Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
People with neck pain may demonstrate other alterations in
sensorimotor function in addition to changes in muscle
activation (Chapter 4). These alterations include changes in
eye movement control, reduced proprioceptive acuity, and
disturbed balance. Understanding how and why cervical
spine disorders can influence such sensorimotor control, as
well as being able to quantify impairments, provides direction
for precise assessment and interventions for people with
neck pain. Thus the mechanisms associated with disturbed
cervical somatosensory input to the sensorimotor control
system will first be reviewed. The impairments in sen-
sorimotor control that may present in patients with neck pain
will then be discussed (Chapter 6).
Afferent information from the vestibular, visual, and
somatosensory systems converges in multiple areas within
the central nervous system and is important for general
equilibrium, body orientation, and oculomotor control. The
abundance of mechanoreceptors in the muscles and joints of
the cervical spine and the central and reflex connections from
cervical afferents to the vestibular, visual, and postural
control systems suggests that cervical proprioceptive
information provides important somatosensory information,
influencing postural stability, head orientation, and eye
movement control.1 Abnormal afferent input from the
vestibular, visual, or somatosensory systems can result in
abnormal sensorimotor control. The resulting mismatch,
which may occur in the presence of conflicting afferent
information, is thought to underlie symptoms of dizziness or
60 Whiplash, Headache, and Neck Pain
&HUHEUDOFRUWH[
+\SRWKDODPXV
7KDODPXV
5HWLFXODUIRUPDWLRQ
6XSHULRUFROOLFXOXV
0HGLDODQGODWHUDOYHVWLEXODUQXFOHL
&HQWUDOFHUYLFDOQXFOHXV
'RUVDOFROXPQQXFOHL
6SLQRWKDODPLF
6SLQRFHUHEHOODU &HUHEHOOXP
3URSULRVSLQDOWUDFWV
9HQWUDO
&HUYLFDODIIHUHQWV
GRUVDOKRUQ
mechanoreceptors in the deep neck and visual reflexes acting on the neck
muscles.30 In addition, many descending musculature, for coordinated stability of
systems, which have been implicated in the posture as well as head and eye control
control of head movement, have dense (Figure 5.2).
projections into the C1 and C2 segments,
which contain the motor neurons for the Head position
deep suboccipital muscles. It has also been The CCR causes activation of neck muscles
shown in the cat that motor neurons of neck when they are stretched with movement of
muscles have their own characteristic the head in relation to the body. The CCR is
patterns of input from the six semicircular integrated with the vestibulocollic reflex
canals of the vestibular apparatus. (VCR) to activate neck muscles to assist in the
Interestingly, the obliquus capitis inferior maintenance of head position and limit
muscle has a different pattern to the rectus unintentional displacements of the head.1, 5
capitis major and minor and mutifidus The CCR has a high sensitivity to small
muscles.33 This may translate to functional stimuli and a lower sensitivity for larger
differences between these muscles in neck rotations, which suggests that muscle
humans where different morphological spindles rather than joint receptors provide
characteristics have been shown to exist. the major input to the CCR. More specifically,
responses have been demonstrated in the
obliquus capitis inferior, the rectus capitis
Reflex-mediated activity posterior major, and splenius muscles when
Synaptic connections from the cervical the CCR has been elicited during rotation of
receptors to other areas of the central nervous the body with the head held fixed. Chan
system play an important role in neck reflex et al.34 in their feline study confirmed the role
activity. Neck afferents are involved in of the perivertebral muscles in evoking the
reflexes which influence head orientation, CCR. The VCR, which is evoked by vestibular
eye movement control, and postural stability, stimuli acting on the neck muscles, is also
namely, the cervicocollic reflex (CCR), the related to the movement of the head in space
cervico-ocular reflex (COR), and the tonic together with the CCR. The behavior of the
neck reflex (TNR). These reflexes work in VCR is similar to that of the CCR, but it occurs
conjunction with other cervical, vestibular, in response to faster neck movements.1, 5
925
9HVWLEXODUDIIHUHQWV
2.5
9&5
&25 &&5
2FXODUPRWRU &HUYLFDODIIHUHQWV &HUYLFDOPRWRU
715
/RZHUOLPEPRWRU
Figure 5.2 Sensorimotor control reflex activity relating to the cervical spine. VOR, vestibulo-ocular reflex; VCR, vestibulocollic reflex;
COR, cervico-ocular reflex; CCR, cervicocollic reflex; OKR, optokinetic reflex; TNR, tonic neck reflex. The bold lines indicate the cervical
afferent effects. Dashed lines indicate reflex activity relating to cervical motor afferents.
CHAPTER
The Cervical Spine and Sensorimotor Control 63
sway in standing than vibration of other also some evidence that the neck may
areas, such as the gluteal, hamstrings, tibialis directly influence vestibular function. For
anterior, abdominal, or lumbar muscles.50, 51 example, stimulation of the deep neck
Neck muscle vibration also influences the mechanoreceptors has a measurable impact
velocity and direction of gait.52, 53 Similarly, on the VOR in cats.62 Altered cervical
Karlberg et al.54 showed that restraining proprioceptive input may give rise to a
cervical mobility (wearing a restrictive brace mismatch of sensory input or an asymmetry
for 5 days) resulted in altered eye move- to the VOR.63 In people with neck pain,
ment control and increased postural sway, altered cervical proprioceptive input
reflecting a consequence of decreased may cause an asymmetry of the VOR,29, 64
cervical somatosensory input. Sustained which may explain some of the reported
isometric contractions to neck muscle fatigue symptoms such as dizziness and
were shown to affect postural sway, gait, unsteadiness. Thus management may need
and head position awareness in healthy to address both the cervical spine’s primary
persons.55–60 and secondary influences on the postural
There is some evidence to suggest that the control system.
deeper structures of the cervical spine have Either a decrease or increase of cervical
a greater role in reflex connections with the somatosensory input may result in altered
visual and vestibular systems. TNRs in the sensorimotor control. Anesthetizing cervical
cat were abolished by cutting the nerve structures reduces somatosensory input
supply to deep intervertebral tissues but yet produces symptoms of ataxia, visual
were not abolished with removal of the large disturbances, and disequilibrium.45 Likewise,
dorsal muscles.61 Similarly, sensory input to increasing the activity of cervical
the deeper region of the vertebrae changed mechanoreceptors by applying low-
the VOR in cats whereas input to the large frequency pulse stimulation has been shown
dorsal muscles had no effect.62 to increase disequilibrium of the eyes and
body. Hinoki and Niki65 also found that,
when a procaine solution, known to interrupt
Mechanisms underlying gamma fibers, was injected into deep
disturbances in muscles of the upper neck in people with
sensorimotor control whiplash-associated disorders, it often led
to an improvement in their disequilibrium
The likely mechanism for disturbances in and pain, which suggests that an overactivity
postural control and eye movement control of the muscle spindles was contributing to
in people with neck pain is a conflict between their symptoms.
converging inputs from the different sen- Overactivity of cervical sympathetic nerves
sory systems due to alterations in cervical may cause an abnormal increase in neck
somatosensory afferent activity.2 Informa- muscle spindle activity.29 However, it has also
tion from the muscle spindles is of primary been found that activation of the sympathetic
importance for cervical proprioceptive nervous system leads to a profound inhibition
acuity and this information is combined of muscle spindle afferents.11, 32
with input from the vestibular and visual It has been postulated that, in trauma-
systems. A changed or disturbed sensitivity induced neck pain, the injury may initiate a
of the muscle spindles may result in one or perpetual cycle of incorrect somatosensory
more complaints of dizziness, disturbance afferent information.66, 67 The proposed
of sense of head movement, eye–head mechanism is that a sudden barrage of
coordination, or postural stability. There is abnormal input from cervical proprioceptors
CHAPTER
The Cervical Spine and Sensorimotor Control 65
and nociceptors, particularly following Figure 5.3). These include direct damage to the
the deceleration phase of a whiplash injury, mechanoreceptors from trauma, which could
results in incorrect somatosensory affect proprioceptive functioning and motor
information. This is followed by control, leading to a functional impairment of
compensatory muscle tension to prevent the the cervical mechanoreceptors.3 Morphological
person from falling. In turn this leads to changes of the neck muscles have been
further altered cervical somatosensory documented in persons with neck pain,23, 68, 69
information, which perpetuates the cycle. which could affect their proprioceptive
The cycle may be augmented from the effects capability. In addition, pain and inflammation
of pain and inflammation from damaged may alter cervical mechanoreceptor function
neck structures. at the spinal level as well as influence the
In summary, there is evidence to suggest central nervous system’s modulation of
that disturbances in sensorimotor control cervical somatosensory information. There are
may result from either a decrease or increase also suggestions that stress and subsequent
in cervical somatosensory afferent activity. sympathetic nervous system activation may
be a factor in the modulation of cervical
somatosensory information.
Possible causes of altered
cervical somatosensory Effects of trauma and changes
input in muscle function
There are several possible causes of altered Trauma to cervical structures at the time of
cervical somatosensory input that could injury, inflammation, ischemia, excessive joint
lead to disturbances in postural stability loading, or stretching can either directly
and eye movement control (Table 5.1 and injure nerve terminals or cause abnormal
Table 5.1 Processes other than pain which may have deleterious effects on muscle spindle function
Cause Mechanism
71, 95
Mechanical disruption Direct damage
Excessive joint loading70, 96 Direct damage/functional impairment
74, 75
Facet joint stretch Direct damage
Muscle damage97 Direct damage/functional impairment
Local ischemia73 Direct damage
Joint inflammation 72 98 Direct damage/functional impairment
Altered protective muscle responses83 Functional impairment
99
Inhibition of deep musculature Functional impairment
Altered feedforward neuromuscular control100 Functional impairment
Increased superficial muscle activity101, 102 Functional impairment
Altered neuromuscular efficiency103 Functional impairment
104
Muscle fatigue Functional impairment
Muscle fiber transformations78 Morphological change
Fatty infiltration into muscle68, 105 Morphological change
Muscle atrophy (reduced cross-sectional area) Morphological change
Enhanced sympathetic nervous system activation11, 32 Functional impairment
66 Whiplash, Headache, and Neck Pain
6HQVRULPRWRUFRQWURO
GLVWXUEDQFHV &16
5HSUHVHQWDWLRQFRUWH[
$OWHUHGDIIHUHQWLQWHJUDWLRQ 6RPDWLFUHRUJDQL]DWLRQ
DQGWXQLQJ
$OWHUHGPHFKDQRUHFHSWRU
3DLQLQIODPPDWLRQ
'LUHFWGDPDJH
7UDXPD )XQFWLRQDOLPSDLUPHQW
0RUSKRORJLFDOFKDQJHV 616DFWLYDWLRQ
0XVFOHVSLQGOHVHQVLWLYLW\
6WUHVV
Figure 5.3 Impact of somatosensory dysfunction in the cervical spine on sensorimotor control. Several peripheral mechanisms can
alter mechanoreceptor function and cervical somatosensory input to the sensorimotor control system. Such changes can also alter the
central nervous system (CNS) processing and subsequent descending information to the periphery. This can further contribute to altered
somatosensory input. Visual and vestibular input to the sensorimotor control system can also be affected indirectly by altered cervical
mechanoreceptor function. SNS, sympathetic nervous system.
spinal cord and during the supraspinal several studies in cats have demonstrated
control and evaluation of cervical experimentally induced, long-lasting
somatosensory information (Figure 5.4). At increased activity in the gamma muscle
the local level, an increase in nociceptor spindle system following excitation of
input occurs as a result of chemical mediators chemosensitive afferents in and around the
released in response to injury. This may cervical joint complex.7, 8, 87, 88 Interestingly,
cause temporary peripheral sensitization, in lower doses of bradykinin were needed to
which normally high thresholds of receptors evoke responses from the fusimotor neurons
are lowered and spontaneous receptor in neck muscles compared to hind-limb
activity is increased. Painful responses can muscles, suggesting that the neck muscles
occur to nonnoxious stimuli such as light may be more sensitive to pain.8, 87, 88 These
touch.80, 81 It has also been speculated that long-lasting and extensive changes in muscle
generation of pain from mechanoreceptors spindle activation in superficial muscles
that normally only generate innocuous of the cervical region in response to pain
responses may result in an increase in would certainly lead to altered cervical
nociceptive input and also a decrease in somatosensory input.89, 90
nonnociceptive input, which might also Pain has also been shown to alter spinal
disturb somatosensory input for inhibition via effects on the somatosensory
sensorimotor control.81 cortex and subcortical levels in humans.
In chronic pain, mechanoreceptors may Tonic muscle pain caused a long-lasting
continue to be sensitive to noxious stimuli, depression of the primary motor area in the
due to changes in the central nervous system contralateral cerebral cortex in humans.10
and decreased central inhibition.80 Sensitivity The effects lasted several hours, even after
following a neck injury often occurs at the pain had ceased. Further, Rossi et al.91
regions both local and remote to the original demonstrated that tonic muscle pain
injury82 and is a feature in many patients discharge strongly interacted with
with chronic whiplash disorders (Chapter nonnociceptive input arising from the same
2).76, 80, 82 Chronic sensitivity may further site and it altered proprioception. It was
prolong disruption of somatosensory input suggested that this was due to a gating of
from the cervical region. input at the cortical or precortical level.
Experimentally induced pain has been There is also evidence to suggest a possible
shown to change muscle activity,10, 83, 84 role of pain in subcortical and cortical
including reflex activity85, 86 and muscle reorganization at many levels of the
spindle sensitivity. In the cervical region somatosensory system in humans. The
Muscle inhibition
Muscle spindle sensitivity Nociceptor input Nonnociceptor input?
EMG activity?
References
1. Peterson BW. Current approaches and future 6. Revel M, Andre-Deshays C, Minguet M.
directions to understanding control of head Cervicocephalic kinesthetic sensibility in patients
movement. Brain mechanisms for the integration of with cervical pain. Arch Phys Med Rehabil
posture and movement. Prog Brain Res 1991;72:288–291.
2004;143:369–381. 7. Thunberg J, Hellstrom F, Solander P, et al.
2. Baloh R, Halmagyi G. Disorders of the Vestibular Influences on the fusimotor-muscle spindle system
System. New York: Oxford University Press, 1996. from chemosensitive nerve endings in the cervical
3. Heikkila H, Astrom PG. Cervicocephalic kinesthetic facet joints in the cat; possible implications for
sensibility in patients with whiplash injury. Scand J whiplash induced disorders. Pain 2001;91:15–22.
Rehabil Med 1996;28:133–138. 8. Wenngren B, Pedersen J, Sjolander P, et al.
4. Karlberg M, Johansson R, Magnusson M, et al. Bradykinin and muscle stretch alter contralateral
Dizziness of suspected cervical origin distinguished cat neck muscle spindle output. Neurosci Res
by posturographic assessment of human postural 1998;32:119–129.
dynamics. J Vestibul Res Equil 1996;6:37–47. 9. Ageborg E. Consequences of a ligament injury on
5. Peterson B, Goldberg J, Bilotto G, et al. neuromuscular function and relevance to
Cervicocollic reflex: its dynamic properties and rehabilitation – using the anterior cruciate ligament-
interaction with vestibular reflexes. J Neurophysiol injured knee as a model. J Electromyogr Kinesiol
1985;54:90–108. 2002;12:205–212.