Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
If you would like a digital copy of this program, please e-mail your request to
justicedebateleague@gmail.com.
Agenda
All opinions, statements, materials and ideas expressed in this
forum are those of the participants and do not and are not intended
to reflect the views of the Illinois Department of Corrections.
Welcome
9
Opening Remarks
Opening Remarks
9
10
Debate
9:30 Debate
10:30
Resolution: The state of Illinois should establish a parole
board to evaluate for release all current and future Resolution: The state of Illinois should establish a parole system to
incarcerated people. evaluate for release all current and future incarcerated people.
Government Opposition
Government Opposition
Prime Leader of
Al Ameen Louie
Minister Opposition Leader of
Prime Minister Eugene Luigi
Opposition
Deputy
Deputy Prime
Howard Leader of Tall Mike
Minister Deputy Prime Deputy Leader
Opposition Howard Michael
Minister of Opposition
Member of Member of
Mike Raúl
Government Opposition Member of Member of
Mike Raúl
Government Opposition
Government Opposition
Raheem Tony
Whip Whip Government Opposition
Richard Alfred
Whip Whip
Q&A
Meet and Greet
12
11:30
Meet and Greet
Optional Tour 12:30
Optional Tour
Team Member Bios Michael*
Complete bios for each team member can be made available upon request. Bios here are My name is Michael Sullivan, I’m 46 years old. I have been incarcerated since I was 21
abridged. years old. I am a father of 4 children and a grandfather of 7. My parents are still alive and
have supported me throughout this ordeal. I also have a supportive fiancée. I am an
Luigi artistic painter and animator as well as a writer. I have illustrated a children’s book for my
.
I am 36 years old, and am currently serving a 38-year sentence for 1st degree murder, of think tank class here at Stateville. I am also currently writing two books. The first is a
which I have already served about 10 years. I am originally from the northwest suburbs of children’s book titled “THE TOOLS OF CHESS: The Cognitive Developmental Process.” The
Chicago. The most important things in my life are my faith and my family. Before my second is “The Restoration of Justice.” It is similar to a dissertation and is based on a
incarceration in late December of 2007, I was president of a property management firm, as restorative justice class I attended here at Stateville.
.
well as an owner/operator of various other small businesses all around Chicagoland. I am Lastly, I want to state that I believe that Illinois should bring back the parole board because
an avid reader, natural problem solver and critical thinker. you’ll discover that a second chance for many will be morally right, and you’ll see that many
.
Since my conviction, I have become dedicated to self-betterment learning as much as I can of us, like myself, will be an asset to our society.
about whatever subjects I can get my hands on. As of this writing, I have earned 137 Tall Mike was incarcerated at age 22 in 1992 and he is ineligible for parole.
certificates or diplomas from classes, courses, or seminars I have taken while incarcerated. ~Michael Sullivan B67920
I have also become a certified paralegal from the Black Stone Career Institute and have
earned an associate’s degree in theology from Calvary Christian College in South Bend, IN,
with a bachelor degree in the same forthcoming in January of 2018. Eugene*
.
I am fairly conservative in my beliefs and opinions, and I try to view all issues through the Eugene is one of Illinois’ juvenile lifers. He has been incarcerated for the last 21 years.
.
lens of my faith in the Messiah Yeshua Ben Elohim. Eugene was hand-selected by his peers – being one out of 1,300 others (for only 12
available seats) chosen to represent Stateville’s debate team; being one of the prison’s
Louie was incarcerated at age 26, though he was 19 years old when the crime was
“best and brightest”. This is one of many accomplishments he has had while incarcerated.
committed, and his release is set for 2045 at age 64.
He has completed multiple classes and programs, contributed to children’s books,
~Luigi Adamo R74391
dedicated himself to mentoring youth, and spearheaded a “My Life Matters” letter writing
campaign among fellow prisoners which resulted in an event at DePaul University and a
Richard* national invitation to a restorative justice conference held in Pittsburg, Pennsylvania. The
I am Richard Morris, 43 years old. I’ve been incarcerated for 22 years. work was presented there to a national restorative justice and educational panel.
.
.
I was wrongfully convicted of first degree murder, aggravated kidnapping and aggravated Eugene’s impeccable leadership and communication skills were on full display as he
vehicular hijacking for which I was sentenced to death. That sentence was commuted by coached his team to a championship in comeback fashion in the prison’s inaugural March
Governor George Ryan. In 2004, the Illinois Supreme Court overturned my conviction and Madness basketball tournament.
.
granted me a new trial due to ineffective assistance of counsel. In addition to these involvements, Eugene is a Muslim by faith and is very active in the
.
Unfortunately, I was once again convicted and given a sentence which I am appealing. prison’s Islamic community. He leads the weekly Friday prayer service, gives weekly
. lectures, and teaches both Islamic studies and Arabic. His nickname “Al Ameen” comes
I would like to be seen as someone worthy of the time and effort that goes into the type of from Arabic and means “truthful and trustworthy”.
assistance I am hoping for.
Eugene was incarcerated at age 20 in 1997 and he is ineligible for parole.
Raheem was incarcerated at age 21. He was originally on death row, but his release is ~ Eugene Ross K73977
now set for 2048 at age 75.
~Richard Morris B65709
Raúl* and bread. It was in the hornets, while loading into my mother’s friend’s minivan, getting
ready to go to church, that I first saw someone get shot multiple times at point-blank
Raúl Dorado is an incarcerated student and author. He is serving a life without parole range.
sentence under the legal theory of accountability. He is working towards a bachelor’s .
degree from the University Without Walls sponsored by Northeastern Illinois University. He Church was a regular in my family. After the passing of my grandfather in ’86, my
has published poetry, essays and articles including, “In Mind’s Eye,” “The Skiff,” “The grandmother, Ollie Mae Simmons, became an ordained minister with her apartment serving
Presumption of Justice: Capitalism and Alchemists” and “Plea Bargains: A Fair Deal or Fair as her church. My mom would take us to live with grandma when we couldn’t afford rent
Game.” which was quite often.
.
Raúl was incarcerated at age 19 in 1998 and he is ineligible for parole. My brother Darryl got involved with the gang crowd in middle school. He would have his
~ Raúl Dorado K53842 friends over while mom worked, which was basically all of the time. They would drink and
smoke and listen to rap music. I was fascinated with the name-brand clothes, gold chains,
and Michael Jordan shoes. Oh yeah, and the cars they drove. I wanted to be just like
Howard them.
.
Howard Keller was a former high school drop-out and alcohol abuser who turned his life It wasn’t long before I started getting into trouble myself. I was in the sixth grade when I
completely around. Today he is a GED and vocational tutor, published writer, poet, and first joined the gang. I didn’t have to go through the so-called ritual of taking an oath like
advocate for higher education in prison. He is also a barber by trade. A staunch believer most gangs did. Because my brother was respected, I was welcomed right on in. I always
in the transformative power of education, Howard uses the barbering platform to engage knew that, deep inside, the person I knew I was on the inside never fit the gang-banging
others in critical dialogue about the importance of education, and to provide valued one- lifestyle that I was living, yet it was hard for me to remove the mask that allowed me to be
on-one tutoring to men with unique learning needs. accepted.
.
.
Howard is currently a visiting student of North Park Theological Seminary. His hope is to I can go forever long about the things that I’ve experienced, things that have left me
become a full-time student there, complete an M.A. in Christian Ministry, and one day work wondering how or why I am still alive today. Not only alive, but so much better and wiser
with organizations that provide counseling and assistance to young people with alcohol than I knew I was capable of being. I’ve been in prison for nearly sixteen years, convicted
addictions. of armed robbery, and murder under accountability theory.
. .
Howard is a positive force both inside and outside of the prison system. His compassion The son of the victim in my case who, like myself, lost his dad to a senseless act at such a
and desire to serve others is what makes him a great leader. young age, and his mother, Mrs. McKinley, have all had the most profound impact on my
Howard was incarcerated at age 21, and his release is set for 2055 at age 77. life. Mrs. McKinley, in her victim impact statement, at what had to be one of the most
~ Howard Keller K67292 difficult times in her life, stated that she hoped that I would someday make my life count for
something. They, along with my family support, for which I am grateful, have been and
continue to be the strength of my resolve to do everything in my power to honor the victim
Mike* in my case and his family. I believe that the things that I’ve been through will somehow
My name is Michael Simmons. I have three siblings, two older brothers and a younger serve a greater cause and this allows me to remain hopeful and able to have a peace of
sister. My earliest memory as a child was being told that my dad had been shot and killed. mind and continue to push for greatness even when my circumstance begs otherwise.
I was 6 ½ years old. Unfortunately for me, my aunt did not possess any tact in informing
me of the bad news. “That damn prostitute got yo daddy shot in the head,” she told me. Mike was incarcerated at age 24, and his release is set for 2052 at age 74.
.
Growing up, we were often on the move as my mother struggled to keep a roof over our
~ Michael Simmons K58311
heads. At one point, we lived in the Henry Hornet projects on Chicago’s west side. The
hornets was probably one of the worst places to live in the city. It was like a super over-
crowded prison where there was constant battle between the mice and roaches for space
.
Joe* Oscar was 18 years old when his crime occurred. He has served 28 years of a mandatory
Joseph Dole has won numerous awards for his writing, including most recently a first-place natural life sentence for guilt by association, under the theory of accountability. Since he
aware in the 2017 Columbia Journal Writing Contest. He is the author of the books “A has been incarcerated, he has striven to better himself even though the natural life
Costly American Hatred” and “Control Units and Supermaxes: A National Security Threat”. sentence took away all incentive to do so. From the beginning, he has taken every class
He has been published in a number of academic journals, including the Mississippi review, that has been available to him.
.
The Columbia Journal, The Journal of Ethical Urban Living, and the Journal Justice Power, Oscar also became a man of faith while in Menard. His faith is a major part of who he is.
and Resistance, as well as in numerous other print media and online. More of his work is .
available at his facebook page, https://www.facebook.com/JosephDoleIncarceratedWriter/. During a class that Oscar took with Professor Jennifer Lackey of Northwestern University on
He is currently serving a life-without-parole sentence at Stateville Correctional Center. He Mass Incarceration, he was one of five students chosen to have an article he wrote
spent nearly a decade of his life in isolation at the notorious Tamms Supermax Prison. published by the New Yorker. During the mass incarceration class, Oscar also met U.S.
Recently, he was granted a scholarship by the Davis-Putter Scholarship Fund in recognition Congresswoman Jan Schakowsky who wrote an op-ed in the Chicago Sun Times titled,
of his activism. “Natural Life for Young Offenders is Indefensible”. In this op-ed Mrs. Schakowsky makes
mention of the atrocity of Oscar being given a natural life sentence after being offered an
Joe was incarcerated at age 22 and is ineligible for parole. unconditional eleven-year plea. Had Smiley taken the eleven-year plea, he would have
~Joseph Dole K84446 served 50% of his time and been home in 1995.
Oscar was incarcerated at age 20 and is ineligible for parole.
Les ~Oscar Parham N95863
Born in 1980 in the ghettos of Chicago, Les grew up with five brothers. As his dad carried Benard
the burden of child support for his three half-sisters, their family always struggled
financially, which contributed to his having moved five times, transferring schools eight Hello, my name is Benard McKinley. I’m 32 years old. I presently reside at Stateville
times, dropping out of school and leaving home all by age 14. The gang he entered Correctional Center. I was born and raised on the west side of Chicago. At the age of 16
trained him to sell crack cocaine and heroin, and excessively abuse marijuana and alcohol. years I was charged with first degree murder. I was later convicted and sentenced to 100
Over the next two years, he had a number of encounters with Chicago police officers in years in the Department of Corrections. While incarcerated, I dedicated my time as a
which he was threatened, assaulted, and physically and emotionally abused. At age 16, he motivational speaker to the incarcerated youth. Since my incarceration, I have become a
was arrested as a juvenile, and was subsequently incarcerated twice more for parole paralegal and a proud member of the National Lawyers Guild.
.
violations. He was on parole for 5 months before his fourth and final arrest, and has now In January 2016, the Federal 7th Circuit Appellate Court ruled that my sentence was a de
been in prison continuously since age 19. Since his incarceration, he has committed facto life sentence. Since that decision, I have been back in state court, and in the process
himself to self-improvement through the rigorous pursuit of faith and education. He wants of having my time vacated and resentenced in light of the US Supreme Court Miller case
to become the best man he possibly can for God and every person who is connected to his decision.
life. .
*Note: All team members who are convicted under accountability theory are denoted with Mandatory Supervised Release (MSR)
an asterisk. This means that though everyone on this team is convicted as a “violent MSR in Illinois operates like parole does in other states. The difference is that it happens
offender”, these men did not commit any acts of violence. after the completion of the legally-mandated prison sentence. Under MSR, people remain
under the legal custody of the IDOC, subject to being retaken at any time. This occurs
Article 1 Section 2 of the Illinois Constitution during the first period of an individual’s freedom.
Due Process and Equal Protection
“No person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law nor be Overcrowding
denied the equal protection of the laws.” To fill beyond what is usual or comfortable. In the Illinois prison system, this would mean
exceeding their residential capacity of approximately 28,000. On August 31, 2017, the
Article 1 Section 11 IDOC reported a residential population of 42,654. At 151%, this makes Illinois prisons #1
Limitation of Penalties After Conviction in the US for overcrowding.
“All penalties shall be determined both according to the seriousness of the offense and Even so, this is a notable improvement from 1993 when Illinois prisons were built to house
with the objective of restoring the offender to useful citizenship. No conviction shall work 16,000 inmates, yet had a population of 32,000.
corruption of blood or forfeiture of estate. No person shall be transported out of the State
for an offense committed within the State.” Parole
The release of a prisoner before the completion of a sentence on the promise of good
Article 1 Section 12 behavior.
Right to Remedy and Justice
“Every person shall find a certain remedy in the laws for all injuries and wrongs which he Parole Board
receives to his person, privacy, property or reputation. He shall obtain justice by law, freely, A panel of appointed members who decide whether an offender should be released from
completely, and promptly.” prison on parole after serving at least a minimum portion of their sentence.
Recidivism
The tendency of a convicted criminal to reoffend. Some also “recidivate” not by re-
offending, but by violating terms of parole or probation.
agency
also
works
to
ensure
the
criminal
justice
system
in
Illinois
is
Prisoner
Review
Board
efficient
and
effective.
http://www.icjia.state.il.us
The
Illinois
Prisoner
Review
Board
(PRB)
is
a
separate
entity
from
the
Illinois
Department
of
Corrections.
The
PRB
is
an
independent
Illinois
Department
of
Corrections
body
whose
members
are
appointed
by
the
Governor
of
Illinois.
The
"The
mission
of
the
Department
of
Corrections
is
to
protect
the
PRB
imposes
release
conditions
for
offenders
exiting
penal
facilities,
public
from
criminal
offenders
through
a
system
of
incarceration
revokes
and
restores
good
conduct
credits
from
inmates,
conducts
and
supervision
which
securely
segregates
offenders
from
society,
hearings
to
determine
whether
parolees
have
violated
conditions
of
assures
offenders
of
their
constitutional
rights
and
maintains
parole,
and
awards
certificates
of
Relief
from
Disabilities
and
programs
to
enhance
the
success
of
offenders'
reentry
into
society."
Certificates
of
Good
Conduct.
The
PRB
notifies
victims
and
their
https://www.illinois.gov/idoc/aboutus/Pages/IllinoisDepartmentofC families
when
an
inmate
is
about
to
be
released
from
custody.
The
orrectionsMissionStatement.aspx
Board
also
makes
confidential
recommendations
to
the
Governor
relative
to
executive
clemency
petitions.
Illinois
Sentencing
Policy
Advisory
Council
(SPAC)
https://www.illinois.gov/idoc/parole/Pages/PrisonerReviewBoard.a
SPAC
was
created
to
collect,
analyze
and
present
data
from
all
spx
relevant
sources
to
more
accurately
determine
the
consequences
of
sentencing
policy
decisions
and
to
review
the
effectiveness
and
Restore
Justice
Illinois
efficiency
of
current
sentencing
policies
and
practices.
SPAC
reports
RJI
believes
in
the
possibility
of
rehabilitation,
redemption,
and
directly
to
the
Governor
and
the
General
Assembly.
reunification
with
the
community
for
all
incarcerated
people,
even
http://www.icjia.state.il.us/spac/index.cfm?metasection=about&m those
who
have
committed
the
most
serious
crimes.
It
is
a
civic
etapage=frontpage
organization
founded
to
mitigate
the
human
and
fiscal
impact
of
the
extreme
sentencing
laws
of
the
1980s
and
1990s,
particularly
where
IL
Commission
on
Criminal
Justice
and
Sentencing
Reform
they
have
impacted
children.
Governor
Rauner
established
the
Commission
in
order
to
develop
a
https://restorejusticeillinois.org
comprehensive,
evidence-‐based
strategy
to
meet
the
goal
of
reducing
Illinois’
prison
population
25%
by
2025.
There
are
also
a
number
of
national
organizations
focused
on
criminal
http://www.icjia.org/cjreform2015/index.html
justice
reform.
If
you
are
interested
in
a
specific
topic
–
please
ask
where
you
can
find
info!
Sources
Cited
During
the
Event
“Issues and Solutions” Restore Justice Illinois, 2016.
https://restorejustice.org/issues-solutions/
“As Arrest Records Rise, Americans Find Consequences Can
Memorandum: From Samantha Gaddy, To Kathy Saltmarsh.
Last a Lifetime” Wall Street Journal, August 18, 2014.
RE: Truth in Sentencing, August 20, 2013.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/as-arrest-records-rise-americans-
find-consequences-can-last-a-lifetime-1408415402
“Offender Risk Assessment in Virginia” National Institute of
Justice, 2002. http://www.vcsc.virginia.gov/risk_off_rpt.pdf
Illinois Department of Corrections Reports & Statistics
https://www.illinois.gov/idoc/reportsandstatistics/Pages/Depart
“Preliminary Findings Concerning the Financial Costs of
mentData.aspx
Implementing Illinois’ Truth-In-Sentencing Laws” Joseph Dole,
January 11, 2011.
“Illinois House Approves State Budget” Associated Press, July http://realcostofprisons.org/materials/dole-preliminary-
7, 2017. findings.pdf
https://www.apnews.com/3d9b53bd21aa474cbf2deed03b885c
6f “Sentencing by a Parole Board: An Evaluation” Northwestern
University, 1976.
“Illinois Prison Overview” Illinois State Commission on Criminal http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent
Justice and Sentencing Reform, 2016. .cgi?article=5965&context=jclc
http://www.icjia.org/cjreform2015/research/illinois-prison-
overview.html “The Irrationality of Natural Life Sentences” Dr. Jennifer
Lackey, Northwestern University, New York Times, February
“Illinois Prisoner Review Board 39th Annual Report” 1, 2016. https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/02/01/the-
https://www2.illinois.gov/sites/prb/Documents/prb15anlrpt.pdf irrationality-of-natural-life-sentences/
“Illinois State Budget Fiscal Year 2018” Bruce Rauner, “The Price of Prisons: What Incarceration Costs Taxpayers”
February 15, 2017. Vera Institute of Justice, January 2012.
https://www.illinois.gov/gov/budget/Documents/Budget%20Bo https://storage.googleapis.com/vera-web-
ok/FY2018%20Budget%20Book/FY2018OperatingBudgetBoo assets/downloads/Publications/price-of-prisons-what-
k.pdf incarceration-costs-taxpayers/legacy_downloads/the-price-of-
prisons-40-fact-sheets-updated-072012.pdf
“Illinois State Commission on Criminal Justice and Sentencing
Reform: Final Report” December 2016.
http://www.icjia.org/cjreform2015/pdf/CJSR_Final_Report_Dec
_2016.pdf