Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ON HYDROGEN
Tokio Ohta
Yokohama National University, Japan
T. Nejat Veziroglu
Clean Energy Research Institute, University of Miami, USA
Keywords: Energy conservation law, entropy increasing law, fossil fuels, nuclear energy,
renewable energy, mechanical energy, potential energy, electric energy, photon energy,
chemical energy, energy resources, nuclear and solar hydrogen energy systems, hydrogen
production from water, electrolysis, photolysis, thermochemical water-splitting, solid polymer
electrolysis, photochemcial and photoelectrochemical water-splitting, fuel cells,
metalhydrides, heat pump, development of hydrogen energy system safety.
Contents
1. Energy Resources
2. Proposed Systems and the Elementary Technologies
3. Metal Hydrides and Hydrogen
4. Safety
Related Chapters
Glossary
Bibliography
Biographical Sketches
Summary
This theme level article introduces the background and outline of hydrogen energy systems
and the relevant elementary technologies. The most significant points are as follows:
Energy, energy resources, and energy carriers are defined. The merits and the demerits of
every energy resource are pointed out. It is emphasized that the combination of every
traditional system with hydrogen systems must be considered.
Hydrogen energy systems are introduced as an important option of future energy systems,
and the elementary technologies are reviewed. The most important fundamental is how to
produce hydrogen using renewable energy resources. However, it is too expensive to be
realized at the present stage.
Feasibilities for realizing the proposed application technologies are promising. Therefore, if
hydrogen fuel can be produced at low cost and safely distributed, our energy systems will
tend to move gradually towards the hydrogen energy systems.
Recently, environmental demands for clean fuel for driving vehicles have been promoting the
application of PEMFC to cars to a practical level. A new age for hydrogen energy is coming
now.
1. Energy Resources
1.1. Energy, Energy Resources, and Energy Carriers
The term "conversion system," which often appears in the contexts of energy essays, has two
meanings. The first is scientific and technological as in the example of: "mechanical energy
conversion to electric energy has high efficiency, whereas thermal energy can be converted to
mechanical energy with somewhat limited efficiency."
The second meaning is economical and political as in the example of "conversion of the main
systems of energy carriers from coal to oil have been going on since the 1960s." The term
"conversion system" used in the present case has the second connotation. Putting this in
concrete terms, "the present systems of energy carriers may be converted to advanced carrier
systemsthe hydrogen energy systemsin the twenty-first century."
Energy is defined as a capacity for motion, which is sometimes equivalent to work. Work is
scientifically defined by the physical quantity that is given to a body when it is moved a
distance by a force. The general meaning of energy includes every quantity that is equivalent
to work as defined above. There are two kinds of energy: dynamic and static. Examples of the
former are kinetic energy, electric current, photon, and sensible heat. The latter includes
potential energy, electro- (magneto) static potential energy, latent heat, and chemical cohesion.
We shall next define the concepts of energy source, resource (the primary energy), and energy
carrier (the secondary energy). Let us consider a domestic refrigerator. The cold generated by
a conventional refrigerator is due to the adiabatic expansion of a heat medium that has been
compressed with the use of a compressor and motor. Energy is provided to the latter in the
form of electricity from an electric power plant, operates the compressor. The electric power
plant gets the electric energy from a steam-power station where fuel oil is burnt. In this
system, the oil is called the energy resource and electricity is called the energy carrier. Strictly
speaking, the electricity provided to the refrigerator is called the energy source on the spot,
and the initial provider of energy, the fuel oil in this case, is called the energy resource.
An innovative refrigeration energy conversion system is possible if the energy resource is a
solar-hydrogen energy system (a system of hydrogen produced by solar energy), the energy
carrier is hydrogen, and a metal hydride refrigeration system replaces the mechanical
compressor system.
There are several kinds of energy carriers in present energy systems, for example, gasoline,
kerosene, electricity, city gas, LNG, and LPG. Some advanced energy carriers, making use of
hydrogen, laser beams, and microwave power transmission in space, may be realized in the
near future.
The basic principles of energy are noted in the following paragraphs. First, "energy is
conserved overall in the universe," where the term energy means the sum of conventional
energy and mass, because mass is equivalent to conventional energy, that is to say, a mass of
m kg can be converted to the conventional energy of mc2 kJ, where c is the velocity of light in
a vacuum. This equivalence is due to Einsteins special relativity. One important energy
resource today, nuclear energy, is the result of precisely this equivalence. There are only
negligible amounts of nuclear energy conversions globally, so that the energy conservation
law holds among the conventional energies, kinetic energy, potential energy, electric energy,
chemical energy, photon energy, and thermal energy.
Let us consider the case of lighting. If the energy resource is oil, the following conversion
systems are realized:
from oil (chemical energy) to burner (heat)
from heat to heat energy (mechanical energy + waste heat)
from mechanical energy to electric generator (electric energy +
waste energy)
from electric energy to light bulb (light energy + waste energy),
where all the waste energies are converted finally to waste heat.
Less than 8.5 percent of the oil energy is used in the illuminating energy of the fluorescent
lamp.
It should be noted that "energy is conserved," but the useful (available) energy decreases at
every step of energy conversion. Therefore, we obtain the second main principle: "available
energy decreases whenever it is converted." This principle is called the second law of
thermodynamics: the law of increasing entropy. This is why energy is not always ability of
work as indicated above; for example energy may be energy at ambient temperature.
Expressing the total energy (enthalpy), Gibbss free energy, entropy, and the absolute
temperature, by E, G, S, and T, respectively, we arrive at the well-known formula:
G = E TS (1)
Free energy is the energy which can be converted to mechanical energy directly rather than
via a heat engine; it has a higher value than heat energy, which is expressed by the term TS.
Equation (1) shows that the useful energy G decreases as entropy increases. The lost heat q
divided by T is the entropy increment in the energy conversion process.
It is understood that dynamic energy (kinetic energy and sensible heat) tends to generate
entropy much more easily than static energy (potential energy and latent heat). Therefore, for
energy storage, static energy systems become indispensable. Coal, oil, fuel gas, wood, and
uranium are the materials wherein cohesive potential energies are stored stably. These
materials are often called "energy media," and are equivalent to energy carriers (secondary
energy). One must be careful to use the term energy media, because all matter, even void
space, can be the energy propagation medium.
1.2. Fossil Fuels
1.2.1. Coal
The ancient remains of plants that were subjected to a dry distillation under geothermal heat
and great geological pressures several hundred thousand years ago, in due course became
coal, of which the major constituent is carbon. Coal has been one of the most important
energy resources since the Industrial Revolution in the eighteenth century. The kinds of coal
are anthracite, bituminous, sub-bituminous, and lignite; however only anthracite and
bituminous are used in practice, because they higher more energy density (about 32,400
kJ/kg) and are cleaner (with a sulfur component of about 3 percent) than the others. The world
has very large coal reserves in the world are very large, with a lifetime estimated at 230 years
in 1998. Moreover, these resources are fairly evenly distributed around the world. The major
problem with coal utilization is the air pollution caused by coal combustion, which gives off
more than three times the amount of sulfur oxide gas than is produced by oil combustion, and
more than twice the amount of carbon dioxide gas, which is the main cause of the greenhouse
effect. Other obvious economic disadvantages are that coal is not readily compatible with
automatic combustion systems or with a pipeline transportation system. However, it is highly
probable that the use of coal will be revived when oil resources are depleted in about sixty-
four years time.
It is obvious that the disadvantages of coal can be overcome if it can be liquefied or gasified.
The simplest way of getting liquefied coal is to mix oil with powdered coal. It is necessary to
add a surfactant (surface active agent) to avoid the precipitation of the coal powder. This
energy carrier is called COM (coal oil mixture), and is often used in order to save oil.
1.2.2. Coal and Hydrogen
The well-known and traditional coal fluidization technologies are coal liquefaction and coal
gasification, which involve the addition of hydrogen to coal under high pressure and at high
temperatures. If the added hydrogen can be supplied from the solar hydrogen energy system,
then the energy quantity of the liquefied coal fuel will be comparable to that of oil, and the
lifetime of the fuel will be greater than 230 years. This fuel could be one of the leading fuels
in the post petroleum era.
1.2.3. Oil
Accumulated masses of ancient remnants of plankton were subjected to dry distillation under
geothermal heat and high geological pressure about a billion years ago, resulting in the
production of oil (petroleum). Oil is a stable liquid energy carrier with high energy density.
For example, the energy density of kerosene is 40,850 kJ/kg, of burner oil 42,680 kJ/kg, and
heavy oil 45,740 kJ/kg. Oil is believed to be the most practical energy carrier in human
history. More than 30,000 oil-producing wells have been drilled so far. They produced, for
example, 3.82 billion kl of oil in 1979 (this is a remarkable record). The vast amounts of oil
produced lowers its price, and not only energy but everything in human civilization has
benefited from oil. Today is said to be the golden age of oil.
There are three major problems with oil energy: the depletion of reserves, uneven distribution
around the world, and pollution.
Depletion of Reserves: The most serious of these problems concern the world reserve of oil.
The ultimate reserve is roughly estimated to be about 2 T barrel, (T = 1012; 1 barrel = 0.159
kl). The production rates and global reserves of every energy resource are usually a function
of time elapsed. For example, oil data for 1985 indicate a production rate of 3.48 T l/Y and
total global reserves of 318 T l. Assuming a constant consumption rate, the total life of the
reserve can be easily estimated. If oil is consumed at a constant rate, then it will be exhausted
in ninety-one years from 1985. However, we know that the situation is not so simple. The
production rate is sensitive to the global economy and the demands of exporting and
importing countries. Since oil first began to play an important role in the economy, the
production rate has been steadily increasing (although it is relatively stable at present). On the
other hand, it is expected that the rate will decrease at some point, when about half of the
reserves have been consumed. In order to express this trend, and to study the resource life
cycle more exactly, we shall study a model.
M. K. Hubbert proposed a life-cycle model for oil in 1956. This is shown in Figure 1, where
the horizontal axis and vertical axes represent the oil production rate and the year,
respectively. The model is based on the following three assumptions:
The total initial oil reserve is 2 T barrel = 318 T l.
The production rate increases to a maximum and then stabilizes
for a short time before decreasing.
The behavior of the production rate is predicted by an extension
of empirical data and is assumed to be symmetrical with respect to
the time when the production rate becomes maximum.
Region TNM3 ( %)
Second, the quantity of CO2 produced from methane combustion is only about half of that
from oil for the equivalent generated calories. The production rate of methane gas was 1.7 T
Nm3 in 1985 (not much different than from today), so that a simple estimation of the lifetime
is 58.8 years as measured from 1985 (the estimated life time in 1998 was 62 years, because
more reserves had been discovered).
1.3. Nuclear Energy
1.3.1. General Survey
As mentioned in the beginning of this chapter, the principle of "mass equivalence of energy"
is expressed by:
E = mc2 (2)
Where c is the velocity of light in a vacuum. According to Equation (2) mass is converted to
energy as follows:
1 g = 57.03 T J (3)
The energy density of burner oil is 42680 J/g, so that the mass of 1 g is converted to generate
energy that is equivalent to 1.34 M t of the burner oil. This is the splendid result of modern
physics. Actually, the application of this principle to the nuclear fission of U235 has been put
into practical use since the World War II (1945). The first experiment for electric power
generation by nuclaer heat by the use of U235-fission was undertaken on 20th of December,
1951 at Argonne National Laboratory. In order to save oil fuels by the principle, one gram of
U235 generates about 2 B cal ", each industrially developed country has tried to install
nuclear plants for generation electric power. In 1982, there were 302 nuclear plants, of which
total output capacity of electric power was about 200 BW. The share of nuclear energy of
some conspicuous countries as of the end of 2005 is as follows:
Country GW
The world reserve of uranium (U235), which is more evenly distributed than oil, is a little more
than that of oil in calorie equivalence, and the lifetime is estimated to be roughly seventy
years from 1998. However, both the quantity and the lifetime are functions of technology,
which is quite versatile, and depend upon the acceptability of nuclear power among different
nations.
Another prospective source of nuclear energy is nuclear fusion. For example, the masses of
the proton and the neutron are 1.007825 amu and 1.008655 amu, respectively, (where amu is
defined as 1 amu x Avogadros number = 1 g) so that two of each nucleon comprises 4.03296
amu. On the other hand, the mass of helium 4 is only 4.00260 amu; the difference, 0.03036
amu, will be released from a nuclear reaction that combines two pairs of proton-neutron to
produce one helium 4 atom. This mass defect is equivalent to 28.2665 erg, so that we have:
1 g of deutron = 2728 T J
Until now, nuclear fusion technology has been applied only in the hydrogen bomb, not yet in
electric power generation. Large-scale research projects on power generation by nuclear
fusion are underway. The merits of nuclear energy (fission and fusion) will be covered in a
separate theme, and we shall point out some difficulties and a new idea, nuclear hydrogen
energy system, later in this article.
1.3.2. Difficulties of Nuclear Power Utilization
Most citizens are unwilling to accept the presence of a nuclear facility near where they live.
This is because they remember the tragic accidents of the nuclear plants in Three-Mile Island
(1979) and Chernobyl (1986). In order to overcome the citizens uneasiness, we must consider
every possible defect in nuclear power plant systems. The main challenges are:
The safety of the nuclear fuel-systems must be ensured. Every
process from the mining of uranium ore to the final disposal of
radioactive waste material could give rise to radioactivity. Even in
the countries where the use of nuclear energy is appreciably large,
complete cycle systems for nuclear fuels have not been established
yet.
The safety of the total systems of plants, subsystems, elemental
machines, and materials must be carefully investigated, and safety
software and training must be provided. However, it is very
difficult to predict the damage to materials due to fatigue or other
stresses caused by aging in the high temperature environment of
reactor cores.
Present technologies for nuclear plants have not yet matured. For
example, control of the fission process to meet fluctuating demands
for output power cannot be achieved yet. Thus the nuclear plant is
operated at a constant rate of output power, even when the demand
of power supply becomes extremely low. This is very different
from thermal plants, in which fossil fuels are burnt and the fuel
supply can be stopped if no output is needed. In other words, the
fuel economy of nuclear plants is worse than that of conventional
thermal plants(and also to the hydraulic power generation stations).
There must be strict adherence to the international protection
regulations for the safekeeping of plutonium, the reactant of the
nuclear reactions, which can be the raw material of atomic bomb.
Large amounts of plutonium are produced from nuclear plants.
Hence, it becomes an important task to use plutonium as a new
fuel. This new system is called a Pluthermal system. However,
Pluthermal systems need much stricter controls, because plutonium
is one of the most poisonous materials ever produced.
1.3.3. Nuclear-Hydrogen Energy Systems
The conventional nuclear-electric energy system is shown diagrammatically in Figure 3, and
an innovative nuclear-hydrogen energy system is proposed, as shown in Figure 4. A
comparison of the two systems is given below:
Figure 3. Conventional nuclear energy system
Country MW (%)
Hydro Power Energy: Rainfall is gathered in dams (mountain dams and river dams) and
converted to electric energy when the water flows down from them. It is estimated that the
total amount of the rainfall on the earths surface is, on average, 25.13 T t per year. If this
amount of water falls from a height of 1 km, then a kinetic energy of 1,062 P J is given to the
earths surface every year. The worlds reserve of hydropower for both types of power
generating dam systems are estimated to be about 2 TW, only about 10 to 15 percent of which
have yet been developed.
Wind Energy: Most of sunshine is absorbed in the atmosphere and is converted to heat . The
temperatures are not uniform, so that the air streams occur to give rise of wind blowing. Thus,
large part of solar energy falling the earth converted to wind energy. The total amount of the
wind energies on the earth's surface are huge, however it is distributed so widely that the
energy density is not large, except for hurricanes, typhoons, and tornados. The wind energy is
not always available (intermittent) and has moderate density.
According to fluid dynamics, the conversion of wind energy by windmills to useful energy is
propotional to the cube of wind speed and the squire of the wheel diameter of windmill.
Top 8 cumulative installed capacities as of the end of 2005 are (Global Wind Energy
Council):
Country MW (%)
The total amount of output wattages in the world was ca. 5,2000MW. This capacity is
equivalent to that of more than 80 conventional nuclear power plants, but the electric energy
generated per year is less than that of a few nuclear plants, because of the intermittent
operation of the wind power stations. However, it is obvious that wind power stations can
compete with nuclaer plants in countries where winds are strong.
Ocean Energy: This can be divided into four kinds: lunar tidal energy, wave energy, ocean
thermal energy, and ocean current energy.
Lunar tidal energy. The periodical movements of the ocean caused by the lunar gravitational
force are known as tides or tidal phenomena. The difference between the sea levels at ebb tide
and high tide varies from coast to coast. Although there are huge amounts of tide energy
resources, the only practical power station that has yet been built is the Rance power plant in
France, where the largest head is 13.5 m and the maximum difference comes every 6 hours
and 12 minutes. This station was installed in 1966, and generates 548 GWh of electric power
every year. There are many suitable sites in Canada, Northern Europe, and Northern Russia.
However, the investment cost is so high that no country has undertaken to construct a new
tidal power station.
Wave energy. The energy density of ocean waves can reach 1 MW/m of the coastline, and is
proportional to the square of the wave height. The merit of wave energy is that the density of
water is about 800 times greater than that of air. On the other hand, the intermittence and
strength variations are so large that the economical installation of power plants is very
difficult.
Ocean thermal energy. There are two kinds of ocean currents, one being hot on the ocean
surface, and the other cold in the deep sea. A heat medium gas such as ammonia and CFC
(chlorofluorocarbon) can be cooled to a liquid state by deep-seawater at a temperature of 510
C; the liquid is then vaporized by the surface seawaters at temperatures of 15 to 25 C. The
resulting vapor pressure is used to drive a gas turbine. This system is called OTEC (Ocean
Thermal Energy Conversion). OTEC has two drawbacks: one is that the thermal efficiency is
very small (as little as 7 percent); the other is that the amount of water that must be pumped is
huge.
It must be mentioned that there are difficulties in transmitting generated electrical power, so
that the power could be used to generate hydrogen gas by electrolysis, with storage at the
plant site. This system is called OTEC-Hydrogen System.
Ocean current energy. It would be necessary to build a huge installation to convert ocean
current to an energy carrier. There are currently no large-scale experiments, and we have
rather low scientific expectations of the practicability of this energy resource.
Geothermal Energy: Geothermal resources are abundant and estimated to be 400 E J. We
currently use a capacity of more than 5 G W, and some 100 electric power plants have been
installed. Suitable sites for geothermal power plants are along volcanic zones, where magma
comes up near the earths surface. These mountainous regions have fine landscapes and are
often designated as National Parks, so that development is almost impossible. It should be
noted that pipeline installation for hydrogen transport also faces many difficulties, so a
"geothermalhydrogen energy system" has many hurdles to overcome.
1.4.2. Feasibilities of Renewable EnergyHydrogen Systems
We have mentioned the possibilities of natural energyhydrogen systems. Although there exist
no large artificial hydrogen systems combining with natural energy, we know that
innumerable natural micro-solar hydrogen energy systems are working on the earths surface.
Photosynthesis has generated about 1220 E g of oxygen in total since green plants first
appeared on the earths surface. Photosynthesis has been absolutely fundamental to every
living thing on earth. We shall investigate whether any large artificial system similar to
photosynthesis is feasible.
1.4.2.1. Preliminary Requirements for Hydrogen Energy Systems: The conventional
assumption is that very large land areas must be progressively dedicated to the solar energy
system if, in fact, we are to make major use of solar energy. However, much of the land area
of the world is simply not suitable for solar energy power installations, because of climate,
terrain, and other land-use commitments. For the more promising regions, typically the semi-
tropical and tropical arid areas such as the great Sahara in Africa and the US Southwest
region, it is not yet clear that the land use will meet the approval of governments, local
citizens, conservationists, and environmentalists. These areas may to be given over to solar
cell stations if the conditions are satisfied.
The most significant point to be observed is quite fundamental. Most high-energy-use
industrialized countries have little or no sizable, favorably insulated region within their
national boundaries.
Another condition for hydrogen energy systems is that the system needs a great amount of
hydrogen, which can be used as an alternative to part of the secondary energies in the relevant
industries. Therefore, very large amounts of hydrogen would have to be produced by solar-
hydrogen energy systems, so that the scale of facility and the sunlit areas needed are large.
Each natural energy system has its appropriate site: the wind power system is suited to windy,
dry plateaus, dam power systems to rainy mountain valleys, geothermal plants to the
geothermal zones, solar-cell power stations to deserts. Where is the proper site for the
hydrogen energy system?
1.4.2.2. World Energy Network Systems: The Japanese government launched a major
project called WE-NET (World Energy Network) in 1993. This is based upon the idea of
importing electrolytic hydrogen generated in the countries blessed with abundant hydraulic
power such as Canada, Brazil, and China. Hydrogen could be transported in supertankers
carrying liquefied hydrogen or chemical materials such as methanol (CH4O), ammonia (NH3),
and cyclohexane (C6H12). These materials can be used not only as energy sources but also as
chemical agents. The relevant technologies have been extensively studied in the WE-NET
project.
A similar project named EURO-QUEBEC had already been set up, in 1989. This was a joint
project of Europe and the Canadian province of Quebec, but the key technologies are the
same as those for WE-NET.
1.4.2.3. Ocean Raft Systems for Hydrogen Energy: Characteristic "maximum insolation"
isopleths congregate for various months of the year in a Central Pacific region with an area of
about 0.5 M km2, centered on 13 W and 8 S. Large amounts of intense sunlight fall onto the
surface of this region, so very few living things exist because even plankton cannot survive;
that is to say, this area is like "an ocean desert."
A clear advantage of ocean basing is the ready availability of an unlimited low temperature
source of water for cooling purposes. If it is also possible to generate high temperatures by
concentrating solar radiation, electric power generation can be achieved.
The first Plan for an Ocean Raft System for Hydrogen Energy (PORSHE) had its origins in
this idea. Feasibility studies were undertaken by W. J. D. Escher and T. Ohta, and by T. Ohtas
group, beginning in 1974. The first requirement is to get high temperature heat sources using
solar collectors based on floating rafts; the heat can then be used to operate heat engine to
generate electric power. Thus one can generate electrolytic hydrogen. The principle is quite
simple, but there are many problems, such as stability of raft systems, control of solar
collectors, desalination of seawater, and transportation of hydrogen. The feasibility study has
been completed, and the conclusion is that the hydrogen fuel generated in this way is more
than twenty times as expensive as methane, if evaluated on a per unit energy basis.
The second version of the PORSHE project utilizes solar cells, and the structure is much
simpler than the first version. The hydrogen fuel produced by this raft system is between
twelve and eighteen times more expensive than methane. The cost is mainly due to the rafts
and solar cells, so that the price of solar-hydrogen could be competitive with methane fuel if
the rafts were multipurpose and the price of the solar cells could be reduced. In addition,
photo-bioproduction of hydrogen, which has been studied since 1942, could be one element of
PORSHE.
Figure 6. Enthalpy (total energy) vs. temperature curves for water splitting
Note: Total energy needed to split water is given by E = G0 + Q0 = Qc
Water vapor at such high temperatures is a mixture of hydrogen, oxygen, and hydroxide-
molecular gases. In addition it contains the atomic and ionic forms of these components. It is
possible, in principle, to get only hydrogen by separating hydrogen from the mixture with the
use of a palladium membrane. However, operations at such high temperatures are difficult to
achieve, and hence direct thermal decomposition of water will not be feasible.
Strictly speaking, the two oblique lines in Figure 6 are not straight lines, because the entropy
is weakly dependent on temperature. However, the analysis described above is a good
approximation.
2.2.3. Principle of Thermochemical Decomposition
It is readily understood from Figure 6 that less free energy is required at higher temperatures.
Therefore, two approaches are possible: electrolysis at high temperatures, or a combination of
chemical energy (a kind of free energy) with thermal energy. The latter is a new method of
water splitting and has been studied since 1970s.
Let us consider, for example, one set of three chemical equations:
(i) X + Y + H2O = XH2 + YO,
(ii) XH2 = X + H2, (8)
(iii) YO = Y + (1/2) O2,
Where X is an oxidizing agent and Y is a reducing agent. The key reaction is the first one in
Equation (8), which splits H2O into XH2 and YO. This means that chemical energy provides
most of the necessary free energy. The remaining two reactions can be advanced by thermal
energy. It is obvious, in the set of three reactions of Equation (8), that the catalysts X and Y are
not consumed, but H2O is split into H2 and O2. Hence this method is called "Thermo-chemical
Water Decomposition." Most of the concrete cycles are operated at temperature ranges lower
than 1,000 C, which is a much higher temperature than that of thermal plants for electric
power generation. The merit is that no electric energy is required. However, if one of the
reactions in Equation (8) is readily achieved by electrolysis (with less electric energy that that
used by direct electrolysis), then the hybrid cycle of thermo-chemical process with
electrolysis becomes more feasible.
Thermo-chemical decomposition technology is being challenged by high temperature
electrolysis combined with an electricity generator combined with high efficiency turbines
(the input temperature of modern gas turbine is as high as 1,300 C, so that the efficiency
becomes 40 percent or more). Therefore the efficiency of the thermo-chemical cycle needs to
be more than 40 percent, which seems to be difficult to attain.
2.2.4. Electrolysis
Electrolytic production of hydrogen and oxygen from water is a traditional technology that
has been known since the eighteenth century. Faradays law of electrolysis was discovered in
1933. We shall review the development of essential points for the traditional as well as
innovative water-electrolysis below.
2.2.4.1. Principle of Electrolysis and Traditional Technology: When two electrodes are
inserted into a glass vessel, containing a solution of potassium hydroxide (KOH) or dilute
sulfuric acid (H2SO4), hydrogen and oxygen evolve at the cathode and anode respectively,
when a direct electric current is applied.
Figure 7 shows a schematic diagram of this electrolyzer. The notations A, C, and S represent
the anode, cathode, and separation membrane respectively. In order to prevent the evolved
gases from mixing, a membrane is installed between A and C. When DC power is applied, the
reaction at the cathode is 2OH = H2O + 2e + (1/2) O2, and at the anode 2K+ + 2H2O + 2e- =
2KOH + H2 occurs, so that oxygen and hydrogen evolve.
Figure 7. Schematic diagram for water electrolysis
Note: A, C, and S are cathode, anode, and separating membrane, respectively.
The required electric energy is dG of Equation (6), which is expressed by:
G = qV = Ivt (9)
The notations q, V, I, and t represent electric charge, applied voltage, electric current density,
and the applied time of electric current density respectively. The relationship: q = It holds.
The applied voltage is of two parts:
V = Vo +V* (10)
Where Vo = 1.23 V is the theoretically estimated voltage, and V* is an excess value called
"over voltage," which depends on temperature, current density, and the type of electrodes.
Every possible step is taken to reduce V*. The values of over voltage in conventional
electrolyzers range from 1 to 0.5 V, so that the electrolytic voltage must be at least 2 V. The
energy efficiency is quite high, reaching more than 60 percent.
According to Equation (6), additional heat energy must be supplied to the electrolyzer in order
to save electric energy. Electrolysis at high temperature and under high pressure has been
investigated since the 1970s. The important point is that it is not necessary to provide
additional external thermal energy, because the Joulian heating of RI2, where R and I are the
resistance of the electrolyte and the current density respectively, increases the temperature of
the electrolysis. However, a heat insulating wrapping around the electrolyzer is necessary. In
addition the high temperatures cause high vapor pressures, so that a strong container structure
is also needed.
Assuming that a conventional electrolyzer has 60 percent efficiency at 80 C and 101.37 kPa
(=1 atmospheric pressure), an increase of the temperature to 100 C and of pressure to 2.075
MPa (= 20 atmospheric pressure) results in about 70 percent efficiency. Examples of the
former and the latter are the elctrolyzers of NORSK Hydro and of Julichs KFA, respectively.
2.2.4.2. Solid Polymer Electrolyte (SPE): The most advanced electrolyser in operation is
equipped with a solid polymer electrolyte, called "Nafion," which has been developed by Du
Pont. No liquid electrolyte such as KOH or H2SO4 is needed; the protons generated can pass
through the solid polymer electrolyte. Note that a hydroxide ion is the charge carrier in the
conventional electrolyte.
Figure 8 shows the polymer structure of Nafion. The proton, which is loosely bound to SO3-
anion, can move through the polymer.
4. Safety
Like any other fuel or energy carrier, hydrogen poses risks if not properly handled and
controlled. The risks of hydrogen, therefore, must be considered in relation to common fuels
such as gasoline, propane, or natural gas. The specific physical characteristics of hydrogen are
quite different from those common fuels. Some of these properties make hydrogen potentially
less hazardous, while others could theoretically make it more dangerous in certain situations.
Since hydrogen has the smallest molecule, it has a greater tendency to escape through small
openings than do other liquid or gaseous fuels. Given such properties of hydrogen as density,
viscosity, and diffusion coefficient in air, the propensity of hydrogen to leak through holes or
joints of low pressure fuel lines may be only 1.26 to 2.8 times faster than a natural gas leak
through the same hole (and not 3.8 times faster as is frequently assumed when only the
diffusion coefficients are taken into account). Experiments have indicated that most leaks
from residential natural gas lines are laminar. Since natural gas has over three times the
energy density per unit volume, a natural gas leak would result in more energy release than a
hydrogen leak.
For very large leaks from high-pressure storage tanks, the leak rate is limited by sonic
velocity. Due to its higher sonic velocity (1,308 m/s), hydrogen would initially escape much
faster than natural gas (the sonic velocity of natural gas is 449 m/s). Again, since natural gas
has more than three times the energy density than hydrogen, a natural gas leak will always
contain more energy.
Some high-strength steels are prone to hydrogen embrittlement. Prolonged exposure to
hydrogen, particularly at high temperatures and pressures, can cause these steels to lose
strength, eventually leading to failure. However, many other construction, tank, and pipe
materials are not affected in this way so, given the proper choice of materials, hydrogen
embrittlement should not contribute to hydrogen safety risks.
If leaks should occur for whatever reason, hydrogen will disperse much faster than any other
fuel, thus reducing the hazard level. Hydrogen is both more buoyant and more diffusive than
gasoline, propane, or natural gas. Table 1 compares some properties and leak rates for
hydrogen and natural gas.
Hydrogen Methane
Table 3 compares the safety of fuels. For each of toxic element and fire hazard characteristics,
it ranks the fuels from 1 to 3, 1 being the safest and 3 the least safe.
Toxicity of fuel 3 2 1
Toxicity of combustion
3 2 1
(Co, SOx, NOx, HC, PM)
Density 3 2 1
Diffusion coefficient 3 2 1
Specific heat 3 2 1
Ignition limit 1 2 3
Ignition energy 2 1 3
Ignition temperature 3 2 1
Flame temperature 3 1 2
Explosion energy 3 2 1
Flame emissivity 3 2 1
Totals 30 20 16
Safety factor 0.53 0.80 1.00
Related Chapters
Click Here To View The Related Chapters
Glossary
Biochemical hydrogen : Hydrogen production from biomass.
production
Biological hydrogen : Hydrogen production with use of living plants such as algae
production and bacteria.
Coal-oil mixture (COM) : Coal powder mixed with oil is an oil-saving fuel.
Direct water-splitting : Water vapor is split into hydrogen and oxygen at a very high
temperature (4,250 K).
FC : Fuel cell.
Hydrogen energy systems : Hydrogen made from water is a clean and undepletable fuel.
(HES) Hydrogen is also an indispensable chemical feedstock, so HES
will replace the petroleum energy system in the near future.
Hydrogen fueled vehicle : A vehicle whose engine can be driven by hydrogen fuel. The
engine can also be replaced by fuel cells.
Liquefied natural gas :Methane gas is liquefied at 111.8 K under the atmospheric
(LNG) pressure.
Liquefied petroleum gas : Ethane, propane, and n-butane are liquefied at 184.2 K, 273.1
(LPG) K, and 272.7 K, respectively.
Ocean-based hydrogen : Systems of hydrogen production from seawater using solar
production energy and/or the available onsite energy sources.
Ortho- and para- hydrogen : If the two directions of spin of the two component atoms in
hydrogen molecule are parallel, it is called ortho-hydrogen,
and if they are antiparallel, it is called para-hydrogen.
OTEC : Ocean thermal energy conversion.
Photo- chemical effect : The chemical reactions caused by photon irradiation.
(PCE)
Photo- electro-chemical : Some semiconductors irradiated by photons emit electrons
effect (PECE) and positive holes, and cause a chemical reaction.
Pluthermal (Plutonium use : The plutonium extracted from the used nuclear fuel (ash) can
in thermal neutron reactor) be applied to the fuel of high breeder reactor, and to the fuel of
thermal neutron reactor.
Proton exchange membrane : A film made of a solid polymer such as Nafion is proton
(PEM) conducting, and is applied, as an electrolyte, to a highly
efficient water electrolyzer and a fuel cell.
Solar hydrogen energy : Energy systems, of which the primary and secondary energies
systems are solar energy and hydrogen respectively.
Solid electrolyte fuel cell : Solid electrolyte such as ceramics of zirconium is applied to
(SOFC) fuel cell.
Solid polymer electrolysis : Fuel cell using PEM.
(SPE)
Therm-ochemical water : Both thermal and chemical energies are applied to split water.
splitting For example, if the chemical agents A and B are dissolved in
water, then AH2 and BO are produced. Water can be split by
decomposing these compounds by thermal energy, and no
agent is consumed.
List of Prefixes
(Prefixes are used in the text for the simplicity.)
Bibliography
Barbir, F.; Veziroglu, T. N.; Plass, H. J. Jr. 1990. Environmental Damage due to Fossil Fuels Use. International
Journal of Hydrogen Energy, Vol. 10, p. 739. [Environmental damage due to fossil fuel combustion is reviewed
and the introduction of hydrogen energy systems is recommended.]
Chambers, A.; Park, C.; Baker, T. K.; Rodriguez, N. M. 1998. Hydrogen Storage in Graphite Nanofibers. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry B, Vol. 102, No. 22, p. 4254, [This is one of the earliest papers that studied the
hydrogen storage capacity of graphite nanofibers.]
Gregory, D. 1973. The Hydrogen Economy. Scientific American, Vol. 228, No. 1, p. 13. [This is the first review
paper on the economical comparison of energy transports; the priority of energy transportation by hydrogen is
stressed.]
Ikeda, S. et al. (Tokyo Institute of Technology Group headed by K. Domen.) 1998. Mecano-Catalytic Overall
Water-Splitting, Chemical Communications. pp. 21856. [The discovery of mechano-catalytic water-splitting.]
Fujishima, A.; Honda, K. 1972. Electrochemical Photolysis of Water at a Semiconductor Electrode. Nature, Vol.
238, No. 37. [This is one of the earliest and most prominent reports of photolysis by TiO2 electrode.]
Fulkerson, W.; Judkins, R. J.; Sanghvi, M. K. 1990. Energy from Fossil Fuels. Scientific American, Vol. 263, No.
3, p. 129. [This is a fresh review of fossil fuels. Recent data are presented also.]
Hannond, A. L.; Metz, W. D.; Maugh II, T. H. 1973. Energy and Future. Washington, D.C., American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). 97 pp. [Future of every kind of energy sources is
discussed. Energy transmission-by-transmission lines, fuel cell, and hydrogen are compared with each other.
Energy conservation and energy policy are also discussed for the future.]
NASA Technical Memorandum. 1968. Hydrogen Safety Manual. Washington, D.C., NASA. 79 pp. [This is the
shrewdest condensed safety manual about hydrogen handling.]
Ohta, T. 1973. Clean Energy System by Hydrogen. Science (Japanese edition of Scientific American), Vol. 2, No.
5, p. 68. Tokyo, Nikkei. [This is the first review article in Japanese on Hydrogen energy systems. The prominent
character of this paper is an introduction of cooperative systems between electric power and hydrogen.]
. 1974. Hydrogen Energy Systems: How they Work. Chemical Economy and Engineering Review, Vol. 6,
No. 7, p. 7. [A historical trend toward hydrogen energy systems is pointed out first by this paper and an
experiment of hydrogen production by solar thermoelectric power is introduced.]
. 1988. Photochemical and Photo Electrochemical Hydrogen Production from Water. International Journal
of Hydrogen Energy, Vol. 13, No. 6, p. 333. [This is a report of most advanced technologies on photolysis, of
which fundamental principles are discussed in detail.]
. 1994. Energy Technology, Sources, Systems, and Frontier Conversions. Oxford, Pergamon. 235 pp.
[Energy systems and their elemental technologies are introduced and evaluated from the viewpoints of efficiency
and the global environment. Principles of effective conversion are explained with the use of reversible
thermodynamics and energy.]
. (ed.) 1979. Solar-hydrogen Energy Systems. Oxford, Pergamon. 264 pp. [This is a compilation of scientific
papers on hydrogen production methods, hydrogen storage by metal hydride systems, and ocean-based hydrogen
energy systems.]
SCIENCE, News Focus. 1998. The Next Oil Crisis Looms Large: And Perhaps Close. SCIENCE, Vol. 281, p.
1128. [An interesting analysis of the global energy situation that discusses demand prospects. The earliest
predicted peak in world oil production will be 2000.]
Veziroglu, T. N. 1987. Hydrogen Technology for Energy Needs of Human Settlements. International Journal of
Hydrogen Energy, Vol. 12, No. 2. [This is an essay about the relationship between human settlements and
hydrogen energy systems.]
. (ed.) 1975. Hydrogen Energy, Part A and B. New York, Plenum. 1369 pp. [These are Proceedings of
Hydrogen Economy Miami Energy Conference, 1976.]
Veziroglu, T. N. et al. (eds.) 197898. Hydrogen Energy Progress, Vols. I-XIII. Each set has about 2500 pp.
Miami, International Association of Hydrogen Energy. [Those are the Proceedings of the World Hydrogen
Energy Conferences, which have been held every two years since 1976.]
Biographical Sketches
Tokio Ohta was born in 1925 in Japan. He studied at the Department of Physics, University of Kyoto obtaining
a Ph.D. in Solid State Physics. He has taught at the University of Kyoto, Portland State University of Oregon,
USA, and the University of Tokyo, and served as Dean of the Faculty of Engineering, Yokohama National
University (19858), and as the President of Yokohama National University (198894) He has been appointed as
Superintendent of the International Network University since 1999, a member of the Staff Committee of Science
and Technology to the Prime Minister (197494), and of the Staff Committee of the Minister of International
Trade and Industry (19949). He has published some 160 papers and sixty books on solid state physics and
energy systems. He has been elected as Vice President of the International Association for Hydrogen Energy, and
is the Founding Past President of the Hydrogen Energy Systems Society of Japan.
T. Nejat Veziroglu was born in 1924 in Istanbul, Turkey. He received an A.C.G.I. Degree in Mechanical
Engineering from the City and Guilds Institute of London, a B.Sc. in Mechanical Engineering from the
University of London, a D.I.C. in Advanced Studies from Imperial College, London, and a Ph.D. in Heat
Transfer from the University of London. He has served as Chair of the Department of Mechanical Engineering,
University of Miami (19715), and as Associate Dean of Engineering Research, University of Miami (19759);
he is presently the Director of the Clean Energy Research Institute, the University Miami. Dr Veziroglu has
published some 250 scientific reports and papers, edited 170 volumes of proceedings, and is the Editor-in-Chief
of the monthly scientific journal, the International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. He is the Founding President of
the International Association for Hydrogen Energy.