Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Burnt clay brick is one of the major and widely used building unit in masonry construction around the
Received 1 February 2016 globe. The manufacturing of burnt clay bricks using waste materials can minimize the environmental
Received in revised form 3 May 2016 overburden caused by waste deposition on open landfills and would also improve the brick performance
Accepted 11 May 2016
at low production cost leading to more sustainable construction. This study aims to evaluate the effect of
the waste addition produced from two major crops: sugarcane and rice in clay bricks manufacturing. In
this study, sugarcane bagasse ash (SBA) and rice husk ash (RHA) were collected locally from a sugar mill
Keywords:
and bulls trench kiln, respectively. Brick specimens were manufactured at an industrial brick kiln plant
Bricks
Sugarcane bagasse ash
using various dosages (5%, 10% and 15% by clay weight) of SBA and RHA. Mechanical and durability prop-
Rice husk ash erties of these bricks were studied. It was observed that clay bricks incorporating SBA and RHA exhibited
Mechanical properties lower compressive strength compared to that of clay bricks without SBA and RHA. However, compressive
Durability strength of bricks with 5% of SBA and RHA satisfied the Pakistan Building Code requirements (i.e. >5 MPa).
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis confirms the porous microstructure of the brick specimens
incorporating SBA and RHA, which resulted into lesser unit weight leading to lighter and economical
structures. Furthermore, resistance against efflorescence was improved in all the tested bricks incorpo-
rating SBA and RHA. Based on this study, it can be concluded that the brick specimens incorporating
lower dosage of SBA and RHA (i.e. 5% by clay weight) will not only relieve the environmental burden
but also result into a more sustainable and economical construction.
2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction bagasse ash can be used in the production of bricks. In this study,
the use of these two wastes for brick production has been
Fired clay bricks are one of the oldest construction material attempted.
used in the construction of partition and load carrying walls in Rice husk is the outer cover of rice kernel, which have two inter-
the buildings. The extensive use of natural clay deposits for brick locking halves. Approximately, husk is obtained 20% of rice paddy
production has caused an alarming deficit level of this natural and Pakistan is capable of producing one million tons of husk every
material [13]. This situation has forced the researchers to shift year [4,5]. Major disposal of rice husk is either in brick industry
their focus towards the development of new materials or recycle where it is used in kilns as a fuel source or in the paper industry.
waste materials produced from various industries. In the same After combustion of rice husk, ash is produced. Different percent-
context, various wastes including rice husk ash and sugarcane age of ash obtained have been reported by various researchers.
Normally, it is obtained 1525% of rice husk [6,7]. The disposal of
this ash is a great challenge. Rice husk ash (RHA) obtained from
Corresponding author.
brick kilns has great potential to be used for brick manufacturing.
E-mail address: safeerabbas26@gmail.com (S. Abbas).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2016.05.084
0950-0618/ 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
30 S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941
This can lead to environmental friendly, sustainable and economi- (freeze-thaw, efflorescence, sulfate attack and porosity) of clay
cal construction. bricks incorporating rice husk and sugarcane bagasse ashes is very
Moreover, after extraction of juice from sugarcane in the sugar scant in the open literature.
mills, the bagasse is left as a residue. Approximately, 1 kg of sugar- In this research program, waste materials (rice husk ash and
cane generates 25% of bagasse and 0.6% of bagasse ash [8]. Sugar sugarcane bagasse ash) have been used for brick manufacturing.
cane is produced around 50 million tons annually in Pakistan The use of these waste materials not only improves the brick per-
and consumed mostly in sugar production [9,10]. As a result, formance but also attractive with respect to environment, sustain-
bagasse is obtained in a range of 2430% and used as a source of ability and economy. RHA and SBA were used in three different
fuel in the sugar industry [11]. The residue left after burning is replacement ratios (5%, 10%, 15% by weight of clay) in bricks to
called as sugarcane bagasse ash (SBA) having two main con- investigate their effect on mechanical and durability properties.
stituents: oxides of silicon and aluminum. Approximately, sugar- Unlike the previous researches, all the bricks were manufactured
cane is consumed 81% in sugar industry [12]. In Pakistan, 0.26 in an industrial brick kiln.
million tons of bagasse ash is produced annually, after combustion
of approximately 11 million tons of bagasse [13], which can be
potentially used in brick production. 3. Research significance and objectives
Table 1
Mixture proportions of raw materials for brick manufacturing.
from water and weighed after wiping off the excess water from the surface. For ini-
tial rate of absorption, specimens after drying were immersed in water up to 5 mm
depth for one minute. Brick specimens were removed and weighted in accordance
with ASTM C67 [34].
The apparent porosity of brick specimens was estimated according to ASTM C20
(Standard test methods for apparent porosity, water absorption, apparent specific
gravity, and bulk density of burned refractory brick and shapes by boiling water)
[35]. Specimens were placed in the water and boiled for 2 h (Fig. 5). After boiling,
Fig. 1. Industrial kiln for brick manufacturing. specimens were left to cool in water for 12 h. Brick specimens were then weighed
while suspended in water. After determining the suspended weight, saturated
weight was determined after cleaning the surface water from the brick specimens.
Apparent porosity was determined using Eq. (1).
W D
4.3. Test methodology P 100 1
W S
To study the properties of raw materials; chemical analysis, particle size distri-
bution, scanning electron microscopy, specific gravity and atterberg limits tests where, P is the apparent porosity, W is the saturated weight, D is the dry weight and
were conducted. Chemical composition was determined using X-ray fluorescence S is the suspended weight of the specimen.
(XRF) and X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD). Scanning electron microscopy was per- To measure the efflorescence, specimens were partially immersed on one end in
formed to examine the microstructure of raw materials. ASTM D422 (Standard test distilled water in a constant depth of 25 mm for 45 days. After 45 days, brick spec-
method for particle-size analysis of soils) [31] and ASTM D854 (Standard test meth- imens were examined after drying in an oven for 24 h.
ods for specific gravity of soil solids by water pycnometer) [32] were used to deter- To check the resistance of brick specimens against freeze and thaw, specimens
mine the particle size distribution and specific gravity respectively, of clay, rice were placed in the freezing and thawing condition according to ASTM C67 [34].
husk ash (RHA) and sugarcane bagasse ash (SBA). Atterberg limits of clay were Samples were kept in freezing and thawing conditions for 50 cycles: each cycle hav-
determined according to ASTM D4318 (Standard test method for liquid limit, plastic ing 20 h of freezing up to 10 C and 4 h of thawing in water at room temperature.
limit, and plasticity index of soils) [33]. Different proportions (i.e. 5%, 10% and 15% After every 5 cycles of freezing and thawing, specimens were air and oven dried for
by clay weight) of RHA and SBA were investigated in order to evaluate the perfor- 24 and 20 h, respectively. The dried specimens were visually examined for cracks or
mance of brick specimens. other damages (if any). Furthermore, specimens were weighed in order to measure
Before testing, all brick specimens were oven dried at 110 C for 24 h. After oven the weight loss.
drying, specimens were cooled at room temperature and weighed. The results were Durability of bricks was studied by fully immersing the specimens in sodium
then divided over the average area to get the unit weight. sulfate solution (Fig. 6). Solution of 50 g of sodium sulfate per liter of water was pre-
Compressive strength and modulus of rupture were determined according to pared as per ASTM C1012 (Standard test method for length change of hydraulic-
ASTM C67 (Standard test methods for sampling and testing brick and structural clay cement mortars exposed to a sulfate solution) [36]. After 30 days of immersion,
tile) [34]. For compressive strength, brick specimens were capped on opposite sides bricks were dried at 110 C, weighed and tested for compressive strength.
using gypsum and left for drying for 24 h. The specimens were then tested at a load- Furthermore, flaws in brick specimens were estimated using ultrasonic pulse
ing rate of 1.25 mm/min. in the direction of depth of brick. For modulus of rupture, velocity test. Brick specimens were tested by placing transducers in opposite direc-
brick specimens were placed flat such that span between the supports was 40 mm tions of the brick specimens along the width (Fig. 7). ASTM C597 (Standard test
less than the actual length. Load was applied in the direction of depth of specimen method for pulse velocity through concrete) [37] was followed to perform this test.
at its mid span. The frog was kept on the compression side. A steel plate of 6 mm Ultrasonic pulse velocity was determined using Eq. (2).
thickness and 40 mm width was used at the top to apply load.
To study the durability properties, water absorption, initial rate of absorption, L
V 2
apparent porosity, efflorescence, freeze-thaw resistance and sulfate attack resis- T
tance tests were performed. To measure water absorption according to ASTM C67
[34], brick specimens were first dried and then completely submerged in clean where, V is the ultrasonic pulse velocity, L is distance between transducers and T is
water at room temperature for 24 h (Fig. 4). Afterwards, specimens were removed the transit time.
(a) Ash mixed with soil/clay (b) wet mixing (c) Lump
Fig. 2. Mixing of raw materials.
32 S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941
(a) Brick placed for sun drying in rain (b) Brick after burning in kiln
protected shed
Fig. 4. Brick specimens during water absorption test. Fig. 6. Bricks immersed in sulfate solution.
5. Results and discussion oxides of aluminum, iron, calcium, magnesium and potassium.
Clay used in brick factories normally contains the percentages of
5.1. Properties of raw materials SiO2 in the range of 5060% [15]. Clay used in this study has SiO2
within the specified ranges. Clay has CaO more than 6% and K2O,
5.1.1. Chemical composition CaO, MgO, Fe2O3 and TiO2 concentration higher than 9%; therefore,
The chemical composition of raw materials is shown in Table 2. this clay can be referred as calcareous with low refractory proper-
It was observed that clay/soil had large fraction of silica along with ties [38,39].
S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941 33
Table 2
Chemical and physical properties of the constituents of brick specimens.
Table 3
Particle size distribution analysis of raw materials used.
[45]. Fig. 13 shows the atterberg limits of the raw clayey material
after addition of SBA and RHA content. Results indicated that plas-
tic limit values increased with higher content of RHA. This increase
in plastic limit may be due to the reduction in the quantity of silt
and clay fraction which require more water. A decreasing trend
in liquid limit and plasticity index was also observed (Fig. 13). Sim-
ilar trend in atterberg limits was reported in previous researches
[4648]. In case of SBA mixture, a decrease in plasticity index along
with decrease in plastic and liquid limit was observed with the
increase in SBA content. This may be due to cation exchange reac-
tion and flocculation of particles, which is in agreement with pre-
vious study [47]. Generally, SBA and RHA are considered non-
plastic and non-cohesive materials, which confirms the decreasing
trend of mixtures plasticity index [29,49].
(a) Clay
5.2. Mechanical properties of brick specimens
30
Atterberg Limits (%)
25
20
15
10
0
RHA5 RHA10 RHA15 SBA5 SBA10 SBA15
ler particles with irregular shapes were observed in RHA speci- 95 RHA
mens. Moreover, all the images showed a wide variety of particle SBA
sizes present in the raw materials in agreement with particle size Clay
90
distribution.
Table 4 60
Weight per unit area of bricks incorporating RHA and SBA.
y = -1.50x + 50.12
Mixtures Weight per unit area (kg/m2) 50 R = 0.77
9
1.6
8
RHA
Compressive strength (MPa)
1.4 RHA
Modulus of rupture (MPa)
7
SBA
1.2 SBA
6 Clay
Clay
5 1.0
4 0.8
3 0.6
2 0.4
1 0.2
0 0.0
5% 10% 15% 5% 10% 15%
Percentage replacement Percentage replacement
Fig. 15. Effect of RHA and SBA wastes on compressive strength of bricks. Fig. 17. Modulus of rupture for brick specimens incorporating RHA and SBA.
36 S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941
different. No significant change in flexural strength was observed [63,64]. Higher amount of fluxing agents in clay (20.53%) was
for 10% incorporation of RHA in comparison with control observed compared to that of the SBA (6.62%) and RHA (13.62%).
specimens. However, 38% reduction in flexural strength was Therefore, increased porosity was observed for brick specimens
observed for RHA15. This trend in flexural strength for RHA was incorporating SBA and RHA leading to decrease the mechanical
in agreement with previous study [59]. Flexural strength of brick strength properties compared to that of the control bricks. SBA also
specimens is normally related to the microstructure of the has calcite in considerable amount. The gaseous generation
specimens [60]. Porous structures as a result of RHA and SBA through decomposition of carbonate also generated porosity in
incorporation in burnt clay bricks reduced the flexural strength. burnt clay bricks incorporating SBA. Moreover, it was observed
According to ASTM C 67 guidelines, the minimum permissible that LOI of SBA was higher compared to that of the clay which con-
limit for modulus of rupture is 0.65 MPa [22,34]. All the tested firms the combustion of organic matter leading to higher porosity.
brick specimens exhibited modulus of rupture values in the range Moreover, increase in porosity could be due to the change in
of 0.671.49 MPa. Therefore, it can be concluded that bricks amount and size of pores after incorporating RHA and SBA [65].
incorporating SBA and RHA can be efficiently produced on massive It may be concluded that the increase in percentage of RHA and
scale leading to economical and sustainable construction. SBA increases the porosity inside the bricks leading to higher water
absorption capacity. On the other hand, bricks with high porosity
are usually lighter than low porosity bricks and have good insula-
5.3. Durability properties of brick specimens tion properties [28,66]. Furthermore, previous research has shown
that the resistance to heat transfer is increased for high porosity
5.3.1. Apparent porosity bricks [67]. Therefore, bricks incorporating SBA and RHA can be
Porosity is one of the important characteristic of clay bricks. The utilized where improved insulation and heat transfer resistance
rate of transport of moisture is ten times faster in bricks as com- is required.
pared to other materials because of capillary effect [61]. During
daytime, moisture is released from the pores and during night, it 5.3.2. Water absorption
is re-absorbed. It helps to control the temperature and humidity Water absorption is a major factor affecting the durability of
of atmosphere inside the structure. On the other hand, porosity bricks [68]. Fig. 19 shows the water absorption for brick specimens
makes vulnerable to weathering affects (polluted air and rain) incorporating SBA and RHA. It was observed that the water absorp-
and chemical attack [44]. Therefore, porosity of construction mate- tion increased with higher percentage replacement of SBA and
rial has a lot of importance with regards to the performance and RHA. For instance, mixture incorporating 10% of SBA showed water
applications. absorption of around 24%; while, 17% for brick specimens without
Fig. 18 shows porosity results for brick specimens incorporating SBA. This can be attributed to increased porosity with higher per-
RHA and SBA. It was observed that control specimens have the centage of SBA and RHA. A linear relationship between water
least porosity (i.e. 36%) whereas, SBA15 specimens have highest absorption and apparent porosity was observed as shown in
porosity value (i.e. 44%). Porosity increased with increase in the Fig. 20. Similar observations were reported in previous studies
percentage of SBA and RHA, similar to the previous studies [26,29]. Brick specimens incorporating RHA showed lesser water
[3,27]. For instance, 5% increase in porosity was observed, when absorption compared to that of the specimens with SBA. For exam-
dosage of SBA in the mixture increased from 5% to 15% by weight, ple, brick specimen incorporating RHA showed water absorption
while an increase of 4% was observed, when dosage of RHA in the less than 21%. However, mixture incorporating SBA exhibited
mixture increased from 5% to 15% by weight. Porosity is related to water absorption up to 26% for 15% replacement of clay with
the water evaporation dehydroxylation reactions, carbonates SBA. This may be due to porous nature of SBA [69,70]. This trend
decomposition, and biomass residual combustion [52]. Generally, of water absorption was in consistent with the porosity values.
small pores in bricks are generated as a result of organic matter According to ASTM C62 (Standard specification for building
decomposition [62]. brick solid masonry units made from clay or shale) [71], water
Fluxing agents (Fe2O3, K2O, MgO, CaO and Na2O) play a key role absorption in bricks should not be more than 17% for severe
in generating or reducing the porosity. Higher amount of fluxing weathering resistance and 22% for moderate weathering resis-
agents increases the liquid phase by generating molten materials tance. Furthermore, various researchers have mentioned maxi-
during firing process of bricks to compress the interspaces mum water absorption limits for brick specimens ranging from
50 30
RHA
RHA
45 SBA
Clay 25 SBA
40
Clay
Apparent porosity (%)
35
20
30
25 15
20
10
15
10
5
5
0 0
5% 10% 15% 5% 10% 15%
Percentage replacement Percentage replacement
Fig. 18. Apparent Porosity results for bricks incorporating RHA and SBA. Fig. 19. Effect of RHA and SBA on water absorption of brick specimens.
S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941 37
[72]. Incorporating SBA and RHA into the burnt clay bricks gener-
40
ated micro-pores because of less amount of liquid phase and
organic waste content [73]. Quality of burnt brick and its durability
30 y = 0.93x + 20.14
is significantly affected by water suction properties. The limit for
R = 0.82
initial rate of absorption normally lies between 0.025 g/cm2/min
20 and 0.15 g/cm2/min [2,71]. For all the tested specimens, the initial
rate of absorption was higher than the limits with minimum value
10 SBA Bricks of 0.46 g/cm2/min for control specimen and maximum value of
RHA Bricks 0.81 g/cm2/min for RHA15. Therefore, it can concluded that bricks
0 should be wetted before laying for efficient bond between brick
16 19 22 25 28 and mortar.
Water absorption (%)
Fig. 20. Relationship between water absorption and apparent porosity of SBA and 5.3.4. Efflorescence
RHA waste bricks. Efflorescence is considered as an aesthetic problem due to
which a thin foggy white colored salt deposit on the surface of
the brick specimens [74]. Slight efflorescence (5% of the surface
20% to 30% [20,26,68]. Water absorption was approximately 21% area) was observed on the control specimens after 7 days. How-
and 18% for brick specimens incorporating 5% of SBA and RHA ever, no efflorescence was observed on brick specimens incorpo-
respectively (Fig. 19), so these can be used in moderate weather rating SBA and RHA. To check the efflorescence for a longer
regions effectively. Therefore, it can be concluded that the bricks period, specimens were also examined after 45 days (Fig. 22). After
incorporating lower contents of RHA and SBA (i.e. 5%) were within 45 days, minor efflorescence (10% of the surface area) was
the specified limits of water absorption leading to cost effective observed on the control specimens; however, no efflorescence
and durable construction. was observed on SBA and RHA brick specimens. Generally, calcium
oxide (CaO) plays a vital role in causing efflorescence [38]. Clay had
5.3.3. Initial rate of absorption approximately 9% of CaO; whereas, in RHA and SBA, it was only
Initial absorption rate can be defined as the absorbed water 3.65% and 2.65%, respectively. After replacing clay with RHA and
over the brick bed area of 30 square inches during one minute SBA, the quantity of CaO reduced, leading to improved efflores-
[34]. Brick and mortar bond is largely influenced by the water cence behavior. Furthermore, ferric oxide (Fe2O3) can also cause
absorption capacity of brick and water retaining power of mortar. efflorescence and less than 10% of Fe2O3 is normally recommended
If the brick absorbs excessive amount of water, the mortar faces [15]. In the clay, 5% Fe2O3 was present and therefore, slight efflo-
deficiency of its hydration water and hardens so fast that brick rescence was observed in control specimens. In RHA and SBA spec-
mortar bond in the next course cannot be developed properly. imens, the quantity of Fe2O3 was reduced further (i.e. 4.69% and
However, if initial absorption rate is too low (i.e. brick absorbs very 2.65% of Fe2O3 in RHA and SBA, respectively). Therefore, no efflo-
small amount of water), then mortar bed will tend to float the next rescence was observed in bricks incorporating RHA and SBA. Sim-
brick course. In both cases, poor bond will be achieved between ilar results were reported in previous studies [28,41]. Thus, bricks
bricks and mortar [24]. Therefore, to achieve good bond between incorporating RHA and SBA can lead to improved esthetic behavior
bricks and mortar, bricks with higher initial absorption should be of masonry construction.
wetted before laying.
Fig. 21 shows the initial rate of absorption for brick specimens
5.3.5. Freeze and thaw resistance
incorporating SBA and RHA. It was observed that the initial rate
Interaction between material and climatic factors plays a key
of absorption for brick specimens incorporating RHA and SBA
role in freeze-thaw durability of bricks [75]. During freeze and
was higher compared to that of bricks without RHA and SBA. For
0.9
Initial rate of absorption (g/min/cm)
RHA
0.8 SBA
0.7 Clay
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
5% 10% 15%
Percentage replacement
Fig. 21. Initial rate of absorption for tested brick specimens. Fig. 22. Efflorescence results on brick specimens after 45 days.
38 S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941
thaw cycles, water inside the pores freezes and expands. During specimens incorporating SBA, high porosity and water absorption
change from liquid to solid state, water expands by approximately was observed and consequently showed less resistance to freeze-
9% [76]. Because of the expansion, unfilled pores can be filled with thaw behavior.
the unfrozen liquid. Damage occurs/initiates if the pore volume is
less than the volume of water expanding [17]. 5.3.6. Sulfate resistance
Fig. 23 shows the weight loss due to freeze-thaw cycles for brick In bricks, different salts are present like sodium chloride and
specimens incorporating RHA and SBA. It was observed that the calcium sulfate [78]. However, all the salts do not cause damage
brick specimens without RHA and SBA showed weight loss less except sodium sulfate and sodium chloride [79]. Sodium sulfate
than 8.5%. Bricks incorporating 5% by clay weight of RHA showed is the most destructive and frequently present salt [80].
results similar to the control specimens. However, at higher Generally, it was observed that the compressive strength of
replacement level (i.e.10% and 15%), more weight loss was bricks decreased in the sulfate environment (Fig. 25). For instance,
observed. In case of bricks incorporating SBA, weight loss up to strength reduction in the control specimen without SBA and RHA
19% was observed after 50 cycles (Fig. 23). was approximately 24%; whereas, it ranged from 18 to 34% and
According to ASTM C67 [34], specimen can be considered as 19 to 35% for SBA and RHA brick specimens respectively, depend-
unacceptable, if it cracks during freeze-thaw cycles or weight loss ing on the percentage replacement of clay with SBA and RHA
increases by 3%. No cracks were observed in brick specimens after (Table 5). This reduction in compressive strength can be attributed
50 freeze-thaw cycles. All the tested brick specimens showed to the pressure generated by the crystallization of sulfate salts
weight loss less than 3% after 30 cycles of freezing and thawing inside the micro-pores leading to internal micro-cracking. Further-
(Fig. 24). However, weight loss greater than 3% was observed after more, it was observed that the brick specimens incorporating 5% of
50 freeze-thaw cycles. RHA and SBA were more sulfate resistant as compared to control
Generally, the resistance against freeze-thaw is governed by bricks because of their lesser reduction in compressive strength
porosity in the specimen [77]. Water penetrates during the thaw- after sulfate immersion.
ing period and produces expansion while freezing. Higher stresses Results also showed that weight gain in the control specimen
due to freeze and thaw were observed in high pore volume speci- was around 17%, whereas, it ranged from 15 to 34% and 11 to
mens leading to decrease the durability properties [38]. In brick 30% for SBA and RHA brick specimens, respectively. The weight
gain may be due to the partial filling of sulfate crystals within
the pores. Similar results regarding compressive strength reduc-
25 tion and weight gain were also reported in previous study [81].
Based on results, it can be concluded that replacement of clay in
Weight loss due to freeze and thaw (%)
RHA
bricks with SBA and RHA up to 5% improves the resistance against
SBA sulfate attack.
20
Clay
15
Reduction in Strength (%) Weight Gain (%)
40
10
35
30
5
25
0 20
5% 10% 15%
15
Percentage replacement
10
Fig. 23. Weight loss due to freeze-thaw after 50 cycles.
5
0
20 C RHA5 RHA10 RHA15 SBA5 SBA10 SBA15
C
RHA5 Fig. 25. Strength reduction and weight loss results due to sulfate attack in brick
RHA10 specimens.
15
RHA15
Mass loss (%)
SBA5
SBA10 Table 5
10 Durability properties of bricks incorporating RHA and SBA.
SBA15
Mixtures Sulfate test Freeze and thaw
Strength reduction Weight gain Weight loss
5 % % %
C 24.78 17.07 8.324
RHA5 19.32 30.02 8.631
RHA10 25.89 16.32 11.621
0 RHA15 35.05 11.48 12.788
0 10 20 30 40 50
SBA5 23.48 18.62 13.245
Freeze and thaw cycles SBA10 17.68 34.19 14.227
SBA15 34.40 15.50 19.737
Fig. 24. Effect of freeze-thaw cycles on weight loss of bricks.
S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941 39
For a long time, the quality of concrete has been evaluated suc-
cessfully using ultrasonic pulse velocity method [82]. Ultrasonic
pulse velocity test (UPV) is appropriate to detect flaws in addition
to predicting compressive strength [83]. For suitable selection of
the brick, the evaluation of its quality is very important. For eval-
uating the mechanical and durability properties of brick, ASTM
standard procedures involve destructive testing and are time con-
suming [83]. Therefore, non-destructive testing like ultrasonic
pulse velocity test can be used in order to reduce the time and cost
of evaluation. In this study, bricks were also evaluated using UPV.
Fig. 26 shows the results of UPV for brick specimens incorporating
RHA and SBA. It was found that UPV decreased for brick specimens
incorporating SBA and RHA. For instance, UPV values reduced from
(a) Clay brick specimen
1643 m/s to 1131 m/s and 1643 m/s to 1098 m/s for 10% SBA and
15% RHA brick specimens, respectively. Generally, pulse velocity
increases with an increase in compressive strength [84]. In all
the tested bricks, UPV results were in consistent with the compres-
sive strength values. According to previous studies [83], bricks may
be considered durable if UPV is greater than 3500 m/s and non-
durable for UPV less than 1000 m/s. For the value of UPV between
1000 and 3500 m/s, it was recommended to evaluate the durability
of bricks using UPV testing along with ASTM standard procedures
[83]. In this study, the UPV values for all the tested brick specimens
ranged from 1000 to 2000 m/s. Therefore, ASTM C67 standard pro-
cedures was adopted for evaluating the performance of bricks.
1600
Ultrasonic pulse velocity (m/s)
400
8. Summary and conclusions
200
In this study, the properties of clay bricks incorporating rice
0
5% 10% 15% husk ash (RHA) and sugarcane bagasse ash (SBA) were investi-
Percentage replacement gated. Utilization of RHA and SBA wastes as a raw material in man-
ufacturing of clay bricks can be an important way of recycling for
Fig. 26. Ultrasonic pulse velocity test for bricks incorporating RHA and SBA. final disposal of these abundant wastes, leading to conservation
40 S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941
of fertile soil. The RHA and SBA used in this study were low-cost [10] Pakistan Sugar Mills Association. Formulation of a national policy to encourage
power co-generation by sugar industry 2005. Available: <www.pakistan.gov.
waste materials, having high percentage of crystalline silica
pk/ministries/>.
(SiO2), which may behave as a filler material. [11] I. Ali, M. Basit, S. Hasan, G. Memon, M. Raza, S. Shah, Some studies on the
RHA and SBA can be potentially used in the production of utilization of bagasse as fuel in Pakistan, Fuel 68 (1989) 125127.
lighter clay bricks. It was observed that 15% replacement of clay [12] N. Akbar, A. Khawaja, Study on Effluents from Selected Sugar Mills in Pakistan:
Potential Environmental, Health, and Economic Consequences of an Excessive
with SBA and RHA wastes result in approximately 15% and 4% Pollution Load, Report by Sustainable Development Policy Institute, Islamabad,
lighter bricks respectively, compared to that bricks without RHA Pakistan, 2006.
and SBA. This decrease in the weight of bricks can reduce the over- [13] T. Akram, S. Memon, H. Obaid, Production of low cost self-compacting concrete
using bagasse ash, Constr. Build. Mater. 23 (2009) 703712.
all dead load and consequently economical structures can be [14] D. Eliche-Quesada, C. Martinez-Garcia, M. Martinez-Cartas, M. Cotes-
constructed. Palomino, L. Perez-Villarejo, N. Cruz-Perez, F. Corpas-Iglesias, The use of
Although, the compressive and flexural strengths decreased different forms of waste in the manufacture of ceramic bricks, Appl. Clay Sci.
52 (2011) 270276.
with increased proportions of RHA and SBA. However, brick speci- [15] P. Velasco, M. Ortiz, M. Giro, L. Velasco, Fired clay bricks manufactured by
mens incorporating 5% by clay weight of RHA and SBA showed adding wastes as sustainable construction material a review, Constr. Build.
compressive strength of 6.62 MPa and 7.18 MPa respectively, Mater. 63 (2014) 97107.
[16] G. Nirmala, G. Viruthagiri, A view of microstructure with technological
which satisfies the requirement of compressive strength specified behavior of waste incorporated ceramic bricks, Spectrochim. Acta Part A
by the Building Code of Pakistan for masonry construction. Simi- Mol. Biomol. Spectrosc. 135 (2015) 7680.
larly, all the tested bricks incorporating RHA and SBA satisfies [17] S. Chidiac, L. Federico, Effects of waste glass additions on the properties and
durability of fired clay brick, Can. J. Civ. Eng. 34 (2007) 14581466.
the minimum modulus of rupture criteria specified by ASTM C67
[18] C. Djangang, E. Kamseu, A. Elimbi, G. Lecomte, P. Blanchart, Net-shape clay
(i.e. >0.65 MPa). ceramics with glass waste additive, Mater. Sci. Appl. 5 (2014) 592602.
Furthermore, it was observed that the porosity increased with [19] D. Eliche-Quesada, A. Corpas-Iglesias, L. Perez-Villarejo, J. Iglesias-Godino,
increasing amount of RHA and SBA leading to increase in water Recycling of sawdust, spent earth from oil filtration, compost and marble
residues for brick manufacturing, Constr. Build. Mater. 34 (2012) 275
absorption. Bricks incorporating 5% of RHA and SBA showed water 284.
absorption less than approximately 18% and 21% respectively; [20] F. Saboya, G. Xavier, J. Alexandre, The use of the powder marble by-product to
therefore, can be used as moderate weather resistive bricks. On enhance the properties of brick ceramic, Constr. Build. Mater. 21 (2007) 1950
1960.
the other hand, these bricks with high porosity usually have good [21] R. Kumar, N. Hooda, An experimental study on properties of Fly ash bricks, Int.
insulation properties. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) also J. Res. Aeronaut. Mech. Eng. 2 (9) (2014) 5667.
showed the porous microstructure of the brick specimens after [22] A. Shakir, S. Naganathan, K. Mustapha, Properties of bricks made using fly ash,
quarry dust and billet scale, Constr. Build. Mater. 41 (2013) 131138.
incorporating SBA and RHA. All the tested bricks showed initial [23] A. Pawar, D. Garud, Engineering properties of clay bricks with use of fly ash,
rate of absorption higher than 0.15 g/min/cm2; therefore, they Int. J. Res. Eng. Technol. 3 (9) (2014) 7580.
should be submerged in water before their use in masonry [24] C. Christy, D. Tensing, Greener building material with fly ash, Asian J. Civ. Eng.
(Build. Housing) 12 (1) (2011) 87105.
construction. [25] N. Hamed, M. Zain, A. Sanaz, The Influence of nano-clays on compressive
Resistance against sulfate attack was improved by incorporat- strength of earth bricks as sustainable materials, Social Behav. Sci. 89 (2013)
ing 5% of RHA and SBA, which shows that these bricks may be used 862865.
[26] A. More, A. Tarade, A. Anant, Assessment of suitability of fly ash and rice husk
in sulfate environment for better performance. Moreover, it was
ash burnt clay bricks, Int. J. Sci. Res. Publ. 4 (7) (2014) 16.
observed that the resistance against efflorescence has been signif- [27] D. Tonnayopas, P. Tekasakul, S. Jaritgnam, Effects of rice husk ash on
icantly improved by incorporating SBA and RHA. Moreover, no characteristics of lightweight clay brick, Technology and Innovation for
brick specimens showed cracking during freeze-thaw cycles. How- Sustainable Development Conference, Thailand, 2008.
[28] M. Madurwar, S. Mandavgane, R. Ralegaonkar, Development of feasibility
ever, bricks showed weight loss greater than 3% after 50 cycles of analysis of bagasse ash bricks, J. Energy Eng. 141 (3) (2015), http://dx.doi.org/
freezing and thawing. It was found that UPV reduces as the quan- 10.1061/(ASCE) EY.1943-7897.0000200. CID: 04014022.
tity of SBA and RHA increases. UPV for all the tested bricks lies [29] K. Faria, R. Gurgel, J. Holanda, Recycling of sugarcane bagasse ash waste in the
production of clay bricks, J. Environ. Manage. 101 (2012) 712.
between 1000 and 2000 m/s. [30] S. Lima, H. Varum, A. Sales, V. Neto, Analysis of the mechanical properties of
Based on limited results and observations, it can be concluded compressed earth block masonry using the sugarcane bagasse ash, Constr.
that the incorporation of RHA and SBA up to 5% in burnt clay bricks Build. Mater. 35 (2012) 829837.
[31] ASTM D422, Standard Test Method for Particle-Size Analysis of Soils,
can be effectively used for massive scale brick production leading American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia PA, 1998.
to economical and sustainable construction. [32] ASTM D854, Standard Test Methods for Specific Gravity of Soil Solids by Water
Pycnometer, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia PA,
2002.
[33] ASTM D4318, Standard Test Method for Liquid Limit, Plastic Limit, and
References Plasticity Index of Soils, American Society for Testing and Materials,
Philadelphia PA, 2000.
[34] ASTM C67, Standard Test Methods for Sampling and Testing Brick and
[1] L. Zhang, Production of bricks from waste materials a review, Constr. Build.
Structural Clay Tile, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia
Mater. 47 (2013) 643655.
PA, 2003.
[2] L. Henry, B. Shankha, J. William, S. Melissa, Test on mercury vapour emission
[35] ASTM C20, Standard Test Methods for Apparent Porosity, Water Absorption,
from fly ash bricks, World of Coal Ash, Covington, Kentucky, USA, 2007.
Apparent Specific Gravity, and Bulk Density of Burned Refractory Brick and
[3] A. Kadir, N. Maasom, Recycling sugarcane bagasse waste into fired clay brick,
Shapes by Boiling Water, American Society for Testing and Materials,
Int. J. Zero Waste Gen. 1 (1) (2013) 2126.
Philadelphia PA, 2000.
[4] Bronzeoak Limited. Rice husk ash market study 2003. Available: <www.
[36] ASTM C1012, Standard Test Method for Length Change of Hydraulic-Cement
berr.gov.uk/files/file15138.pdf>.
Mortars Exposed to a Sulfate Solution, American Society for Testing and
[5] Agricultural Indicators-Federal Bureau of Statistics 2016. Available: <http://
Materials, Philadelphia PA, 2003.
www.statpak.gov.pk/depts/fbs/statistics/agri-indicators/agri_indicators.html>.
[37] ASTM C597, Standard Test Method for Pulse Velocity Through Concrete,
[6] D. Cook, R. Pama, S. Damer, The behaviour of concrete and cement paste
American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia PA, 1998.
containing rice husk ash, Conference on Hydraulic Cement Pastes, Cement and
[38] I. Netinger, M. Vracevic, J. Ranogajec, S. Vucetic, Evaluation of brick resistance
Concrete Association, London, 1976.
to freeze thaw cycles according to indirect procedures, Gradevinar 66 (3)
[7] H. Mahmud, B. Chia, N. Hamid, Rice husk ash - an alternative material in
(2014) 197209.
producing high strength concrete, International Conference on Engineering
[39] A.M. Musthafa, K. Janaki, G. Velraj, Microscopy, porosimetry and chemical
Materials, Ottawa, Canada, 1997.
analysis to estimate the firing temperature of some archaeological pottery
[8] A. Souza, R. Teixeira, A. Santos, F. Cosata, E. Longo, Reuse of sugarcane bagasse
shreds from India, Microchem. J. 95 (2) (2010) 311314.
ash (SCBA) to produce ceramic materials, J. Environ. Manage. 92 (2014) 2774
[40] G. Kirchhof, Plastic properties, in: L. Rattan (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Soil Science,
2780.
CRC Press, Columbus, Ohio, 2006, pp. 13111313.
[9] T. Akram, S. Memon, K. Iqbal, Utilization of bagasse ash as partial replacement
[41] B.E. Hegazy, H.A. Fouad, A.M. Hassanain, Incorporation of water sludge, silica
of cement, International Conference on Advances in Cement Based Materials
fume, and rice husk ash in brick making, Adv. Environ. Res. 1 (1) (2012) 8396.
and Applications in Civil Infrastructure ACBM-ACI, Lahore, Pakistan, 2007.
S.M.S. Kazmi et al. / Construction and Building Materials 120 (2016) 2941 41
[42] United Nations Centre for Human Settlements, A Compendium of Information [65] C.A. Garcia-Ubaque, G. Liliana, C.M. Juan, Quality study of ceramic bricks
on Selected Low Cost Building Materials, UN-HABITAT, Nairobi, 1986. manufacture with clay and ashes from the incineration of municipal solid
[43] M.D. Braja, Advance Soil Mechanics, third ed., Taylor & Francis, New York, wastes, Afinidad LXX 561 (2013) 6166.
2007. [66] G. Majkrzak, J. Watson, M. Bryant, K. Clayton, Effect of cenospheres on fly ash
[44] K. Elert, G. Cultrone, Durability of bricks used in the conservation of historic brick properties, World of Coal Ash, Covington, Kentucky, USA, 2007.
buildings-influence of composition and microstructure, J. Cult. Herit. 4 (2) [67] M. Sutcu, S. Akkurt, The use of recycled paper processing residues in making
(2003) 9199. porous brick with reduced thermal conductivity, Ceram. Int. 35 (2009) 2625
[45] C.H. Benson, J.M. Trast, Hydraulic conductivity of thirteen compacted clays, 2631.
Clays Clay Miner. 43 (6) (1995) 669681. [68] N. Phonphuak, Effects of additive on the physical and thermal conductivity of
[46] M.Y. Fattah, F.H. Rahil, K.Y.H. Al-Soudany, Improvement of clayey soil fired clay brick, J. Chem. Sci. Technol. 2 (2) (2013) 9599.
characteristics using rice husk ash, J. Civ. Eng. Urban. 3 (1) (2013) 1218. [69] M.V. Madurwar, A.M. Sachin, V.R. Rahul, Use of sugarcane bagasse ash as brick
[47] A. Murari, I. Singh, N. Agarwal, A. Kumar, Stabilization of local soil with material, Curr. Sci. 107 (6) (2014) 10441051.
bagasse ash, SSRG Int. J. Civ. Eng. (2015) 3739. [70] O.O. Amu, S.A. Ogunniyi, O.O. Oladeji, Geotechnical properties of lateritic soil
[48] I.O. Agbede, M. Joel, Effect of rice husk ash (RHA) on the properties of Ibaji stabilized with sugarcane straw ash, Am. J. Sci. Ind. Res. 2 (2) (2011) 323331.
burnt clay bricks, Am. J. Sci. Ind. Res. 2 (4) (2011) 674677. [71] ASTM C62, Standard Specification for Building Brick (Solid Masonry Units
[49] H. Chao-Lung, H. Trong-Phuoc, Investigation into the use of unground rice Made From Clay or Shale), American Society for Testing and Materials,
husk ash to produce eco-friendly construction bricks, Constr. Build. Mater. 93 Philadelphia PA, 2013.
(2015) 335341. [72] T. Banu, B. Muktadir, G. Fahmida, A. Kurny, Experimental studies on fly ash-
[50] A.S. Wagh, R.B. Poeppel, J.P. Singh, Open pore description of mechanical sand-lime bricks with gypsum addition, Am. J. Mater. Eng. Technol. 1 (3)
properties of ceramics, J. Mater. Sci. 26 (1991) 38623868. (2013) 3540.
[51] I. Yakub, J. Du, W.O. Soboyejo, Mechanical properties, modeling and design of [73] A.A. Kadir, A. Mohajerani, Effect of heating rate on gas emissions and
porous clay ceramics, Mater. Sci. Eng., A 558 (2012) 2129. properties of fired clay bricks and fired clay bricks incorporated with
[52] L. Aouba, C. Bories, M. Coutand, B. Perrin, H. Lemercier, Properties of fired clay cigarette butts, Appl. Clay Sci. (2014) 18. Article in press.
bricks with incorporated biomasses: cases of olive stone flour and wheat straw [74] A. Ukwatta, A. Mohajerani, N. Eshtiaghi, S. Setunge, Variation in physical and
residues, Constr. Build. Mater. 102 (2016) 713. mechanical properties of fired-clay bricks incorporating ETP biosolids, J. Clean.
[53] G. Gorhan, O. Simsek, Porous clay bricks manufactured with rice husks, Constr. Prod. (2016) (10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.01.094).
Build. Mater. 40 (2013) 390396. [75] S.R. Mallidi, Application of mercury intrusion porosimetry on clay bricks to
[54] I. Demir, An investigation on the production of construction brick with assess freeze-thaw durability, Constr. Build. Mater. 10 (1996) 461465.
processed waste tea, Build. Environ. 41 (2006) 12741278. [76] E.J. Seaverson, D.A. Brosnan, J.C. Frederic, J.P. Sanders, Predicting the freeze-
[55] I. Demir, Effect of organic residues addition on the technological properties of thaw durability of bricks based on residual expansion, in: D. Throop, R.E.
clay bricks, Waste Manage. 28 (2008) 622627. Klingner (Eds.), Masonry: Opportunities for the 21st Century, ASTM STP 1432,
[56] W.M. Carty, U. Senapati, Porcelain-raw materials, processing, phase evolution, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2003.
and mechanical behaviour, J. Am. Cer. Soc. 81 (1998) 118. [77] J.I. Davison, Linear expansion due to freezing and other properties of bricks, in:
[57] P.C. Varghese, Building Materials, second ed., PHI Learning Pvt. Ltd., Delhi, Second Canadian Masonry Symposium, Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada,
2015. 1980.
[58] National Engineering Services of Pakistan, Building Code of Pakistan Seismic [78] D. Young, Rising Damp and Salt Attack, Department of Environment and
Hazard Evaluation Studies, Ministry of Housing and Works, Government of Natural Resource, Adelaide, Australia, 1995.
Pakistan, Pakistan, 2007. [79] S. Zsembery, Manual 2: The Properties of Clay Masonry Units, Clay Brick and
[59] E.I. Ugwu, A. Dickson, Analysis of the effect of blending Nigeria pure clay with Paver Institute (CBPI), Australia, 2001.
rice husk: a case study of ekulu clay in Enugu state, Am. J. Mater. Eng. Technol. [80] L. Binda, C. Molina, Building materials durability: semi-markov approach, J.
2 (3) (2014) 3437. Mater. Civ. Eng. 2 (4) (1990) 223239.
[60] N. Bilgin, H.A. Yeprem, S. Arslan, A. Bilgin, E. Gunay, M. Marsoglu, Use of waste [81] N. Naik, B. Bahadure, C. Jejurkar, Strength and durability of Fly ash, cement and
marble powder in brick industry, Constr. Build. Mater. 29 (2012) 449457. gypsum bricks, Int. J. Comput. Eng. Res. 4 (5) (2014) 14.
[61] MY Chew, TP Ping, Staining of Facades, World Scientific Publishing Co., Pte. [82] T.R. Naik, V.M. Malhotra, The ultrasonic pulse velocity method, in: V.M.
Ltd., Singapore, 2003. Malhotra, N.J. Carino (Eds.), CRC Handbook on Nondestructive Testing of
[62] D. Eliche-Quesada, J. Leite-Costa, Use of bottom ash from olive pomace Concrete, CRC Press, London, 1991, pp. 169188.
combustion in the production of eco-friendly fired clay bricks, Waste Manage. [83] S.R. Koroth, P. Fazio, D. Feldman, Evaluation of clay brick durability using
48 (2016) 323333. ultrasonic pulse velocity, J. Arch. Eng. 4 (1998) 142147.
[63] V. Uz, H. Ozdag, The investigation of properties on plasticity, drying speed and [84] J.A. Bogas, M.G. Gomes, A. Gomes, Compressive strength evaluation of
physico-mechanical effects with the addition of into Eskisehir region roofing structural lightweight concrete by non-destructive ultrasonic pulse velocity
tile clay, Int. Boron Symp. Proc. Book 2 (2004) 147151. method, Ultrasonics 53 (5) (2013) 962972.
[64] E.C.B. Abi, Effect of borogypsum on brick properties, Constr. Build. Mater. 59
(2014) 195203.