Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1. Kindly make a position paper (make a stand) about Ferdinand Marcos' burial at Libingan ng
mga Bayani.
"Kung gusto mong ilibing siya (Ferdinand Marcos) doon (Libingan ng mga Bayani),
PWEDE, pero remember iba ang PWEDE sa DAPAT" just resigned Dr. Maria Serena I. Diokno
There are many reasons why I dissent and in a way condemn, the desicion or the
ruling of the Supreme Court to allow the burial of former Pres. Ferdinand Edralin Marcos at the
Libingan ng mga Bayani here are only some of the reasons why I choose to be against the
aforementioned;
research study entitled "Why Ferdinand Marcos should not be buried at the Libingan ng mga
Bayani" his medals of valor (awards given to honorary soldiers of the World War) and his said
military records were obtained and "fraught with myths, factual inconsistencies, and lies." as the
exemplifying the "Silver Star" medal which was inexistent when it was "said" to be awarded to
Major Marcos at that time because only the "Philippine Gold Cross" could equivalent to the
caption given to his said Silver Star award, also among all the declared 33 medals which Major
Marcos reported he was awarded with, only two medals were existent and could be given at the
time, the former Philippine Gold Cross and the US Distinguished Service Cross.
instated by Former President Corazon C. Aquino, Former Pres. Marcos stole staggering amounts
unrecovered wealth (ill- gotten), and 8 Million US Dollars worth of Jewelry hoard collectives.
Economics and renowned TV personality Prof. Winnie Monsod, analyzed the lies and debunked
the myths of the wide spreading "Marcos years was the Golden Age of the Philippines' Economic
History" that the growth rate of the Philippines before Marcos was 4.3% but when he stepped as
president it downed to 3.8% which posits a large difference, the wage rate of the Filipino Citizens
who are workers were before Marcos Years at an index of 100 but in 1974 downed to the index of
53.4, Another is income inequality where 60% of the people share 25% of the country's income
while the top 10% of the people had 41.4% of the whole country's income.
4. The UP School of Economics together with head researcher Prof. Winnie Monsod
also pointed out the Economic Crises of 1983 when the foreign debt of the Philippines ballooned
so large that it took 14 years after the Marcos dictatorship to pay back. She said that the legacy of
the Marcoses especially of Imelda, resulted to large debts of the country which we are still paying
at this point in time as each Filipino has a debt to the World Financial Institutions of an estimated
PHP 600.00 per Filipino Citizen or more. All the infrastructures which are said to be Marcos
Legacy were deemed National Debt (most of which mainly instigated by Former First Lady
Imelda Romualdez- Marcos assumed as nearing paradise using--- the true, the good, and the
beautiful) namely;
a. The Cultural Centre of the Philippines- instigated by Former First Lady Imelda Marcos
b. The Tanghalang Francisco Balagtas much known as the Folk Arts Theatre opened in
d. Makiling Centre of the Arts (National Arts Centre) opened in 1976 as well.
g. Hospitals: Philippine Heart Centre, Lung Centre of the Philippines, and the National
5. According to the Official Gazette of the Republic of the Philippines, there are
about 3,257 Filipino Citizens who were intentionally killed including Former Senator and threat to
the presidency Sen. Benigno "Ninoy" Aquino during the reign of Marcos and 737 official citizens
Marcos toppling over and condemning his former precedents legacy of Democracy as he
instigated Dictatorship as he lasted 20 years (electoral fraud also depicted) in office and his 9
years of dictator rule under the Proclamation 1081 which he instated on September 21, 1972
declaring Martial Law vested in him by the power of the 1935 Constitution which was rather
7. Truth was silenced as the Official Gazette of the Philippines narrates the story of
the regime closing down "292 Radio Stations, 66, Community Newspapers, 7 Major Daily
Newspapers, and 7 important TV Stations." This maybe the major reason why many people still
today were blinded of the said "Golden Years during the Marcos Era" because Pres. Marcos had
his own crew which regulated as he manipulated the contents of Mass Media showing only the
good points and achievements of the regime and manipulating in way of controlling or
brainwashing minds of Filipino Citizens to support him and his government. A very famous usage
of Anti- Marcos is Voltes V which was banned by Marcos because of its "threatening" contents
because apparently, the protagonists or the heroes in the show are toppling down villains which
he said may initiate a revolution if watched by the Citizens which was for him a cause to ban it
nationwide. All these restrictions caused uproar among other Filipino Citizens who were not in
content with the government's interference with media and their interference to deliver true news
to the people.
8. Greatest of all reasons why I dissent the Marcos Burial is due to the violation of
advocate of Human Rights studying focuses on Social Science, I look to this point as horrid,
According to the Official Gazette of the Republic of the Philippines there were listed
officially "75, 730 Victims of Human Rights Violations, 70, 000 Unwarranted Arrests (primarily due
to the Suspension of Habeas Corpus during Martial Law), and 34, 000 cases of torture." which
was a very dark part of the History of the Philippines as it was considered by many Political
thesis titled TORTYUR: Human Rights Violations During the Marcos Regime, it is a clear
historical research of the crimes committed during the Marcos Era, citing most of the gruesome
1. Electric Shock- electric wires attached to arms, fingers, legs, head, and commonly to
2. San Juanico Bridge- a torture title of the process of placing the body between to beds,
and if the body falls between, the victim would be beaten using clubs, wood, and other available
3. Truth Serum- which is adminstered at medical centres were injectibles used to make
4. Russian Roulette- a famous form of torture which is making the victim aim a gun at his/
her won head and pull the trigger to threaten. (may also fall on being an exemplification of mental
torture)
5. Beating- almost always used, punching, slapping, kicking, karate chops, fist blows, and
other methods though about as well as using torture instruments such as clubs, wood with nails,
6. Pistol whipping- being hit by the butts and the parts of guns most notably of rifles.
7. Water cure- personal favorites of most torture executors which primarily involves
forcive amounts of water pushed inside the victim's mouth and beating to be applied afterwards to
9. Cigar and Flat Iron burns- applied to lengthen the suffering of the victims using heat.
10. Pepper torture- concentrated large amounts of pepper to be placed in victims mouth
or genitalia
11. Animal treatment- the placing of the victims often blindfolded into cages complete with
metal leashes and/ or manacles (handcuffs) for long periods of time, because they were
handcuffed, they were forced to eat like dogs smothering food in their faces as the food were
placed in the iron grills of the cages, not knowing what they were eating because there were no
lights, not knowing as well, if they eat their own feces/ waste as it was mixed in with the food
12. Special Case of Military brutality- Peter Villaseor was brought to a camp in Bataan
where he was tortured for nine nights and nine days. While he was hung naked from the ceiling,
soldiers would flick his genitals and walis tambo was inserted into his urinary tract. Thumbtacks
were also inserted into his fingertips. Bayonets were placed in his elbows and his mouth. Naked,
he was made to sit on three blocks of ice. Electric shock was applied to his toe and his genitalia.
A stone was knocked repeatedly on his knees. While his head and stomach were beaten, water
They placed me in a box. I had only my brief and my t-shirt. I refused to eat
because I thought they were poisoning me. There was nothing in the room, barely
nothing. And I had nothing to do but twiddle my thumb, and for the first time in
my life I heard the ticking of every second, and I was counting every second into
minutes, and as the minutes marched into hours, and hours into days and days into
Sexual tortures were heavily carried at that time and were also quite widespread
which caused heavy blows of pain for victims who suffered it. Selected examples from the book of
Etta Rosales, a teacher at the Jos Rizal College, was brought to a safe house in
Pasig where she was tortured. She was stripped naked when she suffered the Russian Roulette,
electric shocks, strangulation, and candle burns. His torturers only stopped when she pretended
to be dying. Years later, one of her torturers, Lt. Rodolfo Aguinaldo, even became her colleague
Hilda Narciso was placed in a small room where she was raped. She was fed soup
of worms and rotten fish. She would be awoken right after falling asleep in order to be tortured
once more.Yung torture, mental torture, ang sakit. Tapos yung sexual abuse, mas lalo na,
dagdag yun. Physical torture baka sabihin ko pang mabuti pang pinukpok na ako ng pinukpok
kaysa nirapeako e. Currently, she was the executive director Claimants 1081, a group that filed
Lastly, I would like to depict serious cases that resulted to murder much called
genocide which are celebrated as heinous and inhuman in today's contemporary Philippines.
Maynila. In 1973, she was arrested, sexually molested and died in Camp Crame under
constabulary custody. The military claimed she committed suicide by drinking muriatic acid in a
mens bathroom. But the autopsy said otherwise. Her mouth became an ashtray full of cigarette
wounds. Her mother recounted how much Lilys body was maltreated: They cut her body up with
a saw up to her vagina, and they also cut her head. They took out her brain and stomach, tore
them into pieces like dinuguan, soaked them in muriatic acid and placed them in a pale and was
brought to the wake in that manner. During her funeral, there was heavy military presence. She
was 23, the first case of death under detention during Martial Law (Gualberto, 2007).
Dr. Juan "Johnny" Escandor is a cancer doctor from the University of the
Philippines Manila-Philippine General Hospital who organized the protest movement in Sorsogon
and joined the New Peoples Army. In 1983, the military claimed that they killed him in an
encounter in Bohol Ave. and Bayudan St. in Quezon City. But the residents said they did not hear
a single shot fired that night. He was last seen with Yolanda Gordula, who disappeared without a
trace. 52-days after burial, he was exhumed to be re-autopsied and the fact-finding team said he
was shot at closerange and not in a shoot-out and there was evidence of torture: They found his
skull filled with dirty rags, socks, briefs and plastic bags! His brains and other organs were all
placed inside his stomach! One of his eyes was missing, his head and bones severely broken,
and his body was filled with black marks of hematoma. Because of his commitment to the people,
In a BBC documentary, Sen. Pepe Diokno used the story of a young girl and
depicted raids that had happened in her village. Her mother covered her to protect her but when
the shooting stopped she was covered with her mothers blood and brains. She saw how her
brother was cut in half, another boy climbed a coconut tree when the raid happened and from it
he saw how her father was stopped by soldiers, they tied to his feet, and his head turned
sideways. Then they cut his head, played with it and pushed it with a stick to a coconut tree and
covered it with leaves. The boy wanted to avenge his fathers death, he said Even a small chick
can grow into a fighting rooster. This incident was known as the Las Navas Incident.
These teleserye- like events that are happening in contemporary society is really
something tainted with the dirty side of politics considering Duterte's own brand of justice which is
not universal in most ways but only concedes to his individual interest and recognition. It is
saddening to know that the Filipino Citizenry voted for a man who only sees himself as superior
deeming of course, to those who he has close ties with, pertaining especially to Sen. Bongbong
Marcos where he is like a sidekick, just following his orders and giving him all benefits because
Sen. Marcos was according to Duterte, the lead contributor for his success to grab the
Presidency.
I would not be surprised if Martial Law would be reinstated, observing the recent
phenomenon which is happening especially something called "Social Media Wars" where
intellectuals and so called 'trolls' argue over certain topics quite contemptuously as possible
because the trolls have their own understanding of societal events and concedes to everything
History often connotes appreciation, but I would like appreciation to grow into
application, the future is in the hands of the moulder, fortunately, I would be one of those who
would shape students, to surely convey truth and uphold the voices of those who needs to be
heard. Now, as a future educator as well as hoping to be an "Alagad ng Kasaysayan", I would like
to narrate the stories of the Human Rights Victims back then in the Marcos Regime and the
horrible effects of declaring Martial Law. I would like to present, because I was not yet alive in the
time of Martial Law (quite a familiar statement used by trolls nationwide), I would like to gather
and collect the first- hand stories of the experiences, the primary sources, of the people who lived
at that time, especially those who were victimized under the Marcos Dictatorship so that even so,
their stories would reach the future generations to come, for them wto hopefully learn to value the
most important thing, human life, for them to make correct and wise decisions especially when
election nears, for them to appreciate and apply the course of History so that they may not be
doomed to repeat dark history all over again, for them to develop Historical Thinking Skills, for
them to know when, where, and how to fight for what they might believe in, and lastly, for them to
be better citizens of the Philippines to promote development and progress of the entire country
through means of nation- building and love by speaking the truth and fighting for profound justice!
#NoToHistoricalRevisionism
I would like first to cite Paragraph 5 of Sec. 27 of Republic Act 10368 AN ACT
The Commission shall also coordinate and collaborate with the DepED and the
CHED to ensure that the teaching of Martial Law atrocities, the lives and sacrifices
of HRVVs in our history are included in the basic, secondary and tertiary education
curricula.
Citing this provision, supports that Martial Law during the Marcos regime should be
taught and studied among institutions of learning, considering primarily the relevance of
Education in the lenses of History, but the teacher must also be filled with facts and realities as
the teacher should have conducted "research" and equipped Historical Thinking Skills to teach
The impact here, where I believe most matter is in Education, because it is a basic
building block of life, where the students learn things and ideas mostly from the significant
person- - Teacher and prolong or sustain the knowledge gained and carry out the knowledge the
rest of his/ her life because it is the lesson of the teacher. If the student develops a wrong notion
of History, he may be doomed to repeat it, or worse, influence others to develop the wrong notion
using ways that we could not even imagine, as one wrong lesson in History, the future may be at
stake.
(The Butterfly Effect- where one small cause could produce massive effects
If, Education would fail, the next target on impact would be the economy. The
Marcos Era shown lots of failure in economic policy and a low score on GDP- GNP rates, there
was a national recession for almost two decades, (Philippine Statistical Association) but since the
Marcoses controlled the television and mass media sources, this was not known to many. The
Philippines was called the sick man of Asia, as the Philippines' neighbouring countries are
undergoing its climactic economic boom, the Philippines was stagnant, the economy did not
develop especially because of ballooning foreign debt aforesaid. Lastly, although jobs were
increasing because of the many illustrious and extravagant buildings that Former First Lady
Imelda Marcos instigated, wages were not sufficient, and income inequality was also widespread.
The last target on impact would be politics. Politicking in the Philippines is very
evident in today's administration as what was further discussed to be Sen. Bongbong Marcos'
affiliation towards Rodrigo Duterte and their indirect opposition to topple down the current Vice
President Leni Robredo who receives mixed reviews as of today. Politicking was observed in the
last 2016 elections in a way that Duterte symbolizes a misogynistic, authoritarian, and a dictator-
look and appeals especially on what he says or does. Politicking was observed as well, in the
indirect campaigning of Duterte- Marcos. And lastly, politicking was now greatly observed and
seemingly opposed with the latest issue of Duterte allowing Ferdinand Marcos to be buried at the
Libingan ng mga Bayani complete with flower delivery, military rights, and offense to the people
of the Philippines especially to the Human Rights Victims of the Martial Law Era.
Was there really development during the Martial Law Era under the Marcos Regime?
3. Make a comment on the Supreme Court's ruling. Cite applicable laws if there's any. Will you
"National healing cannot simply come when the President pronounces it, It can only
come through a process that leads to social justice. Justice does not come with just forgetting."
disagree with the Supreme Court ruling using also of course, laws as well cited by the 5
Dissenting Supreme Court Judges against the Burial of Former President Ferdinand Marcos at
I would like to cite Section 1 of Republic Act 289 AN ACT PROVIDING FOR THE
To perpetuate the memory of all the Presidents of the Philippines, national heroes
and patriots for the inspiration and emulation of this generation and of generations
still unborn, there shall be constructed a National Pantheon which shall be the burial
Citing this provision, I would likely emphasize the underlined clause, which although
this law was the basis of the Libingan ng mga Bayani's construction, it clearly provides on the
underlined clause that those who are to be buried at the Libingan ng mga Bayani must be an
inspiration and emulation for the generation today, as well as future generations to come. My
previous answers for the first 2 questions, I think would suffice as explanations on why the
Former President Marcos could not be a source of inspiration or emulation of the Filipino
Citizenry.
Secondly, I would cite Section 7 from Republic Act 10368 AN ACT PROVIDING
The amount of Ten billion pesos (P10,000,000,000.00) plus accrued interest which
form part of the funds transferred to the government of the Republic of the
Philippines by virtue of the December 10, 1997 Order of the Swiss Federal Supreme
Court, adjudged by the Supreme Court of the Philippines as final and executory in
Republic vs. Sandiganbayan on July 15, 2003 (G.R. No. 152154) as Marcos
ill-gotten wealth and forfeited in favor of the Republic of the Philippines, shall be the
Firstly, considering that a RA 10368 was approved, the law recognizes that heinous
crimes and terrible atrocities were made during the Marcos regime which states the fact criminal
cases were applied, but a loophole to this maybe that Pres. Marcos was not the one who
committed the crimes directly because he only ordered the Philippine Constabulary or other
Secondly, amount of 10 Billion pesos was stated in law as ill- gotten which is quite
questionable on why the former president according to law, did not commit any criminal or
derogatory offenses provided thereby the penal code, even if the law already stated that the
Lastly, I would cite last paragraph from AFP Regulations G 161- 375 CATEGORIES
In the AFP Regulations, these two categories are not qualified to be interred at the
discharged from the service; and authorized personnel who were convicted by final
Associate Justice Marvic Leonen pointed out that Ferdinand Marcos fits the 2
disqualifications of a person to be buried at the Libingan ng mga Bayani, which I also believe--
Ferdinand Marcos was dishonourably discharged by the people of the Philippines during the
succesful 1986 People Power revolution led by his ouster Former President Corazon C. Aquino
and-- as Republic Act 10368 was made into law, he reiterated according to the aforecited "moral
and legal obligation of the state to recognize the sufferings of the human rights victims." and so,
inflicting that Pres. Marcos offended involving moral turpitude as he ordered murder and
Bibliography:
Aquino, Benigno S. (1984). Testaments from a prison cell. Makati City, Philippines: Benigno
Chua, Michael Charleston Xiao. (2012). TORTYUR: Human Rights Violations During The
Diokno, Jose W. (1983). To sing our own song. British Broadcasting System (BBC)
Gualberto, Alice H. (2007). Liliosa R. Hilao, her life and martyrdoma potential Philippine
leader
Magsaysay, Jing. (1999). The correspondents. Quezon City, ABS CBN News and Current
Affairs
National Historical Commission of the Philippines. (2016). Why Ferdinand Marcos should not
Uson, Mocha. (2016). Madaming Nagawa ang mga Marcos. Retrieved through Mocha Uson
Blog at www.facebook.com