Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
WITH
PE E R RE VIE WE D BY
Introduction
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
1
What if you could know your future?
If you could know how you would live? How you might die? Where your path
might take you in the meantime?
Would you try to fight fate? Or just let yourself be swept along in the river leading
to the inevitable waterfall of your ending?
In 2017 BC, we might have said: The gods. The stars. The spirits. The same
powerful, invisible forces that create gusts of wind also push and pull us along
the path of our lives.
PRECISION NUTRITION
that one?
Are we really just like our fathers, or mothers, or second cousins? Are we
|
2
Genetics seems like the answer to
everything.
But is it really?
For instance:
What can we really know about ourselves using the tools of genetic
analysis, and what is just speculation, wishing, and guessing?
How much certainty can we really gain from knowing about our genome?
Are genetic data a for sure, a maybe, or I dunno?
Whats important and whats not? Our genome has a lot of information. Is
all of it relevant to our concerns and interests? Do we really care about the
genetic program that makes the third eyelash from the left?
Even if we can get all the knowledge we want, what should we do with it?
PRECISION NUTRITION
In 2003, the National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) in the U.S.
announced that they had successfully completed the Human Genome Project.
Now we had a map of ourselves in theory, the code for all human beings on
earth.
And not just humans. Some form of this code is in every living thing on Earth.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
You are directly related to the bacteria that live on your body.
Yes, you might have diverged a billion years ago, and dont really plan to get
together at Thanksgiving, but theres a part of your genome, and a part of their
genome, that came from the same place.
This system of coding created all life from mushrooms, to dolphins, to oak
trees, to us.
|
3
In 2007, commercial genetic testing services like 23andMe became available to
the general public. Anyone could have their genome scanned and read.
Since then, the field of genetic testing and genetic counseling has exploded. Its
now cheaper, faster, and easier to get your genome examined.
What key opens which lock? What exact set of genetic instructions makes
us a sprinter, or have heart disease, or have a funny-looking baby toe?
What does our future hold? What diseases might we get (or avoid)? How
might we grow and develop?
How can we be better? Is there something in our genetic code that could
tell us what to eat or how to exercise? What supplements to take to function
better, or lower our risk of disease?
Some advocates of genetic testing suggest that they also have the Big Answers.
What if we could have a complete plan for everything that we wanted to do,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
change, or improve?
4
Take a back seat, horoscopes! See ya, metabolic typing! Later, random trial
and error!
Theres a new plan in town! And its gonna tell me everything I would ever
need to know about what to do!
Well
You can see in the window. You get a glimpse of what the store contains.
If you squint and peer inside, and crane your neck, you can see tiny bits and
pieces. An action figure here. A train set there.
You know the toy store is full of cool, fun, interesting stuff to play with.
Yet.
Thats where were at with understanding genetics and how we might use it.
PRECISION NUTRITION
store.
Well tell you:
5
Which tests might be better, more accurate, or more useful than others.
What you might do with any information you get from genetic testing.
Why we think this is exciting and cool, and full of potential but not quite
a magic solution to anything yet.
As in, heres what we can realistically do or know right now. Heres what tools
are available right now.
This is cool.
Imagine the possibilities. Its not magic yet but it could be.
This is complex.
PRECISION NUTRITION
There are no simple answers. There are no hacks, appealing as that idea might
be.
We may all look like ignorant idiots in 200 years as knowledge and research
progresses. (Well, assuming we havent lit the planet on fire by then.)
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
So bear in mind that any scientific claims are subject to critical scrutiny and
revision. And try not to write a check that your science cant cash.
|
6
Were personally invested.
Science is not individual geniuses laboring alone in a lab.
Throughout this book, well look at what they discovered in their genes, and
what that might mean for them and you.
At times, with their consent, we share some personal details about them. (Youll
find out, for instance, whos a sugar monster, whos the most Neanderthal, and
who had an ancestry surprise.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
For example, we need to understand such things as:
7
So, well look at the topic from different viewpoints to give you depth and
context.
Its also about psychology and behavior. How we think about ourselves. What
were prepared to do to potentially change our fate.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Getting started with the fundamentals
CHAPTER 2
The basics of genetics
|
key ideas youll need to understand genetic testing and its implications. We
recommend you review this chapter if youre new to the topic, or if youre looking
for a refresher. If youre already running your own biotech lab, feel free to skip it.
|
8
Genetic testing
CHAPTER 3
Introduction to genetic testing
What does genetic testing involve? What are some of the general issues to think
about while deciding if genetic testing is right for you? This chapter includes
a description of the basic process of a genetic test from sample collection to
discovering youre related to Marie Antoinette.
CHAPTER 4
Specific genetic testing services
What should you think about when considering particular genetic testing
services? Which services did we choose, and why?
CHAPTER 6
What we found: Metabolism
In this chapter, we explore some of the basic metabolic processes, such as how
we regulate our blood sugar or thyroid output, and how they might be affected
by genetic factors.
CHAPTER 7
What we found: Body weight and body comp
PRECISION NUTRITION
In this chapter, we look at some genetic factors related to energy balance, what
makes our bodies naturally bigger or smaller, and how much lean or fat mass
were likely to have.
CHAPTER 8
What we found: Food preferences
|
Why we might dislike some foods, like others, and really like others? In this
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
chapter, well cover how genetics influence how we experience the taste of food,
and how they shape our food preferences.
CHAPTER 9
What we found: Food intolerances
Why dont some foods dont agree with you? And how much of that may be due
to genetic factors?
|
9
CHAPTER 10
What we found: Nutrient absorption and use
In this chapter, well examine some genetic factors that may affect how our
bodies digest, absorb, and use particular nutrients.
CHAPTER 11
What we found: Exercise and muscle performance
In this chapter, we look at some of the genetic factors that may shape our
response to (and recovery from) exercise and training, as well as whether we
have a natural athletic type.
References
CHAPTER 13
Glossary of terms
Confused by codons? Mystified by mutations? No worries, weve got a handy
glossary for all the technical terms weve used in this book.
CHAPTER 14
References
PRECISION NUTRITION
Dont believe us? Want to learn more? Enjoy the hundreds of references weve
collected.
CHAPTER 15
Contributors and acknowledgments
Science is a collaborative endeavor. We are most grateful to all of those who
|
10
We suggest you peek at Chapter 2, even though its kinda heavy-duty. Or check
the glossary in Chapter 13 as needed if you dont recognize a sciencey term.
Think about what you want to get out of this book, and read it accordingly.
Look for the What this means for you sections in each chapter.
There, well give you some practical tips for how to think about a given topic,
and/or what to do next.
We have some answers for you, but not as many as youd probably hoped.
(As the physicist Richard Feynman quipped, Give me questions I cant answer,
not answers I cant question.)
Get curious.
Lets go!
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 2
The basics of genetics
|
11
CHAPTER 2
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
12
Warning (or challenge): This chapter is heavy.
Its meant to be a reference for the rest of the book. So theres a lot of
information here.
You dont need to understand or remember it all in order to grasp the key
ideas about genetic testing.
Feel free to skim this chapter, skip it, come back to it whatever you like.
If youve already done your graduate work in genetics, go ahead and breeze on
past.
DNA is a biological molecule that holds the code for making all living things.
Fun factoid!
Some viruses do not have DNA. Some (like parvovirus) have single-stranded DNA
genomes. Some (such as pox viruses) have double-stranded DNA genomes. Most have
PRECISION NUTRITION
RNA genomes of some kind.
Genes are regions of DNA that encode instructions for making specific proteins. |
If genes have names, we put those in italics, like this: FGF21. This helps us tell
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
For instance:
The FGF21 gene (written in italics) codes for a protein called fibroblast
growth factor 21, or FGF21 (no italics).
The TAS2R38 gene codes for a protein called taste receptor 2 member 38,
or TAS2R38.
|
13
Variants of the same genes are known as alleles or polymorphisms.
For instance, the type of earwax you have is controlled by a single gene known
as ABCC11 (which is also involved, by the way, in how your sweat smells). If you
have one of two variants / alleles of the gene, youll have wet earwax; if you have
a third variant / allele, your earwax will be dry.
Genetics is the study of genes, how they work, and how particular traits (such as
eye color) are passed from parent to offspring (known as heredity).
The expression of one gene can influence two or more apparently unrelated
processes or traits. Well see examples of this as we look at specific topics, such
as metabolism. This is known as pleiotropy (from the ancient Greek pleion, or
more, and tropos, or way). A variant in one gene may have a wide variety of
effects.
Our genotype is our genetic code; our phenotype is how that code is actually
expressed as it interacts with our environment. The same genotype can have
different phenotypes. Different environments (for instance, our activity, our
nutrition, our exposure to toxins, and so forth) can change our observable traits
(for instance, our physiology or behavior).
PRECISION NUTRITION
14
A genome is the complete set of an organisms genetic information. For
instance, the Human Genome Project studied the complete genetic code of
human beings.
Generally, this doesnt mean we are testing the entire genome. As youll learn,
the amount of information in an entire human genome is very, very, very
large. We have about 22,000 genes, and about 3 billion base pairs, or pairs
of nucleotides in our strings of DNA. (Well learn more about nucleotides in a
moment.)
Noncoding regions are parts of the genetic code that dont code for any
proteins, and theyre known as introns. Regions that do code for proteins are
known as exons. (Well look more at coding and noncoding regions in
Chapter 4, and at splicing more below.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
15
CNVs can also affect how genes work. For instance, having multiple copies of
genes that make the enzyme amylase would increase our ability to break down
the carbohydrate amylose. This variation may reflect our ancestral history (for
instance, whether we come from an ethnic group that has traditionally eaten a
high-starch diet) and may be linked to our body weight.
Figure 2.3: Duplication of genetic material Figure 2.4: Copy number variation (CNV)
PRECISION NUTRITION
Genes are information.
In the real world, we have to figure out a few things when we use information:
How to transmit and transport information how to get it from one place
|
16
Genes and their associated products and processes do all of this inside our
bodies.
In eukaryotic cells (cells that have a nucleus and distinct organelles bound by a
membrane), DNA is organized in chromosomes in the nucleus.
When cells divide, chromosomes are duplicated and DNA is replicated. Once
cells finish dividing, each cell ends up with its own full set of chromosomes.
Eukaryotes store most of their DNA inside the cell nucleus and some of their
DNA in organelles, such as mitochondria or chloroplasts (in plants).
Genetically speaking, we are about half of each of our parents. But were not
exactly like our mom and dad. And were not a precise 50% of each. Were more
like a 49-point-something percentage of each, plus some random mutations that
sneaked in along the way.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Why does this happen?
How does this work?
And what does this all mean for your own genetic code?
To explain, lets start with a concept that may be a little new to you.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Biology is computation.
Most people tend to think of biology as just a bunch of wet squishy bits. We can
also think about biology as being a type of computation.
|
17
Imagine you were trying to program a computer
to do something.
Computers are pretty literal and only do what you tell them, so you want to
make sure youre absolutely clear. Youll also need to give the computer some
structured parameters for making decisions, otherwise they get confused.
IF todays date is July 18, THEN send Dr. John Berardi a birthday card.
IF you are on a desert island AND today is July 18, THEN spell out Happy
birthday using driftwood instead.
Each receptor is picky and will only bind to particular things (these specific
PRECISION NUTRITION
molecules are known as ligands), much like a key will only work in one or two
locks.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
18
A receptor acts like a switch. If something binds to a receptor, it triggers another
event, like turning a switch to on.
So, we might imagine a situation where the instructions for our cells biological
computer read something like this:
IF gene A is active, AND gene B is available, THEN make the protein from
gene B.
Note that this looks very much like the computer code you might have learned in
school:
Computers are still pretty dumb, relative to biology. But at a basic level, the
concept is similar.
Computers can start from scratch. In theory, you could make a computer that
thinks in a way that nothing ever has before, using components that nobody has
ever used before.
Biological systems dont work that way. They can only use the structures and
systems that they have inherited (along with, of course, any new mutations,
which are only a small part of a much bigger whole).
Sometimes this can mean that biological systems are pretty efficient perhaps
evolution has done a lot of work to tidy things up.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Sometimes the systems can be less efficient. They have a lot of what computer
folks call cruft: clutter and redundant junk such as old equipment or code that
just hangs around and either does nothing or actively gums up the works.
Biology is engineering.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
19
(Thats water.)
Or these?
(Those are caffeine and nicotine, maybe two of your best friends in high school,
you rebel you.)
You might have been left with the impression that molecules are basically flat
polygons and lines.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
20
And nicotine looks more like this:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
21
Youll notice that proteins are not abstract line drawings, but actual, tangible
objects.
If you blew that nicotine protein up larger, it would look like this:
The physical shape of the protein would affect how you could interact with it.
The same thing happens at the molecular level.
For instance, lets imagine you have a protein that is shaped like this:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
22
Then it finds a protein that looks like this:
What happens? Well, if conditions are right, maybe the hook-shaped part of the
first protein will latch on to the eye-shaped part of the other protein, and stick
there.
PRECISION NUTRITION
The physical shapes of the proteins determine how they will interact.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
23
then the J-hook has nothing to connect to.
Yes, eager student in the front with your hand up, the answer is
deoxyribonucleic acid.
Aside from making you the team champ on trivia night, knowing the full name of
DNA actually gives you clues to how DNA is constructed, and to understanding
how genetics work. Part of that has to do with the physical shape of DNA and
how the molecules fit together.
A DNA strand is shaped like a ladder, and made out of two pieces:
A deoxyribose backbone, i.e., the side rails of the DNA ladder. (RNA has
ribose here.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
24
Ribose is a simple sugar. De-oxy means without oxygen, so deoxyribose
means a ribose without an oxygen.
OK, now imagine that the deoxyribose sugar is actually a sort-of T-shaped piece
of Lego, like this:
And imagine a few of those Legos stacked on top of each other, like this:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
25
Then imagine youre getting real fancy with the Lego stack and you want to
indicate which way is up.
PRECISION NUTRITION
And, since you have 3 pokey-outy parts to which other things can attach, you
have also built the foundation for a specific unit of DNA, known as a codon (aka
a sequence of three nucleotides).
Except imagine that in DNA computation, we arent making numbers, but amino
acids.
Remember our Lego structure? We can stick bases, or nucleotides, on it. Bases
are the building blocks of nucleic acids.
|
26
Figure 2.20: Nucleotides on deoxyribose backbone
Adenine (A)
Cytosine (C)
Guanine (G)
PRECISION NUTRITION
Thymine (T)
RNA (which well look at in a moment) gives us one more: uracil (U), which
replaces thymine.
Two of these nucleotides (A and G) are long. Two (C and T) are short. So in a full
strand of DNA, short nucleotides pair with long ones, and vice versa.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Like this:
|
27
Figure 2.21: Short and long pairs of nucleotides
You can imagine that each nucleotide is like a box that could have 1 of 4 possible
nucleic acids inside: either an A, a C, a G, or a T, like this:
DNA codes for proteins. Proteins are made of amino acids. So part of that DNA
has to code for a particular amino acid.
28
We cant do that with 1 box (which can only contain 1 of 4 possible nucleotides),
or 2 boxes (which only gives us 16 possible combinations). We need 3 boxes.
We need many different 3-nucleotide codons to code for these 20 amino acids.
Keeping it all straight can be confusing. Thus, researchers have come up with
some ways to help us catalogue and interpret codons, such as a codon wheel
(shown below).
A codon wheel helps us in both directions: We can decipher what amino acid a
particular codon codes for, and what codons code for a particular amino acid.
To read the wheel, start from the center. Thats one nucleotide. Then go
outwards and pick another one of 4. And outwards again, picking another one
of 4.
For instance:
You might also notice that some amino acids can be made with more than one
combo of nucleotides.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
29
Well learn more about codons and how they work later.
To go back to the idea that genes store information, this shape is not an
accident. Because of the way the DNA Lego blocks fit together:
PRECISION NUTRITION
The molecule is extremely stable.
Our bodies can copy it with extremely high fidelity and accuracy.
This is good, because as well see later, we dont really want things falling apart
or getting sloppy with reproduction. Errors happen all the time, but we have
biological proofreaders to catch them.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
30
Our bodies will always read DNA in a certain order (hence the arrow): from
5-prime to 3-prime, and they go in opposite directions. One side will be 5 to 3
reading up, the other 5 to 3 reading down.
Imagine you were making a machine to read DNA. Its a simple computer, so it
can only read one nucleotide at a time. It scans down the strand, reading from 5
to 3, reading the name of each nucleotide, like this:
PRECISION NUTRITION
ACTTGAATGCATC
and so on. It has to go in that direction, because the reverse (reading from 3 to
5) would be something totally different:
CTACGTAAGTTCA
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
DNA isnt just floating around randomly in cells. Its packed into highly organized
structures, tightly wrapped around proteins called histones like beads on a
string, so that massive amounts of this genetic material can fit into the tiny space
of a cells nucleus.
|
31
Unspooled, your strands of DNA would be around two meters long. Yet they fit
into a space about 1/1,000 of a millimeter.
This protein-DNA complex is called chromatin, and its what makes up your
bodys chromosomes.
The ways that our chromosomes are folded in space, and physically organized in
the nucleus, can significantly affect how genes are expressed.
For example:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Factors known as enhancers, which increase the likelihood that a given
gene will be transcribed, need to be located close to the regions that they
act on.
This research revealed that the way in which chromatin was packed into the
nucleus its shape as well as its density affected its function.
|
32
What this means is that:
Thus, genetic expression is not just about the genes we have, but where
theyre located.
Commercial genetic testing can tell us about some of the specific genes we
have, but not about how theyre physically organized. We cant know the
geography of our genes from a commercial test, which means we cant know
a lot about how those genes may be expressed.
The mRNA is read and each mRNA codon is translated to one amino acid.
Amino acids are linked together to make proteins.
Thus, again, DNAs job is to store the information to make proteins.
PRECISION NUTRITION
All of molecular biology revolves around this basic principle.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
33
Figure 2.27: DNA to RNA to protein
PRECISION NUTRITION
2 | Protein synthesis (translation): Making proteins, using the instructions from
RNA.
RNA has many jobs, and there are several types, which well look at in a
moment.
For now, well focus on messenger RNA (mRNA). mRNA is the intermediary
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
For a long time, scientists thought that one gene coded for one mRNA, that then
coded for one protein: If you had 100 genes, youd make 100 different mRNAs,
and then 100 different proteins. That way, if you knew all the genes, youd know
all the proteins.
|
34
Its more complicated than that. (Warning: Were going to say this a lot. Like, a
lot.)
RNA splicing
One gene can code for many related proteins through RNA splicing.
Some cuts could be minor. Some could completely change the movie (i.e., the
protein thats expressed).
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
35
Now, imagine your movie is also full of commercials. You have to watch the
movie in little bits. This is annoying. So, imagine that you re-cut the movie, take
out the commercials, and stick all the movie bits back together so you get one
uninterrupted full-length feature.
Just like a movie with irritating and useless commercials removed, mRNA is
spliced so that all the introns are taken out, and only the exons, the expressing
sequences, remain.
Now, sometimes theres a small problem: Our editor is excellent but not perfect.
So, when our mRNA movie is re-cut during the RNA splicing process:
Or, if alternative splicing occurs, we might end up with a few scenes missing
from our movie. A few exons might get cut out.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
36
Transporting mRNA in and out of the nucleus
Remember that DNA and RNA live mainly in the nucleus. (In Chapter 6, well talk
about another kind of DNA, mitochondrial DNA, that doesnt.)
Before it can be used to code for protein, mRNA has to clear a couple more
hurdles. Enter mRNA export.
mRNA needs to get out of the nucleus and to ribosomes, the protein-making
factories in the cytoplasm.
It also needs to keep itself from breaking down. If its broken down
(degraded), then it cant be used.
You dont want RNA just randomly escaping the nucleus, just like you dont want
drunken texts to your ex or boss escaping your phone at 3:00 AM.
Thus, you need to regulate mRNA degradation and stability so it can make it to
the ribosome and be translated into a protein.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 2:30: RNA movement through nuclear pore
Once precursor mRNA grows up and becomes mature mRNA (via splicing and
some accessories stuck on for stability), its selected and moved out of the
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
nucleus.
Mature mRNA has a bunch of extra nucleotides stuck on one end (a 3 poly-A
tail) that acts a bit like the little plastic ends on your shoelaces that keep them
from getting frayed. On the other end of the mRNA (the 5 end), it has a cap (a
7-methylguanosine cap).
The cap and the tail protect the mRNA from being broken down and keep it
stable. The more stable the mRNA is, the more protein it can make.
|
37
Other types of RNA
Besides pre-mRNA and mRNA, there are several other types of RNA we need to
make proteins.
Transfer RNA (tRNA). tRNAs are RNA molecules that carry specific amino
acids to the ribosome. They match mRNA codons with their respective
amino acid.
Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is an RNA enzyme that links amino acids together
in the ribosome to make a polypeptide chain. Remember that ribosomes
are where the mRNA is read and matched with tRNA that carry amino acids,
which are then assembled to make the protein.
Other RNAs such as small nuclear RNA (snRNA), microRNA (miRNA), and
small interfering RNA (siRNA) regulate how much and what type protein will
be made.
Theres no exam.
Just remember:
tRNA Bridges between mRNA codons and the amino acids they code for
PRECISION NUTRITION
snRNA RNA splicing
38
Controlling gene expression: from
DNA to protein
There are 5 steps going from DNA to protein that are controlled via mRNA
production, processing and transport.
Your body doesnt constantly make RNA from DNA. Its a very regulated process.
Only certain genes are transcribed, and only at certain times.
promoters
enhancers
terminators
Promoters and terminators (basically starters and stoppers) are similar for all
genes.
PRECISION NUTRITION
But enhancer regions are different. Their variations allow them to match
transcription factors with some specificity, allowing systems to activate and
deactivate transcription of certain genes by the presence and absence of their
transcription factor(s).
Think about nucleotide pairs like matching pairs of socks. Ideally, you have all
your socks properly sorted and paired after doing laundry. Sometimes, that
happens. Sometimes, not.
Sometimes you lose or mismatch socks maybe one sock, maybe a pair of
socks, maybe a few pairs. Sometimes you even end up with new socks socks
that arent even yours.
|
39
The same can happen with the nucleotide pairs of DNA. This is called a mutation
some type of permanent change to the nucleotide pairing sequence. This can
happen in a few different ways, and for different reasons.
You may have heard the term antioxidant (for instance, as an ingredient in
superfoods, or vitamins C and E).
In normal metabolism, we create what are called reactive oxygen species (ROS).
ROS are unstable, oxygen-containing molecules that are normal byproducts of
cellular respiration. Oxidative damage happens naturally during cell metabolism
some estimates suggest this occurs 10,000 times a day per cell.
Usually, our cells are able to balance oxidative damage with their own
antioxidant system.
However, under environmental stress (such as exposure to toxins), ROS can build
up faster than the cell can clear them. This can cause mutations by chemically
modifying the nucleotides to become a slightly different molecule.
There are many other ways for oxidative changes to occur, such as:
PRECISION NUTRITION
ultraviolet light (two nucleotides cytosine and thymine are particularly
sensitive to UV light); and
genes.
Small mutations can sometimes have big effects that change a proteins amino
acid composition:
|
40
Substitution mutations: In a codon, one nucleotide is exchanged for another
(for instance, an A for a G or a C for a T). These can end up being:
Silent mutations that code for the same or a similar-enough amino acid
(e.g., both CCA and CCT result in proline)
Missense mutations, which code for a different amino acid (e.g., CCA
results in proline, but CTA results in leucine).
Nonsense mutations, which create stop codons and can truncate the
protein (e.g., TAC makes tyrosine, while TAA signals stop). This means
that a cells ribosome (the protein-making factory), will stop producing
the protein before that protein has all of its amino acids. Consequently,
this can affect the way the protein works.
Insertions, as the name implies, add one or more extra nucleotides into
the DNA.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
41
More significant mutations that can affect one or more entire genes can include:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
42
Sometimes mutations have observable effects, sometimes not.
For instance:
The effects of genes can get stronger. If we have extra copies of a gene in
a genome (copy number variation, or CNV), there are more copies of the
gene to be transcribed, and the effect can be more pronounced.
PRECISION NUTRITION
How does the body reach that high fidelity we mentioned earlier? By precisely
spotting and quickly repairing some of the more common mutations.
Like the Quality Assurance process of factory production, our bodies carefully
check for DNA damage and quality at various checkpoints in the cell cycle.
If the QA testers spot damage, they (ideally) stop the production line, pause
|
In fact, given how many components our genome has, its quite amazing how
effective and efficient our genetic copying process is as accurate as only one
major error per every 1010 (or 10,000,000,000) nucleotides. Try finding a factory
with that level of precision!
43
Mismatch repair (MMR) happens when a set of genes notices errors in
DNA replication and recombination.
Base excision repair (BER) and nucleotide excision repair (NER) processes
fix lesions and physical damage that can lead to DNA mis-pairing or breaks
during replication. Deficiencies in BER / NER have been linked to cancer as
well as neurodegeneration.
Sometimes, critical mutations occur not to particular genes that do things like
make body structures, but to the genes involved in finding and fixing mistakes.
So diseases of genetic origin occur from not having a strong enough repair
crew.
You could spend your life studying the details of genetics. (Heck, we had a hard
time keeping this basics chapter under 10,000 words.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
But you dont need to know all the details if you simply want to grasp the basics
of genetic testing.
Sometimes mutations take an organism out of the game before it can reproduce.
Or, if the organism does manage to reproduce, the mutation isnt passed to its
offspring.
Sometimes mutations dont affect the reproduction process (for instance, its
something that only affects people over 60, or it gives you a funny-shaped nose
but someone loves you anyway).
|
44
Often, mutations and genetic variations can be inherited, and as a result, they
can affect our health, nutrition, and fitness.
For instance, the BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene variants play a strong role in the
development of breast and ovarian cancers. Many other genes do too, such as
genes involved in DNA repair.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
45
Different types of ovarian cancer
TYPE 1 TYPE 2
Grade & progression Low and borderline, slow and High and aggressive
often isolated to ovary
These variations affect not only the origins of particular types of ovarian cancer,
but also their locations, clinical progressions and outcomes.
They are diverse phenomena that result from complex genetic and
environmental interactions.
PRECISION NUTRITION
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
|
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
46
Epigenetics: Environment
matters.
Have you ever met identical twins that were different? Different
personalities, different habits, maybe even different physical traits
despite being genetically the same?
Studies have compared what happens when one identical twin exercises
or eats nutritiously and the other one doesnt. For example, one study
compared 10 pairs of twins. One twin of each pair exercised regularly; the
other twin was sedentary.
The researchers found that the more active twins were leaner and
metabolically healthier. They also had more grey matter in their brains than
their genetically identical but inactive counterparts. Other studies have
found similar results.
Why arent two people with the same genetic blueprint exact copies of one
another?
The answer is epigenetics, the regulation of whether or not our genes are
expressed.
Our environment (such as what we eat, whats around us, our exercise
habits, what happened to us as children, and so forth) affects gene
expression.
There are many ways that this can happen, such as histone modification.
Youll remember that histones are proteins that make up part of the
package of DNA, and can affect how parts of that DNA are activated or
repressed.
PRECISION NUTRITION
A full discussion of epigenetics is cool, but beyond the scope of this book.
Just knowing our genetic code (our genotype) is not enough to fully
understand what it means, or how it may shape our phenotype (for
instance, our health, our risk of disease, our physical characteristics
like height, and so forth).
Many other factors can affect how and whether specific genes are
expressed.
|
47
Whats up next
Now that you have some fundamentals under your belt, well explore how
genetic tests work, and what they look for.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 3
Introduction Introduction to
genetic testing
|
and what youll learn in this book. What does genetic testing involve?
What are some of the general
issues to think about while deciding
if genetic testing is right for you?
|
48
CHAPTER 3
The idea that biology is about probability rather than a given outcome;
How genetic testing works;
Why and how genetic testing might be helpful or unhelpful;
Guidelines for genetic testing; and
Questions you can ask yourself when considering genetic testing.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
49
Biology is probability.
Probability is prediction and potential, not perfection.
or
or
So any genetic testing service (along with any book, website, or coaching
service) that promises to give you a perfect nutrition plan or workout regime,
or exactly predict your health risks, is being misleading.
Its almost impossible to control all the factors involved in a complex system.
Plus, knowledge and development are incremental. We learn bit by bit. Change
PRECISION NUTRITION
bit by bit. Grow bit by bit.
Genetic information can tell us how we might change (if we wanted to), and
what the payoff from that change might be.
Lets imagine that based on your genetic tests, you knew exactly how likely
it was that you would get a particular disease, and exactly how that disease
|
might progress.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
(Just to be clear, were definitely not there yet. Its imagination time only.)
For instance, lets say that you know from genetic testing that you have a 70%
probability of dying from Alzheimers disease by age 70.
Now lets say that there is also a medication available. This medication will bring
your risk from 70% down to 30%. And it works in 90% of people.
|
50
Would you take it?
Medication: 30% chance of dying at 70 but you may be in the 10% for
whom it doesnt work.
What then?
We know that many breast and ovarian cancers are related to mutations in the
BRCA1 and/or BRCA2 genes. Data suggest that in healthy 30-year old carriers
of these mutations, removing ovaries may add 0.2 to 1.8 years in life expectancy,
and a mastectomy may add 0.6 to 2.1 years.
Is that enough certainty to book surgery if you know you carry those mutations?
PRECISION NUTRITION
take those chances.
Unless a mutation has taken you out of the game right off the bat, theres
almost never 100 100 100. |
As in: We know with 100% certainty that in 100% of cases, this genetic risk will
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Sometimes we dont even know with 50% certainty or 10% certainty or at all.
51
Proceed with caution and critical
thought.
Now that you know from Chapter 2 the basics of how genes work, remember a
few key ideas:
Genetic interactions are vast and complex, and we dont have most
of them mapped.
Keep these concepts in mind, and wear your skeptical scientist hat.
In 2001, sequencing a full human genome (all the DNA in a human cell
nucleus) cost about $100 million US.
PRECISION NUTRITION
In 2011, it cost about $10,000 US.
In 2016, two members of our PN team got their full genome sequenced for
$1,000 US each.
For only $200 US, you can buy a 23andMe kit and get hundreds of thousands
of your genetic variations tested without ever leaving your house. Just spit in a
tube and mail it away for analysis no fancy lab coat required.
52
The graphic below compares when various genetic sequencing technologies
were introduced to how much analytic power those technologies have.
When more material can pass through the process, accuracy goes up and costs
go down. Researchers can now do high-fidelity sequencing on the entire human
genome at a cost that even projects that survive on grants can afford.
Note that the Y axis increases logarithmically (10, 100, 1,000, 10,000, etc.). What
looks like a small step on this graphs Y axis is actually a huge step forward:
The Illumina HighSeq X Ten sequencer has 10,000 times the throughput as the
Sequence Analyzer Illumina created just ten years before.
We can look at the genetic code with more precision and accuracy than
ever before.
PRECISION NUTRITION
This means we also need to consider how to deal with all the data we generate,
which has to be compiled, converted, and stored. We must then analyze the
results and balance any clinical advice or interpretation that we give.
This means that each stage of the genetic testing process is significant,
such as:
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
53
Generating so much data means that we have to think about where to put it,
how to understand it, and what to eventually do with it.
We can also think of it in terms of behavior change and genetic counseling what
we might do with any data or insight we gain.
For example:
Many diseases and health conditions are complex. There may be a genetic
contribution, but it may be from several interacting genes, or even regulatory
pathways that dont involve genes. And environmental or lifestyle choices
may affect the outcome more anyway.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Data are limited. There may not be a lot of research about a particular gene,
or its relationship to health and function.
To understand this better, lets look more closely at the process of genetic testing.
|
54
What does clinical genetic testing
involve?
In general, clinical genetic tests:
analyze DNA for specific genetic variants (SNPs), that code for gene
products such as enzymes or other proteins;
look for variations that are related to disease or health (and, increasingly,
athletic capacity);
are aimed at producing information that patients can somehow use for
instance, to lower their risk of a disease, to choose the right medication, or
adjust their nutritional regime.
Some genetic tests (such as 23andMe) also include ancestry and ethnic
heritage. Well look at the importance of ancestry in Chapter 5.
PRECISION NUTRITION
A closed assay identifies beforehand what its seeking, such as a particular
mutation or another variant.
disease diagnosis;
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
55
pharmacogenomic testing, to explore how you might respond to a particular
medication; or
For instance, genetic tests can currently help us explore such traits as:
Test types
You might think that a genetic test would look at the entire genome, but this
is rarely the case. (Well talk more in upcoming chapters about studying entire
genomes, and why most commercially-available tests dont do it.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
or the BRCA1/2 mutations that are linked to breast and ovarian cancers.
56
Again, commercial tests dont usually sequence entire genomes.
In fact, usually the opposite is true: Most commercially available genetic tests
examine single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), a variation in a single
nucleotide (e.g., having a cytosine, or C, where theres normally an adenine, or
A). Youll remember from Chapter 2 that small substitutions like this are one way
that we can get genetic variation.
Of those SNPs, 98.6% are in noncoding DNA, which means they are stretches
of DNA that arent transcribed into mRNA to make proteins. (This is what people
used to call junk DNA until they realized that it wasnt junk. Sure, some of it
includes leftover odds and ends from our evolutionary history, but a lot of it has
a purpose.)
Noncoding DNA includes a lot of different things. Much like after family get-
togethers when you end up with lots of leftovers and macaroni-salad-encrusted
Tupperware, our genome contains lots of leftover bits from millions of years of
our evolutionary process.
PRECISION NUTRITION
genetic material is known as a provirus. HIV is probably the best-known
example of a retrovirus, but there are many others. Because the process by
which this happens (known as reverse transcription) is relatively unstable
and prone to error, many of these retroviral sequences are inactive.
Inactivated retroviral sequences make up a surprisingly large proportion of
our genome about 10%.
|
Regulatory sequences: parts of DNA that act like a volume knob on gene
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
So, genetic testing services may test for functional SNPs, or they may test for
SNPs found in noncoding regions.
|
57
On one hand, we can get a lot of useful information from SNPs, such as
predictions about our ancestry, or well-known associations with certain heritable
traits or diseases.
We also cant see copy number variation (again, how many copies of a particular
DNA sequence you have) nor translocation mutations (where a gene moves
from one chromosome to another, or from one part of a chromosome to another).
Both of these can affect our phenotype, but simply knowing SNP markers wont
tell us anything about their effects.
With most GWAS, participants are usually picked based on some characteristic
that they share, such as having high blood pressure or osteoporosis. They are
then compared to a control group without that characteristic to see if the test
group shares any genetic variants, or somehow differs from the control group.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
58
A GWAS is usually a broad scan.
Or maybe theyre looking to find novel loci in other words, new SNPs or
other variants such as haplotypes (which well look at in Chapter 5) that are
associated with the characteristic.
Theyre also looking to see whether the SNPs have predictive value: In
other words, does having this SNP make it significantly more or less likely
that you will have a certain trait or other outcome? Or is the relationship
between the SNP and the outcome just kinda random?
Often, the data that commercial genetic testing services use to look for certain
SNPs come from laboratory GWAS that have already identified those SNPs
as significant.
At the time of writing this book, no one currently offers a commercial full-
genome testing service. (However, we did get our co-author Alainas genome
sequenced in a private lab. More on that later.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
and researchers make discoveries about the intricacies of the human genome,
whole-genome sequencing will probably become more and more common.
Eventually your whole-genome sequence will just be a normal part of your
medical records.
It may seem like a commercial test is only offering you a half-assed version of a
real full-genome test, but when you know what parts of the genome you need
|
Its faster, cheaper, and easier to look at only the regions of interest, so you
arent looking for a needle in a haystack. Instead, you already know where the
needle is; you just need to know how long it is.
The only challenge is that research hasnt uncovered all the different
relationships between our genes and our genetic expression. The scientific
community has only scratched the surface.
|
59
So:
These services are really only telling us a small fraction of all there is to
know about ourselves. Thats challenging if were looking for the best way
to eat, or exercise, or live to 120.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Criminal investigations using DNA as evidence may also use discarded DNA,
such as material left behind on coffee cups, straws, or cigarette butts.
somehow get the DNA out of its container, the cell, and read it.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Because cell walls are lipid-based, we have to use some kind of surfactant or
detergent, much like dunking the cells in dish soap.
|
60
Some processes may also use a base such as sodium hydroxide (NaOH) along
with the surfactant sodium dodecyl (lauryl) sulfate (SDS). (The combination of
a base like NaOH and a surfactant is known as alkaline lysis, and it was first
described in 1979 as a way to get DNA out of bacteria.)
Once the DNA is out of the cell, testers break up proteins using proteases
(protein-degrading enzymes) and break up RNA by using RNases (same idea).
Without this step, the sample can degrade rapidly and cause sampling errors.
Luckily, DNA is remarkably stable outside of the cell, much more than RNA or
protein. This is why we can do DNA matching days or even years after a sample
has been left. In fact, ancient DNA can be extracted and analyzed from samples
thousands of years old.
You need to pick apart the crud from the DNA, so the next step is centrifuging,
which spins the mix in a wheel to separate things out (much like that spinning
wheel ride at the county fair that separates you from your stomach contents).
Solid chunks are flung to the bottom of the test sample tube, and the DNA is left
behind, dissolved in the solution.
Next, you want to tidy and purify the DNA from all the stuff you used to get it out
of the cell. Do one of the following:
Use ethanol (the same alcohol as in your martini) or isopropanol (aka rubbing
alcohol, definitely not in your martini) to come out of the solution (precipitate
it). DNA wont dissolve in this, so it clumps when you centrifuge it. If this
PRECISION NUTRITION
clump is clear its pure DNA. If theres still some non-DNA, the clump is
white.
Use something solid, like silica, to which nucleic acids will bind. This works
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
sort of like dumping sawdust on spilt liquid. Most labs that have money use
silica bound to a membrane. This is faster and it gives us clean DNA.
Use a protease to break up and cleave off cellular and histone proteins
bound to the DNA.
|
61
Step 2C: Amplify the DNA.
Lets say youre trying to listen to music, but youre somewhere with lots of
background noise. So what do you do? You turn up your music in other words,
you amplify it.
The same thing happens in DNA analysis you often have to amplify it and
make a lot more copies of the strand of DNA in order to make sure you get
a good signal to test. This is most often done using the polymerase chain
reaction process, or PCR.
The upside of this process is that after several rounds of amplification, you have
a nice big sample more DNA than you know what to do with. The downside is
that if theres contamination, thats amplified too.
Fun factoid!
Legend has it that the inventor of PCR, the Nobel Prize-winning American biochemist
Karey Mullis, got the idea for PCR while on an acid trip in 1983.
Goes to show that winning a Nobel Prize and transforming molecular biology doesnt
mean you arent also a crackpot.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
62
Step 3: Analysis
Once you have a nice big pile of DNA, you can start to read (i.e., sequence)
and analyze it.
Reading DNA isnt as simple as reading a book from start to finish. Its more
like this:
Take a book.
Open the book to a randomly-chosen page.
Start reading at a randomly-chosen word.
Read a few letters, or a word, or a phrase. Maybe a sentence.
Close the book.
Open the book to another randomly-chosen page.
Read a few more randomly-chosen bits.
And so on.
Do that about a zillion times until you understand what the book says.
In real-life terms, that means that sequencing creates a bunch of data that need
to be put together into an order that makes sense. We do this with complex
computing methods and algorithms, using bioinformatics techniques to identify,
understand, and analyze the raw data.
Step 4: Interpretation
PRECISION NUTRITION
Finally, once you have your data, and its been read and analyzed, you can
decide what your findings mean. For example, did your sample have the variant
youre looking for?
Obviously, you could write a Ph.D. thesis on a single aspect of genetic testing
alone.
|
63
But here are a few key points:
There are several types of tests, depending on what you want to find.
Different tests use and look for different amounts of genetic material.
There are several methods for testing.
There are several steps in the process, each with the potential for variation
or mistakes.
Its complicated.
For instance:
PRECISION NUTRITION
A family doctor may want to know how to advise their patients about
medications, family planning, or lifestyle choices.
population.
A sports scientist may want to know how to select or train athletes for
optimal performance.
A family lawyer settling a patrimony case (or a sleazy TV talk show host
doing an OMG! Whos Your Baby Daddy?! episode) may want to know
which kids are the genetic offspring of a particular parent.
|
64
For many people, genetic testing is a way to explore their risk of disease
or health conditions. Yet there is much we still dont know about genetic
contributions to disease, and how we might use information about our DNA to
either treat specific diseases, or improve our odds of staying healthy and fit.
When a second group of scientists tried to replicate these findings, they found
that, as they said, poor documentation hid many simple errors that undermined
the approach. This is a polite sciencey way of saying that the first team might
have fibbed a bit.
However, these problematic profiles were used anyway to direct patient therapy
in clinical trials at Duke University in 2007. When the second group of scientists
protested the poor science, trials were suspended in 2009, then re-started, and
then finally ended in 2010.
The initial exploration held exciting promise: What if cancer patients could have
their treatment individualized, based on their genetic profile?
PRECISION NUTRITION
Yet the scientific reality did not hold up under scrutiny.
That isnt to say that this couldnt happen one day. It very likely could.
The point is that the science is young, and all results must be reproduced
|
reliably before we can have confidence in them, or use them to guide our
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
decisions.
|
65
Establishing guidelines for genetic
testing
The researchers who protested the Duke study suggested that all genetic tests
share the following:
the raw data, such as the reads produced by a sequencer; the called
genotyping data in the file you can download from 23andMe; or the images
taken of gels;
PRECISION NUTRITION
the code used to derive the results from the raw data (in other words, how
software and algorithms computed and analyzed the findings);
evidence of the origin of the raw data so that labels could be checked;
written descriptions of all the steps in the analysis; and
how the researchers planned to run the analysis.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
66
In 2004, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in the United States
established the Evaluation of Genomic Applications in Practice and Prevention
(EGAPP) initiative to establish and test a systematic, evidence-based process
for evaluating genetic tests and other applications of genomic technology that
are in transition from research to clinical and public health practice.
The EGAPP wanted to have a broad perspective on genetic testing. The groups
founding members included experts in:
evidence-based review;
clinical practice;
developing clinical guidelines;
public health;
laboratory methods;
genomics;
epidemiology;
economics;
ethics;
policy; and
health technology assessment.
EGAPP aimed to help healthcare practitioners and their patients understand
some of the results of genetic tests.
PRECISION NUTRITION
After reviewing many genetic tests, they concluded that:
Tests for Predicting Patient Outcomes in Clinical Trials met to discuss the
challenges of genetic testing.
The group concluded, based on reviewing how genetic testing was being used,
that problems were more widespread and severe than we knew.
For instance, many tests could not be reproduced accurately; many clinical trials
based on genetic data were called into question. Along with more complex
problems like statistical analysis, researchers were making basic mistakes like
mislabelling data.
|
67
Clearly, a better system for scientific rigor was
needed.
This reminds us to always be critical and careful of grandiose claims for
genetic testing.
Genetic testing holds exciting promise, and may help us make incredible
breakthroughs in human understanding.
Here are two ways to think about the answer: a simple 4-question rubric from us,
and a more complex checklist from the ACCE.
PRECISION NUTRITION
3 | Predictive: Does it allow me to predict some future challenge or
occurrence, such as a disease or health risk later in life?
genetic testing
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
If you want to think more deeply about how good or useful a genetic test is, you
can use the framework proposed by the ACCE (established by the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention in the United States).
|
68
ACCE takes its name from the four criteria for judging the value of a given
genetic test:
Analytical validity:
How accurately does a given test detect a gene variant or mutation?
How reliable and repeatable is a given test?
Are test results lab significant or real world significant? In other
words, if we find anything, does it mean anything?
Clinical validity:
What evidence supports the relationship between particular gene
variants and risk of disease?
PRECISION NUTRITION
Are patients informed of all their rights and obligations beforehand?
Would prenatal screening be considered appropriate?
Who has access to these tests?
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
69
To help explore these questions, the ACCE has produced a checklist that
can help evaluate particular genetic tests, especially those aimed at finding
relationships between gene variants and disease risk.
b | What are the clinical findings defining this disorder? (In other words, what
does the existing clinical evidence tell us about diagnosing this disorder,
and its specific features?)
g | If this test is part of a series, are all tests done at once, or are some tests
done based on the results of previous tests? (e.g., if Test A finds something,
then do Test B?)
2 | Analytic validity
PRECISION NUTRITION
b | How sensitive is the test analysis? How often is the test positive when a
specific mutation is present?
c | How specific is the test analysis? How often is the test negative when a
specific mutation is not present?
|
d | Is the test method regularly monitored and evaluated for quality control by
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
an external body? In other words, who and what tests the test?
70
the tests, how close would the test results be? (Well look at this more in an
upcoming section, when we look at what we found with sending samples to
different labs.)
i | How often does the test give a useable result? Or fail to do so?
j | How similar are results obtained in multiple laboratories using the same,
or different technology?
3 | Clinical validity
a | How sensitive is the test for clinical purposes? How often is the test positive
when a specific disorder is present?
b | How specific is the test for clinical purposes? How often is the test negative
when a specific disorder is not present?
e | Has the test been adequately validated on all populations to which it may
be offered?
PRECISION NUTRITION
impact? If theres a gene for a trait, does that trait show up a little, a lot, or not
at all?
4 | Clinical utility
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
a | How does the disease normally progress? Can we actually intervene in that
process?
71
d | What can be done about these results, if anything? For instance, are there
medications, actions, or some other measurable benefit to knowing these
genetic test results?
e | If the patient can do something about the results, can they access that?
For instance, can they get the medication that may help them, or make any
applicable lifestyle changes?
h | What are the results of pilot trials for these specific conditions or diseases?
j | Is testing affordable?
k | Are there service providers able to help people understand or take action
with the test results?
o | How well does this program work over the long term, and how do we
know?
PRECISION NUTRITION
a | When it comes to this particular test, do we need to think about:
1 | social stigmatization;
2 | discrimination;
3 | privacy/confidentiality; and/or
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
72
Other questions to ask about
genetic testing
Genetic testing isnt just about the science or clinical use. There are other factors
to think about as well.
How high is the risk or probability of a particular outcome? Do you have a 0.5%
higher chance of something? 5%? 50%?
What happens if you find a gene variant, but dont know what it does? Or dont
have any evidence-based strategies for what to do next?
Are you someone whos looking to start a family, and wondering what you might
pass along to a child?
Are you someone with a family history of a particular disease, and looking to
explore your risk for that disease?
PRECISION NUTRITION
Speaking of that
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
73
Do these results align with your genetic and
ethnic ancestry?
What group was the genetic research done on?
If youre ethnically Hmong from Vietnam, or Quechua from Peru, how applicable
are genetic studies done (for example) on British Europeans?
Who can access your genetic information, and for what purpose? For instance,
can insurance companies review your genetic test results before deciding to
insure you? What about employers, before hiring you?
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
74
Where are you protected from genetic
discrimination?
Different regions have different legislation and regulation of genetic testing.
In March 2017, Canada passed Bill S-201, the Genetic Non-Discrimination Act.
The Act prevents people being pressured to undergo genetic testing in order to be
eligible for goods or services (such as insurance); or from having to disclose their
results.
It prohibits employers from discriminating against workers on the basis of any genetic
test results. It also amends the Canadian Human Rights Act to prohibit discrimination
based on genetic characteristics.
The Canadian Coalition for Genetic Fairness is made up of several advocacy groups,
such as the Parkinson Society of Canada or Muscular Dystrophy Canada. They also
promote genetic nondiscrimination.
In the United States, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 (GINA)
prohibits discrimination based on genetic information in health insurance and
employment. Health insurance companies are not allowed to deny coverage to
healthy people based solely on potential genetic risk, nor are employers allowed to
discriminate based on genetic data.
In the UK, the 2010 Equality Act prevents employers from discriminating based on
genetic data.
In the European Union countries, the 2010 Lisbon Treaty prohibits discrimination based
on genetic features.
PRECISION NUTRITION
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)
adopted the Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights in
2003 and International Declaration on Human Genetic Data in 2012, which includes
provisions for preventing genetic discrimination and any use of genetic information that
would contravene dignity, freedom, and human rights. |
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
75
What behavioral factors are involved?
Once you get your test results, what could you do? What should you do?
For instance, if youre young enough and considering having a family, should the
results of genetic testing change your choice to reproduce?
What if you discover some awkward truths about your genetic heritage or
parentage?
Fun factoid!
In one key case (Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, No.
12-398 [569 U.S.June 13, 2013]), Judge Robert Sweet found that the claims on DNA
molecules were invalid because DNA represents the physical embodiment of
biological information, distinct in its essential characteristics from any other chemical
found in nature.
PRECISION NUTRITION
We wont always have the right answers to
any of these questions.
|
76
Whats up next: Exploring specific
tests
In this chapter, weve given you a broad background to consider.
In the next chapter, well look at specific types of tests, and what we discovered
about them with our own testing practices.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 2 CHAPTER 4
The basics of genetics Specific genetic
testing services
|
and an introduction to some of the What should you think about when
key ideas youll need to understand considering particular genetic
genetic testing and its implications. testing services? Which services
did we choose, and why?
|
77
CHAPTER 4
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
78
But first:
We cant say right now that having a certain genetic variation necessarily makes
something happen.
We can only say that in this particular population studied, we can see that there
is maybe something happening with a particular gene or SNP. Thats all.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Rarely can we know for sure that something will happen or even what that
something is. This might be disconcerting and hard to understand, so celebrate
this feeling of ambiguity. It runs throughout biology.
We cant say for sure based on a single study of fifty people of Finnish, Fijian, or
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Filipino descent whether that study has any relevance to you even if youre
Finnish, Fijian, or Filipino too.
|
79
4 questions to ask about genetic
testing
We also suggest you review our 4 simple questions to ask about genetic testing:
Is a particular test:
Keep these points and questions in mind as you read through this chapter, and
the rest of the book.
PRECISION NUTRITION
carrier status (in other words, whether youre carrying something that you
may not want to pass on to your offspring);
specific traits;
newborn health;
drug response; or
individualized health, nutrition, and fitness recommendations.
|
80
A study of 246 direct-to-consumer genetic testing services found that while
nutrigenetic tests were popular, the pressing question of What should I eat?
was outweighed by Is my kid mine? Some genetic testing services even
offered a discreet surreptitious option, as in, Steal a few bits of someones
body and send it to us; well tell you whether youre about to have an awkward
family conversation.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 4.1: Specific reasons for testing as a percentage of all commercial services offered
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
81
A health, nutrition, and fitness focus
Of course, were interested in general health, nutrition, and fitness or athletic
performance, so thats where we focused our attention.
Metabolism
PRECISION NUTRITION
Response to exercise
Recovery from exercise
Well cover these in more detail in upcoming chapters.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
82
What else were we looking for?
Along with a focus on general health, nutrition, and fitness, we looked for
services that fulfilled a few other criteria:
Scientific credibility
What claims were the companies making?
Over half (21 of the 39) companies didnt actually identify the specific DNA
sequence variants they tested.
Of the 18 companies that did identify what genetic markers they used:
PRECISION NUTRITION
16 of 18 tested the ACTN3 R577X polymorphism (which well look at in
Chapter 10).
The number of variants tested overall was small. Most companies tested
around 6. Some tested only 1, others up to 27.
|
83
When we consider that we have 3 billion base pairs of DNA, you can imagine
that this is still a pretty small sample for drawing potentially big conclusions.
When there seemed to be a link, the studies or sample sizes were too
small to make broad recommendations.
What if, for instance, a particular study finds an association between SNP X and
Nutrient Intake Y but the study is based on something like peoples recall of
what they ate a method known to be often so inaccurate that its potentially
useless? If a genetic testing service bases their interpretation on this study,
theres a chance that they might not be making valid scientific claims.
We just need to understand what claims are substantiated, and which ones
arent. (Yet.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
were supported by the most current scientific evidence;
were reasonable, relatively conservative, and realistic; and
included a discussion of both limitations and advantages of their testing
methods and findings.
Quality control
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
84
This includes ensuring:
In the United States, all labs that test human specimens for health
assessment or to diagnose, prevent, or treat disease must abide by federal
Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) regulations.
Reliability
PRECISION NUTRITION
If we sent the same sample to two different labs, would they come up with
similar results?
Would the same samples sent to different commercial labs come back
with similar results?
If we sent two of the same sample to the same lab, would we get the
same results?
|
85
The answers: Yes, and yes. The results we got were a match with over 99.9%
accuracy.
Our experience closely matches other studies that compared the largest direct-
to-consumer testing services (such as 23andMe, deCODE, and the now-defunct
Navigenics) to one another, and found that lab-to-lab correlation (in other words,
how closely each labs results matched the others) was 99.6 to 99.7%, though
accuracy did vary somewhat for specific SNPs or disease risks.
In particular, predictions were less reliable when labs used genetic markers with
only weak associations (such as, Well, in some people, some of the time, given
some environmental conditions, this SNP may be linked to a 0.1% higher chance
of X).
Predictions were more reliable with strong associations, like Yep, you have
OCTFN1, the gene that always gives people octopus fingers 100% of the time.
Fun factoid!
Octopus finger is not a thing. Do not be alarmed.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Vested interests
Are the testing services selling something else?
In many cases, genetic testing services may offer extended services (such
|
These other services may indeed be helpful, but that help didnt actually come
from knowing your genetic information.
|
86
For instance, while tracking your sleep habits or food intake is very useful and
can help you make some important decisions, that useful data is not based
on your sleep DNA or menu DNA. Its just plain old daily-life observation
that anyone can do. (Back in the old days, we just called that kind of careful
observation and outcome-based decision making coaching. Harrumph.)
Other services may sell supplements once they have determined your genetic
requirement for extra vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, etc. At the time of writing,
there are very, very few known, evidence-based, genetic requirements for
specific supplements. (You may benefit from supplements for other reasons, but
likely not because of any particular SNP that you have.)
There are several technologies and methods that can be used for
genetic testing.
SNP genotyping arrays are fast and cheap. They look at a series of
predetermined locations on the genome (usually hundreds of thousands to
millions) to look for SNP variations. SNP genotyping works well if you know
which SNPs you are looking for, or want to search for novel associations
among well-known regions. Its less useful when the variations are not
SNPs, or when you are looking for variations that arent well characterized
PRECISION NUTRITION
or understood.
87
Exome sequencing provides the genetic code for the exome (every part
of the genome that codes for a part of a protein), which is about 1% of
the total human genome. If researchers are specifically interested in the
protein-coding regions of the genome, exome sequencing gives the most
accurate and cost-effective data. It doesnt include the DNA regions outside
of exomes, which have important regulatory features.
There are other preparation techniques that allow researchers to target specific
functions or regions of DNA.
All sequencing technologies will have some bias and error. Biology and
chemistry are inherently chaotic processes, so nothing is perfect.
PRECISION NUTRITION
accuracy.
explained their process and method, including what they tested and how;
and
|
used testing methods (such as the Illumina chip) that are widely accepted as
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
industry standards.
|
88
Analysis and interpretation
How valid is the analysis, and how useful is the interpretation of the results?
An analysis that says, Here is a specific SNP that you have, heres what we
know about it, and heres what it might say about you if youre from X Population,
but were not totally sure just yet so check back in 10 years is probably accurate.
Thus, we want genetic testing services that give us our test results in context.
If we have, for example, a 1.5 higher lifetime risk of Disease X, what does that
really mean?
We have to know:
PRECISION NUTRITION
what lifetime risk means: Will we likely get this disease at age 20? 50? 99?
how prevalent this disease is in our population: Is it a serious health threat,
or a rare condition?
what other factors besides this genetic variant are involved: Can we escape
|
89
So youre worried: Will your bellybutton explode too?
You get genetic testing to see if you carry the deadly CRUMB gene variant.
Now lets say that Crepitus Umbilicus affects, for example, 50% of the
population. Thats the absolute risk in other words, everyones risk all lumped
together. That means 1 in 2 people will likely, at some point, die by exploding
bellybutton.
Lets say you have a 1.5 higher chance of getting that disease. Thats your
relative risk in other words, how your particular probability stacks up against
everyone else.
You might also want to know your odds ratio, which is the relationship between
an exposure and an outcome. An odds ratio (OR) tells you how likely it is that
Outcome X will happen if youre exposed to Condition Y for instance, how
likely it is that youll get this disease given your genetic makeup.
But if Crepitus Umbilicus affects only 0.00000005% of the population (in other
words, 1 in 2,000,000 people rather than 1 in 2), a 1.5 higher chance of getting
it eh, probably dont worry too much. Just pack a little flame retardant foam in
your navel before you go to sleep each night, and youll likely be just fine.
PRECISION NUTRITION
put results in context as much as possible by telling us the absolute risk as
well as the relative risk.
Again, research suggests that simply knowing about your DNA while very
cool may not change your behavior. In some cases, people may feel as
though they have less control over their choices once they know their genetic
test results.
|
90
It might not be within the testing services scope of practice to make specific
recommendations about what to do next, but were they able to help us identify
where else we might look for guidance?
For instance:
23andMe was one of the first on the commercial testing scene, and offers
a wide array of genetic data ranging from ancestry, to health risks, to traits.
You can spend days deep-diving into all the scientific research and analysis
that theyve collected. https://www.23andme.com/
DNAFit tests about two dozen genes that are related to metabolic health,
nutrition, and athletic performance, and then offers comprehensive
recommendations for what to do with the test results.
https://www.dnafit.com/
Orig3n has a variety of kits available that test sets of variants for fitness and
performance. https://orig3n.com/
PRECISION NUTRITION
https://habit.com/
91
Other services will analyze existing data (for instance, from 23andMe) in ways
that the original labs might not. For instance:
Athletigen doesnt do their own testing (they send it to a lab), but they
offer analysis and interpretation of particular genetic indicators of athletic
performance. https://athletigen.com/
But no.
In most cases, we dont know the testing services, and they dont know us.
(Well, they know us, kinda since DNA is us. But they dont usually know us, like
Hey whats up how are the kids and your sports team? know us.)
Heres why.
Theyre relatively cheap. Hey, we aint made of money. At time of writing, for
instance, 23andMe cost $200 US.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Theyre easily available. Spit in a tube, mail it off. A few weeks later, you
get your data. (Co-authors Helen and Alaina also took and prepped blood
samples for GeneByGene, who offered us the ability to test with both blood
samples and DNA we prepped ourselves in PNs lab.)
to your genetic data. The basic Nutrigenomix kits are used in undergraduate
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
courses.
They can connect to other services and analysis. Once you have your
23andMe data file, for instance, you can link it to other services (such as
Athletigen or Genetic Genie) who will run different analyses on it.
|
92
Theyre relatively accurate. For instance, 23andMe uses the Illumina
HumanOmniExpress-24 format chip (considered an industry standard) in a
CLIA-certified, CAP-accredited laboratory in the United States. Nutrigenomix
uses a similar process in a top university laboratory in Canada, and clinically-
focused GeneByGene has an excellent facility in Texas.
23andMe and Nutrigenomix analyze and interpret the data for you.
(GeneByGene provided us only raw data that we had to analyze, which
makes sense in a clinical setting.)
Research shows that the average person expects genetic testing results to be
much more helpful or directive than they really are.
Research also shows that people are better at correctly interpreting their results
when they are numerate that is, if they understand things like percentages,
odds and risks, and how to understand number-based data like This SNP
increases your odds of Health Condition X by 1.16 or This SNP is associated
with Health Condition Y (p <0.1).
PRECISION NUTRITION
So, if this area interests you, you may want to brush up on your math skills.
also curious, thought it would be fun, and/or simply wanted to help advance the
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
cause of science.
Your goals and reasons for testing will probably affect what test types you
choose, and how you view the test results.
|
93
Consider independent genetic counseling or
coaching.
Genetic test results can be confusing or complex. And, studies suggest that
even if genetic testing results are easy to understand, people often misinterpret
them.
People tend not to change their behavior just because they know their
genetic test results.
But: They do tend to change their behavior if they share their data with
their doctor, another healthcare professional, or a coach.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
94
Whats up next: What we found
In the next few chapters, well focus on some specific topics and explore what
we found in our own genetic tests.
Well cover:
Heredity and ancestry, and how these might affect your genetic test results;
Metabolism;
Nutrition and food preferences; and
Exercise and athletic performance.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 3 CHAPTER 5
Introduction to What we found: Heredity
genetic testing
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
95
CHAPTER 5
Why our history matters, and why we have to consider ancestry when
understanding and interpreting genetic data.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
96
As you read this chapter, remember our usual caution:
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
In this process, genetic traits are passed on from parents to child. You might
inherit your fathers nose, or your mothers curly hair.
But this doesnt mean we are exact clones of our parents. Gametes (the
chromosome-containing cells we get from our mom, an egg/ovum and dad, a
sperm) combine in ways that we cant completely predict.
Gametes are haploid, which means they each have only one copy of the 23
chromosomes that make up the human genome. (The word haploid comes to
us from the ancient Greek haploos, or single, simple, once.)
When the haploid egg and sperm cells unite, they eventually create a person
with diploid cells twice the amount, or 46 chromosomes. (The prefix di refers
to two.) So, aside from our own sperm or egg cells, the rest of the cells in our
bodies have 46 chromosomes.
PRECISION NUTRITION
How does heredity work?
Heredity is complex. Given all the DNA in our genetic code, and given that we
get stuff from mom and dad, there are almost infinite possible combinations of
traits. |
Some traits are dominant, meaning they are more likely to be expressed. Some
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
traits are recessive, meaning that they are less likely to be expressed. We might
need to inherit two copies of a recessive gene in order to express it, whereas we
might need only need one copy of a dominant gene.
97
Figure 5.1: Homozygous and heterozygous inheritance
PRECISION NUTRITION
For example:
There is a gene that makes people more or less likely to think that fresh cilantro
(aka coriander, a herb often used in Latin American and Asian cuisines) tastes
yucky (which well look at in Chapter 8, on food preferences). |
98
In our sample, we found different types of inheritance.
Parent-child group 1:
Parent-child group 2:
Parent-child group 3:
And, as youll see in Chapter 8, just knowing a persons genetic makeup (i.e.,
their genotype) doesnt necessarily tell us what traits they express (i.e., their
phenotype). As it turns out, the cilantro-hatin gene didnt predict which of our
PN sample actually hated cilantro.
PRECISION NUTRITION
This combination of chromosomes is what gives us our biological sex our
collection of physiological characteristics that we might call male or female.
Rather, its a bit more like biological sex is on a continuum. Its quite possible,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
99
For example:
A body can have XY (i.e. biologically male) chromosomes, but for other
genetic reasons (such as variations on other related genes), develop a
female body. Testes dont descend while XY fetuses are in the womb, so
when they are born, they might look like any other baby girl. Often this has
to do with insensitivity to the masculinizing hormones, known as androgens.
Many XY women do not discover they are unusual until they hit puberty and
dont menstruate.
Many bodies can also inherit additional chromosome copies, such as XXY,
XXX, XYY, and so on.
Biology is complicated.
Is transsexualism genetic?
One of our co-authors, Alaina, has an interesting feature: Shes transsexual. (We
also had one more trans woman in our genetic sample.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
Nobody knows exactly how common it is to have some type of mismatch
between ones biological sex configuration (i.e., chromosomes and other
physiological characteristics), and ones gender identity (i.e., ones sense of self
as having a particular gender, or not).
But both gender variation and intersex are common enough that we now ask
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
100
Which sex/gender do you most identify with:
oo Man
oo Woman
oo Other
Given the ways that chromosomal inheritance can work, intersex is a fairly clear-
cut phenomenon. Its simply a normal (though relatively infrequent) variation of
sexual development with a clear mechanism of action.
But what about gender identity? In other words, who we feel we are, at a deep
level? Could genetics play a role here too? Possibly.
For instance, some evidence suggests that genes involved in the production and
function of sex hormones may be important, such as:
Two studies, for example, found that female-to-male transsexuals were more
PRECISION NUTRITION
likely to have variations in the CYP17 gene (which encodes 17-hydroxylase, an
enzyme involved in conversion of sex hormones.) Other research found no such
association.
Another study, yet to be reproduced, looked at the gene (AR, or NR3C4) that
codes for the human androgen receptor.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
101
The AR gene has several variants where a stretch of 3-nucleotide codons
with the makeup of cytosine + adenine + guanine (giving it the acronym CAG)
is repeated different numbers of times. This is known as a variable number
tandem repeat (or VNTR).
The study looked at how often each variant, or allele, appeared in a study
population of both transsexual women (male-to-female) and non-transsexual
men, and found that there might be a link between certain alleles of AR and
being transsexual. Male-to-female transsexuals were more likely to have a
PRECISION NUTRITION
particular number of tandem repeats in the AR gene.
As it turns out, Alaina does, indeed, have this variation. (We didnt test the other
womans full genome, so we dont know if she does.)
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
102
What this means for you
A possible genetic correlation with gender identity is interesting in its
own right, and perhaps validating for many trans people. If these kinds
of results could be replicated and more solidly established scientifically,
it might help demonstrate (at least, for some people) that their deeply felt
sense of being a particular gender has at least some biological roots.
More broadly speaking, variations in genes and structures that affect sex
hormones might also:
affect body composition. For instance, men who more easily convert
(aromatize) testosterone to estrogen may have trouble losing body fat.
Nor, by the way, can you currently test for sexual orientation. 23andMe
also looked for variants that might be related to sexual orientation in
other words, whom we prefer as sex partners. Using a survey of nearly
24,000 people, they eventually concluded that there were no clear links
PRECISION NUTRITION
between any SNPs and sexual orientation. Genetic data in this area, while
intriguing, are still inconclusive and dont yet represent the full range of
human behavior.
Along with our physiological sex, part of what makes us us in biological terms
is our ancestry, ethnicity, and heritage.
Where do you come from? Where are your roots? Who were your ancestors?
Of course, the first answer is that all of us descend from a relatively small
population of hominins (or early humans) who began their journey in Africa.
|
103
Once they could stand upright, those adventurous, ancestral primates started
walking. And walking. And walking. Eventually they spread around the globe,
mutating and evolving and turning into a vast rainbow of humanity.
The second answer explains more recent history: Where have your ancestors
been for the last several thousand years? Where have they traveled? Who did
they meet, and marry, and trade with? (Did someone else trade them?)
How might someone recognize you (or not?) as being from somewhere,
perhaps a particular place on Earth, or a particular group of people? What traits
do you have that might be a dead giveaway or a mystery?
Almost all of us writing this book, and from the PN team who consented to let us
use their data, are from European backgrounds.
For instance:
Kristas family is a mix: part Northern European; part Eastern European; and
part Southern European (particularly the Balkan region).
Our PN team member Tims ancestry is about half European and half South
PRECISION NUTRITION
Asian, with a bit of Sub-Saharan African (mostly West African) thrown in.
104
Heres the list we use:
oo White/European
oo Black/African American
oo Hispanic
oo East Asian
oo South Asian
oo Pacific Islander
oo Arabic/Middle Eastern
oo Aboriginal Australian
PRECISION NUTRITION
our response to diet and exercise;
our food intolerances and sensitivities; and
our health risks or advantages. |
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
105
But in reality, there is no simple answer.
Heredity is complex. (After all, you get stuff from mom, and stuff from dad,
and these days you might get stuff from a third person because why the
heck not!? Science! See below for more.)
Ancestry is complex.
Ethnicity is complex.
How all of these affect your nutrition, exercise, and health is complex.
(Remember, other biological, social, and environmental factors are still in the
mix too.)
One method, known as pronuclear transfer, uses two fertilized eggs, both fertilized
with the fathers sperm: one egg from the mother, and one egg from a donor.
Once eggs are fertilized, but before they start dividing, their nuclei are removed. The
nucleus from the donors fertilized egg is replaced with the nucleus from the mothers
egg.
A second method, known as spindle nuclear transfer, is similar, but the swap occurs
PRECISION NUTRITION
before fertilization.
In this case, doctors purposely created and used a male embryo, so that the resulting
child wouldnt pass on any inherited mitochondrial DNA. (Thus, the genetic disorder
would end.)
106
Genetic data tell us there is no such
thing as race.
At least, not in the way most people think about it, which is a few very simple
categories. Instead, genetically speaking, there are only ethnic subgroups or
common groups of genetic variations that can be loosely distinguished.
History tells us that humans have always been nomadic people. Were social
we like to meet n greet (even if sometimes that greet is with a whackin club to
drive off the other tribe).
We humans like to travel and trade. Some folks wandered up and out of Africa.
Some folks wandered all the way across Alaska to South America. Some of us
even got gutsy enough to take a raft across the ocean, resulting in relatively
historically isolated and genetically distinct populations such as indigenous
Aboriginals in Australia, Torres Strait Islanders, Maori, and Indonesians.
Once we figured out walking, riding, and sailing, we got busy swapping and
selling stuff like spices and silks and appallingly, shamefully, and horribly
sometimes, other humans too. (There is evidence that enslavement, sale, and
other forced migrations of humans happened all over the world, and goes back
at least to around 3,000 BC. Tims great-grandparents were brought to Trinidad
as part of human trafficking routes from India and Africa.)
This means that unless you and your ancestors have lived for tens of thousands
of years undisturbed in some pocket of the Amazon, an isolated mountain pass,
or a desert island that has yet to be turned into an all-inclusive resort, youve
probably got a buffet of mixed-up human DNA inside you.
For instance:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Although Johns DNA is about 97% Southern European, hes got about
3% from North Africa, reflecting patterns of migration and the influence of
Arabic trading with the Mediterranean. Hes also got maternal and paternal
lineage of a type most common in the Middle East.
Krista has a smidge of East Asian, possibly from the dominant Mongol
Empire that swept through the Asian and eastern European continent in the
|
13th and 14th centuries. In fact, genetic testing estimates that 1 in 200 men in
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
107
We are all connected. We are family.
Europeans, East Asians, and Neanderthals
Evolution is rarely nice and tidy. There are lots of branches, dead ends, and false
starts.
Genetic data can tell us about our complex journey to modern humanity, as well
as about our closest relatives both living and extinct.
This means that many people of European ancestry carry at least a little bit
of Neanderthal DNA between 1-3% of their total. However, one study on
a sample from a modern human who lived in what is now Romania between
37,000 and 42,000 years ago contained about 6-9% percent Neanderthal
genetic material, more than any other modern human genome that has
yet been sequenced.
This isnt the whole story, though. Research also suggests that the ancestors
of present-day East Asians split from Europeans, then interacted later with
Neanderthals.
In other words, it wasnt a simple process of a single meeting there were many
PRECISION NUTRITION
complex patterns of genetic mixing with different populations over the course of
early human history.
Krista scores 96th percentile for this genetic material; John 67th; and Alaina
38th. If youve got European or East Asian ancestry, you likely have at least a
little Neanderthal in you.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
108
Ethnic variation within a region
The 1992 film White Men Cant Jump, starring Woody Harrelson and Wesley
Snipes, played on the idea that white athletes would be lousy basketball players.
Indeed, black and white are easy, simple categories, often used to divide
and explain the world, whether in terms of ethnicity, ability, perspective, or other
physical and cultural differences.
Theyre complex, laden with historical baggage, and change in subtle but
important meanings from place to place (for instance, Black historically meant
somewhat different groups of people in North America, South Africa, or the UK).
And they dont tell us much about many important features of people.
For now, lets set aside social and political issues of ethnicity, and look at the
physiology.
And we are more alike than other species for instance, there is more genetic
variation among fruit flies than among humans.
PRECISION NUTRITION
We can safely expect, for instance, that an Indigenous person from Australia
whose ancestors arrived on the island about 50,000 years ago will likely
be measurably different than an Indigenous person from an isolated mountain
village in Chile whose ancestors may have crossed the now-vanished Siberian
land bridge across the Bering Strait (between Russia and Alaska) approximately
30,000 years ago.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Some traits (such as facial features or body shape) may be easy to see. Others,
such as immune system variations, may not be.
109
Somewhere around 1.5 to 2 million years ago, a group of early hominins
from Africa walked north and gave rise to most of modern humans. But other
hominins, of course, stayed.
Thanks to this ancient lineage, the massive continent of Africa is one of the most
genetically diverse regions in the world.
For instance, one study found that the average nucleotide diversity was twice
as high among Africans as among Europeans and Asians. North Africans are
genetically distinct from sub-Saharan Africans, since the Sahara Desert would
have been a barrier that few crossed before modern means of transport. The
further from East Africa early human populations traveled, the less genetically
variable they tended to become.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
110
However, areas with lots of trade (such as the Mediterranean or the Malaysian
peninsula) were perfect environments for population and genetic material
exchange. Not surprisingly, there is more genetic diversity in southern than in
northern Europe, which is further away from the busy shipping routes between
the Middle East, Asia and Africa.
Yet even some small regions such as northern Europe have at least a bit of
diversity evidence suggests that multiple waves of early humans ebbed and
flowed into the northern regions of Europe as Ice Ages came and went. And
Melanesia (the area northeast of Australia that contains Papua New Guinea, Fiji
and other small Pacific islands) has significant genetic diversity.
Well see this when we look more closely at specific responses to nutrition and
exercise in the upcoming chapters.
Genetic testing can tell you about your history, which may be more
diverse than you anticipated. After all, your ancestors had lots of time to
mix things up.
PRECISION NUTRITION
How can you trace your lineage?
The words haplotype and haplogroup come to us from the same ancient
Greek root as haploid. |
(in other words, a small chunk of genetic material) inherited together from a
single parent, and a haplogroup as a group of closely linked haplotypes that
tend to be inherited together.
111
Moms lineage: Mitochondrial DNA
Mitochondria are organelles (cell components) that convert energy from food
into a usable form (in humans, thats adenosine triphosphate, or ATP).
Mitochondria have their own DNA (aka mtDNA) that is distinct and independent
from the 46-chromosome DNA of a cells nucleus. There isnt a lot in there only
16,569 base pairs of mitochondrial DNA that code for only 37 genes but this
relatively small snippet of DNA can tell us a lot about ourselves.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Many people have wondered why we have mtDNA, and why the mitochondrial
chromosome is circular, like a bacterial chromosome.
112
In humans, while sperm cells have mitochondria, they seem to get destroyed by
the egg after it is fertilized. We usually inherit mitochondrial DNA only from our
mothers, not our fathers.
So by categorizing mtDNA and looking at where its spread in the world, we can
retrace the footsteps of our female ancestors.
Fun factoid!
Mitochondrial DNA inheritance is rare but does happen in some species, such as
bivalve molluscs. And, to date, it has been discovered in a human male.
Mitochondrial Eve gave rise to the L haplogroups, which formed the basis for all
others, and which eventually branched into other haplogroups spread all over
the world. Later, nomadic humans returned to Africa, bringing fresh haplogroups
(such as H, U6, X1 and potentially M1) back to the homeland.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
113
Figure 5.6: Distribution and migration of L maternal haplogroups from Africa
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
114
However, well only see paternal haplotypes in folks with a Y chromosome
(i.e., most males).
Though it has few genes including the crucial SRY gene (aka testis-
determining factor or TDF) these genes are important. They code for
things that masculinize bodies, such as developing testicles and producing
sperm. The Y chromosome also carries many duplications and noncoding
genes or transcripts.
PRECISION NUTRITION
as health, medication use, nutritional status, body fat, and so forth). It can also
have a strong genetic component that may include mutations to Y chromosome
material.
seen with ancestry, things can get complicated. Maternal ancestors migrated;
branches of haplogroups spontaneously emerged.
115
Here are just a few examples.
Haplotype I
For instance, Tims maternal ancestor haplogroup, I, was known to migrate into
southwestern Asia as well as into northern Europe (some speculate that it was
carried by the Vikings).
His specific haplogroup, I2, is relatively young, perhaps a few thousand years
old. I2 traveled with a woman out of Iran and the Middle East through Anatolia
and into Europe, where its now predominantly a European haplotype.
Haplotype H
Kristas maternal haplogroup is H, originally a Southwestern Asian group about
20-25,000 years old.
R0 has also been found in over half of bone remains from a large pre-Bronze
Age settlement from around 4300-4000 BC, known as Trypillia, which today is in
central Ukraine more or less where Kristas maternal grandfather was from.
John has a later version of the H group, known as H5a1, which may have
emerged around 5,000 to 8,000 years ago in the western Caucasus or Near
East (for example, Syria or Lebanon).
PRECISION NUTRITION
Haplotype U5a1a
Meanwhile, Alaina carries another relatively young haplogroup: U5a1a, which is
between 8-16,000 years old, and commonly found in far northern Europeans,
particularly Scandinavians. |
116
What this means for you
Youve inherited some stuff from your mother, and some stuff from your
father. We can trace your mothers ancestry through mitochondrial DNA. If
you have a Y chromosome, then we can also trace your fathers ancestry.
Genes tend to travel in groups. If you share some known traits with your
populations of ethnic origin and ancestry, youre more likely to share others.
But this isnt for sure; its just a probability.
If you are male and concerned about infertility, genetic testing may be
able to tell you if particular genes on the Y chromosome are involved.
However, there are many other factors that go into determining fertility for
both men and women (such as nutritional status, stress, etc.).
This is pretty cool, right? Knowing our origins and our roots can give us a
sense of wonder and pride about who we are, and how we got here. Many
people from ethnic groups who have been socially marginalized find that
learning about their ancestry and heritage gives them a stronger sense of
identity and purpose. We can also link ourselves to the larger human family.
For example:
PRECISION NUTRITION
People of South Asian descent (i.e., originating from the Indian subcontinent)
tend to have higher rates of visceral adiposity (fat around the middle) and
higher rates of Type 2 diabetes.
when they eat modern Western diets that are heavy in processed foods.
117
This relationship is not straightforward.
For instance, black men in the US have higher rates of cancer than other ethnic
groups, but the same is not true for women. However, both black men and
women in the US are more likely to die of cancer.
PRECISION NUTRITION
And did this difference truly represent a racial divide?
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, some researchers proposed what came to be
known as the slavery hypothesis. This theory suggested that Africans taken
from their homeland and transported to the slave-based economies of the early
Americas and the Caribbean became a genetically distinct group those who
|
survived a long and dangerous trip across the ocean, imprisoned in slave ships,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
The idea was that people with bodies that retained salt better might be more
likely to survive dehydration, starvation, and illnesses such as diarrhea, vomiting,
and fevers. Those few people who survived may then eventually have passed
along those genes once they arrived at the destination.
|
118
In one sense, this is a scientifically attractive hypothesis it seems logical, it
points to a large-scale social phenomenon that may have created biological
changes in a distinct population, and it may help explain underlying factors for
chronic disease. A body that processes electrolytes (such as sodium) in certain
ways may indeed be more predisposed to high blood pressure, which is (in part)
related to the physiology of fluid and electrolyte balance.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Instead, social factors seem to account much more for high blood pressure
and other chronic diseases, particularly in the United States.
Most importantly, social factors such as racism and stress are strongly linked
to chronic diseases.
|
119
So, being of African descent and living in North America may indeed be linked to
high blood pressure or other chronic metabolic diseases but not necessarily
for genetic reasons.
There is no ethnicity gene. There are no genes found only in one broad ethnic
group, although there may be small, localized genetic variations.
Lifestyle factors and body composition (i.e., body size and amount of body fat
/ lean mass) are much more important, as are broader social, economic, and
political determinants of health (such as where people live, what resources they
can access, or the discrimination they may face).
Even if there were a clear genetic basis for certain diseases, such a genetic
basis might require a particular environment (such as one with pollution or easy
access to high-sodium, high-sugar processed fast foods) to be expressed.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
120
What this means for you
Regardless of your biological sex or genetic ancestry, monitor your blood
pressure and other risk factors, especially as you get older. High blood
pressure is a risk factor for many other diseases, such as cardiovascular
diseases. But it doesnt act alone. It works with other lifestyle factors.
Ethnicity is one factor that may change your risk of chronic diseases,
whether because of inherited genetic or social factors. Get regular
checkups where possible.
Control the factors that you can control. You cant control your genetic
ancestry. But there are many ways to reduce your risk of high blood
pressure, such as:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
121
Whats up next: Metabolism
Now that youre thinking about blood pressure, you might also be wondering
about other metabolic factors. Perfect timing!
In the next chapter, well give you an overview of metabolism, and look at some
of the processes that can be affected by genetic factors.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 4 CHAPTER 6
Specific genetic What we found: Metabolism
testing services
|
What should you think about when some of the basic metabolic
considering particular genetic processes, such as how we
testing services? Which services regulate our blood sugar or thyroid
did we choose, and why? output, and how they might be
affected by genetic factors.
|
122
CHAPTER 6
PRECISION NUTRITION
What you can learn about all of this through genetic testing.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
123
Two important points to keep in mind:
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test can tell you what factors might affect your
metabolic health, it doesnt mean that it can tell you the perfect diet,
exercise, or supplement plan for you.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
What is metabolism?
Life is constant change.
By way of the proteins they code for, genes affect all metabolic processes, such
as:
PRECISION NUTRITION
growth, tissue recovery and repair;
processing nutrients and transporting them into cells;
synthesizing hormones and other cell signaling molecules;
establishing basal metabolic rate (aka our idling speed); and
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
how well we digest, absorb, use, and/or store any nutrients we eat.
|
124
Genes are involved in many ways.
For instance:
We could write an entire textbook (or ten) about metabolism, and how genes
may affect it.
For this chapter, well focus on a few key indicators that may affect your
metabolic health, fitness, and function.
In the next chapter, well look at what affects your body weight and composition.
PRECISION NUTRITION
the nervous system: It interprets chemical messages and information from both
inner physiological processes and the outside world into what to do next.
125
For instance, the hypothalamus helps to regulate:
The hypothalamus monitors and responds to signals from inside the body as
well as the outside world, such as:
how much energy we have available or stored (e.g., in the form of body fat or
circulating glucose);
inputs from our autonomic nervous system (ANS), which is the nervous
system that controls internal organs such as our heart, lungs, or digestive
tract;
PRECISION NUTRITION
pathogens such as bacteria or viruses.
126
Peripheral regulation: sensors and storage
Along with central regulation of our metabolism, we are always gathering
information from physiological processes that are happening peripherally in
other parts of the body besides the brain, such as our:
For instance, if our hypothalamus senses we are getting low on stored energy
(perhaps because blood glucose drops, or our body fat stores are getting low), it
triggers our appetite centers, pushing us to eat.
You can think of genetic expression as part of these feedback loops: When stuff
PRECISION NUTRITION
happens, it triggers other stuff to happen (or stop happening).
Gene expression and epigenetic regulation control what gets turned on or off;
what gets enabled or inhibited. The proteins that genes produce respond to one
another, or what substances are circulating nearby, or environmental factors.
Cells secrete and receive molecules, which help them communicate with
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
signaling pathways. These are a series of interactions that trigger each other in
a step-by-step process.
127
Most often, a substance (known as a first messenger) will bind to a receptor on
a cell membrane. This binding sends signals known as second messengers
elsewhere in the cell to do a specific task. This whole process is known as
signal transduction.
Many of the genes that well talk about code for mRNAs that make messenger
proteins in other words, essential parts of metabolic processes. Variations
in the expression of genes that code for these proteins can affect, for example,
whether the signal even makes it to the cell, whether the cell accepts the signal,
whether the first messenger is able to communicate with the second one, and
PRECISION NUTRITION
so forth.
But you can affect these signaling pathways with your lifestyle choices and
environment. |
When you consider all the moving parts of metabolism, its easy to imagine how
genetic factors might play significant and complex roles.
In this chapter, well look at a few biological markers and processes to see how
your genes may play a role, and what you might learn via genetic testing.
|
128
Vitamin D
Looking at vitamin D helps us understand some of the mechanisms by which
genetic expression and regulation can affect our metabolism, which can, in turn,
affect how we respond to stimuli like food and exercise.
Regardless of the source, our bodies need to convert vitamin D into a bioactive
form a form that they can use.
3 | Then, our kidneys convert 25(OH)D to its active form: 1,25(OH)2D (calcitriol
PRECISION NUTRITION
or calciferol). (Other cells can do this as well, such as cells of our immune
system.)
To do steps 2 and 3, our liver and kidneys use the enzymes 25-hydroxylase and
1--hydroxylase, respectively.
Once vitamin D is made into 1,25(OH)2D, it can affect the activity of over 900
|
genes. 1,25(OH)2D that is circulating in our bloodstream can pass through the
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
plasma membrane of cells, and bind to the vitamin D receptor (VDR) in the
cytoplasm. The VDR is a nuclear receptor, which means its then transported
into the nucleus, where it binds to DNA to affect the expression of genes.
|
129
What vitamin D does
1,25(OH)2D has lots of jobs. For instance:
It affects how calcium and phosphate move across the sarcolemma, the
sheath of our muscle fibers, influencing muscular contraction and fueling.
It can regulate our immune system, helping us fight off pathogens such as
viruses or bacteria.
It can strengthen tight junctions, the seals between cells such as our skin
cells or intestinal lining cells (much like mortar between bricks), which also
prevent pathogens from getting in.
It helps to regulate genes involved in glucose and lipid (fat) metabolism. Low
vitamin D is correlated with metabolic problems such as insulin resistance or
hypertension.
Its involved in the health of our reproductive system. Low vitamin D is linked
to diseases such as polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS), ovarian and breast
PRECISION NUTRITION
cancer, and endometriosis. In men, vitamin D levels are correlated with
testosterone levels.
Thus, how our bodies process and use vitamin D significantly affects our health
and fitness.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
People whose vitamin D is low might not recover, build muscle, or fight off
infections as well as those with more vitamin D. People with low vitamin D
may also feel more pain and have more inflammation. (By the way, this doesnt
necessarily mean that low vitamin D is the cause of all of these things. It may be
a correlation or a secondary effect.)
|
130
Genetic variations in using vitamin D
If you understand the basics of how vitamin D works, you can probably imagine
that genetic variation could affect many components of vitamin D metabolism, as
well as vitamin Ds ability to influence genetic expression.
The gene DHCR7 codes for the 7-dehydrocholesterol reductase enzyme, which
converts 7-dehydrocholesterol (7-DHC) to cholesterol. Since both cholesterol
and vitamin D can be synthesized from 7-dehydrocholesterol, a loss of function
mutation in DHCR7 can interrupt vitamin D synthesis.
Hydroxylase polymorphisms
We might differ genetically in how well our bodies are able to make hydroxlases
the family of enzymes that (among other jobs) convert vitamin D2 and D3 to
the form of vitamin D that we can store and use.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Once bioavailable vitamin D enters the cell, it binds to the VDR. There are
several VDR polymorphisms that affect gene expression, and are linked to
many metabolic diseases (such as cancer, diabetes or heart disease), infectious
diseases (such as tuberculosis), autoimmune diseases (such as multiple sclerosis
or asthma), and chronic inflammation.
|
For instance, the FokI variation (rs10735810) can change the length of the VDR
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
protein, which can then change how it works. Other VDR polymorphisms such
as the ApaI variation (rs7975232), the TaqI variation (rs731236) and the BsmI
variation (rs1544410) are linked to a higher risk of bone and connective tissue
disorders (such as spinal disc degeneration, low bone density, and fractures) as
well as other chronic diseases.
|
131
One handy thing about many of these VDR variations: Unlike many genetic
variations, theyve been studied in non-European populations (such as people of
Iranian, Chinese Kazakh, Gujarati, Indonesian, and Kenyan descent). This gives
us some useful data about what these variants effects might be in different
groups of people.
The GC gene codes for the vitamin D binding protein (DBP), otherwise known as
Gc-globulin. This protein binds to and transports vitamin D.
There are 3 common variants of GC (Gc1F, Gc1S and Gc2), along with over 120
rarer variants. (Because these variants are relatively infrequent, they can help
us explore heredity and links between global populations.) People of European
descent tend to have Gc2, which is rare in people of African descent, who
typically have Gc1f instead.
Variations in GC (and hence DBP / Gc-globulin) have been linked to risk of (or
resistance to) many types of diseases, such as osteoporosis, thyroid disease,
diabetes, cardiovascular disease, multiple sclerosis, and more.
PRECISION NUTRITION
well as athletic performance and fitness. Typically, vitamin D deficiency is
correlated with poorer health and recovery.
Given the complexity of vitamin D metabolism, its entirely likely that you
might have a genetic polymorphism that affects your vitamin D levels. The
effect of having this genetic variant may range from significant to minor.
|
Genetic testing may give you useful information about your potential
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
23andMe tests for several dozen VDR SNPs, though it doesnt include
any predictions about vitamin D levels in its trait or health condition lists.
132
It may be simpler and more straightforward to simply do a vitamin D lab
test to assess your current blood levels.
Based on your lab test, you can then work with a nutrition professional to
decide whether vitamin D supplementation (or getting out in the sunshine) is
appropriate.
Thyroid function
Our thyroid, which hugs our windpipe, is an endocrine gland that helps regulate
many important physiological processes.
In turn, this stimulates the production and synthesis of hormones like calcitonin,
triiodothyronine (T3) and thyroxine (T4), which act elsewhere in the body to help
regulate:
PRECISION NUTRITION
sexual and reproductive functions;
sleep;
moods; and
calcium metabolism (which includes bone health and density).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
133
Hypothyroidism and autoimmunity
Many of our Precision Nutrition clients, particularly women, come to us frustrated
because they cant seem to lose fat. Or their digestion is sluggish. Or they dont
seem to have the energy they used to have.
In AITD, as with other autoimmune diseases, the bodys immune system attacks
and slowly destroys healthy tissue in this case, the thyroid gland. Over time,
the thyroid is unable to produce the hormones it needs to support a healthy
metabolism.
Some estimates suggest that AITD affects about 5% of the American population,
and perhaps as many as 10-20% of all women in their lifetime.
While AITD can be inherited, studies using twins and family members show that
environmental factors and stressors also play a role.
The human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene complex that codes for major
histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins in humans. These cell surface
proteins regulate our immune system by helping our cells recognize
foreign molecules. (Well look at HLA genes more when we look at food
PRECISION NUTRITION
sensitivities.)
TPO, which codes for thyroid peroxidase, an enzyme that helps produce
the thyroid hormones T3 and T4.
|
134
Some evidence also suggests that other factors, such as variants in genes
coding for our vitamin D receptors (there they are again!), may play a role.
PTPN22
The PTPN22 gene codes for the protein tyrosine phosphatase, non-receptor
type 22, a protein expressed mostly in lymphoid, or immune system, tissues.
Variations in this gene are associated with autoimmune disorders such as
rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, Type 1 diabetes, and/or Crohns disease.
Research on European subjects found that each copy of an adenine (A) at this
SNP increases a persons odds of hypothyroidism by 1.36 times, and increases
their odds of developing Hashimotos thyroiditis by 1.7 times.
Other research testing PTPN22 variations in a Korean population didnt find the
same results, but another SNP (rs12730735) and a particular haplotype were
both associated with the risk of autoimmune thyroiditis. Similar results were
found in a Chinese population. In a Japanese population, PTPN22 doesnt seem
to have any connection at all to AITD, though having a particular haplotype
seems to offer some protection against the disease.
In a Jordanian population, researchers did not find that rs2476601 played a role,
perhaps because the SNP doesnt often appear in this group. However, it was
found in an Egyptian population, and did increase the risk of AITD.
FOXE1
PRECISION NUTRITION
Forkhead box (FOX) proteins are typically involved in regulating cell growth,
development, differentiation, and survival. FOXE1 codes for forkhead box protein
E1, a protein that helps develop the physical structure of the thyroid.
135
Another SNP near the FOXE1 gene (rs755109) was found to be associated with
TSH levels in an isolated Pacific Island population.
SH2B3
The SH2B3 gene codes for the Src homology 2-B 3 (SH2B3) protein, which is
part of the SH2B family of proteins. These proteins are found in many types of
tissues and cells.
Another study, also in Europeans, showed a link between the rs653178 SNP and
Graves disease.
VAV3
VAV3 codes for a protein (guanine nucleotide exchange factor VAV3) that
regulates the Rho family of proteins, which regulate a wide range of cellular
activities, such as signal transduction. You can think of Rho proteins as cogs in a
PRECISION NUTRITION
communication system that allows your cells to respond properly to external and
internal changes.
Each copy of a C at rs4915077 in the VAV3 gene was associated with 1.3
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
People with the GG genotype at rs2517532 had 1.16 times higher odds of
hypothyroidism compared to those with the AG genotype. Those with the
AA genotype had 1.16 times lower odds of hypothyroidism.
|
136
What we found in our sample
We asked people whether theyd been diagnosed as hypothyroid.
Four people had. So we looked at their genetic data to see how they stacked up.
We also looked at the people who should (by the genetic prediction) have been
at a higher risk.
Our sample is small, so its hard to draw conclusions. But we did find that these
particular SNPs didnt generally have strong predictive value.
PTPN22 rs2476601
Each copy of an adenine (A) in a European population should theoretically
increase a persons risk of hypothyroidism 1.36 times, and their odds of
developing Hashimotos thyroiditis by 1.7 times.
In this sample, we had no highest-risk AAs, but we did have 5 other AGs who
seemed perfectly healthy.
FOXE1 rs7850258
People with the GG (guanine-guanine) genotype at this SNP in the FOXE1 gene
were 1.35 times more likely to have primary hypothyroidism compared to those
with the AG (adenine-guanine) genotype.
PRECISION NUTRITION
In our sample, 2 people with GG had hypothyroidism, while 2 had the AG.
SH2B3 rs3184504
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Having the TT (thymine-thymine) variant of this SNP slightly increased the risk
of having hypothyroidism, while having the CC (cytosine-cytosine) genotype
lowered the risk slightly.
In our hypothyroid sample, we had 2 CCs and 2 CTs, plus two other healthy TTs.
|
137
VAV3 rs2517532 and rs4915077
Each copy of a C at rs4915077 in the VAV3 gene was associated with 1.3 times
the odds of hypothyroidism.
People with the GG genotype at rs2517532 had 1.16 times higher odds of
hypothyroidism compared to those with the AG genotype, and those with the AA
genotype had 1.16 times lower odds of hypothyroidism.
In our sample, 2 had AG (moderate risk) and two had GG (highest risk). 9 other
healthy people also had the higher-risk GG.
Thyroid disease doesnt just affect our thyroid. It can also affect what is
downstream, such as other metabolic processes.
Your specific genetic risk may vary by ethnicity. This might mean a different
gene variant is more significant than another, or that thyroid disease may
emerge from related but distinct pathways.
Even if you have genetic risk factors, it doesnt necessarily mean you will
get a given disease.
Consider the big picture of other contributing factors. For instance, the
prevalence of AITD varies significantly by geography, from 448 cases per
PRECISION NUTRITION
100,000 in Scotland to 273/100,000 in Western Australia, to 27/100,000 in
Spain. Since these countries all have a large population of white European
descent, there are clearly other environmental components at work.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
138
Glucose, insulin and metabolic
syndrome
Glucose, a simple sugar or monosaccharide, is the raw material for building ATP,
our cells energy.
If we eat carbohydrates (say, bread or rice), they break down into glucose when
we digest them. Our pancreas then releases insulin to transport the glucose into
our cells, to be eventually made into ATP or stored as glycogen or fat for later
use.
This process is tightly regulated. Our bodies sense the presence of glucose;
insulin is released as needed; and glucose is stored in cells. When glucose drops
too low, we release stored fuel and our brain sends us the signal to eat.
Both insulin production (i.e., how well we can make insulin) and insulin
resistance (i.e., whether our cells respond appropriately to insulin) are heritable.
Metabolic syndrome
PRECISION NUTRITION
If our blood sugar is consistently higher than normal, this signals a metabolic
problem. We may be in the early stages of prediabetes, or even full-blown Type
2 diabetes (T2D).
This situation, and other phenomena that go with it (such as high blood pressure,
altered blood lipids, fatty deposits in and around internal organs such as liver
or kidneys) are collectively known as metabolic syndrome. (Well look at
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
139
Metabolic syndrome is a complex health problem that involves many processes
and tissues. Over time, almost the entire body can be affected in some way.
For example:
Along with being a storage depot for excess energy, adipose (fat) tissue is part
of our endocrine system: It secretes hormones (such as estrogen or leptin) along
with other cell signals and messengers.
Adipose tissue is closely linked to insulin sensitivity / resistance, and hence, our
PRECISION NUTRITION
risk of T2D. Yet researchers have wondered:
How are some people metabolically healthier than others, even with the same
amount of body fat?
For instance, through its effects on the AMPK signaling pathway, the fat-secreted
hormone adiponectin plays an important role in insulin sensitivity by helping
our muscles and liver oxidize fatty acids and take up glucose. (This is good.)
When we have a lot of adipose tissue, adiponectin tends to go down. (This is
not so good.)
|
140
Yet people may have genetic variants in ADIPOQ, the adiponectin gene, that
change their risk of metabolic disease. For instance, in some populations (such
as East Asians), having the GT/TT version of the rs1501299 SNP (rather than
GG) is associated with a higher rate of metabolic disorders such as fatty liver or
insulin resistance.
So, our risk for metabolic disease may depend not just on the absolute amount
of adipose tissue we have (though past a certain point, even the luckiest
combination of genes cant protect us from the health effects of extremely low or
high amounts of body fat) but on our genetic makeup as well.
Many genes linked to body weight and fatness are also involved in glucose
metabolism.
In general, gene variants associated with higher body weight or more body
fat are also linked to weight gain when people eat a high-carbohydrate diet.
Or that insulin is a silent but deadly killer (as is often claimed by promoters of
low-carb fad diets).
Our genetic makeup may make us more likely to respond in certain ways to
certain nutrients.
PRECISION NUTRITION
This is especially true with processed carbohydrates, since many processed
foods make a lot of sugar available in a form that is digested very quickly (which
means that a lot of sugar hits our system all at once).
Some research suggests that genes that may make us more susceptible
to obesity also affect how our bodies respond to dietary carbohydrates.
|
Importantly, this response often isnt just about carbohydrates, but also about
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
how our bodies manage and mobilize fats. (More on this below.)
Also bear in mind: Research here is often somewhat contradictory. Its not as
simple as saying More sugar is bad.
|
141
PLIN and ADRB2 genes
For instance, there is a complex relationship between carbohydrate intake, body
fatness, and the family of PLIN genes, which code for perilipin (PLIN).
In our fat cells (adipocytes), we have a lipid droplet essentially an oily bubble
of stored fat.
Perilipin surrounds these lipid droplets, and helps control the metabolism of
adipocytes by regulating how fat-mobilizing enzymes (lipases) interact with the
stored fat.
Since the job of lipases is to break down fats so they can be used for energy,
perilipin surrounds the lipid droplet like a protective wall, and ensures that it
doesnt get randomly digested.
These genes and their variants vary by ethnicity, which can (along with many
other genetic factors, of course) affect how lean or fat you may naturally be.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
142
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 6.2: Activation of -adrenoreceptors and effects on perilipin
In general, we usually want our stored fat to be easily available. However, with
some variations of the PLIN genes, which code for perilipin, the perilipin may
be less responsive to the signal to open the gate. Fat stays locked behind the
protective wall.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
143
In a study of Hispanic people of Caribbean origin, researchers found that
when participants with a particular variant of the PLIN gene (PLIN 11482 G > A)
ate more complex, higher-fiber carbs, they were leaner; when they ate fewer
complex carbs, they were more likely to be obese. Interestingly, at least in this
study, simple sugars or total carbohydrates didnt seem to have any relationship
to body fatness, nor did other PLIN variants.
Other studies have confirmed that PLIN variants predict both metabolic
syndrome and weight loss.
Similar results with some PLIN variants and insulin resistance were found in a
Singaporean population made up of Chinese, Malay, and South Asians. These
variants of the PLIN genes may be old ones, present before human populations
diverged.
The association between specific PLIN gene variants and fatness also seemed
related to fat intake, particularly saturated fats when people with two
copies of a PLIN variant consumed carbohydrates and saturated fats, they
were significantly more likely to have insulin resistance, a precursor to Type 2
diabetes.
So we have to be careful about how we interpret results from any single study.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Nevertheless, the findings suggest:
Not all bodies respond the same way to the same diet. Your friend may
thrive on a low-carb, high-fat diet (or a high-carb, low-fat diet), whereas you
may find yourself feeling and performing worse when you try the same
thing. |
Theres no one-size-fits-all diet plan that will work for everyone, all the
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
time. Its important to test, observe, and assess (based on evidence) what
nutrition protocols work best for your unique body.
Genetic testing can give us some clues, but not a detailed prescription,
for your best diet. We still dont completely understand the complex
relationship between genetic variants and metabolic health. Genetic testing
may suggest particular dietary strategies that might help you make wise
dietary choices for your physiological needs.
|
144
Understanding the impact of genetics on metabolism helps you make
informed decisions about your diet. At the very least, genetic testing
may help explain why a particular diet may affect your health or physical
performance. At best, you may find a diet that matches your metabolic
strengths (i.e., what your body prefers).
We know that T2D is correlated with many physiological and lifestyle factors,
such as:
Early studies on Type 2 diabetes (T2D) often used people with more body
fat, who were more likely to develop T2D. It wasnt always clear whether the
progression of T2D was due to environmental effects (for instance, a high-
sugar diet), having a certain amount of body fat, or an underlying genetic
predisposition (in other words, what someone was born with).
Later studies looked at relatively leaner people to account for the environmental
PRECISION NUTRITION
component of T2D, or for the role that adipose tissue gained in later life might
play.
One way to test for insulin resistance and prediabetes is with fasting glucose:
measuring blood sugar levels after a person hasnt eaten for several hours.
Alhough research suggests that genetic variants linked to higher fasting glucose
|
dont always correlate neatly with T2D risk, theres a lot of overlap and fasting
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
145
G6PC2
This SNP appears in the G6PC2 gene, which codes for glucose-6-phosphatase
catalytic subunit-related protein (also known as IGRP), a protein that is expressed
in islet cells of the pancreas.
This SNP is associated with the function of pancreatic beta cells, which store and
release insulin, as well as C-peptide and amylin (which helps control how quickly
glucose is released into the bloodstream).
For reference, a fasting blood glucose level lower than 5.6 mmol/L is considered
normal, while anything over that is considered prediabetic.
PRECISION NUTRITION
We had some blood tests lying around, so we looked for correlations.
One person from of our PN sample had just been diagnosed with prediabetes.
Yet according to the G6PC2 SNP, with a CC profile, they should have had lower
than average blood sugar.
|
We also had 2 TTs, who were predicted to have higher than average blood sugar
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
146
What this means for you
If you are a do-it-yourself kind of person, you can buy a home glucose
monitor and test your glucose throughout the day, including after meals.
Postprandial after meals blood sugar levels will give you a better idea,
sooner, of what your blood glucose is up to, compared to fasting glucose.
If youd like to improve your overall wellness, see our strategies for
healthy metabolism in Chapter 12.
Much like blood glucose, levels of these blood triglycerides and lipoproteins
(proteins that transport lipids) are important indicators of metabolic health. (Well
look more closely at lipids, triglycerides, and lipoproteins below.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
As with glucose, its normal to have some circulating lipids and lipoproteins, but
we dont want too many, too often.
Lipid and lipoprotein levels are strongly influenced by how much body fat we
have along with our environment and our choices, such as our nutrition, our
activity, smoking or drinking, or other medications. They can also be influenced
|
by genetic factors.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Everyone has that proverbial great-aunt who lived to be 103 and swore by her
daily whiskey and buttered bacon sandwich. And as we witness this fiercely
unrepentant and apparently immortal boozing, buttering, and bacon-ing, we ask
ourselves, Why am I eating all this damn healthy food anyway?
147
Some people seem able to consume unhealthy food, drink like a fish, smoke a
pack of cigarettes a day, and make it to triple digits completely unfazed.
Other people seem to do everything right and get taken out by a heart attack
or some other metabolic disease far too early.
And, indeed, it may be unfair, in the sense that some people may be naturally
better at managing their blood lipids than others. This relative advantage may, in
part, be due to genetic factors.
Of course, not all are equally important or strongly linked. Some operate mainly
in particular processes (such as regulating the expression of other genes) or
particular tissues (such as the liver).
We still dont fully know how all genetic variants interact with blood lipids and
other relevant biomarkers.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
148
Lipoproteins and the basic blood lipid panel
If you go to your doctor and get a cholesterol test done, its helpful to
understand what this really means.
Triglycerides are molecules of fat made of three fatty acids hooked to a glycerol
backbone. When we digest fat, our bodies package fatty acids into this format,
and transport them through the bloodstream to be stored in adipose cells.
Lipoproteins are proteins that transport lipids. Oil and water dont mix, and
neither do lipids and blood. Fats have to hitch a ride on lipoproteins, like a bunch
of passengers on a little inner tube floating down a river. Lipoproteins come in
different sizes, amounts, and densities. Density refers to the fat-to-protein ratio:
When theres more fat and less protein, the particles are considered less dense,
and they become more buoyant.
PRECISION NUTRITION
IDLs, or intermediate-density lipoproteins, somewhere between LDL and
VLDL particles.
149
When we get a basic blood lipid panel done at our doctors appointment, it will
most commonly measure:
Generally, we want most of these to be lower, except for HDL, which we want to
be relatively higher.
All of these are risk factors associated with metabolic syndrome and its
associated diseases, although they dont necessarily mean that someone will
always develop health problems.
All of these risk factors can be affected by diet and exercise, along with other
lifestyle choices and environmental factors but can also be partially shaped by
genetics.
For instance, research has found ethnic differences in the LPL and LIPC
genes, which code for lipases (enzymes that help us break down fats) and are
expressed in liver, heart, muscle and fat tissues.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Compared to people of European ancestry, people of African descent (including
West African, Afro-Caribbean and African-American) were more likely to have
particular lipase variants that protected them from coronary atherosclerosis (aka
hardening of the arteries).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
150
What this means for you
Blood lipids are important health indicators. If youd like to know what they
are, measure them directly with a blood test.
Dont rely only on a genetic test. At best, a genetic test can only predict
possible risk. It cant tell you what your blood lipids actually look like.
Get regular bloodwork done. Having your blood lipids tested along with
your blood glucose (see above) as part of your regular medical checkup
(perhaps annually) is a good idea.
Some people are genetically more likely to have higher blood triglycerides, aka
hypertriglyceridemia.
PRECISION NUTRITION
23andMe tests for a SNP known as rs964184 on the ZNF259 gene (which is also
sometimes known as ZPR1).
While Zinc Finger would be a terrific band name (and, indeed, someone has
already created a song that uses the primary structure of another ZNF
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Most proteins with zinc fingers are interaction molecules that are designed to
bind to DNA, RNA, or other protein molecules. So their shape crucially affects
how they are able to do this job.
|
151
The protein coded by ZNF259 binds proteins that are involved in insulin
sensitivity, glucose and fat metabolism, and fat storage, such as peroxisome
proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPAR-) or hepatocyte nuclear factor 4
(HNF4A).
ZNF259 is also located close to another gene complex that is strongly linked
to blood lipids: APOA5A4-C3-A1. Variants in APOA5 affect metabolism of
chylomicrons, VLDL-C, and HDL-C. (Well look at the APO gene family below.)
Other research in Japanese and South Asian populations has found a similar
relationship between ZNF259 and the overall risk of metabolic syndrome.
In this case, having the G form of the rs964184 SNP was linked to having
higher blood triglycerides along with higher fasting plasma glucose and lower
HDL cholesterol.
This suggests, again, that many features of metabolic syndrome are related.
Hypercholesterolemia
Like hypertriglyceridemia, hypercholesterolemia (excessively high blood
cholesterol) can be inherited, a condition known as familial hypercholesterolemia
(FH). FH is a risk factor for metabolic syndrome and related health problems like
cardiovascular disease.
FH happens when genetic variations affect our bodys ability to clear LDL
effectively from the blood. Over time, LDL and its cholesterol passengers can
build up in tissues such as our blood vessels or connective tissues.
PRECISION NUTRITION
The most common genetic cause of FH is variations in the LDLR gene. LDLR
codes for the low-density lipoprotein receptor that determines whether LDL-C
can bind to a cell, and then be transported into it for safe storage. About 80-90%
of people with FH who are genetically tested show variations in this gene.
23andMe looks at two variations in the APOB gene that are linked to FH:
152
What we found in our sample
Several PN team members sampled reported having had a total cholesterol test
that was higher than average.
Yet none of these people had the genetic variants of APOB that suggested they
should have this profile.
Interestingly, all of these people were fit, often leaner than average. This tells us
that other factors are probably at work in these higher-than-average blood tests.
Blood lipids are important health indicators. If youd like to know what they
are, have them measured directly with a blood test.
Dont rely only on a genetic test. At best, a genetic test can only predict
possible risk. It cant tell you what your blood lipids actually look like.
Get regular bloodwork done. Having your blood lipids tested along with
your blood glucose (see above) as part of your regular medical checkup
(perhaps annually) is a good idea.
Alzheimers disease
PRECISION NUTRITION
Alzheimers disease is a neurodegenerative disease in which brain cells and
their connections slowly break down, while wastes, plaques, and other bits of
crud (such as neurofibrillary tangles, which are sort of like the hairballs that clog
up drains) build up.
Alzheimers is a frightening prospect, and this fear may affect our choice to have
our DNA tested.
|
153
Many of us at PN researching genetic data asked our parents to take part. Some
parents were game. Some parents were not.
Currently, more than 5 million people in the US alone are diagnosed with
Alzheimers disease, and this number is expected to triple by 2050. 1 in 9 people
over 65 has some form of neurodegeneration attributed to Alzheimers; over 1 in
3 people over 85 does. Its one of the fastest-growing causes of death for
older people.
Alzheimers does, indeed, run in families. But, much like Type 2 diabetes and other
chronic diseases, while Alzheimers is a genetic risk, it is not a genetic destiny.
One of the known genetic risk factors in developing Alzheimers disease is our
friend the apolipoprotein in this case, a variant on the APOE gene, which
codes for the protein apolipoprotein E, a cholesterol carrier found in the brain
and elsewhere in the body.
The APOE protein comes in three forms: 2, 3, and 4. (The is the Greek
letter epsilon.)
The APO 4 variant is a major risk factor for Alzheimers in many populations,
and seems to span people of European, African, and East Asian descent. In fact,
PRECISION NUTRITION
compared to the averages for both of those groups:
associated with 4 times higher odds; two copies is associated with 12 times
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
higher odds.
|
154
While the APO 4 variant is associated with a higher risk of developing
Alzheimers, it doesnt act alone. For instance, risk increases when in addition
to the APO 4 variant people also have:
A particular variant of rs2373115, a SNP in the GAB2 gene, which codes for
the growth factor receptor-bound protein 2 (GRB2). This protein is involved
in signaling and communication within and between cells.
A particular form of rs1799724, a SNP near the tumor necrosis factor (TNF)
gene, associated with altered levels of beta-amyloid plaques (one of the
particular plaque types linked to Alzheimers) in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).
Understand your data clearly. Be sure to discuss all results with your doctor
and/or genetic counsellor, to understand the findings and discover what you
can do to lower your risk.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
155
Whats up next
Now that we have a basic understanding of how metabolism works, and a few
genetic factors that may affect it, lets look at how genetics can also influence
our body size, shape, and fatness (or leanness).
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 5 CHAPTER 7
What we found: Heredity What we found: Body
weight and body comp
|
156
CHAPTER 7
How body size, weight, and composition (i.e., our ratio of lean mass to
fat mass) are complex phenomena that are in part, shaped by genetic
mechanisms but not as much as we might assume;
PRECISION NUTRITION
The role of other environmental factors, such as food availability, food
reward, eating behaviors, and so on.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
157
Two important points to keep in mind:
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test can tell you what body weight or composition
you might have, it doesnt mean that it can tell you the perfect diet,
supplement, or exercise plan for you.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
PRECISION NUTRITION
But is it really that simple?
(Spoiler alert: Ha ha! Its biology! You already know by now that it aint.)
Body weight, body composition (i.e., our ratio of lean to fat mass) and
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
But they are also affected by our environment and lifestyle choices.
|
158
Energy balance, nutrient processing, and eating
behavior
Why do you eat? (Or not eat?)
There are many processes that affect body weight and composition:
Energy balance: The balance between food energy consumed, and energy
being expended to support our metabolism and activity. If more energy
comes in than goes out, we will gain mass. If less energy comes in than goes
out, we will lose mass. Thus, our energy balance determines body mass.
Energy sensing: Our bodies ability to know how much energy we have
available (for instance, in the form of stored fat).
Nutrient partitioning: Will the nutrients you eat be stored (e.g., as fat or
muscle glycogen) used (e.g., to build muscles, to repair damaged tissues, to
fuel cellular activities), or burned off as heat?
Appetite and food reward: Do we want to eat? Does eating seem fun and
interesting?
Of course, all of these are influenced by the interactions between our genes and
our environment.
PRECISION NUTRITION
As you can imagine, there are many genes involved in regulating metabolism,
body weight or fatness, and eating habits.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
159
Here are just a handful. As you read about what each one does, try to imagine
how mutations in these genes might have a physiological consequence:
There are 21 APO family genes that code for apolipoproteins, a large family
of molecules involved in lipid transport and processing. We looked at the
role of some APO proteins in the previous chapter.
LEPR, which codes for the leptin receptor. Leptin is a hormone involved in
sensing how much energy we have available, whether stored in the form of
body fat, or how much weve recently eaten.
MC4R, which codes for the melanocortin receptor. The encoded protein
interacts with adrenal and pituitary hormones. Defects in this gene can
cause autosomal dominant obesity, meaning that you only need one copy
of a gene variant to see effects.
FTO, which codes for fat mass and obesity-associated protein, is related to
glucose and energy metabolism, as well as the regulation of body fatness
and size. FTO is also an RNA editor and is involved in regulation of muscle.
Well look at FTO more below.
PRECISION NUTRITION
LRP5, which codes for bone mass. LRP5 gene mutations are associated with
lower bone density and a higher risk of osteoporotic fractures.
There are also genes involved in regulating eating behavior and energy balance
(the balance between energy in from food, and energy out from metabolism and
activity).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
160
These include:
Related to this process is the gene ADRB3, which codes for a protein in the
beta adrenergic receptor family. Beta adrenergic receptors are found mostly
in fat tissue, and help regulate lipolysis (fat breakdown) and thermogenesis
(heat production).
GHRL codes for two proteins: ghrelin and obestatin. Ghrelin goes up when
we are hungry, stimulating hunger. The function of obestatin isnt completely
clear yet, but it may oppose the action of ghrelin.
PRECISION NUTRITION
weight. The higher BMI is, the heavier someone is for their height.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
161
The World Health Organization divides BMI into the following categories.
BMI Category
25.029.9 Overweight
To put this in real terms, lets say we have a person who is 56 (1.68 m) tall.
PRECISION NUTRITION
25.029.9 Overweight 155 to 185 lb (~70-84 kg)
162
What can BMI tell us?
In general, we know that at the population level (in other words, in a big group of
people), if you have a higher BMI (past a certain point), you are more likely to:
At the individual level (i.e., you), BMI is often too broad to be helpful.
BMI tells us only how much body mass someone has, not what that mass is
made of.
So a fit and lean but heavy rugby or American football player may have the
same BMI as a sedentary person with much more body fat and much less dense
muscle and bone. Similarly, an extremely lean ultramarathoner with naturally
lighter bones may be designated as underweight though they are still also very
fit and strong.
PRECISION NUTRITION
obese despite being fit and athletic, perhaps even leaner than average.
Body composition
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Thus, along with height and weight, we also look at body composition: the
relative proportion of fat and lean mass (which, again, includes muscle, bone,
and connective tissues).
163
Well look at data from some genome-wide association studies (GWAS) that
uses the extremely precise computed tomography (CT) method, below.
How measurements of BMI and body composition are taken and used can
affect our conclusions.
Variations in BMI
Though many risk factors (such as FTO gene variants, which well look at below)
seem to be common across most groups, various populations differ in their risk.
For instance, although people of East Asian and South Asian origin tend to be
among the worlds lightest and smallest (both traits shaped by heredity), they
have a higher risk of metabolic disease at a lower BMI than people of European
ancestry.
This means that knowing BMI alone, or potential links between genes and BMI,
may not fully predict health or disease for people from certain groups.
Height is strongly shaped by genetics, but weve been getting taller and taller
over the last several decades. Were also getting heavier.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
164
In 1996, about 52% of Bangladeshi women were considered underweight (BMI
lower than 18.5). Today, its only about 30%.
Eritrea 37.30 NA NA
Data from WHO Global Database on Body Mass Index (BMI). Data for height / weight are most
recent data available.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Although the United States, on average, has some of the worlds tallest and
heaviest people, there are differences by ethnic group. (See table below.)
(As weve seen, theres significant variation within broader groups. For
instance, labels like Asian American or Latin American, as are used in the
|
US Census, are pretty loose categories that cover a wide range of groups
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
People from a given ethnic group not born in the US are more likely to have a
lower BMI than their American-born genetic relatives.
(In other words, if you were born and raised in Somalia or Thailand, and your
genetically similar sibling was born and raised in the US, theyd probably be
heavier than you even if you later moved to the US to join them.)
|
165
Heaviest countries in the world: Percentage of women with BMI higher
than 30
American Samoa
37.30 NA NA
European American
32.8 165.0 cm 55
Australia 24 163.8 cm 54
Data from Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Kit BK, Flegal KM. Prevalence of childhood and adult obesity in
the United States, 2011-2012. JAMA. 2014;311(8):806-814. doi:10.1001/jama.2014.73
PRECISION NUTRITION
BMIs here and elsewhere in the world are going up, often quickly.
This suggests that other factors besides genes are probably contributing.
If, as weve seen, body size and mass depend on factors like energy balance or
sensing, as well as eating and activity patterns, then changing environments can
often disrupt our natural regulatory systems as well.
|
166
This can include, for instance:
changes in chronic stressors e.g., well everything that were all freaking
out about right now.
So even if we have light / small genes or heavy / big genes (were there
such things), our environment would still strongly affect our BMI and body
PRECISION NUTRITION
composition.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
167
What this means for you
PRECISION NUTRITION
habits have a disease or addiction.
168
For example:
Most humans evolved to store body fat. Humans who couldnt do this well
would risk starvation during times of scarcity. In particular, women need to
have enough body fat to support the potential long-term energy demands of
pregnancy and breastfeeding.
Most humans evolved to prefer things that taste good, and to want to
eat lots of food when its available. For most of our history, food was hard
to get, and sweetness signaled things that were energy-dense and good
to eat. This legacy affects our appetite, hunger, and fullness signals and
regulation, especially in the 21st century when delicious, energy-rich foods
are everywhere.
Most humans evolved to seek rewards. What gets us off our butts and out
of the safety of the burrow? The promise of something good. Our brains
have complex circuits that inspire us to explore, be curious, and chase
things that reward us (such as food, fun, and mates). Many types of energy-
dense foods give us a chemical hit, helping us synthesize feel-good
neurotransmitters.
So having some squish on your body, or loving ice cream, or preferring to lie on
the couch rather than go to the gym, doesnt mean your body is broken.
It probably means your genes are doing their job of finding and conserving
precious energy.
Traits that were evolutionary advantages for most of our history when food
was scarce, daily energy demands were high, and rewards were hard to come
PRECISION NUTRITION
by are simply a mismatch now. Especially if we want to be lean or stay away
from the chocolate-covered pretzels.
Lets say we have two genetically identical people in other words, identical
twins.
169
Why the difference?
Good question.
One of the most useful ways to explore the contribution of genes and
environment, particularly when it comes to body size and metabolism, is to look
at twin studies.
Identical twins, of course, share the same genetic blueprint, and often the same
early-life experiences. Yet they end up looking different as adults if they do
different things, or live in different environments.
If we examine our two different-looking twins perhaps one twin is leaner and
lighter, while the other is significantly overweight or obese what might we
find?
For instance, if one twin hogs all the nutrients while both twins are in the womb,
this also affects genes such as IGF1R, which codes for insulin-like growth factor
1. IGF1 is an important protein involved in anabolism (growth) and development,
and thus affects body size and mass.
Fun factoid!
The gene that codes for another insulin-like growth factor, IGF2, is only expressed
from paternal inheritance in other words, the genetic material you got from dad.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
170
As adults, compared to their leaner twins:
Obese twins tend to have more fat in the areas wed expect: under the
skin (subcutaneous fat), around the internal organs (visceral fat), marbled in
muscle tissue (intramuscular fat) and laced into the liver and kidneys.
Obese twins immune systems are more highly activated (aka upregulated),
as if preparing to fight off pathogens. One study found that the most
overexpressed gene in obese twins is SPP1, which codes for osteopontin,
a cytokine (cell signaling molecule) that helps recruit immune cells such as
macrophages and T cells during inflammatory processes.
Obese twins have other gene pathways that are less expressed (i.e.,
downregulated), such as pathways involved in energy metabolism and/or
breaking down fatty acids and amino acids.
Obese twins have fewer copies of mitochondrial DNA in their fat tissue
sometimes nearly half as much as their leaner twins. This might partly
explain the metabolic problems we see. Defects in mitochondrial energy
metabolism in subcutaneous adipose tissue may encourage the body to
store fat elsewhere, particularly in tissues that are especially sensitive to
insulin (such as the liver, skeletal muscle, and pancreas), resulting in severe
insulin resistance.
Obese twins often prefer fatty or sugary foods more than their leaner
siblings.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Given, again, that each pair of monozygotic (identical) twins are essentially
genetic clones, these differences tell us:
Body size, fatness, and metabolic health are not just about the genetic code
we are given.
171
The good news, though, is that many of these up- or down-regulations can
change if:
To date, we know of about 185 genes that are implicated in obesity or more
accurately, in making it slightly more likely that a person may be heavier or fatter
than average.
More advanced GWAS using computed tomography (CT) let researchers look
at various types of body fat and differentiate visceral fat (around the internal
organs) from subcutaneous fat (under the skin).
Such studies have, to date, only confirmed links between fat and 8 SNPs near
the following genes:
PRECISION NUTRITION
FLJ35779, which codes for POC5, a protein involved in regulating cell
mitosis and structure. POC5 is mostly expressed in the prostate. Other key
sites include thymus, mammary gland, and bone marrow.
GIPR, which codes for receptors involved with signaling for gastric inhibitory
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
172
LINGO2, which codes for a protein called leucine-rich repeat and
immunoglobulin domain (LINGO), involved in growth and regulation of axons
in the nervous system (for instance, its linked to Parkinsons disease). Its
also involved in cell signaling (aka signal transduction), the process by
which cells send chemical messages to each other. (Youll remember we
learned about signaling pathways in Chapter 6.) Its not clear exactly how
this protein contributes, though.
NEGR1, which codes for neuronal growth regulation factor 1 (NEGR1). This
protein, strongly expressed in the hypothalamus (which, youll remember
from Chapter 6, helps regulate body weight and appetite), seems to play a
role in brain function and structural integrity. Its also expressed in adipose
tissue, particularly subcutaneous fat. This gene showed up in a study of
patients with bulimia nervosa, and correlated with some of the cognitive
dimensions of disordered eating, such as having poor interoception (i.e.,
being able to correctly read signals from inside ones body).
PRECISION NUTRITION
depending on height).
Each of these genes can affect a different yet related physiological process: fat
or glucose metabolism, cell signaling and gene regulation pathways, membrane
transport, etc. |
While there are certainly some rare genetic conditions that can make a
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
few people more likely to be obese, its not as clear-cut as many people
might think.
173
Even in extreme cases of apparently genetic obesity that dont respond to
nutrition and exercise, the most common mutations (in the melanocortin-4
receptor gene) only appear in 1-6% of people with obesity.
Allelic heterogeneity
Lets say on a few separate occasions, you eat:
The foods that caused that heartburn were different, but all might fall loosely
under the heading of foods you might eat at a carnival.
Allelic heterogeneity works the same way: Related genetic variants, or alleles
(different types of junk food), in the same general location (our carnival) are
associated with the same trait or outcome (heartburn).
This means that if we look only at hot dogs, or only at pie-eating contests, we
might miss the fact that a wide variety of foods might lead to the same result.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Similarly, if we look only at one gene variant, we might not realize that many
related gene variants can affect the same biological process. In the case of
obesity, this is certainly true.
(And come to think of it, most carnival foods dont do our metabolism any favors.)
Many studies on the relationship between body fatness / size and genetics look
at several genetic variants, and create a risk score.
This score simply adds up all the known possibilities from each combination of
variants, and decides how likely (or not) a certain outcome is.
|
174
Lets say a study looks at 10 different genetic variants that are known to affect
body fatness / size. And lets say you have 4 of those variants. Now you have a
risk score of 4, which may explain 0.1% of your body fatness.
Most research has found that even with elaborate risk scores (for instance, with
a dozen or more genetic variants known to affect body fatness / size), specific
genetic combinations may only explain 1 or 2% of the differences in body weight.
So even if you have, say, 15 or 20 of the known genetic variations that make
you more likely to have more body fat than average, those variations may only
explain 2% of the reasons why youre bigger than your buddy.
For instance, a study done in people with Han Chinese ancestry explored 26
genetic variants that might affect BMI.
Of those, four variants (TMEM18, PCSK1, BDNF and MAP2K5) were statistically
significant for a BMI 0.13 higher per variant.
Thus, having all four statistically significant variants might give you a BMI thats
0.52 higher than average, assuming all your other environmental conditions are
the same as everyone else.
Your average buddy might be 150 lb (68 kg), with a BMI of 24.2, in the
healthy range.
You with your four genetic variants might be 153 lb (69.4 kg), with a BMI
of 24.7.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Another study that looked at approximately 12,500 people of European descent
concluded that lifestyle factors, particularly exercise, explained about 6 times
more of the BMI variation than genetic factors.
This means that even if you have quite a lot of genetic variations that make
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
you more likely to be heavier or fatter, those variations only play small roles.
What you eat, how you exercise, your daily routines, your stress level all of
these are far more important in shaping how your genetics are expressed.
Obviously, we cant look at all the genes that might affect your personal body
size and shape.
|
175
But lets look at one that may play a major role: FTO.
FTO
The FTO gene codes for a protein known as fat mass and obesity-associated
protein. It regulates the expression of genes involved in metabolism by
demethylating nucleic acids.
When DNA or RNA is methylated, certain genes are often switched off, which
can be a problem if you want those genes to be transcribed and protein made.
FTO can reverse this process with demethylation removing the methyl group,
and switching on certain genes by increasing gene transcription. Well look
more at methylation in Chapter 8.
The FTO gene is an ancient one, found in many vertebrates. It may have
appeared about 450 million years ago. It even appears in algae, though not
other invertebrates, which suggests that perhaps a horizontal gene transfer
occurred.
Originally, researchers discovered the FTO gene in mice with odd-looking feet,
leading to the original gene name of Ft fused toes.
FTO was one of the first genes to be identified in GWAS. Unlike many other
genes linked to particular traits, its effects in many populations have been fairly
well replicated.
FTO is expressed throughout the body (for instance, in fat, stomach, and skeletal
PRECISION NUTRITION
muscle tissue) but most strongly in the brain, particularly in regions associated
with energy balance and reward-seeking. This suggests that FTO may also
be involved in particular behaviors, such as appetite regulation, self-control or
impulsivity.
physiological processes and behaviors that affect body size and fatness. Indeed,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Many SNPs on the FTO gene have been explored, and potentially linked to
differences in body fatness.
Importantly, these SNPs may not cause changes in body fat; they may simply
predict it. Other factors may be involved.
|
176
These SNPs include:
rs1121980, strongly linked to adult obesity (BMI > 40) with odds ratio of 1.55
in a population of French individuals of European ancestry.
Thus, having particular FTO variations probably means that if you have more
body weight (i.e., a higher BMI), its from body fat rather than lean mass.
PRECISION NUTRITION
larger cluster of FTO SNPs that may relate to BMI, whereas in populations
of African ancestry, there seem to be fewer BMI-related SNPs across a
smaller region.
That said, other more detailed studies in smaller populations (such as Old Order
Amish or Japanese) have also found other SNPs that seem significant to that
|
Old Order Amish, but hadnt been previously associated with obesity in other
studies.
To date, about 90 genetic variants within FTO have been associated with BMI.
177
In particular, 23andMe highlights the SNP rs9939609. People with an AA
genotype for this SNP tend to have a higher BMI, while people with TT tend to
be lower. (ATs are typical odds.)
The 16% of European adults who were AA weighed about 6-7 lbs (about 3 kg)
more than those who were AT or TT. Their chance of being obese was 1.67
times greater.
Other research in Europeans suggests that the AA form was linked to feeling
less satisfied after meals. Some AAs also seemed to have loss-of-control eating
episodes, especially with high-fat foods.
Yet, this SNP did not always seem to have the same relationship for people of
Han Chinese descent, nor did it appear as often in general in that population.
Same goes for several Oceanic populations (Melanesians, Micronesians, and
Polynesians) and a Gambian population in Africa.
In addition, the rs9939609 SNP seemed to flip its function depending on age
before about age 3, having the AA version was associated with lower body
weight.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Well we still dont have the whole picture just yet.
Basically:
Some studies suggest that FTO can affect body size, fatness, and weight loss,
but its not clear to what extent.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
As with other genetic variants that may predispose people to more body fat,
physical activity often seems to override any potential FTO effect on body mass.
|
178
One systematic review found that no matter what type of rs9939609 FTO variant
people had, they responded equally well to weight-loss interventions such as
improving their diet, getting more exercise, or taking weight-loss drugs.
In other words:
Regardless of your genetic makeup, the way to get and stay relatively lean, fit,
and healthy is the same for everyone.
Interestingly, this SNP was also linked to other traits, such as:
Note that each SNP combination has a slightly different possible outcome. For
PRECISION NUTRITION
instance, some predict a higher, typical, and lower BMI. Others might predict
only higher-than-typical and typical (rather than lower).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
179
Gene SNP Variants and trait associated with each
On average, the trend for the PN folks was to be heavier than predicted by a
PRECISION NUTRITION
given SNP.
(This makes sense if we think about the PN population, which is likely to have
more lean body mass than average.)
Second, many people had the wrong SNPs for the predicted outcome.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
For instance, people whose SNP combos said they should be heavier were
actually lighter. People who should be lighter were actually heavier often
significantly.
180
For instance, if they said theyd always been lean / normal, their histories and
BMI showed this. Or if they said theyd always struggled with their weight / fat,
their histories and BMI showed this as well.
In particular, some people who were heavier also said they didnt feel like they
had a shutoff switch with eating. They often found it hard to stop when theyd
had enough.
Nor did liking sugar correlate to body weight. Some of the biggest sugar fiends
in the group were normal weight, perhaps even on the low end of normal.
In particular, many people reported struggling with their weight even if they had
maintained a consistently normal or even low BMI or body fat level for most of
their lives.
BMI (and body fat percentage) can be objectively measured, and potentially
connected to genetic variants, especially with a large population.
PRECISION NUTRITION
be a certain way, might we make choices that reflect that? Might we self-
report as different than we really are, thus confounding the data?
Once we get our test results, which results will we believe? For instance,
you are technically obese but your genetic test tells you that you have
skinny genes, how might you respond? Will this result inspire you, puzzle
you, demotivate you, or somehow change your perspective about your body?
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
181
What this means for you
Your genes are probably working just fine. Most humans have evolved to
store body fat, enjoy eating tasty things, and avoid unnecessary activity. If
you have more body fat than you (or current social norms) would prefer, like
eating tasty things, and dont always feel motivated to exercise, it doesnt
mean there is anything genetically wrong with you.
Even if you carry a ton of genetic variants that may make it more likely
that youll be heavier or have more body fat than average, these will likely
only explain a small percentage of your body size and fat levels.
If you want to change your body weight and/or body fat levels, look at
your environment and behaviors. Nutrition and lifestyle habits (such as
smoking or drinking), plus regular physical activity are the most important
factors affecting body weight and body fat.
Again:
No matter what your genes are, the path to get and stay lean, healthy, and fit
is more or less the same for everyone.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Well look specifically at what you can do in the last chapter of the book.
What about the opposite end of the spectrum of BMI being lighter, smaller, or
thinner than average?
182
One group of researchers initially studying extreme cases of apparently genetic
obesity discovered that the opposite of a particular genetic configuration
that is, duplication of a short region on chromosome 16, rather than a deletion
resulted in the opposite body weight as well. Duplication was often associated
with being underweight, while deletion was associated with being obese.
As with the higher end of the BMI spectrum, being significantly thinner / smaller /
lighter than average often means that energy balance is out of sync with normal
physiological demands. Of course, this often happens when we are sick, injured,
or under extreme stress.
But when circumstances are otherwise normal, very low BMI usually means
that people are eating much less food than their body might need in order to
function properly.
Orexins are hormones that regulate appetite. (Interestingly, no clear link has been
found between HCRT, the gene that codes for orexins, and weight.)
Low appetite can happen for many reasons: illness, injury, stress, aging, medications,
and so forth.
Anorexia nervosa is a form of disordered eating and persistent food restriction thats
usually accompanied by an unusually low body weight, an intense fear of gaining
weight, and a distorted perception of body weight.
PRECISION NUTRITION
People may be choosing to eat less (thus overriding their natural desire to eat).
Or they may be responding to strong signals from their appetite centers that tell
them to stop eating, even though the body is not necessarily getting the energy
or nutrients it requires. (This latter situation is common in older people for
various physiological reasons, and is known as the anorexia of aging.)
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Again, there are many factors involved in having a significantly lower body
weight or less body fat than average, including several possible genetic
contributors.
|
183
BDNF
One of the most-studied genes is variations on the BDNF gene, which can affect
metabolism, eating behaviors, and activity.
The suffix -troph comes from the ancient Greek trophe, meaning food
or nourishment, and generally refers to growth. Thus, neurotrophins are
chemicals involved in the growth, development, differentiation, and survival of
neurons, the cells of our nervous system.
BDNF is found throughout our nervous system, as well as in our blood and other
tissues such as the retinas of our eyes, the kidneys, skeletal muscle, and the
prostate.
For instance:
PRECISION NUTRITION
It helps regulate metabolism, body weight, and energy balance (food energy
in versus metabolic or movement energy out).
activity behaviors, variations in the BDNF gene can be related to both lower and
higher body mass. BDNF protein levels are often low in people who are obese
or have Type 2 diabetes.
Conversely, exercise can increase BDNF levels, suggesting that even if we have
a particular genetic variant of the BDNF gene, we can change how much BDNF
protein we actually have circulating.
|
184
BDNF expression can also be affected by other epigenetic factors from the
environment, such as:
Other research in participants of European descent has found that people with
the met66 variant of BDNF were more likely to have various types of disordered
eating behaviors, such as restricting food, binge eating, or purging.
These variants of BDNF didnt just affect eating behavior; they were also
involved in other behaviors like avoiding harm or taking risks.
By the way, remember our FTO gene from above, particularly the rs9939609
SNP? Of course you do! Well, it too may be involved in disordered eating,
including restricting-type behaviors.
PRECISION NUTRITION
This tells us that FTOs role is more complicated than simply being a fat gene.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
185
Other sets of genes that may be involved in disordered eating behaviors include:
genes such as MAOA (monoamine oxidase A), NET (NE transporter), and/or
SERT (serotonin transporter) related to synthesizing and transporting feel-
good neurotransmitters like oxytocin and serotonin;
genes such as CNR1 (endocannabinoid CB1 receptor) and FAAH (fatty acid
amide hydrolase) related to endocannabinoid pathways. These are involved
in various processes such as our stress response, maintaining homeostasis,
perceiving or dulling pain, and regulating food motivation and appetite
(which is why using cannabis often gives you the munchies and is used for
medical patients who have lost their appetite);
genes involved in monitoring energy balance, such as LEP, which codes for
leptin, a hormone that senses how much stored fat we have;
genes related to appetite peptides such as GHRL, which codes for ghrelin, a
potent stimulator of hunger; and
We asked our test population whether theyd consistently or often done any of
the following disordered eating-type behaviors:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Compensated for their eating (for instance, by restricting their food the next
day, or by exercising a lot);
Thought a lot about restricting food, going on a diet, specific food choices,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
186
Heres what they said:
Figure 7.2: Percent of people reporting disrupted eating and exercise behaviors
OK, so does that mean that three-quarters of our sample has the genes for
disordered eating because theyve gone on strict diets?
Or that over two-thirds have a genetic inability to manage their appetite because
they over-ate, or ate foods they craved when they werent hungry?
Or does that mean that this is common behavior in 2017? Especially for health-
conscious, fitness-oriented people?
Our guess is that it probably means that average or normal genes (in other
words, a genetic makeup without any unusually strong predisposition to do
PRECISION NUTRITION
these things) can interact with our 21st-century environment that is:
full of tasty, easily accessible, crave-able foods that are hard to stop eating.
|
187
What this means for you
Genes affect our body shape, size, and leanness or fatness. You are at
least slightly predisposed to have a certain physical makeup. However, you
are not destined to have a certain physical makeup.
Genes also affect the processes that happen when our body shape is
smaller or bigger, leaner or fatter. For instance, if we gain or lose body fat,
we can up- or down-regulate genes involved in processes like inflammation
or blood sugar regulation.
Human body shape and size is normally variable and diverse. There are
many ways to have a healthy, fit, and functional body. Bodies come in
all shapes and sizes. Some of that is inherited and some it is acquired or
influenced by our environment. Even if you have many genetic variations
that might predispose you to be a certain body shape or size, you are
probably well within the range of average in most ways. Few genetic
disorders are so extreme that they put you outside of normal human
variation.
Your body size and shape does not necessarily tell us everything about
your genes or your behavior. For instance, we dont know for sure that:
a person with a lower body weight is purposely eating less. They may
also be genetically more likely to burn off excess energy as heat, for
example, or have a stronger stop eating signal.
a person with a higher body weight is purposely eating more. They may
also be genetically inclined to store nutrients as fat, or have a stronger
appetite and reward system.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Energy balance, metabolism, and eating behaviors are all complex
phenomena. A change in one can affect the others.
Our environment matters. Consider what is around you: the cues, foods
available, social norms, stressors, and so forth.
Many factors that affect body weight and fat are within our control.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Despite our natural inclinations and makeup, we can choose to eat less or
more, to be more or less active, to eat particular foods, and so on. Well look
specifically at what you can do in Chapter 12.
|
188
Whats up next
In the next chapter, well continue with the theme of food to look at food
preferences, and how these may be affected by our genetic makeup.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 6 CHAPTER 8
What we found: Metabolism What we found: Food
preferences
|
189
CHAPTER 8
some of the genetic and environmental factors that can affect food
choices and preferences, such as whether we like:
sweet tastes;
fatty tastes;
bitter tastes; or
cilantro (coriander); and
PRECISION NUTRITION
what genetic testing can tell us (or not) about food preferences.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
190
Two important points to keep in mind:
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test can tell you what kinds of tastes you might
prefer doesnt mean that it can tell you the perfect diet or supplement
for you.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
Over the years, weve explored human variation and why the concept of a single,
one-size-fits-all perfect diet doesnt make sense.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Non-genetic factors can affect nutrition and
food choices.
There are many non-genetic factors to consider in developing an optimal
nutrition plan for each one of our clients.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
191
For instance, we might ask:
What else is happening in their lives? Are they busy? Working? Students?
Parents?
How is their overall health right now? Are they injured or ill?
What emotional associations do they have with food?
Etc.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Genetic factors can affect nutrition and food
choices too.
For example:
|
192
This may be because:
of the physical structures of tasting (such as how many taste buds we have,
or how densely packed they are);
of how we process those tastes at the molecular signaling level (for instance,
whether we can chemically sense some types of compounds); and
When you drink milk or eat ice cream, do your intestines regret it?
Along with other factors, such as the health of our gastrointestinal tract, our
genetic makeup can affect which foods we digest well, and which ones we dont.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Vitamin D isnt the only nutrient whose digestion, absorption, or use can be
affected by genetic variation.
193
Why do we prefer particular tastes?
Our taste preferences are strongly shaped by
the culture and social milieu that we grew up in.
If you grew up Anglo in North America, you probably have particular taste
preferences and food routines. For instance, breakfast for you might be toast or
cereal with orange juice. You probably like things to be sweet, and you might not
like too many things that are bitter or pungent.
Meanwhile, in Japan, you might be enjoying fish and miso soup for breakfast. In
Sweden, you might be tucking into a smoked herring and dark rye bread smorgs
(open-faced sandwich) with strong coffee. In Nigeria, you might be longing for your
grandmothers traditional akamu, or fermented sour corn porridge.
We can discover (and learn to love) new tastes and textures with travel
whether we literally go to new places, or simply explore the world of cuisine
around us.
Genetic data suggest that to some degree, our tastes are also shaped
by heredity.
If you have had a lifelong preference for sugar, or a lifelong hatred of cilantro
(coriander), or struggle to enjoy vegetables there may be a reason.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Taste receptors, like other receptors that weve learned about, are proteins that
bind to particular molecules.
Like all sensory input (such as sights, smells, and sounds), perceiving and
interpreting taste requires an interaction between one or more specialized
|
194
A chemical must interact with a taste receptor, which sends a signal to our
brains. Our brains then decide whether the taste is good, bad, or something to
ignore completely.
Olfactory receptors in our nose add information from what we smell, which
also affects our brains perception of taste.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
195
We can vary in:
How sensitive they are (or how much of a certain chemical signal they
require to get the message).
How our brains interpret the information they get from our receptors.
Where these receptors are in addition to those in our mouths, we actually
have taste receptors throughout our gastrointestinal tract, including in
our nasal epithelia, our tracheas, our stomachs, our bile ducts, and our
small intestines. These types of receptors even show up in the skin, thyroid,
bladder, testes, and bone.
immunity;
our response to prescription drugs;
appetite control (for instance, TAS2R receptors can communicate
with hormone-secreting cells in our GI tract like those that produce
cholecystokinin (CCK), one of our satiety hormones);
glucose homeostasis; or
whether we like to drink alcohol or smoke.
Again, many of these factors are shaped by our genes, which means that genes
(to some degree) can affect what foods we instinctively like, or avoid.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
196
Some examples:
Variants in the TAS2R16 gene can affect how we perceive the bitterness of
certain plant compounds and our preferences for alcohol.
A TAS2R19 variant may predict how well we taste and/or like grapefruit or
quinine (a bitter extract used in some soft drinks like Brio, or the tonic water
in your cocktail)
There are many genes that contribute to taste perception and food preferences.
And there can be many genetic variations within one person, and between
people, which means that we cant definitely say what a persons preferences or
taste experiences will be.
PRECISION NUTRITION
This makes evolutionary sense. Sweetness usually meant something was good
to eat and energy-dense (like honey or fruit). Even newborn babies typically
prefer sucrose (sugar) solutions to water.
Two genes TAS1R2 and TAS1R3 code for taste receptor proteins that react
to sweetness.
|
197
In one study in a European population, researchers looked at two types of
sweetness preference:
FGF21
FGF21 codes for fibroblast growth factor 21, a protein thats involved in many
metabolic processes, including glucose uptake and the adaptive response
to starvation.
Indeed, the folks who had GG are meh about sugar. One bite of it and theyre
bored.
Fun factoid!
PRECISION NUTRITION
Note from Krista: This is true. I have personally witnessed Johns passionate love for
cookies.
The FGF21 gene and its protein product dont just affect whether were more
likely to reach for the candy dish. They also play other roles in metabolism,
|
and may have relationships with metabolic health. Well look more at FGF21 in
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Chapter 10.
The short version, though, is that sweet taste preference is likely just one small
part of a much larger system of genetic and epigenetic metabolic regulation.
|
198
SLC2A2 and GLUT2
As we saw in the chapter on metabolism, glucose transport in the body can
affect health. Research suggests that it can also affect taste preferences.
After we eat something sugary or starchy and break it down to glucose, we need
to move it somewhere to do a metabolic job (such as storing nutrients in cells).
This is done by a family of glucose transporter proteins known as GLUTs.
The SLCA2 gene codes for one of these GLUT transporters, GLUT2, which is
found in the pancreas, liver, small intestine, kidney, and brain. Because of these
locations, its probably involved in local glucose transport as well as sensing
overall glucose levels throughout our bodies.
Two studies of prediabetics as well as young, healthy people in their 20s found
that in both populations, people with a CT (cytosine-thymine) or TT (thymine-
thymine) at rs5400 ate more sweet foods. These variants of SLCA2 rs5400 and
another SNP, rs5393, are also associated with a higher risk of Type 2 diabetes.
Along with the FGF21 SNP rs838133, the FTO SNP rs1421085 is associated with
sweet taste preference.
PRECISION NUTRITION
FTO var rs1421085 FGF21 rs838133
199
How do you feel about sugar?
I LOVE sweet stuff. I find it hard to stop eating sweets once I get started 30%
First, youll notice that genetically, most people had typical odds of preferring
sweet foods.
And yet, about one-third of people said they loved sweet stuff and found it hard
to stop eating sugar once theyd started.
For instance, many people with a TT allele of the FTO SNP, who should have
liked sugar less, liked it more. Some people with an AA version of the FGF21
SNP, who should have liked sugar more, liked it less.
Is it more likely that the PN sample is less likely to prefer sugar, simply out of
healthy eating habits that have retrained their palates?
PRECISION NUTRITION
Right now, we cant know for sure.
But the potential effect of practicing several years of good nutrition, as well as
exercising regularly and having a lean and healthy body composition (which
typically means that glucose and insulin mechanics work as they should) are
important factors we cant ignore.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
200
What this means for you
Your genetic makeup may affect your preference for sweet foods. Genetic
testing may tell you more about your natural tendencies.
You probably dont need a genetic test to tell you if you like sweet foods.
Most people already know whether they do.
Tastes can change. Though taste is shaped by our genes, its not
determined by it. Taste is one of the most malleable of our senses. We can
learn to like or dislike all kinds of foods, regardless of our genetic makeup.
You may also notice that your preference for sweet foods changes as you age.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Do you like fat?
You order salad in a restaurant. It comes with an oily dressing, plus avocado,
bacon, and blue cheese. Whats your response?
Or
If youre in the second camp, you might have a genetic predisposition for liking
fatty tastes and textures.
|
201
Whether its butter, cheese, avocado, bacon, extra olive oil for dipping, or that
peanut butter thats like a black hole for your spoon, fat can make food delicious.
Yet not everyone likes rich, creamy, oily foods. Why not?
CD36
The CD36 gene codes for a glycoprotein, CD36, with many roles.
Because glycoproteins can bind to all kinds of molecules, they can do lots of
jobs. Theyre often cellular receptors.
That last role is what interests us the most, because CD36 is expressed in our
mouths, our small intestines, and our hypothalamus, all sites of taste and energy
balance regulation.
CD36 bonds strongly with certain types of fatty acids. It seems that people with
variants of the CD36 gene (such as a GG or GA at the rs1761667 SNP, or a TT or
PRECISION NUTRITION
CT at rs1527483) might perceive fattier tastes more acutely than others.
This may mean that less is more for these people, since fat packs more of a
taste punch, they may prefer to eat less fat, or find some foods too rich.
Conversely, people (such as the folks with an AA at rs1761667) who taste fat less
may like it more.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
And, indeed, research suggests that people who are more sensitive to fatty
tastes tend to eat less overall and less fat specifically; they also tend to weigh
less.
The association between having CD36 variations and body weight seems to be
consistent in many populations, including people of European, Latin American,
Middle Eastern, and African ancestry.
|
202
Just a reminder that biology in general and metabolism in particular are complex
systems: CD36 variations are also associated with:
You probably dont need a genetic test to tell you if you like fatty foods.
Most people already know whether they do.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Tastes can change. Though taste is shaped by our genes, its not
determined by it. Taste is one of the most malleable of our senses. We can
learn to like or dislike all kinds of foods, regardless of our genetic makeup.
You may also notice that your preference for fatty foods changes as you age.
203
Do you dislike bitterness?
While many of us learn to like bitter tastes as adults (think coffee or tea, lime,
radicchio (aka red chicory), hoppy beers, and dark chocolate), some of us will
have a lifelong aversion to bitterness.
In our evolutionary past, we tended to avoid bitterness, which can tell us that
certain foods might be bad for us. So it makes sense that genetically, some of us
might be more sensitive to bitter tastes than others.
cabbage;
Brussels sprouts;
kale;
dandelion greens;
rapini;
green peppers;
turnips and rutabaga; and
broccoli.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Many of these foods contain compounds (such as sulfur compounds and/or
terpenes yes, related to turpentine) that make them taste bitter.
There are about 25 known genes that code for TAS2R bitter taste receptor
proteins in humans. Historically, bitterness usually meant poison, so it was handy
to have several mechanisms for detecting it.
|
Heres just one example of how this might affect your preferences.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
204
TAS2R38
A gene known as TAS2R38 affects how well you can taste the presence of bitter
compounds such as 6-n-propylthiouracil (PROP), phenylthiocarbamide (PTC),
goitrin (found in cruciferous vegetables), and related molecules.
23andMe tests for the SNP rs713598 on this gene. The G variant of the SNP
in TAS2R38 is dominant. This means well be able to taste bitter PROP-like
compounds even if we only have one copy, rather than two.
If you get one C and one G, you might also be able to taste another type of bitter
chemical along with the PROPs. This gives you a double evolutionary advantage,
something known as heterozygote advantage.
The CGs who didnt like vegetables were also likely to describe themselves
as picky, suggesting that their heterozygous combination of this SNP leaned
towards bitter tasting.
Conversely, the Ill eat anything crowd was more likely to be CCs or the CGs
PRECISION NUTRITION
who probably got the heterozygous variant that didnt allow them to over-taste
bitterness.
But theres always gotta be those few outlier people that mess up the data.
We had a couple of predicted bitter tasters with the GG version of the SNP that
|
liked vegetables just fine. And they said theyd eat anything.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
205
In the case of the PN sample, the more bitter-averse people have learned to
like many vegetables, or prepare them in ways that taste better (for instance,
by adding a dash of maple syrup to a kale salad dressing, or roasting Brussels
sprouts to amplify their sweetness). They tend to prefer cooked vegetables to raw.
So, theyre still eating vegetables, but in ways that work for them and their taste
preferences.
Genetic testing may give you insight about why you dont like bitter foods.
23andMe tests for rs713598, a SNP on the TAS2R38 gene.
Your environment will also affect your preference for bitter foods. As with
sweet and fatty foods, what we grow up with and habitually choose will
shape our taste habits.
Tastes can change. Though taste is shaped by our genes, its not
determined by it. Taste is one of the most malleable of our senses. We can
learn to like or dislike all kinds of foods, regardless of our genetic makeup.
You may also notice that your preference for bitter tastes changes as you age.
Try a wide variety of healthy foods. You may discover some that you like
better.
Try foods in season or at different stages. For instance, you may find that
baby kale is fine, but mature kale tastes too bitter.
Try a wide variety of preparation methods. You may discover that small
changes to how you prepare, cook, and/or season foods make a big
PRECISION NUTRITION
difference.
Cilantro taste
Cilantro, or Coriandrum sativum, is a herb that looks a bit like parsley and is
found in many cuisines. And many people dont like it.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Fun factoid!
Generally the fresh leaves are known as cilantro, while the dried seeds are known
as coriander.
|
206
Along with our taste receptors, our olfactory (scent) receptors help us perceive
particular chemical compounds. Many volatile chemicals in fragrances are
aldehydes, a particular type of molecule.
Two other markers, rs2741762, and rs3930459, also located near the olfactory
receptor gene OR10A2, may help determine whether someone likes cilantro.
But in terms of actively liking it (thus definitely not disliking it) the OR10A2
rs2741762 SNP was a bit equivocal. Every single person who should have been a
cilantro hater thought it was yummy.
The rs3930459 SNP did a bit better: Out of all the people who actively liked
cilantro, only one person should theoretically have hated it, based on their CC
variation of this allele. Just under half of the cilantro likers were TTs, people with
lower odds of finding cilantro nasty. The rest were CTs and the aforementioned CC.
PRECISION NUTRITION
23andMe tests for rs2741762, and rs3930459 on OR10A2.
If youre a cilantro hater, you probably dont need a genetic test to tell you.
Ignore the people who mock you for picking off the garnish at Mexican, Thai,
or Indian restaurants. You do you.
friends are flavor troglodytes. It really does taste like soap or dirt to
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
some people.
|
207
Whats up next
In the next chapter, well look at food intolerances, which can also affect our
food preferences.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 7 CHAPTER 9
What we found: Body What we found: Food
weight and body comp intolerances
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
208
CHAPTER 9
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
209
In previous chapters, weve explored the idea of whether theres a single best
diet. By now, it should be obvious there isnt.
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test can tell you about your risk of particular food
sensitivities doesnt mean that it can tell you the perfect diet for you.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
It might just mean we should have said no before the third pound of suicide-
spice chicken wings.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Aside from situations in which We Really Should Have Known Better, many
people find that certain, normally innocuous foods such as bananas,
avocados, berries, shrimp, eggs, etc. are just bad news for them in general.
Its also important to understand that these and related digestive and
autoimmune disorders, like most chronic diseases, are polygenic (i.e. many
genes contribute) and emerge from complex interactions between genes,
behaviors, and environment.
|
210
Antibodies, immunoglobulins, and inflammation
An antibody is a type of protein that is produced by the immune system when
it identifies a foreign substance, known as an antigen. Antibodies help identify
pathogens (such as bacteria or viruses) as well as allergens and toxins.
Antibodies are Y-shaped proteins that share the same general structure, but
their tips vary quite a lot. This helps them match a specific antigen.
PRECISION NUTRITION
If our bodies think a particular food or part of a food is harmful or foreign, itll
create a targeted antibody to defend against it.
Over time, with repeated exposure, these immunoglobulins can build up and
create a physiological response. This response can be acute (immediate,
sudden, often dramatic) or it can be chronic (ongoing, persistent, often lower-grade).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
211
We can often see inflammation emerge in real time, with redness, swelling,
rashes, hives or a combination of these symptoms. Chemically speaking, we
can also see inflammation by the presence of particular substances, such as
interleukins (IL), histamine, prostaglandins, and so forth.
Food allergy
An allergen is something that causes a histamine response, known as an
immunoglobulin E (IgE) immune reaction. White blood cells (mast cells and
basophils) release histamine molecules when exposed to an allergen and cause
an inflammatory response such as:
hives;
swelling;
trouble breathing; and
a sudden drop in blood pressure.
Allergies are generally characterized by sudden and strong. IgE spikes quickly,
PRECISION NUTRITION
but also tapers off relatively quickly, generally dissipating within a few days
(though it can last up to a week or two).
Food allergies, like other allergies, do seem to run in families. This suggests that
we can, to some degree, inherit our allergy risk.
Food sensitivity
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Food sensitivities tend to present more with things like abdominal pain and
bloating, which are related to the actions of immunoglobulin G (IgG) rather than
IgE, as in allergies, above. IgG responses tend to be slower than IgE responses,
often taking hours or even days to show up.
|
212
People with health problems such as inflammatory bowel syndrome / disorder
(IBS / IBD), Crohns disease, or ulcerative colitis tend to have higher IgG levels
than healthy controls. IgG antibodies can also infiltrate and affect other tissues,
such as the pancreas, thyroid, respiratory system, kidney, lymph nodes, or
salivary glands.
Food intolerance
Other types of food intolerances, such as the example of lactose intolerance,
below, are typically caused by not making enough of the right types of enzymes
(for instance, lactase). Without enough of a particular enzyme, we cant digest
some foods properly.
Autoimmune-related problems
Gluten sensitivity and celiac disease
Gluten is a protein found in wheat, barley, and rye. Its a type of storage protein
known as prolamins, and made up of two proteins: gliadin and glutenin. (Barley
prolamins are hordeins, rye prolamins are called secalins and oat prolamins
are avenins).
Gluten is what gives wheat its elasticity and viscosity so that it can be made into
bread, pasta, or other baked goods.
You may have heard of gluten intolerance or even gluten allergy. You may
have heard that gluten is the root of all human disorder and dysfunction. (Move
over, money and power! Gluten is the new gangster in town!)
PRECISION NUTRITION
Some people those blessed with iron constitutions seem to be able to eat
anything. They munch on the bread basket cheerfully, crumbs falling out of their
mouths, apparently unaffected.
Other people notice some sensitivity to gluten and similar proteins in other
grains. Perhaps their joints hurt a little bit; perhaps they get a bit of a stuffy nose;
perhaps a slight skin rash.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
213
Why?
Well, at least part of this is, of course, genetic. But we dont yet know all the
factors involved.
Celiac disease
Celiac disease is an autoimmune condition triggered by gluten. Because its
autoimmune, which means that the bodys immune system attacks its own
healthy tissues, symptoms can be widespread through the entire system.
As with most diseases, our risk for celiac disease appears to be polygenic. To
date, research suggests that genetic factors can explain about 55% of celiac
disease cases.
Not surprisingly, research has found links between celiac disease and several
genes related to immune and inflammatory responses, including:
CCR3 codes for the C-C chemokine receptor type 3. Chemokines are a
type of cytokine, or cell signaling molecule, that tell other cells to move
somewhere, like directing immune cells to move to the site of an infection.
The CCR3 protein is highly expressed in immune system cells such as
eosinophils and basophils (types of white blood cells), or T-helper cells, as
well as in the epithelial cells of our airway.
PRECISION NUTRITION
IL12A helps to direct the activities of T-helper cells.
MYO9B, which codes for myosin IXB and is involved in maintaining the
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
integrity of the intestinal lining. It has also been associated with inflammatory
bowel conditions. People with variants of MYO9B may have more intestinal
permeability, aka leaky gut.
PFKFB3, which codes for a protein that plays a role in cancer progression,
circadian clocks, autophagy, and insulin signaling.
|
214
PRKCQ codes for protein kinase C, which is involved in T-cell immune
system signaling.
RGS1 codes for regulator of G-protein signaling 1, which has been used as
a marker of intestinal tissue quality in studies of colorectal cancer. Its also
been linked to mental health and multiple sclerosis (along with IL12A).
TAGAP codes for a protein involved in T-cell signaling; like other genes in
this list, is linked to autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, Type
1 diabetes, and multiple sclerosis.
These genes, and others like them, are probably involved in a wide variety of
immune system function.
For instance, Type 1 diabetes and celiac disease share HLA-DQ, IL2/IL21, CCR3
and SH2B3 SNPs in populations of European ancestry. And vitamin D seems to
interact with IL2RA and TAGAP.
HLA-DQ
PRECISION NUTRITION
You may remember that in Chapter 6, we talked about the human leukocyte
antigen (HLA) gene complex that codes for major histocompatibility complex
(MHC) proteins in humans.
These proteins, which are found on the surfaces and membranes of cells,
|
HLA-DQ is a type of protein that appears on the membrane of what are known
as antigen-presenting cells, cells that tell other cells of the immune system (such
as T cells) that theres trouble spotted (such as a pathogen), and its time to go
to work.
|
215
The most significant genetic risk factor for celiac disease seems to encode the
HLA-DQ2/DQ8 heterodimers (molecular complexes of two macromolecules
stuck together).
When immune cells that have HLA-DQ2 or DQ8 on their membranes come
in contact with gluten (for instance, in the small intestine), this complex can
incorrectly tell the immune system to attack the threat in this case, healthy
tissues. This creates the symptoms of celiac disease, such as gastrointestinal
pain and diarrhea.
However, as weve seen, other genetic variants may also contribute. There are
several dozen known factors so far. Some genes appear to be altered only in
adults or children with celiac disease, suggesting that age may also change the
genetic expression of the disease.
Not everyone with genetic variations will develop the disease, but most people
who have celiac disease do seem to share some related genetic variants.
This subtype is found in roughly 15% of the general population but in over 90%
of people with celiac disease, though only about 3% of people with this specific
variation will actually develop celiac disease.
23andMe also tests for rs6822844, a SNP that lies in a block of genes (KIAA1109/
Tenr/IL2/IL21) that, along with another SNP in the same area (rs13119723), are
strongly associated with autoimmune disease, including celiac disease.
Like many chronic diseases with a strong genetic component, the prevalence of
celiac disease varies with geography and population.
PRECISION NUTRITION
America, Europe, Australia, some parts of South America) as well as populations
in India. It is relatively rare in most local populations in Asia.
216
So, in this case, genetic testing is a much more pleasant option. However:
The solution would still be the same: remove gluten from the diet.
Research suggests that non-celiac gluten sensitivity (sensitivity to gluten
without overt antibodies) is a thing.
Krista, too, avoids wheat, because the connection between eating it and
inflammatory symptoms is pretty clear. Yet Kristas 23andMe test for celiac risk
showed that based on a few different markers, she actually had half the average
risk of celiac.
So what gives?
Many other frustrated people who know they dont respond well to wheat may,
nevertheless, have been told that they dont have legitimate celiac disease, so
they should quit bellyaching (so to speak).
In fact, we are coming to realize that non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) can
also be a problem.
With NCGS, we dont see the same chemical markers (such as immunoglobulin
PRECISION NUTRITION
A, or IgA, antibodies), or the destruction of intestinal tissue that we see with full-
blown celiac disease, but we still see inflammation.
For instance, the researchers in the Nutrigenomix lab looked at the relationship
between genetic markers of celiac and 2-macroglobulin, a protein that goes up
in response to inflammation. They found that eating more gluten was correlated
with more 2-macroglobulin, but this happened regardless of peoples HLA-DQ.
That said, over half of people who have NCGS do carry similar genetic variants
as people will full-blown celiac disease, and both NCGS and celiac sufferers are
much more likely to have these variants than the general population.
|
217
What we found in our sample
With the HLA-DQA rs2187668 SNP tested by 23andMe, each copy of a thymine
(T) increases celiac risk. So TTs (thymine-thymine) are most at risk.
We had no TTs in our sample, but about 16% of the sample had CT (cytosine-
thymine), a slightly increased risk.
Several people said they were definitely intolerant of wheat. Four of those had
had a celiac test done, which suggests that they had enough wheat intolerance
symptoms to check.
Yet none of these wheat-intolerant folks were CTs. All were CCs the lowest-
risk group for celiac.
Moreover:
All the people who said they were definitely intolerant to wheat were CCs,
which, again, is the group that theoretically shouldnt have problems.
A few people said they were definitely not intolerant, and could crush
croissants with no problems. Most, not surprisingly, were CCs, but one of
those was a CT.
Research suggests that even if you do not have celiac disease, you may
still have a sensitivity to gluten or other related proteins. This may be
PRECISION NUTRITION
genetic or may also be related to a wide variety of other factors, such as
your lifestyle, your gastrointestinal health, and your environment.
218
Food intolerances
Lactase persistence / lactose tolerance
Lactase is an enzyme, secreted by the brush border cells of the small intestine,
that helps us digest lactose, a sugar in milk.
Almost all of us can digest lactose when we are born. We need to: Breast milk is
our only source of nourishment. But not all of us keep this ability as we age.
Other populations who dont consume as much milk and dairy for instance,
people with southeast Asian ancestry tend not to carry this gene.
In fact, not being able to digest lactose is more the global norm than the
exception. Some estimates suggest that worldwide, about 65% of adults cannot
digest lactose.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Figure 9.2: Who can drink milk? Global rates of lactase persistence
219
LCT
At the moment, we know of many different alleles of LCT, the lactose tolerance
gene, that can affect this ability.
These alleles tend to travel with different haplotypes. This means that the
outcome (being able to digest lactose, or not) is the same, but the reason (a
specific gene variant) can be different, depending on a persons ancestry.
For example:
Fun factoid!
Tibetans have also crossed domestic cattle (Bos primigenius) with yaks (Bos
grunniens) to create a hybrid called a dzo.
13915*G, the founder mutation for the unusually high lactase persistence
PRECISION NUTRITION
in Saudi Arabians and Bedouins which may not relate to cows milk but
to camels milk. (Despite their high lactose tolerance, the characteristically
European 13910*T variation doesnt seem to appear much in this population
either.)
220
Other candidate variations still being tested include:
Supporting this idea is the fact that there are at least seven different rare alleles
associated with lactase persistence in one small ethnic group (Somali cattle
herders from Ethiopia). In terms of understanding genetic variation, simply
lumping this group into a large category called African or black would be
useless at best.
Although MCM6 doesnt directly affect lactose digestion, it contains two of the
regulatory regions for LCT.
Youll hopefully remember that back in Chapter 2, we talked about how genes
are made, the process that regulates whether a gene is made or not, and a key
region of DNA called the enhancer.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Enhancers for different genes are different, since you dont want all the genes
to be made at the same time. You want some to be turned on, and others to be
turned off, depending on the situation.
Thats what happens with the LCT gene and MCM6. Some people have a
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
particular SNP (rs49882359) in the MCM6 gene that increases the activity of the
LCT enhancer and leads to the expression of the LCT gene and most lactase.
|
221
Sweeps, spreads, and selection
These genetic variations, and the other possible variations that we havent
yet found, give us clear evidence of convergent evolution, or a trait emerging
independently, more than once (rather than developing in a straight linear path).
For instance, wrap-type foods include sushi hand rolls, rice paper wraps, dosas,
crepes, burritos, shawarma, and so forth all having evolved independently in
world cuisines. Sushi didnt directly evolve from burritos (although now we have
the sushi burrito, another one of Natures magnificent miracles).
In this case, we have a situation where various populations are able to produce
lactase, but by different pathways.
Selective sweeps can happen when a beneficial mutation starts out relatively
rare, but quickly moves through the population, pushing out genetic rivals.
This can often happen when environmental conditions change and favor the
new mutation.
For example, if climate rapidly changes, genes that were previously neutral but
now help the organism adapt to the new climate will likely spread.
When the Ice Age suddenly hits, everyone with the genes for a furry pelt, short
PRECISION NUTRITION
limbs, and plenty of subcutaneous fat will be left standing, while everyone with
the genes for squeaky-smooth-as-a-dolphin skin, lanky heat-dispersing limbs,
and six-pack abs will be quickly wiped out.
Many have speculated that lactase persistence emerged over and over among
various populations because it was helpful for pastoral populations who might
have consumed a lot of milk and dairy from cows, sheep, goats, and camels.
|
222
Genetic studies seem to support this hypothesis, since populations with higher
lactase persistence also tend to include milk and dairy as part of their regular
diets. (After all, try to imagine northern Europe without cheese or yogurt no
Icelandic skyr, no British Stilton, no Swiss fondue.)
Indeed, early humans dont appear to have had much lactase persistence. The
genetic variations that now let some of us enjoy ice cream and milkshakes
emerged relatively recently perhaps 10,000 to 25,000 years ago or so (some
estimates even put it around 3,000 years ago).
For instance, Dinka and Nuer in Sudan and Somalis in Ethiopia dont seem
to have lactase persistence despite consuming dairy. In genetically lactose-
intolerant populations that consume dairy but seem to digest it fine, gut
microflora may also be helping out.
In this case, having the GG variant did seem to predict dairy intolerance. All the
people who said they had significant problems digesting dairy were GGs.
That said:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Lactose tolerance still varied. One gut-of-steel GG said they had absolutely
no problems with dairy, while other GGs said their tolerance was sometimes
an issue, sometimes not.
Some AAs (adenine-adenine, the lowest-risk group) also said they had some
problems digesting dairy, though nobody said it was as serious as some of
the GGs did.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
223
AG or CT?
When we were writing up our results for the rs4988235 SNP of the LCT gene, and
checking both 23andMe and Nutrigenomixs reports, we stumbled across something
that seemed confusing.
23andMe listed the SNP variants as A/G. In other words, the 3 options would be
AA, AG, or GG.
Nutrigenomix listed them as C/T. In other words, the 3 options would be CC,
CT, or TT.
If you ask the question about what variant an individual has, you have to know what
they vary from.
Researchers have settled on reference genomes, which are compiled and released as
a set by the Genome Reference Consortium, an international consortium of experts
from some of the top research institutions.
The current human reference genome is called GRCh38.p11 (GRC human genome build
38, patch level 11), released in July 2017.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Remember that DNA has two complementary strands.
For example, if theres an A on one strand, you know theres a T at the same position
on the opposite strand. If theres a C on one, you know it has a G buddy.
The identifiers for SNPs are unique to each genome build, so the position might be
reported as A in one build because one strand is sequenced, and a T in the next build
because the complementary strand is sequenced.
For determining SNP variation, this is fine the location varies and you dont really
care about it.
|
224
However, we discovered that 23andMe always uses the letter on the forward (i.e.,
transcribed) strand, independent of the reference genome.
This is an unusual choice. Most research and clinical literature use the genotypes
defined in the reference genome.
You can see why 23andMe might make this choice, though it makes it easy to say
This is the A or T that gets transcribed, so this is the one we will use.
If you can digest lactase, It may be from one (or more) of a number of
different gene variants, depending on your ancestry. Congratulations!
Enjoy the lattes, thanks to convergent evolution.
There are other reasons you may be dairy-intolerant. For instance, your
gut microbiota can play a role; you can also be sensitive to other proteins
PRECISION NUTRITION
in dairy.
225
Hereditary fructose intolerance
Hereditary fructose intolerance (HFI), as its name suggests, is a genetic
condition in which people cant break down fructose properly. Fructose is found
in fruit, as well as many processed foods (such as soda).
People with HFI cant make enough aldolase B, an enzyme encoded by the
ALDOB gene that helps metabolize fructose. If aldolase B isnt working properly,
our bodies cant properly convert sugar into energy, which can result in
hypoglycemia (low blood sugar).
Hypoglycemia, if severe and left untreated, can lead to seizures, coma and
death. In addition, the accumulation of partially metabolized fructose molecules
becomes toxic to the cells and causes liver and kidney damage.
People who have HFI may avoid many sweets and fruit instinctively, which
means they may never get properly diagnosed. This also means that researchers
arent completely sure how common HFI really is.
HFI is an autosomal recessive disorder, which means that to have HFI, a person
must inherit two copies of the ALDOB gene variant that causes the problem.
While it can be fatal if not properly treated, people can remain healthy and free
of symptoms if they avoid fructose.
There are at least 40 known ALDOB mutations that have been linked to HFI.
23andMe looks at four of the most common ALDOB mutations in people with
European ancestry:
rs1800546, aka A149P (which accounts for about 65% of all HFI-causing
mutations in this population)
PRECISION NUTRITION
rs78340951, aka N334K (about 5-8%)
rs387906225, aka delta4E4 (about 3%)
Together, these mutations make up about 75% of the HFI-causing mutations in
this population.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
226
What we found in our sample
Luckily for our PN team members, nobody had two of the ALDOB HFI mutations
tested for: rs1800546 and rs76917243.
Even if you do not have HFI, you may find that you have digestive
symptoms from eating particular types of carbohydrates known as
FODMAPs: fermentable oligo-, di-, mono-saccharides and polyols. This
group includes fructose.
If you have been diagnosed with HFI, or if youre noticing other food
sensitivities, consider working with a nutrition coach or dietitian to come
up with menu options and strategies to accommodate your food needs.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
227
Whats up next
In the next chapter, well look at how genetic factors other than food intolerances
or sensitivities can affect how we absorb and use nutrients.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 8 CHAPTER 10
What we found: Food What we found: Nutrient
preferences absorption and use
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
228
CHAPTER 10
genetic variations that may affect how our bodies respond to specific
diets, such as high-carbohydrate or high-fat / ketogenic diets;
PRECISION NUTRITION
what genetic testing may tell you about how your body processes
particular nutrients, and what other ways you can discover this.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
229
What role might genes play in nutrient
processing?
We all know that person who seems to be able to eat anything they want and
stay lean and fit.
We also know that person who seems to do everything right and ends up with
a nutrient deficiency or health problem.
Nutrient processing (in other words, how our bodies digest, absorb, and
use both macronutrients like fat, carbohydrates, and protein, along with
micronutrients such as vitamins and minerals) can also be affected by many
factors, such as:
PRECISION NUTRITION
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test may tell you how you might metabolize a
particular nutrient doesnt mean that it can tell you the perfect diet or
supplement for you.
|
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
|
230
How do our bodies process
nutrients?
When you eat an orange or some ripe blackberries that are high in vitamin C,
how does that vitamin C get into your cells?
How does your body know how to extract vitamin C or any other nutrient
from your food, absorb it, transport it where it needs to go, use it in various
chemical reactions, and then get rid of any waste products it creates?
What if a nutrient needs to be in two places at once? How does your body know
which one to prioritize?
Does your body prefer a certain form of a nutrient, such as the retinol form of
vitamin A, instead of the plant-based carotenoid forms?
All these and many other processes and physiological decisions are governed
by genetics.
Although we are more the same than different, there can be subtle genetic
differences in how our unique bodies digest, absorb, use, and excrete the
nutrients from the food we eat.
Macronutrients: Carbohydrates
PRECISION NUTRITION
Carbs have been getting a bad dietary rap lately. Perhaps youve counted
carbs or bought a low-carb product or cut them out altogether. Perhaps
youve been told that to stay lean, carbs are the enemy. Or that needing glucose
is some kind of moral failure.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
231
In fact, the prestigious British medical journal The Lancet recently reported on
one population, the Tsimane of Bolivia, whose diet is over 70% carbohydrate
from foods like manioc (cassava) and plantains, and who have some of the
healthiest hearts in the world.
Such findings of metabolic health in people eating traditional diets have been
consistently reported for decades.
And instead of high-carb diets inevitably making people obese (as is often
suggested about processed-food Western diets), people in many other foraging
societies with a traditional high-carbohydrate diet (such as the Hadza people of
Tanzania) are smaller and lighter than the world average.
(By the way, the !Kung of Namibia, Botswana and Angola, and the Fulani people
of northern Nigeria also have a traditionally low body mass index, or BMI, and
enjoy cardiovascular health, but live on higher-fat diets. Well look more at
potential genetic adaptations to higher-fat diets below.)
For instance:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Traditional societies get more daily-life physical activity than people in
industrialized, urbanized regions. This can affect nutrient partitioning, or
how our bodies use and store those carbohydrates.
People who have lived a relatively traditional lifestyle for hundreds or thousands
|
of years may also share genetic features that have made them uniquely suited to
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
their local, ancestral diet. Over time, genetic selection helps them adapt to their
environmental conditions.
|
232
Amylase and copy number variation (CNV)
In Chapter 2, we looked at the concept of copy number variation (CNV). This
refers to whether chunks of genetic material are repeated. CNVs can also affect
how genes work.
We used the example of genes (AMY1 and AMY2) that make an enzyme
(amylase) that helps us break down the carbohydrate amylose. Digestion starts
in the mouth, where salivary amylase begins the process of breaking down the
starches we eat as we chew them.
Research on various populations has found that those groups with a traditionally
high-carbohydrate diet (for instance, people in Japan, who consumed rice,
buckwheat, sweet potatoes, and so forth) had more copies of AMY1, while
people with a traditionally low-carbohydrate diet (such as people living near the
Arctic Circle in places like Yakut, Russia) had fewer copies of AMY1.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
233
Copy number variation of the AMY1 gene has also been linked to BMI. People
who had more amylase-making genes tended to be leaner; while people with
fewer copies of the genes tended to be heavier.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 10.2: AMY1 copy number and body size
Image adapted from Falchi M, Moustafa JS, Takousis P, Pesce F, Bonnefond A, Andersson-
Assarsson JC, et al. Low copy number of the salivary amylase gene predisposes to obesity.
Nature genetics. 2014 May 1;46(5):492-7.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
AMY1 may also play a role in postprandial (after-meal) glucose digestion and
disposal. People with more copies of the gene tend to have lower blood sugar
after a starch-containing meal.
In short: More copies of AMY1 might mean better starch digestion and more
effective use in our bodies.
|
234
Having more AMY1 may have been a helpful adaptation for populations with
high-carbohydrate diets, and it may mean that people from those populations
may do well on such diets.
We dont know for sure whether all the lean and healthy indigenous populations
of the world eating high-carb diets share this genetic feature of multiple
copies of amylase, or perhaps some other mechanism that helps them digest
carbohydrates effectively. (For instance, a 2017 study that looked at the
relationship between AMY1/2 genes and body mass index also found that
AMY1As effects also interacted with the actions of gut microflora in digesting
starches.) But its an interesting working hypothesis.
Most direct-to-consumer tests do not (yet) test for CNVs. So, we dont
have any PN sample data to share here. Many CNVs dont have clear start
and stop points (which would normally help us see where the DNA segment
occurs). However, higher-end labs do have many techniques for identifying
CNVs, and sequencing the exome or genome can help identify CNV.
Genetic testing can tell you about your ancestry. As we saw in Chapter 5
with examples like lactase persistence, knowing your ancestry may suggest
what types of foods or dietary patterns you might be better-adapted to
eat. Research on indigenous populations who have gone back to more
traditional modes of eating and living (for instance, First Nations or Inuit in
Canada who have gone back to hunting, trapping, fishing, and harvesting
wild foods) shows that they become healthier and fitter when following
PRECISION NUTRITION
dietary patterns that better suit their evolutionary history.
Your ancestry may also teach you about your food heritage. As weve
seen, food isnt just about survival or delivering nutrients; its about history
and culture too. Learning about your genetic heritage may also inspire you
to learn about your cultural food traditions and stories. This knowledge and
practice is part of a healthy diet too.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
235
Insulin and glucose management
Digestion of starches begins in our mouths, with salivary amylase. Another
important step in carbohydrate metabolism is signaling the pancreas to release
insulin.
For instance:
The KCNJ11 gene codes for a protein that regulates insulin release.
Gain-of-function mutations in this gene prevent insulin secretion in
response to glucose. This gene has 219 SNPs, six of which have been
linked to diabetes (rs5219, rs5215, rs5210, rs5218, rs886288, and
rs2285676). 23andMe tests for the rs5219 SNP of KCNJ11. Having a T version
of this allele results in a protein that doesnt respond as well to glucose.
When this happens, we cant clear glucose as well from the bloodstream.
More glucose hangs around, causing problems such as hyperglycemia, Type
2 diabetes, and tissue damage.
We arent quite sure yet what the protein encoded by CDKAL1 does, but it
seems to be similar to another protein that plays a role in insulin resistance.
Some studies have linked SNPs in CDKAL1 (such as rs4712523) to problems
with insulin secretion in European and South and East Asian populations,
though other studies havent found the same links.
The TCF7L2 protein, which is encoded by the TCF7L2 gene, seems to play
a role in developing pancreatic islets, where we have beta cells that make
insulin. If we have the T version of the rs7903146 SNP, we may make less
insulin; if we are female we may also have a higher chance of developing
diabetes during pregnancy (known as gestational diabetes). This link
between the TCH7L2 SNP and problems with insulin has been shown in
populations with European, Asian, and African ancestry.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Chapter 6 on metabolism reviews other factors that can affect glucose and
insulin regulation in our bodies.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
236
Our diverse pancreas?
The INS insulin gene can contain a variable number of tandem repeats (VNTRs),
which we looked at in Chapter 5.
Yet in the case of this particular gene, estimates suggest that about 28-45% of total
genetic variance is due to differences between Africans and non-Africans.
Its not clear why this specific gene diverged so much, but its consistent with the
hypothesis that Homo sapiens originated in Africa, and that humans who remained in
Africa (while others migrated in smaller, more genetically homogeneous groups) had
plenty of time to diversify.
Even more interesting, we cant find a modern primate relative for this gene. So we
cant tell which line of the gene is the oldest.
Variation in the INS VNTR is associated with a wide range of traits and health
conditions, such as Type 1 and 2 diabetes, polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS), birth
weight, and body fat levels. This diversity may also help to explain different rates of
diseases and health concerns in different populations.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
237
What we found in our sample
23andMe tests for these genes and variants:
CDKAL1 (rs4712523)
CDKN2A/B (rs2383208),
HHEX (rs1111875),
IGF2BP2 (rs4402960),
KCNJ11 (rs5219),
KCNQ1 (rs2237892),
MTNR1B (rs1387153),
SLC30A8 (rs13266634),
WFS1 (rs10012946), and
PPARG (rs1801282), which we looked at in Chapter 7.
They use the above to create a combined Type 2 diabetes risk score.
Along with genetic data, we asked people whether theyd ever had their blood
sugar tested, and if so, what it was. Not everyone had, but some were able to
share.
The figure below shows the results of our multi-SNP risk score assessment,
along with known fasting blood glucose test results.
Each row is one person. Read across to see each persons risk score by allele,
PRECISION NUTRITION
and what their actual tested blood sugar levels were (if they had been tested via
blood test; if not, the space will be blank).
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
238
Figure 10.3: Type 2 diabetes-linked variants in PN population
Nobody had the highest possible risk score. Most people were, in fact,
rather boringly average: a slightly higher risk here, a normal risk there.
Of the two people who had higher-than-average blood sugar, nobody had
a high-risk homozygous allele. For them, environmental factors were more
relevant.
PRECISION NUTRITION
to problems with glucose regulation. Mutations with gain or loss of function
may affect how your body processes sugars and starches, as well as the
function of other hormones (such as melatonin, in the case of MTNR1B) that
interact with insulin.
23andMe tests for the following and uses them to develop a diabetes
risk score:
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
CDKAL1 (rs4712523),
CDKN2A/B (rs2383208),
HHEX (rs1111875),
IGF2BP2 (rs4402960),
|
239
KCNJ11 (rs5219),
KCNQ1 (rs2237892),
MTNR1B (rs1387153),
SLC30A8 (rs13266634),
WFS1 (rs10012946), and
PPARG (rs1801282), which we looked at in Chapter 7.
Again, they use these to create a combined Type 2 diabetes risk score.
We probably dont (yet) know all the genes involved. Even if you dont
have any of the risk SNPs, you may have others that affect your
carbohydrate tolerance.
However, other factors besides genetics can also affect your metabolic
health and digestion of carbohydrates. These include:
PRECISION NUTRITION
elevated blood sugar can tell you that there is an underlying health problem.
If you are a do-it-yourself kind of person, you can buy a home glucose
monitor and test your glucose throughout the day, including after meals.
Postprandial after meals blood sugar levels will give you a better idea,
sooner, of what your blood glucose is up to, compared to fasting glucose.
|
240
Regardless of genetic makeup, basic nutritional principles still apply.
Avoiding added sugars, minimizing processed foods, and choosing high-
fiber, nutrient-rich options such as fruits and vegetables, starchy tubers,
whole grains, and beans / legumes is still an excellent strategy.
If you want to know whether your body will thrive on a higher-carb diet,
just try a higher-carb diet for a month or two and see what happens.
Wed define higher-carb as something thats more than 50% of your total
calories from carbs. Track how you feel and perform, as well as your body
weight, body composition, and blood sugar if possible. The data you gather
from this simple experiment will probably give you a clearer answer than
most genetic predictions we could make right now.
If youd like to improve your overall wellness, see our strategies for
healthy metabolism in Chapter 12.
Macronutrients: Fat
High-fat versus low-fat diets: Which is healthier? Which diet helps us stay
leaner, or lose weight better? The debate has raged for decades.
One reason we cant say definitively how much fat people should eat, or what
type of fat is best, is because different people respond differently to different
diets.
Many people are curious about whether genetic testing can answer questions
like:
PRECISION NUTRITION
risk of premature death?
blood chemistry?
How might these changes be connected to our genetic makeup, if they are?
What specific genetic factors might be involved? (Remember that these are
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
241
Methodological problems in studying dietary
responses
Research suggests that there are, indeed, genetic differences in how people
might respond to higher-fat diets.
Yet there is still no clear link between particular genes and particular outcomes.
For one thing, few studies exploring genetic responses to high-fat diets have a
control group. Few are based on data where peoples food intake was strictly
monitored (for instance, people getting a strict menu in a lab).
Instead, many studies about dietary intake are based on people self-reporting
what they ate, which is known to be quite inaccurate.
(What did you eat for lunch last Tuesday? Tuna? What was the exact portion of
tuna? Oh wait, was tuna on Wednesday? And maybe it was salmon? Difficult,
right?)
So, in fact, none of the data in any study that used dietary self-reporting may be
particularly useful.
Higher in fat may be 30% of total calories in some studies; in other studies,
it may be more.
Fat type may differ from study to study (for instance, comparing unsaturated
fats to saturated fats, or processed oils to naturally occurring fats such as
butterfat).
PRECISION NUTRITION
To draw good conclusions, we need good data. So, before you get your genetic
test results, recognize that the scientific research that many of these proposed
genetic links are based on may have significant methodological problems.
All weight loss diets need to control energy balance (energy in versus energy
out). There is nothing magical about eating a given percentage of any particular
macronutrient.
Yet some people swear that a high-fat diet helped them lose weight.
|
242
This may be because some people find higher-fat diets more satiating due to
the effects of gastrointestinal hormones such as CCK, which respond to the
presence of fat and protein in the gut. More satiating means people eat less,
which then creates an energy deficit that helps them lose weight.
Other people, hearing the exciting tales of the miraculous high-fat diet, might
leap on the lipid bandwagon, only to discover that, sadly, cheese and butter
were not their personal path to getting ripped.
Heres what 23andMe suggests as potential genetic markers and how they
might work in European populations:
Other studies have looked at other links between dietary fat, other SNPs, and
BMI. Results are equivocal.
For example:
Some earlier research suggested there may be a link between the PPAR-
gamma (usually written as PPAR- ) pathway (which youll remember from
Chapter 7), dietary fat, and BMI. Yet a later 2016 study involving about
11,000 European men and women found that the influence of dietary fat
on associations between SNPs in the PPAR- pathway and body size was
probably absent or marginal.
PRECISION NUTRITION
a genetic risk score of 32 combined genetic variants found that yes, if
people ate more fried foods they were likely to be heavier. But was this due
to the greater energy intake (in other words, the fact that fried foods are high
in calories), or other factors (such as other behaviors of people who eat a
lot of fast food) as well? (If youre curious, the full list of variants is here:
http://www.bmj.com)
|
This doesnt mean theres no genetic link, just that we havent closed in on a
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
We have a lot of informed hypotheses and areas for further research. And we
can pretty confidently say that different people have different responses to
different diets.
|
243
High-fat diets and metabolic health
The rs662799 and rs662799(C) alleles of APO5 have been shown to be
associated with weight gain and higher triglyceride levels on high-fat diets in
a variety of ethnic groups, such as Han and Guangzhou Chinese, Pakistanis,
Caribbean Hispanics, and Israelis of European (Ashkenazi), Middle Eastern
(Sephardic) and Yemenite origin.
This suggests that for some people at least, high-fat diets may result in a poorer
blood lipid profile.
One study in a South Korean population looked at people with a variant of the
APOA5 gene that made them more likely to have high blood triglycerides. (We
looked at triglycerides in Chapter 6.)
In other words, no matter what genes you have, eating more vegetables and
fiber is a good idea for most people.
This study didnt track weight loss. But, given what weve seen in our PN
Coaching program, wed guess that improving food quality and fiber intake might
have loosened some peoples belts.
PRECISION NUTRITION
hard to draw any conclusions.
With this SNP, AAs were considered normal because theyd theoretically gain
weight on a high-fat diet. GGs would be theoretically more likely to lose weight.
|
Nearly 80% of our sample were AAs. Some AAs did say theyd usually gain
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
weight on a high-fat diet. This would be expected, since high-fat diets are often
also high in calories. Other AAs said theyd just stay the same.
A few people did, however, report that they typically lost weight on a high-fat
diet. All were AGs, not GGs.
|
244
We had no GGs in our sample. The potential rarity of this allele may help explain
why some people in the fitness industry sing the praises of high-fat diets for
weight loss, but also why many other people find that their personal reality
doesnt match the promise.
Of course, again, there are many other factors involved, such as:
the energy density of fat: it packs a calorie punch and is easy to over-eat;
peoples individual preferences for eating more fat, which may also be
affected by genetics (see Chapter 8 for more on fat taste preference);
why people might be eating a high-fat diet in the first place, since some of
our PN population might be looking to gain weight on purpose; and
You may need to watch your total fat intake how much fat you eat
in general.
PRECISION NUTRITION
calories out) is still the most important factor. This doesnt mean that if you
have the wrong genes, youre doomed to never enjoy butter or bacon
again. You might simply have to moderate your intake, stay active, and make
generally healthy choices you know, all the boring non-magical stuff.
245
If you want to know whether your body will thrive on a higher-fat diet
try a higher-fat diet for a month or two, and see what happens. Wed
define higher-fat as something thats more than about 35-40% of your
total calories from fat. Track how you feel and perform, along with your body
weight, body composition, and blood lipids if possible. The data you gather
from this simple experiment will probably give you a clearer answer than
most genetic predictions we could make right now.
Include a blood lipid profile as part of your regular medical checkups (e.g.,
annually or biannually). Again, this will give you a much clearer picture of
what is actually happening right now, rather than simply speculating based
on genetic markers without clear data.
Ketogenic diets
High-fat diets are often discussed together with terms like ketosis and
ketogenic diet. A high-fat diet is not necessarily a ketogenic diet.
However, given that people commonly equate them, and that some form of
ketogenic diet regularly comes in and out of fashion, we thought wed discuss
ketogenic diets here as well.
Dietary ketosis simply means that blood levels of ketones are above a certain
level. Again, this most often happens when we are fasting, or when we are
eating a very low carbohydrate diet (which tends to be a high-fat diet, hence the
PRECISION NUTRITION
confusion between high-fat, low-carb, and ketogenic diets).
We can also raise our blood levels of ketones without changing our diets by
taking ketone supplements, though this isnt necessarily the same physiological
state as ketosis via fasting or carbohydrate restriction. (Heres a link to more
reading about ketogenic diets.)
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
A quick skim of diet support groups will reveal that ketogenic dieting has its
raving fans people who tried ketosis-stimulating ways of eating, felt terrific,
and now want everyone else to do it.
However, as with most other ways of eating, variation in key genes involved in
certain metabolic pathways may shape how we respond to this or any other diet.
|
246
FGF21 and HMGCS2
You might remember FGF21 from Chapter 8 on food preferences. The FGF21
gene codes for FGF21, a protein that helps to regulate energy balance and
insulin sensitivity.
Early work in mice found that the FGF21 protein increased in the liver in
response to one of three states: fasting, ketogenic diets, or low-sugar / low-
protein diets. This increases fat oxidation, decreases inflammation, increases
energy expenditure and increases glucose tolerance. (Generally, all good things.)
However, in humans, FGF21 is only stimulated by fasting for more than 72 hours,
not with other diets.
Lab models suggest that FGF21, along with other genetic and epigenetic factors,
may also affect our response to ketogenic (low-carbohydrate / high-fat) diets.
PRECISION NUTRITION
made.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
247
Figure 10.4: Ketone body metabolism and regulation
Image adapted from Newman JC, Verdin E. Ketone bodies as signaling metabolites. Trends in
Endocrinology & Metabolism. 2014 Jan 31;25(1):42-52.
Mutations in the HMGCS2 gene are associated with a genetic condition known
as HMG-CoA synthase deficiency.
When eating normally, people with HMG-CoA synthase deficiency are fine. But
PRECISION NUTRITION
when fasting, they cannot go into ketosis properly (aka hypoketotic); they may
become hypoglycemic enough to go into a coma.
If youre worried you might have this, probably dont worry too much: Its a
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
relatively rare, autosomal recessively inherited disorder (in other words, you
need two copies of the mutant gene) that only affects fewer than 1 in 1,000,000
people.
Most of us wont have this rare genetic disorder. Yet given the complexity of
metabolism, its still quite possible that we may differ in our responses to a
ketogenic diet.
|
248
What this means for you
Genetic testing may tell you whether you have the HMGCS2 rs28937320
variant that could affect your response to a ketogenic diet and fasting.
23andMe doesnt test for the variant, but other commercial services may.
Again, this variant is quite rare, so theres a strong chance you dont have it.
If you want to know whether your body will thrive on a ketogenic diet
try a ketogenic diet for a few weeks, and see what happens. A standard
ketogenic diet protocol that is used to treat childhood epilepsy typically
uses a 4:1 ratio of dietary fat to protein and carbohydrate combined (in other
words, 4 grams of fat per 1 gram of combined protein and carbohydrate).
Generally, it takes 2-3 days of eating this way to get into ketosis. If you try
several weeks of keto dieting and feel terrific or terrible or meh then
you have your answer. The data you gather from this simple experiment will
probably give you a clearer answer than most genetic predictions we could
make right now.
Experiment and discover the diet that is right for you. Other peoples
results with a given diet may not match yours, in part due to possible
genetic factors.
This enzyme helps us process Vitamin B9, or folate (specifically, folic acid), which
occurs naturally in a wide variety of foods and is involved in many physiological
PRECISION NUTRITION
processes, including having a healthy pregnancy.
Two common MTHFR polymorphisms (rs1801133 and rs1801131) affect how our
bodies metabolize this nutrient. Approximately 60 to 70% of people will have
one of these variations. About 10% of people will have both polymorphisms. |
When MTHFR protein levels are lower (particularly when one has two copies of
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
249
Table 10.1: Two common MTHFR polymorphisms and their effects
For the MTHFR protein to do its job, it also needs riboflavin (aka vitamin B2)
as a cofactor, a substance thats required for an enzyme to work. Riboflavin is
involved as a cofactor in a wide range of reactions and biological processes.
Right now, we know of about 90 genes in the human genome that code for
proteins that depend on riboflavin. There are six genes for riboflavin uptake and
PRECISION NUTRITION
conversion to the active coenzymes flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and flavin
adenine dinucleotide (FAD), and two for converting the enzyme to another form,
dihydroflavin.
This means that our ability to use MTHFR effectively may depend on many
complex factors beyond having a genetic MTHFR variant.
|
While there are quite a few genetic testing services out there that offer advice
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
250
Likewise, the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics actively
discourages testing for the two common polymorphisms in the MTHFR gene,
arguing that:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 10.5: MTHFR variants in PN population
However, it wasnt clear whether having any of these variants had actually led to
any health problems for the affected people. |
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
251
What this means for you
As usual, its complicated. Genes, proteins, and nutrients interact in highly
complex ways.
Work with a qualified healthcare provider if you have concerns. You can
get your homocysteine levels tested directly with a blood test. Dont rely
only on genetic testing data, which at best is simply a prediction of risk
rather than a definitive measure.
Caffeine metabolism
You might have noticed conflicting reports in the media about whether caffeine
is good or bad for you.
One problem in judging research studies on things like the link between, say,
coffee and heart disease, is that we vary genetically in how we process caffeine.
The gene CYP1A2 codes for the cytochrome P450 superfamily of enzymes,
involved in the breakdown of drugs along with cholesterol, sterols, and other
lipids. Caffeine is mainly metabolized by the liver enzyme known as P450 1A2, and
breaks down into byproducts like theophylline, paraxanthine, and theobromine (the
compound in dark chocolate that is supposed to make us feel good).
Variations in the CYP1A2 gene at the rs762551 SNP determine how quickly a
person will metabolize caffeine.
PRECISION NUTRITION
If you have the slow version, more caffeine seems to raise your chronic
disease risk.
If you have the fast version, more caffeine seems to lower your chronic
disease risk.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
It doesnt mean that your caffeine consumption habits are determined by your
genes, though there may be some genetic basis for that as well.
252
For people who were light or moderate caffeine consumers, inheritance
seemed to matter less than environment for instance, what people around
them were doing, whether they liked the taste of coffee or tea (for more on
food preferences, see Chapter 8), etc. But for people who were heavy caffeine
consumers, heredity seemed to play a bigger role though still not 100%.
Youd think that given this love for the magical alkaloid caffeine, all of us might
be fast metabolizers.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
253
Whats up next
In the next chapter, well look at how genetic variation might affect our athletic
performance and response to exercise.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 9 CHAPTER 11
What we found: Food What we found: Exercise
intolerances and muscle performance
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Why dont some foods dont agree In this chapter, we look at some of
with you? And how much of that the genetic factors that may shape
may be due to genetic factors? our response to (and recovery from)
exercise and training, and whether
we have a natural athletic type.
|
254
CHAPTER 11
In this chapter, well look at what genetic testing can tell us about:
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
255
Two important points to keep in mind:
While science is cool, and we have some interesting genetic findings and
areas for further exploration, we still know comparatively very little.
Just because a genetic test can tell you (for instance) what kinds of
muscle fiber types you might have, it doesnt mean that it can tell you the
perfect exercise plan for you.
As with most preferences, health risks, and genetic traits, there are many complex,
interrelated factors.
There is almost never one single gene that inevitably leads to a given result.
Any genetic data we share are simply clues for further exploration.
Maybe likely around December 31 each year youve thought, I should take
up running. Then you abandoned it around January 12 when your knee said,
Bad idea. Smarten up next year.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Maybe you are a runner, and wondering how you could be better.
Maybe your personal trainer is telling you that sprinting is awesome, but all you
want to do is chill out with an easy trail run. Or the other way around every
time you try to run more than 5 minutes, you want to lie down until the world
stops spinning. |
Maybe youve already run 3 miles in the time it took us to read this.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Have you ever wondered whether you are naturally meant to run (as
Christopher McDougall suggests in his book Born to Run)?
256
Human physical capacity is complex.
There are no known golf genes, parasailing genes or hip-hop dance genes.
Yet genetic data can give us some clues about how we might play to our
potential.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Figure 11.1: Sprinter versus endurance athlete
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
The usual implication is that if you want to look like a sprinter, train like one.
|
257
Indeed, fitness media is full of workout programs that promise you the body
youre seeking:
Certain types of training do, indeed, amplify physical abilities and characteristics
such as muscle size or mobility. So you could probably become more graceful
after years of ballet classes, more muscular after years of bodybuilding, or more
likely to grind other peoples faces into the mud after years of rugby.
Yet athletically ideal bodies in other words, bodies that demonstrate elite,
world-class performance and physique development involve a statistically
unusual collection of physical characteristics that are, for the most part, present
on Day 1 of training.
In other words, as Lady Gaga sings, genetically speaking, these top athletes
were born this way.
This is particularly true with events at the polar ends of the running continuum
PRECISION NUTRITION
(e.g., 100-meter sprints compared to endurance or ultra-endurance), or the
size continuum (e.g. gymnastics and horse racing versus basketball and sumo
wrestling).
Yet other events that include sprint or endurance performance also include
other elements, such as hand-eye coordination and reaction speed. Our co-
contributor John, a highly-ranked masters-level sprinter, reports that although
|
he could easily match NFL skill position players in a 40-meter sprint, he got
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Although most youth coaches know intuitively that some athletes show up with
better physical raw material than others, its hard to say exactly what the genetic
basis of those gifts might be.
|
258
What parts of athletic performance
come from our so-called genetic
potential?
And what parts are a result of training and practice?
Maximal oxygen uptake, aka VO2 max, which may be responsible for the
better endurance performance of athletes from mountain populations,
such as the East African highlands, the South American Andes or northern
Mexicos Sierra Madres, home of the famed indigenous Rarmuri /
Tarahumara runners. Although we can improve VO2 max a fair bit with
training, theres also a significant genetic contribution: researchers
speculate that between 40-50% of variance in oxygen uptake is genetically
determined.
Tendon stiffness, particularly in the lower leg, which could offer more elastic
spring to a stride.
PRECISION NUTRITION
enzyme activity: Since mitochondria are the power generators of a cell,
better mitochondrial function may mean more sustained energy for athletic
activity.
Even something that may seem as fixed as skeletal structure can be affected
by our environment.
|
259
For instance, lets say we have genetically-identical twins separated at birth.
One grew up in an affluent region with plenty of good nutrition and early-life
sports training.
The other grew up in a poor region with frequent food deprivation and
malnutrition, where sports training was kicking an old soccer ball around
and walking miles to get fresh water.
Although there will obviously be a family resemblance, the second twin will
probably end up with a somewhat different build likely lighter and smaller than
the first twin.
Even capacities that may seem fairly simple, like endurance, are actually
complex abilities that depend on many factors.
For instance, among endurance athletes from East Africa, how much do cultural
factors contribute to developing endurance capacity and performance for
example, is there a running culture where children are encouraged and
supported to run early in life? Do strong runners have a high social status?
What about the diverse geography of countries like Ethiopia and Kenya, which
contain both highlands and lowlands is there an oxygen advantage for
athletes who grow up at higher altitudes?
Similarly, Chris McDougalls book Born to Run looks at the Rarmuri / Tarahumara
PRECISION NUTRITION
population, who have physiological features that make them good runners, but
who also live in mountainous regions where running is a favored activity.
Or have they simply adapted their fitness and behavior to match to lower-oxygen
environments and/or movement cultures?
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
The Spanish ultra-athlete Kilian Jornet is an example of why its hard to answer such
questions.
260
This sounds like hes a genetic freak designed for endurance work, and maybe
he is but he also grew up as the son of a mountain guide in the Spanish
Pyrenees, in a rustic mountain hut at an altitude of about 6,500 ft (2,000 m).
His genes?
His lifetime physiological adaptation to living at high altitude?
His upbringing?
His family environment?
His training?
Of course, the answer is probably All of the above, and more.
Researchers tested the subjects for the following seven genetic variants,
involving many factors that are part of endurance performance:
The Arg577Ter variant of ACTN3, which codes for alpha-actinin-3, and which
PRECISION NUTRITION
well look more at below.
HFE His63Asp mutation; HFE codes for the human hemochromatosis protein
and is involved in iron uptake.
|
261
GDF-8 Lys153Arg mutation, aka MSTN, which codes for myostatin, a major
determinant of how much muscle mass we can have.
Would endurance athletes likely have more of the particular variations that
promote athletic performance than average? Yes.
But only three of the 46 top world-class endurance athletes had the best
possible score for up to six genes.
More significantly, none of them had the perfect profile of genetic variations.
Could the perfect endurance athlete (at least based on what we currently
know about genetic polymorphisms that favor endurance) theoretically exist?
In the United States, there are around 224 million people who report their main
ethnicity as white European. This means that using this model, 1,120 people
might have this genetic profile.
Should those 1,120 people report for marathon training immediately? Well, even
if we could find them, lots of other factors might affect their performance, such as:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Whether they are motivated to train;
Whether they have the mental skills to stay focused during long events;
Whether they want to spend hours pounding the pavement, or would rather
watch Netflix;
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
262
Some researchers suggest that among top athletes, about two-thirds of their
athletic capacity can be explained by genetic factors that add up, with the
remaining one-third being explained by environmental factors.
Yet that theoretically perfect profile may also depend on an athletes ancestry.
In a study that compared white European and East Asian swimmers, top
swimmers did have the ACE Ins/Del variation, but top Europeans tended to have
the D allele, while the top East Asians tended to have the I version (ACTN3 was
also tested, and it didnt seem to make a difference).
While we might be able to predict which people have the highest ceiling
for athletic development, we cant predict if a person will ever hit that
ceiling. We have some compelling clues and strong hypotheses, but not
enough data yet to build a model.
Most coaches will probably tell you that they would get better data from
simply knowing, observing, and understanding their athletes than from
genetic testing. Standing in a field with a clipboard, watching an athlete
train for several months or years, is probably the best data of all.
Heredity is not destiny. Even if you come from a population of people that
have traditionally done well at a certain activity, its no guarantee that you
will do the same, or that you have any intrinsic natural ability by virtue of
heredity. Conversely, even if you come from a population of people that
traditionally havent done well at a certain activity, its no guarantee that you
cant succeed at that activity.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
263
The genetic makeup of muscle
fibers
Muscles are made up of fibers. Within each muscle fiber are many myofibrils,
bundles of long polymers of the proteins myosin and actin. When myosin and
actin filaments slide past each other, we get muscular contraction.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Actin is an ancient protein that has long been conserved through evolution. In
mammals, there are six actin paralogs: different yet related forms encoded by
separate genes. One study describes actin as cellular steel, because actin can
act as an alloy to form various mixes of protein-based structures in cells.
There are likewise many classes of myosin proteins; myosin II is the type
involved in muscular contraction. Nearly 20 known genes contribute to myosin II.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
264
ACTN3
The ACTN3 gene makes a protein called alpha-actinin-3, which (unlike its buddy
ACTN2) is only expressed in fast-twitch muscle fibers, which we use for speed
and power movements like weightlifting, sprinting, and/or jumping.
Research suggests that particular forms of this gene correlate to sprint and
endurance performance. 23andMe looks at a particular SNP (rs1815739) on the
ACTN3 gene.
The T form of the rs1815739 SNP prevents the full alpha-actinin-3 protein from
being made, and people with two copies of T lack alpha-actinin-3 completely.
Thus, many elite sprinters and strength athletes have the CC type, while few
have the TT type. CT is a mixed type.
Among athletes, power athletes were much more likely to have at least one
working copy of the gene than non-athletes, and at elite levels, nearly everyone
has at least one working copy (in other words, they were either CC or CT).
Seems pretty straightforward: If you have the right ACTN3 variant, you should be
crushing all the strength-power events, right?
As it turns out, so far, only running seems to be strongly affected. It doesnt seem
to make a difference for other movements like throwing and jumping. Nor does it
seem to matter for team sports.
This doesnt necessarily mean that TT makes you a better endurance athlete
(since research suggests that being a TT gives elite cyclists no advantage), but
rather that if youre a TT, you may perform less well in sprint and power-type
events.
On the plus side, while TTs started out weaker in workout programs, they often
PRECISION NUTRITION
made significant gains when trained.
Nor does a TT type seem to cause any type of disease. This may be because
there are other related proteins that can do the job, though less well. For
instance, ACTN2, which is expressed in all muscle fibers, might compensate for
the loss of ACTN3 in fast Type II fibers. |
Alpha-actinin-3 may also affect how muscles use oxygen. Research suggests
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
that having less ACTN3 might make muscles greedier for oxygen, which might
be metabolically costly and slow the CT or TT people down. Studies in mice
have found that muscle fibers lacking alpha-actinin 3 are weaker and smaller, but
more efficient and fatigue-tolerant a perfect recipe for an endurance athlete.
|
265
What we found in our sample
About one-third of us have the pure fast-twitch or sprinter CC type of
ACTN3 SNP variation
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
266
How does this compare to real-world
experience?
Among the people we surveyed:
Our PN sample is a handy one for this particular SNP, because it contains
many people who have achieved significant athletic success (i.e., who were
competitive at the national or international level).
In fact, this high-achieving athlete group included someone with the opposite
SNP to what they should have been doing.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Genetic testing can tell you what form of the ACTN3 variant you have.
Both 23andMe and Nutrigenomix test for the rs1815739 SNP in the
ACTN3 gene.
267
How well can you recover from
exercise?
Being good at movement, sports, and exercise isnt just about how well you
perform during those activities. Its also about how well you recover afterwards.
After all, its hard to become a world-class athlete if most of your training time is
spent sitting on an ice pack.
When we move with vigor, we do minor damage that must be repaired, and we
put stress on our structures, which then remodel themselves to manage the
strain. Its this repair and remodeling process that makes us stronger and fitter,
not the workout itself.
Biological sex is also a factor, though this is usually hormonal rather than genetic
per se (in other words, these are not necessarily characteristics linked to X or Y
chromosomes).
For instance:
Women tend to have more tissue laxity than men (which may mean more
joint injuries) as well as a higher rate of many autoimmune diseases (which
are typically aggravated by stress, including training stress).
PRECISION NUTRITION
Mens higher average testosterone, which helps with protein synthesis,
means that they build more muscle faster.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
268
Then there are emotional, social, and cultural components.
For instance:
Are you a perfectionist, type-A, second place is first loser kind of thinker
who would rather tango with an alligator than miss a workout? (Or maybe
tangoing with the alligator is your workout?)
Do you choose sports and activities that push your limits? Or are you more
of a chill out with a restorative yoga class kind of person?
Do you train on a team where the motto is Pain is weakness leaving the
body or Tape it up and get back in there, ya baby?
Did you grow up doing manual labor from an early age, and/or in a family
where sports, exercise, and movement were encouraged? (In other words,
did you start building titanium tendons as a toddler?)
For instance:
How fast and effectively can your body make connective tissue proteins to
repair damage in structures like ligaments, tendons, and cartilage?
How fast and effectively can your muscles clear waste products and repair
themselves?
How fast and effectively does your immune system respond to the stress of
exercise? (Or does it over-respond and start attacking healthy tissues?)
PRECISION NUTRITION
How does your body manage inflammation? Is it a constantly raging forest
fire? Or a carefully controlled tactical operation, complete with fast and
efficient cleanup crew?
Given all the factors involved in recovery, there are naturally many potential
genetic contributors. Here are just a few. |
We wont look at all of these in depth. Just get the main ideas:
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Its complex.
We still have a lot to learn about what genetic factors affect our recovery
from exercise.
|
269
Gene / variation What its related to
Actin protein gene See above for more on ACTN3; some forms
ACTN3 (rs1815739) may predispose people to exercise-induced
rhabdomyolysis (excessive muscle tissue
breakdown)
PRECISION NUTRITION
IGF-II (C13790G, rs3213221) men)
IGF-II (ApaI, G17200A, rs680)
IGF-II antisense (IGF2AS)
(G11711T, rs7924316)
IGF binding protein gene
IGFBP-3 (C1592A, rs2132570)
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
270
Gene / variation What its related to
Myosin light chain kinase genes Myosin muscle protein phosphorylation; may
MLCK 49 (C>T) (rs2700352) affect how well muscle fibers can tolerate
MLCK 37885 (C>A) (rs28497577) mechanical force
PRECISION NUTRITION
The gene COL5A1 codes for the alpha-1 chain of type V collagen.
Variations of this gene have been linked to connective tissue disorders such as
osteogenesis imperfecta (aka brittle bone disease) or Ehlers-Danlos syndromes,
a group of connective tissue disorders that can range from mild joint laxity to
potentially fatal complications if the connective tissues of major organs are affected.
|
The rs12722 SNP on the COL5A1 gene has been linked to chronic connective
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
271
For many sports, having stiffer tendons and ligaments is an advantage, as these
tissues can bear more load and produce more elastic energy to help generate
force. Conversely, looser joints with laxer tissues may be more prone to injuries, as
the tendons and ligaments are less able to maintain stability around the joint.
Similarly, variations in the COL1A1 gene, which codes for collagen type I, are
associated with several complex connective tissue disorders, as well as shoulder
dislocations and ruptures of the anterior cruciate knee ligament (ACL) and/or
Achilles tendon.
There were clear variations in peoples experiences: Some people felt like they
were always injured; others said they almost never had problems despite regular
and rigorous workouts.
In addition, only one person whod been a high-achieving athlete (but started
athletics later in adulthood, rather than in childhood, as most others had)
reported frequent joint injuries. Most other athletes in the sample said they
rarely suffered from joint pain or injuries (or only had problems if they were really
pushing their training hard).
PRECISION NUTRITION
Or perhaps that people who started athletics young had better-conditioned
connective tissue?
In our sample, its hard to say whether theres any definite connection, but one
possible hypothesis could indeed be that to succeed in athletics, you need to
survive the training, and this includes joints as well as muscles. |
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
272
What this means for you
Genetic testing services may be able to tell you about some of the gene
variants linked to recovery from exercise. If youre considering using
genetic testing to explore this question, try to find a service that offers as broad
an analysis as possible, rather than just one or two exercise-related SNPs.
Even if you dont know your genetic makeup, or dont have genetic
variants that put you at risk, you still have to train intelligently. The freebie
of a genetic advantage (such as some theoretical mutation that gives
you Wolverine-like recovery powers) will run out eventually with age and
cumulative stress.
Pay attention to how well you recover from exercise. Look for how often
you feel joint pain or other aches and pains, and how strongly. These may be
related to your genetic makeup; they may be related to other environmental
factors. Regardless, you still have to address them. If youre always dealing
with some minor problem, consider addressing your recovery more
aggressively. You may not be recovering as well as you could be, or you may
be following inappropriate training methods for your body.
Follow YOUR bodys cues, and dont try to stick to a rigid workout
schedule, or someone elses workout plan. It might be too much work for
you, or not enough. Schedules and plans are only as good as the bodies
that can manage them.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Does exercise help you lose weight
easily?
As weve seen, exercise and daily-life movement are part of a healthy lifestyle
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Exercise does many good things: improves our fitness and strength; build lean
mass (muscle, bone, connective tissues); helps us beat stress; and so forth.
273
Many people who want to be smaller or leaner find themselves frustrated when
they hit the gym regularly, and dont seem to make much progress.
This may be due to poor training practices (in fact, it often is).
One SNP on the gene is associated with both a higher BMI, and seeing different
benefits from exercise, at least among people of European descent.
People with the AA variant at rs9939609 tended to have a higher BMI (in
other words, they were heavier), but also lost weight more readily when they
exercised.
People with the TT variant tended to be lighter, but lost less weight when
they exercised.
In the study used to support this finding, the effect was seen in people living in
North America, but not in Europe. This may be because on average, Europeans
tend to get more daily-life physical activity, such as walking or cycling, than
North Americans.
PRECISION NUTRITION
In other words:
People with the same ancestry and genetic variant see different effects
depending on their environment and choices.
At first glance, you might think this research says that exercise isnt as helpful for
weight loss people with a TT variant, and some people shouldnt bother.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
In fact, it suggests that exercise is more important, and more helpful, for
people who might be genetically predisposed to being heavier.
In our experience coaching over 45,000 clients, weve found that the simplest
explanations are often the most common.
|
274
While exercise alone doesnt necessarily help people lose weight (if thats
their goal), exercise plus a few basic nutrition and behavioral habits, done
consistently, does.
In other words, no matter what your genetic makeup involves, if you want to
lose weight, the pathway to get there is still the same as everyone elses.
Indeed, there are two key problems with predictions about exercise and
weight loss:
There are many ways to exercise. Exercise can be all kinds things, ranging
from yoga to extreme sports. Different types of exercise will affect our
bodies differently.
Weight loss is just one of many possible effects of exercise, but certainly not an
inevitable one, regardless of our genetic makeup.
Only about 22% of our sample matched their predicted FTO profile; about 78%
did not.
People who should have lost weight quickly didnt (or perhaps even put on
PRECISION NUTRITION
mass when exercising); people who shouldnt have lost weight quickly did.
So, at least in our sample FTOs ability to predict weight loss from exercise meh.
You might find that exercise helps you lose weight quickly or
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
moderately or not so much. This might mean you need to adjust your
workout plan, be more consistent with exercise, or simply enjoy the health
and stress-busting benefits of movement while looking for other ways to
keep your body fat and body weight so that its in a healthy range.
275
Whats next: Real-world strategies
By now, you may be wondering what you can do about your genetic makeup,
whether you know you have risk factors or advantages.
In the next chapter, well look at all the things that you can do to give yourself
the best chance of living a healthy, happy, functional life no matter what your
genetic code is.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 10 CHAPTER 12
What we found: Nutrient What does this
absorption and use mean for you?
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
In this chapter, well examine some Chapter 12: Now that you've
genetic factors that may affect learned more about genetic
how our bodies digest, absorb, testing, or even gathered your own
and use particular nutrients. data, what should you do next?
|
276
CHAPTER 12
Congratulations.
Which is:
PRECISION NUTRITION
Keep practicing the basic good habits that you know are helpful,
regardless of your genetic makeup.
277
At the edge of possibility
In 1868, Swiss doctor Friedrich Miescher extracted a compound from the nuclei
of cells, which he called nuclein. Today, we call this DNA, the code of life.
Around this time, Czech monk Gregor Mendel was breeding peas and
developing ideas about how these plants inherited their traits.
In the early 1950s, British scientists Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins used
X-rays to explore the structure of DNA molecules.
Chemist Linus Pauling took a crack at proposing the shape of DNA as a triple helix.
Eventually, with a landmark research paper in 1953, James Watson and Francis
Crick laid claim to the double helix format that we recognize today.
A baby boomer could have been born the day that Watson and Crick published
their paper, and not even be old enough to get the seniors discount at their local
movie theater by the time theyre able to enjoy the benefits of genetic science.
And we are standing on the edge of major scientific discoveries that will
forever change the way we think about ourselves. Our connections to a larger
ecosystem. And our potential.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Weve gone from making ball-and-stick models of a molecule that we barely
understood to fully mapping the human genome.
Now we can literally watch our cells work. Now we can see DNA unzip itself.
Now we can look at long tangles of chromatin tucked into tiny nuclei. Now we
can see proteins folding.
|
We can now see processes inside our bodies that previous generations could
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
barely imagine.
We can now create a child with three parents, and treat or even cure diseases
that have plagued humanity forever. And we are just a few years away from
perfecting the technology that can let us remove genetic diseases or grant
additional abilities to our species.
|
278
Every day, we discover new genes, new proteins, new pathways, new chemical
reactions, new possibilities and opportunities.
But:
PRECISION NUTRITION
occurrence, such as a disease or health risk later in life?
Hopefully by now youve gotten some general ideas about genetics, genetic
testing, and how these might relate to your health, fitness, physical makeup, and
performance.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
279
Whats next for you?
Reading through this book, you probably wondered things like:
Whats in my genes?
What happens if I discover stuff I dont like in my genetic test results?
I got my test results back how do I make sense of them?
What am I supposed to do with all this stuff?
Im a health and fitness professional what do I tell my clients about their
genetic potential and risk factors?
PRECISION NUTRITION
What would I like to find out? Why?
What would be useful to me? Why?
What do I plan to do with the results? Why?
What am I comfortable with knowing or not knowing? Why?
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
280
2. If youve already had genetic testing done,
start with how.
Understand how things work and what that means.
PRECISION NUTRITION
What kind of health professional can help me answer the questions I have?
Who can coach me through my choices in the future, once I know what (if
anything) might help me?
281
You probably have few for-sures in your genetic code.
Your game, should you choose to play it, is optimizing your genetic potential
while reducing your risks.
The problem is, we dont know exactly what this means for every single genetic
combination, or even most individual variations.
However, based on the research we do have, we can say what optimizes some
potentials and reduces some risks.
What to do next
Think like a scientist.
Appreciate the complex, wondrous universe of biology.
DNA unites us with all living things in the world. We are all connected.
Your cells carry ancient stories, and at least parts of those stories can also be
understood by every other organism whether octopus or orchid, mouse or
mushroom, bird or bacteria.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Ask what evidence supports any claims made.
Notice when you may be engaging in magical thinking (Maybe genetic testing
will solve all my problems!) or becoming emotionally attached to the results
that you get.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
If you have a mysterious health problem, or are someone whos always looking
for the edge, you will naturally want to find solutions, or connect dots that
arent related.
If you are someone who likes data and exploration, you might also be tempted
by the utopian promise of quantifying the self and optimizing or hacking
human function.
|
282
This isnt bad. Its normal.
No amount of testing on its own will change your habits. A genetic result will not
somehow scare or motivate you into sustainable behavioral modification.
Expect complexity.
Distrust one size fits all or one factor explains all solutions, and people trying
to sell you something based on them.
If you dont have enough training to interpret the evidence, look for a genetic
counsellor and/or other qualified healthcare provider who is informed and
relatively unbiased.
You can also contribute to things like the Personal Genome Project, Human
Longevity Inc. (HLI), 1000Genomes, or National Geographics Genographic
PRECISION NUTRITION
Project.
Recognize that your ethnicity, heredity, and ancestry will affect your results.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Some genetic tests might not even apply to you if your specific ethnic group
hasnt been well-studied.
(And, if possible, demand that your group is studied. Science should not be an
elite club.)
|
283
Be curious about the paths your ancestors travelled.
A very long and complicated series of events led to you being here right now.
Infinite biological equations and social choices had to happen to make you (or
even to give you eyes and a brain so you could read this).
Where are your people from? How did they get here?
Learning about your history can add to your own sense of identity and pride.
Be curious about food, movement, and health traditions in the regions where
youre from.
Some traditions may be about convenience or belief. Others may reflect actual
data on what has worked in the past for a specific population.
For instance, if people where youre from never drink milk but always win
weightlifting events, this may tell you that your population of origin likely doesnt
have the lactase persistence gene, but could have an inherited tendency for
being strong.
An Owners Manual isnt a real thing (although it could certainly be if you kept a
physical file of your observations). It just means noticing and gathering evidence
from your own experiences, and recording it (whether mentally or literally).
PRECISION NUTRITION
If your genetic test says you may have one trait, but you dont seem to, thats
useful data.
If your genetic test says you may have a high risk for a certain health condition,
but youre not sure, thats useful data too. Go and get other types of tests done,
such as blood work.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Medical tests can be extremely helpful. They can give us an objective picture
of what is actually happening in our bodies, based on known and relatively
reliable indicators.
|
284
At the same time, you can also observe many simple and important indicators on
your own. Such as:
And so on.
In our coaching programs, we teach clients to identify and interpret their own
basic physical cues in order to get a simple snapshot of their own overall health.
Exercise regularly.
Recognize that everyone benefits from exercise, movement, and activity.
Regardless of your genetic makeup, your body will work better when youre
consistently active.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
285
For instance, exercise and movement help us:
Exercise may be one of the most powerful tools in our toolbox, as it improves
almost everything, often relatively quickly.
PRECISION NUTRITION
such as mitochondrial function and fuel use (e.g. PGC-1, transcription
factor A, mitochondrial (TFAM); peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor
(PPAR-); and pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase, isoenzyme 4 (PDK4) and
so forth).
Recognize that genetically speaking, not everyone sees exactly the same
results from exercise.
So dont get frustrated or criticize yourself if youre working hard but not seeing
the same results as your buddy who seems to be a natural athlete.
|
286
Or, if your body naturally seems to respond well to exercise, dont expect other
bodies to do the same (especially if youre a coach who works with all kinds of
clients).
Exercise helps us metabolize sugar and fat properly, but we vary genetically in
how well or quickly we respond to exercise in this way.
For example:
One study looked at the rs1801282 variant on the PPARG gene that codes
for PPAR-, which helps regulate metabolism of glucose and fatty acids.
While some people with a particular variant of rs1801282 (also known as the
Pro12Ala variant) were better at clearing glucose during exercise, everyone
benefited metabolically from exercise.
In another study, people with the -514C allele of LIPC were more likely to
significantly improve their insulin sensitivity if they exercised regularly.
And so on.
Other genetic variants may affect a wide variety of exercise results, such as
heart rate, vascular function during exercise, and other measures of aerobic
performance.
If you have a particular variant of the AMPD1 gene, which codes for an enzyme
known as adenosine monophosphate deaminase (one of the enzymes used
to process ATP), you might get more muscle pain and cramping during intense
exercise. Though you arent alone: At least one world-class runner has this variant.
PRECISION NUTRITION
And not someone elses.
If youre looking for the best results possible, then try to match your physical
activities to your most informed hypotheses about what your unique body prefers.
Over time, gather data about your hypotheses and refine your action plan.
If its pretty clear youre a fast-twitcher, enjoy your strength and power sports, and
dont feel like you should be doing distance running.
|
287
If its pretty clear that youre a slow-burner, enjoy your endurance sports, and
dont try to beat the world high-jump record. (Well, you can try, just dont get
mad if you dont succeed.)
Of course, if you enjoy a sport that you arent naturally well-suited for, go and
have fun doing it. You probably wont be the best in the world at it, but who cares?
But, for the most part, we have a fair bit of control over such factors as:
what we eat;
whether we drink alcohol;
whether we smoke;
what drugs we take (assuming that these are non-life-saving medications,
of course);
PRECISION NUTRITION
how we respond to daily-life stressors; and
how and whether we choose to reproduce and pass on our DNA
to offspring.
You may have heard the expression, Genetics loads the gun; environment pulls
the trigger.
Now, thats a bit of a disturbing analogy that makes genetics sound like a
professional but ambivalent hitman, but it gives you the idea:
288
This includes real things like chemicals as well as more intangible things like
social support. (See below.)
One researcher has coined the term exposome to describe all the
environmental factors that might affect genetic expression throughout our lives.
Environmental stressors (such as pollution, toxic chemicals, medications, or
pathogens like viruses) can all affect expression. This, in turn, can affect things
like our metabolic health.
Regardless of your genetic makeup, its probably not a great idea to stew in a
soup of potentially toxic or DNA-altering chemicals.
Look around your immediate environment and consider the products youre
using, and/or what youre exposed to. Consider whether any of this can be
improved.
The longer our telomeres are, the healthier were likely to be, and the less
cellular aging we likely have.
Shorter telomeres, on the other hand, indicate more aging and degeneration
again, sort of like a shoelace fraying.
So, how long our telomeres are can tell us about how healthy our DNA is, and
how quickly or slowly were aging in a biological sense.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
289
Figure 12.1: Telomere shortening
For instance, a study that looked at women caring for a child with a major
disability or serious chronic illness found that the long-term stress of caregiving
and worry over a childs health was linked to shorter telomeres. Feeling socially
isolated and lonely can change our genetic expression too.
PRECISION NUTRITION
However, stress isnt just whats around us. Its how we respond to whats around us.
290
Parents can play a major role here, not just in offering their own genetic
material, but also in creating surroundings that help their children optimize their
epigenetic expression.
For instance:
Build your own healthy habits. Many of our clients come to us because
theyve decided to be healthy role models for their children. And, as a parent
(especially if your children are younger and they live with you), you can
shape their food and activity choices which will be a lot easier if your own
fundamental habits are in place.
Make wise choices before conception and during pregnancy. This goes for
you too, dad. Both parents genetic material can be affected by their own
health habits. So if youre hoping for a baby but havent gotten started on
the project yet start building those healthy habits now. And, of course, if
youre currently pregnant, choosing healthier options will improve whats
known as the maternal effect the role that the mother plays in her
offsprings epigenetic expression. (More on this below.)
Introduce your child to a wide range of tastes. (If youre currently pregnant,
try a wide range of tastes yourself.) Evidence suggests both prenatal and
early childhood exposure to various foods helps set taste preferences
for later on. If you want your kids to eat healthy foods, eat healthy foods
yourself, and make them readily available.
PRECISION NUTRITION
were moving, and when were connected to other people. Even if you
got every single one of the exercise nonresponder / metabolic disruptor
/ excess adiposity genes, you can still (to some degree) change the
expression of these, especially if you start as early in life as possible. (But of
course, its never too late to make some healthy changes.)
Dont smoke. This should be obvious, but its pretty clear: Smoking changes
|
our epigenetic expression in a bad way. It affects both the smoker and
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
291
Maternal effects
Although, of course, both parents contribute genetic material to their offspring,
given the mothers role in gestation, she can have a powerful effect on her
developing fetus epigenetic expression.
In particular, what she eats and the environment shes in can affect the outcome.
For instance:
Along with physical health, mothers mental and emotional health is also
important.
For instance, the NR3C1 gene codes for the glucocorticoid receptor (GR).
Glucocorticoid hormones, such as cortisol, are involved in our stress response
and inflammation.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Our stress response is organized by a complex set of feedback loops known as
the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. HPA axis function shapes how we
are able to respond to stress, and how generally anxious and physiologically or
psychologically reactive we tend to be.
in NR3C1. This epigenetic change then predicted increases in infants HPA stress
reactivity.
292
Other research suggests that there are similar links between mothers mood or
distress level during pregnancy, and their offsprings epigenetic expression of
other genes such as HSD11B2, which codes for a protein that converts cortisol to
cortisone and vice versa, as well as protecting other tissues from the damaging
effects of corticosteroids.
Of course, as a parent, you cant control all the factors involved in your childs
epigenetic expression. (See above: Control what you can control.)
Rather than worrying too much about the genetic blueprint you or your
child got, focus on how you can help build the best house possible from
those blueprints.
The outer limits of our health, ability, function, and performance are
determined by factors outside our control (factors that include genetics).
So, for instance, a person who is 5 feet tall can learn to run, jump, and throw a
basketball better perhaps even at a world-class level of shot accuracy. But
that person will never be able to dunk a basketball like a 7-footer.
At some point, we bump up against our own limits, and some tasks are simply
PRECISION NUTRITION
impossible for some people.
On the other hand, most of us will never find most of those limits, because the
playing field of our physiology is wider and bigger than we can imagine.
293
So, if youre curious about what that looks like for you:
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 11 CHAPTER 13
What we found: Exercise Glossary of terms
and muscle performance
|
294
295
PRECISION NUTRITION | GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN |
Glossary of terms
CHAPTER 13
#
6-n-propylthiouracil (PROP): A compound that tastes bitter to some people, but
is tasteless to others; the ability to detect it is genetically determined.
A
Absolute risk: In terms of health conditions, the prevalence of a disease within
an entire population (e.g., 3% of all people will get Disease X in their lifetime).
Adenine: One of the nucleotides that forms DNA / RNA, along with cytosine,
guanine, and thymine (uracil in RNA). Often abbreviated as A. In base pairing,
adenine pairs with thymine (T) and uracil (U).
Alkaline lysis: A process for breaking down cell membranes in order to extract
genetic material, using a base like sodium hydroxide and a surfactant.
Allele: A variant of the same gene (usually emerging through mutation), found at
the same place on the chromosome.
PRECISION NUTRITION
location are associated with the same trait or outcome.
Amplicon: A piece of DNA or RNA that has been amplified or copied, especially
through the polymerase chain reaction (PCR).
|
296
Amplicon sequencing: A technique that uses the polymerase chain reaction
(PCR) to make billions and billions of copies of a previously-identified stretch of
DNA, and sequence these copies (known as amplicons).
Antigen-presenting cells: Cells that tell other cells of the immune system (such
as T cells) that theres trouble spotted (such as a pathogen), and its time to go to
work.
PRECISION NUTRITION
sample.
Autonomic nervous system (ANS): The branch of the nervous system that
controls basic functions such as heart rate and breathing.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Autosomal dominant: A form of inheritance in which you need only one copy of
a gene from a parent to express a trait.
|
297
Autosomal recessive: A form of inheritance in which you need two copies of a
gene (one from each parent) to express a trait.
Avenins: A protein in oats that is similar to gluten in wheat, and which can cause
an immune system reaction in some people.
B
BamforthLazarus syndrome: A rare genetic disease in which thyroid tissue is
underdeveloped or missing entirely.
Basal metabolic rate (BMR): The bodys idling speed, i.e., the rate at which
metabolic reactions take place and use energy to do so.
Base excision repair (BER): A method that our cells use to repair damaged DNA.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Biological sex: The collection of physical characteristics (such as chromosomes
or reproductive organs) that identifies a body as male, female, and/or intersex.
298
C
Carbohydrate: A family of biological molecules that includes sugars, starches,
and soluble and insoluble fiber.
Chemokine: A cell signaling molecule (cytokine) that attracts white blood cells
to the site of tissue damage.
Cholesterol: A waxy lipid that we can make in our liver or consume from food.
We use cholesterol to make many important molecules that our bodies use,
including our sex hormones.
Chromatin: The material, composed of DNA, RNA, and proteins, that makes up
our chromosomes.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP): A molecular biology technique that
identifies proteins that interact with known DNA sequences.
299
Chylomicrons: Small lipoprotein particles that circulate in the blood after fat is
absorbed from the small intestine.
Closed assay: An assay that identifies beforehand what its seeking, such as a
particular mutation or gene variant.
Cruft: A computer term for crud or leftover bits of stuff; poorly designed,
unnecessarily complicated, or unwanted code or software.
Cytosine: One of the nucleotides that forms DNA / RNA, along with adenine,
guanine, and thymine (uracil in RNA). Often abbreviated as C. In base pairing,
cytosine pairs with guanine (G).
PRECISION NUTRITION
D
Deletion: A mutation in which some genetic material is lost during the process of
DNA replication.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
DNA: A biological molecule that holds the code for making all living things.
Dominant traits / genes: Traits and/or genes that are more likely to be
expressed, and which require only one copy to do so.
|
300
Double-strand breaks: A mutation or damage that occurs when both strands of
DNA are severed. This often happens in response to ionizing radiation.
E
Electrolytes: Dissolved salts such as sodium or potassium.
Epigenetics: The study of factors that affect genetic expression for instance,
how the same genetic blueprint may actually be used to build different things.
Energy balance: The relationship between energy (calories) in (from food) and
energy out (from metabolism / excretion / activity).
Energy sensing: Mechanisms in the body that monitor how much energy
is available.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Eukaryote: Organisms that have cells with a nucleus and organelles surrounded
by a membrane. The nucleus contains genetic material in the form of
chromosomes. Organisms without this are known as prokaryotes.
Exon: The parts of the gene that code for protein sequences (the opposite
of introns).
301
Exposome: The combination of all environmental factors that might affect
epigenetic and genetic expression.
F
Feedback loop: A coordinated series of if-then actions in which output
determines future input; information at a given outcome is used to determine the
next action.
Fixation: When multiple alleles from a gene pool are removed and only one
remains. Once this happens, the gene is said to be fixed in the population.
Forkhead box (FOX) proteins: FOX proteins are transcription factors that
control the expression of other genes. They are typically involved in regulating
cell growth, development, differentiation, and survival.
G
Gain of function mutation: A type of mutation that results in the altered gene
PRECISION NUTRITION
having new or enhanced activity, a new molecular function, or a new pattern of
gene expression. These mutations are often dominant.
Gametes: A haploid germ cell of sexual reproduction (i.e., egg / ovum or sperm).
fragments by size.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Genes: Regions of DNA that have instructions for making specific proteins.
302
Genetic test: A laboratory assay specifically for clinical testing purposes that
is used to identify specific genotype(s) to diagnose a specific disease in a
specific group of people for a specific purpose. Genetic testing is very targeted
compared to a genetic assay, which may be scanning, or may be targeted.
Genetics: The study of genes, how they work, and how particular traits (such as
eye color) are passed from parent to offspring (known as heredity).
Gender identity: Ones deeper sense of self as having a particular gender (or not).
PRECISION NUTRITION
Gliadin: A protein found in wheat; one of the components of gluten.
Glucose: A simple sugar that is the raw material for building ATP, our cells energy.
Glucose transporter (GLUT): A family of proteins found on cell membranes that help
move glucose across those membranes. GLUT4 is the insulin-regulated glucose
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
transporter.
Gluten: A protein found in wheat to which some people (such as those with
celiac disease) have an immune system reaction.
|
303
Glutenin: A protein found in wheat; one of the components of gluten.
Guanine: One of the nucleotides that forms DNA / RNA, along with adenine,
cytosine, and thymine (uracil in RNA). Often abbreviated as G. In base pairing,
guanine pairs with cytosine (C).
H
Haploid: Containing one set of chromosomes. (Opposite: diploid.)
PRECISION NUTRITION
Heterozygocity / heterozygous: Inheritance of two different copies of the same
gene. (Opposite of homozygous.)
304
Histone modification: Changes to histones (such as acetylation or various types
of methylation) after RNA translation that can affect genetic expression.
Hominin: The taxonomic group that contains genera that have descended from a
common ancestor, the genus Homo (e.g. modern humans H. sapiens, H. habilis,
H. neanderthalensis) and the extinct genera Australopithecus, Paranthropus and
Ardipithecus. Some taxonomists also consider the genus Pan to be hominin. Pan
includes our closest living relatives: chimpanzees and bonobos.
Hordeins: A protein that occurs in barley and can trigger the same type of
immune response as gluten.
Human leukocyte antigen (HLA): A gene complex that codes for major
histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins in humans. These cell surface
proteins regulate our immune system by helping our cells recognize foreign
molecules.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Hypercholesterolemia: Excess cholesterol in the bloodstream.
Hypothalamus: A small gland in the brain that controls many key metabolic
functions.
305
I
Immunoassay: A biochemical test that measures the presence of proteins or
other substances through their properties as antigens or antibodies.
Immunoglobulin: A type of protein in the serum and cells of the immune system
that functions as an antibody.
Imprinting: An epigenetic modification inherited from only one parent, with the
other gene copy from the second parent being turned off.
Insulin: A crucial hormone for nutrient storage and anabolism that is released by
the pancreas in response to higher blood sugar (glucose) levels.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Insulin sensitivity: How able our cells are to respond appropriately to insulin. We
want this to be working well, and to have high insulin sensitivity. If we have poor
sensitivity, we develop insulin resistance.
Interleukins (IL): A group of cytokines, expressed by white blood cells, that are
involved in regulating the immune system response.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
306
Intervening sequences: Another term for introns.
Intron: A part of the gene or gene transcript that is removed before the mature
RNA is translated to a protein (the opposite of exons).
L
Lactase: An enzyme that allows us to digest lactose, a sugar in milk.
Lethal mutation: A mutation that kills the organism, and/or results in the
organism being unable to reproduce.
Ligand: A molecule that binds to another for some biological purpose (such as
initiating a biochemical reaction).
Lipoproteins: Proteins that transport lipids. Since lipids cant dissolve in water
PRECISION NUTRITION
but proteins can, lipoproteins help many fat-based molecules move around the
body through the blood.
Lyse: To break down the membrane of a cell. This occurs in genetic testing to
allow the researcher or technician to remove the genetic material from the cell.
|
307
M
Macrophage: A type of immune system cell thats part of our cellular cleanup
crew.
Major histocompatibility complex (MHC): Cell surface proteins that regulate our
immune system by helping our cells recognize foreign molecules.
Maternal effect: The role that the mother plays in her offsprings epigenetic
expression, whether through her genetic material, in the environment she
provides, or both.
PRECISION NUTRITION
genes are often switched off, which can be a problem if you want those genes
to be transcribed and protein made.
Microarray: A chip with a large array of sensors to detect certain DNA or RNA
sequences.
sequences of DNA.
Mismatch repair (MMR) a system for identifying and fixing errors in DNA
replication and recombination.
308
Mitochondria: An organelle within a cell thats involved in energy production
and respiration.
Mobile genetic element: A type of DNA that can move around the genome.
N
Neurotrophins: Chemicals involved in the growth, development, and survival
of neurons.
Noncoding regions / noncoding DNA: Parts of the genetic code that dont
code for any proteins, but that might be involved in other genetic regulatory and
PRECISION NUTRITION
structural functions.
Nonsense mutation: A mutation that creates stop codons and can truncate the
|
protein in the process of being created. This means that a cells ribosome (the
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
protein-making factory), will stop producing the protein before that protein has
all of its amino acids.
Nuclear pore: A channel between a cells nucleus and cytoplasm that regulates
movement of substances in and out of the nucleus.
|
309
Nuclear receptor: A type of protein found in the nuclei of cells that can bind
directly to DNA and regulate the expression of genes.
Nucleic acid: Linked chain(s) of nucleotides. DNA stands for deoxyribonucleic acid.
Nutrient partitioning: What our bodies do with the food we eat (e.g., use it for
repair, use it for energy, and/or store it).
O
Open-ended assay: An assay that looks for anything of interest, like scanning a
landscape to see what pops out.
PRECISION NUTRITION
P
Paralog: One of two or more genes that come from the same ancestral gene as
a result of gene duplication.
Perilipin: A protein that surrounds lipid droplets in fat cells, helping to control the
metabolism of adipocytes by regulating how fat-mobilizing enzymes (lipases)
interact with the stored fat.
|
310
Pituitary: A small endocrine gland within the brain thats involved in regulating
many other endocrine glands, such as the thyroid.
Pleiotropy: From the ancient Greek pleion, or more, and tropos, or way, one
gene influencing two or more apparently unrelated processes or traits.
Predictive value: How well a given factor, such as a genetic variant (or set of
variants), can explain an outcome, such as a disease or trait.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Prokaryote: Simple organisms whose cells do not contain specialized organelles
or a nucleus with genetic material bound into chromosomes. Many bacteria, for
instance, are prokaryotic. Compare to eukaryote.
Promoter: A region of DNA that binds with RNA polymerase and transcription
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
311
Prostaglandins: A group of lipid-based chemicals that have hormone-like
effects, including regulating inflammation.
Protein: A biological molecule, made of amino acids, that a gene codes for.
Pseudogene: Segments of DNA that are related to real genes, but are not
functional.
R
Reactive oxygen species: Waste products generated from the normal process of
cellular metabolism, which contain oxygen and are chemically reactive.
Recessive traits / genes: Traits that require two gene copies one from each
parent, to express that trait.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Retroviral sequences: A segment of genetic material that is an artifact of
ancestral retroviral infections, but which is now incorporated into current DNA.
Ribose: A sugar that forms one of the components of DNA / RNA. In DNA, the
molecule is deoxyribose; in RNA its ribose.
312
RNA
Ribosomal RNA (rRNA): An RNA enzyme that links amino acids together in
the ribosome to make a polypeptide chain, and makes up some of the struc-
ture of ribosomes.
Transfer RNA (tRNA): RNA molecules that carry specific amino acids to the
ribosome. They match mRNA codons with their respective amino acid.
Small nuclear RNA (snRNA): Short RNA segments that form small nuclear
ribonucleoprotein particles (snRNPs), that then are part of RNA processing.
Small interfering RNA (siRNA): A short segment of RNA that can interfere
with the expression of specific genes.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Secalins: A type of protein found in rye, which may trigger an immune system
response similar to gluten.
a signaling pathway.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
313
Sexual dimorphism: Having two biological sexes with distinct physiological
characteristics within a species (e.g., male and female).
Silent mutations: Mutations that dont significantly alter the phenotype or health
of the organism.
T
T-helper cells: A type of immune system cell that assists other cells by releasing
cytokines.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Telomere: The structures on the ends of chromosomes that function much like
the plastic end of a shoelace, preventing degradation of chromosomes.
Thymine: One of the nucleotides that forms DNA, along with adenine, cytosine,
and guanine. Often abbreviated as T. In base pairing, thymine pairs with adenine
(A). In RNA, thymine is replaced by uracil (U).
|
314
Trait: A particular characteristic of an organism (such as eye color or hair texture)
that is expressed by gene(s) as well as influenced by the environment.
Translesion synthesis (TLS): A type of DNA damage control that allows repair
of genetic material to occur past damaged sites (aka lesions).
Transposon: Segments of DNA that can move around within the genome.
Triglyceride: The storage and transport form of fatty acids, formed with three
fatty acids attached to a glycerol backbone.
Type 2 diabetes (T2D): A disease in which the body cannot use insulin properly,
and blood glucose (sugar) remains consistently high.
PRECISION NUTRITION
U
Uracil: One of the nucleotides that forms RNA, along with adenine, cytosine, and
|
guanine. Often abbreviated as U. In base pairing, uracil pairs with adenine (A). In
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
315
V
Variable number tandem repeat (or VNTR): Repetition of codons different
numbers of times (e.g., the same codon may be repeated 3 times versus 5
times).
Vitamin D receptor (VDR): A nuclear receptor that can bind to vitamin D and
affect genetic expression.
W
Whole-genome sequencing: Reading and analyzing an organisms entire
genome.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 12 CHAPTER 14
What does this References
mean for you?
|
316
| |
317
PRECISION NUTRITION GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
References
CHAPTER 14
#
1000 Genomes Project Consortium. A global reference for human genetic
variation. Nature. 2015 Oct 1;526(7571):68-74.
A
Aaltonen S, Kujala UM, Kaprio J. Factors behind leisure-time physical activity
behavior based on Finnish twin studies: The role of genetic and environmental
influences and the role of motives. BioMed Research International.
2014;2014:931820.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Acevedo, S. F., Valencia, C., Lutter, M., & McAdams, CJ. Severity of eating
disorder symptoms related to oxytocin receptor polymorphisms in anorexia
nervosa. Psychiatry Research. 2015;228(3), 641648.
Adlam J, Zaman R. The role of BDNF and memory in major depressive disorder.
Psychiatr Danub. 2013 Sep;25 Suppl 2:S368-9.
|
Akimoto AK, Miranda-Vilela AL, Alves PC, Pereira LC, Lordelo GS, Hiragi Cde O,
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
318
Al-Attar SA, Pollex RL, Ban MR, et al. Association between the FTO rs9939609
polymorphism and the metabolic syndrome in a non-Caucasian multi-ethnic
sample. Cardiovascular Diabetology. 2008;7:5.
Almn MS, Jacobsson JA, Shaik JH, Olszewski PK, Cedernaes J, Alsi J, et al.
The obesity gene, TMEM18, is of ancient origin, found in majority of neuronal
cells in all major brain regions and associated with obesity in severely obese
children. BMC Medical Genetics. 2010 Apr 9;11(1):58.
Altinisik J, Meric G, Erduran M, Ates O, Ulusal AE, Akseki D. The BstUI and
DpnII Variants of the COL5A1 Gene Are Associated With Tennis Elbow. The
American Journal of Sports Medicine. 2015 Jul;43(7):1784-9.
Altinisik J, Meric G, Erduran M, Ates O, Ulusal AE, Akseki D. The BstUI and DpnII
variants of the COL5A1 gene are associated with tennis elbow. Am J Sports
Med. 2015 Jul;43(7):1784-9.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Alzheimers Association. 2015 Alzheimers disease facts and figures.
Alzheimers Dement. 2015 Mar;11(3):332-84.
An P, Borecki IB, Rankinen T, Prusse L, Leon AS, Skinner JS, et al. Evidence
of major genes for exercise heart rate and blood pressure at baseline and in
response to 20 weeks of endurance training: the HERITAGE family study. Int J
Sports Med. 2003;24:492498.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
319
Ando T, Komaki G, Nishimura H, et al; Japanese Genetic Research Group for
Eating Disorders. A ghrelin gene variant may predict crossover rate from
restricting-type anorexia nervosa to other phenotypes of eating disorders: a
retrospective survival analysis. Psychiatr Genet. 2010 Aug;20(4):153-9.
Asselbergs FW, Guo Y, van Iperen EPA, et al. Large-scale gene-centric meta-
analysis across 32 studies identifies multiple lipid loci. American Journal of
Human Genetics. 2012;91(5):823-838.
Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, No. 12-398 (569 U.S.
June 13, 2013).
PRECISION NUTRITION
IgG antibodies in irritable bowel syndrome: a randomised controlled trial. Gut.
2004; 53: 14591464.
Avau B, Depoortere I. The bitter truth about bitter taste receptors: beyond
sensing bitter in the oral cavity. Acta Physiol (Oxf). 2016 Apr;216(4):407-20.
320
B
Babel Copaver K, Hertogh C, Hue O. Sprint performance changes and
determinants in Afro-Caribbean adolescents between 13 and 15 years old.
Journal of Human Kinetics. 2012 Oct 1;34(1):89-98.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Barres R, Yan J, Egan B, Treebak JT, Rasmussen M, Fritz T, Caidahl K, Krook A,
OGorman DJ, Zierath JR. Acute exercise remodels promoter methylation in
human skeletal muscle. Cell Metabolism. 2012 Mar 7;15(3):405-11.
Baumert P, Lake MJ, Stewart CE, Drust B, Erskine RM. Genetic variation and
exercise-induced muscle damage: implications for athletic performance, injury
and ageing. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2016 Sep 1;116(9):1595-625.
|
321
Bayoumi R, De Fanti S, Sazzini M, Giuliani C, Quagliariello A, Bortolini E, et al.
Positive selection of lactase persistence among people of Southern Arabia.
American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 2016 Dec 1;161(4):676-84.
Behar DM, Harmant C, Manry J, Van Oven M, Haak W, Martinez-Cruz B, et al. The
Basque paradigm: Genetic evidence of a maternal continuity in the Franco-
Cantabrian region since pre-Neolithic times. American Journal of Human
Genetics. 2012 Mar 9;90(3):486-93.
Bentz EK, Hefler LA, Kaufman U, Huber JC, Kolbus A, Tempfer CB. A
polymorphism of the CYP17 gene related to sex steroid metabolism is
associated with female-to-male but not male-to-female transsexualism. Fertil
Steril. 2008;90:5659.
Berciano S, Lai CQ, Herranz J, Aslibekyan S, Claas SA, Irvin MR, Tsai MY,
Hopkins PN, Hidalgo B, Arnett DK, Ordovas JM. Behavior related genes, dietary
preferences and anthropometric traits. The FASEB Journal. 2017 Apr 1;31(1
Supplement):299-1.
Berge T, Leikfoss IS, Brorson IS, et al. The multiple sclerosis susceptibility
genes TAGAP and IL2RA are regulated by vitamin D in CD4+ T cells. Genes
and Immunity. 2016;17(2):118-127.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Berger LR, Hawks J, de Ruiter DJ, Churchill SE, Schmid P, Delezene LK, et al.
Homo naledi, a new species of the genus Homo from the Dinaledi Chamber,
South Africa. Elife. 2015 Sep 10;4:e09560.
Bevan CL, Hoare S, Claessens F, Heery DM, Parker MG. The AF1 and AF2
domains of the androgen receptor interact with distinct regions of SRC1.
Molecular and Cellular Biology. 1999;19(12):8383-8392.
|
322
Bid HK, Konwar R, Aggarwal CG, Gautam S, Saxena M, Nayak VL, Banerjee M.
Vitamin D receptor (FokI, BsmI and TaqI) gene polymorphisms and type 2
diabetes mellitus: a North Indian study. Indian J Med Sci. 2009 May;63(5):187-94.
Bokor S, Legry V, Meirhaeghe A, Ruiz JR, Mauro B, Widhalm K,; HELENA Study
group, et al. Single-nucleotide polymorphism of CD36 locus and obesity in
European adolescents. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2010 Jul;18(7):1398-403.
Bollepalli S, Dolan LM, Deka R, Martin LJ. Association of FTO gene variants
with adiposity in African-American adolescents. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2010
Oct;18(10):1959-63.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Bondar C, Plaza-Izurieta L, Fernandez-Jimenez N, et al. THEMIS and PTPRK
in celiac intestinal mucosa: coexpression in disease and after in vitro gliadin
challenge. European Journal of Human Genetics. 2014;22(3):358-362.
323
Bosco P, Caraci F, Copani A, Spada RS, Sortino MA, Salluzzo R, et al. The CDC2
I-G-T haplotype associated with the APOE epsilon4 allele increases the risk of
sporadic Alzheimers disease in Sicily. Neurosci Lett. 2007 Jun 4;419(3):195-8.
Botigu LR, Henn BM, Gravel S, Maples BK, Gignoux CR, Corona E, et al. Gene
flow from North Africa contributes to differential human genetic diversity in
southern Europe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2013 Jul
16;110(29):11791-6.
Bouchard C, Daw EW, Rice T, Prusse LO, Gagnon J, Province MA, et al. Familial
resemblance for VO2max in the sedentary state: the HERITAGE family study.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 1998 Feb;30(2):252-8.
Brand OJ, Gough SC. Genetics of thyroid autoimmunity and the role of the
TSHR. Mol Cell Endocrinol. 2010 Jun 30;322(1-2):135-43.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Brito-Zern P, Kostov B, Bosch X, Acar-Denizli N, Ramos-Casals M, Stone JH.
Therapeutic approach to IgG4-related disease: A systematic review. Pezzilli. R,
ed. Medicine. 2016;95(26):e4002.
324
Brown JC, Miller CJ, Schwellnus MP, Collins M. Range of motion measurements
diverge with increasing age for COL5A1 genotypes. Scand J Med Sci Sports.
2011 Dec;21(6):e266-72.
Brutsaert TD, Parra EJ, Shriver MD, Gamboa A, Palacios JA, Rivera M, et al.
Spanish genetic admixture is associated with larger VO2 max decrement from
sea level to 4,338 m in Peruvian Quechua. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2003
Aug 1;95(2):519-28.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Cagliani R, Fumagalli M, Pozzoli U, et al. Diverse evolutionary histories for
-adrenoreceptor genes in humans. American Journal of Human Genetics.
2009;85(1):64-75.
Campbell MC, Tishkoff SA. African genetic diversity: Implications for human
demographic history, modern human origins, and complex disease mapping.
Annual review of genomics and human genetics. 2008;9:403-433.
|
325
Canivell S, Ruano EG, Sis-Almirall A, et al. Gastric inhibitory polypeptide
receptor methylation in newly diagnosed, drug-nave patients with Type 2
Diabetes: A case-control study. Holscher C, ed. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(9):e75474.
Cannon DS, Baker TB, Piper ME, Scholand MB, Lawrence DL, Drayna DT, et
al. Associations between phenylthiocarbamide gene polymorphisms and
cigarette smoking. Nicotine Tob Res. 2005 Dec;7(6):853-8.
Carr EJ, Niederer HA, Williams J, et al. Confirmation of the genetic association
of CTLA4 and PTPN22 with ANCA-associated vasculitis. BMC Medical
Genetics. 2009;10:121.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Cecil JE, Tavendale R, Watt P, Hetherington MM, Palmer CN. An obesity-
associated FTO gene variant and increased energy intake in children. N Engl J
Med. 2008;359: 25582566.
Centers for Disease Control. Cancer rates by race/ethnicity and sex. Data from
National Vital Statistics System (NVSS). 2017.
Centers for Disease Control and Center for Surveillance, Epidemiology and
Laboratory Services (CSELS). ACCE model List of 44 targeted questions aimed
at a comprehensive review of genetic testing. United States: 2010.
|
326
Ceperuelo-Mallafr V, Duran X, Pachn G, Roche K, Garrido-Snchez L,
Vilarrasa N, et al. Disruption of GIP/GIPR axis in human adipose tissue
is linked to obesity and insulin resistance. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2014
May;99(5):E908-19.
Cha SW, Choi SM, Kim KS, Park BL, Kim JR, Kim JY, Shin HD. Replication of
genetic effects of FTO polymorphisms on BMI in a Korean population. Obesity
(Silver Spring) 2008;16:21872189.
Chang YC, Liu PH, Lee WJ, Chang TJ, Jiang YD, Li HY, et al. Common variation
in the fat mass and obesity-associated (FTO) gene confers risk of obesity and
modulates BMI in the Chinese population. Diabetes. 2008;57:22452252.
Chen Y, Cao B, Yang J, Wei Q, Ou RW, Zhao B, et al. Analysis and meta-analysis
of five polymorphisms of the LINGO1 and LINGO2 genes in Parkinsons
disease and multiple system atrophy in a Chinese population. Journal of
Neurology. 2015 Nov 1;262(11):2478-83.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Chen J, Yang M, Zhao K, Xu A, Huang Q. Polymorphisms in FTO, TMEM18 and
PCSK1 are associated with BMI in southern Chinese population. J Genet. 2014
Aug;93(2):509-12.
Chen R, Stahl EA, Kurreeman FAS, et al. Fine mapping the TAGAP risk locus in
rheumatoid arthritis. Genes and Immunity. 2011;12(4):314-318.
327
Cheng JB, Levine MA, Bell NH, Mangelsdorf DJ, Russell DW. Genetic evidence
that the human CYP2R1 enzyme is a key vitamin D 25-hydroxylase.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America. 2004 May 18;101(20):7711-5.
Clark AA, Liggett SB, Munger SD. Extraoral bitter taste receptors as mediators
of off-target drug effects. The FASEB Journal. 2012;26(12):4827-4831.
Clarke TK, Weiss AR, Berrettini WH. The genetics of anorexia nervosa. Clin
Pharmacol Ther. 2012 Feb;91(2):181-8.
PRECISION NUTRITION
99(1):154-63.
328
Coffee EM et al. (2010) . Increased prevalence of mutant null alleles that cause
hereditary fructose intolerance in the American population. J. Inherit. Metab.
Dis. 33(1):33-42.
Cook GC, al-Torki MT. High intestinal lactase concentrations in adult Arabs in
Saudi Arabia. British Medical Journal. 1975;3(5976):135-136.
Connelly TM, Berg AS, Harris LR 3rd, Hegarty JP, Ruggiero FM, Deiling SM, et
al. T-cell activation Rho GTPase-activating protein expression varies with
inflammation location and severity in Crohns disease. J Surg Res. 2014
Aug;190(2):457-64.
Corella D, Lai CQ, Demissie S, Cupples LA, Manning AK, Tucker KL, Ordovas
JM. APOA5 gene variation modulates the effects of dietary fat intake on
body mass index and obesity risk in the Framingham Heart Study. Journal of
Molecular Medicine. 2007 Feb 1;85(2):119-28.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Corella D, Peloso G, Arnett DK, Demissie S, Cupples LA, Tucker K, et al. APOA2,
dietary fat, and body mass index: replication of a gene-diet interaction
in 3 independent populations. Archives of Internal Medicine. 2009 Nov
9;169(20):1897-906.
Corella D, Qi L, Tai ES, Deurenberg-Yap M, Tan CE, Chew SK, Ordovas JM.
Perilipin gene variation determines higher susceptibility to insulin resistance
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Covolo, L., Rubinelli, S., Ceretti, E., & Gelatti, U. Internet-based direct-to-
consumer genetic testing: A systematic review. Journal of Medical Internet
Research. 2015;17(12), e279.
|
329
Criswell, LA, Pfeiffer KA, Lum, RF, et al. Analysis of families in the multiple
autoimmune disease genetics consortium (MADGC) collection: the PTPN22
620W allele associates with multiple autoimmune phenotypes. American
Journal of Human Genetics. 2005;76(4), 561571.
Curtin PD. The slavery hypothesis for hypertension among African Americans:
the historical evidence. American Journal of Public Health. 1992;82(12):1681-1686.
D
Dar-Nimrod I, Zuckerman M, Duberstein PR. The effects of learning about ones
own genetic susceptibility to alcoholism: a randomized experiment. Genet Med.
2013 Feb;15(2):132-8.
de Jager W, Vastert SJ, Beekman JM, Wulffraat NM, Kuis W, Coffer PJ, Prakken
BJ. Defective phosphorylation of interleukin-18 receptor beta causes impaired
natural killer cell function in systemic-onset juvenile idiopathic arthritis.
Arthritis Rheum. 2009 Sep;60(9):2782-93.
Degrace-Passilly P, Besnard P. CD36 and taste of fat. Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab
Care. 2012 Mar;15(2):107-11.
PRECISION NUTRITION
den Hoed, M, Westerterp-Plantenga MS, Bouwman FG, Mariman ECM,
Westerterp KR. Postprandial responses in hunger and satiety are associated
with the rs9939609 single nucleotide polymorphism in FTO. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.
2009;90: 14261432.
Dennis EL, Jahanshad N, Braskie MN, et al. Obesity gene NEGR1 associated
|
2):548-557.
330
Denny JC, Crawford DC, Ritchie MD, et al. Variants near FOXE1 are associated
with hypothyroidism and other thyroid conditions: Using electronic medical
records for genome- and phenome-wide studies. American Journal of Human
Genetics. 2011;89(4):529-542.
Dias AG, Eny KM, Cockburn M, Chiu W, Nielsen DE, Duizer L, El-Sohemy A.
Variation in the TAS1R2 gene, sweet taste perception and intake of sugars. J.
Nutrigenetics Nutrigenomics. 2015;8(2):81-90.
PRECISION NUTRITION
in FTO contributes to childhood obesity and severe adult obesity. Nature
Genetics. 2007 Jun 1;39(6):724-6.
331
Dorajoo R, Blakemore AI, Sim X, Ong RT, Ng DP, et al. Replication of 13 obesity
loci among Singaporean Chinese, Malay and Asian-Indian populations. Int J
Obes (Lond). 2012 Jan;36(1):159-63.
Douglas JE, Cohen NA. Taste receptors mediate sinonasal immunity and
respiratory disease. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. 2017;18(2):437.
Drabant EM, Kiefer AK, Eriksson N, Mountain JL, Francke U, Tung JY, Hinds DA,
Do CB. Genome-wide association study of sexual orientation in a large, web-
based cohort. 23andMe research paper. 2012.
Drayna D. Human taste genetics. Annu. Rev. Genomics Hum. Genet.. 2005 Sep
22;6:217-35.
Dures C, Moreira CS, Alvelos I, et al. Polymorphisms in the TNFA and IL6
genes represent risk factors for autoimmune thyroid disease. Arez AP, ed.
PLoS ONE. 2014;9(8):e105492.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Easton DF, Pharoah PDP, Antoniou AC, et al. Gene-panel sequencing and
the prediction of breast cancer risk. The New England Journal of Medicine.
2015;372(23):2243-2257.
332
Elkasrawy MN, Hamrick MW. Myostatin (GDF-8) as a key factor linking muscle
mass and skeletal form. Journal of Musculoskeletal & Neuronal Interactions.
2010;10(1):56-63.
Eriksson N, Tung JY, Kiefer AK, et al. Novel associations for hypothyroidism
include known autoimmune risk loci. PLoS ONE. 2012;7(4):e34442.
Eriksson N, Wu S, Do CB, Kiefer AK, Tung JY, Mountain JL, Hinds DA, Francke U.
A genetic variant near olfactory receptor genes influences cilantro preference.
Flavour. 2012 Nov 29;1(1):22.
PRECISION NUTRITION
related to hereditary fructose intolerance. FEBS Lett. 2002;531(2):152-6.
Eynon N, Banting LK, Ruiz JR, et al. ACTN3 R577X polymorphism and team-
sport performance: a study involving three European cohorts. J Sci Med Sport.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
2014 Jan;17(1):102-6.
333
F
Fahed AC et al. Familial hypercholesterolemia: the lipids or the genes? Nutr
Metab (Lond). 2011;8(1):23.
Fawcett KA, Barroso I. The genetics of obesity: FTO leads the way. Trends in
Genetics. 2010;26(6):266-274.
Fedotovskaya ON, Popov DV, Vinogradova OL, Akhmetov II. Association of the
muscle-specific creatine kinase (CKMM) gene polymorphism with physical
performance of athletes. Fiziologiia Cheloveka. 2011 Dec;38(1):105-9.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Fernandes BS, Molendijk ML, Khler CA, Soares JC, Leite CM, Machado-Vieira
R, et al. Peripheral brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) as a biomarker
in bipolar disorder: a meta-analysis of 52 studies. BMC Medicine. 2015 Nov
30;13(1):289.
The CYP17MspA1 polymorphism and the gender dysphoria. J Sex Med. 2015
Jun;12(6):1329-33.
334
Fernndez R, Esteva I, Gmez-Gil E, Rumbo T, Almaraz MC, Roda E, et al. The
(CA)n polymorphism of ER gene is associated with FtM transsexualism. J Sex
Med. 2014 Mar;11(3):720-8.
Ferreira-Gonzalez A, Emmadi R, Day SP, Klees RF, Leib JR, Lyon E, Nowak
JA, Pratt VM, Williams MS, Klein RD. Revisiting oversight and regulation of
molecular-based laboratory-developed tests: a position statement of the
Association for Molecular Pathology. The Journal of Molecular Diagnostics.
2014 Jan 31;16(1):3-6.
Florez JC. Clinical review: the genetics of type 2 diabetes: a realistic appraisal
in 2008. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2008;93:46334642.
Foster BP, Morse CI, Onambele GL, Williams AG. Human COL5A1 rs12722 gene
polymorphism and tendon properties in vivo in an asymptomatic population.
European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2014 Jul 1;114(7):1393-402.
Frampton GM, Fabrizio DA, Chalmers ZR, Sun JX, Miller VA, Stephens PJ.
Assessment and comparison of tumor mutational burden and microsatellite
instability status in> 40,000 cancer genomes. Annals of Oncology. 2016 Oct
1;27(suppl 6): 520.
Francis Thackeray J. Estimating the age and affinities of Homo naledi. South
African Journal of Science. 2015 Dec;111(11-12):1-2.
Frayling TM, Timpson NJ, Weedon MN, et al. A common variant in the FTO gene
is associated with body mass index and predisposes to childhood and adult
obesity. Science. 2007;316(5826):889-94.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Friedel S, Fontenla Horro F, Wermter AK, Geller F, Dempfle A, Reichwald K, et
al. Mutation screen of the brain derived neurotrophic factor gene (BDNF):
identification of several genetic variants and association studies in patients
with obesity, eating disorders, and attentiondeficit/hyperactivity disorder.
American Journal of Medical Genetics Part B: Neuropsychiatric Genetics. 2005
Jan 5;132(1):96-9.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Friedlaender JS, Friedlaender FR, Reed FA, et al. The genetic structure of
Pacific Islanders. Pritchard JK, ed. PLoS Genetics. 2008;4(1):e19.
Frueh FW, Greely HT, Green RC, Hogarth S, Siegel S. The future of direct-to-
consumer clinical genetic tests. Nature Reviews Genetics. 2011;12(7):511-515.
|
335
Fu Q, Hajdinjak M, Moldovan OT, et al. An early modern human from Romania
with a recent Neanderthal ancestor. Nature. 2015;524(7564):216-219.
Funghetto SS, Prestes J, Silva Ade O, Farias DL, Teixeira TG, Vieira DC, et al.
Interleukin-6 174G/C gene polymorphism affects muscle damage response
to acute eccentric resistance exercise in elderly obese women. Exp Gerontol.
2013;48(11):12551259.
G
Gamero-Villarroel C, Gonzlez LM, Gordillo I, Carrillo JA, Garca-Herriz A, Flores
I, Rodrguez-Lpez R, Gervasini G. Impact of NEGR1 genetic variability on
psychological traits of patients with eating disorders. Pharmacogenomics J.
2015 Jun;15(3):278-83.
Gao W, Bohl CE, Dalton JT. Chemistry and structural biology of androgen
receptor. Chemical Reviews. 2005;105(9):3352-3370.
PRECISION NUTRITION
disease in an ethnically diverse population of young adults. J Nutrigenetics
Nutrigenomics. 2013;6:256-67.
336
Gerken T, Girard CA, Tung YC, Webby CJ, Saudek V, Hewitson KS, Yeo GS, et
al. The obesity-associated FTO gene encodes a 2-oxoglutarate dependent
nucleic acid demethylase. Science. 2007;318(5855):1469-72.
Glas J, Stallhofer J, Ripke S, Wetzke M, et al. Novel genetic risk markers for
ulcerative colitis in the IL2/IL21 region are in epistasis with IL23R and suggest
a common genetic background for ulcerative colitis and celiac disease. Am J
Gastroenterol. 2009 Jul;104(7):1737-44.
Glew RH, Williams M, Conn CA, Cadena SM, Crossey M, Okolo SN, VanderJagt
DJ. Cardiovascular disease risk factors and diet of Fulani pastoralists of
northern Nigeria. Am J Clin Nutr. 2001 Dec;74(6):730-6.
Goldberg AC, Hopkins PN, Toth PP, Ballantyne CM, Rader DJ, Robinson JG,
PRECISION NUTRITION
et al. Familial hypercholesterolemia: screening, diagnosis and management
of pediatric and adult patients: clinical guidance from the National Lipid
Association Expert Panel on Familial Hypercholesterolemia. Journal of Clinical
Lipidology. 2011 Jun 30;5(3):S1-8.
337
Gordon ES, Griffin G, Wawak L, Pang H, Gollust SE, Bernhardt BA. Its not
like judgment day: Public understanding of and reactions to personalized
genomic risk information. 2012 Jun 1;21(3):423-32.
Grant SFA, Li M, Bradfield JP, et al. Association analysis of the FTO gene with
obesity in children of Caucasian and African ancestry reveals a common
tagging SNP. PLoS ONE. 2008;3(3):e1746.
Grealy R, Herruer J, Smith CLE, Hiller D, Haseler LJ, Griffiths LR. Evaluation
of a 7-gene genetic profile for athletic endurance phenotype in Ironman
championship triathletes. PLoS ONE. 2015;10(12): e0145171.
Gunstad J, Schofield P, Paul RH, Spitznagel MB, Cohen RA, Williams LM, Kohn M,
Gordon E. BDNF Val66Met polymorphism is associated with body mass index
in healthy adults. Neuropsychobiology. 2006 Jun 6;53(3):153-6.
Gupta RP, Hollis BW, Patel SB, Patrick KS, Bell NH. CYP3A4 is a human
microsomal Vitamin D 25-hydroxylase. J Bone Miner Res. 2004 Apr 1;19(4):680-8.
PRECISION NUTRITION
H
Hagberg JM, Moore GE, Ferrell RE. Specific genetic markers of endurance
performance and VO2max. Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews. 2001 Jan 1;29(1):15-9.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Hamzelou, Jessica. Exclusive: Worlds first baby born with new 3 parent
technique. New Scientist Sept 27, 2016.
|
338
Hare L, Bernard P, Snchez FJ, et al. Androgen receptor repeat length
polymorphism associated with male-to-female transsexualism. Biological
Psychiatry. 2009;65(1):93-96.
Harvie P, Ostlere SJ, Teh J, McNally EG, Clipsham K, Burston BJ, Pollard TC, Carr
AJ. Genetic influences in the aetiology of tears of the rotator cuff. Bone & Joint
Journal. 2004 Jul 1;86(5):696-700.
Hassan HY, Erp A, Jaeger M, Tahir H, Oosting M, Joosten LA, Netea MG. Genetic
diversity of lactase persistence in East African populations. BMC research
notes. 2016 Jan 4;9(1):8.
PRECISION NUTRITION
heritability: GIANT steps forward in the molecular elucidation of obesity but
still lots to go. Obes Facts 2010;3:294-303.
Heianza Y, Sun D, Wang T, Bray GA, Sacks FM, Qi L. Abstract P223: Starch
digestion related amylase genotypes affect 2-year adiposity changes
in response to weight-loss diets: The pounds lost trial. Circulation.
2017;135:AP223
|
339
Heled Y, Bloom MS, Wu TJ, Stephens Q, Deuster PA. CM-MM and ACE
genotypes and physiological prediction of the creatine kinase response to
exercise. J Appl Physiol. 2007;103(2):504510.
Hennig BJ, Fulford AJ, Sirugo G, et al. FTO gene variation and measures of
body mass in an African population. BMC Medical Genetics. 2009;10:21.
Hettema JM, An S-S, van den Oord EJCG, Neale MC, Kendler KS, Chen X.
Genetic association between RGS1 and internalizing disorders. Psychiatric
Genetics. 2013;23(2):56-60.
Hettling H, van Beek JH. Analyzing the functional properties of the creatine
PRECISION NUTRITION
kinase system with multiscale sloppy modeling. PLoS Comput Biol. 2011 Aug
11;7(8):e1002130.
Hickey SE, Curry CJ, Toriello HV. ACMG practice guideline: Lack of evidence for
MTHFR polymorphism testing. Genet Med 2013;15(2):15356.
Hinney A, Volckmar AL. Genetics of eating disorders. Curr Psychiatry Rep. 2013
Dec;15(12):423.
|
340
Hollands Gareth J, French David P, Griffin Simon J, Prevost A Toby, Sutton
Stephen, King Sarah et al. The impact of communicating genetic risks of
disease on risk-reducing health behaviour: systematic review with meta-
analysis BMJ 2016; 352:i1102.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Huaixing L, Wu Y, Loos RJF, Hu FB, Liu Y, Wang J, et al. Variants in the fat
massand obesity-Associated (FTO) gene are not associated with obesity in a
Chinese Han population. Diabetes Jan 2008, 57 (1) 264-268.
Huang TY, Zheng D, Houmard JA, Brault JJ, Hickner RC, Cortright RN.
Overexpression of PGC-1 increases peroxisomal biogenesis and
mitochondrial lipid oxidation in human primary myotubes. The FASEB Journal.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Hubal MJ, Devaney JM, Hoffman EP, Zambraski EJ, Gordish-Dressman H, Kearns
AK, et al. CCL2 and CCR2 polymorphisms are associated with markers of
exercise-induced skeletal muscle damage. J Appl Physiol. 2010;108(6):1651
1658.
|
341
Hunt KA, Zhernakova A, Turner G, et al. Novel celiac disease genetic
determinants related to the immune response. Nature Genetics.
2008;40(4):395-402.
Hunt SC, Stone S, Xin Y, et al. Association of the FTO gene with BMI. Obesity
(Silver Spring, Md). 2008;16(4):902-904.
I
Imai K, Kricka LJ, Fortina P. Concordance study of 3 direct-to-consumer
genetic-testing services. Clinical Chemistry. 2011 Mar 1;57(3):518-21.
Ingram CJ, Mulcare CA, Itan Y, Thomas MG, Swallow DM. Lactose digestion and
the evolutionary genetics of lactase persistence. Human Genetics. 2009 Jan
1;124(6):579-91.
Ingram CJ, Raga TO, Tarekegn A, Browning SL, Elamin MF, Bekele E, Thomas
MG, Weale ME, Bradman N, Swallow DM. Multiple rare variants as a cause of a
common phenotype: several different lactase persistence associated alleles in
a single ethnic group. J Mol Evol. 2009 Dec;69(6):579-88.
PRECISION NUTRITION
International Federation of Sports Medicine. Consensus statement on direct-
to-consumer genetic testing for sports performance and talent identification.
British Journal of Sports Medicine 2015.
biomarker analysis.
Itan Y, Powell A, Beaumont MA, Burger J, Thomas MG. The origins of lactase
persistence in Europe. PLoS Comput Biol. 2009 Aug 28;5(8):e1000491.
342
J
Jacobsson, JA, Schith HB, Fredriksson R. The impact of intronic single
nucleotide polymorphisms and ethnic diversity for studies on the obesity gene
FTO. Obes. Rev. 2012;13: 10961109.
James KM, Cowl CT, Tilburt JC, et al. Impact of direct-to-consumer predictive
genomic testing on risk perception and worry among patients receiving
routine care in a preventive health clinic. Mayo Clinic Proceedings.
2011;86(10):933-940.
Jiang L, Sun L-Y, Dai Y-F, Yang S-W, Zhang F, Wang L-Y. The distribution and
characteristics of LDL receptor mutations in China: A systematic review.
Scientific Reports. 2015;5:17272.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Jin T, Liu L The Wnt signaling pathway effector TCF7L2 and type 2 diabetes
mellitus. Mol. Endocrinol. 2008; 22 (11): 238392.
Jensen RA. Orthologs and paralogs we need to get it right. Genome Biology.
2001;2(8):interactions1002.1-interactions1002.3.
|
Johansen CT, Wang J, Lanktree MB, et al. Mutation skew in genes identified
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Jolliffe DA, Walton RT, Griffiths CJ, Martineau AR. Single nucleotide
polymorphisms in the vitamin D pathway associating with circulating
concentrations of vitamin D metabolites and non-skeletal health outcomes:
Review of genetic association studies. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. 2016
Nov;164:18-29.
|
343
Jones BL, Oljira T, Liebert A, et al. Diversity of lactase persistence in African
milk drinkers. Human Genetics. 2015;134(8):917-925.
Joshi, L., Ponnana, M., Penmetsa, S. R., Nallari, P., Valluri, V. and Gaddam, S.
(2014), Serum Vitamin D levels and VDR polymorphisms (BsmI and FokI) in
patients and their household contacts susceptible to tuberculosis. Scand J
Immunol, 79: 113119.
K
Kang R, Kim M, Chae JS, Lee SH, Lee JH. Consumption of whole grains and
legumes modulates the genetic effect of the APOA5-1131C variant on changes
in triglyceride and apolipoprotein AV concentrations in patients with impaired
fasting glucose or newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes. Trials. 2014 Apr 1;15(1):100.
Kaplan H, Thompson RC, Trumble BC, Wann LS, et al. Coronary atherosclerosis
in indigenous South American Tsimane: a cross-sectional cohort study. The
Lancet. 2017 Mar 17.
Karmin, M., Saag, L., Vicente, M., et al. (2015). A recent bottleneck of Y
chromosome diversity coincides with a global change in culture. Genome
Research, 25(4), 459466.
Kaufman JS, Hall SA. The slavery hypertension hypothesis: Dissemination and
appeal of a modern race theory. Epidemiology. 2003 Jan 1;14(1):111-8.
Keller KL, Liang LCH, Sakimura J, et al. Common variants in the CD36 gene are
PRECISION NUTRITION
associated with oral fat perception, fat preferences, and obesity in African
Americans. Obesity (Silver Spring, Md). 2012;20(5):1066-1073.
344
Kim S, Eom KW, Cho CR, Um TH. Comparison of commercial genetic-testing
services in Korea with 23andMe service BioMed Research International. 2014.
Kim JY, Kim OY, Koh SJ, Jang Y, Yun SS, Ordovas JM, Lee JH. Comparison
of low-fat meal and high-fat meal on postprandial lipemic response in non-
obese men according to the 1131T> C polymorphism of the apolipoprotein
A5 (APOA5) gene (randomized cross-over design). Journal of the American
College of Nutrition. 2006 Aug 1;25(4):340-7.
Kirk EA, Moore CW, ChaterDiehl EJ, Singh SM, Rice CL. Human COL5A1
polymorphisms and quadriceps muscletendon mechanical stiffness in vivo.
Experimental Physiology. 2016 Dec 1;101(12):1581-92.
Kivell TL, Deane AS, Tocheri MW, Orr CM, Schmid P, Hawks J, et al The hand of
Homo naledi. Nature Communications. 2015 Oct 6;6.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Kobernick AK, Burks AW. Active treatment for food allergy. Allergol Int. 2016
Oct;65(4):388-395.
Kolovos P, Knoch TA, Grosveld FG, Cook PR, Papantonis A. Enhancers and
silencers: an integrated and simple model for their function. Epigenetics &
Chromatin. 2012 Jan 9;5(1):1.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Kongsbak M, Levring TB, Geisler C, von Essen MR. The Vitamin D receptor and
T cell function. Frontiers in Immunology. 2013;4:148.
Koskinen LL, Einarsdottir E, Dukes E, Heap GA, et al. Association study of the
IL18RAP locus in three European populations with coeliac disease. Hum Mol
Genet. 2009 Mar 15;18(6):1148-55.
|
345
Kristeleit RS, Miller RE, Kohn EC. Gynecologic cancers: Emerging novel
strategies for targeting DNA repair deficiency. American Society of Clinical
Oncology. Meeting 2015 Dec (Vol. 35, pp. e259-68).
Kumar S, Verma AK, Das M, Dwivedi PD. A molecular insight of CTLA-4 in food
allergy. Immunol Lett. 2013 Jan;149(1-2):101-9.
Kusuma P, Cox MP, Pierron D, et al. Mitochondrial DNA and the Y chromosome
suggest the settlement of Madagascar by Indonesian sea nomad populations.
BMC Genomics. 2015;16(1):191.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Laeger T, Henagan TM, Albarado DC, Redman LM, Bray GA, Noland RC, et al.
FGF21 is an endocrine signal of protein restriction. The Journal of Clinical
Investigation. 2014 Sep 2;124(9):3913.
Laffitte A, Neiers F, Briand L. Functional roles of the sweet taste receptor in oral
and extraoral tissues. Current Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care.
|
2014;17(4):379-385.
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
346
Larsen SC, ngquist L, stergaard JN, Ahluwalia TS, et al. Intake of total
and subgroups of fat minimally affect the associations between selected
single nucleotide polymorphisms in the PPAR pathway and changes in
anthropometry among European adults from cohorts of the DiOGenes study.
The Journal of Nutrition. 2016 Mar 1;146(3):603-11.
Lee RJ, Cohen NA. Taste receptors in innate immunity. Cellular and Molecular
Life Sciences: CMLS. 2015;72(2):217-236.
Lee T-W, Bai K-J, Lee T-I, Chao T-F, Kao Y-H, Chen Y-J. PPARs modulate cardiac
metabolism and mitochondrial function in diabetes. Journal of Biomedical
Science. 2017;24:5.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Leonard WR. Lifestyle, diet, and disease: comparative perspectives on the
determinants of chronic health risks. Evolution in Health and Disease ed.
Stephen C. Stearns and Jacob C. Koella. Oxford University Press, 2008: 265-
276.
Leskinen T, Kujala UM. Health-related findings among twin pairs discordant for
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
347
Lewinsky RH, Jensen TG, Mller J, Stensballe A, Olsen J, Troelsen JT. T 13910
DNA variant associated with lactase persistence interacts with Oct-1 and
stimulates lactase promoter activity in vitro. Human Molecular Genetics. 2005
Dec 15;14(24):3945-53.
Li P, Yang XK, Wang X, Zhao MQ, Zhang C, Tao SS, et al. A meta-analysis of
the relationship between MYO9B gene polymorphisms and susceptibility to
Crohns disease and ulcerative colitis. Hum Immunol. 2016 Oct;77(10):990-6.
Liao N, Chen M-L, Zhao H, Xie Z-F. Association between the MYO9B
polymorphisms and celiac disease risk: a meta-analysis. International Journal
of Clinical and Experimental Medicine. 2015;8(9):14916-14925.
Liao Y-C, Lin H-F, Rundek T, et al. Multiple genetic determinants of plasma lipid
levels in Caribbean Hispanics. Clinical Biochemistry. 2008;41(4-5):306-312.
Liebert A, Jones BL, Danielsen ET, Olsen AK, Swallow DM, Troelsen JT. In vitro
functional analyses of infrequent nucleotide variants in the lactase enhancer
reveal different molecular routes to increased lactase promoter activity and
lactase persistence. Annals of Human Genetics. 2016. 80: 307318.
PRECISION NUTRITION
history in Island Southeast Asia. Nature Communications. 2014;5:4689.
Little RD, Carulli JP, Del Mastro RG, et al. A mutation in the LDL receptor
related protein 5 gene results in the autosomal dominant highbone-mass
trait. American Journal of Human Genetics. 2002;70(1):11-19.
Little TJ, Isaacs NJ, Young RL, Ott R, Nguyen NQ, Rayner CK, Horowitz M, Feinle-
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
348
Liu X, Meng F, Yang P. Association study of CD36 single nucleotide
polymorphisms with essential hypertension in the Northeastern Han Chinese.
Gene. 2013 Sep 15;527(1):410-5.
Liu XG, Hu HY, Guo YH, Sun YP. Correlation between Y chromosome
microdeletion and male infertility. Genet Mol Res. 2016 Jun 3;15(2).
Locke JM, Wei F-Y, Tomizawa K, Weedon MN, Harries LW. A cautionary tale: the
non-causal association between type 2 diabetes risk SNP, rs7756992, and
levels of non-coding RNA, CDKAL1-v1. Diabetologia. 2015;58(4):745-748.
Loos RJF, Yeo GSH. The bigger picture of FTO the first GWAS-identified
obesity gene. Nature Reviews Endocrinology. 2014;10(1):51-61.
PRECISION NUTRITION
cholesterol among the population of West Mexico. J Nutr Food Sci. 2005;5:1-5.
Lowe JK, Maller JB, Peer I, Neale BM, Salit J, Kenny EE, Shea JL, Burkhardt
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
349
Lucia A, Gmez-Gallego F, Santiago C, Bandrs F, Earnest C, Rabadn M, et al.
ACTN3 genotype in professional endurance cyclists. Int J Sports Med. 2006
Nov;27(11):880-4.
Lucia A, Martin MA, EsteveLanao J, et al. C34T mutation of the AMPD1 gene
in an elite white runner. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2006;40(3):e7.
Luca A, Morn M, Zihong H, Ruiz JR. Elite athletes: are the genes the
champions?. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance. 2010
Mar;5(1):98.
M
MacArthur DG, North KN. A gene for speed? The evolution and function of
alpha-actinin-3. Bioessays. 2004;26(7):786-95.
MacArthur DG, Seto JT, Raftery JM, Quinlan KG, Huttley GA, Hook JW, et al. Loss
of ACTN3 gene function alters mouse muscle metabolism and shows evidence
of positive selection in humans. Nat Genet. 2007; 39(10):1261-5.
MacArthur DG, Seto JT, Chan S, Quinlan KG, Raftery JM, Turner N, et al. An
Actn3 knockout mouse provides mechanistic insights into the association
between alpha-actinin-3 deficiency and human athletic performance. Hum
Mol Genet. 2008; 17(8):1076-86.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Mgi R, Manning S, Yousseif A, et al. Contribution of 32 GWAS-identified
common variants to severe obesity in European adults referred for bariatric
surgery. Grant SFA, ed. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(8):e70735.
Maierhaba M, Zhang JA, Yu ZY, Wang Y, Xiao WX, Quan Y, Dong BN.
Association of the thyroglobulin gene polymorphism with autoimmune thyroid
|
350
Mandel AL, Breslin PA. High endogenous salivary amylase activity is
associated with improved glycemic homeostasis following starch ingestion in
adults. J Nutr. 2012;142:853-858.
Mantha AK, Sarkar B, Tell G. A short review on the implications of base excision
repair pathway for neurons: relevance to neurodegenerative diseases.
Mitochondrion. 2014 May 31;16:38-49.
Marteau TM, French DP, Griffin SJ, Prevost AT, Sutton S, Watkinson C, Attwood
S, Hollands GJ. Effects of communicating DNA-based disease risk estimates
on risk-reducing behaviours. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Oct
6;(10):CD007275.
PRECISION NUTRITION
brain-derived neurotrophic factor in the central nervous system. The Yale
Journal of Biology and Medicine. 2014;87(2):173-186.
351
Marteijn JA, Lans H, Vermeulen W, Hoeijmakers JH. Understanding nucleotide
excision repair and its roles in cancer and ageing. Nature Reviews: Molecular
Cell Biology. 2014 Jul 1;15(7):465.
Martino DJ, Prescott SL. Silent mysteries: epigenetic paradigms could hold the
key to conquering the epidemic of allergy and immune disease. Allergy 2010;
65: 715.
McLeod DS, Cooper DS, Ladenson PW, Whiteman DC, Jordan SJ. Race/ethnicity
and the prevalence of thyrotoxicosis in young Americans. Thyroid. 2015 Jun
1;25(6):621-8.
McNulty H, Strain JJ, Hughes CF, Ward M. Riboflavin, MTHFR genotype and
blood pressure: A personalized approach to prevention and treatment of
hypertension. Mol Aspects Med. 2017 Feb;53:2-9.
PRECISION NUTRITION
2013;8(9):e74151.
352
Meng S, He ST, Jiang WJ, Xiao L, Li DF, Xu J, Shi XH, Zhang JA. Genetic
susceptibility to autoimmune thyroid diseases in a Chinese Han population:
Role of vitamin D receptor gene polymorphisms. Ann Endocrinol (Paris). 2015
Dec;76(6):684-9.
Mennella JA. Ontogeny of taste preferences: basic biology and implications for
health. The American journal of clinical nutrition. 2014 Mar 1;99(3):704S-11S.
Miljkovic-Gacic I, Bunker CH, Ferrell RE, Kammerer CM, Evans RW, Patrick
AL, Kuller LH. Lipoprotein subclass and particle size differences in Afro-
Caribbeans, African Americans, and white Americans: associations with
hepatic lipase gene variation. Metabolism. 2006 Jan;55(1):96-102.
Mills M, Yang N, Weinberger R, Vander Woude DL, Beggs AH, Easteal S, North K.
Differential expression of the actin-binding proteins, alpha-actinin-2 and -3, in
different species: implications for the evolution of functional redundancy. Hum
Mol Genet. 2001;10(13):1335-46.
Miranda-Vilela AL, Akimoto AK, Lordelo GS, Pereira LC, Grisolia CK, de Nazar
Klautau-Guimares M. Creatine kinase MM TaqI and methylenetetrahydrofolate
reductase C677T and A1298C gene polymorphisms influence exercise-
induced C-reactive protein levels. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2012; 112(1):183192.
Mohammad S, Patel RT, Bruno J, Panhwar MS, Wen J, McGraw TE. A naturally
occurring GIP receptor variant undergoes enhanced agonist-induced
PRECISION NUTRITION
desensitization, which impairs GIP control of adipose insulin sensitivity.
Molecular and Cellular Biology. 2014;34(19):3618-3629.
Mokone GG, Schwellnus MP, Noakes TD, Collins M. The COL5A1 gene and
Achilles tendon pathology. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2006 Feb;16(1):19-26.
353
Monaghan AE, McEwan IJ. A sting in the tail: the N-terminal domain of the
androgen receptor as a drug target. Asian Journal of Andrology. 2016 Sep
1;18(5):687.
Moran CN, Yang N, Bailey ME, Tsiokanos A, et al. Association analysis of the
ACTN3 R577X polymorphism and complex quantitative body composition
and performance phenotypes in adolescent Greeks. Eur J Hum Genet.
2007;15(1):88-93.
Mller TD, Greene BH, Bellodi L, et al. Fat mass and obesity-associated
gene (FTO) in eating disorders: evidence for association of the rs9939609
obesity risk allele with bulimia nervosa and anorexia nervosa. Obes Facts.
2012;5(3):408-19.
Mullis KB. The unusual origin of the polymerase chain reaction. Scientific
PRECISION NUTRITION
American. 1990 Apr 1;262(4):56-61.
Associated Loci: The NHLBI CARe Project. Federici M, ed. PLoS ONE.
2012;7(5):e36473.
Myhr CB, Hulme MA, Wasserfall CH, Hong PJ, Lakshmi PS, Schatz DA, Haller MJ,
Brusko TM, Atkinson MA. The autoimmune disease-associated SNP rs917997
of IL18RAP controls IFN production by PBMC. J Autoimmun. 2013 Aug;44:8-12.
|
354
N
Nair S, Lee YH, Rousseau E, Cam M, Tataranni PA, Baier LJ, Bogardus C,
Permana PA. Increased expression of inflammation-related genes in cultured
preadipocytes/stromal vascular cells from obese compared with non-obese
Pima Indians. Diabetologia. 2005 Sep; 48(9):1784-8.
Nath A, Li I, Roberts LR, Chan C. Elevated free fatty acid uptake via CD36
promotes epithelial-mesenchymal transition in hepatocellular carcinoma. Sci
Rep. 2015 Oct 1;5:14752.
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Causes of high blood pressure.
United States, 2015.
Ng PC, Murray SS, Levy S, Venter JC. An agenda for personalized medicine.
Nature. 2009 Oct 8;461(7265):724-6.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Ngun TC, Vilain E. The biological basis of human sexual orientation: Is there a
role for epigenetics. Adv. Genet. 2014 Jan 1;86:167-84.
Niemi and Majamaa Mitochondrial DNA and ACTN3 genotypes in Finnish elite
endurance and sprint athletes. Eur J Hum Genet. 2005 13(8):965-9.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Nikitin AG, Sokhatsky MP, Kovaliukh MM, Videiko MY. Comprehensive site
chronology and ancient mitochondrial DNA analysis from Verteba Cave: A
Trypillian culture site of Eneolithic Ukraine. Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica.
2010;1(1):9-18.
Norhalifah HK, Syaza FH, Chambers GK, Edinur HA. The genetic history of
Peninsular Malaysia. Gene. 2016 Jul 15;586(1):129-35.
|
355
Ntandou G, Delisle H, Agueh V, Fayomi B. Abdominal obesity explains the
positive rural-urban gradient in the prevalence of the metabolic syndrome in
Benin, West Africa. Nutrition Research. 2009 Mar 31;29(3):180-9.
O
Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Kit BK, Flegal KM. Prevalence of childhood and adult
obesity in the United States, 2011-2012. JAMA. 2014;311(8):806-814.
Okafor CI. The metabolic syndrome in Africa: Current trends. Indian Journal of
Endocrinology and Metabolism. 2012 Jan 1;16(1):56.
Ou HD, Phan S, Deerinck TJ, Thor A, Ellisman MH, OShea CC. ChromEMT:
Visualizing 3D chromatin structure and compaction in interphase and mitotic
cells. Science. 2017 Jul 28;357(6349).
zdemir V, Kolker E. Precision nutrition 4.0: A big data and ethics foresight
analysis: Convergence of agrigenomics, nutrigenomics, nutriproteomics, and
nutrimetabolomics. OMICS. 2016 Feb;20(2):69-75.
P
Panhuysen CIM, Cupples LA, Wilson PW, Herbert AG, Myers RH, Meigs JB. A
PRECISION NUTRITION
genome scan for loci linked to quantitative insulin traits in persons without
diabetes: the Framingham Offspring Study. Diabetologia. 2003 46:579587.
356
Pavanello S, Pesatori AC, Dioni L, Hoxha M, Bollati V, Siwinska E, et al. Shorter
telomere length in peripheral blood lymphocytes of workers exposed to
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Carcinogenesis. 2010 Feb 1;31(2):216-21.
Pavlidis C, Nebel J-C, Katsila T, Patrinos GP. Nutrigenomics 2.0: The need
for ongoing and independent evaluation and synthesis of commercial
nutrigenomics tests scientific knowledge base for responsible innovation.
OMICS: a Journal of Integrative Biology. 2016;20(2):65-68.
Peng MS, He JD, Zhu CL, Wu SF, Jin JQ, Zhang YP. Lactase persistence may
have an independent origin in Tibetan populations from Tibet, China. J Hum
Genet. 2012 Jun;57(6):394-7.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Pepino MY, Love-Gregory L, Klein S, Abumrad NA. The fatty acid translocase
gene CD36 and lingual lipase influence oral sensitivity to fat in obese
subjects. Journal of Lipid Research. 2012 March;53 (3): 5616.
Perrin BJ, Ervasti JM. The actin gene family: Function follows isoform.
Cytoskeleton. 2010;67(10):630-634.
Perry GH, Dominy NJ, Claw KG, et al. Diet and the evolution of human amylase
gene copy number variation. Nature Genetics. 2007;39(10):1256-1260.
|
357
Petr M, eda O, Thiel D, et al P-8Is the AMPD1 polymorphism associated with
aerobic performance? Br J Sports Med 2016;50:A35-A36.
Petry CJ, Rayco-Solon P, Fulford AJ, Stead JD, Wingate DL, Ong KK, Sirugo G,
Prentice AM, Dunger DB. Common polymorphic variation in the genetically
diverse African insulin gene and its association with size at birth. Human
Genetics. 2009 Sep 1;126(3):375-84.
Phillips AM. Only a click awayDTC genetics for ancestry, health, love and
more: A view of the business and regulatory landscape. Applied & Translational
Genomics. 2016 Mar 31;8:16-22.
Pimenta EM, Coelho DB, Cruz IR, Morandi RF, Veneroso CE, de Azambuja
Pussieldi G, Carvalho MRS, Silami-Garcia E, Fernndez JADP. The ACTN3
genotype in soccer players in response to acute eccentric training. Eur J Appl
Physiol. 2012;112(4):14951503
PRECISION NUTRITION
Plagnol V, Howson JMM, Smyth DJ, et al. Genome-wide association analysis
of autoantibody positivity in Type 1 diabetes cases. PLoS Genetics.
2011;7(8):e1002216.
358
Poston WS, Pavlik VN, Hyman DJ, et al. Genetic bottlenecks, perceived racism,
and hypertension risk among African Americans and first-generation African
immigrants. J Hum Hypertens. 2001 May;15(5):341-51.
Potti A, Dressman HK, Bild A, Riedel RF, Chan G, Sayer R, et al. Genomic
signatures to guide the use of chemotherapeutics. Nat Med. 2006
Nov;12(11):1294-300. Article retraction / erratum Nat Med. 2007 Nov;13(11):1388.
Nat Med. 2008 Aug;14(8):889.
Prager M, Durmus T, Bttner J, Molnar T, de Jong DJ, et al. Myosin IXb variants
and their pivotal role in maintaining the intestinal barrier: a study in Crohns
disease. Scand J Gastroenterol. 2014 Oct;49(10):1191-200.
Price LH, Kao HT, Burgers DE, Carpenter LL, Tyrka AR. Telomeres and early-life
stress: an overview. Biological Psychiatry. 2013 Jan 1;73(1):15-23.
Price RA, Li W-D, Zhao H. FTO gene SNPs associated with extreme obesity in
cases, controls and extremely discordant sister pairs. BMC Medical Genetics.
2008;9:4.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Pujol-Borrell R, Gimnez-Barcons M, Marn-Snchez A, Colobran R. Genetics
of Graves disease: Special focus on the role of TSHR gene. Horm Metab Res.
2015 Sep;47(10):753-66.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Q
Qi Q, Chu AY, Kang JH, et al. Sugar-sweetened beverages and genetic risk of
obesity. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2012;367(15):1387-1396.
Qi, Qibin, Tuomas O. Kilpelinen, Mary K. Downer, et al. FTO genetic variants,
dietary intake and body mass index: insights from 177 330 individuals. Hum
Mol Genet 2014; 23 (25): 6961-6972.
|
359
Quintana-Murci L, Fellous M. The human Y chromosome: the biological role
of a functional wasteland. Journal of Biomedicine and Biotechnology.
2001;1(1):18-24.
R
Rader DJ. Monogenic hypercholesterolemia: new insights in pathogenesis and
treatment. J. Clin. Invest. 2003; 111(12):1795-803.
Rajan A, Burris C, Iliff N, Grant M, Eshleman JR, Eberhart CG. DNA mismatch
repair defects and microsatellite instability status in periocular sebaceous
carcinoma. American Journal of Ophthalmology. 2014 Mar 31;157(3):640-7.
Raleigh SM, van der Merwe L, Ribbans WJ, Smith RK, Schwellnus MP, Collins M.
Variants within the MMP3 gene are associated with Achilles tendinopathy:
possible interaction with the COL5A1 gene. Br J Sports Med. 2009
Jul;43(7):514-20.
Ramos-Lopez, E., Brck, P., Jansen, T., Herwig, J. and Badenhoop, K. (2007).
CYP2R1 (vitamin D 25-hydroxylase) gene is associated with susceptibility to
type 1 diabetes and vitamin D levels in Germans. Diabetes Metab. Res. Rev., 23:
631636.
Ranciaro A, Campbell MC, Hirbo JB, et al. Genetic origins of lactase persistence
and the spread of Pastoralism in Africa. American Journal of Human Genetics.
2014;94(4):496-510.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Rask-Andersen M, Almn MS, Lind L, Schith HB. Association of the LINGO2-
related SNP rs10968576 with body mass in a cohort of elderly Swedes. Mol
Genet Genomics. 2015 Aug;290(4):1485-91.
360
Razquin C, Alfredo Martinez J, Martinez-Gonzalez MA, Corella D, Santos
JM, Marti A. The Mediterranean diet protects against waist circumference
enlargement in 12Ala carriers for the PPARgamma gene: 2 years follow-up of
774 subjects at high cardiovascular risk. Br J Nutr. 2009; 102(5):672-9.
Reddon H, Gerstein HC, Engert JC, et al. Physical activity and genetic
predisposition to obesity in a multiethnic longitudinal study. Scientific Reports.
2016;6:18672.
Ren D, et al. Neuronal SH2B1 is essential for controlling energy and glucose
homeostasis. J. Clin. Invest. 2007;117:397406.
Rico-Sanz J, Rankinen T, Joanisse DR, Leon AS, Skinner JS, Wilmore JH, Rao DC,
Bouchard C. Associations between cardiorespiratory responses to exercise
and the C34T AMPD1 gene polymorphism in the HERITAGE Family Study.
Physiological Genomics. 2003 Jul 7;14(2):161-6.
PRECISION NUTRITION
for Crohn disease and implicates autophagy in disease pathogenesis. Nat
Genet. 2007. 39(5):596-604.
Rivera MA, Dionne FT, Wolfarth B, Chagnon MO, Simoneau JA, Prusse LO,
Boulay MR, Gagnon J, Song TM, Keul J, Bouchard C. Muscle-specific creatine
kinase gene polymorphisms in elite endurance athletes and sedentary
controls. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 1997 Nov;29(11):1444-7.
361
Rodrigo, L., Hernndez-Lahoz, C., Lauret, E. et al. Gluten ataxia is better
classified as non-celiac gluten sensitivity than as celiac disease: a comparative
clinical study. Immunol Res. 2016;64: 558.
Rosen, CJ, Ingelfinger JR. Unraveling the function of FTO variants. N Engl J
Med 2015; 373:964-965. September 3, 2015.
Roth SM, Rankinen T, Hagberg JM, et al. Advances in exercise, fitness, and
performance genomics in 2011. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise.
2012;44(5):809-817.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Ruiz JR, Gmez-Gallego F, Santiago C, et al. Is there an optimum endurance
polygenic profile? The Journal of Physiology. 2009;587(Pt 7):1527-1534.
S
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
362
Salipante SJ, Scroggins SM, Hampel HL, Turner EH, Pritchard CC. Microsatellite
instability detection by next generation sequencing. Clinical Chemistry. 2014
Sep 1;60(9):1192-9.
Snchez-Moreno C, Ordovs JM, Smith CE, Baraza JC, Lee YC, Garaulet M.
APOA5 gene variation interacts with dietary fat intake to modulate obesity
and circulating triglycerides in a Mediterranean population. The Journal of
Nutrition. 2011 Mar 1;141(3):380-5.
Sanders AR, Martin ER, Beecham GW, Guo S, Dawood K, Rieger G, et al.
Genome-wide scan demonstrates significant linkage for male sexual
orientation. Psychological Medicine. 2015 May;45(7):1379-88.
Saunders CJ, van der Merwe L, Posthumus M, Cook J, Handley CJ, Collins M,
September AV. Investigation of variants within the COL27A1 and TNC genes
and Achilles tendinopathy in two populations. J. Orthop. Res. 2013; 31: 632637.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Saxena R, Voight BF, Lyssenko V, Burtt NP, de Bakker PI, Chen, H, et al. Genome-
wide association analysis identifies loci for type 2 diabetes and triglyceride levels.
Science. 2007; 316:13311336.
Schenkman, Lauren. Japanese guts are made for sushi. Science. 2010 Apr. 7.
363
Schwartz M, Vissing J. Paternal inheritance of mitochondrial DNA.
New England Journal of Medicine. 2002;347 (8): 57680.
Schwarz NA, McKinley SK, Spillane M, Gann JJ, Andre TL, Willoughby DS.
Effect of Resistance Exercise Intensity on the mRNA Expression of PGC-1
Isoforms in Human Skeletal Muscle. International Journal of Exercise Science:
Conference Proceedings 2014;2(6):2.
Scott LJ, Mohlke KL, Bonnycastle LL, Willer CJ, Li Y, Duren WL, et al. A
genome-wide association study of type 2 diabetes in Finns detects multiple
susceptibility variants. Science. 2007; 316(5829):1341-5.
Seip RL, Zoeller RF, Angelopoulos TJ, et al. Interactive effects of APOE
haplotype, sex, and exercise on postheparin plasma lipase activities. Journal
of Applied Physiology. 2011;110(4):1021-1028.
Seim I, Amorim L, Walpole C, Carter S, Chopin LK, Herington, AC. Ghrelin gene-
related peptides: Multifunctional endocrine/autocrine modulators in health
and disease. Clinical and Experimental Pharmacology and Physiology. 2010;37:
125131.
September AV, Cook J, Handley CJ, van der Merwe L, Schwellnus MP, Collins M.
Variants within the COL5A1 gene are associated with Achilles tendinopathy in
two populations. Br J Sports Med. 2009 May;43(5):357-65.
PRECISION NUTRITION
er O, Janoutov J, Ewerlingov L, Hlov A, Lochman J, Janout V, Khan NA,
Balcar VJ. CD36 gene polymorphism is associated with Alzheimers disease.
Biochimie. 2017 Apr;135:46-53.
Shugart YY, Chen L, Day INM, et al. Two British women studies replicated
the association between the Val66Met polymorphism in the brain-derived
neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and BMI. European Journal of Human Genetics.
2009;17(8):1050-1055.
|
364
Sicherer SH, Sampson HA. Food allergy: epidemiology, pathogenesis,
diagnosis, and treatment. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 2014 Feb
28;133(2):291-307.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Soini S. Genetic testing legislation in Western Europea fluctuating regulatory
target. Journal of Community Genetics. 2012;3(2):143-153.
Song S-H, Chiba K, Ramasamy R, Lamb DJ. Recent advances in the genetics of
testicular failure. Asian Journal of Andrology. 2016;18(3):350-355.
Speakman JR. Functional analysis of seven genes linked to body mass index
and adiposity by genome-wide association studies: a review. Hum Hered.
2013;75(2-4):57-79.
|
365
Speeckaert M, Huang G, Delanghe JR, Taes YE. Biological and clinical aspects
of the vitamin D binding protein (Gc-globulin) and its polymorphism. Clinica
Chimica Acta. 2006 Oct 31;372(1):33-42.
Speliotes EK, Willer CJ, Berndt SI, et al. Association analyses of 249,796
individuals reveal eighteen new loci associated with body mass index. Nature
Genetics. 2010;42(11):937-948.
Spielman RS, Fajans SS, Neel JV, Pek S, Floyd JC, Oliver WJ. Glucose tolerance
in two unacculturated Indian tribes of Brazil. Diabetologia. 1982 Aug;23(2):90-3.
Straub L, Wolfrum C. FGF21, energy expenditure and weight loss How much
brown fat do you need? Molecular Metabolism. 2015;4(9):605-609.
PRECISION NUTRITION
disease. Cytokine. 2015;75(2):249-255.
Sun PH, Ye L, Mason MD, Jiang WG. Protein tyrosine phosphatase kappa
(PTPRK) is a negative regulator of adhesion and invasion of breast cancer
cells, and associates with poor prognosis of breast cancer. J Cancer Res Clin
Oncol. 2013 Jul;139(7):1129-39.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
366
T
Tada H, Won H-H, Melander O, Yang J, Peloso GM, Kathiresan S. Multiple
associated variants increase the heritability explained for plasma lipids and
coronary artery disease. Circulation Cardiovascular Genetics. 2014;7(5):583-587.
Tanofsky-Kraff M, Han JC, Anandalingam K, Shomaker LB, et al. The FTO gene
rs9939609 obesity-risk allele and loss of control over eating. Am J Clin Nutr.
2009;90:14831488.
Teutsch SM, Bradley LA, Palomaki GE, Haddow JE, et al. The evaluation of
genomic applications in practice and prevention (EGAPP) initiative: methods
of the EGAPP working group. Genetics in Medicine. 2009 Jan 1;11(1):3-14.
PRECISION NUTRITION
yields new sequence variants at seven loci that associate with measures of
obesity. Nat Genet. 2009 Jan;41(1):18-24.
Thornton LM, Mazzeo SE, Bulik CM. The heritability of eating disorders:
Methods and current findings. Current Topics in Behavioral Neurosciences.
2011;6:141-156.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Tian X, Patel K, Ridpath JR, Chen Y, Zhou Y-H, Neo D, et al. Homologous
Recombination and Translesion DNA Synthesis Play Critical Roles on
Tolerating DNA Damage Caused by Trace Levels of Hexavalent Chromium.
PLoS ONE. 2016; 11(12): e0167503.
|
367
Timpson NJ, Emmett PM, Frayling TM, Rogers I, Hattersley AT, et al. The fat
mass- and obesity-associated locus and dietary intake in children. Am J Clin
Nutr. 2008; 88: 971978.
Tishkoff SA, Reed FA, Ranciaro A, Voight BF, Babbitt CC, et al. Convergent
adaptation of human lactase persistence in Africa and Europe. Nature
Genetics. 2007 Jan 1;39(1):31-40.
Trace SE, Baker JH, Peas-Lled E, Bulik CM. The genetics of eating disorders.
Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2013;9:589-620.
Tsai PC, Van Dongen J, Tan Q, Willemsen G, Christiansen L, Boomsma DI, et al.
DNA methylation changes in the IGF1R gene in birth weight discordant adult
monozygotic twins. Twin Res Hum Genet. 2015 Dec;18(6):635-46.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Tucker KL, Smith CE, Lai C-Q, Ordovas JM. Quantifying diet for nutrigenomic
studies. Ann Rev Nutr. 2013;33:349-371.
368
U
Ueyama C, Horibe H, Yamase Y, et al. Association of FURIN and ZPR1
polymorphisms with metabolic syndrome. Biomedical Reports. 2015;3(5):
641-647.
U.S. National Institute of Health (NIH) and National Library of Medicine (NLM).
Genetics Home Reference.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Usher CL et al. Structural forms of the human amylase locus and their
relationship to SNPs, haplotypes and obesity. Nature Gen. 47(8): 921- 9. 2015.
V
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Vallender EJ, Lahn BT Positive selection on the human genome. Hum Mol
Genet 2004; 13 (suppl_2): R245-R254.
|
369
van der Hoeven F, Schimmang T, Volkmann A, Mattei MG, Kyewski B, Ruther U.
Programmed cell death is affected in the novel mouse mutant Fused toes (Ft).
Development. 1994 Sep 1;120(9):2601-7.
Van Heel DA, Franke L, Hunt KA, et al. A genome-wide association study for
celiac disease identifies risk variants in the region harboring IL2 and IL21.
Nature genetics. 2007;39(7):827-829.
Vaquero AR, Ferreira NE, Omae SV, Rodrigues MV, Teixeira SK, Krieger JE,
Pereira AC. Using gene-network landscape to dissect genotype effects
of TCF7L2 genetic variant on diabetes and cardiovascular risk. Physiol.
Genomics. 2012;44 (19): 90314.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Vasan RS, Larson MG, Aragam J, et al. Genome-wide association of
echocardiographic dimensions, brachial artery endothelial function and
treadmill exercise responses in the Framingham Heart Study. BMC Medical
Genetics. 2007;8(Suppl 1):S2.
Velders, F.P., J.E. De Wit, P.W. Jansen, V.W.V. Jaddoe, A. Hofman, F.C. Verhulst,
H. Tiemeier. FTO at rs9939609, food responsiveness, emotional control and
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
370
Venckunas T, Skurvydas A, Brazaitis M, Kamandulis S, Snieckus A, Moran
CN. Human alpha-actinin-3 genotype association with exercise-induced
muscle damage and the repeated-bout effect. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2012
Dec;37(6):1038-46.
Vimaleswaran KS, Li S, Zhao JH, Luan JA, Bingham SA, Khaw KT, et al. Physical
activity attenuates the body mass indexincreasing influence of genetic
variation in the FTO gene. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2009 Aug
1;90(2):425-8.
Volckmar A-L, Han CT, Ptter C, et al. Analysis of genes involved in body
weight regulation by targeted re-sequencing. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(2):e0147904.
W PRECISION NUTRITION
|
Whln K, Sjlin E, Hoffstedt J. The common rs9939609 gene variant of the fat
mass- and obesity-associated gene FTO is related to fat cell lipolysis. J. Lipid
Res. 2008;49(3):607-11.
|
371
Walia GK, Gupta V, Aggarwal A, et al. Association of common genetic variants
with lipid traits in the Indian population. Prokunina-Olsson L, ed. PLoS ONE.
2014;9(7):e101688.
Wang CY, Wang ZY, Xie JW, Cai JH, Wang T, Xu Y, Wang X, An L. CD36
upregulation mediated by intranasal LV-NRF2 treatment mitigates hypoxia-
induced progression of Alzheimers-like pathogenesis. Antioxid Redox Signal.
2014 Dec 1;21(16):2208-30.
Wang LQ, Wang TY, Sun QL, Qie YQ. Correlation between thyroglobulin
gene polymorphisms and autoimmune thyroid disease. Mol Med Rep. 2015
Sep;12(3):4469-75.
Wang TJ, Zhang F, Richards JB, et al. Common genetic determinants of vitamin
D insufficiency: a genome-wide association study. Lancet. 2010;376(9736):
180-188.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Wang X, Huang N, Yang M, Wei D, Tai H, Han X, et al. FTO is required for
myogenesis by positively regulating mTOR-PGC-1 pathway-mediated
mitochondria biogenesis. Cell Death & Disease. 2017 Mar;8(3):e2702.
372
Watkins WS, Rogers AR, Ostler CT, et al. Genetic variation among world
populations: Inferences from 100 Alu insertion polymorphisms. Genome
Research. 2003;13(7):1607-1618.
Wetterstrand, Kris. DNA sequencing costs: Data from the NHGRI Genome
Sequencing Program (GSP). National Human Genome Research Institute.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Willer CJ, Schmidt EM, Sengupta S, et al. Discovery and refinement of loci
associated with lipid levels. Nature Genetics. 2013;45(11):1274-1283.
Willer CJ, Speliotes EK, Loos RJF, et al. Six new loci associated with body
mass index highlight a neuronal influence on body weight regulation. Nature
Genetics. 2009;41(1):25-34.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Wilson TW, Grim CE. Biohistory of slavery and blood pressure differences in
blacks today. A hypothesis. Hypertension. 1991 Jan;17(1 Suppl):I122-8.
Wing MR, Ziegler J, Langefeld CD, et al. Analysis of FTO gene variants with
measures of obesity and glucose homeostasis in the IRAS family study.
Human Genetics. 2009;125(5-6):615-626.
|
373
Winter Y, Sankowski R, Back T. Genetic determinants of obesity and related
vascular diseases. Vitam Horm. 2013;91:29-48.
Workman AD, Palmer JN, Adappa ND, Cohen NA. The role of bitter and sweet
taste receptors in upper airway immunity. Current Allergy and Asthma Reports.
2015;15(12):72.
Wu YL, Hu CY, Lu SS, Gong FF, Feng F, Qian ZZ, Ding XX, Yang HY, Sun YH.
Association between methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) C677T/
A1298C polymorphisms and essential hypertension: a systematic review and
meta-analysis. Metabolism. 2014 Dec;63(12):1503-11.
PRECISION NUTRITION
Xavier RJ, Huett A, Rioux JD. Autophagy as an important process in gut
homeostasis and Crohns disease pathogenesis. Gut. 2008 Jun;57(6):717-20.
Xu B, Xie X. Neurotrophic factor control of satiety and body weight. Nat Rev
Neurosci. 2016 May;17(5):282-92.
374
Y
Yamin C, Amir O, Sagiv M, Attias E, Meckel Y, Eynon N, Sagiv M, Amir RE. ACE ID
genotype affects blood creatine kinase response to eccentric exercise. Journal
of Applied Physiology. 2007 Dec 1;103(6):2057-61.
Yamin C, Oliveira J, Meckel Y, Eynon N, Sagiv M, Ayalon M, Alves AJ, Duarte JA.
CK-MM gene polymorphism does not influence the blood CK activity levels
after exhaustive eccentric exercise. International Journal of Sports Medicine.
2010 Mar;31(03):213-7.
Yang KC. LDLR and ApoB are major genetic causes of autosomal dominant
hypercholesterolemia in a Taiwanese population. J. Formos. Med. Assoc.
2007;106(10):799-807.
Yang N, MacArthur DG, Gulbin JP, et al. ACTN3 genotype is associated with
human elite athletic performance. American Journal of Human Genetics.
2003;73(3):627-631.
Yilmaz Z, Kaplan AS, Tiwari AK, et al. The role of leptin, melanocortin, and
neurotrophin system genes on body weight in anorexia nervosa and bulimia
nervosa. Journal of Psychiatric Research. 2014;55:77-86.
Yu N, Chen FC, Ota S, Jorde LB, Pamilo P, Patthy L, et al. Larger genetic
differences within Africans than between Africans and Eurasians. Genetics.
2002 May 1;161(1):269-74.
Z PRECISION NUTRITION
|
Zadro JR, Shirley D, Andrade TB, Scurrah KJ, Bauman A, Ferreira PH. The
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
Zemski AJ, Slater GJ, Broad EM. Body composition characteristics of elite
Australian rugby union athletes according to playing position and ethnicity.
Journal of sports sciences. 2015 May 28;33(9):970-8.
|
375
Zerjal T, Xue Y, Bertorelle G, Wells RS, Bao W, Zhu S, et al. The genetic legacy of
the Mongols. The American Journal of Human Genetics. 2003 Mar 31;72(3):717-
21.
Zhao J, Bradfield JP, Zhang H, Sleiman PM, Kim CE, Glessner JT, et al. Role
of BMI-associated loci identified in GWAS meta-analyses in the context of
common childhood obesity in European Americans. Obesity (Silver Spring).
2011 Dec;19(12):2436-9.
Zhu J, Loos RJF, Lu L, et al. Associations of genetic risk score with obesity and
related traits and the modifying effect of physical activity in a Chinese Han
population. Hsu Y-H, ed. PLoS ONE. 2014;9(3):e91442.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 13 CHAPTER 15
Glossary of terms Contributors and
acknowledgments
|
376
| |
377
PRECISION NUTRITION GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
acknowledgments
Contributors and
CHAPTER 15
Science is a collaborative endeavor.
We are most grateful to all of those who contributed their data and expertise to
help us write this book.
Alaina Hardie
Alaina Hardie is a programmer, maker, and biology enthusiast. She
has worked in software development, data security, and network and
systems engineering.
PRECISION NUTRITION
As PNs original tech person and resident bioinformatician, she was responsible
for a lot of the details in chapters 2 and 3, and for most of the computational
analysis of the data we gathered for this book.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
378
Dr. Helen Kollias
Dr. Helen Kollias is a researcher and regular content contributor for
Precision Nutrition. She is also a co-author of the 3rd edition of the
PN Level 1 Certification textbook, The Essentials of Sport and Exercise
Nutrition as well as an advisor for the Precision Nutrition Level 1
Certification.
Helen holds a PhD in Molecular Biology, specializing in the area of cell signaling
in muscle development and regeneration, and a Masters degree in Exercise
Physiology and Biochemistry.
She has also held research positions at some of the most prestigious institutions
in the world, including John Hopkins University and Torontos Hospital for Sick
Children. At Johns Hopkins, she researched muscle signaling of myostatin and
IGF-1 in muscle. At the Hospital for Sick Children she researched the role of
genetics in the emergence of brown fat.
PRECISION NUTRITION
journals, and countless popular exercise and nutrition books and
magazines.
As an elite nutrition coach and exercise physiologist, JB has worked with over
50,000 clients in over 100 countries, including Olympic gold medalists, world
champion UFC fighters, and professional sports teams. He is also an advisor to
Apple, Equinox, Nike, and Titleist.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
379
Judy Rubin
Growing up, Judy was always trying to draw the bugs and creatures
found in her backyard, and the cells seen under the microscope in her
mothers lab. This unusual childhood hobby later turned into a career.
PRECISION NUTRITION
A nationally-ranked competitive bodybuilder from 1996-2001, and now a
certified yoga instructor, Ryan is also an active volunteer with non-profit
organizations to help promote a sustainable future.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
380
Cam DePutter
Camille DePutter is an author, speaker, and communications consultant
with a rich portfolio of experience in marketing, public relations, and
storytelling.
Camille received her HBA in English from the University of Toronto and
trained at the Humber School for Writers. She lends her communication
expertise to Precision Nutrition publications, course materials and
marketing content.
As a consultant, Camille has helped dozens of top brands and business leaders
refine their messaging and improve their customer relationships. Her work has
been published extensively in popular websites, magazines and newspapers.
Camille is a frequent contributor to the Precision Nutrition blog. She is also the
author of the workbook Share Your Story, and self-publishes at
camilledeputter.com.
PRECISION NUTRITION
seminars and is dedicated to the education and outreach in the field of sports
nutrition and dietary supplements.
Trevor has worked with Worlds Strongest Man competitors, 150-mile ultra
marathon runners, and everything in between. Trevor blends anecdotal,
academic, and clinical data, harmonizing it into practical dietary information for
the general public. You can find him at trevorkashey.com.
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
381
Kenny Manson
Kenny Manson is a performance coach and graduate of the PN Level 2
Master Class Certification. In addition to his PN qualifications, Kenny
holds numerous international fitness certifications and is a PTA Global
accredited coach, for whom he has co-presented at the mentorship
level.
After deciding that he would like to prevent rather than treat the
consequences of poor health, Victor changed careers from surgery to the field
of lifestyle medicine.
PRECISION NUTRITION
His work is accredited by respected organizations such as the Harvard Medical
School, Yale University School of Medicine, the American Medical Association
and the George Washington University Medical School.
382
Alex Picot-Annand
Alex Picot-Annand is a holistic nutritionist and writer who studied
psychology at Dalhousie University and nutrition at the Canadian
School of Natural Nutrition. She is also Precision Nutrition Level 1
and Level 2 certified, and a key contributor to the Precision Nutrition
Encyclopedia of Food.
Although they did not earn her any degrees, she would also argue that
she learned many textbooks worth of life wisdom by living in Ecuador for
seven months, and by working on the frontline of the health industry for nearly
a decade. Thankfully, neither Alex nor her husband carry the OR6A2 gene, so
agree on loading their guacamole with cilantro.
Jennifer Petrosino
Jennifer Petrosino earned a BSc in Exercise Science from the University
of Miami (FL) and an MSc in Kinesiology from The Ohio State University,
while powerlifting for EliteFTS as a raw lifter in the 105-pound weight
class.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
383
Dr. Jennifer Zantinge
Dr. Jennifer Zantinge is a Molecular Cereal geneticist at the Field Crop
Development Centre (FCDC) in Lacombe Alberta.
As lead scientist of the cereal biotechnology lab, her primary goals include
the development and evaluation of molecular genetic based tools such as DNA
marker panels to help plant breeders select genetically superior plants.
Additional thanks
Dr. Ahmed el-Sohemy
Dr. el-Sohemy is a pioneer in the field of nutrigenomics. His early
research paved the way for our current understanding of how
genetic and dietary factors interact to regulate various metabolic and
biochemical pathways involved in the development of cardiometabolic
disease, as well as athletic performance.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
384
Dr. Mariane Hroux
Dr. Mariane Hroux received her PhD in Kinesiology and Health Studies
from Queens University, Canada where she was part of the physical
activity epidemiology lab and studied the relationship between
nutrition, physical activity, and obesity in children from different
countries. Before this, she completed her MSc in Community Health
Epidemiology, and studied the relationship between dietary patterns
and chronic disease.
Dr. Hroux has published her work in numerous scientific journals and has
presented at several scientific conferences. Her interest in how nutrition and
physical activity affect the body developed at an early age, when she started
noticing that what she ate influenced her performance as a competitive gymnast.
Dr. Hroux continues to explore the importance of nutrition and physical activity
at Precision Nutrition where she contributes to research and analyses, and
manages key projects.
PRECISION NUTRITION
|
GENETICS: THE UNIVERSE WITHIN
|
385
Singularity University
Special thanks to Singularity University, its faculty, and facilities for their support
of this project.
Alaina would like to personally thank SUs Chair of Digital Biology, Raymond
McCauley, for checking on her the first day of the Graduate Studies Program,
and providing countless opportunities to learn and teach the wonders of biology.
Without Raymonds inspiration and friendship, this book would not exist.
The PN team
Tim Jones, for so freely sharing his genetic data and letting us tell his family
secrets.
Jenny Brook, Ruby Giulioni, Holly Monster, and Lisanne Thomas, all of whom
read and commented on earlier drafts of the manuscript.
PRECISION NUTRITION
CHAPTER 14
References
|
386