Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 136

+NOWLTON3CHOOLOF!

RCHITECTURE +EN3MITH
3OURCE"OOKSIN
,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE ,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT
 5RBAN0ROJECTS
*ANE!MIDON 3ERIES%DITOR

0RINCETON!RCHITECTURAL0RESS .EW9ORK
:6<9*,)662:05(9*/0;,*;<9,!
-ORPHOSIS$IAMOND2ANCH(IGH3CHOOL
4HE,IGHT#ONSTRUCTION2EADER
"ERNARD4SCHUMI:ÏNITHDE2OUEN
5.3TUDIO%RASMUS"RIDGE
3TEVEN(OLL3IMMONS(ALL

:6<9*,)662:053(5+:*(7,(9*/0;,*;<9,!
-ICHAEL6AN6ALKENBURGH!LLEGHENY2IVERFRONT0ARK

0UBLISHEDBY %DITING.ICOLA"EDNAREK
0RINCETON!RCHITECTURAL0RESS $ESIGN*AN(AUX
%AST3EVENTH3TREET
.EW9ORK .EW9ORK 3PECIALTHANKSTO.ETTIE!LJIAN $OROTHY"ALL *ANET"EHNING
-EGAN#AREY 0ENNY9UEN0IK #HU 2USSELL&ERNANDEZ
&ORAFREECATALOGOFBOOKS CALL #LARE*ACOBSON *OHN+ING -ARK,AMSTER .ANCY%KLUND
6ISITOURWEBSITEATWWWPAPRESSCOM ,ATER ,INDA,EE +ATHARINE-YERS ,AUREN.ELSON -OLLY
2OUZIE *ANE3HEINMAN 3COTT4ENNENT *ENNIFER4HOMPSON
¥0RINCETON!RCHITECTURAL0RESS 0AUL7AGNER *OSEPH7ESTON AND$EB7OODOF0RINCETON
!LLRIGHTSRESERVED !RCHITECTURAL0RESSˆ+EVIN#,IPPERT PUBLISHER
0RINTEDANDBOUNDIN#HINA
&IRSTEDITION
,IBRARYOF#ONGRESS#ATALOGING IN 0UBLICATION$ATA
.OPARTOFTHISBOOKMAYBEUSEDORREPRODUCEDINANY +EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURBANPROJECTS*ANE!MIDON
MANNERWITHOUTWRITTENPERMISSIONFROMTHEPUBLISHER EDITOR
EXCEPTINTHECONTEXTOFREVIEWS PCMˆ3OURCEBOOKSINLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURE
)NCLUDESBIBLIOGRAPHICALREFERENCES
%VERYREASONABLEATTEMPTHASBEENMADETOIDENTIFYOWNERSOF )3".   8ALKPAPER
COPYRIGHT%RRORSOROMISSIONSWILLBECORRECTEDINSUBSEQUENT 3MITH +EN ˆ)NTERVIEWS,ANDSCAPEARCHITECTSˆ
EDITIONS .EW9ORK3TATE ˆ.EW9ORKˆ)NTERVIEWS,ANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTUREˆ.EW9ORK3TATE ˆ.EW9ORK)3MITH +EN
4HESEMINARSANDPUBLICATIONSFORTHISSERIESAREMADEPOSSIBLE n))!MIDON *ANE)))+EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT
BYTHEGENEROUSSUPPORTOF$EE$EE"3,! +NOWLTON &IRM )63ERIES
3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTURE AND(ERB'LIMCHER 3"3+
ˆDC

#ONTENTS

!CKNOWLEDGMENTS 

&OREWORD 0ETER2EED 

$ATAAND#HRONOLOGY 

#ONVERSATIONSWITH+EN3MITH 

#OMPILEDANDEDITEDBY*ANE!MIDON

4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN!RT 2OOF'ARDEN 

%AST2IVER&ERRY,ANDINGS 

03 

+EN3MITH ,ANDSCAPEAS#ULTURAL#RITICISM .INA2APPAPORT 

#REDITS 

"IBLIOGRAPHY 

"IOGRAPHIES 
!CKNOWLEDGMENTS

+EN3MITHANDHISOFlCE 7ORKSHOP+EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT+3,! PROVEDEARLYTOBEAPRO


VOCATIVEANDPRODUCTIVESUBJECTFORTHESECOND3OURCE"OOKIN,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE)NTHE
+NOWLTON3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTUREWASFORTUNATETOHOST+EN3MITHSINSTALLATIONOFTHREE$UMPSTER
'ARDENSONTHE/HIO3TATE5NIVERSITYCAMPUSTHEPROJECTNOTONLYCAUSEDBOTHJOYANDCONSTERNATION
WITHINTHEUNIVERSITYAUDIENCEBUTINDICATEDTHEVALUEOFPROVISIONALLANDSCAPESWHENWORDWASRECEIVED
THATTHEUNIVERSITYPRESIDENTHADLOOKEDDOWNFROMHERWINDOWONTO$UMPSTERPLANTEDINSCARLET
CELOSIAANDGREYARTEMISIA ANDPROCLAIMEDTHEPROJECTASUCCESS
3MITHSARTICULATEPRESENTATIONOFIDEASCASTSQUESTIONSTOWARDTHEMAKINGOFCONTEMPORARYURBAN
LANDSCAPES QUESTIONSWHOSEANSWERINGFEEDSTHEPERPETUALFRESHNESSOF+3,!DESIGN-UCHAPPRECIATION
ISOWEDTO+ENFORHISGARDENS FORHISGENEROUSTIMEANDENERGIESSPENTINTHE'LIMCHERSEMINARS AND
FORHISTHOUGHTFULCONTRIBUTIONSTOTHISPUBLICATION
4HECRITICALVALUEOFTHISBOOKISMUCHINCREASEDBYTHEPARTICIPATIONOF0ETER2EEDAND.INA
2APPAPORT4HANKSALSOTOTHESTUDENTSWHOJOINEDINTHESEMINAR*EFF!NDERSON -ICHAEL$ENISON ,IN
'OEPFERT "RIAN'RIFlTH 4IM(ESS +RIS,UCIUS *ILL-C+AIN 'ABRIELA0ATOCCHI #HERYL3OMERFELDT AND
ESPECIALLY*ASON"RABBS FORHISVIDEOGRAPHY-ATT/GBORNWASACHAMPIONTRANSCRIBER
4HE3OURCE"OOKSIN,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTUREWOULDNOTBEPOSSIBLEWITHOUTTHEGENEROUSPATRONAGEOF
$EE$EEAND(ERB'LIMCHERANDTHESUPPORTOFMANYATTHE+NOWLTON3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTURE3PECIlCALLY
THEENCOURAGEMENTOF$IRECTOR2OBERT,IVESEYISESSENTIALTOTHEPROGRAM)AMTHANKFULFORADVICEOFFERED
BYCOLLEAGUESANDFORTHELOGISTICALHELPOF+EN3MITHSSTUDIO INPARTICULAR3ENIOR!SSOCIATE%LIZABETH
!SAWA0RISCILLA-C'EEHONSHAREDINSIGHTFULCOMMENTSINTOTHEWORKOF+EN3MITH&INALLY THEEDITORIAL
GUIDANCEOF.ICOLA"EDNAREKAND+EVIN,IPPERTAT0RINCETON!RCHITECTURAL0RESSISVERYMUCHAPPRECIATED


3OURCE"OOKS
IN,ANDSCAPE
!RCHITECTURE

3OURCE"OOKSIN,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTUREPROVIDECONCISEINVESTIGATIONSINTOCONTEMPORARYDESIGNEDLAND
SCAPESBYLOOKINGBEHINDTHECURTAINANDBEYONDTHESCRIPTTOTRACEINTENTIONALITYANDRESULTS/NEGOALIS
TOOFFERUNVARNISHEDSTORIESOFPLACE MAKING!SECONDGOALISTOCATCHEMERGINGANDESTABLISHEDDESIGNERS
ASFACETSOFTHEIRPROCESSMATUREFROMTENTATIVETRIALINTODElNITIVETECHNIQUE
%ACH3OURCE"OOKPRESENTSONEPROJECTORGROUPOFRELATEDWORKSTHATARESIGNIlCANTTOTHEPRACTICEAND
STUDYOFLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURETODAY)TISOURHOPETHATREADERSGAINASENSEOFTHEPROJECTFROMSTARTTO
lNISH INCLUDINGCRUCIALEARLYCONCEPTSTHATPERSISTINTOBUILTFORMASWELLASTHEIDEASANDMETHODSTHAT
ARESHEDALONGTHEWAY$ESIGNPROCESS SITEDYNAMICS MATERIALSRESEARCH ANDTEAMROLESAREEXPLOREDIN
DIALOGUEFORMATANDDOCUMENTEDINPHOTOGRAPHS DRAWINGS DIAGRAMS ANDMODELS%ACH3OURCE"OOKIS
INTRODUCEDWITHAPROJECTDATAANDCHRONOLOGYSECTIONANDCONCLUDESWITHANESSAYBYANINVITEDCRITIC
4HISSERIESWASCONCEIVEDBY2OBERT,IVESEYATTHE!USTIN%+NOWLTON3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTUREANDPAR
ALLELSTHE3OURCE"OOKSIN!RCHITECTURE%ACHMONOGRAPHISASYNTHESISOFASINGLE'LIMCHER$ISTINGUISHED
6ISITING0ROFESSORSHIP3TRUCTUREDASASERIESOFDISCUSSION BASEDSEMINARSTOPROMOTECRITICALINQUIRYINTO
CONTEMPORARYDESIGNEDLANDSCAPES THE'LIMCHERPROFESSORSHIPSGIVESTUDENTSDIRECT SUSTAINEDACCESSTO
LEADINGVOICESINPRACTICE3TUDENTSWHOPARTICIPATEINTHESEMINARSPLAYANINSTRUMENTALROLEINCONTRIBUT
INGTODISCUSSIONS TRANSCRIBINGRECORDEDMATERIAL ANDEDITINGCONTENTFORTHE3OURCE"OOKS4HESEMINARS
AND3OURCE"OOKSAREMADEPOSSIBLEBYAFUNDESTABLISHEDBY$EE$EEAND(ERB'LIMCHER


&OREWORD

)HADGOODNEWSANDBADNEWSFOR+EN3MITHWHEN)CALLEDHIMIN4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN!RT
-O-! WANTEDTOCOMMISSIONABEAUTIFULANDIMAGINATIVELANDSCAPEATOPTHEROOFOFITSNEWGALLERY
BUILDINGINMIDTOWN-ANHATTANDESIGNEDBY9OSHIO4ANIGUCHI4HATWASTHEGOODNEWS"UTTHEPROJECT
CAMEWITHALONGLISTOFRESTRICTIONSTHATCOULDHARDLYBEATTRACTIVETOALANDSCAPEARCHITECTLIVEPLANTS
WERESTRONGLYDISCOURAGEDTHENEEDFORWATERWASTOBEMINIMIZEDORELIMINATEDALTOGETHERTHEHEIGHT
OFTHELANDSCAPECOULDNOTEXCEEDABOUTTHREEFEETTHEACCEPTABLEROOFLOADWASMINIMALBLACKAND
WHITESTONESROOFBALLAST HADALREADYBEENPURCHASEDANDIDEALLYSHOULDBEINCORPORATEDINTHENEW
DESIGNANDTHEBUDGETWASSLIM"ESIDES THEREWASNOPUBLICACCESSTOTHEROOFGARDEN)NFACT MUSEUM
GOERSWOULDNEVERSEETHEROOFONLYPEOPLEINTHESURROUNDINGBUILDINGS NOTABLYRESIDENTSOFTHEADJA
CENT-USEUM4OWERCONDOMINIUM WOULDENJOYTHEVIEWFROMABOVE4HISWASAWORKTOBELOOKEDAT
NOTWALKEDTHROUGH!FTEREXPLAININGTHISLITANYOFRESTRICTIONS THEREWASAPAUSEONTHEPHONE FOLLOWED
BY3MITHSSOMEWHATCAUTIOUSREPLY h7ELL )LLSEEWHAT)CANDOv
3MITHSPASTPROJECTS SUCHASHIS'LOWING4OPIARY'ARDENANDTHE03SCHOOLYARD SUGGESTEDTHAT
HEWASANIDEALCANDIDATETOTAKEONTHEMUSEUMSROOFGARDEN(ISWORKDEMONSTRATEDAREMARKABLE
ABILITYTOCONFRONTTHECOMMONREALITYOFMANYURBANSITESˆHARDSCAPESANDLOWBUDGETSˆANDPRODUCE
UNCONVENTIONALDESIGNSTHATAREHYBRIDSBETWEENLANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREANDENVIRONMENTALART(IS
APPROACHSTRETCHESTHECONVENTIONALDElNITIONOFLANDSCAPEINRESPONSETOASPECIlCPROGRAMTHATITSELF
SUGGESTSAFOCUSONAESTHETICORPRACTICALISSUESMORETHANECOLOGICALPROCESSES3MITHSIDEASAREBOLD
EVOCATIVE ANDSOMETIMESHUMOROUS ANDINSOMERESPECTSSHAREASENSIBILITYWITHOTHERDESIGNERS PAR
TICULARLY-ARTHA3CHWARTZ WITHWHOM3MITHPREVIOUSLYWORKED


)NHISlRSTPROPOSALFORTHEROOFGARDEN 3MITHTHREWCAUTIONTOTHEWIND&IELDSOFORDINARYCOLORFUL
PINWHEELDAISIESAREhPLANTEDvINAGRIDOFmUORESCENTGREEN06#PIPEˆ!NDY7ARHOLMEETS*OHN7ATERS
MEETS+MART4HEIMAGEOFSIXTHOUSANDWHIRLINGDAISIESARRANGEDINGREATWASHESOFCOLORWASHUMOROUS
IRREVERENT ANDPOTENTIALLYVERYBEAUTIFUL ESPECIALLYWHENVIEWEDFROMANOPTIMALDISTANCE4HENEIGH
BORINGRESIDENTS HOWEVER WERENOTCONVINCEDTHATKITSCHWOULDBEELEVATEDTOTHESTATUSOFART
3OMEWEEKSLATER3MITHSUBMITTEDANEWPROPOSAL WHICHEXPLOREDIDEASOFCAMOUmAGEANDCONCEAL
MENTUSINGREALANDPLASTICSTONES PLASTICSHRUBSANDGRASS CRUSHEDGLASS ANDBRICK4HESEELEMENTS
COULDBEARRANGEDINSEVERALWAYS3CHEMESVARIEDFROMARECTILINEARGEOMETRYTHATECHOESTHE-IESIAN
GRIDOF0HILIP*OHNSONS!BBY!LDRICH2OCKEFELLER3CULPTURE'ARDEN SEVERALSTORIESBELOWTOAN
ORGANICFREE FORMTHATIMITATESCAMOUmAGEPATTERNSANDRECALLSTHEIDIOSYNCRATICDESIGNSOFTHERENOWNED
"RAZILIANLANDSCAPEARCHITECT2OBERTO"URLE -ARX SUCHASHISROOFGARDENFORTHE-INISTRYOF%DUCATION
BUILDINGIN2IODE*ANEIROn 4HECAMOUmAGEGARDENPREVAILEDˆBEAUTIFULINITSOWNRIGHT AND
STANDINGINCONTRASTTOTHECONTROLLEDORTHOGONALGEOMETRYOF*OHNSONSGARDENAND4ANIGUCHISARCHITEC
TURE3EVERALBLOCKSAWAYAT4IMES3QUARE THEROOFOFTHE53!RMED&ORCES2ECRUITING3TATION ASMALL
ONE STORYPAVILIONDESIGNEDBY!RCHITECTURAL2ESEARCH/FlCE ISPAINTEDINMILITARYCAMOUmAGE
PATTERN(ERE THEROOFDECORATIONDOESNOTCONCEALTHESTRUCTUREBUTISTANTAMOUNTTOABILLBOARD
ADVERTISINGTHEACTIVITIESWITHINTHEBUILDING3MITHSROOFGARDENNEITHERCONCEALSNORISINTENDEDTO
EVOKEMILITARYASSOCIATIONS"UTBECAUSEOFITSUNCONVENTIONALITYANDBOLDCONTRASTWITHTHESURROUNDING
ENVIRONMENT ITTOOCALLSATTENTIONTOTHEINSTITUTIONWITHIN HOPEFULLYTOTHEDELIGHTANDCURIOSITYOF
THOSEWHOSEEIT

 9<5505./,(+:
-69,>69+
2ATHERTHANCOVERITSROOFINORDINARYSTONEBALLAST THEMUSEUMSEIZEDANOPPORTUNITYFORAMORE
CREATIVESOLUTION!SSUCH THEROOFGARDENPROJECTISNOTUNLIKE-O-!SEXHIBITIONPROGRAMSTHATPRESENT
EMERGINGTALENTANDFOSTEREXPERIMENTATION4HEMUSEUMSPROJECTSERIES BEGUNIN WASCONCEIVED
ASAFORUMFORNEWARTISTSANDHASBEENCENTRALTOTHEROLEOFCONTEMPORARYARTAT-O-!3IMILARLY THE
9OUNG!RCHITECTS0ROGRAM WHICHTAKESPLACEEVERYSUMMERIN03SCOURTYARDANDISNOWINITSlFTH
YEAR HASRESULTEDINASTONISHINGLYINNOVATIVETEMPORARYSTRUCTURES-O-!S3CULPTURE'ARDENHASALSO
BEENTHESETTINGFORARCHITECTURALPROJECTS MOSTRECENTLY 3HIGERU"ANSlRSTWORKINTHE5NITED3TATES
0APER!RCH AMONUMENTALLATTICEROOFMADEOFPAPERTUBES
3MITHSROOFGARDEN ALTHOUGHLOCATEDOUTSIDETHEPARAMETERSOFAPUBLICGALLERY ISINTENDEDTOBE
NOLESSACOMPELLINGWORK!NDASEVIDENCEDBYTHETHREEPROJECTSPRESENTEDINTHISMONOGRAPH lNDING
SOLUTIONSOUTSIDECONVENTIONALPARAMETERSISJUSTWHERE+EN3MITHSWORKWANTSTOBE

0ETER2EED
#URATOR 4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN!RT

9<5505./,(+:
-69,>69+
(WYPS
/NINVITATIONBY-O-! +EN3MITH
SUBMITSMATERIALSFORUNSPECIlED
PURPOSE

,HYS`5V]LTILY
4HE-USEUMOF
3MITHMEETSWITHMUSEUMSTAFFAND
-ODERN!RT 2OOF CURATORSTODISCUSSPARAMETERSOFTHE
'ARDEN ROOFPROJECT

*30,5;! +LJLTILY
4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN!RT 3MITHDEVELOPS0HOTOSHOPSTUDIESFOR
TWOALTERNATECONCEPTSTHATEXPLORE
+(;(! mOWERSASSUBJECTMATTERANDWRITES
.ORTHROOF SQUAREFEET DESCRIPTIONOFTHE&IELD$AISIES! 5V]LTILY
3OUTHROOF SQUAREFEET MODELISMADEOFTHEASSEMBLYPRO 4HEDESIGNISAPPROVEDAND
POSALANDAMOCK UPISFABRICATED $ECEPTIONBECOMESTHEPRIMARY
-ATERIALPALETTE ONTHE-O-!ROOFTOP!1UICKTIME :\TTLY SCHEME-ATERIALS DETAILING AND
ARTIlCIALBOXWOOD INCHES VIDEOISMADEANDTHEIDEASAREPRE 3MITHDEVELOPSCAMOUmAGECONCEPTS PRICINGRESEARCHPROCEEDWITHDESIGN
HEIGHT SENTEDTO-O-!CURATORS -ATERIALSANDDETAILINGRESEARCH DEVELOPMENT
SHEETS$URAGRATEMOLDED MOCK UPSAREDONEIN+3,!STUDIO
lBERGLASSGRATING INCHTHICK 1HU\HY` 1HU\HY`
INCHSQUAREMESH 0ROJECTISPRESENTEDTO-USEUM :LW[LTILY #HALK LINEMOCK UPISDONEONROOF
GREY06#PIPESEGMENTSAND 4OWERCONDOMINIUMBOARDFOR &OURCAMOUmAGEDESIGNCONCEPTS TOTESTOUTTHEHORIZONTALGEOMETRY
 GREY06#mANGEPIECESFOR APPROVAL!TENDOFTHEMONTHWORD AREPRESENTEDTO-O-!CURATORSAND OFTHESCHEMEATFULLSIZE)NITIALBIDS
BOXWOODASSEMBLY ISRECEIVEDTHATTHE&IELD$AISIESCON STAFFh)MITATIONvANDh$ECEPTIONv REVEALTHATTHEPROJECTISSUBSTAN
 LINEARFEET#.# CUTFOAM CEPTISREJECTEDBYTHECONDOMINIUM ARESELECTEDFORPRESENTATIONTO TIALLYOVERBUDGET6ALUEENGINEERING
HEADERS PAINTED"ENJAMIN-OORE BOARD-EETINGSWITH0ETER2EEDAND CONDOMINIUMBOARD!MOCK UP BEGINS"Y*UNETHEPROJECTISRE BID
(ILLSBOROBEIGE OTHER-O-!STAFFENSUETODISCUSS ISPLACEDONTHE-O-!ROOFIN FORATHIRDTIMEANDAlNALCOSTESTI
ARTIlCIALROCKS BLACK NEXTSTEPS ADVANCE MATEISACCEPTEDIN3EPTEMBER
ARTIlCIALROCKS WHITE
ONE POUNDBAGSRECYCLEDTUM
BLEDGLASSAGGREGATE CLEAR
lFTY POUNDBAGSWHITEMARBLE
CHIPS  INCHDIAMETER
FORTY POUNDBAGSRECYCLEDBLACK
RUBBERMULCH  INCHCHIPS


$ATAAND
#HRONOLOGY

5V]LTILY
.EW9ORK4IMESCOLUMNIST!NNE
2AVERWRITESANADVANCEREVIEWOF
THE-O-!ROOFGARDENDESIGNh! %AST2IVER&ERRY
2OOFTOP'ARDEN7ITH3YNTHETIC ,ANDINGS
'REENv
*30,5;!
1HU\HY` .EW9ORK#ITY%CONOMIC
#ONSTRUCTIONCOMMENCES $EVELOPMENT#ORPORATION
.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF 
-LIY\HY` 4RANSPORTATION
#ONSTRUCTIONREACHESPOINTOFSUB .EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF -HSS
STANTIALCOMPLETIONWITHCOMPLETED 0ARKSAND2ECREATION 3MITHISNOTIlEDTHATHISOFlCEHAS
PUNCHLIST4HEPREVIOUSDAYTHE.EW BEENPLACEDONASHORTLISTOFDESIGN
9ORK0OSTPUBLISHESAPHOTOOFTHE +(;(! CONSULTANTSFORANEWFERRYLAND
-LIY\HY`4HYJO GARDENENTITLEDh)TS!RT IlCIALv4HREE 4OTALPROJECTCOVERAGEACRES INGPROJECTONTHE%AST2IVER+3,!
#AMOUmAGESCHEMESEXHIBITEDAT DAYSLATER0ETER2EEDS-O-!SHOW DIVIDEDINTOFOURSITES TEAMSUPWITH+ENNEDY6IOLICH
(ARVARD5NIVERSITY'RADUATE3CHOOL h'ROUNDSWELL #ONSTRUCTINGTHE 4HIRTY FOURTH3TREETSITEACRES !RCHITECTUREINACOMPETITIONAGAINST
OF$ESIGN #ONTEMPORARY,ANDSCAPEvOPENS WITHAPPROXIMATELY SQUARE FOUROTHERDESIGNTEAMS ANDIS
4HEROOFTOPGARDENISREPRESENTEDIN FEETOFMARSHPLANTERS SELECTEDFORTHECOMMISSION
:LW[LTILY6J[VILY THEEXHIBITIONBUTPUBLICACCESSIS 3IZEOFMARSHPLANTERSFEETBY
+3,!STAFFVISITS#.#SHOPTOVIEW NOTANDNEVERWILLBE ALLOWED FEETINNINEMODULES 1HU\HY`1\UL
MOCKUPDIGITALlLESFOR#.# CUT 3MITHPREPARESPLANSFORTEMPORARY
FOAMHEADERSANDlBERGLASSGRATING (WYPS4H` -ARSHPLANTERELEMENTS LANDINGAT%AST3IXTY SEVENTH3TREET
AREISSUEDWITHlNALCONSTRUCTION 0ETER-AUSSOF%STOPHOTOGRAPHSTHE PUMP WITH*ERSEYBARRIERS CRIBWALLPLANT
DOCUMENTS PROJECT SALTWATERIRRIGATIONCHANNEL ERS ANDTAXODIUMBOSQUEPLANTING
SALTWATERSCUPPERS
FRESHWATERPOP UPSPRAYIRRIGATION
3(%,4%2

SYSTEMS
IVAFRUTESCENSMARSHELDEROR 2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3
/.3425#452%

HIGHTIDEBUSH
/0%.4/7!4%2 &%229

SPARTINAALTERNIFOLIASMOOTH
CORDGRASS




6J[VILY 4H`
0ROJECTSUBMITTEDTO.EW9ORK#ITY 3MITHRECEIVESCALLFROM2OBIN(OOD
&INE!RT#OMMISSIONFORPROJECT &OUNDATIONABOUTAPOSSIBLESCHOOL
APPROVAL YARDPROJECTIN1UEENS

+LJLTILY 03 1\UL


!PPROVALRECEIVED 3MITHMAKESlRSTSITEVISITTOSEETHE
*30,5;! PROJECT
4HYJO 4HE2OBIN(OOD&OUNDATION
CONSTRUCTIONDOCUMENTSDELIV 1\UL
(\N\Z[ ERED&OLLOWINGTHEINITIALCOSTESTI +(;(! 3MITHPRESENTSBOOKLETOF0HOTOSHOP
+3,!PRESENTSSCALEMODELAND MATE VALUEENGINEERINGBEGINS 3ITE SQUAREFEETEXCLUDING hBEFOREANDAFTERvIMAGERYILLUS
3MITHS0HOTOSHOPDIAGRAMSFORNEW BUILDINGFOOTPRINTS TRATINGlVELOW COSTPROTOTYPE
MARSHPLANTERBOXSCHEME3OON 6J[VILY SCHOOLYARDIMPROVEMENTSTOTHE
AFTER 3MITHDEVELOPSTHEFOLDED CONSTRUCTIONDOCUMENTS 3ITECOMPONENTS PROJECTMANAGERATTHE2OBIN(OOD
GEOMETRYPARTIINAPHOTOMONTAGE DELIVERED CUSTOMMODIlEDDUMPSTERS &OUNDATION2ECEIVESACALLWITHIN
CUBICYARDS HOURSh#LIENTLOVESITv
7VZ[:LW[LTILY (WYPS  SQUAREFEETNYLONSCRIMAT
&OLLOWINGTHETERRORISTATTACKSONTHE 4HEPROJECTISOUTFORlNALBIDS4HE FEET INCHESBYFEET 1\S`6J[VILY
7ORLD4RADE#ENTERTHEPROJECTGOES MARSHPLANTERSARELISTEDASANh!DD  SQUAREFEET,EARNING'ARDEN $ESIGNDEVELOPMENTANDCONSTRUC
ONHOLDFORSIXMONTHS !LTERNATEvFORBIDDING TIONDRAWINGSAREPREPARED
,EARNING'ARDENELEMENTS
SQUAREFEETWOODCHIPPATH
LOGS
TYPESOFPERENNIALSANDANNUALS
 TOTALPLANTED
TYPESOFSHRUBS TOTALPLANTED
TYPESOFTREES TOTALPLANTED

 +(;((5+*/965636.@
,HYS`(WYPS
3MITHSUPERVISESSOILPLACEMENT
BERMLAYOUT ANDSCRIMINSTALLATION
+3,!COMPLETESlNALBERMGRADING
PLANSANDWORKSWITHTHE.EW9ORK
2ESTORATION0ROJECTTOPREPARETHESITE
ANDSTAKEOUTTHEBIRDANDBUTTERmY
1HU\HY`-LIY\HY` GARDEN
0LANTINGPLANSFORBIRDANDBUTTERmY :\TTLY
GARDENAREPREPARED 3H[L(WYPS 0AUL7ARCHOLPHOTOGRAPHSTHESITE
,OGSANDPLANTSAREDELIVEREDTOTHE
4HYJO SITE/N%ARTH$AYVOLUNTEERSFROM (\N\Z[:LW[LTILY
3MITHSELECTSSPECIMENLOGSFORTHE THE4IMBERLAND#ORPORATIONDO -ETROPOLISMAGAZINEPUBLISHESTHE
GARDEN INITIALPLANTINGS!LL+3,!STAFFARE PROJECTh'ARDEN3POTv
5V]LTILY ONSITETOSUPERVISETHEVOLUNTEER
0AINTEDGRAPHICSELEMENTOFPROJECT  4HYJO EFFORTSTHROUGHOUTTHEPLANTINGAREA 6J[VILY
ISCOMPLETEDAND!LBERT6EC‡ERKAOF -OCK UPOFDUMPSTERPLANTERIS !DDITIONALPLANTINGSAREINSTALLED 0ROJECTRECEIVESAN!3,!-ERIT
%34/PHOTOGRAPHSTHESITE CREATEDIN7EST"ABYLON .EW9ORK THROUGH-AY !WARD


#ONVERSATIONS
WITH+EN3MITH
#OMPILEDANDEDITEDBY*ANE!MIDON

*ANE!MIDON7HATSIMPORTANTNOWINYOUR THEUNDERLYINGQUALITIESOFMYWORKTHATALLOWITS
WORKANDHOWDOESTHISRELATETOTHEDEVELOP OTHERASPECTSˆTHEFORMALQUALITIESANDTHECOM
MENTOFYOURPRACTICE MENTARYONCONTEMPORARYCULTUREˆTOCOMETO
BEARONTHEPROJECTS WHETHERTHEYARESMALLGAR
+EN3MITH4HEREARESEVERALTHREADSTHAT)THINK DENSORURBANSPACESORCOMPLEXLARGERSITESSUCH
AREVERYIMPORTANT&IRST IFYOUWANTTOPRACTICE ASREHABILITATINGALANDlLL/BVIOUSLY YOUCANT
LANDSCAPEARCHITECTURESERIOUSLY YOUMUSTHAVEA DESIGNALANDlLLONTHEBASISOFIRONYˆYOUMUST
COMMITMENTTOPUBLICSPACE9OUSHOULDALSOBE DEALWITHTHOSEOTHERISSUESOFECOLOGYANDSOCIAL
COMMITTEDTOENVIRONMENTALISM ANDALTHOUGH SPACEANDHISTORY
THELATTERISNOTIMMEDIATELYOBVIOUSINMOST
OFMYPROJECTS ITSIMPLICITINMYTHINKINGABOUT *!7HATARETHEROOTSOFTHEMINIMALISTAND
LANDSCAPE!NDlNALLY YOUMUSTHAVEACOM ICONICTENDENCIESINYOURWORKASWELLASTHE
MITMENTTOHISTORY ARESPECTFORHISTORY WHICH OTHERTHREADSYOUMENTION$OESAMULTIPLICITY
)HOPEISALSOIMPLICITINMYWORK4HESETHREE OFREADINGSOBSCUREACRITICALSTANCEASMUCH
SOCIALAGENDAS IFYOUWILL ARECRUCIALTOACRITICAL ASENRICHIT
PRACTICE"ECAUSEMYDESIGNSAREOFTENBASEDON
MINIMALISM ICONS ANDIRONY )FEELITSEVEN +3)MCOMFORTABLEWITHANOPENINTERPRETATION
MOREESSENTIALNOTTOGLOSSOVERTHESERIOUSNESS OFMYPROJECTS)LIKETHATTHERESACERTAININHERENT
OFMYPRACTICEANDTHENON IRONICASPECTSTHAT ABSTRACTNESSATTHECENTEROFAPROJECTSCONTENTSO
UNDERPINIT!SENSITIVITYFORPUBLICSPACE ENVI THEUNDERSTANDINGOFITCANSHIFTANDITCANHAVE
RONMENTALISM ANDCOMMITMENTTOHISTORYARE MULTIPLEMEANINGS)THINKTHATSWHATMAKES


/PYP`H3HUKMPSS7HYRJVTWL[P[PVU2LU:TP[OPU
JVSSHIVYH[PVU^P[O4PLYSL<RLSLZ"1\SPL)HYNTHUU
+09;:[\KPV"HUK3H\YH:[HYY:HYH[VNH(ZZVJPH[LZ
;LS(]P]

LANDSCAPEWORKOVERTIME4AKE#ENTRAL0ARK FOR DESIGNTEAM-ARTHASSIDEOFTHEOFlCEWASOFTEN


EXAMPLE-YREADINGOFTHEPARKISTHATONCEYOU REFERREDTOASTHEhPLAYPENv BUTTHEREWASASERI
STRIPAWAYTHEWELL WORNNARRATIVEOFMITIGATING OUSEXCHANGEOFIDEASBETWEENBOTHSIDESOFTHE
THEURBANILLS ATTHECOREITSBASICALLYABSTRACT OFlCE AND)LEARNEDTREMENDOUSLYFROMBOTH0ETE
CONTENTˆAGREATEMPTINESSATTHEHEARTOFTHECITY AND-ARTHA5NDERSTANDINGTHEIRDIFFERENTSTRATE
#ENTRAL0ARKHASSURVIVEDBECAUSEPEOPLECANPROJ GIESˆ-ARTHASIN YOUR FACEAPPROACHAND0ETES
ECTONITNEWANDEVOLVINGMEANINGˆEACHGENERA MORESUBTLEBUTCALCULATEDDESIGNSTRATEGIESˆPRO
TIONCANlNDWHATITNEEDS ANDTHEPARKSCONTENT VIDEDMEWITHAGOODSETOFBOOKENDSFORMY
CANSHIFTWITHTHETIMESANDWITHCULTURALCHANGES OWNPRACTICE4HEIMPORTANCEOFHISTORYBECAME
4HISISALSOTRUEOF*APANESEGARDENSSUCHAS CLEARTOMEWHILEWORKINGINTHEIROFlCE BECAUSE
2YOAN *IIN+YOTO ORPLACESLIKE7ALTER$E-ARIAS THEIRWORKWASROOTEDINCULTURALPRECEDENTS IN
,IGHTNING&IELD WHERETHELEVELOFABSTRACTNESS UNDERSTANDINGTHATWEAREPARTOFACONTINUUM
ALLOWSANOPENNESSOFINTERPRETATIONANDMEANING ANDTHATTHEREISADEEPWELLOFDESIGNHISTORYAND
)NMYTHINKINGABOUTLANDSCAPE)LEARNED TRADITIONSTODRAWUPONININNOVATINGCONTEMPO
FROMBOTH0ETER7ALKERSMINIMALISMAND-ARTHA RARYDESIGN
3CHWARTZSPOPAPPROACH)WASHIREDBY-ARTHA 4HEEMPHASISOFTHEIROFlCEWASONREINVIGO
RIGHTOUTOFGRADUATESCHOOLAT(ARVARD WHERE) RATINGTHEARTOFLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURE7HEN
WASASTUDENTOF0ETER7ALKER0ETEAND-ARTHA )MOVEDTO.EW9ORK#ITYTOOPENMYOWNOFlCE
WEREPARTNERSATTHETIME AND)WASBASICALLY )FOUNDITNECESSARYTOEMPHASIZEPUBLICSPACE
-ARTHASENTIRESTAFFATlRSTWHILE0ETEHADASUB ANDTHESOCIALASPECTSOFDESIGNASPARTOFTHEART
STANTIALAMOUNTOFPROJECTSANDASOLIDSTAFFAND OFMYPRACTICE!NDINCREASINGLY ECOLOGYAND

 *65=,9:(;065:
/PYP`H3HUKMPSS7HYRJVTWL[P[VU;LS(]P]

*65=,9:(;065: 
;67!4VU[HNLVMK\TWZ[LYWSHU[LYZZ[\K`
*,5;,9!+\TWZ[LY.HYKLUZ
6OPV:[H[L<UP]LYZP[`
4H`‹1\S`
)6;;64!+\TWZ[LY.HYKLUZ8\LLUZ7SHaHJVTWL[P[PVU
5L^@VYR
=PSSHNLVM@VYR]PSSL7HYR;VYVU[V*HUHKH ‹ 

ENVIRONMENTALISMAREGROWINGASANARTISTIC +3)TENDTODEVELOPIDEASINTHEOFlCETHATARE
INSTRUMENTINMYDESIGNWORK%NVIRONMENTALISM THENEXPLOREDINVARIOUSPROJECTSINDIFFERENTWAYS
ISPROBABLYSOMETHINGTHATISGENERATIONAL)THASA UNDERDIFFERENTCIRCUMSTANCES4HELINEAGEOFCER
STRONGERCURRENTTODAYTHANTWENTYYEARSAGO TAINIDEASCANBETRACEDFROMPROJECTTOPROJECT
"YTHES THEPROFESSIONHADSETUPADICHOTO &OREXAMPLE AFEWYEARSAGO)BECAMEINTERESTED
MYBETWEENENVIRONMENTALPLANNINGANDFORM INTHEIDEAOFCONTAINERS)PROPOSEDUSINGTRASH
ORSPACE DRIVENDESIGN!TSOMEPOINTYOUREALIZE ANDCONSTRUCTIONDUMPSTERSINAWAYSIMILARTO
THATTHISISARIDICULOUSANDCOUNTERPRODUCTIVE CONVENTIONALmOWERBOXESBUTLARGERINSIZEAND
DICHOTOMYANDTHATITSMUCHMORESUBSTANTIVETO SCOPETHISDEVELOPEDINTOTHECONTAINERCONCEPTS
COMBINEALLELEMENTSˆTODOWORKTHATSENVIRON AT03 1UEENS0LAZA ANDINTHEINSTALLATION
MENTALLYSENSITIVEANDARTISTICALLYSTRONGINTERMS OFDUMPSTERGARDENSATTHE/HIO3TATE5NIVERSITY
OFITSMEDIUMASWELLASSOCIALLYRESPONSIBLEINITS 4HEMARSHPLANTERSINTHE%AST2IVERPROJECTAREA
USEOFPUBLICSPACEANDSUSTAINABILITY VARIATIONONTHISINTERESTINTHECONTAINER ASISTHE
COLLECTIONBOXIDEA)USEDAT9ORKVILLE0ARK
*!"UTCANYOUREALLYHAVEITALL +EN !NOTHERIDEADEALSWITHTHECONCEPTOFVERTI
CALGREENˆTHENOTIONTHATLANDSCAPECANOCCUPY
+3)DONTKNOW)MlNDINGOUT ORCO HABITWITHURBANINFRASTRUCTUREINAVERTICAL
ORSTRUCTUREDWAY4HISGOESBACKTOTHEQUESTION
*!(OWDOESAPROJECTGETBORNINYOUROFlCEˆ OFHOWYOUlNDSPACETOMAKELANDSCAPEINHIGHLY
WHATSTHEPATTERNOFINTERACTIONBETWEENYOU BUILTURBANAREAS)EXPERIMENTEDWITHTHISIDEAAT
CLIENTS YOURSTUDIOTEAM THE4IME7ARNER#ENTERAT#OLUMBUS#IRCLE WHERE

*65=,9:(;065: 
/PYP`H3HUKMPSS7HYRJVTWL[P[PVU;LS(]P]

)DESIGNEDAFOLDEDSTAINLESS STEELhTOPIARYWALLv !NOTHERMAJORTHREADINMYWORKISAPPRO


THATISPLANTEDTOCREATEAVERTICALLANDSCAPE AND PRIATIONANDFOUNDOBJECTS4HEDUMPSTERSARE
ATAMUSEUMIN1UEENSWHERE)PROPOSEDATOPIARY CERTAINLYAMANIFESTATIONOFTHIS0ARTOFTHISIS
CURTAIN!TTHEMUSEUMPROJECT PHOTOGRAPHING ALSOMYINTERESTINUSINGCONTEMPORARYMATERIALS
THESITEGAVEMETHEIDEAOFCREATINGAKINDOFTHE THATAREINTENDEDFOROTHERUSES4HE!LUMINUM
ATRICALCURTAINALONGONEEDGEWITHmUIDFOLDSTHAT 'ARDEN WHERE)USEDFACTORYGRATING STRUCTURAL
COULDBEPLANTEDWITHVINES)NANOTHERCURRENT MARINECHANNELS ANDHEAVYCONSTRUCTIONTIMBER
PROJECTALSOIN1UEENS)HAVEPROPOSEDASERIESOF ISANEXAMPLE-YINTERESTINFOUNDOBJECTSAND
LARGEBILLBOARDSTRUCTURESFORTHETOPOFSEVERALLOW THEIRTRANSFORMATIONISEXPLOREDINTHE(OTEL%DEN
RISEBUILDINGSTHATWOULDBEPLANTEDWITHVINES INSTALLATIONFOR.ESTMAGAZINEANDINTHE-O-!
AKINDOFGREENSIGNAGEIFYOUWILL2ELATEDTOTHE ROOFGARDEN4HEROOFGARDENTAKESTHISASPECTOF
IDEAOFVERTICALGREENISMYCURRENTINTERESTIN APPROPRIATIONTOANEWLEVELOFSIMULATION
PLEATS AKINDOFFOLDINGTHATARTICULATESFORM/NE )NTERMSOFHOWWEWORKASASTUDIO )TEND
OFTHElRSTPROJECTSOFTHISTYPEISASMALLURBAN TOSTARTOUTWITHANINITIALIDEATHAT)WANTTO
COURTYARDIN-ANHATTAN WHICHISGOINGTOHAVEA EXPLOREARTISTICALLYANDTOWHICHTHEPROJECTIS
FOLDED FORMTOPIARYSCREENCONSTRUCTEDOFANARMA SUITED4YPICALLY)THINKBEFORE)BEGINTODRAW)
TUREWITHSTAINLESS STEELMESHPANELSANDVINES) LIKEUSING0HOTOSHOPINEARLYDESIGNSTAGESASA
USEDPLEATSINTHE(IRIYALANDlLLPROJECTIN4EL!VIV SKETCHINGTOOLTOMAKEMONTAGESANDDIAGRAMSOF
ANDTHE%AST2IVER&ERRY,ANDINGSPROJECTALSOHASA INITIALCONCEPTS)MOSTLYDOTHESESTUDIESMYSELF
FOLDINGFORMˆORIGAMIFOLDINGINTHISCASEˆASDOES BECAUSETHEYALLOWMETODEVELOPIDEASANDA
THE4IME7ARNERPROJECT LINEAGEOFTHOUGHT)OFTENUSEACOMBINATIONOF

 *65=,9:(;065:
;67SLM[!(S\TPU\T.HYKLU5L^@VYR*P[` 
;67YPNO[!(S\TPU\T.HYKLU
*,5;,9!/V[LS,KLUHY[PMPJPHSNHYKLUPUZ[HSSH[PVUMVY5LZ[
THNHaPUL
)6;;64!;OL4\ZL\TVM4VKLYU(Y[5L^@VYR*P[`9VVM
.HYKLU‹

*65=,9:(;065: 
4\[HU[.HYKLUZ3H\ZHUUL:^P[aLYSHUK

'OOGLEDOWNLOADSANDMYOWNIMAGEANDREFER OWNWORK )MINTERESTEDINDEVELOPINGAKIND


ENCECOLLECTIONINGENERATINGCONCEPTIMAGES OFRANDOMNESSTHATISROOTEDINGEOMETRY&ORAN
)TSPRETTYCOMMONFORMETOSTARTOUTWITHTHESE INTERIORWALLINTHENEWCAFÏATTHE#ORNERSTONE
0HOTOSHOPSKETCHESBEFORETHEOFlCEDOESANY 'ARDEN&ESTIVALIN3ONOMA )CAMEUPWITHTHE
KINDOF#!$WORK/FTEN)GOFROMTHESESTUDIES IDEAOFhWALLmOWERSvˆARTIlCIALmOWERSTHATARE
DIRECTLYTOMODELANDTHENlNALLYTO#!$PRODUC PINNEDTOTHEWALLACCORDINGTOANINVISIBLEGRID
TION)MACOMMITTEDMODELBUILDER%VENTHOUGH )TSABITOFA3OL,EWITTNOTIONTHATTHEmOWERSCAN
)DONTUSUALLYHAVETHELUXURYOFBUILDINGCOM OCCUPYTHECENTEROFTHEGRID ONEOFFOURSIDES
PLETEMODELSMYSELFANYMORE )STILLLIKETOWORK ORONEOFFOURCORNERSˆTHEREARENINEPOSSIBLE
WITHSMALLSTUDYMODELSTOHELPMEUNDERSTAND POSITIONSANDALIMITEDRANGEOFmOWERCHOICES)
THEFORMOFSOMETHING)MTHINKINGABOUT AND CLIPPEDTHEIMAGESOFmOWERSFROMANOTHERPROJECT
MODELSARECONSTRUCTEDTHROUGHOUTTHEDESIGN )HADINMYCOMPUTERTOTESTOUTTHEGRIDPALETTE
PROCESSˆEVENTUALLYEVENATFULLSIZETOTESTOUT PULLINGAmOWER PICKINGANUNUSEDPOSITION
FORMANDSCALEOFFEATURES)AMPROTOTYPING ANDAPPLYINGITUNTILTHElELDWASEXHAUSTED THEN
STARTINGTHEPROCESSOVERAGAINANDAGAINUNTIL
*!7HATSYOURTAKEONSYSTEMATICRANDOMNESS THEENTIREWALLWASCOMPLETE)NTHElNALINSTALLA
TION THEGRIDISGONEBUTYOUCANSENSEIT WHEN
+3)MINTERESTEDINPROCESSANDHOWPROCESSCAN YOULOOKATTHERANDOMPATTERNING)TSLIKEWHEN
BEAGENERATOROFFORM)MAFANOFMINIMALIST YOUTOUCHPOISONIVYANDGETTHESELINESOFWELTS
MUSIC FOREXAMPLE WHEREPROCESSANDSTRUCTURE ONYOURSKIN9OUCANREADTHELINESASGEOMETRIC
AREUSEDTOCREATEANEXPERIENTIALARTFORM)NMY FORMSBUTBEHINDTHEOVERTGEOMETRYTHEREISTHIS

 *65=,9:(;065:
.SV^PUN;VWPHY`.HYKLU2LU:TP[OPUJVSSHIVYH[PVU
^P[O1PT*VU[P5L^@VYR*P[` 

OTHERDYNAMICˆTHEPATTERNEXISTSBETWEENGEOM PRODUCTSˆWITHTHECOUTURELINEBEINGTHEMOST
ETRYANDTHATOTHERFORCE9OUREYEWANTSTORECOG IMPORTANTLINEOFPRODUCTIONARTISTICALLYSPEAKING
NIZEANORDERBUTYOUCANTQUITEPINITDOWN "UTTHEFASHIONHOUSEALSOHASREADY TO WEARAND
BRIDGELINES PERFUMESANDACCESSORIES ANDOTHER
*!9OUINITIALLYGAINEDPUBLICITYINDESIGN PRODUCTSTHATEXTENDTHEIDEASDEVELOPEDFORTHE
CIRCLESFORYOURSMALLER SCALEPROVISIONAL COUTURELINEINDIFFERENTBUTSTILLARTISTICALLYSIGNIl
INSTALLATIONSSUCHASTHE'LOWING4OPIARY CANTDIRECTIONS%ARLYINMYOFlCESHISTORY )USED
'ARDEN -UTANT'ARDENS ORTHE&IFTH!VENUE TOTALKABOUTTHIS ABOUTHAVINGDIFFERENTKINDSOF
#HANDELIERPROPOSAL)NDISCUSSIONSIN PRODUCTLINESTHEREARETHEARTINSTALLATIONS THE
YOUSTRESSEDTHESUBVERSIVENATUREOFTEMPORARY PUBLICPROJECTS ANDTHERESIDENTIALWORK)WAS
WORKASAPRIMARYINTEREST4ODAYYOUAREWORK NEVERINTERESTEDINESTABLISHINGTHEKINDOFOFlCE
INGONLARGE SCALE hPERMANENTvLANDSCAPES AND THATFOCUSESONLYONONESINGULARTHING)NSTEAD)
YOULISTPUBLICSPACE HISTORY ANDENVIRONMEN WANTEDTODEVELOPAGENERALPRACTICETHATALLOWSA
TALISMASMANDATESFORSUCCESS$OSMALL TEM WIDERANGEOFWORK
PORARYWORKSSTILLMATTERINYOURPRACTICE !TlRST ITWASDIFlCULTTOGETLARGERPUBLIC
PROJECTSBECAUSENOBODYWASGOINGTOTRUSTSOME
+3)VEALWAYSTHOUGHTOFTHEPROVISIONALPROJ BODYWITHLITTLEORNOEXPERIENCEINTHISAREA"UT
ECTSASAKINDOFRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTTOOL) NOW)MATAPOINTWHERE)HAVETHEOPPORTUNITY
LIKETOCOMPARETHISTOTHEWORKINGSOFAFASHION TODOMORELARGE SCALEWORK)NMYPRACTICE
HOUSESUCHAS#HRISTIAN$IOROR*EAN0AUL'AULTIER THERESALINKBETWEENSTRATEGYANDCONCEPT AND
!FASHIONHOUSECONSISTSOFAWHOLERANGEOF MATERIALITYANDDETAIL-ISSINGTHATLINKISONEOF

*65=,9:(;065: 
THEFUNDAMENTALPROBLEMSWITHALOTOFLANDSCAPE POST INDUSTRIALERATHAThDIDNOTEXISTASPUB
ARCHITECTUREPRACTICESTHEREAREPEOPLEWHODO LICSPACEHALFAGENERATIONAGOv)NTHESAME
ONLYTHEORETICALANDCONCEPTUALWORKANDNEVER WAYTHATWELOOKBACKTO%LIZABETH+ASSLERS
GETANYTHINGBUILT ANDTHEREAREPEOPLEWHOARE -O-!PUBLICATION-ODERN'ARDENSAND
REALLYGOODATBUILDINGANDDETAILINGBUTDONT THE,ANDSCAPEASASIGNALTHATMODERNISMHAD
HAVEANYIDEAS!NDTHENTHEREARETHECRITICAL COALESCEDINTOADOMINANTPOSTWARPARADIGM
PRACTICESANDAFEWGOODlRMSINTHECOUNTRYTHAT WHATDOESANEXHIBITIONSUCHASh'ROUNDSWELLv
AREENGAGEDATBOTHLEVELS-YAMBITIONISTOCRE SAYTOYOUASALANDSCAPEARCHITECT ANDHOW
ATEWORKTHATISCONCEPTUALLYGROUNDEDANDMATE WILLYOURWORKBEPOSITIONEDINTHECOMING
RIALLYRIGOROUSWITHASTRONGCONNECTIONBETWEEN DECADESOFPOST PRODUCTIVESITES
IDEAANDDESIGNFORMANDMATERIALRESOLUTION)
THINKTHATTHEEXPERIMENTATIONWITHANDRISKTAK +34HEh'ROUNDSWELLvEXHIBITIONISAKINDOF
INGINVOLVEDWITHTHETEMPORARYORPROVISIONAL SUMMARYOFTHEDOMINANTIDEASTOEMERGEIN
PROJECTSISESSENTIALINTESTINGANDDEVELOPINGIDEAS LANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREATTHEENDOFTHETWENTIETH
THATCANCOMETOBEARINTHEEXECUTIONOFLARGER CENTURYANDTHEBEGINNINGOFTHISNEWCENTURY)T
ANDMORECOMPLEXBUILTPROJECTS MARKSATRANSITIONINTHEPRODUCTIONOFLANDSCAPE
SPACEFROMMODERNTOPOSTMODERN)TISREALLYNO
*!4HEh'ROUNDSWELLvSHOWAT-O-!OPENED LONGERFEASIBLEˆECONOMICALLY SOCIALLY ORENVI
IN&EBRUARYOF)TDOCUMENTSTHEPROFES RONMENTALLYˆTOCONTINUEWITHTHEEXPLOITATION
SIONSCURRENTOCCUPATIONWITH INCURATOR0ETER OFRAWSPACETHATTYPIlEDALOTOFTHEMODERN
2EEDSWORDS hNEWURBANLANDSCAPESvOFTHE ERAPRODUCTION4ODAYTHEMOSTINTERESTINGAND

 *65=,9:(;065:
RESPONSIBLEWORKISOCCURRINGINTHEMARGINSOF BROADCONCEPTUALIDEAS)THINKTHESAMEISTRUE
LEFTOVERANDRECLAIMEDSPACE4HISINCLUDESWORK FORAWHOLEYOUNGERGENERATIONOFDESIGNERS
INGWITHINTHECONSTRAINTSOFEXISTINGURBANFABRIC )LIKETOWORKAPROBLEMCONCEPTUALLYFROMBOTH
RECOVERINGDEFUNCTMANUFACTURINGAREAS DERELICT ENDSTOSEEWHERETHESOLUTIONlNDSRESOLUTION
WATERFRONTS ANDMARGINALURBANFRINGEAREAS INTHEMIDDLE
CREATINGNEWPUBLICUSESINTHESUBSIDIARYSPACES
THATOCCURALONGSIDEINFRASTRUCTURERETHINKING
SMALLLEFTOVERURBANSPACESFORNEWSOCIALUSES
ANDRECLAIMINGENVIRONMENTALLYDAMAGEDSPACES
SUCHASBROWNlELDS4HEDIFlCULTYOFWORKING
WITHTHESETYPESOFSPACESLIESINCREATINGNEW
DESIGNAPPROACHESTHATRESPONDTONEWPROGRAM
MATICDEMANDS CHALLENGINGENVIRONMENTALCON
DITIONS ANDTHEREALITIESOFCONTEMPORARYLIFE)
THINKTHEWORKINTHE-O-!SHOWISARESPONSE
TOTHISCHANGINGlELDOFLANDSCAPEDESIGN)NMY
OWNWORK)HAVEEXPERIMENTEDWITHNEWDESIGN
METHODOLOGIES)AMASINTERESTEDININDUCTIVE
hBOTTOM UPvDESIGNAPPROACHESTHATFAVORCONTEXT
ANDOPPORTUNISTICTACTICSAS)AMINLARGERSTRATEGIC
hTOP DOWNvAPPROACHESTHATFAVORSYSTEMSAND
 *65=,9:(;065:
4HE-USEUM
OF-ODERN!RT
2OOF'ARDEN
.EW9ORK .EW9ORK

)N-O-!CURATOR0ETER2EEDASKED+EN3MITH HADRIGHTOFREFUSALANDINDEEDARETHEPRIMARY
TOPROPOSEANhIMAGINATIVEvROOFSCAPEINSTALLATION AUDIENCEFORTHEROOFTOPSITE7HATDIDYOU
FORTHENEWGALLERYADDITIONBYARCHITECT9OSHIO LEARNFROMTHElRSTSCHEMESFAILURE ANDHOWDID
4ANIGUCHI.EVERTOBEACCESSIBLETOTHEGENERAL THATGUIDEYOURIDEASFORTHESECONDSCHEME
PUBLIC THE SQUARE FOOTGARDEN SITTINGSIX
FLOORSABOVESTREETLEVEL WASDESTINEDTOFUNCTION +34HElRSTSCHEMETHAT)CAMEUPWITHWASA
MOREASONEOFTHEMUSEUMSCOLLECTEDWORKSOF GRIDOFSPINNINGDAISIES ANOPTICALlELDOFPLASTIC
MODERNANDCONTEMPORARYARTTHANASANINHABIT mOWERSTHATREACTEDTOWINDMOVEMENT4HEIDEA
ABLELANDSCAPE.UMEROUSDESIGNCONSIDERATIONS WASMAYBETOOOBVIOUS)THINKTHE-USEUM
INCLUDEDWEIGHTRESTRICTIONS ZEROTOLERANCEFORIRRI 4OWERSRESIDENTIALCO OPBOARDDIDNTLIKEITSOVERT
GATION NOELEMENTSABOVETHREEFEETINHEIGHT AND NATURE3OFORTHENEXTPROPOSAL)THOUGHTTHATA
ALOWBUDGET3MITHSFIRSTPROPOSALWASDISALLOWED STUDYOFCAMOUmAGEWOULDBEAGOODSTARTINGPOINT
SENDINGTHEDESIGNERBACKTOTHEDRAWINGBOARDTO FORGETTINGANINTERESTINGSCHEMEUNDERTHERADAR
DEVISEAFINALSCHEMEOFACONTEXTUALLYALERT PAT ASITWERE
TERNEDSURFACECONDITION
*!)SITPROBLEMATICIFTHEDESIGNSUCCEEDSTO
*!9OURlRSTSCHEMEFORTHE-O-!ROOFTOP THEPOINTTHATITSRENDEREDINVISIBLE IE IFA
WASASUCCESSONTHELECTURECIRCUITANDINITS VIEWERMISSESTHEPOINT$OESTHETERMCAMOU
EVENTUALINSTALLATIONATTHE#ORNERSTONE'ARDEN mAGENEEDTOBEUSEDEXPLICITLYINRELATIONTOTHE
&ESTIVALIN3ONOMA #ALIFORNIA"UTITWAS PROJECT
REJECTEDBY-O-!SRESIDENTIALNEIGHBORS WHO


;OLMSV^LYTV[PMPUTVKLYUHY[

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
(UHS[LYUH[P]LPUP[PHSKLZPNUZJOLTLMLH[\YLK
[OLKHPZ`MSV^LYHZHUPJVU

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
:TP[OZMPYZ[YLQLJ[LKKLZPNUZJOLTLMVY[OLYVVMNHYKLU^HZ
IHZLKVUHMPLSKVMZWPUUPUNSH^UMSV^LYZ

9LKHUKNYLLUMSV^LYMPLSK 6YHUNLYLKHUKW\YWSLMSV^LYMPLSK

7\YWSLMSV^LYMPLSK @LSSV^HUKYLKMSV^LYMPLSK
 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
PUJOKPHTL[LYKHPZ`WPU^OLLSH[[HJOLK[VWPWLZJHMMVSKPUNIHZL
 INCHDIAMETER$AISY0INWHEEL ATTACHEDTOPIPESCAFFOLDINGBASE

:JHMMVSKPUN[`WL[\ILHUKJV\WSLYSH[[PJL
3CAFFOLDING TYPETUBEANDCOUPLERLATTICE
Z[HUKHYKNHS]HUPaLKWPWLZWHPU[LKIYPNO[NYLLU^P[OZ[HUKHYKJV\WSLYZ
STANDARDGALVANIZEDPIPESPAINTEDBRIGHTGREENWITHSTANDARDCOUPLERS

9VVMIHSSHZ[YVJR
2OOF"ALLAST2OCK

 INCHOCTYP

  INCHSTEM

+3)THINKITSHARDLYINVISIBLE7HEN)PRESENTED ASASTUDENT)READTHEOLD0ENCIL0OINTSARTICLESBY
THEPROJECTFORAPPROVAL )DIDNTHAMMERTHE $AN+ILEY *AMES2OSE AND'ARRETT%CKBO)NTHE
POINTHOME )DIDNTSTARTOFFBYSAYING hTHISIS SAMEBOUNDVOLUMEOFTHEMAGAZINETHEREWAS
ABOUTCAMOUmAGE vWHICHWOULDACTUALLYHAVE ANARTICLEONTHEARTANDTHEORYANDTECHNIQUESOF
BEENQUITECOUNTERPRODUCTIVE)TALKEDABOUTTHE CAMOUmAGE)TWASGEAREDTOWARDARCHITECTSAND
GARDENINDIFFERENTTERMS BUTMYPRESENTATION TALKEDABOUTHOWYOUCOULDCAMOUmAGEBUILDINGS
ACKNOWLEDGEDWHATITWASABOUTANDHOWITWAS FORREASONSOFNATIONALSECURITY)ALWAYSTHOUGHT
OPERATING4HEDESIGNISABOUTSIMULATION)NFACT THATCAMOUmAGEWASANINTERESTINGQUALITYANDDID
CREATINGALANDSCAPEGARDENONAROOFTOPISINHER MYlRSTCAMOUmAGESTUDIESDURINGTHELATES
ENTLYANACTOFSIMULATION)AMVERYINTERESTEDIN )TWASANIDEATHAT)HADPLAYEDWITHBUTHAD
HOWCAMOUmAGESIMULATESLANDSCAPE ANDINTHIS NEVERGOTTENTOTHEPOINTOFEXECUTING
GARDENTHELANDSCAPESIMULATESCAMOUmAGESIMU
LATINGLANDSCAPE *!$OESTHEMAKINGOFACONSTRUCTEDLANDSCAPE
4HEREISAWHOLESERIESOFDIFFERENTCAMOUmAGE ALWAYSIMPLYTHEARTIlCEOFSIMULATION3OME
STRATEGIESTHATWEREDEVELOPEDATACRITICALMOMENT WOULDSAYTHATALLACTSOFDESIGNCAMOUmAGE
OFTHELATESANDEARLYSˆCOINCIDINGWITH TRUTHWHILEOTHERSSAYITSABRINGINGFORTH AN
7ORLD7AR))0EOPLETHENWEREVERYINTERESTED AGENTOFCLARIlCATIONANDAMPLIlCATION
INTHENOTIONOFCAMOUmAGEˆSCIENTISTSASWELLAS
DESIGNERSANDARTISTS)NTHEARCHITECTUREMAGAZINES +34HEHISTORYOFGARDENDESIGNISlLLEDWITH
OFTHETIMETHEREWASACRITICALDISCUSSIONABOUT EXAMPLESOFSIMULATIONANDCAMOUmAGE#ENTRAL
THEROLEOFCAMOUmAGEINDEFENSE)REMEMBERTHAT 0ARK FOREXAMPLE ISALARGE SCALEGARDENTHAT

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
ARTISTICALLYSIMULATESVISUALANDSPATIALASPECTSOF $ECEPTIONCAMOUmAGEISAMETHODTHATDOESNOT
ANIDEALIZEDPRE INDUSTRIALARCADIAANDDISGUISESA ATTEMPTTOCOMPLETELYHIDETHESUBJECTBUTTO
LARGETERRITORYOFTHE-ANHATTANGRIDWITHIMITATED CHANGEITSAPPEARANCEENOUGHTHATITRESEMBLES
NATURE#ONTEMPORARYLANDSCAPEDESIGNOFTENDEALS SOMETHINGOFADIFFERENTORINNOCUOUSNATURE4HE
WITHTHEFUNDAMENTALISSUEOFAMELIORATINGOR PRINCIPLEISEMPLOYEDTODECEIVETHEBOMBARDIER
COVERINGUPTHEIMPACTSOFTHECONSTRUCTEDENVI WHOISLOOKINGFORAPOWERHOUSEANDlNDSONLYAN
RONMENT0RACTITIONERSREFERTOTHISAShREMEDIA hAPARTMENTHOUSEvWITHAWNINGSANDSHRUBS$ECOY
TION vhSHRUBBINGITUP vhCONTEXTUALIZATION vOR CAMOUmAGEISACHIEVEDTHROUGHTHECONSTRUCTIONOF
SIMPLYhNATURALIZINGv4HISPRACTICEOFLANDSCAPING DUMMYOBJECTSINCONJUNCTIONWITHTHECONCEAL
ASCAMOUmAGEISACOMMONBUTCRITICALLYUNRECOG MENTOFREALONESSOTHATENEMYBOMBERSWILLBE
NIZEDASPECTOFSIMULATIONINTHELANDSCAPEARCHI ATTRACTEDTOFALSETARGETS#ONFUSIONISTHELEASTUSED
TECTUREPROFESSION CAMOUmAGEPROCEDUREANDCONSISTSOFCONCEALING
&OURBASICCAMOUmAGESTRATEGIESWEREIDENTIlED THESUBJECTBYIMPAIRINGVISIONORJUDGMENTBYPRE
BY!RCHITECTAND%NGINEERMAGAZINEINIMITA SENTINGAMULTIPLICITYOFPOTENTIALORILLOGICALTARGETS
TION DECEPTION DECOY ANDCONFUSION)MITATION THATCONFUSEACCURATEDETERMINATION
CAMOUmAGEISTHEMOSTCOMMONANDWIDELYUSED )NCONTEMPORARYURBANLIFE hCAMOUmAGEvIS
TECHNIQUE)TISTHEBLENDINGINWITHSURROUNDING IRONICALLYUSEDTOBOTHBLENDINANDSTANDOUT4HE
TERRITORYSOTHATTHESUBJECTISINDISTINGUISHABLE -O-!PROJECTTAKESTHEARTOFCAMOUmAGEANDTHE
FROMITSSETTING7HETHERITISINTHECOUNTRYOR ARTIlCEOFSIMULATIONASTEPFURTHERBYUSINGTHE
CITY DESERTORFOREST SUMMERORWINTER THESUBJECT SIMULATIONITSELFASASOURCEFORDESIGNSPECULATION
APPEARSTOBEPARTOFTHESURROUNDINGLANDSCAPE /NEMIGHTTHINKOFTHISASTHESIMULATIONOFA

 464(966-.(9+,5
SIMULATION ORUSINGIMITATEDNATURETOGENERATEA EMPLOYINGRECTILINEARFORMSTHATHAVETHESHAPEOF
NEWNATURE SKYLIGHTS VENTS ORELEVATORSHAFTSˆTHESORTOFPLAT
2OOFGARDENSAREINHERENTLYARTIlCIALENVIRON FORMSYOUlNDONTHETOPOFBUILDINGSTHATBLEND
MENTS4HEYHAVELIMITATIONSOFWEIGHTLOADING INTOTHEURBANLANDSCAPE3OOURlRSTSCHEMEWAS
THEREAREISSUESOFHOWTOANCHORELEMENTSAND VERYRECTILINEARˆAKINDOF0ETER7ALKERSCHEME
PROTECTTHEWATERPROOFMEMBRANE ASWELLASENVI 4HESECONDSTRATEGYISBASEDONDECEPTION IN
RONMENTALISSUESOFWIND ACCESSTOLIGHT ANDGEN THISCASEMAKINGTHEROOFTOPLOOKLIKESOMETHINGIT
ERALLYHARSHCONDITIONSFORLIVINGPLANTS INCLUDING ISNT ASOPPOSEDTOBLENDINGIN)USEDCURVILINEAR
LIMITEDMAINTENANCEANDCARE3IMULTANEOUSLY THE FORMSTOIMITATE#ENTRAL0ARK WHICHISJUSTAFEW
DESIGNOFTHESESPACESISOFTENDRIVENBYTHEDESIRE BLOCKSNORTHOFTHEBUILDING)APPLIEDTHEICONIC
TOIMPOSETHEIMAGERYOFIMITATEDNATUREONTO CAMOUmAGEPATTERNYOUlNDINMILITARYCLOTHINGTO
THESEBUILTCONSTRUCTIONS MAKEREFERENCETO/LMSTEDSLANDSCAPING
$ECOYISTHETHIRDAPPROACH THEONEWHERE
*!$ESCRIBEYOURFOURDESIGNPROPOSALSFORTHE YOUBASICALLYTHROWTHEVIEWEROFFTRACKBYBUILDING
ROOFTOPACCORDINGTOTHECATEGORIESOFIMITATION ADUMMYTARGET&ORTHATSCHEME)CREATEDAFOLDED
DECEPTION DECOY ANDCONFUSION LANDSCAPETHATWASNEITHERBUILDINGNORNATUREˆIT
WASJUSTAFALSETHINGUPTHERE AREDHERRING
+34HEMOSTCOMMONCAMOUmAGESTRATEGYISIMITA 4HEFOURTHSTRATEGYWASCONFUSION)NTHE
TION)FYOUHAVEABUILDINGSITTINGINTHEMIDDLEOF MAGAZINEARTICLETHISAPPROACHWASDESCRIBEDAS
THEWOODS YOUIMITATETHEWOODSTOBLENDIN&ORA BUILDINGlRESORSOMETHINGELSETOOBSCURETHE
BUILDINGINMIDTOWN-ANHATTAN IMITATIONMEANS VISIONOFTHEPILOTS)INTERPRETEDITASJUSTDOING

464(966-.(9+,5 
0U[OLSH[L ZHUKLHYS` Z[OLYVSLVMJHTV\MSHNLPU
KLMLUZL^HZKPZJ\ZZLKPU]HYPV\ZHYJOP[LJ[\YLTHNHaPULZ

*(46<-3(.,ŒHLZ[OL[PJZHUK[LJOUPX\LŽ
(YJOP[LJ[\YHS9L]PL^]VS :LW[LTILY 

0UK\Z[YPHS7SHU[7YV[LJ[PVUŽ
(YJOP[LJ[\YHS-VY\T]VS(\N\Z[ 

0UK\Z[YPHS7SHU[7YV[LJ[PVUŽ
(YJOP[LJ[\YHS-VY\T]VS(\N\Z[ 

;OL*HTV\MSL\YHUK/PZ*YHM[Ž
;OL)\PSKLY]VS6J[VILY  

*HTV\MSHNLKLZPNUJVUJLW[HS[LYUH[P]LZMVY[OLYVVMNHYKLU

0TP[H[PVU

+LJLW[PVU

+LJV`

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 *VUM\ZPVU
0TP[H[PVUŽJHTV\MSHNLZ[\K` +LJLW[PVUŽJHTV\MSHNLZ[\K`

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
)SHJRWLIISLZ
)SHJRWLIISLZ >OP[LWLIISLZ
>OP[LWLIISLZ *Y\ZOLKNSHZZ
7SHU[Z 7SHU[Z

+LJV`ŽJHTV\MSHNLZ[\K` *VUM\ZPVUŽJHTV\MSHNLZ[\K`

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
3,-;!*HTV\MSHNLTH[LYPHSZPUP[PHSWHSL[[L
90./;!*VTWHYPZVUVMHS[LYUH[LJHTV\MSHNLZ[\KPLZ

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
3,-;!:LSLJ[LKKLZPNU!KLJLW[PVUŽ
90./;!*HTV\MSHNLTH[LYPHSZPUP[PHSWHSL[[L

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
)SHJRYLJ`JSLKY\IILY >OP[LWLIISLZ *Y\ZOLKNSHZZ -VHTOLHKLY -PILYNSHZZNYH[PUN :OY\IHZZLTIS` )SHJRHY[PMPJPHSYVJR >OP[LHY[PMPJPHSYVJR

*HTV\MSHNLTH[LYPHSZMPUHSWHSL[[L

SOMETHINGSOSTRANGEANDFAROUTTHATITWOULDNT ASPECTSOFTHEDESIGN)CHOSEMATERIALSTHATWERE
BECLEARWHATTHEHELLITWAS4HISSCHEMEHAD ARTIlCIALANDICONIC
GREATBIGDAISYSHAPESmOATINGONTHEROOFLIKE
MUTANTGIANTLILYPADS *!4HECLIENTSELLWASMORESUCCESSFULTHE
SECONDTIMEAROUNDˆWHY
*!4HERESEEMSTOBEACONSISTENTUSEOFFAUX
PLANTS ROCKS ANDPAVINGTEXTURESTHATIGNORES +3)CREATEDGRAPHICSANDAQUARTER SCALEMODEL
THEPHENOMENOLOGICALPOTENTIALANDINHERENT OFEACHSCHEMELATERTHESEWEREONDISPLAYINA
MUTABILITYOFLANDSCAPEMEDIAˆCHARACTERISTICS SMALLEXHIBITIONATTHE(ARVARD'RADUATE3CHOOL
THATCOULDPLAYINTOIDEASOFDECEPTION CON OF$ESIGN ANDPRESENTEDTHEMTOTHEMUSEUM)
FUSION ANDSOON(OWDOESINVESTIGATIONOF METWITH4ERENCE2ILEY 0ETER2EED 'LENN,OWRY
MATERIALITYENTERINTOTHESESCHEMES ANDOTHERSANDWEAGREEDTHATWEWOULDTAKETWO
OFTHESCHEMESTOTHECO OPBOARDTOPRESENTTHE
+34HEMATERIALSHAVESHIFTEDALITTLEBITBUTBASI RECTILINEARONEANDTHECURVILINEARONEˆIMITATION
CALLYALLFOUROFTHESCHEMES)PRESENTEDINVOLVED ANDDECEPTION
ARTIlCIALROCKS ARTIlCIALSHRUBS ANDTHREECOLORS )PUSHEDFORTHOSETWO ALTHOUGH)ALSOLIKED
OFGROUNDMATERIALWHITE BLACK ANDCRUSHED THECONFUSIONSCHEME"UT)THOUGHTTHATTHE
GLASS 4HEPALETTEREMAINEDCONSISTENTINTHEFOUR IMITATIONANDDECEPTIONAPPROACHESWERETHE
SCHEMES!LTHOUGHTHEDESIGNWASMOREABOUTTHE MOSTTRUETOTHEIDEAOFCAMOUmAGETHATWEWERE
FORMANDCONTENTTHANMATERIALITY THEMATERIALS DEVELOPING)WASLEANINGTOWARDTHECURVILINEAR
DOHAVECONTENT ANDTOEMPHASIZETHESIMULATION SCHEME ALTHOUGHDURINGOURMEETINGWITH-O-!

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
THEREWERECONCERNSABOUTTHECURVILINEARDESIGN ARTICULATEDGROUNDPLANEMOREOFACHALLENGETO
BEINGDIFlCULTTOBUILD4HERECTILINEARONEWOULD PREVAILINGSITEAESTHETICS
BESIMPLERTOCONSTRUCT ANDEVERYONETHOUGHTIT
MIGHTALSOBEMOREPALATABLETOTHEBOARDMEM +3)THASAWHOLESERIESOFLEVELSTHATAREINTEREST
BERSOFTHERESIDENTIALCO OPBECAUSEITSINHERENTLY INGBECAUSESOMUCHOFLANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREIS
MORECONSERVATIVE0EOPLEUNDERSTANDMINIMALIST UNCRITICALLYINVOLVEDINCAMOUmAGING7EREA
GEOMETRY ANDCERTAINLYITWASMOREINKEEPING PROFESSIONOFSHRUBBINGTHINGSUP COVERINGUP
WITHTHE4ANIGUCHIBUILDING"UTTHATWASEXACTLY MISTAKES HIDINGANDSMOOTHINGTHINGS AND
WHY)PREFERREDTHECURVILINEARSCHEME)THOUGHT CONTEXTUALIZINGTHEM5SUALLY THECAMOUmAGING
THATITWASMOREINTERESTINGLYSUBVERSIVEABOUT EFFORTSWITHINTHEPROFESSIONAREINVISIBLE4HIS
CAMOUmAGEBECAUSEITPLAYSAREVERSEGAMEOF SCHEMEACKNOWLEDGESTHEISSUEOFCAMOUmAGE
DECEPTIONRATHERTHANSIMPLEIMITATION ANDUSESITCRITICALLYASAVISIBLEELEMENT"UTNOT
EVERYONEWANTSTOHEARABOUTTHAT
*!-ANYCRITICSCOMPLAINTHATTHECURVILINEAR )STARTEDTHEPRESENTATIONTOTHECO OPBOARD
ISADEFAULTPARTI ALIMITING PLANIMETRICINTER BYTALKINGABOUTTHEROOFASAKINDOF*APANESE
PRETATIONOFAROMANTIC PASTORALLEGACY"UT GARDEN0ARTOFTHEPROGRAMSTATEDTHATWE
REALLYSINCETHESWEVEENDUREDAREGIMEOF COULDNTHAVEANYLIVEPLANTS WECOULDNTHAVE
MINIMALISTGEOMETRIESANDAGGRESSIVEFORMALISM ANYIRRIGATION WECOULDNTHAVEANYSUBSTANTIAL
THATOVERLOOKSTHElGURALPOWEROFSITE SPECIlC WEIGHT WECOULDNTHAVEANYPHYSICALATTACH
CONTINUOUSTOPOLOGIES(OWISTHECURVILINEAR MENTS4HEREWEREALSOISSUESOFALIMITEDBUDGET
SCHEMEANDITSIMPLICATIONOFATWO DIMENSIONAL ANDLITTLEORNOMAINTENANCE"ASICALLY THINGS

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
4VKLSZVM[OLMV\YKLZPNUZ[\K`HS[LYUH[P]LZ!
KLJLW[PVUKLJV`PTP[H[PVUJVUM\ZPVU

VWWVZP[L!
+LJLW[PVU

9<5505./,(+: 
3,-;!4VKLSVMKLJLW[PVUJHTV\MSHNLKLZPNU
90./;!;OLJHTV\MSHNLWH[[LYUZ^LYLPUP[PHSS`[YHJLKMYVTH
WHPYVMOPWOVWWHU[Z

 464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
;OLYVVMNHYKLUPUTPKJVUZ[Y\J[PVU1HU\HY`

HADTOBELIGHTWEIGHTANDSETINPLACE)TWAS ANDTHERE,IVEPLANTSWOULDHAVEDIFlCULTYSURVIV
INHERENTLYADRYGARDEN SIMILARTOTHE*APANESE INGINTHEGARDENBECAUSEOFLIMITEDMAINTENANCE
:ENGARDEN WHICHISANABSTRACTIONOFNATUREIN LIMITEDSOIL ANDTHEENVIRONMENTALCONDITIONS
SOMEWAY)CONTINUEDBYTALKINGABOUTTHETWO
SCHEMESTHATWEWEREGOINGTOPRESENT ARECTILIN *!4HESCHEMECHANGEDSOMEBETWEENTHAT
EARGEOMETRYANDACURVILINEARGEOMETRY SHOWING MEETING WHEREYOUPRESENTEDTHEINITIALCON
THEMTHEGARDENSONTOPOF2OCKEFELLER#ENTERAS CEPT ANDTHElNALINSTALLATION(OWDIDVALUE
ANEXAMPLEOFACLASSICALRECTILINEARGEOMETRYGAR ENGINEERINGEFFECTSPECIlCCONSTRUCTIONDETAILS
DENAND.OGUCHISWORKAT5.%3#/IN0ARISASAN ORCHANGEYOURINTERPRETATIONOFDECEPTIONBY
EXAMPLEOFCURVILINEAR MODERNWORK4HEYLOVED DESIGN
IT4HEBIGGESTHURDLEWASTHESYNTHETICPALETTEOF
THEGARDEN +34HESHRUBMASSESAREMADEOFlBERGLASSGRAT
)HADBUILTASMALLMOCK UPONTHEROOFTOP ING ANDTHEBASESARECOMPUTER NUMERICALLYCUT
WHICHEVERYONECOULDLOOKDOWNAT3OINSTEADOF INTOPIECESTHATlTTOGETHERONTHEROOF)SPECI
BRINGINGANARTIlCIALSHRUBINTOTHEMEETING THE lED06#PIPESTHATGOINTO06#mANGESWHICHARE
MATERIALSWEREJUDGEDFROMADISTANCEOFFORTYOR BOLTEDTOTHElBERGLASSGRATINGTOPROVIDESTEMS
lFTYFEET THEACTUALVIEWINGDISTANCE&ROMTHAT FORTHESHRUBS4HESEASSEMBLIESAREHEAVYENOUGH
PERSPECTIVE YOUACTUALLYCANTTELLTHEDIFFERENCE THATTHEYCANJUSTRESTONTHEROOF/RIGINALLY )
BETWEENANARTIlCIALBOXWOODANDAREALONE AND HADPLANNEDTOPLACETHESHRUBSATADISTANCEOF
INFACT THREEYEARSOUT THEARTIlCIALBOXWOODSARE TWENTY FOURINCHESFROMEACHOTHER BUTTHISWAS
GOINGTOLOOKBETTERTHANADEADBOXWOODHERE EVENTUALLYADJUSTEDTOTHIRTYORTHIRTY SIXINCHES

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
 9<5505./,(+:
+L[HPSZOV^PUNHY[PMPJPHSYVJRZ

6WWVZP[L!(LYPHS]PL^VMUVY[OHUKZV\[OYVVMZ

TOSAVEMONEYˆIRONICALLYTHEARTIlCIALBOXWOOD NATURALMATERIAL ALTHOUGHITCOULDBECALLEDINTO


PLANTSWEREMOREEXPENSIVETHANLIVEPLANTS4HIS QUESTIONWHETHERTHISMATERIALISACTUALLYNATURAL
ADJUSTMENTSAVED  BUTASTUDYALSOSHOWED ORNOTATTHISPOINT4HEBLUESURFACEISCRUSHED
THATTHENEWSPACINGACTUALLYWORKEDBETTER)NA GLASS WHICHCOULDALSOBECONSIDEREDANATURAL
REALLANDSCAPEWITHREALPLANTSYOUWOULDWANT MATERIAL)TALSOCALLSINTOQUESTIONWHATSAUTHEN
THESHRUBSTOBEPLACEDCLOSETOEACHOTHER SOTHAT TICANDWHATSSIMULATED
THEYCANGROWTOGETHERASAMASS BUTHERE HAV 3OMEOFTHECHANGES)MADETOTHEORIGINAL
INGTHESHRUBSREADASINDIVIDUALELEMENTSWORKED SCHEMEHAPPENEDTOCUTCOSTS&OREXAMPLE THE
BECAUSEITMADETHEDESIGNMORESYNTHETIC HEADERSWEREGOINGTOBEBRICKINORDERTORELATETO
4HEARTIlCIALROCKS)USEDAREABRANDTHAT THEHISTORICCONTEXTBYCHOOSINGTHESAMEMATERIAL
PEOPLEINTHESUBURBSUSETOHIDETHEIRUTILITIES 0HILIP*OHNSONUSED BUTINSTEAD)ENDEDUPUSING
"ASICALLYTHEYRECAMOUmAGINGELEMENTSINTHE #.# MILLEDSTRUCTURAL3TYROFOAM)NHISTORICPRES
LANDSCAPE!CROSSTHEROOFTOP)LAIDASERIESOFRUN ERVATIONWORKALOTOFDETAILING SUCHASCORNICES
NERSTOWHICHTHEROCKSWEREBOLTED0LACEDOVER ISMADEOUTOFTHISMATERIAL USUALLYWITHAlNISH
THERUNNERSISATHINLAYEROFGROUNDCOVER4HE THATLOOKSLIKELIMESTONEORANOTHERSTONE(EREIT
BLACKGROUNDCOVERWASORIGINALLY-EXICANBLACK ISTREATEDWITHASPRAY ONHARDENINGSURFACETHATS
PEBBLESBECAUSETHATWASWHAT4ANIGUCHISOFlCE REALLYSTRONGANDPAINTEDTHECOLOROFBRICK!LL
HADSPECIlED BUTTOSAVEMONEY)DECIDEDTOUSE THESHAPESINTHECURVILINEARPLANARETRANSLATED
GROUNDTIRESˆRECYCLEDRUBBER AMATERIALRECOM ARCS TANGENTS ANDSTRAIGHTLINESTAKENFROMA
MENDEDBYTHELANDSCAPECONTRACTOR4HEWHITE CAMOUmAGEPATTERNTHATWASTRACEDFROMAPAIROF
SURFACE MADEOFCRUSHEDWHITESTONE ISTHEONLY HIP HOP SKATE BOARDERPANTS)WANTEDTOMAKETHE

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
9VVMNHYKLUSH`V\[JVUZ[Y\J[PVUKVJ\TLU[Z

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
9VVMNHYKLUTH[LYPHSZWSHUJVUZ[Y\J[PVUKVJ\TLU[Z

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+: 
4VU[HNLVMMPUHSKLZPNU

 464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
5VY[ONHYKLU 9HPZLKHYLHH[UVY[ONHYKLU

:V\[ONHYKLU 9HPZLKHYLHH[ZV\[ONHYKLU

(YLHVMYLX\PYLKTVJR\W

*VTWVZP[LWSHUZOV^PUNUVY[OHUKZV\[OYVVMZ

9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
:V\[OYVVM]PL^MYVT>LZ[YK:[YLL[

 464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5 
4VJR\WVMYVVMNHYKLUSH`V\[1HU\HY`

CAMOUmAGEALITTLEMORESYNTHETICSO)REDUCEDTHE DOWN MADETHEPROJECTCONCEPTUALLYSTRONGER4HE


PATTERNTOAKINDOFROADWAYENGINEERING4HERE WHOLEPROCESSOFBEINGFORCEDTOGOBACKTOTHE
ARETHREEDIFFERENTCURVERADIIANDTHREEDIFFERENT CLIENTWITHACOMPLETELYNEWIDEAAFTERTHElRST
LINE SEGMENTANDINTERSECTIONCONDITIONS4OTRANS DESIGNWASREJECTEDANDWORKTHROUGHTHEISSUES
FERTHEPATTERNONTOTHEROOF ITWASDIVIDEDINTOA OFTHEREJECTEDPROPOSALRESULTEDINABETTERDESIGN
SERIESOFSIMPLEUNITS WHICHWEREFACTORY CUTFROM CONCEPT!NDWHILE)MNOTABIGFANOFVALUE
STANDARDSHEETSIZESINTOAPALETTEOFPARTS NUM ENGINEERING INTHISCASEITCLARIlEDTHEMATERIAL
BEREDATTHEFACTORY PUTTOGETHERONSITE AND PALETTEANDMADETHEPROJECTSTRONGERCONCEPTUALLY
GLUEDDOWN ANDMATERIALLY
!S)WASCONCERNEDABOUTTHEINTEGRITYOFTHE
CURVILINEARFORMS MYOFlCESTAFFAND)MOCKEDUP *!)NRETROSPECT WHATGOTSACRIlCEDWHENYOU
ABOUTAlFTHOFTHEAREAONONESIDEOFTHEROOF LETGOOFTHElRSTPROPOSAL THESPINNINGDAISIES
WITHCHALKANDSTRINGLINES)NHALFADAYWELAID
OUTTHEGEOMETRYOFONESUBSTANTIALAREAOFTHE +34HE-O-!TEAMLOVEDTHElRSTSCHEME4ERRY
DESIGNSOWECOULDSEEHOWTHEFORMSlTANDGET 2ILEYLIKEDITBECAUSEITUSEDANICONICELEMENT
ASENSEOFTHESCALE7ELOOKEDDOWNATITFROM TAKENOUTOFCONTEXT0ETER2EEDLIKEDITBECAUSE
THETOWER WHICHWASKINDOFREASSURING7EALSO ITHOVEREDBETWEENPOPARTANDMINIMALISM
DISCOVEREDWEHADSOMEDIMENSIONINGISSUESIN 7HEN0ETERTALKSABOUTLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURE
THEROOFTOPLAYOUT WHICHNEEDEDTOBECORRECTED HISAPPROACHISTOSPEAKABOUTLANDSCAPEDESIGN
4HESELITTLEADJUSTMENTS ANDINSOMEWAYSALSO RELATIVETOTHETUGBETWEENSURREALISMANDCUBISM
THETHINGSWEHADTODOTOBRINGTHEBUDGET )DONTKNOWIFTHOSEQUITETRANSLATETOPOPARTAND

 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
MINIMALISMBUT0ETERTHOUGHTITWASINTERESTING :V\[OYVVM]PL^MYVT*):)\PSKPUN

THATONONELEVELTHESCHEMEWASPOPBECAUSE
YOUVEGOTTHEICONICDAISY THEFOUNDOBJECT
!NDONANOTHERLEVEL THEDESIGNWASPURELYMINI
MALISTASTHEBIGBLOCKSOFCOLORMADEUPAMINI
MALCOLORlELDTHATUNDERLIESTHEOPERATIVELEVELOF
THESPINNINGANDTURNINGOBJECTSINTHEWIND"UT
INTHEEND )THINKTHEDECEPTIONCAMOUmAGEGAR
DENHOVERSINTHESAMEWAY INTHISCASEBETWEENA
KINDOFUTILITARIANINDUSTRIAL DESIGNAPPROPRIATION
STRATEGYAND*APANESEGARDENABSTRACTION

464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+: 
 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+: 
 464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
 9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+: 
9<5505./,(+: 
 464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+:
464(966-.(9+,5
9<5505./,(+: 
 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
 *65=,9:(;065:
%AST2IVER&ERRY
,ANDINGS
.EW9ORK .EW9ORK

)NTHECITYOF.EW9ORKSELECTEDlVEDESIGNlRMS PRACTICESWEREONTHELIST)WASTHEONLYLANDSCAPE
TOSUBMITPROPOSALSFORTHE%AST2IVERWATERFRONT ARCHITECT)KNEW&RANO6IOLICHAND3HEILA+ENNEDY
ALONGSIDETHESIXFERRYLANDINGSINCLUDING4HIRTY FOURTH FROMTEACHINGATTHE(ARVARD'RADUATE3CHOOLOF
3TREETIN-IDTOWN4HEAREAOFINTERVENTIONWASA $ESIGN ANDONEDAY&RANOCALLEDMEUPTOASK
NINETY FOOT LONGSTRIPOFSEAWALLANDATWENTY FOOT WHETHER)WASINTERESTEDINJOININGFORCES)REALLY
WIDERIGHTOFWAYOWNEDBYTHECITY4HEPROGRAMWAS RESPECTEDTHEIRWORK3OWEBECAMEACOLLABORATIVE
TOCREATEAPEDESTRIANENVIRONMENTTHATWOULDEXTEND TEAMANDBASICALLYPICKEDOFFTHECOMPETITIONTHAT
EXISTINGRIVERSIDECIRCULATIONTHROUGHTHESITE)NRELA WAY+ENNEDY6IOLICHSDESIGNSFORBUILDINGSAND
TIONTOABRIDGEDWALKWAYDESIGNEDBYARCHITECTS3HEILA STRUCTURESAREBASEDONAKINDOFSYSTEMSAPPROACH
+ENNEDYAND&RANO6IOLICH +EN3MITHDEVELOPEDAN THEYTHINKABOUTOCCUPYINGSURFACESINTERMSOF
URBANECOLOGICALSYSTEMTHATREVIVESATAVISTICPLANT MOVEMENT)NTHEIRSCHEMEFORTHEPROJECTTHERE
INGSˆGRASSESTHATONCEPROSPEREDALONGTHESLOPED ISASYSTEMOFFURNISHINGSˆALLUTILIZABLEINSOME
BANKSOFTHERIVERˆWITHINACONSTRUCTEDNATUREOF WAYˆTHATMOVETHROUGHTHESITEANDASYSTEMOF
FOLDED UNMISTAKABLYCONTEMPORARYPLANTERS CANOPIES WHICHPROVIDEPROTECTION)NRESPONSE )
STARTEDTOTHINKABOUTTHELANDSCAPEASASYSTEM AS
*!$ESCRIBEHOWYOUGOTINVOLVEDWITHTHIS ANECOLOGICALSYSTEMCONSISTINGOFINDIVIDUALPLANT
PROJECT ERSTHATMIGHTRECLAIMTHERIPARIANEDGEOFTHERIVER
+ENNEDYAND6IOLICHWEREGREATTOWORKWITH
+34HECITYPICKEDlVElRMSTHATWEREINVITEDTO 4HEYNEVERONCESAID h.O YOUSHOULDBEDOING
SUBMITPROPOSALS"ESIDESME THEARCHITECTURALlRM ITTHISWAYv7EBASICALLYDEVELOPEDOUROWN
+ENNEDY6IOLICHANDTHREEOTHERARCHITECTURAL IDEASINACOMMONVOCABULARYANDPROGRAM4HE


3(%,4%2

/0%.$%#+'2!4).'

3/,)$0)%2$%#+).'

2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3
/.3425#452%

0)%23425#452%/0%.4/7!4%2
/0%.4/7!4%2 &%229
2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%

0UP[PHSJVUJLW[Z[\KPLZMVY[OL,HZ[9P]LY-LYY`3HUKPUNZ^LYL
IHZLKVUHZL[VMWSHU[LYZ[OH[JHYYPLKPU[V[OL^H[LY

 ,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'37)4(0(/4/6/,4!)#0!.%,3

2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%

/0%.$%#+'2!4).'

#/6%2%$7!,+7!9

0UP[PHSJVUJLW[Z[\K`

SUBSTRUCTUREWASDESIGNEDBYENGINEERS SOWEBOTH ANDENVIRONMENTALISSUES"UTWHILEWECANGET


RESPONDEDTOASTRUCTURALARMATURE WITH+ENNEDY PERMITSTOBUILDPLATFORMSFORPEOPLETOWALKON
6IOLICHSBUILDINGSOFTENTIMESSITTINGONPIERS ANDFORBOATSTOTIEUPTO THERIPARIANPLANTINGS
4HEYWEREWORKINGWITHASERIESOFORGANICFORMS WHICHACTUALLYDOSOMEGOODINTERMSOFVISIBILITY
ONTHEIRROOFSTRUCTURES4HESEAREFOLDEDSURFACES ANDCOMMUNICATETHEIMPORTANCEANDLOSSOF
ANDWHILEMYOWNFOLDEDFORMSAREMUCHMORE THERIPARIANENVIRONMENT ARETHEPIECESTHATARE
ANGULARTHANTHEIRS THECOMBINEDDESIGNRESULTSIN GETTINGMOSTCRITIQUED)TSVERYFRUSTRATING7ESTILL
ADIALOGUEOFFOLDEDORWARPEDFORMS DONTHAVEALLTHEAPPROVALSNECESSARYTOCONSTRUCT
THEMARSHPLANTERS ANDTHISPARTOFTHEPROJECTIS
*!4HISHIGH PROlLEPROJECTHASSOMEREALLIMI INDANGEROFBEINGDELETED)TJUSTBREAKSMYHEART
TATIONSINTERMSOFWHATYOU ASTHELANDSCAPE )STARTEDWORKONTHISPROJECTINWITH
ARCHITECT CANACHIEVE$ESCRIBETHESITEISSUES SOMEVERYSIMPLE0HOTOSHOPSTUDIES!TTHEBEGIN
YOUAREDEALINGWITH NINGTHEREWASASETOFFORMSTHATCARRIEDINTOTHE
WATER!STHEPROJECTMOVEDFORWARD MYSTAFFDIDA
+34HEPROJECTUNDERWENTSEVEREVALUEENGINEERING LOTOFRESEARCHONSOILS DRAINAGE ANDOTHERASPECTS
INWHICHALOTOFMYDESIGNWASCUT7EALSOHAD OFRIVERECOSYSTEMS4HESTRUCTUREEVOLVEDFROMAN
SOMEDIFlCULTYGETTINGENVIRONMENTALAPPROVAL ORIGINALDESIGNOFSLOPEDPLANTERSMADEOFWOOD
)lNDITIRONICTHATTHERIPARIANMARSHPLANTERS PILESEXPECTINGWEWOULDHAVEPIERCONSTRUCTION
WHICHDOTHEMOSTENVIRONMENTALGOOD ARESODIFl WITHWOODPILES TOONEOFSTEEL( PILESONCETHE
CULTTOGETAPPROVED)TISTHEPARTOFMYPROJECTTHAT ENGINEERDECIDEDTHATSTEELMADETHEMOSTSENSE
MOSTSPEAKSTOTHELOSSOFTHENATURALRIPARIANEDGE STRUCTURALLYANDECONOMICALLY

,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
3%!7!,,3%,)-).!4%32)0!2)!.6%'%4!4)/.!44(%2)6%2g3%$'%

()'( 4)$%

).!.!452!,4)$!,2)6%24()37/5,$"%!.%.6)2/.-%.4!,,9
2)#(6%'%4!4)/.:/.%7()#()3!"3%.4).4(%%!342)6%2%$'%
"%#!53%/&4(%3%!7!,,

,/7 4)$%

-5$ &,//2

)LMVYL[OLKLZPNU^HZWYLZLU[LK[V[OLJSPLU[2:3(
JVSSLJ[LKPUMVYTH[PVUVUZVPSZKYHPUHNLHUKV[OLYHZWLJ[Z
VMYP]LYLJVZ`Z[LTZ[OH[WLY[HPULK[V[OL,HZ[9P]LYZP[L

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
50,!.$ ()'(-!23( ,/7-!23( ).4%24)$!,:/.%

0UP[PHSJVUJLW[Z[\KPLZ

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%
5PPER-ARSH (IGHTIDE0LANT!SSOCIATIONWITHTOPOGRAPHICVARIATION

7).$-),,4)$%7!4%2)22)'!4)/.3934%-
2IVER7ATERFOR3ALT7ATER0LANTS
3TORED2AIN7ATERFROM2OOFAND0AVING2UNOFFFOR&RESH7ATER0LANTS

0!2+02/-%.!$%

&%2290)%2

/0%.$%#+'2!4).'!.$0,!.4$%42)453:/.% &,/!4).'$/#+

;OLWSHU[LKIV_LZOH]LLSL]H[LKHUKSV^HYLHZTPTPJRPUNH
UH[\YHSYP]LYZSVWL(UHY[PMPJPHSPYYPNH[PVUZ`Z[LTW\TWZYP]LY
^H[LYPU[V[OLIV_LZ

VWWVZP[L!
4VU[HNLVMPUP[PHSKLZPNUZ[\K`

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
*!4HEWARPEDRECTANGULARFORMHASSOMETHING CURRENTSWOULDJUSTSCOURTHEMAWAY4HEPLANTERS
INCOMMONWITHTHEPLEATINGOFTHE(IRIYA AREACTUALLYNECESSARYTOPROTECTTHEGRASS)NTHE
LANDlLLPROJECT ALTHOUGHTHESCALESAREVASTLY GIVENSPACETHEREWASNTENOUGHROOMTOCREATEA
DIFFERENT TRUEGRADATEDSLOPETHATWOULDSUPPORTTHERANGE
OFLOWMARSH HIGHMARSH ANDUPLANDBORDER
+39ES THISSIMILARITYREmECTSMYMOVETOWARD )NSTEAD ASASCULPTURALNOTION )DEVELOPEDAFOLD
VERTICALGREENANDFOLDINGFORMS#REATINGATOPOG INGSTRUCTURETHATHASELEVATEDAREASANDLOWER
RAPHYWASIMPORTANTTOMEBECAUSETHEPROJECT ONES!NIRRIGATIONSYSTEMPUMPSRIVERWATERINTO
WASABOUTREPAIRINGANEDGE ANDTHERIPARIANEDGE THEPLANTEDBOXES AKINDOFARTIlCIALTIDE WHICH
ISINHERENTLYAGRADEDSLOPE)NTHE%AST2IVER THE RESULTSINADIFFERENTIATIONOFPLANTSELECTIONSORTING
TIDALmUCTUATIONISABOUTSIXFEETBETWEENHIGHAND ITSELFOUTWITHINTHEPLANTERS.ECESSARILY THELOWER
LOWTIDE)NANATURALCONDITIONTHERIVERSGRADATED AREAS WHEREMOREMOISTUREGATHERS HAVEAGREATER
SLOPEDISSIPATESTHEENERGYOFTHERIVERSMOVEMENT POPULATIONOFMUSSELSANDTHINGSLIKETHAT!THIGH
ALLOWINGTIDALPLANTCOMMUNITIESOFPRIMARILYSPAR TIDETHESEAREASWILLGETmOODED
TINAGRASSTOTHRIVE4HEECOLOGYOFTHE%AST2IVER
HASBEENALTEREDTHROUGHLANDlLLINGANDCONSTRUC *!4HEPLANTINGBOXESMAKEWHATUSEDTOBE
TIONOFSEAWALLS ANDTODAYSCURRENTSWOULDNOT ANATURALCONDITIONˆVEGETATEDSHORELINEˆPOS
ALLOWTHESETYPESOFCOMMUNITIESTOEXISTWITHOUT SIBLEAGAIN BUTINAMANNERTHATREmECTSTHE
SOMEKINDOFPROTECTIVESTRUCTURE3IMPLYPLANT ENGINEEREDCONDITION)STHERESOMEINHERENT
INGSPARTINAGRASSINASLOPEONTHERIVERWOULDNT WRONG DOINGINTHIS4HEFRESHWATERIRRIGATION
WORKINTHISALTEREDENVIRONMENTBECAUSETHERIVER NEEDEDFORTHESPARTINAGRASSESANDFOREIGN

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
0)%2$%#+).'

/0%.7!4%2

7).$-),,4)$%7!4%2)22)'!4)/.3934%-
HOURINNUDATIONFORLOWMARSH
WEEKINNUDATIONFORHIGHMARSH

2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%
5PPERAND,OWER4IDAL-ARSH0LANT!SSOCIATIONS
WITHTOPOGRAPHICVARIATIONS

(Z[OLTHYZOWSHU[LYZ^LYLKL]LSVWLKPUYLZWVUZL[V[OL
YP]LYJVUKP[PVUZPUZ[LHKVMILPUNZ\ITLYNLK^OLYLZ[YVUN
J\YYLU[Z^V\SKKHTHNL[OLWSHU[PUNZ[OL`^LYLYHPZLK
ZSPNO[S`HIV]LOPNO[PKL

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
7).$-),,4)$%7!4%2)22)'!4)/.
2IVER7ATERFOR3ALT7ATER0LANTS
3TORED2AIN7ATERFROM2OOFAND0AVING
2UNOFFFOR&RESH7ATER0LANTS

2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%
5PPERAND,OWER4IDAL-ARSH0LANT!SSOCIATIONS
WITHTOPOGRAPHICVARIATIONS

50,!.$"/2$%20,!.4).'3/."5,+(%!$!2%!
,OWAND4ALL5PLAND"ORDER0LANT!SSOCIATIONS
WITHTOPOGRAPHICVARIATIONS

:[\K`MVYTHYZOWSHU[LYZH[:[YLL[

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
0!6%-%.4490%! 0!6%-%.4490%" "%.#(%3

,/72)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3
5PLAND"ORDER#OMMUNITY
4/0/'2!0()#6!2)!4)/.!40,!.4).'3
#ATTAILS
2USHES
3WITCH'RASS 3(544,%"53452.!2/5.$
4!,,2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3
"UTTON"USH
5PLAND"ORDER#OMMUNITY
%LDERBERRY
*UNIPER
7ILD&LOWERS
!LDER
-ARSH-ARIGOLDS
-ARSH%LDER
'OLDENROD
2OSE-ALLOW
!STER ETC

:[\K`MVYTHYZOWSHU[LYZH[[O:[YLL[

 ,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
/0%.$%#+'2!4).'

3/,)$0)%2$%#+).'

&,/!4).'$/#+'%4$/7.!2%!

7).$-),,4)$%7!4%2)22)'!4)/.3934%-

2)0!2)!.0,!.4).'3/.3425#452%WITHTOPOGRAPHICVARIATION
5PPER-ARSH (IGH4IDE0LANT!SSOCIATION 4WICE-ONTH)NNUNDATION
3PARTINA#ORDGRASS
*UNCUS"LACK'RASS
$ISTICHLIS$ITCH'RASS
3ALICORNIA'LASSWORT
,IMONIUM3EA,AVENDAR
!STER3ALT-ARSH!STER
3OLIDAGO3EA3IDE'OLDENROD

;67!:LJVUKWHZZKLZPNUZ[\K`MVYTHYZO
WSHU[LYZH[ [O:[YLL[
)6;;64!4VKLSVMPUP[PHSKLZPNUZ[\K`

V]LYSLHM!
4VU[HNLVMZLJVUKWHZZKLZPNUZ[\K`

*65=,9:(;065: 
 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
 9<5505./,(+:
VWWVZP[L!
4VKLSVMZLJVUKWHZZKLZPNUZ[\K`

FORTIlEDPLANTINGSOILSWILLENTERINTOTHERIVER PLANTERBOXESAREDESIGNEDTORECEIVEONLYLIMITED
SYSTEM ANDONECOULDIMAGINE IFTHIS TIDALmUSHING INORDERTOPROTECTTHEPLANTINGS
PROJECTSERVEDASAMODELFORMILESOFSHORELINE FROMTHEDAMAGEOFSTRONGCURRENTS3UPPLEMENTAL
THERIVERWATERSNUTRIENTBALANCEWOULDBE WATERISPUMPEDFROMTHERIVERANDDISTRIBUTED
DISTURBED THROUGHASYSTEMOFOPENTROUGHSANDSPOUTSTO
PROVIDEANARTIlCIALTIDALINmUXOFBRACKISHWATER
+37ELL THISPROJECTISINTENDEDFORASTRETCHOF ANDNUTRIENTS4HEREISALSOANAUXILIARYBACK UP
RIVERTHATISALREADYIRREPARABLYOUTOFBALANCE SYSTEMOFFRESHWATERINCASETHEREISAPROBLEM
)TADDRESSESTHEISSUEOFHOWWERESPONDTOAN WITHTHEBRACKISHWATERSYSTEM)DESIGNEDTHE
ALTEREDRIPARIANENVIRONMENTANDHOWWECAN LATTERTOBEAVISIBLECOMPONENTOFTHEPLANTERS
CREATEANAWARENESSOFTHEPROBLEM"ECAUSEOF )TSPARTOFOURATTEMPTTOEXPOSETHESTRUCTUREOF
THERIVERSBULKHEADWALLSANDALTEREDCURRENTS IT WHATWECREATED TOREVEALTHESYSTEMSTHATPROPA
ISIMPOSSIBLETOGROWARIPARIANMARSHINNATU GATEANDSUSTAINTHEPLANTS)WANTEDTOSHOWTHE
RALCONDITIONSHERE SO)RESORTEDTODESIGNINGA MECHANICSANDTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHEMATERIALS
PLANTERSYSTEMTHATWOULDALLOWBRINGINGBACKTHE ANDSYSTEMS SOTHEYBECOMEANACCESSIBLEPARTOF
3PARTINACOMMUNITYUNDERCONTROLLEDANDPROTECT UNDERSTANDINGTHELANDSCAPE)MNOTINTERESTEDIN
EDCONDITIONS4HEPLANTERBOXISAVERYPRACTICAL COVERINGUPANDDENYINGTHESETHINGS
SOLUTION BUTTOMAKEITWORKINTHEALTEREDECOL
OGYOFTHE%AST2IVERITISNECESSARYTOINTRODUCE *!$OYOUIDENTIFYTHISCONCERNWITHREVEALING
IRRIGATIONUSINGBOTHBRACKISHWATERANDABACK UP STRUCTUREANDFUNCTIONASAMODERNISTSTRAININ
SYSTEMOFFRESHWATERTOSUPPORTTHEPLANTINGS4HE YOURWORK

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
*VUZ[Y\J[PVUJVUJLW[VMZLJVUKWHZZKLZPNUZ[\K`

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
% $ " !    
' (+(&$$


&'+(&&&(#"
 ')$$ -""


' (+(&&&(#"
 ')$$ -""


' (+(&')$$&






$#!
 ; 
 

 ;

$#


  "
 

; ;  ; ;  D


 ;  ; ;  ;
D  D
 ;  D
 ;  D


; ;
D  ;
D 
D 
D 
D 






!&'$ "(&
 
D 

$ "

 &' &

 !!%*


'( $ '

 ""&+


'( &!'

 ""&+

D   

 ;



<

; 2(

!&'$ "(&')'(&)()&
 
D 
$ "

*VUZ[Y\J[PVUKVJ\TLU[Z

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
" !       

 #$%.()'*)*'

 (',(

)$%$,! ,."
E 


()'*)*'(##',(


E


"'(%!#)'

E

",
 "
",

"

" 




"!,"

#$!%#   >


$%  '$%

  






 
  

 

 
 
 

  

 #$%.()'*)*'

 (',(

)$%$,! ,."
E
E
E

",
 "
",

"



"!,"

#$)
$#'""#($#
$)$%$")$!#
#$!%#   > ,)
 "
&% 

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
%!#)',!!D
%'((*')'))"'

($!!#).%

F

()!%!

  (##'F(',#

!$$' #D
%'((*')'))"'
 
()!%!

  (##'F(',#

# 


%!#)',!!#$'(

()$#"'(%!#)'  F

!$$' # 

"# 

  "!>"!%

!
"#"& &  >
%!#)',!!
%# 

#!% <
!""$!#!##!

F












G



()'*)*'!'"

-$#$")'"'(%!#)'  F
 )!()!#$'  F

  %!# ()$#

*VUZ[Y\J[PVUKVJ\TLU[Z

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
#  






 
"#&$"""$ 
  #  

 

 
 
 

  

 
!#$&$"!%!
 $$  


!%!!$ "
#"&#   

&#!
"


 !'
  
#"$$=#"&#
#$!
!$ "$ 


!#$""
  

#"$$=#"&#


#$&$"""$ 



#$&$"#%!!"



"#!$"


 #%!! "$ #$"%$ 


 @6("
 #""&#

$ ! !"


E
E


E



E
"#&$"!! & 

#$&$"!!

$ !  $$ $
 $$  !$"#$
$


&  

 %

$"

+39ES"ASICALLYYOUHAVETHEFORMOFTHEFUNC ARTIlCIALITYOFTHERIVERENVIRONMENTTHATWEVE
TION"UT)MALSOINTERESTEDINTHEOVERLAPBETWEEN CREATEDINCONTEMPORARYCITIES"UT)THINKTHERE
STRUCTUREANDTHESYMBOLIC)FYOULOOKATTHE ISASENSEOFAWEANDWONDERINBEINGPLACEDIN
3EAGRAM"UILDING THECOLUMNSONTHEOUTSIDEDO ASITUATIONWHEREYOUREOVERANDSURROUNDEDBY
PROVIDETHENECESSARYSUPPORTFORTHECURTAINWALL WATERANDCLOSEUPTOAhPRIMORDIALvMARSHGRASS
BUTTHEYREALSOPURELYSYMBOLIC4HEUSEOFTHE) COMMUNITYˆYOUCANALMOSTTOUCHANDSMELLTHE
BEAMISBOTHADECORATIVEANDASTRUCTURALELEMENT MARSHANDHEARTHEGURGLINGOFTHEBIVALVES7HILE
ITSNOTATRUEMARSH OBVIOUSLY YOUDOGETASENSE
*!!TWHATMOMENTINTHE%AST2IVERPROJECT OFTHEVEGETATIONBETWEENYOUANDTHEOPENWATER
DOESPERCEPTIONSHIFTFROMAWARENESSOFTHE ANDTHISSTARTSTOSETUPTHEKINDOFEXPERIENCE
URBANCONDITIONˆTHEENGINEEREDRIVERWAY THE YOUWOULDHAVEINANATURALSITUATION4HENOTION
ARCHITECTURALPROMENADEˆTONOTICINGTHE OFURBANECOLOGYISENGAGEDBYTHECONTEMPORARY
VITALDETAILOFWATERCURRENT BARNACLECRUSTING CONDITIONOFTHEWATERSEDGE4HISEXPERIENCEIS
TIDALmUX ROOTEDINTHEPRAGMATICSOFTHEPLACEANDINWHAT
ITTAKESTOMAKETHISMATERIALSTRUCTURALLYSOUND
+34HEREARETENMARSHBOXES/NABRIDGENEXTTO 4HEDESIGNACCOMPLISHESTHISINASYMBOLICWAY
THEM DESIGNEDBY+ENNEDY6IOLICH ISAPUBLIC THATSPEAKSTOTHELOSSOFTHENATURALENVIRONMENT
WALKWAY ANDATBOTHENDSOFTHEWALKWAYISTHE ANDCREATESAPHENOMENALEXPERIENCE
SEAWALL7HENYOUREONTHEBRIDGE YOUREACTUALLY
INANDOVERTHEWATER YOUSEETHEWATERBETWEEN
THESEAWALLANDTHEBRIDGE SOYOUAREAWAREOFTHE

9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.: 
4VU[HNLVMMPUHSKLZPNU

VWWVZP[L!
4VKLSVMMPUHSKLZPNU

 9<5505./,(+:
,(:;90=,9-,99@3(5+05.:
9<5505./,(+: 
 9<5505./,(+:
03
1UEENS .EW9ORK

03ISAPRO BONODESIGNPROJECTCOMMISSIONEDBY ANDBIRDSANDTHEMOVABLEMINIDUMPSTERSUSEDFOR


THE2OBIN(OOD&OUNDATIONASPARTOFTHESUCCESSFUL TEACHINGANDEXPERIMENTALPLANTINGS
h,IBRARY)NITIATIVE vAPROGRAMTHATENGAGESLEADING
ARCHITECTSTOBUILDLIBRARIESINTHECITYSNEEDIESTNEIGH *!.OWTHATYOURSCHEMEFOR03HASBEENIN
BORHOODS)TISTHElRSTLANDSCAPEPROJECTSUPPORTEDBY PLACEFOROVERTWOYEARS WHATBIGGERISSUESHAVE
THEFOUNDATION+EN3MITHSSCHOOLYARDSCHEMEOFFERS EMERGEDFROMTHISPROJECTTOIMPACTYOUROTHER
ABALANCEOFPRAGMATISMANDPRIDE FEATURINGLOW COST WORK
FUNCTIONALANDKID ORIENTEDSOLUTIONSTOTYPICALCONDI
TIONSSUCHASBOUNDARYDElNITION EXCESSIVEASPHALT +303ISTHELARGESTELEMENTARYSCHOOLIN.EW
PAVING ANDTHENEEDFORPLAYSPACETOBEBALANCED 9ORK#ITY)NWECOMPLETEDTHEPROJECTˆWE
WITHOPPORTUNITIESFOROUTDOORLEARNING&IVEPROTOTYPE HADlNISHEDALLDESIGN COLLABORATEDWITHTHEFAB
ELEMENTSWEREDEVELOPEDANDTHENMODIlEDTOADDRESS RICATORSANDVOLUNTEERGROUPS INSTALLEDTHEPLANT
SPECIlCCHARACTERISTICSOFTHE03SITE)NPHASEONE INGS lNISHEDPAINTING ANDPUTUPTHECLOUDSCRIM
GRAPHICSWEREPAINTEDONTHEASPHALTPAVINGANDON 7EHADSETUPALLELEMENTSOFOURDESIGN BUTTHE
THEWALLSOFTHEhTEMPORARYvCLASSROOMSNOWTWENTY BIGUNKNOWNWASHOWTHESTUDENTSANDTEACHERS
YEARSOLD ,ATERACLOUDSCRIMWASSTRETCHEDACROSS WOULDACTUALLYUSETHELANDSCAPE&OREXAMPLE WE
THESCHOOLYARDSCHAINLINKFENCE RAISINGTHEEYETO WERENTSUREHOWTHELEARNINGGARDENS ASERIESOF
ANALWAYS BLUESKYPERIMETER!CURTAINEDSPACEFOR PLANTEDDUMPSTERS WOULDDEVELOPINTOMORETHAN
READINGWASPROPOSED ANDMODULARSEATINGMADEOUT JUSTSOMETHINGTHATWASINSTALLED4HERENEEDEDTO
OFSTANDARDPIPESEGMENTSWASFABRICATED4HETWOELE BESOMEMECHANISMTHATINTEGRATEDTHEGARDENAND
MENTSMOSTPOPULARARETHELINEARGARDENFORBUTTERmIES ITSPIECESINTOTHESCHOOLLIFE7HEN)VISITED03

9<5505./,(+: 
7OV[VNYHWOZVML_PZ[PUNJVUKP[PVUZH[7: HUKH[1HJRZVU
)V\SL]HYKIV[[VT

VWWVZP[L[VWHUKMVSSV^PUNZWYLHKZ!
-P]LWYV[V[`WLLSLTLU[Z^LYLKL]LSVWLKHUKTVKPMPLK[V
HKKYLZZ[OLZWLJPMPJJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZVM7: :OV^UOLYL
VWWVZP[L[VWPZ[OLZJOVVS`HYKMLUJLWYV[V[`WL

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
!GRAPHICPANELOFSIGNMATERIALWOULDBELAYEREDOVER
THETOPPORTIONOFTHETALLSCHOOLYARDFENCETOCREATE
ASTRONGIMAGEFORTHESCHOOLANDVISUALLYBUFFERTHE
ELEVATEDTRAIN
0RODUCTSYSTEMSFORTHISAPPLICATIONINCLUDE
0RINTED-ESH&ABRIC USEDFOR4IMES3QUAREADVERTISING
2EFLECTIVE0AILLETTES USEDFORCARWASHSIGNAGE

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
!GARDENOFSMALLPLANTINGSCOULDBEDEVELOPED
BYFILLINGCOMMONDUMPSTERSLIKETHOSEUSEDBY
THE"OARDOF%DUCATIONWITHSOILANDPLANTS

4HE$UMPSTERSCOULDBEPAINTEDINGRAPHIC
COLORS3HORTDUMPSTERSSHOULDBESELECTED
TOREFLECTACHILDgSHEIGHT!WATERFAUCETSHOULD
BELOCATEDNEARBYFORMAINTENANCE

:JOVVS`HYKWSHU[PUNZWYV[V[`WL

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
06#DRAINAGEPIPECOMMONLYUSEDINCONSTRUCTION
WOULDBECONFIGUREDTOCREATEADIVERSESETTINGOF
MODULARANDPORTABLESEATINGELEMENTS

4HISLIGHTWEIGHTANDDURABLESYSTEMOFSTANDARD
COMPONENTSINCLUDEPIPESECTIONS ENDCAPSANDA
VARIETYOFFITTINGSANDCOUPLERSRANGINGINSIZESFROM
TODIAMETER

:JOVVS`HYKTVK\SHYZLH[PUNWYV[V[`WL

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
!GRAPHICCARPETCOULDBECREATEDINTHESCHOOL
YARDUSINGPAINTLIKETHATUSEDBYTHE$/4
4HECARPETCOULDIDENTIFYSPECIFICUSEAREASOR
GIVEANOVERALLIDENTITYANDSENSEOFPLACETOTHE
WHOLESITE2EFLECTIVEGLASSBEADSLIKETHOSE
USEDINCITYCROSSWALKSCOULDGIVESPARKLE
ANDLIFETOPARTICULARAREASOFTHEGRAPHICPATTERN

7H]PUNHUK^HSSZNYHWOPJZWYV[V[`WL

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
!NOUTDOORCURTAINOFCONSTRUCTIONNETTINGWOULD
BEUSEDTOENCLOSEAREADINGSPACE

4HETRANSPARENCYOFTHECURTAINMATERIALWOULD
CREATEANAREAWHICHISBOTHSPATIALLYDEFINEDAND
VISIBLYOPEN"YMOVINGTHECURTAINTHESPACE
COULDBETRANSFORMEDFORDIFFERNECTTYPESOFACTIVITY

7SHJL[VYLHKWYV[V[`WL

9<5505./,(+:
7:
4VK\SHYZLH[PUNTVJR\W

ABOUTTWOMONTHSAGO )DISCOVEREDTHATTHEENTIRE +3)THINKEVERYTHINGISPRETTYWELLINTEGRATED


SCHOOLHADMADETHELEARNINGGARDENTHEFOCUSOF 7ELLKNOWINAFEWMOREYEARSIFCERTAINPARTS
THEIRSTUDIESFORTHESPRINGSEMESTER4HEARTCLASSES DONTlTINTOTHEGENERALSCHEME&OREXAMPLE
THESCIENCECLASSESˆEVERYTEACHERWASDOINGTHINGS WEVEHADSOMEPROBLEMSWITHTHEWINDCATCHING
THATINVOLVEDTHELEARNINGGARDEN)TJUSTBLEWME THECLOUDSCRIM)THASTOBERETIEDONCEORTWICE
AWAY)TMADEABIGIMPACT AYEARWHENWEHAVEESPECIALLYSTRONGWINDS4HE
4HISPROJECTWASREALLYANESSAYFORME BECAUSE SCRIMISINHERENTLYTHEMOSTTEMPORALPARTOFTHE
INCERTAINSOCIALLYORIENTEDSCHOOLSANDTHEORIESOF LANDSCAPEBECAUSETHEMATERIALITSELFHASONLYA
PUBLICSPACES THEREISTHISSENSETHATYOUCANTHAVE SHELFLIFEOFlVEYEARSORSO)TISCOMMERCIALLY
GOODDESIGNANDSOCIALRESPONSIBILITYATTHESAME INKJET PRINTEDANDCOMESINBIGROLLS SOITCAN
TIME)TSTHESAMEKINDOFSPECIOUSARGUMENTASSAY EASILYBEREPLICATEDANDREPLACED7HETHERORNOT
INGYOUCANTHAVEGOODDESIGNANDENVIRONMENTAL THESCHOOLWILLCHOOSETODOSO)DONTKNOW)TS
RESPONSIVENESSATTHESAMETIME03WASMY THEMOSTEPHEMERALPIECEINTHEDESIGN THELEAST
ESSAYONHOWYOUCANHAVESOCIALRESPONSIBILITYAND ENDURINGINSOMEWAYS BUTITWASALSOTHEONE
COMMUNITYSERVICEWITHINSOMETHINGTHATISAGOOD THATMADETHEBIGGESTSPLASHINTERMSOFTOTALLY
DESIGNSUPPORTEDBYASTRONGVISUALVOCABULARY READJUSTINGTHEPERCEPTIONOFTHEPLACE)TSTHEELE
MENTTHATWILLREQUIRETHEMOSTCOMMITMENTTO
*!!RETHEREPIECESOFTHATSTRONGVISUALVOCABU REPLACE)TSSIMILARTOTHE*APANESEGARDENAT)SE
LARYTHATAREELBOWINGOUTADDITIONALPROGRAM WHERETHEYREBUILDTHETEMPLEEVERYTWENTYYEARS
4HECRITICINMESEESTHEPOLKADOTSASGRATU !LLPUBLICSPACEINVOLVESARITUALOFRENEWAL)TSTHE
ITOUSTHEKIDINMESEESPRIMETERRITORY RITUALOFSWEEPINGTHEPAVEMENTORPICKINGUPTHE

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
:[\K`TVKLSVMZJOVVS`HYKWYV[V[`WLZ

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
 

 
     
       


 


   

"#%
'%"!& !
$%
'%"!& !

 

             


 
    

"&%
'%"!& ! $%
'%"!& !


 
 
 
        

 



 

 
 
  

"#%
'%"!& ! "&%
'%"!& !
$%
'%"!& ! $%
'%"!& !

    
   
    
   

 

  

"#%
'%"!& ! "&%
'%"!& !
$%
'%"!& ! $%
'%"!& !

   
 
    
 

 

  


  

"#%
'%"!& ! "&%
'%"!& !
$%
'%"!& ! $%
'%"!& !    

:JOVVS`HYKNYHWOPJZLSL]H[PVUZ

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
'!2$%."/2$%2 7//$,!.$3(!$% 02!)2)%/,$&)%,$ -%!$/7 ")2$(/53%3
7),$&,/7%23

")2$"544%2&,90,!.4).'3
0,!.4).'3 5.$%2'2/74(

/54$//2.!452%,!"3
&!,,%.,/'2%!$).'3%!43
%8)34).'42%%3 '&2#&!"2)#!4)/.7"-#&).)3( 3(2%$$%$"!2+0!4(

",5%3+93#2)-
/.%8)34).'&%.#%

%8)34).'54),)4)%3

.%7&%.#%
).4%202%4)6%3)'. ).4%202%4)6%3)'.

.!452%345$9!2%!
#524!).2%!$).'2//-
3500/240/,%3
).$5342)!,'2!$%(!.').'42!#+
).$5342)!,&!"2)##524!).
7)4(4)% "!#+37%)'(4%$"/44/-
.%7'!4%

!:!,%!0,!.4).'"%$ 3/&4352&!#% '2!33%30,!.4).'"%$ 0!).4'2!0()#3/.!30(!,4


#54&2/-!30(!,4 7)4().#524!).!2%! #54&2/-!30(!,4
7)4('2!.)4%",/#+(%!$%23 7)4('2!.)4%",/#+
(%!$%23
7!4%20)0%
3%!4).'%,%-%.43

7),,/742%%3
3!7#54g$)!-%4%2/0%.).'3
).!30(!,4
'2!.)4%",/#+(%!$%23!442%%/0%.).'
g2!$)530!).42).'!2/5.$
#/"",%34/.%#)2#,%

"!-"//0,!.4).'"%$
#54&2/-!30(!,4
7)4('2!.)4%",/#+(%!$%23

$5-034%20,!.4%23
#534/--/$)&)%$#5")#9!2$
$5-034%237)4(/54,)$3
#534/-0!).4#/,/23
$)6%23%/2.!-%.4!,0,!.4).'3

%8)34).'&%.#%4/"%2%-/6%$

&!,,%.,/'2%!$).'3%!43
'&2#&!"2)#!4)/.7"-#&).)3(
",5%3+93#2)-
/.%8)34).'&%.#%

,),!#0,!.4).'"%$
'2!.)4%",/#+(%!$%23 #54&2/-!30(!,4
7)4('2!.)4%",/#+(%!$%23

/2.!-%.4!,
3(!$%'!2$%.

:JOVVS`HYKWYV[V[`WLZWSHU

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
7SHJLTLU[VMIS\LZR`ŽZJYPT


 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
:JOVVS`HYKMLUJL^P[OIS\LZR`ŽZJYPT

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
;OL)PYKHUK)\[[LYMS`.HYKLU
^HZWSHU[LK^P[O[OLOLSWVM
]VS\U[LLYZVU,HY[O+H`PU


 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
)PYKHUK)\[[LYMS`.HYKLUZ\TTLY

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
;OLK\TWZ[LYWSHU[LYZ^LYLZJHSLK
KV^U[VHZPaLJVTMVY[HISLMVY
LSLTL[HY`ZJOVVSZ[\KLU[Z[VWSHU[
HUKJHYLMVY

 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
=PL^VMJVTWSL[LKZJOVVS`HYKMYVT1HJRZVU)V\SL]HYK

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
TRASH2ENEWINGTHESCRIMHASALONGERTEMPORAL WITHSTUDENTSWHOGAVEMEALISTOFTHINGSTHEY
TIMEFRAMETHANSWEEPINGANDASHORTERONETHAN WANTEDTOSEEINTHEGARDEN/NESTUDENTWANTED
REBUILDINGATEMPLE BUTESSENTIALLYITSALLTHESAME ROSESSO)VEADDEDROSES ANDSOMEBODYELSEWANT
RITUALOFCONTINUITY EDABIRDBATH)TSTOUGHTODESIGNAGARDENFORAN
4HETEACHERSSPRAY PAINTEDNUMBERSONTHE ACADEMICCALENDAR WHICHIS WITHITSLONGBREAK
DUMPSTERS ANDEACHCLASSSIGNSUPFORONEDUMP INTHESUMMER EXACTLYTHEOPPOSITEOFWHENTHE
STERGARDEN4HEREISAFAIRAMOUNTOFCOMPETITION PLANTSWANTTOGROW
BETWEENCLASSESASTHESTUDENTSADOPTTHEGARDENS 4HISISAGARDENTHEKIDSSEEEVERYDAYWHEN
ANDTAKEOVERTHEPLANTINGANDWEEDING)NTHE THEYCOMETOSCHOOL)TSVISIBLEFROMTHECLASS
SUMMERTHEGARDENSAREMAINTAINEDBYTHE.EW ROOMSANDFROMTHESTREETONTHREESIDES4HEREARE
9ORK2ESTORATION0ROJECT BUTEVENTUALLYTHESCHOOL CERTAINAREASWHEREYOUACTUALLYPASSTHROUGHITˆIF
WILLTAKEOVER YOUENTERFROMTHEWESTSIDEOFTHESCHOOLYARDYOU
7HEN)REVIEWEDTHEPROJECTACOUPLEOF WALKTHROUGHITONYOURWAYTOTHESCHOOL!NDAS
MONTHSAGO )FOUNDAFEWBARESPOTSINTHEBIRD PARTOFTHEOVERALLENVIRONMENTOFTHESCHOOLYARD
ANDBUTTERmYGARDENBUTMOSTEVERYTHINGELSEDID ITSPARTOFTHESTUDENTSDAILYLIFE
WELL4HEREWEREAREASTHATNEEDEDTOBEREPLANTED
AND)REALIZEDTHATTHEREWASNOTENOUGHOFAWIN *!(ASTHEREBEENANYVANDALISM
TERBONESTRUCTURE)HADPLANTEDCERTAINSHRUBS
INCLUDINGILEXANDJUNIPERS BUTITNOWBECAME +3.O4HEREUSEDTOBEALOTOFVANDALISMATTHE
CLEARTHATTHEREWERENTQUITEENOUGH3O)DECIDED SCHOOLˆGRAFlTIMOSTLYˆANDWHILE)DOBELIEVETHAT
WENEEDEDTODOASUPPLEMENTALPLANTING)MET DESIGNCANMAKEADIFFERENCE )WOULDNEVERHAVE

 9<5505./,(+:
7:
PROMISEDTHESCHOOLTHATMYGARDENWOULDSOLVE ;OPZWOV[V^HZ[HRLUMVSSV^PUNJVTWSL[PVUVM[OLZJOVVS`HYK
NYHWOPJZPU
AGRAFlTIORVANDALISMPROBLEM"UTTHEBUILDING
ENGINEERSANDTHESUPERINTENDENTSHAVETOLDME
THATTHEREHASBEENALMOSTNOVANDALISMORGRAF
lTISINCETHEGARDENWENTIN WHICHISJUSTAMAZ
ING)TSNOTJUSTTHESTUDENTSBUTALSOTHEPARENTS
WHOREALLYLOVETHISGARDEN)TSANIMPORTANTELE
MENTOFTHECOMMUNITYNOW ANDCOMMUNITIES
HAVECERTAINMEANSOFENFORCINGSOCIALNORMS)F
SOMETHINGISNTACCEPTABLEWITHINTHECOMMUNITY
PEOPLELETEACHOTHERKNOWTHAT

9<5505./,(+:
7: 
 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
9<5505./,(+:
7: 
 9<5505./,(+:
7:
9<5505./,(+:
7: 
9<5505./,(+:
7: 
 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
9<5505./,(+:
7: 
 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
+EN3MITH
,ANDSCAPEAS
#ULTURAL#RITICISM
.INA2APPAPORT

)NTHEWORKOF+EN3MITH LANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREIS REMOVEPEOPLEFROMTHEEVERYDAY(ISCREATIONSARE


AREINVIGORATEDTHREE DIMENSIONALARTFORM3MITH INSPIREDBYSIXTEENTH CENTURY)TALIANDESIGNERSWHO
ISDEVOTEDBOTHTOMODERNLANDSCAPEAESTHETICSˆ MANIPULATEDSPACETOFORMPLEASUREGARDENSˆSUCH
ASSEENINPROJECTSBY!MERICANLANDSCAPEARCHI ASTHOSEAT4IVOLIS6ILLAD%STEˆWITHFAUXLAKES
TECTS$AN+ILEYŸ 0AUL&RIEDBERGB MINIATUREWATERFALLS ANDPERSPECTIVETRICKSTO
 AND2OBERT:IONB ˆANDTOTHE ENHANCETHEGARDENSSCALE)NVENTINGLANDSCAPEIS
EXPRESSIONOFACONTEMPORARYURBANPLACETHAT SOMETHINGTHATLANDSCAPEARCHITECTSHAVEALWAYS
ENGAGESTHEPUBLICTHROUGHTHEARTISTICANDINVEN DONEANDHAVEALWAYSBEENASKEDTODO ANDTHIS
TIVEUSEOFNATURALANDARTIlCIALMATERIALS&ROM OFTENENCOURAGESANARTISTRYTHAT3MITHEXPRESSES
THEMODERNISTS3MITHLEARNEDHOWTOARTICULATE BYTRYINGTOREVEALBOTHNATURESNATUREANDOUR
THEDIFFERENCESBETWEENHARDSCAPESANDSOFTSCAPES NATUREINTHEWORLD(EPERCEIVESGARDENSINFRAG
TOEXPOSESTRUCTURE TOEMPHASIZETHECONTRAST MENTEDCONTEMPORARYCITIESASFRAMESFORCOM
BETWEENURBANFORESTSANDOPENSPACES ANDTO MUNICATINGIDEASTHATBALANCECULTUREANDNATURE
FORMULATEHISIDEAOFASUBLIMECONSTRUCTEDNATURE ARTIlCEANDNATURE ANDARTANDNATUREEVERYURBAN
THATENHANCESURBANEXPERIENCE3MITHALSOOFFERS ELEMENTISAKINDOFGARDENTHATOFFERSANOPPORTU
ANIRONICVIEWOFCONTEMPORARYCULTURE IMBUING NITYTOREWEAVETHECITYFABRIC3MITHSWORKATITS
HISWORKSWITHCONTENTINASUBTLEMANIPULATIONOF MOSTRElNEDANDTHOUGHT PROVOKINGHASANIRONY
FORM MATERIAL ANDTEXTURETHATENCOURAGESOBSERV TOIT ACRITICALEDGETHAT AS,INDA(UTCHINSON
ERSTOPERCEIVETHEIRENVIRONMENTINANEWWAY NOTESOFVISUALARTS IShAPROCESSOFCOMMUNICA
&OR3MITHTHEGARDENISlRSTAPLACEOFSEPARA TIONTHATENTAILSTWOORMOREMEANINGSBEING
TION ASEXPERIENCEDINWALLEDVILLAGARDENSTHAT PLAYEDOFF ONEAGAINSTTHEOTHER4HEIRONYISIN

9<5505./,(+: 
;67(5+6776:0;,!3L]LY/V\ZL5L^@VYR*P[`
SHUKZJHWLYLZ[VYH[PVU ‹

THEDIFFERENCEIRONYMAKESTHEDIFFERENCE)TPLAYS 3MITHSAPPROACHISCHARACTERIZEDBYITS
BETWEENMEANINGS INASPACETHATISALWAYSAFFEC COMPLEMENTARYNATURESITISBOTHTHEAPPROACH
TIVELYCHARGED THATALWAYSHASACRITICALEDGEv OFACREATIVEARTISTWHOHASAVARIEDPALETTEAND
4HISPLAYISSEENIN3MITHSJUXTAPOSITIONOF THATOFAPRAGMATICCRAFTSMAN4HISPRAGMATISM
UNCONVENTIONALGARDENMATERIALS REUSEOFEVERY ANDHISINDICATIVELOVEFORTRUTHFULDETAILALLOW
DAYOBJECTS ANDTRANSFORMATIONSOFONEFORMINTO 3MITHTODETERMINEHOWEVERYDAYMATERIALSAND
ANOTHER4HEDESIGNFOR-O-!SCAMOUmAGEROOF THEIRPERFORMANCECANBEEMPLOYEDTOREVEAL
GARDENISANEXAMPLEOFTHISCOMMENTARY3MITHS THECONTENTBEHINDTHELANDSCAPEINTHEMAKING
ROOFTOPINSTALLATIONRAISESQUESTIONSABOUTWHATIS .OTTHATTHENUTSANDBOLTSARESHOWN BUTTHE
REALINANURBANGARDENMADEOFARTIlCIALMATERIALS WAYTHEPIECESAREPUTTOGETHERISDEMYSTIlEDAND
SUCHASPLASTICTREESANDGLASSSHARDS AFAUX SCAPE VISIBLEALTHOUGHOTHERCEREBRALGAMESMAYBE
THATISCOLORFULYEAR ROUNDANDVISIBLEONLYTO BEINGPLAYED 
RESIDENTSOFTHEADJACENTHIGH RISE4HEGARDENISA &OR3MITHCLIENTANDPROGRAMPARAMETERSARE
CAMOUmAGEBOTHOFTHEBUILDINGANDOFNATUREˆ PARTOFTHEDESIGNCHALLENGEANDTHEPUZZLETHAT
THEREISNOREALNATURE ANDTHEmATROOFNOWHAS HISWORKHASTOlTWITHIN(ISWORKISASTRATEGIC
ADÏCOR4HEUNINHABITABLEROOFSCAPEISFORDISPLAY EXPRESSIONOFHISPREOCCUPATIONWITHTHEPUBLIC
ONLY NOTFORPHYSICALEXPERIENCEITISSIMILARTO AGENCIESORCLIENTSFORWHOMHEISDESIGNING
LOOKINGATAPAINTINGONAWALL&ROMADISTANCE &ORTHERENOVATIONOFTHE,EVER(OUSE0LAZAIN
ONECANNOTEVENDISCERNWHATKINDOFMATERIALSARE .EW9ORK 3MITHRESEARCHEDTHEORIGINALSCHEMES
USEDONESEESONLYRELATIVELYINERTCOLOR PATTERN INTHE.OGUCHIARCHIVESAND WITHLANDSCAPE
ANDFORM ARCHITECT'AVIN+EENEY RECREATEDTHEORIGINAL

 9<5505./,(+:
9<5505./,(+: 
DESIGNCONCEPTSWHILEUPGRADINGTHEPLAZAFOR 3MITHSPROJECTSBEGINASTEMPORARYINSTALLATIONS
CONTEMPORARYNEEDS)NTHEIMPROVEMENTPROJECT /FTENMADEOFDISPOSABLEMATERIALS THEYGIVEHIM
FOR,AWRENCE(ALPRINSDILAPIDATED-ANHATTAN THEFREEDOMTOEXPERIMENTANDINVESTIGATEMORE
3QUARE0ARK IN2OCHESTER .EW9ORK THE COMPLEXIDEASFORFUTUREPERMANENTSTRUCTURES4HE
WORKWASPHASEDSOTHATTHEDISUSEDAREASOFTHE TEMPORARYNATUREOFTHESEDESIGNSEMPHASIZESTHE
FOUNTAINANDTHESTAGECANBEREVITALIZED WHILE WEIGHTYELEMENTOFTIMEINLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURE
THEREMAINDEROFTHEPARKISONLYMINIMALLYREDE INRELATIONTOBOTHNATURALANDARTIlCIALMATERIALS
SIGNEDUNTILTHECITYOBTAINSFURTHERFUNDING 7HILETHEARTIlCIALELEMENTSIN3MITHSWORKSCAN
!TTHESAMETIME ASANARTIST 3MITHREIN BEREMOVED THEYDONOTDIEORCHANGEQUICKLY
VIGORATESLANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREASACONCEPTUAL 4HISALLOWSTHEDESIGNERMORECONTROLOVERTHE
ARTFORM IMBUINGITWITHALLUSIONSTOCULTURE PALETTE)NCONTRAST THENATURALLANDSCAPEISPRE
$RAWINGAPARALLELBETWEENFASHIONASACULTURAL DICTABLEBUTNOTSTABLE)TISRENDEREDTEMPORARYBY
PHENOMENONANDLANDSCAPEARCHITECTURE HESAYS ITSCONSTANTPROCESSOFCHANGEWHILETHEARTIlCIAL
BOTHAREhARTIlCIALCONSTRUCTIONSTHATlTANORGANIC LANDSCAPEISTEMPORARYBECAUSEITISDISPOSABLE&OR
BODYTHATMOVESANDmUCTUATES     )TISANIDEOLOGI EXAMPLE THESYNTHETICMATERIALSOFTHE-O-!ROOF
CALEXPRESSION MAKINGORREVEALINGTHEBODY ORIN GARDENNEEDONLYLASTTHELIFEOFTHEROOFCONTRAC
THECASEOFLANDSCAPEˆTHECITYv3MITHNOTESTHAT TORSGUARANTEE
FASHIONWASSEENASAREGRESSIVEARTFORMUNTILCRIT !LTHOUGH3MITHDOESNOTPROMOTEENVIRON
ICSSUCHAS2ICHARD-ARTINEVALUATEDITASAFORM MENTALISMPERSE HEISANENVIRONMENTALISTIN
OFCULTURALEXPRESSION ANDHEFEELSTHATTHISISHOW SUBTLEWAYSWHILENOTMAKINGAMORALDISTINCTION
THEPUBLICVIEWSLANDSCAPEDESIGNASWELL-ANYOF OFIT&ORHIMTHEENVIRONMENTISSOMETHINGTOBE

 9<5505./,(+:
RESPECTEDANDUNDERSTOODASAGIVEN&ORTHE%AST
2IVER&ERRY,ANDINGS FOREXAMPLE 3MITHSELECTED
NATURALGRASSESTOBEPLANTEDINmOATINGCONTAIN
ERSˆHINTINGATWHATWASONCETHEREASWELLASAT
WHATCOULDBEIFTHEREWASNORETAININGWALLATTHE
RIVERSEDGE
3MITHSDESIGNAPPROACHREINTEGRATESOFTEN
OBSCUREANDFRAGMENTEDSITESINTOTHEPUBLIC
REALMINCELEBRATORYWAYSASHETRANSFORMSTHEM
INTOSOMETHINGBEYONDTHENORM(ISCONCEPTUAL
STRATEGIESADAPTTOTHELOCALCONDITIONSANDSPECIlC
SITESINANINDUCTIVEMETHODBYlRSTAPPRECIATING
WHATISTHERE(ISARTISTICANDINVENTIVEYETPRACTI
CALAPPROACH ENVIRONMENTALSENSITIVITY ANDBROAD
ARTIlCIALANDNATURALMATERIALPALETTE INTERTWINETO
MAKESPACESTHATTRANSFORMDAILYLIFEANDENGAGE
THEPUBLIC

,INDA(UTCHINSON )RONYS%DGE,ONDONAND.EW9ORK
2OUTLEDGE  

9<5505./,(+: 
#REDITS

4HEPROJECTSINTHISMONOGRAPH 4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN %AST2IVER&ERRRY (9*/0;,*;


RESULTFROMATEAMEFFORTIN !RT2OOF'ARDEN ,ANDINGS +ENNEDY6IOLICH!RCHITECTURE
MYOFlCE)DLIKETOESPE
*30,5; *30,5; 4(905,:;9<*;<9(3
CIALLYTHANK%LIZABETH!SAWA
4HE-USEUMOF-ODERN!RT .EW9ORK#ITY%CONOMIC ,5.05,,9:
3ENIOR!SSOCIATE WHOHASBEEN $EVELOPMENT#ORPORATION -'-C,AREN 0#
INVOLVEDINALLOFTHESEWORKS 3(5+:*(7,(9*/0;,*; .EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF
ANDPLAYSANIMPORTANTROLE +EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT 4RANSPORTATION *65:;9<*;0654(5(.,9:
.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF (UDSON-ERIDIAN#ONSTRUCTION
INTHEOPERATIONOFTHEOFlCE
+,:0.5;,(4 0ARKSAND2ECREATION 'ROUP
4HEPROJECTMANAGERSPLAYED 4OBIAS!RMBORST
ASIGNIlCANTROLEINTHEDESIGN %LIZABETH!SAWA 3(5+:*(7,(9*/0;,*; 4,7
OFEACHPROJECT!LEX&ELSONFOR $AVID(AMERMAN +EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT ,AKHANI*ORDAN%NGINEERING
-ATT,ANDIS
THE%AST2IVER&ERRY,ANDINGS
2OCIO,ASTRAS +,:0.5;,(4 :,*<90;@
!NNIE7EINMAYRFOR03 +EN3MITH 4OBIAS!RMBORST #OSENTINI!SSOCIATES
AND4OBIAS!RMBORSTAND-ATT !NNIE7EINMAYR %LIZABETH!SAWA
,ANDISFORTHE-O-!2OOF *UDITH7ONG (EIKE"ERGDOLT 
#HRISTIAN:IMMERMANN 9OONCHUL#HO
'ARDEN
!LEX&ELSON
+EN3MITH
3(5+:*(7,*65;9(*;69 2UTH(ARTMANN
4OWNAND'ARDENS 2OCIO,ASTRAS-ONTANA
+EN3MITH
$AN7ILLNER

 9<5505./,(+:
03 .9(7/0*+,:0.5 04(.,*9,+0;:
0ENTAGRAM !LLIMAGESAREBY+EN3MITH
*30,5; ,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTUNLESS
2OBIN(OOD&OUNDATION 5<9:,9@ OTHERWISENOTED
"ISSETT.URSERY#ORPORATION 0AGESLEFTTOPANDBOTTOM
6>5,9 LEFT  LEFT BOTTOM
.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF 9,*3(04,+36.:<7730,9  BOTTOM ¥$ANIEL
%DUCATION 03'ENIE#ALIBAR #ITI,OG 7ILLNER
CURRENTPRINCIPAL #ATHY:ARBIS 0AGESMIDDLETOPAND
FORMERPRINCIPAL +<47:;,94(5<-(*;<9,9 BOTTOM BOTTOM  
*#)NDUSTRIES    n  
3(5+:*(7,(9*/0;,*; ¥0ETER-AUSS%STO
+EN3MITH,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT +(--6+037961,*; 0AGESLEFTTOPANDBOTTOM
*669+05(;065     ¥!LBERT
+,:0.5;,(4 .EW9ORKERSFOR0ARKS4HE5RBAN 6EC‡ERKA%STO
4OBIAS!RMBORST #ENTER 0AGESRIGHTTOPANDBOTTOM
%LIZABETH!SAWA       
!LEX&ELSON (++0;065(3*65;90)<;69:  ¥0AUL7ARCHOL
!LICE-AHIN 4HE!UDUBON3OCIETY 0AGES ¥.ATHANIEL
+EN3MITH #LEAR#HANNEL3PECTACOLOR 'OLDBERG
!NNIE7EINMAYR $ANIELLEAND$AVID'ANEK 0AGETOP ¥"ETSY0INOVER
*UDITH7ONG -AUREEN'IBBONS 3CHIFF
-IMIAND0ETER(AAS 0AGERIGHT ¥*OHN"ACH
*65;9(*;69 /VERBROOK&OUNDATION
4HE.EW9ORK2ESTORATION0ROJECT 0ETER0ETERSON
3IGN#RAFT
4IMBERLAND#ORPORATION
9<5505./,(+: 
"IBLIOGRAPHY

0ETER2EED 'ROUNDSWELL !NN2AVER h!2OOF4OP'ARDEN -AGAZINE !RCHITECTURE-AY ,ESLIE3HERR h-ANHATTAN


#ONSTRUCTINGTHE#ONTEMPORARY 7ITH3YNTHETIC'REENv4HE.EW    4AKEOVER v,EVER(OUSE)$4HE
,ANDSCAPE.EW9ORK4HE-USEUM 9ORK4IMES .OVEMBER )NTERNATIONAL$ESIGN-AGAZINE
OF-ODERN!RT  ,AURA3TARR h!YALON0ARKˆ !PRIL 
4OBY-USGRAVE h/UTOFTHE"LUEv %XTREME3ITES4HE'REENINGOFTHE
"ARBARA(OFFMAN h)TS!RT IlCIALv 'ARDENS)LLUSTRATED/CTOBER  "ROWNlELDv!$-AGAZINE-ARCH 3UZANNE3TEPHENS h0ROJECTS
.EW9ORK0OST &EBRUARY !PRIL  ,EVER(OUSEv!RCHITECTURAL2ECORD
+EN3MITH h2AILYARD0ARK 3ANTA -ARCH 
!LLEN&REEMAN h"IG$OTS ,ITTLE &E .EW-EXICOv$IALOGUE $AVID#OLEMAN h/UTINTHE
$UMPSTERSv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE !RCHITECTURE $ESIGN #ULTURE 'ARDEN A2EPUTATION"LOOMSv 3UZANNE3TEPHENS h#OMMENTARY
-AGAZINE&EBRUARY  4AIWAN3PECIAL)SSUEON,ANDSCAPE 4HE.EW9ORK4IMES *ULY #OLLABORATIONSATTHE74#v
!RCHITECTURE3EPTEMBER  !RCHITECTURAL2ECORD-ARCH 
+ENNETH(ELPHANDh(ORTUS 3HARON-C(UGH h.EW,IFEFOR
,UDENSv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE +AREN%3TEEN h'ARDEN3POTv A4ROUBLED0LAZAv#OMPETITIONS +IM3ORVIG h#OMPETINGFOR
-AGAZINE&EBRUARY  -ETROPOLIS-AGAZINE!UGUST -AGAZINE6OL .O3UMMER 3ANTA&ES)DENTITYv,ANDSCAPE
3EPTEMBER    !RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE-ARCH
!LLEN&REEMAN h0ROVING'ROUNDv  
,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE $EBORAH"ISHOP h,ANDSCAPE $EBRA'IBSON h,!!LUMNUSA
*ANUARY  !RCHITECTUREˆ!LUMINUM &ORCE-AJEUREIN$ESIGN#IRCLESv !NNE2AVER h4HIS3TOPTH
'ARDENv$WELL-AGAZINE*ULY $ESIGN.EWS )OWA3TATE5NIVERSITY &LOOR 2AIN&ORESTv4HE.EW9ORK
#HARLES"IRNBAUM ED0RESERVING !UGUST  3PRING  4IMES &EBRUARY
-ODERN,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE))
-AKING0OSTWAR,ANDSCAPES6ISIBLE +EN3MITH 7EST &IELD #ARRIE'EYER h3TOPAND3MELLTHE ,ISA3PECKHARDT h2IVERFRONT
7ASHINGTON $#3PACEMAKER /PERATIONS $)243TUDIO h7HY $UMPSTERSv4HE,ANTERN /HIO 2EVIVALv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE
0RESS  .OT!0ARKv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES 3TATE5NIVERSITY-AY  -AGAZINE*ANUARY 

 9<5505./,(+:
2UTH,A&ERLA h,ET-E'UESS 9OU +IM3ORVIG h2AILYARD2EMAKEIN *AMES'RAYSON4RULOVE h2ETREAT -ELISSA$AVIS h3LEEK-ODERNITYv
-UST"EAN!RCHITECTv4HE.EW 3ANTA&Ev#OMPETITIONS-AGAZINE 0OOLv4HE.EW!MERICAN 'ARDEN$ESIGN-AGAZINE-AY
9ORK4IMES &EBRUARY 6OL .O&ALL  3WIMMING0OOL#ONNECTICUT  
7HITNEY0RESS 
(ERBERT-USCHAMP h"ALANCING $AVID$UNLAP h0LAN#HOSENFOR ,ISA3PECKHARDT h)N4HE0UBLIC
2EASONAND%MOTIONIN4RADE 2EDESIGNOFA0LAZAAT7ATER h$EBATE/VER7ORLD4RADE#ENTER %YEv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE
4OWERS6OIDv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES 3TREETv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES  -EMORIALv#"3%VENING.EWS  -AGAZINE -AY
&EBRUARY 3EPTEMBER $ECEMBER
$ANIELLE2EED h'ARDENINGONTHE
(ERBERT-USCHAMP h!'OALFOR %DWARD7YATT h$ESIGN4EAMSARE 4ERENCE2ILEY ETAL h7HAT #HEAPv7ALL3TREET*OURNAL 
'ROUND:ERO&INDINGAN5RBAN 3ELECTEDFOR.EW0LANSFOR TO"UILDv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES !PRIL
0OETRYv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES  3ITEv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES  -AGAZINE .OVEMBER
*ANUARY 3EPTEMBER +EN3MITH h!LUMINUM'ARDENv
3TEPHANIE#ASH h.OGUCHI'ARDEN 0AGES0AYSAGES.O*ANUARY
#HERILYNh,IVv7RIGHT h!6ISUAL ,ISA2OCHON h5PFROMTHE!SHESv FOR,EVER(OUSEv!RT)N!MERICA  
%XPLOSIONIN(ARLEMv4HE 4HE'LOBEAND-AIL #ANADA  -ARCH 
)NTERNATIONAL2EVIEWOF!FRICAN !PRIL $AVID#OLMAN hTO7ATCH 4HE
!MERICAN!RT  +EN3MITH h7HAT.EW9ORK $ESIGN7ORLDINv(OUSE
:OE2YAN h$UMPSTER'ARDENS .EEDS.OWv4HE!RCHITECTURAL 'ARDEN-AGAZINE*ANUARY 
0ATRICK&RANK h%NVIRONMENTAL $ESIGNING1UEENS0LAZAv6AN!LEN ,EAGUEOF.EW9ORK3PRING
$ESIGNv!RTFORMS !N)NTRODUCTION 2EPORT*ANUARY  3UMMER  'AVIN+EENEY h)DIOSYNCRATIC
TOTHE6ISUAL!RTS5PPER3ADDLE 0UBLIC/PEN3PACEv/N4HE.ATURE
2IVER .*0RENTICE(ALL  *ANE!MIDON 2ADICAL,ANDSCAPES -ARC+RISTAL h4HINK)T9OURSELFv /F4HINGS #ONTEMPORARY!MERICAN
,ONDON4HAMESAND(UDSON $WELL-AGAZINE*UNE  ,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE "ASEL
!NNE2AVER h4HE0LACES(ELL'O  "IRKHAUSER 
4O'REENTHE#ITYv4HE.EW9ORK
4IMES .OVEMBER
9<5505./,(+: 
*AMES'RAYSON4RULOVE *OSEPH(OLTZMAN h1UESTIONOF !RTSv0RESERVING-ODERN,ANDSCAPE %LAINE,OUIE h4HE!RTOFTHE
h!LUMINUM'ARDENv0OCKET $ECENCYv%VERY2OOM4ELLS!3TORY !RCHITECTURE 0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE7AVE (IRSUTEv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES 
'ARDENS "IG)DEASFOR3MALL3PACES .EST-AGAZINE3UMMER (ILL#ONFERENCE7ASHINGTON $# !UGUST
.EW9ORK-ORROW0RESS  3PACEMAKER0RESS 
'AVIN+EENEY h!0ARADISICAL.EW +OJI!IKAWA h,INKAGESWITH5RBAN
$AVID#OLMAN h'ARDEN'OES0OP 0LAZAv/CULUS-AGAZINE3UMMER -ARY*ANE0OOLAND"ETSY0INOVER !CTIVITYv3PACE$ESIGN-AGAZINE
'ARDEN$AISIESv'ARDEN$ESIGN   3CHIFF h'ARDENSOF,IGHTv'ARDENS ,ANDSCAPE#REATION4ODAY
-AGAZINE/CTOBER  INTHE#ITY .EW9ORKIN"LOOM.EW 4HE#HALLENGESOF,ANDSCAPE
!NN2AVER h!3LIVEROF0ARADISE 9ORK!BRAMS0RESS  !RCHITECTS)SSUE*UNE 
+EN3MITHAND!LICE!DAMS h! "LOOMSIN(ARLEMv4HE.EW9ORK
,ONG,OOKAT&IFTH!VENUE $,&)) 4IMES !UGUST .ILS"ALLHAUSEN h5RBAN 0AUL"ENNETT h/NTHE"OARDS
5NBUILT,ANDSCAPESv,AND&ORUM ,ANDSCAPESv"AUWELT/CTOBER 2EINVENTING(ARLEMv,ANDSCAPE
  %LAINE,OUIE h!LUMINUMIS   !RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE*UNE 
'ETTING(OTv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES
h.EW 9ORK 0LAZAv 6AN !LEN 2EPORT *ULY +EN3MITH h,INEAR,ANDSCAPESv $AVID3IMON-ORTON h!NIMATED
&ALL  (ARVARD$ESIGN-AGAZINE3PRING AND)NTERACTIVE$ESIGN,IGHTS5P
4OBIAS3CHNEEBAUM h(OTEL%DENv   &INANCIAL$ISTRICTv!RCHITECTURAL
h'ATEWAYTO(ARLEM .EST-AGAZINE3UMMER  2ECORD !)!(ONOR!WARDS)SSUE
.EIGHBORHOOD2EVITALIZATIONS #ATHERINE3LESSOR h$ELIGHTSv -AY 
%STABLISHA3ENSEOF0LACEAND 'INA#RANDELL h'LOWING4OPIARY 4HE!RCHITECTURAL2EVIEW ,ONDON
-EMORIALIZE-ALCOLM8v 7INTER'ARDENv,AND&ORUM $ECEMBER  7ANDA*ANKOWSKI h'ARDEN
,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE   6ARIETYv!RCHITECTURAL,IGHTING
.OVEMBER  %LAINE,OUIE h7HERE-IES#OULD -AGAZINE!PRILn-AY 
+EN3MITH h#ASE3TUDY 4OWEL/FFv4HE.EW9ORK4IMES 
0RESERVING$AN+ILEYS7ORKAT 3EPTEMBER &RANCISCO!SENSIO#ERVER h6ILLAGE
,INCOLN#ENTERFORTHE0ERFORMING OF9ORKVILLE0ARKv,ANDSCAPE
!RCHITECTURE 4HE7ORLDOF
 9<5505./,(+:
)0)306.9(7/@
%NVIRONMENTAL$ESIGN!TRIUM .INA2APPAPORT h/N4HE$RAWING +EN3MITH h2ELICS 0ROSTHETICS h5RBAN2ENEWAL0ROJECTv
)NTERNATIONAL 3PAIN  "OARDSv/CULUS-AGAZINE*UNE AND3URROGATE2EALITIESv4HE -ETROPOLIS/CTOBER 
  #ULTUREOF,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE
'INA#RANDELLAND(EIDI !USTRALIA  'ARY3TRANG h,ANDSCAPE
,ANDECKER ED h0ARKSv$ESIGNED h9ORKVILLE2ESIDENTS2OAM#ANADIAN !RCHITECTURE 4HE%XPANDING3COPE
,ANDSCAPE&ORUM7ASHINGTON ,ANDSCAPEˆ)NAN5RBAN0ARKv %VE+AHN h.EWS #ONTROVERSIAL AND%VOLVING2OLES v5NIVERSITYOF
$#3PACEMAKER0RESS  !RCHITECTURAL2ECORD*ULY  4ORONTO0ARKSv,ANDSCAPE #ALIFORNIA $AVIS 6IDEO 
!RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE*ULY 
%LAINE,OUIE h#URRENTSv'LOWING 2OBERTA"RANDES'RATZ h&ILLINGTHE h.EWS #UMBERLAND0ARK
4OPIARY'ARDEN0ROJECT 4HE.EW 6OIDIN0UBLIC7ORKSv0ROGRESSIVE *EAN'ODFREY *UNE h0ERSONALITIES #OMPETITION7INNER!NNOUNCEDv
9ORK4IMES $ECEMBERAND !RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE-ARCH  2OCKING4ORONTOv#ONTRACT$ESIGN ,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE
FRONTPAGEPHOTO 4HE.EW9ORK MAGAZINE $ECEMBER &EBRUARY 
4IMES $ECEMBER 'EORGE4HOMAS+APELOS
)NTERPRETATIONSOF.ATURE *7ILLIAM4HOMPSON h$RAWING h.EWS "ROOKLYN"RIDGE'ARDEN
%LAINE,OUIE h#URRENTSv&IFTH #ONTEMPORARY#ANADIAN!RCHITECTURE 0ORTFOLIOSv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE -OUNTv,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE
!VENUE#HANDELIERS0ROJECT 4HE ,ANDSCAPEAND5RBANISM -AGAZINE-AY  -AGAZINE*ANUARY 
.EW9ORK4IMES *ULY +LEINBURG /.-C-ICHAEL
#ANADIAN!RT#OLLECTION  -AC'RISWALD h"OX3ET -ICHAEL,ECCESEAND*7ILLIAM
+EN3MITH h0RESERVINGA #UMBERLAND0ARKv0ARKS 4HOMPSON h,ANDSCAPESFOR
-ODERNIST,EGACYv(ARVARD h%XCAVATING4HE#OMMONPLACE "EYOND/LMSTED)SSUE ,ANDSCAPE THEST#ENTURYv,ANDSCAPE
5NIVERSITY'3$.EWS&ALL  6ISIONARY,ANDSCAPESv,ANDSCAPE !RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE!PRIL  !RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE$ECEMBER
!RCHITECTURE-AGAZINE$ECEMBER  
!NNE%LIZABETH0OWELL h.ORTHERN   +EN3MITH h#OMPUTER3PACE
%XPOSURE 0RESIDENTS!WARDOF )N4HE$ESIGN/F,ANDSCAPEv
%XCELLENCEv6ILLAGEOF9ORKVILLE 2ICK!NDRIGHETTI h&ACINGTHE #ANADIAN3OCIETYOF$ECORATIVE!RTS
0ARK ,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE ,AND 9ORKVILLE0ARKv4HE "ULLETIN!UTUMN 
-AGAZINE.OVEMBER  #ANADIAN!RCHITECT!UGUST 
9<5505./,(+:
)0)306.9(7/@ 
"IOGRAPHIES

1(5,(40+65ISALANDSCAPEDESIGNER CRITIC ANDLEC


TURERCURRENTLYTEACHINGINTHE,ANDSCAPE3ECTIONOFTHE
+NOWLTON3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTURE(ERPUBLISHEDWORK
INCLUDES$AN+ILEY!MERICAS-ASTER,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECT
2ADICAL,ANDSCAPES AND-OVING(ORIZONS4HE,ANDSCAPE
!RCHITECTUREOF+ATHRYN'USTAFSONAND0ARTNERS2ECENT
PRESENTATIONSINCLUDEDISCUSSIONSOFMODERNANDCON
TEMPORARYLANDSCAPEARCHITECTUREATTHE.ETHERLANDS
!RCHITECTURE)NSTITUTE THE2OYAL)NSTITUTEOF"RITISH
!RCHITECTURE ANDTHE7EXNER!RT#ENTER

505(9(77(769;ISANARCHITECTURALCRITIC CURATOR AND


EDUCATORBASEDIN.EW9ORK3HEISPUBLICATIONSEDITOR
AT9ALE3CHOOLOF!RCHITECTUREWHERESHEISTHEEDITOROF
THEBIANNUALPUBLICATION#ONSTRUCTS EXHIBITIONCATALOGS
ANDSTUDIOBOOKS3HEISAFELLOWOFTHE$ESIGN4RUST
FOR0UBLIC3PACEFORh,ONG)SLAND#ITY #ONNECTINGTHE
!RTS vANARTSIDENTITYANDURBANDESIGNPROJECT3HEHAS
CONTRIBUTEDARTICLESTO!RCHITECTURE !RCHITECTURAL2ECORD
$EUTSCHE"AUZEITUNG &UTURE!NTERIOR -ETROPOLIS 0RAXIS AND
4EC!T#ITY#OLLEGESHEISADJUNCTPROFESSOR TEACHING
SEMINARSONTHEPOST INDUSTRIALFACTORYANDONINNOVATIVE
ENGINEERS3HEISCO CHAIROFTHE.EW9ORK4RI STATE
CHAPTEROF$OCOMOMO53

 9<5505./,(+: