gU*Mzg Z

^] ]

}ZZ e

~IgzZxsZ

xk
B ~uzgzZ 16, # ~jd
y[fIZZ $! f
(R CZp
H C -
g EZ ! f wq ]g J z kZ
}~kZ[f 3g6,
*kZwqgzZ(
-ZX M
R! kZ TI Zzgq h~ Vc*
Vz],
Z &Z ZZ g
LZ Y~kZsgzZ Z'
[fgzZg 6,]c* g7
kZgzZ d Hg D
$! f kZgzZ M % ~I{z }uz X : }{ .Z
+zx LZ
5kZZw$ H0g Z',Dq kZ {zgzZ c*
ntu M Z (,
L LVZ
~kZ [f TI ` Z'
w5{z }gzZ X} } M d
$
gzZ
hZ yZ [fgzZ gzV- gz$zx LZ{g} a
 k Z KZgzZ HkCZ
X $ ~]q I: {} ],
wJ. Z ~LZkZ H: kC[s~wJV!*
Z ~&t ~gs jd
y Z Hf X} ], $! f~}
, Zv~} ], D Z6,gt7Vz#Zwq]g
ZC
kZX&} ], YY {y
Z ~} (,  @* } ],
$
X d Z}uz
Z ~v ~ KkZ W 6,} ],
{ 6,Vz], z
Z ~}uz ~ yZ
X Y
` Z Z ) ~ Z vZZZgzZ y{Zug Z',D`kZ~R',
z6,Zxy 0*
x m, $ZzgtC {)z~<%Z+ZgzZZr Zl
x e ~g7

2005c ( 27) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

+zYZ egzZ ~Zh

wD Zh +zY[g Z',DkZ~g` M X J
-{)z ~g7i *gzZt',
X
~ Z {)z =gWz6,gzZ Zi%Zgh
+zY ~OYgZ eX
gzZ Z
}Z ** w V~ qzX Z
+Zq** mr
# ~
*s T ~ ]Z yZ tzg~}g!*
ce *
C g$u k& Z Z
/Z ) C]ZY ]ZkZwXD]Z} (,
kp
X ( [Z
# k& Z **
kZ r V,ZgzZ ~ ZZv
+Zq**
{ kZ ]Z Z r
}uzgzZ c* # ~ [ p c*
J (, M h
+'
G
6,xsZa ~d $! f 4 tzg y Z [Z b+ E C -!
ce g~ft ZjVyZ~}g !*
< $u SX Y
L zg
q)c* +*{z { Zp @*M ~
( !3gzZ `g Zp) V~h wZ
# a 0*
i- M
< $ut kZ:
L zg L X k
<
L zg KyZ V~h
$u: +
+gzZ y M ^zg~% J e ._ Vh
Z k +].L L+gzZ C J e
yxg CkC]gzieZy Za} M g Zh
+].L
L ZgzZsz@*
ze
a kZ {gzg Vr~h
+h
+]. Vr~h w <
+*X Y c* L zg
$u ~
! f{h
+].qYgzZ F ={z
F6, ZgzZ 46, M %**
- T M
$! f{t]g F
d F6, ZgzZ 46,={z F
F6,k Z ~Td
$
KkZgzZd
X > $**
- Z
gZ LZgzZgx gzZp
/Z vt X IZgg]!*

gzZ xsZ gzZ ( t ZgzZ yj
jZ ) Vx L LDq d
$! fp g ;
`
LZ ( 0*gzZ ~r._}gz! f) 9F, ]4Z}
z (F,
}ggzZ H qz"_
** .z l 6gzZ[@* # 6,K
z[ M 5M%Z Z e
VzIyZ Z ewze xsZwzggzZIwZZZ # sm,z6,?
# r
g Z]Z|yZ c*
qz ** zf$Z6, ZzK{g
Z M V ZxgzZ c*
z~g ugzZ B
gzZ ( }gZ Z yZgzZ ) r
# Zzpg " f Zzgt k\ZgzZ Z H
$
Zh
+' z ]Zg Z yZgzZ ) r
+Z`
X g wZ ez CZ ~ kZ ( Z #
Z
2005c ( 28) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

yZgzZ1 I ]c*
6,]c* yZZgzZ s
B ]Z|yZt]!*
k\Z
y@*
D~] D fZzgX } 7,
.)zkg ZLZ] v Zzug Z D
+ Y Zz
yZz6,~gZ ZzggzZ ~g ZY)dKZieZgzZw'~VJZ%LZ Y xX g
g J m
Tg D! W y Z r
Q c* [ x} X
# ~ZZ@Zi **
# IgzZb)X D yZ~i Z0
t # Zq _L)
+Z: qg Y r L x
6, ZgzZ q~
/%~IDsyZ~kZp
X,W
~]t c*
t k Z ~kZ ? Hk Z X
t qg
vZ zmvZ - c*
yZO X 7]gz ]t[Za g V
Z ) X M 7 * y ZgzZ wg ~y
V~ i kZ ( 40:33[Z x M
~g Zz M J zmvZ - c*
-# yZt q
-Z c* x OZt kZa e
$Z@
)f ( y M
)[kZ}uz ( 28:34)X aV }g gzZVY
[Z **
J-Ve Z kZ}( 9:15Z )X gpt 1p
$Z@ K- ett#
yZ \vZC ,'!* Ce
~ $Z@ta( 143:2>Z )X ~g Z)f kZ
C] ~ }i kZ a V KZ ~
b zu) X KgZ
y
 (gzZ ]u)~ ]5ZkZgzZ ( b)V
V ( {)z $ZgzgzZ t :z
y M } Yt]{ , zgzZ ) Y0:
L ])aV]
7ab)z Zz Za J
KZ kZO( $ mz<
-# Lz
gzZDIZ#
Z]gzZ Hx Z wZ ~
CgzZ0*
s~]5yZ g
xsZ + ] OZt X ByZ e
$g ]qgzZ i LZ {z c*
hg6,+$
X gzZax Zz~<gzZ
kZ]!*
ZZ s sZ}g gzZDIZaaZz gZ&
{zV KZp
/Z*ZzZ tX
H{g Z Z ZV- gzZaz*ZzZ -
Y i M Z6,K]!*
KZ WzgzZ Y Z {zB fp < p
L zy M
6,t gzZ ~L6?ZOX $
7,]gzh
+ ~yZ`
2005c ( 29) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

(F, Z }wZ
zg Z ) z 45 m1 ` =Z wZ ]NZ>Z ?Z ) X G Hg6
gzZ Lg7!*
C X Yp Z :( 1993g~k
,$
 R,
Iwc* /
%
: M DIZ~Z~ Z Yt{ c* iX ~sZx4,}iZ
i { c*
s %Z~: M V ZzKWX ]!*
@* ~(,ytg @*
X Ys %Z~
-Z #
$Z ~(, q
e ZgzZ 1wikZ ]!*
V- #
Z, zX Lg
V- X ` MgzZ (gzZ +)g Z[Z ) ; ~ Z
s X7!* X 6,gZ [ Z X
HiLq-Z v g _ OZ ~} (,
+AG +AG
ttzg )EX feg (Ztzg )Evhg3 Zg wZZ V-zg}g
~fZkZgzZ " M kZgzZK+~ Z {g (Z LZv
$U*
+
~ kZgzZ p.
** M swt Bt gzZ V
gzZy H0
+i KZ
C xsZ +X D]< kZX { yvgzZd $gtzgtX 7R
G
)EA+kZZ
# X g Z
/0
+i t7]c*
Z@ZgzZ]Yo^0* Y7
kZgzZ ^ }g J VZz VZzg0
e wJ **
f +i+ kZ Dg D
~ T b:B kZgzZ _xBYg u 0
C + t X
i c*
+AG
V Zzg (Ztzg )EV- X Y{g+ \ MgzZ Y M gu0 +i
X (yv#
ZgzZ+
W,O wqZzg Z V'gzZ V~uz vttzg ~ kZ
k]sZZ tgzZ KF,z dZgzZ YZ zLZZD Y
',
+ LZgzZ CZgzZ f
e wqZzg Z sZ)6,x **
Z {z V- X Y 1g (Z z
sg jgzZ',
+Aj} (,gzZ ~(,wq]gV gzZxsZ ` M X Dyv
D
G
~ gzZ ;~ *ZgzZzz h.' + LZ yX C
! f~ yZgz kZ X [gzZgz$~ V-&g Y6,* J
-wg ZD -Z
q
Kg Z vZ~0
+iZ X{)zx?
ax_x2xi) ]tLZ~
vZgzZ * M '
*s ]y  0
+i *** /0
gZ +i %KZgzZ=KZgzZg Z
MgzZ]y g c*
M * ) Zoz){ *
*: kZa+ Ye
$Z@
2005c ( 30) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

Z[ V {zaX I F,
~*~ZzL ( g Z +
#Z {z` MgzZ J e6,yZc*
x dZH VV Z V,Z
G
{7 ~ h.' + yZ b
z ]V Y {za X yix 6,lzg
LZ y X gg(Z Z N (ZC ~ Zi M Ug6a kZ
{zz!*
-ZxsZ {zp7l{6, {)z} izgi ZC
q X :g (Z Zz +
)Z~]qy ZX 7g wJd
$xzq
-ZggzZ]x gzZ]t
t gzZ g3 6,VZ LZ ,g(Z lzg w4Z ~{z t x ~
Cz DIZ
t X Zg7 VkZgzZ Y a
 + LZ {g !* .
Z,4z]
z #
{z f [%gzZ g Z',DgzZ Z {z+@',
kZX3 Zg ]gzZx Z
T et {z ZV YZgzZ VpkZzz 4 !*
d KZ
$! fBt ~{@*
Dg(Zit{zakZX F,
~* {zgzZ N YZa V YZt~x yZ
aV z! fDgzZ =z sz@*
wJ. +Z m<
L zy M

bkZZ 3g { i Zzg Z <a]]5ZgzZ Y
XE
:E-!
txsZh
+C X Y1^gZ~xsZVzg Z ZkZgzZz! fDwEZ
~g Z V gzZxsZt Y c*
CZa CZ f
/ZgzZ Zet Y c* (
CZ { /Z
E
E
Pa ~g7 ]gz L$g EZ T c* +kZ X
Z xwV+F,
$
G
-ZC
q C C-!!*
yZ h Z zZ ZxZi%p Zg{Zg Z + E X c* -e ]t
eg8
'
X 7]!*

kZ~
G
Z wZziV n7]!* C -!
C~q)+ E
kZ {ztzz~
`z[fn7t{zbZX M /kZwZzi b{zgzZ Hzz
h [Z
gzZ Z kZ F,~ Y (zbkZzz `z[f Bt {zX HzzZ
:XE
-!
** ( {)z a^ggzZ EZ`Z ) ^ Z ) Vp KZ ~ kZgzZ **
*Z
~zc yZd
$! f{z ]guZz kZ T e *
* F,
/Z yZ

2005c ( 31) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

/Z)g f ZgzZ xsZ {z DtggzZ;LZ {z V- X ,

$! f
gzZ d
YZgzZ D7x {zDwJ.
aV VZkZ
~*vtt]!*
ZX { VgzZ F
F6,[ZugZgtqDx
Xn 7wZziz`zV
gzZ [Zg Z *tvZt,sZgzZ 9wZziz `zV~ *

: (Z {z CwEZV6& ~ vZ6,g4{ c* * [Z x gzZ

i6, Z
&X 7m c*
yZvZ G
/ G 9kZX CY M V Zz
ZgzZ DgZ kZ tig yZgzZ D] kZgzZ Z tig
gzZ ]g y k0*
kZ m76,
z y KZ -Z X V 1
/zq
/Z yg Z
/Zzy
KZ  6,"
$q kZgzZX Y>y kZ @*M 7 g V
-Z@',
y kZ @*M 7 Z lp V {zgzZ
Zz y k0*
kZ m6,
z y
#
zygzZ Vzzyc* Y0zyykZ *
ce ** .Zt kZp [p
*~
kZ + CZ ykZpYce qz~zc
z {z t Z lp{z @*
+[x ?
gZ0 /Zce Ity, Z ZX}~i Z0
+Z +4}x gzZ}~0*
$yZgzZ VZyZVzzy?ceIt:z~zcVZ LZ T e
d C
F,
~EV B\ M B;6,d
$!fgzZ[f\ MwVZX z~zc
X bb]sVpkZgzZ[fa
C+B]t{g (ZkZ m F,
c* ~E x t {z K]!*

C kZ c*
) y ZZ6,]tTx {z @* kZ @*
]!* 7 N*

/ZX hZz n kZ mZgzZ ]X{z (
+ZkZ {z
Za V p KZ zc{zg0
V: {z
/ZgzZ ( {)zg Z Zy ~0* L F,
:
^)k ~E N Y
# yX V: Za Vp{z ~ kZ
-Z
{z ~ yZ ghZz + LZ ]gzZ mZ J
V p{z ~ yZ gz$Zzt yZ Z
# gzZ ~gza F,~E I Za V p
6,( {)zx2xi) ]tLZ 0xV! fzgz${zgzZIa **
X [aF,
~E IZa V pzc{z~{zgzZZc]gzZmZ
2005c ( 32) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

! fgzZ [fIZ y tx kZ Z s|T~ !*

HH{g gT
]t[fIZ ]tyZYM
Z !*
h7F,
~zc d
$
sZ6,{)zx_x2xi[fIZ n
pg6,]y g y)
MgzZ
/
~yZ 6,]t[fhg]tLZ {z
C VZ
/Z Z( !*
i + q Z kZ ~gza F,
~EV 7Za s zZ KZ zc{z
Y)g D^Y^Ih
+' ,yZ T ~]gn Z6,6fgzZg _
OZ ~
]!* kZaxq
e** /ZgzZXN Y U~ kZh
-Z +' O
3
f{zgzZ
&tM
7[f /GG h F, ~E~zcd
$! fy Y1n9
7y Z ]y F6,g]y
MgzZ ( 7F M {)zx?
ax_xiC
) * s
T,~zc we , Z q
-ZF,~E {z et aV H 7
]!*
 Z', kZ yq yZZgz$gz$ ]!*
?Y !*
C ',
]yM yZ~
Xce 7~zcd $! fgzZ[fV zg 2 C yz=ZY7
& a _ - kZ )
[, gzZ k Z X6U*> /G
KL L[ ~g G
( gg Zi !*
zg ZZu
$! fV 6,tieZgzZ f{z Z
{gt ~zc VZiZd
Z c*
! f6,x ** Y ._VZ ! f{z T Dz sz@*
+Z xsZ c*

yZ z Y d
$! f * Zg~V Vzg Z ZgzZ]Zg
gzZ <tZgX T e *
X g7t V ~Z u
M %~KZ {zgzZ ;gw1| m
3KZ6,gzzeZ )gzZ ~ugzZ ~$
g @* +Z Z xsZ D Y wieZt
xsZ *7 Z } ?e^k
IZg/ c* , X{zp VZgzik wZZX CY ~^
yZgzZ ` Mv:Z ;gyZ!3xsZ <
{ MvZY L
} (,gzZ m1 K Z Z }g J
-Z ? V ` M!3pg
xsZ xcgzZ D._VZ Z Z =zxsZ ieZgzZ f} (,
$U*
"
! f ` M ieZ {z X d
$! fwq ? VZ yZgzZ V{z ` M X D
Y Y[z[ ayZ gsz@*
zxsZ[% d
$
2005c ( 33) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

^gzZ k', G 7 k k { c*
/F it X 7k
i { c* , i ~g Kd
{ c* $! f
Samuel P. ) X gzZ w { c* it ggz Z ! fp X Y
i { c*
Huntington: Clash of Civilization & Remaking of World Order, Simon

kZgzZ 7~ ,gtt {i Z0
+Z Zg & Scuster, New York, 1997)
t
qyZ ?}HgzZ, HgzZt Y)7zg @*
zkZX Z)x4,
9
$U*
" 9 g Zt` M X=+E ,
g)tp`gyZbgzZDIZ! fpg ZgzZx4,
zg Z e
Y[z`gZ ! f !7 ~LLtL X D7b< a
L zy M
lz$kZgzZ=KZz: F
F6,kz {zY g - `g ~qZ xsZp
X6,]!*

+AG
zg q Z De
$e )E
$w D#
7`w~} .Zo Z V~uzV;ZpF,
T Zu]]
.b
6,xsZ *7 Z } Bw4Z ~ Tgg0
+Z} ],Z ~xsZpce **t

X 3 Zg wZZ X gzZ%[% d
$gzZsZ)
G
A+
X 3 Zg ngzZ 3 Zg gzZ )E

g & VzI
zg6,g & yZgzZ iVzI @*
kC~gzckZ
:t] ZiyZXg M ~+ TyZ @
*Y~wZ e
kZfTgzZ Zwi ** 6,T bkZpY c*
yM gzi6,y M
X1
kZv="tc*
) Y ~: ZVz ( < $u)kZgzZgZkZ~+
L zg
mvZ - Zz ! Z {ZX wgs gzZ {0
+ Ztn7]!*
/Z ` M #
i
( z
:DbkZ {zDYbb

L akZXYc*
ZIgZ"<
L zg
$uX2
$ q Z X 7 OZ.
g ZNyz@* tX li QgzZsz Z g $ q Z
Z ~hu q M gzZ q M hu ZgzZ 2
C G g Z X s y M
$ q Z F,

2005c ( 34) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

L zg
~<
X t +]q[ZX ._ ]q i kZ g
$uX w$ $ q ZX
$U*
X {)zC" # Z OZ.
~P{zs OZ.
**
gzZ q M hu
XgZ hg Z{zZ *ZgzZ Z
akZ[fX 3
 !*
X {zakZaCZwZsZ[fX 4
gzZ
.]|gzZ}]|y
M [IZ {zYceg (Z [fIZX 5
X 9}g
XceF,
~zcyZ F,
~*6,
VZX[fX 6
 VZy
gzZ a ~g ~ V {z q yZY b kZgzZ$ 5 X7
- 4,
X ~gz* )kZgzZ{ kZ}
*W,
/cgzZ ': Z ,q LZ
~
X bgZ /Zy X 8
i ZgzZ bba"
X Z F, 9~
$U* g[fX 9
/c 4c*
X ! Z" s sZX 10
Xg Z q )ZX 11
X 12
X#
X* $yZg`q
*e -VZ~Zi M~} W, O[fX 13
5E
~ {)z H &gzZyG^7wz }* *q b6Z`! fX 14
X 7`w
Cw~g Z Zzg ~ Zi M e
gzZ t ~ $g/* $ VzgZ ZgzZ ]Zg! fX 15
*e
y M z}i~gsZgzZg! fgZyZq{)ze
X t $w
X* $V Zx+" X 17
*e
X* $Vzg Z ZgzZVVo)(gzZ
*e x X 18
 6,
X {)z Cc*
gzZ2Zzu
ZW6,
yZgzZVzgZ Z ~oX 19
X* $wqZzg ZgzZ ` ZzgzxgsZ)sX 20
*e
F6,~AgzZ e
4u~TgzZF $g, Zq -Z+]X 21
E
X:f xsZgzZ+ f 5.Z
2005c ( 35) m] )x
 gU*Mzg Z

X o zZ ~ yZzzwZziV X 22
hg}gzZ YH6,
X Yc* <X 23
$~/Z0
Xe +{X 24
X N Yb}V'b kZ O !*
X 25

$x BVz%gzZ 6,
Xe " ]Zz)~ Zi M V gX 26
X 46,
= ~IX 27
X b F, L !*
6,< gzZX 28
X 6, $OgzZ uX 29
kZ e
G
]gzh
+].xsZXce** A+t
CZ3 Zg wZZhg3 Zg gzZ )E
X ]gz h
+
].xsZ Z L
L 7

6n ]]q+ Xo^] m]

az{ E
+Zkg Z
YE4
R,
R,
gzZ 5GZ
~g YZ~wg^g

-------------------------

,Zga]
OOOOOOOOOOO

) - q **
( **
Zz
4271741yX!Z Z` E ; Z=Z

2005c ( 36) m] )x