Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
*CETI/Athena Research & Innovation Centre, 58 Tsimiski St., Xanthi, 67100, Greece,
(Tel: +30-25410-78787; email: {chrisem, npapatha, pistofid}@ceti.gr)
** University of Portsmouth Business School, Portsmouth, UK (Tel: +44-2392844729, email: ashraf.labib@portsmouth.ac.uk)
Abstract: The Maintenance Management profession requires a truly multidisciplinary set of skills.
Higher education courses do not offer the necessary body of knowledge in a single course. Maintenance
engineering training is offered by some postgraduate & vocational training courses. These often target
specialized aspects of Maintenance skills. An important hurdle is that target groups are in most cases
professionals who have already entered their working life. Due to their professional engagements, such
user groups are under significant time and location constraints, often preventing them from attending a
professional training course. E-Training is a viable, flexible and cost-efficient alternative for delivering
Maintenance Management training. We report on the development of such an e-learning system, namely
iLearn2Main. The main design considerations are briefly discussed, as well as its structure and key
features, including a tool for automated competence assessment. A key focus in this work is to present
results from pilot testing the system with different user groups. Some of the key findings of the user
survey are outlined. It has been particularly encouraging to find evidence of practically uniform
acceptance of e-learning technologies as a means of delivering maintenance management training.
Among the survey findings are useful directions for further system enhancement and enrichment.
Keywords: Maintenance Engineering, Maintenance Management, Educational Technology, Maintenance
Training, e-Learning, Self- Assessment, Learning Management Systems, Engineering Education
The difference could be because trainers are in most cases 4.5 Additional evaluation comments
more knowledgeable about the training subjects and therefore
more demanding. The courses that one can distinguish a There have been many additional comments in ‘free text
much higher satisfaction rate among the trainees, compared format’, ie comments addressing aspects of the training
to the trainers, are (in descending order): content for particular courses, or e-learning-specific issues.
These have been particularly useful for improving fine details trainers and trainees. User testing provided useful knowledge
of both the e-learning and the training content. Sometimes about adoption prospects and pointers for further
comments where received that may reflect the particular improvements. A key finding was that the usage of e-learning
viewpoint taken but a specific user and not necessarily shared technologies appeared to be uniformly accepted by all user
by other users. One common request from all end users is groups. This justifies further investment into the direction of
their wish to see more visual features, ie more figures, tables enriching the e-learning content, by adding more practical
and even possible audio, video and animation. Of course the examples and case studies, preferably in multimedia format.
addition of multimedia-rich content would strengthen the
ACKNOWLEDMENTS
appeal of the courses and will engage the learners more in the
training process. However, this is a more costly development
process that requires resources that were not available, during The authors wish to acknowledge the contribution of Maria
the development stage. The partnership is fully aware of the Dontsiou, Cosmas Vamvalis and George Efremidis
great benefits of adding such multimedia content and is (ATLANTIS Engineering) for their contribution to the
training content and piloting, to Jan Franlund, chairman of
looking at opportunities to enhance the training content in
this way. Another common request was to see more practical the Swedish Maintenance Society for his deep insight into the
examples and case studies. Users generally agreed that the training needs and requirements, and his contribution to the
system was easy to use and navigate. It should be mentioned training content, as well as to Laila Elina and Mirabela
that although an animation demo and a user manual were Borcos from the Latvia Technology Park and the Romanian
available, they were not provided to the users and yet they Association of Small to Medium Enterprises respectively, for
did not have any difficulty using the system. This is a strong their contribution towards the piloting of the project results.
evidence in practice that the system is user friendly, easy to The financial support received through the UK Leonardo
use and navigate. On the other hand there was conflicting Agency, ECOTEC (contract UK/07/LLP-LdV/TOI-004,
feedback too. Some users wish to see a more thorough project iLearn2Main) is gratefully acknowledged.
coverage of the courses topics, while some other believe that
for many of the courses too many details and advanced topics REFERENCES
are covered, which are not necessarily mandatory in such a Bakouros, Y., and Panagiotidou, S. (2008). An analysis of
training course. One issue that appeared to cause difficulties maintenance education and training needs in European
to the users is the extensive use of abbreviations. Such an SMEs and an IT platform enriching maintenance
issue is best dealt with by a proper list of abbreviations and curricula with industrial expertise. Proc. of CM-MFPT
an adequate glossary. After the trial, the individual course 2008, 15-18 July 2008, Edinburgh, UK.
glossaries have been replaced by a global glossary, which can Emmanouilidis, C. (2009). Upskilling via Maintenance e-
be considered as addressing this specific issue. Not all Training. MaintWorld Journal, 1, 46-49
courses had the same length. This also caused some Emmanouilidis, C., Labib, A., Franlund, F., Dontsiou, M.,
confusion to the users, as they did not have an indication Elina, L., and Borcos, M., (2009). iLearn2Main: an e-
about how far they progressed with the course and how much Learning System for Maintenance Management
was still to study. A lesson progress bar was needed. It was Training. Proc. of WCEAM 2009, 28-30 September
found the native moodle features were too buggy and 2009, Athens, Greece.
unstable to serve this request. However, as moodle is an open Franlund, J. (2008). Some European Initiatives in
source LMS, it was possible to add code, thus extending Requirements of Competence in Maintenance. Proc. of
moodle’s features to address this need. CM-MFPT 2008, 15-18 July 2008, Edinburgh, UK.
6. CONCLUSION Haritos, T., and Macchiarella, D. (2005). A mobile
application of augmented reality for aerospace
This paper presented an e-Learning system for Maintenance maintenance training. The 24th Digital Avionics Systems
Management training and e-competence assessment. It has Conference, Washington, DC.
been argued that the use of e-learning technology is very Li, J. R., Khoo, L. P., and Tor, S. B. (2003). Desktop virtual
appropriate in this application domain. As maintenance reality for maintenance training: an object oriented
management training is not usually part of formal education, prototype system (V-REALISM). Computers in Industry,
it falls mostly under the realm of vocational education and 52(2). pp. 109 - 125.
training. End users who receive such training are in most Nakajima, C., and Itho, N. (2003). A Support System for
cases professionals who have little flexibility to enter a Maintenance Training by Augmented Reality. Proc. of
conventional course, due to constraints posed by their job ICIAP’03, Mantova, Italy, pp. 158-163.
function. The use of e-learning enables them to enter a Roe, S. (2003). Condition monitoring and certification of
vocational training e-course at the time, the location and pace personnel in the UK. Insight, 45, pp. 764-765.
of their choice. Furthermore, employing e-tools for Starr, A., and Bevis, K. (2009). The role of education and
knowledge assessment can streamline the assessment of training in industrial maintenance: the pathway to a
competences, thus leading to a more transparent procedure sustainable future. Proc. of WCEAM 2009, 28-30
for skills recognition, which is of great usefulness for September 2009, Athens, Greece.
personnel mobility and human capital recruitment and
management. The system has been pilot tested by different
user groups. These included industrialists and academics,