Chapter’ Social Reality as Appearance: Some Notes oni Marx’s Conception of Reality Heimat Rebel troduction Mars characteris he ensmoiy in Capital "versus sere tig ‘ely ses th formulation andor ss ely been vestgned’ Gong ‘Stans 1999, p25 coon tat Mare refers ae exlsely to Goethe's ‘Pout doce ot appear ound. Man's seraon on te “Difrence Boween ‘emertean and psaean Neural Php” flr a futher he a eat fr fee ae Know tir lege. THs ch is tering ot onl for pilot Teast ale gies nights ito the cove covers of Mars mead In he Tour hope of his cavenation, Marx dicumee diferent natural post, ‘Sonceton nd be emphasizes hat Eps ras appearance a parece” ‘wires Demers, contre ges tat "appearance Cos wot by et show Tres oprance, seething eee fom esac’ (Mrs, 188] p.68): Mark [ine wot uy Got bue as his Hegel ican thet fea sein’ (Eick, 1990 $2) 9 te Phenomensngy of Spratly the hr haar ‘Fes ani he Unerstuning:Arpsrice an th Spesensele Wer ‘Unio about Hega’'s srgunent i tat amouns to othing Less than a fanaa enumenten sd qe of etal o-oo, Which 6 tka Plo, Hegel tracend Pas supesese word: “Tee sipenenible i teens appearance qu eperance, — We, comets ‘eiunoond is fet tha fe pence wed henge he aes ‘onl nuld areas rd sone crac wet exo ‘ett word poses sopcae oe Suh en” wo eas de eave ss et mh is oben sal ht Ge sapere wold ht THranlaor Now Narr i emuon ce fn Cpa (Mu. 179 pS 80: an once ins Conan a Cie of oe! Eman (MAN 1981, 829. Te Epi tele of Conlin sr hn a "people ad lnpyahie (Mann 167d Bagh verso is Creu mss ‘un dvec hg”(aLp yee ‘hers once Sahil gh tn cage heenonl, we beri ig tanlaed Ses22 Faman Din Sei ntonay andi ite of Caplin perc bt wit hee undead by apenas, athe ‘Ss word ete ely otal ee 177,39. ‘he conscas end the fet superenle wo (Cuil te Hegel's argmennten the nton of be verted world. He ofes peculiar eookastng amples fo a te cea! siicane of this new Eocept of appearance. One i eminded hee of Adomo's Tire She ebox! Hegel whore be diferentaes between te connelson of experience of Hoge ‘Phlosopy sed the cones of expeace i Hepes pslasphy (Aco, 1971, 1.00) Adomo fcwer br on seal theme ef satrlist heory~ be omen [i snepoeslunconciouness of thedcl enieaour el He Gat ier’ Hepes pulesopay in al te aspects as a reecive contellaien of sci ‘bec. "OF intrest aot haw Hegel sbjetvely eed a 8 oF at ‘testing bs, and within Hege'sapreach, how the coi character af jective appearance elected nd conned in is pisephy. What ees tbe Sd ha rat dos fi poopy express a = poopy’ (sd p29. “te Hegelian selection othe subj in philosophical Comcouocs is teu te egunng of society's cea cnsclounese shoe fet (bid, p13) Soci cory mt there" ands wat sccrdng Adora, Mar her) ar achowed~euniteHepts pap beck what Hegel Mad projected ao te guage ofthe bse’ (id, p38). eqs is is ing soe tan eis comciow ot "Using previous example’ be wrt nh aed cape of he Phenomenology, what tastes see rela orardy i We tg, 205 ‘st emo pie nh ctl ape nthe mold of appearance, wos be oh Pine ener ov ewental beng (Hep 1977. p97) Bven when vad eel, Ses examples dott or he sgifcnce of th ww coepon of ppecice More tgnfians ad ineatvey aks fem espe of soca, he eae of pain ate “Tu al cin, twee, ineon a tna m pou, te Inno ih "Bath cin repre caro eta Inet nt alpen the essai th aw We cay oped it he Fn, te ce! pst hat se ‘Seay pent nse eprint ay ston 9 coe) "a een ibe fu Al (7 Zhe of ace ae [onc ihe cnt of peat poetic te ‘Sey sexi gn oh ep, oa ec, Towa ehyuterton of Abin idee aga oy Socaing se nee un expe Woes Set Ray a Appearance Sus Nts on Mara’ Coes ofelty 33 “The revoltioay neest of Hegel's poopy i a cnclves of eaity as fgperince, at an iver wold at ib self selfconrabory. Tolar ‘tli iho Sis wien Bye hve, gna pot ey ‘Specie eppeace’ The peenble wold, wh th vec wed fine vanced he tbr word snd contains it within Kel for il a ‘tweed worl ht ered abo ells oe ad oppose in thr sy (Adama, 1971 PD). Rely a at seed woud coaiss of he nity of to contationy woven. Crnepin it re premise othe of ng st flee ‘aly ie a beng at can only be grape a «dye process he esence a ‘Heel ler aged ma ppesr~ However owe must waa a abo es ‘nein t appar “The Concept ef Appearance inthe arly Marx Mars intrptation f Ep reo hi cosception of pperiact. Ini iw, Fp wae te int who emderod "st spose, at a8 ‘nation of enene acting Saline as sacha alien’ (Mr, 9h), ped). Narco Hep owe concept of spenane agunst him. Marx ‘al otine thr dsertaion, bt acer coma igus in it (ike of Hage ory ofthe ete. Mae srgane Strata weit dees Sot “out 2 cam of oppocag mame, but tht (conermpony) rey i {ton pesetng fel in ver form. Ti spi iverson of cone of pperace however, nfnme bythe changed udertng fhan sei (Bln i bngcescey. Theindialbeapes ae tan no ot of ‘eal elon toh ton, os real sanding (Nar, 183 p80), “Teen yea facet ae shows hit oe ot levi omy lat seg ema commit ht payee, Faye i snd oo he nual ck dos, odo ot Sep SS a Zane ec aly an era quay 3h nt eg neh SOS er cat hf ene mS Attowgh Mare bere dose aot yet focus on hse, he neveless dees IBtividinca ne the deci chaarenic of cls scey The noon34———_-Human Digi: Ss Aanomy ana ne ene wa sesteatiy'? pois wits cms oppose, an conn within tale eases ts nig be fobowng ters ‘Demercy Oe a of ae euehy ot th th of dommrcy. Mosc is tess Soe inousst fst Monch aot be unde i on SzrUStoncy cu’ Gln, p29) Tcl, gone wie yg a FE SPS he crc ore hap! tat hey a tore we ‘So ey tent dom (in, 3 Tre democracy & sonny ae ecules il as be ented and wich SEUSicbaat atte to onto f hemselves scons rpg CELERY ofttce col xsenc. Tis ba mast erp comepon of Seach Seo enwmton Qalandar Soe ace Bone aes, a were a tne apa Ts ‘pout cscs ot Men sconzpn of Senn) inca oa oet fm of te wh 3 ee clea fc esis as npnosazel (tno al ay is version, in ‘aleve dine cg Mar comes of Someney ee oa TORE Summa: fal ty un wen ‘Demcey te aed Milrafalcostatons Har nome} implica in eso eng ‘ats Ge sensu consany owt bck ttl bt te ata TEE ing oe nal pep semble ae people's we wai The ett oper as wnt ss ee groduct of Mant (bi, 7.29). Mare SESS Aare reiy of burgess const and rok se wement of opporie, teosen wi-darend acNy aa ‘Pitehac ppearare ne anes fxm o pol power (Horscha) sere seta appewnmc, which neon, i i eed for of Rete ets contadry Hanh = erased fora of ssh aly. Seer time on Hoosen wae comms denowary wh oer ate {Eon (oom, conrtionl mney, gpa). For i rates moc So" Gitar wac'ae aromatic Tie poled! sate nme ot telson and avesion of bam socel ectoe an he tes & wid aera ned on reson whch il ropes eect ot {ss heap 1m mor, eames his part, ca coin ha iia Gr Be fact tomate tnd Saxe eveying prt. eden Be Soe gre te ao apna tt Sm, ey Wt Be Jpn Scio Re ie ta. The rach hr rein He ear mig tm toe donocny he ple st © shed ‘i p30. > mars Noe Man wi aia "Mt rand eg i af nett Pan nee of Man te ohn se euch a ave es aaa econ} Mic fnd rhe me ete mean at an at nd Ado 178 p08 ‘pun’ wep tin te wine bee ae wiles “hig eth nck oF Marti gs hey fe ne ‘Hegel, Marx states, Nests eon sno be Slane fo epcng the atte of be mode sat a 5D fe Fesming hat ch tena of teste Tht aoa a poe [ect ne cmasaon of orton suse bch enter e ny ‘rats eds convey of wat ly 9 ‘ey pe ih sn a i Ye ei Ro nyse ae Ssore SSE ae aie oe Sets ea ie aoe Sparen Lae se ia Ragteniue anchors eines Rome vlition to enter’: ayia eer ofthe sacl coe! of it SD ROT LSet es cas deeee SE Rew ntie ecas wena rare SpE Terai ieee aor cee Sree mad i Ble ee ice ce se cot fe oom ony of oct pup at St Sete mares oman ees Bae yh ieee heen are ecionl an see SS mnsreras anand oe fos sonst Sint, demerit te eee of alte contains — seid mat 2 Pe Si ce ec ane oe cone Sek ‘andes a sysen onstage tea sens oat sis and {tert on parr eons oe gu he smite dts ot ioctl See Miesac tar ie bade remnte encPitenadon wists nhc ee a f ste men pe mena. ‘Rave nan Scion of mercy Cd 9. ‘Bx bow can this humanely, salty of aman sail reason, be conde? ‘Manis ny able offer 'itor age” wos eel laments ar dived om, stoma eset sol ayesha yx oy ni ne ns of pin et ee ‘esa ett rere Siete etree eee SaSeiieirs genera eee ewes eae caheacmnae Deiat een arenas = iia chinieeateaaiiraas an36 Human Digi Soi Auton and th gue of Ceptlim Despite all he ifizenses bermeen Man's and Reusch’ conceptions of Pteraon, hey age ene fing’ tet atempts To comprehend ebty a8 38 renon server for of sin or soil las rests cn ce asimption tthe euence of that reas, he tonsverted uy, can be conned [Edcpenbenty fom ie forme of appearance Ove can see is already Be Storer of eucbac’s The Etsence of Ciisanly, The fist capt. The ‘Een Natu of Mn, develops a seblanc of hinan estes wich Marx hrc sonst ips sh esis on Feuerbach aan ‘tesa, dumb (rocliy which tually unites he many in’ (are 185,157 i ta re of a fh cn, nl cat ‘Det Staci, oper tara of an? Reman, Wi, ion Toe de (Bon um ave iia ma he ty ean oe, i (Tee ae Sn powes nh ran gomere,ehe poing wits hes be na i nt WEEE tem ssn sera wht eer bo ale, WRovetg, ein, poveming poner (Peter 9373) ‘This esene expresses uti inser form in egos cnstouses = free fas campo! God, Hanan emoneption, for Feersch ts sony ‘The coe guion fm eligow consciousness, out Chistian conepons of (God. whch ott nvidulaed Mea smog commit Bat prevents Ge ‘fr craig fer ov, medi sci elton. una fees prclaize md deo emcee he te csiaing we ‘Spent nl cosine sn: any Men ay =e SEES The mir emote sey ha esa oe eco Si liste tac Man Peach 105,529). ‘According tthe young Mace, Feuerbach’ concepfon only theft step, The ‘gut of wligon bar wo be Flowed by te ertqn of the sae (which Mare Fens ie ove eine of is eur of Hap, and then he eae of ‘nmi Hoe to, be slibomtesoppestemevernens win md of te nc ove of sol ny Active dmg is dubs win oe. Socal ati ‘rele coumermovaret ga fo ce (iti ce) ‘Mery, erica ecoane wince te se Woy ashe bd povewly siseaed Hegel conor te binned fr dexbing te sec of minder ‘ononss ean however, be sized fr posting du spanish: ‘tlebour It knows only Be oor ecosoms side ofthe mae ant posts Uke ‘eget posts te edo a et mitt ecogusing he sei] consis of ‘tat cy. oti! Benoa wih he tf pate opt tes not xn pene in gets arma te mor! Foes ou whch PESO stay pene, we te fm he tos fr Todos ot ee tie wee does oon yt om ae rae propery Or 1959, p8). Social Reyes Appearance Some Nett on Man's Concepion of Reity 37 ‘As Heges solid the form ofthe moder the ate ta is poceded not fmm concept: forms a rom he sunita tes are aos, i, {we penned dial lowe of bebaiour given forms of ast of ‘nly sbeiee cencepnn af sjetiy ~ Hee fer example Adam Sea's ‘propensity var are Fate econ thos no ight on he ete of he din bee hod ‘Sinden ols and’ Whe, ae els eaten ef ‘festa ots ies he ees of nui oe he it cue ey ks atpomel nist capponatin expan Pal) Like Hegel, th ecsnomiss peeappase existing forms, tet than 2 any ‘jee, witht comepaing thet detente form. Mar gues uit ts {ogi ofesippston ands amaot at wnesuadng eo, pte), he Ccpnlcatin af depose of exe fms thenciven fom of ‘Suapommnsy fos hice exe fo indole a ida; tatonal ‘Sac eumbleosoncene te genes of fms, ‘However, does Mare eet bis on stundard of erique? Marx desert an vera wri wae per te nde of erste of te wore, in every ape ‘of hr sence tat fhe terson ei Each singe ehrceiste of Be hate of te woker points tovards hs opposite aveent and he coasts ‘ersecossing ems “Te woke bcos lhe pom te ie wate rue. The weer bc ou Seaper oon te mre commas te gets The dvs of ‘Serene: nde poptan oe canny ate ft wn Nag “This means int nothing elo han ht he prot of about “eno ios ‘omuthing lon, ara power fdepordn of he roc The produto abr s ‘Show wich ni bew ej a ing iste ojo aur Labour ceenon ejection, Under | eonois cans ts eluaton of eer pen fs of ation fe Sr Stn of i od 1 poten Lice ie exist ference to Reuetah'seigur of religion i his eine of ‘eel so tn hesecnon abou esuanged abou in he Par Maser. hfe mm he sj, bt se eget eg ‘este pers en, emote won sobs 1p.) “Thess. aed het opel the cts of Maes descrtion of the wrk (Conese The pam of fhe aries he sae” we ae ea With 30 ivened word stich ye bum pracice cents oa poate WO ‘Acive human proces rubs and tyugh an exstng consadicice, wich peas in eft ofan aosomine = mmette ssn wy, We ae Hsst Hamas Dip: Sct soon andthe aga api meee) 2 ea ane pepe psi 8 sang el Seca ea ne in Sete bar Oespge ply ese ea eae et winter emit enna eed toh el ne pt Sey im tn Sor parr ee Stain ein a el i Pat trae ete a foaminveed we ice mocy he ing wn ace ccs of ie ef 0 See aera ace cag nd onnon 9 ane he a ns Oe ener Seaford ran et 20 oman eee te eity of he nia wh ts ces ne ex in ee Reman ets climate ough eon rt. Ony en wr baste alee exh tet sina sone won ve Hon ine wat we tee 7 ean Mat oe Bey ma cee orn. cringe ft of en mbna ep. seme at ei oe sen gece a tg a eect tr el SL en aon rate me en Woh eat pec ht oe Srnec ety cw cree i ust depend of nia 2 be grain eco of ‘a ad Engl 174, p86) Tn aden, te ai se ens li, oe rho. te scaled Sets terme es of a et pedoncly repens 8 ite wide owe "Se upto te Pars nacre _—_ Fr eapcan or nhs wold go Br bn ee oF Ny ‘The verted Word of Capital Mac's st cot of he matali conception of ey ako raised in he Cor of Pola Eom. Thave aud les io Max's charcteration of ‘be comendity a2 soon spe hg” Lamy ie, Marc se epoys Heels consti of he tie cape ofthe Phenomenology of Spit ‘Mar inofucs the commodity ars sedate unity of evalu a va, = tty of semouconsoenst tn of sbroscoes The asta exists becvely ioe common ecyeety of ve a coal” or “rstalizaon’ af ASotect burn our he ety between oe seasons and superenible hat Jef ext sbjentiycoresponds wat Ulege's coneepton of = second ‘optemible world tomas bok What nest be posed ot Rete hat {Eb fin smsodnn of commesiy nn cof money ss Fog pt 0 "uid foraatn, owt oa sie beeen (een of the fst cape ts Crt and int a eon of Copia Mare meatons tat he Bete he oneodiy stale {wil tuto as ate). Te dis of two memes ‘tarmnuly rempposceash other can ei be Stine staal notin ems of Ub subennc, tu elyw vemen. Ont who vale developed as vale in ‘oven ca te ir oft forms be cone, a6 the cae with Jeger ie Te vw nm epee (ts Pai Abort Ganeral Labo an the Commensrabiity of Comnodies ‘Toe conception of te ond sypernsle wold fs anew cms of ‘ray nel genie cocoon of te cl sce, Howes ‘Sige aso Lacon genes ord eae o Troy not hu lak w be ‘penesic pont of comme Heep wy eh Mr eye Cop ne ean Feocked ce te) ring a's npc sb ely nbs ns y id are tn oticton of te concep ete ee ee ee Tana as ep proef s tchp o ee a aero toke shee: pian of semen, {Paecrih de macoseonme sppepiin oa podacs acl pect ‘Re cal iden fn sony tas Gum tbe it pages of Cpl Mieieape oo cxchmgeau a etisalat quanti eon, we proper SRE vimana tte ee Sci, SEU Nady sce comcast on ema fe ‘thong ue at enpenly nent h soet corm, en ‘Staton nt fae 1884 pa). * centavos fay 11868 MeL, 97, 9.52425,40 Haman Digi Sota duoc and th Cogs of Cpilion However, if va were to amount ou o exchange. and tack were no ‘oe ta lave in mt, oposite t we vale, tba aie would be obese (Gufgehoben) in tbe aguepte nam of te soil product. Mar, develops Cas ‘hough in hs etigue of Chie Gaahsswek, whe i Spit of ht See undereanding ofthe ate of al lls aceon te eden conception: dh ntange veh propa ia wish sma A ‘schaae asin conmody 1 , oA ln ea tetange ae mth 8D eve ete Ages 8,60, We conf ecugeie sane sonst he eve poesia wien pao tg eh ‘th Tet any af poses reso etangei es {ich fr ning Henn soy, ne wai cosa feng less ‘wea. Comoe fons 9 ony, Gul hel cones tae ‘Sata walt. wc compo of xcaege ain of ou ne fr ed fee fil exchange ale (ere he rn sa) bs a sn {Sehege ae wins, a Sot nr wea ser wel out ly of ‘Sarge sae a 1995 2200, ‘ae phtopher Kins Hartmann suprisingly made hese covery in is ‘otemnor Bok abut Mare Ae put = ms 2a va suse te ny sr ein of len ol {ose ony aor oon maining gery fac of exc eld neo exng ed wou tu mt Salty op ol sa ‘is Brae a Se pte meth hae chew ‘Sonomi eum aa, 9 p09) aansan focises the problem conctly. The resaaion cn only be a abscite ‘aloe and be ingest rs resets elativeeacage ae fo asc ‘al at i Mar engages in ‘epion (Bi). “Te wea of bourgensrocery hs dubie aracer mas of maliude of were hat a Bomogeous sbsoaet guns ta atthe sane te be ‘ggepted nt a sical prdact the many snd posed to the oa fat both ‘lesen oticeseal wih hem How ca tise comched Econom try ‘ns ll oc saved ts nue Test ats how Ue “neato! egy’ comes bout, how the ‘commensal fhe many ue vases facoaplities Mart, weve, develope diferent lie of engi. The product are commode 20 ‘imanofic, they coupes a tnedne tity borne ie ee, coor ‘Sens, ad the absiacysaprenible Aoygh Man had Ey on ecopsed ‘sui, was oly in Cpa tbe bevel tat he fond vette niyo be waced ack te double character f abou, whl be chaste She ‘woe sxe of erieal understanding” CF Ses 98, ep. 202, Stender ees at Mae aly develope te ane snr abo wee woking oe Bean Pre. Wt etapa th thes bck (refine asf comme as Pre a "Benen th Grane bate at pet gamer el Socal Rea ax Appearance Some Noteron Mars Conception of Rely AL ‘Teri and ae tev he dtu aout he concept of sberast ame lnboura th aban of vale. The erga of ebsantalst eenepions of we [ein my wew comet sn that met he comcpt of geal lout Las to be eermized deal (6 Rein, 2002) The wise dcassion aout alte hs ‘Sever aed the queton wheter Man's conception of he soba af vale ‘hak init sot ron the specie conception of appearance of is ely work ‘abo, is supeomsblemoreat of te commodi sid be the Tea of “peangpetobgtealy, an expense of human oor power’ of abou wich (Seas vile by tue of character of eal sbact uaa abou (an, 1985, p53), whieh = charaenae a “cyslizan’ ocean — xs im te mnie of beng, dened and thas ible" (Marx 198TH p82) Shomodis, bd wish hen “appar in exchange Miah ot be hat he arly omepion of sce pearl ine, ad habe threw oes te heal onscton ina econ Mat iad such dsasrows comequncs Torte reception af Capital? Mas clarsctereaton of casicl plied ccna {evnlsan import metodo! init He accept at aside ala homever ape, alban i age al covered ‘hes bees eos ut nea be que hy cont {htm wsepenmed Uy heen of pone nd bourne ye ese oft vale are 98 pp) “Tis formation mies hat he cota, which spears in this fom, cn aso be foneeved in sepation Hom frm of penance: The quoted passe 8 be fond in the fms secon on fetishism, where be presets many exampls St “ASene he cour of tus Yoon Here be explains te union of value and tae ‘maptde of ari bourgeois Set) daaighmiror ies where te Comet [pyri i vert orm. Espey to easels ~ he desepdon of abn s "TE bath nigh and fe "zocion of fee invite’ who woxk ih xual mt of prods abd whose “abou powers const Srbe combined Ibourpower ef th comma, we heb They Tszte is bac conception of th vale for’ ‘all the chasis of otiasn’s Ibo ae ee rope, bs with ir lence, at heya si {mvedofindabal Gb, pple 8). ‘Are he tice of words nas hat we ae dealing here with bas sae ots that we tow Foo fie early wok slfconsous soll ty Vets [nvert snd stxomized forms of socal existence. Vale ere ace of ‘hot slfcooscous subjects who fecognize temas i and rough Dei {nlecve socal abear and oyanize thew noes tnd be develope of eit proactive feces a det ea froin exon eh firings: Tia nee come rh ber “Tessa can cay it hoe doce ate wad tos {uncer oar mbt tbe commaaty 238 nN Te Eiht of Cap exces why i cme snes a she nen tr 9.939)ve wt same, bt mel Sr the sk of gr wie protion of SE LEOTS date of ech indo pdt ee ee oes ‘xray nee Lure wn ec ply a ni Ft Se een er neo ey Oo ‘SEC tint ato wener arene of he porion he conn hour bere by ‘SS an of se pt ol pet ies ie SEEN Is rn we ncn fey Sng me (het tpt ny odin tu fab i, 98 ‘Mare’s Robinson canple develope the same ight and argues that all eth eminnons af ae ue ere and at ‘all the rls betwen ‘bin aod be sje ta form ths wea of bis own eto, ae bee Soh nd ear a tobe nlite wudout exon, even © Mi. Seley Tyler Se Goce ntsc ng tego (crea cae SE oy ier Poet tat ect peice ero ie a as ee Be cia sattrapec wists roar sea Ae tn ay woes ts me oc mae en ace Seat sgn ye ee tn ea Seatait abe pone mtn ears Ree whee nat ecto ie “eee eee ae ee esate rein ans i ora oee ert hye ae oS ema rene ect cars Seer ae a en neta Freee! Titres sisocees hnve amos excel focused on the fit Soo ae Se Se ras he ume og can te adh abovesentond ewe Laguna me development far catiies "Mar ine cbc his lei metodin Copies Ater the pubiaton of his Conmbuto to a Crue of Plies! ‘Economy, mexioed in Tne 9 Bagels at he need hide his meibod ‘ven mnt the eat tba of assy" One etree ante at at ‘beied sot hide in wo of his previous stud, the Candas aed ie Tract, He aso ots ia de Prefce to Capel (Mare T9835, p18) at bit xpsiion euch prove ia restion opecily tthe Sin baer of Cpu ‘his then encousged tuna commento v0 ague tat the study of Marts unerat aicts in Capal aso be ed om te Scher ‘What however iste coonecon einen ti int cbs and hae a folow? Marx expinged « mos inpertatreerence tot mbodalogy nthe Second ein of Copal Ts relrence xp be fund ht Critiue ati the ‘stein of Capa sheen of the Ss chapter (he comma te mainte nity fel ad ehngeie, at of 8 ‘Pigott meme non hi snr op ‘ten nh exchngeaie pepe, Wwe he corm a whee ocd ‘Sobereonmesier ar Im pS) By deleting ths sence, Marx ot only escued the conection betwee he ape, tb als elised wn important refrence, sel tht Be ants he ‘cnnmodty ansyally nh fit chap “Thc ts aces ere te exposion [)inpove (ie telao ois CCtiqu of 1859) he wean! a chatted a seayoe and whee he ithe is iden derclped conception of wee a the pesppoeion of he fouplet exposition of al ober categories sing In view ts brass of ‘is erams tate dct of Man's method. as nh at as oem on gel’ ication betwen the gil andthe Mistral, has exhosvely been focused on the st chaper Here to, hawever and yet agin ony in st telin of Copal, we find nporant methodologies At he od of the developmat of the wae foam. Mars wres tht it was of “decive ‘mportaace to tere the sural, necomarycomenion bewern te vahefrm, ‘albsubtance and vauemaputud, ats epee in eal ems, show ba ‘he valorm acer Som the concip of wah (bid pal), It mat be ‘ererbered ut Mare undesoed hs method ab 2 mede of roo (Bowes) Gat reproduces the itr, scesry connection of tr bjestamter in Asis Lam vey PRD hsp ate 170 Ree 1970) se oly sy th ala tone deh dason oe le evap jee Uy tings progressing, tll, Chewnaanes eng whet hy ae, ar as, ‘nde le sbi a npg tc tree metro ad te Honea ie ‘Sing asring + much mre ep Sarm dhe mend en ene ah ln Pet (ary a0, p330) Sram ace Ma cen Me, ne Rl (=, Ara time Man as lew eee deepen afb woe$4 Humor Dignity Set Autonomy andthe Cig of Capt ‘hewetial tems. The sariag pio is asthe concept of ale which ste Tounton of te father expen For the form of wae remit fom + ‘Heol operation, which be chrnerians tify be appa The Value Form Only on he ass of gon ehacter dow the ale fem compos ‘nt the cone ae (id, p63). He has has od 2 om at enc {nits geacaly with th generat of he convey of vahe. Abou be oes nt tmpasize here anymore tat the fem of vue ess fom te ean of value, ‘Ge coment fis dcusion doce ne tea ht fm of ae esuppes tee conept of vue. Because” the’ acuton “often spas of “fiber ‘Geelopment, arly from the single wevsloped form tthe developed form (Cie apecise equvalet fom now fstier develped tows © ete ‘spsaler form” (bid, p64) and ecto an “eral ecessry wn supose, eration” became te sceped model fhe ders! mand “The specific coca of vane is almys reseppecd jot a the eal va esapotel a ‘bjefeaton ab “nate sutetaee’, as “rslaton of Shee tama abo [ie vale of common oe in se src expend of Fim nr gee sheep snp ur pose, eb hoor pons so eg pt many cl Sopot sine ogee Boyce indo Seed later tus ny Spe howe ee ‘tbe romped sls boar, um of led eng cnle a0 ‘wer uty o sine iou 9834p 1). ‘The howe cousction wos cay the ta of is premise ‘The Conception of Disotie he Gnd” Inthe Gramdrisehe concept va iat ytdevelpe ad the od nt yt ‘iden Tis werk itl rom all llewag published versions of sce of economses bec off cooceptaldiffreaton been exchange Yale Posing icons a xg ve cig our Eanes ae png Sil be found ecaroal ste Critique bat whch en depp, Fre, de ‘xpesion exchange valeting labour can oly be fad ona few ecasions Corespndng to ese expression iste diflerenaon bette abst ou Ting Decome hstncaly “we iz pace’ (Mua, 1973, p05) aa 8 heer ah of nour, which Mart employs cout cont bat ich only mections rience: ere can be sen ene api tt he pe specify of the reson of ‘eyo, fh any ~ he, apa ed abut "eo rel el i te {Staton of parr mater mse of acu. The post emer be ‘ea eee coecton ihe ea, ce nee ae © Sue wae te pea lowing ace Gum hie Sent Ludi Kapemen Ct toed asec ein Cap 9838 2) Seca ely Appearance Sone Nel on Mare’ Conon fy 45 pose in lao i, wie a he ase fe aaron, vag eo ey ta Sermo ur ahi ton Sep ‘The conept of te exchange value positing clon o inpleculton fsa again sen hi te Werk I eacapanstes» doble ming or it dose ‘mening evened in the contest of is hsty developed eaposion inte ‘Grands: th ons hand, ‘echnage vale psig reins i sero nt [trial conext ut aot inte crude seme ofan oe! desta tat Wat ‘xoorze,folowng Engel urna fons inthe oad tans ‘sernatipbawienbe nga then Vande east ‘corp ht nterbcks te lope of develope wd he dams of develope, tough Max dif ot develop tis ex. On theater hand, Marx he Category of sinpeaccumlason to he nice’ of te caplet Fraction Process te pe of gpperance "The presenston of “einple ciclo’ ako ste with vale, tat he nsec beer bow, uf, Yale td money sao san The taper deals manly with the developinet of the int categancs of poli ‘conomy and shows tht taal Comecton, The act developoeat of ‘Stegve es wh he om of money. To devel the cop of cpl ‘mcsary to beg ao wits abr bat with ve, poss wh change “ale i'n asd developed movement of castor’ (i. p258) Insole ‘elton, exch vale posting reson conse teeters eet ‘os of ttmomcel value cra diferent oder of move te nanan td evr more ananomzed foes of eachange vloe ar the foal ‘ichange ale posting relations. Exchange Yl, ony, eps oll Spl xctange tana! oon" (Mar 1987s, p43) ad asaees ints ‘S dowenintoe which Mars conve fhe yo the fst te tots, ‘Gat, pceora ard mes of eactuon, eft weed indent, ‘sean and metic fom of money. Onty tow doer te tal moves aie’ sat 1s expansion ofthe magaide of yale is movement contnee iif tough coutaicton thet detemaation of money, te sbshte frm, Std i castes ose qumotstvelniaton Exctange veers fo cae ‘lose tothe bole form of money, the see frm of wey gh set ‘mania exgenson™e neverending proces nth id Sona, wa rn ee a ry of os SE pmiocmm otters ce tome Eins ghen Sarees es Sercoee nas Soe etacemane nuiecreene Sie seaememeeenee Sitnnion eigen erence "Marie te ding The ape oo money 0 teeing gt Te fist cape aio ees er46 Fran Digit Seat Autonomy a se ray perme ee eee ggg ete rt oy te et eee Ses ee a cee eos Seis fom ee eee ae Som oe gate vs Selsey ie, earn etine ae Te roe vb et oa en entra rs Scparmmec tar ati eammemraas se ea rece laa Sep ey oat Sion igh ei ees Siege clon rele opal ea Stee Tce few quinn heady, sow te closoes of Mes a er geen ny Sm of Fe seni ea nape eee reece dame accent ps Su eben Sees ee eines ‘ron ene ecm can erm ee be eerste hay tS fe ee Se en en seca yetioneaty brag tg tne ee rae ote cere crentamet eae normal ae Bee shee ae re aera aes fay cee ie de a tee ca a et eee Soetiaes Se ereetcae ae aman mg com agence ge nce tees rpm ene pote at Soe ce egos ec Se Hg i eet, een eke mete a ee erin which te seman world and Ge St Sa rae oe al eee ca eh ees tee a aes om ees Cope set cements moreno eee tien some aac ee Sree d te ooh eee ere Se eee een a ce” 7 ors tn cc of Sinn wo Va a ie! le om te cond wh Meh EGR Wei enti qty, favs ried ELISE AIRS Gre imecran ome wom dots oc ise tomes 17,9280 ss ssa, boo, exhage with ase ~ 6 demoted to a ans of he sl ‘Peperaon ofan abtact process tet eden the le objertve wel of cn acy bss acon nd ome nck rece ound (Seale dat Spe, Space met al apes anit ‘Ent woe a on te comin ofthe comedy a se ee Se ‘Sense ofthe ous oft sarees alee, p87" ‘The most abort coat of capital is therfore st th same tne the fet seneteteaton of Hegel's exept of appearance, and appeiace is ating bal Sppearncespearince qu sppssaac The whe seus word of ban Telags who reproduce deals cash he satan of eos aod Iba epbyep sacked ino ths proces i which all sets ze ie hamlet fovece’s They ae al in ter vanishing appearice, medial their own ‘oppose: he persseooe of he gna The mest xy emer frmstion (Gaduners the law i Wat fea 8 sapparance™ Thr Tomeltion 30 dancteiae Mares cout of cope, whore furter coppice ‘ens this proces uy rough is danas Text devopent of te coment of pil (6) easy, sce Ee ‘Shame ceo low tess or sonal ek hee Save {eeced trae (carapace bras Geb sn Ber Tle ‘Eminem of toro sae he ep flo bebe sep Se tenon man ng mf Oe cnendconeofsougeospesuioe ac he tentay were bad a Man 198.95. Karl Mary as was argu atove, pope his eth and clint step sep all rebences to his nebdology. Why might tis have been so? Was ‘ecase ib conepion of dhincts war uel, a2 Adora (1972, p308) ‘uggs? la any tic, ss sowncrdy tat Marx develope is lect] ‘xpos eto wid specie conepion af ae slo noteworthy {Ga edna expositon of enegore at he metodo Aly of the ely ofa need word a» sven sopesesie wr whch cone he ‘ensnous aod he Bist superbe world ot pose wit a concept of "alae TMS concept peste reat of semua pea, mish eased (eae pat an abet comity. The churcteraton ofthe commodity 4 4 stomous serene tng estes the superset) of reais unre fe re Gin thing, asthe seblsics would ave sas. pte coment, Theoor ‘Adoro speaks about ‘cjetreconespaly”~ wit dou, is was aspred "re eecapin har infirm ice Serato of pi Teal fon sede ewe era cnn eo eo re ee ‘Surrey In economies ny rel won eee ah Be ‘Betol we Mas toweer Svcd pin se pes fom of stcan Se hh ee cheers cen in fie ne sy pc ces, Fra Cpa so i68 Haman Dig Sl Aonomy and he Cie of Captain toy Ald Sots etl inthe 19304 The differentiation is this expres ha Cloeece a rely ef am abomcion, ax ‘objective comepliy, end the "Step" of he subjects tes, who cay tas proces ont “Those wo ‘peceve comely a soc ely do oot have ob efa of i estos Fete What at ine here bo, the contitive cocci of he Ieoging subject a 2 concept a exits the tng ise? (Adon. {OTE p20), Like Sonn Retiel wn ft advanced be moon of real abssction (dsiebrhion, Adorn macely oes impli posta. According hs {Shjecave cncrplty canbe taced bck tae abamction of chang. Yo ‘rman e pu aro bow ebjectve sctviy null gence an objcire Song “Exchange Absraction and Objective Coespati Mar's Cone of Vall tn Capa, Marx bad he fling say about the set of excange sbsaton DOSS Leeda oer gol pen eter en oft net ed #1834 2789) Many have commented tt tt setece welt, Inde tallow for 0 Za pose erp, ocr vat aman abo contin el ony ‘Bae eachage wien ids post er producs as ves oF dosti ‘Sousct equal appear inte exchange proces a somthing tat bs aad (rats proces of tact tr igneac. The comepe of vale hv wo of hemotice ssn visi: compl 8 ‘rsalizaon’ of sac human {Sturas he scbstane of value= the Concept a rel abaact qui. Mae SEES cits shour vue sboactou If we sy aos vos, commodities ae ‘ov congtns of anlar, ede thn by our aly te ‘Tacit, sour bur we ssnbe t hie valbe no form apa fom te toy RE Gua ps) This sberacton ie tur the comprbented Geyer) ‘Serane of va, Marinas owe seiderstuning = brings wo be fore Ca eeteatersctos which nda cary ata exchange process, wie BoSpSEntor or ets spears opresppoce hat tvs cy ou roc of reducon da ens ee equation of tir rode and at ‘ES osn manly oft proces of borat we behinel peers "or sein norman Mare cen only conse of ths proces in comvesionl serpin he abt by bases” Homall ives and concetenes “he nln fh met ns fea cn el ty of Sis acetate ee ere, eStart are mince ps he ted Si scp ge de fan tla wept cpm erry We 2 dae nish nce ae ee a a all ets fects poet mt CTS eR Mak obey od oe al tamer Se pcre Social Realty 2s Appearance: Same Neeson Mar’ Concetion of Realty 9 ioe sof eng te el of ath pret id f aor, nese fom at Ibe ppsal itr wis ar ete pect fou hve eo ‘ely ate vig ae i, p78 empha Mare wes to omits he pes ofa “eusion” ois common eat, los io of ares Kinds nto does no eer oe 1 im a {e'b deaing fee ine Hegsion seme, wih ab "undesrabe abecton of fe ind ht wominion costars ar an Henle. BY aboacing from divest nrc ceeunance,reacaon" bigs 1 before ta whith ‘coms 10 the unre! Max bute ks mde of aberacton 0 Bejenin Pak’ ‘alle ony om he ett Faas sortie oa etic! oom nd a eee le Te amor f seal pour ie change Is Shor nch ade dre ony a qusnen 6 Saco a ese of ee Sint Tg Pantin,“ poor bong ating ce el Oe change of Boar Moe te whe of hinge jt mere by oe is [nce es epced coc nba, rane vi oat ‘Stee one ibang sokont it bon wher for Beceem, ‘Sorc sa eo senor ae See ete ur tthe pes hen na of eae of es? Fasiste 'cmray, cede the vee of we miner ym alia ets lt yaar hous whch rn pl uty a x es ‘elo ony bso ef gue lan, 171,930) In the excep th under thi rgument Mane sunmizes Fk’ argest Inte lowing tao ear athe ale of ang i seedy ‘bear tie Fiegh the lboar of the deconzor?No. Or the nbour of ‘Some? Neier Ergp ough hut boar, wich nett the ope nor he ‘ther (cted in Sender, 1980, 9202)" The Ist sexiemse & devise, Mark ‘Gtrpcted Frank's tod at esti at exact in one ines es {Setter om te many the unvenal ay sstacion May's che of words {hice Gat he ms yt aver coop of he savers rely ot ony 32 acta tat sh ar tune Seo fr example is rositon to the ‘Grove. Irv aimee ep fraud or Adm Sra Cow oo cy tating speticnon of wetecreating ty — ot ony afta, nme o spe] bons, bot nea we as be te, abou in gee (pian 1973 pts). Like He's determination of oe vera i ton i (Sitocnzaion ea dic eatra. a procesal uty of astaron snd © Sle i gen ectoti." tthe Gndrise, Marx characte he hid determination of neney Seoeh ner “The understuding of boar’ tality ad sberaton snouts oa dicta ‘ould Tvs tobe inept inthis way. The qbson tat was eter pose, ‘tem bow Robnon wold determin abated em te ny peal Groce stvites, would be anvered saiacty wih thi ein” ti i ‘ommlaboura genalsbour hat se Hegel's words aher The nr Th 8 ‘oui ans wit equal nifoence Tig wel ae Tt ‘Bt haw cam ths general bear Se conse of ¢ sea eivenal, as supersenihty. wich ex nthe comeety evel sens? Mare ‘feo speciation Tiss because he cncives hi ener nae reat terms at someting tt Os lnspendely fom faman taught ia te ‘eodct ean ha I exciey rene by ain about a testy of [hort human labour Ths abjesvy cams oocicatataes be conceited Sa ing of ough ‘sl the an coi ony of ou, aig 4 wae ction of ‘lng ar nai aes Nowe ry ius nos ach oer {ate dimer i emo snows marino ten, pie wl dbs not cea ance fer omboes ih a sae (ict cies hes ttre reed goon of hana ot es ‘ave evthng ie hat ey ata 3 She The cc of tan aw ‘tthe or racial quay ont ots nea as ec, ag of hugh Inte fay som i ajay Hove ‘moe re thnge hat ty a hy hate how tenon mr [Soeponerscgeted Moved acinrwinracr coca’ ocr efae shen tot needa ay Th ae nen er, ‘i tein presi i au azn sity posing ear sal Sian ag hn ine eo Sc cae oar rms ha om ‘Maca bil cone obo ti ts fale nly ye of 1 ect separation between bara eflestve power a th bestia ‘human labour. Consary to Adorm’s view, Mar seems to excnde, ng fom the sar any temp at combining the consiuve concep of de sujet with tat anes wch resides in thigs” Yeu Marx fre aysgerns a0 ow tha might be done "A gle ing of iin wich trout epoch ie iso Tn 8 osha i eu aifecce Tht welts Ta = sch ig eel {pera ge 977 po) aia ony, eee wea ately em aa! ee he ote ‘The comp ef nea, soto spas le, nasal pear Seth ‘teas pce sre ant mance woth il cd fs ly ‘Soave fom ts ut mpd ef eastenes Qa 1979p 3182, “The our fons the sce of rae, bomorneue ran ke ‘Spun ef rc uo iow pomer Toe iburpome cy, whch [epee [nfs of al commoaten, coms ie vi) he wwe [gopeoter ms f ana our power compu! nuh be o mre ‘Siva au Gah ef wwe san a ny hey, rare he © Gareth vege ioargowe of sc ods le wk; tg 5 nln fr ease coma no mete se a's eae on ee, Rove ssi ec ar pp 46-7 eng). ‘Tans seteces spent, ior Mars pretation of he frm fhe appexance ‘vain excbange, coe fi pages fhe naoucton ofthe etgoy of aie here ‘evening's sas abut be boar enboied a nen’ hat ster exes SE Supesaly Marx as th expression i ail in hs context Supeigty frense vay in tx st some Hrd 0 jects for whom someting at ‘ality whos subjects no salty —Snspetve of bow oe might conete ie ‘es and made of exstnce ofthe vad hg. Oae heefre fds be tasoat latons of valid” sado be va nly wee Marx faces one vaue em asi te appendix tbe fst dion Hee te miasonhg of a 0 ene ‘ele he cenal problem f ecenonic tery = soneorasraii, aaiton of52 aman Dig: Sl Ateromy ed the Cg of Coptise shemct, objective values without prenpposing a sbsuatili category of vals? {leave t open mbeter sch cdtaatio of he efgue of sco can te fenceied of es secousucton If mere Teall fart & tater of esl ‘econetueon coe would fen hve to prvippove ta una interretion of ar's wok inp oe 14 at eth fo be fe cae however, One {hoor ns 9 sat wit Mars ge economic ote pt evloped or of conseouoes, but at he ae time ~ as rgn Habermas (1995, pO) pues 1s Reconsracron of Hore! Motel ~ os ao et he sy pa pvt togeter in ow frm o reac he oa tt at el Beer The pol [Sto overcome apis in aad tough a genes fling of econo cxeg es, ‘We thetefre go bck to the thoagh yroces of th Grande ad conbice he conep of aye etn of Cpt Ext then feu ove moe tin tte “geainy dialectal conceptions of value ad ace ad let sat vis formals fom» poepber ne ner ‘tied aay tom te ska ling short a cess ever nora id be ‘xcuded fiom the seetccommaniy. ‘Money sb teil, existing eaneept, ‘be frm of way, o he pownbily of all Bias” (lapel, 1974, PSH Sed ‘pba HR) Ths fomulson nas aot aa ex, spective adveoe, Heal ‘epeats fhe une Gout ia sleek pion of aw As an xi ences mooey ta he same Sine chamcenaed a the “excang aves (tegl, i974 229) aod head ‘bere vale ests such’, one he ‘ealecitence of the iver, Tie ural aot oly ap externa, sje Tera, bas subjecste univer mnie of a wholly dient sot (ibid, 7230) Hegel was aot able to develop as tooph any futher. What ‘parame, bower ha his nivel ofl dllesent a jet ‘stdat he ame in objet sat an chet i ean cistng iver tt |S touity and abractin, both at fhe same tins. ee Hie the as a eg corp “rston(s) fom wndiffreatited ot ‘o dtentiaen ‘dcinng snd posting of he deeminaon ($65 a6 The Phosopy of ‘igh Burs he be neta uta ng. ‘Acc only plover allowed nese in esos thi sive ne (x the thing) besase, ab takes ‘of he untesal ithe tek a think ‘peclately? Or tan de scestat tik sueh thought aswell? We fod fSemalions smikt 10 Hegel's in the young Mary fer example nthe Para ‘Monserp: “eoey ste es ad ative conept of ae (a 195, [BIDS Ala nthe Gnd, be meas of mney san eng waiver ‘os omy exe in oy ss he compen een of smn. ‘The wh ecunge ley mwa taco hyde sch Othe ccs al er sine, aes tng, pl es gold ‘iver ney is ow te gl among commie Min, 1978 p21) Money ae he individual of general we (Ii :22), ot ony om baat theme tine cont ee ‘Soca Rea arApparace: Some Noes on Man's Concion of Rey 52 ‘Tee conep of wea, pe, ein, idan in parca je Ie ‘ongriit pic value’ aed heuer wath en iy ‘Etcien Gomis pra eso ce (, pp2LED) ne fist edition where he dalesa metho it seal “very mac id one ‘SUI fds Sk scien of Be development of te geal equalent fom [sige tate coupleey ese Gem be coed ein sf which ste rele ead far and recta within ten \Sparstontvear ep jom fe eet ete wns sant Se en ee cera amas an (Sule aet nal eda insane wae sural no Steir rnin wii el he espe te ing tan ‘ma pd ean 198,937) Mars concetom ofthe exiting univer, om he atest ecoonie works © (Copel ae swt Wot to Hegel's How, bowever, cn oe conceit ‘Seeing sbteston av sme tat scarce the ractoe of xchnaing Sbjct Althogt he leary sa he eee, Hegel doesnot ive ws an mse, ‘We'san however fad answer in Marc's Grande ch asa pat aed vert Copal Be Cringur of 1859, Marx eiaes Adam Seth, acorn 10 whom | none was raced as «medians general eas of change, in ott ‘Raise the soupy of exchange where many ewes of lent Commoaies ‘eggs i at acto exchange thr partir proach a icy af ‘her product dt mest thew node This conepaon of money Bat 2 Sent eer mes, mony way Sv ie. receting frie qe pei pit of ven, agnios Dh erat [oky racine tren ec ml amen het ip tea {Spe sn aor xeon a sca aon of oui, al Bot ‘Stow epe Is itr amply nlp ede i eat gl son hich oot nents em wk chloe an 17, ry I te Grniise be sll apes the postive sid of dis He, soe he Femmes tat the devlpmlit of mney seared sth te ample exchange of rode fen ean: "The pou! becomes commode omeoy Etcemesexchmgc vue; the exchmge vloe af be conmodity isi eset ‘tone: pope tas, Hs meney pope, sepais isle Hom i a de fom of ‘ou, tb abit general mca extence”(Mre, 1973, pp]4647 so ho pp 168, 168) Teas of is wpumeat as be fod in Capt hy malone cigs of exec fistoniychsagy cn be fun in Ae anno’ (191; pS0 eset ph Sanyo hog eas