Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
41-59
Alexandru MADGEARU
Faculty of History, University of Bucharest
Of course, the relations with the Late Roman Empire were the
necessary condition for the spreading of Christianity in Dacia, but these
relations were exerted in the 4th century especially through the ruralized
cities that preserved a part of their economic function (which is proved by
the bronze coins). If we compare what happened in Dacia with the better
known situation of Britain, we can observe that the end of the city life did
not affected the development of the conversion to Christianity, like in
Britain, because the Dacian Christendom continued to be supported by the
strong contacts with the empire, even after the disappearance of the
towns. In Britain, the revival took place in different circumstances, which
have no analogy in Dacia (the new mission sent from Rome in 596), but
the folk Christianity (with the words of Peter Brown) had probably
some common features. The local British peasants preserved even
without an organized clergy a folk religion that was ?largely invisible
to outsiders (BROWN 2003, p. 341).
The archaeological evidence shows that the Daco-Roman Christian
antiquities dated between 275 and the middle of the 5th century were
found especially in the former towns or camps inhabited by civilians after
the retreat of the army (10 from the total of 14): Alba Iulia-Apulum,
Moigrad-Porolissum, R`cari, Sarmizegetusa, Turda-Potaissa, Zlatna-
Ampelum (see Fig. 2). The Christian finds from the North-Danubian area
occupied again by the Roman Empire in the 4th century are not included
here, because they are not relevant for this discussion.
Among these sites, only Potaissa has Christian objects from the
2nd-3rd centuries, which means that the Christian communities spread from
the early concentration area of Potaissa-Napoca to other areas. An
important evidence for the conversion to the new religion is the basilica
from Porolissum, built in the 4th century by the transformation of a
heathen temple (GUDEA, GHIURCO 1988, p. 199-200). In the same period,
the Christian objects began to penetrate in the rural settlements of
Criste]ti (Mure] County), and Mic`sasa (Sibiu County). The
archaeological context of two other finds (a finger ring from B`ile
Herculane, Cara]-Severin County, and the liturgic vessels from Biertan,
Sibiu County) is not known. The important discovery from Biertan will
be largely discussed in the second part of this study.
The Christian character of other objects is not sure. They were
found in nine sites, from which four are former cities or camps, still
peopled in the 4th-5th centuries (Ili]ua, Tibiscum-Jupa, Potaissa-Turda,
Micia-Ve\el). Other four come from the rural settlements of C`rbunari
(Cara]-Severin County), Deva (Hunedoara County), Jab`r (Timi]
County), Snnicolaul Mare (Timi] County). A clay lamp from Merchea]a
(Bra]ov County) does not have a known archaeological context
(references for these objects in MADGEARU 2001, p. 114-119).
THE SPREADING OF THE CHRISTIANITY IN THE RURAL AREAS 45
OF POST-ROMAN DACIA (4th-7th CENTURIES)
the chandelier and the plate (CIGLENEKI 1993, p. 219). The medallion
(Fig. 4) has a diameter of 195 mm (237 mm, including the two rings used
for pending). The tickness is 4 mm. The medallion is decorated by
openwork with the superposed Greek letters P and X - the chrismon.
The votive plate (donarium, or ex voto) measures 325 x 126 x 4
mm (Fig. 5). The piece was made in the same technique of openwork.
The inscription EGO ZENOVIVS VOTVM POSVI is put on three lines.
The plate has two ansae, which are larger than the central part (132 mm)
and which are provided with three holes used for binding on a support).
Two rings used for pending were placed up and down. The upper one is
now broken, but it was entire when the plate was found; it appears in the
design made by the cardinal Giuseppe Garampi in 1780 - preserved in the
Latin manuscript 9104, f. 155 from the Vatican Library (POPESCU 1976,
p. 388).
The existence of two binding systems is strange for an object of
this kind. Usually, the votive plates have only rings. It is sure that the
donarium had the two rings when it was made, because they are casted
together with the rest of the piece. However, the holes pierced on the
ansae seem to prove that the donarium was destinated to be fixed on a
wall, on a beam, or on other wooden object. It could be supposed that the
ansae were perforated in another moment, when the function of the object
has changed. This would mean that the plate was initially destinated to be
exposed by hanging, but for some reasons the fixing system was changed.
Another hypothesis was expressed by Mihai Gramatopol. Unlike other
archaeologists, he sustained that the tabula was fixed on a chest, and that
the medallion (linked with a chain) was used as a symbolic fastener of
this chest (GRAMATOPOL 1982, p. 228, 305 n. 10). This can explain the
existence of the holes on the ansae. In this case, the bronze vessels were
put in that wooden casket. We think that this idea deserves full attention.
We do not know proper analogies for the Biertan donarium,
because these tabulae ansatae with pending rings do not usually have
holes on the ansae. If we ignore the holes, then a close analogy is that
indicated by A. Alfoldi: the plate found at Siscia in Pannonia (Sisak,
Croatia), which bears an inscription made in the same technique of
openwork, but with Greek letters (Fig. 6). This votive plate is dated in the
3rd-4th centuries, and the dedicant could be either Christian, either heathen
(ALFLDI 1942, p. 256, Taf. XL/1). The inscription was published by V.
HOFFILLER, B. SARIA, Antike Inschriften aus Jugoslavien, I, Zagreb,
1938, p. 240, nr. 525: Gaeianc Diognou(c) pr eqc njeto.
Another analogy is the tabula ansata (Fig. 7) from Dion (Greek
Macedonia), which has the letters made in the same technique (FEISSEL
1983, p. 79-80, nr. 79 - who quotes the tabula from Biertan).
THE SPREADING OF THE CHRISTIANITY IN THE RURAL AREAS 49
OF POST-ROMAN DACIA (4th-7th CENTURIES)
name Zenovie was used until the 20th century by the Transylvanian
Romanians.
The medallion with chrismon has many analogies in the northern
Dalmatia and in Pannonia. Based on five similar pieces, Andras Alfldi
and Kurt Horedt supposed that these medallions were first produced in the
workshops from Aquileea, one of the most active economic and religious
centers in Illyricum in the 4th-6th centuries (HOREDT 1982, p. 167). Other
four medallions were identified by CIGLENEKI 1993, p. 213-221, and
FIEDLER 1996-1998, p. 392-393. Their mapping shows a penetration from
Aquileea toward East. The medallion from Biertan is the most eastern
piece and it could be observed that its location is in the prolongation of
the direction traced by the pieces from Dalmatia and Pannonia. K. Horedt,
followed by other archaeologists, supposed that this reflects a trading
route. This point of view was challenged by U. Fiedler, who considers
that the spreading of these objects indicates the direction of a Gothic
attack. He supposed that the Goths plundered from Italy or Dalmatia the
objects deposited at Biertan. It seems unlikely that a Gothic warrior has
took from a Italian or Pannonian church these small bronze objects that
had no symbolic value for him, in order to hide them hundreds of
kilometers far from that church. Fiedler was not able to provide a similar
case of deposition of bronze or iron objects made by the Germanic
warriors settled in Transylvania or in the neighbouring areas in the 4th-6th
centuries. All the deposits and hoards that can be ascribed to them are
composed from gold and silver pieces.
The medallioans from Aquileea, Ljubljana, Vipota (2 pieces) and
from the cave of kocjan differ very much from that from Biertan. They
are much more sophisticated and display other symbols, like the letters A
and , or the grape stalks). These pieces belonged to a group specific for
the northwestern Illyricum, created at Aquileea. Other pieces recorded by
Fiedler are in fact chandeliers decorated with the chrismon of Egyptian
fashion, not simple medallions (Rogoznica, near Ptuj-Poetovio)
(KOROEC 1980, p. 55-61). They should be excluded from the list of
analogies for the piece from Biertan. The most similar pieces are those
found in the nearest area, in present-day Hungary. One of them, preserved
in the Rth collection of the National Hungarian Museum, was found
somewhere in Hungary. The chrismon is not very different from that from
Biertan; the disc is smaller (110 mm; 136 mm with the upper and lower
rings) and it has six lateral protuberances. The second close analogy is the
piece said to be found at Bonyhd. In this case, the form is the same. Only
the dimensions are different (diameter 234 mm; 29,2 mm including the
rings) (TTH 1977, p. 147, Abb. 3, 148, note 8, 149, Abb. 4; THOMAS
1982, p. 271, Abb. 12, 13; UBL 1982, p. 575-576). A recent monograph
THE SPREADING OF THE CHRISTIANITY IN THE RURAL AREAS 51
OF POST-ROMAN DACIA (4th-7th CENTURIES)
shows that the location at Bonyhd is not sure, but that the piece could
still be considered of Pannonian origin (GSPR 2002, p. 140).
Because it is obvious that the medallions from Pannonia and
Biertan belong to the same group, it could be supposed that they were
made in the same workshop or in neighbour workshops that can be
located in Pannonia (for instance at Sirmium), not in Aquileea (as has
observed ALFLDI 1942, p. 257). We think that the more simple
Bonyhd-Biertan type was created by the imitation of the Aquileea type.
Therefore, it is much more probable that the piece from Biertan was made
somewhere in Pannonia and that it came in Dacia by the Mure] valley. It
is interesting that the medallion from Bonyhd was found in a place near
the Danube, at the end of the road that linked Partiscum (at the confluence
of Mure] with Tisza) with Dacia. The western connection of the Dacian
4th century sites is proved by the discovery of several coins struck at
Siscia, Sirmium, and even Aquileea, arrived by the same trading route on
the Mure] valley (HOREDT 1982, p. 182-184; BUTNARIU 1991, p. 83). It
seems that this direction of penetration for Christian objects survived until
the 7th century, because two later pieces were found on the lower Mure]
valley (the lamp with the shape of a fish from Lipova and the liturgic
vessel from Periam). The St. Menas flasks found in Transylvania came
too by Pannonia in the 6th century (BARNEA 1995; KDR 1995).
It is certain that the donarium, the medallion, and the two other
liturgic objects from Biertan were used in a church. Some researchers
supposed that this church was located somewhere near the place where
the objects were found (PROTASE 1966, p. 145; POPESCU 1976, p. 389;
HOREDT 1982, p. 165 (perhaps a baptisterium near a spring);
GRAMATOPOL 1982, p. 228; ZUGRAVU 1997, p. 290; TEODOR 2000, p.
14). There is no proof, but this fact can not be excluded. Even U. Fiedler
admits that the Christians worshipped the springs in certain occasions.
This could be the case at Biertan. But, if we consider that the objects were
put in the earth by a Christian, then the hiding can be ascribed to refugee
people who have took with themselves the precious liturgic vessels of a
church located elsewhere. In this case, the time of the hiding is not
necessary close to that when the objects were made. If we take into
account the isolated character of the area where the objects were hidden,
then this supposition is worth of consideration. In fact, nothing proves
that the objects were deposited in the 4th century. Their uniqueness in the
rural milieu can be thus explained. Their presence at Biertan would be
strange for the 4th century, but not also for the 6th century, when the
Christianization of the countryside was already initiated by the people
displaced from the ruralized cities. In this case, the hiding can be dated in
the 6th century or even in the 5th century, when the townsfolk took refuge
in the rural areas. If we accept the idea expressed by M. Gramatopol, then
52 ALEXANDRU MADGEARU
the using for deposition of a wooden chest on which the plate was fixed
can be explained only by the hiding of these objects by a Christian who
transported them to Biertan from another place, for instance from a city.
It is interesting that one of the medallions from Dalmatia (Vipota)
was found into an isolated place, on the slopes of a mountain, where the
people from Celeia (Celje, Slovenia) took refuge in the 6th-7th centuries;
another one was discovered in a cave, at kocjan (CIGLENEKI 1993, p.
219-220).
In conclusion, the significance of the liturgic objects found at
Biertan can be clarified if it is studied within the historical and
archaeological framework of the 4th-6th centuries. These relics are not an
isolated presence in the countryside. Like other objects, they testify the
displacement of the Daco-Roman Christians outside the post-urban
milieu, and, on the other hand, the contacts established with the Christian
communities from Pannonia.
List of illustrations
References
2. Map of the Christian finds dated between 275 and the middle of the 5th century:
1: Alba Iulia; 2: B`ile Herculane; 3: Biertan; 4: C`rbunari; 5: Criste]ti; 6: Deva; 7:
Ili]ua; 8: Jab`r; 9: Jupa; 10: Merchea]a; 11: Mic`sasa; 12: Moigrad; 13: R`cari;
14: Sarmizegetusa; 15: Snnicolaul Mare; 16: Turda; 17: Ve\el; 18: Zlatna.
THE SPREADING OF THE CHRISTIANITY IN THE RURAL AREAS 57
OF POST-ROMAN DACIA (4th-7th CENTURIES)
3. Map of the Christian finds dated between the middle of the 5th century and the
beginning of the 7th century: 1: Alba Iulia; 2: Bra]ov; 3: Bratei; 4: Bumbe]ti; 5:
Craiova; 6: Dej; 7: Feldioara-R`zboieni; 8: Lipova; 9: Moigrad: 10: P`latca; 11:
Periam; 12: Poian; 13: R`cari; 14: Re]ca; 15: Rotbav; 16: Snmicl`u]; 17:
Sighi]oara; 18: Turda.