Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 89


VOL. 3, NO. 2 APR - JUN, 2017 QUARTERLY JOURNAL ISSN 2415-0371

ISSN 2415-0371

Vol. 3 No. 2

Scientific Journal
in Social Science

Berlin Declaration of Open Access to

Knowledge in the Science and Humanities
Budapest Open Access Initiatives
The Cape Town Open Education Declaration


International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.2 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

reviewed scientific journal in social science and
its interdisciplinary fields. The journal is
published quarterly. The Boards of Editors
oversee the acquisition, review, and publication
of quarterly research papers in social science.
Editorial inquiries may be sent by email directly
to: EditorIJRMSS@gmail.com.

Paul T.I. Louangrath ………………………………………… AEC & USA


Asaad abd Allah, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Sudan
Ari Warokka, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Indonesia
Bashkim Lushaj, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Albania
Grzegorz Waszkiewicz, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Poland
Oliver Mtapuri, Ph.D. ………………………………………… S. Africa
Pavle Mašković, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Serbia
Mohamed Cherif Benzouai, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Algeria
Messaoud Djeddou, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Algeria
Md. Shamimul Hasan, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Malaysia
Sarhan Soliman, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Egypt


Abdulnaser Ibrahim Nour ………………………………………... (Jordan)
Arindam Bandyopadhyay, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (India)
Azam, Malik, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (India)
Barbara Sawicka, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Poland)
Bettencourt-Pires, M.A., M.D. / Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Portugal)
Dante Roberto Salatino Cuccia ………………………………………... (Argentina)
Deb Kumar Chakraborty ………………………………………... (India)
Dionéia Motta Monte-Serrat, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Brazil)
Ehsan Zanboori, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Iran)
Ekaterina Dimitrova Kyuskieva-Arabska, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Bulgaria)
Fadel Djamel, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Algeria)
Gary Cokin, EPM/CPM ………………………………………... (USA)
Gözde Ulutagay, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Turkey)
Ioannis Kostakis, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Greece)
Isack Amos Legonda, D. Engr. ………………………………………... (Tanzania)
Kamel Lahmar, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Algeria)
Kevin Cianfaglione, Ph.D.* ………………………………………... (Italy)
Luigi Lepore, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Italy)
Mariano Pierantozzi, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Italy)
Maruşa Pescu Beca, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Romania)
Miguel Angel Peres Benedito, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Spain)
Omar Ali, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Jordan)
Ramesh Chandra Paudel, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Nepal)
Sribas Goswami, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (India)
Theodosios Palaskas, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Greece)
Tomasz Maliszewski, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Poland)
Venelin Terziev ………………………………………... (Bulgaria)
Zeravan Asaad, Ph.D. ………………………………………... (Iraq)

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.3 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Arfat Ahmad Sofi, Ph.D. ………………………………………… India
Galinoma G. Lubawa, MBA ………………………………………… Tanzania
Lukman Olorogun, Ph.D. ………………………………………… Malaysia
Nitin Vihari, Ph.D. ………………………………………… India


Tony Louangrath ………………………………………… Laos
Chanoknath Sutanapong, MPA ………………………………………… Thailand

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.4 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science (IJRMSS)
420 Bourichane Rd., Unit 1 Ban Naxay
Xaysetha, Vientiane LAOS
Tel. +856 21 263585  Email: EditorIJRMSS@gmail.com

The International Journal of Research and Methodology in Social Science (IJRMSS) is a double blind peer-
review, open access, academic research, published quarterly. The journal publishes research articles,
literature review articles, technical commentaries, and case studies.

The mission of the journal is to provide publication service to the academic and research community in
social science that is: (i) peer reviewed, (ii) high exposure, (iii) true open-access, (iv) fully achieved and
retrievable online, and (v) leads to impact factor score.

The objective of the journal is to provide an open access online forum and resource for researchers to share,
disseminate, and exchange ideas and research outcome.

It is the policy of the journal to provide high quality research publication that is a true open access journal.
The journal is committed to “no fees – no charge” to authors. All articles will be subjected to blind peer
review process. We are committed to high quality research publication with free online access and strictly
observe non-predatory publication policy.


IJRMSS is published quarterly. Our call for papers is on-going. Authors may submit the research article(s)
by email to: EditorIJRMSS@gmail.com. We welcome articles in the following fields and their


Anthropology Applied physics Library science
Archaeology Artificial intelligence Mathematical & Theoretical
Criminology Bioethics biology
Demography Bioinformatics Mathematical physics
Economics Biomedical engineering Medicine
Geography (human) Biostatistics Military science
History Cognitive science Network science
International relations Complex systems Neural engineering
Law Computational linguistics Neuroscience
Linguistics Cultural studies Science studies
Pedagogy Cybernetics Scientific modeling
Political science Environmental science Semiotics
Psychology Environmental social science Sociobiology
Science education Environmental studies Statistics
Sociology Ethnic studies Systems science
Evolutionary psychology Urban planning
Web science
All papers submitted must conform to the following format:
Font: Times New Roman 12 points
Margin: Single line spacing; 1 inch top, bottom, right & left.
Reference: APA style. https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/01/
File: MS Words. Originality will be checked by TURNITIN.
Template: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B2B2CwoNDenGejVCSlhMNzRMeUE/view?usp=sharing

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.5 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371


Beyond the Decisions-Making II: Methodological Aspects ………………………. 6–24

Salatino, D. R.

Tanzania under Dependency and Neoliberalism periods:

Examination of Economic Theories since Independence ………………….. 25-38
Mandalu, M.,
Thakhathi, D.R., &
Costa H.

The Inequities in Health Shaped by Political Forces: A Critical View ……………. 39-47
Monte-Serrat, D.M.,
Kabir, R. &
Arafat, Yasir, S.M.

An Extended Meaning of the Concept of ‘Public Space’:

A Semiotic Analysis of French ‘Burqa Affair’ ……………………… 48-59
Arêas, Camila

Awareness and Attitude towards Public Pension:

A Case of Informal Workers at Saba saba Market
in Dodoma Municipality, Tanzania ……………………………… 60-69
James, S.,
Hauli , E. &
Mosha, P.

Knowledge and Attitudes of Male Employees

towards Paternity Leave in Iringa Municipality, Tanzania ……………… 70-77
Nzali, A.S. &
Philipo, F.

Thailand 4.0 Readiness ……………………………………………………… 78-86

Louangrath, P.I.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.6 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Beyond the Decision-Making II: Methodological Aspects

Dante Roberto Salatino

About the author

Dante Roberto Salatino is a researcher of the Institute of Philosophy and of the Institute of
Linguistics - Lecturer in the General Psychology Department - Faculty of Philosophy and Letters -
Teacher and Researcher in Artificial Intelligence in the Mechatronics Career - Faculty of
Engineering - National University of Cuyo - Email for correspondence: dantesalatino@gmail.com

The objective of this work is to show that the determinants of conduct and subjective behavior that
govern research in Social Sciences, especially in Economics. Both the investigative process and the
economy have at their base the same relational pattern that determines subjective reality. We used
the method based on the Transcurssive Logic that is apt to investigate the subjective reality, of
which the economy forms part. Individualistic methodological proposals and the one based on
unification are adjusted. It constitutes a methodological contribution in Economics.

Keyword: Economics, Psychology, Methods, Social Sciences.

JEL Code: A12, B41

Salatino, D. R. (2017). “Beyond the Decisions-Making II: Methodological Aspects.” Inter. J. Res.
Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 6–24. (Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

All attempts that scientists have made over time to control social phenomena have been limited by
the constitutive complexity of human society. This complexity comes from conflicts that operate in
it and the laws that govern its behavior. This situation was evident in the late s. XIX. (Sumner,
The appetite for power always has been part of mankind. It has conditioned even part of the
research in the social science. Perhaps the Economy, as a social science, is one of the most affected
since it has to do with the management of scarce resources and their distribution. No one can deny
that this function, generally in charge by the government and the powerful companies is a
determinant of power.
As we saw in an earlier paper (Salatino, 2017), the individual or social subject, that makes a
community meaningful, is never taken into account. From time immemorial and after an unpleasant
learning subject has been able to find a way to 'survive' biologically, psychically and socially, and
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.7 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
thus was molding their conduct in front of others. Increasingly, that imposed conduct has been
nullifying their behavior and annihilating their beliefs.
If we take the economy as a cooperative game it has become a 'zero sum' game; that is, what
others gain comes at the expense of common individual who, instead of being enabled to generate
conduct based on genuine economic behavior, sunk into abandonment thus, becoming the 'forgotten
man'. (Sumner, 1919, pp. 466)
The aim of this work is to show that both the process of scientific research applied to the
economic phenomena and the economy itself as a science, including its rational and subjective
approaches, as it happens with other branches of scientific knowledge (biology, physics,
psychology, etc.), responds to a common relational pattern. This 'universal' pattern is the same as
that proposed by the Transcurssive Logic (TL) (Salatino, 2017) to explain the importance of the
subject in the determination, analysis and understanding of real facts.


It is done through the approach of the economic conduct from the subject (1) and the existence of
patterns common among the different ways of seeing the economy (2).

2.1 Economic conduct from the subject

John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) English philosopher, politician and economist representing the
classical economic school who theorized about utilitarianism and in his book A system of logic
(1843-1889-1950) says, referring to the social phenomena derived from a psychological law:
"Taking into account that they have no origin in other social facts and that no other circumstance
can interfere , gave rise to have created a department of science called: Political Economy", making
clear allusion to its subjective roots. In contrast, in the chapter devoted to the definition of economic
policy, it says: “Economic Policy can be defined as the science of laws which regulate the
production, distribution and consumption of wealth. Wealth is defined, as all material objects useful
or agreeable to mankind, except such as can be obtained in indefinite without labor.” (ibid., p. 412)
Austrian school of economics: this line of economic thinking emphasizes that individuals do
not act automatically and in response to a rational elaboration which requires a total knowledge of
the ends and means. An individual acts as a consequence of cognitive processes that allow him to
perceive, recognize patterns, learn and understand the social reality that will determine the means
and ends appropriate to his subjectivity to face an economic decision. That is, an individual’s
decisions will always be individual and subjective. Some of the outstanding figures of this school:
Carl Menger (1840-1921) (Subjective value theory, Menger, 2007, p 114); Ludwig von Mises
(1881-1973) (Praxeology: logical structure of human action, Mises, 1998, p. 30) Methodological
individualism: all social phenomena, including economics, can be explained from individuals, their
goals, their beliefs and their actions, Mises, op. cit., p. 41); Friedrich August von Hayek (1899-
1992): the methodological norms adopted by Hayek are a direct reflection of his perception of the
subject. According to Hayek: "It is probably not an exaggeration if we say that any important
advance in economic theory during the last hundred years was a further step in the constant
application of subjectivism" (Hayek, 1955, p. 31)
William Graham Sumner (1840 – 1910), an American academic at Yale University. A
polymath with numerous books and essays published on United States history, economic history,
political theory, sociology and anthropology, whose essay, The Forgotten Man (1883) shows that
politics had already been subverted by a series of 'measures of relief', that which are generally
economic, and which, although they attract public attention, always go to the detriment of the
common man. Sumner was a promoter of the free markets and defender of the anthropological
approach of the economy.

2.2 Common patterns

Carl Gustav Hempel (1905-1997), a logical empiricist philosopher and epistemologist, who in his
Philosophy of Natural Science states: “What scientific explanation, especially the theoretical ... is

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.8 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
achieved by a systematic unification, by exhibiting the phenomena as manifestations of structures
and common underlying structures and processes that conform to specific, testable, basic principles.
If such an account can be given in terms that show certain analogies with familiar phenomena, then
very well.” (Hempel 1966: 83) (Metaphorical by analogy method (Salatino, 2009)..
Milton Friedman (1912-2006) in one of the most influential works in economic
methodology writes: “A fundamental hypothesis of science is that appearances are deceptive and
that there is a way to looking at or interpreting or organizing evidence that will reveals superficially
disconnected and diverse phenomena to be manifestations of a more fundamental and relatively
simple structure." (Friedman, 1966, p. 33).

Supported by the TL the method based on: (A) economic facts, because they belong to the social
sciences, depend on the subjective reality and not on the objective reality that frames traditional
natural science; (B) the basic elements that intervene in the definition of the fact or phenomenon
analyzed must form a relational pattern; (C) the minimum pattern thus formed must form a group
(See Appendix) to demonstrate the presence of symmetry (Salatino, 2016); That is, it must give
evidence of the conservation and invariance of the fundamental laws governing the fact or
phenomenon being studied; and (D) the ontological projection of the developed scheme emphasizes
the presence of a common relational pattern (Salatino, 2012) which link together different real facts
seemingly unrelated, such as economy with the determinants of conduct and human behavior, or
mathematical models and reality.


4.1 Scientific investigation
In the first half of the last century the science of economics, according to prevailing theories, had to
be evaluated either by the accuracy of its predictions or by operationally significant theorems
leading to an empirical verification. One of the central concepts, proposed by Samuelson, was that
of 'revealed preference'. (Serrano, 2007). We must add that this last proposal ignores both the moral
principles derived from ethics and, therefore, the character of the subject that select, as well as the
subjectivity of the preference.
The second half of the last century was invaded by dynamic econometric models and
methods that were based on non-experimental data. They were understood as a learning process
where theoretical information was incorporated through mathematical models and the empirical
information through statistical models. (García, 2007). Here, we invoke an 'information generating
process' as the only representative of 'reality' and Bayesian inference that structures the learning of
that reality.
One of the paradigms of economic thought of the twentieth century was the methodological
individualism, in which a defined equilibrium is promoted in terms of a theory of perfect
competition (Mas-Colell, 2007). It is a very particular 'individualist' view, since it deals with social
reality as a 'collection of individuals', that is, where it is the group that defines what is an individual
called 'consumer' or more generically 'agent', when in fact, as we will see, it is exactly upside down.
Game theory, the great contribution to economic methodology, began with the book Theory
of Games and Economic Behavior of John von Neumann's and Oskar Morgenstern of 1944, reached
its highest recognition with the Nobel Prize awarded to John Forbes Nash in 1994 by the discovery
of necessary equilibria in theory, is based on decision making when there is an uncertainty
associated with any of the alternatives. It is considered as one of the most important contributions to
human thought since it can explain how cooperation arises in conflict situations. (Ferreira García,
2007) It is not a faithful representation of reality, but simply a simplification of the way of saying
the relevant things.
Other methodological ventures, such as dynamic macroeconomics, experimental or
behavioral economics, or the theory of evolutionary games (Diaz-Giménez, 2007; Brandts, 2007;
Thomé, 2007), just to name a few of the most recent, leave aside the ethical and the ontological,

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.9 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
while the epistemological is taken from Cognitive Psychology as is also the case with
Neuroeconomics, or of the Darwinian and Neo-Darwinian theory of evolution used as metaphors
devoid of content.
As we saw in a previous paper (Salatino, 2017), research in a social science as the economy
must be approached: (i) from the ontological or through a set of elements whose existence can be
known by a subject; that is, it belongs to its subjective reality; (ii) from the epistemological or from
the nature of that knowledge or the beliefs that arise in the exchange with such reality; (iii) from the
methodological point of view or through the procedure and the norms used to acquire, control and
systematize this knowledge, including the strategies used; that is, a way of defining the behavior
and conduct of an individual; and finally, (iv) from the ethical or starting from the set of psychic
and affective qualities that form the character as an expression of a knowledge or experience and
condition the behavior of each individual in his real world.
It is clear that research is not always about strictly objective questions, but especially in
human and social sciences, we must take into account that observed and observer are the same
subject. Therefore, it is imperative to take into account the conditioning factors that determine
observation and observed.
In short, social research must be based on a simultaneous assessment of human behavior and
conduct. To understand how these two elements are integrated, let us observe the following scheme
of the subjective reality (Salatino, 2017).

Figure 1. Subjective reality

S: subject – O: object – V: external transformation - : internal transformation

If we look at the previous figure, we can see the relations between the three real systems that
make up the subjective reality, namely: socio-cultural system (SCS), bio-external system (BES) and
psycho-internal system (PIS). Each of these systems is structured as PAU, which makes them
absolutely homeomorphic. On the other hand, they also form a PAU. The real element unifying
them is the subject (S).
The dynamic sequence in the previous scheme is as follows:

As can be appreciated, behavior is strictly individual and unconscious and strongly

biologically rooted, whereas conduct becomes manifest exclusively when we relate to others. Both
respond to the following fundamental elements.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.10 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Figure 2. Fundamental elements of behavior and conduct

Character refers to the peculiar and exclusive way of being of each subject that conditions
the behavior, attitude, reactions, emotions. In short, the affections before any challenge that life
proposes to an individual.
“Things” are everything that exist outside the psyche of the subject; that is, the immediate
surroundings with what interacts which includes their own body. In other words, it includes
everything that occupies the so-called 'subjective space' (Uexküll, 1934) from where the subject
'cuts' its surroundings to configure its 'surrounding world' (Umwelt) composed by the 'perceived
world' (Merkwelt) and the 'world of action' (Wirkwelt).
The rules represent the norms to which the subject has to adjust their behavior, that is, the
ways of acting in front of society or what is the same, the ways of elaborating their conduct, which
are not the formal, prescriptive rules designed and imposed and applied by an exogenous authority
through the administration of certain incentives. Social norms do not represent solutions achieved
through coordination, but emerge when there is a conflict between individual interests and
collective interests. (Bicchieri, 2006)
Beliefs embody 'truth' or what for the subject has 'sense' (or what is useful to survive
biologically, psychically or socially) in the 'perceived world' and that, prior to adequacy with
behavior in their psycho-internal system, can be projected as conduct in its 'world of action', that is,
In the PAU to the conduct correspond the code 11, that is, that of the rules because, like
them, it is the final result of the assemblage between the character of a subject and the 'things' or
'objects' that they come from the outside, instead, the behavior corresponds to the code 00, that of
the beliefs, because the behavior is neither subjective nor objective but biological.
As in any science, the objective of the Economy is to study the real economic facts. Being
consistent with what has been developed so far, we must define what is a real fact for the TL.
From our point of view, it is considered as a real fact the relations between a subject (S) and
a object (O) generics by means of a double transformation: an evident one that connects subjective
and objective aspects through a function and a hidden one that puts in relief the subjective structural
aspect. These relations determine that the subject is the source of these transformations or changes
and the object the destiny of them.
Going back to the initial approach, it may now be easier to understand the link between the
different ways of approaching social research.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.11 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Figure 3. Forms of social research

CH: character – TH: things – RU: rules – BE: beliefs

Starting from a specific object of the study, any research should conform to the norms of the
scientific method and apply them according to ethical principles and criteria; that is, to observe a
conduct adapted to different social and cultural spheres. As antithesis, from a comprehensive
perspective of truth based on science or justified belief, knowledge with a biological support
determines a behavior that allows the cognitive projection (Salatino, 2014) on what the empirical
shows, for its purification, explanation and justification or rejection if it turns out to be a derivative
of dogma or reflection of everyday concerns and prejudices.

4.2 Economic models

The factual sciences, whose object of study are the real facts, require both observation and
experimentation. In natural sciences, such as biology, physics or chemistry, this is basically ensured
because it is easy to separate the observer from the observed; however in the social sciences, such
as economics, for example, this is very difficult if not impossible, because such separation is
One way of achieving a certain approximation to the scientific method as applied to the
natural sciences, when trying to investigate economics, is to vary the point of view, or better, to
adapt the real frame of reference.
Mathematical procedures were chosen, long ago, to analyze the phenomena of economic reality
through its formal methodology, assigning the weight of the decisions to supposed rational agents.
This type of approach has at least two problems. On the one hand, they are considered
unreal by the important distance that separates them from the facts that occur in the economic
reality; on the other hand, when assigning the decision making to rational agents all their results are
crossed by the rules that govern the logical thinking, whose main sustenance is a theory.
Every theory, necessarily represents an abstraction of the real world. Given the immense
complexity that economic reality show in this case, in order to be able to analyze even though it is a
small part of that reality, characterized perhaps by the appearance of a particular economic
phenomenon, there is no known mechanism other than theorizing on the apparent relationships that
show us the primary factors revealed as those that define the problem which will be the object of
our study. Everyone is aware that this crude 'skeleton' or 'economic model', as it is called, is nothing
more than a deliberate simplification for analytical purposes.
There is a variety of economic models, but here we will only address, by way of example,
those dedicated to the static comparative analysis. (Chiang & Wainwright, 2005).
What is it that is compared in these models? The comparison is made between different
states of equilibrium that are associated to different sets of parameters and external variables. This
simple proposition is useful for modeling, for example, an isolated market, or the national income,
or the ratio between total utility and marginal utility.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.12 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
If in the evolution of the model there is an imbalance manifested as a change in the value of
some of the parameters or external variables, the initial equilibrium must be updated, and therefore,
the internal variables of the model will suffer a certain adjustment.
How is the process of comparison between a new state of equilibrium and the previous one?
Ignoring what happens to the variables, the above is restricted to comparing the initial state of
equilibrium (before the change) and the final state of equilibrium (after the change). But if we do
not exclude the possibility of equilibrium instability, then it is clear that the problem under
consideration is essentially different and should focus on the 'rate of change' which evaluates how
quickly an internal variable changes relative to the change of a parameter or external variable to the
system. It is at this point that the concept of derivative becomes important in the static comparison.
In general, one could consider the rate of change of one variable y in response to a change of
another variable x, and where both variables are related through a function.

y  f ( x) (1)

Applied to the context of the static comparison y represents the equilibrium value of an internal
variable (dependent variable), while x represents some parameter or external variable (independent
As an example, we will consider an element that is part of the microeconomic theory,
specifically the theory of consumption and, within it, the demand or the relationship that links
prices and quantities required by the consumer. (García, 2000, p.29).
To understand the above relationship, concepts of total utility and marginal utility are
necessary, which are by no means synonymous. The price is explained through the utility that gives
us the last unit consumed of a product. The total utility derives from the sum of the utilities
provided by the successive units consumed, in contrast, the marginal utility is the utility that derives
from additional unit consumed and that represents a decreasing value, unlike the total utility that is
a value which grows logarithmically to a maximum point and then falls. Formally, marginal utility
(UMg (x)) is the first derivative (or the partial derivative if we consider more than one product) of
the total utility (u (x)).

Figure 4. Marginal and total utility

The mathematical procedure that relates a function to its derivatives is called differential
equation. The method for solving these equations also responds, structurally, to PAU (Universal
Autonomous Pattern), as shown below.
Of the numerical methods for solving differential equations, Euler's is one of the most
imprecise. By including in the calculation an average of two next slopes remarkably adjusts the
results, much closer to the real calculation obtained by the analytical method.
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.13 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Recall that the method of Euler has the form:

New value (dependent variable) = Previous value + h x Slope (2)

where h = step (increase of the independent variable).

The enhanced Euler method, suitable for solving first-order differential equations with initial
values, will have the form:

New value = Previous value + h x Average of slopes (3)

Figure 5.

In Figure 5, we can see the elements that intervene in the application of the improved Euler
method. The codes come from the attached attribute mapping table. Xn and Yn have no difficulty in
assignment. As for the code of predictor slope (superficial) arises from the apparent relationship
that binds directly the independent and dependent variables, transformation that we can call
'organization', since it comes from a structural relationship. On the other hand, the code of the
corrective slope (profound) does not depend on a structure, but on a function in which the variables
intervene, indirectly; we can call it 'disorganization and reorganization' due to greater complexity to
the system achieves a greater approximation to the real value.
The result in K1 is obtained by the evolution of the superficial level through applying XOR (),
while the result in K2 is achieved by the evolution of the profound level through applying the
opposite operation to that of composition, that is, the Equivalence ().
Both levels cycle in the opposite sense and do it simultaneously each time the independent
variable is increased in h. Formal definitions follow:

dy/dx = f(x,y)
y(x0) = y0 (Initial values)
h = paso
Un+1 = Yn+1
Un+1 = Yn + h.f(Xn, Yn) = Yn + h.K1
Xn+1 = Xn + h
K2 = f(Xn+1, Un+1)
Yn+1 = Yn + h.K
K = (K1 + K2)/2
Prediction: Un+1 = Yn + h.f(Xn, Yn) (4)
Correction: Yn+1 = Yn + h.½(f(Xn, Yn) + f(Xn+1, Un+1)) (5)

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.14 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Figure 6. Euler enhanced method

The previous figure shows the good approximation achieved with the Euler enhanced
method to the real values.
In summary, the analysis the evolution of the PAU proposed by the Transcurssive Logic can
explain and understand perfectly how this method of solving a mathematical problem works. This
operation is as follows: from the initial values the first value of the curve is calculated after adding
h. This prediction (apparent or superficial estimate) has a gross error with respect to the correct real
value. This 'difference' (error) is not dissipated, but accumulates. When the sum of the differences
exceeds a predetermined threshold, the system goes to the deep level where a new calculation is
made with the same h and the average between the two results is estimated (corrective calculation),
projecting the final result, again, towards the superficial level to estimate the degree of coincidence
with the real value, with which there may be a small disparity but that should always be much
smaller than the error estimated in the first step, somewhat corroborated in the chart above.
According to what we have seen, we can say that this relational system (PAU) is able to
demonstrate that the system obtained after evolving from an initial situation is more complex than
the one from which we started, because it 'learned' to solve more adequately and properly a
problem, as if it had 'adapted' (sit venia verbo) to the new demands of its surroundings.
All the previous development is not enough to justify that the economy, as a social science,
is being approached 'scientifically', because here the participation of the subject is relegated to a
mere equivalent, to comply with the forms, is established as real reference. Or presented in another
way, utility is a subjective concept that can not be measured; maybe it can be simulated using utility
functions that relate the value of utility (arbitrarily assigned) to the quantity consumed of certain
goods or services.

4.3 Decision Making: Prisoner's Dilemma

A variant in the rationality hypothesis is 'Game Theory', an area of applied mathematics that uses
models to study the interaction between formalized incentive structures (games). This development
contradicts the fundamental idea suggested by Adam Smith: "Individual interest drives human
beings towards the common good" (Smith, 2015), ensuring that individual interest, selfishness and
rationality in making decisions, lead humans to a non-optimal situation.
Among the different types of possible 'games' we will only mention two: cooperative game,
where two or more players do not compete, but collaborate to achieve the same objective by
forming coalitions and therefore win or lose altogether, and the game does not cooperative in which
players make decisions independently for their personal benefit, which does not prevent those
decisions from favoring or harming all, as happens in cooperatives.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.15 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
John Forbes Nash in 1950 presented in his doctoral thesis an analysis of a situation of
equilibrium that occurred in non-cooperative games. There, he defined the concept of balance as

“An equilibrium point is [a set of strategies] such that each player ... maximizes their
gain if the strategies of others are kept fixed. Thus, the strategy of each player is optimal
compared to that of others.” (Nash, 1950, p. 3).

A pair of strategies is in equilibrium only in the event that it is true that if these strategies are
chosen by the players then none of them could achieve a better individual outcome by switching to
another strategy. (Peterson, 2015, p.6)
What Nash proposes approximates the rationality to the subjectivity a little (Tohmé, 2011)
taking into account not only the decision of the others but also the individual's decision. The
equilibrium can be interpreted as a pair of expectations about the choice of each person such that
when one of them reveals his choice, neither wants to change his conduct. In other words, it showed
that decision-making is an interactive question where selfishness ('the intention to survive', in this
case, socially), and that the best results for the group, At least in the short and medium term,
although decisions are taken individually, are achieved when a very particular type of equilibrium is
reached between pairs of opposing and simultaneous strategies.
Let us analyze the above through the example of the 'Prisoner's Dilemma', an expression
coined by Albert W. Tucker in 1950 during a conference in which he discussed the work of his then
postgraduate student John F. Nash. (Peterson, 2015).
The TL focuses on the analysis of this intellectual puzzle, not as a simple mathematical
model, but, as Peterson asserts, a type of situation frequently encountered in real life.
Considering this dilemma in the context of the subjective reality is expressed in estimating
that the subgroups that constitute, the levels in reality represent each and in an alternative form, the
subject with their behavior ( = 00) and their conduct (V = 11), in front of another subject that the
TL considers as object. Throughout the evolution of the system and alternately, the 'object' will
become 'subject' and vice versa.
Returning to the 'Prisoner's Dilemma' we can add that the 'game' alternatives are given until
either of them breaks the 'Nash equilibrium' and loses the game.
Speaking of Nash equilibrium, it is important to realize that this form of analysis reveals the
transfer of an unstable equilibrium or uncertainty (00 given by the behavior of each player) to a
stable equilibrium or certainty (11 given by the conduct of each player) which is the Nash
equilibrium (See Figure 7).

Figure 7. Conduct and behavior under Nash equilibrium

The transfer of a balance to the other is done through an intermediate step, that is the one
that allows the decision to choose the best strategy. In short, we have demonstrated that decision-
making is not, as gambling theorists assert, a rational question of an agent that becomes a

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.16 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
maximizer of a given utility because its preferences obey a set of structural conditions, such as
completeness, transitivity , independence and continuity (Peterson, 2015, p.10), but an assemblage
between the behavior and conduct of an individual.
In this example of the Prisoner's Dilemma, we will make the following fictitious proposal
(Figure 8):

Figure 8. Two players game theory

A police, investigating a bank robbery, has detained two well-known criminals (A and B)
for illegally carrying firearms. But as there is a suspicion that these people are responsible for the
assault on the bank the previous week, his interrogation begins, and this is what is said to each one
separately: for carrying an illegal weapon is a 2 year prison sentence, but as we are sure that you
and your partner have robbed the bank last week, we need your confession. If you confess and your
partner does not, you add only 1 year of jail, that is, you would get 3 years in total, and to your
partner we will get another 10 years. Of course if you do not confess, but your partner will you are
the one who will receive the 10 years, while your partner will receive only 3 years in prison.
In both cases and individually, they see the convenience of confessing and they do so, both
of which will be sentenced to 3 years in prison.

What is the dynamics of the system reflected in Figure 8? We start from a situation of
uncertainty given by a basic behavior, which is to stay as short as possible in jail. The problem is
that not confessing on the part of both is an unstable equilibrium since the final result does not
depend on the behavior of each other, but on the conduct of the other. This uncertainty and the
possibility of reaching a new equilibrium are reflected in the binary operations between the codes
that identify the four possible situations. (See Appendix)
These operations tell us that in the case of A if starting from a non-confession decides to
persist in it and B confesses, his sentence would increase in 10 years; therefore he decides to
confess, something similar happens with B. All of which leads to confluence in a new situation of
equilibrium, now stable (where both confess) known as Nash equilibrium, where each player has
opted for his best strategy and knows the strategy of the other, and where in addition, he will lose
the game if he decides to change strategy again while the other player remains unchanged. The
latter situation can occur in both A and B and this is shown by the remaining binary operations,
which in both cases allow it to return to the initial unstable equilibrium state, loses the game one
who returns to that equilibrium.
From what is shown through the example, it follows as a corollary that a decision making, is
an assemblage between the individual behavior and the conduct that a subject shows according to
the relationship he has with others, all of which can be weighted. That is, in spite of its
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.17 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
mathematical approach, we see that it is possible to approach the fundamental subjective aspects
that give referential frame to the solution of a problem, something that is not usually considered in
the habitual scientific method where math is used.
Without sharing the optimistic prediction of Siegfried (2006) when he believes that game
theory could someday become the nexus that brings together all the pieces of the scientific puzzle,
we must leave it as a precedent that the contribution of Nash can act as a catalyst in a useful way to
understand individual behavior and social conduct, such as TL.

4.4 Economy
In life survival is the imperative need to be satisfied; in society the satisfaction of material needs
(food, clothing, housing, etc.) and not material (education, health, leisure, etc.) is the determinant of
that survival in society, which could be called 'acceptance' or 'recognition' by others.
The traditional definition tells us that economics studies both the basic behaviors of
individual agents and global behaviors when they manage scarce resources to produce goods and
services and distribute them among the individuals. (Mochón Morcillo & Becker, 2008, p.2)
According to Bicchieri (2006), the games that social norms solve are called games with
multiple motives. Such mixed-motivation games are not co-ordination games (such as cooperative)
at first, but social norms can transform games with mixed motives into co-ordination. This
transformation, however, depends on each individual hoping that other people also follow the norm.
If this expectation is violated, an individual will return to playing the original game and behaving
"selfishly" (non-cooperative game) (Bicchieri, 2006, p.3).
In this work, we see economics as such rather as a game, but not as does the game theory of
von Neumann and Morgenstern or Nash where the analysis is done from a language exclusively
mathematical, but from the relational approach that proposes the TL between a structure and a
function or between individual behavior and social conduct to explain the subjective need to
choose, which is the backbone of the economy.

Figure 9. Framework of decision making

CH: character – TH: things – RU: rules – BE: beliefs

The above figure is intended to reflect a real framework for decision making something
different from what was previously discussed. The variant is the fact of focusing the problem from
the subject and not only what results from their interaction with others. In other words, making a
decision here is much more selfish than in the case of non-cooperative games, since what is really at
stake here is 'life' itself.
The illustration in Figure 9 may well represent a situation similar to that evidenced in a non-
cooperative game between two players: a subject with his character and, therefore, with his ethics,
and the environment with his things and his other individuals. There are two well-defined levels: the
superficial or apparent level or that where the future of the players is settled according to a strategy
chosen consciously and unconsciously by the subject according to certain rules that are the product
of a conflict; and the profound level, where the rules of the game (structure) are proposed that
depend on the individual beliefs and to which cannot access or modify neither of the players (the
structural is neither conscious nor unconscious is biological).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.18 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
A system (couple of players: the subject and its environment) represents a dynamic state of
repose that accuses a certain organization (determines a specific behavior), a certain stable
imbalance that promotes an exchange that is projected as evident action (a conduct adjusted to
norms or rules). The irruption of a proposal or challenge by the environment the equivalent of the
'stimulus' specified in a previous point that causes a deviation in that subject (S) that perceives. This
forces the subject to submit that previous 'organization' to the rules of the game. Those general rules
that define the generative structure of their behavior before the situation, as something disorganized
that the profound structure reorganizes. Elaborating either a defense that is arrived at as an adaptive
response to the environment (O), or as a change of level of complexity. It is now possible, by means
of strategy, to respond with an attack, which causes that the environment to become the 'subject'
that receives a challenge and to repeat the alternatives of the game until one of the two does not
adapt and 'die', that is, lose the game or come to an agreement and is terminated.

We have tried to approx repeat, the sequence that would follow an investigator that proposes to
study social phenomena like those that occur in the economy, but raised from the subject’s
perspective. We can see in the diagram (Figure 10) that from the methodological approach and the
use of tools such as mathematical models, to the application of theories that consider the behavior
of others and the relationships with individual behavior, have in their basis a common relational
structure. To this disposal, we could equate it with a kind of ‘universal pattern’, since it
encompasses the different strata that define this universe of study (Salatino, 2009), which also
contains a similar provision among its components. This type of structure behaves in much the same
way as a fractal does in that the same structure is repeated at different scales, and its deepening or
superficialization allows to study or analyze the dynamic relational structure of different real facts
that apparently are not related, as in this case
the economy with the determinants of conduct and human behavior.

Figure 10. Universal pattern

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.19 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Bicchieri, C. (2006). The Grammar of Society – The Nature and Dynamics of Social Norms – New
York, Cambridge University Press.
Brandts, J. (2007). La economía experimental y la economía del comportamiento - En “Sobre la
Economía y sus métodos” – Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Chiang, A. C.; Wainwright, K. (2005). Fundamental Methods of Mathematical Economics. New
York, McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Díaz-Giménez, J. (2007), Modelos y métodos en la macroeconomía dinámica - En “Sobre la
Economía y sus métodos” – Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Ferreira García, J. L. (2007). La teoría de los juegos, sus aplicaciones - En “Sobre la Economía y
sus métodos” – Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Friedman, M. (1966).Essay in Positive Economics. Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.
García, H. S. (2007). Modelos y métodos econométricos dinámicos - En “Sobre la Economía y sus
métodos” – Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
García, V. F. (2000). Para entender la economía política (y la política económica). México, Centro
de Estudios Monetarios Latinoamericanos.
González, W. J. (2012). Scientific Realism and Democratic Society. The Philosophy of Philip
Kitcher. Leiden, Rodopi.
Hayek, F. A. (1955). The Counter-Revolution of Science. Studies on the Abuse of Reason – London,
The Free Press of Glencoe, Collier-Macmillan Limited.
Hayek, F. A. (1958). Individualism and Economic Order – Chicago, Illinois, The University of
Chicago Press.
Hempel, C. G. (1966). Philosophy of Natural Science – New Jersey, Prentice Hall, Inc.
Mas-Colell, A. (2007). La teoría del equilibrio general. En “Sobre la Economía y sus métodos” –
Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Menger, C. (1871-2007). Principles of Economics – Alabama, Ludwig von Mises Institute.
Mill, J. S. (1889). System of Logic. Ratiocinative and Inductive. Being a connected view of the
principles of evidence and the methods of scientific investigation – London, Longmans, Green,
and Co.
Mises, L. von (1949-1998). Human Action. A Treatise on Economics – Alabama, The Ludwig von
Mises Institute.
Mochón Morcillo, F; Beker, V. A. (2008). Economía Principios y Aplicaciones – México,
McGraw-Hill Interamericana.
Nagel, E. (1950). John Stuart Mill’s Philosophy of Scientific Method – New York, Hafner
Publishing Company.
Nash, J. F. (1950). Non cooperative games – Tesis Doctoral – Universidad de Princeton.
Peterson, M. (2015). The Prisoner’s Dilemma – Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Salatino, D. R. (2009). Semiótica de los sistemas reales – Tesis Doctoral en Letras especialidad
Psicolingüística por la Facultad de Filosofía y Letras de la Universidad Nacional de Cuyo,
Mendoza, Argentina – Director: Dra. Liliana Cubo de Severino.
Salatino, D. R. (2012). Aspectos psico-bio-socioculturales del lenguaje natural humano.
Introducción a la teoría psíquica del lenguaje – Mendoza – Argentina, Autoedición – ISBN:
Salatino, D. R. (2014). PSYCHE – Structure and Function – Mendoza – Argentina, Desktop
Publishing – ISBN: 978-987-33-5702-2.
Salatino, D. R. (2015). La verdadera historia de la Lógica Transcursiva. (Vol. 3) – Mendoza –
Argentina, Autoedición – ISBN: 978-987-33-6655-0.
Salatino, D. R. (2016). La importancia de la simetría. En Educación en Ciencias Empíricas en
Facultades de Ingeniería. (ECEFI 2016), pp. 1-29. Ed. Cuadrado, G.; Gómez, L. – Mendoza,
Argentina, Facultad Regional Mendoza –Universidad Tecnológica Nacional. (In press).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.20 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Salatino, D. R. (2017). Beyond the decisions-making: The psychic determinants of conduct and
economic behavior. Inter. J. Res. Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol. 3, Nº 1: pp. 6-26 (Jan. – Mar. 2017);
ISSN: 2415-0371.
Samuelson, P. A. (1965). Foundations of Economic Analysis – New York, Atheneum.
Schmoller, G. von (1901) Grundriß der Allgemeinen Volkswirtschaftslehre – Leipzig, Duncker &
Serrano, D. T. (2007). Los economistas como metodólogos – En “Sobre la Economía y sus
métodos” – Editor: Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Siegfried, T. (2006). A Beautiful Math. John Nash, Game Theory and the Modern Quest for a Code
of Nature. Washington, Joseph Henry Press.
Smith, A. (2015 -1776) La riqueza de las naciones – Edición ePub libre de Carlos Rodríguez
Sum, N-L; Jessop, B. (2013). Towards a Cultural Political Economy. Putting Culture in its Place in
Political Economy. Cheltenham – UK, Edward Elgar.
Sumner, W. G. (1919 – 1883). The Forgotten Man – In “The Forgotten Man and Other Essays”, pp.
465 - 495 – Ed. Keller, A. G. – New Haven, Yale University Press.
Tohmé, F. (2007). Evolución y teoría económica - En “Sobre la Economía y sus métodos” – Editor:
Juan Carlos García-Bermejo – Madrid, Editorial Trotta.
Tohmé, F. (2011). Consideraciones epistémicas en juegos: nociones de solución y conocimiento.
En: “Consideraciones Epistémicas en Juegos: Nociones de Solución y Conocimiento” – Serie
Progresos en Economía – Asociación Argentina de Economía Política pp. 87-99 –
Compiladores: Arozamena, L.; Weinschelbaum, F. – Buenos Aires, Temas Grupo Editorial
Uexküll, J. von (1934). Streifzüge durch die Umwelten von Tieren und Menschen: Ein Bilderbuch
unsichtbarer Welten. Berlin, J. Springer.
Von Neumann, J; Morgenstern, O. (1944). Theory of Games and Economic Behavior – Princeton,
Princeton University Press.

Groups and symmetry in Transcursive Logic

The notion of group is unfailingly associated with the concept of structure. In fact, the oldest
structure known and studied is the group that was discovered by Galois in 1832.
A group, according to the modern definition (Salatino, 2015, p. 122), must show a series of
properties to be considered. To certify such properties, we will take as a guide a generic group. We
see in Figure A1 different ways of representing this type of group according to what we want to
emphasize in its structure.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.21 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Figure A1. Group representation

The structure of this type of group consists of two opposing static elements (A, B) and two dynamic
elements arranged in opposition (V, ). Each alternately occupies each of the four vertices of a
rectangular parallelogram. All elements have a binary code that identifies them and that arises from
a table of assignments with at least two basic attributes (, ).
The static elements besides opposing are complementary and concurrent (simultaneous). Of
the dynamic elements, one of them (V) has the function of “transformer link”, in apparent form,
between both static elements. From the logical point of view behaves as a disjunction and its code
corresponds to the co-presence of both attributes, which is equivalent to the union of the elements
by their differences, so we will also know as 'organization' and is represented by the composition
operation that governs the superficial level of this structure: XOR ().
The other dynamic element () represents a 'hidden transformation' whose function is to
break the previous ligature, which will enable the future evolution of the system. It behaves as a
logical conjunction and its code arises from the co-absence of attributes, which amounts to a
separation of elements by similarities; also known as 'disorganization' and is represented by an
operation opposite to the composition operation of group: Equivalence () that disorganizes and
subsequently reorganizes the profound or hidden level of this structure.
The geometric projection of the tetrahedron in the figure is only to emphasize that the two
levels that form this structure and its temporal evolution in the opposite sense represent, in reality,
the 'shadow' of a topological arrangement of the elements of the group in a superior dimension.

Having done the elementary definitions, we will analyze if this arrangement we have proposed
(PAU) complies with the basic properties of a true group.
Closure: For a set of elements to be closed under a certain transformation, the response to its
application to any possible combination of its elements must be the production of an element
belonging to the set. In order to demonstrate the above, it is essential that we identify more
precisely the applied transformation. Every group must have a 'composition operation', which
represents the transformation that must be applied in order for the group to evolve in an evident
way; that is, to cycle through the different constituent elements (static and dynamic), in any sense
until the element from which it departed and thus demonstrate the presence of symmetry (see

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.22 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
below). The presence of cycles is only admissible if in response to the application of the
transformation we obtain the subsequent element.
In our case, the apparent transformation will be XOR or exclusive disjunction, a logical
Boolean operation that allows us to work with the binary codes of the elements. Figure A1 is
represented by a logical sum and tells us that is taken into account of the simultaneous presence (co-
presence) of the attributes that distinguish each element, (Figure A2).
Exclusive disjunction (AB: is read A unless B): It is true (1) only when one of its
disjunctives is true (1) and the other is false (0). When their values are equal, the exclusive
disjunction is false (0).

Figure A2.

It can be observed in the previous figure the dextro-rotatory cycle (Dx) or in the sense of the
needles of the clock, that causes the continuous application of a transformation, checking itself thus
two things: first, the property of closure of the set, since always, in response to the application of
the transformation we obtain an element of the set, and secondly, the symmetry of the set as a
system, since after applying the successive transformations we arrive at the same element from
where it was depart. Something equivalent to the above would be to say that the equilateral triangle
has undergone three successive rotations of 120º, whereupon the system returns to its initial state.
Identity property: There must be an element of the set such that by affecting by a
transformation to another element of the same set, do not modify it. (Figure A3).

Figure A3.

Inverse property: all the elements of the set must have their inverse, such that the
composition between them give as answer the neutral element. For this to be effective, an operation
opposite to that of composition is needed. This operation is the Equivalence () or double
implication where a proposition is true (1) only in the case where both components have the same
truth value. If their values are different from each other, then it is false (0) (Figure A4).

Figure A4.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.23 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Associative property: all the compositions achieved by a given transformation are
independent of their grouping. (Figure A5).

Figure A5.

If a set satisfies the properties of closure, identity, inverse and associative, it is said that this
set constitutes a group.
The set presented here (PAU) complies with the previous properties and this allows it to
evidence a symmetry by rotation. But in addition, it must comply with another property that we
could call the closure of the conjugate.
Closing the conjugate: if we look closely at Figure A2 we will see that the closure is partially
fulfilled because the neutral element or identity (00) never appears in response to the successive
transformations. This has an explanation. (Figure A6)

Figure A6.

If we analyze the previous figure, we can see that our supposed group is really it and its
reflection through a flat mirror (- - - -). The elements arranged at the vertices of the reflected
triangle (blue) constitute a group that can respond in a closed manner to the continuous application
of a transformation. Unlike the original group, here the non-apparent (or hidden, if it fits)
transformation is the Equivalence (), which as we have already said is the opposite operation to
The evolution shown in Figure A6, where the neutral element (00) appears as an answer,
makes it clear that this 'mirrored' group also observes a rotational symmetry since, after three turns
of 120 °, it returns to its initial position, although rotating in reverse direction to the original group;
that is, in the left-hand (Lv) or anti-clockwise sense.
If we speak of complex or hypercomplex numbers, we could say that the set we are
analyzing represents a group and its conjugate or reflex. We recall that the conjugate of a complex

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.24 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
number is another complex number that is obtained by symmetry with respect to the real axis, that
is, changing sign or denying its argument or imaginary part. In our example, the sense of rotation is
also included.
In the same figure, finally, we can review the basic tables of the minimal finite bodies that
represent the two levels of our group: a superficial level whose internal operation is the logical sum
() and the apparent transformation is XOR; and a hidden or profound level whose internal
operation is the logical product () and its transformation the Equivalence ( which in reality is an
exclusive AND, better known as XNOR). The third table represents the generalized correspondence
between these finite bodies and the group that is called the Galois Connection (an opposition
mediated by another opposition) and where both levels are integrated and where the product of
rotation Dx certifies the closure of the superficial level generated by the apparent transformation,
whereas the product of rotation Lv does the same in the profound level by means of the hidden
In summary, we have verified the existence of symmetry both rotational and reflection of
the group formed by the essential aspects of a problem, which meets the requirements set out in the

Other composition operations

Both XOR () and Equivalence () are applicable when we must specify the dynamics of a
structural PAU, which is where its two levels represent a single system that must interact with its
A different case is the functional PAU or those where each subgroup (level) of the system
represents a different subject that must interact with the one near to it, but to which it is not
subordinate (that is, neither is an ad later of the other, both are independent)
The type of composition operation to be used in functional PAUs is what we have called
'hybrids'. Let's see what this is. (Figure A7)

Figure A7.

What do the symbols mean:  ?

They represent the hybridization between XOR and XNOR (or equivalence). This means that both
operations are applied partially to each column. The  is applied on the spin side, that is, in the
right column in the Dx spin and in the left column in the Lv spin. Anyway, the arrow of the symbol
indicates the same thing; that is, it is enough to apply one or the other to the elements involved in
each turn: 00, 01 and 11 in the Dx spin and 00, 10 and 11 in the Lv.
To this symbol we will know as XENIA: X because both operations are exclusive (XOR =
exclusive OR, XNOR = exclusive AND) and ENIA (of Irish): what unites two people (levels) to
face the demands of their environment and the elements what’s up in it.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.25 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Tanzania under Dependency and Neo-Liberalism Periods:

Examination of Economic Theories since Independence

Martin Mandalu, D.R Thakhathi, and Hofisi Costa

About the author(s)

Martin Mandalu is a lecturer at Stella Maris Mtwara University College at Saint Augustine
University of Tanzania P.O. BOX 674 Mtwara, Tanzania). Corresponding author:
D.R. Thakhathi is a Professor of Public Administration at the University of Fort Hare .
 Hofisi Costa is an Associate Professor and Chair of the Faculty of Public Management and
Administration at North West University.

The paper discusses development theories that underpinned Tanzania’s economy in the past five
decades in the pursuit of development and poverty alleviation. The paper discusses modernization,
dependency, and neo-liberalism. It proposes and discusses an alternative development model that
the country can adopt to realise development and accelerate poverty reduction. Tanzania became a
developmental state during the period of the state-led economy under the influence of dependency
theory, through Ujamaa. However, due to some domestic and international factors, the country
abandoned that development pathway and moved on to attaining its development agenda without a
specific model. Findings have revealed that both dependency and neo-liberal policies had limited
success in achieving the country’s development agenda and poverty reduction. Therefore, the paper
proposes that Tanzania adopts an alternative development model and shifts the attention from
economic growth to economic development.

Keywords: Development Theories, Tanzania, Ujamaa, Developmental State

JEL CODE: E12, E13, O10, O40

Mandalu, M. Thakhathi, D.R., and Costa H. (2017). “Tanzania under Dependency and
Neoliberalism periods: Examination of Economic Theories since Independence.” Inter. J. Res.
Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 25–38. (Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.26 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

This paper discusses the theoretical framework that Tanzania followed to realise its economic
potentials. These development theories influenced the development agenda in Tanzania. The paper
analyses and relates development theories in Tanzania since independence in 1961. The
development theories are necessary in any country since all development agenda need a guiding
philosophy to lead it, and the Tanzanian economy is no exception. The theories examined in this
paper are modernization, dependency and neo-liberalism. At the end of the paper, an alternative
development model is proposed and discussed. The paper argues that the proposed model can
successfully help achieving the development agenda in Tanzania as modernization, dependency and
neoliberalism theories have either been struggling for more than half a century or failed in the war
against poverty in the country since independence in 1961.

This paper has uses a documentary review methodology. The study utilised documentary review in
collecting relevant data. Mogalakwe (2006) and Scott (1990) depict the documentary method as the
technique used to categorize, investigate, and interpret written documents from private and public
sectors. Documentary analysis deals with reliable documents which are cost-effective and reliable.
Documents needed for the study in the documentary approach should have high accuracy,
authenticity, credibility, and representativeness; thus the paper yielded valid findings (Mogalakwe,
2006; Scott, 1990). The researchers used official documents, journal articles, dissertations,
magazines, websites of relevant government ministries to strengthen their observations on
development theories. The methodology is suitable since the development theories information is
found in these sources.


3.1 Modernization
In the 1960s, Tanzania, had a vision of transforming its society from an under-developed to an
industrialized one by improving the socio-economic status of her citizens through service delivery
and human development. Immediately after independence in 1961, the country identified three
enemies that it had to fight namely ignorance, diseases and poverty (United Republic of Tanzania,
2012:1-2; Wangwe & Charle, 2005). The philosophy guiding development agenda at the time of her
independence was modernization.
When the developed world became interested in the development of the under-developed
countries, industrialized states became the role models. Capital accumulation and industrialisation
were the forces of the developed economies of which sub-Sahara Africa could follow (Todaro &
Smith, 2009). Modernization theory is deeply rooted in the concept of growth and economic
dualism. The dualism found in the industry and agricultural sectors had been presented as
“tradition” vis a vis modernity. Modernization is the process of transition from the traditional
society to modern society. It comprises social and cultural frameworks that facilitated the
development of technology: it is argued that through application of science and technology, under-
developed countries will attain similar levels of development as industrialized economies (Siddle &
Swindell, 1990).
McMillan and Harttgen (2014) and Lewis (1954) proposed the idea of dual sectors in which
under-developed countries could achieve economic growth by shifting workers from the
“traditional” agricultural sector into the “modern” industrial sector. Lewis (1954) argues that under-
developed countries have a surplus of unproductive labour in the agricultural sector. These workers
are attracted to the industry sector where there are higher wages. Lewis argues further that
entrepreneurs in the industry sector will make profit which will be reinvested in the business in the
form of fixed capital. The industry’s productive capacity increases and leads to a greater demand of
labour. More employees will be engaged from the surplus in the agricultural sector. The process

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.27 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
continues until all surplus workers from the agricultural sector have been engaged. The industry
sector would have grown, and the economy would have moved from traditional to industrialized
society. Critiques of modernization, including Andre Gunder Frank (1969), argued that
modernization theory ignored the historical experience of colonialism in under-developed countries.
The existence of the under-developed countries is necessary to the development of developed
economies, which extract resources from them. Therefore, it is impossible to simply transfer labour
from the traditional to the industrialized society without affecting their relationship. Thus, such
critiques led to the birth of the dependency theory.
After independence in 1961, Tanzania continued with the colonial capitalist economic
system governed by market economy. The market economy benefited only a small segment of the
population (Ngowi, 2009). During that economic system, farmers cultivated cash crops such as
coffee, sisal, and cotton for export and for some local industrial processing. The idea and practices
of the economy tended to follow the modernisation thinking as that was the practice of the period.
However, the majority of Tanzanians did not benefit from that economy, which was contrary to the
objectives of fighting for independence; thus, the government of the day called for change of
approach. The failure of the modernisation theory to stir economic change and improve people’s
lives in the country influenced the change from market economy to a state-led economy. This
change was influenced by the dependency thinking of industrialisation through revolution and
socialism (Arndt et al., 2016: 238; Siddle & Swindell, 1990)

3.2 Dependency
The dependency theory was very much vivid in the Tanzanian economic history as the country
embraced the theory when it opted for African socialism, Ujamaa, as a guiding philosophy in her
development agenda. Ujamaa failed the country and so did the dependency theory as the country
was obliged to embark on neo-liberalism.
Dependency theories became popular in the 1970s; they were championed by academics of
the under-developed countries (Todaro & Smith, 2009). Leading dependency theorists, such as
Celso Furtado, F.H Cardoso, Samir Amin, Andre Gunder Frank were concerned with the stagnation
of under-developed countries. They look at under-developed countries as positioned at the
boundaries of capitalist systems of production and exchange. They see economic stagnation in
under-developed countries as result of the development of capitalism in Europe. However,
dependency theorists differ with scientific socialists in the belief that capitalism is arrested and will
not develop further in the under-developed countries (Siddle & Swindell, 1990).
The dependency theorists argue that the ruling classes in poor countries have little interest in
industrializing the economy of their countries because they have a beneficial relationship with the
multinational companies which extract wealth from the under-developed countries and
impoverishing them further. Dependency theorists believe that under-developed countries can only
industrialize through revolution and socialism (Siddle & Swindell, 1990). Critiques of the theory
find that theorists committing an error by treating under-developed countries as homogenous. Each
country has its own characteristics, and thus requires a development theory suitable to its needs.
The dependency theory fails to come up with an alternative approach as it confines itself in the
criticism of modernization.
Tanzania wanted to improve rapidly the economic status of its citizens so as to meet the
objectives of fighting for independence (Ngowi, 2009). The dependency theory offered such ideas
that a country could industrialise through revolution and socialism (Siddle & Swindell 1990), thus
following the objective of ameliorating citizens’ economic status, it became logical for Tanzania to
adhere to Ujamaa. When Tanzania embraced the dependency theory through Ujamaa , it succeeded
in some areas and failed in others. Tanzania made great progress in the human development area
through provision of good quality education and health care; however, its economy deteriorated
badly due to weak economic policies under the Ujamaa policy (Arndt et al., 2016; Tanzania Human

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.28 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Development Report, 2014; Edwards, 2012). Thus, after such failures, the country in mid-1980s
resolved to neo-liberal policies to guide its economy.

3.3 Neo-liberalism
In the 1970s, pro market economists became vocal as under-developed countries were struggling to
find their way after independence. The focus is on the relationship between the state and the market
in the process of economic development (Moreira & Crespo, 2012). The central argument was that
under-development in Africa was caused by the state heavy hand on markets, incorrect pricing
policies that caused misallocation of resources (Todaro & Smith, 2009). Tanzania under Ujamaa
went through this experience as the government controlled major means of economy (Edwards,
2012; Leys, 1996; Sandbrook, 1995). The theory has three different approaches, namely: the free
market approach, the public choice approach and the market friendly approach.
The free market approach holds that markets alone are competent and capable of
determining investment in new economic endeavours. The labour market responds accurately to the
demands of the new industries, producers know the demands of the market and know how to
respond efficiently and profitably (Todaro & Smith, 2009). However, in under-developed countries,
governments intervene in the market functions by manipulating prices of agricultural products by
fixing them with low prices while industrial wages are kept high compared to agricultural prices.
The government intervention distorts pattern of resource allocation and consequently, efficiency
and welfare are reduced. Thus, the free market is preferred as it ensures efficiency and economic
growth (Moreira & Crespo, 2012).
The public choice approach was introduced in the 1980s as neo-liberalists concluded that
African governments were the major cause of under-development in the continent (Moreira &
Crespo, 2012). The public choice theory argues the government distorts economic activities because
it is a composition of politicians and bureaucrats who work for their personal benefits. They use the
power and government authority to fulfil their interests. Krueger (1990) in (Moreira & Crespo,
2012) argues that the state’s economic control in under-developed countries is associated with
bureaucratization, corruption and nationalization of private property. The neoclassical theorists
prescribed liberalisation of under-developed economies as a remedy to stagnant economies. It was
argued that liberalization of the economy would encourage economic efficiency and growth. Under-
developed countries were asked to privatize state owned enterprises, promote free market, increase
export diversification and welcome investors from developed countries (Edwards, 2012; Todaro &
Smith, 2009).
The market-friendly approach intervened as an alternative to the two previous approaches to
development. This theory recognizes that markets are imperfect and, at times, the market produces
imperfect goods. Theorists realized that such imperfection could be addressed by the state. The state
can invest in physical and social infrastructure such as roads, railways, health care facilities,
educational institutions and provision of favorable environment for private business to flourish
(Skinner, 2011; Todaro & Smith, 2009).
Since mid-1980s, Tanzania adopted the neo-liberal policies to guide its economy following
failure of the dependency theories through Ujamaa (Tanzania Human Development Report, 2014;
Edwards, 2012; Wangwe & Charle, 2005). In the era of neo-liberal policies, there have been
impressive economic growth in the country; however, this economic growth fails to reduce poverty
significantly amongst the rural people who are the majority in the country (Arndt et al., 2016;
Tanzania Human Development Report, 2014; World Bank, 2015; Kessy et al., 2013; Mashindano,
2011; Mkenda et al., 2010, Twaweza, 2009). It has been more than two decades of economic
liberalisation and neo-liberal policies in Tanzania, yet the majority rural people, who are majority in
the country, continue to be poor; this suggests that neo-liberalism is inefficient remedy poverty in
that sub-Saharan country: hence there was a call for an alternative approach to drive the
development agenda in Tanzania.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.29 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

3.4 Towards an alternative development approach in Tanzania

From the development theories reviewed, there is no single theory that was able to address under-
development effectively in the country; consequently, an alternative approach is necessary. The
scrutiny of development theories exposes the role that Tanzania and development partners have to
play for the development of the country. This paper urges the Tanzanian government to reposition
itself and become a developmental state since historical evidence depicts that African states are
capable of becoming successful developmental states like their East Asian counterparts (Hofisi,
2013; Mkandawire, 2001). A developmental state takes an active role in planning and acting in the
development process of its economy; through diversification of export structures, industrialisation
and engagement in new international economic order through negotiations with industrialized
economies (Ubhenin & Edeh, 2014). Even though Tanzania has to take its development role on its
own, partnership with industrialized countries is necessary to help in attracting foreign investment,
application of science and technology in the industry sector and stimulation of the private sector.
Thus, while calling for Tanzania to become a developmental state, this paper proposes the
fusion of dependency and neo-liberalism theories to bring a new approach to drive the Tanzanian
economy. This alternative approach is evidenced by the South Korean experience: South Korea
adhered to and integrated ideas from both the dependency school by employing industrialisation
strategies, state intervention and neo-liberalism strategies such as institution reforms, use of
innovation and technology in the local industry (Kasahara, 2013; Heywood, 2013; Hansen, 2010).
The input from the two schools of thought saw South Korea succeed industrialisation. This
experience can also be realised in Tanzania.

3.5 Developmental State

Kasahara (2013) defines a developmental state as that which facilitates structural transition from a
traditional/ agricultural to a modern/industrial society. The developmental state is expected to take
the role of restructuring the national economic system for industrial development. In most cases, the
facilitation of growth is influenced by accumulation of agricultural surplus that can be invested for
the development of an industrial society. This thinking is related to the Lewis (1954) argument of
modernization based on unlimited supply of surplus labour from the non-productive agricultural
sector. Mkandawire (2001), on the other hand, defines a developmental state as an ideology-
structure nexus. As an ideology, the developmental state is principally one whose ideology
underpins ‘developmentalism’ because it conceives its objective as that of ensuring economic
development, usually understood to mean high rates of accumulation and industrialisation. Castells
(1992) in Mkandawire (2001) and Mkandawire (2001) in Hofisi (2013) maintain that such a state
establishes, as its principle of legitimacy, its ability to promote sustained development,
understanding by development the steady high rates of economic growth and structural change in
the productive system, both domestically and in its relationship to the international economy.
The developmental state emphasises capacity to implement economic policies ‘sagaciously’
and effectively. Such capacity is determined by various factors including institutional, technical,
administrative and political (Mkandawire, 2001). Undergirding all these is the autonomy of the state
from social forces so that it can use these capacities to devise long-term economic policies
unencumbered by the claims of myopic private interests; it is usually assumed that such a state
should be a ‘strong state’ in contrast to what Gunnar Myrdal (1968) referred to as the ‘soft state’
that had neither the administrative capacity nor the political will to push through its developmental
project. Finally, the state must have some social anchoring that prevents it from using its autonomy
in a predatory manner and enables it to gain adhesion of key social actors (Kasahara, 2013;
Mkandawire, 2001).
On the state and development in Africa, there are a number of opposing discussions. One
outstanding feature in those discussions is the disjuncture between an analytic tradition insisting on
the impossibility of developmental states in Africa and a prescription literature presupposing their

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.30 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
existence. The analytical tradition which argues for the impossibility of developmental states in
Africa is mainly based on a number of reasons including: (i) dependence, (ii) lack of ideology, (iii)
softness of the African states, (iv) lack of technical and analytical capacity, (v) past poor
performance, and (vi) mismatch between international and local policies (Mkandawire, 2001).
Prescription literature believes in the possibility of developmental states in the continent (Ibid).
While it is true that African states are the least developed states in the world, the analytic
traditional view on Africa’s impossibility of developmental states is wrongly informed. We discuss
some of the misinformation about the continent briefly, as our area of focus in this paper is mainly
on Tanzania. Much of the impossibility literature is based on misunderstanding of the economic
history of Africa. The Berge report presented a brief history of Africa’s post-colonial development
and the state’s role in that development. It described both post-colonial policy and performance as
absolute and indistinguishable tragedies (World Bank, 1981).
While there were some facts in the report, to a large extent, the report falsified economic
performance in the continent. Additionally, the report underestimated the importance of the global
influence on Africa; when the world market performs well, African states do well too and vice
versa. Moreover, some of the policies followed by African states were formulated by respectable
world international institutions, thus making them responsible in bad economic policies, which lead
to failure in the continent, but the report saddles all blame on Africa (Hofisi, 2013; Mkandawire,
Furthermore, despite a number of challenges in their economic policies, up until the second
"oil" crisis in the late 1970s, some African states had performed comparatively well. Evidence
reveals that some countries such as Kenya, Ivory Coast, Tanzania and Malawi had growth rates of
more than 6 percent for more than ten years, and this growth was mainly based on agricultural and
industrial expansion. An interesting feature here is that much of this growth was sustained
principally by local savings. The rates of savings and investments compared relatively well with
those of East Asian states, though African savings and investments tended to produce lower growth
rates. The states played a central role in the whole planning process and some states such as Ivory
Coast and Tanzania were highly interventionist and “dirigiste” with the state taking the
development role in the agricultural export activities through state enterprises.
Therefore, this proves that Africa has had states whose ideology was clearly
“developmentalist” and that they pursued policies that produced fairly high growth rates in the post-
colonial era and attained significant social gains and accumulation of human capital. Moreover,
some governments extended infrastructure and social services to degrees never thought of under
colonial regimes. In addition, many African states were able to maintain peace and security in their
countries. Thus, we realise that “developmental states” are not entirely something new in Africa
(Mkandawire, 2001; Sandbrook, 1995).
In response to the impossibility of the developmental states in Africa, Mkandawire (2001)
argues that Africa has had, even though they were less successful, and can have successful
developmental states today. He maintains that the arguments for the impossibility of developmental
states in Africa are “not firmly founded either in African historical experiences or in the trajectories
of the more successful developmental states” (Mkandawire, 2001 in Hofisi, 2013), hence the call
for a developmental orientation of Africa and Tanzania, in particular, which empowers the state to
formulate policies and (and more significantly) execute them efficiently and effectively for the
transformation of all people’s aspects of life in the country.
Mkandawire’s argument sought to respond to critiques, who in the 1980s and 1990s, argued
that African States couldn’t become developmental states as did the East Asian states because of
weaknesses in African states cultural background, lack of ideology, softness of the African states,
lack of technical and analytical capacity, structural reasons and the dependence of rent seeking. This
argument serves to substantiate the proposition of an alternative development model to address
poverty reduction successfully.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.31 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
4.1 Tanzania and the Developmental State
When Tanzania became independent in 1961, it inherited a colonial market economy. The country’s
economy was performing relatively well, but the benefits of the economy were felt by a small group
of individuals, mainly English and Asian businesses who had the major share of the economy. This
market economy was a capitalist model whereby major means of economic production were in the
private sector. Subsequently, the Tanzanian government did not have the authority to intervene even
when market forces failed, yet the state wanted all citizens to experience economic benefits in a
newly independent state (Ngowi, 2009). When it became clearer to the state that it was not possible
to realise its development agenda of poverty reduction and bringing equality amongst the people
through the same market economy, Ujamaa - a state-led socio, political-economic ideology - was
seen as the right strategy to drive the government development agenda (Cornelli, 2012; Kaiser,
1996 in Ngowi 2009).
Under the Ujamaa strategy, the state became responsible in all economic affairs; it became a
real developmental state as argued by Mkandawire (2001) when it became a “dirigiste economy”,
planned and “governed the markets” for the purpose of effective accumulation for industrialisation.
At this stage, the state became the defender of public order and public property rights responsible of
social and physical infrastructure and macro-economic executive. The state also assumed the roles
of economic planning, regulator and to some extent, entrepreneurship, and the private sector
disappeared (Sandbrook, 1995).
The scenario in the Ujamaa era had some similarities to what was happening in the 1960s
and 1970s in the interventionist policies in the Republic of Korea. However, the Korean
developmental state differed from the Tanzanian “developmental state” as Korea’s economic
policies relied profoundly on very close consultations between the state and business leaders and
very large diversified corporate multinationals (Kasahara, 2013). Since the Tanzanian
developmental state under Ujamaa strategy appropriated all the economy and major means of
production, and consequently, the private sector disappeared. It was not possible to have alternative
economic ideas from business leaders in the country. Therefore, the state failed to realise its
development agenda, contrary to what happened in the republic of Korea (Tanzania Human
Development Report, 2014; Edwards, 2012; Nord et al., 2009; Todaro & Smith 2009).
The failure of Ujamaa as an economic policy led to economic and structural reformation
starting in the mid-1980s following fierce pressure from the donor community and the Bretton
woods institutions; thus, Tanzania returned to the market economy which is a neo-liberal approach
driven by market forces (Wangwe et al., 2014; Edwards, 2012; Nord et al 2009). When African
states became independent in early 1960s, Dumont (1966) in Sandbrook (1995) argued that it would
have taken two decades for sub-Sahara Africa to kick out poverty completely; however, as argued
by Sandbrook (1995), by 1980s, African states were poor or even poorer than they were twenty
years earlier. Borrowing the same argument from Dumont (1966), two decades on since adoption of
neoliberalism in Tanzania, the country has neither become a developmental state nor has it been
able to attain its development agenda on poverty reduction. Since independence, Tanzania has
experimented both in the state-led economy through Ujamaa (Fouéré, 2014; Edwards, 2012; Nord
et al., 2009; Ngowi, 2009; Ibhawoh & Dibua 2003) and the market led economy in this era of neo-
liberalism for more than two decades (Tanzania Human Development Report, 2014; Edwards,
2012; Nord et al., 2009).
However, both perionds have failed to bring real substantial progress. Despite impressive
economic growth in recent years of neoliberal economy, poverty continues to trouble many
Tanzanians, especially the majority of those who live in the rural areas (Tanzania Human
Development Report, 2014; Wuyts & Kilama, 2014; Martins, 2013; Mashindano et al., 2013;
Mkenda, Luvanda, & Ruhinduka 2010; Policy Forum & Twaweza 2009). At this juncture, it is
necessary to rethink a new approach for development. This paper proposes for a unification of
dependency and neoliberal thoughts by adopting the Republic of Korea’s development approach
which enabled the republic of Korea become a developmental state and thus industrialized.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.32 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Tanzania can become a developmental state and attain its development agenda by merging the two
experiences it has had of state driven and market-led economy.
During Ujamaa period in 1967- 985, Tanzania adapted the developmental state trajectory as
its pathway to development (Kieh-Klay, 2015; Sandbrook, 1995). Therefore, developmental state is
not a new concept to Tanzania. The question, however, is why did the developmental state in the
country fail? A number of factors, both internal and external, forced Tanzania to abandon the
developmental state (Kieh-klay, 2015). Some of the factors included: lack of a vibrant private
sector, failure of attracting FDIs, use of obsolete technologies in the industries, and poor economic
polies, such as too much state economic intervention (Tanzania Human Development Report, 2014;
Ubhenin & Edeh, 2014; Leys, 1996; Sandbrook, 1995).
This paper proposes developmental state as the appropriate model to attain successfully the
country’s development agenda and poverty reduction. Tanzania has already experienced the
developmental state model. Therefore when it addresses the factors that made it fail to realise its
objectives in the first place, it can strive to achieve its plans successfully this time. Moreover, the
country has experienced both state-led economy under the influence of dependency school of
thought and the open market economy under the influence of neo-liberal policies. Both schools
have their strengths and weaknesses. These factors have influenced the country’s economy
accordingly. The paper proposes that Tanzania builds its developmental state model based on the
strengths found in the two schools of thoughts.
In order for Tanzania to become a successful developmental state, there should be a guiding
theory. When Tanzania became a developmental state in the period after independence especially
from 1967-1985, it was informed by the dependence school. Whereas since mid-1980s to date, it
does not have a distinct development model and is being informed by the neo-liberal school. , The
paper commends the use of combination of revised dependency and neo-liberal schools.
The dependence school calls for revolution and socialism for an economy to industrialise
(Siddle & Swindell, 1990). Tanzania employed the dependence ideas through Ujamaa for about
twenty years; there were both successes and failures.. Socialism in this combination refers to the
state that takes the leading role in its economic growth and development, however, without
nationalising the major means of production. Economic development will ensure poverty alleviation
and thus attain the country’s development agenda. By revolution in this aspect, we refer to the
change of a developmental model from the current status of no specific development model to a
democratic developmental state.
The neo-liberal school of thoughts calls for strong reformed institutions, free market and
vibrant private sector for an economy to industrialise. Tanzania’s economy has, for about thirty
years, been informed by neo-liberalism which promoted economic growth. However, neo-liberalism
has failed to reduce poverty significantly, especially among the majority rural people because the
growth was neither pro-poor nor inclusive (Kessy et al., 2013; Mashindano et al., 2011). Moreover,
neo-liberalism operated in an époque where there was no development model in the country.
Therefore, in order for economic growth to be inclusive and pro-poor for poverty reduction and
attaining the country’s development agenda, this paper proposes that Tanzania becomes a
developmental state while governed by the amalgamation of revised dependency and neo-liberal
schools of thought. This model should shift the attention from economic growth, which has failed to
reduce poverty significantly, to economic development which adopts new technologies, transiting
from an agriculture-based to industry-based economy that improves the standard of living and
economic health of a population.
Kieh-Klay (2015) proposes that African countries become developmental states by adhering
to important factors that would enable African states become developmental. They include: the type
of state – in this case a democratic developmental state; these factors are the same as those that the
paper argues for and calls upon Tanzania to embrace these conditions for a successful
developmental state. The factors in the discussion are the same ones in different vocabularies that
Kasahara (2013) argued for when explaining the success of South Korea as a developmental state.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.33 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
However, Kieh-Klay (2015) adds the aspect of democracy as a factor for development; this
is a new factor which adds value to a developmental state and argues for democratic ones contrary
to South Korea which was authoritarian but became successful; this is different from Tanzania
which was somewhat authoritarian but failed to succeed. When Tanzania adapts and adopts these
factors, then it will be possible for the country to become a successful developmental state this time
and thus meet the country’s developmental goals and poverty reduction.
Tanzania has favourable conditions of becoming a developmental state as the Republic of
Korea did because it has some crucial factors and can continue to improve the necessary conditions
for becoming a developmental state as long as the political will is there. In East Asia, in general,
and in the Republic of Korea in particular, the factors that facilitated the project included good
macro-economic management and stability, a competent bureaucracy, interdependence between the
public and private sectors, publicly controlled financing for development and industrial policy in a
much wider sense (Kasahara, 2013). The factors are summarized into two main categories:
competent bureaucracy and embedded economy.
Competent bureaucracy: Amsden (1989) in Kasahara (2013) argues that competent
bureaucracy was one of the necessary factors that made it possible for the developmental state in the
Republic of Korea. The country created a pilot agency that was staffed with the country’s finest
workforce that was given the task of directing the course of the country’s development. The pilot
agency was empowered with authority to keep on employing outstanding personnel and utilised
policy tools to facilitate their work competently. Consequently, the Republic of Korea was able to
develop the greatest state capacity both to formulate the right development policies and to execute
them efficiently (Kasahara, 2013).
Embedded autonomy: A competent bureaucracy should be able to maintain an effective
relationship with the domestic private sector, specifically on the direction and funding in the
industrial sector. Evans (1995) in Kasahara (2013) coined the slogan “embedded autonomy” to
explain the ideal relationship between the developmental state and the local business sector. It was
argued that a successful developmental state needs to be sufficiently embedded in society so as to
attain its development agenda by acting through “social infrastructure”, but the state should not be
too close to the business class to the point of being influenced by particular interests of the private
sector and forget its major objective of the development agenda (Kasahara, 2013; Mkandawire,
Tanzania has necessary conditions for becoming a developmental state and thus attaining its
development agenda. The government of Tanzania (2005) acknowledges the importance of the
private sector as a key development partner; the government advocates for public, private
partnership in the country; this is a good avenue for consultation between the state and the business
leaders. Moreover, the country has a strong political will and commitment to continue
implementing necessary policy changes and institutional reforms across priority sectors so as to
meet the development agenda (USAID, 2014). The political will can facilitate the formulation of the
right policies and implement them similarly to the Korean model. Tanzania continues to be a
peaceful state - a condition necessary to attract FDI, multinational companies and absorption of
technology and innovation for development, which is more attainable in developing countries like
Tanzania (Kraemer-Mbula & Wamae, 2010).

This paper has discussed the development theories that have applied in the country during the
course of over five decades in the pursuit of development and alleviation of poverty amongst the
population. In the paper, the study has proposed and discussed a new development approach that the
country can adopt to realise development and accelerate efforts on poverty reduction. Through the
theoretical literature review, findings revealed that Tanzania was one of the pioneers of the
developmental state in Africa.
Tanzania became a developmental state during the époque of the state-led economy under
the influence of dependency theory, through Ujamaa. However, due to some domestic and

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.34 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
international factors, Tanzania abandoned that pathway to development, and moved on to attaining
its development agenda without a specific development model while following features of both
dependency and neo-liberal policies.
Findings from the reviewed literature have revealed that both dependency and neo-liberal
policies had limited success in achieving the country’s development agenda and poverty reduction
at different eras. The paper proposes that Tanzania becomes a developmental state and shifts the
attention from economic growth to economic development.

Arndt, C., Demry, L., McKay, A. & Tarp, F. (2016). Growth and Poverty Reduction in Tanzania,
in Growth and Poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa, Arndt, C., McKay, A. & Tarp, F (Eds), UNU-
WIDER, New York: Oxford University Press.
Boesen. J., Madsen, B.S. & Moody, T. (1977). Ujamaa-Socialism from Above. Uppsala:
Scandinavian Institute of African Studies.
Cooksey, B.(2013). ‘What will it take for Tanzania to become a developmental state? Evidence
from Tanzania Governance Review 2010-11. Policy Forum Breakfast Debate 22 February, Dar
es Salaam.
Cornelli, M.E. (2012). A critical Analysis of Nyerere’s Ujamaa: An investigation of its foundations
and values. PhD dissertation, University of Birmingham. Accessed on 26th June 2014 at:
Coulson, A. (2014). Conference of 50 years of Development in Sub Saharan Africa: The experience
of Tanzania, Bradford University, England 29-30 May
Accessed 07th November 2015:
Dollar, D. & Kraay, A. (2001). Growth is good for the poor. Development Research Group, The
World Bank.Washington. (general reference).
Edwards, S. (2012). Is Tanzania a success Story? A long term Analysis. National Bureau of
Economic Research, working paper 17764.
Feldman, M., Hadjimichael, T., Kemeny, T & Lanahan, L. (2014). Economic Development: a
definition and model for investment.
Accessed on 26th April 2015:
https://www.eda.gov/tools/files/research-reports/investment definition-model.pdf
Fouéré, M. (2014). Julius Nyerere, Ujamaa, and Political Morality in Contemporary Tanzania.
African Studies Review, 57(1):1-24.
Hansen, A. (2010). Integration and Late Industrialisation: The Effects of Neoliberal Economic
Globalisation on Development and Late Industrialisation. esharp, issue 15: Uniting Nations:
Risks and Opportuties.
Harvey, D. (2005). A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.(general
Heywood, L. (2013). Why Did South Korea Grow Rich, 1960-1985? E-international Relations
Students. Accessed 26th March 2016 at http://www.e-ir.info/2013/03/16/why-did-south-korea-
Hofisi. C. (2013)., “After the Lost Decades: Rethinking Africa’s development from a Development
State perspective,” Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, Rome: MCSER Publishing,
Vol.4, No.11 October.
Ibbott, R. (2014). Ujamaa: The hidden Story of Tanzania’s socialist villages, London:Crossroads
Books.(general reference).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.35 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Ibhawoh, B. & Dibua, I.J. (2003). Deconstructing Ujamaa: The legacy of Julius Nyerere in the
quest for Social and Economic Development in Africa. African Journal of Political Science,
Kaiser, P.J. (1996). Structural Adjustment and the Fragile Nation: The demise of social Unity in
Tanzania, Journal of Modern African Studies 34(2): 227-237.
Kasahara, S. (2013). The Asian Developmental State and the Flying Geese Paradigm. United
Nations, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Discussion Papers No.213.
Kieh-Klay, G. (2015). Constructing the Social democratic developmental state in Africa: lessons
from the Global South. Journal of the Global South: a Springer Open Journal. Accessed on 31st
May 2017 at https://bandungjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40728-014-0004-4
Kraemer-Mbula, E. & Wamae, W. (2010). The Relevance of Innovation Systems to Developing
Countries,’ in Innovation and the Development Agenda, eds Kraemer-Mbula, E & Wamae, W.
OECD/IDRC: OECD Publications.
Krueger, A. (1990). Government Failures in Development. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4(3).
Lewis, A.W. (1954). Economic Development with unlimited Supplies of Labour. The Manchester
School, 22 (2):139-191.
Leys, C. (1996). The rise and fall of Development Theory. Nairobi: East African Educational
Publishers. (general reference)
Martins, P. (2013). Growth, Employment and Poverty in Africa: Tales of Lions and Cheetahs.
Overseas Development Institute: Background paper for the World Development Report.
Mashindano, O., Kayunze, K., Corta, L & Maro, F. (2013). Growth Without Poverty Reduction in
Tanzania—Reasons for the Mismatch’ in Kessy et al. Translating Growth into Poverty
Reduction: Beyond the Numbers, Dar es Salaam: Mkuki na Nyota.
Mashindano, O., Kayunze,K., Maro, F., Corta, L. & Shepherd, A. (2013). Agricultural Growth and
Poverty Reduction in Tanzania-Emerging Issues and Major Recommendations’ in Kessy et al.
2013, Translating Growth into Poverty Reduction: Beyond the Numbers, Dar es Salaam: Mkuki
na Nyota.
Mashindano, O. & Maro, F. (2011). Growth without poverty reduction in Tanzania: Reasons for
the Mismatch’, Working Paper No.207, Chronic Poverty Research Centre.
Mashindano, O., Kayunze, K., Corta, L. & Maro, F. (2011). ‘Agricultural Growth and Poverty
Reduction in Tanzania 2000-2010: Where has Agriculture worked for the poor and what can we
learn from this? Working Paper No.208, Chronic Poverty Research Centre.
McMillan, M. & Harttgen, K. (2014). What is driving the African growth miracle? National Bureau
of Economic Research, Working paper 2007.
Mkandawire, T. (2001). Thinking about developmental States in Africa. Cambridge Journal of
Economics, 25, 3.
Mkenda, A.F., Luvanda, E.G. & Ruhinduka, R. (2010). Growth and distribution in Tanzania:
Recent experience and lessons. Dar es Salaaam: Repoa.
Msambichaka, L., Luvanda, E., Mashindano, O. & Ruhinduka, R. (2010). Analysis of the
Performance of Agriculture Sector and its Contribution to Economic Growth and Poverty
Reduction. Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs in Tanzania.
Msyani, M.C. (2013). Current Status of Energy Sector in Tanzania: Executive exchange on
developing an Ancillary Service Market. Washington DC: USEA.
Mogalakwe, M. (2006). The use of documentary research Methods in social research. African
Sociological Review, 10(1) 221-230.
Moreira, B.S. & Crespo, N. (2012). Development Economics from the traditional approaches to the
New concepts: New Challenges of Economic and Business Development. Latvia: University of
Ndulu, B.J. (1994). Tanzania’s economic development: lessons from the experience and challenges
for the future, in M, L.A, Msambichaka, H.P.B. Moshi & F.P. Mtafikolo (Eds) Development

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.36 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Challenges and strategies for Tanzania: An agenda for the 21stcentury, Dar es Salaam:
University of Dar es Salaam Press.
Ngowi, P.H. (2009). Economic Development and change in Tanzania since independence: The
Political leadership factor. African Journal of Political Science and International Relations
Nord, R., Sobolev, Y., Dunn, D., Hajdenberg, A., Hobdari, N., Maziad, S. & Roudet, S. (2009).
Tanzania: The Story of an African Transition. Washington, D.C: International Monetary Fund.
Policy Forum & Twaweza. (2009). Growth in Tanzania: is it Reducing Poverty? Accessed on
11th November 2014 at:

Rydenfelt, S. (1986). Lessons from Socialist Tanzania. Retrieved:

http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/lessons-from-socialist-tanzania On 25 June 2014.
Scott, J. (1990). A Matter of Record, Documentary Sources in Social Research. Cambridge: Polity
Shephard. A. (2010). Growth and Poverty Reduction Policy implications from qualitativeResearch.
Chronic Poverty Research Centre, Policy Brief No 21.
Siddle, D. & Swindell, K. (1990). Rural Change in Tropical Africa From Colonies to Nation- tates.
Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Skinner, G. (2011). The Neoclassical Counterrevolution and Developing Economies: A Case Study
of Political and Economic Changes in the Philippines. Social Sciences Journal,7(1): 12.
Tanzania Human Development Report. (2014). Economic Transformation for Human
Development. Dar es Salaam: Economic and Social Research Foundation.
Todaro, M.P. & Smith, S.C. (2009). Economic Development. Boston: Pearson Addison Wesley.
Todaro, M.P. & Smith, S.C. (2012). Economic Development (11th ed.). Boston: Pearson Addison
Ubhenin, O.E. & Edeh, N.J. (2014). Asian Developmental states: Lessons for Africa. Yonetim
Bilimleri Dergisi, 12(1):7-42.
United Republic of Tanzania. (2012). The Tanzania Five Year Development Plan 2011/12 –
2015/16: Unleashing Tanzania’s Latent Growth Potentials. Dar es Salaam: President’s Office,
Planning Commission.
United Republic of Tanzania. (2014). Tanzania Human Development Report 2014: Economic
Transformation for Human Development. Dar es Salaam: Ministry of Finance.
United Republic of Tanzania. (2015). Ministry website on ‘Health service in Tanzania. Accessed on
9th May 2015 at http://www.moh.go.tz/index.php/health-services-in-tanzania
USAID. (2014). Country Development Cooperation Strategy October 3, 2014 – October 3, 2019:
Tanzania’s Socio-Economic Transformation toward Middle Income Status by 2025 Advanced.
Wangwe, S. & Charle, P. (2005). Macro-economic Policy choices for Growth and Poverty
Reduction: The Case of Tanzania. Dar es Salaam: Economic and Social Research Foundation.
World Bank (1981), Accelerated Development in Sub-Saharan Africa: An Agenda for
Action (Washington, D.C.: World Bank).
World Bank. (2013). Tanzania Economic Update, Opening the gates: how the Port of Dar es
Salaan can transform. Tanzania: Washington: World Bank.
World Bank. (2015). Tanzania Mainland Poverty Assessment. Washington DC: World Bank.
World Bank. (2015). Global Monitoring Report 2014/2015: Ending Poverty and Sharing Prosperity. Washington, DC: World Bank.
Wuyts, M. & Kilama, B. (2014). The Changing Economy of Tanzania: Patterns of Accumulation
and structural change. Dar es Salaam: ESRF and REPOA.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.37 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Table1: Tanzania: Income Poverty and Non-income poverty Indicators 1967-1975

During the time of dependency theory – The Ujamaa period

Some Income Poverty 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975
Real GDP Growth (%) 4.8 5.1 2.3 6.0 3.8 5.3 3.5 2.5 5.9
Per capital GDP growth 1.7 2.0 -0.8 2.8 0.6 2.0 0.2 -0.8 2.7
Inflation, consumer, prices 12.2 15.6 16.4 3.5 4.8 7.6 10.4 19.6 26.1
annual (%)
Official Exchange rate 7.14 7.14 7.14 7.14 7.14 7.14 7.02 7.13 7.37
(Tsh/US $ -period
Exports (% of GDP) 26.5 24.2 24.7 24.0 24.1 24.6 22.4 21.3 18.2
Imports (% of GDP) 26.2 26.7 24.4 28.4 33.0 29.8 29.3 34.8 31.0

Some Non-Income Poverty Indicators

Populations (millions) 12.4 12.8 13.2 13.6 14.0 14.5 15.0 15.5 16.0
Life Expectancy at birth 45.6 45.9 46.3 46.7 47.0 47.4 47.9 48.3 48.7
Primary School Enrolment 33.8 35.2 37.2 40.2 43.5 53.1
(% gross)
Secondary School 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.8 3.0 3.1
Enrolment(% gross)
Source: Adapted from Edwards, 2012, Table 4 and Table 5

Table 1: Tanzania: Income Poverty and Non-Income Poverty Indicators 1976- 1985
During the time of dependency theory - The Ujamaa period
Some Income Poverty 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985
Real GDP Growth (%) 5.4 0.4 1.2 3.4 3.0 0.5 0.6 2.4 3.4 4.6
Per capital GDP growth 2.2 -2.8 -1.9 0.2 -0.2 -2.7 -2.6 -0.8 0.2 1.4
Inflation, consumer, 6.9 11.6 6.6 12.9 30.2 25.7 28.9 27.1 36.1 33.3
prices annual (%)
Official Exchange rate 8.38 8.29 7.71 8.22 8.20 8.28 9.28 11.1 15.3 17.5
(Tsh/US $ -period
Exports (% of GDP) 21.7 19.5 14.6 14.1 13.2 12.2 8.5 8.0 9.0 6.8
Imports (% of GDP) 23.9 22.8 29.7 26.9 26.3 20.7 17.7 14.1 16.7 16.8

Some Non-Income Poverty Indicators

Populations (millions) 16.5 17.0 17.5 18.1 18.7 19.3 19.9 20.5 21.1 21.8
Life Expectancy at birth 49.0 49.4 49.7 49.9 50.2 50.4 50.6 50.8 50.9 51.1
Primary School 63.1 71.1 90.7 94.2 95.6 97.2 93.3 91.5 86.9 76.4
Enrolment (% gross)

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.38 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Secondary School 3.2 3.3 3.3 3.4 3.3 3.1 3.0 3.1 3.1 3.3
Enrolment(% gross)
Source: Adapted from Edwards, 2012, Table 5 and Table 6

Figure 1: Annual real growth rates of Gross Domestic Product 1998 -2010
This was during the neo-liberalism period (Growth increased without significant poverty reduction)
Growth rate
7 7.8
7.2 7.4 7.1 7.4
6 6.9 7
5 6 6
4 4.8 4.9
3 4.1

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
ource: adapted from Mashindano & Maro (2011) Figure 1.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.39 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

The Inequities in Health Shaped by Political Forces:

A Critical View
Dionéia Motta Monte-Serrat, Russell Kabir, and S.M. Yasir Arafat

About the author(s)

Dionéia Motta Monte-Serrat is a Collaborating researcher at IEL-UNICAMP. Doctoral degree in
Psychology, FFCLRP-USP. Doctoral degree program partly completed at Université Paris III,
Sorbonne Nouvelle (2010, CAPES-BEX). Internship at École des Hautes Études en Sciences
Sociales, Paris (2012, FAPESP). Lawyer and faculty member (Assistant Professor in the
Undergraduate Law Program) at RibeirãoPreto University (UNAERP) since 2013. Professor in the
Master's Program in Health and Education at University of Ribeirão Preto (UNAERP) since
February 6th, 2017. For correspondence: E-mail di_motta61@yahoo.com.br
 Russell Kabir is Senior Lecturer in Research Methods, Department for Allied and Public
Health, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Anglia Ruskin University, Chelmsford, UK. Editor-in-Chief
of International Journal of Perceptions in Public Health. Email: russellkabir@live.co.uk
 S.M. Yasir Arafat is Resident, Department of Psychiatry, Level 11, Block-D, Bangabandhu
Sheikh Mujib Medical University, Shahbagh, Dhaka-1000, Bangladesh. MD in Psychiatry at BSM
Medical University, Dhaka, Bangladesh. Editor-in-Chief- International Journal of Perceptions in
Public Health; Editorial Member - International Journal of Psychiatry, EC Psychology and
Psychiatry, South East Asia Journal of Medical Sciences; Scientific Advisory Member-Journal of
Behavioral Health; Adjunct Faculty at MPH Program, ASA University Bangladesh. Email:

The aim of this paper is to analyze critically how the State Power is formed and influences health.
We use Discourse Analysis Theory to analyze, in discursive materiality (laws, regulations,
determinations) as indications of the ideological effects that prevent citizens from perceiving the
fact stated in the WHO report (2008). That report places the State in a paradoxical situation: as
responsible for changes in the social determinants of health and, at the same time, as the main cause
of health inequities. Ten years after WHO report on this subject was still being produced as a letter
of intent on the demand for new ways of thinking and acting on health. How can this happen: the
State itself is one of the main causes of health inequities and seems to be another political institution
being challenged? In analyzing the topic of “health inequities”, we can shed some light on the
effects of meaning generated by this ambiguity: the category of a legal subject is subjected and its
action of challenging the unfair distribution of social resources must necessarily take place
according to the laws, within the limits set by the State itself. The appearance of an “object of
choice” is in reality located within limits, leading subjects to misery. How to get around the
inequities in health brought by the State? We believe that the way out lies in the construction of
such social conditions to promote solidarity. It is in this context that health promotion becomes an
end in itself and legitimates actions in health that overcome inequalities.

Key words: Health; Inequities; Political Forces; Discourse Analysis

Monte-Serrat, D.M., Kabir, R. and Arafat, Yasir, S.M. (2017). “The Inequities in Health Shaped by
Political Forces: A Critical View.” Inter. J. Res. Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 39–47.
(Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.40 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

WHO (2008) establishes that there are inequities in health, avoidable health inequalities, which
“arise because of the circumstances in which people grow, live, work, and age, and the systems put
in place to deal with illness”. It also establishes that the conditions in which people live and die are
shaped by political, social, and economic forces.
The mentioned report was promoted by World Health Organization (WHO, 2008) through
the Commission on Social Determinants of Health (CSDH), titled “Closing the gap in a
generation”. Its conclusion is that “social justice is a matter of life and death. It affects the way
people live, their consequent chance of illness, and their risk of premature death”. Although
inequity in power interacts, according to WHO, in four main dimensions: political, economic, social
and cultural, we focus our attention on the role that the State plays as one of the major causes of
inequity in health: “poor and unequal living conditions are the consequence of poor social policies
and programs, unfair economic arrangements, and bad politics” (WHO, CSDH, 2008). The
Commission on Social Determinants of Health indicates a better distribution of power within
society as a solution in the following cases takes as example:

“[…] Urban planning […] that produces sprawling neighbourhoods with little
affordable housing, few local amenities, and irregular unaffordable public transport does
little to promote good health for all (NHF, 2007) […] trade policy that actively
encourages the unfettered production, trade and consumption of foods high in fats and
sugars to the detriment of fruit and vegetable production is contradictory to health
policy, which recommends relatively little consumption of highfat, high-sugar foods
and increased consumption of fruit and vegetables” (Elinder, 2005). (WHO, 2008, p.

We will critically analyze how the State Power is formed and the political aspects of the
protection given by the State to health. These analyses will be made in light of the Discourse
Analysis Theory (Pêcheux, 1988) which seeks discursive materiality (laws, regulations,
determinations) indications of the ideological effects that prevent citizens from perceiving the
following: the fact that the WHO report (WHO, 2008) places the State in a paradoxical situation,
that is, places it as responsible for changes in the social determinants of health and, at the same
time, as the main cause of health inequities.
The term “inequity in health” will also be analyzed under the methodology of the Discourse
Analysis Theory in order to understand that the relationship between citizens and the State places
the latter in a “supposed” role of achieving Social Well-Being. It is a “supposed” role because if we
look at reality, many efforts have been put forward to propose new attitudes towards health since
2008. Texts on the subject were still being produced in 2013. We are in 2017, and there is a letter of
intent on the demand for new ways of thinking and acting on health. There has been a discursive
functioning hidden in the discourse of outlining strategies over so many years. The efficacy of
ideology - related to this discursive functioning and “concealed under the strategy of reference to
evidence” (Zizek, 1999, p. 13) -structures our perception of reality in advance, making it
“indiscernible from its ‘aestheticized’ image” (Ibid, p. 21).


2.1 Concept of State
Before we proceed to the analysis, we need to make some statements about what is the State. Cesar
Luiz Pasold (2008), in an article on the “Conception for the Contemporary State”, affirms that the
notion of State has not always been the same. For that author, the concept of State is historical and
concrete, and it cannot be applied indistinctly for all ages, but only for the period in which the idea
and practice of Sovereignty arose. According to Pasold, the Contemporary State is conceived as a

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.41 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
political institution whose purpose is the Common Good, and it places itself as an “effective
instrument at the service of the Social Whole” (op. cit.).
Paulo Buss (2000, p. 174) also identifies that Sovereignty when he defines the
Contemporary State as a “new conception [...] that (re)establishes the centrality of its public
character and its social responsibility, that is, its commitment to public interest and common good”.
This State’s sovereign power over citizen’s life makes State interests prevail, whatever one claims
that the State promotes well-being.

2.2 Health and the State

The topic of international health protection is part of the international protection of human rights,
which is the responsibility of the United Nations Organization (UNO), an entity created at the end
of World War II which currently comprises 191 of the 193 States of the world. Its purpose is to
maintain peace, uphold human rights and fundamental freedoms and promote the development of
countries on a world scale.
Human rights are protected in a comprehensive way, - including economic, social and
cultural rights - and they are intended to protect the human being, not the State, by means of
instruments, such as treaties and resolutions, applied both at global (UNO) and regional (States)
levels (Batista, 2008). Regarding the application of human rights, Batista (2008) affirms that there
is interaction between international law and domestic law, and “primacy is always given to the
norm that best protects human rights”. In order for international standards to be met, it is necessary
for the States that have adopted them to undertake foreign and domestic policies so as to comply
with what has been agreed upon (Batista, 2008).
In the interest of protecting human rights, States should report to UNO on the measures they
have taken will be forwarded to the Economic and Social Council and specialized agencies so that
they can draw up appropriate recommendations, to help solve problems and make decisions. With
regard to health, the specialized agency to carry out this task within the United Nations is the World
Health Organization (WHO). WHO was established in 1946, when it was necessary to fight
epidemics internationally, since domestic measures were insufficient (Batista, 2008). Over the years
the tasks became more complex and, in 1986, WHO produced the “Ottawa Charter”, which became
a reference for health promotion by innovating with the idea of community participation in actions
aimed at improving quality of life and health.

“The concept of health as well-being transcends the idea of healthy forms of life; health
promotion transcends the health sector [...] the conditions and requirements for health
are: peace, education, housing, food, income, a stable ecosystem, sustainable resources,
social justice and equity” (Buss, 2000, p.170).

According to WHO, health is conceptualized as a state of complete physical, mental and

social well-being (Batista, 2008). This organization has the task of promoting debate on health as
well as the purpose of implementing, in the various States of the international community,
Commissions on Social Determinants of Health (CSDH), composed of representatives of the most
diverse sectors of society in order to “gather scientific knowledge and evidence, make a diagnosis
of the main problems and define recommendations for coping with the situation” (Jornal da Ciência,
2008). Both WHO, at the international level, and CSDH, at the national level, play the role of
giving general policy guidance related to the social determinants of health (SDH).

2.3 Health and the Law

Under the focus of health and based on human rights, we see the State as the formulator of its
supreme law, the Constitution, which outlines the fundamental guarantees of citizens. When the law
deals with human rights, it discusses guarantees for life, freedom and social life, in the pursuit of

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.42 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Such human rights have not always existed. They began to be discussed in the seventeenth
and eighteenth centuries in order to ensure the rights and freedoms of individuals against the
despotism of the state (Dirhum, 2008). Social rights, in turn, date back to the twentieth century and
constitute guarantees for paid work and social assistance, which later evolved into universal health
care (Idem). Rights and freedoms arose as limitations to the State’s power over the individual and
his private life, as they resulted from social movements which, in the mid-nineteenth century, aimed
at protecting workers.
An individual’s rights may be civil, political or social, depending on the institution that
administers them. Social rights include the services rendered by the State to the individual in order
to provide him with well-being, including the rights of education, work and health. The right to
health is given a special category because its holders are not individuals, but the people, the family,
the nation or regional groups (Dirhum, 2008).
Social rights gained from the “Constitution of the World Health Organization in 1946 and
the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in 1976” (Dirhum, 2008); and
its strengthening took place in the twentieth century because, with the tendency to equalize
individuals, they conflicted with the capitalist system of social classes, which was responsible for
the growth of social differences (Dirhum, 2008). Once recognized, human and social rights began to
be realized through public policies and State benefits in relation to the individual, both to recognize
special rights for patients and to prevent health problems (Dirhum, 2008).
According to Buss (2000, p. 171), the discourse of health promotion blends with the idea of
public sector accountability, “not only for the social policies that it formulates and implements (or
for the consequences when it fails to do so), but also for economic policies and their impact on the
health situation and the health system”.
According to the WHO’s final report, “Closing the gap in a generation” - organized by the
Commission on Social Determinants of Health, (see WHO, 2008) - it is the State’s responsibility to
promote health and guarantee its necessary conditions.
However, such guarantees, which have a constitutional nature and are recognized by
governmental entities, suffer limitations, since, in addition to the need for economic resources that
are presently scarce, they require a limit of equilibrium between individual rights and freedoms
(which implies in the State’s not intervening in people’s private lives), on the one hand, and social
rights (which lead to State’s intervention in individuals’ private lives), on the other (Dirhum, 2008).
There is also difficulty in making them effective, thus preventing health inequities from occurring.
Although, for example, “women with no education are likely to suffer more from domestic violence
than who have some education or higher education” (Ferdous et al., 2017), how the State could
intervene in the private life of citizens?

“Health, once recognized and proclaimed as the fundamental right of the human being,
makes it possible, at the same time, to recognize the existence of duties and
responsibilities of governments and the society in general [...] This implies, therefore,
the State’s obligation to establish a legal order such that the enjoyment and exercise of
these rights are fully guaranteed [...]” (Dirhum, 2008).

The law imposes limits to the State’s action regarding health: public policies are designed and
outlined by law. Therefore, a policy is public only if it meets the requirements of the law (Dirhum,

2.4 Inequalities, Inequities and Determinants in Health

The concepts of “inequality”, “inequity” and “determinants” are of crucial importance in the work
performed by WHO and the National Commission on Social Determinants (CSDH). Inequalities,
according to the World Health Organization report “Closing the gap in a generation” (WHO, 2008),
are systematic differences in the health situation of population groups. Inequities are health

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.43 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
inequalities which, in addition to being systematic and relevant, are avoidable, unjust and
unnecessary (Buss, 2008, CNDSS).
The social determinants of health (SDH) are perceived, according to Buss (op. cit.), in the
comparison of differences or inequalities in the health status among individuals or between groups.
The health of a group of young people, for example, differs from the health of a group of elderly
persons due to inequalities caused by diseases that are typical for the age of members belonging to
each of these groups. This situation is regarded as “natural” and results from inequalities arising
from the social conditions in which such people live. These conditions arising from social
inequalities are referred to by WHO (2008) as the Social Determinants of Health (SDH) and, unlike
the “natural” inequalities, they are unjust and unacceptable and, therefore, called “inequities”. An
example of inequity in health is the greater likelihood of a child’s dying before reaching the first
year of life simply because this child was born in one region of the country and not in another or
because his/her mother did not attend school.
The relationship between SDH and their effects is complex, and it cannot be regarded only
as a cause-effect relationship. The Social Determinants of Health (SDH) include cultural,
environmental and socioeconomic conditions, as well as human conditions of life and work, such as
sanitation, housing, health services, work environment and education. It is “the social, economic,
cultural, ethnic or racial, psychological and behavioral factors that influence the health standards of
individuals” (Jornal da Ciência, 2008). If a group in society is excluded from a benefit that should
be available to all, according to the Constitution, that will reflect on the determinants of the health
standards of such group.
Modifying this situation, which imposes differences of treatment among individuals, and
interfering directly in these SDH imply assessing and exercising influence on State policies and
programs. The necessary political support to that end will only be achieved if society is aware of the
serious problem that health inequities The WHO report, “Closing the gap generation” (2008),
states that the national government should strengthen the political and legal systems to ensure that
they will promote the equal inclusion of all in the political process in order to strengthen health
initiatives oriented towards equality in health.
WHO also points out the importance of social movements as to the fact that they should
have space for challenging and questioning. It concludes by stating that a society that is concerned
about better and fairer distribution of health is one that challenges power relations through
participation, thus ensuring that all voices are heard and respected in the decision-making process
related to health equity. (WHO, 2008, Chapter 14).

2.5 The juridical discourse on health

The State legislates on health. The fact that the legal discourse takes place in the juridical body, for
enforcement purpose, implies notions of obligation, of the imperative of the law, which will
influence the materiality of language and the origin of the subjects’ enunciation. Law, as a science
that is said to be “neutral”, erases the historical origins of its impositions.
In this article, we seek to understand how the “neutrality” of Law emerged, going beyond
the idea of transparency and legal idealism. Thus, we understand Law as a mode of reproduction of
a social functioning that reproduces the State, and which, at the same time, wants to be seen as
detached from social phenomena. Michel Pêcheux (1988) states that social phenomena are not
explained politically or ideologically, but have a structural causality. Pêcheux proposes a materialist
theory of discursive processes, in which he approaches the concept of “subject evidence” to the
concept of “evidence of meaning” by stating that the unconscious and ideology have the common
characteristic of concealing their very existence within their own functioning (Pêcheux, op . cit., p.
153) and that there is a play of ideological effects in every discourse: ideology, concealed by “use”
and “custom”, determines “what is” and “what must be” and the legal subject is constituted under
such evidence (ibid, p. 160).
Thus, “the law progressively takes the lead, ensuring other more insidious forms of closure
that will paradoxically pass through the apparent autonomization of the subject” (Haroche, 1992, p.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.44 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
70-71). Such “autonomization” takes place by means of a new form of subjection. Ideology, which
is present in language in an insidious way, leads to an ‘internal’ subjection of individuals, who are
gradually constituted into “free legal subjects” (Haroche 1992, p. 71, emphasis added).
It is in this discursive functioning which Haroche claims that the “juridical subject of
linguistics” exists, in whom there is an “interiorization of the subject’s dependence [...] on the
ideology of power”. The term “subject” is taken according to the conceptualization given to it
Althusser (1976, p. 121), with the following ambivalence of meaning:1)free subjectivity: a center of
initiatives, the author is responsible his actions; 2) a subjected being, submitted to a higher
authority, therefore, devoid of all freedom, except that of freely accepting his submission [..] it is no
longer a situation of understanding or questioning, but only of understanding to submit oneself
(Haroche, 1992, p. 84, emphasis added). Haroche explains that the specificity of juridical language
is what guarantees the power of the State:

“By establishing jurisdictions, laws and regulations, the real power develops the power
of the State apparatus: it cannot, on pain of renouncing such establishment, vulgarize
the meanings of juridical language, which is in fact its best guarantee” (Haroche, 1992,
p. 87).

Wam (1980) states that the subject theory cuts across the divisions of human and social
sciences, ranging from the metaphysical to the linguistic, and takes part in a basic problem relates
to the description and conception of the meaning of enunciations and discourses to state that “The
legal discourse is one of those linguistic forms that express ‘ideology’, hiding the enunciating
subject, but allowing, for that very reason, for him to subsist and retain his dominant ideology”
(Edelman, 1980, p. 15). Such subject is constituted for the Law, in the legal subject category.
Althusser ([1970]1974, p. 29) adopts the thesis that ideology interpellates individuals into subjects.
He also takes the idea that the term “subject” arises with the advent of bourgeois ideology and,
above all, of juridical ideology (the one who adopts the legal category of a legal subject to make it
into an ideological notion: man is by nature a subject) (Edelman, 1980, p. 20). Edelman (1980, p.
21) cites Althusser to state that the subject category is constitutive of all ideology.
According to the theory of Discourse Analysis (Pêcheux, 1988), there is an identification of
the subject with a dominant discursive formation which unconsciously subjects it. Discursive
formation (DF), within Pecheutian Discourse Analysis, is a set of enunciations with similar
formation rules which determines what can and what must be said in a historically determined
social place. It will be under this perspective that we will approach the inequities in health. There is,
according to Haroche (1992, p. 20, emphasis added), a “passivity of the subject” before the
institutions: “the power, the State and the law coerce the subject, insinuate themselves in him
discreetly”; there is “a form of power that classifies individuals into categories, identifies them,
binds them, imprisons them in their identity”. It is important to stress that the active participation of
citizens in coping with inequities in health, WHO (2008, chapter 14) points to the right to a legal
identity which is essential in this process, because people cannot claim their rights - access to
education, social well-being, health care, civic participation and security - without a legalized
According to the theory of discourse (AD, Pêcheux, 1988), the subject is not “born” and does
not “develop”, but he is constituted, and such constitution, which also includes the constitution of
the subject of the unconscious, is articulated to the social plane, where there is the apparent
autonomization of the subject, a “‘freely consented self-repression’ that is induced by the State in
the individual” (1992, p. 26, footnote).
The notion of State, according to Filomeno's lesson (2006, p. 11), includes: “a territory, a
population and the law, to which power is necessarily coupled”. The simple sum of the individuals
who inhabit a certain territory does not correspond to the notion of State; there is something else
that makes its unity possible:

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.45 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
“Old customs would not suffice to define rights and duties in a society such as this, with
its high standard of living, its unequal distribution of wealth, and the vast field that it
offered to the fight for personal interests; new measures of social control would become
necessary, measures that could hardly be put into practice by any means other than the
institution of a government with sovereign authority and submission to that government;
in other words, by the creation of a State” (Burns, 1959, p. 23, In Filomeno, op. cit., p.

State and legal subject are interdependent concepts, therefore: the word subject means
“submitted to sovereign authority”, “which is subordinate” to the State (Haroche, 1992, p. 158).


3.1 Discursive Analysis of Inequities in Health
The concept of inequity in health, as discussed in the WHO report “Closing the gap in a generation”
(WHO, 2008), is explained in Part 1.0 above. Chapter 14 of the abovementioned report points to the
State as the main cause of inequities in health. It so happens that Chapter 10 of the same report
contains recommendations for the implementation of equity in health, and places the same State as
responsible for it. We found the coexistence of such paradoxical relationship between public
policies and health strange, as it generates harm instead of benefits; that is, it created “morbid social
environments that produce sociopathies and psychopathies” (Buss, 2000, p. 173).
Within the concept of legal discourse (Pêcheux, 1988), we can “apprehend the paradoxical
nature of these complex realities”, the contradictory and paradoxical effects of the evidence of
inequities in health, since there is the “invisible”, the “absence” of a power working on “the
relations of domination/resistance. We believe that such “invisible” power is inscribed in the
linguistic forms of the juridical discourse in the literate discourse (Zoppi-Fontana, 2005, p. 55).
In its commissions, WHO defines strategies to promote public health (Buss, 2000, p. 172).
The juridical discourse on health is, therefore, a technical discourse generated by certain members
of society. It has a juridical nature. The WHO report (2008) offers suggestions and the treaty
member States adopt these suggestions, which become law in their territories. These laws are not
equally intelligible to “all subject”, and they create the need for interpreters (Haroche 1992, p. 84), a
role played by a “cultural elite” that uses hermetic language in which the juridical system
misapprehends meanings and guarantees the submission of the subject to the laws (Haroche 1992,
p. 87).
While suggesting strategies for promoting public policies for health, WHO (2008, chapter
14) places the State as a cause of inequities in health and makes suggestions for the solution to this
problem by proposing a change in the distribution of power within society and the challenge to the
unfair distribution of social resources. Here again, ambiguity seems to be present, a political
institution suggesting that another political institution be challenged. There is even a suggestion that
the State itself should implement a “new social institutionality” defined as “the set of state agencies
charged with the design, coordination, execution and financing of social policies, including health
policies” (Buss, 2000, p. 175). How can this happen if the State itself is one of the main causes of
health inequities?
By discursively analyzing the topic of “health inequities”, we can shed some light on the
effects of meaning generated by the ambiguities above. A citizen can only claim for his rights if he
has a legal identity conferred by the State, therefore, if he is a legal subject. The legal subject is
subjugated; the term “subject” arises with the advent of the bourgeois ideology and of the juridical
ideology. The category of a legal subject is ideological; man is, by nature, a subject (Edelman,
1980, p. 20). If the legal subject is subjugated, his action of challenging the unfair distribution of
social resources, as suggested by WHO (2008), must necessarily take place according to the laws,
within the limits set by the State itself. Thus, there is the appearance of an “object of choice”, but in
reality, it is “a subjected-challenge” within the legal limits placed by the law-creating State. Within

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.46 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
these limits the ideology of law is denied by its practice, showing to be “the illusion of illusion: the
belief that there may be a "revolutionary right” (Edelman, 1980, p. 23).
Law, within the capitalist mode of production, emerges as the concrete and ideological
organization of the circulation and functioning of market categories, “whose names are freedom,
equality or will”, and reveals the concrete content of legal humanism: “The exploitation of man by
man” (Edelman, 1980, p.21, emphasis added).
The idea of the legal subject implies that “in the universe of centralist institutions, there is
only one possible discourse and that no one can advance with an open face by having to hold one’s
own whishes” (Legendre apud Haroche, 1992, p. 158, emphasis added).
Therefore, we ask ourselves how a citizen, as a “legal subject” with a legal identity
conferred by the State, can accommodate and subject himself to situations of miserableness in
relation to health, financial, housing and education matters. Edelman (1980, p. 26-27) points out a
pathway by stating that the loss of identity of the revolutionary class lies in the absorption of the
bourgeois juridical and political forms by the proletariat:

“The legal discourse is one of those linguistic forms that express ‘ideology’, hiding the
enunciating subject, but allowing, for that very reason, for him to subsist and retain his
dominant ideology” (Edelman, 1980, p. 15).

The legal subject, who is constituted from the State, in its image and likeness (Gaufey, 1998),
as the big Other, lives his situation of miserability waiting for the State, so that the latter, with its
strategies, will give such subject something that is not exactly what he expects. There is
subjugation, but no challenge.
Contrarily to the strategies of the State, which tries to reaffirm its actions within productive
processes marked by inequality, there are tactics, which consist in a subconscious and constant
struggle against institutions (Michel de Certeau,1994).
When describing everyday practices, Certeau (1994, p. 45) asserts that the law and culture develop
tensions, to which “symbolic equilibria, contracts of compatibility and more or less temporary
commitments are provided”, and he adds:

“Hence, I prefer to use a distinction between tactics and strategies. I call “strategy” the
calculation of the relations of forces that becomes possible from the moment the subject
of will and power is isolable from an “environment” [...] Political, economic or
scientific nationality has been constructed according to this strategic model [...]
Contrarily, I call “tactics” a calculation that cannot count on its own, and, therefore,
nor on a boundary that distinguishes the other as a visible totality [...] the tactic depends
on time, watching to “capture in flight” possibilities of gain [...] It has to constantly play
with events to turn them into “occasions”. Without ceasing, the weak should take
advantage of forces that are alien to him” (Certeau, 1994, p. 46-47, emphasis added).

The subjection of the legal subject is sterilizing and “places all emphasis on the subject’s structure”
(2005, p. 114). It involves a paranoid alienation in which the legal subject submits to conditions that
are imposed by the State and lead him to misery. How to get around the inequities in health brought
by the State in charge of implanting social well Well-Being? We believe that the way out lies in the
suggestion by Certeau (1994, p. 46-47), in the tactic, which does not “count on its own”, which is
not a “subjected challenge”, but transforms events into occasions by capturing in flight” the
possibilities of gain. The tactics hide behind the mask of conformity. Would solidarity be a tactic to
combat State strategies in its “supposed” role of promoting social Well-Being? While the State
continues to produce inequities in health, the subjects organize themselves in strategies of solidarity
that make such social Well-Being a reality. We believe that the overcoming of inequities in health

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.47 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
lies in the construction of such social conditions that promote solidarity. It is in this context that
health promotion becomes an end in itself and legitimates actions to overcome inequalities.

Althusser, L. (1976). Positions, Éd. Sociales, Paris; p. 121.
Althusser, L. (1974). Idéologie et appareils idéologiques d’Etat, Revue La Pensée, n° 151, mai-juin,
1970,trad. Cast. Editorial Laia, Barcelona.
Batista,V., A proteção internacional do direito à saúde. Available
Buss, P. (2000). Promoção da saúde e qualidade de vida, Ciência e Saúde Coletiva, 5 (1); 163-177,
Buss, P. (2008). Comissão Nacional sobre Determinantes Sociais da Saúde (CNDSS). Available at
204656.pdf> Accessed on November 29, 2008.
Burns, E., História da Civilização Ocidental, Rio de Janeiro: Ed. Globo, 1959, p. 23.
Certeau, M., A invenção do cotidiano: 1. Artes de fazer; Petrópolis, RJ: Vozes, 1994.
Dallari, D., Determinantes Sociais da Saúde. Available at <http://www.google.com.br/search?hl=pt-
onNovember 29, 2008.
Dirhum, A saúde como garantia fundamental e a política pública como seu limite. Available at:
Accessed on November29, 2008.
Edelman, B., La PracticaIdeologicadelDerecho: elementos para uma teoria marxista del Derecho,
trad. Roque CarrionWam, Madrid: Editorial Tecnos, 1980.
Elia, L. (2004). O conceito de sujeito, Rio de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar.
Ferdous, N.; Kabir, R., Khan, H. T., & Chowdhury, M. R. K. (2017). Exploring the relationship of
Domestic violence on Health Seeking behavior and Empowerment of Women in Pakistan. In
Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Public Health, 14(1).
Filomeno, J. (2006). Manual de teoria geral do Estado e ciência política, 6ª ed., Rio de Janeiro:
Forense Universitária.
Gaufey, G. (1998). El lazo especular. Unestudiotraversero de launidad imaginaria, trad Graciela
Leguizamón, Argentina:Edelp SA.
Haroche, C., Fazer dizer, querer dizer, São Paulo: Hucitec, 1992.
Jornal da Ciência. Availale at
Accessed on November 29, 2008.
Pasold, C., Concepção para o Estado Contemporâneo. Available at
BR&q=dalmo+dallari+determinantes+sociais+da+sa%C3%BAde&start=40&sa=N.Accessed on
November 29, 2008.
Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semântica e Discurso: uma crítica à afirmação do óbvio, Campinas: Ed.
WHO, Closing the gap in a generation. Available at
AccessedonDecember10, 2008.
Zizek, S. (1999). O espectro da ideologia, In ADORNO, W., Um mapa da ideologia,SlavojZizek
(org.), Rios de Janeiro: Contraponto, p. 7-38.
Zoppi-Fontana, M. (2005). Objetos Paradoxais e Ideologia, In Estudos da Linguagem, n° 1, Vitória
da Conquista, junho 2005, p. 41-59).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.48 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

An Extended Meaning of the Concept of “Public Space”

A Semiotic Analysis of French “Burqa Affair”
Camila Arêas

About the author

Camila Arêas, Researcher at Paris II University, Carism (Centre d’analyse et de recherche sur les
medias). Address: 5/7, avenue Vavin - 75006 Paris, France. Contact: cc.areas@gmail.com

This paper examines the national press coverage of French “burqa affair” (2009-2010) from a
semiotics approach within communication studies. By using theories of discourse analysis (such as
enunciation, argumentation, rhetoric and pragmatic), we propose to observe how the actors that
integrate these debates (among journalists, politicians, religious, experts) assignee different
meanings to public spaces and places according to their interests, strategies, political projects and
dominant discourse in their work or institutional field. While most academic works about French
veil affairs focus on the question of Islamic increasing visibility, the aim of this study is to
investigate the issue of Islamic spatiality, which remains as a blind spot for the media debate.
Motivated by a spatial or geographical problematic of analysis, the objective of this paper is to
retrace the discursive process between 2009 and 2010 that lead to the redefinition of the notion of
“public space”. More precisely, we intend to observe how the concept of “public space” is
conceived, appropriated and re-signified in and by the press coverage of “burqa affair”. The purpose
of this study is to demonstrate how this press debate legitimated an extended meaning of the
concept of “public space”, bringing to light social, political, normative and affective dimensions of
contemporary public spaces and places.

Keyword: Semiotics, discourse, press, “burqa affair”, public space.

Arêas, Camila (2017). “An Extended Meaning of the Concept of ‘Public Space’: A Semiotic
Analysis of French ‘Burqa Affair.’” Inter. J. Res. Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 48–59.
(Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

This paper examines the press coverage of the “burqa affair” in France (2009-2010) from a
semiotics approach within communication studies, centred on discourse analysis and focusing on
spatial, geographical or “territorial” problems. While most academic works about French veil
affairsi focus on the question of Islamic increasing visibility in public sphere, our propose is to
investigate the issue of Islamic spatiality, which remains as a blind spot of this public debate. In the
aim of filling this academic gap, our approach of analysis consists in observing how the concept of
“public space” is appropriated and re-signified in and by the press debate. This discursive process is

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.49 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
conceived as a symbolical operation and a collective elaboration. We intend to observe how “burqa
affair” brings to light some core dimensions of contemporary “public spaces”, such as their social,
political, normative and affective qualities. By this procedure, we intend to demonstrate how this
press debate legitimated an extended meaning of the concept of “public space”.
Some of the questions that constitute our problematic of study are: How do recent media
debates about Islamic veils (scarf, niqab, burqa, burkini) visibility at schools (1989-2004), public
way (2009-2010), nurseries (2008-2015), enterprises (2013), universities (2013-2015) and beaches
(2016) stimulate critical and deep reflections about the meanings and uses of the concept of “public
space”? How do these media debates spur on a redefinition of the boundaries between private and
public spheres? How do political, juridical and media actors taking part at the press coverage of
“burqa affair” participate at the semiotic construction of “public spaces”? How do these actors
speak about the spaces that they contribute to configure in and by this press debate?
To answer these questions with regards to “burqa affair”, we assert two hypothesis: (1)
increasing visibility of Islamic veil in France has less to do with the return of a religiosity pressed
down by modern secularism than with a new visibility construction, transformed and empowered by
the media; (2) Islamic visibility covers spatial problems not yet explored within academic works.
In a previous study, we showed that “burqa affair” and 2010 law determining that “no-one
in a public space may wear an outfit intended to hide the face” raised a different problem than the
one posed by the “headscarf affair” and 2004 law banning all “signs and dress that conspicuously
show the religious affiliation of students”. The spatial problematic inaugurated by the “burqa affair”
is unprecedented: it is precisely the first time in modern French history that a ban on religious signs
applies outside institutional spaces, such as schools, hospitals, courts and other state public services
facilities. Between 2004 and 2010, the geographic perimeter/limit of Islamic veil ban amplifies
considerably. The first and the second perimeters/limits cannot be superposed, but rather they
complete each other, the latest (public way) enabling to expand the former (public school). As we
can see, the study of French veil affairs under a “space” problem gives evidence about a juridical
and semiotic transformation concerning the relation to public spaces and places, as well as their
meanings and practical values.
This paper looks into the press coverage of the “burqa affair” with the objective of retracing
the discursive process between 2009 and 2010 that lead to the redefinition of the notion of “public
space”. We intend to analyse the concerted, yet polemical, re-signification of the concept of “public
space” in the context of press debate whose dispositive favours numerous discursive disputes and
rhetorical confrontations.


The privilege accorded to discourse analysis in this paper engages us in some theoretical
considerations. Language, statements, discourses and speeches are at the heart of meaning process
at different levels and degrees and constitute central elements of analysis in a semiotic approach of
the “burqa affair”. With regards to these notions, we should first stress that we reject a
presupposition coming from philosophy of language and considering that thinking or mental
categories do not exist out of the language. Instead, we consider a reciprocal presupposition of
relations between discourses, perceptions and material reality. Yet, if communication exceeds
verbal language, this one is still a privilege way for intelligibly elaborating thoughts. Nevertheless,
it is worthy to question: which verbal languages are we talking about? Which notions are used to
examine discourses in the materiality of language?

2.1. Statements and discourses

First of all, let’s look into the notion of “statement”. Based on Oswald Ducrot (1980, 1984, 1991)
linguistic theory, we treat this concept as a unity provided with meaning, feasible by the means of
language and having no equivalent to the phrase. We consider that statements differ from phrases in
so far as phrases are linguistic constructions out of use that allows us to produce multiple statements
according to a variety of contexts and communication situations. Unlike discourses, statements do

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.50 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
not need a subject of enunciation because enunciation is more like a linguistic event than a speech
act. We will then use the notion of statement when we want to highlight the problem of meaning,
enunciation and subjectivity inside language.
The second key word of this study is “discourse”. Following language specialists Patrick
Charaudeau (1992) and Dominique Maingueneau (2002), we use this term to refer to a complete
unity of meaning (regrouping one or more phrases), produced by a subject, guided in accordance to
intentions and purposes (a form of action over the other), governed by norms (discourse and social
laws), caught in inter-discourses and self-developing in a precise time-space that works as a
condition of discourses production, circulation and reception. In this paper, we use both notions of
discourse and statement, without neglecting that the term of “discourse” is more appropriate to refer
to speeches or texts produced by someone under situational constraints.

2.2. Language and discourses

With regards to linguist Ferdinand Saussure’s (1972) classical distinction between language
(intrinsic linguistic constants) and speech (extrinsic linguistic) – that has been updated within
Language, Information and Communication Sciences –, we suggest to overlook this dichotomy in
order to conceive that language and discourses are inseparable. Based on Roland Barthes’
semiology studies (1984, 1985) and the philosophical language semiotic theory proposed by Gilles
Deleuze and Félix Guattari (1980), we reject such a distinction between language and speech, and
affirm that language is an informative-representative system dependent on social and political
practices. By mobilizing these authors, we deny the possibility of disentangling language and
discourse in order to consider: (1) the language as a semiotic object in continuous variation, that is,
as a practice among others; (2) the language as part of the “real” and not as a representation of it;
and (3) the discourses of our corpus as intrinsically presenting some social, political and pragmatic

2.3. Discourses’ conditions and stakes

To complete this theoretical framework centred on the discourse issue, Michel Foucault’s “The
Order of Discourse” (1971) configures the third outline of the theory of this research. The
philosopher conceives discourses as some regular and distinct series of events that are dependent on
external conditions. Foucault stresses the importance of analysing discourses according to their
condition of possibility and eventuality, instead of their source or subject of enunciation. Based on
this theoretical framework, we seek, not to unveil a unique and hidden meaning behind them, but to
enlighten the stakes, restrictions and conditions that make their enunciation possible and
meaningful. As Foucault (1971) describes, our analysis procedure will consist “not to go from
discourses to their hidden and interior core, to the heart of a thought or of a meaning that would
manifest on it, but from the very discourses, their appearance and regularity, to go towards their
extern conditions of possibility, to what create a random series of this events and that set their
limits” (p.54).


The corpus of analysis includes all press articles published in national newspapers Le Monde,
Libération, Le Figaro between 16 June 2009 and 14 September 2010. For this data collection, we
used the online databases Factiva and Europresse regrouping main newspapers worldwide and
employed keyword such as “niqab” “burqa” “tchador” “integral veil” to look for texts covering the
“burqa affair”. From a total of 1701 news articles published in that period, we selected 171 of which
content responds better to our problem of study, that is developing the issue of spatiality. From this
pre-selected corpus, we collected for this paper only the discourses or statements that develops, in a
more precise and direct way, some of the main issues of this study.
The method of this study is based on a semiotics approach of discourse analysis
(enunciation, argumentation, rhetoric and pragmatic) to examine public speeches (mostly political,
juridical and journalistic) in “burqa affair” press debate. Under discourse analysis method, we

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.51 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
propose to examine the social, political, symbolical, enunciate, argumentative and pragmatic
dimensions of these public speeches.
First of all, concerning the social and symbolical dimensions of discourses, we follow
Patrick Charaudeau (1997, 2005) in order to inscribe our discursive scope inside the field of public
communication (mostly, media and political). In this field, the meaning of objects – like Islamic veil
– is apprehended as a social construction, that is, as the result of discursive disputes concerning the
legitimate order and the constitution/dissolution of social groups and political positions. In this
paper, we also assume that the type of discourse interaction mediated by press devices contributes
to feed symbolic systems, which update and reconfigure the social and political relations of actors-
interlocutors in the media debate.
Secondly, with regard to the political dimension of public speeches, we rely on Patrick
Charaudeau and Jacques Gerstlé (2008) works with the objective of analysing discourse strategies
mobilized in “burqa affair” not as modes of deployment of political action but as actions
themselves. Discursive practices and enunciation arrangements are inextricably imbricated to power
Thirdly, referring to the enunciation dimension of public discourses, we follow linguists
Emile Benveniste (1970, 1974) and Catherine Kerbrat-Orecchioni (2009) conception of enunciation
as a subjectivity stake related to the positioning, the identification and the personal implication of
actors. We follow as well Oswald Ducrot (1980, 1984, 1991) linguistic theory sustaining that the
enunciation – more precisely, the image or the description of enunciation – constitutes the meaning
of discourses in a self-reference way. The idea is that the discourses meanings (the “said”) are
influenced by the semantic structure of phrases that gives overall instructions, such as context,
target, intentionality and interlocutors’ relations to grasp the enunciation event (the “saying”). In
this enunciation perspective, we move from the “said” to the “saying” in order to consider the
meaning of enunciation as a kind of representation that the speaker gives of his own enunciation.
In what concerns the argumentative dimension of discourses under analysis, we rely on
linguists Ruth Amossy (2006) and Oswald Ducrot (1984, 1991) whose works enable to treat
argumentation in a linguistic (semantic, meaning) and rhetorical (context, interlocutors relations)
sense of the term. The idea is to analyse discourse argumentation in the materiality of language and
to consider the chaining of the phrases as an argumentative orientation that informs about the
meaning of discourses. Sizeable in the language, argumentation is considerer as a public act.
Finally, with regard to the pragmatic dimension of discourses, we lean on linguist Catherine
Kerbrat-Orecchioni (2008) in order to grasp speech acts from a semiotic approach considering the
senses they acquire in the “burqa affair” and the communication situation created by the press. As
stressed by Kerbrat-Orecchioni, statements can only act by means of a semiotic process that is
anterior to any action. Then, the problem is about knowing in which measure we can “modify a
state of things X by producing a meaning Y” (p.30).
By means of this discursive analysis method, our objective is to observe how actors, who
integrate these debates (journalists, politicians, religious, experts) assign different meanings to
public spaces and places according to their interests, strategies, political projects and dominant
discourse in their work or institutional field.


Having presented this introductory overview, lets bend on the analysis and findings of this study
highlighting an unprecedented spatial stake concerning Islamic veil’s visibility in France. Our goal
is to analyse the relations and meanings given to public spaces in the media and political discourses
of the “burqa affair”. We observe that politicians on the parliamentary scene and the law experts
interviewed in the press establish a political-juridical dialogue about the notion of “public space”
that highlights the way in which the concept has been thought, appropriated and redefined in this
media affair.
The lexicometric analysis of all spatial terms used in this public debate sets the following
cartography: 176 texts containing the term “public space”, 116 “street”, 75 “territory”, 47 “public

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.52 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
way” and 29 “public institutions” (See Appendix). In this press coverage, we note that the concept
of “public space” appears as an object of discursive controversies among social, political and media
actors that dispute over the meaning, the legitimacy, the legality and the applicability of it.
While the centrality of the concept of “public space” serves as an evidence of this press
debate, it also contrasts with a lack of precision of the notion. This is at the basis of some specific
semiotic stakes, such as: the elasticity of the signifier (does this term refers to institutional
settlements or to public spaces like square, street, market, beach?), the vagueness of the signified
(which can refer to different quality of publics spaces, such as geographical, social, political,
normative or affective) and a blurred meaning (at last, where can we situate the boundary between
public and private spaces?). This semiotics performance has sustained an extensive interpretation of
the concept of “public space”, especially within the political and parliamentary debate covered by
the national press. We observe that the semiotic stakes opened a large field for argumentative
manoeuvres in favour of prohibitionist discourse. This is precisely the object of study of this paper.

4.1. Redefinition of “public space” within prohibitionist discourse: limits and meanings
By the end of 2009, when the government proposed a new law establishing that “no-one in a public
space may wear an outfit intended to hide the face”, we stated that numerous actors (politician,
journalists, juridical experts) called into question the definition and the precision of some terms of
this legal text. How to define the concept of “public space” and which spaces should we include
under this category? Public institutions, services, hospitals, universities, transport, street, and public
way: up to which limit would it be justifiable and constitutional to apply integral veil ban? Or yet:
which place (physical and symbolical) is reserved to Islam inside French society? All these
questions coming up from the political and parliamentary debates about the “burqa affair” are
central to our study problem.
Thus, let’s look into the most emblematic discourses of the prohibitionist camp that shaped
the “burqa affair” through the national press. Called by president Nicolas Sarkozy’s imperative
question - “one must further clarify the concept of public space, too vague. What to do with a
woman dressed in a burqa that circulates on public ways inside a car, which by definition is a
private domain?” (Le Parisien, 2010) - the most important political actors following the
prohibitionist alignment of the government, expressed their opinions immediately thereafter:

- Xavier Darcos (Minister of work, Right wing leading party): “I recommend some
caution to those tempted to follow the precedent of the 2004 law banning religious signs
in schools because [...] the wearing of the full veil intervenes in an indeterminate space
where the expression of opinions, even religious, is a fundamental right. I decline to rule
on the university, on transport or on the street because that would be subject to legal
controversy. (...) I promote an uncovered face Republic.” (Gabizon, 2009).

- Brice Hortefeux (Minister of Interior, Right wing leading party): “I advocate a

minimum solution by applying a law that circumscribes the niqab ban to public services
(post, prefectures, transport) in order to avoid the risk of unconstitutionality from
Constitutional Council and European court of human rights.” (Auffray & Coroller,

-Éric Besson (Minister of Immigration, Right wing leading party): “I promoted the
general prohibition of the niqab in all of the public space that is to say, in public
services and buildings open to the public, but also in the street. Regarding the risk of
legal constraints of a total prohibition, the prohibition should be on the imperative of
public order.” (Auffray & Coroller, 2009).

- Jean-François Copé, Nicole Ameline, François Baroin and Éric Raoult (Right wing
leading party): “It is clear that the burqa has no place in public services and public

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.53 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
buildings or private places open to the public, such as shops. [...] Still, remains the
question of a general prohibition on public ways. For some, it would be disproportionate
or being misunderstood. Some legal experts also highlight the legal obstacles. The ban
must so be based on the need for public order.” (De Malet, 2009).

- Manuel Valls, Aurélie Filipetti, Philippe Esnol (Socialist Party): “We advocate
banning the niqab in public space and services (town halls, schools, prefectures, social
security) and on all public ways. The formula “uncovered face” is an imperative of
public order.”(Libération, 2009).

By observing these emblematic statements, we note two main general trends of the
prohibitionist discourse within this press debate: the strong use of enunciation markers, as well as
an argumentative construction by “connectors chaining”. In what concerns the enunciation
dimension, we note the use of “I” or “we” personal pronouns as marks of individual or collective
recognition, as well as a mode of engagement that contributes to fabricate a specific discursive
“ethos” (Charaudeau, 2005, p.65) of these actors and reinforce their visibility and authority. In this
sense, while in Sarkozy’s question the pronoun “one” refers to an “undetermined subject of
enunciation” (Benveniste, 1960, pp.12-18) that regroups together the enunciator and co-enunciator,
these quotes show that political actors have taken ownership of the president’s question and
assumed the position of subject of the enunciation, carrying all responsibilities that it implies
(coherence, sincerity, legal liability etc.). Imperative verbs such as “recommend”, “promote” and
“advocate” operates as “assertive” and “declarative” illocutionary “speech acts” (Kerbrat-
Orecchioni, 2008) performing and acting by means of discourse effects. The pragmatic dimension
and performativity force of these discourses refers to the fact that they carry authority and decision-
making power (Charaudeau, 1997, p.184). In this sense, these discourses can be considered as
political actions.
In the second prohibitionist discourse camp, we observe that the argumentative dimension of
theses quotes relies on a linguistic and rhetoric procedure of two steps: (1) taking in consideration
an adversary discourse (legal experts and prohibitionist camp) and showing their personal and
political awareness with the constraints posed by national and international legal frameworks in
order to, (2) sustain the prohibitionist discourse that intend to by-pass the secular legal framework
and promote an extensive meaning of the concept of “public space”. This “argumentation by
chaining” (Ducrot, 1984, pp. 40-45/ Ducrot, 1991, pp.81-91) consists in advancing one “pragmatic
topoi” – a common idea or opinion (Amossy, 2006) about legal framework concerning public
spaces – that will then legitimate and support the prohibitionist discourse. Those “polyphonic
statements” (Ducrot, 1984, p.169) reveal about a “co-enunciation” process (Kerbrat-Orecchioni,
2009, p.18) in which the subject of statement stages, in a second discourse, the prohibitionist
interlocutor with the objective of preventing a “counter-discourse” and producing a “pro-discourse”
(Amossy, 2006). This shows how the interlocutor works as the dynamic force of the statement,
guiding and motivating the message.
The statements of our corpus regarding the idea of “public space” constitutes many ways of
seeing (discriminate and classify) and judging (to assign a value) the spatiality of Islamic religion.
We observe Nicolas Sarkozy judging “too vague” the concept of public space, while Xavier Darcos
speaks in terms of an “indeterminate space”. All other terms illustrate a discursive dispute
concerning the legitimate meaning given of “public space”, which reveals how the concept has been
redefined, during two years, the “burqa affair” press coverage. They show multiple and extended
meanings that the concept of “public space” acquires in this debate (schools, university, post,
prefecture, transport, shops, street, services and buildings open to the public, public services, public
buildings, private places), as well as some of the political discourse strategies concerning the use of
the notion of in terms of 2010 law.
These political statements suggest that the main legal constraints posed by a broad
interpretation of the concept is based on the inclusion of “public way” and “street” under the

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.54 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
category of “public spaces” legally controlled by national state contradicts the principle of liberty.
For example, the European convention of human rights states, in its article 9, that the liberty to
manifest it’s own religion can’t be the object of others restrictions than the ones previewed by the
law. Therefore, we can observe how prohibitionist discourse circumvented legal barriers posed by
secular principles (like the one establishing the neutrality of appearances of state staff) by engaging
the argument of “public order” and the formula of “uncovered face” to legitimize 2010 law. In this
sense, unlike the debate concerning headscarves in schools, in the “burqa affair” it is no more the
“neutrality” principle, but the one of “transparency” and “public order” that defines the quality of
public spaces according to republican “regime of visibility” (Deleuze, Guattari, 1980).
The report of the “Information mission on the practice of wearing the integral veil on the
national territory” (2010), written by the right-wing deputy Eric Raoult and communist André
Gerin, is illustrative on this matter. The question of the legitimate argument and the extensive
definition of the notion of “public space” are seizable by these titles of the report summary:
B. To forbid integral veil in public space?
1. An interdiction would be possible in regards to the Constitution?
a) The laïcity, an inoperative foundation.
b) The dignity of human person, a notion with an uncertain content.
c) The Public order, the less tricky track.

These observations enable us to seize the semantic blur of the concept of “public space” as a
political strategic action and a discursive performative act, which contributes to produce an
extensive definition of the notion that favours prohibitionist political discourse. We observe that the
new legal framework inaugurated by the mediatization of the “burqa affair” and 2010 law
contributed to redefine the practical value of public spaces of relative freedom (of thought and
expression). In this sense, we can affirm that this legal device determines a new social reality. It
legitimates the submission of these spaces to the State grid in accordance to a Republican “regime
of visibility” which prescribes the transparency of actions and the neutrality of appearances.
Therefore, the meaning of “public space” is more political – a security and order matter – than
social, which would suppose the social recognition of Muslim actors and a sense of togetherness.
As a consequence, we argue the mediatization of “burqa affair” displaces the meaning of "public"
on the side of Republican State and its power, rather than of the side of civil society, common good
and interest.
As sociologist Sylvia Ostrowetsky suggested in this regard “the appropriation of public
spaces means the denial of itself” (Paquot, 2009 p.104). Or yet, as proposes Thierry Paquot, “the
choice for open and welcoming urban places is a political act. No more, no less”(Paquot, 2009
p.105). Following this same critical perspective, sociologist Nilüfer Göle remembers that “the
empowerment of public space toward the State is considered as a condition of exit from State
authoritarianism” and also that the “emergence of a Islamic subject has revealed the limits of this
space and its imbrication with the Republic” (Paquot, 2009 p.115). Indeed, in the “burqa affair”,
we note that the 2010 law has reinforced a convergence between the public space and the Republic
by implying that both are synonyms.
Legal devices are revealing about a certain type of relation between government and
citizens. In this sense, the press coverage of “burqa affair” raises the question about the type of
State that is under construction under V French Republic. Journalists, social and political actors
taking part in this debate put into question the role of political power in regulating religious issues
and constructing a legal agenda about Islam in France. Considering that the legal instruments of
political action participate at the construction of interactions, practices and social representations,
we can affirm that “burqa affair” produces a specific representation about Islam and its place in
French society.
We observe that by an extensive interpretation of the concept of “public space”, 2010 law
constructed a new representation and meaning of Islamic full-face veil that is then connoted as
socially blameable and illegal. The 2010 law is at the basis of a semiotic requalification (social and

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.55 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
symbolical) of integral veil concerning the relation between law and customs. If, before the law,
integral veil is represented (by means of images and discourses) as politically suspect and
religiously radical, after the law this Islamic sign is also considered as socially dangerous (public
order and security). Therefore, the wearing of its sign becomes an illicit practice. In this sense, as
legal device, the 2010 law delimits the spatial legal perimeter of Islamic visibility and also states the
weak symbolical recognition of integral veil in France. We move from identity representations to
spatial ones et vice-versa: if the stigmatization of Islamic veil legitimize 2010 law, the geographical
representation (spatial disorganization) inaugurated by this law reinforces in return the identitarian
representations of contemporary Islamic visibility (social disorganization). The 2010 law is then a
product and a producer of identity representations that are inseparable from their spatial dimension.
The press discourses analysed in this paper show to what extent the actors inscribed in this
public debate look for legitimatizing a legal agency of space property as a way of controlling the
representations and the practices that are considered legitimate. In this sense, the displacement and
requalification of the concept of “public space” throughout this press debate reveal more about a
power stake than a power instrument. Considering that public space only exists in relation to a daily
use of it and to the actors that practice them, we can assert that it is at once a social, political,
economical, communicational and historical instrument of power. As it is put by phenomenologist
Maurice Merleau-Ponty, “the space is essential and the existence is spatial” (De Certeau, 1990,

4.2. When a third space emerges within the “burqa affair”

Among all articles of our corpus, we find a title of a news item published at Figaro newspaper that
resumes at best the spatial problematic inaugurated by the “burqa affair”: “Three spaces, three
rules?”. In this article, journalist Cécilia Gabizon remarks that in the context of this debate, the High
Council for the Integration (HCI) proposed the distinction of three spaces controlled by its own
rules: (1) the public space defined by the secular principle of neutrality that concerns the staff of
public service and sometimes their users; (2) the civil space that includes the public domain of
circulation and private enterprises open to the public, where freedom prevails if it doesn’t disturb
public order; and (3) the intimate space that is for essential the one of the house, where freedom
prevails. The distinction of these three spaces (public, civil and personal) in the context of “burqa
affair” allowed the High Council for the Integration to preconize the reinforcement of “laïcity”
inside spaces in which the public authority prevails. Which are of these spaces are submitted to
political jurisdiction and control? Inside the civil space, place of recent tensions about Islamic veil,
which are the boundaries between freedom and public order? What type of laïcity prevails within it?
We can observe how the experts and journalists taking part in this press debate constitutes a
complex thought or discussion about the spatial problem of “burqa affair” with regards to secular
principles that mark public spaces:

- Alain-Gérard Slama, (editorial writer at Figaro): “The problem posed by integral veil is, indeed,
new. (...) The use of burqa, more and more frequent on the streets and public places of peripheral
areas, exceed the competence field of 2004 law that forbids using a conspicuous sign at school, at
public administrations and hospitals. At the exterior of these spheres, in the name of which criteria a
secular society can it be founded to forbid the exhibition of a dress sign that claim a religious
membership, for the only reason that it covers completely the face? This is a first question.”
(Slama, 2009).

- Caroline De Malet (journalist at Libération): “Unlike the law about conspicuous signs
in schools, which was voted by a majority and which resolved the problem immediately
at all schools establishments in France, the law about integral veil poses a problem that
is not quite the same because its perimeter of interdiction is different.” (Caroline De
Malet, 2009).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.56 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
- Cécilia Gabizon (journalist at Figaro and member of the High Council for the
Integration): “The 1905 law didn’t said anything about the civil space because it hasn’t
anticipated society mutation, the affirmation, each day more important, of
particularisms on public way, such as adolescents tribes, gaudy looks or yet religious
membership. The increasing power of Islam, religion of collective rites, has also shaken
up a secular society. These last years, numerous affairs have burst in this juridical blur.”
(Gabizon, 2010).

- Rémy Schwartz (State adviser and former reporter of Stasi commission about laïcity at
school): “There is a crucial difference between the rules able to be enacted in public
service and the constraints that is possible to impose to citizens in public space because
in this one, freedom is the principle and the restriction, without talking about the
interdiction, is the exception. The government has the right to forbid officers and
students from public schools to manifest conspicuously their confession. However, as
State Council has stressed in a recent notice, the Parliament can’t invoke laïcity to
forbid women to wear integral veil on the street.” (Perrault, 2010).

These press quotes highlight how the meaning of public spaces – as they can be discursively
considered in their materiality – are different from the scarf and the burqa affairs. The comparative
perspective putting together these two media debates is a common approach of analysis within the
press coverage of “burqa affair” and the aim of this parallel is to objectify a historical process
moving towards an enlarged conception of “public space”. We note in the first and third quotes that
the connectors “however” and “unlike” do not only enable the comparison between veil affairs, but
they also perform the “argumentative force/orientation” (Ducrot, 1984, pp.27-30/ 1991, p.208) of
these statements, consisting in convincing the lector about the new spatial “problem” posed by
burqa affair, which “is not quite the same” or “is, indeed, new”. These comparative connectors are
also an essential element to grasp the meaning of these statements.
Based on these findings, we can argue that the journalists and experts participating in the
press debate are more concerned about putting into question the spatial problem posed by the
“burqa affair” than looking for a legal framework to justify or extend the State’s control of public
ways. Unlike political discourses, journalists and juridical experts raise more questions than
answers. However that does not mean that they have no personal or political interest in the subject.
On the contrary, their statements represent the institutional instance of each one of their subjects of
enunciation. For journalists Alain-Gérard Slama and Caroline De Malet, it is worthwhile to create a
“public problem” concerning the Islamic veil visibility (polemic content and audience matter) than
following the political definition of the concept of “public space”. For Cécilia Gabizon, member of
the High Council for the Integration, the stake is about promoting the idea of a “third space” in
accordance to the notice publish by this same institution. Finally, for Rémy Schwartz the matter is
about defending the rule of law and, as so, the legitimacy of legal power in face of political
decision-making. These media and expert discourses illustrate how “burqa affair” pursued for an
historical update of the concept of “laïcity”. Following 1905 law, secular principles distinguish only
two spaces, the public – in which prevails the neutrality of public services staff and users – and the
private space – in which predominate the freely expression of religious convictions. Such a binary
segmentation characterizes the specificity of republican political organisation by shaping the
“public space” as a place of State sovereignty that is defined by the negative, that is, the absence of
religious distinction marks. In contrast, the private space is defined as an intimate dimension that
expresses itself by means of Greek term of “aidôs”, referring to the notion of modesty “that
manifests as much a reserve as a shame”, as describes philosopher Thierry Paquot (2009, p.47).
This etymological meaning illustrate the political stake that underlies the burqa law: religious
distinction is no more legitimate, or even worthy, of public manifestation. The risk of such a social
representation of Islamic headscarf concerns the consolidation of State control over public spaces,
when they should defined by a “common” quality and a sense of “shareable”, that is it’s opening to

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.57 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
the deployment of otherness expressions and multiple qualities.
At this point, we can argue that these extracts underline a shift from 2004 to 2010 law
regarding the practical and the symbolic relation to public spaces. As suggested by the quotes of
journalists and legal experts, “burqa affair” inaugurates a new discussion with regards to a third
space, the civil one. These discourses give sense to this “third” or enlarged space emerging within
this public debate, by defining it as a place of “freedom”, “particularisms expressions” and
“collective religious rites”. We note that by engaging such a semantic field, these media and
juridical actors promote a more liberal conception of public space than the political statements of
prohibitionist actors.

The semiotic analysis of discourses constructing the press coverage of “burqa affair” shows how the
secular questions posed by the “headscarf affair” have overtaken the school framework and put into
question the republican concept of public places and spaces. The 20 years of media debate about
Islamic veil widened the scope of religious expression interdiction, which is more and more
intrudes to private spaces. The legal redefinition of the concept of "public space" operated by the
2010 law shows how French public spaces are now partly defined by reference to the Islamic
visibility. Since 1989, public spaces and places are redefined, re-signified and re-qualified with
regards to an increasing media visibility of Islamic signs in recent public debates.
We stress that when the meaning of “controllable public spaces” exceeds the state
institutions settlements to enclose the street or public ways, we have a quantitative and a qualitative
leap that is not measured in centimetres, but can be understood as a “segmentation matter” (Deleuze
et Guattari, 1980, pp.254-281). In both cases, the question is about organizing and distributing
religious signs in secular republican spaces and, as so, about framing Islamic religious visibility, in
a politically and juridical way. This historical process moves from the free circulation of fluxes and
practices towards a segmented organization (always dichotomous) of new laws that delimit religion
to intimate space. In this sense, we can understand the veil affairs and the laws they generated as
products of the media and legal instruments that strengthen the dichotomous distribution of space –
such as public/private, male/female and religiosity/secularism – instead of a three-way distribution
corresponding to the emergency of “civil space” described by journalists and legal experts.
That's not all. The spatial raster of Islamic visibility, emerging as the result of twenty-five
years of public debates about Islamic veil, is still taking place today. As evidenced by the
proliferation of public debates since the end of the “burqa affair” in 2010 and all the new proposals
of veil ban in others public spaces (like universities), private places (like businesses enterprises) or
semi-public ones (like nurseries in the so called “Baby-Loup affair”), we remark that other spatial
boundary lines may be exceeded in favour of an enlarged state grabbing of private and semi-public

Amossy, Ruth (2006). L’argumentation dans le discours. Paris: Armand Colin.
Barhtes, Roland (1984). Le bruissement de la langue. Essais critiques IV. Paris: Seuil.
Barthes, Roland (1985). L’aventure sémiologique. Paris: Seuil.
Benveniste, Émile (1974). Problèmes de linguistique générale. Paris: Gallimard.
Benveniste, Émile (1970). “L’appareil formel de l’énonciation”. Langages, 5ᵉ année, n°17, 1970.
« L’énonciation ». pp. 12-18.
Charaudeau, Patrick (1997). Le discours d’information médiatique: la construction du miroir
social. Paris: Nathan.
Charaudeau, Patrick (2005). Le discours politique. Les masques du pouvoir. Paris: Viubert.
Charaudeau Patrick (1992). Grammaire du Sens et de l'Expression. Paris: Hachette.
De Certeau, Michel (1990). L’invention du quotidien I. Arts de faire. Paris: Gallimard.
Deleuze, Gilles & Guattari, Félix (1980). Mille plateaux. Paris: Minuit.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.58 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Ducrot, Oswald (1980). Les mots du discours. Paris: Minuit.
Ducrot, Oswald (1984). Le dire et le dit. Paris: Minuit.
Ducrot, Oswald (1991). Dire et ne pas dire. Paris: Éditions Hermann, Éditeurs de Sciences et des
Foucault, Michel (1971). L’ordre du discours. Paris: Gallimard.
Gerstle, Jacques (2008). La communication politique. Paris: Armand Colin.
Kerbrat-Orecchioni, Catherine (2009). L'énonciation de la subjectivité dans le langage. Paris:
Armand Colin.
Kerbrat-Orecchioni, Catherine (2008). Les actes de langage dans le discours : Théories et
fonctionnement. Paris: Armand Colin.
Maingueneau, Dominique (2002). Dictionnaire d’analyse de discours. Paris: Le Seuil.
Paquot, Thierry (2009). L’espace public. Paris: La Découverte « Repères »
Saussure, Ferdinand (1972). Cours de linguistique générale. Paris: Payot.

Press corpus
Auffray, Alain & Coroller, Catherine (2009). Récit; Ministres en mission sur le voile. Libération,
17 December.
Slama, Alain-Gérard (2009). Le voile intégral, la loi et les mœurs. Le Figaro, 2 December.
De Malet, Caroline (2009). Voile intégral : une loi indispensable. Le Figaro, 16 December.
Gabizon, Cécilia (2009). Les députés UMP souhaitent une interdiction totale de la burqa. Le Figaro,
16 December.
Gabizon, Cécilia (2010). Trois espaces, trois règles ?. Le Figaro, 17 March.
« ÉLYSÉE - Nicolas Sarkozy veut aller vite sur la burqa » (2010). Le Parisien, 5 May.
« Il faut bannir la burqa de l'espace public » (2009). Libération, 21 December.
Perrault, Guillaume (2010). La dignité de la femme, base juridique du futur texte. Le Figaro, 23

(i) We should remark that the correct terms to denote the veil covering all the body, but not the
eyes, are “integral veil”, “full-face veil” or “niqab”, while the term of “burqa” very used by the by
media actors, denote the veil covering also the eyes that is not the object of the debate, neither of
2010 law. Nevertheless, we keep using the expression “burqa affair” to point out this specific media
(ii) By using this term, we refer to the philosophical conception of territory as a space that is not
only geographic and physic, but also psychological, mental, spiritual, so metaphysics. See: Deleuze
& Guattari (1980, pp. 386-402).
(iii) Amiraux, Valérie (2014). Visibilité, transparence et commérage : de quelques conditions de
possibilité de l’islamophobie… et de la citoyenneté. Sociologie n°1, vol. 5. / Tevanian, Pierre
(2005). Le voile médiatique : un faux débat : "l'affaire du foulard islamique". Paris: Raisons d'agir
editions. / Bouamama, Saïd (2004). L'affaire du foulard islamique : la production d'un racisme
respectable. Paris: Geai ble. / Lorcerie, Françoise (2005). La politisation du voile : l'affaire en
France, en Europe et dans le monde arabe. Paris: l'Harmattan. / Ferrari, Alessandro & Pastorelli,
Sabrina (ed.) (2012). Religion in public spaces : an European perspective. UK: Ashgate./ Brems,
Eva (2014). The experiences of face veil wearers in Europe and the law. UK: Cambridge University
(iv) Arêas, Camila (2016). Quand les signes religieux font débat dans les arènes médiatiques et
scientifiques. Régimes de visibilité et reconfiguration des espaces publics dans les affaires du voile
en France (1989-2010). Paris II University, France. (See http://www.theses.fr/2016PA020024)
(v) When communist deputy André Gerin proposes to create a parliamentary commission of inquiry
about the practice of wearing an integral veil on national territory”.
(vi) When the law banning the “dissimulation of the face in public space” was approved in the
(vii) Le Monde: 583, Figaro: 522, Libération: 354, Le Parisien: 242.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.59 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Spatial cartography of “burqa affair” press coverage

Lexicometric quantitative statistic of all geographical terms mentioned in this media debate

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.60 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Awareness and Attitude towards Public Pension

A Case of Informal Workers at Saba saba Market in Dodoma
Municipality, Tanzania
Stephen James, Emmanuel Hauli, and Peter Mosha

About the Author(s)

Stephen James, Corresponding author and can be reached at Email: skamugisha@irdp.ac.tz
Emmanuel Hauli, Department of Development Finance and Management Studies, P.O.BOX
138, Institute of Rural Development Planning, Dodoma, Tanzania.
Peter Mosha, Department of Population and Development Planning, P.O.BOX 138, Institute
of Rural Development Planning, Dodoma, Tanzania.

The study was conducted at Saba saba market in Dodoma Municipality with the objective of
assessing awareness and attitude towards public pension. Study design was cross-sectional with the
sample size of 282 respondents and 6 key informants. Sampling procedures consisted of both
random and purposive sampling. Methods of data collection were interview and focus group
discussion in which the structured questionnaire, Likert Scale and check list were tools of data
collection on awareness and attitude of the respondents. Quantitative data were analyzed by
Statistical Package of Social Science (SPSS) computer software by using descriptive and inferential
statistics such as frequencies, percentages and chi-square test (  2 ) to determine association
between socio-demographic characteristics and awareness on public pension. Qualitative data were
analyzed through content analysis. Findings revealed that majority of respondents never heard about
public pension. The findings also revealed that among the minority with awareness, it was 26 to 35
years of age which was more aware than less or more years of age. Marital status with more
awareness on public pension was the married than the rest. Female sex also was more aware than
males. Level of education which had more awareness on public pension was the primary education
group than less or higher levels of education. However, the overall findings from ( ) test revealed
that sex and marital status were socio-demographic characteristics which were significantly
associated with awareness on public pension whereby (  2 = 3.840; p = 0.050 and  2 = 9. 725; p =
.021). Age and levels of education were negatively associated with awareness on public pension
whereby the results of  2 = 5.797; p = 0.215 and  2 = 4.085; p = 0.252). The findings further
revealed that majority of the respondents had unfavorable attitudes towards public pension. Based
on these findings recommendations have been indicated.

Key words: Self-employed, urban, pension funds, information, television

James, S., Hauli , E. and Mosha, P. (2017). “Awareness and Attitude towards Public Pension: A
Case of Informal Workers at Saba saba Market in Dodoma Municipality, Tanzania.” Inter. J. Res.
Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 60–69. (Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.61 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Public pension is an element of social protection and social security. This makes it to be one of the
social security rights for all as agreed by United Nations General Assembly (1966) on social
security. All the working people from the formal or informal sectors of the economy have to be
entitled to the pension benefits. Public pension guarantees an individual inflow of income during
retirement. Stewart & Yermo (2009) argued that pensions play a vital role in poverty alleviation of
the elderly which constitute one of the most vulnerable groups in any society. The results in Brazil
demonstrated that poverty rates in household with pension beneficiary were 13% lower than the
households without pension beneficiary (Afenyadu, 2014).
According to Dorfman (2015) there are four pension designs in which the first is the non-
contributory pension (Zero-pillar) in which the state or employers may transfer financial assistance
to the old age universally or by means test without requiring the beneficiaries to make financial
contribution for benefits in advance before retirement. The second, is the mandatory contributory
pension schemes (1 or 2nd pillar) which is entirely based on pay-as-you go. Mandatory contribution
pension is further divided into the defined benefits and defined contribution (Wang et al, 2014;
Heenkenda, 2016). In defined contribution scheme, the contribution to the investment come from
the predetermined fraction of the worker’s salary while the benefit payout at retirement is usually
not specified. The worker and employer contribute and deposit the cash into the individual worker’s
account for the retirement benefits provided on the basis of investment performance.
In defined benefits pension scheme, workers make contribution during their working age
and at the age of retirement they earn annuities based on formula taking into consideration of the
period of service and average earnings (Kayitare, 2016). Tanzania pension system takes features
from both schemes because the workers and their employers from the formal sector for instance are
required to contribute to pension saving of twenty percent of their salaries (Government Retirement
Benefits Fund, 2013; Public Service Pensions Fund, 2017; PPF Pensions Fund, 2015). But the
mechanism of financial percentage to be contributed by workers and employers vary between these
public pension funds. Informal workers too are also supposed to contribute part of their income to
pension funds but based on their level of incomes from self-employment activities. In spite of
contribution to pension funds, the harmonization rules of 2014 defines the pension benefits formula
to be used to compute enrolled members’ benefits at retirement (United Republic of Tanzania,
2014). Advance information on the amount of cash plus interests can be easily understood by
pension participants.
The third pension design according to Dorfman is the voluntary, regulated occupational or
personal saving and insurance arrangements often known as the third pillar. It can be organized by
different sectors of employment to cater for their members. The fourth is the other informal
voluntary saving arrangements such as the household assets, savings or transfers which support the
old age. Out of all these pension designs the mandatory contributory pension arrangements under
the public pension funds also constitute some element of the voluntary design in which the informal
workers are invited to contribute for the retirement benefits as is the case in many public pensions
funds of Tanzania. In spite of the room being left for informal workers contribution in public
pension, the pension coverage in Tanzania has been among the minority (World Bank, 2014)
similarly like Rwanda (Ntibitura, 2013). According to International Labour Organization (2001)
those who tend not to be covered are those who work in the informal economy. But, it has not been
clear as to whether the informal workers had awareness and positive attitude as important individual
characteristics for enrolment and participation in the public pension schemes. This paper therefore
aims to assess the awareness and attitude of the informal workers at Saba saba market towards
public pension. Empirical data on these self-employed workers’ awareness and attitude will act as a
base for policy formulation among stakeholders in order to promote coverage of the informal sector
by public pension at the market.


2.1. Study Area

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.62 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
The study area was Saba saba market which had self-employed workers in petty businesses. The
market was located in one of the central locations of Dodoma Municipality. Many of the self-
employed workers at this market were engaged mainly in the sale of consumable goods and
services. Consumable goods consisted of vegetables, fruits, cereal crops in shops and kiosks,
clothing, and utensils. Some of them were offering services such as restaurants, hair salon, barber
shops, furniture and pubs. Others offered transport services by motor pick-ups, motor cycle riding
and carts. The market had leadership such as the chairperson, secretary, bursar and various
committees’ members as stipulated by the market association constitution (2014).

2.2. Data Collection

Data were collected through a cross-sectional study design at the market. Population of the study
was 1,200 registered self-employed workers. Sample size was 282 respondents while key
informants were six individuals drawn from among the market leadership and committees’
members. Random sampling by lottery was used to constitute the sample elements while purposive
sampling was applied to obtain the key informants. Methods of data collection consisted of
interview in which the tool was structured questionnaire that also included the statements to be
responded on five points Likert Scale to generate quantitative data on awareness and attitude.
Focus Group Discussion (FGD) also was used through a check list as a tool to collect qualitative
data from the key informants.

2.3. Data analysis

Data were edited and entered into Statistical Package of Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20 as a tool
for data analysis. Quantitative data were analyzed by using descriptive statistics such as frequencies
and percentages on public pension awareness. A chi-square test (  2 )of independence was also used
to determine the association between socio-demographic characteristics and awareness on public
pension at 5% levels of significance. Furthermore, analysis of respondents’ attitude was analyzed
from the responses on the Likert scale that were rated with five points scale whereby 5 = strongly
agree, 4 = agree, 3 = neither agree nor disagree, 2 = disagree and 1= strongly disagree of which had
to be indicated by respondents on the attitudinal statements. Qualitative data from the key
informants was analyzed through content analysis by formulation of themes regarding the
awareness on public pension and presented by quotation.


3.1 Socio-Demographics of Respondents
Most of the respondents constituting (44.3%) ranged from 26 to 35 years of age of which belonged
to the youth age group. Those who ranged from 36 to 45 years of age were 24.1% followed by 16 to
25 years and 46 to 55 years of age as shown in Table 1. The respondents who were in the age
category of 56 to 65 years formed the minority group and could be referred as individuals who had
to receive the retirement pension benefits (United Republic of Tanzania, 2014). The findings also
revealed that the most leading sex of respondents at the market were females (61.0%) while males
comprised (39.0%). However, these results at the market differed from those which were found by
Mohd (2015) in Kuala Lumpur among the service workers, shop and market sales workers, craft
and related trades where the number of males and females respondents in the study about the
provident fund was almost the same. Probably, the results differed from Kuala Lumpur because as
argued by Daudi (2011) in an African context, women have been more represented in the informal
labor force than males.
Furthermore, the marital status of the majority of the respondents was married (65.5%)
followed by the singles (29.1%). Other respondents’ marital status constituted the widow and the
separated as shown in Table 1. Level of education of the respondents was mainly primary education
(59.9%) and secondary education (31.2%). Others had completed tertiary education while non-
formal educational achievers were the minority. The findings at the market were contrary from

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.63 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Amlan & Shrutikeerti (2016) who found the majority of the respondents in their study on the
defined contribution pension scheme had college and university education. This was attributed to
the fact that India had higher rate of enrolment in tertiary education consisting of 18% (British
Council, 2014) while Tanzania enrolment still lagged behind to 5.5% as found by the United
Republic of Tanzania (2014).

Table 1. Socio-demographic characteristics of respondents, n  282

Socio-demographics Frequency Percentage
16 – 25 52 18.4
26 – 35 125 44.3
36 – 45 68 24.1
46 – 55 29 10.3
56 - 65 8 2.8
Males 110 39.0
Females 172 61.0
Marital Status
Married 184 65.2
Single 82 29.1
Widow 14 5.0
Separated 2 .7
Non-formal 5 1.8
Primary 169 59.9
Secondary 88 31.2
Tertiary education 20 7.1

3.2 Awareness on Public Pension

Respondents were asked if they had ever heard about public pension. Table 2 below shows that
about one third (32.3%) who responded to the question had ever heard about public pension while
two third (67.7%) never heard about it. The findings at the market is in line with Ainooson (2011)
who also found that the majority of the respondents were not aware about the Social Security
National Insurance Trust (SSNIT) that was responsible to administer pension in the Ghanaian
informal sector. Similarity in results implies that there has been inadequate availability of pension
awareness campaigns by public pension funds in Tanzanian and Ghanaian informal sector
workplaces. The study further assessed the pension benefits members knew to have been provided
by the public pension. The majority mentioned retirement benefits (75.8%) and withdrawal benefits
among others as shown in Table 2. Most participants in the Focus Group Discussion (FGD) that
was conducted also reported:

“Public pension schemes like the National Social Security Fund, Parastatal Pensions
Fund provide retirement benefits that consist of gratuity lump sum, annuity and
withdrawal benefits for members who may wish to cease membership or lose income
for contribution.” (FGD participants).

Surprisingly, a good number of the respondents still had knowledge of withdrawal benefits
being one of the pension benefits provided to the members by public pension funds. This was a
misinformation among respondents because according to the Social Security Authority (2016), the
government had finalized a plan to restrict the pension contributors from withdrawing their
contributions once they lost income or jobs. Instead, arrangements in the pensions funds were made

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.64 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
to pay a certain monthly percentage of income as unemployment benefit until the individual
obtained a new job or stabilized the income sources. According to the authority, this could protect
individual pension contributions whose goal was to support members once they retired from
employment of which began at fifty five or sixty years of age as per United Republic of Tanzania
(2014). However, the overall findings about pension benefits which had been heard at the market
were a bit contrary to Goursat & Pellerano (2016) who found that most of the informal workers in
Zambia had no idea about the benefits offered by the National Pension Scheme Authority. The non-
compliance of results was because of the fact that in Zambia it was much harder to access
information from public agencies and institutions unlike Tanzania (African Platform on Access to
Information, 2013).
Data from Table 2 also reveals that the majority of respondents who heard about public
pension gained information from the television (48.4%) and radio (39.6%) than pension staff,
friends, co-traders and newspapers. These findings at the market partly did not comply with
Aboagyewaa (2013) who found that most of respondents from informal sector in Accra had
obtained information about the old age retirement pension benefits; withdrawal accounts benefits,
death and survivor benefits provided by SSNIT mainly from the fund officials and friends. The
results differed because in Ghana the SSNIT was primarily a public pension fund that was dealing
with the informal sector workers. Therefore, its staff spent their working time with the informal
sector workers than the Tanzanian pension funds staff which were mainly concerned with formal
sector employees’ pension than the informal sector (The Mohanna, Foundation, 2014).
As displayed by Table 2 the study findings also revealed the age of respondents which had
more awareness on public pension ranged from 26 to 35 years old (45.1%) followed by 36 to 45,
16 to 25, 46 to 55 and 55 to 56 years of age. The results to some extent contradicted Arnone (2004)
argument that older individuals were likely to be more knowledgeable on pension financial matters
than the younger age. The reason for these differences in results probably was based on the fact that
the majority of the younger age at the market was curious in seeking information from various
sources that could improve their financial wellbeing than the old age that approached and or were in
terminal exit age. The results also indicated that age was negatively associated with awareness on
public pension among the study population whereby the = 5.797, p = .215. This implied that
information on public pension had not adequately reached the various age groups in the study
population. Sex of the respondents which had more awareness on public pension at the market was
females (52.7%) than males (47.3%). These results also were contrary to Ulrichs (2016) who found
that females had limited awareness about the public pension schemes. The reason behind is that
once females in an urban area had access to self employment in the informal economy, they could
seek more information about their future income security than males. The findings also revealed
that sex at the market was significantly associated with awareness on public pension whereby the
= 3.840; p = .050 which indicated that both males and females had efforts in becoming
conversant with public pension but at different levels.
Table 2 further shows that the marital status which had more awareness on public pension
was the married (73%) than the single, widow and the separated from their partners. This indicates
that those in marriage had efforts in collecting information about the financial matters of which it
was shared probably to seek the means to improve the future income security of their families than
the counterparts. However, the findings also revealed that marital status was significantly associated
with awareness on public pension in which the = 9.725 , p = .021. These results do not comply
with Njuguna & Otsola (2011) who found that marital status did not influence the level of pension
awareness and knowledge in Kenya. The results did not comply because the informal workers at
Saba saba market and those in Kenya were located in different areas which had divergent
information needs in their marital relationship. Comparatively, Table 2 also indicates that primary
education had more awareness on public pension (52.8%) than non-formal education, secondary
and tertiary education. The results among informal workers at the market were contrary to Hastings
et al (2011) argument that individuals with higher education had more knowledge on financial and
pension matters than those with lower levels of education. Non-compliance of the results at the

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.65 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
market possibly emanated from the fact that respondents who had achieved primary education
constituted the majority than those with secondary and tertiary education. However, the level of
education results showed that it was negatively associated with awareness on public pension
whereby the  2 = 4.085, p = 0.252 suggesting that education system around the market put less
emphasis on pension and social security matters.

Table 2. Awareness on public pension among respondents, n  282

Responses Frequencies Percentage
Have you ever heard of Public Pension

YES 91 32.3
NO 191 67.7
Knowledge of Benefits from Public Pension
Schemes ***
Retirement benefits 69 75.8
Withdrawal benefits 26 28.0
Maternity benefits 25 27.5
Health insurance benefits 20 22.0
Loan for education 10 11.0
Funeral grant 10 11.0
Invalidity pension benefits 5 5.5
Survivor benefits 5 5.5
Sources of Information about public pension
benefits (n= 91)***
Television 44 48.4
Radio 36 39.6
Pension staff 19 20.9
Friends 19 18.7
Co-traders 10 11.0
Newspapers 11 12.1
Socio-demographics Awareness on Public
frequency Percentage Chi- P-
square value
16 – 25 12 13.2
26 – 35 41 45.1
36 – 45 22 24.2 5.797 .215
46 – 55 11 12
55 - 56 5 5.5
Males 43 47.3
Females 48 52.7 3.840 .050

Marital Status
Married 66 73
Single 18 20 9.725 .021
Widow/widower 4 4.4
Separated 2 2.2

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.66 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Levels of Education
Non-formal 1 1
Primary 48 52.8 4.085 .252
Secondary 33 36.3
College/University 9 9.9
Significant association p 0.05, non-significant association p 0.05
*** Multiple responses and percentage exceed 100

3.3 Attitude towards Public Pension

A five point Likert scale with five attitudinal statements was used to measure the attitude towards
public pension among those who had heard about it. The respondents were required to indicate
whether they strongly agreed, agree, neither agree nor disagree, strongly disagree or disagree to the
attitudinal statements. Table 3 shows that the majority (52.7%) strongly agreed that public pension
increases financial independence during the old age and thus they were in favor of the statement.
These findings at the market were similar with those found in Enugu, Oyo, Kano, Lagos and Rivers
states in Nigeria by the National Pension Commission (2014) among the informal workers. The
convergence in results indicates that informal workers viewed public pension as a mechanism
which exactly ensured income security in future like their counterparts in Nigeria. Further, the
public pension funds which existed in pension system being the safer custody for informal sector
pension saving was disagreed by the majority of respondents (40.7%). These findings comply with
Ansah (2013) who found negative attitude toward pension scheme saving among the market women
at Madina in Accra, Ghana. These results suggest that the informal workers did not have trust and
confidence in pension funds.
The respondents also viewed that fifteen years of duration for pension contribution did not
favor the informal sector workers as the majority (41.8%) disagreed to the statement. These results
indicate that pension duration contribution as stipulated by the United Republic of Tanzania (2014).
The findings suggested that common application of the duration of contribution in pension for both
formal and informal sector was not appropriate for encouraging favorable attitude. On the other
hand, the respondents also were not in favor that public pension funds had effective recruitment
efforts of pension participants from the informal sector as almost two third (62.0%) disagreed to
the statement that: “there is effective recruitment of pension participants from the informal sector by
public pension funds.” Hence, as it was earlier argued by the Mohanna Foundation above, the
public pension funds were more allied to recruiting many participants from the formal sector
employees. On top of these results, more than half of the respondents (53.8%) also disagreed that
there is adequate public pension information at the market. Possibly, this situation at the market
existed because as it was argued by Maduga (2015), pension social security providers in Tanzania
often provided partial information which failed to go deeper enough to address information needs of
the potential clients. Furthermore, almost half of the respondents (49.5%) agreed to the statement
that low income in the informal sector was a barrier to public pension participation and thus they
were in favor of the statement. As argued by Collins-Sowah et al, (2013) low income among the
informal workers created difficulties for their integration in pension schemes which galvanized the
financial support for them to access capital for income expansion.

Table 3. Respondents’ Attitude towards public pension, n  91

Attitudinal statements Responses %

Public pension increases financial
independence during old age 52.7 4.4 4.4 26.4 12.1 100

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.67 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Public pension funds in pension system are
safer custody for informal sector pension
saving 4.4 6.6 13.2 35.2 40.7 100
Fifteen years of pension contribution favors
informal workers 28.6 8.8 8.8 41.8 12.1 100
There is effective recruitment efforts of
pension participants from the informal
sector by public pension funds 7.6 10.9 9.8 62.0 9.8 100
There is adequate public pension
information at the market 7.7 20.9 12.1 5.5 53.8 100
Low income in informal sector is a barrier
to participation in public pension 15.4 49.5 13.1 8.8 13.1 100
Key: SA = Strongly Agree, A = Agree, NA/ND = Neither Agree nor Disagree, D = Disagree,
SD = Strongly Disagree

3.4. Overall attitudes of informal workers at Saba saba market towards public pension
Based on the attitudinal statements used to determine the attitudes of Saba saba market workers
towards public pension presented on Table 3, the findings from adding all the scores from each
individuals revealed that minimum and maximum points were 8 and 25 respectively with a total
mean score of 16.69. From the attitudinal scores, the data were ranked such that out of all those who
responded to the attitudinal statements with scores less than the mean value of 16.7 were considered
to have unfavorable attitude while those who had total scores above the mean score were considered
to have favorable attitude and those who fell over the mean had uncertain attitude towards public
pension. The results indicated on Table 4 revealed that about half of the respondents (47.2%) had
unfavorable attitudes towards public pension, 44.0% had favorable and for the minority (8.8%) it
were uncertain.

Table 4: Saba saba market workers towards public pension

Overall Attitudes Counts %
Unfavorable 43 47.2
Uncertain 8 8.8
Favorable 40 44.0
Total 91 100


Sab saba market had the majority of respondents who never had awareness on public pension.
Among the minority who had heard about it, mainly knew the retirement benefits being offered
from the public pension schemes. Also public pension awareness at the market was associated with
sex and marital status while age and education had negative association, thus being independent of
awareness on public pension. Regarding the attitudes towards public pension, it was unfavorable
among many respondents. The study derives the following recommendations: awareness campaigns
on public pension should be organized directly at the market by the National Social Security
Regulatory Authority for all regardless of their age and levels of education. Depth clearer
communication strategy based on pension information needs assessment at the market and a trade-
off in recruitment efforts of pension participants from informal and formal sectors could help in
changing the negative attitudes towards public pension. Policy makers also should adopt a more
favorable shorter duration of pension contribution of the informal workers at the market considering
their employment challenges which may differ from formal sector employment.


International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.68 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
African Platform on Access to Information. (2013). Access to information in Africa: Examining
Progress since APAI Declaration. Friedrich-Ebertstiftung. Windhoek. Namibia. p. 75 – 81.
Arnone, W. (2004). Educating Pension Plan Participants. Pension Research Council. University of
Pennsylvania p. 32.
Ansah, D. (2013). Saving Practice of Madina Women on Social Insurance. Masters Dissertation in
Social Policy. University of Ghana, Legon p. xi.
Aboagyewaa, A.A. (2013). Emerging New Patterns in Social Security in the Informal Economy in
Accra, Ghana. MA Social Policy Dissertation. University of Ghana, Legon pp. 45-50.
Ainooson, B. B. (2011). Providing Social Protection in the Form of Pension Funds to the Informl
Sector in Ghana: A Case Study of SSNIT Informal Sector Fund. MBA Masters Thesis. Institute
of Distance Learning p. 16.
Amlan.G & Shrutikeerti. K. (2016). Factors Influencing the Participation in Defined Contribution
Pension Scheme by Urban Unorganized Sector in India. Journal of Global Economics. Vol. 4
No.1 p. 6.
Afenyadu, A. (2014). A Study of Petty Traders in Ghana to Identify the Barriers to Participation in
ISF Pension Scheme. Masters of Science in Capacity Development Thesis. University of
Guelph p. 3, British Council. (2014). Understanding India: The future of Higher Education and
Opportunities for International Cooperation. p. 4.
Castel, P. (2005). Voluntary Defined Benefits Pension System Willingness to Participate: The Case
of Vietnam: Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs p. 29.
Chris,U.K. & Attamah.N. (2015). Impact of Contributory Pension Scheme on Workers’ Savings
and Investment in Nigeria.: Anambra State Case Study. IOSR Journal of Economics and
Finance. Vol. 6. Issue. 2. pp. 9-20.
Collins-Sowah, P.A, Kowornu.J.K.M & Tsegai, D. (2013). Willingness to participate in Micro-
pensions Schemes: Evidence from Informal Sector in Ghana. Journal of Economics &
International Finance. Vol. 5(1).pp. 21-34
Dorfman, M. (2015). Pensions Patterns in Africa. Discussion Paper. World Bank Group p. 4.
Daudi, Z.A. (2011). Challenges facing Women Informal Sector Operations in Balancing Child
Caring and Productive Roles. Case of Women in Food Vendors in Ilala Municipality. Masters
of Arts in Social Work. Open University of Tanzania. p. 4.
Goursat, M.P & Pellerano.L. (2016). Extension of Social Protection to Workers in the Informal
Economy in Zambia. Irish Aid p. 21.
Government Retirement Benefits Fund Act, 2013. United Republic of Tanzania. pp. 1-65.
Hastings, T, Mitchell. and O. Chyn. E. (2011). Financial Literacy and Pension Fund Fees.
Retrieved: http://www.tiaa-crefinstiture.org
Heenkenda, S. (2016). Determinants of Dropouts from Voluntary Pension Scheme: Evidence from
Sri Lanka. International Journal of Business and Management. 1 (1) p. 11.
International Labour Organization. (2001). Facts on Social Security. Geneva. p . 1.
Kayitare, E. (2016). Factors Affecting Rwandan Informal Sector Workers Participation in Public
Pension Scheme. PhD Thesis. Walden University p. 41.
Keizi, L. (2006). Barriers to Pension Scheme Participation by Workers in Informal Economy.
Retirement Benefits Authority. Research and Policy Analysis, p 11.
Maduga, F.C. (2015). Public Communication and Social Security in Tanzania. PhD Thesis.
University of West London p-iv, PPF Pensions Fund. (2015). Operations Guide. pp. 2 – 3;
Public Service Pensions Fund. (2017). Ijue PSPF. p. 15.
National Pension Commission. (2014). Incorporating the Informal Sector in Nigeria into the
Contributory Pension Scheme. Enhancing Financial Innovation and Access (EFINA)) p. 8
Mohd,S. (2015). Provident Fund for Informal Sector: A Case Study of the informal Sector Workers
in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Kajian Malaysia Vol. 33 Supp. 1 pp. 53-67.
Ntibitura, J. (2013). Assessment of the feasibility to extend the Pensions Scheme Coverage to Self-
employed in Rwanda. Master Thesis. University of Mauritius p. 1.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.69 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Njuguna, A.G & Otsola.J.K. (2011). Predictors of Pension Finance Literacy: A Survey of Members
of Occupational Pension Schemes in Kenya. International Journal of Business and
Management. Vol. 6. No. 9 . p. 105.
Stewart, F & Yermo, J. (2009). Pensions in Africa. OECD Working Papers on Insurance and
Private Pensions. No. 3 p. 4.
Saba Saba Market Traders. (2016). Constitution of Saba saba Market Association. Dodoma
Municipality. pp. 8-10.
The Mohanna Foundation. (2014). Social Security Schemes in East and Central African Countries:
An Actuarial Paper. p. 6.
The Social Security Regulatory Authority. (2016). Pension Fund Withdrawals to be restricted in
new plan. Seminar presentation by Director of Legal Services. The Citizen Paper. The United
Republic of Tanzania. (2014). The Social Security Schemes (Pensions Benefits Harmonization)
Rules. Social Security Regulatory Authority p. 4 – 5.
The United Nations General Assembly. (1966). International Covenant on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights. Article 9 p 3.
Ulrichs, M. (2016). Informality, Women and Social Projection: Identifying barriers to provide
effective coverage: Working paper 435. DFID p. 50.
United Republic of Tanzania. (2014). Education for All 2015 National Review for Tanzania
Mainland. Ministry of Education and Vocational Training. p. 64.
Wang,P. Han,M, Shan,R, Kerry, E. (2014). Retirement, Pension Systems and Models of Pension
Systems. Economics Working Papers. p. 3.
World Bank. (2014). Public Expenditure Review: Government Pension Obligations and Contingent
Liabilities: Policy Note p. 3.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.70 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Knowledge and Attitudes of Male Employees towards Paternity Leave

in Iringa Municipality, Tanzania
Nzali, A.S. and Philipo, F.

About the Author(s)

Agnes S. Nzali is affiliated with University of Iringa, P.O. Box 200, Iringa, Tanzania, Department
of Community Development. For correspondence: aggy.nzali@googlemail.com
Frank Philipo is affiliated with University of Iringa, P.O. Box 200, Iringa, Tanzania,
Department of Community Development.

This study aims to establish the knowledge and attitudes of male employees towards paternity leave
in Iringa Municipality. A cross-sectional research design and multistage sampling technique were
used to select 150 male employees from private and public sectors. Respondents’ awareness on
paternity leave was captured by using open and closed ended questions. Attitudes of male
employees towards paternity leave were captured by using a five-point Likert Scale. Findings show
that the majority of male employees were not aware of paternity leave in the study area. The study
found that the majority of male employees were aware of paid paternity leave did not apply for.
Furthermore, the study revealed that male employees had unfavourable attitude towards paternity
leave. The study recommends for workers’ trade unions to increase efforts in educating their
members about paternity leave and its benefits as it will help to change male employees’ negative
attitude towards paternity leave.

Key words: Awareness attitude, paternity leave, employee benefits

Nzali, A.S. and Philipo, F. (2017). “Knowledge and Attitudes of Male Employees towards Paternity
Leave in Iringa Municipality, Tanzania.” Inter. J. Res. Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No. 2: pp. 70–
77. (Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

Paternity leave is often discussed as a policy measure to encourage greater gender equality both in
the family and in the labor market. It strengthens women’s position in the labor market, reduce the
gender wage gap and give children a chance to bond with their fathers, it also increases men’s
involvement in child caring. In this study the male employees’ awareness and attitudes towards
paternity leave were assessed (Burtle and Bezruchka, 2016). In Tanzania, Employment and Labor
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.71 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Relations Act No. 6 entitled three days paternity leave to employee if the leave is taken within
seven days of the birth of the child and the employee is the father of the child (URT, 2004). Despite
the paternity leave entitlement under Tanzania Labour Act of 2004, very little empirical evidence is
available about males’ awareness and attitude towards paternity leave. This study was undertaken to
fill that gap using a case of Iringa Municipality, Tanzania. In the Employment and Labour Relations
Act no. 8 of 2006 section 34 sub-section 1, it is stated that: “During any leave cycle, a male
employee shall be entitled to at least three days paid paternity leave if (i) the leave is taken within
seven days of the birth of the child and (ii) the employee is the father of the child”.


Paternity is the legal term for the relationship between a father and his child. Paternity leave is a
leave of absence from work granted to a father to care for an infant or a period of paid or unpaid
absence from work granted by an employer immediately after the birth of his child (Moss, 2012).
United Nations (2012) defines paternity leave as an employee benefit that provides paid or unpaid
time off to care for a child or make arrangement for the newborn’s welfare. Williams (2004)
defines paternity leave a period of paid or unpaid absence from work granted to a man by his
employer immediately after the birth of his child. The United Nations (UN) explains that male
employees receive special leave (Paternity leave) for the birth of the child. Internationally recruited
male employees are granted a period of up to four weeks and those who work at non-family duty
may receive up to eight weeks paternity leave. This period of the leave may be taken continuously
or in separate periods during the following the birth of the child (United Nations, 2012). According
to Field-Office Memorandum No. 67/2001 of the United Nations, paragraph 11 “Paternity Leave is
not a mandatory, and the employee may choose to use it fully or not to use it at all. It may be taken
in conjunction with or independently of other approved forms of leave such as annual leave, special
leave, and uncertified sick leave. However this applies to internationally employed males. Such
other forms of leave continue to be subject to existing criteria and provisions of employers.
In the United Kingdom, paternity leave was introduced in 2003 with a minimum of two
weeks off work, paid at a minimum of 120 Euros and above per week. The leave allows a male
parent (the father) to stay home with a newborn, recently adopted or foster child (Fisher, 2014). In
the United States of America (USA), it is reported that only 10% of private sector employees access
the leave if an employee is well paid, works in a managerial or professional occupations or working
in a company having at least 100 employees. On the other hand, only four percent (4%) of workers
with low paid may access the paternity leave (Miller, 2014).
In the United Arab Emirates (UAE), new fathers in the private sector are granted to another
type of leave such as annual leave or unpaid leave in order to support their wives and welcome their
new child (Lewis, 2015). In some parts of Africa, there are some laws guiding paternity leave in
the private and public sectors. The Zambia Labour Act, for instance, provides that paternity leave
will allow a working father to spend seven days supporting and looking after partners and the newly
born babies (Mywage, 2013). In South Africa, there is no paternity leave for employees. However,
workers who have been employed for longer than four months may take at least three days off –
paid leave for family responsibility (paternity leave) where an employer may request an employee
to provide reasonable proof of a birth certificate if the employee’s child before the employee is paid
(Cloud, 2015).


This study was conducted in Iringa Municipal Council, Iringa regional. The core activities in Iringa
Municipality are business, tourism, agriculture, and manufacturing industries. It is a fast growing
town accelerated by the fast growing population which has fostered the booms in demand for
different forms of services together with the industrial products.
The study used a cross sectional research design. Purposive technique was used to select the
respondents. This technique is appropriate when respondents are tied with particular characteristics
(Palys, 2008). In this case respondents were to be male employees. The study involved male

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.72 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
employees from both private and public sector, where 96 men employees were selected from public
sector and 54 men employees from private sector making a sample size of 150 respondents. The
study also involved key informants based on their positions they hold in different organizations or
companies. They included Human Resource Officers, CEOs and the Heads of Sections or
Departments from the employees’ work place. The Municipal Labour Officer was also selected for
the study. A questionnaire with closed-ended and open-ended questions was used to male
employees after being pretested to ensure its reliability. The questionnaire also included a five-point
Likert scale with four positive and four negative attitudinal statements to determine the attitudes of
men employees towards paternity leave. The scale was rated with 1 to 5 points, where 1=Strongly
Disagree, 2=Disagree, 3=Undecided, 4=Agree and 5=Strongly Agree.
Interview guide was used to collect information from the key informants concerning the
issue under the study. Data from questionnaire were analysed by descriptive statistics including
frequencies, means, and percentages using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences. The
responses from interviewees were interpreted, categorised and summarised by merging similar ones
to have categories of information based on the study objectives. Mayring (2000) argues that aspects
of interpretation following the research objectives may put into categories, which are carefully
found and revised within the process of analysis.


4.1 Male Employees’ Background information
More than a half (64%) of respondents were taken from the public sector. Results from the study
reveal that about one third (33.3%) of respondents were employed as teachers from secondary
schools and primary schools followed by Agricultural Officers who were less than a quarter
(16.7%). Very few (3.3%) respondents were police officers who were picked from the public sector
only. Only security guards can be employed by the sector and these were ten percent in this study.
Other respondents were social workers (13.3%), lecturers (13.3%), and health workers (10%).

Table 1. Male Employees’ Background Information ( n  150 )

Variable Frequency Percent
Public 96 64
Private 54 36
Total 150 100
Age category
26 – 30 15 10
31 -35 21 14
36 -40 32 21.3
41 – 45 42 28
46- 50 40 26.7
Total 150 100
No. of children
1 to 3 88 58.7
4 to 6 48 32
More than 6 14 9.3
Total 150 100
Teacher 50 33.3
Agricultural Officer 25 16.7
Social worker 20 13.3
Lecturer 20 13.3
Security guard 15 10
Health worker 15 10
Police officer 5 3.3
Total 150 100

4.2 Male Employees’ Awareness of Paternity Leave by Sector

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.73 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Results show that majority (54.2% and 63.0%) of the respondents from both public sector and
private sectors respectively were not aware of existence of paternity leave. This indicates that
employers at their work place had not fully informed male employees on their rights. Awareness is
lower in private sector than in public sector which might imply that in the private sector most
employers were more reluctant to inform their male employees about paternity leave. The results
also reveal that those who were aware of it, more than a half (59.5%) came from the public sector
and received information from Trade Unions at their work place, while the minority (30%) from the
private sector received information from the mass media and trade unions (Table 2). The
implication of this situation is that employers in private sector may not be willing to inform
employees because by doing so male employees might apply for paternity leave and hence reduce
productivity. Ladden (2014) also argue that it is a challenge in the private sector that longer leave
period such as maternity or paternity leaves reduce production and income unless the beneficiary is

Table 2. Male Employees’ Awareness of Paternity leave ( n  150 )

Variable Public sector Private sector
Awareness n % n %
Aware 42 45.8 20 37.0
Not aware 52 54.2 34 63.0
Total 96 100 54 100
Source of information (n=62)
Trade Union 25 59.5 6 30.0
Employer 12 28.6 3 15.0
Mass media 4 9.5 6 30.0
Colleagues 1 2.4 5 25.0
Total 42 100 20 100

4.3 Male Employees’ Application for Paternity Leave

Nearly three fifths (59.5%) of respondents who were aware of paternity leave from the public sector
did not apply for the leave while all (100%) who were aware from the private sector did not apply
(Table 3). This difference between the two sectors might concur with the argument by Ladden
(2014) that the biggest challenge in private sector is that longer leave periods like maternity or
paternity leaves reduce production and incomes unless the beneficiary is replaced by another person
in the job. Therefore employers in the private sector tend not be ready to replace employees on
leave, these employers would rather not informing employees of such a leave benefit.
The results might also imply that being aware of the leave does not mean that men
employees feel that paternity leave is important for them to help their wives in taking care of the
new baby and, therefore, would apply for it. Williams (2004), in a research on men and paternity
leave, it was found that 70% of working fathers did not take paternity leave due to social stigma
attached to it. William also found that 40% of men who opted to take time off for childcare stayed
in the office instead. This suggests that social stigma against men taking time off for childcare is
hindered by social stigma. This stigma is culturally constructed.

Table 3. Respondents’ Application for Paternity Leave by sector ( n  62 )

Application for paternity leave Public sector Private sector
n % n %
Applied 17 40.5 0 0.0
Did not apply 25 59.5 20 100.0
Total 42 100 20 100
Reason for not applying (n = 45)

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.74 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Very few days 10 40.0 4 20.0
Loss of job/deduction of salary 0 0.0 3 15.0
It is worthless 7 28.0 3 15.0
Not well informed 8 32.0 10 50.0
Total 25 100 20 100

During interviews, respondents were requested to give reasons why they did not apply for
the leave even if they were aware of their right to do so. It was revealed that the reasons for not
applying paternity leave include: the time (three days) for the leave is very short and therefore the
leave is just useless, worry due to salary deductions especially in the private sector, worry of loss of
job, as many employers in the private sector would prefer to have unmarried men to avoid
absenteeism at work and others said they feel shy to apply for the leave. McLynn (2014) asserts that
many employers enhance statutory maternity entitlements but were reluctant to do so for shared
parental leave, because of fear that there would be a massive take-up of such entitlements from
eligible male employees. Weber (2013) also comments that leave is the norm for women, but men
have only become a part of the discussion as traditional housewife and breadwinner roles have

4.4 Activities during the Three Day Paternity Leave

Respondents who applied for paternity leave were requested to explain what they did during the
leave. About three quarters (70.6%) of them reported to be out of home and doing other activities
like business, visiting friends and colleagues and having leisure rather than helping their wives. The
reason was that during this time other female relatives like mother in-law, sister in-law or aunt
come at home and help the wife with the new born. Respondents also said that their culture did not
allow them to perform household tasks like washing and cooking for their wives and that if they do
so their relatives would not allow that. They also added that men who requested paternity leave
were being stigmatized because they were perceived to have negative traits that are used to
stigmatize women, showing weakness and uncertainty, not masculine and ambitious. This gives an
implication that culture is still a barrier for men to be involved in women dominated activities
(household tasks). The implications are also harsh for gender equality in the workplace as well as at
household. At household level women do the bulk of the chores and primarily responsible for
looking after the children (Schober and Scottt, 2012)
During interviews with some employers, it was found that many men, who openly identify
with their parental role at work, face pressure or resentment from co-workers. Men who are active
caregivers get teased and insulted at work more than so-called traditional fathers and men without
children. It is as if society dictates that men are incapable of giving the same amount of care to a
child as a woman would do. One of the men employees said:

Table 4. Activities done by Respondents during Paternity Leave ( n  17 )

Activities done during leave time Frequency Percentage
Do other activities out of home 12 70.6

Stay at home and help the wife with the new born 5 29.4
Total 17 100

The rest (29.4%) stayed at home and helped their wives by performing different roles like
cooking, washing, doing shopping, and clean their houses. However, they said that they had to do
so because they had no relatives to help in their homes as they were living far from their relatives
especially the in-laws who could take care of their wives and the new born. Only two respondents
said they would help their wives even if their relatives come and stay in their homes during their
leave time.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.75 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
The results are contrary to those in America, Australia, Britain and Denmark where fathers
who had took paternity leave were more likely to feed, dress, bathe and play with their children
during their leave and after the period of leave had ended (Koune, 2015). Weber (2013) asserts that
increased father-child interaction at an early stage helps children with their development later in
life. Miller (2014) and Luden (2014) also argue that fathers who take longer leaves are more
involved in child care even some months more after returning to work. This implies that providing
paternal leave is about more than just giving time to men with their new born, but it gives babies the
sense of security and nurturing, and creates men (fathers) who understand parenting role. Mason
(2013) adds that paternity leave is aimed at helping parents to share the load of caring for a
newborn, to help fathers play a greater role in the earliest of stages of their child’s life, and enable
the mother to return to her normal health earlier than when she is doing it alone. However, the
contrary results show that in Tanzania culture dictates the gender roles for men and women. In this
case the role for child care is primarily left for women alone.

4.5 Male Employees’ Attitude towards Paternity Leave

A five-point Likert scale with eight attitudinal statements was used to measure male employees’
attitudes towards paternity leave. Four of the statements had positive connotations and four had
negative connotations on which men were required to indicate whether they strongly disagreed,
disagreed, were uncertain, agreed or strongly agreed. The points scored were added up to determine
the overall attitude of the respondents.
The results (Table 5) show that majority (37.28% and 40.6%) from public and private
sectors respectively strongly disagreed that men employees were well informed about paternity
leave, thus they were not in favour of the statement. The time given for paternity leave was also
found to be not enough as majority (35.2% and 40.6%) of the respondents from the two sectors
respectively did not agree with the statement that: ‘The time for paternity leave is enough”

Table 5. Male Employees’ Attitude towards Paternity Leave by sector ( n  150 )

Response (%)
SD D U A SA Total
Attitudinal statement pblc prvt pblc prvt pblc prvt pblc prvt pblc prvt
Men employees are well informed on paternity
leave 37.2 40.6 1.5 1.4 2.4 1.0 14.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 100
Men co-workers usually apply for paternity
leave 10.2 7.0 32 38.2 2.2 1.0 2.0 0.0 1.3 0,0 100
The time for paternity leave is enough 6.0 8.0 35.2 40.6 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 0.0 0.0 100
Paternity leave is important for men to help
their wives 2.8 0.0 9.0 8.0 2.5 0.0 30.7 43.2 2.6 1.4 100
Paternity leave is costly to employers 3.2 0.0 29.0 23.0 7.0 9.8 7.0 18.0 0.0 2.0 100
Paternity leave is worthless 7.2 7.4 22.0 28.0 4.8 3.0 19.0 16.8 0.0 1.8 100
Men employees are reluctant to apply for
paternity leave 2.2 0.0 13.0 9.0 8.0 10.8 28.0 25.0 2.0 3.0 100
Men employees do not need the leave as it is for
mothers only 4.0 0.0 27.6 23.0 5.3 2.5 20.0 16.8 0.8 0.0 100
Key: SD=Strongly Disagaree; D=Disagree; U=Uncertain; A=Agree; Strongly Agree
Pblc = Public; prvt = Private

Majority of the respondents (30.7% and 43.2%) from the public and private sector
respectively viewed that; paternity leave was costly to employers. Some male employees also
viewed paternity leave as worthless. This might be explained that male employees did not regard
that helping their wives in taking care of their newborn as an important task and, therefore, there
was no need for paternity leave. However, it was also revealed that some men employees needed
paternity leave, as they did not agree with the statement that: ‘Men employees do not need the leave
as it is for mothers who are responsible of taking care of young babies.
This response gives an implication that men employees would like to have paternity leave
but they did not apply for it because of stigma at their work place and that majority of them were
not aware of their right to the leave as asserted by Weber (2013). Another reason might be the time
International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.76 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
for the leave is too short (3 days). The cultural aspect also would not be forgotten as stereotypes on
this issue had a great role to play in hindering men from applying for paternity leave.

4.6 Overall Attitudes of Male Employees towards Paternity Leave

Based on the attitudinal statements used to determine the attitudes of male employees towards
paternity leave the findings revealed that the minimum and maximum overall attitude points were
21.0 and 40.0 respectively with an average point of 32.2. Out of the maximum of 40.0 points, all the
points up to 23.0 indicated unfavourable attitudes; neutral attitude was represented by 24 points and
favourable attitude was represented by 25 to 40 points. The results revealed that almost three- fifths
(61.3%) of the male employees had unfavourable attitude towards paternity leave, 25.4% had
favourable attitude towards paternity leave and the rest (13.3%) were uncertain.

Table 6. Male Employees’ Overall Attitudes towards Paternity Leave ( n  150 )

Overall attitudes n %
Unfavourable 92 61.3
Uncertain 20 13.3
Favourable 38 25.4
Total 150 100

Mason (2013) asserts that men are too often mocked in the work place for wanting to go part
time or leaving early to care for their children. Due to this fact which in most cases is caused by
cultural issues, male employees may not apply for maternity leave.


The study set out to establish the knowledge and attitude of males’ towards paternity leave in
Tanzania with special reference to private and public sector employee of Iringa Municipality of
Iringa Region. The study draws the following recommendations: workers trade union should
increases effort to ensure more employees have the right knowledge about existence of paternity
leave and its associated benefits to their members in order to change their negative attitude towards
paternity leave. There is a need for policy makers particularly the employment policy, to increase
the number of days for paternity leave to give more time for males to engage on activities that
support their wives on caring the new born as a significant number of male employee said that the
time for paternity leave was short. There should be programmes to create awareness on the
importance of paternity leave to male employees at work place to reduce the cultural stigma among

Burtle and Bezruchka (2016). Population Health and Paid Parental Leave: What the United States
Can Learn fromTwo Decades of Research. Journal of Healthcare, (4) 30: 1-16.
Cloud, J.R. (2015). Men do not take enough paternity leave: Does it make a
difference?[https://rotacloud.com/blog/men-do-not-take-enough-pate] Site visited on
Fisher, A. (2014). Most new dads take time off, without calling it paternity leave
[http://www.bsa.natcen.ac] Site visited on 28/07/2016.
Koen, G. (2015). Paternity leave creates super dads
[http://www.news24.com/Opinions/Paternity-leave-creates-superdads-20150620] Site visited on
Lewis, K. (2015). Understand Your Paternity Leave Options

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.77 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Site visited on 27/07/2016.
Ludden, J. (2014). More Dads Want Paternity Leave. Getting: It is A Different Matter
http://www.npr.org]. Site visited on 28/07/2016
Mason, R. (2013) Fathers being able to share parental leave. The Guardian, Friday 29 November,
Site visited on 27/07/2016.
Mayring, Philipp (2000). Qualitative Content Analysis [28 paragraphs]. Forum Qualitative
Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research, [http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0114-
fqs0002204] Site visited on 21/01/2017.
McLynn, L. (2014). Why shared parental leave could create more problems?
Miller C.C.(2014). Paternity Leave: The Rewards and the Remaining Stigma
http://www.wsj.com/articles/] Site visited on 28/07/2016.
Moss, P. (2012). International Review of Leave Policies and Related Research 2012
Institute of Education University of London, London.
Mywage, B. (2013) Salary analysis, benefits and working time.
leave] Site visited on 28/07/2016.
Palys, T. (2008). Purposive sampling. In L.M. Given (Ed.). The Sage Encyclopaedia of Qualitative
Research Methods. (Vol.2). Sage: Los Angeles, pp. 697-8
Schober, P. and Scott, J. (2012), 'Maternal employment and gender role attitudes: Dissonance
among British men and women in the transition to parenthood', Journal of Work, Employment
and Society, 26(3): 514-530.
United Nations (2012). United Nations Common System of Salaries, Allowances and Benefits.
United Nations, New York.
United Republic of Tanzania (URT) (2004). Employment and Labour Relations Report. URT, Dar
es Salaam.
United Republic of Tanzania (URT) (2012). Iringa Municipal Council Population Projection
Report. URT, Dar es Salaam.
Weber, L. (2013). Why Dads Don't Take Paternity Leave? [http://www.wsj.com/articles/] Site
visited on 28/07/2016.
Williams, F. (2004), Rethinking Families, London: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.78 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

Thailand 4.0 Readiness

Louanglath, P.I.

About the author(s)

Louangrath, P.I. is an Assistant Professor in Business Administration at Bangkok University,
Bangkok, Thailand. He could be reached by email at: Lecturepedia@gmail.com

This paper presents a situation analysis for a development policy called Thailand 4.0. Thailand 4.0
aims to achieve economic prosperity, social well-being, human values and environmental
protection. Two research questions are presented. Firstly, does Thailand have characteristics of a
developed economy? To answer this question, we use the 10-Factors Test of developed economy.
Secondly, does Thailand have sustainable economy? We tested 20 factors of ADB’s standards for
sustainability. Macroeconomic data from annual reports of ADB, WEF and IMF were used.
Thailand scores U  0.29  0.08 or has 29% of the developed economy characteristics using
Kahnman-Tvertsky prospect theory. The test for sustainability looked at improving and
deteriorating factors. Improving factors include: participation prior to primary school, proportion
women in parliament, GDP growth of employed persons, commercial banks, mobile phone
coverage, household income, GDP growth, value added to GDP, investment, and fiscal balance.
Deteriorating factors include: Gini coefficient, global poverty, national poverty, maternal mortality,
infant mortality, traffic death, and external debt. Among the ASEAN group, Thailand showed one
significant indicator. Within ASEAN, Thailand shows no significant improvement. According to
the 10 characteristics of the First World Economy, Thailand scores 0.295 or achieved 29.5%
probability of the expected value or succeeded 57.84% in achieving FWE status. According to the
ADB’s partial indicators for sustainable economy, Thailand still has not met the standard.

Keywords: Development model, prospect theory, Thailand 4.0

JEL Code: B12, B13, C10, F63

Louangrath, P.I. (2017). “Thailand 4.0 Readiness.” Inter. J. Res. Methodol. Soc. Sci., Vol., 3, No.
2: pp. 77–86. (Apr. – Jun. 2017); ISSN: 2415-0371.

The economic development of Thailand is divided into three stages. The first stage was called
Thailand 1.0; the country was an agriculture based economy. The second stage was called Thailand
2.0, the country’s developmental engine came from light industry. The third stage was called
Thailand 3.0; the country focused on heavy industry as the engine of growth. By the end of the first
decade of the 21st century, Thailand realized that it was caught in a developmental trap of (i) being

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.79 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
middle income country, (ii) income inequality, and (iii) socio-economic imbalance. In response,
Thailand announces Thailand 4.0 development policy.
Thailand 4.0 aims to achieve economic prosperity, social well-being, human values and
environmental protection. These goals will be achieved through raising competitiveness in four
main sectors. First, in the agricultural sector, Thailand 4.0 calls for the transformation of traditional
farming to “smart farming.” Second, traditional SMEs will be transformed into “smart SMEs.”
Third, where the economy had long been sagged with low value services, Thailand 4.0 wants the
country to focus on “high value services.” Fourth, unskilled labor will be transformed into “skilled
To achieve economic prosperity, Thailand 4.0 calls for the use of technology, innovation
and creativity. Specifically, the country will commit 4% of the GDP to R&D and raising the per
capita earning to $15,000 by 2032. To achieve social-well being of the first world economy,
Thailand 4.0 will introduce smart farmers in 5 years and having a functional welfare system in 20
years. The problem in income inequality will also be lessened. To achieve the rise in human value,
the new development policy will create a new Thai 4.0 citizenry that would equate Thais to first
world citizen. The HDI will be raised to 0.80 from its current position of 0.74. In 20 years time, at
least 5 universities in Thailand will be in the top 100 universities of the world. Lastly, on the
environmental front Thailand 4.0 will create the world’s 10 most livable cities in Thailand, reduce
carbon emission, adjust to climate changes and reduce terrorism. The ultimate goal of Thailand 4.0
is to transform Thailand from a developing economy into a developed economy or First World
Economy (FWE).
This paper presents two research questions. Firstly, does Thailand have characteristics of a
developed economy? To answer this question, we use the 10-Factors Test of developed economy.
Secondly, does Thailand have sustainable economy? We tested 20 factors of ADB’s standards for
sustainability. Macroeconomic data came from annual reports of ADB, WEF and IMF.


The literature on economic development may be categorized into 3 lines of thinking, namely
classical, neo-classical and contemporary models of economic growth. Among the classical school,
there were three prominent models. First, the linear-stages-of-growth models asserts that economic
growth depends on savings and investment (Rostow, 1960; Harrod, 1948; and Domar, 1947).
Second, the structural change model of the classical school contends that economic growth comes
from the transferring of economic resources from low-productivity to high-productivity activities.
For instances, resources from the agricultural sector are allocated to the industrial sector (Lewis,
1954, and Cheenery, 1960). Third, international-dependence model was the last school of the
classical thinking. International-dependence model advocated the withdrawal from the international
economy and pursue self-sufficiency or autarky (Cohen, 1973, and Dos Santos, 1973).
The second line of economic development model is the neo-classical school. This school of
economics calls for liberalization, stabilization and privatization. Liberalization means the
elimination of price distortion by government interference in the market, such as protectionism,
subsidy and public ownership (Bauer, 1984; Lal, 1983; Johnson, 1971; and Little, 1982).
Stablization may be achieved by increasing capital and improving technology (Solow, 1956).
In contrast to the classical and neo-classical theories, the third line of developmental model
advocates the new growth theory. According to the new growth theory, technological changes must
also bring about the production of knowledge in order to achieve growth (Romer 1986; Lucas 1988;
Aghion and Howitt 1992). Growth comes from the increasing return of the use of knowledge, not
just a combination of labor and capital. The role of investment shifts to human capital,
infrastructure and R&D. Whereas governmental interference in the market had been condemned by
neo-classical theorist, contemporary developmental theorists embraces the state’s role in promoting
human capital formation and knowledge-intensive industries (Meir, 2000).
Thailand 4.0 is the application of the contemporary economic development theory.
However, the contemporary developmental school is not without criticism. The theory has been

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.80 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
criticized for overlooking the role of social and institutional infrastructure (Skott and Auerbach
1995). These infrastructures may include the availability of adequate capital and goods market
(Cornwall and Cornwall 1994). Thailand 4.0 seems to take these facts into consideration in
pronouncing its four objectives: economic prosperity, social well-being, human values and
environmental protection. These objectives appear to agree with the world consensus on
development. In 2000, the UN announced the Millennium Development Goals (MDG) to include
eight components, namely poverty and hunger, primary universal education, gender equality, child
health, maternal health, HIV/AIDS, environmental sustainability and global partnership. However,
unlike MDG whose development goal is specific, Thailand 4.0’s goal is more general. It intends to
drive Thailand into the first world economy within 20 years. Thus, as a situation analysis paper, we
ask two questions: (i) Does Thailand have characteristics of a developed economy? and (ii) Does
Thailand have sustainable economy?

Table 1. Thailand 4.0 compared to Millennium Development Goals (MDG)

Thailand 4.0* Millennium Development Goals**
20 years target (2012-2032) 15 years target (2000 – 2015)
1. Economic prosperity 1. Poverty and hunger reduction
2. Social well-being 2. Primary universal education
3. Raising human values 3. Gender equality
4. Environmental protection 4. Child health
5. Maternal health
7. Environmental sustainability
8. Global partnership
*A national development policy with 20 years horizon. **Involving 191 member nations and 22
international organizations. By 2016, MDG was replaced by the Sustainable Development Goals
(SDG) involving 193 member nations with a target end year in 2030. The new SDG has 17 goals
and 169 targets.

In analysis of these two issues, we keep these three development goals as the guiding
principle, namely economic growth, improving quality of life, and sustainable development.
Economic growth is measured by the country’s gross national product (Todaro and Smith 2009).
This growth is then quantified into per capita level to reflect the increase in economic benefits at per
capita level (Jaffee 1998). Economic growth at the national level should not come at the expense of
the environment and income inequality among the people. This concerned was summarized, thus:
“[t]o maximize income growth, environmental considerations were left to languish on the sidelines;
the standard of living was often allowed to slide; large inequalities between classes, regions, and
genders were ignored; and poverty was tolerated more than it should have been in the rush to
generate maximum growth” (Basu 2000, p. 64).
Secondly, economic growth must come with the security of the quality of life for the people.
“Quality of life” may be measured by the level of poverty, inequality and unemployment in the
country (Seers, 1969). This implies that Thailand 4.0 must also include income distribution,
environment, health and education Stiglitz (1998). Thailand 4.0’s commitment to well-being of the
people is consistent with what contemporary growth theorists requiring that economic development
must transcend the promotion of growth to the promotion of well-being (Sen,1985, 1992, 1999). In
this paper, we also attempt to assess this life quality goal, i.e. health, education and the environment
(Berenger and Verdier-Chouchane 2007).
Lastly, in order to be successful, Thailand 4.0 must be sustainable. Sustainable development
means that economic growth must involve “maximizing the net benefits of economic development,
subject to maintaining the services and quality of natural resources over time” (Pearce and Turner
1990, p. 24). There had been debates as to what should be included in sustainable development. The
term may be ambiguous (Redclift 1992; Daly 1996; Payne and Raiborn 2001). This ambiguity is

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.81 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
reduced into two questions “What should be sustained” and “What should be developed” (Kates et
al. 2008). It is clear that sustainability includes economic prosperity, social equity and
environmental protection. This paper assesses Thailand 4.0 on these bases.

3.1 Data Source
Secondary data were used in this paper. Macroeconomic data used in this paper came from annual
reports of ADB, WEF and IMF. The 20 factors used for sustainability came from the ADB’s
sustainability indicators (ADB 2017). Data on the competitiveness level came from the WEF annual
report (WEF 2017). Other macroeconomic data, such as GDP and Gini coefficient were obtained
from the IMF’s World Economic Outlook annual report (IMF 2017).
The 10 factors used for situation analysis, of how far is Thailand from becoming the First
World Economy, were constructed using the following: competitiveness index, corruption index,
disposable income 1st Economy, GDP gap ratio, Gini, HDI (0.788 threshold), Industrialization,
rural-Urban migration, service sector predominance, and sovereign risk. The ASEAN 10 countries
were used as a bench mark group. Thailand is used as a subject country. The Z score was used as
observed values and the corresponding CDF or  ( z ) was used as the individual probability of each
factor to calculate the Kahnman-Tvertsky index (Kahnman and Tvertsky, 1979). The Kahnman-
Tvertsky U index is used to gauge the current situation of Thailand in comparison to the ideal
condition of the First World Economy. To that end, Singapore is used as a reference country for
being a developed economy in the ASEAN. The Kahnman-Tversky index is obtained by:

U   wi pi xi (1)

where U = probability indicator; w = weight of the factor or 0.10 for each factor, p = probability of
each factor, and x = observed value for each factor. In this case, x  ( k  k ) / s or the standard
score of the observed factor in the ASEAN 10 countries.
To answer the question of whether Thailand has sustainable economy, 20 factors were used.
These 20 factors were based on the ADB’s sustainability of indicators: Gini, pop. Below $1.90/day
(%), pop. Below national poverty line (%), maternal mortality per 100,000, infant mortality per
1,000, death rate due to traffic per 100,000, participating 1 year before primary school %,
proportion of seats held by women in the National Assembly, pop. Access to electricity (%), real
growth % GDP per employed person, commercial banks per 100,000, population covered by
mobile network (%), household expenditure or income growth (%), forest area as % of total land,
per capita gross national income ($), real growth of GDP, real growth of value added to GDP,
domestic investment (% GDP), external debt % of GNI, and fiscal balance (ADB 2017). These 20
factors were categorized into two groups: (i) targeted low value factors, and (ii) targeted high value
factors, see Table 4. The ASEAN 10 countries were used as a bench mark group. For hypothesis
testing, sustainable economy is found where there is a significant low among the targeted low-
valued factors and significantly high among the targeted high-valued factors. If no statistical
significance exists then sustainability is not found.

3.2 Sample size determination

Macroeconomic data, such as GDP, and Gini coefficient were taken from ten years: 2008-2017. The
sample size for the data is determined by log Monte-Carlo simulation approach. The minimum
sample size obtained from Monte-Carlo simulation is given by:

 
n  ln N  2 (2)

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.82 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
where n = minimum sample size, N = Monte Carlo iteration counts and  = level of precision. The
Monte Carlo iteration is determined by:

 3 
N   (3)
 E 

where   [( x   ) / z ] n taken from the components of Monte Carlo three elements:

x1  max, x 2  min and x 3  (max  min) / 2 ; and mid-point of the distribution curve
E  [(max  min) / 2]  50 . This log Monte-Carlo approach yields a minimum sample size of 6.27.
In the present case, macroeconomic data spanning 10 years were used. The number is consistent
with the minimum sample size requirement under Anderson-Darling test for normal distribution
where n  5 (Anderson and Darling, 1952).

3.3 Data Testing

Test of distribution characteristics were employed to determine assess the current situation for
Thailand 4.0 policy status. Firstly, skewness was used to determine the leaning of the data
distribution. A normal distribution has zero skewness. If the threshold value lies above the mean
and median, a positive skew means that the country falls short of the expected value. Secondly,
kurtosis was used to test the peakedness or the extremity of the tail of the data distribution. Excess
kurtosis means that the error spread (tail extremity) is greater than normally expected. In our
analysis, excess kurtosis means that the data falls far away from the expected target. A kurtosis of
less than ±3.00 means that the distribution does not have extremity in its tail. Skewness and kurtosis
were determined by:
n  Xi  X 
S skew  
( n  1)( n  2)  S 

 4 
n  Xi  X  3( n  1)2 
Kurt         3.0 (5)
  ( n  1)( n  2)  S   ( n  2)( n  3) 
  

Table 2: Skewness and kurtosis of  ( z )

Description Skew Kurt Result Result
Skew Kurt
GDP gap ratio 0.42 -3.36 Fail Fail
10 factors FWE 0.01 -2.10 Fail Fail
20* factors sustainability ADB: HI = 12x 1.66 -4.03 Fail Fail
20 factors sustainability ADB: LO = 7x 2.55 -5.40 Fail Fail
*Per capita GDP has been taken out due to extreme values.
Per capita GDP is discussed separately elsewhere.


The paper presents three main findings. First, the GDP gap for Thailand for the past 10 years (2008
– 2017) remains stable. Second, according to the 10 characteristics of the First World Economy,
Thailand scores 0.295 or achieved 29.5% probability of the expected value or succeeded 57.84% in
achieving FWE status. If the threshold is set at 51%, it means that Thailand has 21.5% points to
climb. Third, according to the ADB’s partial indicators for sustainable economy, Thailand still has
not met the standard.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.83 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
4.1 GDP gap as an indication of social inequality
The general indication for economic inequality is given by the Gini coefficient. However, this
number has limited information about the general distribution of income and possible social
inequality in the country. In general, the Gini coefficient is determined by:

n n
 xi  x j
i 1 j 1
G (6)
2n  xi
i 1
where x j = income per person i in a population j . This measure cannot tell the exact amount of
income inequality; it could only tell the lower half of the population that fails to participate in the
income distribution.
In our analysis of the 10 characteristics of FWE, we constructed a new measure called GDP
gap ratio. GDP gap ratio is defined as the ratio of the difference between the reported per capita
GDP and the per capita GDP earned under the country’s minimum wage:
 
GDPgap  Yreport  Ymin / Yreport . This new measure provides two pieces of information: (i) gap
between the reported GDP and actual earning of the common people working at minimum wage,
and (ii) whether the economic well being of the people had been achieved.

Table 3. GDP gap and gap ratio from 2008 - 2017

Year GDP Actual GDP Difference Gap Gini
per capita Min. wage Ratio Coefficient
2008 4,379.53 2,215.22 2,164.31 0.49 0.40
2009 4,207.58 2,129.37 2,078.21 0.49 0.40
2010 5,065.38 2,337.96 2,727.42 0.54 0.39
2011 5,482.40 2,539.37 2,943.03 0.54 0.37
2012 5,850.30 3,476.02 2,374.28 0.41 0.39
2013 6,157.36 3,516.77 2,640.59 0.43 0.41
2014 5,921.09 3,325.12 2,595.96 0.44 0.41
2015 5,799.39 3,153.28 2,646.11 0.46 0.41
2016 5,899.42 3,060.36 2,839.07 0.48 0.41
2017 6,265.29 3,138.045 3,127.25 0.50 0.41

4.2 First World Economy characteristics

The ultimate goal of Thailand 4.0 is to achieve FWE status, thus, a Thai citizen in Thailand 4.0 is a
“First World Citizen.” In this aspect of Thailand 4.0, we ask whether Thailand possesses FWE
characteristics? A negative answer to this question is a foregone conclusion. Thus, if Thailand does
not possess full characteristics of FWE, how far is it from becoming FWE? In answering this
question, we defined the threshold for FWE as having 51% of the characteristic, i.e. predominantly
FWE if the economy manifests more than half of the characteristic found in FWE.
The Prospect Theory by Kahnman-Tvertsky was used to obtain the percentage probability of
FWE characteristic. The Prospect Theory is given by U   wi pi xi . Presently, Thailand has 0.295.
If the threshold for FWE is 0.51, Thailand has 0.215 points to climb.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.84 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Table 4. First World Economy Indicators
Characteristics of Developed Thailand Expected Prob. U Index
Economy: each weight 0.10 X obs X pi Ui
Competitiveness Index 4.64 4.60 0.5320 0.004
Corruption index 101.00 92.30 0.5750 0.011
Disposable income FWE 5,720 12,000 0.2266 (0.008)
GAP gap ratio 0.49 0.48 0.5990 0.015
Gini 0.39 0.36 0.6030 0.016
HDI (0.788 threshold) 0.74 0.79 0.3264 (0.012)
Industrialization 0.36 0.51 0.2266 (0.015)
Rural-Urban migration 12,272 3,168.01 0.9930 0.246
Service sector predominance 0.55 0.51 0.5710 0.010
Sovereign risk 0.63 0.50 0.6630 0.028
Total U index under Kahnman-Tvertsky: U   wi pi xi 0.295

4.3 Sustainable economy as development goal

The development goal for the 21st Century is no longer confined to economic growth. The growth
has to be sustainable. In order to be sustainable, the economy must contribute to value additivity in
people’s lives. The ADB has produced 50 indicators as relevant factors for sustainability. We
selected 20 factors and used them to test whether Thailand’s economy is currently sustainable? If
not, how much does it need to improve?
The 20 factors are categorized into low and high targeted values. Low values are those that
in order to optimize, the value must be minimal. There are 7 such factors listed in Table 5. The
result of the testing shows that Thailand has two significant factors: Gini coefficient and death due
to traffic accident. These two factors made Thailand failing the first category of sustainable
economy. For low-value targets, Thailand achieved 0.66 while Singapore achieved 0.94. If the
threshold is set at 0.80 under 80/20 rule, then Thailand has 0.14 points to climb.

Table 5: Low target for sustainability indicators

ADF Sustainable Economy Thailand Singapore pValue*
Indicator: 7 factors = the lower the better ( Z ) *  ( Z ) ** 1  ( z)
Gini coefficient 0.709 0.074 0.03
Pop. Below $1.90/day (%) 0.227 0.227 0.50
Pop. Below national poverty line (%) 0.440 0.106 0.16
Maternal mortality per 100,000 0.147 0.106 0.45
Infant mortality per 1,000 0.258 0.106 0.33
Death rate due to traffic per 100,000 0.977 0.061 0.00
External debt % of GNI 0.363 0.997 0.98
*The ASEAN 10 countries were used to obtain Thailand’s CDF.
**Singapore is a First World Economy in the ASEAN. Singapore is used as a threshold value.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goals
Accessed May 30, 2017.

The second prong of sustainability consists of 12 factors of the ADB indicators for
economic sustainability. Table 6 lists these high-value targets. Using Singapore as a reference
developed economy in the ASEAN group, Thailand failed 9 out of 12 indicators for sustainability.
The achievement of sustainability is determined by: 1  U where U   wi pi xi . Thailand achieved
0.71 while Singapore achieved 0.78. If the threshold is set at 0.80 under 80/20, then Thailand has
0.09 points to climb. Note that under 80/20 threshold, Singapore also failed in sustainability test.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.85 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Table 6: High target for sustainability indicators
ADF Sustainable Economy Thailand Singapore pValue*
Indicator: 7 factors = the lower the better ( Z ) *  ( Z ) ** 1  ( z )
Participating 1 year before primary school % 0.9330 0.2266 0.08
Proportion of seats held by women in NA 0.2578 0.4404 0.00
Pop. Access to electricity (%) 0.9550 0.9550 0.03
Real growth % GDP per employed person 0.2266 0.2266 0.03
Commercial banks per 100,000 0.2266 0.2266 0.03
Population covered by mobile network (%) 0.9480 0.9550 0.03
Household expenditure or income growth (%) 0.2578 0.2266 0.05
Forest area as % of total land 0.5240 0.3632 0.13
Real growth of GDP 0.2578 0.2266 0.05
Real growth of value added to GDP 0.2266 0.1977 0.04
Domestic investment (% GDP) 0.4013 0.4404 0.80
Fiscal balance 0.1977 0.2266 0.03
*The ASEAN 10 countries were used to obtain Thailand’s CDF.
**Singapore is a First World Economy in the ASEAN. Singapore is used as a threshold value.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goals
Accessed May 30, 2017.

Thailand 4.0 is a development blue print for Thailand with 20 years horizon to achieve its targets.
The objective of Thailand 4.0 is to achieve economic prosperity, social well-being, human values
and environmental protection. The ultimate goal of Thailand 4.0 is for Thailand to achieve a status
of First World Economy. To that end, this paper presented two research questions: (i) Does
Thailand have characteristics of a developed economy? and (ii) Does Thailand have sustainable
economy? Our analysis showed that there are many hurdles Thailand needs to overcome in order to
attain World First Economy status and the current economy still fall short of sustainability
expectation. For the time being, Thailand 4.0 is a road map to reach a goal. This paper provides a
situation analysis to help Thailand see where is now stands in the cross-road between being a
developing economy and becoming a developed economy.

Aghion, P., & Howitt, P. (1992). “A model of growth through creative destruction.” Econometrica,
60(2), 323–351.
Anderson, T. W.; Darling, D. A. (1952). “Asymptotic theory of certain ‘goodness-of-fit’ criteria
based on stochastic processes.” Annals of Mathematical Statistics. 23: 193–212.
Bauer, P. T. (1984). Reality and rhetoric: Studies in the economics of development. London:
Weidenfield & Nicolson.
Basu, K. (2000). “On the goals of development.” In G. M. Meier & J. E. Stiglitz (Eds.), Frontiers of
development economics: The future in perspective (pp. 61–86). Washington, D.C.: World Bank
and Oxford University Press.
Berenger, V., & Verdier-Chouchane, A. (2007). “Multidimensional measures of well-being:
Standard of living and quality of life across countries.” World Development, 35(7), 1259–1276.
Chenery, H. B. (1960). “Patterns of industrial growth.” The American Economic Review, 50(4),
Cornwall, J., & Cornwall, W. (1994). “Growth theory and economic structure.” Economica,
61(242), 237–251.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.86 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371
Daly, H. E. (1996). Beyond growth: The economics of sustainable development. Boston: Beacon
Domar, E. D. (1947). “Expansion and employment.” The American Economic Review, 37(1), 34–
Dos Santos, T. (1973). “The crisis of development theory and the problem of dependence in Latin
America.” In H. Bernstein (Ed.), Underdevelopment and development: The third world today:
Selected readings (pp. 57–80). Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Harrod, R. F. (1948). Towards a dynamic economics, some recent developments of economic

theory and their application to policy. London: Macmillan.
Jaffee, D. (1998). Levels of socio-economic development theory (2nd ed.). Westport, Connecticut:
Praeger Publishers.
Johnson, H. (1971). “A word to the third world: A Western economist’s frank advice.” Encounter,
37, 3–10.
Kahneman, Daniel; Tversky, Amos (1979). “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under
Risk.” Econometrica, 47(2): 263. doi:10.2307/1914185. ISSN 0012-9682.
Kates, R. W., Parris, T. M., & Leiserowitz, A. A. (2008). “What is sustainable development? Goals,
indicators, values, and practice.” In G. Secondi (Ed.), The development economics reader (pp.
367–387). London: Routledge.
Lal, D. (1983). The poverty of “development economics”. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.
Lewis, W. A. (1954). “Economic development with unlimited supplies of labour.” The Manchester
School, 22(2), 139–191.
Little, I. M. D. (1982). Economic development: Theory, policy, and international relations. New
York: Basic Books.
Lucas, R. E. (1988). “On the mechanics of economic development.” Journal of Monetary
Economics, 22(1), 3–42.
Meier, G. M. (2000). “The old generation of development economists and the new.” In G. M. Meier
& J. E. Stiglitz (Eds.), Frontiers of development economics: The future in perspective (pp. 13–
50). Washington, D.C.: World Bank/Oxford University Press.
Payne, D. M., & Raiborn, C. A. (2001). “Sustainable development: The ethics support the
economics.” Journal of Business Ethics, 32(2), 157–168.
Pearce, D. W., & Turner, R. K. (1990). Economics of natural resources and the environment. New
York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Redclift, M. (1992). “The meaning of sustainable development.” Geoforum, 23(3), 395–403.
Roemer, J. E. (1988). Free to lose. Cambridge, M.A.: Harvard University Press.
Rostow, W. W. (1960). The stages of economic growth: A non-communist manifesto. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Sen, A. (1985). Commodities and capabilities. Amsterdam: North Holland.
Sen, A. (1992). Inequality re-examined. Oxford: Clarendon.
Sen, A. (1999). Development as freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Solow, R. M. (1956). “A contribution to the theory of economic growth.” The Quarterly Journal of
Economics, 70(1), 65.
Skott, P., & Auerbach, P. (1995). “Cumulative causation and the “new” theories of economic
growth.” Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 17(3), 381–402.
Stiglitz, J. (1998). “More instruments and broader goals: Moving toward the post-Washington
consensus.” Helsinki: Wider Annual Lecture United Nations University—World Institute for
Development Economics Research.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2003). Economic development (8th ed.). Boston: Addison Wesley.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2009). Economic development (10th ed.). Boston: Addison Wesley.

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.87 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371

© 2016, 2017 International Journal of Research and Methodology in Social Science. This work
may be reproduced and redistributed, in whole or in part, without alteration and without prior
written permission, solely by educational institutions for nonprofit administrative or educational
purposes provided all copies contain the following statement: “© 2016, 2017 International Journal
of Research and Methodology in Social Science University of Maryland. This work is reproduced
and distributed with the permission of the International Journal of Research and Methodology in
Social Science. No other use is permitted without the express prior written permission of the
International Journal of Research and Methodology in Social Science. For permission, contact:

“17 U.S. Code § 107 - Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair Use

Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted
work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other
means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news
reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or
research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a
work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include—
(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial
nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
(2) the nature of the copyrighted work;
(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work
as a whole; and
(4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
The fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such
finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors. See Pub. L. 94–553, title I,
§ 101, Oct. 19, 1976, 90 Stat. 2546; Pub. L. 101–650, title VI, § 607, Dec. 1, 1990, 104
Stat. 5132; Pub. L. 102–492, Oct. 24, 1992, 106 Stat. 3145.”

In case where an error escapes the review process or is discovered after the publication has already
been released, IJRMSS will contact the author for written comments and/or correction, and the
journal will publish the correction in the errata section in the subsequent issue no later than 2
publication cycles after the error has been discover. Errata will be published when the error is
material and may mislead or misrepresent facts. Minor error, such as typographical error or unless it
involves mathematical formula, does not compel errata publication.

IJRMSS maintains strict policy on originality of works and proper credit given to prior sources. We
employ computer software to check for work originality. The article found more than 10%
similarity with prior works will be automatically rejected for cause and no invitation for
resubmission would be issued. Originality check does not count instances of citation and repeated
citation of names, titles, and/or sentences and paragraphs in quotation or in-text quotation when
proper quotation marks are used.
The opinions expressed in each article are those of the individual author(s). Specific questions about
the article should be directed to the corresponding author(s). The contact information of the
corresponding author is listed in the footnote on the first page of the article marked with a star: .
IJRMSS has editorial discretion to decline articles that are demeaning or disrespectful or otherwise
intended to cause public outcry in matters of race, national origin, religion, ethnicity, and/or sexual
orientation where public sensitivity outweighs the academic value of the proposed article(s).

International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.88 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371


VOL. 3, NO. 2 APR - JUN, 2017 QUARTERLY JOURNAL ISSN 2415-0371

Berlin Declaration of Open Access to Knowledge in the Science and Humanities

Budapest Open Access Initiatives
The Cape Town Open Education Declaration


ISSN 2415 – 0371


420 Bourichane Rd., Unit 1 Ban Naxay 55 / 123 Rangsit-Nakhon Nayok Rd.
Xayasetha, Vientiane, LAOS T. Lamlookka, A. Thanyaburi
Tel. +856 21 263585 Pathumtanee, THAILAND
Email: EditorIJRMSS@gmail.com Email: EditorIJRMSS@gmail.com


International Journal of Research & Methodology in Social Science
Vol. 3, No. 2, p.89 (April – June 2017). ISSN 2415-0371