Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Organization of Spreadsheet:
Descriptions - explains the spreadsheet cells
FMEA - the actual sheet used to enter data
Severity/Likelihood/Detectability - guidelines for the 1-10 rankins in these categories
Example - a partial exmample of an FMEA document
Sheet Protection:
Some sheets are protected. There is no password. Released for review: 31-Jul-98
A. Dembski rev 1
Descriptions
Action Results
Potential P
New RPN
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S D R Responsibility &
Potential Failure Potential Effect(s) Cause(s)/ r Current Design Recommended
Item / Function e e P Target Completion Actions Taken
Mode(s) of Failure Mechanism(s) of o Controls Action(s)
v t N Date
Failure b
0 0
Coolant Crack/break. Leak 8 Over pressure 8 Burst, validation 1 64 Test included in J.P. Aguire 0
containment. Burst. Side wall pressure cycle. prototype and 11/1/95 E. Eglin
Hose connection. flex. Bad seal. production 8/1/96
Coolant fill. M Poor hose rete validation testing.
0 0
Write down each failure mode 0 Response Plans and Tracking 0
and potential consequence(s) 0 0
of that failure. 0 0
0
RiskPriority Number - The combined weighting of 0
Severity - On a scale of 1- Severity, Likelihood, and Detectability.
10, rate the Severity of each RPN
0 = Sev X Occ X Det 0
failure (10= most severe).
See Severity sheet.
0 0
0 0
Likelihood - Write down the Detectability 0- Examine the current 0
potential cause(s), and on a design, then, 0on a scale of 1-10, rate 0
scale of 1-10, rate the the Detectability of each failure
0 0
Likelihood of each failure (10 = least detectable). See
(10= most likely). See 0
Detectability sheet. 0
Likelihood sheet. 0 0
Page 2
Likelihood - Write down the Detectability - Examine the current
potential cause(s), and on a design, then, on a scale of 1-10, rate
scale of 1-10, rate the the Detectability of each failure
Likelihood of each failure Descriptions
(10 = least detectable). See
(10= most likely). See Detectability sheet.
Likelihood sheet.
0 0
Page 3
Severity
None No effect 1
Page 4
Probability
Page 5
Detectability
Page 6
EXAMPLE
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Potential Failure
Item / Function
Mode(s)
Seals
Coolant
containment.
Hose
connection.
Coolant fill. M
Sensor mount. Compression set
Seal
Sensor mount. Loosen during
Seal sensor
assembly/servic
e
Page 7
EXAMPLE
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Potential Failure
Item / Function
Mode(s)
Page 8
EXAMPLE
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Potential Failure
Item / Function
Mode(s)
Page 9
EXAMPLE
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
0
0
Failed mount 5 Vibration 9 Vibration w/road 3 135 Obtain GMB J.P. Aguire
tapes vibration road tape.
Hose leak 6 Overpressure. Poor 5 Burst, validation 2 60 Obtain GMB clamps J.P. Aguire 12/1/95
clamp pressure cycle and clamping
w/GMB clamps. specification.
Page 10
EXAMPLE
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
Leak. Loss of heat 8 Wicking. Material 7 Thermal cycle 1 56 Included in Product E. Eglin 8/1/96
transfer. strength Specification
Air conditioning does this is a test while 0
not work. Sudden dan is here
refrigerant loss.
Leak. Loss of heat 8 Coolant quality. 7 SWAT, service 5 280 Brazilian coolant to J.P. Aguirre 11/1/95 Coolant ordered
transfer. Contamination. simulation. Coolant be evaluated. Zince
Environment - int/ext. evaluation. lined tubes may
need to be released.
Simulated service
test w/GMB coolant
to be performed.
Leak. Loss of heat 8 External damage. 10 Leak test. Simulated 1 80 100% cores tested in E. Eglin 8/1/96
transfer. Coolant velocity. No service. production.
reinf sawcut. Simulated service
included in Product
Specificatin.
Leak. Loss of heat 5 Environment - int/ext. 1 SWAT, service 1 5 Included in Product E. Eglin 8/1/96
transfer. simulation. Specification.
Leak. Loss of heat 8 Over pressure 2 Burst/leak pressure 5 80 GMB to study engine GMB 12/1/95 Study originated
transfer. contamination. cleanliness.
Page 11
EXAMPLE
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
Loss of heat transfer. 8 Contamination. 7 1 56 GMB coolant to be J.P. Aguirre 11/1/95 Coolant ordered
Leakage due to Coolant quality. evaluated. GMB to
increase flow velocity study engine
cleanliness.
Leak. Loss of heat 5 Over pressure 9 8 360 GMB to study engine GMB 12/1/95
transfer. contamination. cleanliness.
Clustomer profile to
be determined.
0
0
0
Page 12
EXAMPLE
on Results
New RPN
0
0
Page 13
EXAMPLE
on Results
New RPN
Page 14
EXAMPLE
on Results
New RPN
0
0
0
Page 15
BOM ID Component
1 frame
Fork
2
Parts #: 005237
Head brg set
3
Parts #: 019009
Decal set
4
Parts #: 119054
Deck
5
Parts #: 030069
Deck bolts
6
Parts #: 030033
Stem asm.
7
Parts #: 011083
Handlebar
8
Parts #: 009078
Pad
9
Parts #: 105048
Grip
10
Parts #: 015038
Mag whl 14
11
Parts #: 045027
Tire
12
Parts #: 040039
Tube
13
Parts #: 041025
14 removed from the design
Brake lever
15
Parts #: 024042
Cbl/scng
16
Parts #: 025530
Brake shoe
17
Parts #: 12114
Rr calipher
18
Parts #: 023535
F.axl/brg st
19
Parts #: 053029
Nuts/rtnr
20
Parts #: 055006
comments
cable
FMEA SCOOTER
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Decal set
4
Parts #: 119054
Deck Lose aderence
5 Parts #: 030069
Page 19
FMEA SCOOTER
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Tube Flattening
13
Parts #: 041025
Brake lever Detaching from
15
Parts #: 024042 brake cable
Cbl/scng Break the cable
16
Parts #: 025530
Brake shoe Detaching from
17
Parts #: 12114 brake cable
Rr calipher Break during ride
18
Parts #: 023535
F.axl/brg st Break during ride
19
Parts #: 053029
Nuts/rtnr Detach from axis
20
Parts #: 055006
Page 20
FMEA SCOOTER
System
Subsystem
Component
Design Lead
Core Team
Page 21
FMEA SCOOTER
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
Handlebar may Exposure to severe Select resistant pad 4 36 Select more resistant
break causing an 9 weather conditions 1 handlebar material
accident
Rider may lose its Rubber wear Use of resistant 3 36 Select more resistant
grip 4 3 material for grip material
Rider may find Mag wheel hit Design it as retracted 5 60 Design more
dificulty on riding the 4 3 as possible - away retracted and
scooter from exterior hits resistant mag wheel
Rider may find Some sharp object Resistant material 3 72 Select more resistant
4 6
dificulty on riding the within the wheel material
scooter
Page 22
FMEA SCOOTER
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
Rider may find Some sharp object Resistant material 3 72 Select more resistant
4 6
dificulty on riding the within the wheel material
scooter
Fail on brakes Brake cables not Holding pin or device 6 54 Design pin dam or
9 1
tight enough hold
Fail on brakes Poor material Resistant material 5 45 Select more resistant
9 1
material
Fail on brakes Brake cables not Holding pin or device 6 54 Select more resistant
9 1
tight enough material
Fail on brakes Poor material Resistant material 4 36 Select more resistant
9 1
material
Wheel instability Poor material Resistant material 4 36 Select more resistant
9 1
material
Wheel instability Screws not tight Proper nut and 4 36 Select proper nut
9 1
enough screws set and screw set
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Page 23
FMEA SCOOTER
Action Results
New Occ
New Sev
New Det
S Potential Cause(s)/ D R Responsibility &
Potential Effect(s) r Current Design Recommended
e Mechanism(s) of e P Target Completion Actions Taken
of Failure o Controls Action(s)
v Failure t N Date
b
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Page 24
FMEA SCOOTER
on Results
New RPN
Page 25
FMEA SCOOTER
on Results
New RPN
Page 26
FMEA SCOOTER
on Results
New RPN
Page 27