Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
because his elder brother, Dhritarastra, was born blind and was
Dhritarastra and
war of such magnitude. Krishna who has sworn not to fight himself
but steer Arjuna chariot in the battle explains to him about his
duty to fight.
One may read the epic as an excellent tale because it has all
own way. Like a diamond that sparkles in the sun light, many
time, the text has gained all the attributes of a rand narrativein
and beliefs. Many useful discourses in the epic took deep roots in
Indian cultural and social life. Power, Stability and order in social and
political organizations in the country are maintained by of this epic.
systems.
explaining that disorder is chaotic and bad and that order is rational
Epoch:
different levels in the text but the fact is that the Indian thought
recognized this and this is precisely what Van Buitenen means when
he writes;
The epic is a series of precisely stated problems imprecisely
solution raising a new problem, until the very end, when the
The Gita teaches that the notions of self, crime and other forms
The heroes are tough-minded who fear neither life nor death. In the
end, victory for the Pandavas in the battle is futile and hollow. The
aesthetics of the epic incorporates everything into itself.
and there is a cosmic context in which gods and men alike grapple
reached the present form. The three phases of the epic were those
that the epic passed through at least three editions to reach its
present shape. The original event of The Mahabharata has been
handed down in the form of lays and ballads and the versified
agathas These songs did not have any fixed form because they
Vyasa who collected and edited them to make The Mahabharata the
sake of defending the traditional religion and creed. But there were
spiritual entities etc. Some say that harmais rewarded after this
life while some others deny it. A few others say that harmais
permanent and there are others who hold the view that it is not. In
the body. The Gita is very critical of the materialists and skeptics
alike. The editors of The Mahabharata modified the ritualism of the
trends; the path of renunciation and the path of action. The epic
ishkamakarma
yugawas over on the tenth day of the war, for the next thirty years
and the others are invincible. Krishna realizes that the time has
decide to poke fun at the holy men. They dress Krishna son,
Samba, in clothes of a fisher woman and take him to the holy men.
They prostrate themselves before the sages. One man says to them,
have a son. Sages of vision, please tell her will she have a
he will give birth to an iron club, and that club will destroy
the hunting arrow of Jara fixed with the metal from the
Samba stomach.3
Abhuthanam adharmasya
Parithranaya sadhunam
Dharma samsthapanarthaya
Sambhavami yuge-yuge4
the protection of the good, for the destruction of the evil, and for the
regretting for his actions. He dances in joy, he kills in anger his own
found mourning even after the terrible end of his clan. He meets
with his end nonchalantly after making arrangements for the safety
of old people, women and children of his clan. This is the path of the
life?
his temper with Arjuna and he insults Arjuna and even the andiva
bow He has vowed that he will not spare anyone who spoke ill of
andiva This puts him in a difficult situation, as he has to kill his elder
brother for this mean act. Krishna, however, is able to save him from
the conflicting obligation. He tells the following story to prove his
argument.
only the truth in life. One day he saw some bandits chasing travelers
to rob and kill them. Kausika saw the travelers fleeing that way. The
Kausika told the truth and the innocent travelers were killed.
Krishna concludes the story telling that this hermit did not reach
have saved the life of travelers even by rejecting his vow of telling
truth .5
is it harmato tell the truth? Will telling a lie in order to save a life
adayudhaparvaHe says:
Wretch, son of a slave, was not your father, Vasudeva,
You were the father of that deadly lie that issued from
lifting his chariot wheel that had sunk and stuck in mud of
sindhu king, to believe that the day was over and he was
safe, then you caused his death when he was off guard.6
a standard dharma in the epic? When one starts defining it, it leads
says;
the majority of people or the good and wise men. The well-known
3. If one refrains from violence, though one is strong, his act can be
considered as harma
after he had staked himself and lost. Vidura and Draupadi argued
that occasion.
is suggested that there are multiple oresto the epic. Search for
the original epic nucleus is like the search for the virgin meaning of
the text that never existed in a unified way even at the origin.
above highlight some of them. Apart from the above, there are
conflicts between many ethical views. Primarily they fall into three
between Ritual and Ascetic Ethics, and conflict between Moral and
Ascetic Ethics.
accepts the terms of exile imposed upon them. While living in exile
shows compassion for them and he asks them to set them free.9
tolerant in that situation and then she says, ou are right, O wise
today.10 Here again Bhima disagrees with his brother and wants to
mortified by the death and sufferings caused by war, even when his
Narada:
matter who wins or loses such a war? The only truth is that
from Dharma deva that the selfless act of the Brahmin family in
giving away their food to a starving beggar is far more virtuous than
for living the true life of a warrior. He voices his objections over this
apparent injustice. The epic here seems to explore the subtleties of
decision. It can mean that both aspects of the issues are equally
valid. The text does not give any definitive judgments to overcome
such conflicts.
many places in the epic. The ritualistic practices are carried out for
prosperity and peace in this world and heavenly rewards in the life
ascetic tradition holds that the ritual practices are worldly and they
up. Jajali replies that animal husbandry provides food and animals
a debate between Kapila and Syumarismi who had taken the form of
agnas Once a sage named Parnada takes the form of a deer and
would be rewarded in heaven for the sacrifice. He gets ready for the
rejects this argument pointing out the fact that the goat kith and
kin does not want it to be sacrificed and that it is not done for the
the recourse to battle and agnaby two classes of people for power
and wealth.
these two ethics in the epic. In the debate after the battle,
homicide in the battle but his brothers and Draupadi argue that
The epic does not make any of the two arguments superior to the
The Mahabharata
stories and narratives nested one within another. It opens with the
first frame of the story in which there are two frames. The readers
first come across the tale of uta a bard or story teller. He recounts
turn, heard the story from his master Vyasa who is supposed to be
the author of the epic. Therefore, Vaisampayana story is the
second frame of the story telling. He recites most of the story at the
occasion, include the story of Nala and Damayanti. The other stories
include the legend of Agastya who drained the ocean and the story
earth. The story of Bhagiratha who brings the Ganges from the skies
to the earth is another story. The story of Vishnu also finds a place in
father, King Parikshit who was killed by a snake. Sage Vyasa visited
this place and persuaded him to give up the idea of revenge. Then
which means arranger. From the epic it is understood that his name
love to her. In return for this, he blessed her that she would be
magician. A son was born of this union. Soon after his birth, he
appear before her when she wanted by just thinking about him. He
many other rituals. The third is the path of haktithat deals with
interesting to note that the epic dos not try to establish any clear-
foundationalism. One can see the epic engaged in the same process
NOTES
1
Iravati Karve, Yuganta: The End of an Epoch (Disha Books,
Hydrabad, 1974)165.
2
J.A.B Van Buitenen, Studies in Indian Literature and
2002)194-198.
8
Kuttikrishnamarar 194-198.
9
Kuttikrishnamarar 194-198.
10
Ramesh Menon, abhaparva 133-137.
11
Ramesh Menon , dyogaparva348-351
12
Ramesh Menon antiparva 598-602.
13
Ramesh Menon, swamedhaparva 751-753.
14
Ramesh Menon, antiparva 598-602.
15
Nicholas Sutton, he Mahabharata Teaching On