Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Debates concerning the nature, essence and the mode of existence of space date back
to antiquity; namely, to treatises like the Timaeus of Plato, or Socrates in his
reflections on what the Greeks called khra (i.e. "space"), or in the Physics of
Aristotle (Book IV, Delta) in the definition of topos (i.e. place), or in the later
"geometrical conception of place" as "space qua extension" in the Discourse on
Place (Qawl fi al-Makan) of the 11th-century Arab polymath Alhazen.[2] Many of
these classical philosophical questions were discussed in the Renaissance and then
reformulated in the 17th century, particularly during the early development of
classical mechanics. In Isaac Newton's view, space was absolutein the sense that
it existed permanently and independently of whether there was any matter in the
space.[3] Other natural philosophers, notably Gottfried Leibniz, thought instead
that space was in fact a collection of relations between objects, given by their
distance and direction from one another. In the 18th century, the philosopher and
theologian George Berkeley attempted to refute the "visibility of spatial depth" in
his Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision. Later, the metaphysician Immanuel Kant
said that the concepts of space and time are not empirical ones derived from
experiences of the outside worldthey are elements of an already given systematic
framework that humans possess and use to structure all experiences. Kant referred
to the experience of "space" in his Critique of Pure Reason as being a subjective
"pure a priori form of intuition".
In the 19th and 20th centuries mathematicians began to examine geometries that are
non-Euclidean, in which space is conceived as curved, rather than flat. According
to Albert Einstein's theory of general relativity, space around gravitational
fields deviates from Euclidean space.[4] Experimental tests of general relativity
have confirmed that non-Euclidean geometries provide a better model for the shape
of space.
Contents [hide]
1 Philosophy of space
1.1 Leibniz and Newton
1.2 Kant
1.3 Non-Euclidean geometry
1.4 Gauss and Poincar
1.5 Einstein
2 Mathematics
3 Physics
3.1 Classical mechanics
3.2 Relativity
3.3 Cosmology
4 Spatial measurement
5 Geographical space
6 In psychology
7 See also
8 References
9 External links
Philosophy of space
Leibniz and Newton
Gottfried Leibniz
In the seventeenth century, the philosophy of space and time emerged as a central
issue in epistemology and metaphysics. At its heart, Gottfried Leibniz, the German
philosopher-mathematician, and Isaac Newton, the English physicist-mathematician,
set out two opposing theories of what space is. Rather than being an entity that
independently exists over and above other matter, Leibniz held that space is no
more than the collection of spatial relations between objects in the world: "space
is that which results from places taken together".[5] Unoccupied regions are those
that could have objects in them, and thus spatial relations with other places. For
Leibniz, then, space was an idealised abstraction from the relations between
individual entities or their possible locations and therefore could not be
continuous but must be discrete.[6] Space could be thought of in a similar way to
the relations between family members. Although people in the family are related to
one another, the relations do not exist independently of the people.[7] Leibniz
argued that space could not exist independently of objects in the world because
that implies a difference between two universes exactly alike except for the
location of the material world in each universe. But since there would be no
observational way of telling these universes apart then, according to the identity
of indiscernibles, there would be no real difference between them. According to the
principle of sufficient reason, any theory of space that implied that there could
be these two possible universes must therefore be wrong.[8]
Isaac Newton
Newton took space to be more than relations between material objects and based his
position on observation and experimentation. For a relationist there can be no real
difference between inertial motion, in which the object travels with constant
velocity, and non-inertial motion, in which the velocity changes with time, since
all spatial measurements are relative to other objects and their motions. But
Newton argued that since non-inertial motion generates forces, it must be absolute.
[9] He used the example of water in a spinning bucket to demonstrate his argument.
Water in a bucket is hung from a rope and set to spin, starts with a flat surface.
After a while, as the bucket continues to spin, the surface of the water becomes
concave. If the bucket's spinning is stopped then the surface of the water remains
concave as it continues to spin. The concave surface is therefore apparently not
the result of relative motion between the bucket and the water.[10] Instead, Newton
argued, it must be a result of non-inertial motion relative to space itself. For
several centuries the bucket argument was considered decisive in showing that space
must exist independently of matter.
Kant
Immanuel Kant
In the eighteenth century the German philosopher Immanuel Kant developed a theory
of knowledge in which knowledge about space can be both a priori and synthetic.[11]
According to Kant, knowledge about space is synthetic, in that statements about
space are not simply true by virtue of the meaning of the words in the statement.
In his work, Kant rejected the view that space must be either a substance or
relation. Instead he came to the conclusion that space and time are not discovered
by humans to be objective features of the world, but imposed by us as part of a
framework for organizing experience.[12]
Non-Euclidean geometry
Main article: Non-Euclidean geometry
Henri Poincar
Although there was a prevailing Kantian consensus at the time, once non-Euclidean
geometries had been formalised, some began to wonder whether or not physical space
is curved. Carl Friedrich Gauss, a German mathematician, was the first to consider
an empirical investigation of the geometrical structure of space. He thought of
making a test of the sum of the angles of an enormous stellar triangle, and there
are reports that he actually carried out a test, on a small scale, by triangulating
mountain tops in Germany.[14]
Henri Poincar, a French mathematician and physicist of the late 19th century,
introduced an important insight in which he attempted to demonstrate the futility
of any attempt to discover which geometry applies to space by experiment.[15] He
considered the predicament that would face scientists if they were confined to the
surface of an imaginary large sphere with particular properties, known as a sphere-
world. In this world, the temperature is taken to vary in such a way that all
objects expand and contract in similar proportions in different places on the
sphere. With a suitable falloff in temperature, if the scientists try to use
measuring rods to determine the sum of the angles in a triangle, they can be
deceived into thinking that they inhabit a plane, rather than a spherical surface.
[16] In fact, the scientists cannot in principle determine whether they inhabit a
plane or sphere and, Poincar argued, the same is true for the debate over whether
real space is Euclidean or not. For him, which geometry was used to describe space
was a matter of convention.[17] Since Euclidean geometry is simpler than non-
Euclidean geometry, he assumed the former would always be used to describe the
'true' geometry of the world.[18]
Einstein
Albert Einstein
In 1905, Albert Einstein published his special theory of relativity, which led to
the concept that space and time can be viewed as a single construct known as
spacetime. In this theory, the speed of light in a vacuum is the same for all
observerswhich has the result that two events that appear simultaneous to one
particular observer will not be simultaneous to another observer if the observers
are moving with respect to one another. Moreover, an observer will measure a moving
clock to tick more slowly than one that is stationary with respect to them; and
objects are measured to be shortened in the direction that they are moving with
respect to the observer.
Mathematics
Main article: Three-dimensional space
Not to be confused with Space (mathematics).
In modern mathematics spaces are defined as sets with some added structure. They
are frequently described as different types of manifolds, which are spaces that
locally approximate to Euclidean space, and where the properties are defined
largely on local connectedness of points that lie on the manifold. There are
however, many diverse mathematical objects that are called spaces. For example,
vector spaces such as function spaces may have infinite numbers of independent
dimensions and a notion of distance very different from Euclidean space, and
topological spaces replace the concept of distance with a more abstract idea of
nearness.
Physics
Many of the laws of physics, such as the various inverse square laws, depend on
dimension three.[20]
Classical mechanics
Main article: Classical mechanics
Classical mechanics
{\displaystyle {\vec {F}}=m{\vec {a}}} {\vec {F}}=m{\vec {a}}
Second law of motion
History Timeline
Branches[show]
Fundamentals[hide]
Acceleration Angular momentum Couple D'Alembert's principle Energy kinetic
potential Force Frame of reference Impulse Inertia / Moment of inertia Mass
Mechanical power Mechanical work
Moment Momentum Space Speed Time Torque Velocity Virtual work
Formulations[show]
Core topics[show]
Rotation[show]
Scientists[show]
v t e
Space is one of the few fundamental quantities in physics, meaning that it cannot
be defined via other quantities because nothing more fundamental is known at the
present. On the other hand, it can be related to other fundamental quantities.
Thus, similar to other fundamental quantities (like time and mass), space can be
explored via measurement and experiment.
Relativity
Main article: Theory of relativity
Before Einstein's work on relativistic physics, time and space were viewed as
independent dimensions. Einstein's discoveries showed that due to relativity of
motion our space and time can be mathematically combined into one objectspacetime.
It turns out that distances in space or in time separately are not invariant with
respect to Lorentz coordinate transformations, but distances in Minkowski space-
time along space-time intervals arewhich justifies the name.
In addition, time and space dimensions should not be viewed as exactly equivalent
in Minkowski space-time. One can freely move in space but not in time. Thus, time
and space coordinates are treated differently both in special relativity (where
time is sometimes considered an imaginary coordinate) and in general relativity
(where different signs are assigned to time and space components of spacetime
metric).
One consequence of this postulate, which follows from the equations of general
relativity, is the prediction of moving ripples of space-time, called gravitational
waves. While indirect evidence for these waves has been found (in the motions of
the HulseTaylor binary system, for example) experiments attempting to directly
measure these waves are ongoing.
Cosmology
Main article: Shape of the universe
Relativity theory leads to the cosmological question of what shape the universe is,
and where space came from. It appears that space was created in the Big Bang, 13.8
billion years ago[22] and has been expanding ever since. The overall shape of space
is not known, but space is known to be expanding very rapidly due to the cosmic
inflation.
Spatial measurement
Main article: Measurement
The measurement of physical space has long been important. Although earlier
societies had developed measuring systems, the International System of Units, (SI),
is now the most common system of units used in the measuring of space, and is
almost universally used.
Currently, the standard space interval, called a standard meter or simply meter, is
defined as the distance traveled by light in a vacuum during a time interval of
exactly 1/299,792,458 of a second. This definition coupled with present definition
of the second is based on the special theory of relativity in which the speed of
light plays the role of a fundamental constant of nature.
Geographical space
See also: Spatial analysis
Geography is the branch of science concerned with identifying and describing the
Earth, utilizing spatial awareness to try to understand why things exist in
specific locations. Cartography is the mapping of spaces to allow better
navigation, for visualization purposes and to act as a locational device.
Geostatistics apply statistical concepts to collected spatial data to create an
estimate for unobserved phenomena.
Public space is a term used to define areas of land as collectively owned by the
community, and managed in their name by delegated bodies; such spaces are open to
all, while private property is the land culturally owned by an individual or
company, for their own use and pleasure.
In psychology
Psychologists first began to study the way space is perceived in the middle of the
19th century. Those now concerned with such studies regard it as a distinct branch
of psychology. Psychologists analyzing the perception of space are concerned with
how recognition of an object's physical appearance or its interactions are
perceived, see, for example, visual space.
Other, more specialized topics studied include amodal perception and object
permanence. The perception of surroundings is important due to its necessary
relevance to survival, especially with regards to hunting and self preservation as
well as simply one's idea of personal space.
Several space-related phobias have been identified, including agoraphobia (the fear
of open spaces), astrophobia (the fear of celestial space) and claustrophobia (the
fear of enclosed spaces).
See also