Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Wen-Guang Li∗
Lanzhou University of Technology, 287 Langongping Road Lanzhou 730050, Gansu, China
Abstract: Acoustic resonances are frequently fatal problems in centrifugal pump operations. Low pressure pulsation of fluid
in the blade pass frequency is helpful to prevent from such problems. In addition, for a high quality centrifugal
pump, a lower broadband noise level is also on demand. The acoustic resonance and broadband noise are asso-
ciated with unsteadiness of flow in the pump. Even there exist extensive analyses of unsteady flow in centrifugal
pumps by means of CFD so far, the effect of high viscosity of fluid pumped on the unsteadiness of flow feature
remains unclear. Thus, the unsteady flow in an experimental centrifugal pump was exploited numerically when
it transported the liquids with different viscosities. The velocity profiles at the impeller discharge were validated
with the results of LDV measurement for water. The viscosity effect on the fluctuation of flow in the volute was
clarified quantitatively. It was shown the increasing viscosity of fluid makes the fluctuation in flow variables less
substantial and results into a less noticed tendency of separation of flow from the blade pressure side.
Keywords: Centrifugal pump • Impeller • Volute • Performance • Unsteady flow • Fluctuation of flow • Viscosity • CFD
© Versita sp. z o.o.
361
Unsteady Flow in a Viscous Oil Transporting Centrifugal Pump
362
Wen-Guang Li
363
Unsteady Flow in a Viscous Oil Transporting Centrifugal Pump
364
Wen-Guang Li
365
Unsteady Flow in a Viscous Oil Transporting Centrifugal Pump
366
Wen-Guang Li
mp
Water 0.3497 0.3086 0.3292
θ=270° Oil 0.3518 0.4872 0.4915
mv
section Water 0.7339 0.8108 0.7724
Oil 1.0656 0.9298 0.9977
mp
Water 0.4975 0.4549 0.4762
θ=360° Oil 0.6844 0.6075 0.6460
mv
section Water 0.8813 0.9124 0.8969
Oil 1.0656 0.8156 0.9406
4.4. Discussion
Figure 9 illustrates the pathlines of water and the viscous
oil flows in the impeller and volute at the best efficiency
and part-loading points at a time instance that a blade is
Figure 10. Water and viscous oil flow pathlines in impeller and vo-
lute at shut-off condition, (a) ν=1mm2 /s, (b) ν=48mm2 /s.
passing the tongue of volute.
Obviously, the water flow has been separated from the
pressure side of the blade approaching the tongue of vo-
lute at the best efficiency point. Surprisingly, for the vis-
cous oil, such a separation doesn’t appear to exist. At the discharge of every flow passage. At the impeller entrance,
part-loading point, for water, a dominated separated flow the flow is in spiral and a recirculation is established. This
is observed on the pressure side of that blade; for the vis- recirculation flow pattern quite resembles that in [24].
cous oil, however, the size of the reverse flow seems to be Note that the extent of the recirculation of water flow
smaller. It suggests that a tongue can induce a separated is around 50% longer than that of the viscous oil. This
flow on the pressure side of a blade whenever coming near indicates that the extensive rotation of flow has been sup-
the tongue. pressed by an increased viscosity of fluid at the impeller
According to above results, it is clear that the tendency of entrance.
separation of a viscous oil flow from the blade pressure
side in the impeller is in decline. Such an effect has
been observed through viscous oil flow visualizations in 5. Conclusions
the impellers of centrifugal pump in [23].
Figure 10 presents the pathlines of water and the viscous The unsteady turbulent flows of water and viscous oil in
oil at the shut-off point when a blade is approaching the an experimental centrifugal pump have been analyzed nu-
tongue. merically by means of CFD code Fluent®. The influences
In the volute, the fluid is in spiral motion. The impeller ac- of viscosity of fluid on the fluctuations in torque and head
commodates full of vortices, further, a vortex obstructs the have been clarified. The relationship between the pulsa-
367
Unsteady Flow in a Viscous Oil Transporting Centrifugal Pump
tion amplitude of static pressure and velocity heads of fluid [10] Parrondo J., Gonzalez J., Fernandez O., Gonzalez
flow behind the impeller at different working conditions P., Perez J., Characterization of Blade-Passing Fre-
and viscosities of fluid have been established. The major quency Sound Sources in a Centrifugal Pump From
findings are as follows: (1) the unsteady flow model can Pressure Fluctuation Measurements, Proceedings of
achieve a more precise estimation of pump head; (2) the the 10th International Congress on Sound and Vibra-
amplitude of fluctuation in flow parameters is comparable tion, Stockholm, Sweden, 7-10 July 2003
at impeller entrance and outlet; (3) the increased viscos- [11] Choi J. S., McLaughlin D. K., Thompson D. E., Exper-
ity of liquid can suppress the pulsation in velocity of fluid iments on the Unsteady Field and Noise Generation
behind the impeller; (4) the decay power of pressure and in a Centrifugal Pump Impeller, Journal of Sound and
velocity behind impeller depends on viscosity and work- Vibration, 2003, 263, 493-514
ing condition, specially the power for pressure decay is [12] Li W. G., Flow of Viscous Oil in the Volute of a
in the 0.31∼0.68 range, but for velocity it is in 0.32∼0.54. Centrifugal Pump, Journal of Thermal Science, 2002,
Further investigations consist of acoustic model for highly 11(1), 10-15
viscous oil flow and pump geometrical optimization for a [13] Stepanoff A. J., Centrifugal and Axial Flow Pumps,
low radiated noise level. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1948
[14] Gonzalez J., Santolaria C., Unsteady Flow Structure
References and Global Variables in a Centrifugal Pump, ASME
Journal of Fluids Engineering, 2006, 128(5), 937-946
[15] Li W. G., Performance computations of centrifugal
[1] Atkins K., Tison J., Solving Pulsation Induced Vibra-
pump handling viscous oils, Journal of Drainage and
tion Problems in Centrifugal Pumps, Pumps and Sys-
Irrigation Machinery Engineering, 2008, 26(4), 1-8
tems Magazine, 1993, (1), 44-46
[16] Zhang H. B., Chen H. X., Zhang W., Li H. F., Effect of
[2] Grokhovskii D. V., Design Peinciples for Low-Noise
Impeller Position in Steady Calculation of Centrifugal
Multistage Centrifugal Pumps in Power Plants, Rus-
Pump, Journal of Shanghai University(Natural Sci-
sian Engineering Research, 2010, 30(4), 315-323
ence Edition), 2009, 15(5), 470-474
[3] Kaiser T., Osman R. H., Dickan R. O., Analysis Guide
[17] Li W. G., Effect of Volute Tongue on Unsteady Flow
for Variable Frequency Drive Operated Centrifugal
in a Centrifugal Pump, International Journal of Turbo
Pumps, Proceedings of the 24th International Pump
and Jet Engines, 2004, 21(4), 223-232
User’s Symposium, Texas: Texas A&M University,
[18] Guelich J. F., Bolleter U., Pressure Pulsations in
USA, 2008, 81-106
Centrifugal Pumps, ASME Journal of Vibration and
[4] Evans L. M., Centrifugal Pump-Noise Control,
Acoustics, 1992, 114(2), 272-279
Sewage and Industrial Wastes, 1956, 28(12), 1507-
[19] Yusa T., Hinata T., Fluctuating Flow Behind the Im-
1512
peller of Centrifugal Pump, Bulletin of the JSME,
[5] Sasaki S., Hayashi H., Application of Wake Charac-
1979, 22(174), 1746-1753
teristics to Prediction of Broadband Noise of a Multi-
[20] White F. M., Viscous Fluid Flow, New York: McGraw-
blade Fan, Journal of Fluid Science and Technology,
Hill, Inc., 1991, 478-481
2008, 3(6), 814-823
[21] Spence D. A., Growth of the Turbulent Wake Close
[6] Khitrik V. L., Acoustic Resonance in Turbine Centrifu-
Behind an Aerofoil at Incidence, London: her
gal Pumps, Acoustic Physics, 2000, 46(5), 698-710
Majesty’s Stationary Office, 1953, ARC CP No 125,
[7] Khitrik V. L., The Effect of the Liquid Flow in the Out-
1-13
let of a Centrifugal Pump on the Acoustic Resonance,
[22] Raj R., Lakashminarayana B., Characteristic of the
Acoustic Physics, 2005, 51(4), 463-468
Wake Behind a Cascade Airfoil, Journal of Fluid
[8] Timushev S. F., Tourret J., Efficient 2D Numerical
Mechiancs, 1973, 61(4), 707-730
Method for Reduction of BPF Pressure Pulsation and
[23] Ohta H., Aoki K., Effect of Impeller Outlet Angle on
Noise by Optimization Design of Centrifugal Pumps
Performance and Internal Flow of centrifugal Pump
and Ventilators, Proceedings of 2002 International
for High-Viscosity Liquids, Proceedings of the School
Congress and Exposition on Noise Control Engineer-
of Engineering, Tokai University, 1996, 30(1), 159-168
ing, Dearborn, MI USA, August 19-21, 2002
[24] Dyson G., Teixeira J. A., Ivey P. C., Closed Valve Flow
[9] Langthjem M. A., Olhoff N., A Numerical of Flow-
Field Investigation using Computational Fluid Dy-
Induced Noise in a Two-Dimensional Centrifugal
namics, Proceedings of the 2nd International Sym-
Pump: Part II-Hydroacoustics, Journal of Fluids and
posium on Centrifugal Pumps, 22 Septemebr 2004,
Structures, 2004, 19, 369-386
IMechE Headquartters, London, UK, 1-16
368