Republic of the Philippines

BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY

Gov. Pablo Borbon Campus II, Alangilan Batangas City, Philippines 4200
College of Engineering, Architecture & Fine Arts
www.batstate-u.edu.ph Tel. No. (043) 425-0139 loc. 118

Chemical and Food Engineering Department

SUMMARY OF COMMENTS

CARMETCEL CORPORATION; The Philippines’ First Carboxymethyl Cellulose Plant

Aquino, Charmaine Pearl L., Gutierrez, Venus Abigail D., Lacdao Drexler B., Nisortado, Harold P., Villano, Dhankay A.

Chapter Page No. Comments Panelists

2 29 Price of sugarcane bagasse by 2022. Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

Include the basis of manufacturing process used in Chapter 5 and

2 29 Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion
in material balance in Chapter 6.

5 141 State material balance & conversion basis Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

5 145 Change the label in block flow diagram of Area 100 Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

6 159 Recheck the tables for the summary of material balance Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

6 163 Summarize the residence time in one table Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion
 Change and use the proper symbol for the process flow diagram
6 167 Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion
and P&ID

7 182 Include column for unit/day in Table 7.4 Utility Requirements Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

9 210 Recheck the unit for equipment capacity (like weighing scale) Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

9 211 Change the dimensions of the Hot Water Basin Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

9 212-213 Recheck computation for Filter Press 1 & 2 specification Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

10 271 Align right all monetary value Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

Recheck the values of initial feed in Table 13.1 Raw Material

10 311 Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion
Cost

APPENDIX Recheck appendix formatting Engr. Rhonalyn V. Maulion

Inset review of related literature with the basis of operation used

2 29 Engr. Joey C. Garcia
in Chapter 5 and in material balance in Chapter 6.

5 141 State material balance & conversion basis Engr. Joey C. Garcia

6 159 Include percent losses in all process/equipment Engr. Joey C. Garcia

Include the residence time calculation in the appendix of material

6 163 Engr. Joey C. Garcia
balance

6 167 Change the Qualitative, Quantitative and P&ID Engr. Joey C. Garcia
 7 176 Recompute mechanical energy balance of selected equipment Engr. Joey C. Garcia

7 178 Recompute mechanical energy requirements of pumps Engr. Joey C. Garcia

8 183 Arrange operating temperature from highest to lowest Engr. Joey C. Garcia

8 184 Include Risk Hazard analysis of all process/equipments Engr. Joey C. Garcia

9 209 Recompute equipment sizing of selected equipment Engr. Joey C. Garcia

13 312 Recompute financial aspects based on adjustment made Engr. Joey C. Garcia

Recheck values of Table 13.2 Individual Cost of Equipment for

13 312 Engr. Joey C. Garcia
Pre-Treatment of sugarcane bagasse

14 331 Change the amount of sugarcane bagasse required per day Engr. Joey C. Garcia

14 332 Write the correct value of updated Total Capital Investment Engr. Joey C. Garcia

APPENDIX Modify appendix of multiple constraint Engr. Joey C. Garcia

Noted by:

ENGR. REJIE C. MAGNAYE

Plant Design Adviser
Verified by:

DR. SICILY B. TIU ENGR. JOEY GARCIA

Panel Chairman Panel Member

ENGR. RHONALYN V. MAULION

Panel Member