Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Each organization works towards the realization of one vision. The same is achieved by formulation of
certain strategies and execution of the same, which is done by the HR department. At the base of this
strategy formulation lie various processes and the effectiveness of the former lies in the meticulous
design of these processes. But what exactly are and entails these processes? Let’s read further and
explore.
The efficient designing of these processes apart from other things depends upon the degree of
correspondence of each of these. This means that each process is subservient to other. You start from
Human resource Planning and there is a continual value addition at each step. To exemplify, the PMS
(performance Management System) of an organization like Infosys would different from an organization
like Walmart. Lets study each process separately.
Human Resource Planning: Generally, we consider Human Resource Planning as the process of
people forecasting. Right but incomplete! It also involves the processes of Evaluation, Promotion and
Layoff.
Employee Remuneration and Benefits Administration: The process involves deciding upon salaries
and wages, Incentives, Fringe Benefits and Perquisites etc. Money is the prime motivator in any job and
therefore the importance of this process. Performing employees seek raises, better salaries and bonuses.
Performance Management: It is meant to help the organization train, motivate and reward workers. It is
also meant to ensure that the organizational goals are met with efficiency. The process not only includes
the employees but can also be for a department, product, service or customer process; all towards
enhancing or adding value to them.
Nowadays there is an automated performance management system (PMS) that carries all the information
to help managers evaluate the performance of the employees and assess them accordingly on their
training and development needs.
Employee Relations: Employee retention is a nuisance with organizations especially in industries that
are hugely competitive in nature. Though there are myriad factors that motivate an individual to stick to or
leave an organization, but certainly few are under our control. Employee relations include Labor Law and
Relations, Working Environment, Employee heath and safety, Employee- Employee conflict
management, Employee- Employee Conflict Management, Quality of Work Life, Workers Compensation,
Employee Wellness and assistance programs, Counseling for occupational stress. All these are critical to
employee retention apart from the money which is only a hygiene factor.
All processes are integral to the survival and success of HR strategies and no single process can work in
isolation; there has to be a high level of conformity and cohesiveness between the same.
It is the HRP process which helps the management of the organization in meeting the future demand of
human resource in the organization with the supply of the appropriate people in appropriate numbers at
the appropriate time and place. Further, it is only after proper analysis of the HR requirements can the
process of recruitment and selection be initiated by the management. Also, HRP is essential in
successfully achieving the strategies and objectives of organization. In fact, with the element of strategies
and long term objectives of the organization being widely associated with human resource planning these
days, HR Planning has now became Strategic HR Planning.
Though, HR Planning may sound quite simple a process of managing the numbers in terms of human
resource requirement of the organization, yet, the actual activity may involve the HR manager to face
many roadblocks owing to the effect of the current workforce in the organization, pressure to meet the
business objectives and prevailing workforce market condition. HR Planning, thus, help the organization
in many ways as follows:
HR managers are in a stage of anticipating the workforce requirements rather than getting
surprised by the change of events
Prevent the business from falling into the trap of shifting workforce market, a common concern
among all industries and sectors
Work proactively as the expansion in the workforce market is not always in conjunction with the
workforce requirement of the organization in terms of professional experience, talent needs,
skills, etc.
Organizations in growth phase may face the challenge of meeting the need for critical set of skills,
competencies and talent to meet their strategic objectives so they can stand well-prepared to
meet the HR needs
Considering the organizational goals, HR Planning allows the identification, selection and
development of required talent or competency within the organization.
It is, therefore, suitable on the part of the organization to opt for HR Planning to prevent any unnecessary
hurdles in its workforce needs. An HR Consulting Firm can provide the organization with a
comprehensive HR assessment and planning to meet its future requirements in the most cost-effective
and timely manner.
Current HR Supply: Assessment of the current human resource availability in the organization is
the foremost step in HR Planning. It includes a comprehensive study of the human resource
strength of the organization in terms of numbers, skills, talents, competencies, qualifications,
experience, age, tenures, performance ratings, designations, grades, compensations, benefits,
etc. At this stage, the consultants may conduct extensive interviews with the managers to
understand the critical HR issues they face and workforce capabilities they consider basic or
crucial for various business processes.
Future HR Demand: Analysis of the future workforce requirements of the business is the second
step in HR Planning. All the known HR variables like attrition, lay-offs, foreseeable vacancies,
retirements, promotions, pre-set transfers, etc. are taken into consideration while determining
future HR demand. Further, certain unknown workforce variables like competitive factors,
resignations, abrupt transfers or dismissals are also included in the scope of analysis.
Demand Forecast: Next step is to match the current supply with the future demand of HR, and
create a demand forecast. Here, it is also essential to understand the business strategy and
objectives in the long run so that the workforce demand forecast is such that it is aligned to the
organizational goals.
HR Sourcing Strategy and Implementation:After reviewing the gaps in the HR supply and
demand, the HR Consulting Firm develops plans to meet these gaps as per the demand forecast
created by them. This may include conducting communication programs with employees,
relocation, talent acquisition, recruitment and outsourcing, talent management, training and
coaching, and revision of policies. The plans are, then, implemented taking into confidence the
mangers so as to make the process of execution smooth and efficient. Here, it is important to
note that all the regulatory and legal compliances are being followed by the consultants to prevent
any untoward situation coming from the employees.
Hence, a properly conducted process of HR Planning by an HR Consulting Firm helps the organization in
meeting its goals and objectives in timely manner with the right HR strength in action.
This article discusses the typical functions of a HR manager and analyzes how he or she can
make a positive contribution to the organization and add value to the process. First, the HR
manager has to juggle between hiring, training, appraisals, and payroll among other things. This means
that a typical function of the HR manager would encompass the end to end management of the employee
people lifecycle which means that the HR manager would have to take care of everything that is
concerned with the people aspect right from the time the employee enters the organization till the time the
employee quits or retires from the organization. Hence, the lifecycle of an employee’s time in an
organization has to be managed and this means that the HR manager is responsible for the hiring,
training, appraisals, payroll, and exit interviews.
In many organizations, employees can take their grievances to the HR managers in case they are not
satisfied with their pay hikes or the quantum of benefits. They can also complain against their managers
in a confidential and private manner.
The last activity that the HR manager is involved in is conducting the exit interviews when employees
leave the organizations. This is usually done on the last day of the employee’s stay in the organization
and this process consist of a free and frank discussion on what the employee feels about the organization
and why he or she is leaving the organization. The exit interviews offer valuable sources of insights into
organizational behavior as the employees can vent their feelings on what works and what does not work
in organizations
In the US, the situation was that many HR managers were asked to take in as many H1B or temporary
workers to the country on board to meet the critical shortage in staff. In Asia, because of this very reason
where many techies had headed to the US and Europe, hiring became a challenge for even the most
seasoned HR professionals. The implications for the HR manager are many as his or her appraisal
depends on a number of targets including how many they have recruited over the last quarter or the year.
The third aspect of the staffing and hiring activity is that many HR managers during the boom years
advised the line managers to find employees from other divisions who wanted a change in their job
profiles and roles. This internal filling up of positions by inter-division and intra company movement was
effective in many companies like Fidelity. Further, overtime by key resources and hiring temporary
workers were the norm in many companies. Of course, the overtime work was adequately compensated
and employees who were doing so were given additional benefits.
Research into the HRM practices of successful companies has shown that these companies significantly
outperform their peers in terms of economic profitability by following the leadership development practices
discussed in this article. By successful companies, we mean those companies in the Fortune 100 list that
have managed to retain their position in the firms over a decade. To put this in perspective, it needs to be
remembered that many companies that were in the Fortune 100 list for a few years failed to retain their
positions in subsequent years and hence, the fact that these companies have managed to stay in the
hunt means that they have outperformed their peers and competitors.
Research into these successful companies has shown that the people management in these companies
is world class and the contributing factor that differentiates these companies from others is that the HRM
function plays a critical role throughout the employee lifecycle and not at the recruitment and training
phase alone. The other factor is that the leaders in these companies are expected to have skill sets that
match the need for adapting to the challenges of the 21st century business landscape. In other words,
these companies groom the leaders of the future right from the middle management level.
Closing Thoughts
Finally, leadership is a combination of natural abilities and the organizational nurturing of the employees
with those skills. Hence, this interplay between nature and nurture is what determines the success or
otherwise of the HRM function and the senior management efforts to develop leadership in these
companies.
This article discusses a couple of the crucial functions that an HR manager has to perform and
those are related to enabling employees to perform to their potential and empowering the
employees to lead fulfilling careers. In the earlier decades, organizational theory and practice limited
itself to ensuring that employees are well paid and their benefits and other perks taken care of. There was
little by way of ensuring personal fulfillment and job satisfaction. This was because of the predominance
of manufacturing in the economies of the 1970s and the 1980s which meant that the workforce was to be
treated as cogs in the machine instead of assets that the modern day HRM theory and practice follows.
With the advent of the services sector, a branch of HRM known as SHRM or Strategic Human Resource
Management grew in response to the changing profiles of employees and this approach when combined
with the systems approach of management thought meant that the enabling of employees and the
empowerment of employees were the buzzwords for HR managers.
The team members are usually assigned a people manager who performs these tasks and ensures that
the employees are performing to their potential. Moreover, the HR function in conjunction with the line
managers conduct periodic trainings in soft skills like communication, personal relations, and leadership.
Indeed, many organizations like Fidelity have established a set protocol for employees to attend
leadership development trainings that bring out the leaders in them and groom them as future managers
and future CEO’s. Hence, the twin objectives of people empowerment and people enabling are thus met
in this paradigm.
Closing Thoughts
Finally, people enabling is all about gaining insights into the personalities of the employees and matching
them with the organizational requirements. As mentioned earlier, by way of understanding the employees
and their motivations and how well these stack up against organizational goals, the HR managers would
be able to perform the critical function of people enabling that is very much required in contemporary
management practice.
This article analyzes the best talent management practices of successful companies and the role
of the HRM function in nurturing and grooming talent.
In other words, these companies start from the lower levels and go on till the middle and senior
management levels. The third aspect of successful talent management is the provision of both vertical
and horizontal job opportunities for the existing employees. This means that the employees are provided
with a menu of career options that would enable them to shift role and find fulfillment in the role of their
choice. The reason why this aspect is very important is that often many companies stifle their employees
by not providing change of job functions or roles leading to widespread dissatisfaction among the
employees.
Indeed, successful companies often have people first policies where the focus is on creating a stimulated
and fast-paced environment that encourages and fosters individual growth and the work environment is
much more engaging than a workplace that is solely concerned with profits.
Closing Thoughts
Finally, successful companies often have lower attrition rates even if their compensation practices match
the industry standard but are not higher than other companies. In other words, as mentioned in the
introductory paragraph, successful talent management requires all around excellence in the realms of
leadership development, talent management, and performance management. While the first two topics
have been covered, the performance management in successful companies would be covered in the next
article.
Hiring can take place in many ways and at many levels. It can be for entry level positions or “lateral”
hiring where people with experience are taken on board. Further, hiring people can be based on
competitive exams (entry level) and the personal approach favored by HR managers for senior level
positions. In recent times, hiring for the entry level has taken on an entirely new dimension with the
campus recruitment procedures that rely on getting the best talent available from the campuses for
companies wishing to hire for entry level positions. The other way of hiring is through selective approach
where the Staffing department entrusts the placement consultants with the task of identifying potential
employees by picking “profiles” from employee databases and the consultants own database as well.
As outlined above, the different hiring strategies are for different levels in the organization. The most
niche hiring takes place at senior levels where the essence is discreetness and hence dedicated
consultants or HR professionals approach people at higher levels on a one-one basis.
Whatever be the hiring strategy deployed, the essential components of the process remain more or less
the same. These include choosing from the available candidates, taking a decision as to the pay and
perks, making an offer and finally, getting them “on board”. The hiring process ranges from as less a
month or so to drawn out affairs for niche placement. The strategic imperatives that underpin hiring
depend on the ability of the organization to effectively leverage its reputation, flexibility in the roles that
are available, availability of skilled resources and finally, the package that the organization is willing to
offer.
Most debates in organizations on the hiring process hinge on the length of time it takes to hire a person
for a particular role and the package that the organization is willing to offer. The term “fitment” is often
used as HR jargon which is all about whether a particular person is suitable for the role that is being filled
and how well he or she “fits” the job profile. One of the reasons for attrition in organizations is the fact that
many employees join them with a set of assumptions about their role only to have their hopes dashed in
reality. Hence, in recent times, industry experts have focused on this aspect of ensuring that people are
hired only if they are of the right fit.
In conclusion, hiring people is a key component of a company’s internal strategy and hence
something that needs detailed attention and focus. We have touched upon the hiring strategies and the
overview of the process. In subsequent articles, we would explore the topic further.
Moreover, the privacy and the sanctity of information that job applicants post on their Facebook and
SNWs profiles is compromised. There is also the risk of security as once the recruiters get access to the
profiles, information can be hacked by third parties and leaked which means that there are many
implications to this practice. Therefore, it is in the interest of all parties if there are proper safeguards that
are drawn up to protect both the parties and this process is followed diligently. This means that the
recruiters cannot access the SNWs profiles of the candidates without their consent and the job applicants
are aware of their rights and disadvantages of posting personal details on their profiles.
Further, for many positions in the US, job applicants are required to undergo a narcotics test, which
means that they would be medically tested for traces of any narcotic substances in their bodies.
Therefore, a strong world of caution to the job applicants is that they better not reveal what they did last
summer especially when they are applying for highly competitive jobs. For recruiters, the word of advice is
that they rely on the traditional route of background checks by independent agencies and not only on the
SNWs profiles of the job applicants to base their hiring decisions. Finally, whether the information is
private or whether it has been obtained illegally and unethically, the fact that such information exists in the
internet domain is cause enough for concern.
Concluding Thoughts
For all those students and potential corporate employees, here is a piece of advice. Be careful when you
are posting all kinds of stuff on social media as the process of the background checks often involve
parsing through the web and online information provided by the potential recruits. Therefore, the next time
you want to rave about that rave party where you had a gala time, be careful about what you post online
as that can be found during the background check. Finally, remember to be ethical and straightforward
about what you declare on your resumes and application forms as otherwise you might get into trouble
with your dream companies.
Retention Strategies - Definition and its
Components
Any employee retention strategy would necessarily include a plan for redressing employee
grievances and ways and means to address employee issues. This would mean that the employees
would be enabled to take their issues regarding pay, their work, their role etc. to the HR manager for each
division and expect to get a fair hearing in the process. There should be a plan where the HR manager in
conjunction with the manager of the employee who has raised the issue works towards resolving the
issue.
Grievance Redressal
An effective retention strategy would focus on preventing as well as addressing grievances. Though it is
not the contention that all grievances can be prevented, they can be “pre-empted” by actively listening to
the employees from time to time. This strategy of “listening” to the employees would revolve around a
concept of “one-one” meetings between the employees and the manager and employees and the HR
representative for the unit or division. The idea of the regular “one-one” meetings would be to identify
potential causes of friction among the employees and any issues they may have vis-à-vis their job and
benefits. These issues need to be brought out into the open before they become contentious resulting in
the employee feeling frustrated and quitting the job. Hence, all efforts must be made to identify sources of
employee dissatisfaction and “hygiene factors” that must be taken care of for proper functioning of the
employees.
Evolution of SHRM
With the advent of new economy industries like IT and the mushrooming of the service sector,
organizations all over the world realized that human resources must be viewed as a source of competitive
advantage as opposed to treating it much the same way in access to technology or capital is concerned.
What this means is that the practice of HRM is being viewed as something that promotes the business
objectives of the firms and not merely another factor in the way the firm is managed.
The practice of SHRM demands a proactive and hands on approach by the management as well as the
HR department with regards to the entire gamut of activities ranging from staffing and training and
development to mentoring and pay and performance management.
Elaborating on this point, one finds that organizations tend to leverage upon the capabilities of the people
employed there and ensuring that the “human capital” is nourished and nurtured as a source of
competitive advantage. This translates into a dedicated HR department and people managers in every
group dealing exclusively with employee issues as opposed to treating this as a line management
function.
Conclusion
The times when management could arbitrarily dictate terms to the employees and tread upon their rights
is something that is not relevant anymore. With the ballooning of the white collar workforce, it becomes
necessary for organizations to pay more attention to the needs of the employees more than ever. Finally,
the fact that organizations derive their strategy from employees instead of imposing strategy upon them is
the essence of SHRM.
Global Human Resource Management -
Meaning and Objectives
With the advent of globalization, organizations - big or small have ceased to be local, they have become
global! This has increased the workforce diversity and cultural sensitivities have emerged like never
before. All this led to the development of Global Human Resource Management.
Even those organizations who consider themselves immune to transactions across geographical
boundaries are connected to the wider network globally. They are in one way or the other dependent
upon organizations that may even not have heard about. There is interdependence between
organizations in various areas and functions.
The preliminary function of global Human Resource Management is that the organization carries a
local appeal in the host country despite maintaining an international feel. To exemplify, any
multinational / international company would not like to be called as local, however the same wants a
domestic touch in the host country and there lies the challenge.
The strategic role of Human resources Management in such a scenario is to ensure that HRM policies
are in tandem with and in support of the firm’s strategy, structure and controls. Specifically, when we talk
of structures and controls the following become worth mentioning in the context of Global HRM.
Also, the deciding upon the top management or key positions gets very tricky. Whether to choose a local
from the host country for a key position or deploy one from the headquarters assumes importance; and
finally whether or not to have a uniform hiring policy globally remains a big challenge.
Nevertheless an organization can choose to hire according to any of the staffing policies mentioned
below:
Ethnocentric: Here the Key management positions are filled by the parent country individuals.
Polycentric: In polycentric staffing policy the host country nationals manage subsidiaries
whereas the headquarter positions are held by the parent company nationals.
Geocentric: In this staffing policy the best and the most competent individuals hold key positions
irrespective of the nationalities.
Geocentric staffing policy it seems is the best when it comes to Global HRM. The human
resources are deployed productively and it also helps build a strong cultural and informal
management network. The flip side is that human resources become a bit expensive when hired
on a geocentric basis. Besides the national immigration policies may limit implementation.
Global HRM therefore is a very challenging front in HRM. If one is able to strike the right chord in
designing structures and controls, the job is half done. Subsidiaries are held together by global HRM,
different subsidiaries can function operate coherently only when it is enabled by efficient structures and
controls.
In earlier times, the Personnel Manager of a factory or firm was the person in charge of ensuring
employee welfare and interceding between the management and the employees. In recent times, the
term has been replaced with HR manager.
This article looks at the differences in usage and scope of functions as well as the underlying theory
behind these nomenclatures. In the section on introducing HRM, we briefly looked at the main
differences. We shall look into them in more detail here.
Personnel Management
Traditionally the term personnel management was used to refer to the set of activities concerning the
workforce which included staffing, payroll, contractual obligations and other administrative tasks. In this
respect, personnel management encompasses the range of activities that are to do with managing the
workforce rather than resources.
Personnel Management is more administrative in nature and the Personnel Manager’s main job is to
ensure that the needs of the workforce as they pertain to their immediate concerns are taken care of.
Further, personnel managers typically played the role of mediators between the management and the
employees and hence there was always the feeling that personnel management was not in tune with the
objectives of the management.
HRM goes beyond the administrative tasks of personnel management and encompasses a broad
vision of how management would like the resources to contribute to the success of the organization.
Personnel Management and HRM: A Paradigm Shift ?
Cynics might point to the fact that whatever term we use, it is finally “about managing people”. The
answer to this would be that the way in which people are managed says a lot about the approach that the
firm is taking. For instance, traditional manufacturing units had personnel managers whereas the services
firms have HR managers.
While it is tempting to view Personnel Management as archaic and HRM as modern, we have to
recognize the fact that each serves or served the purpose for which they were instituted. Personnel
Management was effective in the “smokestack” era and HRM is effective in the 21st century and this
definitely reflects a paradigm shift in the practice of managing people.
Conclusion
It is clear from the above paragraphs that HRM denotes a shift in focus and strategy and is in tune with
the needs of the modern organization. HRM concentrates on the planning, monitoring and control aspects
of resources whereas Personnel Management was largely about mediating between the management
and employees.
Many experts view Personnel Management as being workforce centered whereas HRM is resource
centered. In conclusion, the differences between these two terms have to be viewed through the prism of
people management through the times and in context of the industry that is being studied.
Organizational Focus
Though the role of the HR manager and the organization seems to be relatively small, it is a fact that
organizational goals and culture play a very important part in ensuring that employee performance is
managed to the benefit of the organization. Most of us have read about or heard the benefits of working
for MNC’s (Multinational Companies) in India. The reason why they are highly talked about is the
perception among potential and aspiring employees that these companies treat their people well. Though
the point here is not to belittle Indian companies, the objective of this section is to highlight the ways in
which organizations can shape the treatment of people in theory and practice.
Conclusion
We have seen the centrality of managing employee performance to the success of the organization. If
organizations want to cut down on attrition and boost sagging employee morale, the first thing they can
do is to ensure that the employee performance management system is streamlined. Only by a focused
approach towards this key driver of organizational effectiveness can the firms ensure that they do not lose
out on the “war for talent” as well as “retention” of achievers.
In a nutshell, the performance appraisal interview precedes the normalization process and is subsequent
to the employee filling up the evaluation form and the manager likewise doing so. The interview is the
stage where both sides debate and argue the employees’ side of the story as well as the manager’s
perception.
Objective Evaluation versus Personal Biases
Though management theorists like to propound the benefits of objective evaluation, it is a fact in
contemporary organizations that an element of personal bias enters the evaluation. This is evident from
the studies and surveys done by HR consultants like Hewitt that point to the employee’s dissatisfaction
with the performance appraisal process as one of the main reasons for leaving the company. To curb the
incidence of biases and heuristics playing a role in the appraisal, HR managers typically conduct
orientations and trainings to both the Managers and the Employees to sensitize them to these dangers
that are sometimes inherent in the process.
On the other hand, the employees’ should approach the process without unrealistic expectations and
expect the Manager to agree to whatever they write on the performance evaluation form. Hence, there is
a need for both sides in the interview process to approach the same with an open mind and be as
objective as possible. However, this is easier said than done and hence organizations expend resources
on making the process as transparent and objective as possible.
Though there is no right way to conduct the performance appraisal interview, it is incumbent upon the
manager to avoid the pitfalls described above. A rule of thumb would be set aside a few days to conduct
all the interviews with members of his or her team and ensure follow-ups to the process. The follow-up is
needed when the employee is not satisfied with the interview discussion and hence requests for
additional time to debate the rating. In some cases, the HR manager may need to step in to ensure that
the process is concluded to the satisfaction of the employee and the manager.
Conclusion
Surveys have shown that nearly 70% of the employees who leave organizations cite the bad rating that
they have got as the reason for quitting and often voice their disappointment at the process in the exit
interview. Hence, there is a need for organizations to smoothen the performance appraisal process and
since the performance appraisal interview is the first step; the beginning must be made well. Since the
career progression of employees depends on the ratings that they get, the whole process must be taken
seriously by all the stakeholders.
The increased growth of workforce diversity has led to a need for continuous changes in HR practices
and policies. Managing human relations has become the most difficult challenge that the managers are
facing today. Conflicts within the organization, small or large have become inevitable. This can be
overcome by developing sound interpersonal and conflict management skills within you.
Furthermore employee relations strategies are made in order to overcome these problems. These
strategies define the objectives of the organization to manage its relationships with employee and all
other organizations. These strategies are aimed at enhancing the overall quality of employee
management and ensuring their participation and continuous improvement.
In today’s times, it is really the toughest business for managers to deal efficiently with employees. Failing
to do so can result in high attrition rate. To retain and get the maximum output from them, managers need
to improve their skills such as active listening, effective communication, acceptability, adaptability,
decision-making and conflict management. These are the core skills that supervisors and managers can
use tactfully to resolve conflicts among employees or between employees and organization.
However developing or improving above mentioned skills does not guarantee a smooth and conflict-free
working environment because conflict is the hard core truth that can not avoided fully. It is but natural to
have conflicts and clashes where different people from different backgrounds and cultures come together
and work. Still, we can focus on developing these skills in order to manage employee relations to the
extent possible:
Employees are the most important assets of any organization-big or small. Managing employee relations
effectively can help organizations achieve their goals faster.
The power of employee recognition can not be underestimated especially when they have thousands of
lucrative opportunities in front of them.
Who doesn’t want to attract, hire and retain the best talents of the industry? Why not explore the new
ways to foster employee motivation and drive them to achieve their targets then? After all an
organization’s performance is directly related to the performance of its human resources. This is a simple
logic; if you make their day, they make your organization.
Employee rewards and recognition system is not just a positive thing to do with people but
communicating it effectively is an efficient tool in encouraging them to create and bring business
for you. Treating your employees like your assets and maintaining harmonious relationships with them
doesn’t only yield business in present but also an effective strategy for future. Employers and
management need to be pro-active to develop a talented and dedicated workforce that can take you to
your goals.
Fulfilling employees’ needs, recognizing their efforts and presenting them with monetary and non-
monetary rewards help you create a right workforce for your organization that can be your partner in
success. Recognition of their efforts and boosting their morale results in increased productivity and
decreased attrition rate. It is a proven fact that the motivated and dedicated workforce can change the
fate of a company. After all, human effort is the biggest contributing factor in success of any organization.
It is just next to impossible to achieve organizational goals only by the efforts of top management. It’s the
workforce who executes their plans and helps them achieve their financial as well as non-financial aims.
Establishing and implementing a reward system needs careful analysis of the company policies and
procedures. Deciding how to recognize employees’ efforts and what to provide them requires thorough
analysis of responsibilities and risks involved in a particular job. Reward system of an organization should
also be in alignment with its goals, mission and vision. Depending upon the job profile, both monetary and
non-monetary rewards can encourage employees to contribute more to the organization.
Monetary Rewards: A raise in salary, incentives, movie tickets, vacation trips, monetary
allowances on special occasions, redeemable coupons, cash bonuses, gift certificates, stock
awards, free or discounted health check-ups for the entire family and school/tuition fees for
employees’ children fall in this category. While designing company policies for monetary rewards,
management should make sure that benefits should be as broad-based as possible. It requires
sound planning and effective implementation.
Non-monetary Rewards: Non-monetary rewards may include trophies, certificates, letters of
appreciation, dinner with boss, redecoration of employee cabin, membership of recreation clubs,
perks, use of company facilities, suggestion awards, tie-pins, brooches, diaries, promotion, say in
management, etc.
A combination of monetary and non-monetary rewards can work wonders and drive employees to
perform well continuously. A proper and efficient employee reward and recognition program can establish
harmonious relationships between employees and employer.
In recent times, the concept of linking pay to performance has taken on an entirely new dimension with
the introduction of variable pay. This article discusses some aspects of the variable pay and performance
linked incentives in place in the contemporary organizations.
How it Works
One of the key components of this variable pay plan is the strategy of linking pay to performance. This is
a strategy that has been followed by many Multinational companies across the world and consists of the
overall pay structure being broken down into components. These components would include the basic
pay, benefits and the variable pay. The variable pay would be paid out as a percentage of the whole
subject to the performance of the employee. For instance, if the employee gets a grade of 2 on a scale of
1 to 4, the variable pay would be 70-80% of the eligible amount and if the employee gets a grade of 1, the
variable pay would be 120-100% of the eligible amount. Accordingly, the performance of the employee
determines the variable component of the salary. The international practice is to increase the component
of the variable pay higher according to the hierarchy. This would mean that at senior levels of the
employee hierarchy, the variable component can be as high as 50-60% of the overall pay.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this article has discussed variable pay and performance linked incentives as a necessary
evolution to a system where merit is recognized more than it is being done now. Given the fact that many
organizations in India follow this approach, it is time for the employees and prospective employees to
attune themselves to this concept and work accordingly.
Diversity in Organizations
Introduction
In recent years, organizations in all sectors have been aggressively working towards a concept called
diversity of workforce. When you see a job posting that talks about equal opportunity, you might be
wondering what it is all about. To put it simply, diversity in employment means that the employer is
actively pursuing what can be called non-discrimination of potential recruits on the basis of gender,
ethnicity, physical constraints and the like. What this means is that the employer or the organization
adopts a policy wherein they do not differentiate between applicants on the grounds listed above and
merit is the sole criterion when deciding the suitability of a potential recruit.
Why Diversity ?
With the advent of globalization, it has become imperative for organizations to have a workforce that is
composed of different ethnicities and with the maturing of the business paradigm; gender is no longer a
constraint. This has prompted large scale changes in the way organizations recruit people. Further, in
many countries the laws governing corporates have been legislated in such a way that makes the firms
actively encourage diversity. For instance, the US is the leading proponent of diversity with the adoption
of the “Equal Opportunity Act”. This act mandates employers not to discriminate on any basis be it
gender, color, lifestyle preferences or any other traits as mentioned in the act. This has given a fillip to the
employment of women and people of color and has removed the barriers that were threatening to make
these groups of people at a minority in the corporate world as well.
Some suggestions
Among the ways in which employers can encourage diversity is by promoting the concept of “blind
resumes” that do not have the name, gender or ethnicity of the applicant mentioned. This would ensure
that recruiters screen the resumes on the basis of the applicants’ qualifications alone and other factors
are secondary. Another way to ensure diversity is by sensitizing the workforce to gender and ethnic
issues, and ensure that they are more tolerant of people who are unlike them.
Conclusion
In conclusion, one needs to understand the difference between having a policy of diversity and actually
practicing it by comparing it to the adage about the difference between the letter of the law and the spirit
of the law. Only by ensuring that the law is followed in spirit as well can employers truly embrace diversity.
Hence, it is in the interest of the management of any firm to sensitize their workforce towards race and
gender issues and ensure that the workplace is free of discrimination against minority groups as well as
women.
Gender Sensitization
We have devoted a separate section on gender sensitization because when compared to other issues in
managing diversity, this is the most pressing issue because of the preponderance of women in the
workforce as well as recent trends that point to the emergence of this single issue as the dominant issue
that is taking the mind space of managers. The worrying aspect about this issue is that despite policies
and rules governing gender specific issues in most organizations, there is little evidence to show that they
are being followed. Hence, what is needed is a mindset change rather than more policies and this can
only be done if the workforce is sensitized to the needs of women.
Conclusion
Though the situation in Corporate India or India Inc. has not yet reached the stage where lawsuits are
routinely brought against management for discriminatory practices, nonetheless, the trend in recent years
is towards a more vocal disapproval of such practices from industry leaders and management consultants
who repeatedly emphasize the importance of a non-discriminatory workplace. Hence, the onus is on the
management, senior and middle, to ensure that they follow the norms that is required of them. In our
opinion, the middle management and the managers who directly interact with the teams of people have a
greater role as they are the “Sandwich” between the upper management and the workforce and hence
are in a position to follow the policies as well as enforce them.
December 1984 witnesses the world’s worst chemical disaster in Bhopal, India, when a methylisocyanate
gas leaked from the Union Carbide plant in the city. It killed over 4,000 people and not hundreds but
thousands suffered from permanent health damage. The haunting memories of this disaster are still fresh
in our minds.
Not only insufficient arrangements of workers’ health and safety at workplace have taken away their lives
but these days stress at workplace is also emerging as a major culprit of spoiling employees and their
families’ lives. Every now and then we hear of suicide cases of individuals from the corporate world. Does
mental stress not a factor that should be considered with physical health and safety provisions? Have
workers’ lives become so cheap that small issues can take away their lives leaving their families wracked,
children orphaned and parents shocked with disbelief ?
Does safety at workplace only mean to protect the workers from the danger of accidents or any other
mishaps? Should workplace safety not consider mental stress or emotional trauma or personal issues of
employees? Is the physical presence of an employee enough for an employer to run the business?
There is no end to these questions. In today’s fast-paced life and cut-throat competition, employers need
to rethink about safety provisions at workplace. It not only refers to the absence of accidents. Rather, the
concept expands to both physical and mental safety of the employees. It is possible to show the external
injury but what about something that is suffocating the employees from inside?
Providing safety to the employees at workplace has a moral dimension as well. Though it is a legal
requirement and fetches monetary compensation in case of failure but it can’t bring back an individual’s
life. Eliminating the causes of accidents and counseling employees at workplace play a substantial role in
saving the operating costs, increasing productivity and ensuring reliability and dependability from the
employees.
Employees are the biggest assets of any organization and few well managed and co-coordinated
safety programs can minimize the loss and damage to them as well as to the organization. With
basic safety policies and remedies for accidents, the companies should also provide systematic training
to industrial employees so that they are able to do their jobs efficiently and safely.
Over a few years, even the mental health of employees, particularly at executive level, has grabbed the
attention of the employers. Mental breakdowns because of stress, tension and work pressure, depression
resulting from failure to meet targets and mental illness taking toll from alcoholism and poor human
relations have consumed many brilliant young executives. The need is to provide psychiatric counseling,
co-operation and consultation. Development and maintenance of effective human relations can work
wonders. Therefore, while making arrangements for physical health and safety at workplace, employers
should also take actions to improve mental health of their indispensable resource.
For designing effective safety plans and implementing them requires thorough analysis of workplace
conditions and determining the level of protection required. The degree of protection depends upon the
degree of risk involved in any job. For example, people working in mines require more safety that those
working in a BPO. It also depends on the kind of job the person is engaged in. Sales personnel may
require higher level of protection than the one in any administrative job.
Workplace safety programs are not only effective in eliminating the risk of damage caused to
person but is also an effective tool in retaining the existing and attracting new talent from the
industry. Who doesn’t want a safe and healthy work environment? Around 90 percent of working
professionals seek safety at workplace rather than a fat package.
Organizations can reduce the risk of accidents at workplace by identifying the level of risk, modifying the
already existing policy and implementing it effectively. For this, it needs to design proper and efficient
management programs to improve physical environment employee assistance programs to help them
diagnose and treat their stress-related problems.
Here is a mention of few workplace safety programs that are implemented by top-notch organizations to
ensure workers’ physical and mental safety:
Safety Policy: It contains a declaration of the employer’s intent towards the safety of employees
and means to realize it. It includes causes, extent and remedies for accidents at workplace. The
policy specifies the company’s goals and responsibilities and caveats and sanctions for failing to
fulfill them.
Provision of Physical Health Services: Many organizations render periodical physical health
check-up services to their employees. Regular medical check-ups of employees help detect the
signs and symptoms of tension, stress, ulcers, depression and other diseases resulting from the
exposure to harmful gases or other irritants.
It is considered as one of the major steps to control occupational health hazards and treat them
before they become worse. In addition to this, it helps managers in rehabilitating the employees
by redesigning their jobs in order to eliminate the further damage to their health.
Mental Health Services: In order to reduce the risk of mental breakdowns because of tension,
pressure and depression and mental illness, a mental health service is provided to the employees
in different ways such as psychiatric counseling, co-operation and consultation with specialists,
educating employees about the importance of mental health and establishment, development and
maintenance of harmonious human relations at workplace.
Employee Assistance Programs: These are specially designed to deal with stress-related
problems of the employees and help in diagnosis, treatment, screening and prevention of both
work and non-work related problems. These programs provide real help to professionals and do
not carry any negative implications.
Fitness Programs: These programs focus on overall health of employees and include both
disease identification as well as lifestyle modification. The most common programs carried out by
the organizations are hypertension identification, physical fitness, exercise, nutrition, smoking and
drinking cessation, diet control and personal and work-related stress management.
Awareness Programs: Conducting the workshops about sexually transmitted diseases such as
HIV AIDS help a lot in raising the awareness of employees towards such dreadful diseases. Such
programs clear out the confusion and disruption in the workforce.
We all must have heard of a simple phrase, “Health is Wealth.” This is true for individuals as well as
organizations. Understanding, developing, implementing and evaluating workplace safety programs not
only helps individuals in maintaining their health but also helps organizations in retaining their resources.
The employers covered under OSHA directly or indirectly need to look over their workplaces and meet
OSHA safety requirements to avoid any legal action against them. They should carefully go through the
OSHA Safety Inspection Checklist, arrange for required provisions and get a safety inspection done.
It is really a huge challenge to understand the psychology of workforce, retain the best talents of the
industry, motivate them to perform better and handle diversity while maintaining unity simultaneously,
especially in countries like India, where it is still evolving. Globalization has resulted in many positive
developments but it has left many concerns for HR managers.
In today’s tough world and tight job market, coordinating a multicultural or diverse workforce is a real
challenge for HR department. Human resource managers are on their toes to strike a balance between
employer and employees keeping in mind the recent trends in the market. They may find themselves in
dire consequences if they are not able to handle the human resource challenges efficiently.
To remain in business, human resource managers need to efficiently address following human
resource challenges:
Handling Multicultural / Diverse Workforce:Dealing with people from different age, gender,
race, ethnicity, educational background, location, income, parental status, religious beliefs,
marital status and ancestry and work experience can be a challenging task for HR managers.
With this, managing people with different set of ideologies, views, lifestyles and psychology can
be very risky. Effective communication, adaptability, agility and positive attitude of HR managers
can bind the diverse workforce and retain talents in the organization.
Managing Change: Who wants to change their ideology or way of working? Neither you nor I.
How can we expect others to change then? Bringing change in organizational processes and
procedures, implementing it and then managing it is one of the biggest concerns of HR
managers. Business environment is so volatile. Technology keeps changing every now and then.
All thanks to globalization. Upgrading the existing technology and training people for them is a
real headache for HR department. The success rate of technology change depends how well
HRD can handle the change and manage people issues in the process.
Retaining the Talents: Globalization has given freedom to working professionals to work
anywhere in the world. Now that they have endless lucrative opportunities to work, hiring and
retaining the best industry talent is no joke. Maintaining harmonious relations with them, providing
excellent work environment and offering more remuneration and perks than your competitors can
retain and motivate them.
Conflict Management: HR managers should know how to handle employee-employer and
employee-employee conflicts without hurting their feelings. Although it is almost impossible to
avoid conflicts among people still handling them tactfully can help HR managers to resolve the
issues. They should be able to listen to each party, decide and communicate to them in a
convincing manner in order to avoid future conflicts.
HR professional must be proactive with all strategies and action plans in order to meet the changing
needs of the organization. They must be thorough with the basic functions of HR including planning,
organizing, leading and controlling human resources.
Though HR auditing is not mandatory like financial auditing, yet, organizations these days are opting for
regular HR audits in order to examine the existing HR system in line with the organizations policies,
strategies and objectives, and legal requirements. HR auditor can be internal or external to the
organization. Generally, HR consulting firms render the service of external HR auditors.
It is necessary for the top management to establish the terms and scope of the audit clearly before the
external firm to make the audit successful. This includes defining the exact purpose of audit, viz.
examining compliance with legal requirements and organization’s policies, identifying problem areas to
avoid crisis situation with appropriate planning, analyzing ways to better serve the needs of relevant
parties – employees, partners or society, measuring the work processes, seeking HR related
opportunities available within the organization, dealing with situation of merger and acquisitions, etc.
Primary components of the HR system which are generally audited include – documentation, job
descriptions, personnel policies, legal policies, recruitment and selection, training and development,
compensation and employee benefit system, career management, employee relations, performance
measurement and evaluation process, termination, key performance indicators, and HR Information
Systems (HRIS).
The first three phases involve extensive collection of quantitative as well as qualitative information. The
method for collection of information depends upon the size of the target audience, availability of time and
type of data to be collected. The pre-audit information phase includes a review of the organization’s
policies, HR manuals, employee handbooks, reports, etc. which form the basis of working in the
organization. The next phase of on-site review, involves questionnaires, interviews, observation, informal
discussions, surveys, or a combination of such methods to get the necessary inputs from the members of
the organization. The records review phase requires detailed scanning of current HR records, employees’
files, employee absenteeism and turnover statistics, notices, compensation claims, performance
assessments, etc.
Utilizing the data so collected, the HR checklist is completed which is the widely used method for carrying
out HR audit. In the checklist method, a list of all the system particulars under audit, viz. the policies,
procedures, or practices, is created in a sequential manner. Against each particular item, the actual
practice as followed by the organization is mentioned. The defined practice and the actual practice are
then compared to determine compliance between the two as well as analyzing the deviation from
compliance. On the basis of this analysis, the final audit report is complied with appropriate conclusions
and recommendations highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of the HR function along with the
necessary improvements as required.
HR audit, thus, contributes towards the best possible use of internal resources and maximizing the
effectiveness of human capital in the organization. At the same time, it is useful in streamlining the HR
processes and practices with the industry best practices and standards.
Indeed, there is a sea change from the time when candidates used to take calls from other
companies when the interview for a particular company was going on. This is an indication of the
change from the exuberant times in the 1990s and the early 2000s to the present where the overall mood
is of stagnation and low growth.
Hiring Strategies in a Low Growth Economy
The hiring strategies have similarly changed with the change in the economic scenario. Earlier, the HR
function used to be given a target of the number of employees to be recruited in a specified period and
their performance and the bonuses were measured in terms of how well they met these targets. The
present scenario is one where the HR function is given qualitative limits instead of quantitative limits.
What this means is that quality matters more than numbers and companies are no longer tolerating low
skilled or low quality candidates. This has increased the pressure on both the recruiters as well as the HR
functions. Whereas in earlier years, the pressure was on finding the high number of people required, now
the pressure is on finding the right candidate.
Closing Thoughts
Finally, when times are tough, the tough get going and so, the hiring of those with mental toughness and
the ability to work under pressure is the norm. Apart from this, the fact that the hiring is more location
based because of various factors means that proximity to the major cities would be an added advantage.
The recent encouragement of the development of Tier Two cities means that candidates who are not near
to the cities can still benefit if they are located in these up and coming cities.
Conclusion
In recent years, with the high levels of attrition in the service sector, it has become imperative for firms to
have a structured separation plan for orderly exits of employees. Of course, the concept of “pink slips” or
involuntary exits are another matter altogether and involve some bitterness that results because of the
employee losing his or her job. In conclusion, it is our view that employee separations must be handled in
a professional and mature manner and though attrition is a fact that concerns everyone in the industry,
once an employee decides to leave, the separation must be as smooth as possible.
Closing Thoughts
Talking about boundaries, one of the most important skills that HR professionals can have is to respect
the boundaries (physical and mental) between people. Indeed, we can say that the differentiating factor
that determines success or otherwise of HR professionals is to know the difference between what is
personal and what is professional. This would be covered in detail in subsequent articles. It would suffice
to state here that this aspect is representative of the skills and abilities that you must learn while playing
second fiddle to your boss. Finally, once you are given responsibilities of your own, it is time to put your
theoretical knowledge and practical exposure to work. A parting word of advice is that do not be too eager
to show off your theoretical knowledge in your interactions as most companies value insights over theory
and experience and expertise over textbook knowledge.
Closing Thoughts
Finally, the HRM function also has to cooperate with the organizational imperatives on the need to reduce
costs and hence, must play its role and part in ensuring that the organization practices what it preaches
and does not merely indulge in cost cutting, layoffs, and freezing of pay hikes and bonuses.
The Emergence of SHRM and the Need for People Enabling and People
Empowerment
The reason why many organizations are keen to have the post of a people manager is mainly because of
the need felt by the organizations to treat people as key assets and sources of competitive advantage as
opposed to treating them as yet another factor of production. This shift in emphasis or paradigm shift is
known as the strategic human resource management perspective wherein employees are considered the
chief asset and sources of sustainable advantage to the organizations. When compared to the earlier
paradigms where employees were treated as yet another factor of production and the intervening
paradigm where employees were considered important but not to the level that is being witnessed in the
SHRM view. The reason for this is the rise in the services sector wherein technology and financial
services firms have taken center stage in the economy and where people make the difference between
success and failure. This is the key aspect of multinationals having a people manager distinct from a
project manager.
Concluding Thoughts
Finally, after the positives and the negatives have been tallied, it is found that the practice of hiring
temporary workers does add value to the companies and provided they are managed well and contracts
drawn up in clear and unambiguous terms, the practice or hiring temporary workers can result in cost
savings and increased productivity and profitability.
Indeed, the employment contracts are drafted in such a way that there is no ambiguity and confusion in
the type of the employer and employee relationship.
For instance, there are several cases in which the wording and the clauses in the employment contracts
have resulted in legal matters and other disputes wherein each party has tried to sue the other for
noncompliance.
To take an example, the cases involving Sexual Harassment in the United States in recent months have
highlighted the need for explicit provisions that protect the employer as well as the employee.
Indeed, the point to be noted here is that unless everything in the employment contract is spelled out
in black and white and all the terms and conditions stated and specified, there is always a
likelihood of legal disputes arising from misinterpretation and misunderstanding between the
parties concerned.
In our experience, this can have serious as well as somewhat hilarious consequences if the terms and
conditions in the employment contracts are not specified clearly.
For instance, in our experience, there have been cases where the Non-Disclosure Clause, as well as the
Non-Compete Clause, have not been defined properly leading to theft of intellectual property as well as
disclosure of propriety information to third parties and competitors by disgruntled employees.
It can also have hilarious consequences as some employees we know have refused to work beyond 6
PM every day since the contract did not specify so.
Given the fact that work in contemporary corporates is not time-bound, there is a case to be made for
clearly specifying the terms and conditions in the contract.
However, the emergence of the Freelance and the Gig Economy has opened up new forms of
employment that do not fall into any of the usual categories.
As can be seen in the way there are several class action lawsuits in the United States between firms such
as Uber and its drivers; there is a need to change with the times and draft proper and foolproof
employment contracts.
Moreover, whenever organizational policies are violated, it is often the case that the lawyers on either
side tend to point to noncompliance by the other side when arguing their case.
As can be seen in the way some women have sued the Silicon Valley firms in recent months, there needs
to be a clear specification of what constitutes harassment and what constitutes a ground for dismissal.
In other words, while the employees can claim that they were harassed, the employers too can claim that
such alleged victims have violated organizational policies by going public with their allegations.
For instance, the employment contracts of executives and other senior positions often state how long they
have wait after resignation to join rivals and competitors and how much they can reveal the information
that they have gained from their employment as it relates to intellectual property.
Indeed, as can be seen in the recent dustup in the Indian IT Bellwether, Infosys, there needs to clear exit
and separation clauses specifying non-disclosure and non-compete so that there is no ambiguity on
account of this.
Thus, it is clear that there are several aspects to the need to draft proper and foolproof employment
contracts and hence, it is our contention that the Human Resources Managers apply adequate thought
and do their due diligence by consulting lawyers and other company law experts so that the employment
contracts do not leave room for doubt and misinterpretation.
On the other hand, there is a need to protect the employee as well, and hence we suggest prospective as
well as working professionals to study their employment contracts and see if their rights are protected.
Conclusion
Lastly, while we are not saying that there is an ideal scenario where both employer and employee win
with clearly worded and clearly stated employment contracts since legal disputes often arise in situations
that cannot be completely predicted, nonetheless, a well drafted and proper employment contract can be
made foolproof against major disputes.
To conclude, with the changing nature of the employer-employee relationship, more than ever there is a
need to draft proper and precise employment contracts where the employer and the employee are “on the
same page” most, if not all the time.
Unplanned Vacations
The previous section dealt with planned vacations. However, managers have to be ready for
unplanned vacations as well that result from personal emergencies and sudden and unexpected
events like the employee falling sick or meeting with an accident. The key aspect here is that
planned vacations are easier to manage than unplanned vacations because the sudden absence of the
employee leads to disruption in work schedules and affects the delivery of key deliverables. This is where
the manager’s skills at people management, project management, and risk management are tested. This
is because the manager has to convince other team members to finish the tasks that the absent
employee was performing, budget fort disruptions in the project management plan, and actualize the risk
management plan, which details the steps to be taken in such a scenario. Indeed, unplanned absences
are potentially damaging to the prospects of organizations and especially so, when the absent employee
was performing a critical or a crucial task. Therefore, person dependence must be kept a minimum and
this is the requirement of all capability maturity models that certify process and organizational maturity.
Concluding Thoughts
Further, the need for person independence is felt when such instances occur and this is the reason why
organizations must not put all their eggs in one basket and promote key resources all the time. In other
words, playing favorites by depending overtly on some employee and making them the stars with halos is
okay as long as this employee(s) is present and is doing his or her work. When this key resource is
absent, the team must not suffer and therefore, it is better if other team members are groomed as well.
Concluding Thoughts
Finally, it must also be mentioned that there are cultural factors at play here. For instance, being laid off in
the West is seen as normal wherein in India, it is seen otherwise where social stigma to being laid off is
more. Therefore, this aspect has to be considered as well when deciding on the appropriate labor policy
in these countries.
Role of HR Consulting Firm During
Termination and Outplacement
Termination of employment simply means the ending of employment in a particular organization.
Termination of employment is inevitable in any employment relationship and it may happen either
voluntarily or involuntarily.
1. Voluntary termination may come through resignation, retirement or death of the employee.
2. Involuntary termination of employment can take place by employee dismissal or lay-off.
Dismissals and lay-offs often result in hampering the terminated employee’s chances of finding a
new job. Moreover, such employees do avoid mentioning such jobs in their resume which create
unexplainable gaps in their career profile. On the part of employer, it is mandatory to follow
proper termination rules and policies while applying dismissals or lay-offs as the terminated
employees may opt for legal recourse. Also, such terminating activities are taken in negative
sense among the workforce market, which adversely impacts the reputation of the organization
as an employer.
It is during such situations that an organization decides for outplacement and career transition services. A
carefully handled termination along with proper severance package and outplacement service helps the
organization in avoiding legal action from employee’s side.
Actually, outplacement is the service offered by the former employer to help the terminated employee in
locating a new job. The former employer, in this case, covers all the costs to facilitate the employee with
the new job. This minimizes the impact of termination on employee and prevents him from the pressure of
being jobless/finding a new job. Such services also alleviate the standing of the organization as an
employee-centered organization. Moreover, by taking up outplacement services, an organization
diminishes the risk of lawsuit.
The organization generally calls for the services of an HR Consulting Firm in cases of termination
and outplacement to deal with the whole process in a professional and dignified manner. The HR
Consulting Firm works along with both, the employee and the employer, so as to make the event of
separation strategically fitting to the needs of both the parties.
Throughout these three broad phases of termination and outplacement, an HR Consulting Firm generally
provides following individual services to the organization and retained/ terminated employees:
Career evaluation
Planning the career continuation and development process
Career guidance
Resume writing
Interview preparation
Network development
Job search, and research on the same
Job market analysis
Administrative assistance - preparation of concerned documents and letters, etc.
Handling exit meeting
Skill development programs
Workshops to deal with the period of transition
Checking legal compliances
Preparing severance packages
Besides, an HR Consulting Firm also guides the concerned managers handling the termination
meetings in carefully communicating the news to the terminated employees as well as to the staff,
so as to maintain the dignity of the terminated employee and negate the concern among the
retained employees. A detailed plan about the sequence and content of the meeting is chalked out to
make it more definitive and justified.
Hence, the HR Consulting Firm aims at making the process of termination and outplacement manageable
and respectful for the organization and the terminated employee.
In other words, there are three components of EQ as defined by the famous psychologist, Daniel
Goldman and they are the capacity to relate to colleagues, superiors, and subordinates at an emotional
level; the ability to defer gratification in the pursuit of professional and personal objectives; and having an
anchor within oneself or having an inner rudder through which the decision making can be made. We
shall discuss each of these traits in detail subsequently. It would suffice to state here that being an
emotionally aware person is one of the key traits that are needed for professional success in the 21st
century workplace.
Concluding Thoughts
Finally, Daniel Goleman’s books about Emotional Intelligence have been bestsellers for many years
mainly because of the rigorous research and data that underpins the conclusions reached in his books.
Therefore, if you want further insights into how EQ can help you become a successful professional, you
must pay heed to the traits that have been discussed here and actualize them in your professional and
personal lives.
How many of us really enjoy going to work? I would expect honest answers. Why do we feel lazy on a
Monday? Such feelings arise only when people do not enjoy their work and find office the most boring
place in the world.
Why do individuals treat their work as a mere source of burden? Management needs to understand that
employees put their heart and soul in work only when work is assigned as per their skills and
expertise. Key responsibility areas (KRAs) refer to a detailed summary of what all an individual is
expected to do at the workplace. Remember, if an organization is paying you a decent salary, it also
expects you to perform certain tasks and activities which would eventually earn revenues for the
organization. Such tasks and activities are nothing but their key responsibility areas or in short their
KRAs.
It is crucial for the employees to understand their role in the organization if you expect them to
perform as per your expectations. Assigning work to employees is one of the major responsibilities of
the management.
Let us go through few parameters which play an essential role in assigning Key responsibility areas.
Key responsibility areas need to be assigned only after discussing with the employees. Employees
need to be very clear as to what ought to be their contribution towards the overall profitability of the
organization. Let employees decide their own KRAs.Trust me, this way, not only they take active interest
in work but also develop a strong bond with their organization. When they themselves decide their work,
they never create problems later on and also strive hard to deliver more than hundred percent.
Assign job responsibilities only when you feel the employee concerned is really capable of doing the
same. Do not expect an accounts professional to do miracles in marketing department. Work needs to be
distributed equally among the employees. Why should only one person do everything while others enjoy?
Make sure employees accept their key responsibility areas with a smile. Management’s job is not
only assigning KRAs but also finding out whether employees are satisfied or not with their work
responsibilities. Acceptance of key responsibility areas by the employees is important.
The first and the foremost responsibility of HR team is to design the entire appraisal process.
Make sure the process is simple and does not take too much time. The HR team needs to know the
responsibilities assigned to each and every employee for them to create and design a system where their
overall achievements can be rated with respect to their key responsibility areas. An individual
representing the MIS team cannot rate himself/herself on the KRAs of a marketing professional. As a HR
professional, you need to sit with the functional heads of all departments so that you exactly know what
all tasks have been assigned to which all team members.
The employees need to be fully aware of the performance appraisal process. The criterion of
performance appraisal needs to be very clear and transparent. Provide proper training to employees
so that they take the entire process of performance appraisal gracefully and sportingly. You need to make
them understand that appraisals are done not to downgrade or insult anyone but help individuals set
realistic goals and expectations for themselves and work towards it. There are employees who do not
appreciate the idea of performance appraisal and feel it is just a waste of time and energy filling elaborate
forms. It is the HR’s responsibility to change this perception. Performance appraisal is just not a method
to increase one’s salary but provide feedbacks to employees and guide them accordingly. Call employees
on a common platform and make them understand the importance of appraisal process and how would it
help them in their respective careers.
The HR team also needs to sit with the reviewing authorities to ensure appraisals are done on
time and only the deserving employees get the benefits. Appraisals should not be for everyone but
only for those who have worked really hard all through the year. You need to help and sometimes also
guide the managers and supervisors so that a fair appraisal is done and no deserving employee is at
loss. You can also give your valuable feedback to the functional heads based on your day to day
interaction with the employee concerned. Apart from his /her routine work, how one behaves at the
workplace, what is his relation with superiors/ fellow workers, punctuality, and discipline also play an
important role in performance appraisal.
Once the appraisal is done, it is your responsibility to hand over the increment letters or review reports.
Make sure the letter is handed only to the employee concerned and not to anyone else. Appraisals and
increments ought not to be discussed in public. Your role does not end here. As a HR professional, you
need to ensure employees are satisfied with the appraisal process. You need to explain an individual as
to why he/she has got or not got a salary hike .Immediately arrange a meeting with his superior if you are
not able to handle the situation or find a solution. Many people start looking for a change or quit
immediately after the appraisal process.
This happens because either the doubts are not addressed properly or individuals who have got a decent
hike look for better opportunities outside. Take feedbacks from employees as to what they feel about their
appraisal and whether they are satisfied or not?
Such documents clearly define the benefits to be provided to the employee, various procedures as
followed in the organization and the standard of work maintained in the work place. In case there is any
issue from either the side of the employer or the employee, the HR policies and procedures manual and
employee handbook prove the necessary source of information to be adhered to in order to resolve the
issue.
Administration, managers and supervisors can consult these documents from time to time while
formulating various procedures and orders. These documents provide them the details regarding the
company policies and implementation procedures to be followed. The employees can also consult these
documents to acquaint themselves with the organizational policies and procedures regarding various
aspects like leaves’ sanction, different allowances, insurance plans, anti-harassment rules, anti-drugs
rules, etc. The employees’ handbook should contain all such data, pertaining to the employment of the
employees, in complete detail so as to ensure that employees can obtain all the required information in
time.
The HR policies and procedures manual and employee handbook should be prepared with utmost
objectivity and comprehensibly so as to make the documents standard and consistent in
approach, as well as free from any complexity or overlap. This is essential to negate any sort of
differential treatment with the company, and ensure a smooth and conflict-free working within the
organization.
Organizations can hire an HR Consulting Firms for the preparation both or either of the HR policies and
procedures manual and the employee handbook. An HR Consultant can assist the organization in:
Preparing a new HR policies and procedures manual/ employee handbook for the organization
Revise certain aspects of the documents or completely revise the HR policies and procedures
manual/employee handbook
Check the documents for the ever changing legal rules and regulations, and make the necessary
changes
Audit the existing HR policies and procedures manual and/ or employee handbook to make sure
that the given details provided are relevant to the current industry/market scenario.
The work of the HR Consultant can include covering just one of the document or both, the HR policies
and procedures manual and the employee handbook. Also, as per the requirement of the administration,
the Consultant may be asked to either work upon the entire document or cover just a few policies.
While compiling an HR policies and procedures manual, an HR Consultant should keep in mind the
following important factors:
Organizational culture
Legal rules and regulations
Market trends
While preparing an employee handbook, the Consultant should consider the following:
An HR Consultant, on the call from the organization, may also guide and train the administration and
managers in implementing the policies and procedures properly. Further, the Consultant can also train
the employees in complying with the details as laid down in these two major documents of the
organization.
Thus, by helping the organization with the preparation and updation of the HR policies and procedures
manual and employee handbook of the organization, an HR Consulting Firm facilitates in creating an
environment in the company which is equitable, balanced and free from conflicts.
Whatever be the reason, downsizing is a painful process for both the employees and the
organization and more for the former. Therefore, the Human Resources Function must handle
downsizing with utmost care and caution and with sensitivity.
Payment of Compensation
For instance, when laying off employees, it is usually the case that the organization pays severance
packages and some additional pay to compensate the employee for the sudden event or occurrence of
losing his or her job. Of course, when employees are laid off for disciplinary reasons, there is usually no
severance pay since the employee has violated the code of conduct and hence, is not liable for any
compensation. Having said that, it must also be noted that the law mandates payment of compensation in
the other forms of downsizing. However, the reality is that very few companies follow the law because in
gloomy economic conditions, even the government which is eager to please the businesses does not
really enforce the laws.
The history of Corporate America is littered with examples of how the HR botched up the downsizing
process which led to the employee(s) taking the organizations to court and in some cases, if the evidence
is strong, winning Multi-Million Dollar lawsuits against the organizations for wrongful termination.
If the organization does not handle layoffs properly, it is at the risk of losing even those who are not likely
to be downsized. This is because these employees who are good performers would decide that they
would anyway get jobs elsewhere and instead of sticking around in an organization that is on the verge of
economic debilitation, they might as well move jobs. Therefore, any organization that is planning to
downsize must approach the same in a calculated and careful manner.
All organizations have something called a performance improvement plan wherein the employees whose
performance is suspect are told about the same and their performance put on watch. During this period,
they are monitored by their immediate managers along with the HR manager and if they do not improve
even after the mandatory watch period is over, they are then let go with the reasons for the same being
stated clearly and in writing.
Organizations have to be Humane but Firm
As mentioned in the introduction, downsizing is very painful to the employees since their source of
livelihood is being taken away from them. Especially in these gloomy economic times when everyone
wants job security and assured income, downsizing can be extremely traumatic to the employees.
Therefore, it is indeed the case that a humane approach must be adopted so that the employees do not
feel that they have been treated unfairly. Having said that, no organization exists for charity and hence,
they too need to be firm on when to downsize and whom to downsize. These are complex challenges that
need creative and humane approaches and this is where the personality of the HR manager comes into
question since he or she must be responsible and balance the competing needs of the employee and the
organization.
Indeed, among all the reasons for attrition, the two most important ones are that employees do not
leave the organizations but their managers and those they leave because they are getting a better
pay and better role in other organizations.
Moreover, attrition is harmful for the morale in the organization since it is infectious meaning that when
people start leaving, it can soon turn into a torrent wherein other employees also leave. In addition, loss
of managers and senior management personnel is extremely painful for the organizations since these
employees who were handling sensitive and critical roles are often responsible for formulating and
executing strategy.
In addition, involuntary attrition which is when organizations ask employees to leave is a type of
attrition that many organizations resort to weed out the poor performers every year. Indeed, some
consultancies and investment banks have policies that mandate firing the bottom 10% of the performers
every year so that the culture of excellence is maintained as well as to send a message to the existing
staff that they need to perform or perish.
Moreover, involuntary attrition is also beneficial to the organizations since they were incurring costs on
the poor performers which can now be utilized for the other employees.
Typically, most industries have average attrition rates at or between 10-15%. Any figure above this is
considered problematic and the examples cited above had attrition rates that were beyond this figure.
Indeed, when attrition is manageable, the HR managers usually do not mind it since it leads for fresh
energy coming into the organization and deadwood being replaced with green shoots.
However, the worst form of attrition and the one which is the most worrying is when senior and middle
level managers leave. The reasons for this can be that they have been overlooked for promotions or they
do not see themselves progressing into the executive and leadership positions. In these cases, the CEO
and the Board often step in to persuade and convince these management figures from leaving.
This list is usually prepared periodically and updated regularly to ensure that the managers and the HR
managers have mitigation measures in place to deal with the exits of these employees. Moreover, such
lists also help the organization in preparing for any eventuality when high profile figures in the
organization leave.
Despite extensive studies that indicate these aspects, sadly not many organizations take steps to correct
this since they feel that the managers are more valuable than the employees who are leaving. While we
do not say that this should stop, we would like to conclude this article with the hope that junior level exits
are taken as seriously as the senior level exits in all organizations.
Rise of the Temp Jobs and the
Freelance/Sharing Economy
The Emerging Uber Economy
Most if not all of us would have heard of the ride sharing cab aggregator Uber. Anyone who has taken a
ride with the associated drivers belonging to Uber would be aware that the cabs and the drivers who work
for the company are not regular full time employees but just about anybody who has a car and has
“signed up” with the company on a part time basis.
This is the business model where unlike in the traditional rent a cab model, Uber works by allowing
anyone to register with them and work for them on a freelance basis. Similarly, this “sharing model” is
now being adopted by other companies such as AirBnB which lets house owners let their spare rooms to
be used as “Bed and Breakfast” motel rooms without necessarily turning their homes into full fledged
hotels.
Further, there are many freelance work sites such as Upwork-Elance, Craigslist, and People per Hour that
“connect” freelancers with potential clients and thereby “facilitate” the exchange of work between buyers
and sellers on a part time basis. Indeed, some estimates suggest that nearly one third of the total
workforce in the United States is now engaged in some form or the other of freelance work.
The Rise of the Temp Economy and its Implications for Workers
This has implications for the upcoming generation of workers who would find that “lifelong employment”
and a stable and secure job are things of the past. Instead the motto for the future is sharing one’s skills
and expertise through online and mobile portals with potential buyers for a fee and where the mode of
working is temporary and devoid of any longer term contractual and stable work arrangements.
Further, they can hire according to seasonal demand and whenever a project comes up instead of hiring
employees and keeping them on the “bench” until the projects are finalized. Already employers are saving
on the benefits by hiring temps and added to this is the purely temporary nature of work which results in
savings in areas ranging from idle capacity to easier hiring and firing.
Therefore, this temp economy or the gig economy does indeed benefit the employers and one of the
reasons for employers worldwide pushing for temp work is the very tangible benefits that they get from
this business model.
The emerging temp economy has been variously called the Uber economy and the gig economy and the
reality for workers around the world is that in future job and work are not things that one can take for
granted but instead, one has to work harder and be agile and nimble all the time thereby remaining
competitive. Indeed even workers in the developing world have to be on the lookout for competition from
even lower wage workers from the bottom of the heap. This “race to the bottom” means that unless one is
constantly reinventing oneself, there is no guarantee that one can find work all the time.
On a concluding note, we would also like to point out that all workers everywhere better realize that the
good old days of stable and secure employment are being converted to a ruthless marketplace for
workers where the ability to bid lower, the ability to go beyond customer satisfaction and instead, aim for
customer delight and customer wow are the things that would serve them well in the future.
The details such as Name, Gender, Colleges, and Universities Attended, as well as details regarding
personal beliefs and preferences are supposed to be left blank in the applications. Further, the hiring is
supposed to be based on the applicants solving case studies as well as presenting solutions to given
tasks instead of the traditional screening and hiring process wherein the applicants are called for
interviews based on their educational and professional qualifications.
Moreover, the hiring in this case is supposed to be “blind” to the personal details of the
applicants so as to remove any bias or conflict of interest between the hiring team and the applicant
since it is believed that some hiring managers shortlist applicants based on which school or college they
attended as well as based on their location, religion, ethnicity, and other personal details.
Indeed the fact that many hiring managers tend to display the all too human trait and habit of short-listing
applicants based on personal details is the reason and the prime driver behind some companies hiring
applicants based on “blind hiring” practices.
The need for such practices also arises from the fact that almost all organizations have what are known
as “old boys clubs” wherein employees belonging to certain colleges and universities as well as those
belonging to some past employers tend to “get” their classmates, peers, and coworkers from the past
employers into the present workplaces.
Moreover, with the extremely polarized social atmosphere, some companies have found that more often
than not, employees tend to hire those belonging to their religion or ethnicity in addition to hiring
those from their cities and other personal characteristics.
Therefore, it can be said that blind hiring removes all these sources of bias as well as conflicts of interest
and instead, provides the organizations with a hiring method that is transparent and purely based on
merit.
In addition, blind hiring would also obviate the expensive lawsuits and other legal actions against
companies that arise from hiring based on personal details. Apart from this, blind hiring also ensures that
prospective applicants cannot use “back door entry” strategies wherein they “manage” the hiring process
in collusion with insiders and hence, gain unfair advantages over their other applicants.
Having said that, it must be noted that despite the obvious advantages of blind hiring, there are some
disadvantages as well. For one, blind hiring means longer processing times for applications since the
hiring team must devise the appropriate method of assessing and evaluating the candidacy of applicants
either through task based hiring or lengthier interview processes since the hiring team has no knowledge
of the applicants personal and other details and hence, once they are shortlisted based on “objective”
criteria, they must be screened by performing due diligence that can take more time than the traditional
hiring methods.
Moreover, designing case studies and tasks that are to be solved by the applicants means that enough
time must be devoted to each hire as well as coordinating with several managers and teams since the
hiring process is essentially one where the applicant is judged not on past achievements but on how well
he or she solves the task or provides solutions to the case studies.
In addition, given the short staffed HR departments in most organizations, blind hiring increases the
workload as well as introduces additional layers of complexity into the process. of course, the fact
that most hiring is done based on employee referrals is another factor that counts against blind hiring
since such referrals are effectively eliminated or reduced in blind hiring practices.
However, blind hiring might represent the future since many organizations are struggling to hire the right
candidates in the traditional methods since research has shown that candidates who are hired based on
which college they attended or which company they worked are as good or as worse as hiring based on
impersonal methods wherein the applicant is judged not according to their past but based on present
capabilities as well as future potential and contribution to the organization.
Moreover, with research suggesting that employees who are “good interview candidates” might not
always be good employees or be aligned with the roles for which they have been hired. For these
reasons, it would not be surprising if more organizations jump on the blind hiring bandwagon in the
coming years.
Finally, given the various points discussed so far, it is our view that it would be better for
organizations to try blind hiring especially for the junior to middle level positions where the
maximum amount of hiring is done and where the chances of blind hiring succeeding are more.
Moreover, it is absolutely imperative that organizations hire applicants based not on “whom they know” or
“where they studied or worked previously” and more importantly, not based on “which religion or ethnicity”
they belong to but purely based on the capabilities and competencies as well as the expertise and fit
between the applicants and the roles for which they are being hired.
In conclusion, while these are early days for blind hiring to emerge as a mainstream hiring method, there
is no harm in organizations trying this out to ensure greater transparency and accountability into the hiring
process.
Indeed, given the proliferation of business scandals arising from unethical conduct and unacceptable
behaviour, organizations are even more keen to ensure that such instances of bad behaviour that have
the potential to destroy their reputations, as well as cause monetary losses, and also lead to punitive
actions by the authorities do not happen.
In this context, organizations typically entrust the Human Resource Function with educating the
employees about the ethical norms and rules and regulations. They also task the HR Managers with
ensuring compliance, punishing violations, enforcing the codes of conduct, as well as keeping an eye on
potential break of rules and regulations. Thus, the HR Managers have a pivotal role to play in the overall
organizational ecosystem as far as ethics and values are concerned.
Let us now turn to the specific ways in which the HR Managers function to fulfil their responsibilities and
mandates. Ethics starts from the time the potential employees apply to the organizations as there can be
cases where aspirants “fudge” their resumes as well as hide instances of past violations in other
companies.
Indeed, in some countries, there are laws and rules and regulations which empower organizations
to report such violations not only to the management of their companies but record them in a
centralized database accessed by all firms that have signed up for the service so that potential cheats
can be marked and tagged which would help the entire industry.
Indeed, the pre-selection phase is very important as given the fact that Millions of graduates aspire to be
absorbed into the industry; it is indeed the case that the “Weeding Out” of “ Bad Apples” is done as early
and as soon as possible.
Even during the selection phase, the HR Managers must be on the lookout for possible
misrepresentations of data, wrong information pertaining to the aspirants’ education or previous
employment history in addition to the “gaming the system” aspect which in layman’s words means
aspirants collude with each other and with “insiders” in the organizations so that they are selected through
dubious means.
Next, the primary task of the HR Manager begins when the employees are on-boarded, or the phase
where the selection is made and the employees join the organization and are in the training phase.
Indeed, this is the most critical phase as far as the education of the fresh and the new employees
regarding the organizational policies are concerned.
To take examples, the new recruits must be given the Codes of Conduct and clearly told that any
violations, would result in termination of employment or other punitive actions.
Indeed, some organizations have policies and rules that specify that even minor transgressions such as
claiming inflated expenses and accepting gifts and other favours from external parties to provide benefits
to them are not tolerated. This is the case with many MNCs or Multinational Corporations which take
these violations very seriously.
Turning to the meat of the policies, the most frequent violation is often linked to the practice of violating
the organizational policies.
Some instances of this can be recording attendance for others by swiping their identity and authentication
cards in order to “mask and hide” the time that the other employee clocks in practice; the practice of
using company resources for personal use when such use is explicitly prohibited, impersonating other
employees; and most importantly, using the internet and external network access to transmit confidential
and restricted information and data.
In recent years because of the boom in some sectors, there has been another form of violation wherein
employees approach their colleagues with offers of jobs in other companies, and this is a violation that is
taken very seriously in almost all firms.
Indeed, there are several firms that routinely dismiss the employees when such violations are brought to
their notice. In all these cases, the HR Manager plays a vital role as it is his or her job to not only
monitor such violations but also to enforce the rules and regulations as well as punish
infringements of the rules.
Apart from this, another trend that has been noticed of late is the practice of cyber hacking wherein
employees misuse the confidential information that is given to them as part of normal work by sending it
to external parties, stealing passwords and other personal information and passing them on to dubious
characters, and above all, a tendency to overuse the internet and visit prohibited sites.
Indeed, the problem is so acute that the HR Managers regularly monitor the browsing habits of
employees and keep a check on whether the employees are misusing the facilities.
As can be seen from the discussion so far, there are any number of ethical violations. and we have
covered some of them in this article in addition to detailing how the HR Managers can deal with such
violations. As mentioned in the introductory sections, with the increase in the instances of business
scandals and unethical behaviour, it has become very important for organizations to track violations and
perhaps, ensure that such violations do not happen in the first place by laying down the rules and
enforcing them with an Iron hand.
Indeed, it can be said that HRM is the key function in the hospitality sector considering that firms
such as Hotels, Tour and Travel Operators, Restaurants, and Holiday Resorts all depend on their
employees as sources of distinctive competitive advantage. Thus, HRM in the Hospitality Sector has
to be practiced well in order to ensure the commercial viability of the firms in the sector.
Issues Related to HRM in the Hospitality Sector
Some of the issues that HR Managers in the Hospitality Sector deal with are related to intercultural
management, people empowerment, and people enabling all of which are very important to ensure that
the employees of firms in the hospitality sector actualize their duties and provide stellar and superlative
customer service.
While in earlier decades, the HRM in the Hospitality Sector focused on personnel management, it is now
the case that SHRM or Strategic Human Resource Management or the treatment of employees as
strategic sources of competitive advantage is the norm in the sector.
Turning to the specific cultural challenges related to intercultural management and cross cultural
communication that HR Managers have to contend with in the hospitality sector, it is a fact that hotels,
airlines, restaurants, tour and travel operators, and the like depend on foreign tourists and travellers from
around the world for their existence as profit making entities.
Thus, there is a need for their employees to bridge the cultural gaps and cross the chasm between
different cultures. Some people mistake cross-cultural management and intercultural communication as
being concerned solely with foreign language proficiency or the ability to converse with the international
guests in their own language.
However, while being multilingual can indeed help employees in the hospitality sector, it goes beyond this
and what is needed is an ethnocentric approach to intercultural management wherein the staff in the firms
in the hospitality sector have to place themselves in the position of their guests and talk to them and
communicate to them from the perspective of the guests’ culture. This means that there is a need for HR
Managers to emphasize the importance of bridging the cultural gap by reaching out to the guests’ that
goes beyond multilingual capabilities.
Since the job is also a 24/7 one where there is constant rotation of shifts in order to ensure round the
clock service, HR Managers have to rotate duties of the employees in as humane manner as possible so
that the same employees do not end up doing the night shift all the time in addition to being stressed out
because they have been in the shift where the maximum workload takes place.
Indeed, some of these policies are already being tried out in many international hotels and tour and travel
operators where such policies are being implemented based on extensive research into the high-
performance attributes of employees in the hospitality sector. Moreover, such policies also ensure that
employees do not jump ship frequently or in other words, high attrition which is the hallmark of the sector
can be avoided.
Conclusion: It is Important to Walk the Talk and Practice What One Preaches
In addition, the current trends in the hospitality sector indicate the need for global thinking and local
execution for the HR Managers wherein they do not dilute the global brand image of their firms and yet,
do not neglect the local ways of doing things. Indeed, this is a very important requirement for employees
in the hospitality sector as the industry is highly globalized and at the same time, depends on highly
specialized localized forms of execution.
Lastly, it is one thing to preach and theorize and it is another thing to actually practice what one preaches
and walk the talk. Thus, HR Managers in the hospitality sector would well remember the fact that unless
their actions match their words and unless the policies are actually implemented, the employees are more
likely to see through the disconnect between talk and reality. To conclude, HR Managers in the hospitality
sector face umpteen challenges, and it is the way in which they deal with such challenges that determine
the end results.
Indeed, HRM which started out as an ancillary and auxiliary function in the manufacturing era evolved to
a core function and a source of competitive advantage in the services era. This evolution has
necessitated several changes in the way the field of HRM operated and continues to operate to this day.
Indeed, with the emergence of firms such as Uber, AirBnB, Task Rabbit, Amazon, and Upwork that
provide freelance jobs and contractual employment and where the pay is based on per task basis rather
than a monthly consolidated amount, HR managers have to keep pace with the changes in the broader
economy and evolve accordingly.
This calls for some adjustment and even a radical overhaul in the way the field of HRM operates. For
instance, HR managers in any of the Digital Economy firms typically are involved in the initial
screening and pre-employment interviews and formulation and finalization of the contractual
obligations and terms and conditions for the workers. Further, HR managers in the sharing economy
are more concerned with the Digital Interface model of engagement rather than face to face model of
engagement.
Some Examples of HRM in Digital Economy Firms
Take the example of a sharing economy firm such as Uber. Once the contractual Drivers are on-boarded,
the HR managers interact with them through the App based and Virtual Interfaces rather than meeting
them in person.
Though some firms in the Digital Economy do make it a point to invite their employees for in-person
interactions from time to time, most firms such as UpWork and Task Rabbit rely on “armies of globally
dispersed” employees where the possibility of even interaction through Skype or Video is remote let alone
face to face and in person interaction.
This means that HR managers in these firms should be conversant with the way the Digital Economy
works and understand what it takes for businesses in this paradigm to succeed. Therefore, HRM as a
field has to evolve from being physical bound to a new model where Digital and Virtual modes of people
management are the norms.
Thus, as mentioned earlier, HRM now faces the prospect of a “paradigm shift” in the way it has to be
practiced and in the way HR mangers operate.
Returning to the example of Uber and AirBnB, HR managers in these firms have to typically manage the
contractual workforce and address their grievances related to low pay, lack of orders, shift timings and
managing workload, and deal with regulatory concerns.
Indeed, if events over the past year are any indication, most sharing economy firms are spending much of
their time dealing with these concerns and in particular, the “grey areas” between their business models
and the prevailing regulatory frameworks rather than on people management or what were earlier the
main concerns of firms in the Industrial and even the Post-Industrial Era.
Moreover, taken together with globalization, the emergence of the Digital Economy means that the firms
are located in one jurisdiction, the freelancers (one should be careful when using the term employees
since the sharing economy firms work on the concept of digital labour and not physical labour) are
dispersed globally, and the firms themselves operate 24/7 across time zones.
Thus, HR managers now have to learn to deal with challenges such as complying with regulatory
requirements across the world and where laws and rules differ from location to location. Meanwhile, the
primary concern of HR managers has to be that they have to manage a dispersed workforce wherein the
interface and the intersection between globalization and localization mean that Glocal or the merging of
Global and Local modes of engagement are the norms rather than the exception.
For instance, HR managers in any of the Digital Economy firms have to contend with freelancers in one
location being affected by purely local events and at the same time, the common rules of global
engagement have to be tweaked to suit the local conditions.
Indeed, the times have speeded up so much that responses to events are no longer timed on the basis of
days and weeks, but, on the basis of hours and minutes and even seconds.
For instance, the ever present and ever powerful chatter of Twitter Feeds and Facebook Posts means
that professionals and laypersons alike are expected to respond to evolving and changing events and
trends almost instantaneously without pausing to check the consequences or the repercussions from both
the events as they happen in real time and their responses which are equally fast.
Thus, the HRM or the Human Resource Management Function is equally caught up in the
acceleration of business and life. This means that HR professionals are under stress to deliver results
the outcomes of which are instantaneous as opposed to being spread out over months and years.
Take, for instance, hiring, and recruitment. While the advent of the IT or the Information Technology
Sector and the Financial Services sector compressed the hiring cycles to quarters and months, the
present age of acceleration has further compressed it to days and weeks.
Indeed, even during the IT boom, HR managers were expected to fill positions within a quarter or a month
and even this was considered too hectic by many old timers among the HR professionals hitherto used to
hiring cycles that were more elaborate.
This resulted in the dilution of the quality of the talent that was being hired by many IT and Services
sector firms as there was simply not enough time to perform due diligence on all aspects of the
candidates being hired including and not limited to their technical and communication abilities but also
their backgrounds and other vital checks.
Indeed, the other aspect here is that due to the constrained economic situation, many organizations are
paring down their bench strengths so that they do not incur overheads and at the same time, make
optimal use of the existing resources.
This has led to a double whammy where positions and vacancies arise quickly, and the HR professionals
are expected to fill them even more quickly while being unable to tap the bench leading to a situation
where everyone is under pressure to act and deliver results.
Further, with the rise of temping and short duration positions, HR professionals are expected to give their
assent to recruits and talent as soon as possible since the talent being hired is either on a temporary
basis or on contractual and vendor based positions that do not require extensive vetting.
Thus, the contemporary HR professional is caught in a bind wherein the pressure to fill positions quickly
is doubled by the need to do a thorough if not basic vetting.
In addition, the performance appraisal and evaluation cycles have also shortened leading to more stress
on the HR professionals as they have to cope with the increased workload and the stress and strain.
Indeed, when everything happens “Now” and when the HR professionals are expected to deliver
results “As of Yesterday”, no wonder the burnout rate among this class of professionals’ ranks
with that of the Investment Bankers and Doctors.
Moreover, with feedback related to job performance and other attributes being sought as soon as the task
or the quarterly review is completed, the entire organizational ecosystem has to be geared towards
operating on a continuous and round the clock basis.
The Promise and the Perils of the Current Age for the HR Profession
Having said that, this does not mean that one should not take up HR as a profession anymore. On the
contrary, HR professionals now have more autonomy and options before them when compares to the
earlier decades.
For instance, the Age of Acceleration has meant that HR professionals now have more control over their
functions and jobs as organizational resources are divided in such a way that line managers and rank and
file employees focus on their core competencies leading to the HR function being left to the pure play HR
professionals instead of excessive interference.
Moreover, the HR professionals have more options related to hiring and firing as the former are aided by
a Phalanx of tools that give them more choices and channels for hiring and the latter are made easier by
the liberalization of labor laws and regulations that give organizations greater power over downsizing and
layoffs.
On the other hand, this has also led to some situations wherein excessive too quick firing has been
challenged in the courts and at the same time, hiring with more autonomy has not necessarily led to
better quality of talent.
To conclude, there are opportunities and challenges for the contemporary HR professionals, and hence,
the success or failure of these professionals depends to a large degree on how they have mastered the
art of quickness and have developed the ability to maintain a Zen like calmness in the face of constant
distraction.
In addition, some employees might be designated as Star Performers based on their appraisals and technical
acumen and the categorization of employees as either Star Performers or Fast Trackers or both is based on a
Matrix of factors such as the ones listed above.
Indeed, in some Multinationals, it is common for the high performers to be given paid vacations as well
as access to premium clubs and other benefits such as funding their children’s education and otherwise,
ensuring that such performers feel wanted and hence, continue to perform better and sustain their
performance.
Indeed, the history of modern corporates is littered with examples of Prima Donnas and Star Performers who
have gone on to flout ethical and normative rules resulting in such corporates being hauled up by the
regulators and consequently, leading to loss of brand image and monetary loss as well.
Apart from this, too much focus on Start Performers can lead to other employees being disgruntled or de-
motivated, and this can lead to attrition as well as a general dip in the morale of the workforce.
Moreover, Mollycoddling the Star Performers can lead to dissatisfaction among the other Star Performers due
to competition for limited places at the top.
In other words, not only can those performers who are doing well though not superlative being demoralized, it
can also lead to unhealthy competition among the Fast Trackers for promotions and a shot at the top job and
this can result in boardroom battles as well as jostling for senior management and executive positions.
Once, the evaluation is done, it becomes easier for the organizations to decide on appropriate roles and assign
key responsibilities accordingly.
For instance, HR Theory states that we have a composite need matrix comprising a Need for Achievement,
Need to be a People’s Person, and a Need for Power and hence, the HR managers must first identify which of
these needs as well as the combination of needs do the Star Performers have and then manage them
accordingly.
If a particular Fast Tracker has a Need for Achievement, then he or she must be placed in roles that provide
them with an opportunity to showcase their technical brilliance and shine in such roles.
Likewise, if such employees have a Need for being a People’s Person, then he or she is better suited for
People Management and Leadership roles that require such skills. On the other hand, a great need for Power
can mean that such employees must be handled with care lest they become power hungry and destabilize the
organization.
On the other hand, some of such high performers derive their motivation and drive from the external
environment where money and the need for approval from others are paramount and key to their success.
It follows from this that the former group of employees must be given challenging tasks that test their mettle
and reward them accordingly whereas the latter group of employees must be given roles where they manage
other people and are driven by the overall sense of satisfaction they get from seeing their fellow employees or
those who report to them succeed.
Both categories of employees must be rewarded monetarily, and the key difference or distinction here is to do
with the kinds of roles and the type of work they are assigned.
Conclusion
Lastly, it goes without saying that any Star Performer or Fast Tracker has to contend with the Bell Curve
method of performance evaluation as well as the very real limit on how high they can go up the hierarchy since
the Pyramidal nature of organizations means that only a few can get to the top, and only one can make to the
CEO or Chief Executive Officer position. To conclude, the way in which the Management and the HR
Professionals manage the Star Performers and Fast Trackers would determine the overall levels of
organizational success.
Indeed, not only is trust between people is necessary for the success of any endeavor, it is also essential
for any entity to even exist.
The recent events in some Indian corporates such as Infosys and the TATA group illustrate how even
venerable and reputed organizations known for their Corporate Governance standards can run into rough
weather when trust within the organization and with the external stakeholders breaks down.
This means that HR professionals have the task of building trust, and more importantly, maintaining and
sustaining it so that organizations continue to thrive in the Uber competitive marketplace.
While many factors determine whether a particular organization is a High Trust or Low Trust one, the key
aspect is the organizational culture which needs to encourage trust between the employees and
the organizational stakeholders and within the employees as well.
As can be seen from the definition given above, every organization and HR Function with clear
instructions from the Senior Management and Executive leadership codifies some rules or codes of
conduct that determine how employees must behave and act in their interactions with each other and with
the larger organizational ecosystem.
Thus, it is contingent upon the HR function to first assist the stakeholders in defining the rules, and then
ensuring that such rules are consistently maintained and enforced, and perhaps, the most important
aspect here is that such codes of conduct must be upheld meaning that during times of crisis, the HR
function must indeed “Walk the Talk” or must back up words with action.
Indeed, in the same manner in which social interactions between individuals are governed by spoken and
unspoken rules of conduct, so do organizations have codes of conduct that are both formal and informal
or written and codified and unwritten and implicit.
The task before the HR function is to ensure that both explicit and implicit codes of conduct are aligned to
the central aim of the key imperative of maintaining trust between the employees and the organizational
ecosystem and between and within the employees.
The Impact of Culture on Trust
A key challenge for any HR professional is to ensure that Cultural Factors and Socio-Cultural Influences
do not come in the way of actualizing a High Trust organization.
To explain, trust is as much a function of personality as it is about the societal culture in which the
people come from.
Thus, as many sociologists have pointed out, most Western nations are implicitly High Trust ones, and
while developing countries do have High Trust cultures, it is often the case that due to the diversity of
such cultures, there are challenges arising from cultural norms as far as building and maintaining trust is
concerned.
This means that HR professionals in Low Trust cultures have the additional task of ensuring that cultural
attributes do not affect the organizational norms related to maintaining and upholding trust between the
employees and the larger ecosystem.
Both these organizations have faced problems in recent times mainly due to the clash of cultures
between the old and the new or the founders and the outsiders wherein trust between these sets of
individuals broke down since each group had different notions of how trust operates in specific contexts.
Indeed, both these organizations are reputed for their High Trust organizational culture, and it is was
indeed consternating to witness the unseemly spectacle of the very public spat between each group and
the boardroom battles that arose from breaking down of trust between those groups.
Lastly, as has repeatedly been mentioned throughout this article, High Trust organizations also ensure
that trust is upheld in times of crisis and hence, this is where the senior leadership and the HR
professionals come into play when organizational crises happen.
Conclusion
Indeed, the necessity of maintaining trust is complemented by the behavior of the leadership during crises
when it becomes necessary to return to “First Principles” or the Raison D’être of Existence which when
translated into plain English means the core of what it means to work for such organizations.
To conclude, in the same manner in which personal crises threaten the character of individuals and how
they respond is indicative of their personality, organizational crises impact the core trust or the glue that
binds the organization, and hence, how the leadership responds determines whether the Trust Quotient
has broken down or is very much in existence.
HRM Strategies for an Increasingly Complex,
Uncertain, and Volatile World
Need for HRM Strategies to Change with the Times
Given the volatility and uncertainty that characterize the present day world which is also increasingly
becoming more complex, the HRM or the Human Resource Management strategies need to change with
the times.
For instance, conventional recruitment and training strategies are heavily oriented towards hiring science
and finance professionals and then training them on soft skills as well as other life skills.
However, given the fact that the basic education in finance or management does not include courses in
humanities such as political science and sociology as well as some amount of literature and other art
courses, contemporary firms must ensure that they recruit people with such skills.
In addition, grounding in humanities also teaches graduates the ability to think laterally instead of linear
thinking alone which the domain of management studies is.
Indeed, in times when exponential change is the order of the day, it makes sense for firms to hire
graduates in humanities apart from their usual hiring of management and commerce majors.
We do not recommend hiring arts and humanities majors and then expect them to perform according to
the requirements of the roles that they are assigned.
Rather, what we are saying is that there should be some shift towards either recruiting humanities majors
with some exposure to management or ensuring that management majors have some grounding in
finance and management.
While this might sound nonsensical to most HR Managers and leaders of leading firms, it is also the case
that many Wall Street firms in recent years have begun to make this shift.
Moreover, the fact that exposure to geopolitics is essential in a globalized world where business decisions
now include geopolitical calculations; this is another area where contemporary HR Managers can indeed
fine tune their recruitment strategies.
Also, it would be better for contemporary firms to train fresh as well as existing employees on a gamut of
skills instead of focusing narrowly on specific skills that are deemed critical to the job.
In other words, the volatile and unpredictable world needs people with the ability to sense the
pulse of undercurrents and the trends that shape the world. What better than train employees on
how to detect fast changing situations and be on top of the emerging trends that require a combination of
data driven skills as well as an intimate understanding of human nature which the humanities provide.
Need for Business Schools and Universities to Step up to the Occasion
Having said that, it is also not the case that firms alone should change their recruitment and training
strategies.
On the contrary, there is a role to play for business schools, and indeed, all universities wherein they offer
courses on a broad range of disciplines rather than offer courses on data based decision making or pure
humanities alone.
This means that the education sector too needs to change its attitudes towards broadening the skills of
their graduates.
In this context, it is worthwhile to note a few of the leading business schools in the United States and Asia
have woken up to this fact and are ensuring broad based education rather than narrow specializations.
However, some of the premier business schools in India were much ahead of the curve and offered a
wide variety of courses only to face resistance from several quarters who questioned whether they were
management schools or humanities colleges.
This calls for greater academia industry linkages wherein each is in tune with the requirements of the
other as well as cognizant of the limitations of each.
In addition, business schools must rework their executive management programs that run for a few weeks
or months instead of more elaborate programs that have the time for the executives to refresh themselves
and acquire new skills in the process.
There is also a role for the governments in this aspect, and this relates to allocating funds and
encouraging such broad based skill education to the extent that they can subsidize some of the costs
along with corporates and other stakeholders such as philanthropists.
Quants Nearly Crashed the Global Economy which was Rescued by the Quals
The point that we are making in this article is that the modern day business landscape is radically
different from what it was even a few decades ago and hence, there needs to be a Renaissance in the
way HRM is practiced regarding broad skill development rather than narrow specialization.
While we are not arguing against the latter, it needs to be kept in mind that the so-called Quants or the
Math wizards in Wall Street nearly crashed the entire global economy in 2008 and the rescue of which
happened because of the politicians who were grounded in the humanities who sensed the pulse better
than the bankers.
To conclude, while pure managerial skills are paramount, there is also a need for broad basing the
curriculum, HRM strategies, as well as the attitudes towards those who are perceived as merely being
artsy or intellectual with no quantitative abilities.
How Human Resource Managers can deal
with Difficult Employees
Introduction
One of the key challenges that HR (Human Resource) Managers face in any organization is how they
respond to employees violating organizational policies and plain disgruntled employees who are angry
with their appraisals and consequent pay hikes and bonuses.
Indeed, how astutely and adroitly the HR Managers deal with such employees determines their
competency and the maturity of not only them but also the organization.
It is also the case that every organization has its share of “difficult” employees and hence, how
well the HR professionals rise to the challenge of dealing with them is of paramount importance.
These violations can range from as simple as using the official internet access for personal work, as
medium as filing incorrect expense claims, and as severe as sexual harassment and outright violation of
the organizational rules governing ethics.
Also, there are the everyday cases of employees who are not happy with their managers and hence,
complain to the HR Managers about issues ranging from dissatisfaction with their present role to that of
protesting the low bonuses or inadequate pay hikes.
In these cases, the employee typically is kept on watch, and his or her browsing activities monitored for
compliance or otherwise. In most cases, such employees cease their activities and fall in line with the
organizational rules.
In cases where it does not happen, the HR Manager has to take a call about more serious action against
the employee, and this is where the GPM or the Group Project Manager comes into the picture. In our
experience in the corporate world, we have found that some employees are also fired for these
transgressions since the need to maintain organizational discipline overrides other concerns such as the
performance of the employee and his or her value to the organization.
Indeed, in our experience, we have come across an employee of a leading firm using the company
guesthouse for his partner and himself by wrongly stating that they are married. In this case, after the
preliminary inquiry and the subsequent investigation found that the employee had indeed committed the
transgression and violated the organizational norms, the employee was fired immediately.
In all these cases, it is usually the HR Manager who is in charge of the investigation along with the Chief
Compliance Officer and the dedicated committee that is set up to determine offense and punishment.
Indeed, most organizations do not leave any scope for the line managers to take decisions regarding
dismissal and it is usually these stakeholders who decide in such cases.
In these times when sexual harassment has become a serious issue, no organization is willing to brook
such acts of harassment and discrimination, and this is the reason all leading organizations have
dedicated committees set up for the purpose of investigating such claims.
Indeed, the laws now demand that all organizations have a committee that is comprised of both external
and internal representatives wherein along with in-house staff and the HR Managers, there are external
individuals representing NGOs (Non-Governmental Organizations) working in the field of women’s rights
and other experts drawn from individuals working in the same fields.
To conclude, all organizations need to enforce discipline and compliance with their rules, and the HR
Manager plays a critical and crucial role in this respect.
Thus, it is no longer an if, but, when robots start taking away jobs and hence, it is contingent on the HR
Managers to change accordingly.
Indeed, the fact that automation is like a “slap in the face” for older workers who are unable or even
unwilling to learn new skills means that HR Managers would have a tough time in handling involuntary
exits.
The term involuntary exit refers to the downsizing and hiring of workers wherein they are made to leave or
exit the company against their will.
The least that the HR Managers can do in these circumstances is to offer office facilities for the laid-off
workers to find other jobs as well as negotiate a generous severance package for them.
In addition, the HR Managers must also prepare themselves for some tough bargaining by the workers
who might even sue the organization for firing workers on flimsy pretexts. Indeed, this is what is
happening in India right now where IT (Information Technology) industry employees are being fired in the
hundreds and thousands, and some of whom have gone to court to protest the layoffs.
They also have to envisage a scenario wherein top performers and the best employees in the
organization are re-skilled and retrained instead of being let go.
In other words, if the employees are valuable to the organization and hence, firing them is the last option,
the key challenge, in this case, is to upgrade their skills and enhance their performance through value
addition.
Thus, it becomes incumbent upon the HR Managers to devise retraining and re-skilling programs so that
employees move up the value chain.
In this context, it is worthwhile to note that retraining and re-skilling of employees can be done through
customized training programs where the HR Managers have to take a call in conjunction with the
Immediate Managers to identify the employees as well as design training programs based on the need
analysis and the identification of gaps between current skills and required skills.
It is this aspect that calls for adroit and adept personal and professional skills for the HR Managers to
respond to automation and robotics revolutions.
Moreover, automation and robotics also lead to changes in the way the HR Function works, and with the
downsizing of rank and file employees, there is also a chance that the HR Staff would be made redundant
since routine processes can be automated, and robots replace the personnel.
Indeed, given that technology has already made many HR Staff redundant means that the next wave of
automation wherein robots takes the place of nonessential personnel means that there is a need to
rethink the very concept of an HR Professional.
The key point to note in all this is that just like computerization made the workers migrate to higher value
adding activities, robotics, and automation would also ensure that lower value-adding activities are
automated.
Thus, the central challenge for any professional or organization is how to move up the value chain, and
this is where the field of HRM can answer these questions by formulating new theories and revisiting
existing theories. After all, capitalism is built around value addition, and we contend that sooner or later,
the teething problems associated with automation and robotics would be resolved.
Thus, it is clear that there needs to be another evolutionary leap to deal with the challenges of automation
and robotics so that there is a win-win situation for all stakeholders and not only employers.
The fact that the search for profits means that employers would always find the most cost-effective ways
to get work done should serve as a signpost to the future for HR Professionals.
To conclude, HR Managers must prepare for not only job losses and retraining but also a fundamental
change in the way their profession operates to compete in the coming Fourth Industrial Revolution.
While Silicon Valley firms were always known for their employee-friendly policies, what is different in
recent years has been the business need to be competitive and productive in a market landscape that is
cutthroat and extremely difficult without their employees contributing the fullest. Indeed, the IT and
Software Industry is based on a business model where employees are sources of sustainable competitive
advantage and are viewed as assets and the key intellectual capital that the firms possess. Thus, it
makes sense for the Silicon Valley firms to implement HRM policies that are known to be people-centric
as defined in the theoretical model of SHRM or Strategic Human Resource Management.
Apart from that, with intensifying competition between the Big Five of Tech, or the five firms such as
Amazon, Google, Apple, Facebook, and Microsoft that dominate the tech industry, these firms have to
have human resources that are optimally used. Indeed, given the fact that technology is accelerating
exponentially, it is indeed a dire necessity for these firms to stay ahead of the technology and
innovation curve. Thus, this calls for extremely innovative and inventive practices in the
workplace which is what the Silicon Valley firms are doing.
For instance, Google allows its employees to work on projects of their choice every month for a few days
which means that the creative and innovative pursuits that employees have are nurtured and encouraged.
Moreover, it is sometimes mentioned that important breakthroughs such as Chrome Browser and other
plug-ins have been the result of these initiatives which place Google in a strong position to compete with
other tech firms. In addition, Google also has a policy wherein employees are encouraged to bring their
children and even pets to work wherein the offices have crèches and pet holding areas which create an
atmosphere of familiarity and congeniality for the employees.
Indeed, Silicon Valley firms have been the pioneers in creating a workplace culture that is
collegiate in nature wherein the atmosphere and the workplace are akin to that of campuses and
colleges from which the youthful workforce is drawn from. It can be said that given the composition
of the workforce which is predominantly under thirty, there is a business need as well to ensure that free-
flowing ideas and innovation thrive among the employees. Thus, this has resulted in a situation where
most Silicon Valley firms pride themselves on their ability to attract and retain top-tier talent from
campuses and universities.
Further, the dress down policy that allows employees to come to work in casual attire has been another
feature of Silicon Valley firms in their quest to create a workplace culture that is informal. Also, employees
are encouraged to participate in a creative dialogue about the workplace culture and the organizational
policies as well through Electronic Bulletin Boards and Town Halls where the founders often interact
directly with the employees to understand their grievances and needs as well as to seek feedback on how
the workplace can be made better.
In recent months, Silicon Valley has been shaken by controversies about gender discrimination and
harassment based on minority categorization which means that maybe it is time for them to rethink some
of the assumptions that underlie their belief that all is well as far as workplace culture is concerned. What
has ignited the debate about these issues is that after the election of President Trump, most
organizations and not only the Silicon Valley firms are finding it difficult to create a workplace that is not
ideologically polarized and which is free from partisan debates.
Thus, it is imperative that the Top Management of firms such as Google and Facebook along with Apple
address the issues raised by some employees and ensure that they regain the tag of being organizations
where creativity and innovativeness thrive. Indeed, as mentioned earlier, organizations across the United
States and elsewhere as well are finding it hard to control the partisan debates and politically loaded
comments from employees and this means that maybe it is time for HR Managers across Corporate
America and especially the Silicon Valley firms to engage with others in the industry on ways and means
to detoxify the workplace.
Lastly, Silicon Valley firms also operate in a “bubble” meaning that it is easy for employees
working in those companies to be divorced from the realities of the majority of Americans who are
not as well paid or as well looked after like them. Thus, it is our view that Silicon Valley firms should
take the lead in anticipating future societal challenges in the same way it is known and famous for being
ahead of the future. To conclude, with the Smartphone and Computing revolution, the Big Five have a
golden opportunity to reshape the workplace of the future and ensure that they remain innovative through
their HR policies.
Effective HRM Strategies to Smoothen and
Sweeten the Downsizing and the Layoff
Process
Exits, Whether Voluntary Or Involuntary, are Inevitable
Organizations let go of employees for a variety of reasons. While voluntary exits or those employees who
leave organizations to seek greener pastures elsewhere are at one of the spectrum in terms of process
and the HR (Human Resource) strategies used, involuntary exits where employees are made to resign for
indiscipline and violation of company policies as well as are downsized and laid off represent the other
end of the spectrum in terms of the manner and the ways in which such exits are handled.
Indeed, given the fact that organizations routinely downsize employees on economic and
business grounds means that HR Managers must devise innovative and inventive strategies when
handling such exits.
Indeed, the fact that downsizing and layoffs without sufficient grounds and reasons can lead to such
employees suing the organizations as well as the media reporting on such events thereby leading to legal
problems means that organizations have to have effective strategies to deal with such layoffs.
The examples of Infosys, Tech Mahindra, and Cognizant Technologies shows, the legal route is much
preferred whenever there are mass layoffs in addition to negative media coverage that can lead to the
reputation and image of the organization taking a hit.
Apart from this, the employees who are to be laid off must be provided with sufficient monetary
“handshakes” wherein a few months salary or a onetime severance allowance is given to them. Indeed,
many countries have such explicit rule where it is legally mandated that employees being laid off for
business and economic reasons ought to be provided with some benefit.
Also, the exit process must be handled with care and caution so that charges of insensitivity and
indifference are not leveled against the organizations.
For instance, in the same examples of the Indian IT sector, there were many stories in the so-called “pink
papers” or the business and economic newspapers about the HR managers terminating the services of
employees in a rude and unprofessional manner.
The fact that some of these organizations did not even bother to talk to the employees in a polite manner
was highlighted thereby tarnishing the reputations of the organizations.
What we are suggesting and recommending, however, is the professional handling of exits whether
voluntary or involuntary.
After all, the employees have given their best to the organizations, and it is but natural that they expect
some consideration for their services.
Thus, the approach should be one where neither the organizations nor the employees who are being laid
off get the “short end of the stick” and hence, there must be an acceptance of the inevitability of
downsizing from all stakeholders.
These agencies are staffed with experts who are adept at handling the downsizing process, and their
services include smoothening and sweetening the exit process through professional handling.
For instance, some of these agencies provide the downsized employees access to office spaces where
they can utilize the facilities for searching for other jobs without having to find such facilities on their own.
Moreover, such agencies also address the employees who are to be laid off in Town Halls and other
gatherings where the business case for the exits is made and where the terms and benefits of severance
are explained.
Thus, we recommend firms in India and elsewhere as well to hire such agencies for handling exits in case
their in-house HR staff finds itself inadequate to the task.
For instance, the recruitment value chain consists of placing ads in various media to attract potential
employees, receiving the resumes from them, matching the resumes with the job descriptions through
keyword parsing and other aspects, sending the resumes to the appropriate managers for further
processing, shortlisting candidates for interviews, and lastly, arranging for written tests and face to face
interviews.
Most of these tasks can be automated and by using advanced Artificial Intelligence enabled tools
and software; the HR function can indeed save time and actualize efficiencies from the economies of
scale and synergies from the integration of the end to end value chain of the recruitment process.
For instance, apart from placing ads and other such details about the vacancies in the various media, the
recruitment process also consists of receiving the resumes and matching them with the job descriptions.
This is a routine and repetitive activity which when done manually takes a lot of time in addition to
devoting dedicated staff and other resources.
There are many tools and software in the market that automate this task wherein they use AI and Big
Data as well as Data Analytics to pars the resumes and find matching keywords with the job descriptions.
Indeed, this key task that is often time-consuming can be automated thereby saving time.
Also, the HR function can reach out to the potentially unlimited number of applicants through the use of
such tools and software as once this task is automated; then it becomes easier to “blast the resumes” and
process them on a mass scale.
Indeed, Resume Blasting means that candidates can send their resumes to unlimited number of
recruiters in addition to the recruiters receiving such resumes on a mass scale. This activity is mostly
automated in most companies, and when the task of matching the resumes with the job descriptions and
then sending them to the appropriate managers is automated, it leads to further time savings as well as
efficiencies from the economies of scale. Tools that use AI often parse through the resumes for matching
the skills with the job descriptions.
Indeed, even the managers can save time by using these tools to “winnow” the resumes and then
“narrow” them down to a few so that they need not spend too much time on this task.
Further, once the resumes are shortlisted, the next task of contacting the candidates can also be
automated whereby mass mailers can be used to inform the candidates about the next round in the
selection process, whether it is a written test or a face to face interview.
Apart from this, the other tasks that lead right up to the actual interview and fitment rounds can also be
automated thereby ensuring that the HR Function focuses on value building and concentrates on higher
value-adding activities.
Indeed, such tools and software save the HR Function a lot of time with some industry experts reporting
that nearly 50-60% of the time that the HR function spends can be saved in the process. This means that
automating routine and repetitive tasks can indeed result in efficiencies and synergies for the HR
Function.
Indeed, the fact that Payroll is automated in most organizations means that even the other tasks that are
driven and performed on a mass scale can be automated as well. As technology often creates value
through providing economies of scale due to its ability to scale up, it also actualizes synergies from
integration.
For instance, when disparate and separate tasks that the HR does are automated, then the integration
often creates value that was hitherto hidden and hence, can lead to significant benefits for contemporary
organizations.
Thus, it is clear that while the HR function can be trimmed and some staff let go due to automation, the
benefits are that the remaining staff can focus on higher value-adding activities not to mention leaps in
productivity and efficiency.
To conclude, most organizations typically have lean HR functions that are staffed with minimal people
mainly because the tasks that this function does are largely routine and hence, they focus on automating
such tasks and ensuring that the key personnel focuses on value addition to the organizations.
How HR Managers Can Help Employees
Avoid Burnout and Manage Stress
In the increasingly fast-paced and uber-competitive business landscape, stress and burnout are inevitable
consequences for employees in organizations that have to adapt and respond to the external pressures
through internal excellence.
This means that the pursuit of profit-driven excellence creates a high-pressure working environment
where burnout and stress often take a toll on the employees.
Indeed, most Western firms report that nearly half of their employees mention stress and burnout
to a lesser extent as the reason for low productivity as well as lack of focus and an inability to
prioritize work.
Apart from this, stress and burnout are reported at all levels of the organizational hierarchy and it only
“gets worse as one move up the ladder”.
This can create problems for the organizations regarding lost hours of work from stressed-out employees
taking frequent leave of absence on medical grounds as well as poor decision making and an impaired
ability to exercise proper judgment.
Indeed, this was borne out in the recent case of the ride-hailing app based firm, Uber, where nearly the
entire board was replaced including its founder who cited burnout and stress as the reasons for their
allegedly unethical conduct during cases of sexual and other forms of harassment.
While it is not the intention of the authors to justify such poor decision making and impaired sense of what
is right and wrong on the basis of burnout, it is also the case that unless organizations evolve strategies
to counter stress and avoid burnout, such instances of bad behavior will continue to the point of
exhaustion and slow-motion collapse of the employees thereby jeopardizing the future of the
organizations.
Indeed, the fact that everyone experiences stress to some extent and which if left unchecked and
untreated can lead to complete burnout harming the careers and threatening the very existence of the
organizations should serve as a wakeup call to all stakeholders to take this malaise seriously.
Perhaps this was the reasoning behind the recent decision of the British Government to pass legislation
termed Thriving at Work that seeks to remedy the instances of mental health issues and other
manifestations of stress and burnout in organizations.
This legislation addresses such problems by mandating organizations and Human Resource (HR)
Managers to proactively work with the employees reporting such disorders and provide them with the
necessary support and resources to address their disorders.
This can include asking them to take time off with pay, providing help to them by creating support
systems that include other managers with the task of people management to work with them to spot
symptoms of extreme stress and act on them to prevent complete burnout.
While this legislation is indeed a welcome piece of the action by the government, it is also the case that
HR Managers must put in place measures to help employees cope with stress and burnout.
Indeed, despite legislative and regulatory mandates, surveys have found that most organizations leave it
to the employees to devise coping mechanisms to deal with stress and burnout without overt support.
This cannot be the case since stress and burnout cost the organizations as much as they cost the
employees in both monetary and non-monetary terms and hence, it is equally beneficial to both
organizations and employees if they start taking these problems seriously.
Moreover, the fact that despite slogans of Work-Life Balance and Fun at Work programs, there is a
need for fundamental change in the attitudes of the HR managers and other stakeholders where
they begin to empathize with the employees rather than treating stress and burnout in a matter of
fact manner.
Indeed, the point to note here is that stressed out and burned out employees’ need the “human touch”
and the “humane treatment” since surveys have also found that most employees report feeling lonely at
work and report indifference to their problems.
Having said that, it is also the case that despite the best efforts of some organizations to help employees
“take it easy”, the fact remains that in our “over-connected world”, stress, and burnout due to working in a
24/7 environment that is technologically mediated and driven by constant disturbance also contribute to
stress and burnout.
Thus, there is a need to address such problems as well by measures such as requiring no after office
hours calls and emails.
Indeed, this is precisely what the French Government has done by passing a law that requires employers
not to contact employees after working hours and not penalizing employees for not returning calls or
responding to emails after they leave work.
More such laws and legislation, as well as voluntary measures from the employers and the HR Managers,
are needed if we are to navigate the terrain of stress and burnout successfully.
Lastly, we have reached a point where the race to be productive becomes a race to keep up and avoid
falling by the wayside.
Thus, unless there is a paradigm shift in the way employers and employees with the HR Managers
mediating between address the problems of stress and burnout, the future world of work already
threatened by automation and robots taking our jobs would become that much more attractive since
robots do not burnout (except in case of electrical short circuits) and hence, it is in our collective interest
to deal with stress and burnout.
A diverse enhances organizational effectiveness by creating a culture of plurality and tolerance that
promotes collective decision making through multiple viewpoints that can be used for better decision
making.
Thus, the HRM or the Human Resources Management strategies must include end-to-end
capabilities that promote diversity. This can take the form of color-blind recruitment and gender neutral
as well as location independent recruitment that ensures that the employees who are recruited are not
according to the biases of the recruiters or the managers and instead, reflect true diversity in action.
Further, HR professionals can also actualize a diverse workforce through retention strategies and
promotion strategies that enhance the diversity of the workforce. Above all, the HRM strategies must also
be towards actualizing a workplace culture free from harassment and discrimination on account of
gender, race, sexual orientation, or geographies.
These imperatives call for end-to-end policies and strategies that span the entire HRM value chain
starting with recruitment, including retention, and covering workplace culture policies. Also, it is not
enough to have such policies in place, and there must be effective enforcement of such policies as well.
For instance, bias-free recruitment can help in preventing recruitment of specific region or geographical-
based candidates wherein recruiters from the same region or place does not have a say in selecting only
such candidates.
Apart from this, color-blind recruitment can also help in loading the new employees with specific races or
ethnicities such as barring African Americans or Hispanics and instead, recruiting White Americans alone.
Further, these strategies can be implemented by requiring the resumes of potential applicants to not
include their gender, race, or ethnicity as well as sexual orientation. Also, the resumes need not have the
names of the candidates as well to ensure that bias-free recruitment happens.
In these times, when trans-genders and those who are gays or lesbians are being sought to be recruited
by multinationals with a view to promote diversity, these types of recruitment strategies would go a long
way in meeting such goals.
Indeed, recruiting employees of different races and genders as well as ethnicities alone would not help if
such employees are demoralized due to workplace discrimination and hence, either quit their jobs or
perform below par which can again lead to a workplace culture that is not fully discrimination free.
Thus, the key aspect to note here is that employee retention strategies must not only be put in place but
also enforced. Indeed, the key to a diverse workforce is through “walking the talk” which means that
enforcement is as important or perhaps more than having policies in place.
For instance, having anonymous helplines and mentors to guide the employees to report cases of
harassment and discrimination can help in retaining such employees. In addition, efforts must be made to
listen to such employees and act on their concerns which mean that there should not be double
standards when it comes to such employees. In short, all employees must be made to feel welcome and
not only those belonging to specific categorizations.
This calls for effective monitoring of the workplace behavior of all the employees so that the workplace
culture is free from discrimination.
Glass Ceilings and How to Eliminate Barriers
Having a workplace culture free from harassment and promoting diversity also means that the glass
ceiling for women and those from minority races and ethnicities must be discouraged. The term glass
ceiling refers to the aspect of women employees not being allowed to move up the hierarchy by covert
means that are expressed in both verbal and nonverbal terms.
For instance, women employees must not be discouraged from pursuing their ambitions through
innuendo and other forms of indirect harassment where the discrimination is insidious and morale-
sapping. Also, employees belonging to specific races or ethnicities should not be made to feel that they
are unwelcome.
Indeed, the fact that a “ghetto culture” that segregates the employees according to race, gender, ethnicity,
or sexual orientation is a clear sign that such employees are being made unwelcome and hence, are
either forced to quit or suffer from poor performance.
Apart from this, promotion policies must be color blind and gender neutral as well. While we are not
advocating affirmative action where employees belonging to specific categories are explicitly favored over
others, what we are recommending is a level playing field for all employees irrespective of their
categorization.
By automating selection and recruitment and by using technology to gather data about promotion and
workplace behavior, the effectiveness of the diversity policies can be enhanced.
To conclude, organizational diversity can turn into a key asset if the end-to-end value chains of the
HRM activities are done through a view to actualizing a workplace that is diverse and more importantly,
free from harassment.
Indeed, in the manufacturing era, the term used for HR functions was personnel management and
industrial relations wherein the job of the personnel manager was to ensure that salaries are paid on time,
mediating between the unions and the organizations, and otherwise being peripheral to the other
functions such as production, operations, sales and marketing, and strategy formulation.
It was only with the advent of the services sector that the role of the erstwhile personnel manager
transformed into “human resources” management and later on, to people management and people
enabling and people empowerment.
Note the emphasis on resources and people as the services sector relies on human capital as the key
asset and hence, the HR managers were expected to contribute to strategic goals and objectives.
In other words, the HR function evolved and transformed into one where it was no longer peripheral or a
support function, and instead of times when human resources are viewed as sources of sustainable
strategic advantage, the role of the HR manager was to aid and enable such resources to contribute
effectively and meaningfully to the organizational strategies.
What is an HR Scorecard?
Concomitant to these developments was the evolution of the initiatives such as HR Scorecard which are
tools to measure how well the HR function is aligned to the overall strategic goals of the
organization.
In other words, HR now was expected to align its recruitment, compensation, and employee retention
strategies to the organizational strategies.
What this means is that in contemporary organizations, the HR managers have a “seat at the leadership
table” or to put it simply, they have to be aligned with the larger organizational strategies.
Towards this end, the HR Scorecard works by providing decision-makers with data and inputs about how
much the employee recruitment and retention processes cost and what are the benefits of the same.
For much of the 20th century, it was commonly understood that these costs are part of the overall
organizational costs and there was no way to measure the benefits of such expenses in “tangible” ways.
In other words, what this means is that an HR Scorecard provides the organizational leaders with metrics
and data in tangible terms about the payoffs and the benefits from HR processes and activities.
For instance, if high potential and highly talented employees are hired, the costs of hiring and retention
are then measured and stacked against the likely benefits that such activities bring to the organization.
Apart from this, the real usefulness of HR Scorecards is that it gathers metrics about activities and
processes such as training and then identifies the likely benefits in terms of result oriented and metric-
based training outcomes.
In other words, “by keeping score” of which training cost how much and how useful or relevant it was in
addition to how much benefit that such training meant to the attendees, the HR Scorecard provides the
leadership and the HR managers with measures and metrics on the “value” that is being created to the
organization.
Thus, HR scorecards are indeed useful and relevant in contemporary organizations that take human
resources seriously.
What are the Benefits of HR Scorecards?
The key benefit or the relevance of tools such as HR Scorecards is that it aligns the broader
organizational strategies with the HR strategies and the convergence of organizational goals with the HR
goals brings the HR function in line and tune with the overall organizational ecosystem.
For instance, how this works in the real world is that if an organization identifies superlative customer
service as a strategic goal, the HR scorecard helps in measuring the benefits of initiatives such as
training the customer service representatives and the associated staff costs involved in hiring and
retaining such key personnel.
At the end of the year, the benefits of the initiatives as measured by customer feedback surveys are
tallied to the costs of the initiatives so that organizational decision makers and more importantly, the HR
Managers have an idea about the effectiveness and efficacy of their hiring and retention strategies and
their usefulness and relevance to the broader organizational goals and objectives.
In other words, the HR function is no longer a “silo” that stands apart in “splendid isolation” and is instead,
aligned with the overall organizational ecosystem of goals and objectives.
Indeed, while it can be argued that the HR Function was always expected to be aligned to the overall
organizational imperatives, the key benefit that the HR Scorecard brings is that it provides data and
metrics to support its qualitative narrative.
In other words, the HR Scorecard operates through data-driven and metric-based measurement and
tracking of the progress and the benefits of the various initiatives.
This data based approach combined with an objective CBA or Cost-Benefit Analysis means that decision-
makers can identify where costs can be cut or where optimization and rationalization of benefits accrued
from such costs can be done.
To conclude, an HR Scorecard represents an entirely new way of aligning the HR and the wider
organizational goals and objectives.
For instance, if metrics related to hiring and retention of resources needs to be collected, technology can
certainly help in this aspect by both speeding up the process as well as through more targeted and
accurate collection of such metrics.
Indeed, using technology such as Big Data Analytics and Artificial Intelligence powered tools, the metrics
can be made more granular meaning that there can be more targeted and relevant as well as accurate
collection.
For instance, using Big Data and AI, metrics can be made more fine or accurate wherein data
related to recruitment and retention of the resources can be made more granular. Indeed, both Big
Data and AI help the collection of data related to how well the profiles of the candidates interviewed and
eventually hired match with each other.
This can help subsequent iterations of the recruitment process by ensuring that the gap between “needs”
and “fulfillment” is narrowed.
Indeed, technology helps the HR Function to “continuously evolve” and optimize wherein each
round of the process helps in learning for the future and subsequent rounds. Further, Big Data and AI can
also help in reducing the time it takes to collect data and metrics.
For instance, using technology, the data collection process can be speeded up and indeed, made real the
process need not have “lags” between the recruitment step and the data collection step.
Apart from this, data and metrics related to employee retention strategies can be collected wherein each
part of the retention value chain such as hiring, on the job performance, the value derived from training
and people empowerment, and the longevity of the employees in the organization can all be made more
efficient.
To take an example, if ten employees were recruited for a particular position and then trained on value
adding skills apart from being monitored for their performance, depending on how many of them were still
with the organization, the data about each of these steps can be collected and measured in a more
efficient manner.
Data is the New Oil and Technology Helps the Data Transformation into
Information
In addition, technology can help in the HR Scorecard objectives of aligning the HR function with
the organizational goals and strategies. For instance, data related to the “bottom line” imperatives of
the organization can be matched with the data related to the HR Scorecard parameters and then, can be
matched with each other thereby revealing how well these are aligned to each other.
Indeed, using Big Data and AI, such matching can be made more efficient by accurately reporting on the
exact misses and hits between the organizational goals and the HR process outcomes. In other words,
using technology, not only can data be collected better but the use of such data can be made more
efficient and productive.
Because the HR Scorecard is aimed at data-driven measures, it is indeed the case that technology that
thrives on data can help the objectives and goals behind the same. Further, in an age where “Data is the
New Oil” or in other words, data is precious and valuable, technology can definitely help in ensuring that
datasets that are rich on information are collected.
Apart from this, the transformation of data into usable information that is not only relevant but also more
accurate can be made better using technology since any technology typically is about raw data collection
as well as making it more usable and relevant.
Indeed, Big Data and AI can help in this transformation of data into information and knowledge by
algorithmic driven matching of the datasets with the needed information by the organizational
stakeholders.
Example of Siri
To take an example, iPhone and other Smartphone users are aware of the AI Driven Voice
Assistants such as Siri that take commands from the users and retrieve and display relevant
information.
In the same manner, technology can help the HR Executives and the Senior Leadership in organizations
to have a “Bird’s Eye View” of the HR Scorecard by feeding in the requirements and then using the
information retrieved to make better decisions about which aspects of the HR Scorecard have met the
objectives and which aspects need improvement.
Conclusion
Lastly, Knowledge is Power, and as mentioned earlier, Data is the New Oil. As the HR Scorecard is all
about how well the data and the metrics square up with the goals and objectives, technology can help
decision-makers in making informed decisions about the organizational and the HR strategies.
Organizations consist of people who perform the needed work for them. Also, such work is determined by
the strategies that the organizations plan for the year or quarter ahead. Thus, it can be said that while the
organization strategizes, the people implement the strategy.
In this context, there has to be a mechanism to measure the outcomes of the strategy such as the
performance of the organization across the parameters and the individual components of the strategies.
This is where the Human Resources (HR) Scorecard comes into the picture wherein it provides the
decision makers with an easy method to evaluate the success or otherwise of the strategies by
quantifying the outcomes associated with such strategies.
While one can legitimately ask about how organizations overall measure their outcomes of the strategies,
the answer to this would be that tools such as Balanced Scorecard and other methods are typically
employed by the organizations as far as the overall strategies are concerned.
On the other hand, the HR Scorecard provides the decision makers with an easy tool to measure
the Human Resources component of the strategies in addition to aligning the HR Outcomes with
the overall strategic outcomes of the organization.
In other words, the real usefulness of the HR Scorecard is that it integrates the HR Function into the
overall organizational grid of strategic outcomes. To take an example, say a software firm wants to find
out how much a particular employee who was recruited in the last fiscal contributed to the success of the
organization.
Using the HR Scorecard, such measures can be quantified by tying in the costs spent on recruitment,
training, and compensation with the benefits that the organization actualized from that particular
employee. In this manner, the HR Scorecard provides decision makers with an easy to use tool to
align the people, strategy, and performance aspects of the integrated organizational strategic
matrices and the grids.
For instance, one can argue that performance in numerical terms is an intangible aspect as it is not
always easy to put a number on the specific performance of the employees in monetary terms. Indeed,
the fact that the monetary calculations are often the hardest part of the HR Scorecard means that cost-
benefit analysis and other aspects have to be taken up only after due diligence is done on the measures
as well as the methods to arrive at such measures.
This is where Algorithmic methods come in handy as it becomes easy using Big Data and Algorithmic
driven tools to at least arrive at approximations of how the performance of specific employees measures
against the overall strategic objectives.
Further, the best part in this respect is that the HR Scorecard provides the Algorithms with the needed
parameters through which the measurement of such parameters can be arrived at. Thus, the HR
Scorecard used in conjunction with such computing tools can help decision-makers make considered
decisions.
As can be seen from the discussion so far, the HR Scorecard provides us with a method to align the
broader organizational strategies with the specific people aspects by bringing in the performance
measures into the calculation.
While quantification of the measures would indeed help the organization, it needs to be remembered that
even qualitative tallying of the measures and reporting them would help all stakeholders.
To take an example, end of year assessments can be done using the HR Scorecard both by quantitative
as well as qualitative means. Whereas the former can be done using any of the methods as discussed
earlier, the latter can be done in a tabular or grid manner wherein the objectives and the outcomes can be
arrived at using the HR Scorecard.
Conclusion
Lastly, the real usefulness of the HR Scorecard is that it “keeps the score” on the performance of the HR
Function. To take a Cricket Analogy, it does not matter how many runs a Batsman scores or how many
wickets a Bowler takes if such outcomes do not help the team or are not measured accurately.
In the same manner, the HR Scorecard aligns the various HR and the Organizational parameters into a
cohesive and coherent whole that can be used to assess how well the HR Function ties into the overall
organizational strategy and performance imperatives.
It can be the result of a sense of atrophy due to the organizational arteries being clogged as a result of
inertia and apathy. It can also be due to the lack of the senior leadership and the rank and file employees
“not being on the same page” as far as coordination and communication are concerned.
A common thread that runs all these factors and causes of organizational dysfunction is the people
equation wherein the human resources in the organization are failing in their duty to discharge their
responsibilities.
Indeed, when the organizational parameters start failing the test of success and when different functions
of the organization pull it in different directions, there is something seriously wrong about the way in which
the people in the organization are interacting with each other.
The obvious solution here would be to then recruit the right people and train them according to the
organizational needs and more importantly, put in place measures that would capture how much value
the people are creating for the organization.
In addition, it is also important for the HR Strategies to be “tied into” the overall organizational goals and
objectives.
How this works in practice would be first to recruit the people that are needed for such objectives and
goals and then train them according to the needs of the various functions for which they have been
recruited.
Also, it is important to measure how much value is being created by such resources and whether they are
contributing to the organizational value creation. All these measures and steps must be data-driven, and
this is where the HR Scorecard has an important role to play in tying the HR Function to the overall
organizational imperatives.
For instance, there can be measures of how each employee in different functions are performing
and whether the costs of recruitment and training are paying off.
In addition, there can be financial indicators of the usefulness or otherwise of the efficacy of the HR
Function wherein the costs incurred by it are compared to the benefits that accrue to the organization.
To take an example, if the HR Function spends a Hundred Thousand Dollars on Recruitment and
Training as well as Retention strategies, the benefits in terms of how much sales each employee has
generated or the number of billable hours that they have worked on can be used in the HR Scorecard to
tabulate and arrive at measures to reduce any dysfunction in the way the organization as a whole is
performing.
Indeed, the fact that if you can measure it, it works means that the HR Scorecard provides organizations
a key data-driven tool with which they can evaluate the usefulness of the HR Function to the organization.
It needs to be mentioned that the P&L Accounting, in this case, is not as easy or straightforward as it
seems since computing the benefits and apportioning them to the costs calls for advanced data gathering
and analytics based calculations.
In this context, it would be worthwhile to note that the HR Scorecard can help in this regard since it uses
such measures as required under the P&L Accounting and with using software and technical tools that
are part of the HR Scorecard Toolkit, organizations can have a better grip on how well the HR Function is
contributing to the organization.
In short, the HR Scorecard “brings together” the organizational goals and the HR strategies so that the
decision makers know what to target in case of dysfunction due to people issues.
Conclusion
Lastly, organizational dysfunction can be addressed by first analyzing the causes and then finding the
solutions. The specific aspect of people contributing to such dysfunction can be addressed using
the HR Scorecard as discussed so far and this is where the Integration of the HR Function with the other
P&L Centers can be quite useful. In times when human resources are the main asset in most
organizations, the HR Scorecard is indeed valuable and useful to understand how successful the HR
Function has been as far as meeting the organizational goals are concerned. To conclude, using data-
driven measures, the HR Scorecard can be invaluable to decision makers to address people dysfunction
that is causing organizational dysfunction.
Western Transnational corporations first introduced these practices in response to the emerging needs of
people enabling and people management.
While Manufacturing firms did follow some of these employee and labor-friendly policies, it was only after
the advent of the services sector that firms in the Software and Financial Services sectors began to take
people enabling seriously.
Soon, what began in the West was adopted by Eastern firms as well wherein many Chinese and Indian
firms started to follow some of the people friendly HRM policies of the Western firms.
This was because some Indian firms located in the Big Metros often felt that due to the scarcity of
affordable accommodation as well as constraints to do with accommodation in the central parts of such
cities, it would be better if they saved their employees the trouble of finding accommodation on their own.
Moreover, the fact that commute times were longer, as well as lead to lower productivity, meant that many
Asian firms started providing free pickup and drop to their employees.
This is also recommended by HRM experts who often point to the highly charged and stressful modern
workplaces and hence, suggest that unless employees are allowed to de-stress and rejuvenate and take
time off during work, they might not contribute to their best.
Further, some of these Best Practices have also been introduced due to the highly creative nature of the
work that firms in the Software sector do. For instance, Google and Facebook, as well as Amazon, have
workplaces that are highly creative as well as demanding, these firms go the extra mile as far as ensuring
that their employees are engaged and relaxed at work.
In addition, they also provide for their employees to work on their personal projects and initiatives during
some part of the month to ensure that they are motivated by their inner need for fulfillment of their
personal desires.
Apart from this, the concept of variable pay as well as performance-linked pay is now followed uniformly
across the world. Further, fun and entertainment budgets are now common to most firms worldwide which
see such activities not only as a way to enhance employee relaxation but also for team building through
offsite camps and experiential training in resorts.
Thus, it can be said that modern and contemporary organizations have realized the need for
embracing best practices as far as human resource management is concerned.
The main aspect here is that there needs to be a balance between internal and external motivators
and this is where contemporary organizations often stimulate the inner drives and needs for self-
actualization as well as by providing external rewards that act as other motivators.
For instance, many organizations provide their employees with stimulating and challenging work so that
they are internally motivated and on the other hand, they also reward them appropriately so that their
need for money and other material benefits is fulfilled.
Conclusion
Lastly, contemporary organizations often take a toll on their employees’ physical and mental aspects and
hence, it is our view that to avoid burnout and stress among their employees, they must adopt as many
people-friendly policies as possible.
Indeed, it is better to let the employees relax and de-stress instead of losing them to ill health as well as
extended medical leaves that can cause monetary and non-monetary losses.
To conclude, the HRM Best Practices create a win-win situation for both the organizations and their
employees.
Also, the HR (Human Resources) scorecard represents how the performance of employees and the HR
Function, as well as the larger organization, can be optimized and be made more efficient through data-
driven measures of performance and analysis using advanced forms of forecasting and analysis.
Thus, the combination of Analytics and HR Scorecard can indeed be a game changer for organizations
seeking to leverage their human resources and make them more efficient in addition to tying them to the
broader organizational performance.
Analytics, on the other hand, can be used in any organizational function to derive the CBA or the Cost
Benefit Analysis of various organizational initiatives. Further, Data and Business Analytic tools can be
used to arrive at prognostications about the future using large datasets and trends.
Taken together, Analytics tools can be used with the HR Scorecard to actualize truly Next Generation
Measures of organizational performance as well as to actualize advanced forms of forecasting and
measuring performance.
Indeed, both the HR Scorecard and Analytics represent the marriage of advanced forms of data and trend
analysis with the scorekeeping and reporting of measures and indicators in a format based manner.
To see how this works in practice, we can take the example of the HR Scorecard measures of employee
performance and how specific employees have justified the costs incurred on them with the derived
benefits from their performance.
Thus, it is indeed the case that specific employees and their performance can be quantified and reported
on the HR Scorecard using financial and operational measures.
In this context, Analytics using Big Data and Artificial Intelligence can be used to arrive at granular
methods of data and business analytics. In other words, while the HR Scorecard can be used to
generate and report the financial and operational measures, the Data and Business Analytics can
be used in such reporting of measures by preparing the necessary measures of performance in a
highly granular and sophisticated manner.
Indeed, the coming together of Analytics and the HR Scorecard represents a truly next-generation
method of gathering, analyzing, and reporting performance measures that can be financial and
operational in nature.
In times when business trends and events change in real time and where speed and accuracy are of the
essence to enable Next Generation Business Strategies, the combination of Business Analytics and the
HR Scorecard represent truly revolutionary and game-changing approaches to the way in which
organizations perform.
Indeed, when the current “Business at the Speed of Thought” paradigm demands accuracy and speed at
the same time in any measures of organizational performance.
Thus, in this context, the HR Scorecard represents a novel and innovative approach to making human
resources count in the overall organizational universe.
On the other hand, Data and Business Analytics represent methods that can aid organizations in arriving
at macro and micro measures of performance from complex trends and events that can made as granular
as possible for the micro part and as Big Picture Analysis as possible for the macro part.
Thus, while the HR Scorecard is a reporting tool, the Analytics tool is a data gathering and analysis tool
that can be used to discern trends and the Big Picture. This means that when used in conjunction, the HR
Scorecard and the Data and Business Analytics tools can be used to both report and forecast measures
of employee performance and broader organizational performance.
Indeed, the fact that the former reports measures and the latter finds patterns in such reports means that
taken together, they represent a powerful combination.
Conclusion
Lastly, when used together, the HR Scorecard and the Analytics tools can be used to actualize synergies
and actualize efficiencies from the economies of scale.
Indeed, the fact that synergies accrue from the combination of reporting and analysis and which can drive
efficiencies from scale since all employees can be covered means that Next Generation reporting and
forecasting capabilities are within reach of organizations that use these tools.
In times when forecasts often fail the moment they are released, the power to measure and report with
speed and accuracy is indeed an asset for organizations that seek to optimize their returns from their
employees.
To conclude, using the HR Scorecard with Analytics represents a truly game-changing approach to
business.
How the HR Scorecard Helps Actualize
Cross Functional Excellence in
Organizations
How the HR Scorecard Helps Organizations
What is the HR Scorecard? It is a tool that measures the performance of the Human Resources (HR)
Function using data and aligns the same with the other functions in terms of costs and benefits.
In other words, the HR Scorecard is a useful tool to record the costs incurred by the HR Function for the
various activities and processes that are part of the function and then tallies the benefits that accrue from
these various costs.
Further, the HR Function is also useful to check and measure how well the HR Function is aligned with
the overall organizational objectives and the cross-functional benefits and linkages with the other
functions.
For instance, using the HR Scorecard, the HR Managers can present senior leadership and management
with data about how well the HR Function is faring and contributing to the success or otherwise of the
other functions as well as the larger organizations.
To take examples, the HR Scorecard provides data on the costs incurred by it for recruitment and training
of employees and then measures the outcomes or the benefits accrued on account of such costs. Indeed,
using the HR Scorecard, organizations can become truly integrated and systemic in nature since there is
a clear basis of accounting for the usefulness or otherwise of the various activities and processes of the
HR Function.
Indeed, using the HR Scorecard, the HR Function can no longer be standalone or separate from the
overall systemic nature of the organization.
For instance, the HR Scorecard can be used to track the success of specific recruitment and training
efforts for each of the functions such as Marketing, Operations, Finance, and other such functions.
Further, since the HR Scorecard essentially keeps score of the efficiency of the HR Function with regards
to the other functions and the larger organizational objectives, the HR Head or the HR Manager can have
a “seat at the management table” since there is a clear basis due to the HR Scorecard to keep track of
how well the HR Function is aligned with the broader organizational objectives and the cross-functional
efficiencies.
For instance, using data-driven measures, organizations have an opportunity to measure how well the HR
Function helps the other functions and in addition, by tallying how well the HR Function serves the
broader organizational needs, there is clarity on how aligned the HR Function is to the rest of the
organization and in this manner, actualize cross-functional linkages and excellence.
How the HR Scorecard Helps Organizations to Treat Their Employees as Assets
Moreover, using advanced technological tools such as Big Data Analytics and AI or Artificial Intelligence;
organizations can track the risks and anticipate the future challenges that can arise.
For instance, if the senior leadership feels that the ROI or the Return on Investment from specific
employees is not in the broader objectives and needs of the organization, they can simply change the
way the recruitment and training of such employees are being done.
In addition, given the advent of the services sector where the focus of the organization is on treating
employees as sources of sustainable competitive advantage and as key assets or the only assets, the HR
Scorecard can indeed help organizations in the services sector to measure the ROI as well as the
efficiencies that accrue from them.
Further, given the fact that the HR Scorecard allows the other functions to “tie in” their objectives with the
objectives of the HR Function as far as employees and human resources are concerned, there is scope
for genuine and true cooperation and coordination as well as integration and cross-functional linkage
between such functions and the HR Function.
As management theory states, how well the various parts of the system work together determines the
synergies from the whole that are greater than the sum of the parts, organizations can indeed reap such
synergies as well as derive efficiencies from the integration.
For instance, if the data reveals that organizations are rewarding employees lesser than what they
deserve as well as rewarding some employees more than the others or those who deserve or otherwise,
the incentive and the pay and perk system, as well as specific employee bonuses, can all be aligned to
the true needs of the organization.
Apart from that, in times when cross-functional expertise is much sought after and where
generalists and “Jacks of All Trades” are needed, the HR Scorecard can indeed help
organizations to identify such individuals and reward them appropriately so that they are
motivated to perform better.
Thus, the HR Scorecard is indeed an extremely useful tool to foster cross-functional excellence as well as
actualize synergies from such cross-functional linkages in addition to reaping the efficiencies from rolling
out data-driven measures on a mass scale.
Lastly, the HR Scorecard also helps senior leadership to get a Bird’s Eye View of the HR Function as well
as track the nuts and bolts or the micro measures of success of the HR activities and processes.
How the HR Scorecard can Help Gig
Economy Firms to Manage Freelancers
Better
How the HR Scorecard Helps Gig Economy Firms
It is usually thought and understood that the HR Scorecard is useful to only those firms in the
manufacturing and services sectors. However, there are uses for the HR Scorecard in the Gig Economy
or the Freelancing Economy firms as well.
These relate to how such firms can use the HR Scorecard to optimize their operations and to manage
freelancers better. For instance, Gig Economy firms can maximize the ROI or the Return on Investment
from Freelancers by measuring their productivity and tallying them against the costs that are incurred on
them.
To take an example, suppose firms such as Uber and Upwork spend 1000 Dollars on recruitment and
training costs of their freelancers. Now, if the costs incurred this way have to be recovered along with
profits, then the HR Scorecard can help by aligning the returns from such costs against the
objectives of the firms.
In other words, because such firms typically report only their freelancers as the primary asset or the only
asset, the HR Scorecard can indeed help such firms determine whether they ought to remain in business
or not.
The fact that the HR Scorecard is all about aligning the Strategic Objectives of firms with their HR
Objectives is reason enough for Gig Economy firms to use the HR Scorecard effectively and efficiently to
determine whether they are fulfilling such objectives.
Indeed, considering the fact that the HR Scorecard is used to determine whether the “fit” between the
organizational strategies and the HR Strategies means that Gig Economy firms can benefit from using the
HR Scorecard due to the primacy of Human Resources in the operations of such firms.
While this is also true of the Services sector firms such as Software and Financial Services, it is also the
case that Gig Economy firms can use the HR Scorecard to their advantage. For instance, since
freelancers make up the business model of Gig Economy firms, the HR Scorecard helps such firms to
actualize more efficient management of their human resources in a manner that is consistent with their
larger organizational objectives.
Anticipating Future Risks and Challenges
Having said that, it is also the case that Gig Economy firms can benefit from using the HR Scorecard
to anticipate future risks and challenges. Indeed, this can be done in a manner in which such firms can
understand how future risks arise and how to combat them accordingly.
For instance, if the organizational objective is to know how the future unfolds for such Gig Economy firms,
then the HR Scorecard can be of help in stacking up how the present scenario is and how such scenarios
can be extrapolated into the future to determine the strategic direction of such firms and whether they are
proceeding in ways that would ensure sustained success even in the future.
Apart from this, the HR Scorecard can also help Gig Economy firms in understanding the present as well
as looking backward to the past to determine whether they give clues and insights into the future
challenges. Indeed, both Big Data and AI used in conjunction with the HR Scorecard can benefit the Gig
Economy firms to map their strategic direction accordingly.
The HR Scorecard is first and foremost a tool that aligns the HR Function with the larger organizational
strategic objectives. Thus, the HR Scorecard helps in understanding whether the human resources in
firms are optimized and whether they are being used efficiently. Gig Economy firms that thrive on using
human resources can then align both their organizational objectives as well as measure the efficiency of
the human resources against their bottom line imperatives.
Moreover, Gig Economy firms thrive on efficiencies from the economies of scale and the synergies from
the integration of disparate and discrete organizational processes. Using the HR Scorecard would thus
help such firms by spreading the costs against the scale and by integrating their various functions and
processes.
Conclusion
Lastly, the HR Scorecard is extremely useful to any firm and in particular, the Gig Economy firms since
they can now use the same implement those changes that are beneficial to such firms and to discard
obsolete and outdated processes. Indeed, the fact that redundancies can be eliminated or reduced is
one reason why the HR Scorecard does help the Gig Economy firms to optimize their processes
and to make them efficient. To conclude, the future of work is freelancing and this means that we are
going to see more Gig Economy firms and hence, business leaders would be well advised to use the HR
Scorecard to their and their organization’s benefit.