Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

ARTICLE IN PRESS

Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81


www.elsevier.com/locate/biombioe

Biodiesel from Jojoba oil-wax: Transesterification with methanol and


properties as a fuel
Laureano Canoira, Ramón Alcántara, Ma% Jesús Garcı́a-Martı́nez, Jesús Carrasco
Department of Chemical Engineering and Fuels, School of Mines, Polytechnic University of Madrid, Rı´os Rosas 21, 28003-Madrid, Spain
Received 14 April 2005; accepted 27 July 2005
Available online 19 September 2005

Abstract

The Jojoba oil-wax is extracted from the seeds of the Jojoba (Simmondsia chinensis Link Schneider), a perennial shrub that grows in
semi desert areas in some parts of the world. The main uses of Jojoba oil-wax are in the cosmetics and pharmaceutical industry, but new
uses could arise related to the search of new energetic crops.
This paper summarizes a process to convert the Jojoba oil-wax to biodiesel by transesterification with methanol, catalysed with sodium
methoxide (1 wt% of the oil). The transesterification reaction has been carried out in an autoclave at 60 1C, with a molar ratio methanol/
oil 7.5:1, and vigorous stirring (600 rpm), reaching a quantitative conversion of the oil after 4 h. The separation of the fatty acid methyl
esters (the fraction rich in FAME, 79% FAME mixture; 21% fatty alcohols; 51% of methyl cis-11-eicosenoate) from the fatty alcohols
rich fraction (72% fatty alcohols; 28% FAME mixture; 26% of cis-11-eicosen-1-ol, 36% of cis-13-docosen-1-ol) has been accomplished
in a single crystallization step at low temperature (18 1C) from low boiling point petroleum ether.
The fraction rich in FAME has a density (at 15 1C), a kinematic viscosity (at 40 1C), a cold filter plugging point and a high calorific
value in the range of the European standard for biodiesel (EN 14214).
r 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Simmondsia chinensis Link Schneider; Cryogenic crystallization; European standard EN 14214

1. Introduction (see Scheme 1), and therefore is more properly referred to


as a wax; however, Jojoba oil-wax is the term in general
Jojoba (Simmondsia chinensis Link Schneider) is a use. Jojoba oil-wax contains minor amounts of free fatty
perennial shrub that grows naturally in the Sonora desert acids and alcohols, phytosterols, tocopherols, phospholi-
(Mexico) and in the South-West of USA. Jojoba is now pids and trace amounts of a triacylglycerol which have
cultivated in some countries: Argentina (2.0 kt yr1), Israel been carefully analysed [3]. These minor constituents have
(1.1 kt yr1), USA (1.0 kt yr1) and some Mediterranean also an economical interest and a pilot-scale plant for their
and African lands are the main seed producers (data are for extraction has been built [4].
the campaign 2002–03). Actually, there are in the world The Jojoba oil-wax has a low chemical reactivity and a
7930 ha planted of Jojoba [1]. very high normal boiling point (398 1C) that gives this
The Jojoba seed has a nut shaped form and is around product very important physico-chemical properties and
1–2 cm long, with red-brown to dark-brown colour. This uses. One of the first uses of the Jojoba oil-wax in the 1970s
seed contains between 45 and 55 wt% of Jojoba oil-wax, a was the substitution of the sperm whale oil, when whale
golden liquid that can be obtained by cool pressing or hunting was banned worldwide, but it has many other uses
solvent extraction [2]. Unlike vegetable oils and animal in cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, dietetic foods, animal
fats, Jojoba oil is not a triglyceride but a mixture of long feeding, lubrication, polishing and gardening [5].
chain esters (97–98 wt%) of fatty acids and fatty alcohols Biodiesel is defined as ‘‘a fuel comprised of mono-alkyl
esters of long chain fatty acids derived from vegetable oils
Corresponding author. Tel.: +34 1 336 6949; fax: +34 1 336 6948. or animal fats’’ [6]. Transesterification (also called alcoho-
E-mail address: laucan@qyc.upm.es (L. Canoira). lysis) of triglycerides for biodiesel manufacture has been

0961-9534/$ - see front matter r 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.biombioe.2005.07.002
ARTICLE IN PRESS
L. Canoira et al. / Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81 77

O
CH3(CH2)7 (CH2)m C O (CH2)n (CH2)7CH3
C C C C
H H
H H

m = 7, 9, 11, 13 n = 8, 10, 12, 14

CH3OH

O
CH3(CH2)7 (CH2)m C OCH3 + HO(CH2)n (CH2)7CH3
C C C C
H H H
H

Scheme 1. Transesterification reaction of Jojoba oil-wax with methanol, showing a general structure for methyl jojoboate (bottom left) and jojobyl
alcohol (bottom right).

extensively studied in the past few years [7] but the acetyl chloride (25 g, 0.32 mol) added drop wise so that the
transesterification of Jojoba oil-wax has received much inside temperature was kept below 5 1C. The addition took
less attention [8]. Recently, Selim et al. [9] have published a 25 min. This solution was then added to 49.2 mL (42.4 g,
paper on the combustion of Jojoba methyl esters in an 0.072 mol) of Jojoba oil-wax and 40 mL of toluene placed
indirect injection diesel engine. in a 1 L cylindrical glass tank reactor, and the mixture was
Moreover, the feasibility of the commercial use of Jojoba refluxed at 62 1C for 4 h with vigorous stirring (600 rpm).
methyl ester as biodiesel is strongly dependant of the added On cooling, it was poured into 0.6 L of distilled water. The
value (around 1.16 $ kg1) [10] obtained for the fatty organic phase was decanted, and the aqueous phase was
alcohols produced as secondary products in the transester- extracted with petroleum ether (b.p. 30–70 1C). The organic
ification process, since the maximum price of the Jojoba phases were combined, washed with 0.1 M sodium carbo-
oil-wax for to make the process economically attractive nate solution, saturated sodium chloride solution (three
is 0.75 h kg1 [11] far less than the actual market price times) and dried over anhydrous sodium sulphate. Eva-
of the Jojoba oil-wax in USA (2.60 $ kg1), although a poration of the solvent in a rotary evaporator left 43.2 g
much lower price has been recently reported in Egypt of (97% isolated yield, 97% gas chromatography conversion)
0.80 h kg1 [12]. of a mixture of methyl jojoboate and jojobyl alcohol in an
The aim of this paper is to report the methods of approximately 1:1 ratio. IR: 1745 cm1 (CQO), 3649 cm1
transesterification with methanol of Jojoba oil-wax with (O–H).
acid and basic catalysis, and the procedure of separation of
methyl jojoboate (the fraction rich in FAME) from jojobyl 2.2. Transesterification of jojoba oil-wax to methyl jojoboate
alcohol (the fatty alcohols rich fraction) by crystallization. with basic catalysis
A preliminary evaluation of some properties of methyl
jojoboate as a diesel fuel (viscosity, density, cold filter Freshly cut sodium metal (0.736 g, 0.032 mol) was added
plugging point and high calorific value) is also reported. in small pieces to 50 mL of methanol (39.5 g, 1.23 mol)
placed in a glass flask in a hood over a period of about
2. Experimental 30 min. The solution obtained was then poured over
200 mL of Jojoba oil-wax (172.4 g, 0.293 mol) and 100 mL
Methanol, toluene and petroleum ether (b.p. 40–70 1C) of methanol (78.7 g, 2.46 mol), placed in a 1 L autoclave
all were commercial grade and used without drying or Burton-Coblin from Autoclave Engineers. The autoclave
purification. was closed, and the mixture was heated at 65 1C with
stirring at 600 rpm for a 4 h period. On cooling at room
2.1. Transesterification of jojoba oil-wax to methyl jojoboate temperature, the autoclave was opened and the mixture
with acid catalysis was neutralized adding concentrated hydrochloric acid
(2.8 mL, 0.032 mol) with vigorous stirring. The excess
In a 1 L round bottomed flask, 0.4 L of methanol (316 g, methanol was evaporated under vacuum, and the crude
9.87 mol) were cooled in a ice-salt-water bath, and 23 mL of product was dried with anhydrous sodium sulphate and
ARTICLE IN PRESS
78 L. Canoira et al. / Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81

filtered, yielding 163.4 g (90% isolated yield, 100% gas 2.4. Separation of methyl jojoboate from jojobyl alcohol
chromatography conversion) of a mixture of methyl
jojoboate and jojobyl alcohol in an approximately 1:1 The mixture of methyl jojoboate and jojobyl alcohol
ratio. IR: 1745 cm1 (CQO), 3690 cm1 (O–H). (43 g, 50 mL) was dissolved in petroleum ether (b.p.
30–70 1C, 100 mL), and the solution was left overnight
2.3. Analysis in the freezer (18 1C). An abundant white solid crystal-
lized that was quickly filtered at vacuum while cool using a
IR spectra were registered with a FT-IR Bruker Vector water pump. The mother liquors were concentrated in a
22 in 1,1,2-trichlorotrifluoro ethane solution using a cell for rotary evaporator yielding 23.8 g of oil (55.3% yield), the
liquids with potassium bromide windows and a 0.1 mm FAME mixture methyl jojoboate, whose composition was
Teflon spacer, or in film between potassium bromide disks. determined by GC-MS (Table 1, 4th column). The solids
The gas chromatography-mass spectrometry analyses were filtered in the Büchner funnel were left at room tempera-
determined in a GC-MS HP-6890/MSD-5973 system. The ture and they melted slowly (20 h) to yield after vacuum
sample was dissolved in dichloromethane and 4 mL of this concentration in a rotary evaporator 17.9 g of an oily
solution were injected in the splitless mode at 275 1C in the product (41.6% yield), the fatty alcohols rich fraction
injection port using an automatic injector. The column was jojobyl alcohol, whose composition was also determined by
a 5% diphenylpolydimethylsiloxane AT-5 from Alltech GC-MS (Table 1, 5th column). A small amount of oily
(25 m  0.25 mm  0.20 mm), and helium was used as the solids (0.638 g, 1.6% yield) did not melt at room
carrier gas at a constant column head pressure of 4.0 psi. temperature, and this oily white solid was also analysed
The gradients used were as follows: 60 1C (1 min), heating by GC-MS (Table 1, 6th column).
at 6.00 1C min1 to 300 1C, 10 min at 300 1C, and leaving
15 min between runs. The mass selective detector MSD- 2.5. Determination of the physicochemical properties
5973 was set at 70 eV of accelerating voltage in the ion of the biodiesel of jojoba oil-wax
source. Mass spectra were matched against the Wiley 275
mass spectral library for the identification of compounds, Some physicochemical properties of the raw Jojoba oil-
using the software Chemstations from Hewlett-Packard. wax, the transesterification crude product and the methyl
The Fig. 1 shows a chromatogram of the crude transester- jojoboate separated by crystallization were determined in a
ification product obtained in the GC-MS instrument, preliminary study of the feasibility of use these products as
corresponding to the composition of the Table 1, 3rd a fuel in diesel engines. The ASTM, EN or ISO testing
column. methods used as well as the values obtained for the samples

TIC: 364A2.D
28.64

5e+07 28.57
4.8e+07
4.6e+07
4.4e+07
4.2e+07
4e+07
3.8e+07
3.6e+07
3.4e+07
3.2e+07 27.61
3e+07
Abundance

24.29
2.8e+07
2.6e+07 33.14
2.4e+07
2.2e+07 34.40
2e+07
1.8e+07
1.6e+07
1.4e+07
1.2e+07
1e+07
8000000
6000000
4000000 20.83 34.50 42.07 44.24
2000000 23.54 35.11
0
10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00
Time -->

Fig. 1. Gas chromatogram of the crude product of the transesterification of Jojoba oil-wax. Retention times of the products marked in the peaks
correspond approximately to those in Table 1.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
L. Canoira et al. / Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81 79

Table 1
Composition of the products of the transesterification and separation of Jojoba oil-wax analysed by GC/MS

Compound RT (min) Crude product (%) Methyl jojoboate (%) Jojobyl alcohol (%) Residual solids (%)

Methyl palmitoleate C 16:1 20.34 0.21


CAS No: 1120-25-8
Methyl palmitate C 16: 0 20.83 1.08 1.27 0.43
CAS No: 112-39-0
Methyl 8,11-octadecadienate 24.09 0.04
C 18:2, CAS No: 56599-58-7
Methyl oleate C 18:1 24.29 7.22 9.51 3.39
CAS No: 112-62-9
Methyl cis-11-eicosenoate 28.60 37.55 51.46 18.33 25.96
C 20:1, CAS No: 3946-08-5
Methyl eicosanoate C 20:0 28.87 0.23
CAS No: 1120-28-1
Methyl cis-13-docosenoate 34.45 11.15 14.49 5.02 5.30
C 22:1, CAS No: 1120-34-9
Methyl docosanoate C 22:0 35.11 0.29
CAS No: 929-77-1
Methyl 15-tetracosenoate 44.24 1.07 1.96 0.62
C 24:1, CAS No: 56554-33-7
Cis-9-octadecen-1-ol 23.54 0.66 0.82 0.53
CAS No: 143-28-2
Cis-11-eicosen-1-ol 27.61 19.30 11.58 26.10 27.26
CAS No: 629-96-9
Cis-13-docosen-1-ol 33.14 19.00 7.21 35.75 41.48
CAS No: 629-98-1
Trans-13-docosen-1-ol 33.82 0.88 1.36
CAS No: 23519-83-7
15-Tetracosen-1-ol 42.00 1.34 1.70 7.99
CAS No: cis-50995-29-4
CAS No: trans-69521-46-6
FAME ¼ 79 FAME ¼ 28
Alcoh. ¼ 21 Alcoh. ¼ 78

Table 2
Properties of the biodiesel from Jojoba oil-wax

Sample Density at 15 1C (kg m3) Kinematic viscosity at 40 1C Cold filter plugging point High calorific value (kJ g1)
ASTM D 4052 (mm2 s1) ASTM D 445 (CFPP, 1C) EN 116 ASTM D 2382

Jojoba oil-wax 868.6 24.89 +14


43.47
Crude producta 866.0 11.82 +4
42.17
Methyl jojoboateb 863.5 9.04 14
41.52
Methyl jojoboatec 871.6 10.44 10
42.82
Reference values Min. Max. Min. Max. Winter Summer
EN 14214 860 900 3.50 5.00 10 0
a
Crude transesterification product.
b
Methyl jojoboate obtained by crystallization of the crude product.
c
Methyl jojoboate obtained by elimination of the volatile compounds by distillation followed by crystallization.

and the reference values for biodiesel after EN 14214 are catalysis, with acetyl chloride and methanol to yield
summarized in Table 2. anhydrous hydrogen chloride [8]. The conversion of the
oil (measured by GC/MS) was 97% and the yield of crude
3. Results and discussion isolated product was also 97%. However, the main
drawbacks of this method are the work-up of the reaction
The transesterification of Jojoba oil-wax with methanol product, that is time consuming and requires the use of
has been carried out by two alternative methods: (a) acid a great amount of petroleum ether to extract the aqueous
ARTICLE IN PRESS
80 L. Canoira et al. / Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81

phase, and the formation of emulsions due to the free soaps to raw oil used for the transesterification reaction (0.1)
formed in the neutralization step, that difficult the phase implied that a significant amount of the product was
separation. unreacted Jojoba oil-wax; as a proof of the above assertion,
(b) With this precedent, we tried a basic catalyst, sodium the kinematic viscosity at 40 1C of the biodiesel used
methoxide (1 wt% of the oil), freshly prepared from (24.6 mm2 s1) is very close to that of the raw Jojoba oil-
sodium metal and methanol, that has proven very wax (24.8 mm2 s1, Table 2) and very far from the limits
successful in the transesterification reaction of triglyceride marked by the European standard for biodiesel
oils [7]. In this method, the laborious steps of extraction (3.5–5.0 mm2 s1).
were avoided but, although the GC/MS conversion was On the light of these preliminary results, a separation
quantitative, only 90% of the crude mixture could be step was devised, since the poor fluidity properties are due
isolated, probably due to the adsorption of some polar mainly to the fatty alcohols that present strong inter-
components in the sodium sulphate used to dry the mixture molecular hydrogen bonds. The mixture of methyl
after neutralization. jojoboate and jojobyl alcohol (50 mL) was dissolved in
The crude product, mixture of methyl jojoboate and low boiling point petroleum ether (100 mL) in a volumetric
jojobyl alcohol, was analysed by GC-MS and FT-IR, ratio 1:2, and the solution was left in the freezer overnight
showing good agreement with its molecular structure at 18 1C. An abundant white solid crystallized, that was
(Table 1, 3rd column). However, although its density and quickly filtered at vacuum while cool. The mother liquors
high calorific value were adequate (866 kg m3 and were concentrated at vacuum, yielding 23.8 g (55%) of an
42.17 kJ g1, respectively), its fluidity properties were not: oil, the FAME mixture methyl jojoboate, whose GC-MS
kinematic viscosity (11.82 mm2 s1) and cold filter plugging analysis showed a composition of 79% FAME mixture
point (CFPP, +4 1C). These fluidity properties were much (51.5% of methyl-cis-11-eicosenoate, C 20:1, and 14.5% of
better than that of the raw Jojoba oil-wax (Table 2), due to methyl-cis-13-docosenoate, C 22:1), and 21% fatty alco-
the breaking of the long molecular chains of the original hols (11.6% of cis-11-eicosen-1-ol).
wax into shorter chains of methyl jojoboate and jojobyl The solids filtered in the Büchner funnel were left at
alcohol, but still they did not meet the specifications room temperature and they melted slowly (20 h) to yield
of biodiesel as defined in the European standard EN 14214. after vacuum concentration in a rotary evaporator 17.9 g
In the work of Selim [9], the low molar ratio of methanol (41.6% yield) of an oily product, the fatty alcohols rich

Fig. 2. Block diagram of the batch transesterification process of Jojoba oil-wax with methanol, catalyzed with sodium methoxide. From left to right:
M1 ¼ fresh methanol feed; M2 ¼ recycled methanol; M ¼ methanol feed to the reactor; CAT ¼ catalyst feed; OIL ¼ Jojoba oil-wax feed; Pn ¼ Products
of the different unit operations; TKNEUTRL ¼ neutralization tank; HCL ¼ hydrochloric acid 35 wt%; TKSECADO ¼ drying tank; NA2-
SO4 ¼ anhydrous sodium sulphate; FILT1 ¼ filter 1; R ¼ residual solids (NaCl and Na2SO4  nH2O); DEST-ATM ¼ distillation column for the
recovery of methanol; E1 ¼ fresh petroleum ether; E2 ¼ recycled petroleum ether from the fatty alcohols mixture; E3 ¼ recycled petroleum ether from the
FAME mixture; CRISTALZ ¼ crystallizator; E ¼ petroleum ether feed to the crystallizator; FILT2 ¼ filter for FAME and fatty alcohols separation;
DEST-1 and DEST-2 ¼ distillation columns for the recovery of petroleum ether; P8 ¼ fatty alcohols mixture (42% yield); P9 ¼ FAME mixture
(55% yield).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
L. Canoira et al. / Biomass and Bioenergy 30 (2006) 76–81 81

fraction or jojobyl alcohol, whose GC-MS analysis showed energetic crop for South Europe and North Africa has a
a composition of 28% FAME mixture (18.33% of methyl- high potential.
cis-11-eicosenoate, C 20:1) and 72% fatty alcohols (26.1%
of cis-11-ecosen-1-ol, 35.75% of cis-13-docosen-1-ol, and
Acknowledgements
8.0% of 15-tetracosen-1-ol).
Only a minor amount of residual solids remained in the
We wish to thank to the CEPSA research centre in
filter (0.64 g, 1.6% yield) after the 20 h fusion period, whose
Torrejón de Ardoz (Madrid) for the analysis of the density,
composition is showed in the Table 1.
viscosity and cold filter plugging point of the samples, and
After this relative success in the separation by a single
EIEC Complex SL for the gift of Jojoba oil-wax.
crystallization step of the FAME mixture from the fatty
alcohols, the physicochemical properties of the FAME
mixture sought as biodiesel were analysed: density References
(863.5 kg m3), high calorific value (41.52 kJ g1) and cold
filter plugging point (14 1C) were now in good agreement [1] International Jojoba Export Council. http://www.ijec.net.
with the European standard, although kinematic viscosity [2] Abu-Arabi MK, Allawzi MA, Al-Zoubi HS, Tamimi A. Extraction
of Jojoba oil by pressing and leaching. Chemical Engineering Journal
(9.0 mm2 s1) was still above the maximum allowed 2000;76:61–5.
(5.0 mm2 s1). Fig. 2 shows a block diagram of the process [3] Busson-Breysse J, Farines M, Soulier J. Jojoba wax: its esters and
of transesterification of Jojoba oil-wax with basic catalysis, some of its minor components. Journal of the American Oil Chemists
including the steps of methanol recovery from the reaction Society 1994;71(9):999–1001.
[4] Abbott TP, Holser RA, Plattner BJ, Plattner RD, Purcell HC. Pilot-
and of petroleum ether recovery from the cryogenic
scale isolation of simmondsin and related Jojoba constituents.
crystallization. Industrial Crops and Products 1999;10:65–72.
A different separation method based in the vacuum [5] Shani A. The struggles of Jojoba. Chemtech 1995:49–54.
distillation of the crude transesterification product was [6] European Committee for Standarisation (DIN). Automotive fuels.
totally unsuccessful, since only a very small amount of light Fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) for diesel engines. Requirements
cracked products could be distilled. The bottom product and test methods. European Standard EN 14214; 2003.
[7] Alcantara R, Amores J, Canoira L, Fidalgo E, Franco MJ, Navarro
was then separated by the single crystallization step and the A. Catalytic production of biodiesel from soy-bean oil, used frying oil
properties of the FAME mixture fraction analysed, and tallow. Biomass and Bioenergy 2000;18:515–27.
resulting poorer values of the CFPP (10 1C) and the [8] Shani A, Lurie P. Synthesis of jojobamide and homojojobamide.
kinematic viscosity (10.4 mm2 s1) due to the evaporation Journal of the American Oil Chemists Society 1980:112–4.
of the lighter products in the distillation. [9] Selim MYE, Radwan MS, Elfeky SMS. Combustion of Jojoba
methyl ester in an indirect injection diesel engine. Renewable Energy
This work demonstrated the successful production of a 2003;28:1401–20.
Jojoba-based FAME biodiesel which is close to meet the [10] Chem Systems. Oleochemicals 99/00S12, PERP Report, May 2001.
biodiesel standard EN 14214. This was achieved through [11] Carrasco J. Obtención de biodiesel por transesterificación de aceite-
the use of sodium methoxide as a catalyst and a cryogenic cera de Jojoba. MSc Thesis. School of Mines. Polytechnic University
of Madrid 2004.
separation of the products. While FAME from Jojoba can
[12] El Moguy N. Jojoba: the green gold hope for the Egyptian desert
be produced in 55% yield, its use as a fuel will be development United Nations: Economic and Social Commission for
dependant on the co-production of value added products Western Asia. Report of the Experts Group Meeting Manama
from the fatty alcohols to make it economical. Jojoba as an (Bahrain) 10–12 June 2002.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi