Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Jalen M. Smith
Seattle University
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 2
Introduction
The higher education academy gives rise to diverse voices and narratives that often go
unnoticed. In this analysis Sam, a student that identifies as a first-generation, Black, and
transgender college freshman that is attending a predominantly White institution (PWI), will be
evaluated against several theories of learning and development. Furthermore, the goal of this
analysis is to underscore the importance of institutional type, the barriers that are particular to
specific learning settings, and how current issues within society impact learning. Sam is
challenges to those navigating the unfamiliar terrain. For Sam, they are embarking on a journey
that will take them into a foreign domain, which will ultimately present several obstacles. As an
practices can collaborate to inform intersectional applications for the empowerment and safety of
students like Sam. By examining Erikson’s psychosocial development theory, Bem’s theory of
enculturated gender lens, and Parham’s model of racial identity development, this work will
postulate that salient identities influence learning. The goal of this analysis is to explore how a
combination of these theories is necessary to inform how students with multiple target identities
perceive and navigate through stressors related to identity and institutional barriers.
Theories of Practice
particular individual responds to an environment. In the case of Sam, who is host to several
1
Sam uses “they/them” pronouns and will be referred to as such throughout the remainder of this analysis.
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 3
meaning of lived experiences. Merriam and Bierema (2014) explain that one of the central
49). The eight stages follow an individual throughout the trajectory of their lifespan, from
infancy to late adulthood. Fleming (2004) creates a clear path for the eight theories: Stage 1 is
trust versus mistrust, Stage 2 is Autonomy versus Shame and Doubt, Stage 3 is Initiative versus
Guilt, Stage 4 is Industry versus Inferiority, Stage 5 is Identity versus Role Confusion, Stage 6 is
Intimacy versus Isolation, Stage 7 is Generativity versus Isolation, and Stage 8 is Integrity versus
Despair (pp. 7-18). For a clearer understanding of the prescribed stages, see Figure 1.
Erikson noted that each stage of development was led by a “crisis,” which offset the
growth process for the individual involved (Fleming, 2004, pp. 3-4). Elkind (1970) describes the
stages of the Eriksonian developmental process as being direct responses to social forces that
result in a “crisis.” These crises, ultimately, cause a questioning of values and social norms that
have been accepted or forced upon the individual. Finally, Crain (2011) has developed the
rationale that each stage of Erikson’s model is not confined to the other; achieving one stage does
not lead to the next. That said, one can move through the eight stages in a non-linear fashion and
Erikson’s Application to Sam. Sam is a new college student and entering a PWI. They have
multiple marginalized identities and claim their cultural heritage as a salient quality. For Sam,
applicable to Sam’s life pre-college, but now Sam is stepping into another role and repetition of
this process is occurring for Sam. For example, while Stage 1 (“Trust vs. Mistrust”) in Figure 1
is noted for infants, Fleming (2004) describes the first stage as a dichotomy emerging between
“hope” and “withdrawal” (p. 7). For many first-generation college students, the learning curve is
steep. Sam, as a Black and transgender student at a PWI, not seeing any of their identities or
cultural practices reflected back could easily be cause for withdrawal. Upon adhering to this first
stage of development, it would be beneficial for student affairs professionals to move toward the
“hope” area in Erikson’s model. This could be developed by hosting more culturally specific
programs, or providing space for first-generation students to grow comfortable with the
Given that funding and resources allow, it would be appropriate to partner with
community programs, such as those catering to people of color, which could be brought back to
the campus community. An example of this could be a group that focuses on cultural dances and
music that could be brought to a residence hall or public campus space. This could attract
attention and allow Sam to understand that while the campus community is not necessarily
accommodating, there are resources within the greater region of the area. And if these
partnerships are deemed credible, it could be worthwhile for student affairs professionals to
reach out to campus groups and create a schedule of events in the community. This information
could be disseminated to students so they have connections and resources to be involved with
Bem (1993) states that the enculturated gender lens approach positions the individual in
varying contexts, such as the social and historical. Greenbaum (1999) uses the metaphor of
“lens” for gender by determining that people in different states of development and personality
view gender in different ways. How it is perceived in one society may differ from another;
several factors influence how gender and gender identity are expressed and reciprocated. In the
case of the enculturated theory, gender is viewed and constructed through the lens of the
dominant culture (O’Brien, 2009). Gender is defined by collective societal agreement (Bem,
1993; Greenbaum, 1999; Ross-Gordon, 1999), but the option to resist this lens is what promotes
spaces that are not safe, or are otherwise hazardous, to their development and existence. Not only
is Sam a Black individual, but their gender identity falls outside of the binary and has, by default,
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 6
“resisted” the lens of enculturated gender. An example of the enculturated gender theory being
enacted would involve Sam requesting gender neutral restrooms in residence halls at an
institution that does not abide by this rule, and Sam advocating for the usage of gender neutral
applicable to Sam, because being transgender has an enculturated reputation in the United States.
It has been socialized to be regarded with disdain, legal barriers, and medical challenges.
However, there exist many other cultures around the world that embrace transgenderism, such as
certain Native American tribes and their classifications of “two-spirit” (Murg, 2011).
For the adult educators that encounter students like Sam, it is important to remember that
there are an abundance of resources available. It may be easy to go directly to the source (i.e.
Sam) and ask questions about their identity, but it should never be on the student to educate the
teacher. Given this, it is critical that educators reach out to the appropriate resources, whether
that is campus multicultural centers, online artifacts, or discussions with supervisors to support
best practices for students like Sam. Additionally, since Bem’s model is rooted in enculturation,
that means it is an idea that is socially constructed and supported. It will benefit the practice of
student affairs professionals if they actively resist the established binary by addressing everyone
in their classroom with gender neutral pronouns and consistently challenge university policy
rooted within the binary. Professionals can seek support from colleagues in order to challenge
Racial identity development theories have been utilized to determine how people of color
(for this case, Black/African/African American) develop senses of racial identity in the context of
society and other specific triggers (Chavez and Guido-DiBrito, 1999). Cross, Parham, and Helms
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 7
(1991) determine that racial identity development is a way for young children to engage with
their culture from an early age and gain an idea of who they are, which carries them through
adolescence, and eventually adulthood. Throughout these stages, various emotions and actions
Racial Identity and Sam. It has been noted that Sam maintains close ties with their family and
this relationship has been a source of support during their transition to college. This theory not
only offers an explanation as to how Sam’s familial connection persists, but it creates an
opportunity for the adult educator to understand that Sam is in a developmental process and
should be regarded with support and reassurance from higher education staff and faculty (Chavez
and Guido-DiBrito, 1999). While this is a jarring transition for Sam, this would be an optimal
time for residence hall directors to inform Resident Assistants (RAs) to include diverse programs
within the halls if they are not already doing so. Chavez and Guido-DiBrito (1999) would
surmise that RAs should include programs that offer support, such as programs that affirm Sam’s
most salient identities. An idea for a program could be to invite faculty and staff of color from
across the campus and include them in a dinner within the residence hall. It could be a
conversational gathering to represent the diversity that Sam may be seeking. Furthermore, this
would establish a partnership with the academic perspective that Sam is currently engaging in as
a first-year student. If Sam has an awareness of the space they are in is supportive of their
identities, they may feel more at ease in their new home. This theory presents an opportunity to
not only engage Sam in their developmental path, but for staff and faculty of higher education
spaces to challenge their outreach and programming efforts for diverse student populations.
Herein this situation, multiple intersecting identities meet and are pressured to move forward for
professionals should be aware of for their practice. When developing these outreach initiatives or
programs, students will be bringing with them their personally-defined senses of self. They may
already think they know who they are, so for professionals that choose to follow a specific model
or theory that has been discussed in this analysis, it would not be for the benefit for the student.
Sam will be an incoming student with salient cultural and racial identities. What a White student
affairs professional may see as helpful and inclusive could appear as foreign and confusing to
Sam. Therefore, student affairs professionals should gauge their audiences. Performing
assessments to get a check on what the students would like to experience, what they think they
need, and how they would like to receive this information could help inform inclusive practices.
These assessments could be done via formal software systems, or simple informational
spaces.
challenge, students as they are making strides through their own developmental paths. With Sam,
they are entering a space that will reveal many challenges and setbacks. Sam will be living in a
gendered residence hall, on a PWI campus, with academic advisors that are not well-versed in
African American Vernacular English (AAVE)—a cultural token Sam takes with them and
communicates with frequently. With this, it is critical that practitioners in higher education not
attempt to “solve” the problems that marginalized and underrepresented students have; instead, it
will be worthy to “treat” the symptoms of a much larger problem. Furthermore, professionals in
this field will be continuously challenged as political and social climates evolve, and moods shift
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 9
regarding specific identities. Institutional policy is not static, and changes will come—both for
the good and for the bad—and educators within this field must be ready to advocate, challenge,
For a first-generation, Black, and transgender student attending a PWI, there will be
several challenges to learning and development. The perception of learning appears in many
different ways through several contexts, ranging from environmental, structural, and cultural.
The application of adult learning theories in humanism, constructivism, and behaviorism will
attempt to undergird how different contexts influence the learning path for marginalized students.
It is evident that traditional learning theories influence how the procurement of knowledge
appears differently for varying types of students. For students of color, learning does not happen
at the same rate for White students; there are several outside and influential factors that
corroborate this claim (Allen, 2007; Fosnot, 1996). The presented theories will seek to strengthen
future practices to provide a chance for all students to learn and develop within the higher
education academy.
Learning has been a tool used to understand and collect information for centuries
(Merriam and Bierema, 2014). How information is transmitted between populations is crucial for
the adult educator to understand in order to better serve diverse adult learning populations.
Everyone is engaged in the learning process. Whether the perceived role is student, teacher, tutor,
or facilitator, theory can account for how marginalized populations interact with their
environments. For example, the student in this case study is a first-generation, Black, and
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 10
transgender student entering a higher education institution. Theory will prescribe best practices
for confronting difference and tips for using personal narratives to influence continued learning.
Behaviorism and Applications. Marquardt and Waddill (2004) determine that the behaviorist
theory is focused on how individuals respond to their external environment. This theory is
described as a direct response to a behavior or activity that produces a result where a change is
necessitated. Merriam and Bierema (2014) use the example of Pavlov’s experiment with a dog
salivating when ringing a bell. Yang (2004) also concurs with Marquardt and Waddill, proposing
that the purpose of behaviorist learning is to “produce behavioral change in the desired direction
and to increase performance” (p. 138). Behaviorism is concerned with refocusing the locus of
Behaviorism and Sam. For marginalized students such as Sam, they are entering an
environment that is different from one they are accustomed. Specifically, first-generation college
students are moving into a structure that, historically, has not been built to accommodate them.
Legacy has influenced much of the higher education academy, and breaking from this norm will
be wrought with challenge. As an added layer, there is a new culture to understand within higher
education (Byrd and Macdonald, 2005). Sam may not be aware that some specific cultural and
racial practices are not accommodated in this new space. Behaviorist theory provides an outlet
for adult educators and practitioners of the higher education institution to develop best practices
for Sam. Yang (2004) concluded that behaviorist approaches in learning should keep the
individual student at the center of the practice. By this, it would be beneficial for students who
28). Throughout the development of the behaviorist approach, it has been noted that a reward is
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 11
paramount to eliciting positive results as a result of undesired behavior (Allen, 2007; Merriam
and Bierema, 2014). Creation of objectives and quickly noting what behavior is tolerated and
Objectives-centered instruction would provide Sam with clear goals and areas to achieve;
Allen (2007) describes this as a controlled setting, which can be changed and shifted depending
on what the controller deems appropriate. Sam could visit an academic advisor for course
guidance and develop set goals they wish to achieve as they enter into coursework that may be
challenging or unfamiliar. Once these goals have been achieved, a feeling or “reward” will be
offered, such as a personal treat (e.g. going for a walk, receiving a good grade, etc.). Students
with marginalized identities play host to perceived stigmas they feel they must overcome when
taking on a new role, such as becoming a college student (Eisenberg, Downs, Golberstein, Zivin,
2009), therefore it is important to give them consistent and clear sources of support.
Merriam & Bierema (2014) define humanism as a contrast to other theories, such as the
cognitive and the behaviorist approaches (p. 29); instead, humanism focuses on the whole person
and incorporates their various narratives, identities, and roles into the learning environment. To
the adult educators that wish to construct classroom and work settings in a humanist approach,
they might first consider several alternate possibilities. Those facilitating classroom discussions
may look to the establishment of teaching practices as a gauge of how the student has learned in
the past, or they integrate role-playing activities that allows the student to embrace and showcase
their own personal experiences (Spurgeon and Moore, 1997, p. 12). One example of this would
be to break the larger class group up into small discussion groups and give prompts and/or
Application of Humanist Theory. The usage of the humanist theory is crucial to Sam’s personal
journey through academia. All they have to rely on is family support and minimal resources that
are available on-campus. Humanism promotes development both inside and outside of the
classroom, with Hall (1990) noting: “We desperately need bold attempts to design and to use
programmes (sic) of study in which pupils are placed in situations where they have time and
space to become active builders of their own intellectual structures” (p. 323). Using this
approach, Sam has the ability to create their own network and direction as they navigate through
expanding on personal history and experiences, which would be welcome in a domain lacking
diversity, such as within a PWI (Hall, 1990; Spurgeon and Moore, 1997).
Humanism and Sam. Returning back to an earlier assertion, Sam’s multilayered and sundried
identities have been scrutinized and assumed via scholarly works and critical assessments (Ross-
action for Sam would manifest as opportunities for them to choose their own residence hall space
instead of being assigned based on gendered policy. Furthermore, Sam could choose classes in
which professors would work in a collaborative manner to create spaces that were both
accommodating and cooperative to Sam’s multiple identities. Cooks et al. (2002) characterize
humanistic education as the student taking charge of their learning. One form of learning that
could appeal to Sam is eLearning, or an online segment of a class that would not require physical
presence in a classroom. Sam is a first-generation college student that has to work multiple jobs
in order to afford tuition. This could offer Sam the opportunity to contribute to a class on their
own time, but still be engaged with the learning that occurs (Merriam & Bierema, 2014).
Additionally, the professor could offer Sam the opportunity to do a research project on areas
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 13
within the city that provides medical assistance for transgender individuals in the community.
Allowing Sam to connect with community resources while subsequently fully participating in
class work could serve as a great source of motivation. This approach would give Sam agency in
Fosnot and Perry (1996) found that the constructivist theory of learning stands in “direct
from the application of past experiences, such as life events or cultural practices that assist in
developing the learning trajectory (Fostnot & Perry, 1996). Essentially, constructivist approaches
to learning incorporate lived experiences and knowledge as the foci of development (Fosnot &
Perry, 1996). With this approach, students of color and other marginalized populations can bring
with them their experiences and traditions into the higher education academy.
Constructivism and Sam. Expanding on Yosso’s (2005) model of community cultural wealth,
students who are entering new environments cannot be expected to abandon their cultural and
ethnic practices. Instead, the model of cultural wealth asserts that there are specific types of
“capital” that one may possess if they are a product of a community of color (Yosso, 2005). This
capital manifests in different ways, such as familial, navigational, and linguistic (Yosso, 2005). If
one possesses navigational capital, for example, they will have experience in navigating
unfamiliar systems and structures. A constructivist approach to learning is allowing the students
to bring in various forms of capital as opposed to changing or modifying this behavior. Jonassen
(1991) offers that constructivism is rooted in the belief that learning should be developed based
on the individual’s experiences or their own reality. Especially for Sam, who is coming from a
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 14
background where race is a salient identity for them, it would provide a more comfortable
One example to incorporate Sam’s salient racial identity would be to allow them
opportunities within the curriculum to bring in personal stories and narratives. For example, if
Sam is taking a general education history course, perhaps one week could be dedicated culture
throughout history. Students could be asked to either bring an item (i.e. a dish, clothing, etc.)
from their own culture or write a reflection paper about their own cultural experiences and
provide a presentation to the class. This would allow Sam not only the creativity, but the
Sam also identifies as transgender, which is another identity that is in a literal state of
transition. Jonassen (1991) adds that while constructivism does not actively reject an external
reality, the theory does state that we all conceptualize various iterations of our own realities (p.
10). Sam’s development of their own gendered role within a predominately White, hetero-
dominant culture has been changing and this should be understood. Given these identities,
however, offering tangible resources for Sam as they navigate this new landscape they are
constructing would benefit their development. It would be optimal if student affairs professionals
provided mentors for students like Sam, so they feel as if they have partners as they engage in
their learning path. These mentors could provide resources to the community and how to
navigate the challenges of college. These mentors could be other student affairs professionals,
upperclassman students, or members from the community. As Sam moves into their residence
hall space, the constructivist theory of learning would likely surmise that Sam become engaged
in activities that are pertinent to their salient identities. While this could be overwhelming,
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 15
Merriam and Bierema (2014) described discomfort with change is necessary, especially when
students within the higher education academy to understand how differences in learning impact
individuals. In this case study, behaviorism for students of color and marginalized populations
presents opportunities to modify learned behaviors and challenge established actions. Likewise,
humanism focuses on the totality of experiences that shape a person; this holistic picture helps to
inform more authentic styles of learning. Finally, constructivist approaches posit that, while in
the individual. These three theories imply that students from marginalized backgrounds are
bringing with them various experiences and narratives that could potentially counter the
dominant culture’s expectations. For student affairs practitioners and adult educators, acting as
an agent of inclusion for these ideas will provide a vehicle for mobility and advancement for
students of color. For this case study, student affairs professionals are charged with the task of
clearing all barriers that may prevent students from achieving success. Application of these three
distinct traditional learning theories can prescribe concrete steps for how to begin dissolving
these barriers.
The purpose of this analysis is to examine how Sam perceives challenges to learning at a
PWI. The institution that Sam is attending is a public, 4-year, land grant establishment and is the
largest in the state, with roughly 40,000 students in attendance. A close model of this would be
Given that the university is public, it is directly impacted by both state and federal laws
and policy, along with structural hierarchies. Politics plays a major role in how establishments of
higher education receive funding, including the participation of alumni constituents. While Sam
is emerging into this setting, they may also face barriers to learning such as no sense of
belonging, lack of institutional support, and minimal resources for transgender health care and
representation. These barriers critically affect how Sam is able to feel safe and secure, and thus
Strayhorn (2008) notes that while enrollment numbers for many races have increased
over the last decade, the reason why Black students (namely, Black men) depart from college is
due to a lack of “sense of belonging” (p. 502). These feelings are compounded at PWIs, because
Black individuals feel that they are constantly “alienated or unsupported” (Strayhorn, 2008, p.
502). For Sam, this could be a similar issue and could result in them potentially withdrawing or
choosing not to continue their education. Allen (1992) posits that highest levels of achievement
for Black students on predominantly White campuses reside with students who feel that they
made the correct institutional choice. If Sam is at the mercy of an institution that is not providing
opportunities for Black students, then they may feel a disconnect with their choice and question
if they should be there. Additionally, Black students at PWIs have remarked lower levels of
social involvement over all (Allen, 1992). This corroborates Strayhorn’s assertion that Black men
may feel lessened senses of motivation if the institution does not reflect them or their identities.
It is important to note that while at PWIs, Black students are in the process of
restructuring their self-identities and choices (Brooms & Davis, 2017; Yosso, 2005). Up until this
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 17
point, Sam has been surrounded by people that look like them and can share similar experiences.
Without this support, it may be difficult for them to connect with, and understand, the
highlights that an understanding of an institution’s mission and objectives can create a stronger
connection to an educational establishment, and thus could promote learning and enhance
motivation. Given this, it would be beneficial if student affairs professionals hosted workshop
sessions within common spaces, such as within residence halls, that allowed students to write
what they think the university’s mission statement means. They could leave this feedback and the
professionals could consider this an informal assessment on how students perceive the
university’s mission and vision. Patton et al. (2016) underscore the importance of having this
strong connection to the institution, because it increases motivation for continued learning and
mission could help build their knowledge and provide them opportunities to provide their own
input.
The university that Sam attends is composed of 40,000 students. For example, at the
University of Washington, Seattle, only 2.7% of the population identifies as Black or African
American (“Office of Multicultural Affairs & Diversity Fact Sheet”, 2016). For the institution in
this case study, Sam does not see a reflection of their identities on the campus, nor do the campus
administrators see the need for “diversity” programs. Harper (2007) documents that changing
role of institutions supporting students of color throughout the twentieth century. The success
and permanency of programs catering to students of color have depended on the laws from
federal agencies. African American and Black students have been systematically barred from
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 18
achieving higher education in the United States due to calculated policy and political acts. This
creates a disconnection for Sam, who may develop fatigue in response to facing constant
Public institutions are also susceptible to criticism from donations from alumni
(Manning, 2012). Programs that offer support for students of color, first-generation, or other
marginalized identities could lose funding from donors that disagree with the purpose of their
use. This could, in turn, stifle Sam’s growth and comfort with their identities. Learning is not
simply a cognitive action; it is influenced by the personal and self-development of the student
(Pizzolato, 2003). Political and institutional factors collaborate to create dire consequences, such
as loss of funding for programs that assist students of color, which could inevitably erode
It is important to note that Pizzolato’s (2003) research affirmed that in order to address
the lack of support, students must have a sense of who they are and what they want to achieve.
For Sam, who feels that the university and climate of the campus is no longer supporting them, it
would be important for the student affairs practitioner to network Sam and students holding
similar identities and introduce them to professionals that may closely mirror these identities.
This will get them involved in the university’s climate so they can understand exactly what is
happening from the inside and they would have a way to articulate their goals for what they want
to change. Pizzolato (2003) describes the confusion students have when they are attempting to
create space for themselves without proper understanding of what it is they want to achieve or
change.
It is important for the health and safety of students be maintained in order to hold a sense
of trust within the institution. If Sam cannot acquire the appropriate resources for their specific
transgender identity, then they may be forced out of the institution and must discontinue their
learning. Keuroghlian, Ard, and Makadon (2017) offer the solution that clinical trainees
(especially on college campuses) should be taught to use the correct gender pronouns as a way to
create patient comfort; additionally, it would assist for practitioners to be aware of the gender-
affirmation process for students. However, if an institution is not transgender-friendly, there may
not be a move to provide safe and equitable health care for students.
Woodford et al. (2017) have determined that transgender students experience several
forms of microaggressions on college campuses. For example, the lack of gender neutral
restrooms within Sam’s residence hall could be a form of a microaggression, because they are
being forced to share a space that is not one they identify with. It would also be detrimental to
the development of transgender students if they were not included on campus climate surveys
and assessments. According to Woodford et al. (2017), transgender students are normally
forgotten on these very important pieces of policy used to inform campus climate. If a population
is never included on an assessment, then there will never be active steps taken to remedy trauma
and maltreatment. Craig et al. (2017) reveal that most transgender students were forced to
acknowledge unfriendly policies during orientation sessions on their first day of their institution.
This creates a picture that, from the immediate start, the institution is in no way ready to
Returning to a previous assertion in this analysis, it would benefit Sam to get involved
with the community to find resources for medical assistance. Sam could consult with a professor
to do a research project on the types of medical assistance for transgender individuals. Craig et
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 20
al. (2017) determine that these policies that frequently forget about trans students can be
remedied if trans students get involved to change the culture of exclusion. This is an opportunity
for Sam to make deliberate attempts to engage in a meaningful way. Student affairs professionals
could connect Sam with faculty and other university staff that may have resources in the
community. For example, at Seattle University, there is a Health and Wellness Center that
liaisons with community groups to discuss sexual health and wellbeing. Connecting Sam with
groups that hold similar roles would better prepare students with these diverse needs on how to
Predominantly White institutions, while very prominent, are often at the mercy of other
forces outside of their control. For public universities, they play host to political and economic
players that influence every level of the structure. Higher education is represented by many
different forms of hierarchy that can produce unfavorable results for student populations.
Whether students are first-generation, Black, or transgender, there stands to be a loss if any of
these identities are not accepted and celebrated. It is the adult educator’s duty to help inform and
understand their student constituencies to deliver the most equitable and safe practice.
Conclusion
Adult learning is composed of many different forms, theories, and models. Development
is not static and is empowered by several factors—some of which may be beyond control. Sam
has begun a process that many in their position never get to experience. With this, they must face
the challenges of feeling isolated and out of place. However, through the use of intentional and
deliberate use of available resources and faculties, Sam will be able to create a space that is safe
for them to grow and learn. Learning is a continuous process that will manifest in numerous
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 21
ways. Sam has the opportunity to take advantage of these possibilities to begin a new and
exciting adventure.
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 22
References
Review, 7, 26-37.
predominantly white and historical black colleges and universities. Harvard Educational
Barger, M. (2015, June 27). I Love You. Please Don't Leave Me: Erikson's Psychosocial Stages
https://www.psych2go.net/i-love-you-please-dont-leave-me-eriksons-psychosocial-
stages-of-development-intimacy-vs-isolation/
Beemyn, B., Curtis, B., Davis, M., & Tubbs, N. J. (2005). Transgender issues on college
Brooms, D. R., & Davis, A. R. (2017). Stay focused on the goal . Journal of Black Studies, 48(3),
305-326. doi:10.1177/0021934717692520
Byrd, K. L., & Macdonald, G. (2005). Defining college readiness from the inside out: First-
doi:10.1177/009155210503300102
Chávez, A. F., & Guido-Dibrito, F. (1999). Racial and ethnic identity and development. New
Cooks, A., Hackney, D., Jackson, S.G., Stevens, C. & Zumwalt, D. (2002). A humanistic
Craig, S. L., Austin, A., Rashidi, M., & Adams, M. (2017). Fighting for survival: The
colleges and universities. Journal of Gay & Lesbian Social Services,29(1), 1-24.
doi:10.1080/10538720.2016.1260512
Crain, W. (2011). Theories of development: Concepts and applications (6th ed.). Upper Saddle
Cross, W. (1995). In Search of Blackness and Afrocentricity: The Psychology of Black Identity
Cross, W. E., Jr., Parham, T. A., & Helms, J. E. (1991). The stages of Black identity
development: Nigrescence models. In R. L. Jones (Ed.), Black psychology (3rd ed., pp.
Diversity Statistics & Policies. (n.d.). Retrieved June 04, 2017, from
http://www.washington.edu/diversity/diversity-statistics-policies/
Eisenberg, D., Downs, M. F., Golberstein, E., & Zivin, K. (2009). Stigma and help seeking for
mental health among college students. Medical Care Research and Review, 66(5), 522-
541. doi:10.1177/1077558709335173
Perspectives, edited by L. Allman and D. Jaffe, pp. 3–11. New York: Harper &
Row, 1977.
http://swppr.org/Textbook/Ch%209%20Erikson.pdf
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 24
Constructivism: Theory, perspectives, and practice (pp. 21–40). New York: Teachers
College Press.
Gibbons, M. M., Rhinehart, A., & Hardin, E. (2016). How first-generation college students
adjust to college . Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice.
doi:10.1177/1521025116682035
Hall, D. (1990) The national curriculum and the two cultures: Towards a humanistic perspective,
doi:10.1007/bf02296434
Keuroghlian, A. S., Ard, K. L., & Makadon, H. J. (2017). Advancing health equity for lesbian,
gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people through sexual health education and
doi:10.1071/sh16145
Kroger, J. (1997). "Gender and identity: The intersection of structure, content, and context." Sex
Mael, F., & Ashforth, B. E. (1992). Alumni and their alma mater: A partial test of the
Manning, K. (2013). Organizational theory in higher education. New York, NY: Routledge.
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 25
Marquardt, M., & Waddill, D. (2004). The power of learning in action learning: A conceptual
analysis of how the five schools of adult learning theories are incorporated within the
practice of action learning. Action Learning: Research and Practice, 1(2), 185-202.
doi:10.1080/1476733042000264146
Merriam, S. B., & Bierema, L. L. (2014). Adult learning: linking theory and practice. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Murg, W. (2011, June 06). Momentum Mounts to Again Embrace two-spirits. Retrieved April 20,
embrace-two-spirits/
Pappano, L. (2015, April 08). First-generation students unite. Retrieved June 2, 2017, from
https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/12/education/edlife/first-generation-students-
unite.html?mcubz=0&_r=0
Patton, L. D., Renn, K. A., Guido-DiBrito, F., & Quaye, S. J. (2016). Student development in
college: theory, research, and practice. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, A Wiley Brand.
doi:10.1353/csd.2003.0074
0167.54.3.259
Reid, M. J., & Moore, J. L. (2008). College readiness and academic preparation for
added-pressure-faced-by-first-generation-students/384139/
Spurgeon, L. P., & Moore, G. E. (1997). The educational philosophies of training and
Strayhorn, T. L. (2009). Fittin in: Do diverse interactions with peers affect sense of belonging for
black men at predominantly white institutions? Journal of Student Affairs Research and
doi:10.1177/2378023116664351
Woodford, M. R., Joslin, J. Y., Pitcher, E. N., & Renn, K. A. (2017). A mixed-methods inquiry
doi:10.1080/15313204.2016.1263817
Yang, B. (2004). Can adult learning theory provide a foundation for human resource
doi:10.1177/1523422304263325
TRANSGENDER, BLACK, AND FIRST-GENERATION 27
Yosso, T. J. (2005). Whose culture has capital? A critical race theory discussion of community
doi:10.1080/1361332052000341006