Title: Effect of blanching green vegetables with baking soda
Problem Statement: Some chefs recommend blanching green
beans, broccoli and other vegetables with a little baking soda to keep them bright green. Chef John however, claims that this treatment can destroy much of their nutritional value. Hypothesis: Vitamin C is easily destroyed by oxidation. This occurs due to heating, exposure to air and alkaline conditions. Baking soda causes alkaline conditions which breaks down the pectin structures in vegetables. Aim: To determine if baking soda causes alkaline conditions which destroys Vitamin C in vegetables. Method: This method can work but you cannot use different vegetables to assess the decrease in Vitamin C or different amounts of baking soda at the same time. Choose one vegetable and vary the baking soda. Keep mass or number of discs constant and then compare. 1. Cut out 5mm discs of beans and broccoli (5 for each) and two other vegetable of your choice. 2. Place each vegetable into separate boiling tubes. 3. Add one teaspoon baking soda for the first vegetable (broccoli), then two teaspoons baking soda for the second vegetable (beans), three teaspoons for the third (cabbage) and four teaspoons for the fourth (dasheen) to 10ml boiling water in another boiling tube. 4. Pour solution into each boiling tube which contains vegetable discs. 5. After a few minutes add a few drops of universal PH indicator to the vegetables. 6. Observe colour change and record it in a table form.
Variables: Controlled: Size of vegetable disc : Volume of water Manipulating: Amount of baking soda Responding: Colour change after PH was added
Data to be collected (Expected Results)
Vegetable Observations Broccoli Blue colour Beans Dark blue colour Cabbage Very dark blue, close to purple Dasheen Light purple colour Treatment of results In the experiment conducted, the baking soda was thought to have caused alkaline conditions when it reacted with the vitamin C in the green vegetables. The PH added, was to test if the alkalinity of the vegetable would increase as the concentration of sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) increased. This was seen through the colour change from a neutral colour which was yellow to a darker colour such as a dark blue or purple. The more alkaline the substance, the darker colours were seen or observed. Since this occurred, it proves that baking soda creates an alkaline solution for vegetables and causes the vitamin C to be oxidised, destroying it. Also another observation that can be made is how soft or mushy the vegetables gets which means the pectin structures in the vegetables were broken down, thus destroying the nutritional value of it. Limitations: Sources of Error: 1. Inappropriate measurements 2. Adding too much indicator Precautions 1. Taking readings accurately to prevent parallax error 2. Adding the same number of discs to each boiling tube