More Oil, More Water
How Produced Water Will Create
Big Cost Problems for Shale Operators
I
f crude prices, rig counts, and tight oil
production demonstrate a stronger
upward trend in the months to come,
US shale operators may find themselves
with more produced water than they bar-
gained for.
The concern is that a surge of pro-
duced water could eat into profit mar-
gins even as oil prices improve by
drivingup costs for hauling and disposal.
Many shale producers can ill afford a
significant spending hike on such ser-
vices when, according to IHS Markit,
produced water management can rep-
resent half of a shale wells operat-
ingexpenses.
Trent Jacobs, JPT Senior Technology Writer
The severity of this issue will depend
on how aggressively shale producers
seek to rebound from the downturn by
drilling new wells. It also will depend on
how quickly they activate the estimated
4,000 oil-rich, drilled-but-uncompleted
wells (DUCs) that have amassed over the
past 2 years as both a cost-cutting and a
production management maneuver.
If you get a lot of new completions
in a short amount of time, that means
you are going to get a whole bunch of
water too, and this is something that
the industry needs to be thinking about
and planning for, said Piers Wells,
co-founder and chief executive offi-
cer of Digital H2O, a company that uses
analytics-based models to forecast oil-
field waterresources.
Because it is the most active and pro-
lific shale play, the Permian Basin of
Texas is already under pressure. As
shown by Digital H2Os model, the
recent uptick in drilling there and in the
adjacent Delaware Basin is yielding pro-
duced water volumes that are approach-
ing what many of the disposal wells can
take away.
While they may not be at full pressure
utilization today, many are getting close
and, in a higher-price environment, you
will see many more areas shifting into

high utilization, Wells said. The thing
that people need to be aware of is that
this could all happen really, really fast.
With far less drilling activity happen-
ing, North Dakotas Bakken and Texas
Eagle Ford shales are not facing quite
the same situation as the Permian cur-
rently is. However, higher prices would
start to change that, and there are also
more than 2,000 DUCs in those two
plays that if brought on line in quick suc-
cession have the potential to drive water-
handling costs higher.
Produced water management is com-
plex and expensive for shale produc-
ers partly because they have fewer
options than their conventional coun-
terparts on what to do with it. One
major disadvantage is their inability
to reinject into unconventional reser-
voirs, underscoring that disposal wells
will always play an outsized role in
shale developments.
And proving that even virtuous solu-
tions have their limits, if every shale well
in the US was hydraulically fractured
with recycled produced water, it would
account for only a single-digit fraction
of the total volume of water generated
each day.
Those studying water management
practices say that if operators start adopt-
Source: Getty Images.
ing longer-term strategies, they can gain
leverage over rising wastewater costs.
Their recommendations include lessen-
ing reliance on inefficient water trucks
by building more water pipelines along
with permanent processing and treat-
ment facilities.
Michael Dunkel, a vice president for
the engineering consultancy CH2M, has
been involved with water infrastructure
projects in Texas and Oklahoma and said
a number of operators are on the cusp
of investing more capital on this front.
However, he noted that a meaningful
expansion of water facilities in the shale
sector will be years in the making.

390
380
370
Millions of Barrels
360 360
350
340
330
320
310
300
290
Jan-16
Feb-16
Oil prices are directly correlated to both oil and water production in US shale
plays, which is why they may be the best predictor of how intense the issue of
excess produced water becomes. Because it is the largest onshore producing
region, the Permian Basin of Texas is likely to feel the squeeze before other
areas. Source: Digital H20.
It will be slow to evolve, he empha-
sized. But 5 years from now, I am con-
fident that there will be a lot more water
infrastructure in place, both to move
around source water and to interconnect
disposal water, which will give greater
flexibility in transporting it to different
disposal wells.
Price Matters
The place to watch will be the Permian
where, according to the Baker Hughes
rig count, there are more rigs turning
to the right than in any other place on
Earth. Having maintained solid growth
throughout the downturn, the Permian
is producing about 2 million B/D of oil
and about 11 million B/D of water.
Assuming that even modest gains
in crude prices will encourage more
drilling in the Permian, as has been
the case since June, Wells said one of
his firms clients there is expecting the
prolific region to see a wall of water
next year.
It is an assertion that the firms model
for produced water largely agrees with
36
Forecasted Permian Basin Produced ducing formations for waterflooding or
Water at Different WTI Prices enhanced oil recovery. Unfortunately for
shale producers, neither of those practic-
es are applicable to nanoscale permeabil-
ity reservoirs, yet.
363 Shale wells are also drilled in much
tighter clusters from pad sites than what
one would see in conventional develop-
346
342 344 ments. This concentrates the volumes of
334 produced water and places high demand
333 on nearby disposal wells.
As to why operators did not plan for
this earlier, during the beginning of the
shale revolution they had to be some-
what nomadic, in search of the best fair-
ways and sweet spots. This left them
Mar-16
Apr-16
May-16
Jun-16
Jul-16
Aug-16
Sep-16
Oct-16
Nov-16
Dec-16
Jan-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
May-17
Jun-17
Jul-17
uncertain about exactly where future
production would come from, mak-
ing it hard to invest in multimillion-
dollar water facilities that could not
Reported Production USD 30 WTI Price
be moved.
USD 50 WTI Price USD 70 WTI Price And lastly, while some data show that
shale wells produce less water than con-
ventional wells on average, they gener-
ate significantly more in the early life
of the well. Industry-reported numbers
show that a typical shale well unloads
30-40% of the water that it will churn
out over an entire decade in the first year
depending on prices. Wells said that if of production.
prices maintain a holding pattern of About 20% of that water, termed
around USD 50/bbl, the model expects flowback, includes the fluids used for
many disposal wells in the Permian to hydraulic fracturing, which are also
soon begin flirting with their upper injec- growing in volume. To get more prop-
tion limits. pant into fractures, many operators are
The screws tighten at around using two or three times the volume of
USD 70/bbl. It is a price point many in water for fracturing that they were just
the business are longing for, but Digital 3 years ago.
H2Os model shows that it will overstrain Laura Capper, president of Houston-
many disposal networks in the Permian based technology consultancy CAP
and other high-producing basins. Resources, explained that though water
Wells noted that lead times to plan, cuts from shale wells begin leveling
permit, and drill new disposal wells could off after year 1, their front-loaded pro-
be at least a year. If demand outpaces duction creates especially high demand
supply, then bottlenecks could form and for disposal services in areas where oper-
operators may be forced to expand their ators are ramping up.
batteries of water storage tanks in order What you have is a hot play, where
to keep producing unconstrained. all of a sudden youre doing consider-
ably more business there than you used
Uniquely Unconventional to and youre trying to inject the water
There are several reasons why this par- close to the wellsite, she said, adding
ticular produced water problem is unique that, those neighboring injection wells
to unconventional developments. are getting substantially higher injection
In the conventional world, opera- volumes than the ones that are maybe 50
tors have the luxury of reinjecting much miles away and only running at say 10%
of their produced water back into pro- of their volume capacity.
JPT DECEMBER 2016
More Pipes, More Infrastructure
When it comes to whether companies
should be using trucks or pipes to trans-
port water, Capper said investing in the
latter should be a no brainer decision.
Operators can be charged more than
USD 100 per truck per hour to move
their water. Shale producers use thou-
sands of these trucks each day to carry
only 130 bbl of water a time. The trucks
are hard on public roads, and represent
a sizable proportion of the oilfield traffic
that is attributed to an increased number
of collisions around active shale plays.
Pipelines, on the other hand, can
move water continuously, and quietly,
while avoiding many of the safety and
environmental risks that come with
trucking. Aware of these issues, a hand-
ful of larger shale producers have com-
mitted to building long networks of
waterpipelines.
There is also a burgeoning industry of
third-party companies that act as mid-
stream operators for produced water. A
recent example of this is a 30-mile pro-
A snapshot of Grady County, Oklahoma, in 2014 highlights that even during periods of high drilling activity there is far
more produced water generated in a shale play than can be used by oil and gas companies. The costs and logistics of
recycling that water to drinking quality are also extreme. Source: Laura Capper.
JPT DECEMBER 2016
duced water pipeline that was completed
in July by a company called Oilfield Water
Logistics. Located in the Delaware Basin
of New Mexico, several operators includ-
ing Chevron will have access to the pipe-
line that will transport 150,000 bbl of
produced water each daywhich oth-
erwise would require more than 1,000
water trucks.
In addition to a need for more pipes,
more processing infrastructure will be
required to handle and treat the pro-
duced water before it heads back to the
subsurface. Just like a garbage disposal
in a home, disposal wells run smoother
and last longer when solids and other
harmful elements are removed prior
toinjection.
And while there are a number of new
well-side treatment technologies avail-
able, in this case bigger is better. Dun-
kel said that based on his research, small
and mobile treatment systems will not
be a viable answer for mid- to large-
sized operators who have intensive
waterneeds.
The issue is actually very simple; its
not that their capital cost is too high or
that the technology itself doesnt work
in many cases they do work well, he
said. But if you have to have two people
on site to run the system, the per barrel
costs are just too high and the labor cost
alone is almost a non-starter.
Elaborating on this point, Dunkel
estimated that a two-person staff for a
5,000B/D water treatment system costs
an operator about USD 5,000 a day. But
if those two workers, or even a third,
operated a 50,000 B/D water treat-
ment facility, economies-of-scale kick
in and make small well-side options far
lessattractive.
Dunkel said more operators are think-
ing about infrastructure today than
before the downturn, but with cash flows
still suffering, many have placed their
plans on hold.
One exception is the water treatment
and handling facility that Pioneer Natural
Resources is building for its unconven-
tional development in the Permian. Pub-
37
lished company materials show that the
facility will handle source water for frac-
turing operations and also recycle pro-
duced water for fracturingoperations.
Speaking to the vast nature of shale
developments, the permanent infrastruc-
ture is supported by 100 miles of main-
line, 10 pumping stations, and an addi-
tional 500 miles of subsystem piping.
Pioneer says that upon completion, the
project will move the equivalent of 2,000
truckloads of water a day.
In addition to recycling, more pro-
duced water can be removed from the dis-
posal equation if the multipurpose water
facilities of the future come equipped
with evaporation units.
Another idea being discussed is
for shale producers to join forces and
create water management co-ops. This
would help smaller companies deal
with the high costs of infrastructure
but it will come with competitive and
regulatorychallenges.
Outside of Texas, liability laws make it
difficult or impossible for oil companies
to transfer ownership of produced water
unless it is heading down a disposal well.
SPE EVENTS
WORKSHOPS
1214 December HoustonAIChE/SPE:
Next Generation Deepwater Facilities
67 February 2017 MuscatSPE
Advanced Field Development
Sustainability and Challenges
67 February 2017 Abu DhabiSPE
Global Integrated Series: Managing Well
Integrity in a Low-Cost Oil Environment
1314 February 2017 Kuala Lumpur
SPE Mature Field RedevelopmentsHow
to Stay Relevant For the Foreseeable
Future
2021 February 2017 AberdeenSPE
Brownfields RedevelopmentA Meeting
of Minds To Meet the Challenges
2021 February 2017 Kuala Lumpur
SPE Improve Well Control and Drilling
Performance with the Advances in
Managed Pressure Drilling Technology
28 February2 March 2017 Dubai
SPE Well TestingTechnology,
Operations, Sampling, and Reservoir
Characterisation in the Current Price
Environment
There are also operational consider-
ations regarding who gets first rights
to the services if a shared facility tempo-
rarily lost some of its capacity to take or
supply water.
Big Limits on Recycling
If you thought stepped-up recycling
efforts would be the ultimate answer to
the question of what to do with produced
water, you would be wrong. Though recy-
cling is seen as important for lessening
the sectors reliance on fresh water, shale
producers will never drill and complete
enough wells to reuse all their produced
water for hydraulic fracturing.
Capper said her analysis shows that
while the majority of slickwater fracture
jobs in the US now use recycled water,
prior to the downturn when there was
considerably more drilling taking place,
the amount of water needed for frac-
turing vs. the total volume of produced
water was fractional.
Using one of Oklahomas most active
areas as an example, Cappers data show
that from 20122014 overall injection
volumes in Grady County quadrupled,
CONFERENCES
2426 January 2017 The Woodlands 1416 February 2017 RotterdamSPE:
SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology
Conference and Exhibition
1516 February 2017 CalgarySPE
Canada Heavy Oil Technical Conference
1516 February 2017 CalgarySPE
Canada Unconventional Resources
Conference
2022 February 2017 Montgomery
SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference
69 March 2017 ManamaSPE Middle
East Oil and Gas Show and Conference
(MEOS)
1416 March 2017 The HagueSPE/
IADC Drilling Conference and Exhibition
SYMPOSIUMS
1516 March 2017 SalvadorSPE Latin
American and Caribbean Mature Fields
1516 March 2017 AmmanSPE Iraq
The Petroleum Potentiality and Future
ofEnergy
and daily injection volumes per disposal
welltripled.
She estimated that at the peak only 3%
of that briny wastewater, which in 2014
totaled 80 million barrels, was needed
to support the countys entire oil and gas
operations. It could require an annual
spend of USD 400 million to treat the
other 97%.
On top of that, we would have to dis-
pose of some 16,500 railcars of associat-
ed salt, said Capper. No matter how you
slice it, it is difficult to make the numbers
work in a 100% recycling scenario
thus industrys extreme dependence on
relatively low-cost disposal wells.
All of this highlights two things: that
disposal wells will always be critical to
shale developments, and that though
there is a need, it will not be easy to make
large volumes of recycled produced
water available to outside industries.
The latter idea is termed beneficial
reuse and may not always involve treat-
ing produced water to drinking quality
if it is used for agriculture. In Califor-
nia, treated produced water has been
used for many years for the irrigation
FORUM
Emerging Technologies for Enhancing
Reservoir Contact
CALL FOR PAPERS
SPE/IATMI Asia Pacific Oil & Gas
Conference and Exhibition Bali
Deadline: 9 December
SPE Offshore Europe Aberdeen
Deadline: 13 January 2017
SPE Annual Technical Conference and
Exhibition San Antonio
Deadline: 31 January 2017
OTC Brasil Rio de Janeiro
Deadline: 8 March 2017
SPE 3rd Kuwait Oil & Gas Show and
Conference Kuwait City
Deadline: 13 March 2017
Find complete listings of
upcoming SPE workshops,
conferences, symposiums, and
forums at www.spe.org/events.
 Seismicity To Drive Costs Higher
High-rate injection activity in disposal wells connected to
fault-prone formations has been cited by both industry
and government experts as the primary contributing
factor to induced seismicity in the US.
In areas where regulatory actions over induced
seismicity have limited the supply of disposal wells,
operators who want to increase production will have
tospend more money hauling loads of excess water
outof a quake zone.
The epicenter of this scenario is in northern
Oklahomas Mississippi Lime play where injection-linked
earthquakes have led regulators to force shut-ins or
curtail injections at hundreds of disposal sites spread
across more than 10,000 sq. miles. In 2016, the state
experienced three 5.0-magnitude quakes while the rest
of the country saw two.
While the regulatory restrictions will undoubtedly
impact operators, the problem is in fact manageable,
albeit with more planning and analysis, which costs
money, said Capper, who recently contributed to a
state-by-state risk analysis on disposal wells.
She said for those companies working in potential
seismic risk zoneswhich also include parts of Texas,
of tangerines and almond groves. Texas But aside from these isolated exam-
A&M University also recently concluded ples, this concept has not been warmly
a study that used treated produced water embraced or benefited from the type
to grow cotton. of extensive, and expensive, research
Get Out Of Trouble, Stay Out Of Trouble.
Repair Production Tubulars
Repair Damaged Casing
Reinforce Production Tubulars
Case-Off Perforations
Repair Parted Connection
Recompletions Solutions
Arkansas, and Ohiothe short-term solution to avoiding
induced seismicity will involve a more granular
approach to monitoring injection volumes and downhole
pressures. It will also be key to understand local
geological factors that may facilitate seismicity.
By taking these steps, Capper explained that observant
operators should be able to stay under the thresholds
thought to trigger seismicity, something she added has
been proven to work in certain areas where disposal
activity was restricted. Though she emphasized that it
can take 18 months or more for injection reductions to
result in fewer observable, or felt, earthquakes.
The idea taking shape around disposal wells in
seismic risk zones is that geomechanics must trump
logistics. If the industry can demonstrate an ability to
self-regulate injection activity, and where necessary use
a more dispersed network of disposal wells, additional
government-enforced restrictions may be avoided.
We know where these events have happened, so they
should be able to manage their businesses there, Capper
said. But its still going to be an additional cost burden
to the industry in that you will probably have to drive
your water trucks farther out, or pipe it farther away.
that is needed to prove to the wider
public and relevant government agen-
cies that it can be done safely on a
larger scale. JPT
Enventures ESeal solid expandable products
are the advanced, efficient, economical way to
mitigate troubled casing intervals permanently.
Onshore or offshore, conventional or
unconventional, Enventure ESeal products
are designed to provide permanent solutions
to sealing off troubled casing intervals,
restoring integrity. Each product represents
an effective and permanent alternative
to cement squeezes. Plus, with ESeal,
wellbore ID is maximized.
To find out more, visit us at:
www.EnventureGT.com/ESeal