to storm water drains during heavy showers. open bottom wastewater pits for grey water. However, very often, grey
aquaculture sources. Effluents from industrial and agricultural sources and from Such behavior is motivated by the lack of public collection and sanitary water is channeled illegally to storm water drains directly or indirectly.
hospitals are considered water pollution; comprehensive pollution control measures disposal systems, a situation prevalent in many developing countries. In underserved areas of Colombo and other cities, residents often have
no choice but to share common toilet pits and dispose kitchen and bath
that go beyond mere disposal of wastewater are necessary to handle the problem
of water pollution. On the other hand, managing wastewater from domestic and
Common methods for disposal of wastewater water to storm water drains, creating uninhabitable conditions in the
surrounding environments. Coupled with ill-designed storm water drains
commercial sources and urban run-off is largely a matter of proper disposal.
There are two basic wastewater management strategies. They are and run-off water disposal facilities, non-standard waste water disposal
However, given the scale and frequency of wastewater generated from these
onsite (non-sewered) disposal and off-site (sewered) disposal with or methods are the reason that Colombo and other major cities in the island
sources, especially in urban areas where population and economic activities are
without centralized treatment facilities. In urban areas, off-site disposal are plunged into chaos during flash floods.
of wastewater and disposal of surface run-off are closely connected.
Therefore, in some countries, combined systems that convey run-off Overall, poor investment on standard public wastewater disposal facilities
water with foul sewage in the same pipes can be found. However, many has led many residents in urban areas to depend on individual onsite
countries have resorted to systems that carry surface run-off and foul wastewater disposal facilities. The quality of these facilities varies greatly.
sewage separately. Off-site disposal systems are more effective and Moreover, this causes accumulation of wastewater in large quantities
are in place worldwide. Modern cities in developed countries have in local neighborhoods, affecting the groundwater. In some suburban
established extensive systems for wastewater collection and disposal areas, residents are still dependent on shallow groundwater wells for
with centralized treatment facilities. Like other public infrastructure domestic water supply and they get affected from groundwater polluted
facilities such as transport, urban parks, water and electricity supply, by accumulated wastewater. Considering this situation, some technical
these wastewater management facilities also play a major role in making standards have been imposed in building approval criteria regarding
these cities more habitable, contributing to high living standards enjoyed locating septic tanks and wastewater pits when constructing houses.
by citizens. However, the effectiveness of such measures, monitoring of those
standards and level of compliance cannot be guaranteed.
However, establishing such off-site disposal facilities are costly
operations. They need high capital investments for establishment Wastewater challenge
and large operational budgets for running and maintenance. Users
are charged for these services by utility companies that operate on Sri Lanka boasts of the prevalence of sanitation facilities even among
volumetric basis. Large utility companies are usually run as public- poorer communities, when compared with many other developing
private partnerships under close supervision of city administrations. In countries. However, the management of wastewater is an exception, and
developing countries, city administrators have limited means to invest in remains a challenge. It is a public health and environmental hazard that
modern wastewater management systems and low-income city dwellers cannot be left for residents to resolve on their own. Serious health and
cannot be expected bear the full cost of services they offer. As a result, environmental issues demand public solutions where individuals have to
many developing countries are unable to afford such systems. Hence, play their roles considering their own and community welfare. Individuals
modern wastewater treatment facilities are restricted to limited areas cannot make large public investments required for establishing
of large urban centers in the developing world. When available, these standard facilities and the government and city administrations need to
systems are usually located in service opulent neighborhoods and a give due priority to initiate such facilities. However, effective systems
large majority of the population suffers due to lack of proper wastewater need resources for establishment of facilities and efficient operation
disposal facilities. These underprivileged areas are usually left with that cannot be borne by cash strapped city administrations alone.
onsite disposal systems in various forms of operational arrangements. Beneficiaries of the facilities also have to bear some burden here. This
Usually such systems are less hygienic, and chaotic situations arise requires innovations in technical as well as management and institutional
during disasters such as urban floods. Furthermore, poor storm water aspects of wastewater management solutions in the country.
36 37
People are reliant on numerous benefits or ecosystem services offered towards environmental sustainability. Thus, while environmental literacy
by the nature. The ecosystem services range from provision of food begins with knowledge, it is completed only with behavioral aspects
for sustenance to provision of cultural services such as recreational which are vital for environmental sustainability.
Connecting People
experiences. However, a long lasting connection between people and
nature requires careful and responsible behavior of humans in all It is unlikely that many individuals are unaware of the environmental
activities that involve nature. The responsibility lies with all sects of impact of certain activities. The problem occurs when it comes to
to Nature:
the society, ranging from the individuals, corporates, civil society and responsible behavior. Therefore, though environmental education and
the government. There is enough evidence to show that lack of true awareness have always been an important element in environmental
connectivity between people and nature causes negative implications for policies, the ultimate policy goals are yet to be achieved.
development. A meaningful connectivity between people and nature leads
Lines
Department of Census and Statistics (DCS), the latest data set available persons are still at risk of slipping back to poverty. As the poor and near
at present. The analysis examines the status of poverty at national, poor could easily get affected due to various economic shocks and/or
sectoral, and district levels, as well as by different population groups weakening of any of the other three dimensions, education, health and
based on the occupation or activity of the head of the household (Groups living conditions, it would be more appropriate to look at persons who
are given in Table 2). are in Income Poverty and / or Multidimensional Poverty, which covers
By Wimal Nanayakkara
all dimensions of poverty. This is especially important, as SDG 1 also
envisages reduction of all forms and dimensions of poverty, everywhere.
Information on poverty estimated using different poverty lines, which
There are 1.8 million persons (or 9.3 per cent) who are in IP and/or
measures Income Poverty, Multidimensional Poverty, Extreme Poverty MDP (columns 8 and 9, Tables 1 and 2).
based on global poverty lines etc., could be useful to those involved
in developing strategies to achieve SDG 1. It is important to note that To measure extreme poverty, the Global Poverty Line $ 1.25 a day (2005
both, the Poverty Headcount (or the percentage of poor within a region/ PPP) was being used until October, 2015. Since then the World Bank
population group), and the share (out of the total) in each region/ and UN agencies have introduced a new Poverty Line $ 1.90 a day
population group, need to be considered when developing strategies to (2011 PPP) to measure extreme poverty, soon after the declaration of
reduce poverty everywhere in the country. SDGs in September, 2015. They also changed the lines used to measure
40 41
Saman
Moderate Poverty, from $ 2.00 a day (2005 PPP) to $ 3.10 a day cent), because MDP is high (17.9 per cent) in this sector (column 4, Table
(2011 PPP). The World Bank claims that Poverty Headcounts computed 1). This is mainly due to inadequate access to safe drinking water and
using these new poverty lines, should not make much of a difference, safe sanitation, in the
Table 2- Poverty Headcount and Share of Poor Persons Based on Different Poverty Lines by Household Groups Classified by Occupation Estate Sector. Out of the
or Activity of the Head of Household-2012/13
Kelegama
districts, Batticaloa is
Poverty Headcount (HC) and Share of Poor Persons Under Different Poverty Lines the poorest, in terms of
Household Groups Extreme Extreme both Poverty Headcount
Classified by Occupation or Income and Poverty Poverty
Income poor MD Poor Near MDP / or MD [<$1.25 a [<$1.90 a and Share of Poor,
Activity of the Head of
Poor day (2005 day (2011 followed by Monaragala.
Household PPP)] PPP) ]
HC share HC share HC share HC share HC share HC share Other districts with high
The text of our commission had covered migration of their skilled workers on the ground trade liberalization. His doctoral dissertation The CEPA is a mere extension of the free regime, even under severe strains of political
Without her, I couldnt have done what I have
the economic benefits of migration and of what is known as brain drain, says Saman. was also on the trade liberalization process in trade agreement to investment and services instability and macroeconomic instability.
done. My son, Chandana, is studying for his
Sri Lanka. In the recent past, he was one of as well. But many have expressed the fear that
issues such as increasing the value of annual
The brain drain occurs if the human capital the architects of the proposed comprehensive it is simply a wholesale selling of Sri Lankas
Popular economics columnist A-Level and daughter Jayathri for her O-Level.
remittances flow to each member country and I have given them freedom to pursue their
illegal migrant traffic which had been rampant stock of a developing country declines as economic partnership agreement or CEPA with services sector to India which is not true. When Saman had to take forward his fathers legacy own career paths and therefore they may
in countries like Bangladesh, India, Nepal a result of the migration of its skilled and India. The CEPA, which was the product of a India has made a deep opening of its services as an economic columnist as well. His father not necessarily end up as economists. The
and Pakistan. The policies recommended by educated workers. It would weaken its long-drawn consultative process with business sector, Sri Lanka has opened its services sector wrote a very popular economics column to professional family man reveals to me.
the commission were to be used for taking economy and in extreme cases can lead even and industry people in both countries, ran into to India very cautiously and in a limited way. a Sunday newspaper under the pen name
remedial measures for migrants issues at to a collapse of the economy. But this fear is a stormy weather when the local businessmen For instance, India has agreed to open 80 sub of Kanes. After his untimely demise, Saman I wonder whether it is the end of the family
international forums like the Colombo Process counteracted by the development of a new took to streets in an unprecedented manner sectors upfront while Sri Lanka would do so continued the column now under a different legacy of producing reputed economists. But it
and the Abu Dhabi Dialogue. The aim of concept called brain gain. forcing the government to shelve it temporarily. only in the case of 20 such sub sectors. pen name, The Economist, which became may be too early to make that judgment.
46 47
and poor interaction with formal financial institutions. Undoubtedly, Therefore, providing potential clients with comprehensive explanations on
this highlights significant opportunities that exist in the microinsurance the policy, and continuously engaging with the clients as explained during
Loss of assets; lowered agricultural Loss of assets/income/ production Low income earning, rural clients face multiple risks. Therefore,
productivity and returns & Denial of benefits composite products that cover multiple risks have the potential to attract
more clients to increase demand, as well as outreach. However, since
I had not thought of buying an insurance policy until I listened to Which Opportunities are Available? Source: Authors field experiences such complex schemes may be more difficult for clients to comprehend
one of the agents who built the trust in me and impressed me with a consultations in Sri Lanka reveal that trust, value proposition, irregular easily, starting with simple schemes that can be understood by anyone
clear explanation on the benefits it offers for different events such as Rural poor households are vulnerable to various risks which exacerbate incomes (liquidity constraints) and awareness as the most important will be more appealing. Awareness creation can eventually facilitate the
illnesses, financial safeguard for retirement, non-claim bonus, etc. their poverty levels (Figure 1). While informal risk management determinants of demand for microinsurance. move towards schemes covering multiple risks.
Microinsurance policy holder mechanisms and social safety nets like Samurdhi are available, these are
often insufficient, particularly when risks frequently occur over a short Dissatisfaction or lack of trust about insurance policies, and agents in The poor generally prefer to rely on savings and informal borrowings for
Sri Lankans living in most areas of the island are highly vulnerable to risk period of time. Further, low and volatile incomes hinder the accumulation particular, has been the biggest concern for households while renewing, emergencies due to the flexibility they offer. Therefore, bundling with
and uncertainty. They frequently suffer from various disasters such as of savings and even the available savings are exposed to high inflation in purchasing or choosing to purchase an insurance policy in Sri Lanka. savings is preferred, as it gives some assurance for premium payments.
floods, droughts and landslides, diseases and deaths, pest and disease Sri Lanka. Insurance agents are usually not direct employers of the service provider Technological advancements such as expansion of mobile phone
networks in Sri Lanka can be used to make the system more efficient
outbreaks for crops, etc. Inability to effectively deal with such risks is and are paid based on the premiums collected and the number of new
However, the poor have been excluded from existing formal commercial and to minimize operational costs.
widely accepted as a contributory factor for persistent poverty. Insurance enrolments. Rumours or experiences of insurance scams by so-called
has evolved as an effective instrument to compensate the financial insurance schemes due to various reasons. From the supply side, formal agents have led people to mistrust insurance agents.
insurance products have been designed primarily for middle and high Since microinsurance in Sri Lanka is still at the infant stage, the
losses from such shocks affecting assets and livelihoods. In developing
income classes, and not much has been done to reach out to the informal gestation period for the returns on investments could be bit longer for
countries like Sri Lanka, where the formal insurance markets are Volatility in main income flows, which makes it difficult to ensure timely
economy, especially in remote areas. From a demand perspective, the the insurance companies. The possible solution for this could be initial
inefficient in its delivery and ineffective in reaching the needy, especially payments of high premium values, also plays a key role in the lack of
poor lack the capacity to access formal insurance. This supply and cooperation with nonprofit-oriented government or non-government
in rural areas, microinsurance is often available. Hence, microinsurance demand for microinsurance. Not having a continuous income stream
demand gap, along with inadequate insurance organizations, has raised organizations in order to reduce the cost of product design and
has the potential to make the poor less vulnerable to such risks, by sometimes prevents policy holders from paying the premium without implementation. Finally, the facilitative role of government in promoting
the need for a micro level insurance scheme that targets low income
offering a convenient risk transfer mechanism for them. Unfortunately, households. defaults which then results in the automatic cancellation of insurance microinsurance among the poor by creating awareness and breaking
convincing people, especially the poor, to trust a stranger to safe- policies. However, people who are able to pay the premiums regularly are the barrier of distrust and making an enabling environment through
keep their hard-earned money, which they may or may not get back, Moreover, there are certain household socio-economic and demographic satisfied with their policies. Therefore, the reason for mistrust may not be regulation is also very important.
is a difficult task. Therefore, the demand for microinsurance products characteristics that underpin the necessity of microinsurance for rural necessarily misconduct of the agent, but a lack of understanding about
by the rural inhabitants is very low and the outreach of microfinance inhabitants. These include poor infrastructure, higher risk of illnesses due the terms and conditions of the policy. For example, field consultations (This article is based on a desk review and set of focus group discussions
institutes in the rural areas is very limited, despite the increasing need of to poor sanitation, inadequate nutrition and access to health services, revealed that the automatic cancellation due to unpaid premiums is the conducted by the IPS to evaluate the demand for micro-insurance in Sri
microinsurance. high risk occupations, volatile incomes, lack of savings and other assets, reason behind certain policyholders mistrust. Lanka.)
48 49
World No Tobacco Day:
Where Does Sri Lanka
Stand? By G D Dayaratne
World No Tobacco Day (WNTD) was established twenty nine years ago in 1987 by The WHO Initiative impact of tax increases on smokers who are poor is often portrayed as a
the Member States of the World Health Organization (WHO). The theme for this years disadvantage of policies that increase taxes on tobacco products.
World No Tobacco Day, Tobacco a threat to development, calls for countries
to accelerate tobacco control efforts as a part of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable As WHO has pointed out, the objective of WNTD is to abstain from
Next to the increase of prices, anti-tobacco campaigns are concentrated
Development. Tobacco control has been included in Sustainable Development tobacco use for 24 hours and draw worldwide attention to the
on pictorial warnings, accompanied with text warnings. Many European
Agenda and is identified as an effective means to help achieve SDG target 3.4 of prevalence of tobacco use and its negative health effects. According
countries opted to display only text warnings such as SMOKERS
reducing one third of the global tobacco use, by 2030. This target covers tobacco to WHO, tobacco kills nearly 6 million people a year and if the current
DIE YOUNGER or SMOKING KILLS while Australia introduced plain
control, reduction of premature mortality from non-communicable diseases by one trends continue, the number is estimated to rise to 8 million by 2030.
packaging without pictorial and text warnings. In Sri Lanka introducing
third, and prevention of disaster risks which lead to improvements in the health It further says, the day also sheds lights on the significant number of
pictorial warning took place in different stages. In 2012, the government
conditions of the population. Improvements in health subsequently lead to economic deaths, nearly 600,000, resulting from passive smoking and the health
announced through a Gazette notification, the enforcement of pictorial
development. WHO estimated that the global economy is losing around US$ 1 hazards posed by secondhand smoke. This dire situation has led to
warnings covering 80 per cent the cigarette packet. Subsequently the
trillion (820bn) due to depleting productivity levels, and the additional burden the focus of the initiative being on advertising efforts of the industry
court reduced the percentage of the pictorial warning to 60 per cent,
on health services caused by tobacco use. Controlling tobacco use has been a sources, especially aimed at youth; as WHO has revealed the tobacco
after an interim order sought by the industry players. In 2016, new
proven approach to improve the health of the workforce which in turn improves the industry is aiming to replace older, quitting, or dying smokers with
legislation was introduced to the effect that 80 per cent of the surface
business productivity and profitability of companies, leading to enhanced revenue, younger consumers. The campaign to stop these efforts of the tobacco
of the cigarette packet should be covered by the pictorial warning. India,
according to the Centre for disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Reducing tobacco industry has met with growing support from world, and public health
on the other hand uses a combination of pictorial and text warnings,
use also enables families to redistribute the money spent on tobacco products on organizations, amidst resistance from tobacco users, growers and
with graphic photographs of oral and throat cancers occupying 65%
covering household expenditures and reduces expenditure on health care. the industry itself. WHO initiative for WNTD is further strengthened by
creating a global public health policy through the Framework Convention of tobacco packages, while 15 per cent of the surface is used for text
on Tobacco Control (FCTC) Treaty, with the agreement of 170 parties, warnings.
In this context, the article examines the effectiveness of various tobacco control
measures used by different countries, including Sri Lanka, in reducing the use of and 80 per cent of the global population, to implement policies toward
tobacco. cessation of tobacco. WHO tobacco control framework, involves warning Sri Lankas Achievements
about the dangers of tobacco use, enforcing bans on tobacco advertising,
and raising taxes on tobacco. Sri Lanka ratified FCTC in 2003 and in
line with the above initiative, introduced measures such as restrictions According to NATA, in Sri Lanka and around the world there has
on smoking in public places, the pictorial health warnings on cigarette been tremendous progress made in both adopting these measures
packets to cover 60 per cent area of the pack, in addition to text and reducing the devastating toll of tobacco. Annual tobacco related
warnings on all packs, and established the National Authority on Tobacco deaths in Sri Lanka have been estimated at 24,000 by the Ministry of
and Alcohol (NATA) along with penalties for violating these regulations. Health. With the aim of curtailing tobacco related noncommunicable
Further, in October 2015, the government raised prices of cigarettes by diseases, the government introduced amendments to NATA Act 3 of
43 per cent and tax on tobacco was increased to 90 per cent. 2015, to increase the pictorial warnings on tobacco pack to 80 per cent.
Further, according to Department of Excise, the battle against tobacco
smoking, mainly cigarettes, gathered momentum in recent time with the
Measures Relating to the Reduction of increasing of prices, while beedi (raw tobacco) not smoked or even seen
Demand for Tobacco on the streets of Colombo is growing in popularity in rural Sri Lanka,
unchecked. Beedi is a small and medium scale industry. It engages local
farmers to cultivate tobacco, imports a specific leaf called tendu that is
Among the measures that the world adopted to control smoking, the
used to roll the beedi, and women in most rural households, engage in
most effective has been the raising the prices of cigarettes or tobacco
rolling beedi for a pittance using the tendu leaves imported from India.
products, which leads to a reduction in the demand and limits the
market power of tobacco companies, as per Article 6 of FCTC. It was
reported in Australian Budget Review 2010-2011 that, policies to control Sri Lankas effort in battle against tobacco smoking has yielded positive
tobacco use, including introducing tobacco tax and increasing prices, can results but smokers will find alternatives to satisfy their addiction due
generate significant government revenues for health and development to availability of low cost raw tobacco products, and the easy access
work. Tobacco prices have steadily increased in European countries, to smuggled cigarettes. The only good sign is, there is a marked drop
Australia, African countries and some East Asian countries as a measure in smoking by the younger population, as reported by industry sources,
to curb tobacco smoking. According to World Bank estimates, a 10 per which will lead to building a healthy generation in the future, and could
cent increase in taxes will decrease demand by 8 per cent. However, the help to achieve SDG 3.4.
50 51
also a contributory challenge. Overall, measures and research to combat among vulnerable populations by the Ceylon National Association for
the problem of TB remain underfunded. the Prevention of Tuberculosis, the incidence of the disease continues
to escalate. The Government has also taken measures to increase
This article aims to outline the burden of TB in Sri Lanka and highlights the price of cigarettes by 90% in addition to the legal obligation of an
the institutional challenges in TB control, limiting access to care, and 80% pictorial warning on the package and a recent proposition to ban
proposes recommendations to overcome these discussed challenges in the selling of individual cigarettes with the intend of reducing the risk
accordance with this years focus mentioned above. factors associated with contracting TB and other non-communicable
diseases. Regardless of these efforts, inefficiencies in the design and
Burden of TB in Sri Lanka implementation of TB prevention and control strategies continue to
prevail.
Sri Lanka is considered a low burden TB country, although in the recent
past reported TB cases have been on the rise. Given that the disease is Treatment Outcomes
airborne and easily transmitted through an infected person, poverty, poor
According to the National Strategic Plan for Tuberculosis Control 2015-
2020, Sri Lanka has successfully maintained a high treatment rate for
TB with the highest rate of 87.1% in 2011 coupled with a significant
decrease in failure to follow up from 13.8% in 2000 to 3.5% in 2010.
However, the report further highlights that as of recently, there has been a
Unite to End
notable increase in those failing to continue treatment from 3.7% in 2011
to 4.6% in 2012 and 4.8% in 2013. These statistics are noteworthy and
a serious cause for concern since they are severe lapses in the control of
TB care. Substandard in-patient treatment facilities at district hospitals
Tuberculosis
and deficiencies in trained human resources for TB care are factors
inhibiting the control of the disease.
Challenges
By Yolanthika Ellepola
Given that the incidence of the disease is relatively low in Sri Lanka,
the extent of discrimination and stigma associated with the disease
is comparatively less compared to India, China and other South Asian
countries. A slowdown in the reported TB cases in 2012, as depicted in
Figure 1, was not due to a sharp decrease in the total TB cases but rather
due to programmatic errors at primary and regional hospitals. Centralized
Figure 1: Reported New and Relapse Case Notifications from 2005-2013 treatment at the district chest clinics, limited use of private providers of
Directly Observed Treatment Short course (DOTS), and an absence of a
10000
centralized system of registering patients and initiating treatment at this
9000
clinic inhibits access to care. Due to these inefficiencies at peripheral
8000
hospitals, TB most often remains undetected in some patients or detected
7000
6000
at a later stage of the disease where the medication fails to respond to
5000
the bacteria. Others discontinue the medication prescribed and opt for
4000 traditional methods of healing due to the transportation costs and other
3000 associated personal costs involved in travelling to these clinics/hospitals.
2000 All these factors curtail access to TB care.
1000
0 Way Forward
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
New Cases Relapse Cases Since Sri Lanka is not a high burden TB country as its neighbor,
Source: Annual Report of the National Programme for Tuberculosis Control and Chest Diseases, 2013. India, ending the disease is not a mammoth task. This requires a
multidimensional approach, where political will and commitment plays
a central role. Given that TB stems from diverse factors, collaboration
living conditions and increased use of tobacco, expedites the occurrence and coordination among several government agencies, civil society and
On 24 March 2017, the United Nations celebrated World Tuberculosis Despite medical advances to cure TB, formidable challenges continue to
and transmission. The recent influx of migrants from China and India is private sector is essential to effectively control the disease. Initiating
Day, under the theme Unite to End TB: Leave no one behind. This is prevail. These include fragile health systems, the co-epidemics with HIV,
considered a contributory factor towards the increased incidence of the mobile clinics to alleviate the barriers involved in access to care and
a World Health Organizations (WHO) End TB Strategy, which calls for diabetes, tobacco use and perhaps most importantly, human resource
disease. introducing a family health worker to monitor the progress of TB patients
a 90% reduction in Tuberculosis (TB) deaths and an 80% reduction in and financial constraints.
will help ease the issues relating to lost follow up and access to care.
the TB incidence rate by 2030. The focus this year is to address issues According to the latest data published by the National Programme for In addition, given that Sri Lanka has implemented several national
relating to stigma, discrimination, marginalization and access to care. According to the Global Tuberculosis Report, low and middle income Tuberculosis Control and Chest Diseases (NPTCCD), and as depicted in policy programmes and secured funding through the GFATM, these
countries rely on international donors for 90% of financing on national Figure 1, it is evident that the incidence of the rate of TB in 2013 was funds could be effectively utilized by enhancing the present institutional
TB is one of the major public health threats, with 10.4 million people programmes. These countries incurred a deficit of USD 2 billion of the 44.1 per 100,000 population compared to 42.5 per 100,000 population arrangements to control the spread of the disease. However, in reality the
contracting the disease globally in 2015, of which 1.8 million died. Most USD 8.3 billion required in 2016. The report further predicts that this in 2006. Despite external funding received by the Global Fund for extent to which these stakeholders work in unity to control the spread of
of these cases were reported from India which accounted for a 34% annual gap will widen to USD 6 billion in 2020, if funding does not AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria (GFATM), and heightened awareness this disease and alleviate bottlenecks to improve access to care to end
increase from 2013. increase. Apart from this, Multi Drug Resistance Tuberculosis (MDR-TB) is campaigns to promote knowledge and improve access to medication TB remains to be seen.
52 53
health services (National Institute of Mental Health), 23 psychiatric in-
Figure 1: Prevalence Rate of Major Depression by Gender, 1990-2015 patient units/wards, 86 outpatient clinic centers and 250 outreach clinics
3 are operated throughout the country. In addition, day-treatment facilities
2.9 as well as 22 intermediate mental health care rehabilitation units are also
2.8
being managed by the Health Ministry. Apart from the hospital based
Male treatments and services, psychiatric nursing officers, CSO, and PSWs
on Depression:
2.4
2.3
Adequacy and rationality of financial resources being mobilized for
2.2 mental health is still questionable. One reason is that, the Health Ministry
2.1 spends a large portion on curative care while a very small amount is
Sri Lanka Figure 2: Years Lived with Disability (YLD) due to Major Depression, (000),
1990-2015, Sri Lanka
120
Developing evidence-based mental health intervention and utilizing
financial resources effectively can only be done with proper information
on mental health. However, Sri Lanka is still far behind of maintaining a
By Samanthi Bandara unique information system on mental health within the country.
100
This paper examines Sri Lankas experience with manufacturing exports expansion, placing
CHINA NGO NETWORK FOR emphasis on opportunities and policy priorities in a rapidly changing global context in which
INTERNATIONAL EXCHANGES global production sharing has become the prime mover of cross border production and trade. The
(CNIE) STUDY TOUR findings make a strong case for redressing policy backsliding and continue with the market-
Highlighting the need for engaging think tanks oriented reforms agenda that was left incomplete in the late 1990s, and set up institutional
and other NGOs to make Chinas Belt and Road safeguards to avert further backsliding.
Initiative more inclusive, IPS Research Fellow,
Dr. Ganga Tilakaratna noted that think tanks By Prema-chandra Athukorala | April 2017
in particular can play an important role in
minimizing the information gaps, and creating
knowledge and awareness of the objectives and
benefits of this initiative at all levels which is INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON POLICY DIALOGUE ON THE ESCAP
crucial as there is not much information at the HUMAN CAPITAL, FOOD SECURITY ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL SURVEY
FORTHCOMING PUBLICATIONS
ground level.
AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN FOR ASIA PACIFIC 2017
Dr. Tilakaratna made this observation, while SOUTH ASIA
A Policy Dialogue on the ESCAP Economic and
participating at a study tour organized by the IPS in collaboration with the Centre of Social Survey for Asia Pacific 2017 was held at
China NGO Network for International Exchanges Development Economics and Sustainability
(CNIE). The study tour included discussions on (CDES), and the South Asia Research Network
IPS on 08 March 2017, with the participation of
IPS Executive Director Dr. Saman Kelegama and Sri Lanka: State of the Economy 2017
the One Belt and One Road initiative, meetings
with the NGO networks in China, and field visits
(SARN), Monash University, Australia, organized
a conference on Human Capital, Food Security
several IPS researchers. Demographics, Labour Markets and Growth
in Guangdong and Fujian Provinces. and Economic Development in South Asia. Economic Affairs Officer of ESCAP, Jose Antonio
Pedrosa Garcia, made a presentation on the The IPS annual flagship report Sri Lanka: State of the Economy provides a critical assessment
The conference provided an opportunity for Survey at the Policy Dialogue which was of the countrys economic performance and near term outlook for growth and macroeconomic
researchers from Monash University, the IPS followed by a lively and engaging discussion. stability. Each year, the report also examines crucial medium term policy priorities to achieve
and other academics to engage with scholars sustained growth and strengthen socio-economic development outcomes for the country.
and policy analysts from the South Asia region
to strengthen links, and plan and implement
Despite lackluster GDP growth in 2016, the policy setting suggests that investors can look
collaborative research activities on major
development challenges facing South Asia. forward to progressive improvements in the macroeconomic environment as fiscal reforms in
particular pay-off. However, a complimentary set of broad-based reforms that address structural
constraints on growth need to be implemented alongside. Access to cost-effective and reliable
infrastructure services, finance, and land; an efficient institutional and regulatory environment;
and a good human resource pool of professional and technical skills, to name a few.
Against this backdrop the Sri Lanka: State of the Economy 2017 report draws attention to
WORLD CONSUMER RIGHTS Demographics, Labour Markets and Growth as its main thematic focus. Two of the biggest
DAY FORUM constraints holding back labour market efficiency in Sri Lanka are its stringent employment
To mark the World Consumer Rights Day, IPS protection laws and its low female labour force participation rates. Another main constraint
held a forum, centered on the theme Consumer dampening labour market efficiency in Sri Lanka is the availability of skilled workers and the
Rights in the Digital Age on 15 March 2017 related large number of Sri Lankan workers annually exiting the labour market in search of
in the IPS Auditorium, with the participation THIRD MEETING OF THE BIMSTEC employment overseas. At a broader level, other institutional and regulatory reforms that impinge
of experts in the field, digital consumers, NETWORK OF POLICY THINK on the competitiveness and productivity of economic activities discussed in some details in the
entrepreneurs and stakeholders. TANKS report under Policy Debates: Special Issues are:
IPS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
The keynote address was delivered by Jayantha PARTICIPATES AT SANEM ANNUAL IPS Research Fellow, Dr. Janaka Wijayasiri, Fuelling Tourism to Move Forward
Fernando, Legal Adviser of the Information
ECONOMISTS CONFERENCE 2017 participated in the Third Meeting of the Revisiting Land Policy: Reforms to Match Evolving Economic Needs
and Communication Technology Agency (ICTA). BIMSTEC Network of Policy Think Tanks Managing Natural Disaster Risks: A Need of the Hour
The panelists were Dr. Dayanath Jayasuriya, IPS Executive Director, Dr. Saman Kelegama, (BNPTT) held at the BIMSTEC Secretariat, Exploring Sustainable Development Goals: What is Ahead for Sri Lanka?
Presidents Counsel, former Chairman of participated at the South Asia Network on Dhaka, Bangladesh on 22-23 April 2017.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC),
Confronting Food Security in Sri Lanka: A Formidable Challenge
Economic Modeling (SANEM)s Second Annual
Lahiru Pathmalal, CEO of Takas Pvt. Ltd, Suhaila Economists Conference on Managing Growth IPS is the focal point of BNPTT in Sri Lanka. Battling NCDs for a Healthier Population
Hussain, President of Sri Lanka Housewives for Social Inclusion in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Issues discussed included activities undertaken
Association, Jiffrey Zulfer, CEO of Digital since the last meeting, celebration of the 20th
Mobility Solutions Lanka and Thishya Weragoda, Dr. Kelegama was one of the speakers on the Anniversary of the BIMSTEC, establishment of Visit our YouTube Channel IPS Sri Lanka for Interviews with the Authors.
Attorney at Law of the Supreme Court of Sri high-level panel on Managing Growth for the Centre for Bay of Bengal Studies, funding, For Details on IPS Publications Contact:
Lanka. Social Inclusion in South Asia. and new initiatives by the BNPTT. Amesh Thennakoon, Publication Officer, 011 214 3107 or 011 214 3100 | amesh@ips.lk or publications@ips.lk
56 57
Nisha Arunatillake Samanthi Bandara G D Dayaratne Yolanthika Ellepola
Nisha Arunatilake is a Research Samanthi Bandara is a Research G. D. Dayaratne works on health Yolanthika Ellepola is a Research
Fellow at the IPS. She heads the Officer in the Health Economics Policy economic policy issues at IPS. He Assistant at IPS whose research
Labour, Employment and Human Unit at the IPS. Her research interests is the Manager of the Health Policy interests covers Health Economic
Resource Development research are health care financing, healthcare Programme. Policy, Millennium Development
unit. Her research interests include evaluation, and impact assessment of Goals, and Sustainable Development
labour market analysis, education health policies/interventions. Goals, in relation to health policy.
and skill development, migration and
development and health economics.
Charmaine Wijesinghea
Charmaine Wijesinghe is Manager
CONTRIBUTORS
Publications & Events at IPS and is
a member of the Talking Economics
Team.
58
38
FAST FACTS
Recent environmental
problems are mostly due
08 The present Sri Lankan
labour market is besieged 12 A fairly large proportion
of the Sri Lankan
Rs.110
to lack of meaningful
by labour shortages. This population is differently
connectivity between
article shows that making abled. This article argues
people and nature.
education provision more that affirmative action
Enhancement of
efficient and effective can is needed to help such
BILLION environmental literacy is
a vital step in minimizing
get more youth to enter the
labour market.
persons enter the labour
market.
such problems in Sri
Sri Lankas tourist arrivals In February, the COPE report Lanka.
hit a record high in 2016 by revealed that the losses of
surpassing two million key public entities have
- Tourism Development exceeded Rs. 110 billion
Minister John Amaratunga. and will continue to increase.
40 More than 70% of the
poor in Sri Lanka are in
54 Depression is a health
concern that cannot be
households headed by
14 Female labour force
participation continues to
agricultural laborers/
workers, non-agricultural
ignored as it leads to
social and economic
be low in Sri Lanka. This repercussions and could
The Asian Development Bank (ADB) article highlights some of
laborers and those unable/
shorten the span of
too old to work, and
doubled its lending capacity to the key social and cultural
therefore poverty reduction
productive lives due to
constraints holding women
Sri Lanka to $800 million. back.
strategies should mainly
suicide.
focus on them.
GSP+
According to the government,
Sri Lankan government Sri Lanka stuck in a
sector kept on expanding Gigantic-Debt-Trap and that
year on year, and as of The European Union paying off foreign loans would 16 Apparel industry has been
10 Setting the national 50 Sri Lankas effort in its
battle against tobacco has
experiencing a difficulty standards for all higher yielded positive results
February, the total number formally restored GSP+ hit a record $2.41 billion this in recruiting women for education providers will but smokers will find
of state employees trade concessions year, up from $1.82 the lower level positions. help meet Sri Lankas skill alternatives due to the
was over 1.1 million. to Sri Lanka in May. billion in 2016.
Protecting the industry demand, by unraveling the availability of low cost raw
is of vital importance controversy surrounding tobacco products, and the
given its contribution to private higher education easy access to smuggled
Sri Lankas economy and providers. cigarettes. However
its role in empowering there is a marked drop in
The Land (Restrictions on women. smoking by the younger
Alienation) Amendment Act No.
IN A NUTSHELL
population.
3 of 2017 was signed in April,
removing the tax on the lease
of land by foreigners.
06 06 June 2017 marks
20 years since the
establishment of Bay
60 61
DIGEST
A PUBLICATION BY
THE INSTITUTE OF POLICY STUDIES OF SRI LANKA
SUPPORTED BY
The Institute of Policy Studies of Sri Lanka (IPS) is an autonomous institution that aims to promote policy-oriented economic research and to strengthen the capacity for medium-term policy
analysis in sri lanka. Its mission is to contribute to the socio-economic development of the country through informed, independent and high quality research that seeks to influence the policy
process. With over two decades of substantial research expertise, IPS has emerged as a regional centre of excellence and the most influential think tank in Sri Lanka.