Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Renewable Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/renene
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Energy use in the built environment is globally recognized as a key issue for sustainable urban devel-
Received 11 June 2009 opment. In temperate-cold arid regions with a generous solar resource, such as those of western
Accepted 10 November 2009 Argentina, adequate design and technology can substantially reduce the energy demand for space and
Available online 16 December 2009
water heating in urban buildings. The solar potential of low-density residential urban areas in the city of
Mendozas Metropolitan Area (MMA), has been studied earlier in this research [1]. Several indicators of
Keywords:
the solar potential were elaborated. They provide necessary information when planning and designing
Sustainable urban development
new urban structures or refurbishing existing ones. However, a more direct indicator, relating the
Building morphology
Solar access available solar radiation during a heating season to the space volume to be heated, the Volumetric
Energy efciency Insolation Factor (VIF), seems to be of most practical use as far as contributing a helpful evaluation
indicator, to the above mentioned design processes. The present study follows the methodological steps
used in the former research, evaluating comparatively the results of a Graphic-Computational Model and
a Multiple Linear Regression Statistical Model. As in the earlier study, the good t of both models results
clearly point at the reliability of the statistical procedure and its valuable contribution of a simplied
calculation tool as its by-product.
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0960-1481/$ see front matter 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.renene.2009.11.027
1552 M. Arboit et al. / Renewable Energy 35 (2010) 15511558
4. Results
Table 1
Values of urban and building variables of the sample set.
Urban Building
obtaining maximum, minimum and close to mean values of solar Scenario 29 presents the lowest value of VIFnw (30 Mj/m3)
collection are also identied. among the urban city blocks analyzed; several reasons support this
VIF values for north facing walls (VIFnw) vary substantially from result:
a mean value of 75 Mj/m3 for a heating season, reaching down to
a minimum of 30 Mj/m3 and up to a maximum of 116 Mj/m3; in the It presents an unfavourable orientation (67 east from north)
present conguration of low-density urban city-blocks, a very high which masks the insolation of the longest longitudinal wall,
percentage of the total radiation impinging on north facing walls is which, combined with the homogeneous building morphology,
masked by neighbouring buildings (solid) and urban trees substantially reduce the access to solar energy.
(permeable) (Fig. 25). The VIFnw values represent a mean 23% of the The high building density expressed by high values of soil
total energy demand for space heating during a heating season occupation (SOF) and of total occupation (TOF), at 0.63 and
(324 Mj/m3) (Fig. 7). 1.05 m2/m3.
Fig. 3. Volumetric integration of the urban environment. Fig. 4. Insertion of urban trees.
1554 M. Arboit et al. / Renewable Energy 35 (2010) 15511558
Fig. 5. Graphic presentation of area calculations of openings and elevations of an analyzed building group.
The magnitude of urban trees (2nd) and the high plenitude related to the built volume (Scenario 1), the heterogeneous
levels (79%) in the city-block add one more reason for the low building morphology represents a disadvantage due to the
insolation. irregular roofs slopes that partially block the impinging radiation
on the surfaces, presents the lowest Form Factor of the sample
Scenario 8 presents the highest insolation values on north facing group (0.49) and a substantial increase of building density: SOF
walls, as a consequence of: 0.74 and TOF 0.97.
37
235
32
a hierarchical listing according to the explanatory variables
(energy indicators) incidence level, discarding all the non-signi-
41
245
31
cant variables; ii. It contributes a simple calculation tool from the
data obtained from the sample-set and the results of the two
38
245
30
models, graphical and statistical, by means of a simple equation.
With the aim of generalizing the results, departing from
30
253
29
a limited number of cases, the MLRSM allowed correlating the solar
potential values of the existing building stock, resulting from the
83
416
28
simulation performed with the graphic-computational model, to
a set of urban and building explanatory variables. Those correla-
85
418
27
square that symbolize the variance explained by the model and vi.
63
395
VARIABLE: VIFnw
39
381
6. Conclusions
100
245
18
Volumetric insolation factor (VIF) comparative values of the calculated indicator for north facing vertical surfaces and roofs.
available north facing walls and horizontal roofs are added (421 MJ/
m3) and the resulting data are compared to the energy demand for
80
388
15
than that on north facing walls (30%). For this reason, it is essential
to maximize the solar energy use for domestic water heating, space
100
394
11
tional and statistic, are close for the 32 cases of the sample (Fig. 5),
7
the data obtained of the sample set and the graphic and statistic
91
272
procedure.
3
VIFhr
Fig. 7. Calculated values of Volumetric Insolation Factors on north facing walls (VIFnw).
Table 5
Table 3
Analyzed variables by MLRSM for VIFhr.
Analyzed variables by MLRSM for VIFnw.
Coefcients Standard Error p-value
Coefcients Standard error p-value
VIFhr (Intercepcion) 114.5414 0.439 0.665
VIFnw (Intercepcion) 66.9313 1.477 0.15448
Shape of city-blocks (sha.) 6.6961 0.786 0.441
Shape of city-blocks (sha.) 4.0424 2.410 0.02520*
Orientation of city-blocks (orie.) 6.3749 0.517 0.611
Orientation of city-blocks (orie.) 3.8528 3.718 0.00127**
Street width (st. wi.) 3.4321 0.940 0.358
Street width (st. wi.) 2.1490 2.808 0.01053*
Trees Magnitude (magn.) 9.6944 0.302 0.766
Trees magnitude (magn.) 6.0683 2.063 0.05170
Trees Completion (comp.) 0.4842 0.310 0.760
Trees completion (comp.) 0.3056 1.024 0.31770
Trees permeability (perm.) 1.1301 0.199 0.845
Trees permeability (perm.) 0.7159 1.247 0.22623
Building Morphology (B. Morp.) 18.1269 5.894 9.15e06***
Building morphology (B. Morp.) 11.0255 5.153 4.18e05***
Form Factor (FF) 80.5018 5.303 3.44e05***
Form factor (FF) 47.5472 3.119 0.00519**
Soil Occupation Factors (SOF) 102.4719 6.881 1.10e06***
Soil occupation factors (SOF) 63.3348 0.241 0.81152
Total Occupation Factor (TOF) 39.8857 9.873 3.92e09***
Total occupation factor (TOF) 23.9571 1.985 0.06034
***Highly signicant.
*Signicant, **Very signicant, ***Highly signicant.
the number of study cases to the total number of low-density units, A later verication and validation of the model outside the main
allowing determining the available energy for the mentioned uses. sample-set was performed, obtaining an explained variance of
The tool derived from MLRSM attains a mean condence level of 87.90%.
99%. The results obtained yielded the following information:
i. Correlation between the indicators values and the maximum and
Table 4
Selected variables by MLRSM for VIFnw.
minimum found in the sample-set units. ii. Comparative analysis of
Table 7
Statistical model results.
Residual standard error DF degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared Adjusted R-squared F-statistic DF degrees of freedom p-value
VIFnw 10.89 24 0.849 0.805 19.28 724 2.028e08
VIFhr 16.07 26 0.9593 0.9531 153.3 426 <2.2e16
Table 8
Equations resulting from the statistical model.
exp34:319512 8:45980 sha 13:968244 orie: 5:675619 st:wi: 8:642648 magn: 50:619810 B:Morp: 141:079372 FF 35:746419 TOF
VIFnw
1 exp34:319512 8:45980 sha 13:968244 orie: 5:675619 st:wi: 8:642648 magn: 50:619810 B:Morp: 141:079372 FF 35:746419 TOF
exp92:57562 91:46402 B:Morp: 478:43853 FF 723:43454 SOF 373:47541 TOF
VIFhr
1 exp192:57562 91:46402 B:Morp: 478:43853 FF 723:43454 SOF 373:47541 TOF
the results of substituting the morphological variables statistically of the equations derived from the analysis to structurally similar
determined, grouping the most and the least favourable in each situations but quantitatively diverse, establishes a valuable
case. iii. City-blocks presenting extreme values on all signicant instrumental contribution to establishing urban and energy plan-
variables for the statistical model. iv. The impact of varying all ning criteria, basic to the elaboration of norms aimed at the
values of explanatory variables is being studied. consecution of a greater energetic and environmental sustainability
Finally, the calculation tool derived from the statistical analysis, share in urban planning towards the future.
allows simulating situations where the best and worst conditions of
the studied indicators are encountered, which are obtained by Acknowledgements
grouping the most and the least variables values of the most
signicant variables ordered by MLRSM. In this case, the maximum Most of the work presented in this paper was conducted within
and minimum resulting values are: 207.52 MJ/m3 and 5.13 MJ/m3 the research project: PICT No.13-12734/02, Calidad de Vida Urbana
for VIF north facing walls and 623.86 MJ/m3 and 2.46 MJ/m3 for VIF y Desarrollo Urbano Ambientalmente Sustentable en Ciudades
on horizontal roofs. The great amplitude of the ranges puts into Andinas de Clima Arido (Urban Life Quality and Sustainable Urban
evidence the important possibilities for improvement, which could Development in Andean Cities of Arid Climate), which is funded by
be obtained through the adequate design of urban and building the Agencia Nacional de Promocion Cientca y Tecnologica (ANP-
morphologies in the region. CyT), (National Agency for Scientic and Technological Promotion)
Considering again the methodological aspect of this study, it is and is coordinated by Carlos de Rosa at the Laboratorio de Ambiente
evident that the good t of the results obtained through the Humano y Vivienda (LAHV), (Laboratory for Human Environment
Graphic-Computational Model and the MLRSM is indicative of the and Housing), an R D unit of the Instituto de Ciencias Humanas,
statistical methods dependability for complex situations analysis, Sociales y Ambientales (INCIHUSA) (Institute for Human, Social and
such as those in the present research, where the consideration of Environmental Sciences), belonging to the Consejo Nacional de
a signicant number of variables (explanatory variables) must be Investigaciones Cientcas y Tecnicas (CONICET), (National Council
integrated, determining the relative weight of each variable on for Scientic and Technological Research) of Argentina.
a determined indicator (response variables). The possible extension
References
[1] Arboit M, Diblasi A, Fernandez Llano JC, de Rosa C. Assessing the solar
potential of low density urban environments in andean cities with desert
climates the case of the city of Mendoza, in Argentina. Renewable energy.
Elsevier Editorial System. Renewable Energy 2008;33(8). 09601481.
[2] Meadows DH, Randers J, Meadows DL. Limits to growth. The 30-year update.
USA: Chelsea Green Publishing Company; 2002.
[3] Dresner S. The principles of sustainability. London: Earthscan Publications
Ltd; 2002.
[4] Daly H. Beyond growth. Boston: Beacon Press; 1996.
[5] Jenks M, Burton E, Williams K. Compact cities and sustainability: an intro-
duction to the compact city. London: E &FN Spon; 1996.
[6] Owens S. Energy planning and urban form. London: Pion Ltd; 1986.
[7] Blowers A, editor. Planning for a sustainable environment. A report by the
town and country planning association. London: Earthscan Publications
Limited; 1993.
[8] Rogers R. Cities for a small planet. USA: Westview Press; 1997.
[9] Watson D, Labs K. Climatic design. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company; 1983.
[10] Givoni B. Climate considerations in building and urban design. USA: John
Wiley & Sons, Inc; 1998.
[11] Balcomb JD, Dennis Barley, Robert McFarland, Joseph Jr Perry, William Wray,
Scott Noll. Passive solar design handbook, vol. 3. New York: American Solar
Energy Society, Inc; 1983.
[12] Brager G, de Dear R. Thermal adaptation in the built environment: a literatura
review. Energy and Buildings 1998;27:8396.
[13] Brager G and de Dear R. Climate, comfort and natural ventilation: a new
adaptive comfort standard for ASHRAE standard 55. In: Proceedings of the
moving thermal comfort standards into the 21st century, Windsor, UK; 2001.
pp. 0118.
[14] Nicol F, Humphreys MA. Adaptive thermal comfort and sustainable thermal
Fig. 9. Compared values of VIFnw from the graphic-computational and statistical standards for buildings. Energy and Buildings 2002;34(6):56372.
model for the 32 sample-set units. [15] Codigo Urbano y de Edicacion. Mendoza: Municipalidad de Mendoza; 2000.
1558 M. Arboit et al. / Renewable Energy 35 (2010) 15511558
[16] Kristl Z, Krainer A. Energy evaluation of the urban structure and dimen- [19] Robinson D. Urban morphology and indicators of radiation availability. Solar
sioning of building site using the ISO-shadow method. Solar Energy Energy 2006.
2001;70(1):2334. [20] Faraday JA. Linear models with R. London, New York: Chapaman & HLL/
[17] Capeluto IG, Shaviv E. On the use of solar volume for determining the urban CRC; 2005.
fabric. Solar Energy 2001;70(3):27580. [21] Venables WN, et al. Modern applied statistics with S-Plus. Berlin, New York
[18] Ratti C, Raydam D, Steemers K. Building form and environmental perfor- Heidelberg, London: Springer-Verlag; 2002.
mance: archetypes, analysis and an arid climate. Energy and Buildings [22] Box GRP, Cox DR. An analysis of transformations. Journal of the Royal Statis-
2003;35:4959. tical Society, Series B 1964;26:21152.