Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
COMPROMISE
Amicable settlement of differences by mutual
concession by the parties to dispute or difference by
agreeing not to try it out. In,
[Mercantile Investment & General Trust Co. v. International Co. of Mexico]
[1893] 1Ch.484 & In re N.F.U Development Trust Ltd. [1971] 1 WLR
1548- {It has been held that compromise pre-supposes existence of a
dispute}.
[Dani Chand & co. v. Narain Das & Co.] (1947) 7 Comp. Cas. 195 F.B-
{For compromise it is essential that each party should be empowered
to make necessary concessions (adjustments)}.
ARRANGEMENT
Explanation to S.230 [2013 Act] & [S.390 (b) 1956 Act] - provides that the expression
arrangement includes a reorganisation of share capital of the company by
(combining) i.e. consolidation of shares of different classes (merger/amalgamation)
or by the division of shares (demerger) of different classes or by both the methods.
More wider than compromise. It includes arrangements which modify rights about
which there is no dispute.
Demerger or Merger have not been defined in the Companies Act. Thus, though
[S.230 Exp.] does not mention about demerger word directly but talks about
division of shares of different class which implies Demerger.
When a Co. has a dispute with a member or class of members or with a creditor or a
class of them, a scheme of compromise may be drawn up, but where there is no
dispute but there is a need of readjusting the rights or liabilities of a member or a
class of them or of a creditor or class of them, the Co. may resort to a scheme
arrangement with them.
COMPROMISE
ARRANGEMENT - DIFFERENCE
COMPROMISE ARRANGEMENT
When a Co. has a dispute with a Where there is no dispute but there
member or class of members or is a need of readjusting the rights or
with a creditor or a class of them, a liabilities of a member or a class of
scheme of compromise may be them or of a creditor or class of
drawn up. them, or to reorganise the share
capital of the Co. ; the Co. may
resort to a scheme of arrangement
with them.
CORPORATE RECONSTRUCTION
Restructuring as per Oxford dictionary means to give a new structure to, rebuild or
rearrange". As per Collins English dictionary, meaning of corporate restructuring is a
change in the business strategy of an organization.
Corporate restructuring is defined as the process involved in changing the organization of
a business. It implies rearranging the business for increased efficiency and profitability.
In other words, it is a comprehensive process, by which a company can consolidate its
business operations and strengthen its position for achieving corporate objectives-synergies
and continuing as competitive and successful entity.
Demerger not defined in 1956/2013 Act but Explanation to S.390 (1956) &230 of
2013Act talk about division of shares. It has been defined in 2(19AA) of IT Act,1961.
Demerger - Arrangement where some part of one Co. is transferred to another Co.
which operates separately from Original Company. The corporation is split into parts
for purpose of different operations or different line of business.
It is a business strategy in which a single business is broken into components, either
to operate on their own, to be sold or to be dissolved.
The Co. from which the undertaking, assets and liabilities are transferred is the
Transferor Co. or the Demerged Co. and the Company to which it is transferred is
the Transferee or the Resulting Co.
The shareholders may be given shares in the resulting Co. or consideration.
Generally, the gains arising from a demerger are exempt from capital gains tax, while
those arising from a slump sale are not. [Section 47 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 under
subsection (vid)]. One of the benefits associated with demerger .
CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
METHODS
SLUMP SALE
A slump sale is defined in Section 2(42C) of the IT Act,1961 and not in the Companies Act.
It means the transfer of one or more undertakings as a result of the sale for a lump-sum
consideration without values being assigned to independent assets and liabilities.
Suppose Co. ABC has three assets having value- A (of Rs. 10) , B (of Rs. 20) and C (of Rs. 30)
and it decides to sell these assets to Co. PQR for a lump sum consideration of Rs. 40 instead
of Rs. 60 (actual value when independent values are assigned to these assets) then it is a
slump sale.
AMALGAMATION
Amalgamation is defined in Section 2(1B) of the IT Act,1961 and not in the Companies Act.
It means - two or more existing companies amalgamate and a new company is formed. As
such all existing companies amalgamating Co. disappears and a new company comes into
the existence.
Amalgamation is an arrangement, whereby the assets and liabilities of two or more
companies become vested in another company (which may or may not be one of the
original companies) and which would have as its shareholders substantially, all the
shareholders of the amalgamating companies.
CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
METHODS
JOINT VENTURES
Joint ventures are new enterprises owned by two or more participants. They are
typically formed for special purposes for a limited duration.
It is a combination of subsets of assets contributed by two (or more) business
entities for a specific business purpose and a limited duration. Each of the
venture partners continues to exist as a separate firm, and the joint venture
represents a new business enterprise.
It is a contract to work together for a period of time each participant expects to
gain from the activity but also must make a contribution.
E.g.: -DCM group and Daewoo motors entered in to JV to form DCM
DAEWOO Ltd. to manufacture automobiles in India.
Section 2(6) of the Companies Act,2013 includes a Joint Venture Company in
the definition of associate company.
CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
METHODS
Technically , no difference between the two terms - used interchangeably.
TAKEOVER ACQUISITION
Certain thresholds are prescribed for takeover A corporate action in which a company buys
under the Takeover Regulations,2011. most, if not all, of the target company's
ownership, stakes in order to assume control
Usually takeover is a hostile act in which an of the target firm. Acquisitions are often made
Acquirer alone or acting with Persons in as part of a company's growth strategy
Concert (PAC) acquires or agrees to acquire whereby it is more beneficial to take over an
voting rights , shares or control in the target existing firm's operations and niche compared
Company. to expanding on its own. Acquisitions are
often paid in cash, the acquiring company's
Shareholders are not given shares in the new stock or a combination of both.
company but paid consideration according to
an exit price. Usually if 50 percent or more stakes is gained
it may be said that the Co. has been acquired
and control can be exercised.
CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
METHODS
MERGER
Combining of two or more companies whereby the identity of one or more is
lost and the result is a single enterprise. One company is taken over by the
other company and only the company taking over remains in existence.
Merger is restricted to a case where the assets and liabilities of the companies
get vested in another company, the company which is merged losing its
identity and its shareholders becoming shareholders of the other company.
There is mutual benefit that the merging companies realise in getting merged;
usually done by businesses in the same line to increase productivity, efficiency,
to achieve synergy and to diversify and may be to further some common
objective.
Explanation to S.232(8) talks about two kinds of Merger:
Merger by Absorption and
Merger by Formation of a New Company.
CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
METHODS
MERGER BY MERGER BY
ABSORPTION FORMATION OF A NEW
COMPANY
Undertaking, property and liabilities of one or more Undertaking, property and liabilities of one or more
companies , including the company in respect of companies , including the company in respect of
which the compromise or arrangement is proposed which the compromise or arrangement is proposed
are to be transferred to another existing company. are to be transferred to a new company.
Example : If merging Companies are A,B,C then in Example: If merging Companies are A,B,C then in
merger by absorption; the equation will be A+B+C = merger by formation of a new company; the equation
A/B/C where A or B or C will remain in the end as will be A+B+C = D or ABC where D or ABC is he new
the final company in merger. If it is Company A it will company and not any of the existing companies that
absorb (B+C in itself) , if B (then A+C) and if C ( then mergerd.
A+B).