Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
5, 2006
Kinetics of dissolution of silver present in precious metal scraps in HNO3 was studied in temperature range of
26∼85◦ C. Dissolution rate of silver was much faster than that of copper at all temperatures. Effects of particle
size, stirring speed, acid concentration and temperature on the rate of dissolving of silver were evaluated.
Dissolution rate decreases with particle size and increases with temperature. Dissolving was accelerated with
acid concentrations less than 10 mol/L. Concentrations greater than 10 mol/L resulted in slowing down of the
dissolution rate. Shrinking core model with internal diffusion equation t/τ =1−3(1−x)2/3 +2(1−x) could be
used to explain the mechanism of the reaction. Silver extraction resulted in activation energies of 33.95 kJ/mol
for Ag-Au0.04 -Cu0.10 and 68.87 kJ/mol for Ag-Cu0.23 particles. Inter-diffusion of silver and nitrate ions through
the porous region of the insoluble alloying layer was the main resistance to the dissolving process. Results
were tangible for applications in recycling of the material from electronic silver-bearing scraps, dental alloys,
jewelry, silverware and anodic slime precious metal recovery.
KEY WORDS: Silver; Copper; Kinetics, Dissolution; Shrinking core model; Internal diffusion
reactions[6,12] .
3Ag(s)+4HNO3 (aq) → 3AgNO3 (l)+NO(g)+2H2 O(l)
(1)
Ag(s) + 2HNO3 (aq) → AgNO3 (l) + NO2 (g) + H2 O(l)
(2)
With alloy compositions and nitric acid concentra-
tions used in this investigation, Reactions (1) and (2)
are spontaneous at room temperature. Sum of the
two reactions is as follows:
4Ag(s) + 6HNO3 (aq) → 4AgNO3 (l) +
NO(g) + NO2 (g) + 3H2 O(l) (3)
At high nitric acid concentrations, the following reac-
tions may also become feasible[7∼9] :
2Cu(s)+4HNO3 (aq) → Cu(NO3 )2 (aq)+
Cu(NO2 )2 (aq) + 2H2 O(l) (4)
Cu(NO2 )2 (aq) + 2HNO3 (aq) →
Fig.3 Effect of temperature on extraction: (a) silver and Cu(NO3 )2 (aq) + 2HNO2 (aq) (5)
(b) copper from Ag-Cu0.23 alloy having a particle
size of 75∼150 µm with 10.4 mol/L HNO3 and a Cu(s) + HNO3 (aq) + HNO2 (aq) →
stirring rate of 250 r/min Cu(NO2 )2 (aq) + H2 O(l) (6)
Cu(NO2 )2 (aq) + 2HNO3 (aq) →
Cu(NO3 )2 (aq) + 2HNO2 (aq) (7)
HNO2 (aq) + HNO3 (aq) → 2NO2 (g) + H2 O(l) (8)
Cu(s)+4HNO3 (aq) → Cu(NO3 )2 (aq)+
2NO2 (g) + 2H2 O(l) (9)
Dissolution reaction of silver depends on the ni-
tric acid concentration. With a dilute acid, Eq.(1)
is applicable. With a concentrated one, Eq.(2) pro-
ceeds further. For simplicity, we chose Eq.(3), which
Fig.4 Effect of temperature on fractional extraction of is a combination of two reactions. With nitric acid,
silver from Ag-Cu0.23 and Ag-Au0.04 -Cu0.10 alloys HNO2 has a catalytic effect on dissolution of copper.
leached with 10.4 mol/L HNO3 at 250 r/min. The Nitrogen dioxide can react with water to form nitric
data on ternary alloys are from literature [6] acid (compare Eqs.(8) and (9)). We have, therefore,
chosen Eq.(9) for our evaluations.
The standard Gibbs free energy change (∆G◦ ) in
Table 1 Thermodynamic properties of substances at Reactions (1)∼(9) can be determined from ∆Hf◦ and
298 K and 105 Pa[27] S ◦ data of compounds and elements (see Table 1).
Substance ∆Hf◦ /(kJ/mol) S ◦ /(J/mol·K)
Standard Gibbs free energies in Reactions (3) and (9)
Ag(s) 0 42.68
are, thus, obtained to be −209.06 and −196.20 kJ/mol
Cu(s) 0 33.14 at 298 K and 105 Pa, respectively. If all activities are
AgNO3 (l) −124.52 140.92 considered unity, the reactions seem spontaneous at
Cu(NO3 )2 (aq) −350 193 room conditions. Figure 3 shows that Reaction (3) is
HNO2 (aq) −119 46.1 more favorable than Reaction (9) under the experi-
HNO3 (aq) −207 53.5 mental conditions used in this research. Therefore, it
H2 O(l) −286 69.95 is logically reasonable to assume the activity of silver
NO(g) 90.2 211 greater than that of copper and gold.
NO2 (g) 33.2 240 Reactions (1)∼(3) require NO− 3 /Ag
+
ion trans-
port between the reaction-site and the bulk-liquid
indicates that the presence of gold in the scrap has phase. The experimental data obtained in this re-
an increasing effect on the rate of extraction of sil- search were used to check the different kinetic mod-
ver especially at lower temperatures. This implies a els available for solid-fluid reactions[26] . Since copper
positive interaction parameter of gold on silver in Ag- and gold do not favor reaction with HNO3 at room
Au0.04 -Cu0.10 alloys employed in this study[25] . temperature, a porous metallic layer composed of Cu
The closest kinetic mechanism indicates the op- (and Au) remains on the surface of the un-reacted Ag-
timal condition for maximum recovery of silver from Cu0.23 (or Ag-Au0.04 -Cu0.10 ) core. The radius of the
silver containing metallic objects. From thermody- scrap grains does not, therefore, considerably change
namics, the spontaneity of the dissolution process can with advancement of the reaction.
be predicted. The dissolution reaction of the impure Pore diffusion control with constant particle-size
alloys in nitric acid can be expressed by several typical gave the best answer with correlation coefficients
J. Mater. Sci. Technol., Vol.22 No.5, 2006 699
greater than 0.96. For spherical particles having the
average initial radius of R0 , the total conversion time
τ is defined by the following equation.
ρa R02
τ= (10)
6bDe cA
t
= 1 − 3(1 − x)2/3 + 2(1 − x) (11)
τ
Silver dissolution plot on the right side of Eq.(11) is
depicted against time in Fig.5. Regression analyses
of the data indicated correlation values of 0.99 at dif-
ferent temperatures. Other model correlations were Fig.6 Effect of initial radius on the total extraction time
plotted against time. No cases gave better straight of silver from Ag-Au0.04 -Cu0.10 alloy
lines than those in Fig.5.
The data plotted in Fig.2 confirms the above con- tortuosity are two important factors that affect the
clusion. As it is seen, the size of the alloy particles amount of the diffusion coefficient in porous regions.
has a substantial effect on the extraction rate of the De = D(Ag+ /NO− ) εθ (12)
silver. In order to assess the quantitative relationship 3
between the total conversion time and the average where DAg+ /NO− is bulk inter-diffusion coefficient; ε
size of the particles, the slopes of the curves shown in 3
is porosity and θ is the tortuosity coefficient of the
Fig.5 were plotted vs R0−2 , as shown in Fig.6. The porous region.
straight line regression equation was found to have a Bulk diffusion coefficient of AgNO3 in aqueous
correlation factor of 0.98. It was, therefore, assessed HNO3 media is reported to be 1.71×10−5 cm2 /s at
once more that the silver dissolution from the alloys
room temperature[28] . The inter-diffusion coefficients
into the nitric acid was controlled by diffusion.
obtained in this research are mush smaller than this.
The effective internal diffusion coefficient De was Considerable difference between these coefficients in-
estimated from Eq.(10). The density of the Ag- dicates significant influence of the electrochemical and
Au0.04 -Cu0.10 scrap is nearly 11.03 g/cm3 while that geometrical characteristics of the present porous sys-
of Ag-Cu0.23 is about 10.25 g/cm3 (estimated from tem.
densities of pure elements with an ideal solution AgNO3 has lower solubility at higher acid con-
model). The average initial size of the filings was used centrations (cHNO3 ≥10 mol/L). Solid precipitate
from the sieve analyses data. The results obtained may thus partially block the reaction front at
was De =7.59×10−7 cm2 /s for Ag-Au0.04 -Cu0.10 and cHNO3 ≥10 mol/L. Rate controlling mechanism can
5.76×10−7 cm2 /s for Ag-Cu0.23 scrap at room tem- hence locally change from pore diffusion into transfer
perature. in solid phase. The reaction rate is therefore reduced
The radius of Ag+ ions (0.113 nm) is smaller than due to lowering of De inside the porous layer.
that of Ag atoms (0.144 nm). On the contrary, the The frequency factor and the activation energy of
radius of NO− 3 ions (0.200 nm) is larger. Consider- dissolution of silver are thus determined using the Ar-
ing geometry of the system, it may be concluded that rhenius law.
the pore diffusion for Ag+ /NO− 3 ions is not easy for De = D0 e−Q/RT (13)
their transfer within the bulk phase. Porosity and
700 J. Mater. Sci. Technol., Vol.22 No.5, 2006