THE NATION

Published: September 27, 2017 12:30 IST | Updated: September 26, 2017 18:26 IST
FRONTLINE SPECIAL

Tainted guru

Despite several serious charges against Asaram Bapu, there has been little progress in the cases against
the godman. By ANUPAMA KATAKAM
THE godman Asaram Bapu may not be as flamboyant as Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh, chief of the Dera Sacha Sauda who was recently
convicted for rape, but he was also allegedly involved in several crimes. In September 2013, 76-year-old Asaram Bapu was arrested on
the charge of having raped a 16-year-old girl. Subsequently, several allegations of sexual assault, illegal confinement, black magic, land-
grabbing and murder were levelled against him. He is currently serving time in jail for rape.
With the Gujarat courts dragging their feet on the other cases, there has been little progress in them. Despite several serious and
shocking charges and extremely incriminating evidence against Asaram Bapu, it is curious that the cases have not been fast-tracked.
Additionally, it raises the question whether there is a need for stricter laws specifically for gurus and godmen who exploit the
vulnerable.
It is expected that after the ruling against Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh, Asaram Bapu will be the next godman to be tried. In fact, the
Supreme Court had earlier this year asked the Gujarat government to expedite Asaram Bapus case. Recently, it rapped the State
government for not examining the victim. The godman faces charges of rape and illegal confinement in two cases, one in Rajasthan and
the other in Gujarat.
Asaram Bapu began his spiritual movement in Gujarat, which soon spread to other parts of western and northern India. He built a
network of 400 ashrams in 12 nations and has a legion of followers. He enjoyed the patronage of senior politicians, bureaucrats, police
officials and well-known businessmen. It is believed that he also enjoyed a certain amount of protection from his powerful associations.
However, his smooth run hit rough weather in 2008 when four boys were found dead in two ashrams. This opened a can of worms and
out tumbled sordid tales of sexual assault and the alleged possibility of children being used in sacrificial ceremonies.
It was the rape of a minor girl in an ashram in Jodhpur that led to his arrest. The victims parents filed charges and with witnesses
bearing testimony to the crime, the godman was promptly booked and arrested. This story took a dark twist when three witnesses who
spoke to the police were shot dead one after the other. Their families live in hiding, fearing that Asaram Bapus followers will eliminate
them. Its the influence he continues to wield even from behind bars, a former follower said.
Deaths in the ashram
On July 3, 2008, two boys aged 10 and 11 went missing from the Motera Ashrams gurukul. Two days later their mutilated bodies were
found by the Sabarmati riverbed near the ashram. According to informed sources, a part of one boys body was burnt and organs from
the others body had been removed. The deaths led to a Statewide strike. I have never seen the State shut down in this manner. People
were really angry because the police would not register a complaint. It was at this time that the allegations of black magic began, says
Dakxin Chhara, a film-maker based in Ahmedabad who followed the issue.
Later that month two nursery students were found dead in the ashrams toilets. Forensic examination revealed bite marks on one body.
A reliable source said that a senior student was arrested in this connection. Strangely, the childrens parents did not press charges
against the boy or Asaram Bapu.
The outrage that followed the killings led to an inquiry by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) and later the setting up of the
D.K. Trivedi Commission. Initial investigations conducted by a special force did not find any evidence of occult practices on the ashram
premises. Six people were arrested in connection with the killings. The commissions independent probe of the deaths revealed much
more. Two aides of Asaram Bapu and his son Narayan Sai told the commission that they had seen father and son perform strange rituals
around dead bodies and that they had seen unusual tools used for these ceremonies. For reasons best known to them, the victims family
initially backed away and their lawyer said they would not press charges. But a few years later, the boys parents took the ashram to
court. The case is pending in the Sessions Court.
The D.K. Trivedi Commission summoned Asaram Bapu and his son several times but they refused to depose. According to informed
sources, the father-son duo threatened the then Chief Minister, Narendra Modi, that they would bring the government down if they
continued to be harassed. Eventually, in 2012, they were forced to depose. The godman told Justice Trivedi that linking him to these
crimes was a planned conspiracy against the ashram and the Hindu religion.
Several of Asaram Bapus followers admitted their children to the gurukuls attached to the ashrams. A source familiar with the case said
that in August 2013, a couples 16-year-old daughter was summoned by Asaram Bapu as she was apparently unwell. They took her to his
chamber to be treated. He asked them to leave her with him. The victim said that once the parents had left, Asaram Bapu removed his
clothes and forced himself on her, according to a Special Investigation Team (SIT) report. The area was secluded and her screams could
not be heard. Reportedly, he told her that he was God and that she should offer herself to him and threatened to kill her and her family
if she resisted.
It took her a few weeks to confide in her parents, and when she did, they tried to confront Asaram Bapu. He refused to meet them. The
parents then filed a complaint, and the guru was booked under Section 376 (rape) and several other charges, including a few under the
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POSCO) Act. Asaram Bapu was arrested a month later and has since been in the Jodhpur
jail.
The victims family lives with 24-hour security. That he (Asaram) is in jail does not mean the family is safe. Every killing took place
after his arrest. People attached to this case have either disappeared or have been killed. He is a dangerous and powerful man, said an
Ahmedabad-based lawyer who was involved in the Motera boys case.
Asaram Bapu and his son also face charges of rape from two sisters in Surat. One of the women said that she was raped for three years
by the guru. The other charges the son with rape. A SIT of the Gujarat Police, on the basis of depositions from about 100 witnesses,
booked Asaram Bapu, his wife, daughter and four sevikas (volunteers) for rape, illegal confinement, criminal conspiracy and unnatural
sex.
Dead and missing witnesses
When Asaram Bapu was arrested, his followers threatened to take revenge. It was not an empty threat. Three close associates of the
guru who stepped forward as witnesses were shot dead.
Amrut Prajapati was killed on May 23, 2014. An ayurvedic doctor, he was Asaram Bapus personal physician. Prajapati had worked in
various ashrams for 15 years. When he left the ashram in 2005, he was repeatedly threatened by the gurus henchmen. He was even
kidnapped once and beaten and warned not to reveal any information. Prajapati, however, went ahead and deposed as a witness. He
was shot dead by gunmen in Rajkot outside his clinic.
Akhil Gupta, Asaram Bapus cook, was shot dead in Muzaffarnagar on January 12, 2015. He was a confidante of the guru and helped in
the organisations finances. He told the SIT that he left the ashram in 2008 as he was not comfortable with the misdeeds of the father
and son. Gupta was the prime witness in the 16-year-olds rape case. He was shot dead while going home from work.
The third witness to be killed was Kirpal Singh. He had been a follower of Asaram Bapu since the early 2000s. He reportedly knew one
of the alleged rape victims. Singh was a key witness in the rape case. He was shot on July 10, 2015, in Punwara.
A fourth witness, Rahul Sachan, also a key witness in the rape case, went missing on the afternoon of November 21, 2015. He is feared
dead. Sachan was a former assistant of the godman and had reportedly quit the ashram as he was also privy to information which he did
not approve of. Sachan had also been demanding a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the assault and murder of
witnesses. Charges have not yet been filed in these cases.
Asaram Bapus popularity
An informed source said Asaram Bapu was once a sugar trader in the Kalupur market in Ahmedabad. Born Asumal Sirumalani in Sindh,
Pakistan, Asaram, like thousands of Sindhis, came to India during Partition. His family settled in Ahmedabad and began a business
trading in various commodities in the wholesale market. Some sects among Sindhis are known to patronise gurus, and Asarams family
godman was Lila Shah, who lived in the Himalaya. It is not known when Asaram took the spiritual path, but in 1971 he surfaced on the
banks of the Sabarmati in a small hut-like structure where he would hold sermons and dish out ayurvedic medicines to the local people,
according to the source.
His biggest draw was [that] he did not distinguish between caste and community. Therefore, he was extremely popular among the
backward classes of Gujarat, who bear the brunt of a regressive caste system that tends to define their existence, the source said.
In the aftermath of the Nirbhaya rape case, Asaram Bapu incurred the wrath of activists and the media when he said that the victim was
partly to blame for the assault. It remains to be seen if the authorities will expedite his case and deliver justice to his victims.
Printable version | Nov 7, 2017 7:11:07 PM | http://www.frontline.in/the-nation/tainted-guru/article9874185.ece
Frontline