Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
61–68, 2002
© 2004 Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum.
All rights reserved. Printed in Canada.
0964-1823/00 $17.00 + .00
Abstract — Natural gamma ray well logging, an effective tool in geophysical prospecting, is used to
investigate the radioactive and phosphatic layers in the Khneifiss mine in Syria. The interpretation of
the gamma ray measurements, using numerical methods of analysis developed previously and applied
successfully in some phosphatic areas in Syria, make it possible to define precisely the phosphate
thickness from place to place in the study area. This technique has been successfully applied while
studying seven boreholes in the area. Sixty-three core samples from phosphatic layers in the boreholes
have been analyzed, using gamma ray spectrometry for the determination of P2O5 , U, Th, and K.
Good correlation between P2O5 content and U concentration has been found. The total count gamma
logs correlate reasonably well with the U core analysis, suggesting that radioactive equilibrium exists
in the U decay series. These gamma logs can be therefore used effectively to quantitatively map the
distribution of P2O5 and U. The characteristics of both subsurface phosphatic sand and phosphatic
rocks have been investigated and outlined using a statistical approach. The affinity of uranium to some
trace elements such as V, Sr, Cu, and Ni has been verified using correlation matrices of these elements.
© 2004 Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum. All rights reserved.
61
62 Explor. Mining Geol., Vol. 11, Nos. 1-4, 2002
Fig. 2. Simplified geological map of the Palmyrides Mountain Chain in Central Syria. Phosphatic
deposits are also shown.
Geological Setting the Arak and Tantour formations. The phosphatic deposits
in Syria can be classified in two types, A and B (Fig. 2).
The Palmyrides Mountain Chain located in central Type A includes the phosphates of Upper Cretaceous age,
Syria is composed of a NE-SW elongated group, 35 km while type B includes the Syrian Desert phosphorites of
long, of mountains covering an area of 30 000 km2. The Paleogene (Lower Eocene) age.
chain is segmented by a vast Neogene-Quaternary depres- In addition, phosphatic deposits in Syria contain secondary
sion, into northern and southern ranges. The sedimentary uranium concentrations in open pores and fractures (Abbas,
series exposed in the Palmyride Mountain Chain, which has 1987). These uranium concentrations can be interpreted as a
ages ranging from the Upper Triassic up to Neogene, con- result of syngenetic precipitation along with the formation of
sists of several lithologic units (Fig. 2); among these, the phosphate, or perhaps, as a result of secondary concentration
Soukhneh group is characterized by its significant phospho- caused by surface run-off and ground water flow.
rite deposits (Al-Maleh and Mouty, 1994). This unit is com-
posed mainly of two rock types: calcareous and siliceous.
The first type is dominated by limestone, marly limestone, Experimental Work
limy marl, and marl with characteristic limy concretionary
structures of few centimeters up to 2 m size. The siliceous Natural Gamma Ray Well Logging
rocks are composed of thin layered chert horizons or chert
lenses and nodules. Natural gamma ray well logging was conducted in
The Soukhneh Group is devided into two lithologic seven boreholes in the Khneifiss region (labeled S1 to S7).
units, the Rmah and Sawwaneh formations. The phospho- Figure 3 shows the study area and the location of the bore-
rite deposits in the region are attributed to enrichment holes. The borehole logging equipment used for conducting
processes of phosphorus and plankton particles that indi- these measurements was Mount Sopris model 1000-C Log-
cate a paleogeographic evolution related to Cenonian ger system (Mount Sopris, 1982). This equipment is a com-
transgression and the subsidence of the Arabian Platform. plete, fully portable, lightweight (27.3 kg), backpack-
The phosphatic layers appear to be thick in the central part mountable logging unit. Using the standard probe (G375/A),
of the Palmyrides and become thinner toward the west Gross Count, dead time corrected total gamma radiation was
until they completely disappear under the marly rocks of recorded in the boreholes.
Phosphate Prospecting Using Natural Gamma Ray Well Logging • J. ASFAHANI 63
Fig. 4a. Lithology, natural gamma ray measurements, and theoretical models of the seven studied boreholes.
in the S2 well, with an average of 13.7 m and a standard tively. The measured gamma ray intensities in the phos-
deviation of 4.1 m. phatic layers are related directly to uranium concentration,
Figure 4a shows the lithology of the seven wells, the where Th and K values in the analyzed phosphatic samples
natural gamma ray measurements, and their corresponding are below the lower limit of detection (which is 0.1%).
theoretical models. The thickness of phosphatic layers has It is worth mentioning that relationships among P2O5
been precisely determined, and the correlation of this layer content, uranium concentration, and total radioactivity are
according to the studied profile (from S1 to S6) is obvious, well known in most worldwide phosphatic deposits (Atfeh,
as is shown in Figure 4b. This figure shows the variation of 1967; Gavshin et al., 1974; Altschuler, 1980; Abbas, 1987;
this phosphatic unit in three dimensions. It is thin and shal- Asfahani and Kamarji, 1996; Jubeli, 1998; Asfahani, 1999;
low at well S1, and becomes thicker and deeper, reflecting Asfahani and Abdul-hadi, 2001). These mutual relationships
the basin morphology. Asfahani and Mohamad (2000) have have been demonstrated in the Khneifiss region as shown in
proved the distribution of variations of phosphatic ore con- Figure 6. The regression analysis indicates the presence of
tent in Al-Sharquieh mine through the application of geo- strong relationships between natural gamma ray count rates
electrical measurements. in c.p.s. and phosphate content (c.p.s., P2O5) and between
P2O5 content in the phosphatic layers varies between phosphate content and uranium (P2O5, U), where R2 is equal
15% and 34.6%, with an average of 27.2% and a standard to 0.66 and 0.81, respectively.
deviation of 4.9%. U concentration of these layers varies The main radioactive characteristics of both phos-
between 42 ppm and 130 ppm, with an average of 94 ppm phatic rocks and phosphatic sands are investigated and
and a standard deviation of 20.3 ppm. outlined by the application of a statistical approach as
The values of P2O5 contents, U concentration, and nat- indicated in Table 1. Uranium concentration in the phos-
ural radioactivity of the 63 core analyzed samples have been phatic rocks varies between 58 ppm and 114 ppm, with an
–
used in order to establish cross-sections related to these average X of 82.7 ppm and a standard deviation of 15.5
parameters, as shown in Figure 5. Two clear anomalies are ppm. The phosphatic sands are characterized by higher
observed by analyzing these cross-sections. The first one is uranium concentration in comparison with phosphatic
concentrated between wells S6 and S7 at 70 m deep, where rocks, where this concentration varies between 79 ppm
–
P2O5, U, and natural radioactivity reach 32%, 115 ppm, and and 130 ppm, with an average X of 106.8 ppm and a stan-
360 c.p.s., respectively. The second one is concentrated dard deviation of 13.7 ppm. The coefficient of variability
under S2 at the depth of 78 m, where P2O5, U, and natural (CV) of uranium in phosphatic rocks and phosphatic
radioactivity reach 32%, 115 ppm, and 360 c.p.s., respec- sands (Table 1) is 18.75 and 12.8, respectively. Table 1
Fig. 5. Cross-sections of P2O5 content, U concentration and radioactivity of the phosphatic layers in the study area.
66 Explor. Mining Geol., Vol. 11, Nos. 1-4, 2002
also shows that uranium in the phosphatic rocks is The correlation between these elements for both phos-
slightly more variable. These figures provide quantitative phatic sands and phosphatic rocks was computed to charac-
measurements of the degree of homogeneity in the distri- terize any inter-relationships (Tables 2 and 3). High affinity
bution of uranium. The higher the coefficient of variabil- of uranium to some trace elements, especially V, Sr, and Pb,
ity, the lower the degree of homogeneity. This slight dif- has been observed in the study area. The good correlation
ference in CV could be explained by the fact that between phosphorus and uranium and between phosphorus
phosphatic sands are more enriched with P2O5 than phos- and other trace elements (Pb, V, Sr) may provide other
phatic rocks, due to its high porosity, friability, and its important indicators. These elements and uranium are con-
high absorbtion capacity. Consequently, these character- tained within apatite, so the formation of these elements
estics will be accompanied by increasing U and other may also occur with apatite in the sedimentary basin,
trace elements. through organo-metallic complexes (Baturin, 1973, 1982;
Radioactive equilibrium is likely to exist in the Syrian Gavshin et al., 1974). The correlation of uranium with other
phosphatic regions. Abbas (1987) found such equilibrium elements is very poor.
through geochemical and isotope studies in the phosphatic A comparison study between the phosphatic deposits
formations of the Palmyrides as a whole. Asfahani and in the regions of Khneifiss, south Al-Abter (Asfahani and
Abdul-hadi (2001) found similar equilibrium in wells in Abdul-hadi, 2001) and Al-Sharquieh, has been carried
the phosphatic formations of the south Al-Abter region, out for uranium concentration and P2O5 content. Uranium
using alpha spectrometry and U234/U238 ratio. This equilib- concentration decreases gradually northward from
rium is found to be very useful for forecasting U concen- Khneifiss toward Al-Sharquieh. This difference in ura-
tration from natural gamma ray borehole logging mea- nium concentration could be attributed to two factors: 1)
surements. Computation of mean, standard deviation, the formation environment, and 2) the degree of alter-
threshold (mean +2σ) have been conducted for the phos- ation. The formation environment of Khneifiss is differ-
phatic samples (Table 1) in an attempt to detect the pres- ent from that of Al-Sharquieh deposits, by being more lit-
ence of anomalous values of the different elements stud- toral, more carbonatic, and more detrital in Al-Sharquieh
ied in this work. This computation indicates that the than in Khneifiss. The degree of alteration is also greater
content of P2O5, U, c.p.s., and other trace elements are in Al-Sharquieh than in the Khneifiss deposits (Asfahani
generally higher in phosphatic sands than in the phos- and Abdul-hadi, 2001). This alteration might remove
phatic rocks. entirely a part of the uranium adsorbed in the phospho-
rite. In the Khneifiss deposit, part of the uranium is still AL-MALEH, A. KH. and MOUTY, M., 1994. Lithostratigra-
related to organic matter in the interior of phosphatic phy of Senonian Phosphorite deposits in the Palmyridean
region and their general sedimentological and paleogeo-
grains. It is also found that the relationship between P2O5
graphic framework. Proceedings, 29th International Geo-
and U is indirect and not linear in south Al-Abter phos- logical Congress, Part C, p. 225-232.
phatic deposit (Asfahani and Abdul-hadi, 2001), while
ALTSCHULER, Z. S., 1980. The bearing of geochemistry on
this same relationship is direct and linear in Khneifiss the recovery of uranium and rare earth in phosphorites.
deposit (Fig. 6). Thus, the difference between these two Proceedings, 2nd International Congress on Phosphorus
deposits could probably be related to the difference in Compounds, p. 605-625.
sedimentological and geochemical conditions. AQCS, 1995. Intercomparison Runs Reference Materials.
International Atomic Energy Agency, p. 44.
ASFAHANI, J., 1999. Determination of radioactive and phos-
Conclusions phatic layers by measuring γ-ray intensities in well logging
in the south Al-Abter region in Syria, using numerical
Geophysical surveys including natural gamma ray methods of analysis. Journal of King Abdulaziz University
well logging and spectrometry techniques enabled identi- “Science”, 11, p. 39-51.
fication of some of the characteristics of the subsurface ASFAHANI, J. and ABDUL-HADI, A., 2001. Geophysical nat-
phosphatic layers in the Khneifiss region. The phosphatic ural gamma ray well logging and spectrometric signatures
of south Al-Abter phosphatic deposits in Syria. Applied
sands and phosphatic rocks have an average uranium con-
Radiation and Isotopes, 54/3, p. 543-557.
centration of 106.8 ppm and 82.7 ppm, respectively.
ASFAHANI, J. and KAMARJI, Z., 1996. The automatic inter-
Regression analysis indicates good correlation between
pretation of natural gamma rays in well logging of the
P2O5 content and U concentration. It is also found that phosphatic deposits in the Palmyra region in Syria.
total count gamma logs correlate reasonably well with the Applied Radiation and Isotopes, 47/516, p. 591-598.
U core analysis, suggesting that radioactive equilibrium ASFAHANI, J. and MOHAMAD, R., 2000. Investigation of
exists in the U decay series. The gamma ray intensities of electrical properties of radioactive phosphatic layers in the
the phosphatic layers in the studied wells are related Al-Sharquieh Mine, Syria. Exploration and Mining Geol-
directly to uranium concentration, where the Th and K ogy, 9, p. 141-148.
values in the analyzed phosphatic samples are below the ATFEH, S., 1967. The Phosphate Deposits of Syria. Ph.D. the-
lower limit of detection. As a result, gamma logs can be sis, University of London, Kings College, London, 348 p.
used to quantitatively map the distribution of P2O5 and U. BATURIN, G.N., 1973. Uranium in the modern marine sedi-
The affinity of uranium and phosphate to some trace ele- mentary cycle. Geochemistry International, 9-10, p. 1031-
ments has been demonstrated through the statistical analy- 1041.
sis and correlation matrix results. BATURIN, G.N., 1982. Phosphorite on the Sea Floor: Origin,
Composition and Distribution. Developments in Sedimen-
tology, 33, Elsevier, 343 p.
Acknowledgments CAYEUX, L., 1935. Contribution sur les phosphate Senoniens
de Syrie. C.R. Académie des Sciences, France, 200, p.
1553-1555.
The author wishes to thank I. Othman, general director
of the Syrian Atomic Energy Commission (SAEC), for his GAVSHIN, V.M., BOBROV, V.A. and ZORKINA, L. S., 1974.
Quantitative relation between uranium and phosphorus in
continuous encouragement and permission to publish this
phosphorites and phosphatic sedimentary rocks. Litho.
paper. Special thanks are due to A. Abdul-hadi and H. Min. Deposit, 6, p. 118-126 (English translation, p. 740-
Arssan from the SAEC chemistry department for conduct- 746).
ing the spectrometric gamma ray measurements on samples. JUBELI, Y.M., 1998. The role of airborne radiometric survey in
A.R. Saadeh and Ihsan Layyous are acknowledged for geo- defining the distribution of phosphate rocks in Syria desert
logical map preparation. Special thanks to the reviewers for and the northern Palmyrides. Exploration and Mining
their constructive suggestions and comments which improve Geology, 6, pp. 269-278.
considerably the quality of this paper. MOUNT SOPRIS, 1982. Borehole Logging Instruments.
Mount Sopris Instrument Company; division of EG&G
Geometrics, P.O. Box 449 Delta, Colorado U.S.A.
References NUCLEAR ANALYSIS SOFTWARE, 1991. GANAAS,
IAEA, Vienna, IAEA/CMS/3.
ABBAS, M., 1987. Geochemie de l’uranium des phosphorites RUSSIAN TECHNOEXPORT MISSION, 1966a. The geologi-
des Palmyrides Centrals, Syrie. Science thesis, Université cal map of Syria. Scale 1/200.000: Explanatory notes,
Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg, 166 p. Sheet: XIV, XV, XVI, XX, XXII. (Technoexport,
AL-ISSA, S., 1972. The Geological Structure and the Compo- U.S.S.R). Ministry of Industry-Syria.
sition of Phosphatic Deposits in Palmyridean Basin. Ph.D. RUSSIAN TECHNOEXPORT MISSION, 1966b. The geolog-
thesis, Institute of Geological Research, University of ical map of Syria. Scale 1/100.000: Explanatory notes
Moscow, Moscow. (Technoexport, U.S.S.R). Ministry of Industry-Syria.