Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
OF RESILIENCEK.-L. EDWARD
Feature Article
The phenomenon of resilience in crisis care mental
health clinicians
Karen-leigh Edward
School of Nursing, Faculty of Health and Behavioural Sciences, Deakin University, Burwood, Auastralia
ABSTRACT: The purpose of this study, undertaken in 2003, was to explore the phenomenon of
resilience as experienced by Australian crisis care mental health clinicians working in a highly
demanding, complex, specialized and stressful environment. For the purpose of this research, the term
resilience was defined as the ability of an individual to bounce back from adversity and persevere
through difficult times. The six participants for this study were drawn from Melbourne metropolitan
mental health organizations the disciplines of nursing, allied health and medicine. A number of
themes were explicated from the participants interview transcripts Participants identified the
experience of resilience through five exhaustive descriptions, which included: The team is a protective
veneer to the stress of the work; Sense of self; Faith and hope; Having insight; and Looking after
yourself. These exhaustive descriptions were integrated into a fundamental structure of resilience for
clinicians in this role. The studys findings have the potential to inform organizations in mental health
to promote resilience in clinicians, with the potential to reduce the risk of burnout and hence staff
attrition, and promote staff retention and occupational mental health.
KEY WORDS: community psychiatric nursing, education and practice development, mental health
care, phenomenology.
autonomously within the parameters of their role, which risk, emotionality and self-regulation in predicting chil-
is primarily concerned with facilitating a seamless, appro- drens adjustment problems and positive adjustment
priate and timely mental health service to clients in the (Lengua 2002); Criss et al. (2002) used a descriptive,
least restrictive manner (DHS 1986). Service provision exploratory correlational design with regression analysis
for people in crisis, therefore, occurs within a stringent to explore a longitudinal perspective on risk and resilience
legal framework as outlined by the Mental Health Act in relation to family adversity; resilience has been
of Victoria (1986). Examples of such crisis situations explored by an examination of age differences in
include: life-threatening events including attempted/suc- perceived coping resources and satisfaction with life
cessful suicide, exacerbation of acute psychotic symptoms (Hamarat et al. 2002; Himelein and McElrath 1996)
resulting in potential harm to the person or others, and examined cognitive coping strategies associated with
domestic violence as a result of a psychiatric illness, such resilience in a nonclinical sample of children who had
as a person experiencing symptoms of paranoid schizo- been sexually abused.
phrenia (Davison & Neale 2001). The nature of such From a qualitative perspective, there appears to be
complex and often unpredictable situations accompanied fewer research studies undertaken when compared to
by the ever-present potential risk of harm is an added quantitative studies pertaining to the topic of resilience.
stressor on the mental health clinician in intervening in Examples of available research on the phenomenon of
such crises. Given the level of stress of such a work envi- resilience follows: a qualitative analysis was conducted
ronment, the potential risk for burnout is considered concerning resilient factors in people who have a history
by many researchers as extremely high in Australia of experiencing violence in the family (Humphreys 2001);
(Armstrong 2002; Lilly 2002; RANZCP 2002). and a qualitative examination of the phenomenon of resil-
Despite the unrelenting and demanding nature of ience among formerly incarcerated adolescents in an
psychiatric crisis care work, many of my professional attempt to capture the essence of that particular lived
colleagues who entered this field 1020 years ago have experience (Todis et al. 2001).
not succumbed to the pressure of the workplace but Resilience appears to have been explored to a great
rather, have continued to remain enthusiastic, empathic degree in children and adolescents in terms of looking at
and skilled in their clinical approach to care, while others resilient behaviours in the face of adversity in this age
became burnt-out (i.e. to make or become exhausted, group. The results of such research provides suggestions
especially as a result of long-term stress (Skovholt 2001)). for educators and supportive communities for youth who
This situation seemed to be more than coping in a stress- have experienced trauma, family dysfunction and other
ful moment. These clinicians appeared to have an ability forms of adverse life events (Todis et al. 2001; Wang et al.
to move beyond the stressors of the moment time and 1997; Werner 1993; Werner & Smith 1982, 1992; Wolin
time again. Witnessing such an ability ignited in me a & Wolin 1993). After a search of Proquest, Ovid, Gale
process of questioning about the essential nature of what Journals online, Harvard Business Review, Blackwell Syn-
I was seeing and what I believed was resilience. As a ergy and Medline, no Australian-based published works
means of expanding a taken-for-granted understanding on the phenomenon of resilience in clinicians working in
of this phenomenon, I engaged in a search of the litera- the area of crisis care were found.
ture for further enlightenment about the topic.
Contribution of the study
Literature review The findings of this study have the potential to provide
The notion of resilience has been the focus of study for further insight and understanding about the phenomenon
many years with the vast majority of the research relating of resilience through the perspective of crisis care clini-
to this topic being located within the quantitative para- cians in mental health; additionally the findings have
digm. Resilient behaviours have been explored through a the potential to contribute to extant knowledge of this
descriptive and exploratory correlational design to look at phenomenon.
the relationship of resilience in homeless adolescents The outcomes of this study have the prospect to con-
(Rew et al. 2001); another study examined whether there tribute to crisis care clinicians knowledge of resilience
was a correlation between personality constructs in rela- through the inclusion of such information in teaching
tion to adolescent behaviour and resilience (Hart et al. modules and clinical role modelling for clinicians working
1997); resilience has also been explored using a combina- in complex, demanding and stressful work environments.
tion of questionnaire and observational measures to And finally, the findings of this study may offer a basis for
investigate the additive and interactive effects of multiple future research into the nature of resilience.
144 K.-L. EDWARD
memories of past events that are told in the present The next step in the analysis process (Colaizzi 1978a,b)
moment and the participants often change their descrip- involved integrating the significant statements, the for-
tions from one account to the next, however, in reality it mulated meanings, and the clusters of themes into a nar-
is the same experience retold as if a new experience. rative description of the phenomenon of resilience as
Rigour in qualitative research is believed to be more experienced by the participants in this study.
about fidelity or trustworthiness of the essence of a phe- There were four descriptions of resilience that
nomenon (Sandelowski 1993). Research undertaken by emerged as experienced by the crisis care clinicians in
Guba and Lincoln (1985, 1989), which examined rigour mental health who participated in this research (Table 3).
in qualitative analysis, posited that trustworthiness of the The final step in the analysis described a statement of
information allows for greater accuracy (Guba & Lincoln the fundamental structure of the phenomenon under
1985, 1989; Rice & Ezzy 1999; Sandelowski 1993). This investigation. The fundamental structure of the phenom-
concept has been endorsed by other qualitative research- enon of resilience on crisis care mental health clinicians
ers (Brink 1991; Giorgi 1992; Holloway & Wheeler 1997; in mental health is achieved through analysis and is an
Koch 1994; Morse & Field 1995; Parse 2001; Parse et al. integration/blending of the phenomenons components as
1985; Rice & Ezzy 1999; Sandelowski 1993), and in this documented in the descriptions.
context Guba and Lincolns (1985, 1989) model offered a
general framework for assessing trustworthiness of qual-
itative information, which consists of credibility, transfer- TABLE 2: The eight theme clusters that emerged throughout this
ability, dependability and confirmability, and was the process
framework used in this research.
Having nonwork-related support or tasks can reduce anxiety and bolster
resilience.
Resilience is fostered through professional development.
RESULTS Resilience is experienced when you have insight into the work you do.
Phrases and statements directly pertaining to resilience Resilience is a result of using creativity, flexibility and humour in your
work.
were considered significant statements and extracted
Resilience is promoted through having a sense of faith, advocating for
from each of the participants interview transcripts in others and having a sense of morality.
keeping with Colaizzis (1978b) analysis process. This pro- Resilience is a product of experience, clinical expertise, a sense of
cess produced 191 significant statements, examples of autonomy, responsibility and confidence.
significant statements are presented in Table 1. Resilience is promoted through support at work.
Resilience in crisis care is associated with keeping work separate from
Consistent with Colaizzis methodology (Colaizzi
home.
1978a,b), formulated meanings were assigned to each sig-
nificant statement. These formulated meanings were
sorted into groups that represented specific theme clus-
ters (Table 2), and the aggregated theme clusters were TABLE 3: Descriptions of resilience that emerged
then referred back to the original significant statement in
1. Being resilient in crisis care roles in mental health is consistent with
order to validate them (Colaizzi 1978a,b). having a sense of self, the clinicians level of experience, clinical
expertise, confidence, flexibility, creativity with clinical situations and
TABLE 1: Example of significant statements the ability to take on the responsibilities associated with the role of
crisis work in an autonomous and accountable way.
Debriefing with the team/with colleagues is important to keeping my 2. Resilience is connected with having a sense of faith, advocating for
anxieties down. another and using an empathic and humanistic (client-centred)
[Keeping work and home separate is important to keeping stress down]. approach. Crisis care clinicians in mental health feel less work-
I can leave work and its gone most of the time and I find this keeps related tension or anxiety (and as a result feel more resilient) when
my anxieties down. they felt they had made a positive contribution in their clinical role.
The other way I continue to try to deal with stress and crisis pressure 3. Resilience is experienced when you have insight into your clinical
is the use of humour. I remember that consumers are also human and role. This can be achieved through feedback, introspective analysis,
that if I was in their position I would like it and so I try to include in professional development and comprehensive dissemination of
the conversation some more light-hearted conversation to help the work-related information.
person feel happier. It is also a good way to release the anxiety in the 4. Looking after oneself in terms of exercise, relaxation, having a
situation and the stress you or the client are under to talk about balanced diet, getting adequate sleep, having a good social network
something good and share a bit of a laugh. or having hobbies promotes a sense of well-being and in
I think on a personal level it [resilience] is about building up your consequence facilitates greater opportunities for resilient behaviour
credibility and confidence in a team. for work-related stressors.
THE PHENOMENON OF RESILIENCE 147
Lengua, L. (2002). The contribution of emotionality and self- Skovholt, T. (2001). The Resilient Practitioner: Burnout Preven-
regulation to the understanding of childrens response to tion and Self-care Strategies for Counselors, Therapists,
multiple risks. Child Development, 73, 144162. Teachers, and Health Care Professionals. USA: Allyn &
Lilly, A. (2002). Improving nursing recruitment and retention Bacon.
in a sub-acute health service. Australian Health Review, 25 The Oxford Modern English Dictionary, 2nd edn. (1996). Great
(6), 9599. Britain: Suffolk University Press.
Morse, J. & Field, P. (1995).Qualitative Research Methods for Todis, B., Bullis, M., Waintrup, M., Schultz, R. & DAmbrosio,
Health Professionals, 2nd edn. USA: Sage Publications. R. (2001). Overcoming the odds: Qualitative examination of
Parse, R. (2001). Qualitative Inquiry: The Path of Sciencing. resilience among formerly incarcerated adolescents. Excep-
Canada: National League for Nurses. tional Children, 68 (1), 119140.
Parse, R., Coyne, A. & Smith, M. (1985). Nursing Research: Wang, M. C., Haertel, G. D. & Walberg, H. J. (1997). Fostering
Qualitative Methods. USA: Brady Communications resilience: What do we know? Principal (Reston, VA.) [H.W.
Company. Wilson Educ], 77 (2), 1820.
Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists Werner, E. (1993). Risk, resilience, and recovery. Perspectives
(RANZCP) (2002). Under-funding + Mental Illness = Recipe from the Kauai longitudinal study. Development and Psycho-
for Disaster. [Cited 16 November 2003]. Available from: pathology, 5, 503515.
URL: http://www.ranzcp.org/publicarea/media2003.asp Werner, E. & Smith, R. (1982). Vulnerable But Invincible. New
Rew, K., Taylor-Seehafer, M., Thomas, N. & Yockey, R. (2001). York: Adams, Bannister & Cox.
Correlates of resilience in homeless adolescents. Journal of Werner, E. & Smith, R. (1992). Overcoming the Odds. New
Nursing Scholarship, 33, 3340. York: Cornell University Press.
Rice, P. L. & Ezzy, D. (1999). Qualitative Research Methods Wolin, S. & Wolin, S. (1993). The Resilient Self. How Survivors
A Health Focus. South Melbourne, Australia: Oxford Univer- of Troubled Families Rise Above Adversity. New York:
sity Press. Random House.
Sandelowski, M. (1993). Rigour or rigour mortis: The problem
of rigour in qualitative research revisited. Advances in Nurs-
ing Science, 16 (2), 18.
The author has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate.