Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 7

Research

Comparison of Blood and Brain Mercury Levels in Infant Monkeys Exposed to


Methylmercury or Vaccines Containing Thimerosal
Thomas M. Burbacher,1,2,3 Danny D. Shen,4 Noelle Liberato,1,2,3 Kimberly S. Grant,1,2,3 Elsa Cernichiari,5 and
Thomas Clarkson 5
1Department of Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences, School of Public Health and Community Medicine, 2Washington
National Primate Research Center, 3Center on Human Development and Disability, and 4Departments of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutics,
School of Pharmacy, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA; 5Department of Environmental Medicine, University of
Rochester School of Medicine, Rochester, New York, USA

overestimate Hg in the brain after exposure to


Thimerosal is a preservative that has been used in manufacturing vaccines since the 1930s. ethylmercury; and c) because ethylmercury
Reports have indicated that infants can receive ethylmercury (in the form of thimerosal) at or decomposes faster than MeHg, the risk of
above the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency guidelines for methylmercury exposure, depend- brain damage is less for ethylmercury than for
ing on the exact vaccinations, schedule, and size of the infant. In this study we compared the sys- MeHg. These conclusions are based on only a
temic disposition and brain distribution of total and inorganic mercury in infant monkeys after few studies, none of which included measure-
thimerosal exposure with those exposed to MeHg. Monkeys were exposed to MeHg (via oral gav- ments of both blood and brain Hg levels in
age) or vaccines containing thimerosal (via intramuscular injection) at birth and 1, 2, and 3 weeks infant subjects.
of age. Total blood Hg levels were determined 2, 4, and 7 days after each exposure. Total and We initiated the present study in order to
inorganic brain Hg levels were assessed 2, 4, 7, or 28 days after the last exposure. The initial and directly compare the blood and brain levels of
terminal half-life of Hg in blood after thimerosal exposure was 2.1 and 8.6 days, respectively, Hg in infant nonhuman primates exposed
which are significantly shorter than the elimination half-life of Hg after MeHg exposure at orally to MeHg or via intramuscular (im)
21.5 days. Brain concentrations of total Hg were significantly lower by approximately 3-fold for injections of vaccines containing thimerosal.
the thimerosal-exposed monkeys when compared with the MeHg infants, whereas the average Nonhuman primates have been used exten-
brain-to-blood concentration ratio was slightly higher for the thimerosal-exposed monkeys (3.5 sively in previous studies of MeHg toxico-
0.5 vs. 2.5 0.3). A higher percentage of the total Hg in the brain was in the form of inorganic kinetics and developmental neurotoxicity
Hg for the thimerosal-exposed monkeys (34% vs. 7%). The results indicate that MeHg is not a (Burbacher et al. 1986, 1990b; Gunderson
suitable reference for risk assessment from exposure to thimerosal-derived Hg. Knowledge of the et al. 1986, 1988; Rice and Gilbert 1982,
toxicokinetics and developmental toxicity of thimerosal is needed to afford a meaningful assess- 1990, 1995; Stinson et al. 1989; Vahter et al.
ment of the developmental effects of thimerosal-containing vaccines. Key words: brain and blood 1994, 1995). The routes of administration
distribution, elimination half-life, ethylmercury, infant nonhuman primates, methylmercury, (oral for MeHg and im injection for
thimerosal. Environ Health Perspect 113:10151021 (2005). doi:10.1289/ehp.7712 available via thimerosal-containing vaccines) were chosen
http://dx.doi.org/ [Online 21 April 2005] to mimic the two routes of Hg exposure for
humans. The dosages and schedule of
administration of Hg were chosen to be com-
Public perception of the safety and efficacy of some cases, exceeds the U.S. EPA guidelines parable with the current immunization sched-
childhood vaccines has a direct impact on for MeHg exposure during pregnancy ule for human newborns, taking into
immunization rates (Biroscak et al. 2003; (0.1 g/kg/day). Other estimates (Halsey consideration the faster growth (~ 4 to 1) of
Thomas et al. 2004). The current debate link- 1999) have indicated that the schedule could the macaque infant (Gunderson and Sackett
ing the use of thimerosal in vaccines to autism provide repeated doses of ethylmercury from 1984). The results of the present study pro-
and other developmental disorders [Institute approximately 5 to 20 g/kg over the first vide important new information regarding
of Medicine (IOM) 2001, 2004] has led many 6 months of life. Studies in preterm infants the comparative toxicokinetics of these two
families to question whether the potential risks indicate that blood levels of Hg after just one compounds in newborns and infants.
associated with early childhood immuniza- vaccination (hepatitis B) increase by > 10-fold
tions may outweigh the benefits (Blaxill et al. to levels above the U.S. EPA guidelines
2004; SafeMinds 2005). Thimerosal is an (Stajich et al. 2000). Address correspondence to T.M. Burbacher,
effective preservative that has been used in the The U.S. EPA guidelines for MeHg (U.S. Department of Environmental and Occupational
Health Sciences, 1705 NE Pacific St., Health
manufacturing of vaccines since the 1930s. EPA 2005) are based on several decades of Sciences Building (F555), School of Public
Thimerosal consists of 49.6% mercury by studies of humans and animal models of Health and Community Medicine, University of
weight and breaks down in the body to ethyl- developmental toxicity (Burbacher et al. Washington, Seattle, WA 98195 USA. Telephone:
mercury and thiosalicylate (Tan and Parkin 1990a; National Research Council 2000). (206) 685-1862. Fax: (206) 685-4696. E-mail:
2000). Recent reports have indicated that Because few data exist for ethylmercury, the tmb@u.washington.edu
some infants can receive ethylmercury (in the use of the MeHg guidelines would seem We thank the staff of the Infant Primate Research
Laboratory for their cooperation during this study and
form of thimerosal) at or above the U.S. appropriate if the two compounds have similar D. Blough for his assistance with statistical analyses.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) toxicokinetic profiles and neurodevelopmental We also thank J. Treanor from the University of
guidelines for methylmercury exposure (U.S. effects. The results from the few studies that Rochester for supplying the vaccines used in the study.
EPA 2005), depending on the exact vaccina- have provided a direct comparison of these This project was supported by funds from the
tions, schedule, and size of the infant (Ball two compounds have been reviewed recently National Institutes of Health, grants RO1ES03745,
et al. 2001). Clements et al. (2000) calculated by Magos (2003), who concluded that a) Hg P51HD02274, P51RR00166, P30ES07033, and
NO1-A1-25460.
that children receive 187.5 g of ethylmercury clears from the body faster after the adminis- The authors declare they have no competing
from thimerosal-containing vaccines given tration of ethylmercury than after the admin- financial interests.
over the first 14 weeks of life. According to istration of MeHg; b) the brain-to-blood Hg Received 2 November 2004; accepted 20 April
the authors, this amount approaches or, in concentration ratio established for MeHg will 2005.

Environmental Health Perspectives VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 1015


Burbacher et al.

Materials and Methods Sacrifice schedule. Infants were sacrificed 2, Greenwood et al. (1977). The method deter-
Subjects. Forty-one infant Macaca fascicularis 4, 7, or 28 days after their last Hg exposure on mines total Hg and its inorganic fraction
born at the Washington National Primate day 21 (Table 1). Infants were sedated with an (Magos and Clarkson 1972). Cadmium chlo-
Research Centers Infant Primate Research im injection of ketamine (10 mg/kg) and ride in the presence of stannous chloride at
Laboratory were used in the study. The birth atropine (0.4 mg/kg) and then given an intra- high pH breaks the Hgcarbon bond with the
weights of the infant monkeys were within the venous overdose of Nembutal (20 mg/kg; subsequent reduction of Hg2+ to Hg0; the lat-
normal range for this species; the average birth Abbott Labs, North Chicago, IL). Autopsy ter is then measured by cold vapor atomic
weight was 341 g (range, 255420 g). Infants personnel from the primate center drew blood absorption at 254 nm with a Hg monitor
were weighed daily throughout the study, and and removed the brain and other organs (Laboratory Data Control, model 1235;
any clinical problems were recorded. for analysis. The autopsy typically lasted Thermo Separation Products, Waltham, MA).
Mercury dosing schedule. The Hg dosing approximately 1 hr. Inorganic Hg is determined by the addition of
schedule is shown in Table 1. Infants were The numbers of monkeys at each sacrifice SnCl2 in the absence of cadmium chloride.
assigned to one of three exposure groups at day for both the MeHg and thimerosal groups Concentration of organic Hg was calculated
birth. Seventeen infant monkeys assigned to were as follows: day 23 (2 days after most from the difference between the measured
the thimerosal group were given the typical recent dose), n = 4; day 25 (4 days after most total and inorganic Hg concentrations. The
schedule of vaccines for human infants recent dose), n = 4; day 28 (7 days after most original concentration of SnCl2 used for the
(Table 1). Thimerosal (Omicron Quimica recent dose), n = 5; and day 49 (28 days after Magos method (Magos and Clarkson 1972)
S.A., Barcelona, Spain), dissolved in saline, was most recent dose), n = 4. The seven control was modified to prevent the decomposition of
mixed with thimerosal-free vaccines to yield a monkeys were assigned sacrifice days as fol- the ethylmercury during assay (Magos et al.
final concentration of 4, 8, or 20 g/mL Hg, lows: day 23, n = 3; day 25, n = 1; day 28, 1985). To measure Hg in aqueous solution of
depending on the vaccine and the age of the n = 2; and day 49, n = 1 (Table 1). Monkeys thimerosal, the amount of SnCl2 was reduced
infant. The total dose of Hg administered via were assigned to sacrifice groups at birth on a from 100 g to 50 g/aliquot analyzed. For
the vaccines was 20 g/kg on day 0 and at 7, semirandom basis that balanced sex ratios and tissue homogenate samples, 500 g SnCl2 was
14, and 21 days of age. A dose of 20 g/kg was average birth weights across groups. added to each aliquot. All reagents used for
chosen based on the range of estimated doses Blood and brain Hg measurements. Blood preparation and analysis of the samples were
received by human infants receiving vaccines samples were prepared for Hg analysis by of analytical grade.
during the first 6 months of life. diluting them with an equal volume of 1% Quality control was assured by analysis
Seventeen infant monkeys assigned to the wt/vol NaCl solution. Aliquots were removed of reference samples before each assay run.
MeHg group were given MeHg hydroxide for Hg determination without digestion. One Fisher Mercury Reference Standard Solution
(MeHgOH, 97% pure; Alfa Aesar, Johnson drop of antifoam reagent was added to the (SM114-100, certified 1,000 ppm 1%; Fisher
Matthey Co., Ward Hill, MA) dissolved in aliquot at the time of the analysis. Scientific, Hampton, NH) was used as a stock
water to a concentration of 20 g Hg/mL. Half brain samples were fixed in for- solution. Working standards of 30 and 10 ng
MeHg was administered to infant monkeys maldehyde before analysis. Samples of the fix- Hg/mL were made daily from appropriate dilu-
via oral gavage at a dose of 20 g/kg on their ative were analyzed to check for Hg content. tions of the stock solution. In addition, the fol-
day of birth (day 0) and at 7, 14, and 21 days The tissue was removed from the jar and blot- lowing certified reference materials were
of age. ted dry. A homogenate of the brain in 1% analyzed daily before analysis of the samples:
Seven infant monkeys were assigned to a NaCl was prepared using a Polytron homo- trace elements in whole blood (Seronorm Trace
control group. These monkeys did not receive genyzer PT 10-35 (Brinkmann Instruments, Elements, Certified Reference Material
any gavages or im injections. Infants were Westbury, NY) while keeping the sample in 201605, 6.88.5 g/L; Accurate Chemical &
assigned to the three groups on a semirandom an ice slurry. An aliquot of the homogenate Scientific Corp., Westburg, NY), and trace ele-
basis, in order to balance sex ratios and aver- was digested with 1 mL 1% wt/vol cysteine ments in human hair (Certified Reference
age birth weights across groups. and 2 mL 45% NaOH by heating at 95C for Material 397, 12 g/g 0.5; Commission of
Blood draw schedule. Blood was drawn 1015 min. Digest was allowed to cool and the European Communities, Geel, Belgium).
from the saphenous vein of all infant mon- then diluted to volume by addition of 7 mL The detection limit of the instrument was esti-
keys at birth (before any Hg exposure). Blood 1% wt/vol NaCl. The digests were kept in an mated to be 0.75 ng Hg per aliquot used for
was also drawn 2, 4, and 7 days after the ini- ice slurry until analysis. Aliquots were removed analysis.
tial Hg exposure (day 0) and after subsequent for Hg determination. One drop of antifoam Data analysis. The mean total blood Hg
exposures on days 7 and 14. Depending on was added to the aliquot at the time of concentration data from both the oral MeHg
the sacrifice group, blood was drawn up to the analysis. and im thimerosal groups (n = 17 in each)
28 days after the final exposure on day 21 to Total Hg concentrations in blood and total were analyzed using the compartmental mod-
further characterize the washout kinetics of and inorganic Hg concentrations in brain were ule of the pharmacokinetic modeling software
Hg (Table 1). measured using a procedure adapted from SAAM II (SAAM Institute, Seattle, WA).

Table 1. Study design and schedule.


Age (days)
0 (birth) 2 4 7 9 11 14 16 18 21 23 25 28 31 35 38 42 45 49
MeHg group (oral dose, g/kg) 20 20 20 20
OPV (0) OPV (0)
Thimerosal group [ethylmercury dose, OPV (0) HB (4) OPV (0) HB (4)
in im vaccine (g/kg)] HB (20) DTP (8) DTP (10) DTP (8)
Hib (8) Hib (10) Hib (8)
Blood draws (days after most recent dose) 0 2 4 7 2 4 7 2 4 7 2 4 7 10 14 17 21 24 28
Sacrifice day (days after last dose) 2 4 7 28
Abbreviations: DTP, diphtheria/tetanus/pertussis vaccine; HB, hepatitis B vaccine; HIB, haemophilus influenzae type b vaccine; OPV, oral polio vaccine.

1016 VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 Environmental Health Perspectives


Thimerosal and blood and brain mercury

The accumulation and washout of total high concentration is most likely due to conta- or brain between groups was indicated by a sig-
blood Hg concentrationtime data from the mination of the sample. Therefore, data from nificant regression coefficient for time-by-group
MeHg monkeys were well described by a one- this brain and its corresponding blood were interaction. If there was no evidence for inter-
compartment model featuring a first-order excluded from the regression analysis. The aver- action, a significant decline in blood or brain
absorption process. Regression fit of the data to age brain-to-blood concentration ratio was also Hg concentration over time for each group was
the model yielded estimates of the absorption calculated using data from the earliest sacrifice assessed by the t-statistic associated with the
rate constant (ka), elimination rate constant (K), duration (2 days). Because of different washout estimated regression coefficient for time.
and an apparent volume of distribution (V/F; F half-lives in blood and the brain, brain-to-blood The following statistical comparisons of
is the implicit bioavailability term). Half-lives concentration ratio is expected to vary with the the washout rate of Hg were also undertaken:
(T1/2) corresponding to each of the rate con- duration of washout. Samples at day 2 offered total Hg in blood versus total Hg in the brain,
stants were calculated by dividing ln 2 by the the best measure of the extent of uptake of Hg total Hg in blood versus organic Hg in the
rate constant estimate. Blood clearance (Cl/F ) species into the brain that are least confounded brain, and total Hg versus organic Hg concen-
was derived from the product of K and V/F. by differences in their clearance rate. tration in the brain. The difference between
A one-compartment model failed to Between-group statistical comparisons of the pair of log-transformed Hg concentrations
provide a satisfactory fit of the mean total the rate of washout of total Hg in blood, as well for each animal sacrificed at the various times
blood Hg concentrationtime data from the as total and organic concentrations in the brain, was calculated. Individual difference values in
thimerosal monkeys. The model overpredicted were accomplished through multiple regression both groups were then entered as the depen-
the blood concentration during accumula- analysis as implemented in the PROC GLM dent variable in the regression model. The
tion; at the same time, it underpredicted the subroutine in SAS (version 9.1; SAS Institute, independent variables were time, group, and
blood concentration during washout rate (i.e., Cary, NC). PROC GLM performs multiple time-by-group interaction. A significant
overpredicted washout rate). Further exami- regression within the framework of general lin- regression coefficient for the time variable
nation of a scatter plot of the individual mon- ear models and can accommodate missing data indicates that the paired-log concentration dif-
key data suggested a biphasic pattern in the or sparse sampling and confounding from corre- ference (or the concentration ratio) varied
washout of Hg from the blood after the last lations between repeated measures. Hence, it is with time; that is, the two concentration
dose. Accordingly, we attempted a regression able to provide tests of hypotheses for the effects measures (e.g., blood and brain) did not
fit of the mean total blood Hg concentration of time and group using blood and brain data decline in parallel with time.
data with a two-compartment model. This obtained from sacrifice of individual animals at
yielded a much better visual fit of the data, with varying times during washout. Log-transformed Results
minimal change in the objective function and blood or brain Hg concentrations in animals Growth and health status. The weights of
Akaike information criterion. The two-com- from both the MeHg and thimerosal groups infant monkeys during the study are shown in
partment parameter estimates from the regres- were entered as the dependent variable. The Figure 1. We found no significant differences
sion analysis included the absorption rate independent variables consisted of sampling in the weight gain across the three groups
constant (ka), rate constants for Hg transfer time, group (MeHg = 0, thimerosal = 1), and a (p > 0.10, all comparisons); the average weight
from the central to the peripheral compart- time-by-group interaction. Once the overall sig- gain during the first 23 days of life was 135 g.
ment (k12) and the return from the peripheral nificance of the regression model was verified, The brain weights at sacrifice and brain-to-
to the central compartment (k21), the elimina- the significant sources of variation (i.e., time, body weight ratios are shown in Table 2; we
tion rate constant from the central compart- group, and time by group) were identified. A found no significant differences in brain
ment (k10), and the apparent volume of the difference in the rate of washout of Hg in blood weights or brain-to-body weight ratios across
central compartment (V c /F ). From these
primary parameters, we further estimated the 550
Controls (n = 7)
apparent distribution volume at steady state MeHg group (n = 17)
(Vss /F ) and the peripheral volume referenced Thimerosal group (n = 17)
to blood concentration (i.e., Vp = Vss Vc ). 500

The initial and terminal rate constants and half-


lives (T1/2, and T1/2,) for the biexponential
Weight (grams)

decline of total blood Hg concentration were 450


estimated by standard formulas (Gibaldi and
Perrier 1982). Blood clearance was computed
by the product of Vc and k10. For both the 400
MeHg and thimerosal model fits, a fractional
SD of 0.1 was used as the weighting scheme.
The washout half-life of total and organic 350
Hg in the brain of both the oral MeHg and
im thimerosal groups was estimated by
regression fit to a monoexponential model 300
using WinNonlin software (Pharsight Corp., 0 5 10 15 20 25
Age (days)
Mountain View, CA). One of the day 28
Figure 1. Weight gain of infant monkeys during study. Error bars indicate SE.
brain samples from the MeHg exposure group
had a spuriously high total Hg concentration, Table 2. Mean SE body and brain weight and brain-to-body weight ratio at sacrifice.
that is, a concentration of 151 ng/g, which is
more than 50% higher than the other samples Exposure group Body weight (g) Brain weight (g) Brain:body weight ratio
obtained on day 28 (7190 ng/mL) and higher Controls (n = 9) 509.3 52.0 52.1 2.5 0.107 0.009
than those observed at the earliest sacrifice time MeHg exposed (n = 17) 499.1 17.5 51.1 1.1 0.103 0.003
at day 2 (75129 ng/g). The unreasonably Thimerosal exposed (n = 17) 529.1 25.4 52.7 1.2 0.102 0.003

Environmental Health Perspectives VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 1017


Burbacher et al.

the three groups (p > 0.10, all comparisons). consistent with the known extensive extravas- SE of 2.5 0.3) 2 days after the last MeHg
Also, no serious medical complications were cular distribution of Hg after MeHg exposure dose. This brain-to-blood concentration ratio
observed in any of the monkeys. in primates and agrees with previous estimates increased as the duration between the last dose
Oral MeHg kinetics. The total blood Hg of Hg distribution volume in adult M. fascic- and the sacrifice lengthened. The ratio ranged
concentrations at 2 days (observed peak) after ularis (Stinson et al. 1989). The elimination from 3.9 to 7.4 at 28 days after the last expo-
the first dose ranged from 8 to 18 ng/mL T1/2 of total blood Hg is 21.5 days, which sure. The time dependence for the brain-to-
across the monkeys, that is, a 2-fold variation. agrees with reported estimates in adult M. fas- blood ratio (p = 0.06) is primarily due to the
Progressive accumulation of total blood Hg cicularis (Stinson et al. 1989; Vahter et al. difference in the washout T1/2 between total
was observed over the three subsequent doses 1994, 1995). The blood clearance is esti- Hg in the blood and brain. The average brain-
of MeHg, such that the peak total blood Hg mated at 46.1 mL/day/kg, well within the to-blood ratio for these infant monkeys at
concentrations after the fourth dose were range of clearance values observed earlier in day 2 after the last MeHg dose (2.5 0.3) is
about 3-fold higher (3046 ng/mL). The adult M. fascicularis (Stinson et al. 1989). It slightly lower than previously reported values
interanimal variation in blood Hg concentra- appears that the systemic disposition kinetics (35) for adult macaque and squirrel monkeys
tions remained at about 2-fold during accu- of MeHg are the same between infant and over various durations of washout (Berlin et al.
mulation. Blood Hg persisted through the adult M. fascicularis, that is, no change during 1975; Stinson et al. 1989; Vahter et al. 1994).
entire period of washout and was readily development. Although the cited differences in brain uptake
measurable in all four monkeys in the 28 day A plot of the blood and brain total Hg and clearance of MeHg between adult and
sacrifice group (1621 ng/mL). This is consis- concentration data from the monkeys sacri- infant monkeys may be attributed to the effects
tent with previous reports of an elimination ficed at various times during the washout of postnatal brain growth and development, it
T1/2 > 20 days for MeHg in adult M. fascicu- period is shown in Figure 3. There was a sig- may also be related to variation in exposure
laris (Stinson et al. 1989; Vahter et al. 1994, nificant decrease in total Hg from the blood regimen between studies.
1995) and explains the minimal decline during the washout period (p < 0.01). The A plot of the organic and inorganic Hg
(< 20%) in blood Hg concentrations during apparent T1/2 for total Hg in blood is 19.1 concentrations in the brain of MeHg-exposed
the weekly intervals between MeHg doses. 5.1 days ( SE of regression estimate). The monkeys sacrificed at various times during the
The time course of total blood Hg was fit- decrease in total Hg in the brain over time was washout period is shown in Figure 4. The
ted to a one-compartment model. Figure 2 marginally significant (p < 0.07), with an decrease in organic Hg in the brain over time
shows the excellent regression fit of the mean apparent T1/2 of 59.5 24.1 days. The T1/2 for was not statistically significant (p = 0.17). The
blood concentrationtime data. Table 3 pre- total Hg in brain was significantly longer than apparent T1/2 for the washout of organic Hg
sents parameter estimates from the one-com- the T1/2 for total Hg in blood (p = 0.05) for from the brain was 58.4 25.0 days, close to
partment model fit of the mean blood Hg the MeHg-exposed monkeys. The T1/2 for the T1/2 for total Hg. The concentration of
concentrationtime data. The distribution total Hg in brain is also longer than the previ- inorganic Hg in the brain samples was below
volume of total Hg after MeHg administra- ously reported washout T1/2 from the brain for the quantifiable limit of the assay (7 ng/mL) in
tion is estimated to be 1.7 L/kg, or about adult M. fascicularis (37 days; Vahter et al. 8 of 17 MeHg-exposed monkeys. The average
20 times the blood volume (~ 8%). This 1994, 1995). It should be noted that the rela- concentration of inorganic Hg for those
means that only 1/20th of the body burden of tively high SE of the half-life estimates for the monkeys with values above the detection
Hg is confined to the vascular space. This is brain reflects the large interanimal variation in limit (n = 10) did not change significantly
Hg concentrations at each sampling time, lim- over 28 days of washout and was approxi-
50 ited number of data points, and the short dura- mately 78 ng/mL (Figure 4). Inorganic Hg
Predicted
Observed
tion of sacrifice relative to the washout half-life. represented only 610% of total Hg in the
40 The concentration of total Hg in the brain is
Blood total Hg (ng/mL)

1.7- to 3-fold higher than in the blood (mean 1,000


Organic
30 Inorganic
1,000
Blood
Concentration (ng/g)

Brain
Concentration (ng/mL or ng/g)

20 100

10

100 10
0
0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49
Time (days)
Figure 2. Comparison of predicted and observed
1
mean blood total Hg concentrations during and
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
after four weekly oral doses (20 g/kg) of MeHg.
Error bars indicate SD. 10 Days after last dose
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Days after last dose Figure 4. A semilogarithmic plot of the washout of
Table 3. Parameter estimates derived from a one- organic and inorganic Hg in the brain after four
compartment analysis of the mean blood total Hg Figure 3. A semilogarithmic plot of washout of total weekly oral doses (20 g/kg) of MeHg. The data
concentration for the oral MeHg group (n = 17). Hg in blood and the brain after four weekly oral were collected from groups of infant monkeys sac-
Model parameters Mean SD doses (20 g/kg) of MeHg. The data were collected rificed at 2, 4, 7, and 28 days after the last dose. The
from groups of infant monkeys sacrificed 2, 4, 7, and lines represent nonlinear regression fit of the data
V/F (L/kg) 1.67 0.07 28 days after the last dose. The lines represent non- to a monoexponential model. The regression esti-
ka (day1) 2.07 1.04 linear regression fit of the data to a monoexponen- mate ( SE) for organic Hg is T1/2 = 58.4 25.0 days
K (day1) 0.0276 0.0024 tial model; the regression estimate ( SE) of T1/2 is (r = 0.57). The half-life of inorganic Hg is too long
T1/2 (days) 21.5 T1/2 = 19.1 5.1 days (r = 0.81) for blood and T1/2 = (> 120 days) to be accurately estimated from the pre-
Cl/F (mL/day/kg) 46.1 59.5 24.1 days (r = 0.59) for brain. sent data (i.e., r is not significantly different from 0).

1018 VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 Environmental Health Perspectives


Thimerosal and blood and brain mercury

brain. These values are consistent with previ- peak concentrations are extrapolations and thimerosal-exposed monkeys is 2.6- to 4.6-fold
ously reported data in adult M. fascicularis should be viewed with caution. The initial vol- higher than in the blood (mean SE, 3.5 0.5)
(Vahter et al. 1994, 1995). ume of distribution in the central compart- at 2 days after the last injection. Again, this
Intramuscular thimerosal kinetics. The ini- ment was 1.7 L/kg, which is comparable with ratio increased as the sacrifice was performed at
tial total Hg concentrations in the day 2 blood the overall distribution volume for oral MeHg. longer durations from the last dose, primarily
samples, which ranged from 6 to 14 ng/mL, are The initial and terminal blood half-lives were due to the difference in the half-lives of total
comparable with the concentrations observed in 2.1 and 8.6 days, respectively. Mercury derived Hg in the blood and brain.
the oral MeHg group. These blood levels are from thimerosal is eliminated much more A plot of the organic and inorganic Hg
also similar to those reported in preterm human rapidly than MeHg. The steady-state volume concentrations in the brain of thimerosal-
infants receiving 12.5 g Hg from a hepatitis B of distribution (i.e., Vss or the fully equilibrated exposed infant monkeys sacrificed at various
vaccine (Stajich et al. 2000). Blood Hg concen- volume) was estimated to be 2.5 L/kg, which is times during the washout period is shown in
trations declined relatively rapidly (by > 50%) 50% larger than the initial distribution volume Figure 7. There was a significant decrease in
between doses. As a result, there was minimal (i.e., Vc ). Hence, the effective peripheral com- organic Hg in the brain over the washout
accumulation in blood Hg concentrations dur- partment volume at steady state is about period (p < 0.01). The apparent T1/2 for the
ing weekly dosing. Also, blood Hg concentra- 0.8 L/kg. Alternately, this means that, at steady washout of organic Hg from the brain was
tions dropped below the detection limit of the state, partitioning of the body burden of Hg 14.2 5.2 days, which is significantly shorter
assay in some animals by day 10 after the last between the tissue regions associated with the than the T1/2 for total Hg in brain (p < 0.01).
vaccine injection. central and peripheral compartments is about The inorganic form of Hg was readily measur-
The time course of total blood Hg 2:1. The blood clearance of total Hg was esti- able in the brain of the thimerosal-exposed
concentrations was best described by a two- mated to be 248 mL/day/kg, which is 5.4-fold monkeys. The average concentration of inor-
compartment model; that is, the disposition higher than the estimate for oral MeHg. ganic Hg did not change across the 28 days of
kinetics are biphasic, with a rapid initial phase Figure 6 presents a scatter plot of the blood washout and was approximately 16 ng/mL
followed by a slower terminal phase of clear- and brain total Hg concentration data for mon- (Figure 7). This level of inorganic Hg repre-
ance. Table 4 presents the parameter estimates keys sacrificed at various times during the sented 2186% of the total Hg in the brain
derived from the two-compartment model washout. There was a significant decrease in (mean SE, 70 4%), depending on the sacri-
analysis. A comparison of the model prediction total Hg concentration in the blood during the fice time. These values are considerably higher
and the observed blood concentration data is washout period (p < 0.01). The apparent T1/2 than the inorganic fraction observed in the
shown in Figure 5. The model predicted some for total Hg in blood is 6.9 1.7 days. There brain of MeHg monkeys (610%).
accumulation in peak blood Hg concentrations was also a significant decrease in total Hg con-
and minimal accumulation in trough concen- centration in the brain over time (p < 0.01), Discussion
trations. Because blood concentration data with an apparent T1/2 of 24.2 7.4 days. The There are notable similarities and differences
were not available before day 2, the predicted T1/2 for total Hg in brain was significantly in the kinetics of Hg after oral administration
longer than the T 1/2 for total Hg in blood of MeHg and im injection of thimerosal in
Table 4. Parameter estimates derived from a two- (p < 0.01) for the thimerosal-exposed monkeys. vaccines. The absorption rate and initial distri-
compartment analysis of the mean blood total Hg In addition, the T1/2 for total Hg in blood and bution volume of total Hg appear to be simi-
concentration for the im thimerosal group (n = 17). brain for these monkeys (6.9 1.7 days and lar between im thimerosal and oral MeHg.
Model parameters Mean SD 24.2 7.4 days, respectively) are significantly This means approximately equal peak total
shorter (p < 0.01) than the T1/2 for total Hg in blood Hg levels after a single exposure to
ka (day1) 3.24 3.00
k12 (day1) 0.081 0.076
blood and brain for the MeHg monkeys (19.1
k21 (day1) 0.177 0.138 5.1 days and 59.5 24.1 days). The concen- 100
Organic
k10 (day1) 0.148 0.024 tration of total Hg in the brain of the Inorganic
T1/2, (day) 2.13 100
T1/2, (day) 8.62
Concentration (ng/g)

Blood
Vc/F (L/kg) 1.68 0.30 Brain
Concentration (ng/mL or ng/g)

Vss/F (L/kg) 2.45


Vp (L/kg) 0.77 10
Cl/F (mL/day/kg) 248

10
16
Predicted
Observed
Blood total Hg (ng/mL)

12
1
0 5 10 15 20 25 30

8 Days after last dose


1
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Figure 7. A semilogarithmic plot of washout of
Days after last dose
organic and inorganic Hg in the brain after four
4
weekly im injection of vaccines containing
Figure 6. A semilogarithmic plot of washout of total thimerosal (20 g/kg Hg). The data were collected
0
Hg in blood and the brain after four weekly im injec- from groups of infant monkeys sacrificed at 2, 4, 7,
0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 tions of vaccine thimerosal (20 g/kg Hg). The data and 28 days after the last dose. The lines represent
Time (days) were collected from groups of infant monkeys sacri- nonlinear regression fit of the data to a monoexpo-
ficed at 2, 4, 7, 10, 17, and 21 days after the last dose. nential model. The regression estimate ( SE) of
Figure 5. Comparison of predicted and observed The lines represent nonlinear regression fit of the T1/2 for organic Hg is T1/2 = 14.2 5.2 days (r = 0.76).
mean blood total Hg concentration during and after data to a monoexponential model. The regression The half-life of inorganic Hg is too long (> 120 days)
four weekly im injections of vaccine containing estimate ( SE) of T1/2 is 24.2 7.4 days (r = 0.74) for to be accurately estimated from the present data
thimerosal (20 g/kg Hg). Error bars indicate SD. brain and 6.9 1.7 days (r = 0.82) for blood. (i.e., r is not significantly different from 0).

Environmental Health Perspectives VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 1019


Burbacher et al.

either MeHg or thimerosal or after episodic A much lower brain concentration of total the results did not indicate the presence of
exposures that are apart by longer than four Hg was observed in the thimerosal monkeys inorganic Hg deposits in the area where the
elimination half-lives (i.e., > 80 days for compared with the MeHg monkeys, that is, a cerebellar damage was localized (granular layer).
MeHg or > 28 days for thimerosal). Studies in 3- to 4-fold difference for an equivalent expo- In contrast, previous studies of adult
preterm and term human infants have sure of Hg. Moreover, total Hg is cleared M. fascicularis monkeys exposed chronically
reported similar results (Stajich et al. 2000). much more rapidly from the brain after to MeHg have indicated that demethylation
Infants receiving 12.5 g Hg from a single thimerosal than after MeHg exposure (24 vs. of Hg occurs in the brain over a long period
hepatitis B vaccine had blood Hg levels at 60 days). It appears that the difference in brain of time after MeHg exposure and that this is
4872 hr, consistent with what would be Hg exposure between thimerosal and MeHg is not a detoxification process (Charleston et al.
anticipated after an equivalent dose of MeHg. largely driven by their differences in systemic 1994, 1995, 1996; Vahter et al. 1994, 1995).
Although the initial distribution volume of disposition kinetics (i.e., the blood level). The Results from these studies indicated higher
total Hg is similar for the two groups, a bipha- average brain-to-blood partitioning ratio of inorganic Hg concentrations in the brain
sic exponential decline in total blood Hg is total Hg in the thimerosal group was slightly 6 months after MeHg exposure had ended,
observed only after im injections of thimerosal. higher than that in the MeHg group (3.5 0.5 whereas organic Hg had cleared from the
This suggests continual distribution into and vs. 2.5 0.3, t-test, p = 0.11). Thus, the brain- brain. The estimated half-life of organic Hg
localization in tissue sites over time. It is rele- to-blood Hg concentration ratio established for in the brain of these adult monkeys was con-
vant to note that the kidney-to-blood concen- MeHg will underestimate the amount of Hg in sistent across various brain regions at approxi-
tration gradient of total Hg is much higher in the brain after exposure to thimerosal. mately 37 days (similar to the brain half-life
the thimerosal monkeys than in the MeHg The large difference in the blood Hg half- in the present infant monkeys). The esti-
monkeys (mean SE, 95.1 10 vs. 5.8 0.6). life compared with the brain half-life for the mated half-life of inorganic Hg in the brain in
The second slower phase of washout could also thimerosal-exposed monkeys (6.9 days vs. the same adult cohort varied greatly across
represent the gradual biotransformation of 24 days) indicates that blood Hg may not be a some regions of the brain, from 227 days to
ethylmercury (the presumed principal organic good indicator of risk of adverse effects on the 540 days. In other regions, the concentrations
form of Hg after thimerosal administration) to brain, particularly under conditions of rapidly of inorganic Hg remained the same (thala-
Hg-containing metabolites that have a differ- changing blood levels such as those observed mus) or doubled (pituitary) 6 months after
ent tissue distribution or are more slowly elimi- after vaccinations. The blood concentrations of exposure to MeHg had ended (Vahter et al.
nated. Further investigations of the disposition the thimerosal-exposed monkeys in the present 1994, 1995). Stereologic and autometallo-
fate of thimerosal-derived Hg should address study are within the range of those reported for graphic studies on the brains of these adult
these issues. human infants after vaccination (Stajich et al. monkeys indicated that the persistence of
Total Hg derived from im thimerosal is 2000). Data from the present study support inorganic Hg in the brain was associated with
cleared from the infant M. fascicularis much the prediction that, although little accumula- a significant increase in the number of
more quickly than MeHg. The washout T1/2 tion of Hg in the blood occurs over time with microglia in the brain, whereas the number of
of total blood Hg after im injections of repeated vaccinations, accumulation of Hg in astrocytes declined. Notably, these effects
thimerosal in vaccines is much shorter than the the brain of infants will occur. Thus, conclu- were observed 6 months after exposure to
T1/2 of MeHg (6.9 vs. 19.1 days). These results sion regarding the safety of thimerosal drawn MeHg ended, when inorganic Hg concentra-
support the earlier conclusion of Magos (2003) from blood Hg clearance data in human tions were at their highest levels, or in animals
that Hg is cleared from the body faster after infants receiving vaccines may not be valid, solely exposed to inorganic Hg (Charleston
the administration of ethylmercury than after given the significantly slower half-life of Hg in et al. 1994, 1995, 1996). The effects in the
the administration of MeHg. More interest- the brain as observed in the infant macaques. adult macaques were associated with brain
ingly, the washout blood Hg T 1/2 in the There was a much higher proportion of inorganic Hg levels approximately five times
thimerosal-exposed infant macaques (7 days) is inorganic Hg in the brain of thimerosal mon- higher than those observed in the present
remarkably similar to the blood Hg T 1/2 keys than in the brains of MeHg monkeys (up group of infant macaques. The longer-term
reported for human infants injected with to 71% vs. 10%). Absolute inorganic Hg con- effects (> 6 months) of inorganic Hg in the
thimerosal-containing vaccines reported by centrations in the brains of the thimerosal- brain have not been examined. In addition,
Pichichero et al. (2002). exposed monkeys were approximately twice whether similar effects are observed at lower
An important consequence of the difference that of the MeHg monkeys. Interestingly, the levels in the developing brain is not known. It
in blood half-lives is the remarkable accumula- inorganic fraction in the kidneys of the same is important to note that an active neuroin-
tion of blood Hg during repeated exposure to cohort of monkeys was also significantly higher flammatory process has been demonstrated in
MeHg. Although the initial blood Hg concen- after im thimerosal than after oral MeHg expo- brains of autistic patients, including a marked
tration (at 2 days after the first dose) did not sure (0.71 0.04 vs. 0.40 0.03). This sug- activation of microglia (Vargas et al. 2005).
differ between the MeHg and thimerosal gests that the dealkylation of ethylmercury is The American Academy of Pediatrics
groups, the peak blood Hg concentration in the much more extensive than that of MeHg. and the U.S. Public Health Service (1999) pub-
MeHg-exposed monkeys rose to a level nearly Previous reports have indicated that the lished a joint statement that urged all govern-
three times higher than in the thimerosal mon- dealkylation of Hg is a detoxification process ment agencies to work rapidly toward reducing
keys after the fourth dose. Furthermore, the that helps to protect the central nervous sys- childrens exposure to mercury from all
blood clearance of total Hg is 5.4-fold higher tem (Magos 2003; Magos et al. 1985). These sources. The statement recommended that
after im thimerosal than after oral MeHg expo- reports are largely based on histology and his- thimerosal be removed from vaccines as soon as
sure. The results indicate that for an equivalent tochemistry studies of adult rodents exposed possible as part of this overall process. Between
level of chronic exposure, the area under the to Hg for a short period of time. The results of 1999 and 2001, vaccines currently recom-
curve of total blood Hg concentrations in these studies indicated that damage to the mended for children 6 years of age were made
human infants receiving repeated im injections cerebellum was observed only in MeHg- available in thimerosal-free formulations in the
of thimerosal-containing vaccines will be treated animals that had much lower levels of United States (Centers for Disease Control and
significantly lower than that in those exposed inorganic Hg in the brain than animals com- Prevention 2001). Exposures to thimerosal
chronically to MeHg via the oral route. parably treated with ethylmercury. Moreover, through pediatric vaccines, however, still occur

1020 VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 Environmental Health Perspectives


Thimerosal and blood and brain mercury

in other countries where multiple-dose vials are REFERENCES Immunization Safety Review Committee. Washington,
used to maintain childhood immunization pro- DC:National Academy Press.
American Academy of Pediatrics and U.S. Public Health Knezevic I, Griffiths E, Reigel F, Dobbelaer R. 2004. Thiomersal
grams and the control of preventable disease in vaccines: a regulatory perspective. WHO Consultation,
Service. 1999. Thimerosal in vaccines: a joint statement.
(Knezevic et al. 2004). MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 48:563565. Geneva, 1516 April 2002. Vaccine 22:18361841.
Recent publications have proposed a direct Ball LK, Ball R, Pratt RD. 2001. An assessment of thimerosal use Magos L. 2003. Neurotoxic character of thimerosal and the
allometric extrapolation of adult clearance half-time to
link between the use of thimerosal-containing in childhood vaccines. Pediatrics 107:11471154.
Berlin M, Crawford A, Grant DVM. Hellberg J, Hellstrom J, infants. J Appl Toxicol 23:263269.
vaccines and the significant rise in the number Schultz A. 1975. Neurotoxicity of methylmercury in squirrel Magos L, Brown AW, Sparrow S, Bailey E, Snowden RT, Skipp
of children being diagnosed with autism, a monkeys. Arch Environ Health 30:340348. WR. 1985. The comparative toxicology of ethyl- and
serious and prevalent developmental disorder Biroscak BJ, Fiore AE, Fasano N, Fineis P, Collins MP, methylmercury. Arch Toxicol 57:260267.
Stoltman G. 2003. Impact of the thimerosal controversy on Magos L, Clarkson TW. 1972. Atomic absorption of total,
(for review, see IOM 2001). Results from an hepatitis B vaccine coverage of infants born to women of organic and inorganic mercury in blood. J Assoc Off Anal
initial IOM review of the safety of vaccines unknown hepatitis B surface antigen status in Michigan. Chem 55:966971.
found that there was not sufficient evidence to Pediatrics 111:645649. National Research Council. 2000. Toxicological Effects of
Blaxill MF, Redwood L, Bernard S. 2004. Thimerosal and Methylmercury. Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
render an opinion on the relationship between Pichichero ME, Cernichiari E, Lopreiato J, Treanor J. 2002.
autism? A plausible hypothesis that should not be dis-
ethylmercury exposure and developmental dis- missed. Med Hypotheses 62:788794. Mercury concentrations and metabolism in infants receiving
orders in children (IOM 2001). The IOM Burbacher T, Grant K, Mottet NK. 1986. Retarded object perma- vaccines containing thiomersal: a descriptive study. Lancet
review did, however, note the possibility of nence development in methylmercury exposed Macaca 360:17371741.
fascicularis infants. Dev Psychol 22:771776. Rice DC, Gilbert SG. 1982. Early chronic low-level methylmercury
such a relationship and recommended further Burbacher T, Rodier PM, Weiss B. 1990a. Methylmercury poisoning in monkeys impairs spatial vision. Science
studies be conducted. A recently published developmental neurotoxicity: a comparison of effects in 216:759761.
second review (IOM 2004) appears to have humans and animals. Neurotoxicol Teratol 12:191202. Rice DC, Gilbert SG. 1990. Effects of developmental exposure to
Burbacher T, Sackett GP, Mottet NK. 1990b. Methylmercury methylmercury on spatial and temporal visual function in
abandoned the earlier recommendation as well monkeys. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 102:151163.
effects on the social behavior of Macaca fascicularis
as backed away from the American Academy infants. Neurotoxicol Teratol 12:6571. Rice DC, Gilbert SG. 1995. Effects of developmental methyl-
of Pediatrics goal. This approach is difficult to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2001. Notice to read- mercury exposure or lifetime lead exposure on vibration
ers: update on the supply of tetanus and diphtheria toxoids sensitivity function in monkeys. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol
understand, given our current limited knowl- 134:161169.
and of diphtheria and tetanus toxoids and acellular pertussis
edge of the toxicokinetics and developmental vaccine. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 50:189190. SafeMinds. 2005. SafeMinds Homepage. Available: http://
neurotoxicity of thimerosal, a compound that Charleston J, Body R, Bolender R, Mottet NK, Vahter M, www.SafeMinds.org [accessed 22 June 2005].
has been (and will continue to be) injected in Burbacher T. 1996. Changes in the number of astrocytes Stajich GV, Lopez GP, Harry SW, Sexson WR. 2000. Iatrogenic
and microglia in the thalamus of the monkey Macaca fas- exposure to mercury after hepatitis B vaccination in
millions of newborns and infants. cicularis following long-term subclinical methylmercury preterm infants. J Pediatr 136:679681.
The key findings of the present study are exposure. Neurotoxicology 17:127138. Stinson CH, Shen DM, Burbacher TM, Mohamed MK, Mottet NK.
the differences in the disposition kinetics and Charleston J, Body R, Mottet NK, Vahter M, Burbacher T. 1995. 1989. Kinetics of methylmercury in blood and brain during
Autometallographic determination of inorganic mercury chronic exposure in the monkey Macaca fascicularis .
demethylation rates of thimerosal and MeHg. Pharmacol Toxicol 65:223230.
distribution in the cortex of Macaca fascicularis following
Consequently, MeHg is not a suitable refer- long-term subclinical exposure to methylmercury and Tan M, Parkin JE. 2000. Route of decomposition of thiomersal
ence for risk assessment from exposure to mercuric chloride. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 132:325333. (thimerosal). Int J Pharm 208:2334.
Thomas AR, Fiore AE, Corwith HL, Cieslak PR, Margolis HS.
thimerosal-derived Hg. Knowledge of the bio- Charleston J, Bolender R, Mottet NK, Body R, Vahter M,
Burbacher T. 1994. Increases in the number of reactive 2004. Hepatitis B vaccine coverage among infants born to
transformation of thimerosal, the chemical glia in the visual cortex of Macaca fascicularis following women without prenatal screening for hepatitis B virus
identity of the Hg-containing species in the subclinical long-term methylmercury exposure. Toxicol infection: effects of the joint statement on thimerosal in
blood and brain, and the neurotoxic potential Appl Pharmacol 129:196206. vaccines. Pediatr Infect Dis J 23:313318.
Clements CJ, Ball LK, Ball R, Pratt RD. 2000. Thiomersal in vac- U.S. EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). 2005.
of intact thimerosal and its various biotransfor- cines. Lancet 355:12791280. Integrated Risk Information System. Available: http://www.
mation products, including ethylmercury, is Gibaldi M, Perrier D. 1982. Pharmacokinetics. New York:Marcel epa.gov/iris/subst/0073-htm [accessed 22 June 2005].
urgently needed to afford a meaningful inter- Dekker. Vahter M, Mottet NK, Friberg L, Lind B, Charleston J, Shen D,
Greenwood MR, Dahir P, Clarkson TW, Farant JP, Chartrand A, et al. 1995. Demethylation of methylmercury in different
pretation of the potential developmental effects brain sites of Macaca fascicularis monkeys during long-
Khayat A. 1977. Epidemiological experience with the Magos
of immunization with thimerosal-containing reagents in the determination of different forms of mercury term subclinical methylmercury exposure. Toxicol Appl
vaccines in newborns and infants. This infor- in biological samples by flameless atomic absorption. J Anal Pharmacol 134:273284.
mation is critical if we are to respond to public Toxicol 1:265269. Vahter M, Mottet NK, Friberg L, Lind B, Shen D, Burbacher T.
Gunderson V, Grant K, Burbacher T, Fagan J, Mottet NK. 1986. 1994. Speciation of mercury in the primate blood and brain
concerns regarding the safety of childhood The effect of low level prenatal methylmercury exposure following long-term exposure to methylmercury. Toxicol
immunizations. on visual recognition memory in infant macaques. Child Appl Pharmacol 124:221229.
Dev 57:10761083. Vargas DL, Nascimbene C, Krishnan C, Zimmerman AW, Pardo
CORRECTION Gunderson V, Grant-Webster K, Burbacher T, Mottet NK. 1988. CA. 2005. Neuroglial activation and neuroinflammation in
Visual recognition memory deficits in methylmercury the brain of patients with autism. Ann Neurol 57:6781.
In the original manuscript published online, exposed Macaca fascicularis infants. Neurotoxicol Teratol
there were two errors that have been corrected 10:373379.
here. First, in the Abstract, the standard errors Gunderson V, Sackett GP. 1984. Development of pattern recog-
nition in infant pigtailed macaques (Macaca nemestrina).
for the average brain-to-blood concentration Dev Psychol 20:418426.
ratios were incorrect for thimerosal and Halsey NS. 1999. Perspective on the Use of Thimerosal-
MeHg-exposed monkeys. Second, in the last Containing Vaccines: Slide Show. Baltimore, MD:Institute for
Vaccine Safety. Available: http://www.vaccinesafety.edu/
paragraph of Data analysis, the statement sld001.htm [accessed 15 June 2005].
about the two concentration measures has IOM (Institute of Medicine). 2001. Immunization Safety Review:
been corrected to the two concentration Thimerosal Containing Vaccines and Neurodevelopmental
measures (e.g., blood and brain) did not Disorders (Stratton K, Gable A, McCormick M, eds).
Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
decline in parallel with time. IOM (Institute of Medicine). 2004. Vaccines and Autism.

Environmental Health Perspectives VOLUME 113 | NUMBER 8 | August 2005 1021

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi