Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Final Paper/Project
Melissa K. Campbell
Abstract
Pronunciation and accent are two things that can instantly give away a non-native Spanish
speaker. If pronunciation is such an important piece of being a good Spanish speaker, why isnt
there more emphasis on it in second language classes? This paper discusses the linguistic aspect
of Spanish pronunciation, in particular, the five vowel sounds but also looks at the incorporation
of pronunciation teaching in Spanish courses. There are several studies out there that suggest
that incorporating lessons on pronunciation can be extremely beneficial, even from the beginning
levels. Some of these studies suggest methods that can be used in Spanish courses and these will
be summarized. Finally, two instructional activities are included for the instruction of
Linguistic Introduction
Pronunciation and accent are two factors that can be used to easily identify non-native
(2012), factors such as geographical location, socio-economic group, ethnic group, gender, or
age can explain variations in the pronunciation of the same language or even variations within
one particular speaker. Phonetic rules and pronunciation change among different languages so
this paper will only examine Spanish phonetics and pronunciation, in particular, Spanish vowels.
First, an overview of the definition and rules of Spanish phonetics in regards to vowels will be
presented and then there will be a brief overview of the history of the vowels and the
Articulatory Phonetics
Stewart (2012) states that there are two main varieties of Spanish, Castilian and Latin
American, and the phonological system of Spanish is an idealization of the language. Spanish
exhibits a relatively simple system of vowels with only five in comparison to sixteen for French.
Before looking at the vowel system in particular, it is necessary to define articulatory phonetics.
According to Salcedo (2010), articulatory phonetics is a branch of linguistics that studies the
speech sound primarily depends on three variables. These variables include the activity of the
larynx in terms of a sound that is voiced or voiceless, the point of articulation which is the place
of maximum constriction in the mouth or pharynx, and the manner of articulation or the type of
modifying mechanism in the mouth or pharynx (Salcedo, 2010). The tongue and roof of the
mouth play an important role in pronunciation and they are each split into four portions. The
roof of the mouth is split into the alveolar, the palate, the velum and the uvula. The tongue is
Final Paper/Project 4
divided into four sections based on the point of contact for each. Those four sections are the
apex, the front, the back or dorsum and the root (Salcedo, 2010). In addition to the roof of the
mouth, tongue, and pharynx, the diaphragm and abdominal muscles also play a part in
pronunciation. All speech requires the inhalation and exhalation of air but vowels require a
What exactly is the difference between a vowel and a consonant? According to Pharies
(2008), a vowel is a sound produced when air passes, through the mouth or nose, without audible
obstruction. The audible obstruction excludes the vibration of the vocal chords. In contrast, a
consonant depends on the obstruction of air by another speech organ. The five vowels of
Spanish are described using the terms high/mid/low and front/central/back which refer to the
position of the tongue height and location. Pharies (2008) stated that front vowels are unrounded
while back vowels are rounded which refers to the lips. In articulatory phonetics, vowels are
named by their horizontal axis first and then the vertical. The vowel [i] is a high front vowel, [u]
is a high back vowel, [e] is a mid front vowel, [o] is a mid back vowel and [a] is a low central
vowel. Again, the distinction comes from the position of the tongue in the mouth.
When two vowels are found together in one syllable, they form a dipthong and when
three vowels are found together in one syllable, they form a tripthong. According to Salcedo
(2010), a dipthong must consist of a strong vowel and a weak vowel. The strong vowels include
[a], [e], and [o] while the weak vowels include [u] and [i]. There are thirteen possible dipthongs
in Spanish and they are ie, ia, io, iu, ui, ue, ua, uo, ei, ai, oi, eu, and au. While dipthongs occur
in one syllable of a word, they can also be formed across words when a vowel ends one word and
beings another such as in mi amigo. The words blend together to form the dipthong ia.
Final Paper/Project 5
Tripthongs are not common in Spanish but they do exist. Most tripthongs occur in the second
person plural form of vosotros. For example, leis and estudiis are tripthongs meaning you all
read and you all study. Another example of a tripthong that is not a second person plural form of
Phonological change
Many phonological changes go unnoticed because the ability to hear and describe
phonetic changes is difficult and requires training in articulatory phonetics (Pharies, 2008).
There were several phonological changes that took place in Spanish but because the focus of this
paper is vowels, those are the changes that will be described. Of the main phonological changes
that took place during the Romance Period, three of them included the vowels. Those changes
include vocalic mergers, dipthongization and the loss of intertonic vowels (Pharies, 2008).
In Latin, thirteen vocalic phonemes exist. They include /a e i o u/, short and long, and
three dipthongs (Pharies, 2008). Through the vocalic mergers, the thirteen phonemes are
reduced to seven in tonic or stressed position, to five in atonic or unstressed position (initial or
final), and to three in intertonic position (unstressed, neither initial nor final) (Pharies, 2008, p.
79). After this change, vowels were eventually distinguished by their quality which led to the
Another change that happened from Latin to Spanish is the dipthongization of the low
mid vowels [] and [] to [j] and [w] in Castilian (Pharies, 2008). Unlike French and Italian,
Castilian has dipthongization in open and closed syllables. Open syllables end in a vowel, while
closed syllables end in a consonant. According to Pharies (2008), some examples of these
changes include bene in Latin to bien in Spanish and bonu in Latin to bueno in Spanish.
Final Paper/Project 6
The final vocalic change Pharies (2008) looks at is the loss of intertonic vowels between
Latin and Spanish. Intertonic vowels occur between two stressed syllables. Examples of this
change between Latin and Spanish include populu to pueblo and tempornu to temprano.
Conclusion
Because the Spanish phonological system covers all of the consonants and vowels, the
topic is too broad to cover in one sitting. Even studying just the vowels takes time and effort but
is much easier to handle than looking at all phonemes. As was stated earlier, the Spanish
phonological system of vowels is fairly simple in that it only has five. This phenomenon makes
pronunciation much simpler than many other languages as the language is extremely phonetic.
By learning the pronunciation of the vowels first, an entire language is opened up.
Pedagogy Introduction
but many researchers agree that explicit phonetics instruction is indeed beneficial for students
(Counselman, 2015; Kissling, 2013; Lord, 2005; Lord, 2010). At the same time, even though
explicit instruction of phonetics does improve pronunciation, it is rare that students will acquire
language (L2) rarely acquire a native-like pronunciation even after being immersed in the L2
environment for quite some time. Even the most excellent students still have a noticeable
foreign accent after years of study. Though this sounds discouraging, learners can be trained to
produce new sounds and can acquire new phonological patterns (Lord, 2010). In the numerous
studies for second language pronunciation, there exists a wide variety of strategies used to teach
pronunciation. These strategies range from explicit instruction in class, perception-based and
focused repetition and study abroad (Counselman, 2015; Levis, 2007; Lord, 2005). Some of the
studies focus on Spanish pronunciation, and sometimes specifically on vowels, while others look
at the learning of pronunciation of other languages. To better understand the impact of these
studies on second language teaching, it is necessary to look into each of the studies.
Dipthongs
Part of Lords (2005) study included the teaching of Spanish dipthongs to non-native
speakers and included dipthongs within words and between words. The English language has
some dipthongs but not nearly as many as Spanish, especially between words. English speakers
tend to articulate each word individually while Spanish speakers blend entire phrases together.
The study included students of an undergraduate Spanish Phonetics course which included
textbook explanations, oral practice, transcription practice and other strategies as well. Students
engaged in activities designed to increase their phonological awareness and they also practiced
self-analysis. In order to assess the students improvement, they were given a pre-test and a
post-test. The study found that there were significant gains made in the production of dipthongs
both within words and between words. Thus, the explicit instruction of phonetics did aid
In a study by Counselman (2015), the focus was shifted to just the vowels /e, o/. Students
in an undergraduate conversation course were split into two groups but both groups did receive
recorded themselves reading various selections of a text throughout the course and the
perception-based group listened to the recordings. The perception-based group was asked to
Final Paper/Project 8
provide specific written feedback on any non-target-like articulations within the recording. They
had to provide specific feedback as to why the pronunciation was incorrect. Counselman (2015)
found that the perception-based group showed more improvement than the production-based
group. Ultimately, this showed the author that students should be aware of phonetic differences
Study Abroad
In another study by Lord (2010), instead of focusing on dipthongs, she focused on the
effects of classroom instruction and study abroad programs. Like her first study, this study
confirmed that explicit instruction on phonetics is beneficial for learners, even in introductory
courses. Lord (2010) stated that a learners first language somehow interferes with second
language phonology. Many students produce sounds that do not necessarily fit into their L1 or
L2 phonological systems, but this can be changed through practice. Even though the acquisition
of native-like pronunciation is rare, significant gains can be made through explicit instruction.
This study combined early classroom instruction and full immersion through a study abroad
program. All participants showed great improvements but those who had previously received
pronunciation.
Many of these studies focus on what teachers can do to improve students pronunciation,
but there is another option. In 2007, Levis looked into Computer-Assisted Pronunciation
Teaching (CAPT) and its usefulness in classroom instruction. Many second language teachers
lack adequate training to provide efficient and consistent pronunciation teaching. Because of the
Final Paper/Project 9
lack of training and time, many teachers emphasize other skills rather than pronunciation. CAPT
aims to improve accuracy which may conflict with some teachers viewpoints. Some teachers
focus on accuracy, while others prefer to focus on intelligibility to achieve communicative goals.
CAPT allows teachers to provide individualized instruction and offers additional instructional
time outside of class. Unlike classroom teachers, CAPT is tireless, consistent, provides variety
and meets varied individual needs in the teaching of pronunciation. Just like in the study by
Counselman (2015), this study found that improvements in perception can lead to improvements
in production.
Strategies
Educators know that there is not one correct way to teach, but rather, should use an
eclectic approach. Kissling (2013) stated that the use of a variety of instructional methods is
most beneficial in the teaching of pronunciation. The same goes for students and their learning.
Baker Smemoe & Haslma (2012) found that both good and poor learners of a second language
use the same learning strategies, but good learners apply those strategies more efficiently and
consistently. They defined learning strategies as the conscious actions that learners take to
improve their language learning (As cited in Baker Smemoe & Haslma, 2012, p. 436).
Although there is an extensive list of pronunciation learning strategies that students can employ,
Eckstein (2007) created a taxonomy to help consolidate the strategies into a four-step process (as
cited in Baker Smemoe & Haslma, 2012). The four stages include input and practice, feedback
and noticing, hypothesis forming and hypothesis testing. There are a wide variety of factors that
affect students pronunciation in a second language but this taxonomy provided a framework that
Conclusion
Final Paper/Project 10
Through all of the research, one thing remains consistent. There is substantial evidence
that explicit instruction in phonetics and pronunciation does in fact improve second language
instructional methods and learning strategies should be used to aid students in their quest for
native-like pronunciation. While it can be discouraging to find that most students will never
reach the level of a native speaker, there is evidence that significant improvements can be made.
Educators must take this research and implement explicit phonetics instruction, beginning at the
most basic level of second language learning. Phonetics instruction can include textbook
instruction and teaching students strategies to use on their own, students should see improvement
in their pronunciation.
Instructional Activity #1
Instructional objectives:
1. Students will be able to accurately pronounce the five Spanish vowels in a variety of
situations.
Final Paper/Project 11
2. Students will be able to correctly record Spanish words using the correct vowels during a
dictation exercise.
3. Students will be able to compare the Spanish vowel sounds to the English vowel sounds.
investigate, explain, and reflect on the nature of language through comparisons of the language
Integration: This activity should take place in the early days of a first semester Spanish class.
At this point in my class, students have learned some basic greetings, farewells and
introductions. Now they will start learning the Spanish alphabet and work on pronunciation,
Equipment & Materials (these can be found at the end of this document):
Teacher instructions:
* Note: The student instructions are written in English. If your students are at a place
where you can direct them in Spanish, please use the target language rather than English.
1. Tell students that they will be focusing on the 5 Spanish vowels today. Project the notes and
take the students through them. You can copy the notes and give them a handout if you
would like. Ask the students, What major differences do you hear or see between the
2. Model the pronunciation and have the students repeat after you. Do this several times until
students have a good grasp on the pronunciation. Emphasize the position of the lips and
A. Student instructions: Repeat each vowel after the teacher. Focus on each sound
3. Write this on the board: A, E, I, O, U el burro sabe ms que t. Practice the pronunciation
of each word while having the students repeat after you again. Point out that the vowels are
A. Student instructions: Repeat after the teacher again. Focus on each sound and the
4. Allow students to perform for you. Have the entire class say the phrase together, then you
can have the boys say it, the girls say it, or split the class by rows. Depending on your class,
you could turn this into a competition and choose the winning group based on their good
pronunciation.
A. Student instructions: With your assigned group, read the line from the board with your
best pronunciation.
5. Once the students have a good grasp on the pronunciation, complete a dictation activity.
Read the list of 10 words aloud while students write the words with correct spelling based on
the vowels they hear. You will want to repeat each word 2-3 times. At the end of the
dictation, project or write the words on the board so students can check their answers. You
could also have students come to the board to write their answers and make corrections as
A. Student instructions: Take out a sheet of scratch paper. Number your paper from one
through ten. I will read a list of ten words, repeating each two or three times. You must
listen to each word and write it on your paper. Focus on the vowels. At the end, we will
6. Now the students will do another oral speaking practice. Take students through each line of
7. After practicing each line several times, give students a partner. You can draw their names
from popsicle sticks in a cup, assign them ahead of time or use shoulder partners (the person
sitting next to them). Give each student a copy of the speaking exercise. Each student will
take turns reading each line of the pronunciation practice. While they are reading, their
partner should mark each place they hear an error or each place the student stumbles. The
student reading should redo each one that had an error to reinforce the correct pronunciation.
Then the students change roles and the recorder becomes the performer. You should
circulate during this activity to check on progress and to help the students make corrections
as needed. If the students are having a lot of trouble, bring them back together to review
A. Student instructions: Now you will be working with a partner to practice your
pronunciation. The first person will read each line of the exercise aloud. The other
person will mark each place where there was an error, or where the reader stumbled.
After the first person finishes reading each line, show them the places they had errors and
allow them to repeat and correct them. Then switch roles. The second student will read
Assessment:
1. Have students assess themselves by recording themselves reading each line. Most can do
this on their phones. They can do this for homework and then write a reflection or evaluation
of themselves in their journal the next day during their warm up.
2. Once students have had adequate practice, you can assess them individually. You could do
this one-on-one in class while the other students are working on a project or watching a
movie/video, or you could do it electronically. With Google Voice, you can set up a local
phone number with a voice mailbox. Students can call in and leave a message of them
reading each line. You can listen to it as many times as you need to complete the assessment
Follow-up activities:
1. Continue to review the pronunciation each day as a part of your warm up activities.
2. Once the students have mastered the initial speaking practice, change the order of the vowels
in each line. This forces them to pay closer attention to each line and each vowel.
3. Create a list of words of the day that use a variety of vowels. Have a different student
A like father
E like hey, but
shorter
Final Paper/Project 16
I like the e in be
O like Oh, but
shorter
U like the u in
flute
Read each word two to three times while students write them down. Check the answers
after.
1. garaje
2. corona
3. hormiga
4. cama
5. mueca
6. flecha
Final Paper/Project 17
7. vestido
8. rima
9. futuro
10. inteligente
Practicamos hablar!
ma me mi mo mu
pa pe pi po pu
sa se si so su
Final Paper/Project 18
la le li lo lu
ta te ti to tu
da de di do du
ra re ri ro ru
na ne ni no nu
fa fe fi fo fu
ba be bi bo bu
Instructional Activity #2
Instructional objectives:
Final Paper/Project 19
1. Students will be able to distinguish between an English vowel sound and a Spanish vowel
sound.
3. Students will be able to memorize and teach a tongue twister to their classmates.
investigate, explain, and reflect on the nature of language through comparisons of the language
Integration: This activity should take place in the early days of a first semester Spanish class.
At this point in my class, students have learned some basic greetings, farewells and
introductions. Now they are working on the Spanish alphabet and pronunciation, specifically the
five vowels. This activity should take place after youve already spent some time practicing the
vowels.
Equipment & Materials (these can be found at the end of this document):
3. List of tongue twisters (trabalenguas) - cut these out so each group can choose one
Teacher instructions:
* Note: The student instructions are written in English. If your students are at a place
where you can direct them in Spanish, please use the target language rather than English.
1. Tell the students that they will be focusing on the five Spanish vowels again today. Review
the pronunciation of each vowel. Write A, E, I, O, U on the board and have the students
repeat each letter after you. Read them in order, backwards and randomly.
Final Paper/Project 20
2. Play the following video from YouTube. Its short and silly but also encourages the students
3. Now the students will do a listening exercise. Hand out the exercise. Tell them that you will
read each English word. The students need to mark the words whose underlined vowel
matches the vowel sound of the Spanish letter. If the vowel sound does not match, do not
mark it. After reading each word twice, check the students answers. While going through
the answers, ask the students if the vowel sound matches any other Spanish vowel sound.
A. Student instructions: While I read the English words, listen and mark the words whose
underlined vowel sounds the same as the Spanish vowel should. I will say each word
twice.
4. Now, divide the class into groups no bigger than four. Give each group a tongue twister
from the list. Each group must practice their tongue twister and then will each take a turn
teaching their tongue twister to the rest of the class. Model this first for the students. Write
on the board. Practice each word individually and then practice the phrase in chunks
before putting it all together. When students are practicing you can have them say it as a
large group, or split them into smaller groups by gender or row. Its extremely important that
while the groups are practicing their tongue twister, that you circulate to each group and
check their progress. At this point you can correct any errors they may be making.
A. Student instructions: Choose one of the papers for your group. Practice reading the
tongue twister aloud with your group and in 7 minutes, you will be teaching your tongue
5. After their practice time, each group must come to the front of the room, write their tongue
participation grade. This holds them accountable for being good listeners and participants while
the other groups are teaching. 2) If you have a group who does an exceptional job teaching,
you could offer them a few points of extra credit or a prize (piece of candy, bookmark, pencil,
etc.)
Assessment:
1. Informally assess each group as you circulate through the room during their practice time.
3. Once students have had adequate practice, you can assess them individually. Students must
choose one tongue twister to master. They will practice it and then record it for you.
Students should record it on their phone and email you the recording. This way, they can
practice it and repeat it as many times as they want. If a student doesnt have the ability to
record it on their phone, they could leave you a message on Google Voice. You must set up
a local phone number through the application first. Then the student can call the number and
record their tongue twister as a voicemail. They can redo the recording as many times as
they want before they save it, just like they would do as a recording on their phone.
Follow-up activities:
2. Create a dictation activity in which students record words while you read them.
3. Create another listening exercise like the one you did today.
Final Paper/Project 22
4. Create a list of cognates. Model the pronunciation of the English word and the Spanish word
As your teacher reads each word, mark the words whose underlined vowel sounds like the
As your teacher reads each word, mark the words whose underlined vowel sounds like the
As your teacher reads each word, mark the words whose underlined vowel sounds like the
Trabalenguas: Cut these apart and have each group choose one to teach to the other students.
paquetes.
la agua.
9. Pepe Pecas pica papas con un pico. Con un pico pica papas
Pepe Pecas.
References
Baker Smemoe, W., & Haslam, N. (2013). The effect of language learning aptitude, strategy use
docview/1504417125?accountid=13946
search.proquest.com/docview/1718055798?accountid=13946
Final Paper/Project 26
1540-4781.2013.12029.x
login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/85669655?accountid=13946
Lord, G. (2005). (How) Can We Teach Foreign Language Pronunciation? On the Effects of a
Lord, G. (2010). The combined effects of immersion and instruction on second language
lynx.lib.usm.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/772290369?
accountid=13946
Pharies, David A.. A Brief History of the Spanish Language, edited by David A. Pharies,
ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/usmiss/detail.action?docID=408155.
search.proquest.com/docview/862776398?accountid=13946
Stewart, Miranda. The Spanish Language Today (1). London, US: Routledge, 2012. ProQuest