Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 4

Select a page 

Home Resources Articles About Us Site Map Contact Us Privacy Policy 

How is Working Stress Method (ASD) different from Limit state method
(LRFD or LFD)? Assumptions, Advantages and comparisons

How is Working Stress Method (ASD) different from Limit state method (LRFD or LFD)?
Assumptions, Advantages and Comparisons
Limit state method (LRFD or LFD)
“A limit state is a condition beyond which a structural system or a structural component ceases to fulfill the function for which

Various limit states are


Design and Build Construction Causes of Stress

Structural Design Method

Strength limit states: With respect to strength in shear, flexure, torsion, fatigue, bearing, settlement, bond or combined effects.

Serviceability limit states: With respect to deflection & cracking. The appearance, durability and performance of the structure must not be affected by deflection
& cracking, buckling, stability

Special limit states: Damage or collapse in extreme earthquakes. Structural effects of fire, explosions, or vehicular collisions.

Design Assumptions and advantages of Limit state method

1. Partial safety factor for material (γm) for yield and ultimate stress.
2. Working loads are factored (increased) as per partial safely factor (γf) causing Limit State of strength.
3. The design strength is calculated dividing the characteristic strength further by the partial safety factor for the material (γm), where γm depends on the
material and the limit state being considered.
4. Post buckling and post yielding plays important role in estimating capacity of structural elements at Limit State.
5. Deformations are evaluated at working loads.
6. This is based on the behavior of structure at different limit states ensuring adequate safety against each limitation.
7. Tensile strength carried by of concrete is zero.
8. The stress block represents in a more realistic manner when the structure is at the collapsing stage (limit state of collapse) subjected to design loads.
9. Does not obey Hook`s law
10. It consider the variability not only in resistance but also in the effects of load. Concept of separate partial safety factors of loads of different combinations in
the two limit state methods.
11. Concept of separate partial safety factors of materials depending on their quality control during preparation. Thus, γm for concrete is 1.5 and the same for
steel is 1.15. This is more logical than one arbitrary value in the name of safety factor.
12. A structure designed by employing limit state method of collapse and checked for other limit states will ensure the strength and stability requirements at the
collapse under the design loads and also deflection and cracking at the limit state of serviceability. This will help to achieve the structure with acceptable
probabilities that the structure will not become unfit for the use for which it is intended.

Working stress method

1. Since the specifications set limit on the stresses, it became working stress method
2. Factor of safely for yield stress, allowable stresses are less than ‘fy’.
3. Pure elastic approach for analysis of structures under working loads.
4. Yielding or buckling never occurs at working loads
5. This method is based on the condition that the stresses caused by service loads without load factors are not to exceed the allowable stresses which are
taken as a fraction of the ultimate stresses of the materials, fc’ for concrete and fy for steel.
6. It deals only with elastic behavior of member perfectly elastic at all stages of loading; Stress-strain relations obey Hooks law (linear)
working stress method

1. Tensile stresses are taken by steel only.

2. The Modular ratio is well defined value independent of time which is not true
3. Results in larger compression steel percentage
4. Working stress method does not give reasonable measure of strength, which is more fundamental measure of resistance than is allowable stress.
5. Another drawback in working stress method is that safety is applied only to stress level. Loads are considered to be deterministic (without variation). For
example, Permissible bending & direct compression are as fraction of crushing strength.

Start Download 3 Major Design Download PDF Septic Tank and Soak
Philosophies: Working Pit - Domestic sewage
Stress, Ultimate Load... treatment systems

Ad pdf-convert.co civildigital.com Ad ProPDFConverter civildigital.com

Start Download - View Bridge Engineering - Ground Improvement Pavement Design in

PDF Classification of Bridges with Sand Compaction Road Construction -
| CivilDigital | Piles | Advantages |... Design Parameters |...

Ad EasyPDFCombine civildigital.com civildigital.com civildigital.com

Posted by Anand Paul

July 28, 2015

Tags: advantages of limit state, allowable stress design, allowable stress method, difference between working stress and limit state, limit state, limit state design,
types of limit states, working stress, working stress design
Share: 223 3 Google + 1 10 0   1
 Design of Steel Structures Part 4 – Quiz and Interview Questions Plastic modulus and shape factors – Quiz and Interview Questions 


Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beam (RC Beam) | Methods

Ground Improvement with Sand Compaction Piles | Advantages
Retaining Wall | Types of Retaining Walls | Design Considerations
Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) & Portland Pozzolana Cement (PPC) | Differences
Field Tests for Cement | Check the Quality Cement at Site
Important points for a Civil Site Engineer | Civil Site Engineer Job Tips
Effects of Corrosion in Reinforcement | Signs & Preventive Measures
Blasting Technique for Ground Improvement
What are Grit chambers | Classification & Disposal of Grit | Skimming Tanks
One way Slabs & Two way Slabs | Spanning of Slabs | One way & Two way Action

Related Posts

3 Major Design Philosophies: Working Stress, Ultimate Load and Limit State
Failure modes in beams | Types of Failure in Reinforced Concrete Beams
Buckling of Columns – Euler Theory for Elastic Buckling
Shear Wall | Functions & Loads Transfer Mechanism | Design Example of Shear Wall
How to Prepare Civil Engineering Project Report | Steps | Contents Required
View Inventory View Details


1 How is Working Stress Method (ASD) different from Limit state method (LRFD or LFD)? Assumptions, Advantages and Comparisons
1.1 Limit state method (LRFD or LFD)
1.1.1 Design Assumptions and advantages of Limit state method
2 Working stress method

Goto Top 
©2018 CivilDigital.com · Built by CivilDigital · Powered by WordPress

Free Download of Thermal Analysis of Polymers Handb

1 Polymers Handbook - Thermal Analysis Applications mt.com/TA/Polymers

2 Start Your Free Trial Digital Solutions That Create A More Productive & Engaged Workforce. Learn More. igloosoftware.co