Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Occasional Survey
THE SYNDROME OF DISAPPEARING
INTRAHEPATIC BILE DUCTS
SHEILA SHERLOCK
Department of Surgery, Royal Free Hospital School of Medicine,
Pond Street, London NW3 2QG
The diseases result not from failure of bileducts to form Aberrant expression of HLA class 2 antigen on bileducts
but from destruction during embryonic development.1 is seen in the transplanted human liver undergoing rejection
Histological examination may indicate the stage at which the and in patients with graft-versus-host disease following
damage started.1 At the early stage of formation of the ductal allogeneic bone-marrow transplantation.9-10 Rejection is
494
culminating in disappearance of interlobular bileducts; 11 the such as nuclei, actin, or mitochondria are absent or present
bileduct epithelium is penetrated by mononuclear cells, in low titre.
resulting in focal necrosis and rupture of the epithelium. Primary sclerosing cholangitis has also been associated
Similar lesions are found in graft-versus-host disease with several immunodeficiency syndromes, including
following allogenic bone-marrow transplantation.12 In one familial combined immunodeficiency, 24,25 hyperimmuno-
such patient, severe cholestatic jaundice lasted 10 years, and globulin M immunodeficiency,26 angioimmunoblastic
serial liver biopsies confirmed progressive biliary-type lymphadenopathy,27 and X-linked immunodeficiency.21
,
fibrosis and cirrhosis.13 She ultimately died in liver failure The immunodeficiency may reduce host defences, allowing
that progressed rapidly during the last year of life. This intestinal bacteria to overgrow and so cause ascending
course strongly resembles that of primary biliary cirrhosis. cholangitis. The association may be analogous to that seen
Vanishing bileducts after human liver transplantation with ulcerative colitis-ie, the sclerosing cholangitis could
seem to be related to donor/recipient HLA class 1 mismatch well be infectious rather than immunological.
with class 1 antigen expression on bileduct epithelium and Serum immune-complex activity is higher in patients
also to an immunological reaction at the level of HLA class 2 with ulcerative colitis and primary sclerosing cholangitis
antigens.14 than in those with ulcerative colitis alone z9 Moreover, Fc
receptor-mediated systemic clearance of immune-complex-
Chronic Sarcoidosis .
DISCUSSION
results. Immunosuppressed patients, particularly those
with human immunodeficiency virus infection, may be The processes by which the intrahepatic bileducts can be
prone to cholangitis. In patients with the acquired destroyed are of five main types--developmental,
immunodeficiency sydrome (AIDS) cytomegalovirus immunological, infective, vascular, and chemical.
infection has caused progressive mucosal irregularities of the The developmental group start in utero. Some may have a
intrahepatic and extrahepatic bileducts, with ultimate duct truly developmental origin, but in the majority an extrinsic
destruction.34 Cryptosporidia may cause a mild cholangitis, (non-developmental) cause, such as alpha-1-antitrypsin
but biliary strictures are unlikely.35 However, in one patient deficiency or a virus, operates.
with transfusion-related AIDS a picture resembling The immunological group, exemplified by primary
sclerosing cholangitis developed and cryptosporidia, biliary cirrhosis and hepatic graft-versus-host disease, is ,.
Candida albicans, and Klebsiella pneumoniae were found in marked by loss of tolerance to HLA class 2
the gallbladder tissue and bile.36 histocompatibility antigens on the bileduct and cytotoxic
attack by lymphocytes. Treatment, theoretically, is by
HISTIOCYTOSIS X immunosuppression. In the case of graft-versus-host
disease, intravenous hydrocortisone and cyclosporin A are
A cholangiographic picture identical with that of primary the most satisfactory drugs. The various drugs that have
sclerosing cholangitis may complicate histiocytosis X.37 been used to treat primary biliary cirrhosis range from
The biliary lesions progress from a hyperplastic to a corticosteroids,48 to azatliioprine,49 D-penicillamine,50
granulomatous, xanthomatous, and, finally, a fibrotic chlorambucil,51 and colchicine. 52 Reported trials have
stage.38 Clinically, the picture resembles primary sclerosing usually been too short, too small, and poorly controlled.
cholangitis. Statistically significant long-term benefits are difficult to
establish in disease with such a long and varied natural
a
VASCULAR CAUSES OF DISAPPEARING BILEDUCTS history. Rarely, sarcoidosis produces a similar immuno-
The bileducts are richly supplied by the hepatic artery. logical bileduct injury and here cortoicosteroids may be
Interference leads to ischaemic necrosis and the ultimate useful.
The end picture of sclerosing cholangitis as demonstrated
disappearance of the bileducts, both extrahepatic and
intrahepatic. by cholangiography may be due to a variety of causes.
High-resolution, polyester-resin casts show that the Primary sclerosing cholangitis is associated with
hepatic arterial supply of the bileducts between the immunological features. Immunodeficiency may simply be
confluence of the right and left hepatic duct and the first the mechanism that allows microorganisms to attack the
part of the duodenum is essentially axial, and largely bileduct epithelium. Similar bileduct abnormalities are
towards the porta.39 Injury to this supply-for instance, being reported in other immunodeficient states such as
AIDS.32,33 Other immunological associations, such as HLA
during cholecystectomy-leads to ischaemia of the duct
wall, damage to the ductal mucosa, and entry of bile into the B8, may rather be with the ulcerative colitis than with the
duct, tocause fibrosis and stricture.’ A similar sequence can biliary tract disease. More attention should be paid to the
role of infection in the aetiology of primary sclerosing
complicate hepatic transplantation, especially if the segment
of recipient duct is too short and thus deprived of its arterial cholangitis.
Bacterial cholangitis has two major associations-access
supply. Biliary ischaemia secondary to intimal thickening of
of intestinal microflora to the biliary passages and biliary
hepatic arterioles is a rare feature of chronic allograft
rejection in man." obstruction. Obstruction without infection probably does
not lead to disappearance of bileducts.
5-fluorodeoxyuridine (5-FUDR) can be infused into the
Interference with the hepatic arteriolar supply to the
hepatic artery through an implantable pump to treat hepatic
metastases from colorectal adenocarcinoma. This therapy bileducts leads to necrosis of bileduct epithelium. Sclerosing
may be followed by biliary strictures and a picture cholangitis can follow intrahepatic arterial chemotherapy or
traumatic biliary stricture and, possibly, some of the biliary
resembling primary sclerosing cholangitis.41,42 Ducts in zone
1 (portal) are affected as these depend mainly on hepatic features of liver-transplant rejection may be vascular in
arterial supply. The narrowing of the main bileducts can be origin. More detailed studies of the hepatic arterial tree are
so severe that treatment by the insertion of an endoscopic
needed in all forms of sclerosing cholangitis.
Whatever the mechanism, once the bileducts have
biliary stent may be necessary.43 Bileduct necrosis has also vanished they do not return. In the case of primary biliary
followed hepatic arterial embolisation for malignant liver
tumours.44 cirrhosis, primary and secondary sclerosing cholangitis, and
Cytomegalovirus causes colonic vasculitis with partial biliary atresia a slow biliary cirrhosis develops over 10
to 15 years, the speed depending on the extent of bileduct
consequent haemorrhage.45 It is possible that the sclerosing
loss. The process is much quicker in the graft-versus-host
cholangitis complicating cytomegalovirus infections may reaction. In all these groups the end-stages can usually be
have a vascular basis.
predicted and hence the time when liver transplantation
becomes the only worthwhile therapeutic option.53
CHEMICAL (CAUSTIC) CHOLANGITIS
Prognosis after transplantation will depend on the suitability
Hydatid cysts often communicate with the biliary tree of the patient in other respects, including psychosocial
and sclerosing cholangitis has followed the injection of a stability, age, and concomitant diseases, but generally
scolicidal solution (2% formaldehyde, 20% sodium children with biliary atresia can look forward to a 1-year
chloride or alcohol).46,47 Within months, the strictures result post-transplant survival of 85%, followed by a virtually
in jaundice, biliary cirrhosis, and portal hypertension. Only normal life style,51 while the 1-year survival after transplant
a part of the biliary tree is usually affected. Similar lesions for primary biliary cirrhosis in patients is 83%, and that for
have been produced in animals by injecting formaldehyde or primary sclerosing cholangitis is 75%.54 Retransplant for
20% sodium chloride into the biliary tree.8 chronic rejection results in a 46% survival at 1 year. 54
496