Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
EXHIBIT A
012321405 Case 5:17-cv-07303 67Document
89
7ÿ7
97
1-1
8
ÿ
ÿ7Filed
712/26/17
ÿ
7ÿÿ6
Page 2 of 142
#$%&'$ÿ$'&$')'*+,+-%*ÿ-*ÿ+$,.'/,$0
/,++'$)
1-2-*3ÿ,ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ5-+6ÿ+6'ÿ7*-+'.ÿ8+,+')ÿ#,+'*+ÿ,*.ÿ9$,.'/,$0ÿ:;;-4'ÿ<78#9:=ÿ)+,$+)ÿ,ÿ2'3,2ÿ&$%4''.-*3ÿ+6,+ÿ-)
3%>'$*'.ÿ?@ÿ7A8Aÿ2,5AÿÿC6-2'ÿ,*ÿ,&&2-4,*+ÿ/,@ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ-+)'2;ÿ-*ÿ+6-)ÿ2'3,2ÿ&$%4''.-*3Dÿ5'ÿ)+$%*32@ÿ$'4%//'*.ÿ+6,+
;%$'-3*ÿ,&&2-4,*+)Dÿ,*.ÿ,*@ÿ,&&2-4,*+)ÿ56%ÿ,$'ÿE*;,/-2-,$ÿ5-+6ÿ+6'ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ&$%4'))Dÿ6-$'ÿ,*ÿ,++%$*'@ÿ5-+6
'F&'$+-)'ÿ-*ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ/,++'$)ÿ+%ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ+6'/ÿ,*.ÿ&$%>-.'ÿ2'3,2ÿ,.>-4'Aÿ
GHIÿKLÿMNOPKQQNRÿQIÿONMONLNSQÿTIUÿKSÿVÿQOVRNPVOWÿPVQQNOÿXNYIONÿQHNÿZ[\]^_ÿLU`HÿVLÿV
QOVRNPVOWÿVMMaK̀VQKISb
7*.'$ÿ7A8Aÿ;'.'$,2ÿ$'3E2,+-%*)Dÿ+6'ÿ%*2@ÿ-*.->-.E,2)ÿ56%ÿ/,@ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ,*ÿ,&&2-4,*+ÿ%$ÿ$'3-)+$,*+ÿ-*ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ/,++'$)
?';%$'ÿ+6'ÿ78#9:ÿ,$'c
d%EDÿ-*ÿ,ÿ/,++'$ÿ-*>%2>-*3ÿ+6'ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ@%Eÿ%5*A
d%Eÿ/,@ÿ;-2'ÿ%*ÿ@%E$ÿ%5*ÿ?'6,2;ÿ,*.ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ@%E$)'2;ÿ-*ÿ,*ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ;%$ÿ$'3-)+$,+-%*ÿ%;ÿ,ÿ/,$0ÿ+6,+ÿ@%E
%5*A
d%Eÿ/,@ÿ;-2'ÿ,ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ;%$ÿ,ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ%5*'.ÿ?@ÿ,ÿ&,$+*'$)6-&ÿ%;ÿ56-46ÿ@%Eÿ,$'ÿ,ÿ&,$+*'$Dÿ%$
?@ÿ,ÿ4%$&%$,+-%*Dÿ2-/-+'.ÿ2-,?-2-+@ÿ4%/&,*@Dÿ%$ÿ%+6'$ÿ2'3,22@ÿ;%$/'.ÿ%$3,*-e,+-%*ÿ%;ÿ56-46ÿ@%Eÿ,$'ÿ,*ÿ%;;-4'$
%$ÿ+6'ÿ'fE->,2'*+ÿ,*.ÿ56-46ÿ@%Eÿ,$'ÿ,E+6%$-e'.ÿ+%ÿ$'&$')'*+A
gÿ&$->,+'ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,++%$*'@ÿ56%ÿ-)ÿ2-4'*)'.ÿ-*ÿ+6'ÿ7*-+'.ÿ8+,+')ÿ,*.ÿ-)ÿ,E+6%$-e'.ÿ+%ÿ&$,4+-4'ÿ?';%$'ÿ+6'
78#9:Aÿ
ÿ
h,*,.-,*ÿ,3'*+)ÿ%$ÿ,++%$*'@)ÿ56%ÿ,$'ÿ,E+6%$-e'.ÿ?@ÿ+6'ÿ78#9:ÿ+%ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ,&&2-4,*+)ÿ2%4,+'.ÿ-*ÿh,*,.,A
h'$+,-*ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,3'*+)ÿ$'4%3*-e'.ÿ+%ÿ&$,4+-4'ÿ?';%$'ÿ+6'ÿ78#9:ÿ&$-%$ÿ+%ÿi,*E,$@ÿjDÿjklmA
n/&2%@-*3ÿ,ÿ;%$'-3*ÿ,++%$*'@ÿ%$ÿ%+6'$ÿ-*.->-.E,2ÿ56%ÿ-)ÿ*%+ÿ,E+6%$-e'.ÿ+%ÿ&$,4+-4'ÿ?';%$'ÿ+6'ÿ78#9:ÿ+%ÿ$'&$')'*+ÿ@%Eÿ-*
4%**'4+-%*ÿ5-+6ÿ@%E$ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ/,@cÿ
ÿ
o'2,@ÿ,*.ÿ&$%2%*3ÿ+6'ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*ÿ'F,/-*,+-%*ÿ&$%4'))A
p',.ÿ+%ÿ+6'ÿ,?,*.%*/'*+ÿ%;ÿ@%E$ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*A
i'%&,$.-e'ÿ+6'ÿ>,2-.-+@ÿ%;ÿ,*@ÿ$')E2+-*3ÿ$'3-)+$,+-%*Aÿ
ÿ
nF4'&+ÿ,)ÿ*%+'.ÿ,?%>'DÿSISqVQQIOSNTLÿVSRÿYIONKrSÿVQQIOSNTLÿPVTÿSIQÿMNOYIOPÿVSTÿIYÿQHNÿYIaaIsKSrÿV`QKISLÿ,)ÿ,
$'&$')'*+,+->'ÿ%;ÿ,*%+6'$ÿ&'$)%*ÿ-*ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ/,++'$)ÿ?';%$'ÿ+6'ÿ78#9:c
ÿ
h%*)E2+-*3ÿ5-+6ÿ%$ÿ3->-*3ÿ,.>-4'ÿ+%ÿ,*ÿ,&&2-4,*+ÿ%$ÿ$'3-)+$,*+ÿ-*ÿ4%*+'/&2,+-%*ÿ%;ÿ;-2-*3ÿ,ÿ+$,.'/,$0ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*
%$ÿ,&&2-4,+-%*t$'2,+'.ÿ.%4E/'*+A
$%&'()*+,-ÿ/'ÿ)+(0,1(+2ÿ(334%5()%/'-ÿ('0ÿ(--/5%(),0ÿ0/5*1,')-
677ÿ9:;<=>?@AÿA<B=C@@>9ÿ@:ÿ@D>ÿEFGHIÿC?ÿ;:??>;@C:?ÿJC@DÿKÿ@LK9>=KLMÿKNN7C;K@C:?ÿ:LÿL>OCA@LK@C:?ÿ=<A@ÿB>ÿACO?>9ÿBPÿK
NL:N>LÿN>LA:?Qÿ
HD>ÿNL:N>LÿN>LA:?ÿ@:ÿACO?ÿ9>N>?9Aÿ:?ÿ@D>ÿ?K@<L>ÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿA<B=CAAC:?QÿT>L@KC?ÿA<B=CAAC:?Aÿ=KPÿB>ÿACO?>9ÿBPÿK?P:?>ÿJC@D
SCLA@DK?9ÿM?:J7>9O>ÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿSK;@AÿK?9ÿK;@<K7ÿ:LÿC=N7C>9ÿK<@D:LC@Pÿ@:ÿK;@ÿ:?ÿB>DK7Sÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@UÿJDC7>ÿ:@D>LAÿ=<A@ÿB>
ACO?>9ÿBPÿ@D>ÿKNN:C?@>9ÿK@@:L?>PUÿ:LÿBPÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@ÿCSÿ?:ÿK@@:L?>PÿCAÿKNN:C?@>9Qÿÿ
677ÿACO?K@<L>Aÿ=<A@ÿB>ÿN>LA:?K77Pÿ>?@>L>9ÿBPÿ@D>ÿC?9CVC9<K7ÿN>LA:?ÿC9>?@CSC>9ÿKAÿ@D>ÿACO?K@:LPQÿÿHD<AUÿK?:@D>LÿN>LA:?ÿ=KP
?:@ÿACO?ÿ@D>ÿ?K=>ÿ:SÿK?ÿK@@:L?>Pÿ:Lÿ:@D>LÿK<@D:LCW>9ÿACO?>LQÿÿFCO?K@<L>AÿXBPÿ@D>ÿ;:LN:LK@C:?Yÿ:LÿXBPÿ@D>ÿSCL=YÿKL>ÿ?:@
N>L=C@@>9Qÿ
Z13+/3,+4[ÿ-%&',0ÿ-*\1%--%/'-ÿ1([ÿ0,4([ÿ/+ÿ3+/4/'&ÿ)],ÿ(334%5()%/'ÿ3+/5,--^ÿ1([ÿ4,(0ÿ)/ÿ)],ÿ(\('0/'1,')ÿ/_
[/*+ÿ(334%5()%/'^ÿ('0ÿ1([ÿ̀,/3(+0%a,ÿ)],ÿb(4%0%)[ÿ/_ÿ('[ÿ+,-*4)%'&ÿ+,&%-)+()%/'cÿÿZ_ÿ)],ÿe$fghÿ0,),+1%',-ÿ)]()ÿ(
-*\1%--%/'ÿ%-ÿ%13+/3,+4[ÿ-%&',0^ÿ)],ÿ-*\1%--%/'ÿi%44ÿ'/)ÿ\,ÿ(55,3),0ÿ('0ÿ('[ÿ(+&*1,')-^ÿ,b%0,'5,^ÿ/+
(1,'01,')-ÿ-,)ÿ_/+)]ÿ%'ÿ)],ÿ-*\1%--%/'ÿi%44ÿ'/)ÿ\,ÿ5/'-%0,+,0ÿ/+ÿ,'),+,0cÿ
ÿ
j,+%_%5()%/'-ÿ/_ÿk(5)-
6ÿV>LCSC;K@C:?ÿACO?K@<L>ÿCAÿA<B=C@@>9ÿS:Lÿ@D>ÿN<LN:A>ÿ:SÿV>LCSPC?OÿSK;@AÿC?ÿKÿ9:;<=>?@ÿ:?ÿB>DK7Sÿ:SÿK?ÿKNN7C;K?@Qÿ
HD>ÿACO?K@<L>Aÿ:?ÿ@D>ÿS:77:JC?OÿA<B=CAAC:?AÿKL>ÿ;:?AC9>L>9ÿ@:ÿB>ÿV>LCSC;K@C:?ÿACO?K@<L>Al
HLK9>=KLMÿKNN7C;K@C:?AQ
677>OK@C:?Aÿ:Sÿ<A>Q
m>n<>A@AÿS:Lÿ>o@>?AC:?ÿ@:ÿSC7>ÿKÿA@K@>=>?@ÿ:Sÿ<A>Q
p>;7KLK@C:?AÿC?ÿA<NN:L@ÿ:SÿA<BA@C@<@>ÿAN>;C=>?AÿK?9ÿ;7KC=Aÿ:SÿK;n<CL>9ÿ9CA@C?;@CV>?>AAQ
q>LCSC;K@C:?ÿACO?K@<L>Aÿ=KPÿB>ÿACO?>9ÿBPÿK?Pÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿS:77:JC?OÿC?9CVC9<K7AlÿrstÿKÿN>LA:?ÿJC@Dÿ7>OK7ÿK<@D:LC@Pÿ@:ÿBC?9ÿ@D>
KNN7C;K?@uÿrvtÿKÿn<K7CSC>9ÿK@@:L?>PÿL>NL>A>?@C?Oÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@uÿ:LÿrwtÿKÿN>LA:?ÿJC@DÿSCLA@DK?9ÿM?:J7>9O>ÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿSK;@AÿK?9
K;@<K7ÿ:LÿC=N7C>9ÿK<@D:LC@Pÿ@:ÿK;@ÿ:?ÿB>DK7Sÿ:Sÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@Qÿ
ÿ
x,-3/'-,-^ÿy1,'01,')-^ÿz]('&,-ÿ/_ÿz/++,-3/'0,'5,^ÿ{|3+,--ÿy\('0/'1,')-^ÿ('0ÿh)],+ÿ$*\1%--%/'-
HD>ÿACO?K@<L>ÿL>n<CL>=>?@AÿS:LÿL>AN:?A>Aÿ@:ÿISSC;>ÿK;@C:?AuÿK=>?9=>?@Aÿ@:ÿKNN7C;K@C:?AuÿL>n<>A@AÿS:LÿL>;:?AC9>LK@C:?u
L>n<>A@Aÿ@:ÿ9CVC9>uÿL>n<>A@Aÿ@:ÿ;DK?O>ÿ@D>ÿ;:LL>AN:?9>?;>ÿK99L>AAuÿ9>ACO?K@C:?AÿK?9ÿL>V:;K@C:?Aÿ:Sÿ9:=>A@C;
L>NL>A>?@K@CV>AuÿK?9ÿL>n<>A@AÿS:Lÿ>oNL>AAÿKBK?9:?=>?@AÿKL>ÿ=:L>ÿAN>;CSC;ÿKB:<@ÿJD:ÿ=<A@ÿACO?Qÿ}:Lÿ@D>A>ÿA<B=CAAC:?AUÿCS
@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@ÿCAÿL>NL>A>?@>9ÿBPÿKÿn<K7CSC>9ÿK@@:L?>PUÿ@D>ÿK@@:L?>Pÿ=<A@ÿACO?Q
~SÿP:<ÿKL>ÿK?ÿC?9CVC9<K7ÿKNN7PC?OÿS:LÿL>OCA@LK@C:?ÿ:SÿKÿ@LK9>=KLMÿ@DK@ÿP:<ÿ:J?UÿK?9ÿP:<ÿKL>ÿ?:@ÿL>NL>A>?@>9ÿBPÿKÿn<K7CSC>9
K@@:L?>PUÿ@D>?ÿP:<ÿ=<A@ÿACO?ÿ@D>A>ÿA<B=CAAC:?AuÿACO?K@<L>AÿBPÿK?P:?>ÿ:@D>LÿP:<ÿKL>ÿO>?>LK77Pÿ?:@ÿK;;>N@KB7>Q
~Sÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@ÿCAÿKÿ<LCA@C;ÿ>?@C@PÿrCQ>QUÿ?:@ÿK?ÿC?9CVC9<K7ÿN>LA:?tÿK?9ÿCAÿ?:@ÿL>NL>A>?@>9ÿBPÿKÿn<K7CSC>9ÿK@@:L?>PUÿ@D>?
A:=>:?>ÿJC@Dÿ7>OK7ÿK<@D:LC@Pÿ@:ÿBC?9ÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@ÿ=<A@ÿACO?ÿ@D>A>ÿA<B=CAAC:?AQÿÿHD>L>S:L>UÿCSÿ@D>ÿKNN7C;K?@ÿCAÿK
;:LN:LK@C:?UÿKÿ;:LN:LK@>ÿ:SSC;>LUÿA<;DÿKAÿKÿNL>AC9>?@ÿ:LÿVC;>ÿNL>AC9>?@UÿCAÿNL>A<=>9ÿ@:ÿDKV>ÿ@D>ÿ7>OK7ÿK<@D:LC@Pÿ@:ÿBC?9ÿ@D>
92298827
727
79
8
!
29789
77
97
8
7
7
7 "2#
012321405 Case 5:17-cv-07303 67Document
89
7ÿ7
97
1-1
8
ÿ
ÿ7Filed
712/26/17
ÿ
7ÿÿ6
Page 5 of 142
#$$%&'#()*ÿÿ-&./0&1/2ÿ#ÿ$#3)(/3ÿ&1ÿ$3/145/6ÿ)7ÿ8#9/ÿ)8/ÿ#$$37$3&#)/ÿ%/:#%ÿ#4)873&);ÿ)7ÿ<&(6ÿ#(ÿ#$$%&'#()ÿ)8#)ÿ&1ÿ73:#(&=/6ÿ#1
#ÿ$#3)(/318&$*ÿ>(ÿ)8/ÿ7)8/3ÿ8#(62ÿ1&:(#)73&/1ÿ&6/()&?&/6ÿ<;ÿ)/35&(7%7:;ÿ14'8ÿ#1ÿ@)3#6/5#3.ÿ#65&(&1)3#)732Aÿ@<41&(/11
5#(#:/32Aÿ@70(/3B1ÿ6/1&:(#)/6ÿ#:/()2Aÿ73ÿ1&5&%#3ÿ)&)%/1ÿ#3/ÿ$3/145/6ÿ)7ÿ</ÿ4(#4)873&=/6ÿ1&:(#)73&/1*ÿ
C&(#%%;2ÿ&?ÿ)8/3/ÿ&1ÿ573/ÿ)8#(ÿ7(/ÿ#$$%&'#()2ÿ#(6ÿ(7ÿD4#%&?&/6ÿ#))73(/;ÿ8#1ÿ<//(ÿ#$$7&()/62ÿ)8/(ÿ#%%ÿ#$$%&'#()1ÿ541)ÿ1&:(
)8/1/ÿ14<5&11&7(1*
EXHIBIT B
012321405 6789
87ÿ
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 8Filed
1-1
ÿ
12/26/17
7ÿÿ6 Page 7 of 142
+.(B/C(.DÿFGGHGI(J'/ÿK/JI/.
L]^M^Nÿ_`
OP)(QN MRÿTUUVUWNXYPÿZPXWPMÿ[LTZ\
JaÿbI.//I
c(BHG&Jÿd(GIeÿK&J'&`.G/ÿ%/f/)
F)/g(JB.H(ÿeÿhFÿiijkl
%&'()*mnk,ini,oim^ÿpq./GGÿ^r
+&)),-.//*s^^,ns],okooÿp&qIH&Jÿkr
LMNOPQNMRTUUVUWNXYPZPXWPMtuUvWwxywz
+{/ÿ+.(B/C(.DÿFGGHGI(J'/ÿK/JI/.ÿp+FKrÿHGÿI{/ÿC(HJÿG`qq&.Iÿ'/JI/.ÿ|&.ÿ())ÿ'`GI&C/.Geÿ|.&Cÿ|H.GI,IHC/ÿ|H)/.GÿI&ÿ)/}()
q.&|/GGH&J()Gÿ(JBÿ/gq/.H/J'/BÿI.(B/C(.Dÿ(qq)H'(JIG~ÿ/ÿ'(Jÿ(JG/.ÿa&`.ÿ`/GIH&JGÿ&Jÿ(ÿf(.H/Iaÿ&|ÿI.(B/C(.DÿI&qH'G~
5;:7<:ÿ>8ÿ65?
/J/.()ÿHJ|&.C(IH&Jÿ(
&`Iÿ./}HGI/.HJ}ÿ(ÿI.(B/C(.D
+.(B/C(.Dÿ)HI/.(I`./ÿ(JBÿq`
)H'(IH&JG
qB(I/Gÿ&JÿI{/ÿGI(I`Gÿ&|ÿI.(B/C(.Dÿ(qq)H'(IH&JGÿ(JBÿ./}HGI.(IH&JG
FJG/.GÿI&ÿ'(G/,Gq/'H|H'ÿ`/GIH&JGÿ(
&`Iÿ(Jÿ(qq)H'(IH&Jÿ&.ÿ./}HGI.(IH&J
/)qÿJ(fH}(IHJ}ÿ/)/'I.&JH'ÿ|&.CGÿ(JBÿGaGI/CG
/)qÿ|HJBHJ}ÿHJ|&.C(IH&Jÿ&Jÿ&`.ÿ/
GHI/ÿ(
&`IÿI{/ÿC/(JHJ}ÿ&|ÿI.(B/C(.DÿI/.CGÿ(JBÿ'&J'/qIGeÿ{&ÿI&ÿGI(.IÿI{/
(qq)H'(IH&Jÿq.&'/GGeÿ(qq)H'(IH&Jÿ(JBÿ./}HGI.(IH&JÿIHC/)HJ/Geÿ(JBÿC&./~
3ÿ<7;;5:ÿ93ÿ37ÿ7@9<3ÿ098ÿ9;<>@38
FBfHGHJ}ÿ(qq)H'(JIGÿ&Jÿq.&q/.ÿ./Gq&JG/GÿI&ÿb+ÿ||H'/ÿ('IH&JG
K&JB`'IHJ}ÿq./,|H)HJ}ÿG/(.'{/Gÿ|&.ÿq&I/JIH())aÿ'&J|)H'IHJ}ÿI.(B/C(.DG
FJ()aHJ}ÿ&.ÿq./,(qq.&fHJ}ÿB&'`C/JIGÿ
/|&./ÿ|H)HJ}
FBfHGHJ}ÿ(qq)H'(JIGÿ&JÿG`
GI(JIHf/ÿ/g(CHJ(IH&JÿHGG`/GeÿG`'{ÿ(GÿI{/ÿ(''/qI(
H)HIaÿ&|ÿGq/'HC/JGÿ(JBÿ')(GGH|H'(IH&Jÿ&|
}&&BGÿ(JBÿG/.fH'/G~
=5>?8
0123ÿ56ÿ78898:7;<3 =5>?8ÿ7;@ÿ<5;:7<:ÿ9;65?A7:95;
22! "2#
87!$89$7
7
2 7$
72789
87$88
$
7 021
012321405 6789
87ÿ
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 8Filed
1-1
ÿ
12/26/17
7ÿÿ6 Page 8 of 142
%&'(ÿ*+ÿ,--.-/,01( 2*34-ÿ,05ÿ1*0/,1/ÿ.0+*46,/.*0
7*0/,1/ÿ1(0/(4 89:;<=>?@A;<=BÿDEFGÿ<HIHÿJ9ÿDÿKHIHÿLM
M9NN>O@PPEÿDGG>QDR>STSSÿU9KJA9:ÿTV
W9X<NEÿYQT>ZQZ>SZYGÿUK@P[[ÿGV
\:JP@:<JA9:<NEÿT>YQT>ZQZ>SZYGÿUK@P[[ÿGV
]6,.^ _`abcda`efgghgiajkclcjic`mngoipqrps
t0+*46,/.*0ÿu.05*u 89:;<=>?@A;<=BÿDEFGÿ<HIHÿJ9ÿYÿKHIHÿLM
v9:X9w@[PÿNPxPNBÿ8<;A[9:ÿL<[JÿywAN;A:z
RGGÿ{wN<:=ÿ|J@PPJBÿ}NP~<:;@A<BÿA@zA:A<
9ÿ<KK9A:JIP:Jÿ:PXP[[<@=
ÿ(ÿ,4(ÿ1^*-(5ÿ*0ÿu(((05-ÿ,05ÿ/(ÿ+*^^*u.0
ÿ+(5(4,^ÿ*^.5,&-
PÿP<@[ÿ{<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ8PI9@A<Nÿ{<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿv9NwIw[ÿ{<=
8<@JA:ÿWwJP@ÿA:zÿ@H[ÿA@J;<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ\:;PKP:;P:XPÿ{<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿPJP@<:[ÿ{<=
<[A:zJ9:[ÿA@J;<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿW<9@ÿ{<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿM<:[zAxA:zÿ{<=ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ
ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿv@A[JI<[ÿ{<=
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
22! "2#
87!$89$7
7
2 7$
72789
87$88
$
7 121
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 9 of 142
EXHIBIT C
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 10 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 11 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 12 of 142
0121321405 6789
Document
Case 5:17-cv-07303 87ÿ
ÿÿ1-1
ÿ8ÿ6789Filed
87ÿ12/26/17
ÿ6789
87ÿ
Page
7813 of 142
ÿ"#$%ÿ&'%()*+,(%-.ÿ/*'ÿ0*'.ÿ1'(%'ÿ"#$%ÿ* 23*ÿ.ÿ.ÿ.ÿ
4*230'*%ÿ"#$%ÿ,(%-ÿ#5.
/*'ÿ1'(%'*)ÿ&M0*%N3O*0M'%()*,(%-P%*230'%('3# + ÿ Q*(%ÿ,#%*
7#5ÿ8%()*,(%-ÿ9 23*ÿ:#%-0
;<=ÿ>?@AÿA<BCD=<A<Eÿ=AFE<GFAHÿCIÿJÿ<FD>ÿD=<KDL
1*(%OSÿT#%ÿUN(3V(W3V3'"
XY<ZHÿ=?ÿD<<ÿC[ÿ>?@Aÿ=AFE<GFAHÿCDÿF\A<FE>ÿ]<CIBÿ@D<EL
22789
87
2 023
0121321405 6789
Document
Case 5:17-cv-07303 87ÿ
ÿÿ1-1
ÿ8ÿ6789Filed
87ÿ12/26/17
ÿ6789
87ÿ
Page
7814 of 142
,-2)%ÿ'ÿ3)2ÿ4$)-&0#,-
5677ÿ9:;ÿ9:<ÿ=6>?7@ÿA:@=;69BBC6<@ÿ;9ÿD@E6Bÿ;F@ÿ<@E6=;<C;69Bÿ?<9G@==H
//01'&0#,ÿJ0,.
K9:<ÿC??76GC;69BÿL677ÿD@ÿM67@NÿL6;Fÿ;F@ÿOHPHÿQC;@B;ÿCBNÿR<CN@>C<SÿTMM6G@ÿUOPQRTVH
ÿ"#$%ÿ&%'()*'%+ÿ,))(-ÿ'&ÿ'ÿ.%)'&ÿ/%01)
W%'()*'%+ÿX)'%1Y)-
Z[\]
P;C<;6BEÿC;
^B9LÿD@M9<@ÿ_9:ÿM67@Hÿ̀ CS@ÿ=:<@ÿ_9:<ÿ>C<Sÿ6=ÿB9;ÿD@6BEÿ:=@NH
ab96NÿLC=;6BEÿ;6>@ÿCBNÿ>9B@_
c9>@=;6GÿCBNÿdB;@<BC;69BC7ÿ=@C<GF@=
e9>?<@F@B=6b@ÿG:=;9>ÿQc5ÿ<@?9<;
f)'%,ÿg#%)ÿhi-)%j01)-i1#*/%)Y),-0j)k&%'()*'%+k-)'%1Yl
W%'()*'%+ÿm).0-&%'&0#,
Z]]
P;C<;6BEÿC;
nÿOPQRTÿM676BEÿM@@=
o@E6=;@<ÿ_9:<ÿ;<CN@>C<Sÿ9B76B@ÿ6BÿC=ÿ76;;7@ÿC=ÿpÿ>6B:;@=H
q:6GSÿCBNÿ@C=_ÿA:@=;69BBC6<@
22789
87
2 123
0121321405 6789
Document
Case 5:17-cv-07303 87ÿ
ÿÿ1-1
ÿ8ÿ6789Filed
87ÿ12/26/17
ÿ6789
87ÿ
Page
7815 of 142
E?9>:3ÿL:8=3;;ÿ=8CLM393Bÿ8?M>?3
NOMMÿ=O;98C3:ÿ;OLL8:9
P3Q>35ÿ<?Bÿ=8?R>:CÿS3R8:3ÿR>M>?@
TUVWÿ;3=O:3ÿ8?M>?3ÿ<==3;;
X&0'/ÿY$'&ÿZ["&'*+G&"[#'0I&%0'J\'&]+"#'0#+$/^
.'0I&%0'JÿY$/+#$'+/]
_`Wa
29<:9>?@ÿ<9
b39ÿ=8?9>?O3BÿL:893=9>8?ÿ96:8O@6ÿ<=9>Q3cÿ=8CL:363?;>Q3ÿC8?>98:>?@
b39ÿ?89>R>3Bÿ<S8O9ÿ>?R:>?@3C3?9
d?@8>?@ÿ=8CL:363?;>Q3ÿ;3<:=6
P3=3>Q3ÿB39<>M3BÿC8?96M7ÿ:3L8:9;
X&0'/ÿY$'&ÿZ["&'*+G&"[#'0I&%0'J\%$/+#$'+/]^
!"#$%&'ÿ)&*+&,"ÿ-ÿ.&"#+%$/+01"
233ÿ567ÿ8963:;ÿ<:3ÿ=688;>?@ÿA:<B3C<:DÿE?@>?3F
)&G&/#1Hÿ.'0I&%0'J&Iÿ$%K0/+&"
22789
87
2 23
0121321405 6789
Document
Case 5:17-cv-07303 87ÿ
ÿÿ1-1
ÿ8ÿ6789Filed
87ÿ12/26/17
ÿ6789
87ÿ
Page
7816 of 142
!"ÿ$%&'(ÿ%'ÿ)*'%"$%ÿ+',*ÿ( -"ÿ%'. +/
012345674ÿ159:ÿ;<2=:>=:7ÿ=1:?<ÿ@<567ÿ@AÿB?C?6Dÿ5ÿ=<57:E5<FG
R3?>FÿC?6F4
0<57:E5<FÿS:D?4=<5=?26ÿTU4:<9?>:4U=<57:E5<FV<:D?4=<5=?26W
X2E;<:1:64?9:ÿY:5<>1ÿTU4:<9?>:4U>2E;<:1:64?9:V=<57:E5<FV4:5<>1W
0<57:E5<FÿZ26?=2<?6DÿTU4:<9?>:4U=<57:E5<FVE26?=2<?6DW
[<::ÿ0<57:E5<FÿY:5<>1ÿTUB<::V=<57:E5<FV4:5<>1U=<57:E5<FV4:5<>1W
X2;A<?D1=ÿS:D?4=<5=?26ÿTU4:<9?>:4U>2;A<?D1=V<:D?4=<5=?26W
\BB?>:ÿ]>=?26ÿS:4;264:ÿTU4:<9?>:4U2BB?>:V5>=?26V<:4;264:W
X2E;56A
]@23=ÿ34ÿTU43;;2<=U5@23=W
X26=5>=ÿ34ÿTU43;;2<=U>26=5>=W
X5<::<4ÿTU43;;2<=U>5<::<4W
\3<ÿ^35<56=::ÿTU43;;2<=UD35<56=::W
X266:>=ÿa?=1ÿ34
]@23=ÿ34ÿTU43;;2<=U5@23=W
X5<::<4ÿTU43;;2<=U>5<::<4W
[2CC2aÿ34
_ÿT1==;4ÙUaaaGB5>:@22FG>2EU=<57:E5<F:6D?6:UW
bÿT1==;4ÙU=a?==:<G>2EU0<57:E5<Fc6D?6:W
dÿT1==;4ÙUaaaGC?6F:7?6G>2EU>2E;56AUefgheeggi
=<Fj=A51k=<Fl6B2j>C?>F:7m:<=?>5Cno]>2E;56AnpX>C?>F:7c6=?=Al7no]efgheeggnpX?7qno]pV
eVpnpX=5<l7no]erserfeepergpnpX=54no]0<57:E5<Fnpgc6D?6:W
22789
87
2 323
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 17 of 142
EXHIBIT D
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 18 of 142
FILE DETAILS
Other Comments:
START OF TRANSCRIPT
Facilitator: Thank you for calling Trademark Engine. This is Aaron. How can I
help you?
Interviewee: Yeah, hi. I just placed a trademark filing request, but I have a
question or two.
Interviewee: Yes.
Facilitator: Okay. So did you - you got the basic five-day package?
Interviewee: I don’t know. I guess - I think so, yeah. But - yeah, basic package.
Facilitator: So what will happen is our processors, the first thing they do is they’ll
run your mark that you’re applying for through a direct federal
[Unclear] words are denoted in square brackets and time stamps may be used to indicate their location within the audio.
Distribution of this transcript requires client authority and is subject to the provisions of the Australian Privacy Principles.
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 19 of 142
Trademarkengine2 Page 2 of 6
database and see if there’s any kind of direct conflicts with existing
marks. If there are, we’ll let you know right away and give you the
opportunity to cancel your application for a refund, or just change your
name to something else, or did you do a name or a logo.
Interviewee: Mm-hm.
Facilitator: Then we go ahead. Did you indicate on your application that you are
currently using the trademark, or that you’re not currently…
Interviewee: Well, I used it in 2002 and I’m going to restart again now, so I put, yes,
I’m using it, but…
Facilitator: Yes, okay. So what that’s going to mean is that you’re going to need
to require a specimen - you’re going to need to provide a specimen,
rather - at the time that we send your application to the government.
So that’s another thing that our processor will ask you for, if you
haven’t already provided it, would be a - what do you sell under that
name?
If you can’t provide that yet because you’re not going to have it yet,
we can change your application to not in use and that would give you
the opportunity to file that in a few months. However, it costs an extra
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
$100 if you want to do it that way, but they don’t charge you that until
you submit your evidence in a few months. So - but you keep it how it
is now and you can provide evidence now, if you have it, or we can
switch it to not yet in use and you can do that later.
Interviewee: Okay. Will you help me take a class or will you pay the government
fees or do I pay the government fees? How does that work?
Facilitator: Yeah, so we collect the - if we run that search and we see no direct hit
conflicts, we go ahead and collect that $275 at that time. Then once
you sign off on the final application summary we send you, that’s
when we pay that to the government on your behalf along with your
application.
[Over speaking]
Interviewee: Okay. So you email it to me and then I sign your form, or is it like - or
do I have to…
Facilitator: You’ll sign our form and then we submit everything on your behalf to
the government, because you’re basically giving us - part of the thing
that you’re signing is you’re giving us permission to file on your behalf.
We file with the government and then about five business days after
we file they give you a serial number. They’ll email you a registration
serial number and receipt to let you know that they’ve received the
application. That’s when your protection actually begins for the name
that you’ve applied for. However, you don’t receive final approval for
another few months. It takes them a while to process it.
Interviewee: Okay. Then are you - so basically with my description and stuff, is
that going to be something you’re going to help fix, or is that - because
I wrote a description.
Facilitator: Yes. Yeah, that’s correct. That’s one of the things that we offer as
part of our service. Our processor, once they ran that search, the next
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
thing they’re going to do is make sure that the class that you’ve
selected lines up with the description as you’ve written it. They’ll also
make some suggestions about improving the wording of the
description to make it a little better for the application, make it more
likely to be approved.
Interviewee: Okay. Then, so, are you guys my lawyers then? Or is that going to
be like, you’re going to be a lawyer? Are you going to be my lawyers,
or how does that work?
Facilitator: We’re not a law firm. We’re just a trademark filing company. I mean,
we were founded by lawyers, but we don’t offer legal advice or - we
are not attorneys, but we file the application on your behalf. So we’ve
done thousands of these and so we know what the government’s
looking for and is going to expect to see. So we make it - we save
you a lot of time and struggle trying to do it yourself.
Interviewee: Okay. Cool. Then if the search report comes back and suppose
someone has a mark that’s - what does that mean? I don’t - can you
explain that a little more? I don’t get it.
Facilitator: Yeah, so if someone else already has that name and they already
trademarked that name exactly, then we’re going to tell you you
probably should not file that name, because you’re just - you’re going
to get rejected. The government will reject your application. So we
give you a chance to change your name and we’ll run a search on
something else if you want, or you can just request a refund and sign
up at a later time.
Interviewee: Okay. So then I’ll get a full refund then? Or how does that work if…
Interviewee: Okay. Then - so, let’s see what else questions I have. If I want to file
in other countries, can you help with that?
Facilitator: No, sir. We can run a global search for you if you want us to get other
- if the trademark that you’re filing for exists in other countries already.
But the - we only apply for the US Patent and Trademark Office.
Interviewee: Okay. What if there’s a mark that’s not exactly the same as mine, but
it’s kind of similar? Is that a problem, or how does that work?
Facilitator: So it is a little subjective. If it’s confusingly similar, then they will reject
it. So if they’re spelt differently, but pronounced the same, that’s
grounds for rejection. If they’re just a letter or two different, that’s also
considered close. Sometimes it’s hard to tell. You just have - we -
you just have to make a judgment call, because at the end of the day
a lot of it depends on how picky the processor you get at the
government is. Because they assign it to an individual attorney and
they’re the ones who make the final call. So some of them are pickier
than others.
Interviewee: Thank you. Okay. That makes sense. I just wanted to make sure. I
placed the order, but I just want to make sure I record everything and
make sure I have this written down so I can follow up with you. How
do I go forward now? Just wait? What do I do?
Facilitator: Yeah, just keep an eye out on your email. We’ll send you the - if
necessary, we’ll send you search results. If there are no search
results that come back, then we’ll just proceed with the application
and we’ll send you an email requesting the specimens and you can - it
will - you can upload those to your account, or you can email them to
support@trademarkengine.com. But we’ll include instructions in that
email we send you, so just keep an eye out for that.
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
END OF TRANSCRIPT
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
FILE DETAILS
Other Comments:
START OF TRANSCRIPT
Facilitator: Yeah.
Interviewee: I have your account pulled up, I'm just looking over everything. Your
[your first name] [pause] [and your sector] [pause] [unclear] [pause].
Okay, I'm definitely going to have to, let's see, reach out to the
processing team. Let me just go over your notes. [Unclear] filed my
trademark on the 6th. Okay, I'm going to reach out to the processing
team to just see exactly where we are with the application, because
we did receive your response to file it after we gave you the [unclear]
assess report results.
Facilitator: Ah-ha.
[Unclear] words are denoted in square brackets and time stamps may be used to indicate their location within the audio.
Distribution of this transcript requires client authority and is subject to the provisions of the Australian Privacy Principles.
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 25 of 142
TrademarkEngine-statuscheck (1) Page 2 of 3
Interviewee: Let's see here, they probably just haven't gotten to the application yet,
but still it needs to definitely move forward. Okay, all right, so where
are we now with the - okay, so I'm going to let the processing team
know that we've moved forward and start on the next step, which will
be the application summary that is to be reviewed and signed and
we'll email that to you. That will be the last step to do once we file out
the trademark application.
Facilitator: Okay, can you check with them right now, or how?
Interviewee: Let me see here, I can only message them. I don't know how long it
will it take for them to message me back on it. I'll just definitely update
them and let them know that the order needs to be processed further.
Facilitator: Okay, are you guys are in different offices or can you just go over and
speak with them?
Interviewee: Right, it's like different offices. We have our processing team and then
we have our CSR team, those then they can say that they'll definitely
move forward and they'll just send over the application process
whenever they can, which could take up to one business day.
Facilitator: Okay and are you, so are guys in Texas or where are you guys at, are
you located…
Facilitator: Okay, cool. So if you could like move this forward, that would be good,
you know?
Interviewee: Yeah, absolutely. We should send that out to you by tomorrow. It'll be
an application summary sent to your email, so say, application
summary needs to be - no, requires your attention and it'll let you click
on the link and review the application and sign it electronically and
that will be the last step and then we'll file it out.
Facilitator: Okay, so after I sign your application, like do I file on your website? Do
I sign on your website or do I sign it on the government website or
how does that work?
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
Interviewee: It's on our website. We actually send you a link to it and it will pull up
your application and the summary, so that way you'll be able to sign it
electronically.
Facilitator: Okay and so once I sign it, then you guys will pay the government
fees or how does it work? Like do I do it?
Interviewee: Right, yes. The 275 government filing fee will be processed and then
we'll file it out with the USPTO.
Facilitator: Okay, so you'll process that and you'll file it out. Okay, cool.
Interviewee: Right.
Facilitator: Bye-bye.
Facilitator: Bye-bye.
END OF TRANSCRIPT
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
FILE DETAILS
Other Comments:
START OF TRANSCRIPT
Facilitator: …mark, through Trademark Engine and I'm just about to sign. But I
have some questions.
Interviewee: [Okay].
Interviewee: Michelle.
Facilitator: Okay, yeah hi Michelle. So I'm confused about one thing, maybe you
can help me. Like, is that description - I put a description on your
website, but then it changed the description and I'm just wondering
what the - why it was changed.
Interviewee: Um, okay, our processors changed the description to make it more
acceptable to the USPTO. So the government is primarily interested in
the services that you're providing. If you're interested - I mean if you
would rather use your description, then we can use your description,
[Unclear] words are denoted in square brackets and time stamps may be used to indicate their location within the audio.
Distribution of this transcript requires client authority and is subject to the provisions of the Australian Privacy Principles.
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 28 of 142
trademarkengine-AudioBeforeSignature-Dec14 (1) Page 2 of 3
Facilitator: Okay and then like a - I don't know, it's a weird symbol, like a tilde
mark on it, like can we maybe get rid of that? Why is there a tilde mark
on it? Like, it says: financial investment in the field of tilde mark real
estate. What does that mean?
Interviewee: That is probably - they copy and paste the description from the
government website, so that's probably just a result of HTML. Oh, the
parentheses things, is that what you're talking about?
Facilitator: Yeah.
Facilitator: Yeah.
Interviewee: I mean we can remove the brackets if you want, but that's, once
again, that's for USPTO purposes, so they were - that's - they're like
lingual - legal language, like jargon for them. So but if you don't want
that there, then we can remove it.
Facilitator: Okay. All right, so you guys changed the description for me, okay,
good, all right and thanks. The class, what does that mean exactly?
Did you guys - what does that mean?
Facilitator: Okay, all right and so you guys picked that. Okay, cool, thank you so
much, I think I'll just proceed with it, thank you.
END OF TRANSCRIPT
PO Box 745 Indooroopilly QLD 4068 AUSTRALIA Ph 1300 662 173 or +61 7 3378 2668
EXHIBIT E
0121321405 6789
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ
ÿÿFiled
12/26/17
ÿ Page 31 of 142
!"#$ÿ#& '()*
+ ÿ!"#$ÿ#&ÿ,-&#.."/$-0!"#$1
+ ÿ2 3&ÿ,-&#.."/$-405&1
+ ÿ60/77/&ÿ,-&#.."/$-80/77/&1
+ ÿ9#/ÿ:#0/0;$77ÿ,-&#.."/$-<#0/0;$771
+ ÿ6";$08$ÿ=&ÿ,-&#.."/$-8";$08$1
>?@*AÿCDEF(GEDHÿI)JK)(
L/0M7N0/OÿP;<Q;7ÿQ&ÿ4"8#&7Mÿ";ÿ./"RQMQ;<ÿ&N0SSÿ!#&Q;7&&ÿ"T;7/&ÿÿ
0ÿ&QN.S7Uÿ40&$Uÿ0;Mÿ78";"NQ80Sÿ0../"08Vÿ$"ÿ./"$78$Q;<ÿ$V7Q/ÿÿ
!/0;Mÿ0;Mÿ!#&Q;7&&ÿT"/SMTQM7W
L/0M7N0/OÿP;<Q;7ÿT0&ÿ&$0/$7Mÿ!Xÿ0;ÿ7Y.7/Q7;87Mÿ$/0M7N0/OÿS0TX7/ÿ0;Mÿ$78V;"S"<Q&$&ÿ$"ÿ!/Q;<ÿ$/0M7N0/Oÿ4QSQ;<ÿ&7/RQ87&ÿ$"
8";&#N7/&ÿ0;Mÿ&N0SSÿ!#&Q;7&&7&ÿTV"ÿM"ÿ;"$ÿ;77Mÿ"/ÿ80;;"$ÿ044"/Mÿ0ÿ4#SSZ&7/RQ87ÿQ;$7SS78$#0Sÿ./".7/$Xÿ0$$"/;7XWÿ[7ÿ&$/QR7ÿ$"
N0O7ÿ$VQ&ÿ./"87&&ÿ0&ÿ744Q8Q7;$Uÿ#;M7/&$0;M0!S7ÿ0;Mÿ044"/M0!S7ÿ0&ÿ."&&Q!S7ÿ$"ÿ<QR7ÿ7R7/X";7ÿ$V7ÿ0!QSQ$Xÿ$"ÿ"!$0Q;ÿ0ÿ$/0M7N0/Oÿ4"/
$V7Q/ÿ!#&Q;7&&Wÿ[7ÿ0/7ÿ;"$ÿ0ÿS0Tÿ4Q/Nÿ0;MÿM"ÿ;"$ÿ./"RQM7ÿS7<0Sÿ0MRQ87Uÿ!#$ÿ75#Q.ÿX"#ÿTQ$Vÿ$V7ÿ."T7/ÿ$"ÿV7S.ÿX"#ÿ"!$0Q;ÿX"#/ÿ"T;
$/0M7N0/OW
\7R7/0<Q;<ÿS7<0SÿO;"TS7M<7ÿ0;Mÿ$78V;"S"<XUÿ=$QSQ]Q;<ÿ$V7ÿ8"N!Q;7Mÿ&OQSS&ÿ"4ÿ"#/ÿ4"#;M7/&UÿT7ÿV0R7ÿ&$/70NSQ;7Mÿ$V7ÿ./"87&&ÿ0;M
$/0Q;7Mÿ"#/ÿ8#&$"N7/ÿ&7/RQ87ÿ/7./7&7;$0$QR7&ÿ$"ÿV7S.ÿX"#ÿ7R7/Xÿ&$7.ÿ"4ÿ$V7ÿT0XWÿ[7ÿ0QNÿ$"ÿ./"RQM7ÿX"#ÿ7R7/X$VQ;<ÿX"#ÿ;77Mÿ4"/
$V7ÿ&70/8VQ;<Uÿ4QSQ;<ÿ0;MÿN0Q;$0Q;Q;<ÿ"4ÿX"#/ÿ$/0M7N0/Oÿ$"ÿ./"$78$ÿX"#/ÿ;0N7Uÿ!/0;MUÿ&S"<0;ÿ"/ÿS"<"ÿ4"/ÿ$V7ÿSQ47ÿ"4ÿQ$&ÿ#&7W
9#/ÿ&7/RQ87&ÿ0/7ÿ;"$ÿ0../"./Q0$7ÿ4"/ÿ7R7/X";7ÿ!780#&7ÿ&"N7ÿ&V"#SMÿ&$QSSÿ&77Oÿ!7&."O7ÿS7<0Sÿ&7/RQ87&Uÿ!#$ÿ4"/ÿN"&$UÿX"#ÿ&V"#SM
.#$ÿ$V7ÿL/0M7N0/OÿP;<Q;7ÿ$"ÿT"/Oÿ4"/ÿX"#W
3#Q8OÿSQ;O&
L/0M7N0/Oÿ^7<Q&$/0$Q";ÿ,-&7/RQ87&-$/0M7N0/OZ/7<Q&$/0$Q";1
6"N./7V7;&QR7ÿ_70/8Vÿ,-&7/RQ87&-8"N./7V7;&QR7Z$/0M7N0/OZ&70/8V1
L/0M7N0/Oÿ̀ ";Q$"/Q;<ÿ,-&7/RQ87&-$/0M7N0/OZN";Q$"/Q;<1
2/77ÿL/0M7N0/Oÿ_70/8Vÿ,-4/77Z$/0M7N0/OZ&70/8V-$/0M7N0/OZ&70/8V1
6".X/Q<V$ÿ^7<Q&$/0$Q";ÿ,-&7/RQ87&-8".X/Q<V$Z/7<Q&$/0$Q";1
944Q87ÿ8$Q";ÿ^7&.";&7ÿ,-&7/RQ87&-"44Q87Z08$Q";Z/7&.";&71
6"N.0;X
!"#$ÿ#&ÿ,-&#.."/$-0!"#$1
6";$08$ÿ#&ÿ,-&#.."/$-8";$08$1
60/77/&ÿ,-&#.."/$-80/77/&1
22
82
98
2789
021
0121321405 6789
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ
ÿÿFiled
12/26/17
ÿ Page 32 of 142
KB&ÿLB0&06*22ÿFG;B$$#&*G(B0&06*22I
"#662@*ÿ='*)ÿB;
ZC#B*ÿB;ÿFG;B$$#&*G0C#B*I
"0&22&;ÿFG;B$$#&*G@0&22&;I
]#>>#=ÿB;
MÿF)**$;NGG===9<0@2C##49@#3G*&01230&426('62GI
OÿF)**$;NGG*='**2&9@#3G/&01230&456('62I
PÿF)**$;NGG===9>'6421'69@#3G@#3$06%G-Q,R--,,S
*&4T*%0)U*&4V6<#T@>'@421W2&*'@0>XYZ@#3$06%X+"@>'@42156*'*%V1XYZ-Q,R--,,X+"'1[XYZ+H
-H+X+"*0&V1XYZ-\.-\Q--+-\,+X+"*0;XYZ/&01230&4X+,56('62I
Z;;';*06@2
^_`aÿcdef
gÿhijjkÿjlgmnojpÿhfa^qgmijjmjlgmnojpk
rstmuv_ÿpermwxr
ÿ"#$%&'()*ÿ+,-.ÿ/&01230&4ÿ56('627ÿ88"9ÿ/&01230&4ÿ56('62ÿ$&#:'12;ÿ'6<#&30*'#6ÿ061ÿ;#<*=0&2ÿ#6>%9ÿ/&01230&4ÿ56('62ÿ';ÿ6#*ÿ0ÿ?>0=%2&ÿ&2<2&&0>ÿ;2&:'@2?ÿ061
1#2;ÿ6#*ÿ$&#:'12ÿ>2(0>ÿ01:'@2ÿ#&ÿ$0&*'@'$0*2ÿ'6ÿ06%ÿ>2(0>ÿ&2$&2;26*0*'#69ÿA;2ÿ#<ÿ/&01230&4ÿ56('62ÿ';ÿ;BCD2@*ÿ*#ÿ#B&ÿ/2&3;ÿ#<ÿE2&:'@2ÿFG>2(0>G*2&3;H#<H;2&:'@2I
061ÿJ&':0@%ÿJ#>'@%ÿFG>2(0>G$&':0@%H$#>'@%I9
22
82
98
2789
121
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 33 of 142
EXHIBIT F
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 34 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 35 of 142
EXHIBIT G
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 36 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 37 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 38 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 39 of 142
EXHIBIT H
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 40 of 142
In the Matter of )
)
Matthew H. Swyers, ) Proceeding No. D2016-20
)
Respondent )
~~~~~~~~~~~-l
FINAL ORDER
Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 11.27(b), the Director of the United States Patent and
Trademark Office ("USPTO" or "Office") received for review and approval from the
Director of the Office of Emollment and Discipline ("OED Director") an Affidavit For
For Consent Exclusion to the USPTO for the purpose of being excluded on consent
For the reasons set forth herein, Respondent's Affidavit For Consent Exclusion
shall be approved, and Respondent shall be excluded on consent from practice before the
Office in trademark and non-patent matters commencing on the date of this Final Order.
Jurisdiction
Commonwealth of Virginia and the District of Columbia and has practiced before the
Responsibility, which is set forth at 37 C.F.R. § 10.20 et seq., and the USPTO Rules of
Director has the authority to approve Respondent's Affidavit for Consent Exclusion and
to exclude Respondent on consent from the practice of trademark and non-patent matters
1 The USPTO Code of Professional Responsibility applies to conduct prior to May 3, 2013, and
the USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct apply to conduct on or after May 3, 2013.
2
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 42 of 142
Exclusion that:
1. His consent is freely and voluntarily rendered, and he is not being subjected
to coercion or duress.
No. D2016-20) alleges that he violated the following Disciplinary Rules of the USPTO
3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 43 of 142
4
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 44 of 142
5
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 45 of 142
6
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 46 of 142
7
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 47 of 142
8
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 48 of 142
9
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 49 of 142
10
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 50 of 142
11
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 51 of 142
12
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 52 of 142
13
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 53 of 142
14
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 54 of 142
15
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 55 of 142
16
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 56 of 142
17
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 57 of 142
18
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 58 of 142
3. Without admitting that he violated any of the Disciplinary Rules of the USPTO
Code of Professional Responsibility and/ or the Rules of Professional Conduct which are
that, if and when he applies for reinstatement to practice before the USPTO in trademark
or other non-patent matters under 37 C.F.R. § 11.60, the OED Director will conclusively
19
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 59 of 142
presume, for the limited purpose of determining the application for reinstatement, that
(a) the allegations regarding him in the complaint filed in Proceeding No. D2016-20 are
true and (b) he could not have successfully defended himself against such allegations.
4. He has fully read and understands 37 C.F.R. §§ 11.5(b), 11.27, 11.58, 11.59, and
11.60, and is fully aware of the legal and factual consequences of consenting to exclusion
Exclusion on Consent
Based on the foregoing, the USPTO Director has determined that Respondent's
Affidavit For Consent Exclusion complies with the requirements of 37 C.F.R. § 11.27(a).
1. Respondent's Affidavit For Consent Exclusion shall be, and hereby is,
approved;
2. Respondent shall be, and hereby is, excluded on consent from practice
before the Office in trademark and non-patent matters commencing on the date of this
Final Order;
3. The OED Director shall electronically publish the Final Order at the Office
4. The OED Director shall publish a notice in the Official Gazette that is
20
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 60 of 142
21
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 61 of 142
22
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 62 of 142
While Mr. Swyers did not admit to violating any of the Disciplinary
Rules of the USPTO Code of Professional Responsibility or the
USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct as alleged in the pending
disciplinary complaint, he acknowledged that, if and when he
applies for reinstatement, the OED Director will conclusively
presume, for the limited purpose of determining the application for
reinstatement, that (i) the allegations set forth in the OED
investigation against him are true, and (ii) he could not have
successfully defended himself against such allegations.
23
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 63 of 142
6. Respondent shall comply fully with 37 C.F.R. § 11.60 upon any request for
reinstatement.
~
David Shewchuk
Deputy General Counsel for General Law
'2~ 1~11
Date
20\ l
on behalf of
Michelle K. Lee
Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and
Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office
cc:
Danny M. Howell
Robert Jackson Martin IV
Anne M. Sterba
Law Office of Danny M. Howell, PLLC
2010 Corporate Ridge, Suite 700
Mclean, VA 22102
Counsel for Matthew H. Swyers
24
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 64 of 142
EXHIBIT I
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 65 of 142
In the Matter of )
)
Tracy W. Druce, )
) Proceeding No. D2014-13
Respondent )
)
FINAL ORDER
The Director of the Office of Enrollment and Discipline ("OED Director") for the United
States Patent and Trademark Office ("USPTO" or "Office") and Tracy W. Druce ("Respondent")
have submitted a Proposed Settlement Agreement ("Agreement") to the Under Secretary of
Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the United States Patent and Trademark
Office ("USPTO Director") for approval.
The Agreement, which resolves all disciplinary action by the USPTO arising from the
stipulated facts set forth below, is hereby approved. This Final Order sets forth the parties'
stipulated facts, legal conclusion, and agreed upon sanction.
Jurisdiction
2. The USPTO Director has jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to 35 U.S.C.
§§ 2(b)(2)(D) and 32 and37 C.F.R. §§ 11.19 and 11.26.
Stipulated Facts
6. In 2005, Noval, Druce LLP became Novak, Druce & Quigg LLP.
8, At all relevant times, Respondent was responsible for the supervision of the
non-lawyer assistant.
9, From at least 2004 through 2006, the non-lawyer assistant submitted, with intent
to deceive, knowingly false statements to the Office in many patent applications that Respondent
was responsible for prosecuting on behalf of clients,
10, The non-lawyer assistant submitted the following types offalse statements to the
Office in patent applications that Respondent was responsible for prosecuting:
c, fabricating a United States Postal Service Express Mail label that falsely
represented a patent application had been mailed to the Office on a certain
date when, in fact, the application had never been sent to the Office; and
d, backdating certificates of mailing that falsely represented that papers had been
mailed to the Office weeks and/or months earlier than they actually had been
sent.
12, Additionally, the non-lawyer assistant electronically "cut and pasted" a digital
version of Respondent's signature and affixed it to papers filed with the Office in many patent
applications that Respondent was responsible for prosecuting on behalf of clients,
2
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 67 of 142
14. Respondent knew that the non-lawyer assistant had signed Respondent's name to
application papers submitted to the Office in many patent applications that Respondent was
responsible for prosecuting on behalf of clients.
16. Respondent represents that he did not know of the non-lawyer assistant's
misconduct described in paragraphs 9-12, above, and the non-lawyer assistant represents that he
acted alone and kept his misconduct secret from Respondent.
18. Previously, Respondent completed and returned to the OED Director the USPTO
Mandatory Survey (Form PTO 107S) issued under 37 C.F.R. § 11.1 1(a)(2). Respondent
indicated on the survey that he did not wish to remain on the register of registered practitioners
(37 C.F.R. § 11.5), and the OED Director removed Respondent from the register. Accordingly,
ptlrsuant to 37 C.F.R. § 11.10(a), Respondent is not permitted to prosecute patent applications of
others before the Office or represent others in any proceedings before the Office unless and until
he is reinstated to the register.
19. Respondent aclmowledgeS' that, based on the above stipulated facts, he violated
37 C.F.R. § 1O.77(c) (a practitioner shall not neglect a legal matter entrusted to the practitioner)
by not adequately supervising his non-lawyer assistant.
3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 68 of 142
g. Respondent shall use his best efforts to identifY each patent application that
Respondent prosecuted before the Office at any time between January 1,2004,
and December 31, 2006, that meet all of the following three conditions:
i. For each present and former client(s) identified by Respondent pursuant to the
preceding subparagraph, Respondent shall provide each such present and former
client(s) with the following documents:
j. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
4
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 69 of 142
k. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent repres'ented in connection with
U.S. Patent Application No. _ o f the specific potentially false
statements described in ~ 15 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
Application N 0._
1. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
of the specific potentially false statements described
in ~ 15 of the April! 0,2014 declaration;
m. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application No._ofthe specific potentially false statements described
in ~ 15 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
n. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) ~dent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application N o . _ of the specific potentially false statements described
in ~ 15 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
o. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application No. _ o f the specific potentially false statements described
in ~ 15 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
p. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application No._ofthe specific potentially false statements described
in ~ 16 of the April 10, 2014 declaration and the potential backdating of
certificates of mailing described in ~ 17 of the Apri110, 2014 declaration;
q. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application No. _ o f the potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in ~ 17 of the April 10, 2014 declaration; ,
r. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
5
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 70 of 142
s, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U,S, Patent
Application N o , _ o f t h e potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
t, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in counection with U, S, Patent
Application N o , _ o f t h e potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the Apri110, 2014 declaration;
u, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
fornier client(s) ~dent represented in connection with ofU,S, Patent
Application N o , _ o f t h e potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 ofthe April 10, 2014 declaration;
v, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U,S, Patent
Application No, _ o f the potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
w, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) ~dent represented in counection with U,S, Patent
Application N o , _ of the potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 ofthe April 10, 2014 declaration;
x, Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with ofU,S, Patent
Application No, _ o f the potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the April 10, 2014 declaration; ,
y. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application No. _ o f the potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the Apri110, 2014 declaration;
z. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) that Respondent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application N o . _ o f t h e potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in 'If 17 of the Apri110, 2014 declaration;3 ,
3 The patent application serial number identified in ~ 14 of the Apri110, 2014 declaration as
' _ ' is incorrect. The correct serial number i s _
6
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 71 of 142
aa. Respondent shall also provide unambiguous written notification to the present and
former client(s) ~dent represented in connection with U.S. Patent
Application N o . _ o f t h e potential backdating of certificates of mailing
described in ~ 17 of the April 10, 2014 declaration;
bb. Within 120 days of the day that the Final Order is signed, Respondent shall
submit the following to the OED Director: (1) an affidavit or declaration attesting
to his compliance with the terms of this Agreement and the Final Order for
notifying present and former client(s) as set forth in subparagraphs i. through aa.,
above, and (2) a copy of the correspondence to clients, including the written
notifications transmitted to the current and former client(s), evidencing his
compliance with the terms of this Agreement and the Final Order for notifying
present and former client(s); the client correspondence provided to the OED in
accordance with this subparagraph shall be marked "CONFIDENTIAL" by the
Respondent, and the OED shall keep the correspondence confidential;
cc. (1) lfthe OED Director is of the good faith opinion that Respondent, during
Respondent's probationary period, failed to comply with any provision of the
Agreement, this Final Order, or any provision of the USPTO Rules of
Professional Conduct, the OED Director shall:
(2) In the event that after the 3 O-day period for response and consideration of the
response, if any, received from Respondent, the OED Director continues to be of
the opinion·that Respondent, during Respondent's probationary period, failed to
comply with any provision of the Agreement, this Final Order, or any provision of
the USPTO Rilles of Professional Conduct, the OED Director shall:
(A) Deliver to the USPTO Director: (i) the Order to Show Cause;
(ii) Respondent's response to the Order to Show Cause, if any; and
(iii) argument and evidence causing the OED Director to be of the opinion that
Respondent, during Respondent's probationary period, failed to comply with
any provision of the Agreement, Final Order, or any provision of the USPTO
Rules of Professional Conduct; and
7
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 72 of 142
dd. Nothing herein shall prevent the OED Director from seeking discipline for the
misconduct leading to Respondent's suspension pursuant to the preceding
subparagraph;
ee. In the event the USPTO Director suspends Respondent pursuant to subparagraph
cc., above, and Respondent seeks a review of the suspension, any such review of
the suspension shall not operate to postpone or otherwise hold in abeyance the
suspension;
ff. The OED Director shall comply with 37 C.F.R. § 11.59 exceptthat.
and all patent application serial numbers shall be redacted
from the Final Order.
gg. The OED Director shall electronically publish the Final Order at the Office of
Enrollment and Discipline's electronic ForA Reading Room, which is publicly
accessible at http://e-foia.uspto. govlFoialOEDReadingRoom.jsp;
hh. The OED Director shall publish a notice in the Official Gazette that is materially
consistent with the following:
Notice of Discipline
8
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 73 of 142
Mr. Druce represents that he did not have actual knowledge of the
non-lawyer assistant's false submissions to the Office, and the non-
lawyer assistant represents that he acted alone and kept his misconduct
secret from Mr. Druce.
ii. Nothing in this Agreement or the Final Order approving this Agreement shall
prevent the Office from considering the record of this disciplinary proceeding (1)
when addressing any further complaint or evidence of the same or similar
misconduct concerning Respondent brought to the attention of the Office; andlor
(2) in any future disciplinary proceeding against Respondent (a) as an aggravating
factor to be taken into consideration in determining any discipline to be imposed
andlor (b) to rebut any statement or representation by or on Respondent's behalf;
jj. The OED Director shall file a motion with the administrative law judge requesting
the dismissal of the pending disciplinary proceeding within fourteen (14) days of
the date ofthe Final Order; and
9
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 74 of 142
Ide The OED Director and Respondent shall each bear their own costs incurred to date
and in carrying out the terms of this Agreement and the Final Order.
SEP - 5 20H
Wi JAMES O. PAYNE Date
Deputy General Counsel for General Law
United States Patent and Trademark Office
on behalf of
Christopher Man
Chadbourne & Parke LLP
1200 New Hampshire Ave N.W., Washington, DC 20036
Respondent's Counsel
10
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 75 of 142
EXHIBIT J
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 76 of 142
FINAL ORDER
Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § l1.27(b), the Director of the United States Patent and Trademark
Office ("USPTO" or "Office") received for review and approval from the Director of the
submitted the affidavit to the USPTO for the purpose of being excluded on consent pursuant to
37 C.F.R. § 11.27.
For the reasons set forth herein, Respondent's Affidavit of Resignation shall be approved
and Respondent shall be excluded on consent from practice before the Office in patent,
trademark, and other non-patent matters commencing on the date of this Final Order.
Jurisdiction
Respondent of San Jose, California, is a registered patent attorney (Reg. No. 26,344) and
Pursuant to 35 U.S.C. §§ 2(b)(2)(D) and 32 and 37 C.F.R. § 11.27, the USPTO Director
has the authority to approve Respondent's Affidavit of Resignation and to exclude Respondent
on consent from practice before the Office in patent, trademark, and other non-patent matters
I. His consent is freely and voluntarily rendered, and he is not being subjected to
coercion or duress.
that he violated the USPTO Rules of Professional Conduct, namely: OED File No. G2239. The
a. By Final Order dated April 12, 2013, Respondent was suspended for five years
from the practice of patent, trademark and other non-patent matters before the
USPTO for neglecting patent matters by allowing patents to expire for not timely
paying maintenance fees, fora failing to inform clients of important USPTO
correspondence and giving misleading information to clients about the status of
their patents. He also failed to conduct an inquiry reasonable under the
circumstances prior to signing and filing certain submissions with the USPTO;
b. By Final Order dated April 12,2013, Respondent was granted limited recognition
to practice before the USPTO commencing on the date the Final Order and
expiring thirty (30) days after the date the Final Order is signed, with such limited
recognition being granted for the sole purpose of facilitating Respondent's
compliance with the provisions of37 C.F.R. § 11.58(b).
d. Respondent did not inform his clients or the trademark examiner in U.S.
Trademark application nos. 85/906,074 and 85/906,085 that he was not authorized
to represent the clients before the USPTO.
3. He is aware that the disciplinary complaint pending against him alleges that he
2
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 78 of 142
Respondent acknowledges that, if and when he applies for reinstatement under 37 C.F.R. §
11.60, the OED Director will conclusively presume, for the purpose of determining the
application for reinstatement, that (a) the allegations set forth in OED File No. G2239 and
USPTO disciplinary proceeding D2014-22 are true and (b) he could not have successfully
5. Respondent has fully read and understands 37 C.F.R. §§ I 1.5 (b), 11.27,
11.58, 11.59, and 11.60, and is fully aware of the legal and factual consequences of
consenting to exclusion from practice before the USPTO in patent, trademark, and other
non-patent matters.
Exclusion on Consent
Based on the foregoing, the USPTO Director has determined that Respondent's
Affidavit of Resignation complies with the requirements of37 C.F.R. § 11.27(a). Hence, it
is ORDERED that:
b. Respondent shall be, and hereby is, excluded on consent from practice before
3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 79 of 142
the Office in patent, trademark, and other non-patent matters commencing on the date of this
Final Order;
c. The OED Director shall electronically publish this Final Order at the Office
of Emollment and Discipline's electronic ForA Reading Room, which is publicly accessible
at http://e-foia.uspto.govlFoialOEDReadingRoom.jsp;
d. The OED Director shall publish the following notice in the Official
Gazette:
4
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 80 of 142
While Mr. Tachner did not admit to any ofthe allegations at issue in the
pending disciplinary investigation or to violating any of the Disciplinary Rules
of the USPTO Code of Professional Conduct, he acknowledged that, if and
when he applies for reinstatement, the OED Director will conclusively
presume, for the purpose of determining the application for reinstatement, that
(i) the allegations set forth in OED File No. G2239 and USPTO disciplinary
proceeding D2014-22 are true, and (ii) he could not have successfully
defended himself against such allegations.
g. Respondent shall comply with 37 C.F.R. § 11.60 upon any request for
reinstatement;
h. The OED Director and Respondent shall bear their own costs incurred to date;
and
5
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 81 of 142
JUN 3 0 2014
Date SO. PAYNE
epu y General Counsel for General Law
it States Patent and Trademark Office
'oJ
on behalf of
Michelle K. Lee
Deputy Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual
Property and Deputy Director of the United States Patent and
Trademark Office
cc:
Cameron Weiffenbach
Miles & Stockbridge, P.C.
1751 Pinnacle Drive, Suite 500
McLean, Virginia 22102
Respondent's counsel
6
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 82 of 142
EXHIBIT K
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 83 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 84 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 85 of 142
EXHIBIT L
012021304 Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1567896
12/26/17 Page 86 of 142
Filed
eQQÿ
%&'%()*+ iÿni
,-./01234ÿ26ÿ3/1ÿ0-78912:-; <-703ÿ:/0-
226896
88822
28
8631 !!"0000#1
93 !!#0410" 020
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 87 of 142
EXHIBIT M
12/24/2017 Case 5:17-cv-07303Gray Reed Elects New
Document 1-1Shareholders - Gray Reed Mobile
Filed 12/26/17 Page 88 of 142
(../../../Search)
(../../../.)
Related People
Media Contacts
(https://twitter.com/grayreedlaw)
(https://www.facebook.com/GrayReedLaw)
(http://www.linkedin.com/company/grayreed)
http://m.grayreed.com/NewsResources/Press-Releases/101704/Gray-Reed-Elects-New-Shareholders 1/1
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 89 of 142
OUR PEOPLE
Travis Crabtree
Travis Crabtree brings a unique perspective to his litigation, techn
Travis graduated from the University of Missouri School of Journa
television news before embarking on a law career. More recently,
COUNSEL Reed & McGraw, he has opened and helps operate a number of e
background and experience gives him a more personal understan
D: 713.986.7149 desire for efficient and practical legal advice.
T: 713.986.7000 F: 713.730.5811
1300 Post Oak Blvd., Suite 2000, Houston, TX 77056 His technology practice focuses on media communications, online
promotion compliance, domain name disputes, policy and govern
tcrabtree@grayreed.com and audits, copyrights and trademarks, and related transactional
companies. You can explore the legal issues involved in his pract
Assistant
eMediaLaw.com. In addition, Travis represents plaintiffs and defe
Rae Lynn Cuddihy
with a particular emphasis on technology, marketing and media d
D: 713.730.5105
along with fiduciary litigation, partnership and shareholder dispute
rcuddihy@grayreed.com
His commercial litigation experience allows him to counsel clients
disputes, resolving them, trials and appeals. Most importantly, Tra
Education keep his clients out of the courtroom if he can, but aggressively re
Bar Admission Travis earned his undergraduate degree from University of Misso
University of Houston Law Center.
Court Admissions
Representative Experience - Conflicts
Practices
Defense of software audits initiated by the BSA and the SIIA
Prosecute and defend DMCA takedown notices
Reputation management for clients dealing with online defam
protection and counseling with consultants specializing in on
with the Communications Decency Act
Successfully settled DTPA and false advertising claims broug
educational provider after defeating bulk of requested injunct
Successfully defend corporate officer in case brought by ban
Travis S. liabilities for marketing and advertising misrepresentations by
Crabtree Defend minor in cyber-bullying lawsuit and a defendant in a
SELECTED IN 2014 discreet settlement
Counsel and advise clients on copyright and trademark
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 1/3
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 90 of 142
THOMSON REUTERS Assist clients in obtaining domain names that rightfully belon
purchase or arbitration claims
Successfully prevented competitor from using client's tradem
AdWords marketing program through negotiation and litigatio
Counsel clients on data breach issues including required not
Litigation regarding termination and enforceability of various
Create and help execute crisis management and media com
associated with communications internally and externally for
Successfully assisted and defended client in middle of conte
report
Defended defamation claim and obtained judgment for all att
against plaintiff prior to availability of Texas Citizens Participa
Successfully obtained several Freedom of Information ruling
help clients obtain records from various school districts and o
First-chaired a jury trial obtaining a finding that the other side
dollar claim
First-chaired a successful six-day jury trial for a minority part
development partnership. The jury awarded the client 35 tim
partnership for the minority partner's proportionate interest o
Brought a shareholder derivative and shareholder oppressio
seven-figure purchase of the minority shareholder's stock in
company on grounds including misuse of corporate assets, u
the personal benefit of the majority shareholder and misman
Serves as counsel on the national Insurance Brokerage Anti
collected large settlements for claimants nationwide.
Second-chaired a five-day jury trial for an electronic supply c
owed, plus interest and all attorney's fees while defeating the
$750,000
As lead counsel, obtained a summary judgment for a family-
by a former investor in a related transaction dismissing all of
the case was filed
First-chaired the successful defense of a chemical trading co
deficiencies in the shipment of benzene in an international a
Successfully obtained tax rebates on behalf of owners of bus
because the taxing districts failed to provide sufficient interst
Tax Code and the United States Constitution. These matters
various Appraisal Review Board proceedings, bench trials at
to the courts of appeal throughout the State of Texas.
As lead counsel for a civic club, obtained a final summary jud
injunction against various salvage yard operators prohibiting
too close to churches, schools and homes in violation of the
advocating the client 's interest at the courthouse, Travis also
with local state representatives to strengthen legislative enfo
Successfully obtained temporary restraining orders and temp
enforce non-competition agreements against former employe
Obtained a summary judgment as lead counsel in a sexual h
infliction of emotional distress claim against corporate officer
Settled a shareholder derivative lawsuit against officers of fra
confidential amount
Prosecution of several False Claims Act claims with Jim Ree
treasury of millions of dollars by presenting false claims for p
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 2/3
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 91 of 142
Assist and draft necessary agreements to transfer or obtain
applications and other technologies
Assist with basic corporate formation and initial documentati
facing technology companies
Negotiated asset purchase agreement of software company
oilfield services company in excess of $20 million
Pro bono counsel for open data citizen journalist program
Draft and negotiate international content licensing agreemen
use in East Asia.
Asses internet security, web-based business plans and proce
software and ERP implementation, outsourcing and technolo
Review and advise clients on legal and regulatory complianc
promotional programs both on and off-line
Review and analyze interactive online promotional programs
state laws and follow-up efforts to comply with Do Not Call la
Review and analyze affiliate marketing programs to avoid py
Advise clients on competitive intelligence efforts to mitigate r
Review and analyze online coupon programs to ensure lega
Draft and monitor customized online privacy policies and term
other businesses under FTC and COPPA guidelines includin
take “anonymous information” to merge with “personally iden
more traditional sales efforts
Review and analyze email marketing efforts to ensure comp
Past Experience
Sports Videographer and Producer, KCRG-TV9 (ABC), Ceda
Sports Anchor, Reporter, Producer, KOMU-TV8 (NBC), Colu
Honors
Named Top Attorney in Houston by H Texas Magazine (2013
Profiled in 2011 Rising Stars by Super Lawyers (a Thomson
Texas Monthly and Law & Politics magazine "Travis Crabtree
Named a Texas Super Lawyers - Rising Star by Super Lawy
published in Texas Monthly and Law & Politics magazine (20
© 2017 Gray Reed & McGraw LLP All rights reserved worldwide.
Home Our People Practices Industries Our Firm News/Resources Careers Contact Us Site Map Disclaimer Privacy Policy Upload Files Em
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 3/3
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 92 of 142
Travis Crabtree brings a unique perspective to his litigation, technology, media and marketing
practice. Travis graduated from the University of Missouri School of Journalism and spent
several years in television news before embarking on a law career. More recently, in addition to
serving his clients at Gray Reed & McGraw, he has opened and helps operate a number of e-
commerce businesses. His background and experience gives him a more personal
understanding of his clients’ needs and their desire for efficient and practical legal advice.
Travis earned his undergraduate degree from University of Missouri and his J.D., cum
laude, from University of Houston Law Center.
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 1/4
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 93 of 142
also assisted the client in its effort to work with local state representatives to strengthen
legislative enforcement procedures.
Successfully obtained temporary restraining orders and temporary injunctions as lead
counsel to enforce non-competition agreements against former employees and agents
Obtained a summary judgment as lead counsel in a sexual harassment, assault and
intentional infliction of emotional distress claim against corporate officer
Settled a shareholder derivative lawsuit against officers of fracing company for substantial
confidential amount
Prosecution of several False Claims Act claims with Jim Reed against companies bilking
the federal treasury of millions of dollars by presenting false claims for payment to the
Federal Government.
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 3/4
12/24/2017 Travis Crabtree
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1- Gray Reed 12/26/17
Filed & McGraw LLP Page 95 of 142
Draft and monitor customized online privacy policies and terms of use for internet
marketing and other businesses under FTC and COPPA guidelines including complex
marketing programs that take “anonymous information” to merge with “personally
identifiable information” to follow-up with more traditional sales efforts
Review and analyze email marketing efforts to ensure compliance with CAN-SPAM
Past Experience
Sports Videographer and Producer, KCRG-TV9 (ABC), Cedar Rapids, Iowa
Sports Anchor, Reporter, Producer, KOMU-TV8 (NBC), Columbia, Missouri
Honors
Named Top Attorney in Houston by H Texas Magazine (2013-2014)
Profiled in 2011 Rising Stars by Super Lawyers (a Thomson Reuters company) as
published in Texas Monthly and Law & Politics magazine "Travis Crabtree's Second Dream
Job"
Named a Texas Super Lawyers - Rising Star by Super Lawyers (a Thomson Reuters
company) as published in Texas Monthly and Law & Politics magazine (2009 - 2014)
http://www.grayreed.com/Our-People/Travis-S-Crabtree 4/4
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 96 of 142
EXHIBIT N
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 97 of 142
12/24/2017 BBB Business1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document Profile |Filed
Trademark Engine, LLCPage 98 of 142
12/26/17
Type of Entity
Limited Liability Company (LLC)
Business Management
Mr. Travis Crabtree, Owner
Business Category
Trademark Consultant
Overview
This company specializes in trademark screening, processing and research.
https://www.bbb.org/houston/business-reviews/trademark-agents-and-consultants/trademark-engine-llc-in-houston-tx-90044544 1/3
12/24/2017 BBB Business1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document Profile |Filed
Trademark Engine, LLCPage 99 of 142
12/26/17
BBB Reports On
Licensing
Licensing information is provided in the BBB Business Profiles to inform the public about industries that
may require professional licensing, bonding, or registration. Better Business Bureau encourages you to
check with the appropriate agency to be certain any requirements are currently being met.
Advertising Review
BBB promotes truth in advertising by contacting advertisers whose claims conflict with the BBB Code of
Advertising. These claims come to our attention from our internal review of advertising, consumer
complaints and competitor challenges. BBB asks advertisers to substantiate their claims, change ads to
make offers more clear to consumers, and remove misleading or deceptive statements.
Government Actions
BBB reports on known significant government actions involving the business's marketplace conduct.
Out of Business
BBB reports on a company that is out of business for one year from the date the company closes its doors
or ceases to do business.
Bankruptcy
BBB reports on a business’s bankruptcy as long as the business remains in bankruptcy.
Mail Returned
BBB reports when mail sent to the business was returned by the Postal Service.
NR
BBB Rating System Overview (https://www.bbb.org/council/overview-of-bbb-grade)
https://www.bbb.org/houston/business-reviews/trademark-agents-and-consultants/trademark-engine-llc-in-houston-tx-90044544 2/3
12/24/2017 BBB Business1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ProfileFiled
| Trademark Engine, LLC
12/26/17 Page 100 of 142
The BBB Customer Review Rating represents the customer's opinion of the business. The Customer Review Rating
percentages are based on the total number of positive, neutral, and negative reviews posted.
BBB Business Profiles may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes.
BBB Business Profiles are provided solely to assist you in exercising your own best judgment. Information in this
BBB Business Profile is believed reliable, but not guaranteed as to accuracy.
When considering complaint information, please take into account the company's size and volume of transactions,
and understand that the nature of complaints and a firm's responses to them are often more important than the
number of complaints.
BBB Business Profiles generally cover a three-year reporting period. BBB Business Profiles are subject to change
at any time. If you choose to do business with this business, please let the business know that you contacted BBB
for a BBB Business Profile.
For Consumers
File a Complaint (/consumer-complaints/file-a-complaint/get-started)
BBB Scam Tracker (//www.bbb.org/scamtracker/us)
File an Auto Warranty Complaint (//www.bbb.org/autoline)
For Businesses
Become Accredited (//whybbb.org)
BBB EU Privacy Shield (//www.bbb.org/EU-privacy-shield)
About BBB
BBB Directory (http://www.bbb.org/bbb-locator)
Give.org (http://www.give.org)
Council of Better Business Bureaus (https://www.bbb.org/council)
Contact (https://www.bbb.org/houston/get-to-know-us/contact)
BBB Business Partner Code (https://www.bbb.org/en/us/partner-code-of-conduct)
Mission & Vision (https://www.bbb.org/en/us/mission-and-vision)
© 2017, Council of Better Business Bureaus, Inc., separately incorporated Better Business
Bureau organizations in the US, Canada and Mexico, and BBB Institute for Marketplace
Trust. All Rights Reserved.
https://www.bbb.org/houston/business-reviews/trademark-agents-and-consultants/trademark-engine-llc-in-houston-tx-90044544 3/3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 101 of 142
EXHIBIT O
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 102 of 142
DESCRIPTION
Everest Clay is a real estate
brokerage in California that will
also do property management
and create a website to help
them find their real house as well
as find their own real estate
investments. We will also self
manage my properties.
Chat on December 5, 2017 at 12:39pm
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 103 of 142
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 104 of 142
EXHIBIT P
12/24/2017 Please
Case CONFIRM Your Application Document
5:17-cv-07303 Details - Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
105 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
P l e a s e C O N F I R M Yo u r
Application Details
We are ready to file your application. Please confirm the information below and approve
your application.
2. We have collected your $275 USPTO filing fee, which is the government fee for
Approve by “signing” here by using a forward slash, then your name, and a forward
slash. Example /John Doe/. By signing and approving, you are verifying subject to
perjury that:
1. You are the owner of the mark, it is used in commerce or you intend to use it in
commerce and believe you have the right to do so and the specimen (if
applicable, concurrent users, have the right to use the mark in commerce,
3. To the best of the signatory's knowledge, information, and belief, formed after
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/%22Trademark+Engine%22/160531f671b575a7 1/3
12/24/2017 Please
Case CONFIRM Your Application Document
5:17-cv-07303 Details - Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
106 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
factual contentions made above have evidentiary support.
4. You understand that willful false statements and the like are punishable by fine
or imprisonment, or both, under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, and that such willful false
statements and the like may jeopardize the validity of the application or
submission or any registration resulting therefrom, and thus you declare that all
statements made of your own knowledge are true and that all statements made
Type: Name
Address: 1580 W. El Camino Real Suite 14, Mountain View, Mountain View, CA, 94040
Email: raj@legalforcelaw.com
Phone: 4083983126
Description: Everest Clay is a real estate brokerage in California that will also do
property management and create a website to help them find their real house as well as
find their own real estate investments. We will also self manage my properties.
SUGGESTED Class: 036 - Insurance and Financial and Real Estate Affairs
SUGGESTED Description: Real estate brokerage; Real estate service, namely, rental
field of real estate concerning the purchase and sale of new and resale homes and
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/%22Trademark+Engine%22/160531f671b575a7 2/3
12/24/2017 Please
Case CONFIRM Your Application Document
5:17-cv-07303 Details - Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
107 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
condos; Real estate investment services; Real estate investment services in the nature
of purchasing and selling of real estate for others; Financial investment in the field of
Additional Comments: If you would like to file with the suggested class or class
If you believe there is a need for any changes, or you are ready to provide your
signature, please click on the "Submit Signature OR Request Change" button below. You
will be taken to your account where you can take further action. As always reach out to
or phone 1-877-721-4579.
1 In some circumstances, we may be able to use the less-available TEAS PLUS system which means we will pay $225 to
the USPTO which streamlines the process. If we are able to use it without changing the substance of your application, we
will use it and retain the difference between the TEAS RF filing fee and the TEAS Plus filing fee as a result of the additional
processing by the Trademark Engine. By signing here, you authorize the Trademark Engine to sign your name on the
application in the exact same format.
Trademark Engine provides information and software only. Trademark Engine is not a "lawyer referral service" and does
not provide legal advice or participate in any legal representation. Use of Trademark Engine is subject to our Terms of
Service and Privacy Policy.
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/%22Trademark+Engine%22/160531f671b575a7 3/3
12/24/2017 Your5:17-cv-07303
Case Trademark Engine LLC Document
receipt [#1608-9720]
1-1 - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 - LegalForce RAPC
Page 108 ofWorldwide
142 Mail
Description Amount
Total $198.00
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/%24198/1602872a9eb4195e 1/1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 109 of 142
EXHIBIT Q
12/24/2017 Comprehensive Search Report Completed
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document- Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
110 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
Comprehensive SearchReport
Because the application processing fees are non-refundable, we have not processed your application
before giving you a chance to review your search results. Your searchresults have been included in this
email for your review. Now that your results are available, let us know what you would like us to do before
we process your application. PLEASE NOTE THAT IF YOU DO NOT PICK ONE OF THESE OPTIONS
WITHIN 7 DAYS, WE WILL PROCESS YOUR ORDER AND YOUR APPLICATION PROCESSING FEE
WILL BECOME NON-REFUNDABLE. We are not a law firm and cannot provide legal advice regarding
your search results. You may want to review them with counsel to consider your options. After you have
reviewed your search results listed below, you can tell us what to do through your online account and notify
us there.
Your results are below. The first section is the federal trademark search results. You can click on the
hyperlinked serial number to learn more about these other filings. Next is the state trademark results.
Unfortunately, many of the state results do not offer online viewing. Next comes the common law entity
results which include business filings and several business directories. Following that is the common law
web results that show where your mark may be in use online by others. Finally, if applicable, you will find
the international results which includes hits from the World Intellectual Property Organization ("WIPO") and
DATE
TRADEMARK STATUS SERIAL
FILED
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/search+report+trademark+engine/1602c5a0f1c25c6f 1/5
12/24/2017 Comprehensive Search Report Completed
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document- Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
111 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
EVEREST CLAY 02/23/2002 ABANDONED- 78110674
REALTORS FAILURE TO
RESPOND
OR LATE
RESPONSE
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/search+report+trademark+engine/1602c5a0f1c25c6f 3/5
12/24/2017 Comprehensive Search Report Completed
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document- Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
113 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
Not included with your search order level
File My Application: Even if the matches are similar to your name, your application may still get approved.
If the two marks are used in completely different industries, there is less chance of confusion and your mark
has a greater chance of approval. For example, “Sonic” is used by the hamburger drive-in, an oil and gas
driller, a wireless router access point and a car among others. There is little chance a consumer is going to
believe they are all associated with the same company. Please note, a rejection from the USPTO will not
Run a more comprehensive search: You may consider conducting a more comprehensive search to
better assess the availability of your mark before we process your application. We have a variety
of search options for you that can be purchased independently or as part of an economical package. Your
application has been saved, so with a few clicks we can add more comprehensive searches to your order.
Try another mark: You may want to make a slight variation to your mark that may give you a better chance
at approval. Your information has been saved in your account, so you would simply choose this option and
provide a new mark with a few clicks. We will run the same search and continue the process with the new
mark.
To submit your response, simply click on the "Give My Response" button below. If you have any questions
whatsoever regarding your options, please do not hesitate to contact us, we are more than happy to assist.
Give My Response
We use commercially reasonable methods to identify marks that may be matches to the ones you seek to
use. We, however, cannot guarantee that your mark will make it through and be approved even if you use
our search services. There may be a number of reasons the USPTO rejects your mark and there are
circumstances where an automated search may not identify a mark the USPTO identifies as a reason to
reject your mark. We cannot guarantee that your mark will be free of or prevail to all claims or challenges
made by holders of common law rights to all marks. There are circumstances where an
automated search may not identify a common law mark that may be similar to your mark.
The purpose of the search report is to provide you with marks to satisfy the parameters identified for the
type of search you use. It is not meant to be legal advice as to whether your proposed mark will be
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/search+report+trademark+engine/1602c5a0f1c25c6f 4/5
12/24/2017 Comprehensive Search Report Completed
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document- Trademark
1-1Engine - raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 Page - LegalForce
114 ofRAPC
142Worldwide Mail
rejected or whether it would be considered similar to another mark. You may want to consult with an
attorney regarding the results of the search report we furnish you.
Trademark Engine provides information and software only. Trademark Engine is not a "lawyer referral service" and does not
provide legal advice or participate in any legal representation. Use of Trademark Engine is subject to our Terms of
Service and Privacy Policy.
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/search+report+trademark+engine/1602c5a0f1c25c6f 5/5
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 115 of 142
EXHIBIT R
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 116 of 142
1. You are the owner of the mark, it is used in commerce or you intend to use it in commerce and believe you have the right to do so and the specimen (if applicable) shows the mark as used in commerce.
2. To the best of your knowledge and belief, no other persons, except, if applicable, concurrent users, have the right to use the mark in commerce, either in the identical form or in such near resemblance as to be
likely, when used on or in connection with the goods/services of such other persons, to cause confusion or mistake, or to deceive.
3. To the best of the signatory's knowledge, information, and belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, the allegations and other factual contentions made above have evidentiary
support.
4. You understand that willful false statements and the like are punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both, under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, and that such willful false statements and the like may jeopardize the validity of
the application or submission or any registration resulting therefrom, and thus you declare that all statements made of your own knowledge are true and that all statements made on information and belief are
believed to be true.
5. By signing, you are authorizing us to collect from you $275 per class as the USPTO filing fee.
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 117 of 142
EXHIBIT S
12/24/2017 Application Filed - Trademark
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Engine - 1-1
Document raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 - LegalForce
Page RAPC
118Worldwide
of 142 Mail
Application Filed
Great news! Your trademark application has been filed with the USPTO. You should have
received or will receive an email from an USPTO.GOV email account that contains a
If you do not receive the email within 24 hours from now, please let us know.
Because USPTO applications are publicly-available on the internet, you are likely going
to receive solicitations from private companies other than Trademark Engine. Some of
these companies try to use names similar to or formal looking documentation to make it
appear their solicitations come from the USPTO. All official USPTO correspondence will
be mailed only from the “United States Patent and Trademark Office” in Alexandria, VA;
or sent by e-mail from the domain “@uspto.gov.” The official Trademark Engine
At this time, the USPTO is taking about three to five months to process
Check into your account at any time to check the status, see pertinent documents and
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/trademark+engine/1606b38d2a3ad758 1/2
12/24/2017 Application Filed - Trademark
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Engine - 1-1
Document raj@legalforcelaw.com
Filed 12/26/17 - LegalForce
Page RAPC
119Worldwide
of 142 Mail
Trademark Engine provides information and software only. Trademark Engine is not a "lawyer referral service" and does
not provide legal advice or participate in any legal representation. Use of Trademark Engine is subject to our Terms of
Service and Privacy Policy.
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#search/trademark+engine/1606b38d2a3ad758 2/2
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 120 of 142
EXHIBIT T
12/24/2017 trademark
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1filingFiled
- Google Search
12/26/17 Page 121 of 142
trademark filing
Filing Your Application Online - United States Patent and Trademark ...
https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks-application.../ ling.../ ling-your-application-online
Filing Your Application Online - United States Patent and Trademark ...
https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks-application.../ ling.../ ling-your-application-onlin...
Dec 15, 2011 - TEAS can be accessed at http://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/teas/index.jsp. You must
decide which application ling option to use, namely, TEAS Plus, TEAS Reduced Fee (TEAS RF), or TEAS
Regular. The TEAS Plus ling option has a ling fee of $225 per class of goods or services, but has the
strictest requirements.
https://www.google.com/search?q=trademark+filing&oq=trademark+filing&aqs=chrome..69i57j0j69i60j69i61j69i60j0.1700j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UT… 1/3
12/24/2017 trademark
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1filingFiled
- Google Search
12/26/17 Page 122 of 142
Sep 29, 2014 - Use an initial application form to le an application electronically to register a trademark
for goods or a servicemark for services. ... Check out our trademark initial application forms
comparison chart. ... Watch our TEAS “nuts-and-bolts” video series on how to ll out initial ...
https://www.google.com/search?q=trademark+filing&oq=trademark+filing&aqs=chrome..69i57j0j69i60j69i61j69i60j0.1700j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UT… 2/3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 123 of 142
EXHIBIT U
12/24/2017 trademark1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document registration
Filed - Google Search Page 124 of 142
12/26/17
trademark registration
The trademark registration process is a legal proceeding that requires you to act
within strict deadlines (based on Eastern Time). See the trademark application and
post-registration timelines. Jul 4, 2009
https://www.google.com/search?ei=zd4_WvmsDsyMjwSDpYvIAQ&q=trademark+registration&oq=trademark+registration&gs_l=psy-ab.3...32449.3364… 1/3
12/24/2017 trademark1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document registration
Filed - Google Search Page 125 of 142
12/26/17
Search trademark database | USPTO
https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks-application-process/search-trademark-database
Jul 4, 2009 - Although not required prior to ling an application, you are encouraged to search the
USPTO's trademark database to see if any mark has already been registered or applied for that is
similar to your mark and used on related products or for related services. If your search yields a mark
that you think might ...
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next
https://www.google.com/search?ei=zd4_WvmsDsyMjwSDpYvIAQ&q=trademark+registration&oq=trademark+registration&gs_l=psy-ab.3...32449.3364… 2/3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 126 of 142
EXHIBIT V
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 127 of 142
!"#$%ÿ'(ÿ)"#*+,"
-./012/.3ÿ567861ÿ-1.29ÿ:;ÿ<1.=8>1
?@ÿA%+BCÿDE"ÿ!#FG"$F#HÿIBC+B"J,'$ÿK"L%+D"ÿMDE"ÿNO"L%+D"PQRÿ@'AÿFC#""ÿD'ÿDE"%"ÿD"#$%ÿFBGÿ,'BG+D+'B%ÿF%ÿFBÿFC#""$"BDÿL@ÿFBG
L"DK""Bÿ@'AÿFBGÿ!#FG"$F#HÿIBC+B"J,'$ÿFBGÿ!#FG"$F#HÿIBC+B"RÿSSTÿM#"("##"GÿD'ÿF%ÿNK"PRÿNA%Pÿ'#ÿN'A#PQJÿ!E+%ÿUC#""$"BDÿFV%'
+B,'#W'#FD"%ÿ'A#ÿX#+*F,@ÿX'V+,@ÿF%ÿ+(ÿ%"Dÿ('#DEÿFDÿV"BCDEÿE"#"+BJÿY(ÿ@'AÿG'ÿB'DÿK+%EÿD'ÿFC#""ÿD'ÿDE"%"ÿD"#$%RÿWV"F%"ÿ#"(#F+Bÿ(#'$
A%+BCÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"J
Z1ÿ[.:=801ÿ7161./\ÿ86;:.2/]8:6ÿ.1\/]10ÿ]:ÿ]./012/.39ÿ/60ÿ[.:=801ÿ/ÿ^1_98]1ÿ]`/]ÿ/\\:^9ÿa:bÿ]:ÿ[.1[/.1
/60ÿc\1ÿ]./012/.39dÿZ1ÿ/.1ÿ6:]ÿ/ÿ\/^ÿc.2dÿZ1ÿ0:ÿ6:]ÿ[.:=801ÿ/60ÿ>/66:]ÿ[.:=801ÿ\17/\ÿ/0=8>1ÿ]:ÿa:bd
-ef<ÿghi55j5k-lÿm5noZlÿpok-gfk<ÿgÿmfkqfkhÿgimf-ig-fokÿriosf<fokÿhos5ik5qÿmtÿ-e5ÿu5q5ign
gimf-ig-fokÿgp-ÿgkqÿgÿZgfs5iÿouÿpng<<ÿgp-fok<d
p:608]8:69ÿ]:ÿv91ÿ:b.ÿZ1_98]1
w'A#ÿW"#$+%%+'BÿD'ÿA%"ÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"ÿ+%ÿ,'BG+D+'B"GÿAW'Bÿ@'A#ÿFC#""$"BDÿDEFDÿ@'Ax
yÿK+VVÿ,'$WV@ÿK+DEÿDE"%"ÿ!"#$%ÿ'(ÿz%"{
yÿ@'AÿF#"ÿ|}ÿ@"F#%ÿ'(ÿFC"ÿ'#ÿ'VG"#{
yÿK+VVÿB'Dÿ,'W@ÿ'#ÿG+%D#+LAD"ÿFB@ÿWF#Dÿ'(ÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"ÿ+BÿFB@ÿ$FBB"#ÿK+DE'ADÿ'A#ÿW#+'#ÿK#+DD"Bÿ,'B%"BD{
yÿK+VVÿW#'*+G"ÿF,,A#FD"ÿ+B('#$FD+'BÿKE"Bÿ,#"FD+BCÿFBÿF,,'ABDRÿ%AL$+DD+BCÿ,'BD"BDÿ'#ÿ#"C+%D"#+BCÿ('#ÿ'A#ÿO"L%+D"{
yÿK+VVÿB'DÿFVV'Kÿ'DE"#%ÿD'ÿA%"ÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"ÿABG"#ÿ@'A#ÿz%"#ÿY~{
yÿF#"ÿ%'V"V@ÿ#"%W'B%+LV"ÿ('#ÿ@'A#ÿz%"#ÿY~ÿFBGÿDE"ÿF,D+*+D@ÿDEFDÿ',,A#%ÿDE#'ACEÿ@'A#ÿz%"#ÿY~{
yÿK+VVÿB'DÿA%"ÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"ÿ('#ÿFB@ÿ,'$$"#,+FVÿWA#W'%"%ÿ'DE"#ÿDEFBÿDE"ÿ%W",+(+,ÿ,'$$"#,+FVÿF,D+*+D+"%ÿ,'BDF+B"Gÿ'BÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"
FBGÿK+VVÿB'DÿA%"ÿ+DÿD'ÿ'LDF+BÿGFDFÿ'#ÿW"#%'BFVÿ+B('#$FD+'BÿFL'ADÿFB@ÿ'DE"#ÿA%"#%ÿ'#ÿD'ÿ%'V+,+Dÿ'DE"#ÿA%"#%ÿ'#ÿFG*"#D+%"#%{
yÿF#"ÿ%'V"V@ÿ#"%W'B%+LV"ÿ('#ÿFB@ÿ,'BD"BDÿW#'*+G"GÿL@ÿ@'Aÿ'BÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"Rÿ+B,VAG+BCÿLADÿB'DÿV+$+D"GÿD'ÿFB@ÿG+%,A%%+'BÿW'%D%RÿW#'(+V"
+B('#$FD+'BRÿV+BH%Rÿ*+G"'%ÿFBGÿW+,DA#"%ÿ+B,VAG+BCÿDE"ÿ'KB"#%E+Wÿ'(ÿFB@ÿV+,"B%"%ÿ'#ÿ#+CED%ÿB","%%F#@ÿD'ÿA%"ÿDE"ÿK'#Hÿ'(ÿ'DE"#%ÿFBG
K+VVÿB'Dÿ%AL$+DÿFB@ÿ,'W@#+CED"Gÿ$FD"#+FV%ÿ'#ÿK'#Hÿ%AL",DÿD'ÿ'DE"#%ÿW#'W#+"DF#@ÿ#+CED%{
yÿC#FBDÿDE"ÿO"L%+D"ÿFBGÿ'DE"#ÿA%"#%ÿFÿB'B",VA%+*"ÿV+,"B%"ÿD'ÿ#"FGÿ@'A#ÿ$FD"#+FV%ÿFBGÿD'ÿA%"Rÿ#"W#'GA,"RÿG+%D#+LAD"RÿW#"WF#"
G"#+*FD+*"ÿK'#H%ÿ'(ÿFBG'#ÿG+%WVF@ÿFB@ÿ$FD"#+FV%ÿW#'*+G"GÿL@ÿ@'A{ÿFBG
yÿFC#""ÿK"ÿEF*"ÿDE"ÿ#+CEDÿD'ÿ#"$'*"ÿFB@ÿFBG'#ÿFVVÿ'(ÿ@'A#ÿ,'BD"BDÿFBGÿD"#$+BFD"ÿ@'A#ÿF,,'ABDÿK+DEÿ'#ÿK+DE'ADÿW#+'#ÿB'D+,"J
t:b.ÿg>>:b6]r.:c\1
228798779272789
787 0200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 128 of 142
!"ÿ$%%&''ÿ%&()$*+ÿ,$()'ÿ"-ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&1ÿ2&ÿ3$4ÿ(&56*(&ÿ4"6ÿ)"ÿ%(&$)&ÿ$+ÿ$%%"6+)ÿ$+78"(ÿ,("-*9&:ÿ;99ÿ'6%.ÿ*+-"(3$)*"+ÿ,("<*7&7ÿ04
4"6ÿ'.$99ÿ0&ÿ$%%6($)&ÿ$+7ÿ4"6ÿ$=(&&ÿ)"ÿ>&&,ÿ'$*7ÿ*+-"(3$)*"+ÿ6,ÿ)"ÿ7$)&:ÿ;+4"+&ÿ2."'&ÿ,(*<*9&=&ÿ)"ÿ6'&ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&ÿ2$'
,(&<*"6'94ÿ)&(3*+$)&7ÿ04ÿ6'ÿ3$4ÿ+")ÿ(&=*')&(ÿ-"(ÿ$+").&(ÿ,("-*9&ÿ"(ÿ$%%"6+)1ÿ+"(ÿ6'&ÿ$+").&(?'ÿ,("-*9&ÿ"(ÿ$%%"6+)ÿ)"ÿ6'&ÿ).&ÿ'*)&
"(ÿ%(&$)&ÿ$+ÿ$%%"6+)ÿ"+ÿ4"6(ÿ0&.$9-:
@&%$6'&ÿ'.$(*+=ÿA'&(ÿBC'ÿ*'ÿ,(".*0*)&7ÿ2&ÿ$''63&ÿ).$)ÿ$%%&''ÿ)"ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&ÿ).("6=.ÿ4"6(ÿA'&(ÿBCÿ*'1ÿ*+ÿ-$%)1ÿ4"6:ÿD"6ÿ$(&
'"9&94ÿ(&',"+'*09&ÿ-"(ÿ$+4ÿ$+7ÿ$99ÿ$%%&''ÿ)"ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&ÿ04ÿ,&('"+'ÿ6'*+=ÿ4"6(ÿA'&(ÿBC:ÿB-ÿ4"6ÿ0&9*&<&ÿ4"6(ÿA'&(ÿBCÿ*'ÿ0&*+=ÿ6'&7
2*)."6)ÿ$6)."(*E$)*"+1ÿ+")*-4ÿ6'ÿ*33&7*$)&94ÿ$)ÿ'6,,"()F)($7&3$(>&+=*+&:%"3ÿG3$*9)"H'6,,"()F)($7&3$(>&+=*+&:%"3I
JKLMÿOKPQRPQ
/&ÿ(&'&(<&ÿ).&ÿ(*=.)ÿ)"ÿ$6)."(*E&ÿ).&ÿ,609*'.*+=ÿ"-ÿ<$(*"6'ÿ%"+)&+)ÿ,("<*7&7ÿ04ÿ4"6ÿG.&(&*+$-)&(ÿSA'&(ÿT&+&($)&7ÿU"+)&+)ÿ"(
ATUVI:ÿD"6ÿ$=(&&ÿ+")ÿ)"ÿ,"')ÿ"(ÿ6'&ÿ$+4ÿATUÿ*+ÿ$+4ÿ2$4ÿ).$)H
Wÿ*+-(*+=&'ÿ).&ÿ%",4(*=.)1ÿ)($7&3$(>1ÿ)($7&ÿ'&%(&)1ÿ"(ÿ").&(ÿ*+)&99&%)6$9ÿ,(",&()4ÿ"(ÿ,(",(*&)$(4ÿ(*=.)'ÿ"-ÿ").&('X
Wÿ<*"9$)&'ÿ).&ÿ,(*<$%41ÿ,609*%*)41ÿ"(ÿ").&(ÿ(*=.)'ÿ"-ÿ).*(7ÿ,$()*&'X
Wÿ*'ÿ6+9$2-691ÿ-$9'&1ÿ*+$%%6($)&1ÿ7&-$3$)"(41ÿ7*'%(*3*+$)"(41ÿ9*0&9"6'1ÿ,"(+"=($,.*%1ÿ"0'%&+&1ÿ$06'*<&1ÿ).(&$)&+*+=1ÿ.$($''*+=1
.$)&-691ÿ"(ÿ&+%"6($=&'ÿ%"+76%)ÿ).$)ÿ2"697ÿ0&ÿ%"+'*7&(&7ÿ$ÿ%(*3*+$9ÿ"--&+'&1ÿ=*<&ÿ(*'&ÿ)"ÿ%*<*9ÿ9*$0*9*)41ÿ<*"9$)&ÿ$+4ÿ9$21ÿ"(ÿ*'
").&(2*'&ÿ*+$,,(",(*$)&1ÿ$'ÿ7&)&(3*+&7ÿ04ÿ6'ÿ*+ÿ"6(ÿ'"9&ÿ7*'%(&)*"+Xÿ"(
Wÿ%"697ÿ7$3$=&ÿ"6(ÿ%"3,$+41ÿ,$(&+)ÿ%"3,$+41ÿ'*')&(ÿ%"3,$+*&'1ÿ$--*9*$)&'1ÿ$7<&()*'&('1ÿ"(ÿ").&(ÿ,$()*&':
/&ÿ$(&ÿ+")ÿ"09*=$)&7ÿ*+ÿ$+4ÿ2$4ÿ)"ÿ(&3"<&ÿ$+4ÿATUÿ).$)ÿ3$4ÿ<*"9$)&ÿ"+&ÿ"(ÿ3"(&ÿ"-ÿ).&'&ÿ(&')(*%)*"+':ÿ/&ÿ3$41ÿ06)ÿ$(&ÿ+")
"09*=$)&7ÿ)"1ÿ(&3"<&ÿ$+4ÿATUÿ*+ÿ<*"9$)*"+'ÿ"-ÿ).&'&ÿ)&(3'1ÿ)&(3*+$)&ÿ6'&(ÿ$%%"6+)'ÿ"(ÿ)$>&ÿ").&(ÿ$%)*"+':ÿ/&ÿ$(&ÿ+")
(&',"+'*09&ÿ-"(ÿ$+4ÿ.$(3ÿ)"ÿ4"6ÿ%$6'&7ÿ04ÿATU:
JKLMÿOKPYLZQ
@4ÿ6'*+=ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&1ÿD"6ÿ$=(&&ÿ+")ÿ)"H
Wÿ%"+76%)ÿ"(ÿ,("3")&ÿ$+4ÿ*99&=$9ÿ$%)*<*)*&'X
Wÿ$))&3,)ÿ)"ÿ(&<&('&ÿ&+=*+&&(ÿ"(ÿ*+)&(-&(&ÿ*+ÿ$+4ÿ2$4ÿ2*).ÿ).&ÿ-6+%)*"+*+=ÿ"-ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&ÿ"(ÿ").&(2*'&ÿ$))&3,)ÿ)"ÿ7&(*<&ÿ).&
'"6(%&ÿ%"7&ÿ"-ÿ).&ÿ'"-)2$(&ÿG*+%967*+=ÿ).&ÿ)""9'1ÿ3&)."7'1ÿ,("%&''&'1ÿ$+7ÿ*+-($')(6%)6(&IX
Wÿ$))&3,)ÿ)"ÿ=$*+ÿ$%%&''ÿ)"ÿ'&%6(&7ÿ,"()*"+'ÿ"-ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&X
Wÿ6'&ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&ÿ)"ÿ=&+&($)&ÿ6+'"9*%*)&7ÿ&3$*9ÿ$7<&()*'&3&+)'ÿ"(ÿ',$3X
Wÿ6'&ÿ$+4ÿ$6)"3$)*%ÿ"(ÿ3$+6$9ÿ,("%&''ÿ)"ÿ'&$(%.ÿ"(ÿ.$(<&')ÿ*+-"(3$)*"+ÿ-("3ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&X
Wÿ*+)&(-&(&ÿ*+ÿ$+4ÿ2$4ÿ2*).ÿ).&ÿ,(",&(ÿ-6+%)*"+*+=ÿ"-ÿ).&ÿ/&0'*)&Xÿ"(
Wÿ*3,&('"+$)&ÿ$+").&(ÿ6'&(:
[\P]^ÿQKÿ_Q`RMÿa\QR^
228798779272789
787 1200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 129 of 142
"#ÿ%&'ÿ(&)#ÿ*+,-.ÿ/0ÿ/(+1234&1/'ÿ5#6.+/#.ÿ/(&/ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ05,#27ÿ80,/10**#2ÿ01ÿ04#1&/#2ÿ6'ÿ9.:ÿ"#ÿ20ÿ,0/ÿ&..9%#ÿ&,'
1#.40,.+6+*+/'ÿ;01ÿ/(#ÿ80,/#,/7ÿ41+)&8'ÿ40*+8+#.7ÿ01ÿ41&8/+8#.ÿ0;ÿ&,'ÿ0/(#1ÿ5#6.+/#.ÿ01ÿ/(#+1ÿ05,#1.:ÿ"#ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ#,201.+,<ÿ01
1#80%%#,2+,<ÿ&,'ÿ0/(#1ÿ5#6.+/#.7ÿ410298/.ÿ01ÿ.#1)+8#.ÿ6'ÿ/(#ÿ.+%4*#ÿ+,8*9.+0,ÿ0;ÿ&ÿ*+,-ÿ/0ÿ&,0/(#1ÿ5#6.+/#:
=>?@ABCDAEB
"#ÿ1#.#1)#ÿ/(#ÿ1+<(/ÿ/0ÿ&*/#1ÿ01ÿ2+.80,/+,9#ÿ/(#ÿ"#6.+/#ÿ01ÿ&,'ÿ0;ÿ/(#ÿ.#1)+8#.ÿ410)+2#2ÿ(#1#+,ÿ&/ÿ&,'ÿ/+%#ÿ5+/(09/ÿ41+01ÿ,0/+8#:
"#ÿ&*.0ÿ1#.#1)#ÿ/(#ÿ1+<(/ÿ/0ÿ/#1%+,&/#ÿ/(+.ÿF<1##%#,/ÿ&/ÿ091ÿ#*#8/+0,ÿ&,2ÿ;01ÿ&,'ÿ1#&.0,7ÿ5+/(09/ÿ41+01ÿ,0/+8#:ÿG(+.ÿF<1##%#,/
5+**ÿ&9/0%&/+8&**'ÿ/#1%+,&/#ÿ+;7ÿ+,ÿ091ÿ.0*#ÿ2+.81#/+0,7ÿ'09ÿ)+0*&/#ÿ&,'ÿ0;ÿ/(#ÿ/#1%.ÿ&,2ÿ80,2+/+0,.ÿ.#/ÿ;01/(ÿ6#*05:ÿFÿ/#1%+,&/+0,
5+**ÿ1#.9*/ÿ+,ÿ/(#ÿ+%%#2+&/#ÿ8#..&/+0,ÿ0;ÿ&88#..ÿ/0ÿ/(#ÿ"#6.+/#:ÿG(#ÿH+.8*&+%#1.ÿ0;ÿ"&11&,/'ÿ&,2ÿI+%+/&/+0,ÿ0;ÿI+&6+*+/'7
J,2#%,+/'7ÿH+.49/#ÿK#.0*9/+0,ÿ.#8/+0,.ÿ&,2ÿ&**ÿ/#1%.ÿ&,2ÿ80,2+/+0,.ÿ1#*&/#2ÿ/0ÿ'091ÿL0,/#,/ÿ.(&**ÿ.91)+)#ÿ/(#ÿ/#1%+,&/+0,ÿ0;ÿ/(+.
F<1##%#,/:
MANOPCQÿESÿTCDCÿCBTÿU>C?VW
"#ÿ1#*'ÿ940,ÿ<0)#1,%#,/ÿ1#8012.ÿ&,2ÿ%&'ÿ2+.4*&'ÿ/(#%ÿ0,ÿ/(+.ÿ5#6.+/#:ÿ"(+*#ÿ5#ÿ/1'ÿ/0ÿ9.#ÿ/(#ÿ%0./ÿ1#8#,/ÿ+,;01%&/+0,
&)&+*&6*#7ÿ5#ÿ8&,,0/ÿ<9&1&,/##ÿ+/.ÿ&8891&8'ÿ01ÿ/+%#*+,#..:
XCP>BTC?ÿY>@ABT>?N
F.ÿ4&1/ÿ0;ÿ091ÿ.#1)+8#.7ÿ5#ÿ%&'ÿ0;;#1ÿ1#%+,2#1.ÿ01ÿ,0/+;+8&/+0,.ÿ&609/ÿ8#1/&+,ÿ2#&2*+,#.ÿ/(&/ÿ%&'ÿ&44*'ÿ/0ÿ'091ÿ/1&2#%&1-:
G(#.#ÿ,0/+;+8&/+0,.ÿ&1#ÿ;01ÿ+,;01%&/+0,&*ÿ49140.#.ÿ0,*'ÿ&,2ÿ&1#ÿ/(#ÿ<#,#1&*ÿ./&,2&12.ÿ&44*+8&6*#ÿ/0ÿ%0./ÿ/1&2#%&1-.:ÿZ091
4&1/+89*&1ÿ.+/9&/+0,ÿ%&'ÿ6#ÿ2+;;#1#,/ÿ/(&,ÿ/(#ÿ<#,#1&*ÿ<9+2#*+,#.ÿ&,2ÿ'09ÿ.(09*2ÿ80,.+2#1ÿ80,.9*/+,<ÿ5+/(ÿ&ÿ*+8#,.#2ÿ&//01,#'
1#<&12+,<ÿ/(#ÿ&44*+8&6*#ÿ2#&2*+,#.ÿ/(&/ÿ&44*'ÿ/0ÿ'091ÿ.4#8+;+8ÿ.+/9&/+0,:ÿ"#ÿ20ÿ,0/ÿ0;;#1ÿ*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#ÿ&,2ÿ/(#ÿ&9/0%&/#2
,0/+;+8&/+0,.ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#ÿ01ÿ*#<&*ÿ+,/#141#/&/+0,.ÿ6&.#2ÿ0,ÿ'091ÿ.4#8+;+8.:
X?>CDAEBÿESÿ[E?@NÿCBTÿMANVPCA@>?
"#ÿ&1#ÿ&ÿ/#8(,0*0<'ÿ4*&/;01%ÿ/(&/ÿ(#*4.ÿ81#&/#ÿ;01%.ÿ&,2ÿ5#ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ&ÿ*&5ÿ;+1%ÿ01ÿ*#<&*ÿ.#1)+8#ÿ410)+2#1:ÿ\(09*2ÿ'09ÿ4918(&.#
0,#ÿ01ÿ%01#ÿ4&8-&<#.ÿ/(&/ÿ+,8*92#.ÿ8#&.#ÿ&,2ÿ2#.+./7ÿ&..+<,%#,/ÿ0;ÿ/1&2#%&1-ÿ*#//#1.ÿ01ÿ0/(#1ÿ;01%.7ÿ'09ÿ5+**ÿ6#ÿ#,/+/*#2ÿ/0ÿ&
;01%ÿ2089%#,/ÿ/(&/ÿ+,8*92#.ÿ/(#ÿ+,;01%&/+0,ÿ410)+2#2ÿ6'ÿ'09ÿ01ÿ;10%ÿ'091ÿ;+*#.:
"#ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ&ÿ.96./+/9/#ÿ;01ÿ&,ÿ&//01,#'ÿ&,2ÿ5#ÿ8&,,0/ÿ410)+2#ÿ'09ÿ&,'ÿ*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#:ÿ]91ÿ89./0%#1ÿ.#1)+8#ÿ1#41#.#,/&/+)#.
8&,,0/ÿ&,.5#1ÿ*#<&*ÿ^9#./+0,.ÿ&,2ÿ6#8&9.#ÿ5#ÿ20ÿ,0/ÿ(&)#ÿ&,ÿ&//01,#'38*+#,/ÿ1#*&/+0,.(+47ÿ&,'ÿ80%%9,+8&/+0,.ÿ5+/(ÿ091
89./0%#1ÿ.#1)+8#ÿ1#41#.#,/&/+)#.ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ41+)+*#<#2ÿ&,2ÿ'09ÿ.(09*2ÿ,0/ÿ.(&1#ÿ80,;+2#,/+&*ÿ+,;01%&/+0,ÿ5+/(ÿ/(#%:ÿ"#ÿ8&,ÿ(#*4
'09ÿ41#4&1#ÿ'091ÿ05,ÿ/1&2#%&1-ÿ&44*+8&/+0,7ÿ69/ÿ5#ÿ8&,,0/ÿ;+*#ÿ+/ÿ;01ÿ'09ÿ&.ÿ'091ÿ809,.#*ÿ0;ÿ1#8012:ÿ"#ÿ8&,,0/ÿ410)+2#ÿ'09ÿ&,'
*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#ÿ1#*&/#2ÿ/0ÿ'091ÿ4&1/+89*&1ÿ/1&2#%&1-:
"#ÿ%&'7ÿ69/ÿ&1#ÿ,0/ÿ&9/(01+_#2ÿ/07ÿ1#)+#5ÿ/(#ÿ+,;01%&/+0,ÿ'09ÿ410)+2#ÿ/0ÿ9.ÿ;01ÿ80%4*#/#,#..7ÿ+,80,.+./#,8+#.ÿ01ÿ0/(#1
&2%+,+./#1+&*ÿ#1101.:ÿF/ÿ,0ÿ/+%#ÿ20ÿ5#ÿ1#)+#5ÿ'091ÿ&,.5#1.ÿ;01ÿ*#<&*ÿ.9;;+8+#,8'7ÿ21&5ÿ*#<&*ÿ80,8*9.+0,.7ÿ410)+2#ÿ*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#7
04+,+0,.ÿ01ÿ1#80%%#,2&/+0,.ÿ&609/ÿ'091ÿ*#<&*ÿ1+<(/.7ÿ1#%#2+#.7ÿ2#;#,.#.7ÿ04/+0,.7ÿ.#*#8/+0,ÿ0;ÿ;01%.7ÿ01ÿ./1&/#<+#.7ÿ01ÿ&44*'ÿ/(#
*&5ÿ/0ÿ/(#ÿ;&8/.ÿ0;ÿ'091ÿ4&1/+89*&1ÿ.+/9&/+0,:ÿJ;ÿ'09ÿ6#*+#)#ÿ'09ÿ(&)#ÿ1#8#+)#2ÿ&,'ÿ*#<&*ÿ.#1)+8#.ÿ01ÿ&2)+8#ÿ;10%ÿ9.7ÿ'09ÿ5+**ÿ,0/
%&-#ÿ'091ÿ4918(&.#:ÿZ09ÿ&8-,05*#2<#ÿ&,2ÿ9,2#1./&,2ÿ/(&/ÿ'091ÿ4918(&.#7ÿ205,*0&27ÿ&,2`01ÿ9.#ÿ0;ÿ&ÿ;01%ÿ2089%#,/ÿ+.ÿ,#+/(#1
*#<&*ÿ&2)+8#ÿ,01ÿ/(#ÿ41&8/+8#ÿ0;ÿ*&5:ÿZ09ÿ;91/(#1ÿ&8-,05*#2<#ÿ&,2ÿ9,2#1./&,2ÿ/(&/ÿ/(&/ÿ#&8(ÿ;01%ÿ&,2ÿ&,'ÿ&44*+8&6*#
+,./198/+0,.ÿ01ÿ<9+2&,8#ÿ+.ÿ,0/ÿ89./0%+_#2ÿ/0ÿ'091ÿ4&1/+89*&1ÿ,##2.ÿ6'ÿ9.:
228798779272789
787 !200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 130 of 142
!"#$%#ÿ'()#ÿ)*$)ÿ+#ÿ,#)$-'ÿ.(/,ÿ0,#1-)ÿ0$,1ÿ-'2(,3$)-('ÿ%(ÿ)*$)ÿ+#ÿ3$.ÿ!$.ÿ)*#ÿ4(5#,'3#')$"ÿ2-"-'4ÿ2##
$%%(0-$)#1ÿ+-)*ÿ.(/,ÿ(,1#,ÿ('".ÿ$2)#,ÿ.(/ÿ$!!,(5#ÿ(,ÿ*$5#ÿ)*#ÿ(!!(,)/'-).ÿ)(ÿ$!!,(5#ÿ)*#ÿ$!!"-0$)-('
$'1ÿ$,#ÿ3$1#ÿ$+$,#ÿ(2ÿ)*#ÿ0(%)ÿ(2ÿ)*#ÿ2-"-'4ÿ2##6ÿ+7ÿ89:;<=7ÿ>:?ÿ@<ABÿCÿ=9CDAÿ:DÿAB7ÿC88E<FCA<:GÿD:9ÿ>:?9ÿ97;<7@6ÿ-Dÿ>:?
=:ÿG:AÿA<H7E>ÿ97I8:G=Jÿ>:?ÿC?AB:9<K7ÿ?IÿA:ÿI<LGÿ>:?9ÿGCH7ÿA:ÿAB7ÿC88E<FCA<:GJÿD<E7ÿ<AÿCIÿ89:;<=7=ÿ<GÿAB7ÿ=9CDAÿCG=ÿA:ÿF:EE7FAÿD9:H
>:?ÿAB7ÿL:;79GH7GACEÿD<E<GLÿD77ÿ:DÿMNOPÿ879ÿFECIIÿCAÿABCAÿA<H76
QRSTUVÿQRTXYURZ
-Dÿ>:?ÿ?I7ÿ:?9ÿI7C9FBÿI79;<F7IJÿ@7ÿ?I7ÿF:HH79F<CEE>ÿ97CI:GC[E7ÿH7AB:=IÿA:ÿ<=7GA<D>ÿHC9\IÿABCAÿHC>ÿ[7ÿHCAFB7IÿA:ÿAB7ÿ:G7Iÿ>:?
I77\ÿA:ÿ?I76ÿ+7JÿB:@7;79JÿFCGG:AÿL?C9CGA77ÿABCAÿ>:?9ÿHC9\ÿ@<EEÿHC\7ÿ<AÿAB9:?LBÿCG=ÿ[7ÿC889:;7=ÿ7;7Gÿ<Dÿ>:?ÿ?I7ÿ:?9ÿI7C9FB
I79;<F7I6ÿ)B797ÿHC>ÿ[7ÿCÿG?H[79ÿ:Dÿ97CI:GIÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿ97]7FAIÿ>:?9ÿHC9\ÿCG=ÿAB797ÿC97ÿF<9F?HIACGF7Iÿ@B797ÿCGÿC?A:HCA7=
I7C9FBÿHC>ÿG:Aÿ<=7GA<D>ÿCÿHC9\ÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿ<=7GA<D<7IÿCIÿCÿ97CI:GÿA:ÿ97]7FAÿ>:?9ÿHC9\6
"<\7@<I7Jÿ@B7Gÿ>:?9ÿ:9=79ÿF:;79IÿF:HH:GÿEC@ÿHC9\ÿI7C9FB7IJÿ@7ÿ?I7ÿF:HH79F<CEE>ÿ97CI:GC[E7ÿH7AB:=IÿA:ÿ<=7GA<D>ÿHC9\IÿABCA
HC>ÿ[7ÿHCAFB7IÿA:ÿAB7ÿ:G7Iÿ>:?ÿI77\ÿA:ÿ?I76ÿ+7JÿB:@7;79JÿFCGG:AÿL?C9CGA77ÿABCAÿ>:?9ÿHC9\ÿ@<EEÿ[7ÿD977ÿ:Dÿ:9ÿ897;C<EÿA:ÿCEE
FEC<HIÿ:9ÿFBCEE7GL7IÿHC=7ÿ[>ÿB:E=79Iÿ:DÿF:HH:GÿEC@ÿ9<LBAIÿA:ÿCEEÿHC9\I6ÿ)B797ÿC97ÿF<9F?HIACGF7Iÿ@B797ÿCGÿC?A:HCA7=ÿI7C9FB
HC>ÿG:Aÿ<=7GA<D>ÿCÿF:HH:GÿEC@ÿHC9\ÿABCAÿHC>ÿ[7ÿI<H<EC9ÿA:ÿ>:?9ÿHC9\6
)B7ÿ8?98:I7ÿ:DÿAB7ÿI7C9FBÿ978:9Aÿ<IÿA:ÿ89:;<=7ÿ>:?ÿ@<ABÿHC9\IÿA:ÿICA<ID>ÿAB7ÿ8C9CH7A79Iÿ<=7GA<D<7=ÿD:9ÿAB7ÿA>87ÿ:DÿI7C9FBÿ>:?ÿ?I76
-Aÿ<IÿG:AÿH7CGAÿA:ÿ[7ÿE7LCEÿC=;<F7ÿCIÿA:ÿ@B7AB79ÿ>:?9ÿ89:8:I7=ÿHC9\ÿ@<EEÿ[7ÿ97]7FA7=ÿ:9ÿ@B7AB79ÿ<Aÿ@:?E=ÿ[7ÿF:GI<=797=ÿI<H<EC9ÿA:
CG:AB79ÿHC9\6ÿ.:?ÿHC>ÿ@CGAÿA:ÿF:GI?EAÿ@<ABÿCGÿCAA:9G7>ÿ97LC9=<GLÿAB7ÿ97I?EAIÿ:DÿAB7ÿI7C9FBÿ978:9Aÿ@7ÿD?9G<IBÿ>:?6
(?9ÿ)9C=7HC9\ÿ#GL<G7Jÿ""0ÿD7=79CEÿA9C=7HC9\ÿI7C9FBÿ97;<7@IÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿ=CAC[CI7ÿCG=ÿ<IÿE<H<A7=ÿA:ÿ=<97FAÿHCAFB7IJÿ8B:G7A<FCEE>
I<H<EC9JÿI<H<EC9ÿ<GÿA79HIÿ:DÿA9CGIECA<:GJÿ:9ÿC887C9CGF7ÿ[>ÿ@C>ÿ:Dÿ=7I<LG6
(?9ÿ)9C=7HC9\ÿ#GL<G7Jÿ""0ÿD7=79CEJÿIACA7ÿCG=ÿF:HH:GÿEC@ÿI7C9FBÿ97;<7@IÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿ=CAC[CI7JÿAB7ÿ=CAC[CI7Iÿ:DÿCEEÿP^ÿIACA7IJ
Cÿ[?I<G7IIÿ97L<IA9>ÿCG=ÿAB7ÿ=CAC[CI7ÿ:Dÿ=:HC<GÿGCH7I6ÿ-Aÿ<IÿE<H<A7=ÿA:ÿ=<97FAÿHCAFB7IJÿ8B:G7A<FCEE>ÿI<H<EC9JÿI<H<EC9ÿ<GÿA79HIÿ:D
A9CGIECA<:GJÿ:9ÿC887C9CGF7ÿ[>ÿ@C>ÿ:Dÿ=7I<LG6
(?9ÿ)9C=7HC9\ÿ#GL<G7Jÿ""0ÿLE:[CEÿI7C9FBÿ97;<7@IÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿ=CAC[CI7JÿAB7ÿ=CAC[CI7Iÿ:DÿCEEÿP^ÿIACA7IJÿCÿ[?I<G7IIÿ97L<IA9>JÿAB7
=CAC[CI7ÿ:Dÿ=:HC<GÿGCH7IJÿAB7ÿ+:9E=ÿ-GA7EE7FA?CEÿ!9:879A>ÿ(9LCG<KCA<:Gÿ_`+-!(abÿ=CAC[CI7ÿCG=ÿAB7ÿ#?9:87CGÿ0:HH?G<A>
=CAC[CI76ÿ-Aÿ<IÿE<H<A7=ÿA:ÿ=<97FAÿHCAFB7IJÿ8B:G7A<FCEE>ÿI<H<EC9Jÿ:9ÿC887C9CGF7ÿ[>ÿ@C>ÿ:Dÿ=7I<LG6
cTSdReSTfÿghiYjhTYikÿQRTXYURZ
(?9ÿA9C=7HC9\ÿH:G<A:9<GLÿI79;<F7ÿ97;<7@IÿAB7ÿD<E<GLÿ:DÿG7@ÿC88E<FCA<:GIÿABCAÿC97ÿ=<97FAÿHCAFB7IJÿ8B:G7A<FCEE>ÿI<H<EC9JÿI<H<EC9ÿ<G
A79HIÿ:DÿA9CGIECA<:GJÿ:9ÿC887C9CGF7ÿ[>ÿ@C>ÿ:Dÿ=7I<LGÿA:ÿ>:?9ÿHC9\IÿCIÿ8?[E<IB7=ÿ<GÿAB7ÿ(DD<F<CEÿ4CK7AA7ÿ:DÿAB7ÿ/%!)(ÿCG=
)9C=7HC9\ÿ#GL<G7Jÿ""06
lYZUmSYeRTZÿhnÿoSTTSijpÿSidÿqYeYjSjYhiZÿhnÿqYSrYmYjp
+7ÿ89:;<=7ÿAB7ÿ+7[I<A7ÿCG=ÿAB7ÿ97ECA7=ÿI79;<F7IÿsCIÿ<IsJÿ`@B797<IaJÿCG=ÿsCIÿC;C<EC[E76sÿ+7ÿHC\7ÿG:ÿ7t897IIÿCG=u:9ÿ<H8E<7=
@C99CGA<7Iÿ:9ÿL?C9CGA77IÿC[:?AÿAB7ÿ+7[I<A7JÿAB7ÿL::=IÿCG=ÿI79;<F7Iÿ=7IF9<[7=ÿAB797:Gÿ:9ÿAB7ÿ$=;79A<I79I6ÿ)(ÿ)*#ÿ3$v-3/3
#v)#')ÿ!#,3-))#1ÿw.ÿ"$+Jÿ+#ÿ$'1ÿ(/,ÿ(22-0#,%Jÿ1-,#0)(,%Jÿ$4#')%Jÿ5#'1(,%Jÿ$'1ÿ)*#ÿ3#,0*$')%ÿ+*(
$15#,)-%#ÿ+-)*ÿ/%ÿ1-%0"$-3ÿ$'.ÿ$'1ÿ$""ÿ#v!,#%%ÿ(,ÿ-3!"-#1ÿ+$,,$')-#%ÿ)*$)ÿ)*#ÿ+#w%-)#ÿ$'1ÿ%#,-50#%ÿ$,#
3#,0*$')$w"#Jÿ(2ÿ%$)-%2$0)(,.ÿx/$"-).Jÿ$00/,$)#Jÿ)-3#".ÿ(,ÿ2-)ÿ2(,ÿ$ÿ!$,)-0/"$,ÿ!/,!(%#ÿ(,ÿ'##16ÿ+#ÿ-'ÿ'(
228798779272789
787 3200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 131 of 142
"#$ÿ&'#(#)*++ÿ*,#*ÿ"+ÿ"-..ÿ/++*ÿ$0'(ÿ(+1'-(+/+)*23ÿ-2ÿ+((0(45(++3ÿ#66'(#*+3ÿ(+.-#7.+3ÿ"-*,0'*
-)*+(('8*-0)ÿ0(ÿ#9#-.#7.+ÿ#*ÿ#..ÿ*-/+2:ÿ"+ÿ/#;+ÿ)0ÿ&'#(#)*++ÿ*,#*ÿ$0'ÿ"-..ÿ7+ÿ#7.+ÿ*0ÿ#66+22ÿ0(ÿ'2+ÿ*,+
"+72-*+ÿ#*ÿ*-/+2ÿ0(ÿ.06#*-0)2ÿ05ÿ$0'(ÿ6,002-)&:
$0'(ÿ20.+ÿ#)<ÿ+=6.'2-9+ÿ(+/+<$ÿ50(ÿ#)$ÿ<-28'*+ÿ0(ÿ6.#-/ÿ"-*,ÿ'2ÿ-2ÿ*0ÿ6+#2+ÿ'2+ÿ05ÿ*,+ÿ"+72-*+:ÿ"+3ÿ0'(
#55-.-#*+23ÿ055-6+(23ÿ<-(+6*0(23ÿ#&+)*23ÿ9+)<0(23ÿ#)<ÿ/+(6,#)*2ÿ",0ÿ#<9+(*-2+ÿ,+(+3ÿ2,#..ÿ)0*ÿ7+ÿ.-#7.+
50(ÿ#)$ÿ-)<-(+6*3ÿ28+6-#.3ÿ-)6-<+)*#.3ÿ60)2+1'+)*-#.ÿ0(ÿ+=+/8.#($ÿ<#/#&+2ÿ#(-2-)&ÿ5(0/ÿ$0'(ÿ'2+ÿ053
-)#7-.-*$ÿ*0ÿ'2+3ÿ0(ÿ(+.-#)6+ÿ'80)ÿ*,+ÿ"+72-*+ÿ-)ÿ#)$ÿ"#$:ÿ*,+2+ÿ+=6.'2-0)2ÿ#88.$ÿ*0ÿ#)$ÿ6.#-/2ÿ50(ÿ.02*
8(05-*23ÿ.02*ÿ<#*#3ÿ.022ÿ05ÿ&00<"-..3ÿ"0(;ÿ2*088#&+3ÿ60/8'*+(ÿ5#-.'(+ÿ0(ÿ/#.5')6*-0)3ÿ<#/#&+ÿ*0ÿ#)$
0*,+(ÿ+1'-8/+)*3ÿ0(ÿ#)$ÿ0*,+(ÿ60//+(6-#.ÿ<#/#&+2ÿ0(ÿ.022+23ÿ+9+)ÿ-5ÿ"+ÿ;)+"ÿ0(ÿ2,0'.<ÿ,#9+ÿ;)0")ÿ05
*,+ÿ8022-7-.-*$ÿ05ÿ2'6,ÿ<#/#&+2:ÿ-5ÿ#)$ÿ>'(-2<-6*-0)ÿ<0+2ÿ)0*ÿ#..0"ÿ*,+ÿ+=6.'2-0)ÿ0(ÿ*,+ÿ.-/-*#*-0)ÿ05
.-#7-.-*$ÿ50(ÿ60)2+1'+)*-#.ÿ0(ÿ-)6-<+)*#.ÿ<#/#&+23ÿ-)ÿ2'6,ÿ>'(-2<-6*-0)3ÿ0'(ÿ.-#7-.-*$3ÿ#)<ÿ*,+ÿ.-#7-.-*$ÿ05
0'(ÿ#55-.-#*+23ÿ055-6+(23ÿ<-(+6*0(23ÿ#&+)*23ÿ9+)<0(23ÿ#)<ÿ/+(6,#)*2ÿ",0ÿ#<9+(*-2+ÿ,+(+3ÿ2,#..ÿ7+ÿ.-/-*+<
*0ÿ*,+ÿ+=*+)*ÿ8+(/-**+<ÿ7$ÿ.#":
-?ÿ@A??B@CDA?ÿEDCFÿCFBÿGAHBIAD?IÿHBJBKLB3ÿMANÿFBHBOMÿEKDPBÿ6KJDGAH?DKÿ6DPDJÿ6AQBÿ2B@CDA?ÿRSTUÿVK?QÿK?MÿLDWDJKHÿXHAPDLDA?ÿD?ÿK?M
ACFBHÿYNHDLQD@CDA?ZÿEFD@FÿLCKCBL[ÿ\#ÿIB?BHKJÿHBJBKLBÿQABLÿ?ACÿB]CB?QÿCAÿ@JKDWLÿEFD@FÿCFBÿ@HBQDCAHÿQABLÿ?ACÿ^?AEÿAHÿLNLXB@CÿCA
B]DLCÿD?ÿFDLÿGKPAHÿKCÿCFBÿCDWBÿAGÿB]B@NCD?IÿCFBÿHBJBKLB3ÿEFD@F3ÿDGÿ^?AE?ÿOMÿFDWÿWNLCÿFKPBÿWKCBHDKJJMÿKGGB@CBQÿFDLÿLBCCJBWB?CÿEDCF
CFBÿQBOCAH:_
`abcdaefg
$ANÿKIHBBÿCAÿQBGB?Q3ÿD?QBW?DGMÿK?QÿFAJQÿFKHWJBLLÿNL3ÿANHÿAGGD@BHL3ÿQDHB@CAHL3ÿHBXHBLB?CKCDPBL3ÿBWXJAMBBLÿK?QÿKIB?CLÿK?QÿKJJÿAG
ANHÿXKHB?Cÿ@AWXK?DBL3ÿKGGDJDKCBL3ÿHBJKCBQÿ@AWXK?DBLÿK?QÿCFBDHÿAGGD@BHL3ÿQDHB@CAHL3ÿHBXHBLB?CKCDPBL3ÿBWXJAMBBLÿK?QÿKIB?CLÿGHAW
K?QÿKIKD?LCÿK?MÿK?QÿKJJÿ@JKDWL3ÿQKWKIBL3ÿAOJDIKCDA?L3ÿJALLBL3ÿJDKODJDCDBL3ÿ@ALCLÿAHÿQBOC3ÿK?QÿB]XB?LBLÿVD?@JNQD?IÿONCÿ?ACÿJDWDCBQÿCA
HBKLA?KOJBÿKCCAH?BMhLÿGBBLZÿKHDLD?IÿGHAW[ÿVDZÿMANHÿPDAJKCDA?ÿAGÿK?MÿCBHWÿAGÿCFBLBÿ*BHWLÿAGÿ2BHPD@BiÿVDDZÿMANHÿPDAJKCDA?ÿAGÿK?MÿCFDHQ
XKHCMÿHDIFC3ÿD?@JNQD?IÿEDCFANCÿJDWDCKCDA?ÿK?Mÿ@AXMHDIFC3ÿXHAXBHCM3ÿXHDPK@MÿHDIFC3ÿAHÿK?MÿK?QÿKJJÿD?CK?IDOJBÿAHÿD?CBJJB@CNKJÿXHAXBHCM
HDIFCLiÿAHÿVDDDZÿK?Mÿ@JKDWÿCFKCÿK?MÿAGÿMANHÿ'&6ÿ@KNLBLÿQKWKIBÿCAÿKÿCFDHQÿXKHCM:
jeklmfcÿockpqmfepa
-?ÿCFDLÿ#IHBBWB?C3ÿ<DLXNCBÿDLÿQBGD?BQÿKLÿ\K?MÿQDLXNCB3ÿ@JKDWÿAHÿ@A?CHAPBHLMÿOBCEBB?ÿMANÿK?Qÿ*HKQBWKH^ÿ+?ID?B3ÿ..63ÿDCL
WBWOBHL3ÿAGGD@BHL3ÿQDHB@CAHL3ÿKIB?CL3ÿXKHB?Cÿ@AWXK?DBLÿK?QÿPB?QAHLÿCFKCÿKHDLBLÿANCÿAGÿAHÿHBJKCBLÿCAÿCFDLÿ#IHBBWB?CÿAHÿNLBÿAGÿCFB
2DCBÿAHÿ2BHPD@B3ÿAHÿACFBHEDLBÿHBIKHQD?IÿK?MÿKLXB@CÿAGÿMANHÿHBJKCDA?LFDXÿEDCFÿ*HKQBWKH^ÿ+?ID?BÿCFKCÿFKLÿK@@HNBQÿAHÿWKM
CFBHBKGCBHÿK@@HNB3ÿEFBCFBHÿOKLBQÿD?ÿ@A?CHK@C3ÿLCKCNCBÿVD?@JNQD?I3ÿONCÿ?ACÿJDWDCBQÿCA3ÿK?Mÿ@A?LNWBHÿXHACB@CDA?ÿLCKCNCBL3ÿHBINJKCDA?3
AHQD?K?@B3ÿCAHCÿVD?@JNQD?I3ÿONCÿ?ACÿJDWDCBQÿCA3ÿGHKNQ3ÿWDLHBXHBLB?CKCDA?3ÿGHKNQNJB?CÿD?QN@BWB?C3ÿ?BIJDIB?@BÿAHÿK?MÿACFBH
D?CB?CDA?KJÿCAHCZ3ÿAHÿK?MÿACFBHÿJBIKJÿAHÿBrNDCKOJBÿCFBAHM:
*FBÿKHODCHKODJDCMÿAGÿK?Mÿ<DLXNCBLÿDLÿIAPBH?BQÿOMÿCFBÿ5BQBHKJÿ#HODCHKCDA?ÿ#@CÿK?Qÿ?ACÿK?MÿLCKCBÿJKELÿKXXJD@KOJBÿCAÿKHODCHKCDA?L:
(BIKHQD?IÿCFBÿLNOLCK?CDPBÿJKEÿAGÿK?Mÿ<DLXNCBL3ÿCAÿCFBÿWK]DWNWÿB]CB?CÿKNCFAHDsBQÿOMÿJKE3ÿCFBÿJKELÿAGÿCFBÿ2CKCBÿAGÿ*B]KLÿIAPBH?
CFBÿ?A?4KHODCHKCDA?ÿHBJKCBQÿD?CBHXHBCKCDA?ÿAGÿCFDLÿ#IHBBWB?CÿK?QÿCFBÿLNOLCK?CDPBÿJKEÿAGÿK?Mÿ<DLXNCB3ÿHBIKHQJBLLÿAGÿ@A?GJD@CÿAGÿJKEL
XHD?@DXJBL:
#HODCHKCDA?:ÿ#?Mÿ<DLXNCBÿLFKJJÿOBÿ5-)#..$ÿK?Qÿ+=6.'2-9+.$ÿHBLAJPBQÿOMÿOD?QD?IÿD?QDPDQNKJÿKHODCHKCDA?ÿ@A?QN@CBQÿOMÿCFB
#WBHD@K?ÿ#HODCHKCDA?ÿ#LLA@DKCDA?ÿV\###_ZÿN?QBHÿDCLÿ6A?LNWBHÿ#HODCHKCDA?ÿ(NJBL:ÿ*FDLÿKHODCHKCDA?ÿKIHBBWB?CÿDLÿWKQBÿXNHLNK?CÿCA
KÿCHK?LK@CDA?ÿD?PAJPD?IÿD?CBHLCKCBÿ@AWWBH@B3ÿK?QÿLFKJJÿOBÿIAPBH?BQÿOMÿCFBÿ5BQBHKJÿ#HODCHKCDA?ÿ#@CÿVtÿ':2:6:ÿR4RuZ:
228798779272789
787 !200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 132 of 142
"#$%&#"&%'(ÿ'*ÿ+',#ÿ-."%/ÿ%0ÿ/"(1"&'#+ÿ"(1ÿ$%(1%(23ÿ(4%&54#ÿ6"#&+ÿ7%..ÿ5"84ÿ&54ÿ#%25&ÿ&'ÿ.%&%2"&4ÿ&5"&
-."%/ÿ&5#',25ÿ"ÿ-',#&3ÿ%(ÿ"#$%&#"&%'(9ÿ(4%&54#ÿ6"#&+ÿ7%..ÿ5"84ÿ&54ÿ#%25&ÿ&'ÿ"ÿ:,#+ÿ&#%".ÿ'#ÿ&'ÿ4(2"24ÿ%(
1%0-'84#+9ÿ4;-46&ÿ"0ÿ6#'8%141ÿ*'#ÿ%(ÿ&54ÿ"""ÿ-'14ÿ'*ÿ6#'-41,#43
"<<ÿ=>?>@ABCD?BECFÿDFÿ?Eÿ?G>ÿFHEI>9ÿBC?>@I@>?D?BEC9ÿ>CJE@H>DKB<B?LÿDC=ÿMD<B=B?LÿEJÿ?GBFÿ"N@>>A>C?ÿFGD<<ÿK>ÿAD=>ÿJBCD<ÿ>OH<PFBM><LÿKL
?G>ÿD@KB?@D?E@9ÿQGBHGÿDQD@=ÿFGD<<ÿK>ÿKBC=BCNÿDC=ÿJBCD<3ÿ:P=NA>C?ÿECÿ?G>ÿD@KB?@D?BECÿDQD@=ÿADLÿK>ÿ>C?>@>=ÿBCÿDCLÿHEP@?ÿGDMBCN
RP@BF=BH?BEC3ÿ&GBFÿD@KB?@D?BECÿI@EMBFBECÿFGD<<ÿFP@MBM>SÿBTÿ?G>ÿ?>@ABCD?BECÿEJÿ?G>ÿ"N@>>A>C?UÿE@ÿBBTÿ?G>ÿKDCV@PI?HLÿEJÿDCLÿID@?L3ÿ%JÿDCL
IE@?BECÿEJÿ?GBFÿD@KB?@D?BECÿI@EMBFBECÿBFÿ=>>A>=ÿBCMD<B=ÿE@ÿPC>CJE@H>DK<>9ÿ?G>ÿ@>ADBCBCNÿIE@?BECFÿFGD<<ÿ@>ADBCÿBCÿJE@H>3
('ÿ-."00ÿ"-&%'(9ÿ'#ÿ'&54#ÿ#46#404(&"&%84ÿ"-&%'(ÿ'#ÿ6#%8"&4ÿ"&&'#(4+ÿ24(4#".ÿ"-&%'(ÿ'#ÿ:'%(14#ÿ'#
-'(0'.%1"&%'(ÿ'*ÿ"(+ÿ-."%/ÿ7%&5ÿ"ÿ-."%/ÿ'*ÿ"('&54#ÿ64#0'(ÿ'#ÿ-."00ÿ'*ÿ-."%/"(&0ÿ05"..ÿ$4ÿ"..'7"$.43
#%25&ÿ&'ÿ'6&ÿ',&ÿ'*ÿ$%(1%(2ÿ"#$%&#"&%'(ÿ"(1ÿ-."00ÿ"-&%'(ÿ7"%84#ÿ7%&5%(ÿWXÿ1"+03ÿ%*ÿ+',ÿ1'ÿ('&ÿ7%05ÿ&'ÿ$4
$',(1ÿ$+ÿ&54ÿ$%(1%(2ÿ"#$%&#"&%'(ÿ"(1ÿ-."00ÿ"-&%'(ÿ7"%84#ÿ%(ÿ&5%0ÿ04-&%'(9ÿ+',ÿ/,0&ÿ('&%*+ÿ,0ÿ%(ÿ7#%&%(2
7%&5%(ÿWXÿ1"+0ÿ'*ÿ&54ÿ1"&4ÿ&5"&ÿ+',ÿ"--46&ÿ&5%0ÿ"2#44/4(&3ÿ+',#ÿ7#%&&4(ÿ('&%*%-"&%'(ÿ/,0&ÿ$4ÿ4Y/"%.41ÿ&'
&#"14/"#Zÿ4(2%(49ÿ..-9ÿ0,66'#&[&#"14/"#Z4(2%(43-'/ÿ\ADB<?ESFPIIE@?[?@D=>AD@V>CNBC>3HEATÿ7%&5ÿ&54ÿ0,$:4-&
.%(4ÿ]'6&Y',&^ÿ"(1ÿ%(-.,14Sÿ\_Tÿ+',#ÿ("/49ÿ\`Tÿ+',#ÿ"11#4009ÿ"(1ÿ\aTÿ"ÿ-.4"#ÿ0&"&4/4(&ÿ&5"&ÿ+',ÿ1'ÿ('&ÿ7%05
&'ÿ#40'.84ÿ1%06,&40ÿ7%&5ÿ,0ÿ&5#',25ÿ"#$%&#"&%'(3
"CLÿD@KB?@D?BECÿQB<<ÿK>ÿHEC=PH?>=ÿKLÿ?G>ÿ"""ÿPC=>@ÿB?Fÿ-EAA>@HBD<ÿ"@KB?@D?BECÿ#P<>F3ÿ%Jÿ?G>ÿMD<P>ÿEJÿ?G>ÿ=BFIP?>ÿBFÿbcd9XXXÿE@
<>FF9ÿB?Fÿ0PII<>A>C?D@Lÿ6@EH>=P@>FÿJE@ÿ-ECFPA>@Y#><D?>=ÿ1BFIP?>FÿQB<<ÿD<FEÿDII<L3ÿ'Cÿ=BFIP?>FÿBCME<MBCNÿbcd9XXXÿE@ÿ<>FF9ÿQ>ÿQB<<
I@EAI?<Lÿ@>BAKP@F>ÿLEP@ÿJB<BCNÿJ>>FÿDC=ÿIDLÿ?G>ÿ"""eFÿDC=ÿD@KB?@D?E@^FÿJ>>FÿDC=ÿ>OI>CF>F3ÿ+EPÿDN@>>ÿ?EÿHEAA>CH>ÿD@KB?@D?BEC
EC<LÿBCÿLEP@ÿHEPC?LÿEJÿ@>FB=>CH>ÿE@ÿBCÿ5D@@BFÿ-EPC?L9ÿ&>ODF9ÿ,03ÿ7>ÿDN@>>ÿ?EÿHEAA>CH>ÿD@KB?@D?BECÿEC<LÿBCÿLEP@ÿHEPC?LÿEJ
@>FB=>CH>3ÿ+EPÿADLÿ@>fP>F?ÿDÿ?><>IGECBHÿE@ÿBCYI>@FECÿG>D@BCNÿKLÿJE<<EQBCNÿ?G>ÿ"""ÿ@P<>F3ÿ%CÿDÿ=BFIP?>ÿBCME<MBCNÿb_X9XXXÿE@ÿ<>FF9
DCLÿG>D@BCNÿQB<<ÿK>ÿ?><>IGECBHÿPC<>FFÿ?G>ÿD@KB?@D?E@ÿJBC=FÿNEE=ÿHDPF>ÿ?EÿGE<=ÿDCÿBCYI>@FECÿG>D@BCNÿBCF?>D=3ÿ&G>ÿD@KB?@D?E@ÿADL
DQD@=ÿ?G>ÿFDA>ÿ=DADN>Fÿ?EÿLEPÿBC=BMB=PD<<LÿDFÿDÿHEP@?ÿHEP<=3ÿ&G>ÿD@KB?@D?E@ÿADLÿDQD@=ÿ=>H<D@D?E@LÿE@ÿBCRPCH?BM>ÿ@><B>JÿEC<Lÿ?E
LEPÿBC=BMB=PD<<L9ÿDC=ÿEC<Lÿ?Eÿ?G>ÿ>O?>C?ÿ@>fPB@>=ÿ?EÿFD?BFJLÿLEP@ÿBC=BMB=PD<ÿH<DBA3ÿ(E?GBCNÿG>@>BCÿI@EGBKB?Fÿ&@D=>AD@Vÿ4CNBC>9ÿ..-
J@EAÿDFVBCNÿ?G>ÿD@KB?@D?E@ÿ?EÿDQD@=ÿ&@D=>AD@Vÿ4CNBC>9ÿ..-ÿD<<ÿHEF?FÿEJÿ?G>ÿD@KB?@D?BECÿBCH<P=BCNÿDCLÿ"=ABCBF?@D?BM>ÿ*>>FÿIDB=ÿEC
LEP@ÿK>GD<J3
%Jÿ?G>ÿ1BFIP?>ÿBFÿCE?ÿD@KB?@D?>=ÿKLÿ?G>ÿHGEBH>ÿEJÿ?G>ÿID@?B>FÿE@ÿDÿHEP@?ÿ=E>FÿCE?ÿHEAI><ÿD@KB?@D?BECÿBJÿ>B?G>@ÿID@?Lÿ><>H?Fÿ?E
D@KB?@D?>ÿJE@ÿQGD?>M>@ÿ@>DFEC9ÿ?G>ÿ1BFIP?>ÿQB<<ÿK>ÿ=>HB=>=ÿKLÿDÿHEP@?ÿQB?GEP?ÿDCLÿ@BNG?ÿKLÿ>B?G>@ÿID@?Lÿ?EÿDÿ?@BD<ÿKLÿRP@L3ÿ"CLÿFPHG
HEP@?ÿI@EH>>=BCN9ÿBCH<P=BCNÿDCLÿ>JJE@?Fÿ?EÿHEAI><ÿD@KB?@D?BECÿE@ÿBCB?BD<<LÿJB<>=ÿ<DQFPB?Fÿ?GD?ÿD@BF>FÿEP?ÿEJÿE@ÿ@><D?>Fÿ?Eÿ?GBF
"N@>>A>C?ÿE@ÿPF>ÿEJÿ?G>ÿ0B?>FÿFGD<<ÿK>ÿ=>HB=>=ÿ>OH<PFBM><LÿKLÿDÿHEP@?ÿEJÿHEAI>?>C?ÿRP@BF=BH?BECÿ<EHD?>=ÿBCÿ?G>ÿ5EPF?EC9ÿ5D@@BF
-EPC?L9ÿ&>ODF3
ghijkkjlimnkÿpqrsjqit
7>9ÿE@ÿI>EI<>ÿJ@EAÿQGEAÿQ>ÿEK?DBC>=ÿDÿ<BH>CF>9ÿ@>?DBCÿEQC>@FGBIÿEJÿD<<ÿBC?><<>H?PD<ÿI@EI>@?Lÿ@BNG?FÿEJÿDCLÿVBC=ÿDFFEHBD?>=ÿQB?G
?G>ÿ7>KFB?>9ÿBCH<P=BCNÿD<<ÿDII<BHDK<>ÿ?@D=>AD@VF9ÿHEIL@BNG?FÿDC=ÿE?G>@ÿI@EI@B>?D@Lÿ@BNG?FÿFPHGÿDFÿ?@D=>ÿF>H@>?F3ÿ&G@EPNGÿ?G>ÿPF>
EJÿ?GBFÿ7>KFB?>ÿIP@FPDC?ÿ?Eÿ?GBFÿ"N@>>A>C?9ÿLEPÿGDM>ÿDÿ<BAB?>=ÿ@BNG?ÿ?EÿPF>ÿ?G>ÿ7>KFB?>9ÿKP?ÿBCÿCEÿQDLÿD@>ÿQ>ÿN@DC?BCNÿDCL
<BH>CF>ÿ?EÿLEPÿPC=>@ÿDCLÿEJÿ?GEF>ÿBC?><<>H?PD<ÿI@EI>@?Lÿ@BNG?F3ÿ7>ÿ@>F>@M>ÿD<<ÿ@BNG?Fÿ?GD?ÿD@>ÿCE?ÿ>OI@>FF<LÿN@DC?>=ÿ?EÿLEPÿBCÿ?GBF
"N@>>A>C?3ÿ+EPÿADLÿI@BC?ÿ<BAB?>=ÿCPAK>@FÿEJÿEC>ÿE@ÿAE@>ÿIDN>FÿJ@EAÿ?G>ÿ7>KFB?>ÿJE@ÿLEP@ÿI>@FECD<ÿPF>3
7>ÿ@>?DBC9ÿ?Eÿ?G>ÿADOBAPAÿ>O?>C?ÿIEFFBK<>9ÿD<<ÿEQC>@FGBI9ÿQB?GEP?ÿ<BAB?D?BEC9ÿEJÿD<<ÿ?G>ÿ?>O?9ÿFEJ?QD@>9ÿFH@BI?F9ÿN@DIGBHF9ÿIGE?EF9
FEPC=F9ÿBC?>@DH?BM>ÿJ>D?P@>FÿDC=ÿ?G>ÿ?@D=>AD@VF9ÿF>@MBH>ÿAD@VFÿDC=ÿ<ENEFÿHEC?DBC>=ÿ?G>@>BCÿ\u/D@VFuTÿPC<>FFÿ?G>LÿD@>ÿAD@VF
PF>=ÿKLÿ/>@HGDC?FÿQGEÿGDM>ÿI@EMB=>=ÿ?G>Aÿ?EÿPFÿJE@ÿPF>ÿECÿ?GBFÿ7>KFB?>3ÿ&G>ÿ/D@VFÿD@>ÿEQC>=ÿE@ÿ<BH>CF>=ÿ?EÿPF9ÿFPKR>H?ÿ?E
HEIL@BNG?ÿDC=ÿE?G>@ÿBC?><<>H?PD<ÿI@EI>@?Lÿ@BNG?FÿPC=>@ÿ?G>ÿ<DQÿEJÿ?G>ÿ,CB?>=ÿ0?D?>FÿEJÿ"A>@BHD9ÿ?G>ÿ<DQÿEJÿ?G>ÿRP@BF=BH?BECÿQG>@>
228798779272789
787 !200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 133 of 142
!"#ÿ%&'()&*ÿ+,)ÿ(,-&%,+-(",+.ÿ/",0&,-(",'1ÿ2..ÿ/",-&,-ÿ",ÿ-3&ÿ4&5'(-&ÿ6%"0()&)ÿ5!ÿ#'ÿ('ÿ6%"0()&)ÿ-"ÿ!"#ÿ728ÿ98:ÿ;"%ÿ!"#%
(,;"%<+-(",ÿ+,)ÿ6&%'",+.ÿ#'&ÿ",.!ÿ+,)ÿ<+!ÿ,"-ÿ5&ÿ#'&)*ÿ/"6(&)*ÿ%&6%")#/&)*ÿ<")(;(&)*ÿ)('-%(5#-&)*ÿ-%+,'<(--&)*ÿ5%"+)/+'-*
)('6.+!&)*ÿ'".)*ÿ.(/&,'&)*ÿ"%ÿ"-3&%=('&ÿ&>6."(-&)ÿ;"%ÿ+,!ÿ"-3&%ÿ6#%6"'&'ÿ=3+-'"&0&%ÿ=(-3"#-ÿ-3&ÿ6%("%ÿ=%(--&,ÿ/",'&,-ÿ";ÿ-3&
%&'6&/-(0&ÿ"=,&%'1ÿ4&ÿ%&'&%0&ÿ+..ÿ%(?3-'ÿ,"-ÿ&>6%&''.!ÿ?%+,-&)ÿ(,ÿ+,)ÿ-"ÿ-3&ÿ4&5'(-&1
@"#ÿ%&-+(,ÿ+,!ÿ(,-&..&/-#+.ÿ6%"6&%-!ÿ%(?3-'ÿ(,ÿ+,!ÿ/"6!%(?3-&)ÿ<+-&%(+.'ÿ+,)ÿ-%+)&<+%A'ÿ-3+-ÿ+%&ÿ/",-+(,&)ÿ(,ÿBCDÿ-3+-ÿ!"#ÿ6"'-
-"ÿ-3&ÿ4&5'(-&1ÿ@"#ÿ?%+,-ÿ#'ÿ+,ÿ(%%&0"/+5.&*ÿ6&%6&-#+.*ÿ,",E&>/.#'(0&*ÿ%"!+.-!E;%&&*ÿ;#..!ÿ6+()*ÿ="%.)=()&ÿ.(/&,'&*ÿ=(-3ÿ%(?3-'ÿ-"
'#5.(/&,'&ÿ-3%"#?3ÿ<#.-(6.&ÿ.&0&.'ÿ";ÿ'#5.(/&,'&&'*ÿ-"ÿ%&6%")#/&*ÿ<+A&ÿ)&%(0+-(0&ÿ="%A'ÿ";*ÿ-%+,'.+-&*ÿ)('-%(5#-&*ÿ6#5.(/.!ÿ6&%;"%<
+,)ÿ6#5.(/.!ÿ)('6.+!ÿ(,ÿ+,!ÿ;"%<ÿ"%ÿ<&)(#<*ÿ=3&-3&%ÿ,"=ÿA,"=,ÿ"%ÿ.+-&%ÿ)&0&."6&)*ÿ<+A&*ÿ#'&*ÿ'&..*ÿ(<6"%-*ÿ";;&%ÿ;"%ÿ'+.&*
"-3&%=('&ÿ/"<<&%/(+..!ÿ&>6."(-ÿ+,)ÿ&>&%/('&ÿ+,!ÿ+,)ÿ+..ÿ'#/3ÿ%(?3-'*ÿ#,)&%ÿ+,!ÿ+,)ÿ+..ÿ";ÿ!"#%ÿ(,-&..&/-#+.ÿ6%"6&%-!ÿ%(?3-'ÿ%&.+-&)
-"ÿ-3&ÿBCDÿ(,ÿ+,!ÿ<+,,&%ÿ=&ÿ/3""'&1
FGHIJKLMNÿPGNKQR
9;ÿ!"#ÿ5&.(&0&ÿ=&ÿ3+0&ÿ(,;%(,?&)ÿ",ÿ!"#%ÿ/"6!%(?3-'*ÿ6.&+'&ÿ'#5<(-ÿ+ÿ,"-(;(/+-(",ÿ6#%'#+,-ÿ-"ÿ-3&ÿS(?(-+.ÿT(..&,,(#<ÿD"6!%(?3-
2/-ÿUVWÿB181D1ÿXÿYVZU/[U\[[ÿ(,ÿ=%(-(,?ÿ-"ÿ'#66"%-]-%+)&<+%A&,?(,&1/"<ÿU<+(.-"^'#66"%-]-%+)&<+%A&,?(,&1/"<[ÿ"%ÿ-"ÿ-3&
/"6!%(?3-ÿ+?&,-ÿ",ÿ;(.&ÿ=(-3ÿ-3&ÿB181ÿD"6!%(?3-ÿ_;;(/&ÿ=(-3ÿ-3&ÿ8#5`&/-^ÿ7/"6!%(?3-ÿ,"-(/&1:ÿ@"#%ÿ,"-(/&ÿ,&&)'ÿ-"ÿ(,/.#)&^ÿUV[ÿ2
63!'(/+.ÿ"%ÿ&.&/-%",(/ÿ'(?,+-#%&ÿ";ÿ+ÿ6&%'",ÿ+#-3"%(a&)ÿ-"ÿ+/-ÿ",ÿ5&3+.;ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ"=,&%ÿ";ÿ+,ÿ&>/.#'(0&ÿ%(?3-ÿ-3+-ÿ('ÿ+..&?&).!
(,;%(,?&)bÿUZ[ÿ9)&,-(;(/+-(",ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ/"6!%(?3-&)ÿ="%Aÿ/.+(<&)ÿ-"ÿ3+0&ÿ5&&,ÿ(,;%(,?&)*ÿ"%*ÿ(;ÿ<#.-(6.&ÿ/"6!%(?3-&)ÿ="%A'ÿ+-ÿ+ÿ'(,?.&
",.(,&ÿ'(-&ÿ+%&ÿ/"0&%&)ÿ5!ÿ+ÿ'(,?.&ÿ,"-(;(/+-(",*ÿ+ÿ%&6%&'&,-+-(0&ÿ.('-ÿ";ÿ'#/3ÿ="%A'ÿ+-ÿ-3+-ÿ'(-&bÿU\[ÿ9)&,-(;(/+-(",ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ<+-&%(+.
-3+-ÿ('ÿ/.+(<&)ÿ-"ÿ5&ÿ(,;%(,?(,?ÿ"%ÿ-"ÿ5&ÿ-3&ÿ'#5`&/-ÿ";ÿ(,;%(,?(,?ÿ+/-(0(-!ÿ+,)ÿ-3+-ÿ('ÿ-"ÿ5&ÿ%&<"0&)ÿ"%ÿ+//&''ÿ-"ÿ=3(/3ÿ('ÿ-"ÿ5&
)('+5.&)ÿ+,)ÿ(,;"%<+-(",ÿ%&+'",+5.!ÿ'#;;(/(&,-ÿ-"ÿ6&%<(-ÿ-3&ÿ'&%0(/&ÿ6%"0()&%ÿ-"ÿ."/+-&ÿ-3&ÿ<+-&%(+.bÿUc[ÿ9,;"%<+-(",ÿ%&+'",+5.!
'#;;(/(&,-ÿ-"ÿ6&%<(-ÿ-3&ÿ'&%0(/&ÿ6%"0()&%ÿ-"ÿ/",-+/-ÿ!"#*ÿ'#/3ÿ+'ÿ+,ÿ+))%&''*ÿ-&.&63",&ÿ,#<5&%*ÿ+,)*ÿ(;ÿ+0+(.+5.&*ÿ+,ÿ&.&/-%",(/
<+(.bÿUY[ÿ2ÿ'-+-&<&,-ÿ-3+-ÿ!"#ÿ3+0&ÿ+ÿ?"")ÿ;+(-3ÿ5&.(&;ÿ-3+-ÿ#'&ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ<+-&%(+.ÿ(,ÿ-3&ÿ<+,,&%ÿ/"<6.+(,&)ÿ";ÿ('ÿ,"-ÿ+#-3"%(a&)ÿ5!
-3&ÿ/"6!%(?3-ÿ"=,&%*ÿ(-'ÿ+?&,-*ÿ"%ÿ-3&ÿ.+=bÿ+,)ÿUd[ÿ2ÿ'-+-&<&,-ÿ-3+-ÿ-3&ÿ(,;"%<+-(",ÿ(,ÿ-3&ÿ,"-(;(/+-(",ÿ('ÿ+//#%+-&*ÿ+,)ÿ#,)&%
6&,+.-!ÿ";ÿ6&%#̀%!*ÿ-3+-ÿ!"#ÿ+%&ÿ+#-3"%(a&)ÿ-"ÿ+/-ÿ",ÿ5&3+.;ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ"=,&%ÿ";ÿ+,ÿ&>/.#'(0&ÿ%(?3-ÿ-3+-ÿ('ÿ+..&?&).!ÿ(,;%(,?&)1
efNKJRÿgLJRRhRfN
i3('ÿ2?%&&<&,-*ÿ(,/.#)(,?ÿ-3&ÿj%(0+/!ÿj".(/!*ÿ/",'-(-#-&'ÿ-3&ÿ&,-(%&ÿ+?%&&<&,-ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ6+%-(&'ÿ=(-3ÿ%&'6&/-ÿ-"ÿ-3&ÿ'#5`&/-ÿ<+--&%
3&%&";1ÿk"ÿ=+(0&%ÿ5!ÿ&(-3&%ÿ6+%-!ÿ";ÿ+,!ÿ5%&+/3ÿ"%ÿ)&;+#.-ÿ3&%&#,)&%ÿ('ÿ+ÿ=+(0&%ÿ";ÿ+,!ÿ6%&/&)(,?ÿ"%ÿ'#5'&l#&,-ÿ5%&+/3ÿ"%
)&;+#.-1
mGnKoQpNKGfqÿNGÿNMRÿgLJRRhRfN
4&ÿ%&'&%0&ÿ-3&ÿ%(?3-ÿ+-ÿ+..ÿ-(<&'ÿ-"ÿ)('/",-(,#&ÿ"%ÿ<")(;!ÿ+,!ÿ";ÿ-3&'&ÿ-&%<'ÿ+,)r"%ÿ"#%ÿj%(0+/!ÿj".(/!ÿ+'ÿ=&ÿ)&&<ÿ,&/&''+%!ÿ"%
)&'(%+5.&1ÿ8#/3ÿ/3+,?&'ÿ<+!ÿ(,/.#)&*ÿ+<",?ÿ"-3&%ÿ-3(,?'*ÿ-3&ÿ+))(,?ÿ";ÿ/&%-+(,ÿ;&&'ÿ"%ÿ/3+%?&'1ÿ4&ÿ<+!*ÿ5#-ÿ+%&ÿ,"-
,&/&''+%(.!ÿ"5.(?+-&)ÿ-"ÿ,"-(;!ÿ!"#ÿ0(+ÿ&<+(.ÿ";ÿ+,!ÿ'#5'-+,-(+.ÿ/3+,?&'*ÿ5!ÿ'&,)(,?ÿ!"#ÿ+,ÿ&E<+(.ÿ-"ÿ-3&ÿ&E<+(.ÿ+))%&''ÿ-3+-ÿ('
%&?('-&%&)ÿ=(-3ÿ!"#%ÿ+//"#,-ÿ+,)r"%ÿ5!ÿ6"'-(,?ÿ,"-(/&ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ/3+,?&ÿ",ÿ-3&ÿ4&5'(-&1ÿ2,!ÿ/3+,?&'ÿ-"ÿ-3('ÿ2?%&&<&,-ÿ=(..ÿ5&
&;;&/-(0&ÿ#6",ÿ-3&ÿ&+%.(&%ÿ";ÿ"#%ÿ)('6+-/3ÿ";ÿ+,ÿ&E<+(.ÿ,"-(/&ÿ-"ÿ!"#ÿ"%ÿ"#%ÿ6"'-(,?ÿ";ÿ,"-(/&ÿ";ÿ-3&ÿ/3+,?&'ÿ",ÿ"#%ÿ4&5'(-&1ÿ4&
'#??&'-ÿ!"#*ÿ-3&%&;"%&*ÿ%&E%&+)ÿ-3('ÿ'&/-(",ÿ";ÿ"#%ÿ4&5'(-&ÿ;%"<ÿ-(<&ÿ-"ÿ-(<&ÿ-"ÿ'-+!ÿ(,;"%<&)ÿ";ÿ+,!ÿ'#/3ÿ/3+,?&'1ÿB'&ÿ";ÿ-3&
4&5'(-&ÿ5!ÿ!"#ÿ+;-&%ÿ'#/3ÿ,"-(/&ÿ'3+..ÿ5&ÿ)&&<&)ÿ-"ÿ/",'-(-#-&ÿ+//&6-+,/&ÿ5!ÿ!"#ÿ";ÿ'#/3ÿ<")(;(/+-(",'1
gsNMGJKtpNKGf
u!ÿ'#5<(--(,?ÿ+,ÿ"%)&%*ÿ!"#ÿ+/A,"=.&)?&ÿ-3+-ÿ!"#ÿ+%&ÿ+#-3"%(a(,?ÿ#'ÿ-"ÿ.('-ÿ"#%'&.0&'*ÿ+.",?ÿ=(-3ÿ!"#*ÿ+'ÿ+ÿ%&/(6(&,-ÿ";
/"%%&'6",)&,/&ÿ;%"<ÿ-3&ÿB8ji_ÿ%&.+-&)ÿ-"ÿ!"#%ÿ-%+)&<+%A'1ÿ@"#ÿ<+!ÿ/3+,?&ÿ-3('ÿ+-ÿ+,!ÿ-(<&*ÿ5#-ÿ(,/.#)(,?ÿ#'ÿ+.."='ÿ#'ÿ-"
5&--&%ÿ'&%0&ÿ!"#ÿ+,)ÿ<+!ÿ6%&0&,-ÿ#'ÿ;%"<ÿ6%"0()(,?ÿ/&%-+(,ÿ'&%0(/&'ÿ'#/3ÿ+'ÿ<",(-"%(,?ÿ+,)ÿ/+.&,)+%(,?1
228798779272789
787 5200
0121321405 6789
ÿ
1-1
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document ÿ787Filed
ÿÿ68712/26/17
98ÿ7 Page 134 of 142
"#$%&'ÿ)*+,-.
/01ÿ/34516437ÿ89:;91ÿ<=3;>1<ÿ=?ÿ611=ÿ=01ÿ=34516437ÿ9115<ÿ?@ÿ?A3ÿBA<=?613<ÿ;9ÿ4ÿC3?@1<<;?94DEÿB?A3=1?A<ÿ495ÿ1@@;B;19=ÿ649913F
G1ÿH49=ÿ1>13IÿBA<=?613ÿ=?ÿJ1ÿKLLMÿ<4=;<@;15Eÿ<?ÿH1ÿH;DDÿH?37ÿH;=0ÿ49IÿBA<=?613ÿH0?ÿ04<ÿ49IÿNA1<=;?9<ÿ?3ÿB?9B139<ÿ4J?A=
=01;3ÿ@;D;9:<FÿOA3ÿBA<=?613ÿ<13>;B1ÿ=146ÿ;<ÿ6451ÿACÿ?@ÿ515;B4=15ÿ=34516437ÿ31C31<19=4=;>1<ÿH;=0ÿ?91ÿ:?4DÿPÿ=?ÿ611=ÿ14B0ÿBD;19=Q<
9115<ÿ;9ÿ4ÿ@3;195DIEÿB43;9:Eÿ495ÿ1@@;B;19=ÿ649913FÿR@ÿI?Aÿ5?ÿ9?=ÿ=0;97ÿH1ÿ04>1ÿ61=ÿ=0;<ÿ:?4DEÿD1=ÿA<ÿ79?Hÿ495ÿH1ÿH;DDÿJ1ÿ04CCIÿ=?
6471ÿ1>13Iÿ1@@?3=ÿ=?ÿ31<?D>1ÿ=01ÿ;<<A1<ÿ=?ÿI?A3ÿ<4=;<@4B=;?9FÿR@ÿH1ÿ5?9S=EÿCD14<1ÿ31NA1<=ÿ4ÿKLLMÿ31@A95ÿ?@ÿ=01ÿ@11<ÿI?AÿC4;5ÿ=?ÿ=01
/34516437ÿ89:;91FÿT?AÿB49ÿ<195ÿA<ÿ49ÿ164;Dÿ4=ÿ<ACC?3=U=3451643719:;91FB?6ÿV64;D=?W<ACC?3=U=3451643719:;91FB?6Xÿ?3ÿB4DD
A<ÿ=?DDÿ@311ÿ4=ÿKÿVYZZXÿZ[KP\]Z^F
R@ÿH1ÿ6471ÿ49ÿ133?3ÿ;9ÿI?A3ÿ@;D;9:EÿH1ÿH;DDÿ5?ÿ?A3ÿJ1<=ÿ=?ÿ456;=ÿ;=ÿ495ÿ6471ÿ=01ÿB049:1<ÿ911515ÿ=?ÿ@;_ÿ=01ÿB?331B=;?9ÿ4<ÿ<??9ÿ4<
H1ÿB49ÿ4=ÿ9?ÿ455;=;?94DÿB?<=ÿ=?ÿI?AF
`D14<1ÿ9?=1ÿ?9DIÿ/34516437ÿ89:;91ÿ@11<ÿ431ÿ31@A954JD1aÿ4DDÿ:?>139619=ÿ@11<ÿ;9>?D>15ÿ;9ÿI?A3ÿ@;D;9:ÿ<13>;B1<ÿ431ÿ9?9P31@A954JD1F
/01ÿbc`/Oÿ64Iÿ1_C13;19B1ÿ51D4I<ÿ?3ÿ519IÿI?A3ÿ4CCD;B4=;?9ÿH;=0?A=ÿ49Iÿ@4AD=ÿ?@ÿ=01ÿ/34516437ÿ89:;91Fÿ/01<1ÿ;<<A1<ÿ431ÿ?A=ÿ?@
?A3ÿB?9=3?Dÿ495ÿH;DDÿ9?=ÿJ1ÿ=01ÿJ4<;<ÿ@?3ÿ4ÿ31@A95F
R@ÿI?Aÿ51B;51ÿ=04=ÿI?AÿH49=ÿ4ÿ31@A95Eÿ4DDÿ<AB0ÿ31NA1<=<ÿ6A<=ÿJ1ÿ<AJ6;==15ÿH;=0;9ÿdLÿ54I<ÿ?@ÿCA3B04<1FÿT?A3ÿ31@A95ÿH;DDÿJ1ÿ;<<A15
;9ÿ=01ÿ<461ÿ@?36ÿ=04=ÿ;=ÿH4<ÿ31B1;>15Fÿe?3ÿ1_46CD1Eÿ;@ÿ=01ÿC4I619=ÿ=?ÿ/34516437ÿ89:;91EÿffgÿH4<ÿ6451ÿJIÿB315;=ÿB435ÿ=019ÿ=01
31@A95ÿH;DDÿJ1ÿ;<<A15ÿ=?ÿ=01ÿ<461ÿB315;=ÿB435ÿA<15ÿ=?ÿ6471ÿ=01ÿC4I619=Fÿh?H1>13Eÿ;@ÿI?AÿB0??<1EÿI?Aÿ64Iÿ31NA1<=ÿ=?ÿ31B1;>1ÿ4
B315;=ÿ@?3ÿ@A=A31ÿ/34516437ÿ89:;91EÿffgÿCA3B04<1<iC4I619=<ÿ;9<=145ÿ?@ÿ4ÿ31@A95F
j,k-#++l&#*%k
G1ÿ31<13>1ÿ=01ÿ3;:0=EÿJA=ÿ431ÿ9?=ÿ?JD;:4=15Eÿ=?ÿD;6;=ÿ=01ÿ<4D1<ÿ?@ÿ?A3ÿC3?5AB=<ÿ?3ÿ<13>;B1<ÿ=?ÿ49IÿC13<?9Eÿ:1?:34C0;Bÿ31:;?9ÿ?3
mA3;<5;B=;?9FÿG1ÿ64Iÿ1_13B;<1ÿ=0;<ÿ3;:0=ÿ?9ÿ4ÿB4<1PJIPB4<1ÿJ4<;<FÿnDDÿ51<B3;C=;?9<ÿ?@ÿC3?5AB=<ÿ?3ÿC3?5AB=ÿC3;B;9:ÿ431ÿ<AJm1B=ÿ=?
B049:1ÿ4=ÿ49Iÿ=;61ÿH;=0?A=ÿ9?=;B1Eÿ4=ÿ=01ÿ<?D1ÿ5;<B31=;?9ÿ?@ÿA<FÿG1ÿ31<13>1ÿ=01ÿ3;:0=ÿ=?ÿ5;<B?9=;9A1ÿ49IÿC3?5AB=ÿ4=ÿ49Iÿ=;61Fÿn9I
?@@13ÿ@?3ÿ49IÿC3?5AB=ÿ?3ÿ<13>;B1ÿ6451ÿ?9ÿ=0;<ÿ<;=1ÿ;<ÿ>?;5ÿH0131ÿC3?0;J;=15F
/01ÿ<1B=;?9ÿ0145;9:<ÿA<15ÿ0131;9ÿ431ÿ@?3ÿB?9>19;19B1ÿ?9DIÿ495ÿ<04DDÿJ1ÿ?@ÿ9?ÿD1:4Dÿ@?3B1ÿ?3ÿ1@@1B=FÿR@ÿ49IÿC3?>;<;?9ÿ?@ÿ=0;<
n:311619=ÿ;<ÿ01D5ÿ;9>4D;5ÿJIÿ4ÿB?A3=ÿ?@ÿB?6C1=19=ÿmA3;<5;B=;?9Eÿ<AB0ÿ;9>4D;5;=Iÿ<04DDÿ9?=ÿ4@@1B=ÿ=01ÿ19@?3B14J;D;=Iÿ?@ÿ49Iÿ?=013
C3?>;<;?9<ÿB?9=4;915ÿ;9ÿ=0;<ÿn:311619=Eÿ495ÿ=01ÿ3164;9;9:ÿC?3=;?9<ÿ?@ÿ=0;<ÿn:311619=ÿ<04DDÿB?9=;9A1ÿ;9ÿ@ADDÿ@?3B1ÿ495ÿ1@@1B=F
/0131ÿ431ÿ9?ÿ=0;35PC43=IÿJ191@;B;43;1<ÿ?@ÿ=0;<ÿn:311619=FÿT?Aÿ64Iÿ9?=ÿ4<<;:9ÿ=0;<ÿn:311619=ÿ?3ÿI?A3ÿ3;:0=<ÿ495ÿ?JD;:4=;?9<
0131A9513Eÿ;9ÿH0?D1ÿ?3ÿ;9ÿC43=Eÿ=?ÿ49Iÿ=0;35ÿC43=IÿH;=0?A=ÿ?A3ÿC3;?3ÿH3;==19ÿB?9<19=Eÿ495ÿ49Iÿ4==16C=ÿJIÿI?Aÿ=?ÿ5?ÿ<?ÿH;DDÿJ1
;9>4D;5F
oA;B7ÿD;97<
/34516437ÿp1:;<=34=;?9ÿVi<13>;B1<i=34516437P31:;<=34=;?9X
g?6C31019<;>1ÿc143B0ÿVi<13>;B1<iB?6C31019<;>1P=34516437P<143B0X
/34516437ÿq?9;=?3;9:ÿVi<13>;B1<i=34516437P6?9;=?3;9:X
e311ÿ/34516437ÿc143B0ÿVi@311P=34516437P<143B0i=34516437P<143B0X
g?CI3;:0=ÿp1:;<=34=;?9ÿVi<13>;B1<iB?CI3;:0=P31:;<=34=;?9X
O@@;B1ÿnB=;?9ÿp1<C?9<1ÿVi<13>;B1<i?@@;B1P4B=;?9P31<C?9<1X
228798779272789
787 !200
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 135 of 142
EXHIBIT W
12/12/2017 Case 5:17-cv-07303 Trademark/Service
Document 1-1 Mark Filed
Application, Principal Register
12/26/17 Page 136 of 142
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Trademark Electronic Application System - TEAS Application
Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 no persons are required to respond to a collection of information unless it displays a valid OMB control number.
PTO Form 1478 (Rev 09/2006)
OMB No. 0651-0009 (Exp. 02/28/2018)
On Tue Dec 12 15:31:07 EST 2017 You completed all mandatory fields and successfully validated the form. It has NOT been filed to the USPTO at this
point. Please complete all steps below to submit the application.
Note: It is important that you review this information for accuracy and completeness now. Corrections after submission may not be permissible, thereby possibly
affecting your legal rights.
Note: If you are using the e-signature approach or the handwritten pen-and-ink signature approach, you must click on the final link to access the specific "text form"
for that purpose.
Application Data
STEP 2: If there are no errors and you are ready to file this application electronically, confirm the e-mail address for acknowledgment. Once you submit the form
electronically, we will send an electronic acknowledgment of receipt to the e-mail address entered below. If no e-mail address appears, you must enter one. If we
should send the acknowledgment to a different e-mail address, or to an additional address(es), please enter the proper address or additional address(es). For multiple
addresses/receipts, please separate e-mail addresses by either a semicolon or a comma.
NOTE: This e-mail address is only for the purpose of receiving the acknowledgment that the transmission reached the USPTO, and is not related to the e-mail that will be used for correspondence purposes
(although it could be the same address. The official e-mail address that the USPTO will use for any future communication is whatever appears in the specific correspondence section of the form.)
Important Notice:
(1) Once you submit this application, we will not cancel the filing or refund your fee. The fee is a processing fee, which we do not refund even if we cannot
issue a registration after our substantive review. This is true regardless of how soon after submission you might attempt to request cancellation of the filing.
Therefore, please review ALL information carefully prior to transmission.
(2) All information you submit to the USPTO at any point in the application and/or registration process will become public record, including your name, phone
number, e-mail address, and street address. By filing this application, you acknowledge that YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO CONFIDENTIALITY in the
information disclosed. The public will be able to view this information in the USPTO's on-line databases and through internet search engines and other on-line
databases. This information will remain public even if the application is later abandoned or any resulting registration is surrendered, cancelled, or expired. To
maintain confidentiality of banking or credit card information, only enter payment information in the secure portion of the site after validating your form. For any
information that may be subject to copyright protection, by submitting it to the USPTO, the filer is representing that he or she has the authority to grant, and is
granting, the USPTO permission to make the information available in its on-line database and in copies of the application or registration record.
(3) Be aware that private companies not associated with the USPTO often use trademark application and registration information from the USPTO's
databases to mail or e-mail trademark-related solicitations (samples of non-USPTO solicitations included).
If you have read and understand the above notice, please check the box before you click on the Pay/Submit button.
Pay/Submit
Help Desk | Bug Report | Feedback | TEAS Home | Trademark Home | USPTO
https://teas.uspto.gov/forms/teas.service?form.action=SIGNRES&formId=bas&id=USPTO/BAS-24.5.91.150-20171209150659049380-New/Application-… 1/2
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 137 of 142
EXHIBIT X
12/12/2017 Applicants
Case 5:17-cv-07303 and registrants
Document 1-1represented
Filed by excluded parties
12/26/17 Page| USPTO
138 of 142
Review copies of show-cause orders and exclusion orders issued by the Commissioner for Trademarks
Get information on unauthorized practice of trademark law and who may practice before the USPTO in trademark matters
Once a party has been excluded, the USPTO will change the correspondence address for each affected application or registration file record to that of the
applicant, registrant, or domestic representative, as appropriate, and will notify the affected applicant or registrant that:
The excluded party is not entitled to practice before the USPTO in trademark matters and, therefore, may not represent the applicant or
registrant.
Any power of attorney granted to the excluded party is void ab initio, meaning it was invalid from the start of any action taken by the excluded
party.
The excluded party may not sign responses to Office actions, authorize examiner’s amendments or priority actions, conduct interviews with
USPTO employees, or otherwise represent an applicant, registrant, or party to a proceeding before the Office.
All correspondence concerning the application or registration will be sent to the domestic representative if one has been appointed, or,
alternatively, and in most circumstances, to the applicant or registrant at its address of record.
Go to the Trademark Status & Document Retrieval (TSDR) system and enter your serial number or registration number to retrieve the record for
your application or registration.
Once you have retrieved your application/registration record in TSDR, select the “Status” tab and review the Attorney/Correspondence Information
to confirm that the correspondence information is correct.
If the correspondence information is incorrect, correct it by filing a Change of Correspondence Address form. If necessary, you may also change the
owner’s address information, using the Change of Owner’s Address form. Both forms are available at Correspondence and Attorney/Domestic
Representative Forms.
Select the “Documents” tab in TSDR and view the outgoing correspondence from the USPTO in the record to determine if you are required to file
anything in connection with your application or registration, such as a response to an Office action, a statement of use, or a registration maintenance
document.
If your application is still pending and you fail to file a required document before the deadline, your application will be abandoned. If your mark is
already registered, and you fail to submit the required registration maintenance documents on time, your registration will expire or be cancelled. All
required documents may be filed electronically by using the appropriate electronic form in the Trademark Electronic Application System (TEAS).
After your initial review of your application or registration record, continue to monitor the status of your application or registration, using the
“Status” tab in TSDR.
For applications, you should check the status every six months between the filing date of the application and issuance of a registration.
If your mark is already registered and you have filed an affidavit of use or excusable nonuse under §8 or §71 of the Trademark Act, or a
renewal application under §9 of the Act, you should check the status of the registration every six months until you receive notice that the
affidavit or renewal application has been accepted.
https://www.uspto.gov/trademark/trademark-updates-and-announcements/applicants-and-registrants-represented-excluded 1/3
12/12/2017 Applicants
Case 5:17-cv-07303 and registrants
Document 1-1represented
Filed by excluded parties
12/26/17 Page| USPTO
139 of 142
Questions?
For pending applications, contact the assigned examining attorney, whose contact information is provided in Office actions sent in
connection with your application. In TSDR, Office actions are identified as “Offc Action Outgoing” in the “Documents” tab. For registrations,
contact the assigned Post Registration specialist, whose contact information will be provided in any Office action sent in connection with
registration maintenance filings, or the Office of Petitions at 571-272-8950.
For general questions about the trademark process, guidance on the type of information required in a particular electronic form, or
information about which USPTO offices or employees to contact for particular issues, contact the Trademark Assistance Center at
571-272-9250, or toll-free at 1-800-786-9199. You can also email TrademarkAssistanceCenter@uspto.gov.
If your application is still pending, and a registration has not yet issued, you should review any documents submitted on your behalf to confirm that
it was signed by the appropriate party and that all the information in the document is correct. If you believe that any submitted document was
improperly signed or contains incorrect information, you should contact the assigned examining attorney, who can answer questions about the
process for resubmitting documents.
If your mark is already registered and registration maintenance documents have been submitted on your behalf, you should review the documents to
confirm that they contain accurate information and are properly signed. If you have any questions about a registration maintenance document
submitted on your behalf, you may contact the assigned Post Registration specialist whose contact information will be provided in any Office action
sent in connection with registration maintenance filings, or the Office of Petitions at 571-272-8950.
For additional information on who may sign documents submitted to the USPTO in connection with trademark applications and registrations, see
Proper Representation in Trademark Matters and TMEP §§611.03–611.04.
Consider hiring a qualified attorney with expertise in trademark matters to represent you in the application process. While a USPTO trademark
examining attorney will try to help you through the examination process even if you do not hire an attorney, USPTO attorneys are not permitted to
give you legal advice.
A private trademark attorney who is licensed in the United States and is authorized to practice before the USPTO may:
Help you avoid future costly legal problems by conducting a comprehensive search of federal registrations, state registrations, and
"common law" unregistered trademarks before you file your application. Comprehensive searches are important because other trademark
owners may have protected legal rights in trademarks similar to yours that are not federally registered. Therefore, those trademarks will not
appear in our Trademark Electronic Search System database, but they could still ultimately prevent your use of your mark.
Help you during the application process with several things that could seriously impact your trademark rights, such as determining the best
way to describe your goods and services and preparing responses to refusals to register your mark that we may issue.
Assist you after your mark is registered by filing registration maintenance documents and by taking actions to help you police and enforce
your trademark rights. While the USPTO registers trademarks, you, as the trademark owner, are fully responsible for any enforcement of
your private trademark rights.
If you decide to hire an attorney, you should be aware that, under U.S. federal regulations, the only individuals who may represent an applicant or
registrant in trademark matters before the USPTO, other than certain previously authorized trademark agents, are (1) attorneys who are licensed to
practice in the United States and (2) Canadian agents or attorneys who are authorized by the USPTO to represent applicants located in Canada.
Employing a foreign attorney or other individual who is not authorized to practice before the USPTO to represent you in connection with your
trademark application may delay and prolong the trademark application examination process and could jeopardize the validity of any resulting
registration.
The USPTO has established a Law School Clinic program in which participating law schools provide free legal services to trademark applicants in
connection with trademark applications before the USPTO. Each school in the program has its own criteria for accepting clients. If you are interested,
you should contact a participating school to inquire about becoming a client. For a list of schools participating in this program and additional
information about the program, visit Law School Clinic Certification Program.
For more information on finding a qualified private attorney to assist you, visit Using Private Legal Services.
For more information on the unauthorized practice of trademark law and who may practice before the USPTO in trademark matters, visit Proper
Representation in Trademark Matters.
What to do when your application is abandoned
https://www.uspto.gov/trademark/trademark-updates-and-announcements/applicants-and-registrants-represented-excluded 2/3
12/12/2017 Applicants
Case 5:17-cv-07303 and registrants
Document 1-1represented
Filed by excluded parties
12/26/17 Page| USPTO
140 of 142
When an application is abandoned, it means that the application is no longer pending and, thus, a registration will not be issued. The USPTO may deem
your application abandoned if you fail to submit a response to an Office action or fail to respond completely to an Office action; if you fail to respond to a
suspension inquiry; or if you fail to file a statement of use. In addition, an application may be “expressly abandoned,” meaning that the applicant has
requested that application be abandoned and that no further prosecution of the application will occur.
In some cases, you may file a petition to revive an abandoned application or request that an abandoned application be reinstated. More information about
abandonment and the process of reviving or reinstating an abandoned application may be found at Abandoned Applications.
If you failed to timely respond to an Office action refusing to accept a §8 affidavit, §71 affidavit, or §9 renewal application due to an extraordinary
situation, you may file a formal petition under 37 C.F.R. §§2.146(a)(5) and 2.148 to accept a late response. You may file the petition electronically using the
Petition to the Director under Trademark Rule 2.146 form, available at Petition Forms. You must file the petition within two months of the issue date of the
cancellation notice. If you did not receive the cancellation notice, or no cancellation notice was issued, you must file the petition must within two months
of the date the Trademark database was updated to indicate that the registration expired or was cancelled.
If your registration expires or is cancelled, but you have proof that a USPTO error led to the cancellation or expiration, you may file a request to
reinstate a cancelled or expired registration. You may file the request electronically using the Petition to the Director under Trademark Rule 2.146 form,
available at Petition Forms. Although a petition fee is required in order to file the form, it will be refunded if USPTO error is found. For a list of examples of
situations where the USPTO may reinstate a cancelled or expired registration, please see TMEP §1712.02(a).
For additional information about maintaining your trademark registration, visit Keeping Your Registration Alive.
https://www.uspto.gov/trademark/trademark-updates-and-announcements/applicants-and-registrants-represented-excluded 3/3
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 141 of 142
EXHIBIT Y
Case 5:17-cv-07303 Document 1-1 Filed 12/26/17 Page 142 of 142