Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 7

Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104

Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect

Energy Conversion and Management


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/enconman

Exergy analyses in cement production applying waste


fuel and mineralizer
Maria Luiza Grillo Renó a,⇑, Felipe Martins Torres a, Rogério José da Silva a,
José Joaquim Conceição Soares Santos b, Mirian de Lourdes Noronha Motta Melo a
a
Federal University of Itajubá, Av. BPS 1303, CP 50, Itajubá, MG, Brazil
b
Federal University of Espírito Santo, Av. Ferando Ferrari 514, Vitória, ES, Brazil

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The cement industry is an energy-intensive industry and emits large quantities of carbon dioxide, so
Received 24 May 2012 waste fuels could usefully substitute part of the fossil fuels. They can also help resolve air pollution prob-
Accepted 22 May 2013 lems associated with the use of fossil fuels. Other wastes have properties of reducing the thermal energy
consumption of clinker production. They are named mineralizers. Then the application of both in the
cement industry contributes to the reduction of environmental liabilities and provides lower cost of
Keywords: acquisition of fossil fuels. The aim of the present study is confirm the advantages of the application of
Cement production
waste SPL (spent pot lining) as a mineralizer in clinker production from an exergetic viewpoint.
Mineralizer
Waste fuel
Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Exergy analysis

1. Introduction temperatures – 1450 °C) inside rotary kilns of raw materials (lime-
stone, clay, sand, iron ore). The next steps are the cooling of the
Industrial growth is accompanied by a growth in waste produc- clinker, grinding the clinker with gypsum and other additives to
tion. This is a challenge to overcome and has been an environmen- produce cement and finally storing, packaging and transporting
tal problem in recent years, mainly for the industries that generate the cement to the end user [4,5]. The use of wastes in the cement
hazardous residues. According to the Brazilian Association of industry has another important advantage, which is the property of
Waste Treatment Companies [1], 2.9 million tons of hazardous mineralizing some wastes. Their incorporation in small propor-
industrial wastes are generated annually in Brazil. Only 600 tions improves the clinkering conditions as well as decreasing
thousand tons (about 22%) receive appropriate treatment. The the maximum clinkering temperature, or improves the phase
remaining 78% are deposited in landfill without treatment [1]. formation in the clinker without altering the final properties of
Brazil, for example, in 2010 produced 67.3 million units of tyres the product [6].
[2] that are incorrectly classified as useless and cause negative One waste applied as mineralizer is the SPL (spent pot lining)
impacts on the environment and serious problems for public originating from the aluminum industry, whose properties allow
health. One alternative for waste tyres is to burn them in the rotary the clinkering temperature to be reduced by up to 80 °C [7]. With
kilns of the cement industry, in this way recovering the energy this advantage this work selected this mineralizer, and an exergy
from the tyres and simultaneously promoting a thermal treatment analysis of clinker production was computed based on the second
of the waste. In 2008, 32 million waste tyres were burned in ce- law of thermodynamics. This analysis identified the exergy losses
ment plants [3]. and irreversibility, producing suggestions on how the process
The cement industry has characteristics that make the burning could be improved [8]. At the end of the present study, the exergy
of wastes viable, since it is characterized by high energy thermal efficiencies of each stage of clinker production are compared.
consumption due mainly to the high temperatures necessary to
produce the clinker which is the main component of the cement,
1.1. Exergy analysis in cement industry
and it is responsible for its hydraulic properties. The clinker is
obtained from the grinding, homogenization and burning (high
In the literature, there are many works that have applied exergy
analysis for the cement industry. For example, the work [9]
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +55 3536291493. reviewed exergy analysis, exergy balance and exergetic efficiencies
E-mail addresses: malureno@yahoo.com.br (M.L.G. Renó), betinho.torres@
for the cement industry. The results showed that exergy efficiency
yahoo.com.br (F.M. Torres), rogeriojs@unifei.edu.br (R.J. da Silva), jose.j.santos@ remains lower than 26% and the main source of irreversibility in
ufes.br (J.J.C.S. Santos), mirianmottamelo@unifei.edu.br (M.de.L.N.M. Melo). the cement industry is the rotary kiln where the pyro-process

0196-8904/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2013.05.043
M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104 99

occurs. Pyro-processing also accounts for the major share of the to- the organic part of the waste and the material value from the min-
tal energy use (93–99% in some cases). Thus the use of alternative eral part of the waste are also important [17].
fuels or waste heat recovery could be important for future research Another aspect is the influence of the use of alternative fuels on
and development [10]. the clinker properties. The burning behavior of most alternative
The work [11] examined heat recovery from the rotary kiln at a fuels differs significantly from the behavior of fossil fuels due to
cement plant in Turkey. First, an exergy analysis was carried out higher particle sizes and different material densities and transport
based on the operational data of the plant. The results indicated characteristics. This can change the temperature profile of the kiln,
the presence of 217.31 GJ of waste heat, which is 51% of the overall including the sintering temperature, the length of the sintering
heat of the process. Then a mathematical model was developed for zone and the cooling conditions. All of these changes can affect
a new heat recovery exchanger for the plant. It was determined different clinker characteristics like the burning grade of the clin-
that 5% of the waste heat can be utilized with the heat recovery ker, the porosity of the granules, the crystal size of the clinker
exchanger. This system is expected to reduce domestic coal and phases or their reactivity [18].
natural gas consumption by 51.55% and 62.62% respectively. CO2 The work [19] found that the addition of different types of
emissions may also be reduced by 5901.94 kg/h and 1816.90 kg/h waste fuels requires an excellent control of the temperature in
when waste heat is used instead of coal and natural gas. the clinkering zone, because even slightly exceeding the required
The work [12] performed energy and exergy analyses of a coal- temperature would excessively fluidize the clinker and might
preparation unit in a cement plant and investigated the effect of cause damage to the refractory lining of the furnace.
varying dead state (ambient) temperatures on exergy efficiency. Currently, a wide range of hazardous waste materials may be
The mean values of energy and exergy efficiencies of the unit were co-processed, such as rubber residues, pulp sludge, used tyres,
found to be 74.03% and 21.36% respectively, while the average plastic residues, wood waste and more. There are also hazardous
potential improvement of the unit was calculated as 78.24%. The liquid wastes such as tar, chemical wastes, distillation residues,
analyses also demonstrated that the exergy destruction ratio waste solvents, used oils, wax suspension, and oil sludge [20].
affected the CO2 emission rate of the unit. The technique can there- Examples of waste which is not suitable for co-processing in the
fore be a tool used for the purpose of developing energy policies cement industry include nuclear waste, infectious medical waste,
and providing energy conservation measures, especially concern- entire batteries and untreated mixed municipal waste. Thus, the
ing similar types of industrial processes. co-processing needs an adequate quality control system for all
The raw mill in a cement production plant has also been inves- materials used. This ensures that they are co-processed in an envi-
tigated in relation to exergy analysis. The work [13] performed an ronmentally safe and sound manner, safeguarding the [21]:
energy and exergy analysis of a raw mill and raw materials prepa-
ration. The results obtained for the energy and exergy efficiency of 1. Health and safety of the workers in the plant and the people
the raw mill were 84.3% and 25.2% respectively. The results identi- living in the neighborhoods.
fied heat losses by conduction; convection and radiation from the 2. Environmental impact of the production process.
surface of the raw mill were about 14,300 MJ/h, which indicates an 3. High quality of the final product.
energy recovery of 15.70% of the total input energy into the raw 4. Correct and undisturbed functioning of the production
mill. The work [14] also studied the raw mill, especially the effects process.
of ambient air temperature and the moisture content of raw mate-
rials on the performance of the raw mill. The results showed that Due to the danger inherent in some wastes, in Brazil there is a
an external hot gas supply provides a 6.7% reduction in energy con- system of federal agencies designed to ensure the efficacy of envi-
sumption, corresponding to a saving of 1.66 kW h per ton of farine ronmental legislation. The main Federal Standards controlling
production. emissions from cement kilns are Resolution CONAMA 264/1999,
which provides the procedures and the specific criteria of co-incin-
1.2. Co-processing (waste fuel) eration, and Resolution CONAMA 316/2002, which sets out the
procedures and criteria for the operation of waste treatment
The cement industry has one of the most intensive energy con- systems [22].
sumptions. For example, to produce one ton of cement, it is neces- In Brazil, the waste fuels are exploited by the cement industry
sary to use 60–130 kg of fuel and 110 kW of electricity [15]. Due to using a co-processing technique that has been used in Brazil since
the large consumption of energy, which represents over 30% of the the 1990s. The co-processing has the following characteristics dur-
total production cost for the cement industry, the reduction in ing the production process [23]:
spending on energy inputs is a motivation for technological ad-
vances in the production process. – The alkaline conditions and the intensive mixing favor the
In this context, the burning of waste materials in cement kilns absorption of volatile components from the gas phase. This
represents a ‘‘win–win’’ situation. The cement manufacturer wins internal gas cleaning results in low emissions of components
because kiln fuel costs are dramatically reduced by replacing such as SO2 and HCl.
primary fuel from the kiln with waste material and potentially – The clinker reactions at 1450 °C allow incorporation of ashes
earning disposal fees from waste generators for treating the waste and chemical binding of metals to the clinker.
in the kiln. In the co-processing, hazardous waste is not only
destroyed at a higher temperature (around 1450 °C), with a long In 2008, approximately one million tons of industrial wastes
residence time (retention time up to 8 s), alkali combustion mate- were co-processed in cement kilns. 44% of the wastes were em-
rial, and an oxidizing atmosphere [16], but its inorganic content is ployed as substitutes for raw materials, 39.4% were applied as fuels
fixed with the clinker, quite apart from using the energy of the in the kiln, and 16.6% were tyres. In the period 2001–2006, 40
waste. million tyres were sent for use by the cement industry [24].
The decision on what type of substance to use is based on the
clinker production processes, the raw material and fuel composi- 1.3. Mineralizer and spent pot lining (SPL)
tions, the feeding points, the air pollution control devices and the
waste management problems involved. Certain kinds of waste Mineralizers have been applied in the cement industry for
must be dried and pulverized. In addition, the calorific value from years, with the purpose of reducing thermal energy consumption
100 M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104

without altering the final properties of the product. For example, It is important to take into account that in the cement industry
the mineralizing properties of the compounds CaF2 and CaSO4 have it is usual to burn 60% of the fuels inside the calciner (including all
already been described in the literature. It has been confirmed that waste fuel) and the remaining 40% inside the rotary kiln. So these
the combined addition of CaF2 and CaSO4 to raw materials results considerations were also included in this study.
in a decrease of the maximum clinkering temperature to approxi-
mately 1350 °C. This temperature reduction by 100 °C is expected 2.1. Calculation of solids exergy
to result in a fuel saving of 80–100 kcal/kg clinker [25,6].
The other potential mineralizer is the SPL, which is a solid res- The solids exergy of the raw material and clinker were calcu-
idue of the aluminum industry that presents fluoride and cyanide lated according to the following equation [32]:
compounds, which are classified as hazardous waste of group 1, X
n
o
according to ABNT NBR 10004/04. The chemical composition of Bs ¼ nms bMs þ  ½ðh  h0 Þ  T o ðs  so Þk ð1Þ
the SPL is presented in Table 1. k
The amount of SPL generated in modern industrial plants is
where Bs is the solids exergy (kJ/s), nms is the number of moles of the
around 20–30 kg/ton aluminum [27]. The particular characteristics o
solid mix, bMs is the total chemical exergy of the mixture (kJ s), nk is
of this hazardous waste have consumed a lot of investment and
the number of moles of each component k, h and s are the enthalpy
research to find solutions that are economically and environmen-
(kJ/kg) and entropy (kJ/kg K) of chemical compounds, respectively,
tally acceptable, but no satisfactory solution has yet been found.
h0 and s0 are the enthalpy and entropy of chemical compounds in
The incineration of SPL waste in cement kilns is an alternative
standard condition and T0 is the standard conditions of temperature
to its destruction. The SPL has a calorific value that may partially
(K).
replace the fuel supply of the system, besides acting as a mineral-
The variation of enthalpy (h  h0) and entropy (s  s0) of chem-
izer of the clinker, providing a fuel saving without changing the
ical compounds of clinker and raw material can be computed
physico-chemical properties of the final product [7,28].
according to the temperature, as in the following equations:
This is due to the fluxing property of the fluoride found in the
SPL composition, which lowers the melting point in the clinkering h  h0 ¼ ðA  T þ B  T 2  103 þ C  T 1  105 þ DÞ  4:186 ð2Þ
process. The reduction observed in the process at Cimento Poty S/A

was approximately 80 °C (from 1450 °C to 1370 °C). With the drop T
s  so ¼ A  ln þ 2  B  103  ðT  T o Þ
in temperature it was noted that the heat consumption of the kiln To
dropped on average 10 kcal/kg of clinker produced [29]. ! !
C 1 1
þ  105   þ D  4:186 ð3Þ
2 T 2 T 2o
2. Exergetic analysis of clinker production where A, B, C and D are constants obtained from Refs. [33–35], T is
the temperature of the clinker and raw material, T0 is the standard
The exergy is a property that determines the useful work poten- conditions of temperature (298.15 K).
tial of a given amount of energy in a specific state [30]. More
broadly, one can say that exergy is the capacity to do work. Exclud- 2.2. Calculation of gases exergy
ing electric, magnetic, nuclear effects and interfaces, the total exer-
gy of a substance is the sum of kinetic exergy, potential exergy, The gases exergy is calculated using Eq. (4) below [32]:
physical exergy and chemical exergy. Clinker production includes o
X
thermal and chemical processes, so the emphasis will be on Bg ¼ nmg bMg þ ðT g  T o Þ  ðngk  C bgk Þ ð4Þ
k
thermal exergy, which is the sum of physical and chemical exergy
[31].
The analyzed system of clinker production comprises a pre-hea-
ter (with four stages), a calciner, a rotary kiln and a cooler, as
shown in Fig. 1. Thus, the system was divided into four control vol-
umes (pre-heater, calciner, rotary kiln and cooler) for the purpose
of calculating the exergy flows of solids and gases, as soon as the
exergy destroyed.

Table 1
Chemical composition of the SPL waste [26].

Composition % mass
C 46.5
Na2O 20.2
Al2O3 10.5
CaO 7.6
SiO2 2.5
S 0.82
Fe2O3 0.71
K2O 0.45
TiO2 0.11
MgO 0.10
SrO 0.03
Cl 0.03
P2O5 0.02
ZrO2 0.01
F 10.3
CN 0.12
Fig. 1. Control volumes of the clinker production.
M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104 101

Table 2 3. Case studies


Composition of raw material.

Component % mass The composition of the raw material considered for this study is
CaCO3 75.214 shown in Table 2. For computing the composition of the chemical
SiO2 12.79 components in kmol/s, it was considered that the production of
Al2O3 3.44 clinker is 34.72 kg/s and the production of 1 kg clinker requires
Fe2O3 1.86
1.56 kg of raw material for a cement plant operating as a dry
MgCO3 3.57
SO3 0.92 process (based on real data on the Brazilian cement industry).
Na2O 0.03 Therefore, the cement plant consumes approximately 54.16 kg
K2O 0.8 raw material/s.
With respect to the fuel supply, two case studies are considered.
In Case Study 1, 30% of the energy needed for the production of
clinker is provided by petroleum coke, 20% by charcoal, 23.6% by
Table 3 coal and 26.4% by wastes (scrap tyres (20%) and SPL (6.4%)). On
Chemical composition and LHV of the fuels and wastes applied in clinker production
[36–38,31,26].
the other hand, in Case Study 2 has 30% of petroleum coke, 20%
of charcoal, 30% of coal and 20% of scrap tyres.
Composition Petroleum Scrap SPL Charcoal Mineral The chemical composition and the lower heating value (LHV) of
coke tyres coal
the fuels used in the analysis of this study are given in Table 3.
Carbon 81.32 74.30 46.50 71.91 70.12 It was estimated that burning in the kiln occurs with 1.7% of
Hydrogen 2.87 7.20 0 4.20 4.51
Sulfur 6.02 1.71 0.82 – 1.28
free oxygen, and in the calciner it follows with 2.4% of free oxygen
Oxygen 0.45 15.89 0 11.36 1.13 (medium value of the cement industry). The specific heat con-
Nitrogen 0.88 0.90 0 1.11 2.25 sumption in the system when the SPL mineralizer is applied is
Water 8.00 – 0 7.80 0.85 around 3558 kJ/kg (Case Study 1), according to [29]. Usually the
Ash 0.46 – 0 3.62 19.86
cement industry presents a specific heat consumption of around
LHV (kJ/kg) 31,750 30,500 2720 27,900 26,928
3600 kJ/kg (Case Study 2) [39].

where Bg (kJ/s) is the gases exergy, nmg is the number of moles of the 4. Results
o
mixture of gases, bMg is the chemical exergy of the mixture (com-
puted as Eq. (5)), Tg is the gases temperature (K), T0 is the standard To compute the exergy flows of raw materials and clinker pro-
conditions of temperature, ngk is the number of moles of each gas of duced, it is necessary to take into account that the raw materials
the mixture. C bgk takes into consideration the enthalpy and entropy mix enters the kiln and is continuously and slowly moved to the
between the temperature range, as computed by Eq. (7): lower end by rotation of the kiln, and the raw material then reacts
X X at very high temperatures to form 3CaOSiO2 (C3S), 2CaOSiO2
o o
bM g ¼ ðygk  bgk Þ þ R  T o ðygk  lnygk Þ ð5Þ (C2S), 3CaOAl2O3 (C3A) and 4CaOAl2O3Fe2O3 (C4AF). The main
k k chemical reaction in the formation of clinker is presented below
From Eq. (5), ygk is the molar fraction of the gas, bgk is the stan-
o [40]:
dard chemical exergy (kJ/kmol), defined in the following equation 2CaO þ SiO2 ! ðCaOÞ2 SiO2 ð8Þ
[35]:
o
X CaOAl2 O3 þ 2CaO ! ðCaOÞ3 Al2 O3 ð9Þ
b g k ¼ DG o þ E0el ð6Þ

where DGo is the standard molar Gibbs function of formation (kJ/ CaOAl2 O3 þ 3CaO þ Fe2 O3 ! ðCaOÞ4 Al2 O3 Fe2 O3 ð10Þ
kmol) and E0el the standard chemical exergy of the constituent ele-
ments (kJ/kmol). ðCaOÞ2 SiO2 þ CaO ! ðCaOÞ3 SiO2 ð11Þ
Z Tg Z Tg 
1 dT From these compounds, C3S and C3A are mainly responsible for
C bgk ¼ cpk dT  T 0 cpk ð7Þ the strength of the cement. High percentages of C3S (low C2S) re-
Tg  T0 T0 T0 T
sult in high early strength but also high heat generation as the con-
From Eq. (7), cpk is the specific isobaric heat capacity (kJ/kmol K) crete sets. The reverse combination of low C3S and high C2S

Table 4
Exergy flows of gases and solids: Case Study 1 and Case Study 2.

Case Study 1 Case Study 2


Flux Temperature (°C) Exergy (kJ/s) Flux Temperature (°C) Exergy (kJ/s)
1 60 8483 1 60 8483
2 660 24,423 2 660 24,423
3 800 52,249 3 800 52,249
4 1643.15 66,464 4 1723.15 69,102
5 120 36,835 5 120 36,835
6 350 20,189 6 350 19,993
7 820 46,850 7 820 46,264
8 1000 22,062 8 1000 22,234
9 764 14,063 9 764 13,590
10 25 74,120 10 25 74,995
11 25 49,413 11 25 49,997
12 1115 10,651 12 1115 10,774
102 M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104

Fig. 2. Grassmann Diagram of clinker production – Case Study 1.

develops strength more slowly (over 52 rather than 28 days) and Na2 O þ SO2 þ 0:5O2 ! Na2 SO4 ð15Þ
generates less heat. C3A causes undesirable heat and rapid reaction
properties, which can be prevented by adding CaSO4 to the final
product [31]. K2 O þ SO2 þ 0:5O2 ! K2 SO4 ð16Þ
Other compounds are formed: for example, the sulfur dioxide
that originates from raw material and fossil fuel burning may react
CaO þ SO2 þ 0:5O2 ! CaSO4 ð17Þ
with compounds of calcium, sodium and potassium contained in
the raw materials, according to Eqs. (13)–(18), generating products The equations from Sections 2.1 and 2.2 were used to compute
that are incorporated into the clinker [41]. the exergy flows from the gases and solids presented in Fig. 1. The
CaCO3 þ SO2 ! CaSO3 þ CO2 ð12Þ results are shown in Table 4.
From the exergy flows of Table 4 it was possible to plot the
CaO þ SO2 ! CaSO3 ð13Þ Grassmann diagrams related to the process (Fig. 2 (Case Study 1)
and Fig. 3 (Case Study 2)), where the exergy destroyed (ED) of four
CaSO3 þ 0:5O2 ! CaSO4 ð14Þ control volumes (pre-heater, calciner, rotary kiln and cooler) is
computed.

Fig. 3. Grassmann Diagram of clinker production – Case Study 2.


M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104 103

Table 5 References
Exergetic efficiency of Case Study 1 and Case Study 2.

Case Study 1 Case Study 2 [1] ABETRE, Brazilian Association of Waste Treatment; 2003. <http://
abetre.org.br> [accessed 04.06.12, in Portuguese].
Exergetic efficiency 0.298 0.294 [2] ANIP, National Association of Manufacturers of Tyres; 2012. <http://
www.anip.com.br> [accessed 02.05.12, in Portuguese].
[3] SNIC, National Union of the Cement Industry, Press Kit 2011; 2011. <http://
www.snic.org.br> [accessed 03.05.12, in Portuguese].
From Figs. 2 and 3, the results indicate that the rotary kiln and [4] Ferreti J. Cement manufacturing plant guidelines – an approach to reconciling
the financing of cement manufacturing plants with climate change objectives.
calciner present more irreversibility (as [9]), and approximately
Document of, the Inter-American Development Bank; 2010.
30% and 47% of total exergy was destroyed respectively in the [5] Tripathy SC, Roy MC, Balasubramanian R. Energy auditing kit for cement
two case studies. The main causes are calcination reactions inside industries. Energy Convers Manage 1992;33:1073–8.
[6] Giménez-Molina S, Blanco-Varela MT. Solid state phases relationship in the
the calciner, as well as heat loss through the wall of the kiln and
CaO–SiO, Al2O, CaF2–CaSO4 system. Cem Concr Res 1995;25:870–82.
clinkerization reactions. The total exergy destroyed was [7] Pawlek RP. Spent pot lining: an update. Light Metals 2012:1313–7.
2157 kW/kg clinker in Case Study 1 and 2208 kW/kg clinker in [8] Zhang Y, Feng J, Xu J, Zhang Y, Yang J. Energy and exergy analyses of a mixed
Case Study 2. This result proves the advantage of using the SPL fuel-fired grate-kiln for iron ore pellet induration. Energy Convers Manage
2011;52:2064–71.
mineralizer. [9] Madlool NA, Saidur R, Rahim NA, Islam MR, Hossian MS. An exergy analysis for
To compute the exergetic efficiency of both case studies it was cement industries: an overview. Renew Sustain Rev 2012;16:921–32.
used the concept presented in [9] was used, which corresponds to [10] Madlool NA, Saidur R, Hossian MS, Rahim NA. A critical review on energy use
and savings in the cement industries. Renew Sustain Rev 2011;15:2042–60.
the following equation: [11] Sögüt Z, Oktay Z, Karakoç H. Mathematical modeling of heat recovery from a
rotary kiln. Appl Therm Eng 2010;30:817–25.
Desired exergetic effect Product [12] Sögüt Z, Oktay Z, Karakoç H, Hepbasli A. Investigation of environmental and
g¼ ¼ ð18Þ
Exergy used to drive the process Fuel exergetic performance for coal-preparation units in cement production
process. Energy 2012;46:72–7.
Applying Eq. (18) in the case studies, in which the product is the [13] Utlu Z, Sogut Z, Hepbasli A, Oktay Z. Energy and exergy analyses of a raw mill
clinker formation exergy, and the fuel is the sum of the exergy in a cement production. Appl Therm Eng 2006;26:2479–89.
[14] Atmaca A, Kanoglu M. Reducing energy consumption of a raw mill in cement
content of the fuels and waste fuels used. The result is shown in industry. Energy 2012;42:261–9.
Table 5. [15] Lamas WQ, Palau JCF, Camargo JR. Waste materials co-processing in cement
The values of exergetic efficiency are similar to the values com- industry: ecological efficiency of waste reuse. Renew Sustain Energy Rev
2013;19:200–7.
puted in the work [12]. Despite the small difference between the [16] Mokrzycki E, Uliasz-Bochénczyk A, Sarna M. Use of alternative fuels in the
exergetic efficiencies of the two case studies, the case study that Polish cement industry. Appl Energy 2003;74:101–11.
employed SPL reduced the fossil fuel consumption by 0.20 kg/s. [17] Ottoboni AP, Souza I, Menon GJ, Silva RJ. Efficiency of destruction of waste used
in the co-incineration in the rotary kilns. Energy Convers Manage
For an industry operating 24 h, this corresponds to a reduction of 1998;39:1899–909.
17.32 t/day of fossil fuel. From the economic point of view, this [18] Schneider M, Romer M, Tschudin M, Bolio H. Sustainable cement production –
would be a great advantage. present and future. Cem Concr Res 2011;41:642–50.
[19] Trezza MA, Scian AN. Waste fuels: their effect on Portland cement clinker. Cem
Another way of improving the exergetic efficiency would be by
Concr Res 2005;35:438–44.
recovering the waste heat from hot gases and hot kiln surfaces [20] Kääntee U, Zevenhoven R, Backman R, Hupa M. Cement manufacturing using
[42]. According to Sogut et al. [43], the use of energy recovery alternative fuels and the advantages of process modelling. Fuel Process
systems improves the exergy efficiency values by approximately Technol 2004;85:293–301.
[21] CEMBUREAU. Co-processing of alternative fuels and raw materials in the
48%. The waste energy may be recycled, as in the example of a European cement industry; 2006. <http://www.cembureau.be> [accessed
recycling system that heats and cools energy for residential areas 03.04.12].
around the cement plant [44]. Another way is to use the waste [22] Rocha SDF, Lins VFC, Santo BCE. Aspects of the coprocessing of waste in kiln of
clinker. Eng Sanit Ambient 2011;16:1–10 [in Portuguese].
energy to generate electricity by means of a heat recovery steam [23] HOLCIM. Guidelines on co-processing waste materials in cement production;
generator [42]. 2006. <http://www.coprocem.com> [accessed 10.04.13].
[24] Neto GK. Co-processing of industrial waste in Brazil; 2009. <http://
www.sftecnologiaambiental.blogspot.com.br> [accessed 01.05.12, in
5. Conclusion Portuguese].
[25] Raina K, Janakiraman LK. Use of mineralizer in black meal process for
improved clinkerization and conservation of energy. Cem Concr Res
This study presented an exergy analysis of clinker production, a 1998;28:1093–9.
powerful tool which has been used in the performance evaluation [26] US Prado, New alternative for reuse of hazardous waste generated in the
of energy-related systems. The results indicated that the main irre- production of primary aluminum (SPL): obtaining opaque glass frit.
Dissertation, Instituto de Pesquisas Energéticas e Nucleares, São Paulo; 2008
versibility source in the cement industry is the rotary kiln and
[in Portuguese].
calciner process where the clinkerization process occurs. Therefore [27] Miksa D, Homsak M, Samec N. Spent potlining utilisation possibilities. Waste
the use of mineralizers and alternative fuels is important, espe- Manage Res 2003;21:467–73.
[28] Macedo JM, Jesus CAB, Campos D, Menezes JBF, Nascimento AS, Porto SRM,
cially for reducing the fossil fuel consumption (in this study the
et al., Coprocessing coating spending cuba (SPL) in Portland cement industry;
reduction was 17.32 t/day of fossil fuel) and waste management Anais do VII Seminário de Tecnologia da Indústria do Alumínio, São Paulo;
problems. However, it is necessary to take into account that the 2002 [in Portuguese].
choice of alternative fuel depends on price and availability, and [29] Gomes V, Drumond PZ, Neto JOP, Lira AR. Co-processing at cement plant of
spent potlining from the aluminum industry. Light Metals 2005:507–13.
that the energy and ash contents are also important, as are the [30] Çengel YA, Boles MA. Thermodynamics: an engineering approach. New
moisture and volatiles contents. This is a potential area for future York: McGraw-Hill; 2008.
research and development. [31] Paula LG. Thermoeconomic analysis of the production process of Portland
cement with co-processing of mixed wastes. Dissertation, Universidade
Federal de Itajubá, Itajubá; 2009 [in Portuguese].
Acknowledgements [32] Kotas TJ. The exergy method of thermal plant analysis. Florida: Krieger
Publishing Company; 1985.
[33] Carvalho JLR. Thermodynamics data for metallurgist. Belo Horizonte: UFMG;
The authors would like to acknowledge FAPEMIG – Fundação de 1977.
Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de Minas Gerais, CNPq – Conselho [34] Perry RH, Chilton CH. Chemical engineers handbook. 5th ed. New
Nacional de Pesquisa and CAPES – Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamen- York: McGraw-Hill; 1982.
[35] Szargut J, Morris DR, Steward FR. Exergy analysis of thermal, chemical and
to de Pessoal de Nível Superior for the financial support that al- metallurgical process. New York: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation; 1988.
lowed this study to be conducted.
104 M.L.G. Renó et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 75 (2013) 98–104

[36] Berguerand N, Lyngfelt A. The use of petroleum coke as fuel in a 10 kWth [41] Santos AR. The generation of petroleum coke due to processing heavy oil and
chemical-looping combustor. Int J Greenhouse Gas Control 2008;2:169–79. its use in the production of Portland cement clinker. Thesis, Universidade
[37] Önenç S, Brebu M, Vasile C, Yanik J. Copyrolysis of scrap tires with oily wastes. Federal de Itajubá, Itajubá; 2007 [in Portuguese].
J Anal Appl Pyrol 2012;94:184–9. [42] Engin T, Ari V. Energy auditing and recovery for dry type cement rotary kiln
[38] Machado FS, Andrade AM. Thermochemical properties of charcoal fines and systems – a case study. Energy Convers Manage 2005;46:551–62.
coal for injection tuyeres in blast furnace steel. Biomassa Energia [43] Sogut MZ, Oktay Z, Hepbasli A. Energetic and exergetic assessment of a trass
2004;4:353–63. mill process in a cement plant. Energy Convers Manage 2009;50:2316–23.
[39] Carpio RC, Coelho LS, Jorge AB, Silva RJ. Case study in cement kilns alternative [44] Sogut MZ. A research on exergy consumption and potential of total CO2
secondary fuels mixing using sequential quadratic programming, genetic emission in the Turkish cement sector. Energy Convers Manage
algorithms, and differential evolution. In: 6th World congress on structural 2012;56:37–45.
and multidisciplinary optimization, Rio de Janeiro; 2005.
[40] Çamdali U, Erisßen A, Çelen F. Energy and exergy analyses in a rotary burner
with pre-calcinations in cement production. Energy Convers Manage
2004;45:3017–31.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi