Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Recruiting
Harris (1991) reports how recession during the 1970s and 1980s contributed to
selection preferences in Britain favouring younger applicants. The Australian
experience has been similar and the difficulty faced by older staff wanting to
change jobs or, once they lose their job, to be re-employed is well documented.
ABS statistics in 1993 show an increasing length of time between jobs for each
succeeding age cohort – 27.6 weeks at age 15-19 years, rising to 106.2 weeks at
age 60-64 years. Though legislation now in place in most Australian states
prevents any reference to age, gender or associated characteristics for job
applicants, most present day recruiting practices are still biased towards the
younger person.
The research of Steinberg et al. (1994) indicated that many Australian em-
ployers are as reluctant to hire those over 45 years as employers in Europe.
Older workers are credited with possession of fewer key productivity related
skills than younger counterparts. Partly in response to this situation, the 1980s
experienced a growth in data banks of older staff seeking work, e.g. DOME
(Don’t Overlook Mature Expertise) in South Australia or similar organizations
interstate which assist older workers seeking to rejoin the workforce or retrain
into alternative occcupations. Since 1984 DOME has contacted over 18,500
employers in their efforts to assist members to secure employment and, as well
as offering skill training, provides encouragement in building up self-esteem
through sponsoring self-help discussion groups.
While it is possible that some older applicants may not possess the education,
skill levels, and adaptability needed in the 1990s, many others are the victims of
prejudice and negative stereotyping. Desperation resulting from a lack of com-
International petent younger people may be the driving force to counteract some of this
Journal of discrimination by potential employers. A constructive approach would be to
Manpower search actively for older staff in some job categories where their attributes are
better suited. Recruiters need to focus on the qualities which older staff have to
16,5/6 offer, and identify the jobs in which these qualities have potential for sustained
higher performance.
38 Warr’s (1993) work indicated that, given the increasingly cognitive content of
many jobs, older workers should maintain their competence, as long as
organizations continue to provide developmental opportunities which update
skill portfolios. Programmes aimed at assisting older workers re-enter the
workforce have largely been sponsored by government either as the direct
provider through DEET, or as the source of funding. There are no published
examples of organizational programmes in Australia.
Stereotypes against older workers are widely held and limit their access to
jobs. These vary between beliefs concerning outdated skills, low motivation,
ambition and enthusiasm, and beliefs of greater loyalty, less aggression and
more contentment with their present career (Johnson and Zimmermann, 1993).
Empirical evidence, about worker performance, by contrast, is generally
lacking and much needed. Anecdotal communication indicates that many
employers who have recruited older staff have been pleasantly surprised with
their dedication, their productivity and their reliability. To quote one employer:
I hired an older man because he was all I could find. It’s turned out to be the best thing I ever
did. He’s so keen, and he knows the business (listener comment, Life Matters, ABC Radio).
Training
An ageing workforce may also mean changes to ensure equity in access to
training. Many employers have applied subtle pressure to older staff to suggest
that they might find retraining too demanding (McFee, 1992). Steinberg et al.
(1994) found training was more frequently offered to younger employees and to
women, and that older employees did not volunteer in the same proportion as
their younger colleagues. This may be gradually changing and recent efforts in
NSW to assist older workers learn new skills through the Mature Workers
Programme have achieved high success (McFee, 1992). Communication from
Telecom staff, who operate one of the largest training centres, indicate that
older staff enrol in training programmes roughly in proportion to their
numbers in the Telecom workforce.
Contrary to popular stereotypes, many older staff have been as keen to learn
new skills as their younger colleagues, especially if the new skills are neces-
sary for maintaining their employment or improving their circumstances
(Knowles, 1984; Lahteenmaki and Paalumaki, 1993). However older staff may
not necessarily learn in the same way. Teaching methods need to be tailored to
their learning styles and incorporate techniques which permit additional time
without leading to feelings of inadequacy.
Warr (1993) comments that older workers may benefit from special in-
formation aids, extended familiarization activities with new equipment, the
building-in of early success experiences, and training in interconnected tasks
which help promote more effective learning. Above all, the older worker needs
encouragement from management that their efforts are appreciated and that
appropriate incentives will be offered for satisfactory completion.
It is disappointing that there is so little evidence that older people are
participating in organizationally sponsored training. Their numbers are
increasing dramatically in self-initiated learning such as The University of the
Third Age (TAFE)-sponsored retraining programmes, and community based
learning schemes which may not necessarily be related directly to
employment. So there is no reluctance to learn associated with ageing. Simply,
less opportunity to do so or fewer rewards associated with job based reskilling.
International Access to training is one means by which the organization communicates the
Journal of value it places on an older worker’s contribution. Those organizations which
Manpower encourage their older workers to participate should reap future dividends, not
only in the form of the increased skill levels, but equally importantly, in the
16,5/6 form of increased loyalties, and reduced turnover. Evidence from Tesco in the
UK (Kern, 1992) indicates the retention rate of older staff completing training
40 programmes exceeded that of younger staff by a significant margin.
Remuneration
Older workers in Australia have generally benefited from wages and salaries
which reflect their increased experience. Yet, unless increased age is ac-
companied by increased expertise, this simply makes them more expensive.
Restructuring of remuneration policies to replace age-related criteria with
measures of competence is overdue. Typical public sector practices, in which
years of service entitle job holders to regular annual increases, for example, are
gradually being replaced by broader banding of salary ranges and fewer levels
within each band (Selby-Smith, 1994). Similar changes are occurring in the
private sector (Cullen Egan Dell, 1991-1994) where “pay-for- performance”
philosophies, in which performance, either individual or collective, is the single
important determinant of pay, are becoming more common and filtering below
senior ranks.
Perceived entitlement to increased pay solely on the grounds of length of
service is a dying practice, unless the increased service is associated with
increased responsibility. Few HR managers appear to disagree with these
values. However, setting up an equitable alternative has been time consuming
and daunting.
Before performance-based pay can be introduced on a broader scale in highly
unionized industries, changes in award conditions need to be negotiated and
accepted as part of new enterprise agreements. This is happening slowly (see,
for example, the Australian Financial Review, 1995, p. 1) but there are large
sections of the workforce still untouched. Once the practice is more widespread,
it will be the job performance which is rewarded, not the job holder. Micro-
economic reforms, such as team-based incomes and multi-skilling initiatives,
are interacting with pay scales to eliminate or reduce any income benefits
associated with length of service.
Few nowadays would argue against the use of differential skill levels or
performance as more equitable criteria for compensation payments. Such
problems as do occur, are largely associated with the difficulties of measure-
ment. Some of the issues are considered in the next section.
Performance measurement
Performance measures can only be developed once those involved agree on the
essential components of what constitutes a “good” performance. Quantity,
quality, style, effort, have all been used but lack of sophistication in measure-
ment often confused productivity measures with attitude measures. The
emphasis is switching to depth and breadth of knowledge, reliability, quality Australia’s
and innovation, the ability to work in teams and to develop and nurture sound ageing
interpersonal relationships as the key indicators of “good” performance, population
factors in which age is likely to be an independent variable (Charness, 1985;
Salthouse, 1990), and where compensation for deficiencies can be undertaken.
Age may, therefore, not have the same effect on performance levels in the
future. 41
Measurement still relies heavily on supervisor judgement, yet a sizeable
proportion of organizations (16-17.5 per cent) in the Nankervis and Penrose
(1990) survey reported concerns and distrust of their scheme. Measures of
competence which are relatively independent of the assessor should benefit
older staff as they focus on performance and not on personal attributes.
If the measurement process in place is valued, and accompanied by a fair
and frank exchange of views between supervisor and worker, then it provides
an ideal opportunity for older staff and their supervisors to open up
discussions concerning the future. Alternatives can be canvassed and
explored. Without reciprocal trust the process runs the risk of being
interpreted as intimidation. If the organization is known to encourage options
and to view older workers empathically, there is a strong possibility that
appraisals will emerge as the vehicle whereby older workers can table their
ambitions and concerns. However, recent recession and widescale downsizing
have resulted in few older staff approaching performance appraisal without
stress, believing that the interview may be used to pressure them into
accepting a form of “ voluntary” early retirement.
Career development
Career development by its very nature of integrating present job occupancy
into a future developmental path will have quite different meanings for
younger and older staff. The young are far more interested in where a job
might lead, especially in the longer term. The more mature have a shorter time
horizon simply because they have fewer years ahead and may have fewer
promotions or job changes in front of them. Older staff may be vitally
concerned with how any career move may affect the manner and terms of
potential retirement.
Career plateauing may arise as a problem should larger numbers of older
workers create potential bottlenecks within promotion ranks and slow down
promotion velocity. Strategies to counteract potential disenchantment include
policies which encourage higher value on horizontal career development (Hall,
1985) and programmes which reward non-promotional type achievements.
Recent practices such as downshifting (Sundstrom, 1992) or project work
assignments (Hall, 1985) in the USA may have application in Australia.
More effort needs to be directed to programmes which utilize the experience
of older staff as mentors for their younger colleagues. Provision of emotional
support, sounding board roles, or even simply listening may be very
International constructive in terms of developing teamwork, and reduce the time taken up by
Journal of senior management.
Manpower
Occupational health and safety
16,5/6 European statistics (WHO, 1993) indicate mixed outcomes linking safety with
age. Accident rates for younger staff are comparatively high, largely associated
42 with their relative inexperience. High accident rates for older workers, are often
the consequence of higher risk assignments. When risk was partialled out of the
analysis, the higher accident rates of older workers disappeared. However, older
workers often took longer to recover from similar accidents than their younger
colleagues. Ageing was also associated with increased vulnerability to
problems associated with poor sight and poor hearing and the risk of falling.
Reported Australian statistics (Work Cover Authority of NSW, 1994) indicate
the highest accident percentages occurring in the age group 25-29 years or
males (13.1 per cent) and 40-44 years for females (14.8 per cent). However, time
lost for disability, measured in weeks, rose with age for each succeeding cohort
until 64 years. No Australian statistics are readily available which compare the
type of claim with age. The majority of work related accidents occur in
manufacturing and construction, though many longer term and, therefore, more
expensive claims chiefly relating to stress injuries are from people working in
clerical and administrative areas, where the extent of any rehabilitation period
may be influenced by non-medical factors. There may be an apparent economic
advantage for older workers in prolonging the rehabilitation process until an
early retirement option becomes accessible.
International HR
Unlike Australia, where age is often evaluated negatively, our major trading
partners – Japan, China, Korea and other Asian nations – venerate age as
connoting wisdom and demanding respect. Consequently ageing alone is
unlikely to be a handicap in international negotiations. Attempts to locate
personal factors which contribute to success in international assignments
(Barham and Devine, 1990; Black et al., 1991) have suggested adaptability,
sensitivity, and interpersonal skills as being important. These are personality
variables likely to be independent of ageing and may even improve with ageing
as they are associated with the accumulation of experience (Harris and Moran,
1991). Mammon (1995) comments on how the connection between age and
status so often found in Asian society may generate respect for older people.
The issue of ageing and looking older is a problem which has not yet been
investigated in international HR. One might anticipate mixed results
depending on the value placed on age in other cultures, and the typical practice
of the overseas country regarding their own older workers.
Conclusion
It appears that within the next ten to 15 years HR staff will need to confront the
changes which an ageing workforce will have on their industry. Nor are they
themselves immune. Perhaps their views may be tempered to some extent by
the ageing they perceive within their own ranks. Pressures to eliminate
negative bias against recruitment of older people, to provide them with
training opportunites befitting their learning styles, and to ensure that
performance measures reflect actual competence and not prejudicial
judgements, will increase as the ranks of the over 50s increase and their
political voice becomes louder. More HR professsionals are needed to act as
champions for their older workers and ensure that equity is a reality as well as
an ideal for all workers. In the past they have been all too ready to follow the
trend of championing the young and the ambitious, and valuing more highly
those who are radically innovative. This is a plea to temper this approach and
to acknowledge that excellence can take many forms. Older workers are as able
to craft and fashion new strategies, to manage ongoing operations and to bring
initiative and enthusiasm to their role as are younger ones. Furthermore their
International lesser investment in their career future may result in their having less personal
Journal of and more corporate stake in organizational achievements. Work attitudes,
Manpower though they may change with age and experience, are as much a product of the
organizational environment as of the individual. It is up to HR staff to ensure
16,5/6 that the appropriate environment is provided to ensure their talent does not
wither.
44
References
Australian Bureau of Statistics (1992), Labour Force Projections Australia 1992-2005, Catalogue
No. 6260, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra.
Australian Financial Review (1995), “New enterprise agreements negotiated”, Australian
Financial Review, 6 January.
Arrowsmith, J. and McGoldrick, A. (1994), “Older worker employment: toward a model of
organisational practice”, Working Paper, British Academy of Management Conference,
Lancaster.
Bardwick, J. (1986), The Plateauing Trap, AMACOM, New York, NY.
Barham, K. and Devine, M. (1990), The Quest for the International Manager: A Survey of Global
Human Resource Strategies Special Report No. 2098, The Economist Intelligence Unit,
London, in Dowling, P., Schuler, R.S. and Welch, D.E. (Eds), International Dimensions of
Human Resource Management, 2nd ed., Wadsworth, Belmont, CA.
Black, J.S., Mendenhall, M. and Oddou, G. (1991), “Towards a comprehensive model of
international adjustment: an integration of multiple theoretical perspectives”, Academy of
Management Review, Vol. 16 No. 2, pp. 291-317.
Cascio, W. (1993), “Downsizing: what do we know? What have we learned?”, Academy of
Management Journal, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 95-103.
Charness, N. (1985), “Aging and problem-solving performance”, in Charness, N. (Ed.), Aging and
Human Performance, Wiley, Chichester.
Collins, R. (1994), “The strategic contribution of the personnel function”, reprinted in Nankervis,
A. and Compton, R. (1994), Readings in Strategic Human Resource Management, Thomas
Nelson, Melbourne, pp. 35-48.
Cullen Egan Dell (1991-1994), Quarterly Salary Review, Cullen Egan Dell, Sydney.
Dawson, P. (1994), Organizational Change: A Processual Approach, Paul Chapman, London.
Denney, N.W. and Palmer, A.M. (1981), “Adult age differences in traditional practical problem
solving measures”, Journal of Gerontology, Vol. 36, pp. 322-8.
Devito, G. (1995), “The views of South Australian employers towards older workers (40+)”,
unpublished thesis, University of South Australia, Adelaide.
Dowling, P.J. (1988), “Psychological testing in Australia: an overview and an assessment”, in
Palmer, G., Australian Personnel Management: A Reader, Macmillan, Melbourne, pp. 61-74.
Dunphy, D. and Stace, D. (1990), Under New Management: Australian Organizations in
Transition, McGraw-Hill, Sydney.
Fevre, R. (1991), “Emerging alternatives to full time and permanent employment”, in Brown, P.
and Scase, R. (Eds), Poor Work: Disadvantage and the Division of Labour, Open University
Press, Milton Keynes.
Foot, D. and Venne, R.A. (1991), “Population ageing and human resource management in
Australia”, Bond Management Review, Vol. 2 No. 2, pp. 89-97.
Hale, N. (1990), The Older Worker: Effective Strategies for Management and Human Resource
Development, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.
Hall, D.T. (1985), “Project work as an antidote to career plateauing in a declining engineering
organisation”, Human Resource Management, Vol. 24 No. 3, pp. 271-92.
Harris, C.C. (1991), “Recession, redundancy and age”, in Brown, P. and Scase, R., Poor Work: Australia’s
Disadvantage and the Division of Labour, Open University Press, Milton Keynes, pp. 103-15.
Harris, P.R. and Moran, R.T. (1991), Managing Cultural Differences, Gulf Publishing, Houston,
ageing
TX. population
Heneman, H.G., Schwab, D.P., Fossum, J.A. and Dyer, L.D. (1986), Personnel/Human Resource
Management, 3rd ed., Irwin, Homewood, IL.
Johnson, P. and Zimmermann, K.F. (1993), Labour Markets in an Ageing Europe, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge. 45
Kern, A. (1992), “International developments in expanding work options for older workers”, in
Ageing: Law, Politics and Ethics, Directions for the Twenty-first Century, Proceedings of
Symposium, University of Melbourne, Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Melbourne,
pp. 129-34.
Knowles, M. (1984), The Adult Learner: A Neglected Species, 3rd ed., Gulf Publishing, Houston,
TX.
Kramar, R. (1994), “Strategic human resource management: theory and practice”, in Nankervis, A.
and Compton, R. (Eds), Readings in Strategic Human Resource Management, Thomas Nelson,
Melbourne, pp. 105-23.
Laczko, F. and Phillipson, C. (1991), Changing Work and Retirement, Oxford University Press,
Buckingham.
Lahteenmaki, S. and Paalumaki, A. (1993), “Retraining and mobility motivations of key
personnel: dependencies in the Finnish business environment”, The International Journal of
Human Resource Management, Vol. 4 No. 2, May, pp. 377-406.
Lansbury, R.D. and Spillane, R. (1983), Organizational Behaviour: The Australian Context,
Longman Cheshire, Melbourne.
McFee, G. (1992), “The employment of mature age workers”, Ageing: Law, Policy and Ethics,
Directions for the Twenty-first Century, Proceedings of Symposium, University of Melbourne,
Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Melbourne.
Mammon, A. (1995), “Expatriates’ intercultural effectiveness: relevant variables and
implications”, Asia-Pacific Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 33 No. 1, pp. 40-59.
Nankervis, A. and Penrose, J. (1990), “Performance appraisal: where are we now”, Asia-Pacific
Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 28 No. 3, pp. 74-81.
OECD (1994), OECD Economic Surveys 1993-1994 Australia, Organization for European Co-
operation and Development, Paris.
Patrickson, M. and Hartmann, L. (1994), “Gender differences in the work values of older staff”,
paper presented to the International Conference of Applied Psychology, Madrid, July.
Rock, M.L. (1991), “Performance measurement: chasing the bottom line”, in Rock, M.L. and
Berger, L.A. (Eds), The Compensation Handbook , 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
Rosen, B. (1978), “Management perception of older workers”, Monthly Labor Review, No. 101,
pp. 33-5.
Salthouse, T.A. (1990), “Cognitive competence and expertise in aging”, in Birren, J.E. and Schaie,
K.W. (Eds), Handbook of the Psychology of the Aging, 3rd ed., Academic Press, San Diego, CA.
Selby-Smith, C. (1994), “Restructuring office work in the public service”, in Patrickson, M.,
Bamber, V. and Bamber, G. (1994), Organizational Change Strategies: Case Studies of Human
Resource and Industrial Relations Issues, Longman Cheshire, Melbourne, pp. 115-28.
Spillane, R. (1994), “Personality or performance: the case against personality testing in
Management”, in Nankervis, A. and Compton, R.L., Readings in Strategic Human Resource
Management, Thomas Nelson, Melbourne, pp. 239-48.
Steinberg, M., Najman, J., Chesney-Clark, G. and Mahon, C. (1994), “Attitudes and practices of
employers and employees toward older workers in a climate of discrimination”, Department of
Social and Preventative Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane.
International Sterns, H.L., Alexander, R.A., Barrett, G.V., Schwartz, L.S. and Matheson, N.K. (1990), “Ageing,
work and retirement”, in Parham, I.A., Poon, L.W. and Siegler, I.C. (Eds), Access: Aging
Journal of Curriculum Content for Education in the Social-Behavioural Sciences, Singer, New York, NY.
Manpower Stewart, V. (1992), “Human capital issues in organizational change”, Asia-Pacific Journal of
16,5/6 Human Resources, Vol. 30 No. 3, pp. 53-64.
Storey, J. and Sisson, K. (1993), Managing Human Resources and Industrial Relations, Open
University Press, Buckingham.
46 Sundstrom, D. (1992), “Downshifting: the new career management”, The International Journal of
Career Management, Vol. 2 No. 2, pp. 3-7.
Taylor, P. and Walker, A. (1993), “Employers and older workers”, Employment Gazette, August,
pp. 371-8.
Waldman, D.A. and Avolio, B.J. (1986), “A meta-analysis of age differences in job performance”,
Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 71 No. 1, pp. 33-8.
Warr, P. (1993), “Age and employment”, in Dunnette, M., Hough, L. and Triandis, H. (Eds),
Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, Vol. 4, Consulting Psychologists
Press, Palo Alto, CA.
WHO (1993), Aging and Working Capacity, WHO Technical Report Series, World Health
Organization, Geneva.
Wood, S. (1989), The Transformation of Work? Skill, Flexibility and the Labour Process, Unwin
Hyman, London.
Work Cover Authority of NSW (1994), Workers Compensation Statistics, New South Wales
Government, Sydney.