Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
STRATEGY ADVISOR,
BMO CAPITAL MARKETS
115
110
105
100
96.86
95
90
85
80
Aug-09 Oct-09 Dec-09 Feb-10 Apr-10 Jun-10 Aug-10
Source: Reuters
Looking back year over year, it outperformed from November 8th until April
23rd at which point it was up 16% relative to the S&P, and that was a time
when we could feel pretty optimistic that the economic recovery was intact.
However since then it’s been going down — it’s now minus 4%; (relative to
the S&P on a year over year basis) not devastatingly bad, but this tends to
confirm all those other indicators out there.
It was only up 1.6% — they had previously estimated it at 2.4%, and that’s
despite booming business investment up 17.6% in the quarter.
Well, exports only up 9.1% and imports up 32.4% — the previous high
which was way back in the 80s was 28.8% — in other words, this was just
an astounding growth in imports, and that isn’t because every American
consumer suddenly turned bullish.
I think what that reflects is that so much of the business equipment and
software, which may be designed in Silicon Valley or Austin Texas (or
places like that) is actually manufactured abroad and so that was coming in
along with machinery made in Germany, that sort of thing.
I think that the capital goods — I am not an economist but I suspect that
that particular surge in growth was driven by capex, but it was capex that is
going to make America more efficient — that’s the good news.
In the New York Times today, Paul Krugman got into one of his splenetic
rages but he is a terrific and articulate exemplar of the post-Keynesian
(that claims to be Keynesian) school, which basically doesn’t believe that
government deficits are bad, (they are good) and paying for things in the
next generation or the generations after it is okay where it to get us out of
what we are in now, so as far as he’s concerned, stimulus has to be done by
increasing government deficits.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/27/opinion/27krugman.html?ref=todayspaper
He’s critical of Obama not doing enough, but he blames that on the
Republicans who are just saying ‘no’ to everything.
The monetarists would say, “If the central bank isn’t expanding its balance
sheet, don’t expect the economy to grow”, and you’ve got to have it growing
faster than GDP in order to have the economy grow and the only component
of their book that’s been growing is cash.
Hunkering down…
What we’ve got here is the phenomenon that people are holding cash,
(which does nothing for the economy) and in addition we’ve had those
statistics from the World Gold Council, (this is worldwide admittedly, but
I suspect Americans are a big part of this) which is the amount of gold
that they are buying in various forms, lots of it in actual specie and that’s
evidenced by the amount of advertising one sees on television in the United
States for buying gold coins and buying small pieces of gold, plus of course
the gold ETFs where the flows are just gigantic.
So we have a buildup in cash (in print money that is) and we have a buildup
in gold, and beyond that there’s not much going on.
That’s why the S&P is up about 1% year over year and it’s hardly of the kind
of environment that’s going to get those investors who left the stock market
after the Flash Crash, saying “We don’t believe the market is any realistic
place for ordinary individuals anymore”— this is not going to get them
running back in to buy stocks.
I am not sure I know exactly how to explain it but in any case crude oil is
flat year over year, copper is up a bit, the Dollar is up 5%, the euro is down
10%, the Loonie’s up 4%, but corn and the grains are up – they are the
strongest area with corn up 15% and wheat up over 12%.
It’s the only really good thing about the Illinois economy at the moment
because the farmers in Illinois are going to have a great, great year.
What we don’t have now is the basis for optimism that we had last fall, that
the economy was growing and that it seemed to be working.
What this suggested was yes, we’d been through the worst downturn since
the Great Depression but we were coming out of it and the people in charge
knew what they were doing.
Lacking leadership…
You could criticize them (as we did) about the fact that the money that they
were spending wasn’t productive for the economy in the longer run because
it was just paying off various constituencies, but it did seem to be producing
economic growth.
Well as Lady Macbeth’s words; “Nought’s had, all’s spent” because now
there’s no stomach in Washington for further programs like this, and we are
coming up to midterm election where all the polls show it’s going to be a big
swing to the Republicans.
The Republicans don’t have any answer to this situation either; they’ve
gotten by, by just saying ‘no’ to whatever it was that Obama proposed,
and if you see some of the people who managed to win in the Republican
primaries, you can’t have much confidence that the new Congress is going
to be any more responsible than the old, it’s just going to be irresponsible in
another direction.
Corporate confidence?
We can also see that with the takeovers that are going on that big
corporations are saying that (somehow or other) the world is not going to all
go down into a double dip, if that’s the fate of the US and that still remains
to be seen.
We’ve got lots of takeovers going on in the software side of the economy and
then of course the big, big story which is the Potash takeover, and this is a
fascinating one; we talked about it last week at length.
As you know our mantra has always been you buy commodity stocks on
the basis of unhedged reserves in the ground in politically secure areas of
the world, and Marius Kloppers is doing just that with his bid, because the
duration of the other assets that BHP has are in the order of a few decades.
They’ve got the Olympic Dam mine; they’ve got some wondrous properties
out there, Escondida, these kinds of things — that’s what makes them such
a formidable corporation, but nothing like the duration that lasts century
after century.
This is their chance to offset the declines in duration that they have in lots
of their other assets such as their oil production, where they don’t have
anything like multi-decades of reserves, so it’s a big chance and therefore I
am still skeptical about the valuations that are being used by these analysts
who are saying, (particularly the British analysts) “BHP, if they pay more
than $152 they should fire Marius Kloppers.”
First of all, BHP’s earnings are so spectacular and their balance sheet is
bulletproof — this is their chance because remember he was only in the
job 6 weeks and tried to buy Rio Tinto and failed on that because they got
Chincalco in and scotched his bid.
They are saying that already about 40% of the stock may be in the hands of
hedge funds and arbitrageurs — it was over 50% for Inco and Falconbridge
at the time of that frenetic series of takeovers.
Saskatchewan speaks…
What the province of Saskatchewan has indicated is they are going to take
a strong look at this, and their argument is that they want to make sure that
when he was talking about breaking up Canpotex and using BHP’s idea,
which is producing flat-out, relying on the quality of their production to
drive out marginal producers, that’s just not going to be applicable to what’s
going on in Saskatchewan.
They want to develop and let other smaller companies prosper and the
other two members of Canpotex, Agrium and Mosaic, have been in effect
sheltering under the wings of Potash and now Kloppers is doing a bit
of a backspin on this and saying he’s got no near-term plans to breakup
Canpotex, but I believe that will be a condition of getting the Saskatchewan
government’s sign off on this, and that’s not related to the price of the stock.
Headquarter hassle…
What does seem to be influencing this is the fact that the executive
management of Potash although the company is headquartered in
Saskatoon that they are located in a suburb of Chicago and therefore it
doesn’t have quite the same ‘Canadian flag’ character to it.
I don’t put much stock in that because Bill Doyle spends so much of his
time in Saskatchewan and they are the biggest feature in the tremendous
economic growth Saskatchewan has experienced in recent years, but when
you are talking about emotions and soft qualities like this, it’s difficult to
generalize.
They deserve some kind of premium — if they don’t get it, it’s because most
people disagree with us.
Most analysts use fairly short-term earnings projections and they do good
work but in effect, they treat commodity companies too much the way they
would treat other companies.
I certainly agree with you’ve got to use 1 and 3 and 5-year earnings forecasts
if you are taking over a supermarket or if you are taking over a software
company, but if you are taking over a mining or oil company, I think the first
thing you should be looking at is what this does to the total reserve picture
of the company that’s acquiring them.
If it does, (in this case you’ve got a gigantic adrenaline shot into reserve
calculations) then to that acquirer this is worth more money than any of
those CFAs are going to ascribe to it, and if the deal goes through at a higher
price, they can ridicule Kloppers as much as they want, he will have done
something for the stockholders of the company.
Ben is up to bat…
I think frankly that this is a case in which it becomes really important for
Ben Bernanke and his colleagues to find some way to expand the monetary
base, and the argument against it is they are just pushing on a string — I
doubt that, but clearly they can’t sit back and just let the monetary base be
as flat as the surface of Lake Michigan.
At that time, Bernanke had expanded his balance sheet in the most dramatic
fashion ever seen by a major central bank, so the Fed had done its work first,
and Congress responded with an increase in the deficit of money that was to
be spent soon, but they pitched it to us as “shovel-ready” projects, and of the
money that’s been spent so far on this, about 4% went into highways and
bridges under the federal projects, that’s all.
And by the way, the Congress went through by giving a pay increase to all
federal employees, and since government employees already had a huge
margin (when you took in their benefits, pension plans and health care)
relative to private sector employees, that was really sticking it into the
eye of the private sector, but again you can argue that that created some
stimulus at the time.
Healthcare headaches…
Unfortunately this is one case where the classic expression that they used
which is, “It’s a shame to waste a good crisis” and bringing in the health
care bill, there is no doubt that the implications for businesses who have
more than 25 employees are really negative for this.
So what you are going to have is companies that are very careful not to
expand past that magic number — at that point they have to pay a cash
penalty if they don’t provide health insurance to them.
It’s interesting that the Dollar did in fact strengthen when the monetary
base stopped growing, which is one of the things that the quantitative
analysts about gold and money numbers should have appreciated.
We’ll see how they do it, but Bernanke has exhibited first of all a knowledge
of encyclopedic character of what led to the Depression and what sustained
the Depression, and he’s also shown that he’s extremely creative and
original and gutsy about what he can do, so the ball is in his court, and I
suspect we are going to get some kinds of announcements fairly shortly.
It’s clear the United States is not going to be the ‘rescuer of the economy’
in this economic cycle (as it has been in so many) but as long as they don’t
drag it down then commodity prices will hold up, so our favorite asset class
will continue to outperform as it has been doing, and that is I guess the best
consolation that’s out there — I wish I could be more ebullient.
Thank you all for tuning in — We’ll talk to you next week.
THE CALL
The Call: Don Coxe’s weekly conference call conducted exclusively for employees and clients of BMO Capital Markets and
BMO Nesbitt Burns.
Published by: COXE ADVISORS LLP.
4th Floor
190 South LaSalle Street
Chicago, Illinois 60603
Web: www.CoxeAdvisors.com
Contact: Angela Trudeau, Editor
email: AT @CoxeAdvisors.com