a New Views on Kant’ Judgment of Taste Kans Astras (Notte Dame) ‘he 10s ate acy Hough 4H of ingen so Ka series I int my bur few rs wo hee ea emai Ena sce en eon ow ey pee Bre os fa the coca snd coy af Res oe Gy Se” a an wat Kt el ae gens et fect wt fr stot ey om ns te The pet Tee ben teem fy on conto the a Kat nets! agp eos pun ere yee ed ntl noe vena ee wm noe of he trot impresine Usk ter dened Kan etc e fo Bon 9% Ger 1958 Eck 19 Hendy 15 Nate 9 Mea Sa 90 ne ceson yf bio Hara nog conti Son Her bok The Ral Tat fa Ty of Ce eons ot ecco he seta ve be fen oc 0 Inti vole, Kant andthe Seiya Tae” (98) eee het ‘fren ts os et equ of my wm pston Heron onan etn re el weed ht ae ud ew SS cw efron em iy hel ft one vey bey wha own pon ben Sioce Ran umber fey ees fee oe tomate sci dec op uy abou ht epi Sec own sot Te man er on Ka ee, ‘Sis, steppe an cei Alf se ne Sse speed fo go epee tt, bur when common? Fe Sos Cer a eed oe ty ‘the remaining features In parla, the cam of universal, that adaments 1 See Ames, 1980, 1982, 1983, 199. Very mia ws, deeopd indepen wd mon, [LenS EE reer eementeen sco SSS Erstean ut Amete of te can be propel etkon ol for others and unt one Sheree Ren see of he nun cael snd appa ner wefan Cinen the npc uti of sextet eam of Univer Pris ser hae ew defend, bur tll Bbeve Ua ie whore we 2.Gytiaaa fom in any amp to tndertand Kanth own tenons. At Ting a8 one takes scion the tid Cogs alk of 4 dn of tse, sure appeas that what Kane ie prima sing to dois je aesthetic Joichers in general which jst bo explain ow they can be univrsly MIDE trimay em out hee a wth is other dedvewons, that is explanations Ie nor easy compcling for everyone, but Lake ito be a course of ast {ort to consrct an terpetaton that docs ot even have 4 chance of Jielng the prime rsd that Kant was siming to deduce Hence, wl abel 2B rvcong esos any interpreters who dere rm hr the cla fot univer even heir wea te neni to ther aspcers of efecve Jogos oe connec ic ery cluly with suc fetus 2 xieretedness Dr sbjcrit purpumveness On the other hand 1 wily that one being, {Spill exit” sone propos a nterpreration that sie to show how Kans universality claim can be defended oughly inthe terms he proposed even whic acknowledging that some of the other feature (2g dnterest- fdnes) Kane seach to taste might have to be consiered dispensable {ores they are pena sepulztve definition that makes them one eoul, for example ina that a vate “dsincresed” prciscly when and only ‘when tallow uniter) Tn addin, nthe service of preserving compat bby withthe itenson to provide » dedocton of tat, a mid revaonist, account could inzoduce some features which seem even diel conay £0 some of Kanth own espanatons ofthe grounds of tate. In patulan we Admicing hat Kant frequent speaks ofthe non concep and non obj: {ve saute of ate, amd ein coud goon to propose that precy for Kan's own purposes t would ultimately be beer t sy chat ste concep snd objective Suth 2 mld feisionim is worth exploring, 1 believe, because the main semaines ae on the one hand, + srong revisionism that amounts (0 a {empiricism which may be inteenting ine own sight but too uikly fortis the ght o al iself Kanan, and, on the other hand an orthodoxy that hos on the guage of non-concepeulty and nor-objeciy but the cof malig te of Kann te ly ttn ‘ould non-eoncepuaiy and non-object be mysterious here? ‘The very simplest and al woo ofenrached-over ~sesors ae these lest, ‘atest matter of odgmen for Kast and taal one of the basi doctines ofthe Cigar of Pare Rear hat uaent rere concep hence, 90 7 eh ar ly ine bow nan of hr fan ef indepen ‘he. mane how oo te eared td pe ‘nti “ uch wm pes eg ne Tear rage i ped at» mon, iceomcpa Saye Kents ee Siow fbn ay cme sare at it Shes Sole evga ae ee Sivonen wdc dcionp a Beak ee ae Sm crctys bore ged chin Sos hapa oan ie Sr att snes pido Newser cot ange ee ‘Spc ts wl ftree be de cet wat asda Bee coh be amen a ‘onc Ko ots fen spa ftw nn cna nd on bj, she one fe hte ee ee cane fat Oa Stir unpaged note troop aod pee mc supa bar en micro acre Sat dt canbe Ee of neuen wy sce wet the she steer of scutes nthe ther thet eens irons Forte ttn nto sen wen tea ter formal psy ur "coed combate sarang ‘cima of Kam ascendetl pony et oferta en Shc rt nF ope yon te of Ket Sitedtmemen itt niece psn fie eae eae tm mesa merare orton un fe mf eee Spec annoy we cpm spe Kae Henley of olen ty showing how ora ane edt ing al dans spent eof emg oped cnc Pabttoc tac tec Suc we al tee a Geog sae Thad een aermanesolsTe Raf Ta fey of Cet. Urch irae eeu eon er ene fe ae eae ec tol tet po mary of ect rr a ther iy in cer tw sub be pr whee we ethene aye he we pe By eae me Sphere anne of cn ow penn {o bold on wo the orthoon ine. The an otto magn onhedory bat Sarat Sh te er asset a Kan cae SHELS MPA Sitocsane teen amily a i Be ‘ithe befor Rar Fear ng onde sonconrpaiy of Kian te comet eps Cay preset ecu of oe neresig spel Se ST SUR Sein oposite am bowen pee cn eas eae soln tt Rane a ply ee Tg 2 maton fm Cit, 98 1% “Bain ud em ae “ste jen onan ne San om oe Ba iD. Garena sew Oopa Kan Ate ‘ona dninetion erveenseshevie ree a the uments, seh Sees Cae hs pres he aking he juhene proper ene Se par of ter ohh nlf openly sueceeds an unenial™ eee Rel pencedare™ whch the barron of the faebes na aesthetic Fe lation pres that we dn a al sch a complex ana EP vcncs Rant reatnce in 59 thatthe plesore i tase the Gactcne ace han he uses ene Rant sks“Wheter [ii hamcnr of easte the feclng of pure precedes the ding ofthe Ghipelor tn ler proces the formen” and Kar gies there "the (ese ong the sce pnd hi eee temo of he copie facut “Thr teu doce ser to nate lly enmigh that for Kathe pease in ase po he source of judgment such, butt consequent and iter here the nesly thse would obo be al the harder to runnin, Ths ot an especialy mysterio iden one els that ini Erie ovk oo eae Kant aspen of how atc fein. namely fips can be the consequence of onc acknowledgement ofthe mor a, SrScitowledgmene wich anal undertod a he jdgmene ha the tae is Binding’ (Note also that making jugmen fandaental ere come asl ch ewan tha ar the scctence ofthe plese tat ren From ss jmen, hee co aoe all ort of high level adementa ‘Sou the aprpraenss of the Bat vel gent and its pleases Complessnnt ante bees ether tin resting withthe soliton dha Kansan thet judgment precedes ane please, Ginsborg repeatedly iss tha hey ate "one andthe same’ I uepet she tesoets to sch a8 xtreme vew bees of n unfortunate preseppotion. Once one stony tached to the doctne ofthe non-coneepuaiy of taste, karly seems Steacive to daw asthe judgment elowe to feeling and thus not make zope to bean indepement nee act. However, Ras does oe ean tery tot in aste the plesure doesnot precede the judging, what he says i thatthe ugg mun precede the plessre This 4 prio hei, ta ¥en these Of eoune the quezuon can be prevsed, how can one je shout the pleasure, if one docs alrendy have 1 Here again I beheve the Gar enim tae tt et Fieri See camera piitigt fatten cases Ea mn 4 Sadho i. Cece 18 4 Smeaton ale Settee Cet ne Sein niemenel waeeterene rey eta osha d na arene he Tenchi cimnes Stolen aps epee Seer alperae meee age SUT an chains tence em ees acaceence sass oc ne damn mrs ee sin anda ee Le pee eee es Siar ace iontec orate costae Sedna unten ame Sonoma iysareoemeea ain mallee SOTGRETES ng RS ha er Seman oh race ig pen nies rd ec ey Danae a clan clade Ra tebetah eer Tr Salny abort eet cope nec ate ee et ee Reena ie ames oe Se neta seal eran aaer pean hee dren pens ee a el ee cee lore yan fori che tn'me MES He a eae ee raigriae tod Soe eee eee ase ‘iculars, in individual states of judging and feeling (which can, of course, be sa iiee ty ae hoe cabot cas Te i a i ee eee {ch have very different necessary srotures ~ for example only udgents ‘can have truth value ~ and there is no point in jettisoning such # sensible ioe Ce neces nema na! i tn meet tart “Rants neepe eaea ut Ane oe ee objet cert Wat To employ such a “eerain way is precisely what fs common called using a concep. (Otten ic is anzved that such aesthede perception cannot be concepral becuse concepts ar rule governed, and tha hind of perception dot not consist in tubing tems onder 2 rule, More cocenuyy Wiigenseiian Potts abou the lntaons of deserminate rules sem to hat inepted some to aque that something ke a non-conceptal aesthetic ely mt eit 98 4 general precondison forthe posnibly of oor employment of emprcal ‘onceprs" Bur this aqgument can be tered around, fr what rather ap [eats o show dat she mere noon of roles ives ut too aie a picture in general of what having a concept consists in. Ae Anthony Save has argued, fone asumes that for concepts one must have a lest exten of cote ppition and if] shi asamp is Bing wed 1 ty of Fung what an empl nce thn one mig wel be che {o at there ae re, mie share one wat oy with We ‘etn da what une gency male he aon of ptt ele ithe radine of peo in ight of al toe cneumsance ome ogee ‘hone another it sang hat the objet 8 there seems to be na eeson ‘oh Kinase agents which we mateo the spon at oar ‘a comet age wh wil ne coun steal bjtne nts tat 2 way to eco without Wetton 28 epioel Seve jumps hereto concision about objet, but leaving that ide ‘Grn, hs rea show at How onan ten conden boxe 2 Sot ‘ "Ghatak 0, 10, Shape 1992, = i Sas ee eee a eee sai) kine em tenig oe ce aa a roma ohn Newey een a te inky suf poopie ton ee abner ene "compan sate soca” peer eases eh Salpw ndonand see ee sa a nanop dint™ Noting ote mec ase Roe Tate ov abo Kas pty oan bya has es no sneer endewendeg ead "ae ene aa ecirs Ts crpon Re te es ony fone soot Sar Ral rh ha he bes ps eon ees ti at snhete peed eg mean tease espe “Semi per me aban es crderancng ofthe erm, We cul tera at le moray of ge trees pre in pr adh gf emepad te wa Shes sy cncpsn arse Ra a et BThatt wus apeningo oper ras ne See Sr be “indecent em ie Oe oe tpn owed Guth rete e we founded una we was ey feral ean esd eaten Tey cul be fora ee ‘Sree soa pc dome see A cen boc eo SE no apes par ony “oben ee trans cs fe Sat eoplooe pea! ofa oe eerie aoe tse pel harm fo tl eal WSinme concep fr hee ce comept ot ee arse) in he eRe cchccay acne meee bun ren ened TE TSRETSPA Sy Te hon we atu nbd oe “Te onton might coumer tt the be ume Nt hl ot whe ee ct ad oc what we approve inte, resansby cverthing that has any sense in the Kanan word cin in pine come SOE Moctnpi tea ya te oe ea 17 Sesto om 2, lame andan bat sae wwe apron inte" ft eae whether concep ae (scape al ae Solin edag ste Rar ven wl every un ot thar ‘Ren psn fle ony i cul he sow that st tte ean be fle cnc Te ne of yr ae Fema tei on thy sai, in pais that Se tisgrmer ara cacoess what reve thc besa Nowe do at Kis oun dificult ronsa shout concept temo bied co clams sat ow te come to knw the hen leap ache jdgen ose etee parposive for does tox bse tslf om ay reer coneepe or Jos [RSs any such" Th gn can be ae co mean simply that what such Faden deca fst on or furmsh in. partear atrl Kind of determining Freperg of te “perce” of "an" objet Fi, he ges 10 ny the {round of tate isn he form of the ubect for reeevon in generh”™ a in this wae the aesthetic uderont “determines the object in espet of ‘sts and the predate of bens" Unfortunatly, Kane al ya tat th very determining happens “independent of eonespte” Bu agin it feikng tha he aks the rouble to indicate what he ess i eo of very {pec echion, andthe wine cash vue of his "ndcpendence” cam {in be spelled out in term of hese eclont His pone that theres ne nae” of “deren eogetion” he, tha hee “no ele sence oan cnespe which anche ils do thatthe jument not ‘Sceasoned by an itll sn or “ital” act (C59 8 ‘ne were carly to avoid thee Linds of cocspatzstone and sy tat teste snce doce involve predtin and jadgme ad aprcement wih 3 ‘objec ina cetin way, sl annon be wholly wathout what we ander byeoncepty I cannot te how Kant hrf would have fered expe a the eel of terminology Given the atch Liban radon he had tg Se. Neg i diy ec cc ea ‘gel tee my tpt pray ee a eer dee ee step ee a li ttm Copan grande % Cingucten e1e" de m es Crp i Rein ht ‘peace C90 Ss) ha ctr eof ha ae ght Re em lh Tita of oman mp Se cae nh dau 1 fe Bt Cia em oy mayan emp cmn feogon sete tpn He, wo pup om Rae eS ae GL $9, 21: "Nas benim aber das Geschnacaure unaioyg, won Begs, das (Shan Rehan Whee un i Pi dre” see Nese het i ae : ” ste ses oly undersudabethat he mph have one aie oer fant aver ak of eomeep ‘have lied a Kant Schon ad Kive asta fom Laer he pone charatertes th ste "aha ar cone Aneres tate 28» harmo ase a ce play of oe een ea Ute anus that since ate i nivery va, he ste Be see tcmnmiicabl for there coud ot be neoplion ves eee tem ofthe abject with which gen epesentaon Gm hate ea) ae to gece" Tha te contin, scope js oc note et tie conept i ao inves eny what nan weed coponn™ “The operave eontaing avon for “Ucnecopicr he no "hon ceyriton bo ther “top inner the fiw py of te ope feels io tne ems ia imation and unde pei "WHO cach other equ f ogo npc (CLS) Anorher way to proach the conceal sue tha 0 conier wha is inv nthe greet or “aroun of flesh Kant noes here Since tino me vy snd se eget nd een a > prt rlson of nur hgher fl, aber of very pee snd ete irl sccm only mata to contrac th tron a ox cy IRakpendco of sess Cinsbngsvews nteprtone ft bay Shc iestca ke bebe non conceal cops of pure oma Teter of the mand She ces ti approsch on been ofthe ‘sn-concptaliy elim but beau she think the ter "pee formal” Coheed bee fr ening wha meant by the armony of fest ctl desgnates whatever ist reas sucha hamany” | beeve thr ae mlpedes ss neseve woe 0 fhe ew of here bare more important sbjecton is thst a longa 8 cx tut rccogit imac opens epecaly 068 os a a « “SNow-concepne” act insborg doc ot rae hs oi bu se does Gute Srrwoprcht po ou to conser an tren propel ty Guyer wich ‘Topprecisey tseateand aes te harmony of can cos ot ina ayes of ecopon but thr justin elation of what Kano fly teed te pisces of aceon eo) a o> Socion Gn og) * Here Gitborg repens he gett ad ne ton cbjeaon tat king the harmony tobe vo cenenary woud imprest way that would ppt fee Kao ino the audi of teqaingcverying we perce a exe © Gator i. 56 Gey te 2 Gen fs she es Gaeta (979 15-0 of eR oman reise c ie ct fe non arene mE, om tos nd acme Ave » Cult iva Ct Aw 0h 1-38“w Ans ein wis approach wl ein wih he pin hat Kane 2c ieee eared ah ee ion uf mag SES teaaing bof iaon and magnon. The reece cnt Spree ths perso inter of 4 eoneepe ray ore ere eden” bur in terms of 2 pecched “raion berwern the reo x eotie elses Lak gun ta uch x complex pereepton Pee Sunderam without sre se of coer and Ue Kan EeScno mean or thane er oo concept a abt that ese EOS" Tubahing af rer sence soda” soe Cir a ‘Sac te opp weeps ec than adit hte Barony led etter Sp tht cal sl vag ee Tormey she propore draping the wk that he Nasmony oe ym Sear a Cowesing ht fn Kaves sunre ew sythets shay ag cnequazaien sng why she contends ta he Rarmony is se ‘eho sui epreseon one wich Kant srs ge with Uucstomparso’ to ates Thur se siposely emaine feof synthe Sh and cncep On my tw th soy only eater ence an the td of atte poston tha oer cn foee one ito Wo be trch caro coeds hn of sone fy peeepon of spese ration tx apeenentbewcencomples ens =n ths cae get fle of og Soa mat ioe te sec sd ome concep even boat taper none veprsonan anderen fie docs vate a 9p epee {Shand comparatte proses? if the harmony ofthe faces nd tase a8 Corp wd jets Kast ppnow ct help bbe hee Sd concep On Glsborgs owen tate nen“ a compeely fcr fom 3 cin co univer ai tht involved in tote deter fare wy nal enpiseoion” But came tht ae une nd ‘eben al ogsiton dono become non cone ot ose sete chat ter smpy hen they can be cette wt ome her Cams ato Der pe np on enna jer Henn rece inerpetaion has focwsed om pei thi point. He ashe armor ply fe eas ne tole sn opteon ftbeundersundings “power of xhibng concep by vito of fare ‘Eeincave ofthe cxhbioon [Dent concep tat ne deed fom eepion in gener an oral way Hse hens gee compas the ste f be imgoon wth condos of pole con- {Sprang Re} one Gre ten ach for ce ls oe cones} of nl ni fh ny eh ay cn —* into, 190, 88, om Ga ao, 1979, 22, om he Ft aac {eric Bg a a ne Aang Wo Weiss EC new Seee et fle te met eine Tne a ne to ty re Belt steelees bestimmt ec tarectree oe Aer ial concede at tp ho nde ters the play porto the acqusion of try pace coneeee oe athe far aby spoken of tows Seecbog mae er ee tren om isd of can ot re nd ee ‘unavoidable. ee be ‘The non-conceprualist can of course always proceed by using some resid stipulate noson of cones and in tat way cay gee proses etn ny cps ppc a hr one cme iy pes the ot nerd teary fcc eee Batacs Sneak hoes sand» on-concepua level of mind that ndats kind of ey can ‘ete rh int ane of pm ef epson eb tae ie sho ce Ste for Te Soci bees Pee a tne of expres dn wt te eho ae weet reso oar so me ee Oa Fgmens andthe ans of mid thy eqae shel eerl Je tue that “to fel war on touching 2 stone i ot Jett hee 8 concept so nde pope of ede ie Soe! cntay wh Gig mre ve ag itor eet the mcf pepo el cer on pee 7 lar one tay sma neyo Soro pion oa Te ec cot np en fare Br Galea ete shee mile of ge ta ol sy Sel of Kansan epee we machin tn ee The Ginsborg speaks of an “assimilation that I am ‘between the way in which representations are represented in a judgment of perception and ther neh eye te bce yo pees Ther upon Geng own sun y+ eer Oe Tre cone some nes Sf oc pee ta ‘Septcn of epeenates evan seal hore etc tec jecoeay rdeyfam Rann oget of peepot wrth Ana selec ef epee ny or beet ‘of “experience”; as merely 4 “sequence,” it is not at the level of truth or che. Hat hat ames ing Sera eer cuerer ae see ape eegie Eke ae an Pee SR:we a jg tl aa se petra gar omen tha € bres ee pe ray Soar theeshnowlage af tn eternal word reel in oer se Se UNI inthe hes hth cal be aleve of universal ay Tenet mle cea of tal py bjt npn ico snmine janes ppsscss wo a "betve wy” Of mind Sir iiherm rent ta hae julgmone ai aad concep sore, Ghind and pong up he nomconcepalt approach ste ake is be esr ‘Trin te conceal domain, there io couse an importa distinction berween cones snes n ger and the specie Re ode acts of isdonen: tne nse: cea jet ht one cin hol onto thi dite Tetra sel go ooo a ht the end Karun tnt Best eonseved 2 invog voip conepaiy bur ao objet ‘One mutation for cece the wa ean ep espn 03 eu itn ord eat, ary tat one she Kans deuton oF te Ee to bence the conc tha ales ae bea fal hat he “eden sys tat tte is round on a haemony ha is unites conmanzble hecnse part of wat eid for “coon in gene fa then can seem that sae al ets meet these condos for cog Sen they must be sid tobe bens. On a non-concepunln view shi prolem can appeat epi act, sine in that ese the condtions that Ee sufhcen for someting be acetal aproved ae met een Te carly since they donot ern nslve conception "Nos ft added thst harmony and ate do rege concept nd eva concept ofa very ophisiened ort, the od problem sbout omnipresent ‘eu des cae ela an ye ks oul happen the al ‘jee we eneumter mig have to be sd vo Be ben ty do mest thea tea coneptal condos fo oon in gre Bat sts important ot that Kant speshs no simpy ofa gee amon fected fr copison but abo of "oe spec propoon of the cognitive felis that some objects may generate more than ethers © Object Ceres ina ths pin, by wg hat the anal way to develop the de of {hi speci propouon i ay tat some objects have moe ofan seibete form han her, and tat the perception of di form which i invaved inthe apc proporion uf we Al hs ean sks puce Ina ay at ‘mpasble wih the barmony of fucken rqued fora eogion and th tere can be univer commasleabe even ft involves more than mkeng cynic ayes that Kant Pet SSR aL Sah amet nae an er Sate ave eee wy oo encae o Saar costean ea anes reve bec nod Jecaho be uve a eee ieee area eee Lies eae etn ce tinker opin EEO MON gee Biase et Ret or lt ly an sia cae ube Srna eae i ig term tof bs rece meh oe rn ear spencer cena fo te ete toe bet bee he ponepbet le icc tM of eco eo sy ecm come on ee eng, cas sei oeeaa cutee dmesg decal Se yang eet occ Spy ll tg cots ar oe Seas ed feta are et sme ae cniternseerac creme rate mate aes ponghelp appear erp rears io ine cee ig mtn friend ty ice ores See ae orl iy ome cen rain ore petiabenir repeats where what it ta be ‘with seuhei quale (1 yen of "ihe fui nthe search for specific wa" of beauty and {a “no 1 do say that one option for the nt conde in general «parce comple of pmary qien™ end then ndei het ea notes how Wiggins brings out the “normativiry” of aesthetic claims: “if judg- oan sects en eperaene ae SNR to te ad Wad tehie eae a is rere aie peed einer si es entrar ern ee Seca areata, arom Men eo ad sti ene ream dee itr Toni emake aaa es oe oa eas Se re aa ees 4 ro Ka de a goa perpetrate as capper amare pepe eer ere pen keener See et ees, eee eee eae metre rene cen nai er ioe ee pba es Bebe sens aren etme See Det eeepiaporererie mas ens ee eed oe a eee ner ie ae a oe oa herr walter aoe mpuaewykerpid opie ‘of what underlies taste, Taste ittelf is basically « perception of besudfal oped clergy ‘not know of or even think about such explanatory notions es primary quali- ee ae det ot set wg ied i a eb ee se a re el Se cease SL Site pal ne 8 SE Sc 193s ao Geno, an $8 a Gare, 1 < Se osfa his ice fo Kat pi tf ma oy 1 Bote he dun aye ha foe she ott "he felis wf ee Peo Bki pana eta fr ne je wy the hero te wan [ian Tires bay boca they would serve as evdence forthe pce nc essen ofthe pesuecnsing propery Ath abjeconsle Exerc of Rants oc howe insitence tht “the approval of other can promds eo val prof for the judment of beay"™ Tyee ar a numberof suet be tinged her. 1 i conceded that te ucion fens about fone people actualy prtced in tasty that ithe need thatthe objet br eane ha to believeth in “real Hie oo shold sm at reer could come op with eur rales suey tf other perceiver that would supplant ones cnn diet sextet ection, then the Gusto simply whether a judge of tate could be waraned It prnpn one brew hat the “objet condos” were aid even ‘hough one was not actualy vig ny atte eaperence” Ginsbong ‘eres peecils he pili by apg“ ela that he nq is beaut {amps thn have seen mee but cane ke sen foe met judge tat of sso bent i hase never experienced ie ‘th pont cl be tat the tue has Bote mae of mere ‘words One could certainly be permed to secre the term “jgment of Este" frat by defnton mnt be diet pscepaaljdsrtny, oa then ie coud be simply added tha although such dents could always have tm inciminabesticance, there cold abo be someting else which one ‘in eal “jdnents of beat” oF asthe value, which would not them: seks hve wt dey peep bt oad pk ot he ey se duals a proper fudgrens Of ase. Aralogousy, one might gue tat 0 maser how sence develops, observational watemenseannot be tty replaced by teorecal stem, no matter how closely these might core ‘spond orimersect~ and ye the basic ath of since could el be picked ‘uti tes of theoretic statment ‘The ermioloia procedure saves the doctine ofthe autonomy of taste inne senator i a very intresting wy, Gabon seen to he mate in mind, becaae she beever that here the scaton with taste i fundamen. {ly une that with color Even if one alows tat colon have a neceery ‘btn 1 human experience, evesyne would at lest on oeestion concede ‘object has «pare calor without oneself making » dee expesenee = aya | Cosh cy ao hi re i een ct ea bo ‘gr Sei art emo tama paren ag el opal ee ‘ivi hes wa ne si) Se nang scan ke an Pal omen ae ee ' z Se cre et ech ith ee eee eer aia Sl epg ola ti arrenee a rd luteal Weare or aes Soak at Serrano ge ppt Se ee lerore cel iat nen emer i Feira mien re rngry coe Src scan then how cou be eereoperinr lly crn erenemetiomn peal ge rote ti een ren oat sta wera epee ee a on aie se me one hae ee a scant tare ae moa Ret rts ae el be puns pela ‘best new views on Kant’s judgment of taste. ty i 6.