Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Faculty- Dr Gajavelli V S
CFM PROJECT
Economic growth triggered shifting of steel demand from developed world to the developing world
High globalization and competition leading to high consolidation in the global steel market
Steel: Five-force analysis
Backed by strong volumes as well as realisations, steel Industry has registered a phenomenal growth
across the world over the past few years. The condition in the domestic industry was no exception. In
fact, it enjoyed a double digit growth rate backed by a robust growing economy. However, the current
liquidity crisis seems to have created medium term hiccups. Below we have analyzed the domestic steel
sector through Michael Porter's five force model so as to understand the competitiveness of the sector.
Barriers to entry: We believe that the barriers to entry are medium. Following are the factors that
support our view.
2. Economies of scale: As far as the sector forces are concerned scale of operation does matter.
Benefits of economies of scale are derived in the form of lower costs, R& D expenses and better
bargaining power while sourcing raw materials. We can deduce that those steel companies, which
are combined, own mines for key raw materials such as iron ore and coal and this protects them
for the probable threat for new entrants to a significant extent.
3. Government Policy: The government has a favourable policy for steel manufacturers. However,
there are certain differences involved in allocation of iron ore mines and land acquisitions.
Furthermore, the regulatory clearances and other issues are some of the major problems for the
new entrants.
4. Product differentiation: Steel has very low barriers in terms of product differentiation as it
doesn't fall into the luxury or specialty goods and thus does not have any substantial price
difference. There are some companies which still enjoy a premium for their products because of
their quality and brand value created more than 100 years back. Bargaining power of buyers:
Unlike the FMCG or retail sectors, the buyers have a low bargaining power. However, the
government may limit or put a ceiling on prices if it feels the need to do so. The steel companies
either sell the steel directly to the user industries or through their own distribution networks. Some
companies also do exports.
Bargaining power of suppliers: The negotiating power of suppliers is low for completely integrated
steel plants as they have their own mines of key raw material like iron ore coal for example Tata Steel.
However, those who are non-integrated or semi integrated has to depend on suppliers. An example could
be SAIL, which imports coking coal.
Competition: It is medium in the domestic steel industry as demand still exceeds the supply. India is a
net importer of steel. However, a threat from dumping of cheaper products does exist.
Threat of substitutes: It is medium to low. Although usage of aluminum has been rising continuously
in the automobile and consumer durables sectors, it still does not pose any significant threat to steel as
the latter cannot be changed completely and the cost disparity is also very high.
Producer wise crude steel capacity in India by 2015-16 this is likely to increase further by 2019-20
Indian Steel Scenario
During April-March 2016-17, Crude Steel production was reported at 97.4 million tonnes, growth of
about 8.5% over last year. The finished steel production also registered a handsome growth of 11.3%
during April-March 2016-17. Import of total finished steel was at 7.5 million tonnes in the Financial
Year 2016-17 and saw a significant decline of 36.6 % compared to same period of last year. India saw a
growth of 102.1% in exports during 2016-17 (8.244 million tonnes) over the last year and India emerged
as a net exporter of total finished steel.
India's consumption of total finished steel saw a growth of 3% in April-March 2016-17 (83.93 MT)
over same period of last year.
Further, with the Government's focus on manufacturing and industry coupled with spending on
infrastructure (roads, rail and ports etc.), the demand for steel is going to increase in the coming years.
SWOT FOR SAIL
Strengths
SAIL continues to be among the leading steel producers of the Nation.
Multi located production units give us an edge over other domestic steel players.
Reasonably modernised units after completion of the on-going modernisation and expansion.
Well established nationwide marketing and distribution network helps in enhancing the reach
for SAIL products all over the nation.
Most diverse product range offered by any domestic steel company.
Availability of land bank at existing plant/unit locations for future brownfield expansion.
Input security - 100 per cent integration in iron-ore.
Highly skilled professionals with practice in steel making.
Weaknesses
Dependence on external sources for key input - coking coal leads to exposure of the Company to the
market risk.
Recently commissioned large volume blast furnaces are highly in demand with respect to raw material
quality and consistency..
High manpower cost and relatively low manpower productivity.
Currently, around 25% of the products are in the form of semi-finished steel, resulting in lower value
addition to the product portfolio. The share of semis is being targeted to be brought down by increasing
the output from new rolling mills.
Opportunities:
With an augmented push from the policies projected by the Government regarding steel intensive
segments such as infrastructure, capital goods and construction, India is all set to become the 2nd largest
steel consumer in the World in the future years.
High export potential to markets of Middle East and South East Asia.
Scope for improving product quality and optimizing cost through operational efficiency and utilization
of the modernized units.
Threats
Dumping of steel from abroad and increased competition from domestic and international steel
companies located in India.
Low-priced sourcing of steel from countries with whom India has Free Trade Agreement(FTA).
** Now let us analyse the market trend and futuristic outlook for the company through charts and
deduce some important facts with the help of these graphs.
Demand projections were made using econometric modelling technique. Separate demand functions
were fitted to historical data for all major categories of steel products
The Demand Side Pattern of finished steel consumption in India 1980-81 to 2009-10
From the above graph we can see a decline in 1993-94 and significant up-turn since 2002-03 in the
Pattern of steel consumption in India.
Enhanced Productivity with Rationalized Manpower
SAIL manpower strength was 82,964 nos. as on 31.3.2017 with manpower rationalization of 5,691
achieved during the year. To give further thrust for enhancing productivity and manpower
rationalization, SAIL has recently introduced Voluntary Retirement Scheme-2017 w.e.f. 15th June,
2017. Trend of enhanced productivity and manpower rationalization since 2007-08 onwards is depicted
below:
The enhanced productivity with rationalized manpower could be achieved as a result of judicious
recruitments, building competencies and infusing a sense of commitment and passion among employees
to go beyond and excel.
Steps taken by government to revive SAIL
India has set up a panel to turn around loss-making Steel Authority of India Ltd (SAIL) and help the
state-owned company increase production.
It is done to revive SAIL after a government review found the company to be far less efficient than its
rivals despite spending more than $10 billion in the past eight years.
Performance of SAIL in stock market & steps taken to enhance its performance.
The company added it is in its final leg of completing its balance modernization projects which is aimed
at diversifying its product basket by adding more value-added products and ready-to-use products
customized to market demand.
SAIL has tied the ECB at the lowest possible spread and the overall cost, on a fully hedged basis. This
would work out cheaper than that applicable coupon on Term Loans and Bonds for similar period.
OUTLOOK
We can expect above normal monsoon and higher GDP growth. The slow pace of public and private
sector projects is expected to improve with the Government of India's thrust on infrastructure projects.
Further, 'Make in India' initiative has got a boost by a slew of measures aimed at improving the ease of
doing business in the Country. Small and medium industry- a major employment generator for the
economy- has been liberated to participate in the Nation's development in accordance with its potential.
Bold measures by the Government such as improved targeting of subsidy, broadening of the tax base
and expected buoyancy in tax revenue are all aimed at achieving the fiscal consolidation which had been
an area of concern in the recent past.
References:
SAIL annual report 2016-17
HSBC market analysis report.
Antique Stock Broking Report
Dr Subir Bhattacharyas report on SURGE IN INDIAN STEEL INDUSTRY.
https://sail.co.in/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steel_Authority_of_India
Money Control, Rediff Money for stock market analysis.