Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 8

G3516C Series 50 Hz Gas

Competitive Comparison

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors

• Who is the competition for the G3516C?


– Cummins
– Deutz
– Jenbacher
– Waukesha

• Why is the CAT G3516C better?

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors
Cat 3516

Model Rating 50 Hz Elec. Eff.


G3516 1030 32.7%
G3516B 1165 34.3%
G3516C w/opumps 1600 40.8%

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors

Cummins 1370 GQMA 1370 37.4%


1570 GQMB 1570 38.6%
1540 GQNA 1540 38.2%
1750 GQNB-50/60 1750 38.9%
Deutz TBG 620 V 12 K 1050 41.3%
TBG 620 V 16 K 1400 41.3%
Jenbacher J320GS 1065 39.8%
J420GS 1413 42.4%
J612GS 1644 42.4%
Waukesha VHP P9390 1175 36.6%
8L-AT27GL 1480 37.5%

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors
Electrical Efficiency of Competition
Electrical Efficiency

1800 Prechamber
GQNB
unit
1700
J612GS
1600
GQMB G3516C wopumps
GQMA
Power Rating (ekW)

1500
8L-AT27GL Cummins
Deutz
1400 J420GS
Caterpillar
GQMA TBG 620 V16K
Jenbacher
1300 Waukesha

1200
G3516B VPH P9390 Miller cycle
–G3516E
1100 competition
J320GS
TBG 620 V12K
G3516
1000
30.00% 32.00% 34.00% 36.00% 38.00% 40.00% 42.00% 44.00%
Electrical Efficiency

Competitors

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


G3516 Competition

Model G3516C TBG 620 V16K J612GS VHP P9390


(ekW) (1618) (1400) (1644) (1175)

Bore x Stroke (mm) 170 x 190 170 x 195 190 x 220 238 x 216
Configuration V-16 V-16 V-12 V-16
Displacement (L) 69 70.8 74.9 154
Brake MEP (bar) 19.2 15.8 18.22 9.75
Compression Ratio 11.7 12 10.5
Footprint (sq. m) 8.45 9.90 18.00 9.25
Weight (kg) 12809 10830 18600 13040

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors

• Why is CAT 3516C better?

– High Efficiency
– Low Emissions
– Low Installed cost
– Excellent Performance
– High degree of configurability
– Low Maintenance Cost
– Good Transient response

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.


Competitors
Questions & Answers

One company.™ A multitude of solutions.