Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
The increase in size of individuals in a population implies an Fréchette & Lefaivre (1990) established a method to dis-
increment of their space and food requirements. These factors tinguish between both causes of competition – space or food –
when limiting can cause intraspecific competition, resulting in in the relationship between the maximum biomass that can be
a decrease of the growth rate and an increase in the mortality supported by a population and its density (self-thinning). The
rate (Alunno-Bruscia et al., 2000). The self-thinning process method is based on the equations described above, ascribing to
describes the negative relationship between body size and the space-limiting factor (spatial self-thinning, SST) the
population density when growth results in mortality through relation m ¼ kN 23/2 (or B ¼ kN 21/2) and to the food-limiting
intraspecific competition (Westoby, 1984). Self-thinning can be factor (food self-thinning, FST) the relation m ¼ kN 24/3 (or
studied by means of successive sampling of the growth of B ¼ kN 21/3).
even-aged individuals that are maintained at different densities In the present study we analysed a dataset of dry weights
(see Fig. 1 in Alunno-Bruscia et al., 2000). The following and densities of Mytilus galloprovincialis cultivated in the Rı́a de
equation describes the self-thinning rule (Westoby, 1984): Ares-Betanzos (NW Spain). The data came from the regular
sampling carried out by our research group for various other
studies. At each sampling, two replicates of 50 cm of rope were
B ¼ kN 1=2 ; ð1Þ
scraped free of mussels. The mussels were counted, weighted,
measured and classified into length classes. The data were
where B is the total biomass, k the intercept of the relationship taken during the years 2004 (n ¼ 111), 2005 (n ¼ 149) and at
and N the population density. The last expression is obtained the beginning of 2006 (n ¼ 8). The use of data sampled across
from the mean morphometric relationships between the sub- years allowed us to consider the assumption of constant energy
stratum area occupied by the individual (S), length of the indi- flow less likely violated because fluctuations in food abundance
vidual (l) and its weight (m). Assuming isometric growth (S a l 2 over years should only cause increased variance around the
and m a l 3) and an inverse relationship between density and self-thinning line (Steingrı́msson & Grant, 1999). Mussels were
area occupied (N a S 21), the following equation is obtained: cultivated on ropes at high densities, which presented an ideal
situation to study the self-thinning processes because this
m ¼ kN 3=2 ; ð2Þ method involves mortality by intraspecific competition. The
diameters of 25 commercial ropes were measured to calculate
which given the relationship between population biomass and the available area for mussel attachment. Ropes were hung
individual average weight (B ¼ Nm) can be expressed as from rafts following the technology used commonly in the
Equation 1. Galician Rı́as, which includes three phases: seed settlement
Although this theory is based on studies focused on plants, it (initial), early thinning-out and thinning-out. In the two last
can be applied to both sessile and mobile animal populations phases, the mussels are detached from the ropes and replaced
(Hughes & Griffiths, 1988; Steingrı́msson & Grant, 1999). in culture at lower densities. The reduction of the density
Damuth (1981) observed in primary consumers an exponent of caused by this manipulation alters the natural process of self-
24/3 between average weight and density and suggested that thinning and invokes mitigation in the mortality by intra-
this can be related to the metabolic requirements of indivi- specific competition. The subsequent inclusion of values in
duals. In this way, Begon, Firbank & Wall (1986) stated a which the mortality by intraspecific competition has not yet
theoretical relationship between the self-thinning process and begun will flatten the estimated slope of the self-thinning fit
the population metabolic rate (MR), which is related to the (Zhang et al., 2005). Several studies have suggested corrective
individual average weight (MR a Nm 3/4) and environmental techniques that include the removal of these data points
conditions (MR a F, where F is the total amount of food con- (Westoby, 1984) or the use of different regression models that
sumed by the population). Assuming a constant consumption allow a good fit without the omission of data points (see review
of food by the population (Fcte), in stable environmental con- by Zhang et al., 2005). These last authors compared several
ditions the following relationship can be obtained: regression models [quantile regression, deterministic frontier
function and stochastic frontier function (SFF)] that have the
potential to establish an upper limiting boundary line above
m ¼ kN 4=3 ; ð3Þ all plots for the maximum size –density relationship, without
subjectively selecting a subset of data points based on pre-
which given the relationship between population biomass and defined criteria. Zhang et al. (2005) concluded that the SFF
individual average weight (B ¼ Nm) can be expressed as: was the most suitable model given that this method can easily
yield statistical inference on the model coefficients.
In the present study, the mathematical expression that
B ¼ kN 1=3 : ð4Þ
describes the self-thinning (m ¼ kN g) was calculated by means
of the logarithmic linear transformation (log m ¼ log
Correspondence: M.J. Fernández-Reiriz; e-mail: mjreiriz@iim.csic.es k þ g log N) following two regression models: reduced major
416
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mollus/article-abstract/74/4/415/1001518
by guest
on 17 April 2018
RESEARCH NOTE
Figure 2. Dry weight of individual mussels vs culture density, and linear fits performed by RMA, where N is the effective density calculated from
the projected area of the parallelepiped (A), and where N is the effective density calculated from the image analysis (B). In both cases, only RMA
is shown because the SFF estimates identical parameters and the likelihood value is less than that obtained using RMA. ANCOVA following Zar
(1984) was performed to compare the exponents observed in the present study with theoretical values for FST and SST (24/3 and 23/2,
respectively).
417
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mollus/article-abstract/74/4/415/1001518
by guest
on 17 April 2018
RESEARCH NOTE
LATTO, J. 1994. Evidence for a self-thinning rule in animals. Oikos, ZAR, J.H. 1984. Biostatistical analysis. Prentice-Hall, New Jersey.
69: 531–534. ZHANG, L., BI, H., GOVE, J.H. & HEATH, L.S. 2005.
STEINGRÍMSSON, S.Ó. & Grant, J.W.A. 1999. Allometry of A comparison of alternative methods for estimating the self-thinning
territory size and metabolic rate as predictors of self-thinning in boundary line. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 35: 1507–1514.
young-of-the-year Atlantic salmon. Journal of Animal Ecology, 68:
17– 26.
WESTOBY, M. 1984. The self-thinning rule. Advances in Ecological doi:10.1093/mollus/eyn027
Research, 14: 167– 225. Advance Access Publication: 27 August 2008
418
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mollus/article-abstract/74/4/415/1001518
by guest
on 17 April 2018