Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A Nielsen BuzzMetrics White Paper by Pete Blackshaw and Mike Nazzaro | Second Edition, Spring 2006
1.877.999.7335 www.nielsenbuzzmetrics.com
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101
Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
numbers grow each day. On the Internet, word-of-mouth The Marketing Impact:
behavior leaves a digital, archived trail—one that can now
be measured and transformed into market research and
New Challenges, New Sources, New Measures
intelligence. Marketers, as a breed, are accustomed to guiding and
controlling marketing efforts, research and outreach. They
CGM also has emerged as a new source of news (i.e., assume marketing emanates primarily from the marketing
political and activist blogs) and is influencing the concept department. They assemble focus groups. They launch
of “search.” Type in any brand name or product into a surveys. They test concepts and copy, they arrange for
Google or Yahoo! search engine, for example, and you’re and expect orderly feedback to help them plan better and
just as likely to find a consumer-owned Web site, blog or tap the public’s pulse. Information travels predictably:
online forum about that product (positive or negative) as from them and back to them.
you are to find the corporate or brand Web site. The same
high-ranked links that marketers work so hard to achieve The Internet and CGM, however, throw that paradigm
often share the same real estate with heavily-trafficked to the wind. Web-enabled CGM is a mixture of fact
consumer-generated links and personal Web sites, yet the and opinion, impression and sentiment, founded and
CGM links often carry higher credibility and trust. So what unfounded tidbits, experiences, even rumors. It is created
does this mean for marketers? by, shared by and absorbed by other consumers, for other
consumers. What separates it from traditional marketing
intelligence is that most of it is unsolicited, unfiltered and
outside traditional marketers’ ability to contain or control
it. It exists primarily as a medium that allows consumers
to communicate directly with other consumers—not with
CGM Escalation: The Role of Search the companies or marketers who are trying to capture
their attention. Most importantly, it plays a growing role
in shaping consumer purchase behavior, especially as
consumers increasingly place their buying power and trust
in other consumers rather than other forms of media and
marketing.
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Indeed, marketers’ abilities to understand online behavior
needs to be adaptable, because consumers’ behaviors
expand over time and with experience and technological The Evolution of CGM Vehicles
evolution. If today’s camera-cell phone technologies
already are raising privacy issues, what will tomorrow’s
technological wonders bring?
Advanced Chat
& Phone-Enabled
The Internet: A New Shopping Experience
High Penetration
It’s important for marketers to understand how the
Internet Forums Blogs
Internet has fundamentally shaped and changed the shop- & Ratings
ping experience from the consumer’s point of view. No
longer limited by bricks-and-mortar shopping encounters, Mobile Camera
the pendulum has fully shifted as consumers turn to the Better Sharing Forums
Internet
Internet for actual purchases and pre-shopping informa- Forums
Low Penetration
tion. They use the Internet to read about products, shop Consumer-Created
around for prices and sales, determine price ranges, Internet Chat, AIM Ad Copy
Forums
and compare what’s available from different online and
traditional retailers.
Ninety percent, in fact, have used an Internet search Early Stage Internet Recent Internet
engine to research a product or service (Source: Pew
Internet & American Life Project, December 2005). More
CGM vehicles are quickly evolving to higher-impact,
than 75% of car buyers cite word-of-mouth recommenda- multi-media formats. Digital photos and online videos
tions as most influential in their purchase decisions, are beginning to dramatically raise the stakes for brand/
and many of those recommendations emanate from corporate reputation.
thousands of online car forums and discussion boards.
Moreover, they use the Internet to consult with other
consumers by reading opinion sites where consumers
post reviews and personal experiences about specific
products, companies or brands. They browse or engage in Why Internet Insights
discussion boards where active consumers share informa- are Important to Marketers
tion freely, sometimes daily and frequently with passion
And as every marketer learns in Marketing 101, word-
and influence. They use the Internet to give feedback to
of-mouth is already an important factor in consumer
companies or ask questions before they buy so that they
behavior and purchase patterns. In fact, word-of-mouth
feel comfortable making a final transaction and sale.
has a reputation as the most trusted and reliable form of
advertising—a finding that was bolstered by a 2003-2004
But importantly for marketers, consumers turn to the
Nielsen BuzzMetrics survey about trust levels in various
Internet for influence—good and bad. They view it as a
advertising formats. As and it grows in volume and abun-
trusted, third-party, independent source of information
dance, so does its influence–all at a time when traditional
that’s populated by other consumers—consumers who
forms of advertising (especially television) are becoming
can share their “been there, done that” experiences.
less trusted, less dominant and more fragmented by the
According to Nielsen BuzzMetrics research, more than
boom in media outlets and consumers’ growing tendency
60% of consumers trust other consumers’ online post-
toward “media multi-tasking,” which might involve watch-
ings. These online consumers are important to marketers
ing TV while simultaneously cruising the Internet.
precisely because they are so active and so influential.
They are not the typical focus group. They are not the
CGM is also measurable. Because it exists and thrives
folks typically found in rep-panel research. They are
on the Internet, online word of mouth leaves a “digital
talkative, active consumers who try new products first
trail,” so to speak, allowing its content to be located,
and have no qualms about sharing and spreading their
categorized, analyzed and understood for basic data and
experiences among other consumers. They are highly
trends, sentiment, polarity and experience. More than
active and highly influential teens, stable middle-agers
many traditional types of market research, it provides
and growing numbers of seniors. Some describe them as
unclouded, real-life entry into the minds of consumers.
“viral” consumers because they spread their opinion and
influence rapidly among consumers.
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Where do Consumers
Hang Out on the Internet?
Not all Internet players are the same, either in size, influence
or reach. But consumers tend to migrate to specific and
well-defined areas of the Internet when looking for information
that’s important to themselves and, ultimately, to marketers.
• Large Internet Portals: The largest players • Groups/Nanocommunities: These are highly
in the Internet world draw the most consum- focused, highly specialized sites where
ers/viewers, and they fuel most of the aficionados congregate around a single
discussions. These include USENET post- issue, product or item. Groups can be public
ings, and the big Internet Service providers or private, and even though membership is
and portals, such as MSN, Yahoo!, America usually small (tens to hundreds of users),
Online and Google. They represent tens of thousands of such groups can exist on the
millions of Internet users. major Internet Service Provider and search
Web sites that host them.
• Verticals: These are industry- or interest-
focused areas of the Internet that draw • Web Logs, or “Blogs”: A growing sphere
consumers based on a particular product, of influence involves blogs, short for “Web
specialty or niche. Typically, they draw logs.” These are self-published online
consumers interested in specific products diaries or commentary sites, many of
(automobiles, computers, electronics, which provide regular updates on various
software) or issues (politics, baby/parenting, topics, issues and themes. Most blogs are
lifestyle, travel, etc.) They represent millions maintained by an individual or collaboratively
of users. by an organization or group.
• The Clubs/Microcommunities: These are • Third-party Web sites: Small but active
sites or online groups where fans and enthu- groups of consumers gather at third-party
siasts of particular products, personalities, sites that offer the ability to complain (com-
companies or brands hang out and share plaints.com), review/rate products (epinions.
information, likes, dislikes. They can range com) and provide feedback to companies
from celebrity fan clubs to stamp collectors online. They often represent early-warning
clubs to automotive owners’ sites to book experiences and behaviors, especially if
clubs. Users are in the tens of thousands. consumers turn to them first to report and
share information.
*USENET is a broad term that describes a network of public-access links on the Internet where people share,
post and read information
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Consumer-generated media on the Internet holds key • Benchmark a product/service/company against major
insights for marketers. Because it represents candid and competitors, and use information for competitive
unsolicited feedback, Internet discussion is untainted, advantage
unfiltered and unbiased by marketers. With Internet
insights, marketers can: • Spur product development, feeding it with immediate
real-time feedback, suggestions, alternative-use ideas
and product-testing insights
• Intuitively discover the “right” questions for supple-
mental research. Often, the best question asked in • Gather product suggestions, alternate uses and
any one-on-one or small-setting interview is the last enhancements offered by consumers
one: “What haven’t I asked about that I should have?”
On the Internet, that information often emerges first • Spot damaging issues/rumors quickly, many of which
because it is driven by the consumer’s deepest needs originate today on the Internet
and emotions, not the interviewer’s timetable or focus
• Intervene quickly if potential problems are mentioned,
• Understand emerging issues, trends and themes by circulated or spotted on the Internet. (See Case Studies
studying and listening in to consumers’ real-time experi- on Page 12)
ences
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
CGM is the Most Trusted Form of Advertising
• Do consumers speak highly of your company or brand, • Does your company/brand have a system in place to
or do their conversations tend to exist as if you didn’t? notify key personnel of trends, rumors, changes, new
information?
• Is sentiment positive or negative? Changing or shifting
over time? Full of emotion or eerily dull?
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Phase Two: Identify and Flag Key Issues • Can internal processes be changed to help facilitate
Once you have a marketing intelligence plan in place to clearer understanding of online behavior (e.g., can CRM
identify Internet buzz, expand it by looking critically and data be guided or forwarded differently? Can lingering
strategically so that you find the information you need, issues be dealt with on the Web site? Can frequently
want and can act upon. Internal data and findings can asked questions be answered automatically?)
guide your assumptions, but those assumptions can be
altered and changed because of what is found on the Phase Three: Deepen Relationship Marketing Efforts
Internet. In order to market effectively and intelligently, you need
to know your audience. According to research, 70% of
Again, here are some questions to ask as you get consumers who give feedback to a company are active
started: on Internet discussion boards and forums, making them
a key target for outreach. Once you’ve pinpointed active
• Which issues fuel the most Internet discussion? online consumers, take time to get to know them and
their habits by offering opt-in programs that allow them to
• Which issues inspire the most emotional online discus- engage further, on their terms. Questions to ask include:
sion? (Is it, for example, customer service? Price? An
ad campaign? A celebrity spokesperson? Unmet expec- • How often do you tell others of your shopping/buying/
tations? Product availability? A rumor? The company brand experiences?
president’s latest public faux pas?)
• How often do you visit Internet discussion boards?
• What issues are most likely to prompt consumers to
spread information to others? • How much time you spend consulting Internet ratings/
reviews/opinion sites?
• Do topics and issues change over time? Can you track
the changes and trends? • What sites or blogs do you consider to be the most
credible? Influential?
• Which issues or topics spread faster than others?
• How likely are you to act or change your behavior based
• Which issues deserve the most attention/intervention on what another Web site or online consumer says?
from marketers?
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer
Exploit Your Own Web Site
Some companies want only bare-bones information on Examples of Influential CGM
their Web sites on the theory that too many questions
or inquiries from pesky consumers just mean more
Subservient Chicken
work. Web sites, in fact, can be classified into several
camps, depending on how well they treat CGM. Does the In April of 2004, a Web site called
site enable CGM by inviting feedback? Does it sponsor The Subservient Chicken took the
forums and discussion opportunities? Does it neutralize blogosphere by storm, moving from
potentially damaging information? Indeed, truly intelligent, obscurity to an astounding 46 million
tuned-in companies consider the company/brand Web visits in the first week, thanks almost
site a gathering place that invites consumers in and entirely to online “buzz marketing.”
makes them feel at home in a way that respects and Within a day of launch, in fact,
fuels positive, external buzz. The Web site should be your BuzzMetrics’ BlogPulse tracking tool ranked www.subser-
company’s/brand’s face to the world, as well as an ear to
vientchicken.com as the top-linked Web site among highly
the ground and a gut check for trends and watch-outs.
active blog writers.
Web-site Tips for Internet-Savvy Marketers On the Web site, a guy in a chicken costume acted out
commands typed by visitors into a text box. The site was
• Make sure all the right information is on your Web site created by Burger King’s Crispin Porter + Bugusky agency
and updated regularly to promote the food chain’s new chicken sandwich,
and it included pass-along links, TV clips, photos and a
• Answer all questions from consumers, quickly
downloadable chicken mask. The Subservient Chicken
• Be up front and candid about difficult questions/issues, was one of the first online-only campaigns fueled almost
too entirely by consumers, bloggers and others willing to
pass it digitally around the Internet because of its
• Establish a great first impression. (Ask yourself this uniqueness. It falls into the category of trail-blazing CGM.
question: If your Web site were a person, who would it
be? Someone friendly? Warm and fuzzy? Helpful and
Super Bowl Integration
reassuring? Or someone Cold? Gnarly? Bureaucratic?)
For some brands, a TV ad during the Super Bowl game
• Consider your Web site to be a subtle (or not so) form remains the largest single-day expense for TV air
of marketing time. And between the 2005 and 2006 Super Bowls,
something big happened: more than half of the 2006
brands that advertised during the Super Bowl somehow
Reach Out to Consumers
integrated their online and offline efforts. TV viewers
Rather than assume your Web site is easy to navigate and were directed to a brand Web site or a stand-alone Web
find information, set it up and design it so that it offers a
site where they could find more: more information, video
way to identify and build relationships with the consumers
links, promotions and other goodies. It was a marked
and potential customers who visit it. For example:
change from 2005, when only a handful of advertisers
coordinated the multi-million-dollar TV spots with their
• Enable word-of-mouth and referral programs with easy
Web-site campaigns. In addition, at least five separate
send-a-link functions
Web sites featured links that allowed Internet visitors to
• Segment particularly positive or high-value customers play the TV ads on their computers or download them to
and treat them as special ambassadors by offering video players—a first for the Super Bowl.
loyalty programs, members hip clubs, special offers,
survey possibilities and the like.
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer 10
Know that unsatisfied visitors to your Web site go away
from you and migrate to the broader Internet community
Buzzmetrics provides the technology and applications that
for commiseration. Why not let them get it off their chest
on your site and be satisfied? can help marketers understand consumer “buzz” on the
Internet and its various information sources, with tools such
Ask for feedback. More than anything, consumers often as BrandPulse, the BlogPulse.com search engine/analysis
just want to feel that someone is listening. portal, and issue-specific research reports. Singularly, they
are powerful tools. Combined, they provide a 360-degree
Just as consumers gain new tools to educate, information
and arm themselves, marketers also need the technology of consumer intelligence never before possible. In today’s
and tools to stay apace for critical purposes: research, technologically advanced, Web-enabled world, they are
market information, trend analysis, rumor detection, emerging as critical tools to help marketers carry out the
product launch and research, consumer understanding,
principles and practices of their profession.
loyalty programs and promotions and much more.
8000
In Dealerships $5/day Lease Model X Sales
7000 Pricing Announced
Incentives Model X Buzz
TV/Print Ads Begin
6000
Positive Sentiment
Auto Show Debut
# of Messages
Magazine
2000 Award
1000
Jan 04 Feb 04 Mar 04 Apr 04 May 04 Jun 04 Jul 04 Aug 04 Sep 04 Oct 04 Nov 04 Dec 04
Not only can CGM be quantified, it can be tracked and linked to specific marketing and ad campaigns,
product launches, offers, news events and industr y fluctuations. This exhibit shows how var ying
degrees of Internet buzz—by volume, by sentiment, by model—correlate with key marketing events for
an auto client.
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer 11
Case Studies
Which companies and brands benefit from Internet
capabilities? And how does the ability to understand
Internet content play out? Consider these scenarios:
Wireless Industry
Issue: Wireless consumers discover a code that allows them to steal pre-paid minutes
from one of the nation’s largest wireless carries, and they begin sharing it freely on
Internet discussion boards.
Entertainment
Issue: A major movie studio needs advice on positioning a marketing campaign for its
blockbuster summer film.
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer 12
56 West 22nd Street | Third Floor | New York, NY 10010 | 1.877.999.7335 | www.nielsenbuzzmetrics.com
Consumer-Generated Media (CGM) 101: Word-of-Mouth in the Age of the Web-Fortified Consumer 13