FYP I Pindaan.

1 2015

FACULTY OF MANUFACTURING ENGINEERING

BACHELOR DEGREE PROJECT I
(BMFG 4932)
2016/2017
SUPERVISOR EVALUATION FORM GENERAL CONDUCT
BMFP BMFR BMFA BMFB BMFU
NAME OF STUDENT
STUDENT MATRIX NO.
TITLE OF PROJECT
PLEASE CIRCLE THE SCORE FOR EACH EVALUATION CRITERIA
A. PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION
Score Weightage
Log book & Frequency of Meeting (LO3, PO7, EM1)
12 weeks 5
10 - 11 weeks 4
8 - 9 weeks 3 1
Logbook is not submitted 0
< 80% or less than 3 times attending a meeting with the supervisor Status
BAR
Progress of the work (LO4, PO12, CTPS3)
The student are able to:
Describe the research planning clearly.
Execute the plan accordingly. 5
Complete the information about the cost involved in the project (if applicable).
Provide informative Gant Chart (progress within 100%).
The student are able to:
Describe the research planning clearly.
Provide satisfactory information about the cost involved in the project (if applicable). 4
Provide informative Gant Chart (progress wihthin 85%).
The student are able to:
Provide acceptable research planning. 3
Provide satisfactory information about the cost involved in the project (if applicable). 2
Provide satisfactory information on Gant chart (progress within 70 %).
The student provide:
Poor research planning and justification on project progression. 2
Acceptable information on cost involved in the project (if applicable).
Acceptable information on Gant Chart (progress within 55 %).
The student provide:
Inaffective research planning, limited information on Gant Chart (progress within 1
40%) and acceptable information on cost involved in the project (if applicable).
No Gantt chart and absent of explanation of the cost involved in the project (if 0
applicable).
B. STUDENT PERFORMANCE
Score Weightage
Critical Thinking and Problem Solving Skill (LO2, PO2, CTPS3)
Able to independently identify and analyse problem proposes with good justification.
5
Have creative solutions to choose an approriate strategies in solving the problem.
Able to identify, analyse the problem and propose common solutions using effective
4
strategies with minimum supervision. 1
Able to identify, analyse the problem and propose common solutions using acceptable
3
strategies however requires extensive supervision.
Able to identify the problem and propose solutions with minimum justification. 2
Able to identify the problem however unable to propose sounds solutions for the
1
problems.
1
 FYP I Pindaan. 1 2015

Unable to identify the problems and propose any possible solutions. 0

Discussion and Contribution of Ideas (LO2, PO2, CTPS3)
Effective discussion with supervisor. Student propose ideas with high degree of clarity
5
with scientific references.
Effective discussion with supervisor. Student propose ideas with good clarity. 4
Acceptable effective discussion with supervisor. Student propose ideas with limited 1
3
clarity.
Inffective discussion with supervisor, poor contribution in providing original ideas 2
Poor discussion, no contribution of original ideas. 1
No discussion. 0
Communication and Interpersonal Skill (LO5, PO9, CS3 )
Excellent level of communication with outstanding interpersonal skill. 5
Good level of communication, with good interpersonal skill. 4
Satisfactory level of communication and interpersonal skills. 3 1
Acceptable level of communication and interpersonal skills. 2
Poor level of communication and interpersonal skills. 1
Ineffective level of communication and interpersonal skills. 0
Attitude, Commitment and Discipline (LO3, PO7, EM2) Score Weightage
Outstanding attitude, highly commited and excellent discipline. 5
Good attitude, commitment and good discipline. 4
Satisfactory attitude, commitment and discipline. 3 2
Acceptable attitude, commitment and discipline. 2
Poor attitude, commitment and acceptable discipline. 1
Bad attitude, incommited and poor discipline. 0

C. LECTURE SERIES (ONLY APPLICABLE FOR PIC)

Score Weightage
Frequency of Meeting (LO3, PO7, EM1)
Technical English 3
Chapter 1: Introduction 3
Chapter 2: Literature Review 3 0.5
Chapter 3: Methodology 3
Reference and formatting 3

(SV signature & official stamp) Date: