Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Erick Castro
Professor Batty
English 102
When analyzing David Henry Hwangs play M. Butterfly, a common interpretation is the
exercise of Western colonialism over the East; having the relationship between the main
characters, Gallimard and Song, represent the West intruding upon Eastern culture and the East
having to seemingly accept it. This, however, is but one of many ways to view such a play; as
attention to the suppressive nature that comes with the concept of heterosexuality and the
difficulty found in analyzing the gender issues that are also being called into question. At first
glance, it can quickly be found that the main character, Gallimard, is clearly representing the
Western culture and their dominant behavior. Even though Gallimard is introduced as a weaker
and less masculine male, when he meets song he adopts more confident and powerful
characteristics. Song plays the role of a delicate looking Chinese woman who turns out to be a bit
submissive; this is to further emphasize the way Western cultures view Asian culture and the
Eastern cultures in general. Although this is a valid argument, it adds another obstacle when
femininity, which constrains some people to the role that has been created by society. When the
play M. Butterfly was written, the concept of heterosexuality became a controversial topic that
left many questioning why there was a defined gender and the thought of masculinity and
femininity. Everyones gender is decided at birth and that determines how a child is going to act
and what type of person they will grow up to be; or at least that was what was considered
socially acceptable for most of human history. The concept that a man should be strong and
behave confidently, as well as the notion that women should be more empathetic and fragile has
had a significant impact on everyones life by insinuating that someones biological gender
dictates their character. Certain individuals have had a tough time trying to adjust and forcing
themselves to follow social norms, keeping their true selves hidden from the world because of
the desire to be normal. These social constructs make it hard to analyze a piece like M. Butterfly
because the actions of a character like Gallimard are simply overlooked and it is assumed that he
was simply being tricked by Song and the illusion of being a woman that she provided;
because of this, the possibility that Gallimard is a homosexual trying to conceal his true nature
while living in a world where such ideals are not accepted is often overlooked.
Hwang uses the setting to express his views on heterosexuality and how people who do
not identify with it can live a life as a social outcast. The play begins with Gallimard in a jail cell
as an outcast to society; he does not belong with the rest of the world and therefore must remain
exiled, secluded, and confined to not disturb anyone. He states that he is a celebrity and has
known and been loved by... the Perfect Woman (Hwang Act 1, Scene 1). He begins to speak of
the tragic events that led him to where he is currently, but even so, those around him seem to
have trouble understanding him, eventually giving up on him and instead just laugh at his
Castro 3
predicament. At the start of the play Hwang is already portraying the main character, Gallimard,
as a man who is different and does not fit in with everyone else. Gallimards reputation, his
identity as a man has come into question simply because of the way he is. He is described to be
this weak individual who has always struggled with dating due to his awkwardness. His
masculinity is being called into question and because of this he begins to question himself,
struggling to find that power and confidence that he desires. He is trapped by the preconceived
notion of a man having to play the role of a man. His sexuality is being suppressed and he can
Perceived happiness will sometimes originate from contempt and the feeling that they
belong somewhere. For certain people who struggle with their identity, it becomes a matter of
whether they can find and accept who they are. When he first came across Song, he felt as
though he and was ecstatic. When around Song, his perception of who he was changed and was
reflected in the way he acted. He began to seem more confident and felt better about who he was.
He fell in love with her and even went so far as to divorce his wife so he could live together with
Song. He went on to live with her for twenty years before his trial for treason. During the case
Song was asked to testify and he appeared before the jury. When it was revealed that Song was a
man, Gallimard refused to accept it. Another result of the trial was that it was made apparent that
Gallimard should have known about Songs identity; "Did I not undress her because I knew,
somewhere deep down, what I would find?" (Hwang Act 2, Scene 6) in the play he admits that
he always had a feeling that something was different. He accepted the illusion that it provided.
So long as everyone around him saw Song as a woman, there were no perceived issues.
Gallimard had more than likely come to terms with his sexuality but could only do so under the
illusion that Songs mask provided. Once it was revealed that Song was nothing more than a
Castro 4
homosexual man pretending to be a woman, Gallimard could no longer live that life that he so
desired.
Because of the pressure that is exerted on an individual to fit in with their peers,
sometimes people have trouble accepting their sexuality; some refuse to acknowledge it and
suffer psychological and sometimes even physical traumas. Death with honor is better than
life... life with dishonor. (Hwang Act 3, Scene 3). Nearing the end of the play, Gallimard can no
longer live with the events that have taken place and decides to die an honorable death rather
than live a dishonorable life. After learning of his true nature and discovering who he really is,
he can neither accept himself nor continue living because of it. When he can finally come to
terms and accept his homosexuality, he realizes that things would no longer be the same; his
reputation had already been hindered and he would no longer be respected by his peers. The
social construction of gender can have a significant impact on individuals who do not fall under
the category of heterosexual. Gallimard had always struggled to conform with the social norms
and tried to appear more confident and powerful to show his masculinity.
Other interpretation may make it harder to analyze the controversies that come with the
socially constructed ideas of gender that are present within the play. What was originally
intended to be nothing more than just classification as biological gender got turned into a role
that people began to follow. This had a negative impact on many people and forced some
individuals to hide their true sexuality, being left with nothing but a feeling of suppression.
Although Hwangs play M. Butterfly did not directly state that Gallimard was a homosexual,
there was plenty reason to believe he was hiding his true nature and just avoiding reality. He fell
Balaev, Michelle. "Performing gender and fictions of the nation in David Hwang's M. Butterfly."
Forum for World Literature Studies, vol. 6, no. 4, 2014, p. 608+. Literature Resource
Center, library.lavc.edu
Literary Criticism, edited by Jeffrey W. Hunter, vol. 196, Gale, 2005. Literature
Hwang, David Henry. M. Butterfly. New York: Dramatists Play Service, 2008. Print.
Martin, Robert K. "Gender, Race, and the Colonial Body: Carson McCullers's Filipino Boy, and
Jeffrey W. Hunter, vol. 196, Gale, 2005. Literature Resource Center, library.lavc.edu