Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Theconstructionindustryknowledgebase Search
Lastedited11Feb2016
Seefullhistory
Createanarticle
Variationsinconstructioncontracts
Share Follow
Contents
Relatedarticles
1Introduction
2Valuationofvariations Abortivework.
3Sourceofconflict
4Limitsonvariations Architect'sinstruction.
5Extensionoftime
6Conclusion Billofquantities.
7Findoutmore Changecontrolprocedures.
7.1RelatedarticlesonDesigningBuildingsWiki
Changeorder.
7.2Externalreferences
Confirmationofverbalinstruction.
Introduction Compensationevents.
Constructioncontract.
Avariation(sometimesreferredtoasavariationinstruction,variationorderorchangeorder)is
analterationtothescopeofworksinaconstructioncontractintheformofanaddition,
substitutionoromissionfromtheoriginalscopeofworks.
Featuredarticles
Almostallconstructionprojectsvaryfromtheoriginaldesign,scopeanddefinition.Whether
smallorlarge,constructionprojectswillhaveinevitablydepartfromtheoriginaltenderdesign, IdeascompetitionMakeBuildingsBetter
specificationsanddrawingspreparedbythedesignteam.Thiscanbebecauseoftechnological
advancement,statutorychangesorenforcement,changeinconditions,geologicalanomalies,
nonavailabilityofspecifiedmaterials,orsimplybecauseofthecontinueddevelopmentofthe
designafterthecontracthasbeenawarded.Inlargecivilengineeringprojectsvariationscanbe
verysignificant,whereasonsmallbuildingcontractstheymayberelativelyminor.
Variationsmayinclude:
Alterationstothedesign.
Alterationstoquantities.
Alterationstoquality. BSRIAandDesigningBuildingsWikiare
Alterationstoworkingconditions. askingwhatyourideasareforimprovingthe
Alterationstothesequenceofwork.
performanceofbuildingsinuse.Win500of
BSRIAgoodies.
Variationsmayalsobedeemedtooccurifthecontractdocumentsdonotproperlydescribethe
worksactuallyrequired.
HexHouseproject
Variationsmaynot(withoutthecontractorsconsent):
Changethefundamentalnatureoftheworks.
Omitworksothatitcanbecarriedoutbyanothercontractor.
Beinstructedafterpracticalcompletion.
Requirethecontractortocarryoutworkthatwasthesubjectofaprimecostsum.
Inlegalterms,avariationisanagreementsupportedbyconsiderationtoaltersometermsofthe
contract.Nopowertoordervariationisimplied.Hencethereshouldbeexpresstermsin
contractswhichgivethepowerinstructvariations.Intheabsenceofexpresstermsinthe
contractthecontractormayrejectinstructionsforvariationswithoutgivingrisetoanylegal ArchitectsforSocietyrevealprototypedesign
consequences. foremergencyreliefandrefugeecamps.
http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Variations_in_construction_contracts 1/4
4/21/2016 VariationsinconstructioncontractsDesigningBuildingsWiki
Standardformsofcontractgenerallymakeexpressprovisionsforthecontractadministrator Unusualbuildingoftheweek
(generallythearchitectorengineer)toinstructvariations(forexample,FIDICClause51.1).Such
provisionsenablethecontinued,smoothadministrationoftheworkswithouttheneedforanother
contract.Variationinstructionsmustbeclearastowhatisandisnotincluded,andmaypropose
themethodofvaluation.
Valuationofvariations
Variationsmaygiverisetoadditionsordeductionsfromthecontractsum.Thevaluationof
variationsmayincludenotjusttheworkwhichthevariationinstructiondescribes,butother
expensesthatmayresultfromthevariation,suchastheimpactonotheraspectsoftheworks.
Oneoftheworld'slargesthotels,the
Variationsmayalso(butnotnecessarily)requireadjustmentofthecompletiondate.
EgyptianthemedblackpyramidtheLuxor
LasVegas.
Variationsmaybevaluedby:
Agreementbetweenthecontractorandtheclient.
Thecostconsultant.
Britain'sgreatestmaverickbuilding
Avariationquotationpreparedbythecontractorandacceptedbytheclient.
Bysomeothermethodagreedbythecontractorandtheclient.
Valuationsofvariationsareoftenbasedontheratesandpricesprovidedbythecontractorin
theirtender,providedtheworkisofasimilarnatureandcarriedoutinsimilarconditions.Thisis
true,evenifitbecomesapparentthattheratesprovidedbythecontractorwerehigherorlower
thanotherwiseavailablecommercialrates.Theydonotbecomereasonableorunreasonableby
theexecutionofvariations(seeHenryBootConstructionvAlstom(2000)).
Insomecontracts,whenratesareappliedtothevaluationofvariations,thecontractorisnot
abletoclaimforadditionalpaymentsinrelationtoprofitsandoverheads. DesigningBuildingsWikiattendedtheRoyal
Academy'sdebatetodecideBritain'sgreatest
Ifsimilartypesofworkstothoseinstructedbyavariationcannotbefoundinthedrawings, maverickbuilding.
specificationorbillsofquantities,thenfairvaluationofthecontractor'sdirectcosts,overheads
andprofitisnecessary.
WestEndGreen
NBNECcontractsdonotvaluevariationsbasedonratesinthetender.Guidanceonassessing
compensationeventsstates:
"AssessmentofcompensationeventsastheyaffectPricesisbasedontheireffectonDefined
CostplustheFee.Thisisdifferentfromsomestandardformsofcontractwherevariationsare
valuedusingtheratesandpricesinthecontractasabasis.Thereasonforthispolicyisthatno
compensationeventforwhichaquotationisrequiredisduetothefaultoftheContractoror
relatestoamatterwhichisathisriskunderthecontract.Itisthereforeappropriatetoreimburse
theContractorhisforecastadditionalcosts(oractualcostsiftheworkhasalreadybeendone)
arisingfromthecompensationevent." Publicconsultationreducesheightof
proposedmixedusedevelopmentinLondon.
Inotherwordsthecontractorcanignoretheirtenderpricingandclaimcostplusonvariations.
Theargumentscomeonitemssuchasfactoryoverheadsandmanagementwhichareveryhard
toevaluate.Inaddition,giventhecomplexityandlengthofthesupplychaininmajorbuilding BRESMARTWaste'JohnMuir'release
works,gettingforecastpricingoutofallthepartiesaffectedtakestime,oftenbeyondthedateby
whichthecontractadministratorhastomakethedecisionastowhetherornottoinstructthe
variation.Theymaythenhavetodecidewhetherornottoproceedwithavariationbasedon
estimatesfromthecostconsultantwhichinduecoursegetreplacedbytheactualcost.Ithas
beenarguedthatthispracticalitydefeatstherationaleoftheNECcontractsinrelationtocost
controlanddecisionmaking.
Sourceofconflict
BREreleaseadditionalfunctionalitytotheir
SMARTWastemanagementtool.
http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Variations_in_construction_contracts 2/4
4/21/2016 VariationsinconstructioncontractsDesigningBuildingsWiki
Conflictcanarisewhenworkisnotmentionedinthebillsofquantities,drawingsor
NBSNationalBIMReport2016
specifications.Incommonlawthissilencedoesnotmeanthecontractorhasanautomaticright
toclaimforextrapayment.Theclientisnotboundtopayforthingsthatareasonablecontractor
musthaveunderstoodweretobedonebutwhichhappentobeomittedfromthebillsof NBSfinduptakeofBIMhasimproved,but
quantities.Wherethereareitemsthat,whilsttheyarenotexpresslymentioned,arenonetheless thereisstillpoorunderstandingofwhatlevel2
requiredinordertocompletetheworks,thenthecontractorshouldhaveincludedthemintheir involves.
price.Thebillsofquantitiesandspecificationdonotnecessarilyhavetoincludeeverynailtobe
punchedin.ForexampleinfixingGRCfaadesitisnecessarytohavesteelsupports,anda
reasonableexperiencedcontractormustmakeprovisionforthisinthecontractprice.Unless InprofileArchitecturalPhotographer
expresslyexcluded,suchsupportsarenotpaidforasavariation.
Conflictcanalsoarisewhenasubcontractorqualifiesthat,forexample,Supply&Fixingof
DoorisincludedbutSupply&FixingofIronmongeryisexcluded.Areasonablesubcontractor
shouldforeseethatadoorcannotbefixedwithouthingeswhichisapartoftheironmongery.
Soevenifironmongeryisexcluded,thesubcontractorcannotexpectavariationforanyofthe
itemsrequiredtofixthedoors.
Alsounderthepretextofvariation,thecontractadministratorcannotchangethenatureofworks.
Forexample,ifthecontractprovidesforsecantpileshoring,theycannotaskfordiaphragmwall
shoringasitwillentirelychangethenatureofthework.Further,ifthecontractadministrator
omitsworkfromcontractorsscope,suchanomissionmustbegenuine:thatis,theworkomitted
mustbeomittedfromthecontractentirely,itcannotbeusedtotakeworkawayfromthe DesigningBuildingsWikitalktoPaulGrundy
contractortogiveittoanother(forexample,seeFIDICClause51.1).Similarly,thecontract aboutwhatittakestobeanarchitectural
administratorisnotempoweredtoordervariationstohelpthecontractorifthecontractworksare photographer.
provingtoodifficultorexpensiveforthem.
Limitsonvariations BuildingoftheweekFlatironBuilding
FIDICformsofcontractputlimitationsonvariationsthatcanbeinstructed.Ifthevalueofthe
contractincreasesordecreasesbymorethan15%ofthenetcontractsum(excluding
provisionalsumsanddayworks)thenthecontractadministratorcanaddordeductfromthe
contractsumadeterminedvalueuponconsultationwiththecontractor,havingdueregardtotheir
siteexpensesandothergeneraloverheads.Notethatthis15%increaseordecreaseisnotfora
singleitemofwork,butthetotalcontractsumatcompletion.
InNEC3(OptionB)iftherateinthebillmultipliedbythefinaltotalquantityofworkdoneismore
than0.5%ofthepricedtotalofthebillatthecontractdate,thenitwillconstituteavariation(see
Clause60.4)
Extensionoftime
Manyconstructioncontractsallowtheconstructionperiodtobeextendedwheretherearedelays
Withitsdistinctivewedgeshape,theFlatiron
thatarenotthecontractor'sfault.Thisisdescribedasanextensionoftime(EOT).
remainsoneofNewYork'smosticonic
buildings.
Variationsmay(butdonotnecesarily)constituterelevanteventsthatcanmeritanextentionof
timeandsoadjustmentofthecompletiondate.Seeextensionoftimeformoreinformation.
GreenDealslammed
Conclusion
Variationsareoftensourcesofdispute(eitherinvaluingthevariation,oragreeingwhetherpartof
theworksconstituteavariationatall)andcancostalotoftimeandmoneyduringthecourseof
acontract.Whilstsomevariationsareunavoidable,itiswisetominimisepotentialvariationsand
subsequentclaimsbyensuringthatuncertaintiesareeliminatedbeforeawardingthecontract.
Thiscanbedoneby:
Undertakingthoroughsiteinvestigationsandconditionsurveys.
Ensuringthattheprojectbriefiscomprehensiveandissupportedbystakeholders.
http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Variations_in_construction_contracts 3/4
4/21/2016 VariationsinconstructioncontractsDesigningBuildingsWiki
Ensuringthatlegislativerequirementsareproperlyintegratedintotheproject.
Ensuringthatrisksareproperlyidentified. NAOreportfindstheGreenDealnotonly
Ensuringthatdesignsareproperlycoordinatedbeforetender. failedtodeliveranymeaningfulbenefit,it
Ensuringthecontractisunambiguousandexplicit.
Ensuringthecontractor'sratesareclear. increasedsupplierscostsandtherefore
Preparingconcisedrawings,billsofquantitiesandspecifications,providingforallsituations energybills.
whicharereasonablyforeseeable.
Findoutmore
LondonMayoralelections2016
RelatedarticlesonDesigningBuildingsWiki
Abortivework.
Architect'sinstruction.
Billofquantities.
Changecontrolprocedures.
Changeorder.
Confirmationofverbalinstruction.
Compensationevents.
Constructioncontract.
Contractdocuments.
Definedcost.
Delaydamages.
Extensionoftime.
Liquidateddamages.
Lossandexpense.
Astheelectiondatenearsweexaminewhat
Outturncost.
Relevantevent. thecandidatesaresayingaboutLondon'sbuilt
Requestforinformation. environment.
Externalreferences
TheJCT05StandardBuildingContract:LawandAdministrationByIssakaNdekugri,
MichaelRycroft. Formorenews,gotothehomepage.
http://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Variations_in_construction_contracts 4/4