Aban

1. Palay, Inc. vs. Clave, 124 SCRA 638 (1983)

2. National Power Corporation vs. Philipp Brothers Oceanic, Inc. 369 SCRA 629
(2001)
3. Republic Planters Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 216 SCRA 738 (1992)

4. A.F. Realty & Development, Inc. vs. Dieselman Freight Services Company, 373
SCRA 385 (2002)

5. DBP vs. Sps. Francisco and Leticia Ong 460 SCRA 170 (2005)

6. Nielson & Company, Inc. vs. Lepanto Consolidated Mining Company, 26 SCRA
540 (1969)
7. Goachan vs. Young, 354 SCRA 207 (2001)

8. Philippine National Bank vs. Andrada Electric and Engineering Company, 381
SCRA 244 (2002)

9. Merrill Lynch Futures, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 211 SCRA 824 (1992)
10. Andaya vs. Abadia, 228 SCRA 705 (1993)
11. Philippine Airlines vs. Zamora 514 SCRA 584 (2007)

Aiquidamos
1. Cruz vs. Dalisay, 152 SCRA 482 (1987)
2. Filipinas Broadcasting Network vs. Ago Medical and Educational Center 448
SCRA 413 (2005)
3. Industrial Refractories Corporation of the Philippines vs. Court of Appeals, 390
SCRA 252 (2002)
4. Filipinas Port Services, Inc., v. Go et al, 518 SCRA 453 (2007)
5. Litonjua Jr. vs. Eternity Corporation 490 SCRA 204 (2006)
6. Madrigal & Company, Inc. vs. Zamora, 151 SCRA 355 (1987)
7. Reyes vs. Hon. RTC Makati Br. 142, 561 SCRA 593 (2008)
8. Babst vs. Court of Appeals, 350 SCRA 341 (2001)
9. Philipp Morris, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 224 SCRA 576 (1993)
10. Torio vs. Court of appeals, 230 SCRA 626 (1994)
11. Union Bank of the Phil. vs. ABS Devt. Corp. G.R. No. 172895 560 SCRA 578
(2008)

Artienda
1. Remo vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 172 SCRA 405 (1989)
2. Meralco v. TEAM Electronics Corp. 540 SCRA 62 (2007)
3. P.C. Javier& Sons, Inc., v. Court of Appeals 462 SCRA 36 (2005)
4. Associated Bank vs. Sps. Rafael and Monaliza Pronstroller 558 SCRA 113 (2008)
5. Easycall Communications Phils., Inc. vs. Edward King 478 SCRA 102 (2005)
6. Republic Planters Bank vs. Agana, 296 SCRA 1 (1998)
7. Hi-Yield, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals GR 168863 590 SCRA 548 (2009)
8. Omictin vs. Court of Appeals 512 SCRA 70 (2007)
9. Signetics Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 225 SCRa 737 (1993)
10. Pearson & George, (S.E. Asia), Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 253
SCRA 136 (1996)
11. China Banking Corporation v. ASB Holdings, Inc. 575 SCRA 247 (2008)

Baylon
1. Pabalan vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 184 SCRA 495 (1990)

2. Villa Rely Transit vs. Ferrer, 25 SCRA 845 (1968)

3. Hyatt Elevators and Escalators Corp., vs. Goldstar Elevators Phils., Inc. 473 SCRA 705
(2005)
4. Cebu Country Club Inc., et al., v. Elizagaque 542 SCRA 65 (2008)
5. Elcee Farms, Inc. vs. NLRC 512 SCRA 602 (2007)
6. Bitong vs. Court of Appeals, 292 SCRA 503 (1996)
7. Stockholders of F. Guanzon vs. Register of Deeds of Manila, 6 SCRA 373 (1962)
8. McLeod v. NLRC 512 SCRA 222 (2007)
9. George Grotjahn GBBH & Co. vs. Isnani 235 SCRA 216 (1994)
10. Ongkingco vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 270 SCRA 613 (1997)
11. Garcia vs. Philippine Airlines, G.R. No. 164856 576 SCRA 479 (2009)

Carabbacan
1. Umali vs. Court of Appeals, 189 SCRA 529 (1990)

2. A.C. Ransom Labor Union- CCLU vs. National Labor relations Commission, 150 SCRA
498 (1987)
3. Marissa R. Unchuan vs. Antonio J.P. Lozada 585 SCRA 421 (2009)
4. People of the Philippines vs. Hermenegildo Dumlao and Emilio La’o 580 SCRA (2009)
5. Aratea vs. Suico, 518 SCRA 501 (2007)
6. Citibank, N.A. vs. Chua, 220 SCRA 75 (1993)
7. Philippine National Bank vs. Bitulok Sawmill, Inc., 23 SCRA 1366 (1968)
8. McLeod v. NLRC 512 SCRA 222 (2007)
9. Litton Mill, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 256 SCRA 696 (1996)
10. Garcia vs. Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc. 585 SCRA 450 (2009)
11. Malayan Insurance Company, Inc. vs. Victorias Milling Company, Inc. 586 SCRA 45
(2009)

Datangel
1. Indophil Textile Mill Workers Union PTGWO vs, Calica, 205 SCRA 697 (1992)
2. Indino vs. National Labors Relations commission 178 SCRA 168 (1989)
3. Pioneer Surety & Insurance Corporation vs. Court of Appeal, 175 SCRA 668 (1989)
4. Westmont Bank vs. Inland Construction and Development Corporation 582 SCRA 230
(2009)
5. Pamplona Plantation Company vs. Ramon Acosta et al, 510 SCRA 249 (2006)
6. China Banking Corporation vs. Court appeals, 270 SCRA 503 (1997)
7. Rivera vs. Florendo, 144 SCRA 643 (1986)
8. Spouses Ramon Nisce vs. Equitable PCI Bank 516 SCRA 231
9. Communication materials and Design, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 260 SCRA 673, (1996)
10. Calleja vs. Panday 483 SCRA 689 (2006)
11. Onapal Philippine Commodities, Inc. vs. Court of appeals, 218 SCRA 281

De Guzman
1. EPG Construction Company, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals 210 SCRA 230 (1992)
2. Shoemart, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations commission, 225 SCRA 311 (1993)
3. People vs. Garcia, 271 SCRA 621 (1997)
4. Board of Liquidators vs. Kalaw, 20 SCRA 987 (1967)
5. People of the Philippines vs. Hermenegildo Dumlao and Emilio La’o 580 SCRA (2009)
6. Loyola Grand Villas Homeowners Association (South) Association, Inc. vs. Court of
Appeals, 276 SCRA 681 (1997)
7. De Erguiga vs. Court of Appeals, 178 SCRA 1 (1989)
8. Litonjua vs. Court of Appeals, 286 SCRA 136 (1998)
9. Columbian Pictures, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 261 SCRA 144 (1996)
10. Orendain vs. BF Homes, Inc. 506 SCRA 348 (2006)
11. Union Bank of the Philippines vs. Securities and Exchange Commission 358 SCRA 479
(2001)

Galera
1. Boyer Roxas vs. Court of Appeals 211 SCRA 470 (1992)
2. Manuel R. Dulay enterprises, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 225 SCRA 678 (1993)
3. Lozano vs. Delos Santos, 272 SCRA 452 (1997)
4. De Tavera vs. Philippine Tuberculosis Society, Inc., 112 SCRA 243 (1982)
5. James U. Gosiaco vs. Leticia Ching and Edwin Casta 585 SCRA 471 (2009)
6. PMI College vs. National labor Relations Commission, 277 SCRA 462 (1997)
7. Embassy Farms, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 188 SCRA 492 (1990)
8. Long vs. Basa, 366 SCRA 113 (2001)
9. Hahn vs. Court of Appeals, 266 SCRA 537 (1997)
10. Yujuico vs. Quiambao 513 SCRA 243 (2007)
11. Fabia vs. Court of Appeals, 388 SCRA 574 (2002)

Gatpolintan
1. Boyer Roxas vs. Court of Appeals 211 SCRA 470 (1992)
2. Guatson International Travel & Tour, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission 230
SCRA 815 (1994)
3. Lim Tong Lim vs. Philippine Fishing Gear Industries, Inc., 317 SCRA 728 (1999)
4. Sia vs. People, 121 SCRA 655. (1983)
5. Professional Services, Inc., vs. CA 544 SCRA 1780 (2008)
6. Nakpil vs. Intercontinental Broadcasting Corporation , 379 SCRA 653 (2002)
7. Tan vs. Securities and Exchange Commission, 206 SCRA 740 (1992)
8. Ao-As vs. CA 491 SCRA 339 (2006)
9. Eriks Pte., Ltd. vs. Court of Appeals, 267 SCRA 567 (1997)
10. Reyes vs. RTC of Makati 561 SCRA 593 (2008)
11. Power Homes Unlimited Corporation v. SEC 546 SCRA 567 (2008)

Gorospe
1. Sebreno vs. Court of Appeals, 222 SCRA 466 (1993)
2. First Philippine International Bank vs. court of appeals, 252 SCRA 259 (1996)
3. International Express Travel & Tour Services, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 343 SCRA 674
(2000)
4. AC Ransom Labor Union vs. NLRC 142 SCRA 269 (1986);
a. Villanueva vs. Adre 172 SCRA 876 (1989). Please see, however, decisions to
the contrary, infra.)
5. Jesus V. Lanuza, et al. vs. Court of Appeals 454 SCRA 54 (2005)
6. Ong vs. Tiu, 401 SCRA 1 (2003)
7. Razon vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 207 SCRA 234 (1992)
8. Manuel R. Dulay Enterprises, Inc. vs. Court of appeals, 225 SCRA 678 (1993)
9. Avon Insurance PLC. Vs. Court of Appeals, 278 SCRa 312 (1997)
10. Unlad Resources Devt., Corp., et al. vs. Renato P. Dragon, 560 SCRA 63 (2008)

Hortal
1. Robledo vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 238 SCRA 52 (1994)
2. Tomas Lao Construction vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 278 SCRA 716
(1997)
3. Sawadjaan vs. Court Appeals 459 SCRA 516 (2005)
4. Prime White Cement Corporation vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 220 SCRA 103
(1993)
5. Digital Microwave Corp. vs. Court of Appeals, 328 SCRA 289 (2000)
6. Ong vs. Tiu, 401 SCRA 1 (2003)
7. Rural Bank of Salinas, Inc vs. Court of Appeals, 210 SCRA 510 (1992)
8. Naguiat vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 269 SCRA 54 (1997)
9. Hutchison Ports Philippine Limited vs. Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority, 339 SCRa 34
(2000)
10. Peneyra vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 181 SCRA 244 (1990)
11. Timeshare Realty Corporation v. Cesar Lao and Cynthia V. Cortez 544 SCRA 254 (2008)
Inabangan
1. Laguio vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 262 SCRA 709 (1996)
2. Concept Builders, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 257 SCRA 149 (1996)
3. Gokongwei vs. Securities Exchange Commission, 89 SCRA 336 (1979)
4. Tramart Mercantile, Incl. vs. Court of Appeals, 238 SCRA 14 (1994)
5. BA Savings Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 336 SCRA 484 (2000)
6. Ryuichi Yamamoto vs. Nishino Leather Industries, Inc. and Ikuo Nishino 551 SCRA 447
(2008)
7. Torres vs. Court of Appeals, 270 SCRA 493 (1997)
8. San Juan Structural and Steel Fabricators, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 296 SCRA 63
(1998)
9. MR. Hondings, Ltd. vs. Bajar, 380 SCRA 617 (2002)
10. Securities and Exchange Commission vs. Court of appeals, 246 SCRA 738 (1995)
11. Tyson’s Super Concrete, Inc., v. Court of Appeals 461 SCRA 69 (2005)

Jadap
1. Matuguina Wood Products, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 263 SCRA 490 (1996)
2. Reynoso vs. Court of Appeals, 245 SCRA 335 (2000)
3. Sales vs. Securities and Exchange Commission, 169 SCRA 109 (1989)
4. De Guzman vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 253 SCRA 46 (1996)
5. Shipside Incorporation vs. Court of Appeals, 352 SCRA 334 (2001)
6. Baltazar vs. Lingayen Gulf Electric Power Company, Inc., 14 SCRA 522 (1965)
7. China Banking Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 270 SCRA 503 (1997)
8. Mambulao Lumber Company vs. Philippine National Bank, 22 SCRA 989 (1968)
a. National Abaca & Other Fibers Corporation vs. Pore, 2 SCRA 989 (1961) (See
however, Gelano and Reburiano cases, infra)
9. Lorenzo Shipping Corp. vs. Chubb and Sons, 431 SCRA 266 (2004)
10. Spouses Sobrejuanite v. ASB Development Corporation 471 SCRA 763 (2005)

Juarez
1. Republic vs. Sandiganbayan, 266 SCRA 515 (1997)
2. Lipat vs. Pacific Banking Corp., 402 SCRA 339 (2003)
3. Pena vs. Court of Appeals, 193 SCRA 717 (1991)
4. New Durawood Company Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 253 SCRA 740 (1996)
5. San Pablo Manufacturing Corporation vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue 492 SCRA
192 (2006)
6. Gonzales vs. Philippine National Bank, 122 SCRA 489 (1983)
7. Bitong vs. Court of Appeals, 292 SCRA 503 (1998)
8. Gelano vs. Court of appeals, 103 SCRA 90 (1981)
9. Expertravel & Tour, Inc. vs. CA. 459 SCRA 147 (2005)
10. Philippine Stock Exchange vs. Securities & Exchange Commission 281 SCRA 232
(1997)
11. Sy Chim vs. Sy Siy Ho & Sons, Inc. 480 SCRA 465 (2006)

Latigay
1. Traders Royal Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 269 SCRA 15 (1997)
2. Mavest (USA) Inc., v. Sampaguita Garment Corporation 470 SCRA 440 (2005)
3. Visayan vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 196 SCRA 410 (1991)
4. Tabang vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 266 SCRA 462 (1997)
5. Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines, Inc. vs. Aladdin Transit Corp. 494 SCRA 358 (2006)
6. Datu Tagoranao Benito vs. Securities & Exchange Commission 123 SCRA 722 (1983)
7. Thomson vs. Court of Appeals, 298 SCRA 280 (1998)
8. Chase vs. Buencamino, 136 SCRA 365 (1985)
9. B. Van Zuiden Bros Ltd. vs. GTVL Manufacturing Industries 523 SCRA 233 (2007)
10. Philippine National Construction Corporation vs. Pabion, 320 SCRA 188 (1999)
11. Excellent Quality Apparel, Inc. vs. Win Multi-Rich Builders Inc. 578 SCRA (2009)

Licuanan
1. Presidential Commission in Good Government vs. Sandiganbayan, 290 SCRA 639
(1998);
2. Presidential Commission on Good Government vs. Sandiganbayan, 365 SCRA 538
(2001)
3. Pamplona Plantation company, Inc., vs. Tinghil 450 SCRA 421 (2005)
4. Lee vs. Court of Appeals, 205 SCRA 752 (1992)
5. Naguiat vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 269 SCRA 564 (1997)
6. Cagayan Valley Drug Corporation vs. CIR 545 SCRA 10 (2008)
7. Edward A. Keller 7 Co., Ltd. vs. COB Group Marketing, Inc., 141 SCRA 86 (1986)
8. Garcia vs. Jomouad, 323 SCRA 424 (2000)
9. Chung Ka Bio vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 163 SCRA 534 (1988)
10. Rimbunan Hijau Group of Companies v. Oriental Wood Processing Corporation 470
SCRA 650 (2005)
11. Development Bank of the Philippines vs. Court of Appeals, 363 SCRA 307 (2001)

Magbitang
1. Union Bank of the Philippines vs. Court of appeals, 290 SCRA 198 (1998)
2. Times Transportation Co., Inc., vs. Sotelo, 451 SCRA 587 (2009)
3. Citibank, N.A. vs. Chua, 220 SCRA 75. (1993)
4. Llamdo vs. Court of Appeals, 270 SCRA 423 (1997)
5. Maranaw Hotel & Resort Corporation vs. Court of Appeals 576 SCRa 463 (2009)
6. Remo vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 172 SCRA 405 (1989)
7. Rural Bank of Lipa City, Inc. vs. Court of appeals, 366 SCRA 188 (2001). See also-
8. Batangas Laguna Tayabas Bus company, Inc., et al., vs. Benjamin Bitanga, et al., 362
SCRA 635 (2001)
9. Clemente vs. Court of Appeals, 242 SCRA 717 (1995). See also-
10. Reburiano vs. Court of Appeals, 301 SCRA 342 (1999)
11. Marubeni Nederland B.V. vs. Tensuan 190 SCRA 105 (1990)

Mallero
1. Asionics Philippines, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations commission, 290 SCRA 164
(1998)
2. Apex Mining Co., Inc. vs. Southeast Mindanao Gold Mining Corp. 492 SCRA 355 (2006)
3. Grace Christian High School vs. Court of Appeals, 281 SCRA 133 (1997)
4. Uichico vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 273 SCRA 35 (1997)
5. Expetravel & Tours, Inc. vs. CA 459 SCRA 147 (2005)
6. Apocada vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 172 SCRA 442 (1989)
7. Ponce vs. Alsons Cement Corporation 393, SCRA 602 (2002)
8. Philippine National Bank vs. Bitulok Sawmill Inc., SCRA 269
9. Aboitiz Shipping Corp. vs. Insurance Co. of North America 561 SCRA 262 (2008)
10. TCL Sales Corporation vs. Court Appeals, 349 SCRA 35 (2001)
11. Boman Environmental Corp. vs. Court of Appeals, 167 SCRA 540 (1988)

Monte
1. Francisco Motors Corporation vs. Court of appeals, 309 SCRA 72 (1999)
2. GCC v. Alsons Development and Investment Corporation 513 SCRA 225 (2007)
3. Naguiat vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 269 SCRA 564. (1997)
4. Torres, Jr. vs. Court of Appeals, 278 SCRA 793 (1997)
5. Government Service Insurance System vs. Court of Appeals 585 SCRA 679 (2009)
6. Saw vs. Court of Appeals, 195 SCRA 797. (1991)
7. Republic of the Phil. (PCGG) vs. Sandiganbayan and Victor Africa, 402 SCRA 84 (2003)
8. Yam vs. Court of Appeals, 303 SCRA 1 (1999)
9. J.G. Summit Holdings, Inc., vs. Court of Appeals 450 SCRA 169 (2005)
10. Pilipinas Loan Company, Inc. vs. Securities and Exchange Commission, 356 SCRA 193
(2001)
11. Cemco Holdings vs. National Life Insurance Company, 529 SCRA 355 (2007)
Nubla
1. Complex Electronics Employees Association vs. National Labor Relations Commission
310 SCRA 403 (1999)
2. Sta. Monica Industrial and Development Corporation vs. The Department of Agrarian
Reform Regional Director for Region III, et al. 555 SCRA 97 (2008)
3. Yao Ka Sin Trading vs. Court of Appeals, 209 SCRA 763 (1992)
4. San Juan Structure and Steel Fabricators, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 296 SCRA 631
(1998)
5. Republic vs. Acoje Mining Company, Inc. 7 SCRA 661 (1963)
6. Africa vs. Presidential Commission on Good Government 205 SCRA 39 (1992)
7. Republic of the Phils. vs. Sandiganbayan, 402 SCRA 84 (2003)
8. Vesagas vs. Court of Appeals, 371 SCRA 506 (2001)
9. Condominium Act. Yamane vs. BA Lepanto Condominium Corporation 474 SCRA 258
(2005)
10. Mobilia Products, Inc. vs. Umezawa 452 SCRA 736 (2005)
11. Provident International Resources Corp.. et al. vs. Joaquin T. Venus, et al. 554 SCRA
540 (2008)

Pagaduan
1. Lim vs. CA, 323 SCRA 120 (2000)
2. Sps. Pedro and Florencia Violago vs. BA Finance Corporation and Avelino Viologo 559
SCRA 69 (2008)
3. Benguet Electric Cooperative, Inc. vs. National Relations Commission, 209 SCRA 55
(1992)
4. People Aircagro and Warehousing Company, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 297 SCRA 170
(1998)
5. National Power Corporations vs. Vera, 170 SCRA 721 (1989)
6. Lee vs. Court of appeals, 205 SCRA 752 (1992)
7. Republic vs. Estate of Hans Menzi 476 SCRA (2005)
8. Knecht vs. United Cigarette Corporation, 384 SCRA 48 (2002)
9. The President of PDIC as Liquidator of Pacific Banking Corporation vs. Reyes 460 SCRA
473 (2005)
10. Abacus Securities vs. Ampil 483 SCRA 315 (2006)
11. Danilo G. Punogbayan vs. Perfecto G. Punongbayan, Jr. 491 SCRA 581 (2006)

Payumo
1. Marubeni Corporation vs. Lirag, 362 SCRA 620 (2001)
2. Claude P. Bautista vs. Auto Plus Traders Inc. 561 SCRA 223 (2008)
3. Louis Vitton, S.A. vs. Villanueva, 216 SCRA 121 (1992)
4. Restaurante Las Conchas vs. Llego, 314 SCRA 24. (1999)
a. (Please see, however, decision to the contrary in Carag vs. NLRC and Macleod
 vs. NLRC, infra)
5. Aurback vs. Sanitary Wares Manufacturing Corporation, 180 SCRA 130 (1989)
6. Lopez Realty, Inc. vs. Fontecha, 247 SCRA 183 (1995)
7. Nautica Canning Corporation v. Yumul 473 SCRA 415 (2005)
8. Paramount Insurance Corp. vs. A.C. Ordonez Corp. 561 SCRA 327 (2008)
9. Philex Mining Corporation vs. Reyes, 118 SCRA 602 (1982)
10. Fortune Cement Corporation vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 193 SCRA 391
(1991)

Penalosa
1. Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Court of Appeal, 364 SCRA 375 (2001)
2. Lucia Magaling, et al. vs. Peter Ong 562 SCRA 152 (2008)
3. Louis Vitton, S.A. vs. Villanueva, 216 SCRA 121 (1992)
4. Consolidated Food Corporation vs. National Labor Relations, 315 SCRA 129 (1999)
5. Pena vs. Court of Appeals, 193 SCRA 717 (1991)
6. Republic Planters Bank vs. Agana, Sr., 296 SCRA 1 (1998)
7. Trans Middle East (Phils.) vs. Sandiganbayan, 490 SCRA 455 (2006)
8. Home Insurance Company vs. Eastern Shipping Lines, 123 SCRA 424 (1983)
9. Union Glass & Container Corporation vs. Securities & Exchange Commission, 126 SCRA
21 (1983).
a. See also Magalad vs. Premier Financing Corporation, 209 SCRA 260 (1992)
10. Securities and Exchange Commission vs. Interport Resources Corporation 567 SCRA
354 (2008)

Quilantang
1. PNB vs. Ritratto Group, Inc., 362 SCRA 216 (2001)
2. Silverio vs. Filipino Business Consultants, Inc. 466 SCRA 584 (2005)
3. Slain Enterprises, Inc. vs. Cupertino Realty Corporation, Inc. et al. 590 SCRA 435
(2009)
4. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. vs. Quilts & All, Inc., 222 SCRA 480 (1993);
a. See also Lee vs. Court of Appeals, 345 SCRA 579 (2000)
5. Rural Bank of Milaor (Camarines Sur) vs. Ocfemia, 325 SCRA 99 (2000);
6. Soler vs. Court of Appeals, 358 SCRA 57 (2001)
7. Lopez Realty vs. Fontecha, 247 SCRA 183 (1995)
8. Neugene Marketing Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 303 SCRA 295 (1999)
9. Pacific Basin Securities v. Oriental Petroleum 531 SCRA 667 (2007)
10. Ao-As vs. CA 491 SCRA 339 (2006)
Recaido
1. Jardine Davis, Inc. vs. JRB Realty, Inc. 463 SCRA 555 (2005)
2. Gonzales vs. Philippine National Bank, 122 SCRA 489 (1983)
3. Lopez Realty, Inc. vs. Fontecha, 247 SCRA 183 (1995)
4. Lao vs. C.A. 325 SCRA 694 (2000)
5. Laureano Investment and Development Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 272 SCRA
253 (1997)
6. Republic vs. Sandiganbayan, 246 SCRA 760 (2000)
7. Valley Golf and Country Club, Inc. vs. Vda. De Caram 585 SCRA 218 (2009)
8. Top-Weld Manufacturing, Inc. vs. Eced, S.A. 138 SCRA 118.
a. See also Granger Associates vs. Microwave Systems, Inc., 189 SCRA 631
(1990)
9. Philippine School of Business Administration vs. Leano, 127 SCRA 778 (1984)

Saguiguit
1. China Banking Corporation vs. Dyne-Sem electronics Corporation 494 SCRA 493 (2006)
2. Feliciano vs. Commission on Audit, 464 Phil. 439 (2004)
3. Premium Marble Resources, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 264 SCRA 11 (1996)
4. BA Savings Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 336 SCRA 484 (2000)
5. Islamic Directorate of the Philippines, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 272 SCRA 454 (1997)
6. Reyes vs. Tan 3 SCRA 198 (1961)
7. Calatagan Golf Club, Inc. vs. Clemente, Jr. 585 SCRA 300 (2009)
8. Bulakhidas vs. Navarro, 142 SCRA 1 (1986)
9. DMRC Enterprises vs. Este Del Sol Mountain Reserve, Inc., 132 SCRA 293 (1984)
10. Securities and Exchange Commission vs. Performance Foreign Exchange Corporation
495 SCRA 579 (2006)

Salles
1. Spouses Ramon Nisce vs. Equitable PCI Bank 516 SCRA 231 (2007)
2. Albert vs. University Publishing Company, Inc., 13 SCRA 84 (1965)
3. Esquerra vs. Court of Appeals, 267 SCRA 380 (1997)
4. Security Bank and Trust Co. vs. Cuenca, 341 SCRA 781 (2000)
5. Tang Eng Kee vs. Court of appeals and Benguet Lumber Company, 341 SCRA 740
(2000)
6. Republic Bank vs. Cuaderno, 19 SCRA 671. (1976)
7. Republic vs. Sandiganbayan, 199 SCRA 39 (1991)
8. Antam Consolidated, Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 143 SCRA 534 (1986)
9. Development Bank of the Philippines vs. Ilustre, Jr., 138 SCRA 11 (1985)
10. Philippine Association of Stock Transfer and Registry Agencies, Inc. v. CA et al. 539
SCRA 61 (2007)
Santos
1. Pasricha v. Don Luis Dison Realty, Inc. 548 SCRA 273 (2008)
2. MISCI-NACUSIP Local Chapter vs. National Wages and Productivity Commission, 269
SCRA 173 (1997)
3. Traders Royal Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 269 SCRA 19 (1997)
4. Atrium Management Corp. vs. Court of Appeals, 353 SCRA 23 (2001)
5. Pilipinas Loan Company, Inc. vs. Securities and Exchange Commission, 356 SCRA 193
(2001)
6. San Miguel Corporation vs. Kahn, 176 SCRA 73 (1991)
7. Bitong vs. Court of Appeals, 292 SCRA 503 (1998)
8. Converse Rubber Corporation vs. Universal Rubber Products Inc., 147 SCRA 154
(1987)
9. Banez vs. Dimensional Construction Trade and Development Corporation, 140 SCRA
249 (1985)
10. Eustacio Atwel, et al. vs. Conception Progressive Association, Inc. 551 SCRA 272
(2008)

Tan
1. Ryuichi Yamamoto vs. Nishino Leather Industries, Inc. and Ikuo Nishino 551 SCRA 447
(2008)
2. Samahan ng Optometrists vs. Acebedo International Corporation, 270 SCRA 298
(1997);
3. Acebedo Optical Company, Inc. 381 SCRA 293 (2002)
4. Western Institute of Technology, Inc. vs. Salas, 278 SCRA 216, (1997)
5. Safic Alcan & Cie vs. Imperial Vegetable Co., Inc., 355 scra 559 (2001)
6. Heirs of Antonio Pael vs. Court of Appeals, 371 SCRA 587 (2001)
7. Western Institute of Technology, Inc. vs. Salas, 278 SCRA 216 (1997)
8. Boman Environment Development Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 167 SCRA 540
(1988)
9. Wang Laboratories, Inc. vs. Mendoza, 156 SCRA 44 (1987)
10. Dy vs. The National Labor Relations Commission, 145 SCRA 211 (1986)

Tubosa
1. Virgilio S. Delima vs. Susan Mercaida Gois 554 SCRA 731 (2008)
2. Islamic Directorate of the Philippines vs. Court of Appeals, 272 SCRA 454 (1997)
3. Bitong vs. Court of Appeals, 292 SCRA 503 (1998)
4. Nakpil vs. Intercontinental Broadcasting Corporation, 379 SCRA 653 (2002)
5. Benito vs. SEC G.R. No. L-56655, July 35, 1983
6. Edward J. Nell Company vs. Pacific Farms, Inc., 15 SCRA 415 (1965)
7. N.V. Reederij Amsterdam vs. Commissioner on International Revenue, 162 SCRA 487
(1988)
8. Abejo vs. Dela Cruz, 149 SCRA 654 (1987)
 9. Baviera vs. Standard Chartered Bank, et al. 515 SCRA 170 (2007)
10. New Frontier Sugar Corporation vs. RTC of Ilo-ilo and Equitable PCI Bank 513 SCRA
601 (2007)

Villanueva
1. Seaoil Petroleum Corporation v. Autocorp Group, et al. G.R. No. 164326, 569 SCRA 387
(2008)
2. International Express Travel & Tours vs. Court of Appeals, 373 SCRA 474 (2002)
3. Tan Wing Talk vs. Makasiar, 350 SCRA 475 (2001)
4. Great Asian Sales Center Corporation vs. Court of Appeals, 381 SCRA 557 (2002)
5. Dee vs. SEC G.R. No. L-60502, July 16, 1991
6. Lim vs. Lim Yu, 352 SCRA 216 (2001)
7. Associated Bank vs. Court of Appeals, 291 SCRA 511
8. Schmid & Oberly Inc. vs. RJL Martinez Fishing Corporation, 166 SCRA 493 (1988)
9. Malayan Intergrated Industries Corporation vs. Mendoza, 154 SCRA 548. (1987)
a. Please see Reyes vs. RTC of Makati, infra.

-----------------------------------------------