Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction 2
Range of Brands 11
Future Application 20
Advertising 21
Conclusion 23
References 24
1
According to the Harvard Business Review (2009), women are responsible
for making the final decision in 94 percent of home furnishing purchases, 92 percent
purchasing (Brennan, 2015), and with statistics this strong, it is hard to ignore such
a large portion of the consumer market. This paper will examine current advertising
trends directed toward women, which methods have the best reactions from
women can be placed into at least one of two broad categories: (1), comparison and
competition ads, and (2), women empowerment ads, (kestam, Rosengren, &
Dahlen, 2017). Comparison and competition advertisements are ads that present a
specific ideal woman and aim to sell a product by making the consumer believe they
can achieve this ideal if they buy the product for sale (kestam, Rosengren, &
Dahlen, 2017). This style of advertising is built off the assumption that women
compare themselves to the ideal woman and strive to not only be the ideal
woman, but to be a better version of her and other women collectively. It drives
sales through comparison and competition of women. Conversely, the more recent
level with and relating to the consumer (kestam, Rosengren, & Dahlen, 2017).
2
Comparison and competition advertisements
The comparison and competition advertising method plays on the idea that women
view each other as competition and strive to be seen as the best. Author Jennifer
Holt believes that the creation of this ideal woman in advertising became most
popularized during the 1950s, after World War II (Holt, 2014). During this time,
advertisements directed to women were focused on being the ideal wife and
mother. In her work Not June Cleaver, Women and Gender in Postwar America,
Joanne Meyerowitz explains that advertisers can use comparison and competition to
making women feel connected to this icon--the icon of the 1950s being the
Women across the country soon began building their identities and lives
around this image of the ideal woman, who was created for them to emulate
societal gender norms of her time (Holt, 2014). Advertisers realized that by
3
associating their product with the ideal woman of the era, female consumers might
consider purchasing their product in order to further identify themselves with that
While societys idea of the perfect woman has changed over time, this
advertising strategy of social comparison has stayed largely the same, simply
changing the woman to fit the current fashion and aesthetic trends. An example of
this in modern day advertisement would be Pepsis launch of the Skinny Can and Get
the Skinny campaign, during 2011 Fashion Week. Our slim, attractive new can is
the perfect complement to todays most stylish looks, Chief Marketing Officer of
PepsiCo, Jill Beraud said. The campaign launch, meant to entice women by
connecting them to the skinny, modeling world, was met with backlash and
ultimately influenced the brand image negatively. The National Eating Disorders
Association and other similar groups quickly took action against Pepsi, saying that
The Pepsi Skinny Can campaign, which launched during the 2011 Fashion Week,
illustrates the comparison and competition method in a modern context, (Source: Zmuda,
2011).
4
Women Empowerment Advertisements
competition and social comparison, women tend to react more favorably to a self-
Panigirakis & Panopoulos, 2016). In other words, if this method is used, advertisers
should highlight how the product will help a woman achieve a personal goal and
avoid blatantly playing on how the product will make her seemingly better than
other women. This realization could be a factor in the recent trend towards self-
follows trends that society already has in place, so women have been categorized by
the time they are living in and not what they could be. Research shows that this way
these type of advertisements may have worked in the past, they stopped being as
effective because they ignore the constant fluidity of society. With the rise of
feminism, the theory of political, economic, and social equality of the sexes, females
have shifted their goals; the problem with this traditional way of advertising is that
5
women feel as if they couldnt measure up as an employee, spouse, mother, or even
just as a female, (kestam, Rosengren, & Dahlen, 2017). The stereotypical female
is more than one way of living your life as a woman, therefore increasing positive
embracing their differences and uniqueness, then women watching at home would
associate that brand with a positive sentiment. When females are presented with
very thin, traditional models, they directly compare that image to how they perceive
themselves.
Actress, Zendaya Coleman, reacts to Modeliste magazine for slimming her thighs and waist for their
November cover. The 19-year-old actress said the manipulation created unrealistic expectations for her
young fans, (Source: Instagram.com, 2015)
6
Femvertising presents a wide range of body sizes, skin pigments, and
lifestyles, which creates a more inclusive environment for women watching at home,
reading online, or reading in magazines. To test this theory and to give more insight
to marketers, researchers from the Stockholm School of Economics, tested these two
types of ads against one another in a series of three tests. They wanted to know if
generates lower levels of ad reactance than traditional advertising and that this, in
turn, leads to higher ad and brand attitudes (kestam, Rosengren, & Dahlen, 2017).
commercials to test their reactions and attitudes. The first advertisement was
created by a graphic designer for the case study specifically, so that there would be
7
Advertisement created by a graphic designer that depicted models that fit traditional
beauty standards to test the reactions and attitudes of women towards traditionally thin models
(Source: kestam, Rosengren, & Dahlen, 2017).
The second ad shows an advertisement with two models. One is photo-shopped and
traditionally thin, while the other is a curvier woman without any photoshop.
The above ads were created by a graphic designer, both selling the same brand of lingerie, however one
was photo-shopped with a thin, while the other was untouched and with a curvy model. Females in the
survey had a much higher positive sentiment to the untouched photo on the left,
(Source: kestam, Rosengren, & Dahlen, 2017).
8
In both cases, the ads with women that females felt they could relate more to
The table above shows that for every traditional ad, the reactance was higher
and the ad attitude was lower. The researchers concluded that the reactance the
women were having to these advertisements were negative, which made the
positive advertisement attitude lower and ultimately the brand perception more
traditional advertisement for Fiat, two automobile companies. The reactance to the
9
of 2.58 from the Fiat traditional advertisement in ad attitude--meaning the
reactance to the traditional advertisement was higher, but the positive attitude was
higher for the traditional advertisement. This has direct implications for automobile
advertisements and how women are depicted in them and what strategies are more
effective.
the past. They need to set the tone, adopt processes and create a working
environment for change and not wait until consumers are repulsed of them. Until
2012, only 3 percent of creative directors were women, (Winesett, 2017). This is a
purchases and upwards of 60 percent of social media sharing. The number of female
creative directors in advertising has risen to 11 percent since 2012. The 3 Percent
Movement was a campaign started to explain why women werent getting hired for
these positions and to prove what an asset a female creative director is (Winesett,
2017).
Men have been making critical decisions about advertising to women, but
thinking from a mans perspective. That is perhaps why advertisements were often
sexualizing women or emphasized gender stereotypes. Now that more women are
desires, aspirations, and goals are starting to be represented more effectively. This
10
practitioners in a new position, where they need to be aware of the societal role of
advertising, as well as its direct effects on consumers, (Dahln & Rosengren, 2016).
Brands that have already started femvertising are already seeing the positive
effects of this practice. During the 2015 Super Bowl, Proctor & Gambles Always, one
of the biggest producers of feminine care products, launched its Like A Girl
campaign. This was one of the first feminine hygiene products to run during the
Super Bowl. It highlighted the idea that saying run like a girl or fight like a girl
becomes an insult as people grow older. The ad then has young girls come out and
do things like a girl. They put all of their effort into the instructions and prove that
when you do anything like a girl it should not be perceived as an insult, but is
Above a young adult woman runs like a girl in the Always: This Like A Girl commercial
debuted during the 2015 Super Bowl (Source: Samakow, 2014).
targeting moms, and these moms were depicted as super moms, because they
11
bought the best game day food for their sons and husbands. The Like A Girl
advertisement was different, yet it ranked as the top digital campaign of the Super
Bowl by Adobe, and the ad was the most mentioned ad on social media platforms of
companies and many studies, especially those companies with a strong female
target market. Women want to see people in commercials that put less pressure on
them to conform to a specific type of woman. Several studies found that consumers
and that challenging them can, in fact, increase ad and brand attitudes, while also
The success of femvertising can be seen in contrasting the way the following
competition method, while American Eagles Aerie brand recently launched their
12
Above, is a Victorias Secret ad from their perfect body campaign, (Source: Time, 2014).
the ideal woman, but the company has received backlash and criticism for one of
their most recent campaigns: the Perfect Body campaign. The campaign was
composed of Victorias Secrets traditional models, the Angels, who are all of a
similar body type: tall, thin and beautiful. Built upon the ideal woman of the day,
Victoria Secret assumed their consumers would see the advertisements, associate
their product with their ideal woman and be inclined to buy the product. This
method is the same approach Joanne Meyerowitz discussed in her work Not June
Cleaver, Women and Gender in Postwar America, simply set in a current time. This
pull the campaign or change the name received over 27,000 signatures (Bahadur,
2014). Aside from the negative brand image this caused Victorias Secret, their
direct sales have been dropping since this campaign launched in 2014, and fell 7.2%
13
#AerieReal ad shown above, displaying an unphotoshopped model.
(Source: Huffington Post, 2014).
Shortly after the Perfect Body campaign launched, American Eagles Aerie
launched their Get Real, Think Real campaign, a photoshop-free campaign, built
around multiple women with different body types, which was met with praise from
critics (Dockterman, 2014). Aerie was praised for incorporating women of all sizes,
body types, and ethnicities in their ads, as compared to more traditional ads from
other brands that primarily showcased skinny, thin models, of similar appearance
with little diversity. Aerie wanted to step away from traditional appeals to women,
and instead wanted to have an ad campaign that felt more authentic with real
women today and the numbers that came in after Aeries monumental decision
14
Consumer response to the #AerieReal campaign. (Source: Twitter, 2016).
Another example of a product being sold using both broad categories seen in
advertising to women (and one category positively impacting women more than the
other) can be seen in body wash brands. Traditionally, when advertising body wash
to women, many companies sell an ideal experience to women, rather than simply
selling a product through brand image, core values, etc. This can be seen in brands
such as Caress, Suave, Dial, and Olay, who use the advertising tactic of portraying the
15
An ad used by Dove previous to the start of their Real Beauty campaign, using a thin white woman to
advertise their soap. (Source: Dove, 2010)
Campaign. The video was shared 3.74 million times in its first month, and had a
share ratio of 1 share for every 30 views, making it the most viral ad campaign of all
time, (Stampler, 2013). The ad focused less on the product for sale and more on
boosting their brand as a whole. By showcasing real women of all ethnicities, age,
shapes and sizes, the ad created a more authentic brand, rather than a typical ideal
body wash womens advertisement. While other body wash brands have not seen
negative results from their advertising, the positive viral reaction that followed
Doves campaign proved that the company made the right decision to use
favorably to women when selling products for women, they end up leaving money
16
on the table because they insist on still holding on to outdated perceptions and
strategies.
An ad from Doves Real Beauty campaign as shown above. (Source: Dove.com, 2017)
Food brands also illustrate a sharp contrast between the two methods of
advertising. Hardees and Carls Jr. have a long history of overly sexualized
advertisements, that portray beautiful white women seductively eating burgers. The
most famous of these ads feature Kate Upton, Paris Hilton and Kim Kardashian
After years of consumer backlash, and with other major brands stepping
toward women empowerment, Hardees and Carl's Jr. were forced to reinvent their
brand (Diaz, 2017). After a poll showed that the company's advertisements were
viewed as offensive and irritating, the company released their Food, not Boobs
campaign, which aims to poke fun at their old tactics (Diaz, 2017). While Hardees
and Carl's Jr. do not apologize for their previous overtly sexualized campaigns and
17
refute the claims that they hurt their brand, they said that in order to keep up with
other food sales, they needed to revamp their image, (Diaz, 2017).
Above is a Carls Jr. advertisement using overtly sexualized women to sell their burgers to men. (Source:
Daily Mail, 2015)
Carls Jr. pokes fun at previous sexy ads, as shown above in a screenshot from one of their
most recent commercials. (Source: AdWeek, 2017)
retail yogurt business sales had fallen 7 percent, and the company was looking for a
18
way rebuild sales (Wohl, 2017). After survey results stated that 75 percent of
mothers said they wished they would receive less judgment in advertising, Yoplait
their Youve Got This! Mom On campaign (Coffee, 2017). Yoplaits marketing
communications senior manager, Susan Pitt, commented on the issue of how moms
are portrayed in the media, stating, When we talk to moms, judgment, especially on
know it [social criticisms and judgment] makes a hard job even harder and we want
to surround moms with support and encouragement. The final results of this
campaign have not been released, as the fourth-quarter of 2017 is just coming to an
end. However, one can assume that because of the speed in which the video is
circulating on the internet, they are not likely to disappoint. The campaign has
earned over 5 million YouTube hits and positive feedback in the four months since it
Yoplait explains that the first rule of motherhood is that someones always judging, as seen
above in a screenshot from a commercial from their most recent ad campaign.
(Source: Huffington Post, 2017).
19
The examples above show the success in sales and brand image found in the
current trend of advertising from brands that target women. They are shifting away
from the comparison and competition method, and are now moving toward the
styles can be closely tied with the social movements and trends of the day.
Future Application
What an advertiser can gather from the positive reactions to and success of
critical to know what they are wanting to see. The push of feminist ideas over the
last decade has shaped many of the young female consumers to view women as
partners and friends, not competition. Women also come in all shapes, sizes, age and
ethnicities and they want to see that reflected in communication targeted to them.
Facebook, for example has over 1.5 billion active users, Twitter has 270 million, 60
million photos are uploaded to Instagram daily, and YouTube receives an average 4
billion views a day--which equals over 46,000 views per second (Wellons, 2014).
Each of these sites contain trend trackers, which feature the most popular
discussions at the moment. The growing popularity of social media has made it
When looking to the future, we suggest that advertisers learn from the
success of observing and using the trends of women empowerment and apply that
20
knowledge to advertising to people in general including men. While the
femvertising, men have not experienced the same phenomenon while being
advertised to.
Tide is one brand that took a leap out in this direction with their Dad-Mom
reflects the changing roles of men in the home. Although the campaign mostly
received praise, there were a few who wished it wouldnt have been named the
Dad-Mom campaign, as they believed it was still pushing that at the end of the day
The shift seen in advertising to women shows that advertisers are listening
more to female consumers, and are seeing positive results from the group that
men, in order to be able to better promote their goods, services and ideas to them.
advertisements
Hire people specifically to stay ahead of social and popular trends among all types
actresses, athletes, musicians, and politicians, since they have such a strong
Hire trending celebrities to endorse your brand before they infiltrate the
21
Dont demean men in advertisements in the same women have been treated in
former years.
Depict a wider variety of men and avoid using only muscular male
models.
Stop promoting the stereotype that men cannot have or show emotions.
It is okay to have a campaign for men that shows men exhibiting emotions
Diversify the career roles of men as well. Show some men with careers
different roles such as dancers, artists, fashion designers and stay at home
dads.
Ignoring some consumers can impact brands negatively as the ignored group feels
Dont shy away from speaking candidly about traditional gender roles in your
skinny or curvy.
22
Joan Didion, for example, became the face of French luxury fashion
Conclusion
success, but changing trends have led to women reacting more positively to
if they pay close attention to trends, push inclusivity and avoid traditional stigmas
competition advertisements, but the past shows that femvertising will likely not
work forever. No one approach of advertising will work forever due to the fluidity of
how women might react to ads that are directed toward them.
23
References
Berman, J. (2015, February 02). Why That 'Like A Girl' Super Bowl Ad Was So
Groundbreaking. Retrieved September 07, 2017, from
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/02/always-super-bowl-
ad_n_6598328.html
Brennan, B. (2015, January 21). Top 10 Things Everyone Should Know About Women
Consumers. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from
https://www.forbes.com/sites/bridgetbrennan/2015/01/21/top-10-things-everyone-
should-know-about-women-consumers/
Bologna, C. (2017, June 26). This Yoplait Ad Goes Out To Every Mom Who's Been
Judged. Retrieved September 21, 2017, from
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/this-yoplait-ad-goes-out-to-every-mom-
whos-been-judged_us_594dc22be4b02734df2a88d2
Cochran, A. (2011, November 17). Flap over Tide ads glorifying stay-at-home dad.
Retrieved September 11, 2017, from https://www.cbsnews.com/news/flap-over-
tide-ads-glorifying-stay-at-home-dad/
Dahln, M., & Rosengren, S. (2016). If advertising wont die, what will it
be? Toward a working denition of advertising. Journal of Advertising.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00913367.2016.1172387
Dahln, M., Rosengren, S., & Smit, E. (2014). Why the marketers view
matters as much as the message: Speaking down to the consumer speaks
badly to a brands image. Journal of Advertising Research, 54(3), 304312.
Diaz., A. (2017, March 29). It's 'Food, Not Boobs' in Carl's Jr. and Hardees' Brand
24
Refresh. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from http://adage.com/article/cmo-
strategy/food-boobs-carl-s-jr-hardees/308464/
Holt, Jennifer. (2014) The Ideal Woman. Retrieved September 07, 2017, from
https://www.csustan.edu/sites/default/files/honors/documents/journals/soundings/
Holt.pdf
Instagram post by Zendaya Oct 21, 2015 at 2:49am UTC. (n.d.). Retrieved September
21, 2017, from https://www.instagram.com/p/9FV2sdJmOk/
Jones, C., & Meyer, Z. (2017, March 29). Sexy Burger Girls? No longer at Carl's Jr. and
Hardee's. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/03/29/sexy-burger-girls-no-longer-
carls-jr-and-hardees/99595086/
Kyrousi, A., Panigyrakis, G., & Panopoulos, A. (2016). Attitudes toward ads portraying
women in decorative roles and female competition: An evolutionary psychology
perspective.International Journal of Advertising, 35(5), 771-798. doi:
10.1080/02650487.2016.1138576
Masaryk, H. (2014, November 04). When This Lingerie Brand Stopped Photoshopping
Models, Sales Shot Up 9%. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from
http://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/when-lingerie-brand-stopped-
photoshopping-models-sales-went-through-roof-161224/
Silverstein, M., & Sayre, K. (2009, September). The Female Economy. Retrieved
October
25
24, 2017, from https://hbr.org/2009/09/the-female-economy
P. (2017, March 30). Outgoing Carl's Jr. CEO Says Sexy Ads No Longer 'Have as Much
of an Impact'. Retrieved September 21, 2017, from
http://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/outgoing-carls-jr-ceo-says-sexy-
ads-
no-longer-have-as-much-of-an-impact/
P. (2017, June 20). Sassy Yoplait Campaign Encourages Moms to Ignore the Haters-and
Keep Breastfeeding in Public. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from
http://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/sassy-yoplait-campaign-encourages-
moms-to-ignore-the-haters-and-keep-breastfeeding-in-public/
Samakow, J. (2014, June 26). Proof That We're Not Born Thinking Doing Things 'Like A
Girl' Is A Bad Thing. Retrieved September 21, 2017, from http://
www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/06/26/like-a-girl-campaign_n_5533810.html
Stampler, L. (2013, May 22). How Dove's 'Real Beauty Sketches' Became The Most
Viral Video Ad Of All Time. Retrieved September 08, 2017, from
http://www.businessinsider.com/how-doves-real-beauty-sketches-became-the-
most-viral-ad-video-of-all-time-2013-5
Wellons, M. C. (2014, October 02). 11 key predictions on the future of social media.
Retrieved September 11, 2017, from https://www.cnbc.com/2014/10/02/11-
predictions-on-the-future-of-social-media.html#.
Zmuda., N. (2011, February 21). Skinny Pepsi Can Launch Is Heavy With Controversy.
Retrieved September 07, 2017, from http://adage.com/article/news/skinny-pepsi-
launch-heavy-controversy/148982/
26